I found mob vs mogami spirits better animation than the final boss fight, the effects were just astonishing and incredible for the human eye to experience
I will change this stupid comment to something better. instead of asking an animator to talk about how good demon slayer is you should be asking a 3d animator (ufotable does things in 3d 90% of the time) about how good ufotable is at compositing and a breakdown on ufotable as a studio, stuff like that. Really I just want a breakdown on Terao, Yuuichi atm.
Okay but CLANNAD, the scenes with the loli and the robot. Its not really that nice these days but that sh*t was smooth AF and it was made in 2009 / 2010
It's beautiful to see how "art begets more art", how you, an animating artist, are inspired by other animating artists. It makes me think of a quote from Stephen King: "if you don't have time to read, you don't have time to write." 😊
Nice response but I believe art's main source should be reality, otherwise we are going die under the weight of remakes, and remasters and reboots, self-indulgent self-referential meta-fiction losing more of its core in spectacle.
@@6drk6mrc6 Reality and originality are two of those topics that can be debated ad infinitum. 😊 I personally don't mind remakes as long as they are not a way of plagiarizing or carbon-copying but a way of exploring. They show me how an artist experiences a glimpse of reality captured by another artist. But you made a very good point about reality being a source of inspiration. When artists capture that reality in their own style, in a way that feels authentic, unguarded, well ... that's some powerful art. 😊
@@maya_yaser Yes, there can be art without other artists to be inspired from: Cave people didn't learn how to draw pictures to cave walls from others. But, I see what do you mean of course it is important to be inspired by others, but what I mean is this: If your only resource of inspiration is other artists in your field (nowadays it seems most people are like this) what you are going to do is not creation but regurgitation. Hollywood for example now acts like Ouroboros or more like Human Centipede, something fresh and new is hardly coming out. For me art is a natural inclination of humans in hopes to transfer experience, be it physical or intellectual. So, if a creator has no real experience but only other peoples creations, then you can't find a uniqe angle in their works.
@@maya_yaser No worries, I couldn't find anything in your words to take offence. Yeah, you are right I wouldn't be dabbling in art if I have never seen previous masterpieces.
On the Berghaus ad: "Berghaus is using a series of original paintings, created for the campaign by up and coming UK artists Steve Playdell-Pearce, Kitty Cooper, Dot Jupitus and Tom Marsh" Adding a source to a response because I don't want to be auto flagged as spam.
Everyone talking about KNY ep 19 but here are some also good recommendations: Mob phsycho: animations’ unique and has some pretty cool and colorful moments and everything is just so perfect. It’s a master piece. Saitama: it’s animation is RAW! It’s so intense. So wild! So fast! It’s just so big and over the top. Levi v beast titan: the animation was intense. It was full of hype. And very fast paste. You really feel the strikes Levi gave to beast titan.
All my respects for all those animators in this video who achieved getting to a high level of recognition (including you Howard), as a teenager with certain amount of drawing skills and aiming for art related careers i really enjoy watching and analizing all this type of videos. I personally wish to be an animator and inprove my art skills traditionally and digitally, also as a young person who is about to finilize highschool i have some ideas for several art related careers and i would appreciate that people who see this comment answer me with inspiring chances and advices that help me increase... thank you Howard for your intuitive manner of expressing your art and knoledge with us.. really, thank you.
@@kumarthecowboy Anything by Ghibli (both by Miyazaki and Takahata) including Nausicaa and Lupin III Castle of Cagliostro which are not technically Ghibli, anything by Mamoru Hosoda or Satoshi Kon (he just made 4 films, all great). also Akira, Ghost in the Shell (or any film by Mamoru Oshii), Your Name, Weathering with you, Silent Voice, Maquia, Liz and the Blue Bird, Redline, Jin Roh the wolf brigade, Legend of the galactic heroes: My conquest is a sea of stars, & the sequel Overture to a New War. I think these are available only on Highdive, or pirate streaming sites like 9anime (the sequel series "Legend of the galactic heroes" is a bona fide classic but pretty long, 100 eps) Wolf Children Sword of the Stranger Vampire Hunter D Bloodlust ninja scroll Night is short, walk on girl tekkonkinkreet metropolis steamboy Patlabor Macross: Do you remember love? Mind game Penguin Highway (I dont know if they're out where you're at) Ride Your Wave, & Children of the Sea That should be enough of a primer ;P
Something you may have missed with that steven universe one by james baxter, is he also rotates the camera in the opposite direction the characters are spinning, while maintaining their lifelike movement, with perfect accuracy and expression. James Baxter is truly an animation genius.
