Scholars of old would refrain and fear giving fatwa on even the simplest matters of Deen. Nowadays it is norm to see or hear a student of Deen confidently and at times egotistically pass a ruling over a grave matter. May Allah guide us all, Amiin.
@Ibn Kamal Al-Hanbali If ibn uthaymeen said the same thing, it holds more weight because it is coming from him(a world renowned scholar) rather than an unknown usthath.
So many ppl in the comment section are being rude and calling the sheikh names. It doesn't matter if he's wrong, mind your tongues guys. Your deeds will go into his account
The thing is people who listens to him they come and type haram haram on videos and i know everybody has there own opinion but all they type is (haram) and they are not giving any explanation why is it haram and if they give explanation and reasoning they don't make a lot of sense and if someone told them that they might be wrong they will not listen. May Allah forgive us all Muslims and show all of us the right way.
This so called Sheikh/Ustadz will be the one judged for opening his mouth without thinking of the consequences in the public domain. Guy must have lived in a deep dark hole all his life. He's causing fitnah to the Deen.
Yhh even I disagree with some of the stuff he said, But why condemn him? Why insult him? I disagree but I’m not gonna have hatred or condemn him for a belief he has, Cos I don’t have nothing against him either I believe he’s done a lot of good But I just disagree on some of these things here he said
Assalam o alaikum, Bismillah. Brother Hijab you make some very valid points. Although, in defense of brother AbdulRahhman Hasan, he also made some valid points regarding the inherent backbiting and "tribal" behaviors associated with the sociology of the sport. And of course the point about the exposed 'Awrah of the football players and both men and women audiences observing this, was significant. In my opinion (which probably doesn't matter), I believe the problem isn't intrinsically with the mechanics of the sport but rather with what the sport has become. And I think that's what Muslims need to be cautious about. May Allah reward you all. Assalam o alaikum.
you can say the same thing about anything in these so I will say buying a phone is haram, going to school is haram, going on a holiday in haram.... so don't be stupid, watching football and playing it is not haram but it could be a little sinful like anything else in today's world but if you didn't commited the sin in purpose it will be forgiven.
@@marocmaghrib5524 It's very disrespectful of you, to say 'so don't be stupid' to a brother when he wasn't even being informal and childish. Have some basic respect, kid.
@@marocmaghrib5524how do you think something can be ‘a little sinful’ but it’s not haram? Do you even think about what you’re saying? The point was never that the game is haram, but more so watching it. If all the stuff you mentioned contain haram that can’t be avoided then without a doubt they would be haram as well.
@@ObscureServant what I am saying is those claims are a little extreme cause we have bigger problems in the world to fix like 'LGBTQ' and after that we can talk about football and holidays, if you are a true believer then yes but for biginner muslims it's better to not go that deep, the prophet himself PBUH did not went all the way with Quraish it was like baby steps (islam was going on secretly). Anyway that was just my point, talking about football is not a wise move.
You need to stop using this style of belittling your brothers when they make a mistake. Just bring your evidences and arguments that he misjudged the situation.
I think you'll find MH and others are not interested in correcting what they perceive to be a mistake. Everything they do is calculated. These guys in their social media 'war' with spubs, actually took on their attributes... The irony...
I agree with your points over all brothers. However, these people with no knowledge are leading our brothers astray and turning reverts back to ignorance. Look at the Salif they were harsh on fools that caused fitnah. The brother should be silent
He face an ignorant who claim having knowledge, and the issue is important. If can't forbid something if it is something Allah have permit, الحكم الا لله, so we have to be carefull with ijtihad.
@@OptimisedHealth The only credibility we Muslims have is our adherence to Allahs book and Messenger (saw). Now if he is saying he does not like soccer that is fine. However soccer is not Haram. Allah hates that people make Halal things Haram. People must be held accountable. The "ruling" the brother gave was illogical and childish. If you do not understand deen do not speak on it
@@burhaanmohamed19 The worst thing is that I see many people say "Since it's not mentioned in the Quran or Ahadith then it's haram". They say this about a lot of stuff.
The ustadh has a wealth of knowledge, he got it wrong on certain points here. May Allah reward him for his efforts, there is no need to mock him like people in the comments are doing.
@@Rukiya-z2b nothing to conceal when he makes his views public. Yes he has a lot of knowledge, but he also needs to live and breathe his knowledge. He gives of vibes of hate. He’s a bad example for other Muslims and non-muslims who are looking to learn about the religion.
@@specter1019 I don’t think he that knowledgeable just because he memorised many txt and speak the Arabic language eloquently don’t mean he knowledgeable.
@@Taznoor1984 hes way better than Muhammad Hijab hes an Ustadh in matters of Deen while Muhammad Hijab is an daee and the fields of Muhammad Hijab and Ustadh are different , we shouldn't indulge our noses in the matters we aren't expert, just like Ustadh shouldn't indulge his noses in Comparative Religion and like Muhammad shouldn't indulge his noses in these matters both are good people in their respective fields , Hijab shouldn't go over and look at the few mistakes of the ustadh and openly make a rad of it hes not the one to make rad of him, many more knowledgeable scholars exist to correct the ustadh only if hes wrong but hes not wrong. I saw the video when Hijab published the video entitled "Refutation of a Muslim Preachers who forbids Football" then after some time he changed it to Correcting, Why is Hijab so desperate to conceal the mistakes of the Ustadh in Public? These kinds of mistakes (which you guys call so) can be settled in private if Hijab tried to contact the Ustadh Privately man ! I mean both Ustadh and Hijab lives in UK they can meet eachother and have a dinner and settle this thing or else even setting it in dms or somewhere else. Did Hijab did it? No he didn't. Look brother Hijab is one of the most famous daee in the world rn he has millions of followers all over the world now after he made this video the arrogants and ignorants will come in the comments section and backbite the ustadh will Hijab take the sins of the backbiting done in the comments section? Will he be responsible for it? Will he carry the sins of Ustadh in the day of Judgement? No worries Ustadh is getting free hasanah here
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته One big announcement! Let's say brother Abdurrahman Hassan made a mistake for the sake of argument, this does not justify at all to backbite him and everyone who does this should repent immediately. Rather we should ask Allah to guide him and us to the straight path and to reward him for his great work he has done for years.
@@MrRebel247 May Allah guide you, Muhammad Hijab did a good job making this video, many people will backbite the ustadh in this comment section so he is getting free hasanah no worries lol
@@houseoftawhid Bro that's exactly the point, would you want them to eat their dead brother's flesh? Moreover the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم said: الدين النصيحة (The Religion is Advise). [Bukhari and Muslim] So it's our obligation to call them out, but as I said, even if he did a misktake it doesn't justify to backbite him. Refuting persons has its rulings as well as backbiting, so don't equate them
My only concern with fotball is showing of Aowrah (thighs), other than that it is up to the individual to give the game its size and place in his life as a "game".
Yes but Allah encourages us to exercise , football is one of the best form is exercise and is good for the mind and the body . Secondly it keeps the yout away from drugs and crime . So yes the sheikhs that forbid are ignorant about these issues
You're not obligated to expose your Aurah. Some players wear shorts that are a little bit too short but others wear shorts that do cover the Aurah. Maybe be hasnt watched soccer since the 80s lol back then yea they did wear practically booty shorts, but now you have many religious rights and accommodations you can get in these regards.
When you make the religion difficult there’s going to be a max exodus of youth from the faith. They go to public schools and are told movies, music, dating, drinking, etc are all haram. Fine no problem with that. But then you tell them chess is makruh and soccer is haram. What are they supposed to do? Don’t make things difficult on ppl that’s not the way of the religion.
@ReBel kiD Essentially he is since there are rules that need to be followed (which he mentioned in hypothetical situations). IF we have taken the brother out of context and twisted his words, then know he and others in the refutation culture do exactly the same thing.
His awful breakdown can be applied to anything. "Man-made laws" include stopping at a traffic light. I'm assuming this dude runs through red-lights since he doesn't follow "Man-made laws"
May Allah bless brother Abdulrahman Hassan and grant him Jannahtul Firdaws A'ala, and may Allah increase him in Knowledge of the Deen and strengthen, protect and preserve him. He made his points clear. If we are trying to modernised our Deen because of foolishness and desires then, this is what happened, felt bad when the truth is spoken.
May Allah bless you sister it's sad to see you (Mohamed hijab) talk about another Muslim like this I would like to speak to you about certain things in the park if your there there seems to be a strong hatred towards salafiyah or the people who identify as salafis. His opinion is his opinion.
Sister he is saying things no scholar said before that a yellow card in a game is ruling by other than sharia, there is no precedence for this in Islam that’s not modernising to reject flawed fiqh Allahu’Alim
Ustadh Abdulrahman Hassan is one of the best things that has happened to TH-cam. So much knowledge, so much akhlak and such a great example for the youth. Brother Mohammed, I like your videos where you defend Islam, but respectfully you are nowhere near the level of knowledge of someone like Ustad Abdulrahman Hassan. You are simply not even close to being qualified to even debate someone of his calibre. You may know a lot about philosophy and history but in actual Islamic Sciences you yourself know you don't count as a scholar or even a student of knowledge. I rarely come to the defense of people, but I cannot begin to describe how beneficial the Ustad's lectures and videos have been to me and to the community who follows Al Madrasatu Al Umariyyah. It's difficult enough to find actual knowledgeable English-language Muslim content (note: knowledgeable, Speaker's Corner is just debating and da'wah, it's not the same; English Muslim social media is full of da'wah but desperately low on actual knowledge, Alhamdulillah I speak other languages so I can seek other Ustadhs). You should be humble and support the people of knowledge, because they are the heart of the Ummah, while you are supposed to be following them, not acting superior to them and exposing them to the youth who do not understand whom to look up to and whom to take knowledge from. Please do not let your many followers and big status delude you into being arrogant, my brother. I hope anyone reading this can check out Ustad's channel and benefit from the great knowledge and example that he sets. Please brother, set a good example to the youth, who comprise the vast majority of your followers. Look at these comments and how much they make negative assumptions. Wallahi, these accusations are not accurate. Wallahi, my fellow youth, please check Ustad's channel and watch his other videos before you judge. This is not correct. May Allah protect and increase Ustad Abdulrahman Hassan in patience and knowledge. May the misunderstandings and accusations in the comments remove his sins in the 10 blessed days of Dhul Hijjah. May Allah bless all the students of knowledge.
Ustadh Abdulrahman Hassan Reponds To The Negative Feedback On ‘The Reality Of Football’ Podcast… th-cam.com/video/78kq14dMCmY/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=AnonymousBrother
Sheikh AbdulRahman is a knowledgeable brother on the deen. No need to call him names, insult or belittle him as if he's a jaahil. He has made some corrects points and some that may not be correct. It's not like you're more knowledgeable in deen than him to talk down on him like that. You're not a scholar and neither is he but students still learning
@@AbdulH97 m. Hijab is such a jahil ignorant person. He everytime tells that sectarianism has to stopped. Still he is criticizing & insulting ustadh ARH over football. Never seen a bigger hypocrite than him
But you just called him sheikh?. You called a student a sheikh?. And sorry but so far we have seen very minor mistakes of no severity from muhammad hijab. ARH may have memorized more books but his implementation shows his lack of maturity and intellect so it accounts to nothing. It’s clear Muhamad hijab is a lot more smarter and a deeper thinker.
Look up 'Ruling on watching football Sheikh Uthaymeen' for nuanced and careful examination of this matter, link th-cam.com/video/X3tyOPoK3fo/w-d-xo.html
this abdurahman hassan guy is a saudi madkhali who refuses to make takfir on the rulers for giving up Islamic law but is applying the Quranic verses to a soccer game
@@capnsmo6888 This Ustadh Abdurahman Hassan, may Allah continue to honour him, is a true follower Of Prophet Muhammad pbuh who has more knowledge of Islam than you and your family combined.
Can I ask why a video is being posted in TH-cam. Wouldn't it be best to contact the brother directly and then make public about the Consensus opinions of the scholars regarding this.
@@muhammedsalam8493 no, public videos require private refutation so the person can remove the video and issue another one saying they were wrong. Public videos are only needed when you are unable have a private conversation with the person.
@@muhammedsalam8493 has private refutation been made? More over, he made lots of other points but he totally ignored them and focused on his flaws only which is very bad. This brother is his brother in Deen and not his enemy, why treat the issue as if they both have some other unresolved issues.
@@riiaz muhammad hijab has balls mind your own buisness. you go contact that saudi madkhali deviant privately, public causers of corruption need to be publicly refuted
Fear Allah AnyOne in this comment section talking bad about Ustadh AbdulRahman Hassan And Making Fun of Him Just remember You're in The 10 day's of hajj, All your Fasting Praying, Being Good to your Parents Etc All Your Good Deeds, All can Go in blink of eye Because You BackBiting Your brother in Islam Allāhu ʾAʿlam. This is what happens when you follow people like this, And leads you into foolishness and think it's All Fun And Game's.
I have to watch the whole video of ustadh Abdulrahman. From what I saw from the present clip, I do agree with some of the things you said. However, I am shocked by your enmity towards ustadh Abdulrahman. Why do you always want to humiliate the one whom you refute, even if he is your muslim brother? The way you talk sometimes is absolutely disgusting. Look at around 11:20. Are you proud of speaking in that manner? Incredible
Because if you have been following MH for the past year, he has really started an anti-salafi campaign. And anyone who is a madkhali is under attack by Mohammed hijab. These guys are wasting their time doing these video refutations that benefit no one in the ummah.
Akhi, he has too. Firstly Abdurahman Hassan is a knowledgeable brother. But he is slipping in some areas in knowledge, where is he getting these from? Why dont we hear our ulema give these type of refutations? Hes simply not at that level, and these types of videos make him undesirable to listen to. If he wants to perfect his knowledge, firstly he shouldn’t be giving fatwah, hes no mufti. Secondly he has to think before speaking.
@@rewardedwithemaan646 salam alaikum brother, if you watch the podcast ARH referred to the fatwa given by ibn baz and a whole committee in 1401 AH (1979)
These statements from this man are wild. People need to understand Islam is a simple religon and we need to stop trying to stretch, twist, and turn every single verse and hadith to apply it to everything. Theres no correlation to half of the stuff he says. He just connects dots that arent there
@@ibnmuhammad886 There were some valid points like not covering the awrah and waste of money and time but a muslim footballer can wear longer shorts and of course we shouldnt spend too much time on these things. Play sport with your friends and family its great exercise and good family bonding time as well if you watch a game together. Dont have your entire life revolve around it. Like most things in moderation its fine and when its excessive and causing you to miss prayer its haram but cant just declare it to be haram because it has a chance to become excessive.
@@hilal8461 The Ustadh literally said there is nothing wrong with going with your brothers to play football if it has benefit to stay fit for jihad and the like Also Abdur-Rahman Hassan was preceded by many scholars in this, such as Ibn Baz, so be careful of who you call “wild”.
