In the far future. Right now i can see a remake of persona 4 happening next since the success of p3 reload. The soup of success is exactly the same. In p1 and p2 since they are more megami tensei in nature they could make them similar to refantasio in some form or shape.
If they do I think their may be an issue because will atlus make persona 1 a Dungeon Crawler which the first one was or something else and will they rewrite a lot of things in the story that may have made it different form persona 3,4,5. If they do make it a Dungeon crawler the persona fans now may have an issue with the game I think but depending how atlus does it it can work.
@@alexamiridis2317 I would actually like that for p1 and p2 if they do remake them but persona 4 I wonder would they do a little bit more then just make it a better looking game like add more mystery in the game or something else even though it would sell well regardless.
@@DragonKingX78 We don't really need more ports tbh, maybe an official translation for P2EP, but otherwise I would think just do a full remake. Persona 1 is very outdated and in a big need of a brush up
@@Raytheman581 those psp ports besides EP's had a a lot of controversial things changed that it lead to not being people's preferred version in their base vanilla state
If they do remake 1 and both 2s I hope.... 1)They do not add the calendar system/school sim stuff. 2)They keep the party number at 5. 3)That everyone can use every persona. 4)That if the main character dies it is not game over. 5)Update unique Personas/demons, don't just delete them from the game like the P3 remake. 6)That I still like the character designs. 7)That they do no mess up/replace the music.
Naw a lot of those are going to get changed, you're getting your hopes up with all of that. They are going to add some sim type element because those help the game sell well regardless of if we're tired of it in games or not. Also I'm fine with 1 adding most stuff to it cause on its own its a very bland game. There was also nothing really special about any of the character designs for p1, they looked like characters in any person, which is generic school teens. P2 had some flair, and I doubt they would mess with the designs much.
@@Eclipse_NT Yeah people who haven't played Persona 3 like Reload, as well as people who didn't like original Persona 3 (because of the things that made that game unique!!) And sales prove nothing about quality. It's not surprising whatsoever that a Persona 3 remake sold well
@@Eclipse_NT High sales = not always good game. The best proof is Sonic and Pokemon, who have dogshit quality, but sells well, because kids have no brains.
You said that "older persona fans want to see p1 and p2 remade" but I can say as one of the "new" persona fan that I want a persona 2 remake more then anything. I think p4 is still a solid game that plays perfectly fine on any platform, but first two entries need remakes more. I loved persona 2 and it is my second favorite persona game after p3
p1 should get the remake treatment first, mainly due to the obvious continuity that it's more of a prevalent thing then the modern games where some of the p1 cast return as party members and have their own continuation story to continue off of
@@nightwish1453 if atlus remaking the game based on the poling placement unfortunately we will get p2is/ep remake first and then not p1 but digital devil saga 1 and then finally persona 1
I know this isn't something you'll report on but former Midori now ryanfromthebronx (who despite being a disgraced leaker was still fairly accurate) said that P1 is getting a remake and P2 is getting a remaster, all in development. As well as a spin off game with multiple characters from each series (apparently that project isn't dead I guess?). I kinda believe it just because ATLUS is in a new era and it feels like they're really trying to make persona as massive as possible to take the company to new heights.
I'd like to see P1/2 with modernized gameplay and mechanics. M@ybeneven a reimagining, keeping the story but bringing the feel somewhat closer to the newer games. A _lot_ of Persona fans are curious about the early games, but don't have easy access to them. And the gameplay didn't age well. I think there's be a lot of momentum to the early games reworked into something fresher.
After seeing what can be done following P3 Reload I would like to see all of the persona games be brought up to that level. It's certainly needful for the first two installments. I would be happy to see P4 get that level of love and attention also.
I would love a p1 and p2 remake but I could definitely see p4 getting a remake before those 2 becuase outside of updating the graphics and maybe some gameplay mechanics, p4 would probably be easier to remake than p1 and p2. The fact that Wada didnt outright say its not happening is a good sign. Plus with the 30th anniversary coming up, i feel like anything is possible even if its just remasters and ports of old games.