@@evilgirlfangs well Kimetsu no Yaiba is already saved in my keyboard so, it's easier.. Kimetsu comes just after I type Kim and the rest follows up as well
@@evilgirlfangs This is just me, but I know the show as Kimetsu no Yaiba and not demon slayer because that's what its called on the site I watch it on. While you might find typing extra few letters to be a waste of time, for me, the mental jump required for me to connect the show I'm thinking of to a different name than I'm used to seeing it referred to as and then typing it, is actually more time-consuming. But really in the grand scheme of things taking the time to write your (and my own) comments is significantly more time-consuming than typing it either way so in conclusion this is a pointless argument. demon slayer has 12 characters including the space kimetsu no yaiba has 16 characters including the spaces I type around 70-80 wpm, so at 75 wpm which, assuming the average word to 5 letters long, implies a typing speed of 6.25 keystrokes a second therefore there is less than a second difference in typing both names...
I have a theory on how the painting commercial was made. Again because it is a theory it is not fact and should not be taken as so. I believe that they recorded the video and then use modern-day editing to get the effects of images constantly changing into other images. Once they had the commercial they liked, they broke this commercial down into individual frames.Hired a single painter to paint each frame individually and then recompiled these images that he had painted reforming it back into a video.
James Baxter is someone who I have followed for years because of his super smooth cells plus they way he portrays emotion. Like, raw emotion. It just fills my heart so much with how much work he puts into his animations, even if it is for half a minute
I so enjoyed this video, you seem like the kind of person I could sit down with and talk for hours about creativity. You have a really genuine attitude and a softness about you that reveals how much you appreciate your art-form. Subscribed
@@arnoygayen1984 its, basically, something peoole say when they hear a piece of music so good they can't even describe it. Or that's how I've seen the word been used tho ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Mr.Fear by SIAMES has some really well emoted and fluid action effects, that would be cool for you to react to! (The wolf is good too) A lot of animation from mob psycho 100 has really stylized, fluid movements too (paint on glass parts especially)
@@mrknowitall2303 One Punch Man had good animation, but it's nowhere near as creative or expressive as the Mob Psycho animation. Both Mob seasons are still some of the best animation in anime period. May I remind you the Mob season 1 outro was made out of oil paintings on glass?
I love and live for these kinds of videos HOWARD because its honest and insightful especially for those who are still working on achieving their goals and who looks up to people like you.
Anthony Varela they did their best for the amount of time they had, overall mediocre to somewhat above. There are so many more animes out there with worse animation *cough* seven deadly sins season 3
LaylaMiki may of the best animators from not even madhouse worked on opm season 1 as a passion project, it was a one time one of a kind season without the amount of work put in. The only anime fight I have ever seen animated better than saitama vs boros was a fight in the fate movies by ufotable
@@Azrael_Shade do u have source for that? Cuz I doubt it. I mean, its stupid for incredibly skilled artist like james baxter to rotoscope 3d sequence when he can just animate by hand
@@mobi8046 I heard about it a while ago so I'd have to find it to make sure. But rotoscoping something like that is NOT stupid by any means. Even if it's by a skilled artist.
If you like the pained style, you should watch Loving Vincent. It was filmed with actors then hundreds of painters went in and painted over every frame in van Gogh's style.
I dearly recommend you the movie "Loving Vincent" the animation is brilliant and every frame is painted by hand by a lot of artists, it's truly a work of art ❤️
Even when Crimson Alpine looks a bit choppy since there aren't enough frames between an action, it still maintains the feeling of momentum and that's something I find really neat
Some stories can only be told through animation, some ideas can only be interpreted in animation, some things are just meant to be animated, some things can only just be animated, and that’s okay, because there are so many talented animators out there, and I know, without a single doubt in my mind, that they can make tell those stories, they can interpret those ideas, and these animations are living proof of that. Godspeed, animators and aspiring animators.
Please stop asking me about Demon Slayer episode 19 - I already made a video breakdown of it here: th-cam.com/video/Df9RNez-HPI/w-d-xo.html And yes, I am aware that ANIME exists. I made a whole different video for Anime th-cam.com/video/Swq4j-x9u2Y/w-d-xo.html You can download my Animator's Checklist PDF guide for FREE here: www.animatorguild.com/checklist-pdf-predownload.html Very helpful for the animation process.
man, i hope you can do a video on the animation for episode 19 of kimetsu no yaiba or demon slayer because the animation for the dance was literally some of the best animation i had ever seen in anime
If you are talking about the fathers dance in the snow, the thecnique they are using is rotoscopia so they film a real person doing that movements and then redarwn it frame by frame instead of normal animation.
Then you ignorants need to watch more anime if you think demon slayer has the best animation, renember everything you idiots say is opinions and not facts
James Baxter is definetly a great example. Though I'm a bigger fan in Japanese animations, his animations in western cartoons really blew me away. When I first watched that Steven Universe episode, that one scene actually stood out a lot because it was just so smooth and look so 3D animated that it was mind blowing.
