Ten years on: Who is responsible for the downing of Flight MH17? | 101 East Documentary
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ก.ค. 2024
- Ten years after Malaysian Airlines Flight MH17 was shot down, the guilty are hiding in plain sight.
Two Russians and a Ukrainian have been convicted in absentia by a Dutch court for the murder of 298 people, but Russia refuses to hand them over, denying any involvement in the downing of the plane.
Investigators now believe Russian officials much higher up could be responsible - including President Vladimir Putin.
The Netherlands' chief prosecutor says there are "strong indications" that Putin personally signed off on supplying the missile that brought the plane down.
101 East investigates.
Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Check out our Instagram page: / aljazeeraenglish
Download AJE Mobile App: aje.io/AJEMobile
#documentary #Malaysia #putin #mh17 #vladimirputin #aljazeeraenglish #aljazeera
Thank you for watching. Let us know what you think in the comments below.
Watch more documentaries from 101 East and stay updated with the stories from across Asia and the Pacific: th-cam.com/play/PLzGHKb8i9vTyyefrSwaJ5qEmwub4jF1H6.html
More on 101 East:
‣ Twitter: twitter.com/AJ101East
‣ Facebook: facebook.com/AJ101East
‣ Instagram: instagram.com/aj101East
@@aljazeeraenglish what about the residents of the apartment building in Ryazan catching the Moscow apartment bombers in their basement?
Shame on Russia again
Not on Russia. Shame on Putin and his dictatorship. Holland's population is smaller than the number of Russian who hate Putin..
Shame on Nathanyahu . Shame on Biden
Be afraid of a leader who does not respect international laws
Biden, Sunak, Scholz, Macron, Zalenski,Starmer, Albanese, etc etc
Exactly!! So many are guilty yet we always point it out when it's Russia 😢.It is disgusting,yet the money made is irresistible for all. I'm sorry for All the innocent civilians in All the wars .@@MrRespectable-gw2xd
@@MrRespectable-gw2xd 😅😂🤣😆
Like Biden, Nathanyahu right?
@@ahmedfalah9647 neither of them are associated with downing a passenger airliner
As Malaysian, felt sad and to justified Russia just because we wanted to joint BRICS, im doubting the moral of my country
I Malaysian Christian, I very shame that my country want to join BRICS!!! Malaysian Muslim sympathy for Russia action for downing MH17 and I don't accept it!!!
@@LAAB-uk8pkDiam kafir laknat
Those missiles and launchers were directly owned and used by the Ukrainians. The Russians have nothing to do with them. In fact, those missiles and launchers came from the Soviet era, the Russians no longer produce or use them. It is a fact that the Ukrainians have been keeping a large number of Soviet made weapons since their defence budget is cash strapped. In that video, the Ukrainians were using the same Russian language, In fact, Ukrainians are actually Russians.
@@shaqisumari304 brics is an organization for nations unwilling to make an effort to compete in a worldwide economy
@@namastezen3300 "unwilling to make an effort to compete in world wide economy"? Dude, there's an overcapacity of sanctions on your left, right, front, back, up and down just because you said 'no' to Uncle Sam. Learn geopolitics next time.
Now we should expect seeing Russian cyber propagandist start attcking this documentary and leave BS comments here doing their best to muddy the water and change the truth, what a disgusting disgraceful beings
Oh boy! You've fallen for the warmongering of the US, UK and other NATO sissies.
Not good. Watch credible sources
Just look at all the "WHAT ABOUT" comments desperately trying to change the conversation
How about Nathanyahu?
Innocent people have been killed by dangerous politicians and their combatants, but look at you all here in the comments section fighting over who to point a finger at, and if the documentary is necessary. Just take a second to ask yourself if it were you or your wife, husband, child, siblings or parents on that plane. Will you be here arguing for politicians who obviously do not care about you or that of your loved ones?
Exactly. Same what Nathanyahu
Great work, All Jazeera! You do some of the finest reporting on almost everything happening today. You're probably my most watched news channel. The"Why" is mostly what haunted me through this whole report. Why would they shoot down that airliner, and if it was not deliberate, exactly what were they trying to shoot down? These questions haven't been addressed, and are probably not yet known.
Do you remember this - US in 1988 downed Iranian civil plane? Ukraine shot down a civil Russian Tu-154 on 2001? Iran on 2020 downed ukrainian passenger plane? Or it is DIFFERENT? Just so you know: the Dutch Hague court believes that MH17 was shot down too by mistake.