P1 and P2 are definitely getting remakes. Especially with how much fans wanted a 2 remake alongside the 3 remake (as evidenced by the Persona game remake poll they ran a few years back)
Theyd have to rebuild the story make it like 3 to 5, but using persona 2 characters and villians, youd have to forgo the duology and make it a single story
1 and 2 are far better then the rest. They went into the sim territory and that totally turned me off all the games. As for 1 and 2’s they were incredible. The music was amazing and the vibe was so good. It’s to dated graphically for me to try and give them another go but I would love a remake
@@sumireravenclaw8034Duh. The whole point of a remake is to revamp the outdated stuff, of course they'd rework the battle system and the persona system.
I think P1-P2 deserves the remake treatment more but then again P4 is popular and the safer route to go even if it's unnecessary. Although given with Atlus being greedy I will not be surprised they locked content from the third semester and probably more I guess we will see if P4 remake happens.
that seems like the next best thing for the persona franchise. persona 4 had a somewhat remake with persona 4 golden, and the og persona 5 had a remake to with persona 5 royale with a new character and new things to do. persona 1 and 2 remakes would only seem like the next step, and I would give atlus all my money.
100% agree, P4 is just too safe compared to P1 and P2. I low key expect them to soft reboot P1 and P2, closer to Soul Hackers 2 but with bigger budget and effort and longer than the originals of course.
I don't think that's a good idea with Persona 1, the gameplay design is really outdated. There is a need for a big rework on a gameplay front really. And P2IS is just a bit too easy, need a need for a rebalance
Nah, there are some things worth keeping like multiple Personas for all party members and finding a way to keep the formation system would be cool but things like negotiations need some serious streamlining
@@heterosexualtraplord7861 Yeah tbh you only need two formations, one for one you're attacked from behind and one for literally everything else. It definitely needs reworking but it has potential
Bro sorry if this is a weird comment but you are speaking way clearer now than you used to, it makes your videos a lot better and easier to watch. Well done, man
As a newer fan who got and finished P5 a few weeks before the announcement of P5r (unfortunate timing, i know, lol). I really do appreciate P3r, as it allowed me to play the game without playing the (from what I've herd) janky port or getting my hands on an older console and old game that might not work due to second hand selling, all while massivly upgrading the visuals to the point of being one of the best looking anime style games out there. But, while i would also love a remake in the same quality as Reload for P1, P2IS, P2EP, and P4; I would much rather prefer a P6, as it's been a while since the last Persona game, and I know most long time fans probably feel the same way too, probably more so. So my hope is at least one remake AFTER P6.
I would like to play Persona 1 and 2 in the Persona 3 Reload style. I think they would do great! Give me Persona 4 in that style too. Also Atlus remake Persona Q, and Q2 and my life is yours.
So, my idea for a "remake" of p1 and 2 is: An updated UI in line of 3R and 5R Voice acting and updated art, while everything else is the same. Keep the same music but allow us to switch from PS1 and PSP, but use the psp version as the base.(for P1) They could be remasters in the same way metroid prime 1 hd is a remaster. Obviously, this more than just a port but its less than a full remake. They won't really have to rewrite anything but tweak it to make a better overall experience. Like in P1 make it to where you only need to play through the game once, while in p2 make it a collection of the 2 like in P3 and The Answer. You'd be able to choose. The PSP ports of P2 are fantastic versions of the games, they'd just need tweaking. While P1 needs the most work. I do think we get a P4R first, and that it'd look similar to P3R, but imo it'd be fantastic just like P3R is. Especially since they'd want to be as faithful as the original.(which would be P4G). Give P4R to the same people who did P3R and it'd be great.