I’m a 3D artist, it’s somewhat different, I haven’t really tried 2d animation,nor 2d at all. I only tampered with it when I was looking at game development in 2d. But, I do gotta say. You can do something for 5 hours and you’ll end up with a 8 second animation. So how people do this is beyond me. I’ve been animating for 4 years and I still have mild skill level. When you animate yourself, it really brings the attention to how much dedication and skill it takes to do this stuff.
@@SigmaSigmaBoy-m2b what? You think naruto fights are shit? Go watch kakashi vs obito, madara vs ninja alliance, naruto vs Sasuke part 2, literally the best choreography fights you can get in anime, don't be under a delusion, opinions don't care about facts
Just so you know the reason that the Castlevania intro is done in that way is because it is flames. The first few seconds are Draculas wife burning at the stake, and the rest is either the consequences of that or the cause/main characters. It is so good even without that context, but if you watch the show it just is amazing!
I love art so much its really amazing what we can create with just a pencil and our imagination never stop trying guys dare to be different keep grinding 🙏🏽
I got shocked when you reacted to crimson alpine- I've watching the same animator for years now and I'm glad he reached here Sorry for bring late whoops--
the Third one looks like made with grease pen in Blender. It looks like a 2-d, but it's a 3-d animation I think. By the way, I like the first one, I like the transitions of scenes.
Hi Howard, I know a few of the people involved with the Berghaus film, the director was Em Cooper, additional production from the Kitchen at Jelly London.
Ik like people dont like anime. But Demon Slayer ep 19 the fight scene against lower 5 and Boku no Hero Academia Deku vs Todoroki is worth reacting to and getting your opinion on. Could you pleas react to those 2?
He said the best animation he’s ever seen... those two episodes are just standard animation. Maybe kny will get an exception but mha is literally just a generic animated anime
I'm working on a pretty long project, and since I'm only animating for fun, do you think it would be a good idea to make other shorter animations as well?
I personally think it's up to you. If you make shorter films, you can be more consistent on uploading, if you are trying to make an image for yourself. Longer projects get recognized later, but still recognized. I guess it's more like, how much work you are willing to do for each project. For me, I got too many projects and it hinders me greatly. I am re-planning a few to shorter animations to fit all that I want to do. I dont know your situation at all, just try to understand what you are doing and what you want and judge with those things in mind.
I tend to recommend building up to a long film. A bit like how runners train for a marathon - first they run a 5k then 10k, 15k... if you just go straight in for a marathon you will struggle
@@HowardWimshurst I get it. Lota of beginners tackle something they never done, or for a lengthy degree. Its up to the persona ability for there are some who have talent and can handle longer films. Me for example cant. I produce animations under 10 seconds.... my last was like 3 seconds long and I added some effects. I'm still a frame by frame beginner though, if you wondering how long I been doing it for....... not very long. But I still apply certain principles when tackling new fields. Always take my time, get used to it, learn the necessities and become decent enough to start being more creative. I did that with my garage and on my ipad. Got some songs for my animations. Sorry, I ramble. I really try not to when replying....
Yes I realize that I'm commenting on this a few years after you made this vid, but I might as well say that my favorite animation that I've ever seen(and I haven't seen a lot so don't judge me) is the music video for The Wolf by SIAMÉS. It was really well done and idk its just my long time favorite
In terms of animation quality,I highly recommend akira and redline.Akira used over 160,000 animation cels while redline was handrawn and worked on for 7 years.Both required a lot of money and one even made a studio nearly bankrupt.
It is really good, but definitely isn't the best I've seen. But for a weekly anime is is high quality. The anime uses a very unique art style and great uses of camera movement and CG. I really liked the drum demon with the rooms changing orientation. THAT was impressive.
This man is the first person on utube that ive seen pausing a vid with space, forward/backward with arrow keys without using a freakin mouse and clicking on those stupid slidy bar
Imagine how much time they spend just to create those animations. All animators out there we appreciate ya'll!!!
They work so hard! That sand one and Van Gogh one were really creative!
1 week
After spending 2 hours to 1 second animation (as an absolutely beginner) I can imagine😅
@@Tokax no
Very True
Mob Psycho's second season opening would have been worth reviewing too.
finally someone talking about mob
I salute you
Or the fight btw mob and the main boss dude in s2
I found mob vs mogami spirits better animation than the final boss fight, the effects were just astonishing and incredible for the human eye to experience
all Mob fight scene is worth reviewing
I'm agreed
I will change this stupid comment to something better.
instead of asking an animator to talk about how good demon slayer is you should be asking a 3d animator (ufotable does things in 3d 90% of the time) about how good ufotable is at compositing and a breakdown on ufotable as a studio, stuff like that.