Its is different because Russia is not accepting the fault
...and all out of sudden Saudi Arabia were involved in the Twin Tower and the MH17 get media attention , old mainstream media need to be neutral or will not be taken seriously anymore
3 convicted by Dutch court; 2 rossiya, 1 Ukrainian separatist
@@namastezen3300in absentia
@@kahuna_eht They missed their chance to defend themselves or accept the judgment of the court.
the Dutch Hague court did not establish that Russia downed MH17. It was ruled only that "the Buk-TELAR was brought from Russia." But now a lot of WEST weapons are being imported to Ukraine. Is WEST be held responsible for the deaths of civilians during war?
The founder of Bellingcat was absolutely right: pro-Russian bots and propagators do their best to cover tracks and draw your mind from the truth. Good job, kgb!
Don't bother, ruzzian bot. Everyone understands who did that. ruzzia will pay for that and for many others crimes
@@sokratnekrasov Bellingcat itself is pro-west bot
@@EliasAngelo9426 Could you please provide any evidence? By the way, it was established by a British resident, it doesn't have to be "pro-west" :)
@@sokratnekrasov That british resident is listed as an expert on atlantic council website, he's described as a "Nonresident Senior Fellow, Digital Forensic Research Lab, Future Europe Initiative". That website is known for its pro-US/NATO and anti-Russian stance, and among the members of its Advisory Board and Directors are Henry Kissinger, Madeleine Albright, Colin Powell, Condoleeza Rice, James Woolsey, James Clapper, Rupert Murdoch and the heads of finance and defense corporations such as Lockheed Martin, Airbus and Goldman Sachs, and some others. Bellingcat too is biased.
Clearly, CIA and MI6 is doing a good job at keeping a sheep such as you stay obedient and accept everything coming from your media as the truth even though it's filled with narratives and propagandas too, just like Russian sources. :)
Voetsek, stupid videos about Russia and Putin
Triggered
So heartbreaking 😢! What was the reason behind bombing this passenger plane and killing all these people?
@AimHigh1 - to blame it on Russia and increase the hate propaganda. And Ukraine has many times attack civilians and destroyed civilian infrastructure. Look what their friends are doing in Gaza.
While I believe the Russian separatist was involved, I stopped and closed this video as soon I realised Bellingcat was involved. Very unfortunately, this investigative journalist association is very murky.
They knew the was Fighting in that area and PLANES HAVE TO REDIRECT THEIR FLIGHG PATH BUT THEY REDIRECT THE FLOGHT PATH AND ENCOUNTERED SUCH AN INCIDENT THE UKRAINE CRISIX STARTED 2012 WHEN THD ELECTED PRESIDENT WAS FORCED BY DEMONSTRATION BY WESTERN AUTHORITIES SO WE HAVE TO BLAME THE WESTERN AUTHORITIES
Lock pootin up and his BOTS
It looks like Nathanyahu bots are commenting as well
Who shot it down ,then you said Russia did it 🤔
Ukraine,they think the plane is Rusia airforce one.Wallahuaklam only Allah know the truth
The Rusky bot farm is working overtime huh
Bots spreading doubt, disinformation and conspiracy theories. Typical playbook.
bro making his own happiness.
Who directed the civilian aircraft over the active war zone? It seems like a CIA op my opinion, they need to change the narrative and this is what they did with this incident.
Bookmark Novaya Gazeta and Bellingcat. You need nothing else to get a real glimpse into what Russia under Putin is capable of. The Russians though are cultured people. They will eventually get rid of him.
31 JANUARY 2024
UN Court clears Russia of financing terror in Ukraine, which led to Flight MH17 downing
After seven years, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) in The Hague has ruled in Russia's favour over the downing of Malaysia Airlines flight MH17. The case was brought by Ukraine, who alleged that Russia violated an anti-terrorism treaty by supporting separatists in eastern Ukraine with military aid and financing.
In its verdict, the ICJ ruled that Ukraine did not prove that Russia knew its financing would be used for the purposes of terrorism, even if its weaponry was used to shoot down the aircraft, killing innocent civilians. Russia will not have to pay damages in the case.
The truth shall be revealed in due time.
What i want to know is why did not Malaysian Airlines re- route the plane away from a war zone,it makes sense to divert or cancel a flight.
Because no one thought that separatists are armed with advanced weaponry.
@@golmgolm That's a good one.
MH17 wasnt the only plane flying wtihin the airspace. Some basic research will show that at the very same time there was a Singapore Airlines flight and and Indian Airways flight right within the vicnity of the incident. That shows that it was accepted across the board that it was supposed to be safe for it to fly over Ukrainian airspace at Donetsk. The fact that someone violated that safety with a cruise missile is the bigger problem, not that the victims flew over a battlefield which by itself did not constitute a breach of aviation safety rules at that time.