Obviously we all want P1 and P2 remakes, but it definitely makes more sense to do P4 first. P4 really doesn't NEED one, P3 actually needed one, But it's more so that P4 actually deserves a modernized, smooth version like P3R. We all know P1 and P2 will get theirs, and they definitely need the remakes the most, But P4 is one of the all time GOAT's. Let's not act like it'd hurt to have a smooth remake of it. It definitely deserves one as well. Then P1 & P2 can fall right after. I personally world like to see a SMTIII/SMTIV remake as well as many other things. They got a lot of great options, and they can only do 1 at a time guys. Be patient!
I just don't get their obsession with a P4 remake. P4 got it's definitive edition on modern platforms, and P3 needed a more definitive edition considering it's situation (of course one could argue P3 still isn't definitive lol). P1 and 2 have like no way modern or accessible ways to play them. And P4 just doesn't really have much more you can add, unless they add crazy stuff like having Marie be a party member like Kasumi, or having an Adachi story. I just wish these companies could see more than just dollar signs. Hell doing P1 and 2 first would have it so that more time passes, and P4 will feel more needed for a remake
Im ok with 4 getting a remake if it do good we will definitely get a remake 1 and 2 like of course they're going to start remakes of the most popular persona games in the franchise first if we keep supporting them we will get there eventually
We all want that could've got that now if fans didn't feel the need to waste advocating for an unnecessary remake of a story that's been told in like 10 variations
After the success of P3 Reload I can see them having plans to remake P1, 2 and even 4. However when it comes to P1 and 2 I think they would need to rework them "slightly" I think some of the gameplay mechanics aged poorly specially P1 and having P1 with gameplay style of modern persona sounds very interesting. Would they also include after school life? Could they include a calendar and sim emulator mechanic into these older games? Who knows... Would old P1 and P2 fans be happy with these changes. Many questions!
Persona 1 and 2 likely will never get remade, adding the calander system will bassically ruin the game so remaking it with a lot of modernized mechanics we see in P3R/P5R wouldn’t sit well with the fans of P1/P2 and wouldn’t fit. Old gameplay is also very clunky so while it can be modernized in some way like the shift mechanic but they can’t add a calender system because that just wouldn’t work with the way the entire story/gameplay is structured. I think we will see Smt 4/Smt 4 apocalypse remakes way before we ever get something from persona 1/2.
I think the remakes for P1 and P2 would have more fitting to be made more in the style of SMT games, giving them a post P3 school system will probably not work, especially with persona 1, it will require a full rework of the game itself
@@heterosexualtraplord7861 yeah I think an Smt style remake would work best for it, I don’t believe a persona style remake would be good for it imo, even if it is a persona game it’s very different from the usual typical persona game you would see in p3 and upwards, that’s the reason p3 and P4 as a much easier endeavor for the devs, remaking P1 and P2 will likely not be remade by the persona team but by the Smt team if anything because they are more suited to handle this type of work, with that being said I do not think we will get a p1/p2 remake until Smt 4 and Smt 4 apocalypse gets remade, only until those two gets remakes that I can see a p1/p2 remake. I think atlus could theoretically remake Smt 1 and Smt 2 but the story in that game is very outdated and the writing was pretty mediocre. They could remake Smt 3 but why would they when they already released Smt 3 nocturne HD, the only Smt game that has yes to go fully 3D was Smt 4 and I think Smt 4 will likely be in the higher priority for a remake because 1: the game was never in 3D and 2: it was on outdated tech and 3: Smt 4 and Smt 4 apocalypse revolutionized Smt series in a way that’s very distinct from nocturne which makes it good in its own unique way, regardless of whether you prefer nocturne or Smt 4, you can’t exactly deny that Smt 4 didn’t have its own unique distinct flare, environments and vibe to it including gameplay gimmicks that could be revolutionary for its time (smirk mechanic was bad but was made way better in apocalypse so I can see smt 4 remake having the same gameplay changes and QOL changes as apocalypse
@@Holy_Crusader I don't really think smt 4 and apocalypse are in any need of a remake, but they may re-release it for new consoles similar to how they did with Nocturne, unless Nintendo will get stingy about the exclusivity
Persona 2 is pretty good. I'd love to play a remake of that. Persona 1, yea I'd definitely play a remake of this. I just hope they give us 3rd person. I really get dizzy with the first person stuff. Anyway, I hope this isn't just a lifeless remaster.