Really I just want a breakdown on Terao, Yuuichi atm.
Ikr. And BNHA Deku vs Todoroki is worth reacting to. Same as Deku vs Bakugou season 3
Okay but CLANNAD, the scenes with the loli and the robot. Its not really that nice these days but that sh*t was smooth AF and it was made in 2009 / 2010
@@persephonepomegranate9652 yeah but even before that there is Akira lol smooth as f. We need an animator that would actually look at anime T^T
vp 787 i think its just a matter of relevance since it is new
@@sirkibble2864 Mob is also new ...
I want to be an animator
Me: can't draw, too lazy
Me still: I want to be an animator
it's 3d stuff then
@@ridhosamudro2199 too much shortcut, too lazy
Lol I'm lazy too but I wonna be comic book artist
@@mr.2minutes161 are you saying creating 3d art is lazy or that you're lazy?
@@dabi8895 WE CAN DO THIS!!!! LAZY PEOPLE UNITE!!!
1:14 - Time to get out
2:56 - Confusion through sand
4:41 - Crimson alpine
8:20 - Castlevania
9:13 - Fumiko's confession
10:21 - Steven's fusion
It's beautiful to see how "art begets more art", how you, an animating artist, are inspired by other animating artists. It makes me think of a quote from Stephen King: "if you don't have time to read, you don't have time to write." 😊
Nice response but I believe art's main source should be reality, otherwise we are going die under the weight of remakes, and remasters and reboots, self-indulgent self-referential meta-fiction losing more of its core in spectacle.
@@6drk6mrc6 Reality and originality are two of those topics that can be debated ad infinitum. 😊 I personally don't mind remakes as long as they are not a way of plagiarizing or carbon-copying but a way of exploring. They show me how an artist experiences a glimpse of reality captured by another artist.
But you made a very good point about reality being a source of inspiration. When artists capture that reality in their own style, in a way that feels authentic, unguarded, well ... that's some powerful art. 😊
@@maya_yaser Yes, there can be art without other artists to be inspired from: Cave people didn't learn how to draw pictures to cave walls from others. But, I see what do you mean of course it is important to be inspired by others, but what I mean is this: If your only resource of inspiration is other artists in your field (nowadays it seems most people are like this) what you are going to do is not creation but regurgitation. Hollywood for example now acts like Ouroboros or more like Human Centipede, something fresh and new is hardly coming out.
For me art is a natural inclination of humans in hopes to transfer experience, be it physical or intellectual. So, if a creator has no real experience but only other peoples creations, then you can't find a uniqe angle in their works.
@@BiancaAguglia I don't mind remakes in the sense that they can be a good way to introduce classics to upcoming generations.
Thanks for the feedback.
@@maya_yaser No worries, I couldn't find anything in your words to take offence. Yeah, you are right I wouldn't be dabbling in art if I have never seen previous masterpieces.
On the Berghaus ad:
"Berghaus is using a series of original paintings, created for the campaign by up and coming UK artists Steve Playdell-Pearce, Kitty Cooper, Dot Jupitus and Tom Marsh"
Adding a source to a response because I don't want to be auto flagged as spam.
fantastic, thank you so much!!!
please react to demon slayer episode 19 it's a God tier animation
incREDiblast X oooo yeeees
Thought I was the only one that thought so, that episode was amazing
YESSSS PLEASE OMG OMG
YESSSS DO ITTT
I was gonna comment this if no one said it lls
Everyone talking about KNY ep 19 but here are some also good recommendations:
Mob phsycho: animations’ unique and has some pretty cool and colorful moments and everything is just so perfect. It’s a master piece.
Saitama: it’s animation is RAW! It’s so intense. So wild! So fast! It’s just so big and over the top.
Levi v beast titan: the animation was intense. It was full of hype. And very fast paste. You really feel the strikes Levi gave to beast titan.
especially the ed for mp100, goddamn.
All my respects for all those animators in this video who achieved getting to a high level of recognition (including you Howard), as a teenager with certain amount of drawing skills and aiming for art related careers i really enjoy watching and analizing all this type of videos.
I personally wish to be an animator and inprove my art skills traditionally and digitally, also as a young person who is about to finilize highschool i have some ideas for several art related careers and i would appreciate that people who see this comment answer me with inspiring chances and advices that help me increase... thank you Howard for your intuitive manner of expressing your art and knoledge with us.. really, thank you.