@@ibnmuhammad886 The other points arent even worth addressing. No one is worshipping ronaldo and if they are then of course that is haram but it doesnt make the whole sport haram. And your right i shouldnt have called him wild, i edited my initial comment.
A muslim should live by Quran and Sunnah and connect it to everything in his life :) Have you watched the entire podcast ? Its not only his statement but preceded by scholars as well
So why not show the same passion against yasir qadhi or omar suleiman when they makes crazy statement regarding aqeedah As you do when ARH makes a fiqhi point about FOOTBALL
@@Muhammad-gm5ho Or maybe he is effected by the environment. The corruption in the west is really hard to keep out especially when you live in the middle of it. It will make you value little things more than the big things without even realizing. Allahu aalam
Very interesting to see how everyone now has their own definition of "extreme". Sheikh Abdurahman Hassan is someone who puts a lot of his time into the dawa. Comments like "he has too much time for such thoughts" are disrespectful. Do you think the enemies of greater scholars of the past were also concerned about the time of the scholars? Shariah just works like that, you take the evidence we know and try to implement it into today. People do not understand that one should not only look at the results of past scholars, but their approach to interpreting the evidence. This video and these comments prove to me once again that the biggest problem in our society is the lack of respect for differences of opinion. May Allah guide us
then he should stick to Dawah and not get in Fatwa /fiqh.... cause he translated the hadeeth in 9:26 wrong... he did qeyas (comparison) of sport game to Jenaya (crime)....so if he puts a lot of his time into Dawah, it's really good for him and the rest that he just focuses on that.
There is a lot of stuff he said which leads to being extreme, For example “ man made laws “, I can tell he probably passes a red light, Cos it’s not the law of Allah it’s a man made law 😂, Also the fact that he mentioned the hadith saying some scholars classes it as weak and some hasan but we don’t know for sure, Why are you even mentioning it then 😂 If you’re not sure of it’s authenticity we don’t use that hadith as evidence for our arguments or situation. I have nothing against this Abdulrahman Hassan, But I believe the things he said here are wrong, But some people make mistakes, We shouldn’t condemn him, But I just disagree with him
Ustadh abdirahman is so knowledgeable and has benefitted the ummah, you are not in the same level of knowledge to refute such a knowledgable teacher of deen.....
@@صلاحالدينإسماعيل-ح6ب No i dont, i am not a scholar in islam to argue with Ustad Abdirahman, he has many valid point that i agree with and some I dont agree with but i cannot stay i know Islam or Quran more than such a knowledgable person....he has helped in so many of his videos with so much information
I don’t agree with the Ustadh on this matter but in fairness, he did mention many other reasonable points. You just focussed on a few of the less convincing points
After watching the entire podcast I honestly agree with a lot of what the brothers were saying. There’s nothing wrong with playing football, but watching these professional games does seem to lead to haram or can even be haram to watch. It’s also a huge waste of time, and it encourages a lot of bad behaviour to the point of people being obsessive or even idolize these players. We should definitely avoid watching it, however nothing wrong with playing the sport as long as certain conditions are met.
With all that being said where did ALLAH say it was haram? They always use it leads to haram smh...By the logic it's haram for you not to buy an alarm clock, or haram for you not to turn it on bc it can lead to you over sleeping fajr...As far as being obsessive ie extreme ppl can do that in many things including the deen...This line of thinking, is a new religion not Al Islam! And it causes ppl to legislate things ALLAH swt has not legislated.
Anything can drive u into addiction thats where u need to control urself... even playing football should be avoided also based on your argument as at some points you'll keep playing to the point you forget to even pray (happened with me lot of times lol). It's all up to you bro
Once some imam said to boycott zakir naik because he uses Christian, Jewish, hindu scripture in his speech and that we should not use non-Muslim things for dawah , then my uncle stood up and said brother ma-sha-allah the mic and speaker you are using is surely invented by and made by Muslims.
I am from Russia 🇷🇺 Allah blessed me with a good voice, so I decorated him when reciting the Qur’an, so is there any fan of the people of the Qur’an? And may Allah reward you with the best reward ❤️🌙
Allahumma baarik brother Abdulrahman. He’s such a knowledgeable man. I do listen to him a lot and I always learn a lot from him. However, brother Mohammad Hijab, you got to understand that كل ابن ءادم خطا and you could also talk of this matter in very different way. You need to talk of the goodness of the person then try and rectify if there might be errors in his speech. This religion is naseeha and even our habib and Sayyid Muhammad Salallahu Aleihi wasallam didn’t respond harshly to the bedouin who urinated in the middle of the mosque and in fact let him finish only to calmly tell the matter afterwards. It’s the Sunnah of the Prophet SAW to explain politely to one another. Wallahu A’lam
Very true... I have benefited a lot from Ustadh Abdulrahman Hassan's lectures, dawrahs... its really sad to see how people are belittling him... though i watch football myself... Ustadh has so many valid points... when u see these football matches u can constantly see they put up ads of alcohol and rainbow (lgbtq).... their awrahs are seen... their bodies are full of tattoos.... young men try to follow them... I agree with him that its a fitnah for sure... i dont like the manner or speech that Brother Hijaab is using... plz learn to respect others... this is really sad...
Footballers are glorified and glorifying a person who is a disbeliever is not appropriate... simple point that was being made. Ustadh Abdulrahman has so much beneficial knowledge. Please watch his content rather than make judgements of him from a few minute clips. Jazak Allahu Khairan.
@@SpaceCadetIsabellaWa iyakum. haven't followed this channel, so I don't know what the agenda is, if any. There was a comment by someone else showing on top of this video with excellent and concise breakdown of different factors to consider when addressing something like modern football, but it somehow disappeared.
Refrain from speaking Ill of others. We may disagree with the point , bring it up and discuss it in a better manner . May Allah him and us to do better
@@onabillchoudhury4470 And if you ask them, they will surely say, ‘We were only conversing and playing.’ Say, ‘Is it Allah and His verses and His Messenger that you were mocking?’” [at-Tawbah 9:64-65].
When you think you are so righteous that you raise the bar of Islam so high that it becomes difficult for others to practice May Allah give us beneficial knowledge and humble us
@@Alpine1996 Do we live in the same world? What's happening is exactly the opposite! People are doing haraam stuff, thinking it's halal or that's it's no big deal. It doesn't mean something is halal just because you haven't heard it's prohibited and because everyone else is doing it.
@@Alpine1996 Apart from the issues brother Hijab has addressed, ustadh Abdulrahman has talked for 2,5 hours regarding SO MANY issues of football. And you say "there is no Hadith or Ayah that can even be secondarily used to forbid a Muslim from partaking." Personally, seeing a man's awrah is enough for me. And I am one who is struggling with abandoning watching football. I hope ustadh Abdulrahman's video helps me to abandon it once and for all. And what about the music on the stadiums and the music played in almost every commercial pause on TV (seeing at your profile, you seem to not have any issues with music), the almost-naked women shown in the stands, idolizing the players, wasting time, being happy or sad for useless things, etc.? I understand if many of you blame the ustadh for some of his conclusions mentioned in this bro Hijab's video, but most of you seem to make halal what is obviously haram. I would also like Hijab to talk about these other points. Also, I am certain that if brother Hijab has made such a video, he did not give all of you a green light to show in the comments all your "kindness", frustrations, and disrespect toward learned people. His whims and desires??? "Stupid" conclusions? How disrespectful!
@@Alpine1996 You also seem to have misused the Imam Malik's example? What about it? Are you saying the sheikhs and daees should not talk about the issues they see present in their people? Should they only "look at their own plate"? Are you sure Allah will not ask them why did they not speak up, raise their voices? People know the Sharia well enough to avoid most sins? I don't see that on the streets, mate. Nor on social networks. So, you think no one should advise people to not watch football? Well, seeing the detrimental effects only watching highlights, searching for streams (to watch a few minutes of a live match), reading football news, and following a club and it's players had on me and many youngsters (if not all), I congratulate ustadh Abdulrahman for making a video about this. Honestly, I would question my eman if I did not see anything problematic in watching football.
Brother Hijab. The thing- is why so triggered? If you do not agree with it it's fine. The worst honestly that would happen is many will stop watching football and life will move on. I cannot imagine Abu Bakar if he today was alive he would tune in and watch NBA or NFL/Soccer and whatever else there is. What would he do with the music in the background or the women that come on during halftime/sidelines ect.. It's just not befitting. Your reaction is overkill. Chillllll.
Bro if this is the case, The children making up their own games are also haram. Not even that, playing PlayStation is also haram and etc. This logic is also just so bad. This is extreme! Understand that this religion is a religion of balance. We can play games. As long as they are halal and have no haram content in it. - this fiasco reminds me when they said that Nike was haram to wear. Altough I see the wisdom in that verdict. It does open up a can of worms. Because then that logic needs to be applied to everything. Like buying cars, buying certain pens and etc. Not even that, allot of things which we do on a daily basis are of pagan origin. For example, most of us eat an egg in the morning because we like to and it’s a tradition for most cultures to have this food item with their breakfast. Little do many people know that this practice has an pagan origin. Like Mufti Muneer said: “ if you are gonna apply this logic, apply it fully not partially”.
@@heartsxday you got a playlist on your account with women on a beach doing yoga, somali girls dancing and other weird stuff. i actually get disgusted by people like you. Before talking watch your own sins.
Mohammed Hijab wrestling was done in the Prophet's time, doesn't ARH know that there are plenty of rules in wrestling? Didn't the Prophet defeat the top wrestler of the day which led to a his conversion?
What rules were there in wrestling during the Prophet's time? صلى الله عليه وسلم Secondly, do not compare wrestling during his صلى الله عليه وسلم time to the football programs we have today
@@MysticYusha You are mentioning ISLAMIC RULES. How does that tie in with what we are talking about (football and the rules ARH is saying goes AGAINST Islamic rulings)? Had you brought an example of a wrestling rule that contradicted the Shariah then your example would have made sense. I personally don't find this argument of ARH to be strong. If you watch his full video he does mention other aspects of football with go against Islamic teachings.
If you disagree, make your points in a manner in which you deliver the proofs clearly to the people on how he is wrong without using old pictures (being childish) and talking down on him in such a manner. Respectfully disagree then deliver your points, these unnecessary and childish actions will be followed by heavy questions from الله on the day of judgement. Fear Allah and atleast change the picture.
We often times forget that backbiting is backbi whether done on social media or in real life. You will be held accountable for every comment you make. Social media is REALITY and you will have to face the severity of the things that you type. Imagine hundreds or even thousands of people residing your comments where you backbite and or slander a brother/sister. Subhanallah, imagine the severity. Fear Allah. Again, backbiting is backbiting, even if done from behind a screen. A lot of you should really be ashamed of yourselves.
So it's ok when one has a history of the culture of refutations orchestrated, then when one is on the receiving end of a refutation, we cry foul (excuse the pun)?
Respect to shikh abdurahman Hassan ,most of points he made made a clear sense and unfortunately some people dislike and fight each other over non believers they support
A beautiful response of Ustadh Abdur Rehman Hassan to the criticism he faced in his opinions. I used to watch and admire brother Hijab but after looking at the manners of Ustadh, Brother Hijab just lost the level of respect I had now that I recall his debates and how he replies usually. Mohammed Hijab brought the points that are not as strong as his other arguments and proof. That was a long podcast, he took only fractions of it. May Allah guides us all and give us the ability to understand one another without any disease of the heart within us. Ameen Response: th-cam.com/video/78kq14dMCmY/w-d-xo.html
@reshmaazadsheriff1344 well I'm not sure now... but you can still listen to the podcast if you wish on AMAU channel... Also the ustadh is now gone may more serious in learning and teaching the deen of Allah - you should check out the academy He & Ustadh Tim Humble are running and various lessons. Muhammad Hijab is just some random person speaking about things he don't know... If he is good in one thing - doesn't make Hijab good in others...
Even as a big football fan i can see the idolatry & "idol worship" from fans towards their idols as being a contradiction to Islam. The chanting at times is almost "religious". I actually think that the religion of a lot of English people is football.
Not religious at all, but even I can see that. Not sure how hijab can't understand that obvious point. For gods sakes ronaldo is idolized like a god in the middle east. The dude has half a billion instagram followers. Its quite bizarre tbh.
@@saraelmi875 Ustadz never ruled out "playing Football being Haraam" He Specifically mentioned that. His whole talk was focused on "Watching Football" and he stated that in the beginning. Youth should be doing things instead of watching things. I'd say throw them in the Park and have them play in that same time they are watching the game. Talking about more beneficial vs less beneficial argumentation. and we have better things to do.
Narrated `Ali: I relate the traditions of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) to you for I would rather fall from the sky than attribute something to him falsely. But when I tell you a thing which is between you and me, then no doubt, war is guile. I heard Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) saying, "In the last days of this world there will appear some young foolish people who will use (in their claim) the best speech of all people (i.e. the Qur'an) and they will abandon Islam as an arrow going through the game. Their belief will not go beyond their throats (i.e. they will have practically no belief).
So "man made laws" forbidden in football, which are actually just rules whilst participating in a game, but all the real man made laws in Saudi are justified e.g. Interest, music concerts....? Saudi hosts big international boxing fights, which in his context given, ticks all the boxes of football but to a bigger degree i.e. more awrah, more brutal. At this stage, all you'll hear is FIX YOURSELF.
@@تعلومة-ز1ر not angry, just expressing. Nk need for foul language. I'm basing it on this person and their support for Saudi regime. Just see a massive contradiction on this topic of man made laws. If someone wants to discuss man made laws, they should actually address it based on all our muslim nations who have man made laws in a govt/societal level and not base it on a football game where this discussion is not in context. Also muslim nations which people want to give immunity from criticism
@@yasin8396 no need for it the fact that he it’s worse than major sins in fact when Shirk is the only thing that is worse than major sins think 🤔 where is he gonna do with shirk is he gonna say shirk is worse than football why didn’t Allah talked about football or even Mohammed pbuh it’s crazy how you guys think because if shirk is only worse than football surely Allah would talk about it or Mohammed pbuh
@@Sweeti924 wallahi I love you for the sake of Allah, but it’s hard to understand what you have wrote and I fear that I would miss quote you if I tried to reply.
Should I not love my mother because she’s not a muslim and I am? Can I not say that the halal food she has prepared for me is delicious? These people want to make life difficult for everyone.
@@snap_fit8686 Hey pal. You need to grow out of this 2001 911 mindset. Its outdated. Guys like you are Saturday morning cartoon villains with logically fallacious arguments that are like old meat you try to put gravy on to make make its seem edible, in this case the gravy is emotional provocation and regurgitating arguments back at people. Tell you what though, you wouldn’t do this with the Jews, otherwise you’ll be labelled as anti Semitic. You might try it but it won’t end well.