You are being too logical. You can't think that way because then you can't blame Russia.
@@quintinout Cuando hay que echar la culpa por cualquier cosa, es 'logico' que lo hizo Putin.
Al Jazeeera is the best TV channel both for news and investigative journalism
In 2012 Bush, Cheney and Rumsfeld were convicted for war crimes by a Malaysian Court, and no one thinks it peculiar that 2 Malaysian passenger airliners crash under less than clear circumstances 2 years later? Wake up already. Malaysia itself withdrew from the JIT, why?
😂what
@@angeline12345 😎✈✈
First they never ask for Russia to cooperate with them, Russia presented proves even have videos of the tests on the Internet but Australia and Netherlands didn't accepted.
All the medias at that time deactivated the comments on the videos about this, the videos continue here on TH-cam, everyone can see for themselves.
The Malaysia plane at that time had precisely the same colors of Vladimir Putin presidential plane, the only difference was one is bigger and the other was smaller, since that accident Malaysia airlines change the colors of their air planes 7 or 8 times.
The missile that hit the Malaysia airline plane are the same type of missiles found in Donbass and Donetsk(areas controlled by Russia)that didn't explode and they didn't attack themselves, remember the Tochka-U missile with the message "this is for the children" and when a Italian TVNews show that the missiles that didn't explode in Donetsk and Donbass, have a similar serial number they stopped.
Old videos (2012) of Ukraine military parades show that Ukraine have this missiles.
Russia since the Malaysia airline accident always said that they destroyed this missiles because they are not efficient and they have more modern missiles but Ukraine like all old Soviet country also have it and even the US have this Soviet missiles and on the list of armaments that the US send to Ukraine on the beginning of the war, a lot of old Soviet armaments are on that list.
What is this word salad??
😂😂
If one of two possible suspects is part of the investigation, you can guess its outcome.
Al Jazeera! Please, make a documentary about the Peshawar School Massacre in Pakistan in December 2014.
Your Royal Highness thank you for keeping it honest 🫡
Lying is a vitus
make a documentary on Bangladesh student movement agains unjust quota system in govmnt jobs plz🙏🙏🙏
soooo
⌛
How about handing over Nathanyahu ? He is a criminal too
😞wow
om
What a crock ....
They will never call western countries criminal but they Mouth talk about the other countries if it’s they are innocent
are always the innocents people to pay the price more hight
Yes . Sadly US government is financing genocide too
HI
The bots are onfire today😮
Yes exactly. All Nathanyahu supporter commenting as well
At least he change it because he didn't notice that happened last year
Aljezeera 😂
Girkin would live longer in a Rotterdam prison, better food too.
I thought this plane had disappeared from Radar 44 minutes after taking off in Kuala Lumpur. Or which plane is this?
That is another MH plane, this was a second one
That's mh 370,this mh17 Malaysian also forgot about it,,
Bellingcat...😂
Ukraine is the culprit!!
Not really no...
Assisted no doubt by Bigfoot's lovechild.
🇳🇱
ايش الالعاب دي؟؟ 👿
Pooptin, pooptin, pootin is responsible.
Not
the moment I hear Bellingcat investigates, I know this is BS
Why?
@@sokratnekrasov Bellingcat is funded by the UK government and MI6. It is a one person, one flat investigation person that always side with the establishment. See the Syria gas attack that was completely debunked. Actually pretty much everything he investigated was debunked as propaganda
The majority of people in the world prefer to stay in North Korea rather than South Korea. Until they are in North Korea than they want to crossover ❌ 🛑.
Innnalilah waainailla hirojiun 💐💐💐😕😕😕🌹
Ukraine cldn't had such an advance missile, to down such a high lattitude flying plane...!!!☝️🙄😬🤨
The Buk system is soviet era system. By right both side have the weapon
@@orkeddiary2758 Thk goodness, I wasn't in that plane, then...!!!😏
But US and NATO have. They are supplying those to Ukraine
@@ahmedfalah9647So..., I see...!!!🤔🙄😬
The timing is extraordinary
Really, Aljazeera? Might want to do some research on that one.
How dumb are you? Have you even seen the JIT and Bellingcat reconstruction? The complete traject of bringing and removing the BUK to Ukraine back to Russia is known. Including telephone recordings etc. The evidence is overwhelming. Everything Russia put to the table is a complete joke. No evidence of Ukrainian responsibility what so ever.
Already did...