9:08 Just incase no one knows, Hiroyasu Ishida had his feature film debut last year as director of Penguin Highway!
hey hey help me ....
i am not into anime so much can you suggest some good movies to watch 😊
@@kumarthecowboy "Weathering with You" will start airing 21st August. Or if you haven't seen "Your Name" (Kimi no Na Wa) it's highly recommended
@@gildas2684 Thank You
@@kumarthecowboy Anything by Ghibli (both by Miyazaki and Takahata) including Nausicaa and Lupin III Castle of Cagliostro which are not technically Ghibli, anything by Mamoru Hosoda or Satoshi Kon (he just made 4 films, all great).
also
Akira,
Ghost in the Shell (or any film by Mamoru Oshii),
Your Name, Weathering with you,
Silent Voice,
Maquia,
Liz and the Blue Bird,
Redline,
Jin Roh the wolf brigade,
Legend of the galactic heroes: My conquest is a sea of stars, & the sequel Overture to a New War. I think these are available only on Highdive, or pirate streaming sites like 9anime (the sequel series "Legend of the galactic heroes" is a bona fide classic but pretty long, 100 eps)
Wolf Children
Sword of the Stranger
Vampire Hunter D Bloodlust
ninja scroll
Night is short, walk on girl
tekkonkinkreet
metropolis
steamboy
Patlabor
Macross: Do you remember love?
Mind game
Penguin Highway
(I dont know if they're out where you're at) Ride Your Wave, & Children of the Sea
That should be enough of a primer ;P
@@kumarthecowboy Silent Voice and Violet Evergarden.
I think some good examples of amazing Modern 2D Animation are the Violet Evergarden CMs and the Levi vs Kenny chase scene, among others
There's still tons of phenomenal modern 2D animations out there, MOB Psycho 100 and One Punch Man S1 are prime examples.
Levi v beast titan is a good short animation
Xtra but a bit spoily
@@ryantheanimator1156 One Punch Man is one of my favorites!
Bruh
Broly vs Gogeta in the movie Dragon Ball super Broly
THAT is a work of art
I can never miss a video of yours...
It's always just full of information and so much to learn from.
Thank you and keep up the good work!
"Cameras so low to the ground makes everything seem massive..."
*camera immediately starts panning up
Something you may have missed with that steven universe one by james baxter, is he also rotates the camera in the opposite direction the characters are spinning, while maintaining their lifelike movement, with perfect accuracy and expression. James Baxter is truly an animation genius.
"Animator reacts to incredible modern 2D Animation"
it's not true, Crimson Alpine in not an incredible animation.
It's a godlike one
i want him to make an anime of that girl
Yesss
violet evergarden: not even close
@@goofy_mf45 crimson alpine is made by 1 person
@@evoid.3949is pretty good for one person and by pretty good I mean SUPER GOOD
Kudos to everyone who is talking bout Kimetsu no Yaiba ep19
Not epic battle but very good... Ufotable animation as always
@@evilgirlfangs what's wrong with that??
@@evilgirlfangs well Kimetsu no Yaiba is already saved in my keyboard so, it's easier..
Kimetsu comes just after I type Kim and the rest follows up as well
@@evilgirlfangs how is that annoying ? I don't get it , you're weird .
@@evilgirlfangs This is just me, but I know the show as Kimetsu no Yaiba and not demon slayer because that's what its called on the site I watch it on. While you might find typing extra few letters to be a waste of time, for me, the mental jump required for me to connect the show I'm thinking of to a different name than I'm used to seeing it referred to as and then typing it, is actually more time-consuming. But really in the grand scheme of things taking the time to write your (and my own) comments is significantly more time-consuming than typing it either way so in conclusion this is a pointless argument.
demon slayer has 12 characters including the space
kimetsu no yaiba has 16 characters including the spaces
I type around 70-80 wpm, so at 75 wpm which, assuming the average word to 5 letters long, implies a typing speed of 6.25 keystrokes a second therefore there is less than a second difference in typing both names...
I have a theory on how the painting commercial was made. Again because it is a theory it is not fact and should not be taken as so.
I believe that they recorded the video and then use modern-day editing to get the effects of images constantly changing into other images. Once they had the commercial they liked, they broke this commercial down into individual frames.Hired a single painter to paint each frame individually and then recompiled these images that he had painted reforming it back into a video.
The more skilled of an animator you are
The more appreciation you can give to these works of arts
The tale of Princess Kaguya is the most beautiful and underrated animation I've seen
The Midoriya vs Todoroki fight in BNHA, is pretty good, the scene that Todoroki release all his fire power for the first time is so great
Anime 2d are pretty cool!
Effort and details.
James Baxter is someone who I have followed for years because of his super smooth cells plus they way he portrays emotion. Like, raw emotion. It just fills my heart so much with how much work he puts into his animations, even if it is for half a minute
man, that castlevania intro give me goosebumps, the first seconds transition ,when its falling ashes from dracula's hand... dear god
I so enjoyed this video, you seem like the kind of person I could sit down with and talk for hours about creativity. You have a really genuine attitude and a softness about you that reveals how much you appreciate your art-form. Subscribed
I had only seen Steven's so far so I'm super grateful to have seen all the others now! Thank you so much for sharing them!!