@@abdullahx4908 what ? What have i done wrong ? That guy is saying as if combat sport is haraam because we dont alowed to hit someone head .. well we learn boxing wrestling or other is so we dont get hit in the head .. so dont say boxing is haraam because it does not make sense
Huge difference between when you’re refuting someone like apostate prophet and when you’re refuting a Muslim brother. Why’re you using old pictures being childish and belittling the brother ? Respectfully disagree, drive your points home and khalaas, this is a Muslim brother. Wallahi thuma wallahi لتُسألن
In my opinion the man is wrong but please don't be too harsh on him from what I've seen of him he is very good and has lots of knowledge we can learn from may Allah bless us all and guide us on the straight path.
I’m not a scholar but even I know that there’s a lot about football that should worry a Muslim, the feigning of injury, the cheating and corruption, gambling etc etc. So for you to think that there’s nothing wrong with professional football as we know it in England also raises some concerns. I agree there’s some good in it, no doubt, but am pretty sure there are more bad in it these days. And Allaah knows best.
Not even mentioning the time wasting and that we will be asked for how we utilised our time! Also just thinking about the issues of ‘shirt swapping’ or whatever and feeling as if it’s blessed or whatever is just disgusting tbh
All of these issues you mentioned are individual issues not issues with the game itself. Because people can gamble on anything and in order to watch a game or play there is no obligation to gamble. And its not a waste of time because in actuality it brings communties closer together and allows for a segway of communication and interaction between different faiths so we can get along better as a society. Its even an opportunity for Dawah by seeing so many muslim players like Kante, Salah, Mane, Ozil etc with how generous in donation they are and when they stick to their convictions there are many people who watch this and become inspired and want to learn more about islam. The same way wrestling back in the time of the prophet Muhammad Salalahualaihiwasalam was watched by others and people of different faiths wrestled eachother and praised eachother for their wrestling abilities and techniques the same is done with Futbol no? If anything as muslims we should work harder to make the sport more dominated by muslim athletes so we can have a greater influence in being able to give dawah.
@@donutwarrior8596 you have mentioned some good points and no doubt there are benefits in sports such as football however one thing me and you know for sure is that the negatives outweigh the positives. One can sit down for 90 min on his backside being so endorsed, screaming cheering and stressing himself out for 21 people who don’t even know who he is so he’s ultimately just tiring himself. And when it comes to prayer he wants to rush it as quickly as possible to go back into watching the game and perhaps can’t even wake up for qiyaam layl. I’m just mentioning some realities here bro. I get your points especially the dawah bit but bro how can you give dawah if you need dawah yourself? (And I’m not taking about you directly lol) Save yourself first before you try to help others bro. Learn your religion seek knowledge, then start giving dawah to your family members AND THEN we can talk about other people
@@lookaway375 it depends on the individual, but to label it haram for everyone just doesnt make any sense. The things you are talking about are characteristic flaws of individuals who watch or play not issues with the game itself. Its similar to how there are some people who do bad things in the name of religion. The religion isnt to blame its the individuals who chose to act irresponsibly.
I’m 44 and have played football my whole life and I also coach…. I must say it’s haram because it’s a big distraction on people. It consumes their minds too much. I think playing sport just for fun is ok So professional sports I say is haram but recreational… No
I just wonder if it's possible that one is able to perform an open-mind or open-heart surgery on matters of Faith (Iman) in order to judge a professional Muslim footballer? I'm convinced that this is only in the hands of Allah Azza Wa Jal. No need for man-made judgements here, excuse the pun.
@Nograveworship Firstly, could I humbly ask you to refrain from any name-calling since I didn't initiate any. Secondly, I'm not sure what are you referring to? I was responding to this comment by @Sam W. No mention about the name of the Ustads here! Thirdly, you seem to casually whitewash and veneer my assertion and fact that there is not a single being, in the totality of Allah's creation, that can perform an open-mind and open-heart operation/surgery, to determine or make judgements of matters of Faith. Fourthly, Actions judged by Allah alone: "*Actions are Judged by Intentions*" - Forty Hadith 1 [Al-Bukhari & Muslim] Fifthly, a vast majority of Muslim Football Players such as Mohamed Salih, Sadio Mane, Paul Progba, Hamza Choudhury, Mezut Ozil, Riyad Mahrez, etc., have become much-loved household names for leading and being the torch-bearers of Islam for Muslims in the Footballing world and role models for our kids should they also take up the sport. Let's just for the moment, hop over to UFC. Have we seen the impact of Khabib Nurmagomedov as a role model in sport? Massive! Do we tell him what he was doing was Haram? Let's now hop over to Rugby. Have we seen the impact of Sonny Bill Williams as a role model in sport? Do we tell him what he was doing and still doing is was/is Haram? I can quote pages and pages examples. Let's also not forget the late Muhammed Ali and numerous other sportsmen and sportswomen spreading across sporting disciplines. Finally, herein exist my qualm. Indeed the are a few minor exceptions, but just a few names mentioned above, I haven't come across an incident where they may have acted indecently and inappropriately within the realm of being a Muslim. I never made any judgement calls except stating the obvious, i.e. the conclusion of "man-made" judgement!
First I thought he would say to avoid football because it attracts a lot of racists, the football hooligans for example. But he talk about breaking bones and whatnot. With that logic, you pretty much can't leave your home, exercise and do your daily chores. You can get an accident on your way to work or school and break something.... it sounds like as if he is against socialising/working, or associating with non Muslim as much. Edit; maybe not with non Muslims, but trying to avoid things that have high risk of injuries, which is pretty almost anything, you can trip down the stairs at home and break something for example.
@@ibnmuhammad886 explain it because you obviously have, who is he to say that football is forbidden. He might have more knowledge then me but he is an idiot
@@ibnmuhammad886 His explanation didn't make sense at all. Even with your version. You are purposely trying to deflect that on others for some odd reason!
Brother hijab please dont treat muslim brothers who have different opinion than you like how to treat non muslims.... the words and the tone u used is almost exact as u used against the enemies of islam....... u are making muslims hate muslims..... please humble urself and react to opposing opinions in a better fashion... jazakALLAH
This argument against fotball is insanity, no offence. Sounds like trying to make something Haram for Haram's sake. If people lived like this you wouldn't leave your house or do anything. Sport is very good for people.
@@TazImahc I'm not a Muslim so yes. But also Muslim girls can play together for fun and fitness without men. And they can also watch women's sports on TV.
@Member of the universe Football for normal people still uses a Referee. His argument is stupid about man made laws. So you're saying to play football without a Referee? Stay in YOUR lane of stupidity.
Are we going to follow our desires vs the truth? Abdul Rahman mentioned dozens of reasons why football is not good. MH only touched on two or three of his points and we are here agreeing with him.. MH should make a full video refuting every single point and only then we can judge.. If MH cannot refute all points then its safe to say Abdul Rahman is right... What about the scholars he referenced? The prophet pbuh praised a non-believer because what they said was in line with Islam just like we can practice cultural customs as long they are in line with Islam..
Who made Abdul Rehman the authority ? This is the problem ...You guys listen to these young guys who go abroad and study for a few years and all of a sudden they become an authority for you and they start giving rulings and even fatawa ..Come to Hijaz and sit with the Lajna Daimah and learn your deen from the real scholars.
No he is not Abdul Azim Al Hindee, but below are my teachers who I have personally studied under over the last 25 years and they have not come out with the nonsense I keep hearing time and time again from this young student of knowledge...Thats exactly what he is, "young' and a "student" ...Perhaps he should pay more attention in class and ask the teacher if he don't understand rather than come up with his own misguided understanding and rulings. Anyway Allah and Mohammed sallalaho alayhee wasslaam are the authority first and foremost and then the 1st 3 generations and the Salaf who came after them to this present day. Shaykh Abdul Aziz Al Shaykh, Shaykh Saleh Al Fawzan, Shaykh Abdullah Ibn Munee, Shaykh Saleh bin Mohammed al Luhaydan, Shaykh Salih bin Sa'd as Suhaymee, Shaykh Salih bin Abdul Aziz Sindi, Shaykh Ibrahim al Ruhayli, Shaykh Khalid al-Mushayqih, Shaykh Muqbil al Harbee, Shaykh Abdullah bin Zayd bin Muhammed al Musallam, Shaykh Abdul Aziz Mohammad as Sadhan.
Syaikh Sulaiman Ar Ruhaily, the syaikh of Masjid An-Nabawi, was give a fatwa regarding playing football and admiring non Muslim player or club. He said the basic ruling of sport is mubah (allowed). It become haram if there are sharia violation in it, otherwise it should be allowed. Wallahu a'lam bishawab.
I agree, more critical thinking and arguments needed to come to those sort of conclusion. Differences are there, cultural, social etc etc one cannot ignore it- I guess.
Fear Allah Muhammed. You’ve been grazing in the meadows and pastures of Aristotle, Plato and Ibn Sina to the point where you’ve filled your belly with philosophy and egocentricity. The Ustadh is clearly trying to divert the people’s attention from things that don’t benefit them to tawhid. Remember Allah (swt) said: وَإِذَا ذُكِرَ اللَّهُ وَحْدَهُ اشْمَأَزَّتْ قُلُوبُ الَّذِينَ لَا يُؤْمِنُونَ بِالْآخِرَةِ ۖ وَإِذَا ذُكِرَ الَّذِينَ مِن دُونِهِ إِذَا هُمْ يَسْتَبْشِرُونَ And when Allah is mentioned alone, the hearts of those who do not believe in the Hereafter shrink with aversion, but when those [worshipped] other than Him are mentioned, immediately they rejoice. Think deeply about this ayah and I ask Allah to guide us to the straight path, Ameen
Diverting attention from football and calling Muslims who enjoy football match munafik are two different things. Clearly there are better activities for Muslims than to support a football team but it does not mean it is Haram. His fatwa was weak, majority of scholars will disagree with him on this matter. What I think could be considered Haram in today's football is the women they show when the cameras are on the audience. They are usually half naked.
@@Empiricist14 @Fabio1349 Sure, it is all about sex in marriage. Sex is mentioned in the Quran and prophet Muhammad peace and blessing be upon him explained what is lawful in the intercourse. Most men marry one wife but polygamy is needed in some cases. My great grandma straight after second world war was cheated on by my great granddad. He had child with another woman and lived double life. There were simply not enough men around and so many children were born out of wedlock. Polygamy would solve such issue and give dignity to both mistress and the child. Having a wife is different to having a side b**ch. Every wife needs to have a house provided for her and equal time needs to be shared among wives. It is more headache than pleasure for the man at the end.
As usual. Ustadh brings Ayaat, Ahadiith and sayings of the Sahaba and Ulama, whilst the critiques uses "logic" and "critical thinking". HasbunAllah wa ni3mal Wakeel
Of course you have to bring Ayat, Ahadith, Fiqh and Sharia rules into this, what muhammad hijab tried to explain is that you not only have to consist the knowledge but more importantly understand the meaning of all it.
The use of sound reasoning in making sense of adillat from the Quran and Sunnah is needed in order to form correct judgements. Bringing ayaat and ahaadith without proper critical analysis leads to misapplication of the adillat. This was clearly shown in Ustadh's Abdurrahman's use of the verse 44 from surat al Ma'idah in forbidding football. Disparaging Mo Hijab's arguments under the convenient pretext of 'Ustadh using ayaat and ahaadith' is totally delusional. Furthermore, Mo Hijab clearly used evidence from the Quran and sunnah in putting forth his arguments.
Show us ayat, ahadith, and sayings of the Sahaba and Ulama that say football is haram. You won't be able to provide evidence. What will you do then? You'll use qiyas and logic to arrive at these conclusions. And yet you critique Hijab when he uses logic.
People need to realise that Abdulrahman hassan is a student of knowledge, khalas. Don’t blindly follow people, learn your deen from the authentic books and them only, Allahu A’lam
About the term student of knowledge, which people use today, what kind of level in islamic science does it have. Because if we see the students of the past, for example of imam malik or other scholars, they already reach some level of ijtihad
@Master ROSHI Thanx for ur answer. But i was refering more about the term student of knowlege of today. Can we compare for example those students of today with the students of the past?
@1ummah I have a question for u. When u hear lectures, or answers, of scholars did u check everything they say if its fits with quran n sunnah and understanding of the salaf?
If you finish a higher eduation and get a degree it doesn't mean you are suddenly smartest and sharpest mind out there where you can insensibly make all kind of claims and be righteous about them.
الله يبارك فيك و يكرمك و يحفظك من كل سوء او شر و تكون فالفردوس الاعلى مع الصحابة ويثبتك علي فتح عقول الناس و عنيها زي ما فتحت عقلي وكنت سبب في قربي لله اكتر و اكتر
guys I get that brothers reasoning is a bit far fetched and he was very strict with it . But mashallah the iman he must have to be so stringent and strict with his analysis. wallah instead of dissing him straight up, give bro his props too.
But one thing is being strict and another is warping things to fit your narrative. Being strict in avoiding haram things is one thing but to outright label something is haram with dubious claims regarding rules and regulations in a game and all kinds of other nonsensical claims i must say is just wreckless and irresponsible especially those who watch his content closely and take advice from him should be weary.
This is what happens when you try to preach Islam by studying everything under the sun except Islam itself from classical sources. It results in us putting our own limited, human logic over Quran and sunnah. Ustadh ARH didn't make a fatwa, if you watch the podcast, he transmitted one made by ibn baz among others.
Everyone, let’s not bash the brother. He has stated his view. We shouldn’t insult or make fun of him, since he may be more beloved to Allah than you or me. Edit: I’m talking about people in the comment section-Mohammed Hijab is being respectful.
I can agree with that. As much as i agree with brother Hijab in this video, i think he can take a more appropriate approach to correct the speaker he is referring to. I also think there is a underlying, more fundamental issue which some Muslims like the speaker in the video hold that leads them to such radically different views. I think we need to find that out first and discuss that in a respectable way. I think that issue is about coexisting with non-Muslims.
@@checkmate5338 I wasn’t talking about brother Mohammed Hijab Akhi. More or less, he was respectful in the video. I was referring to the people in the comment section making fun of the other brother.
@everything has an ending I can’t speak for you Brother, but this man is definitely more knowledgeable than me. Any valid difference of opinion needs to be respected.
