I'm glad Muppet Carol got perfect! It does capture the spirit of the book and uses many lines of the book's wonderful narrator dialogue due to Gonzo playing Dickens.
Totally agree with Mysterious Benedict. Hobbit is a fabulous movie, but ya not a great adaptation. And I think the things they change in Wingfeather Saga actually make it better!
These were fun! The only Mansfield Park I've enjoyed is the series from 1983 which I thought was really good. And Northanger Abbey needs better adaptations than it's gotten.
I never understand why crucial parts are changed for adaptations - especially super popular classics. They are successful for a reason! Just make the movie like the book and the masses will love it. [hehe]
I love the hobbit movies and think they’re better then the books 🤣🫣 I personally like how the movies changed the plot/characters because it added more depth. But I can see why some people don’t like that
How did I miss this one? What a fun video! "Did you EVEN read the chapter titles?" 😆
Well, some of them don't! 😂😂😂
@@MorgansEndlessBookshelf they should seek employment elsewhere😆
Same!!
Girllllll I thought you were about to put Anne further down on the list and I was about to have a heart attack
😂😂😂
😂😂😂 No, of course Anne is perfect! 😂😂
😂😂 lol me too
When you first slid 'Felicity' into mediocre... I think I gasped. [haha] But then you put her in her proper place. :)
Oh, yeah, her movie is so good!
@@MorgansEndlessBookshelf 💙
I'm glad Muppet Carol got perfect! It does capture the spirit of the book and uses many lines of the book's wonderful narrator dialogue due to Gonzo playing Dickens.
So true!
Loved this video!! I haven't watched several of them, but I think for the most part I agree with a lot of your rankings.
Thanks!
Yesssss North & South is perfect 💯 and 95 P&P!!
💯💯💯
As a manly man (full of manliness), I heartily approve of the '95 Pride and Prejudice ranking
😂😂😂
I love Barbie Nutcracker
Barbie movies are so underrated!
This is great. I’ve seen most of these and agree with most of your rankings. Loved hearing your thoughts.
Glad you enjoyed!
Totally agree with Mysterious Benedict. Hobbit is a fabulous movie, but ya not a great adaptation. And I think the things they change in Wingfeather Saga actually make it better!
I did really love that Janner and Sara already have a relationship in the show!
These were fun! The only Mansfield Park I've enjoyed is the series from 1983 which I thought was really good. And Northanger Abbey needs better adaptations than it's gotten.
Totally agree about Northanger!
Of all the ones I have seen, I agree with your assessment and ranking!
Yay!
I was thinking of doing this!
You totally should!
I never understand why crucial parts are changed for adaptations - especially super popular classics. They are successful for a reason! Just make the movie like the book and the masses will love it. [hehe]
Exactly!
Felicity is a great movie!!
Yes! 💯💯
This was a fun video and I haven't read or seen the vast majority of these. 🤣
Glad you enjoyed it! 😂😂
I didn’t like the Voyage adaptation, though I do like how they added the theme of temptation
It was just so different from the book!
*gets Narnia out of the way first 😂
Look, everyone knew how that one would go. 😂😂😂
Wait but LOTR is perfect???
😂😂 I should probably make a LotR movie video sometime with all my thoughts.
I love the hobbit movies and think they’re better then the books 🤣🫣
I personally like how the movies changed the plot/characters because it added more depth. But I can see why some people don’t like that
See, I think the books have more depth, but they're also more subtle about it. Maybe that's why they changed so many characters, I'm not sure.