These were all so beautiful man. And the fact that they kept on going is inspiring.
Stop asking him to react to demon slayer, he already has. Leave him alone
Yeah . U r right , but
Why doesnt this have reply?
@@xusux ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
If you haven't reacted to anything from Violet Evergarden, you're missing out dude...
Yeah , it is great
Kyoto animation...
You know "eargasms"? Well this is the animation equivalent to that.
@@moonkafu2157 now , what is EARGASMS ?????
Violet... Wow... I got something in my eye... Lemme get It out
@@arnoygayen1984 its, basically, something peoole say when they hear a piece of music so good they can't even describe it. Or that's how I've seen the word been used tho ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
I don't know anything about Steven Universe and that scene almost made me cry.
That cartoon is pretty good but the fandom sucks, better don't join the fandom and enjoy
Dude, James Baxter's Chel animation is AMAZING! Not just because the character, but the expression and movement is soooo damn fluid.
Mr.Fear by SIAMES has some really well emoted and fluid action effects, that would be cool for you to react to! (The wolf is good too)
A lot of animation from mob psycho 100 has really stylized, fluid movements too (paint on glass parts especially)
peachie5000 omg yesss
Demon slayer episode 19, has some of the best animation I have ever seen.
Yeah the best i think than other anime
@@smalif2852 come on now let's not forget OPM and aot . It's in top list i guess
Ya but i think its better thou..just an opinion🙌
what about this - th-cam.com/video/xU47nhruN-Q/w-d-xo.html
@@mrknowitall2303 One Punch Man had good animation, but it's nowhere near as creative or expressive as the Mob Psycho animation. Both Mob seasons are still some of the best animation in anime period. May I remind you the Mob season 1 outro was made out of oil paintings on glass?
I love and live for these kinds of videos HOWARD because its honest and insightful especially for those who are still working on achieving their goals and who looks up to people like you.
You made my eyes sweaty with the amount of passion you had described the last animation.
Best animation I have ever seen :
One Punch Man season 1
Worst animations I have ever seen:
One Punch Man season 2
Except for the parts animated by akoi
Anthony Varela they did their best for the amount of time they had, overall mediocre to somewhat above. There are so many more animes out there with worse animation *cough* seven deadly sins season 3
LaylaMiki may of the best animators from not even madhouse worked on opm season 1 as a passion project, it was a one time one of a kind season without the amount of work put in. The only anime fight I have ever seen animated better than saitama vs boros was a fight in the fate movies by ufotable
When I saw for the first time the scene on Steven universe made by James Baxter, I thought the giant woman, white diamond, was 3d!!!
Same here.
But it isn't. :0
Actually that rotation was made in 3d but then 2d was put over top of it.
@@Azrael_Shade thx for the info
@@Azrael_Shade do u have source for that? Cuz I doubt it. I mean, its stupid for incredibly skilled artist like james baxter to rotoscope 3d sequence when he can just animate by hand
@@mobi8046 I heard about it a while ago so I'd have to find it to make sure. But rotoscoping something like that is NOT stupid by any means. Even if it's by a skilled artist.
You should have watched Siames - The Wolf
this is too profissional , pro
@@VisitTube700 THAT one is professipnal
Oh shut somebody knows !
That MV is GOLDEN
Man this video is amazing!
everything you say its so sincere, not much talking, and very understandble. This made me open my eyes to Animation!
Bro...YOUR VOICE PLUS THIS 2:15(THE GRASS) IS LIKE SO SO RELAXING... DAMNNN
If you like the pained style, you should watch Loving Vincent. It was filmed with actors then hundreds of painters went in and painted over every frame in van Gogh's style.
I dearly recommend you the movie "Loving Vincent" the animation is brilliant and every frame is painted by hand by a lot of artists, it's truly a work of art ❤️
Ada Moreno well ehm i recomend you alexander petrov ..... 🤷🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️🤷🏻♂️
James's part on Steven Universe always actually makes me fkin cry its so good TT
Even when Crimson Alpine looks a bit choppy since there aren't enough frames between an action, it still maintains the feeling of momentum and that's something I find really neat
Love seeing anything resh animates
"I'm a professional animator" I love that chance
Plot twist: he’s reacting to his own animations to compliment himself
Plot twist : you are the animator giving clues that its his own animation
“James Baxter”
The horse?
Dude xD
the horse is actually voiced and named after James Baxter! im so glad I wasn't the only one thinking this.