I used to think you were arrogant from misreading certain videos I’ve watched of you. I watched quiet a few of your videos now your whole debate with Wood who you turnt to fire Wood ‘ bun him up’ and I must say I admire you ahki your knowledge how you convey your opinion alhamdulillah you’ve made me want to study the religion so much more so i can be strong when faced with people trying to talk down on the religion. All praise to Allah but thank you for being such a good example of a Muslim for the brothers wallah 👊🏽👊🏽
I am pretty sure even many salafi preachers won't agree with what ustadh AbdulRahman Hassan had to say on this issue. Watched a recent video of sheikh Assim al Hakeem about watching football & supporting football team, even though sh. Assim is not a fan of watching football, his response was in line with Muhammad Hijab's response. He did not say it is haram to watch football & when asked if it is kufr he replied that to say supporting a football team is kufr is ridiculous. He also mentioned muslim supporting romans against persian.
it also has terms and conditions which he is forced to comply with which directly conflict with sharia like allowing others to curse the prophet Muhammad
@@ibnmuhammad886 He took a pictures but did he praised it? did he worshiped it or supported it? No? I don't see any problem here. Also maybe it was a mistake as mistakes can happen.
I love BOTH ustadh Abdul Rahman Hassan and Muhammad Hijab. I wish we could engage in civilised dialogue. Many shuyookh have changed their opinion with new knowledge, I just don’t want any toxicity with these beloved brothers.
Exactly, mohammed hijab should address the shiekh in private. This is childish tbh. This videos that go back and forth create controversy and a toxic environment which we don't want
@@ajhammer1701 no disrespect akhi but your understanding to mine understanding of who is a student of knowledge and who is a heavyweight it's like a fishpond compared to 7 seven seas of ink that will never exhaust even if all the trees of the world were pens to write it down, surely the world would run out of pens without even diminishing those oceans slightly, and I'm a miskeen being happy if Allah blesses me with a 100th part of a drop from that ocean. In sha Allah, I hope this gives you some perspective regarding ilm and at what depth the true ulema/inheritors of prophets go.
Disagreeing with someone on a matter is not bashing,nor does it prevent good realtions. You can be someones brother in Islam and still confront them about ideas they have shared publicly. No one says "oh first you said you love your wife and then you refuse to buy her this bag", one doesnt prevent the other.
Hijab is someone I respected so much and always felt bad when he's refuted. But I guess you wrong here because the guy never said playing football is Haram. Rather the way it's done all over the world like showing the Aurat and their earning are not from halal means from what I understand plus a lot of Haram they get into. So it's not advisable to choose it as a professional. Wallau alam
I dont know if its Haram or not what i know is and fact which even Non Muslims would agree that football or any sport is waste of time and im not very good Muslim but i know every minute in this life we are given should not be wasted its haram to waste time. May ALLAH guide us.
@@umertracker816 by indulging in physical activities like sports like football, I gain health. Besides, it is sunnah to be fit. Just because Madkhalis are the most unhealthiest sect of Islam, doesn't mean they can issue fatwas against good activities.
That "imam" will struggle in the real world outside of his jubba. Critical thinkers will be denounced as heretics. That man is a danger to himself before anyone else
@@redtyphon9919 i implied that😊 My point was he doesnt even realise what harm he is doing to himself thus is in need of help 1st & foremost. I accept that its tantamount to making an excuse for him.
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم السلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته It is clear from reading this comments section that some people have done an absolutely pathetic job of trying to understand the arguments made by the respected Ustadh (حفظه الله) and infact completely butchered what was said. You see comments like "O well, don't follow traffic laws then" or "well then children who make their own games are ruling by other than Allah Azzawajal's Law" etc. Anyone who had watched the podcast would know that the Ustadh explicitly said this is not what he meant. Then there were those who said that "Then we shouldn't leave our houses because we can get injured". Once again the point was, Football as a game HAS SCOPE FOR FOULING. There are two types of tackling (according to football). One that is allowed, and that is off the Ball, and the second is that of the player which is not allowed. There are players WHO MALICIOUSLY TACKLE TO OBTAIN AND INJURY and The Ustadh made the point that the most such players will get is a red card or perhaps a fine. This is the problematic issue since these specific rules of football completely contradict Islamic rulings on Qisas as explained by the Ustadh. A better analogy for this would be, you go on the street and purposefully trip someone leading to them breaking their leg. This is not allowed in football but there is provisions for it to take place WITHOUT THE PLAYER RECEIVING ANYTHING MORE THAN A RED CARD OR FINE. This clearly shows how deep the love of football has penetrated the hearts that people who loosened their tongues and backbitten the Ustadh severely due to their beloved being attacked. We ask Allah Azzawajal alone for justice THIS IS PURPOSEFUL INJURY, NOT ACCIDENTAL EVEN
@@imaknexus Brother Hijab selectively refuted the points. Watch the full podcast and decide for yourself. I'm not taking any sides. Just trying to be balanced..
@@RaihanShaheed i agree brother abdulrahman says alot of things that totally makes sense why the football industry is garbage but he doesnt really know the sport itself and its rulings.
@@abdisalan10 Yeah he pointed out many things for saying it is haram. If any one single point of his stands, then it would make it haram. So if it is going to be refuted, every single point should be refuted. Not just the few selected weaker ones. الله أعلم
The problem is that some people are disconnected from their surroundings. I'm not saying we should accept everything in the society we live in, but atleast have some awareness and knowledge of what's going on around you! (i.e. the other brother gave real-life example/experience of colleagues at work. You don't HAVE to love them!...but he says this because he is part of the society he lives in and understands it!).
Imagine our prophet saw said we wont do business with mushrikeen yahudis and nasaras. SORRY but their dawah is a joke... i feel like its stopping the muslims from developing. Extremist thinking and lack of understanding
I ask you guys to watch the entirety of ARH's video regarding this before joining a discussion on a topic we are jahil on, and engage in back biting calling people extreme.
This is what happens when you really really want to prove something is haraam. Your ego takes command of your brain. Rather take a balanced approach and warn people against excessively watching of football
I believe we shouldn't do anything that contains more bad than good that's a reason why god forbid alcohool because the bad is greater than the goodness of it
I'm a dedicated subscriber and viewer of this channel but I have to admit that Ustadh Abdurrahman Hassan does make some good points which causes one to think. What's so special about watching or playing football anyway? It might not be haram or sinful but in essence, it's just entertainment and a relatively tame manner to while away time. Also, Hijab came off as quite a bit rude and arrogant towards AH. May Allah forgive us and guide us all. Ameen.
Yeah honestly he needs to be a bit humble. He's right most of the times but shouldnt he personally talk with him first? The first thing he does us go online and make a video about it.
This isn’t how you should be addressing nor critiquing another person of knowledge. Why are you always speaking with such pomp and arrogance ? You can say “with all due respect” as much as you like but your smirk and choice of wording hides nothing. Regardless of whether or not he said the wrong this, your reacting and your pomp and arrogance and treatment of another Muslim leads me to believe you have too much Pride in your heart. Do not think you have become someone Mohammed Hijab for you are less than a drop of water in the ocean just like the rest of us. May Allah have mercy on us.
You didn’t even start the video off explaining who this person is and how much good he has done for others. Instead I’m looking at the comments in this video and people are suggesting he’s a radical and he doesn’t know what he’s talking about. Astaghfirullah. This is the type of behaviour you promote on your platform?
Look at the bloody TH-cam comments ??? Why are all your people attacking him? A year ago you did a whole interview with him and even then you couldn’t speak to the brother respectfully. Now look at your followers and look at the things they say about the Ustadh. Look at the majority of the comments on this video and you tell me if you did more good than bad ????
The way I see it is that Muhammad Hijab's response is the unreasonable one Just because it is hypothetically possible to rule according to the Islamic laws if the game is played in a place where Sharia is applied does not mean that there is no problem when Muslims support this system in which no crime is punished according to the Islamic laws , whether it is cheating or insulting players and fans or causing injures you will not find anywhere in the world where football-related crimes are dealt with according to Islamic laws And you shouldn't ridicule someone just for addressing this problem
All of those things you mentioned are against the rules and nobody accepts them (except some for the cheating one). What Mohammed Hijab said makes sense. By the way, if you accept this line of thinking, then all contact sports would be impermissible according to you along with most other sports.
Scholars of old would refrain and fear giving fatwa on even the simplest matters of Deen. Nowadays it is norm to see or hear a student of Deen confidently and at times egotistically pass a ruling over a grave matter. May Allah guide us all, Amiin.
@Ibn Kamal Al-Hanbali If ibn uthaymeen said the same thing, it holds more weight because it is coming from him(a world renowned scholar) rather than an unknown usthath.
@Ibn Kamal Al-Hanbali no
Beautifully Put Brother Bilal.
It's a fatwa sale
is kafala system halal in Saudi Arabia?
So many ppl in the comment section are being rude and calling the sheikh names. It doesn't matter if he's wrong, mind your tongues guys. Your deeds will go into his account
The thing is people who listens to him they come and type haram haram on videos and i know everybody has there own opinion but all they type is (haram) and they are not giving any explanation why is it haram and if they give explanation and reasoning they don't make a lot of sense and if someone told them that they might be wrong they will not listen. May Allah forgive us all Muslims and show all of us the right way.
Important comment
This so called Sheikh/Ustadz will be the one judged for opening his mouth without thinking of the consequences in the public domain. Guy must have lived in a deep dark hole all his life. He's causing fitnah to the Deen.
Yhh even I disagree with some of the stuff he said, But why condemn him? Why insult him? I disagree but I’m not gonna have hatred or condemn him for a belief he has, Cos I don’t have nothing against him either I believe he’s done a lot of good
But I just disagree on some of these things here he said
@@uncledan2u there you go, Slandering again without knowing " the consequences in the public domain" as well as Akhira DOMAIN
Assalam o alaikum,
Bismillah. Brother Hijab you make some very valid points. Although, in defense of brother AbdulRahhman Hasan, he also made some valid points regarding the inherent backbiting and "tribal" behaviors associated with the sociology of the sport. And of course the point about the exposed 'Awrah of the football players and both men and women audiences observing this, was significant. In my opinion (which probably doesn't matter), I believe the problem isn't intrinsically with the mechanics of the sport but rather with what the sport has become. And I think that's what Muslims need to be cautious about. May Allah reward you all. Assalam o alaikum.
you can say the same thing about anything in these so I will say buying a phone is haram, going to school is haram, going on a holiday in haram.... so don't be stupid, watching football and playing it is not haram but it could be a little sinful like anything else in today's world but if you didn't commited the sin in purpose it will be forgiven.
@@marocmaghrib5524 It's very disrespectful of you, to say 'so don't be stupid' to a brother when he wasn't even being informal and childish. Have some basic respect, kid.
@@marocmaghrib5524how do you think something can be ‘a little sinful’ but it’s not haram? Do you even think about what you’re saying? The point was never that the game is haram, but more so watching it. If all the stuff you mentioned contain haram that can’t be avoided then without a doubt they would be haram as well.
@@ObscureServant what I am saying is those claims are a little extreme cause we have bigger problems in the world to fix like 'LGBTQ' and after that we can talk about football and holidays, if you are a true believer then yes but for biginner muslims it's better to not go that deep, the prophet himself PBUH did not went all the way with Quraish it was like baby steps (islam was going on secretly). Anyway that was just my point, talking about football is not a wise move.
@@999legend8 sorry bro that was just my way of talking
You need to stop using this style of belittling your brothers when they make a mistake. Just bring your evidences and arguments that he misjudged the situation.
Exactly.
I think you'll find MH and others are not interested in correcting what they perceive to be a mistake. Everything they do is calculated. These guys in their social media 'war' with spubs, actually took on their attributes...
The irony...
I agree with your points over all brothers. However, these people with no knowledge are leading our brothers astray and turning reverts back to ignorance. Look at the Salif they were harsh on fools that caused fitnah. The brother should be silent
He face an ignorant who claim having knowledge, and the issue is important.
If can't forbid something if it is something Allah have permit, الحكم الا لله, so we have to be carefull with ijtihad.
@@OptimisedHealth The only credibility we Muslims have is our adherence to Allahs book and Messenger (saw). Now if he is saying he does not like soccer that is fine. However soccer is not Haram. Allah hates that people make Halal things Haram. People must be held accountable. The "ruling" the brother gave was illogical and childish. If you do not understand deen do not speak on it
This is when you have too much time on your hand and finding problems where no problems exist
No problem?????
Awra being seen, wasting time, music , free mixing and more?
@@ibnmuhammad886 should i also ignore red light ?? Its a man made law
@@wawawick247 yes true and if it’s not possible to move into a Muslim country then you should try your best to stay away from all of that
@UCqiKknZacspmDQJpm248Bdg bruh
@@omar-9617 He gave you reasons why it's haram and you're talking about this?
This is dangerous making something halal if it’s haram and vice versa football is a sport Allah knows best
Ustadh responded th-cam.com/video/78kq14dMCmY/w-d-xo.html
Everything is halal till proven haram
@@burhaanmohamed19 The worst thing is that I see many people say "Since it's not mentioned in the Quran or Ahadith then it's haram". They say this about a lot of stuff.
is kafala system halal in Saudi Arabia?
The ustadh has a wealth of knowledge, he got it wrong on certain points here. May Allah reward him for his efforts, there is no need to mock him like people in the comments are doing.
@@Rukiya-z2b nothing to conceal when he makes his views public. Yes he has a lot of knowledge, but he also needs to live and breathe his knowledge. He gives of vibes of hate. He’s a bad example for other Muslims and non-muslims who are looking to learn about the religion.
Exactly, MH is only entertaining these fools like him. May Allah bless and preserve Ustadh Abdur Rahman
@@specter1019 I don’t think he that knowledgeable just because he memorised many txt and speak the Arabic language eloquently don’t mean he knowledgeable.
@@Taznoor1984 hes way better than Muhammad Hijab hes an Ustadh in matters of Deen while Muhammad Hijab is an daee and the fields of Muhammad Hijab and Ustadh are different , we shouldn't indulge our noses in the matters we aren't expert, just like Ustadh shouldn't indulge his noses in Comparative Religion and like Muhammad shouldn't indulge his noses in these matters both are good people in their respective fields , Hijab shouldn't go over and look at the few mistakes of the ustadh and openly make a rad of it hes not the one to make rad of him, many more knowledgeable scholars exist to correct the ustadh only if hes wrong but hes not wrong. I saw the video when Hijab published the video entitled "Refutation of a Muslim Preachers who forbids Football" then after some time he changed it to Correcting, Why is Hijab so desperate to conceal the mistakes of the Ustadh in Public? These kinds of mistakes (which you guys call so) can be settled in private if Hijab tried to contact the Ustadh Privately man ! I mean both Ustadh and Hijab lives in UK they can meet eachother and have a dinner and settle this thing or else even setting it in dms or somewhere else. Did Hijab did it? No he didn't. Look brother Hijab is one of the most famous daee in the world rn he has millions of followers all over the world now after he made this video the arrogants and ignorants will come in the comments section and backbite the ustadh will Hijab take the sins of the backbiting done in the comments section? Will he be responsible for it? Will he carry the sins of Ustadh in the day of Judgement? No worries Ustadh is getting free hasanah here
@@Taznoor1984 this proves how much humble Mr. Hijab is
السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
One big announcement!