I’m sick of this anti Russia hysteria, seriously!
Seems appropriate or even not hysterical enough based on behaviour…. I mean, they targeted and destroyed a children’s hospital a few days ago in Ukr. What do you expect? Should they be given a peace prize?
And yet you are not sick of Russia downing a civilian airplane? What a disgrace you are
@@louislemire6691 I thought we were talking about Russia? There is clear video of the Russian warhead entering the children's hospital in Ukr a few days ago. The silhouette of the missile shows clearly it is a Russian warhead. If anyone is interested in facts, they can see the Bellingcat opensource analysis by searching for "Russian Missile Identified in Kyiv Children’s Hospital Attack". But thanks for the "what aboutism" comment though.
@@louislemire6691 anyone interested in facts can search for the beling cat article “russia identified in children hospital”
@@grasmi If we did really "targeted and destroyed", there would be just a big hole, not a building standing. Please try to learn something about the world around you, not just binge stupid propaganda.
All "JIT countries" are de facto, interested and biazed in this case. Netherlands, Australia - victim (sufferer) the party. Ukraine is a party to the conflict, during which the MH17 was shot down, that is, one of the suspects. And had the same Buks and missiles and could have shot down MH17.
How dumb are you? Have you even seen the JIT and Bellingcat reconstruction? The complete traject of bringing and removing the BUK to Ukraine back to Russia is known. Including telephone recordings etc. The evidence is overwhelming. Everything Russia put to the table is a complete joke. No evidence of Ukrainian responsibility what so ever.
Putin in Guantanamo
Along with Nathanyahu and US government officials
Now comm'on... these pictures found on the net from Bellingcat remind me Colin Powell and his pathetic sat pictures...😂. That being said, i do strongly believe russian rebels were responsible (certainly not Putin), i find amusing those argument. The dutch judge said in the video, i quote " territories of wars. " Let me tell you this: Why do they allow a civilian airplane to overfly such territories of war ? WHY Nobody mention this ?...
My request to Yemen is please dont destroy Norwegian 🇳🇴 ships because they are supporting Palestinians 🇵🇸 like Spain 🇪🇦 and Irland 🇮🇪 let this 3 countries ships go in pease shukkran
Who Else use the brain Guys same whit flight 370 is Putin and Russia
May be US was involved in it. Talk about US financing genocide, they can be involved in this as well
Every from bellingcat is fake !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
This programme asks who is responsible and then lays blame on Russia.
Ukraine had the Russian Buk missile system in its inventory at 2014.
Shame on you for being such a disgusting disgraceful being
@@ramatgan1 Both Ukrainian and Russian government are telling lies about the downing of flight mh17.... They points the blame together....
yes, because they denied everything.....100% Russian did this
How dumb are you? Have you even seen the JIT and Bellingcat reconstruction? The complete traject of bringing and removing the BUK to Ukraine back to Russia is known.
Love from North Korea ❤ - Chairman Kim
Biden bots pretending to be Kim
Isnt that airplane shot down by ukranian ?
Nope... It was Russian and pro Russians separatists...
@@adamdaniel8909 What was the sacred meaning of shooting down a Boeing for the Russians?
and here's food for thought
The Soviet warhead report log states that the missile fragments of which were found at the crash site were fired in 1986 and belonged to the 223rd anti-aircraft regiment and the deployment of this regiment was the city of Lviv
So the rocket is Ukrainian...
@@aquilifer_1823 rocket is Ukrainian... Huh...
Yet it was Russia's fault... Oh I forgor that there are separatists who are pro Russia and got old weapons from Russia and after hours of the shooting...some local Russian news reported it as they shot it down... And the veto at the UNSC by the Russians to make an independent investigation...
They just want to put it up on Russia
It was Russia that shot it down and everyone was scared of accusing Putin....
Russia will never admit to amything
Same as Nathanyahu and Biden
"Who else...!!!"🙄😬🤨
MH 370 what happened Al jazeera seems has the answers
We don't have any answers yet...
Passenger planes should not fly over a combat zone. Ukraine should have banned flights there in 2014, April-May, when it began. But she wanted money(fee for flights) and didn't do it. Thanks to Ukraine FIRSTLY for MH17.
Not even a minute in and I just saw Eliot Higgins of bellgincrap, and I'm out
The investigation story lacks facts
The facts seem pretty clearly laid out in this video. Russia is obviously at fault
Malaysian Airlines is at fault for routing the flight over a war zone. I'd be idiot to fly on such route if I knew, and I'm sure the passengers didn't know.