THAT'S WHAT I WAS THINKING
*Jaaaeaeaemees baxteer*
@@ali-amaza *and animated by James baxter
Some stories can only be told through animation, some ideas can only be interpreted in animation, some things are just meant to be animated, some things can only just be animated, and that’s okay, because there are so many talented animators out there, and I know, without a single doubt in my mind, that they can make tell those stories, they can interpret those ideas, and these animations are living proof of that. Godspeed, animators and aspiring animators.
ok, these animations are great, but your shirt is on whole another league, love it
The paint one, they probably animated normally and painted over it
Please stop asking me about Demon Slayer episode 19 - I already made a video breakdown of it here: th-cam.com/video/Df9RNez-HPI/w-d-xo.html
And yes, I am aware that ANIME exists. I made a whole different video for Anime th-cam.com/video/Swq4j-x9u2Y/w-d-xo.html
You can download my Animator's Checklist PDF guide for FREE here: www.animatorguild.com/checklist-pdf-predownload.html
Very helpful for the animation process.
You need to see the warhammer part 1-5 animation its incredible
men create a part 2 where you react to demon slayer,mob psycho,jojo?,etc
man, i hope you can do a video on the animation for episode 19 of kimetsu no yaiba or demon slayer because the animation for the dance was literally some of the best animation i had ever seen in anime
YES. I only came here just to say that
If you are talking about the fathers dance in the snow, the thecnique they are using is rotoscopia so they film a real person doing that movements and then redarwn it frame by frame instead of normal animation.
@@TheMr.PrinceKnight And it was on 60 fps which is way above anime standard
@@hamody238 Oh i don't knew that but it make sense because it was looked way to smooth.
Then you ignorants need to watch more anime if you think demon slayer has the best animation, renember everything you idiots say is opinions and not facts
10:00 Did you just disregard the most accomplished work in the bunch with no comments?!?!
James Baxter is definetly a great example. Though I'm a bigger fan in Japanese animations, his animations in western cartoons really blew me away. When I first watched that Steven Universe episode, that one scene actually stood out a lot because it was just so smooth and look so 3D animated that it was mind blowing.
Everybody’s talking about demon slayer, I literally just came here for Resh
**s a m e**
Yup that's right
Samee
i wanted umbrella smh
Resh and Rush should collab
When he says "Steven's universe" 🥺
Everyone: talks bout kimetsu no yaiba ep 19.
Me: *laughs in shimazaki fight*
Haha yes that was one crazy fight.
I dont know why but this video cleared the fog in my mind ..... made me appreciate the creativity in the world again!!
I’m a 3D artist, it’s somewhat different, I haven’t really tried 2d animation,nor 2d at all. I only tampered with it when I was looking at game development in 2d. But, I do gotta say. You can do something for 5 hours and you’ll end up with a 8 second animation. So how people do this is beyond me. I’ve been animating for 4 years and I still have mild skill level. When you animate yourself, it really brings the attention to how much dedication and skill it takes to do this stuff.
REACT to DEMON SLAYER PLEASE!! EPISODE 19 FIGHT SCENE
That was epic
Or react to naruto best fights
@@livetochange974 ehhhh
@@SigmaSigmaBoy-m2b what? You think naruto fights are shit? Go watch kakashi vs obito, madara vs ninja alliance, naruto vs Sasuke part 2, literally the best choreography fights you can get in anime, don't be under a delusion, opinions don't care about facts
@@livetochange974 most of them are kinda shit. The ones you mentioned are good. But there are a lot of shit ones
That first clip where everything was painted is cool, but there’s an entire movie about Van Gogh on netflix which is animated in that style
"Hi there, my name is Howard Wincest"
Just so you know the reason that the Castlevania intro is done in that way is because it is flames. The first few seconds are Draculas wife burning at the stake, and the rest is either the consequences of that or the cause/main characters. It is so good even without that context, but if you watch the show it just is amazing!
I love art so much its really amazing what we can create with just a pencil and our imagination never stop trying guys dare to be different keep grinding 🙏🏽
I got shocked when you reacted to crimson alpine-
I've watching the same animator for years now and I'm glad he reached here
Sorry for bring late whoops--
the Third one looks like made with grease pen in Blender.
It looks like a 2-d, but it's a 3-d animation I think.
By the way, I like the first one, I like the transitions of scenes.
I think mobpsycho 100 feels like a movie bcz of how they animate it is so badass in each episode
Hi Howard, I know a few of the people involved with the Berghaus film, the director was Em Cooper, additional production from the Kitchen at Jelly London.
Everyone talking about everything:
Me: oh, Steven Universe is here too!