Let's say brother Abdurrahman Hassan made a mistake for the sake of argument, this does not justify at all to backbite him and everyone who does this should repent immediately.
Rather we should ask Allah to guide him and us to the straight path and to reward him for his great work he has done for years.
Exactly!
Lol get outta here. Dumbness will be called out.
@@MrRebel247 Oh ignorance....
@@MrRebel247 May Allah guide you, Muhammad Hijab did a good job making this video, many people will backbite the ustadh in this comment section so he is getting free hasanah no worries lol
@@houseoftawhid Bro that's exactly the point, would you want them to eat their dead brother's flesh?
Moreover the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم said: الدين النصيحة (The Religion is Advise).
[Bukhari and Muslim]
So it's our obligation to call them out, but as I said, even if he did a misktake it doesn't justify to backbite him.
Refuting persons has its rulings as well as backbiting, so don't equate them
My only concern with fotball is showing of Aowrah (thighs), other than that it is up to the individual to give the game its size and place in his life as a "game".
Yes but Allah encourages us to exercise , football is one of the best form is exercise and is good for the mind and the body . Secondly it keeps the yout away from drugs and crime . So yes the sheikhs that forbid are ignorant about these issues
You're not obligated to expose your Aurah. Some players wear shorts that are a little bit too short but others wear shorts that do cover the Aurah. Maybe be hasnt watched soccer since the 80s lol back then yea they did wear practically booty shorts, but now you have many religious rights and accommodations you can get in these regards.
@@yahyaelmi8435
Exercise yes, that does allows to get uncovered (AWRAH)
You can wear compression to hide the thighs knees.
@AA thank you very much ill continue to watch it 😁
When you make the religion difficult there’s going to be a max exodus of youth from the faith. They go to public schools and are told movies, music, dating, drinking, etc are all haram. Fine no problem with that. But then you tell them chess is makruh and soccer is haram. What are they supposed to do? Don’t make things difficult on ppl that’s not the way of the religion.
I encourage my kids for social sports and discourse from commercial ones and being addicted to anything.
@ReBel kiD Essentially he is since there are rules that need to be followed (which he mentioned in hypothetical situations). IF we have taken the brother out of context and twisted his words, then know he and others in the refutation culture do exactly the same thing.
@@stevengrantofthegiftshop1549 Whats the point of discussing hypotheticals if it is going to cause fitnah? Can you answer please
There’s mass exodus of youths already
@@MultiOzzyProductions I'm talking about the fact that Sheikh Abdurahman was the one talking about hypotheticals
His awful breakdown can be applied to anything.
"Man-made laws" include stopping at a traffic light. I'm assuming this dude runs through red-lights since he doesn't follow "Man-made laws"
Going to hospital and waiting in-line...."Man-made laws"
He has other reasons. Watch the podcast idiot.
@@Haiofhqnnetula 🤣🤣 triggered
@@Haiofhqnnetula I know right, he actually made a reasonable argument in the podcast and also justified why he believes in his opinions
Brother, this man made law point is ONE point! How are you going to refute every other part of football being haram? The podcast is 2.5 HOURS LONG!
May Allah bless brother Abdulrahman Hassan and grant him Jannahtul Firdaws A'ala, and may Allah increase him in Knowledge of the Deen and strengthen, protect and preserve him. He made his points clear. If we are trying to modernised our Deen because of foolishness and desires then, this is what happened, felt bad when the truth is spoken.
May Allah bless you sister it's sad to see you (Mohamed hijab) talk about another Muslim like this I would like to speak to you about certain things in the park if your there there seems to be a strong hatred towards salafiyah or the people who identify as salafis. His opinion is his opinion.
Sister in Islam, Football is Not a part of our Deen, but may Allah increase Him in knowledge and us as well
Sister he is saying things no scholar said before that a yellow card in a game is ruling by other than sharia, there is no precedence for this in Islam that’s not modernising to reject flawed fiqh Allahu’Alim
If people started giving fatwahs with that logic and ignorance, it would eventually end up being haram to even get out of your house.
@@heartsxday i rather just die then literally anything is forbidden
Ustadh Abdulrahman Hassan is one of the best things that has happened to TH-cam. So much knowledge, so much akhlak and such a great example for the youth. Brother Mohammed, I like your videos where you defend Islam, but respectfully you are nowhere near the level of knowledge of someone like Ustad Abdulrahman Hassan. You are simply not even close to being qualified to even debate someone of his calibre. You may know a lot about philosophy and history but in actual Islamic Sciences you yourself know you don't count as a scholar or even a student of knowledge.
I rarely come to the defense of people, but I cannot begin to describe how beneficial the Ustad's lectures and videos have been to me and to the community who follows Al Madrasatu Al Umariyyah. It's difficult enough to find actual knowledgeable English-language Muslim content (note: knowledgeable, Speaker's Corner is just debating and da'wah, it's not the same; English Muslim social media is full of da'wah but desperately low on actual knowledge, Alhamdulillah I speak other languages so I can seek other Ustadhs). You should be humble and support the people of knowledge, because they are the heart of the Ummah, while you are supposed to be following them, not acting superior to them and exposing them to the youth who do not understand whom to look up to and whom to take knowledge from.
Please do not let your many followers and big status delude you into being arrogant, my brother. I hope anyone reading this can check out Ustad's channel and benefit from the great knowledge and example that he sets. Please brother, set a good example to the youth, who comprise the vast majority of your followers. Look at these comments and how much they make negative assumptions. Wallahi, these accusations are not accurate. Wallahi, my fellow youth, please check Ustad's channel and watch his other videos before you judge.
This is not correct. May Allah protect and increase Ustad Abdulrahman Hassan in patience and knowledge. May the misunderstandings and accusations in the comments remove his sins in the 10 blessed days of Dhul Hijjah. May Allah bless all the students of knowledge.
Hijab never said he is a scholar
Ustadh Abdulrahman Hassan Reponds To The Negative Feedback On ‘The Reality Of Football’ Podcast…
th-cam.com/video/78kq14dMCmY/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=AnonymousBrother
@@abd-ar-rahmaniii5650 then hes just a laymen and what has the quran said about these types of people. hes cringey and does not have adab as well.
Aameen
@@abd-ar-rahmaniii5650 but he's big enough to criticise great scholars
Sheikh AbdulRahman is a knowledgeable brother on the deen. No need to call him names, insult or belittle him as if he's a jaahil. He has made some corrects points and some that may not be correct. It's not like you're more knowledgeable in deen than him to talk down on him like that. You're not a scholar and neither is he but students still learning
Next time ARH critiques fatawa of Abu Hanifa or Malik, I want u to tell him the same thing, let's see if ur consistent
@@AbdulH97 m. Hijab is such a jahil ignorant person.
He everytime tells that sectarianism has to stopped. Still he is criticizing & insulting ustadh ARH over football.
Never seen a bigger hypocrite than him
@@AbdulH97 facts
But you just called him sheikh?. You called a student a sheikh?. And sorry but so far we have seen very minor mistakes of no severity from muhammad hijab. ARH may have memorized more books but his implementation shows his lack of maturity and intellect so it accounts to nothing. It’s clear Muhamad hijab is a lot more smarter and a deeper thinker.
He’s extreme just like dawah man
What Usadth Abdurhman Hassan said is completely right, it's taken as a small thing. It becomes bigger and bigger and no one cares.
Look up 'Ruling on watching football Sheikh Uthaymeen' for nuanced and careful examination of this matter, link th-cam.com/video/X3tyOPoK3fo/w-d-xo.html
this abdurahman hassan guy is a saudi madkhali who refuses to make takfir on the rulers for giving up Islamic law but is applying the Quranic verses to a soccer game
@@capnsmo6888 exactly lmao
💯
@@capnsmo6888 This Ustadh Abdurahman Hassan, may Allah continue to honour him, is a true follower Of Prophet Muhammad pbuh who has more knowledge of Islam than you and your family combined.
Can I ask why a video is being posted in TH-cam. Wouldn't it be best to contact the brother directly and then make public about the Consensus opinions of the scholars regarding this.
@Asad TROLL
Public videos get public refutation.
@@muhammedsalam8493 no, public videos require private refutation so the person can remove the video and issue another one saying they were wrong. Public videos are only needed when you are unable have a private conversation with the person.
@@muhammedsalam8493 has private refutation been made? More over, he made lots of other points but he totally ignored them and focused on his flaws only which is very bad. This brother is his brother in Deen and not his enemy, why treat the issue as if they both have some other unresolved issues.
@@riiaz muhammad hijab has balls mind your own buisness. you go contact that saudi madkhali deviant privately, public causers of corruption need to be publicly refuted
Fear Allah AnyOne in this comment section talking bad about Ustadh AbdulRahman Hassan And Making Fun of Him Just remember You're in The 10 day's of hajj, All your Fasting Praying, Being Good to your Parents Etc All Your Good Deeds, All can Go in blink of eye Because You BackBiting Your brother in Islam Allāhu ʾAʿlam. This is what happens when you follow people like this, And leads you into foolishness and think it's All Fun And Game's.
Be Careful what You say to become it Could Become Slander.
Calling an idiot out for his extremism is not slander.
@@ahmadqazi2648 if you call someone an idiot cos you think he's and idiot makes u an idiot, humble yourself
@@omanhakimi3321 Sounds like a Madkhali logic.
I have to watch the whole video of ustadh Abdulrahman. From what I saw from the present clip, I do agree with some of the things you said. However, I am shocked by your enmity towards ustadh Abdulrahman. Why do you always want to humiliate the one whom you refute, even if he is your muslim brother? The way you talk sometimes is absolutely disgusting. Look at around 11:20. Are you proud of speaking in that manner? Incredible
Because if you have been following MH for the past year, he has really started an anti-salafi campaign. And anyone who is a madkhali is under attack by Mohammed hijab. These guys are wasting their time doing these video refutations that benefit no one in the ummah.
.
Akhi, he has too. Firstly Abdurahman Hassan is a knowledgeable brother. But he is slipping in some areas in knowledge, where is he getting these from? Why dont we hear our ulema give these type of refutations? Hes simply not at that level, and these types of videos make him undesirable to listen to. If he wants to perfect his knowledge, firstly he shouldn’t be giving fatwah, hes no mufti. Secondly he has to think before speaking.
@@rewardedwithemaan646 salam alaikum brother, if you watch the podcast ARH referred to the fatwa given by ibn baz and a whole committee in 1401 AH (1979)
These statements from this man are wild. People need to understand Islam is a simple religon and we need to stop trying to stretch, twist, and turn every single verse and hadith to apply it to everything. Theres no correlation to half of the stuff he says. He just connects dots that arent there
Have you watched the entire podcast?
@@ibnmuhammad886 There were some valid points like not covering the awrah and waste of money and time but a muslim footballer can wear longer shorts and of course we shouldnt spend too much time on these things. Play sport with your friends and family its great exercise and good family bonding time as well if you watch a game together. Dont have your entire life revolve around it. Like most things in moderation its fine and when its excessive and causing you to miss prayer its haram but cant just declare it to be haram because it has a chance to become excessive.
@@hilal8461 The Ustadh literally said there is nothing wrong with going with your brothers to play football if it has benefit to stay fit for jihad and the like
Also Abdur-Rahman Hassan was preceded by many scholars in this, such as Ibn Baz, so be careful of who you call “wild”.
@@ibnmuhammad886 The other points arent even worth addressing. No one is worshipping ronaldo and if they are then of course that is haram but it doesnt make the whole sport haram. And your right i shouldnt have called him wild, i edited my initial comment.
A muslim should live by Quran and Sunnah and connect it to everything in his life :) Have you watched the entire podcast ? Its not only his statement but preceded by scholars as well
So why not show the same passion against yasir qadhi or omar suleiman when they makes crazy statement regarding aqeedah
As you do when ARH makes a fiqhi point about FOOTBALL
Subhanallah
Exactly ✊🏽! Hijabs reality is coming crystal clear Wallahi
Because Hijab can have his own oppinion to.. just like you..
Beside .. Whats wrong if Someone take a side ?
@@Muhammad-gm5ho
Or maybe he is effected by the environment. The corruption in the west is really hard to keep out especially when you live in the middle of it. It will make you value little things more than the big things without even realizing.
Allahu aalam
Very interesting to see how everyone now has their own definition of "extreme". Sheikh Abdurahman Hassan is someone who puts a lot of his time into the dawa. Comments like "he has too much time for such thoughts" are disrespectful. Do you think the enemies of greater scholars of the past were also concerned about the time of the scholars? Shariah just works like that, you take the evidence we know and try to implement it into today. People do not understand that one should not only look at the results of past scholars, but their approach to interpreting the evidence. This video and these comments prove to me once again that the biggest problem in our society is the lack of respect for differences of opinion.
May Allah guide us
WHY YOU SPEAKING ENGLISH WHICH IS A MAN MADE LANGUAGE AND ALPHABET AND GRAMMAR? Haram speak arabic or shut up
@@DeparturetimeArsenal you’re too ignorant to even understand what is going on lol
@@DeparturetimeArsenal شكرا على هذه الفكرة الرائعة 😄
then he should stick to Dawah and not get in Fatwa /fiqh.... cause he translated the hadeeth in 9:26 wrong... he did qeyas (comparison) of sport game to Jenaya (crime)....so if he puts a lot of his time into Dawah, it's really good for him and the rest that he just focuses on that.
There is a lot of stuff he said which leads to being extreme, For example “ man made laws “, I can tell he probably passes a red light, Cos it’s not the law of Allah it’s a man made law 😂,
Also the fact that he mentioned the hadith saying some scholars classes it as weak and some hasan but we don’t know for sure, Why are you even mentioning it then 😂 If you’re not sure of it’s authenticity we don’t use that hadith as evidence for our arguments or situation.
I have nothing against this Abdulrahman Hassan, But I believe the things he said here are wrong, But some people make mistakes, We shouldn’t condemn him, But I just disagree with him
Ustadh abdirahman is so knowledgeable and has benefitted the ummah, you are not in the same level of knowledge to refute such a knowledgable teacher of deen.....
So you genuinely think that football in of its self is haram?
@@صلاحالدينإسماعيل-ح6ب No i dont, i am not a scholar in islam to argue with Ustad Abdirahman, he has many valid point that i agree with and some I dont agree with but i cannot stay i know Islam or Quran more than such a knowledgable person....he has helped in so many of his videos with so much information
@@Akaa77777 oh OK what you say is fair enough brother
"There are two kinds of people that don't learn the knowledge a shy person and a arrogant person" - Never heard this before but it is soooo true!
is kafala system halal in Saudi Arabia?
I don’t agree with the Ustadh on this matter but in fairness, he did mention many other reasonable points. You just focussed on a few of the less convincing points
Because they are outrageous points that no student of knowledge should mention.
whats the point of discussing hypotheticals if it is going to cause fitnah?