The airspace was open to civil aviation because Russia failed to declare it as a warzone. Hundreds of civilian aircraft flown by many airlines flew through that airspace that week. A Singapore Airlines aircraft from Copenhagen to Singapore was flying mere minutes behind MH17. The area was an active civilian airway, commonly referred to as a highway in the sky.
shame on you al jazeera , garbage
They just want attention seeker and also money!!!
I know for a fact and instinctively that you lie until you're covered in mushrooms.
Double standards, donr believe this
Blaming putin again 🙄
your delusional
Si. Es verdad.
@user-if2kq8nh8m maybe you are mate
what do you expect from him destroying children hospitals purposely destroying civilian shelters and you don't think he wouldn't give the clearance to shoot down a passenger airliner your delusional
Horrible biased investigation
It was NOT Russia or Separatist who downed MH17.
I blamed Ukraine for not closing the aviation flights...
Evidence???
@@LAAB-uk8pk yeah I blamed both :Ukrainian and Russian government sending evidence which is true or false....They shoot down mh17.... Both Ukrainian and Russian government were pigs, blaming each other....
After the lies of the gazprom pipes..its difficult to believe any thing anymore..
Typical confusion technique and whataboutisn.
It was a innocent casualty of war. They were surprised themselves!
no way russian will do that..bcoz when US accused for sure US involved..we are malaysian knew who involved in this..
How dumb are you? Have you even seen the JIT and Bellingcat reconstruction? The complete traject of bringing and removing the BUK to Ukraine back to Russia is known. Including telephone recordings etc. The evidence is overwhelming. Everything Russia put to the table is a complete joke. No evidence of Ukrainian responsibility what so ever.
Only you know who is involved in this which you don't...
And don't say all Malaysians...
al Jazeera i use to support your channel now im seeing you more to western and you not even do your investigation ..
So you're saying that journalism is bad...?
they wanna drag Malaysia to the same side of NATO🤔😒
😂 knowing the iran passenger plane was downed and with intent and one was prosecuted
Jesus loves you.
But we are the chosen children.
The weapons Russia give to the Donbass separatists at the time were not Russian anymore but Donbass weapons. Why double standards
It doesn't matter. The fact is that Russia violated the Budapest memorandum according to which it was to have respected and defended the territorial integrity of Ukraine whereas Putin annexed the Crimea and supplied missile systems to the separatists.
Amazing how European countries dismiss the authority of ICC and ICJ
How about MH370?
I strong believe it the Ukrainian down the plane.
After mh17 got shot, second day later they changed mas plane colour on the region, full 🔵 version after got shot on full 🤍 with red blue line,why? because they don't want Ukraine airforce make stupid on twice.wallauaklam
Evidence??? I know that you are from Malaysia and sympathy for Russia action for downing MH17. You humiliated your country victims. How dare you!!!
NATO 0 responsibility?
they r out of propaganda
No need to watch any more of this because after the first 21 seconds you claimed you knew who committed the act.
What has Russia done?
Nothing
According to search results, on October 4, 2001, a Russian passenger plane Tu-154 flying from Tel Aviv to Novosibirsk was shot down over the Black Sea. All 78 people on board were killed.
The investigation showed that the plane was shot down by Ukrainian military forces during air defense exercises. Ukrainian Defense Minister Oleksandr Kuzmuk and Air Force Commander Volodymyr Tkachov apologized for the incident, and Ukrainian President Leonid Kuchma acknowledged Ukraine's responsibility. Several high-ranking military personnel were dismissed during the investigation.
Experts did not rule out the possibility that the cause of the crash could have been an explosive device on board the plane. However, the Ukrainian side insisted that the exact cause could not be reliably determined, as the "black boxes" of the Tu-154 were never found.
Isn't it Strange that any Civil aviation flew Over Ukraine during hot conflict After such "trainings" of Ukrainian army before?
This is a joke
Who so ever did ..why did it ?????
for propaganda
Malaysian airlines for flying over a war zone. Idiotic. Especially when one side is not a professional army.
You are so stupid, MH17 did not enter restricted territory, MH17 was on a flight from Amsterdam to Kuala Lumpur when it was shot down over eastern Ukraine. At the time, the plane was flying at an altitude deemed safe by international aviation authorities, including the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) and on the same day Malaysia was not the only one using that strip
Malaysian Muslim still sympathy for Russia action for downing MH17, what a stupid decision!!!!!!
Why in world would Russia deliberately shoot down a civilian airplane?
They wouldn't
Not very compelling arguments or evidence.
Blaim UKRAINE
Nope... It was Russia...