Next video can you do the video about this anime call demon Slayer cause the animation is totally awesome you gotta see it
Ik like people dont like anime. But Demon Slayer ep 19 the fight scene against lower 5 and Boku no Hero Academia Deku vs Todoroki is worth reacting to and getting your opinion on. Could you pleas react to those 2?
OMG MHA
He said the best animation he’s ever seen... those two episodes are just standard animation. Maybe kny will get an exception but mha is literally just a generic animated anime
You seen the fight between todoroki and Deku? Or All Might vs All for One???
@@blazette2064 all might Vs all for one was pretty meh in terms of Animation, except a few cuts
Yeah ngl, idk what I was thinking then lol
Samurai Champloo can still go toe to toe with modern animation it's such an amazing series.
no animator's free time and hands were harmed in this video except the ones who made the animations
Me: wants to animate but sucks
Me after watching this: cries in the corner of the room cause i cant animate as good as these peopl
They all started where you did as well.
dude the people that made these people are VERY experienced with animation and you’re only starting
I'm working on a pretty long project, and since I'm only animating for fun, do you think it would be a good idea to make other shorter animations as well?
I personally think it's up to you. If you make shorter films, you can be more consistent on uploading, if you are trying to make an image for yourself. Longer projects get recognized later, but still recognized. I guess it's more like, how much work you are willing to do for each project. For me, I got too many projects and it hinders me greatly. I am re-planning a few to shorter animations to fit all that I want to do. I dont know your situation at all, just try to understand what you are doing and what you want and judge with those things in mind.
@@TheLuconic thanks for the advice
I tend to recommend building up to a long film. A bit like how runners train for a marathon - first they run a 5k then 10k, 15k... if you just go straight in for a marathon you will struggle
@@HowardWimshurst thanks so much
@@HowardWimshurst I get it. Lota of beginners tackle something they never done, or for a lengthy degree. Its up to the persona ability for there are some who have talent and can handle longer films. Me for example cant. I produce animations under 10 seconds.... my last was like 3 seconds long and I added some effects. I'm still a frame by frame beginner though, if you wondering how long I been doing it for....... not very long. But I still apply certain principles when tackling new fields. Always take my time, get used to it, learn the necessities and become decent enough to start being more creative. I did that with my garage and on my ipad. Got some songs for my animations. Sorry, I ramble. I really try not to when replying....
You gotta react to Kimetsu no Yaiba episode 19, the last fight scene was way too freaking beautiful.
Yes I realize that I'm commenting on this a few years after you made this vid, but I might as well say that my favorite animation that I've ever seen(and I haven't seen a lot so don't judge me) is the music video for The Wolf by SIAMÉS. It was really well done and idk its just my long time favorite
In terms of animation quality,I highly recommend akira and redline.Akira used over 160,000 animation cels while redline was handrawn and worked on for 7 years.Both required a lot of money and one even made a studio nearly bankrupt.
So many see this on their recommendations and thought that he was reacting to kimetsu no yaiba but no,So we all want him to react to episode 19 lol.
Literally 2 days after the demon slayer fight scene blows up,react to it please
My hero academia: United States of Smash!
This video made me fall in love with animating all over again.. Thank you!
damn that reel of your work was rly impressive! keep it up
Haven’t heard medicine by Joji since middle school lmao
everyone: demon slayer ep 19
me: *my hero academia s4 ep 76*
no
*insert Kimetsu no Yaiba episode 19*
Very informative video as I’m getting started as an animator thank you for making it :)
Oh man. I can just see so many deep learning application that can make lots of the stuff so much easier.
Please react to Goku vs Broly from Naotoshi Shida! It's absolutely insane! 🔥 Very Good video btw👍👌💯
*Gogeta vs Broly
@@yusufkrz5839 all 3 of the fights had god tier animation.
So I heard demon slayer episode 19 was good (from these comments lol) I guess I have to see it
YES.
It is really good, but definitely isn't the best I've seen. But for a weekly anime is is high quality. The anime uses a very unique art style and great uses of camera movement and CG. I really liked the drum demon with the rooms changing orientation. THAT was impressive.
Watch Ufotable's animation..... splendid
Wow dude thx for reacting to my friend RESHs animation hes really happy
did he see my video about it?
I saw Crimson Alpine soo much times...I love that animation. It's so smooth even yet it's only 2 color animation.
I think you should react to the jojo’s bizarre adventure opening!
Inappropriate comment sorry
Howard be out here looking like a snack. 🤭
joseph's daughter's son thank you for stating the underlying reason we all gathered here today
facts
React to Violet Evergarden and Kimetsu no Yaiba ;)
This man is the first person on utube that ive seen pausing a vid with space, forward/backward with arrow keys without using a freakin mouse and clicking on those stupid slidy bar
I think I bump into this video 3 times a year and I still enjoy it
A big round of applause for the Japanese anime industry..