It's just personal grudges
@@1purpose482 that's correct no student of knowledge mentioned only scholars
@@osamaal-farra3026 the response really seem like that.
After watching the entire podcast I honestly agree with a lot of what the brothers were saying. There’s nothing wrong with playing football, but watching these professional games does seem to lead to haram or can even be haram to watch. It’s also a huge waste of time, and it encourages a lot of bad behaviour to the point of people being obsessive or even idolize these players. We should definitely avoid watching it, however nothing wrong with playing the sport as long as certain conditions are met.
With all that being said where did ALLAH say it was haram? They always use it leads to haram smh...By the logic it's haram for you not to buy an alarm clock, or haram for you not to turn it on bc it can lead to you over sleeping fajr...As far as being obsessive ie extreme ppl can do that in many things including the deen...This line of thinking, is a new religion not Al Islam! And it causes ppl to legislate things ALLAH swt has not legislated.
Anything can drive u into addiction thats where u need to control urself... even playing football should be avoided also based on your argument as at some points you'll keep playing to the point you forget to even pray (happened with me lot of times lol). It's all up to you bro
is kafala system halal in Saudi Arabia?
@Hisham Malik as long as they cover their knees what’s wrong with 10 kids kicking a ball together ?
@Hisham Malik give me solid reasons other than covering knees playing football is haram??? the only criticism is not covering your knees
Once some imam said to boycott zakir naik because he uses Christian, Jewish, hindu scripture in his speech and that we should not use non-Muslim things for dawah , then my uncle stood up and said brother ma-sha-allah the mic and speaker you are using is surely invented by and made by Muslims.
I am from Russia 🇷🇺 Allah blessed me with a good voice, so I decorated him when reciting the Qur’an, so is there any fan of the people of the Qur’an? And may Allah reward you with the best reward ❤️🌙
Subbed
Allahumma baarik brother Abdulrahman. He’s such a knowledgeable man. I do listen to him a lot and I always learn a lot from him. However, brother Mohammad Hijab, you got to understand that كل ابن ءادم خطا and you could also talk of this matter in very different way. You need to talk of the goodness of the person then try and rectify if there might be errors in his speech. This religion is naseeha and even our habib and Sayyid Muhammad Salallahu Aleihi wasallam didn’t respond harshly to the bedouin who urinated in the middle of the mosque and in fact let him finish only to calmly tell the matter afterwards. It’s the Sunnah of the Prophet SAW to explain politely to one another. Wallahu A’lam
Very true... I have benefited a lot from Ustadh Abdulrahman Hassan's lectures, dawrahs... its really sad to see how people are belittling him... though i watch football myself... Ustadh has so many valid points... when u see these football matches u can constantly see they put up ads of alcohol and rainbow (lgbtq).... their awrahs are seen... their bodies are full of tattoos.... young men try to follow them... I agree with him that its a fitnah for sure... i dont like the manner or speech that Brother Hijaab is using... plz learn to respect others... this is really sad...
shut up
@@mustafabek1323 And y is that
Very true barakallahufeek akhi
Totally agree, too harsh instead of calling the brother to have a conversation..
Footballers are glorified and glorifying a person who is a disbeliever is not appropriate... simple point that was being made. Ustadh Abdulrahman has so much beneficial knowledge. Please watch his content rather than make judgements of him from a few minute clips. Jazak Allahu Khairan.
Here is Sheikh Uthaymeen detailing this matter: th-cam.com/video/X3tyOPoK3fo/w-d-xo.html
@@adamj1190 Jazak Allahu Khairan
@@SpaceCadetIsabellaWa iyakum. haven't followed this channel, so I don't know what the agenda is, if any. There was a comment by someone else showing on top of this video with excellent and concise breakdown of different factors to consider when addressing something like modern football, but it somehow disappeared.
He probably got nutmeg rushed at school
ahahahahahahhahah
Thats prob true
Refrain from speaking Ill of others. We may disagree with the point , bring it up and discuss it in a better manner . May Allah him and us to do better
@@MuslimFatherhoodAlliance He’s not speaking ill of him lol it’s just a joke…
@@onabillchoudhury4470 And if you ask them, they will surely say, ‘We were only conversing and playing.’ Say, ‘Is it Allah and His verses and His Messenger that you were mocking?’”
[at-Tawbah 9:64-65].
When you think you are so righteous that you raise the bar of Islam so high that it becomes difficult for others to practice
May Allah give us beneficial knowledge and humble us
@@Alpine1996 Do we live in the same world? What's happening is exactly the opposite! People are doing haraam stuff, thinking it's halal or that's it's no big deal. It doesn't mean something is halal just because you haven't heard it's prohibited and because everyone else is doing it.
Exactly. It's a form of religious narcissism.
@@Alpine1996 Apart from the issues brother Hijab has addressed, ustadh Abdulrahman has talked for 2,5 hours regarding SO MANY issues of football. And you say "there is no Hadith or Ayah that can even be secondarily used to forbid a Muslim from partaking." Personally, seeing a man's awrah is enough for me. And I am one who is struggling with abandoning watching football. I hope ustadh Abdulrahman's video helps me to abandon it once and for all. And what about the music on the stadiums and the music played in almost every commercial pause on TV (seeing at your profile, you seem to not have any issues with music), the almost-naked women shown in the stands, idolizing the players, wasting time, being happy or sad for useless things, etc.? I understand if many of you blame the ustadh for some of his conclusions mentioned in this bro Hijab's video, but most of you seem to make halal what is obviously haram. I would also like Hijab to talk about these other points. Also, I am certain that if brother Hijab has made such a video, he did not give all of you a green light to show in the comments all your "kindness", frustrations, and disrespect toward learned people. His whims and desires??? "Stupid" conclusions? How disrespectful!
@@Alpine1996 You also seem to have misused the Imam Malik's example? What about it? Are you saying the sheikhs and daees should not talk about the issues they see present in their people? Should they only "look at their own plate"? Are you sure Allah will not ask them why did they not speak up, raise their voices? People know the Sharia well enough to avoid most sins? I don't see that on the streets, mate. Nor on social networks. So, you think no one should advise people to not watch football? Well, seeing the detrimental effects only watching highlights, searching for streams (to watch a few minutes of a live match), reading football news, and following a club and it's players had on me and many youngsters (if not all), I congratulate ustadh Abdulrahman for making a video about this. Honestly, I would question my eman if I did not see anything problematic in watching football.
@@Alpine1996 Proving something with the wrong arguments and disrespecting learned people again. I am done responding to you.
Brother Hijab. The thing- is why so triggered? If you do not agree with it it's fine. The worst honestly that would happen is many will stop watching football and life will move on. I cannot imagine Abu Bakar if he today was alive he would tune in and watch NBA or NFL/Soccer and whatever else there is. What would he do with the music in the background or the women that come on during halftime/sidelines ect.. It's just not befitting. Your reaction is overkill. Chillllll.
Nice point
Bro if this is the case, The children making up their own games are also haram. Not even that, playing PlayStation is also haram and etc. This logic is also just so bad. This is extreme! Understand that this religion is a religion of balance. We can play games. As long as they are halal and have no haram content in it. - this fiasco reminds me when they said that Nike was haram to wear. Altough I see the wisdom in that verdict. It does open up a can of worms. Because then that logic needs to be applied to everything. Like buying cars, buying certain pens and etc. Not even that, allot of things which we do on a daily basis are of pagan origin. For example, most of us eat an egg in the morning because we like to and it’s a tradition for most cultures to have this food item with their breakfast. Little do many people know that this practice has an pagan origin. Like Mufti Muneer said: “ if you are gonna apply this logic, apply it fully not partially”.
True!
Mufti Muneer my man
@@heartsxday you got a playlist on your account with women on a beach doing yoga, somali girls dancing and other weird stuff. i actually get disgusted by people like you. Before talking watch your own sins.
@JayRedRum you can gamble on elections you know that right? is the election haram?
@JayRedRum listen to firas zahabi explain if mma is haram
Mohammed Hijab wrestling was done in the Prophet's time, doesn't ARH know that there are plenty of rules in wrestling? Didn't the Prophet defeat the top wrestler of the day which led to a his conversion?
What rules were there in wrestling during the Prophet's time? صلى الله عليه وسلم
Secondly, do not compare wrestling during his صلى الله عليه وسلم time to the football programs we have today
@@khoyrulislam what you think the rule was? Not punching in the face? Not punching in the neck? Its called wrestiling so there are rules!
@@khoyrulislam wrestling by definition has rules otherwise it would be fighting or killing
@@khoyrulislam loooooooool. stop talking
@@MysticYusha You are mentioning ISLAMIC RULES. How does that tie in with what we are talking about (football and the rules ARH is saying goes AGAINST Islamic rulings)? Had you brought an example of a wrestling rule that contradicted the Shariah then your example would have made sense.
I personally don't find this argument of ARH to be strong. If you watch his full video he does mention other aspects of football with go against Islamic teachings.
If you disagree, make your points in a manner in which you deliver the proofs clearly to the people on how he is wrong without using old pictures (being childish) and talking down on him in such a manner. Respectfully disagree then deliver your points, these unnecessary and childish actions will be followed by heavy questions from الله on the day of judgement. Fear Allah and atleast change the picture.
Ameen. And how he only singles out a single point.
We often times forget that backbiting is backbi whether done on social media or in real life. You will be held accountable for every comment you make. Social media is REALITY and you will have to face the severity of the things that you type. Imagine hundreds or even thousands of people residing your comments where you backbite and or slander a brother/sister. Subhanallah, imagine the severity. Fear Allah. Again, backbiting is backbiting, even if done from behind a screen. A lot of you should really be ashamed of yourselves.
100%
does this apply to non muslims as well?
So it's ok when one has a history of the culture of refutations orchestrated, then when one is on the receiving end of a refutation, we cry foul (excuse the pun)?
Ustadh responded th-cam.com/video/78kq14dMCmY/w-d-xo.html
@@getinspired7687 lol this turd is such a cry baby. Guys dont bother watching the video theres nothing in it except for this takfeeris cryings.
This is what Salafism does to your mind
Respect to shikh abdurahman Hassan ,most of points he made made a clear sense and unfortunately some people dislike and fight each other over non believers they support
A beautiful response of Ustadh Abdur Rehman Hassan to the criticism he faced in his opinions.
I used to watch and admire brother Hijab but after looking at the manners of Ustadh, Brother Hijab just lost the level of respect I had now that I recall his debates and how he replies usually.
Mohammed Hijab brought the points that are not as strong as his other arguments and proof. That was a long podcast, he took only fractions of it.
May Allah guides us all and give us the ability to understand one another without any disease of the heart within us. Ameen
Response:
th-cam.com/video/78kq14dMCmY/w-d-xo.html
What's the title of the video?
@reshmaazadsheriff1344 well I'm not sure now... but you can still listen to the podcast if you wish on AMAU channel... Also the ustadh is now gone may more serious in learning and teaching the deen of Allah - you should check out the academy He & Ustadh Tim Humble are running and various lessons. Muhammad Hijab is just some random person speaking about things he don't know... If he is good in one thing - doesn't make Hijab good in others...
Even as a big football fan i can see the idolatry & "idol worship" from fans towards their idols as being a contradiction to Islam. The chanting at times is almost "religious".
I actually think that the religion of a lot of English people is football.
That was literally his point but everyone butthurt cuz deep down they know he’s right
@@mustafamu7852 yes some of the things he said are okay but saying it's haram is not true. Some youth watch football instead of eating khat.
Not religious at all, but even I can see that. Not sure how hijab can't understand that obvious point. For gods sakes ronaldo is idolized like a god in the middle east. The dude has half a billion instagram followers. Its quite bizarre tbh.
@@saraelmi875 Ustadz never ruled out "playing Football being Haraam" He Specifically mentioned that. His whole talk was focused on "Watching Football" and he stated that in the beginning. Youth should be doing things instead of watching things. I'd say throw them in the Park and have them play in that same time they are watching the game. Talking about more beneficial vs less beneficial argumentation. and we have better things to do.
Narrated `Ali:
I relate the traditions of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) to you for I would rather fall from the sky than attribute something to him falsely. But when I tell you a thing which is between you and me, then no doubt, war is guile. I heard Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) saying, "In the last days of this world there will appear some young foolish people who will use (in their claim) the best speech of all people (i.e. the Qur'an) and they will abandon Islam as an arrow going through the game. Their belief will not go beyond their throats (i.e. they will have practically no belief).
Says a guy with a username "shinobi" and gokus pfp yeah alright dude
@@Theticus.11 Yeah I have been seeing this too much, hahahaha it's actually quite funny.
This is talking about the kharijis. Or the extremists like ISIS. They are young and you see them using islam as an excuse to kill innocent people.
is kafala system halal in Saudi Arabia?
sheikh abdur rahman hasan is not a kafir u fool
So "man made laws" forbidden in football, which are actually just rules whilst participating in a game, but all the real man made laws in Saudi are justified e.g. Interest, music concerts....?
Saudi hosts big international boxing fights, which in his context given, ticks all the boxes of football but to a bigger degree i.e. more awrah, more brutal.
At this stage, all you'll hear is FIX YOURSELF.
Whas has SA got to do with this bullshit? Redirect your anger to someone else.
@@تعلومة-ز1ر not angry, just expressing. Nk need for foul language.
I'm basing it on this person and their support for Saudi regime. Just see a massive contradiction on this topic of man made laws.
If someone wants to discuss man made laws, they should actually address it based on all our muslim nations who have man made laws in a govt/societal level and not base it on a football game where this discussion is not in context.
Also muslim nations which people want to give immunity from criticism
@@تعلومة-ز1ر because ARH is a hypocrite for supporting Saudi who is doing the opposite of the things he is "legitslating"
True about boxing
I disagree with Abdul Rahman Hassan too but this got nothing to do with Saudi lol
How can you memorise so much Qu'ran and Ahadith and come to these conclusions? SubhanAllah
Akhi wallahi just go watch the full video of ustadh.
@@yasin8396 no need for it the fact that he it’s worse than major sins in fact when Shirk is the only thing that is worse than major sins think 🤔 where is he gonna do with shirk is he gonna say shirk is worse than football why didn’t Allah talked about football or even Mohammed pbuh it’s crazy how you guys think because if shirk is only worse than football surely Allah would talk about it or Mohammed pbuh
@@Sweeti924 wallahi I love you for the sake of Allah, but it’s hard to understand what you have wrote and I fear that I would miss quote you if I tried to reply.
*memorise mind numbing technique*
Should I not love my mother because she’s not a muslim and I am? Can I not say that the halal food she has prepared for me is delicious? These people want to make life difficult for everyone.
Completely agree! That's a good point you're making. Defo carry on complimenting your mum for just being your mum!
Islam allows wrestling. There are no rules for grappling sports in our shariah.
No hitting the head.
@@thegamerkhan but your enemy is allowed to cut your head off and eat your organs
@Trolling-The-Truth do You want some ?
@@snap_fit8686 Hey pal. You need to grow out of this 2001 911 mindset. Its outdated. Guys like you are Saturday morning cartoon villains with logically fallacious arguments that are like old meat you try to put gravy on to make make its seem edible, in this case the gravy is emotional provocation and regurgitating arguments back at people. Tell you what though, you wouldn’t do this with the Jews, otherwise you’ll be labelled as anti Semitic. You might try it but it won’t end well.
@@abdullahx4908 what ? What have i done wrong ? That guy is saying as if combat sport is haraam because we dont alowed to hit someone head .. well we learn boxing wrestling or other is so we dont get hit in the head .. so dont say boxing is haraam because it does not make sense
Huge difference between when you’re refuting someone like apostate prophet and when you’re refuting a Muslim brother. Why’re you using old pictures being childish and belittling the brother ? Respectfully disagree, drive your points home and khalaas, this is a Muslim brother. Wallahi thuma wallahi لتُسألن
zajak allahu brother.
Well said!!
Facts
In my opinion the man is wrong but please don't be too harsh on him from what I've seen of him he is very good and has lots of knowledge we can learn from may Allah bless us all and guide us on the straight path.
Now can you do a video on bro hajji and his call to qubooriyyah or you want to come across as total clown with more gheerah for football than tawheed?
Can't make a video against his boys obviously.
@@SAEECLIPSE Hijab should've chosen comedy instead of dawah as a career
Haji actually has knowledge as compared to these youtube reaction video folks
@@kadduponka3565 are you joking? Watch ebn Hussein and wake up ponka
I’m not a scholar but even I know that there’s a lot about football that should worry a Muslim, the feigning of injury, the cheating and corruption, gambling etc etc. So for you to think that there’s nothing wrong with professional football as we know it in England also raises some concerns. I agree there’s some good in it, no doubt, but am pretty sure there are more bad in it these days. And Allaah knows best.
Gambling is a big one people are oblivious to
Not even mentioning the time wasting and that we will be asked for how we utilised our time! Also just thinking about the issues of ‘shirt swapping’ or whatever and feeling as if it’s blessed or whatever is just disgusting tbh
All of these issues you mentioned are individual issues not issues with the game itself. Because people can gamble on anything and in order to watch a game or play there is no obligation to gamble. And its not a waste of time because in actuality it brings communties closer together and allows for a segway of communication and interaction between different faiths so we can get along better as a society. Its even an opportunity for Dawah by seeing so many muslim players like Kante, Salah, Mane, Ozil etc with how generous in donation they are and when they stick to their convictions there are many people who watch this and become inspired and want to learn more about islam. The same way wrestling back in the time of the prophet Muhammad Salalahualaihiwasalam was watched by others and people of different faiths wrestled eachother and praised eachother for their wrestling abilities and techniques the same is done with Futbol no? If anything as muslims we should work harder to make the sport more dominated by muslim athletes so we can have a greater influence in being able to give dawah.
@@donutwarrior8596 you have mentioned some good points and no doubt there are benefits in sports such as football however one thing me and you know for sure is that the negatives outweigh the positives. One can sit down for 90 min on his backside being so endorsed, screaming cheering and stressing himself out for 21 people who don’t even know who he is so he’s ultimately just tiring himself. And when it comes to prayer he wants to rush it as quickly as possible to go back into watching the game and perhaps can’t even wake up for qiyaam layl. I’m just mentioning some realities here bro. I get your points especially the dawah bit but bro how can you give dawah if you need dawah yourself? (And I’m not taking about you directly lol) Save yourself first before you try to help others bro. Learn your religion seek knowledge, then start giving dawah to your family members AND THEN we can talk about other people
@@lookaway375 it depends on the individual, but to label it haram for everyone just doesnt make any sense. The things you are talking about are characteristic flaws of individuals who watch or play not issues with the game itself. Its similar to how there are some people who do bad things in the name of religion. The religion isnt to blame its the individuals who chose to act irresponsibly.
Sheik Abdurrahman somali is good preacher but any one may be mistake. And not all what he said was mistake.
I’m 44 and have played football my whole life and I also coach…. I must say it’s haram because it’s a big distraction on people. It consumes their minds too much. I think playing sport just for fun is ok
So professional sports I say is haram but recreational… No
I just wonder if it's possible that one is able to perform an open-mind or open-heart surgery on matters of Faith (Iman) in order to judge a professional Muslim footballer? I'm convinced that this is only in the hands of Allah Azza Wa Jal. No need for man-made judgements here, excuse the pun.
@Nograveworship Firstly, could I humbly ask you to refrain from any name-calling since I didn't initiate any.
Secondly, I'm not sure what are you referring to? I was responding to this comment by @Sam W. No mention about the name of the Ustads here!
Thirdly, you seem to casually whitewash and veneer my assertion and fact that there is not a single being, in the totality of Allah's creation, that can perform an open-mind and open-heart operation/surgery, to determine or make judgements of matters of Faith.
Fourthly, Actions judged by Allah alone:
"*Actions are Judged by Intentions*" - Forty Hadith 1 [Al-Bukhari & Muslim]
Fifthly, a vast majority of Muslim Football Players such as Mohamed Salih, Sadio Mane, Paul Progba, Hamza Choudhury, Mezut Ozil, Riyad Mahrez, etc., have become much-loved household names for leading and being the torch-bearers of Islam for Muslims in the Footballing world and role models for our kids should they also take up the sport.
Let's just for the moment, hop over to UFC. Have we seen the impact of Khabib Nurmagomedov as a role model in sport? Massive! Do we tell him what he was doing was Haram?
Let's now hop over to Rugby. Have we seen the impact of Sonny Bill Williams as a role model in sport? Do we tell him what he was doing and still doing is was/is Haram?
I can quote pages and pages examples. Let's also not forget the late Muhammed Ali and numerous other sportsmen and sportswomen spreading across sporting disciplines.
Finally, herein exist my qualm. Indeed the are a few minor exceptions, but just a few names mentioned above, I haven't come across an incident where they may have acted indecently and inappropriately within the realm of being a Muslim.
I never made any judgement calls except stating the obvious, i.e. the conclusion of "man-made" judgement!
First I thought he would say to avoid football because it attracts a lot of racists, the football hooligans for example. But he talk about breaking bones and whatnot. With that logic, you pretty much can't leave your home, exercise and do your daily chores. You can get an accident on your way to work or school and break something.... it sounds like as if he is against socialising/working, or associating with non Muslim as much.
Edit; maybe not with non Muslims, but trying to avoid things that have high risk of injuries, which is pretty almost anything, you can trip down the stairs at home and break something for example.
Have you watched the entire podcast?
He addressed much more
@@ibnmuhammad886
I have. It didn't make sense at all!
@@ibnmuhammad886 explain it because you obviously have, who is he to say that football is forbidden. He might have more knowledge then me but he is an idiot
@@ibnmuhammad886
His explanation didn't make sense at all. Even with your version. You are purposely trying to deflect that on others for some odd reason!
@@ibnmuhammad886 chill out with your anger dude
Brother hijab please dont treat muslim brothers who have different opinion than you like how to treat non muslims.... the words and the tone u used is almost exact as u used against the enemies of islam....... u are making muslims hate muslims..... please humble urself and react to opposing opinions in a better fashion... jazakALLAH
This argument against fotball is insanity, no offence. Sounds like trying to make something Haram for Haram's sake. If people lived like this you wouldn't leave your house or do anything. Sport is very good for people.
Would you encourage your wife or sister into it
@@TazImahc I'm not a Muslim so yes. But also Muslim girls can play together for fun and fitness without men. And they can also watch women's sports on TV.
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم
السلام على من ٱتبع الهدى
@@alexojideagu May Allah Azzawajal guide you to Islam
@Member of the universe Football for normal people still uses a Referee. His argument is stupid about man made laws. So you're saying to play football without a Referee? Stay in YOUR lane of stupidity.
Are we going to follow our desires vs the truth? Abdul Rahman mentioned dozens of reasons why football is not good. MH only touched on two or three of his points and we are here agreeing with him.. MH should make a full video refuting every single point and only then we can judge.. If MH cannot refute all points then its safe to say Abdul Rahman is right... What about the scholars he referenced? The prophet pbuh praised a non-believer because what they said was in line with Islam just like we can practice cultural customs as long they are in line with Islam..
Who made Abdul Rehman the authority ? This is the problem ...You guys listen to these young guys who go abroad and study for a few years and all of a sudden they become an authority for you and they start giving rulings and even fatawa ..Come to Hijaz and sit with the Lajna Daimah and learn your deen from the real scholars.
@@MrCriterion
So Mr hijab is your authority ?
No he is not Abdul Azim Al Hindee, but below are my teachers who I have personally studied under over the last 25 years and they have not come out with the nonsense I keep hearing time and time again from this young student of knowledge...Thats exactly what he is, "young' and a "student" ...Perhaps he should pay more attention in class and ask the teacher if he don't understand rather than come up with his own misguided understanding and rulings.
Anyway Allah and Mohammed sallalaho alayhee wasslaam are the authority first and foremost and then the 1st 3 generations and the Salaf who came after them to this present day.
Shaykh Abdul Aziz Al Shaykh, Shaykh Saleh Al Fawzan, Shaykh Abdullah Ibn Munee, Shaykh Saleh bin Mohammed al Luhaydan, Shaykh Salih bin Sa'd as Suhaymee, Shaykh Salih bin Abdul Aziz Sindi, Shaykh Ibrahim al Ruhayli, Shaykh Khalid al-Mushayqih, Shaykh Muqbil al Harbee, Shaykh Abdullah bin Zayd bin Muhammed al Musallam, Shaykh Abdul Aziz Mohammad as Sadhan.
you are delusional
@@alibeebatty885 Mr BeeBum eat some honey and maybe you will feel a little better
Syaikh Sulaiman Ar Ruhaily, the syaikh of Masjid An-Nabawi, was give a fatwa regarding playing football and admiring non Muslim player or club. He said the basic ruling of sport is mubah (allowed). It become haram if there are sharia violation in it, otherwise it should be allowed. Wallahu a'lam bishawab.
I agree, more critical thinking and arguments needed to come to those sort of conclusion. Differences are there, cultural, social etc etc one cannot ignore it- I guess.
Fear Allah Muhammed. You’ve been grazing in the meadows and pastures of Aristotle, Plato and Ibn Sina to the point where you’ve filled your belly with philosophy and egocentricity. The Ustadh is clearly trying to divert the people’s attention from things that don’t benefit them to tawhid. Remember Allah (swt) said:
وَإِذَا ذُكِرَ اللَّهُ وَحْدَهُ اشْمَأَزَّتْ قُلُوبُ الَّذِينَ لَا يُؤْمِنُونَ بِالْآخِرَةِ ۖ وَإِذَا ذُكِرَ الَّذِينَ مِن دُونِهِ إِذَا هُمْ يَسْتَبْشِرُونَ
And when Allah is mentioned alone, the hearts of those who do not believe in the Hereafter shrink with aversion, but when those [worshipped] other than Him are mentioned, immediately they rejoice.
Think deeply about this ayah and I ask Allah to guide us to the straight path, Ameen
Diverting attention from football and calling Muslims who enjoy football match munafik are two different things. Clearly there are better activities for Muslims than to support a football team but it does not mean it is Haram. His fatwa was weak, majority of scholars will disagree with him on this matter.
What I think could be considered Haram in today's football is the women they show when the cameras are on the audience. They are usually half naked.
Lol what? Go cry kid ibn sina and aristotle have done more good to the ummah than your saudi scholars combined
Are you making MUHAMMAD HIJAB pass for a mild believer? OMG You guys are beyond absurd
@@sadiqdelil5189 will you please explain to me how can a religion so obsessed with poligamy and legitimising sex can actually be this afraid of sex?
@@Empiricist14 @Fabio1349 Sure, it is all about sex in marriage. Sex is mentioned in the Quran and prophet Muhammad peace and blessing be upon him explained what is lawful in the intercourse. Most men marry one wife but polygamy is needed in some cases. My great grandma straight after second world war was cheated on by my great granddad. He had child with another woman and lived double life. There were simply not enough men around and so many children were born out of wedlock. Polygamy would solve such issue and give dignity to both mistress and the child. Having a wife is different to having a side b**ch. Every wife needs to have a house provided for her and equal time needs to be shared among wives. It is more headache than pleasure for the man at the end.
This guy does not strike me as sincere whatsoever, the guy who forbids futbol
As usual. Ustadh brings Ayaat, Ahadiith and sayings of the Sahaba and Ulama, whilst the critiques uses "logic" and "critical thinking". HasbunAllah wa ni3mal Wakeel
He also presented ahadith
Of course you have to bring Ayat, Ahadith, Fiqh and Sharia rules into this, what muhammad hijab tried to explain is that you not only have to consist the knowledge but more importantly understand the meaning of all it.
The use of sound reasoning in making sense of adillat from the Quran and Sunnah is needed in order to form correct judgements.
Bringing ayaat and ahaadith without proper critical analysis leads to misapplication of the adillat. This was clearly shown in Ustadh's Abdurrahman's use of the verse 44 from surat al Ma'idah in forbidding football.
Disparaging Mo Hijab's arguments under the convenient pretext of 'Ustadh using ayaat and ahaadith' is totally delusional.
Furthermore, Mo Hijab clearly used evidence from the Quran and sunnah in putting forth his arguments.
How can you understand interpret hadith without logic
Show us ayat, ahadith, and sayings of the Sahaba and Ulama that say football is haram. You won't be able to provide evidence. What will you do then? You'll use qiyas and logic to arrive at these conclusions. And yet you critique Hijab when he uses logic.
People need to realise that Abdulrahman hassan is a student of knowledge, khalas. Don’t blindly follow people, learn your deen from the authentic books and them only, Allahu A’lam
About the term student of knowledge, which people use today, what kind of level in islamic science does it have.
Because if we see the students of the past, for example of imam malik or other scholars, they already reach some level of ijtihad
@Master ROSHI
Thanx for ur answer.
But i was refering more about the term student of knowlege of today.
Can we compare for example those students of today with the students of the past?
@1ummah
I have a question for u.
When u hear lectures, or answers, of scholars did u check everything they say if its fits with quran n sunnah and understanding of the salaf?
If you finish a higher eduation and get a degree it doesn't mean you are suddenly smartest and sharpest mind out there where you can insensibly make all kind of claims and be righteous about them.
الله يبارك فيك و يكرمك و يحفظك من كل سوء او شر و تكون فالفردوس الاعلى مع الصحابة ويثبتك علي فتح عقول الناس و عنيها زي ما فتحت عقلي وكنت سبب في قربي لله اكتر و اكتر
guys I get that brothers reasoning is a bit far fetched and he was very strict with it . But mashallah the iman he must have to be so stringent and strict with his analysis. wallah instead of dissing him straight up, give bro his props too.
But one thing is being strict and another is warping things to fit your narrative. Being strict in avoiding haram things is one thing but to outright label something is haram with dubious claims regarding rules and regulations in a game and all kinds of other nonsensical claims i must say is just wreckless and irresponsible especially those who watch his content closely and take advice from him should be weary.
If he truly had iman he'd think sensibly, not crudely mustafa my friend
Prophet SAW said “be easy going and do not be harsh “
so should i leave my salah because i feel free and i think things will go easy when i leave it
@@abubekerashref188 I quoted that in regards to the content hijab posted
Should quote it in regards to this salafi clown
For those who are looking to persecute AbdulRahman, Ibn Baz said that football is haram. He didn’t pull it out of his pocket
Yeah, i don’t know why he is being beaten with a stick for what he has narrated from of the giants in our modern era!!!! It is not his
Don't let Internet "fame" go to your
head. It isn't real. Stay grounded
This is what happens when you try to preach Islam by studying everything under the sun except Islam itself from classical sources. It results in us putting our own limited, human logic over Quran and sunnah. Ustadh ARH didn't make a fatwa, if you watch the podcast, he transmitted one made by ibn baz among others.
hhhhhhh mohamed hijab you kill me with that reaction when you said :"what happens when a muslim marries a christian or jew" at #7:06
Everyone, let’s not bash the brother. He has stated his view. We shouldn’t insult or make fun of him, since he may be more beloved to Allah than you or me.
Edit: I’m talking about people in the comment section-Mohammed Hijab is being respectful.
I can agree with that. As much as i agree with brother Hijab in this video, i think he can take a more appropriate approach to correct the speaker he is referring to. I also think there is a underlying, more fundamental issue which some Muslims like the speaker in the video hold that leads them to such radically different views. I think we need to find that out first and discuss that in a respectable way. I think that issue is about coexisting with non-Muslims.
Bruuu didn’t you hear what hijab said at the end 🤦🏽♂️ I’m not making fun of him or backbiting him. You didn’t even watch the whole vid
@@mr.unknown3620 I’m not talking about Mohammed Hijab, there are people making fun of him in the comment section.
@@checkmate5338 I wasn’t talking about brother Mohammed Hijab Akhi. More or less, he was respectful in the video. I was referring to the people in the comment section making fun of the other brother.
@everything has an ending I can’t speak for you Brother, but this man is definitely more knowledgeable than me. Any valid difference of opinion needs to be respected.
I used to think you were arrogant from misreading certain videos I’ve watched of you. I watched quiet a few of your videos now your whole debate with Wood who you turnt to fire Wood ‘ bun him up’ and I must say I admire you ahki your knowledge how you convey your opinion alhamdulillah you’ve made me want to study the religion so much more so i can be strong when faced with people trying to talk down on the religion. All praise to Allah but thank you for being such a good example of a Muslim for the brothers wallah 👊🏽👊🏽
I am pretty sure even many salafi preachers won't agree with what ustadh AbdulRahman Hassan had to say on this issue. Watched a recent video of sheikh Assim al Hakeem about watching football & supporting football team, even though sh. Assim is not a fan of watching football, his response was in line with Muhammad Hijab's response. He did not say it is haram to watch football & when asked if it is kufr he replied that to say supporting a football team is kufr is ridiculous. He also mentioned muslim supporting romans against persian.
This is sh. Assim's video: th-cam.com/video/QDumt5KlnTw/w-d-xo.html
Tell him youtube has man made software coding.
Loool
it also has terms and conditions which he is forced to comply with which directly conflict with sharia like allowing others to curse the prophet Muhammad
@@MohammedHijab Haha! Love your videos bro!
@@MohammedHijab Lol 😂😂
Dude he is a takfeeri kharji, did u honestly expect some sense from a known kharji takfeeri
Doesn't Football help spread the message of Islam? I mean look at players like Salah, Ozil, Mane, Mahrez, Pogba.
@@ibnmuhammad886 one person making mistakes doesn't mean all of the community is the same. Don't judge based on one person akhi.
@@ibnmuhammad886 He took a pictures but did he praised it? did he worshiped it or supported it? No? I don't see any problem here. Also maybe it was a mistake as mistakes can happen.
@@ibnmuhammad886 maybe he was ignorant. Don't judge him bro.
Not necessarily. However, it does give a platform to Muslims.
Exactly Muslim men can marry Christians and jews. So how can he claim you can't praise or love non Muslims
I love BOTH ustadh Abdul Rahman Hassan and Muhammad Hijab. I wish we could engage in civilised dialogue. Many shuyookh have changed their opinion with new knowledge, I just don’t want any toxicity with these beloved brothers.
Exactly, mohammed hijab should address the shiekh in private. This is childish tbh. This videos that go back and forth create controversy and a toxic environment which we don't want
@@khalid2733 exactly.
The ustadh is an email leaker.
@@aryan1645 without adab you cannot refute in public
I love brother ustadh Abdulrahman. He has so many beneficial materials and has great knowledge.
But at the same time, no scholar is infallible.
He's not a scholar, a student of knowledge at best
Ibrahim Khalil inshaAllah we all continue to be students of knowledge
@@ajhammer1701 no disrespect akhi but your understanding to mine understanding of who is a student of knowledge and who is a heavyweight it's like a fishpond compared to 7 seven seas of ink that will never exhaust even if all the trees of the world were pens to write it down, surely the world would run out of pens without even diminishing those oceans slightly, and I'm a miskeen being happy if Allah blesses me with a 100th part of a drop from that ocean. In sha Allah, I hope this gives you some perspective regarding ilm and at what depth the true ulema/inheritors of prophets go.
If another person said this, they would have been degraded and ostracized and called a jaahil probably for the rest of his life.
Silly guy , used to be better and more respectful in the beginning. Gets more subscribers and instantly gets arrogant typical fir3own
A Hassan refuted those who use philosophy in dawah and also defended Sheikh Albani so you felt offended so you want to strike back.
First u invite him to ur podcast on quran preservation now u bash him
Good.
OH BUD BUD DING PAOOO
Disagreeing with someone on a matter is not bashing,nor does it prevent good realtions. You can be someones brother in Islam and still confront them about ideas they have shared publicly. No one says "oh first you said you love your wife and then you refuse to buy her this bag", one doesnt prevent the other.
Ustadh has also leaked the emails of Yasir Qadhi to Dawah Man.
@@fallenprince2146 IT'S ME YASSIR CADDY CMON MAN
Hijab is someone I respected so much and always felt bad when he's refuted.
But I guess you wrong here because the guy never said playing football is Haram. Rather the way it's done all over the world like showing the Aurat and their earning are not from halal means from what I understand plus a lot of Haram they get into. So it's not advisable to choose it as a professional. Wallau alam
Some people read one Islamic book and become scholars lol. This is why it’s important to do our own research
So true sis
Hijab's Best Moments... th-cam.com/video/Hr8STeLHMVU/w-d-xo.html
@Nograveworship lol you need to learn about real scholars and you’ll realise how wrong you are
@Nograveworship evidently not. Man is going to start encouraging radicalism next.
I dont know if its Haram or not what i know is and fact which even Non Muslims would agree that football or any sport is waste of time and im not very good Muslim but i know every minute in this life we are given should not be wasted its haram to waste time. May ALLAH guide us.
Kindly research....
I don't agree
Only unhealthy Madkhalis say this
@@ahmadqazi2648 What do you gain for this world or Akhira by watching football?
@@umertracker816 by indulging in physical activities like sports like football, I gain health. Besides, it is sunnah to be fit. Just because Madkhalis are the most unhealthiest sect of Islam, doesn't mean they can issue fatwas against good activities.
Most Pakistani shop owners sell alcohol and they will say to you is halal 😱 they are following different side of Islam
That "imam" will struggle in the real world outside of his jubba. Critical thinkers will be denounced as heretics. That man is a danger to himself before anyone else
And to everyone else*
@@redtyphon9919 i implied that😊
My point was he doesnt even realise what harm he is doing to himself thus is in need of help 1st & foremost. I accept that its tantamount to making an excuse for him.
"imam"? Did anyone claim that?
@@Haiofhqnnetula i wasnt. it was metaphorical. Hence the quotes.
بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم
السلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته
It is clear from reading this comments section that some people have done an absolutely pathetic job of trying to understand the arguments made by the respected Ustadh (حفظه الله) and infact completely butchered what was said.
You see comments like "O well, don't follow traffic laws then" or "well then children who make their own games are ruling by other than Allah Azzawajal's Law" etc. Anyone who had watched the podcast would know that the Ustadh explicitly said this is not what he meant.
Then there were those who said that "Then we shouldn't leave our houses because we can get injured".
Once again the point was, Football as a game HAS SCOPE FOR FOULING. There are two types of tackling (according to football). One that is allowed, and that is off the Ball, and the second is that of the player which is not allowed. There are players WHO MALICIOUSLY TACKLE TO OBTAIN AND INJURY and The Ustadh made the point that the most such players will get is a red card or perhaps a fine. This is the problematic issue since these specific rules of football completely contradict Islamic rulings on Qisas as explained by the Ustadh. A better analogy for this would be, you go on the street and purposefully trip someone leading to them breaking their leg. This is not allowed in football but there is provisions for it to take place WITHOUT THE PLAYER RECEIVING ANYTHING MORE THAN A RED CARD OR FINE.
This clearly shows how deep the love of football has penetrated the hearts that people who loosened their tongues and backbitten the Ustadh severely due to their beloved being attacked. We ask Allah Azzawajal alone for justice
THIS IS PURPOSEFUL INJURY, NOT ACCIDENTAL EVEN
what do you have to say about the other clear cut reasons such as looking at awrat, alcohol billboards and the likes?
Ustadh responded th-cam.com/video/78kq14dMCmY/w-d-xo.html
@@getinspired7687 jazzakallahu khayran
@@abdul2499 aameen wa iyyaak
Do you comper tight to alcochol?Wow
@@abdul2499 Assalamu Alaykum Brothers and Sisters,I hope your Supports to my Islamic channel
on youtube,Jazak Allah Khayr🇹🇷🇨🇦
Just cuz you don’t like certain things doesn’t mean it’s haram
Also, you agree or not, you have no right to question his studies and contemplation ability... This is disrespectful.
I watched the full podcast. Some of the points are valid though.
Come on then, don't keep us in suspense
@@imaknexus go watch it. Is he your servant?
@@imaknexus Brother Hijab selectively refuted the points. Watch the full podcast and decide for yourself. I'm not taking any sides. Just trying to be balanced..
@@RaihanShaheed i agree brother abdulrahman says alot of things that totally makes sense why the football industry is garbage but he doesnt really know the sport itself and its rulings.
@@abdisalan10 Yeah he pointed out many things for saying it is haram. If any one single point of his stands, then it would make it haram. So if it is going to be refuted, every single point should be refuted. Not just the few selected weaker ones. الله أعلم
What a nut case does he not know that prophet Mohammad pbuh praised the Romans and said they had four qualities better than the believers
The problem is that some people are disconnected from their surroundings. I'm not saying we should accept everything in the society we live in, but atleast have some awareness and knowledge of what's going on around you! (i.e. the other brother gave real-life example/experience of colleagues at work. You don't HAVE to love them!...but he says this because he is part of the society he lives in and understands it!).
Imagine our prophet saw said we wont do business with mushrikeen yahudis and nasaras. SORRY but their dawah is a joke... i feel like its stopping the muslims from developing. Extremist thinking and lack of understanding
By this logic wrestling should also be haram but prophet Muhammad s.a.w used to do wrestling. Where is this guy even going
So is it haram to stop at a red light because it’s a rule other than that of Allah swt
I ask you guys to watch the entirety of ARH's video regarding this before joining a discussion on a topic we are jahil on, and engage in back biting calling people extreme.
I’m assuming brother hijab watched the whole video, but who is this guy to make fatwa.
Couldn't agree more.
@@issamkholoud2009 he was preceded in this by many such as Ibn Baz
@@issamkholoud2009 hes not making a fatwah. Hes quoting from the Quaran, Sunnah and repeating what scholars have said.
He is making fatwa, he is saying football is haram
This is what happens when you really really want to prove something is haraam. Your ego takes command of your brain. Rather take a balanced approach and warn people against excessively watching of football
I believe we shouldn't do anything that contains more bad than good that's a reason why god forbid alcohool because the bad is greater than the goodness of it
The haram police is one of the main reasons why the Ummah has moved backwards.
I'm a dedicated subscriber and viewer of this channel but I have to admit that Ustadh Abdurrahman Hassan does make some good points which causes one to think. What's so special about watching or playing football anyway? It might not be haram or sinful but in essence, it's just entertainment and a relatively tame manner to while away time. Also, Hijab came off as quite a bit rude and arrogant towards AH. May Allah forgive us and guide us all. Ameen.
Yeah honestly he needs to be a bit humble. He's right most of the times but shouldnt he personally talk with him first? The first thing he does us go online and make a video about it.
This isn’t how you should be addressing nor critiquing another person of knowledge. Why are you always speaking with such pomp and arrogance ? You can say “with all due respect” as much as you like but your smirk and choice of wording hides nothing. Regardless of whether or not he said the wrong this, your reacting and your pomp and arrogance and treatment of another Muslim leads me to believe you have too much Pride in your heart. Do not think you have become someone Mohammed Hijab for you are less than a drop of water in the ocean just like the rest of us. May Allah have mercy on us.
You didn’t even start the video off explaining who this person is and how much good he has done for others. Instead I’m looking at the comments in this video and people are suggesting he’s a radical and he doesn’t know what he’s talking about. Astaghfirullah. This is the type of behaviour you promote on your platform?
💯💯💯
Look at the bloody TH-cam comments ??? Why are all your people attacking him? A year ago you did a whole interview with him and even then you couldn’t speak to the brother respectfully. Now look at your followers and look at the things they say about the Ustadh. Look at the majority of the comments on this video and you tell me if you did more good than bad ????
The way I see it is that Muhammad Hijab's response is the unreasonable one
Just because it is hypothetically possible to rule according to the Islamic laws if the game is played in a place where Sharia is applied does not mean that there is no problem when Muslims support this system in which no crime is punished according to the Islamic laws , whether it is cheating or insulting players and fans or causing injures you will not find anywhere in the world where football-related crimes are dealt with according to Islamic laws
And you shouldn't ridicule someone just for addressing this problem
All of those things you mentioned are against the rules and nobody accepts them (except some for the cheating one). What Mohammed Hijab said makes sense. By the way, if you accept this line of thinking, then all contact sports would be impermissible according to you along with most other sports.
Pure waff
He's a literal extremist he also probably supports the Taliban