I feel like they probably still do persona 4 remake before those games I’m mainly waiting for it cause they did ports p3 and p4 wrong giving them to limited run games
I hope for a remake they keep everything primarily the same. QOL updates, better graphics obviously, side quest as replacements for SL etc. the calendar system just doesn’t work for the story of P1 and P2
P1/2 remake would be an instant buy/preorder P4 remake would be mehhh I’d hold off buying it and continue playing my backlog while waiting for it to come on sale
I wonder if they can tweak the modern mechanics to the older games, idk if the s. Links would work, but given than reload managed to add new interactions with the boys I'd like to think they can make it work without hindering the storyline, I've heard they are pretty much linear
As much as I like Persona 1 and 2, I'd rather get Shin Megami Tensei I and II remakes instead. Any of those 4 would do, to be honest. Oh, and I'm still holding my breath for a P3RP (Persona 3 Reload Pink)!
While I would love a remake of Persona 1 and 2 games. Personally I would not mind or hate the idea of a remake of 4. It’ll be a lot easier for Atlus they can just use the assets of 3 Reload for 4 Remake similar to how they originally did for P3 to P4, like you said on the video remaking the first two especially the first one sounds way more challenging that I feel a lot of folks don’t realize. Like how exactly should those games play. Do we go with the first person dungeon crawler or do they do it similar to P3 Reload and P5 Vanilla/Royal? Would people be happy about the change or them keeping true the original (gameplay wise I mean). A remake of P4 wouldn’t be THAT challenging nor long for them to make. I know they’re are folks saying that P4 doesn’t need it because of P4 Golden is perfect (which I agree), but looking at the casual market who got into P5 Vanilla/Royal and Persona 3 Reload I can assure you they’re not interested in playing P4 Golden BECAUSE of how it looks in comparison though you can say the very same thing about the first two Persona games. It’s very similar to the remake of Trails in the Sky. I know people that wants to get into it, but refuse to play the first couple of games because it looks old and that doesn’t appeal to them. I do think we’ll see remakes of P1, 2 games and obviously 4, but if I was Atlus why not remake 4 first knowing it won’t be much trouble, they can release remastered versions of P1 & P2 games with QoL and THEN remake those games for newer audiences and the diehard fans.
So despite being an all-around weirdo, was "Midori" ever wrong about a leak? Cause i think he confirmed remakes of 4, 1 and 2 were already being planned
It's better to make new raidou and p6 games rather than remake p1 and p2 imo.imagine new detective like story in modern day japan as raidou jump from building to building with overthetop costume like batman and your cat mentor by your side.. I'll buy that that game in second lol.
p4 remake does not make any sense lol.. we just got updated ports of golden much more interested in SMT if.., 1 and the 2duo to at least get ported with updated controls. they sort of "remade" some of them for psp before..
Your roadmap prediction just triggered some deep seeded fears I didn't know I had, like some kind of unrealized PTSD... I was so excited for Persona 6, I never stopped to think about the inevitable 20 spinoffs over the next 10+ years, or the fact we'll surely get a "Persona 6 Royal" a couple years later...And that's not mentioning the guaranteed day 1 DLC & microtransactions! Ugh... as much as I love this series, I'm genuinely starting to dislike Atlus.
there is hope as some of the later surveys suggest them realising people are getting fed up of the re-releases that happen only a few years after the original game. I am not sure where your microtransactions point came from though
@@connorharnage6697 P4 is the best game of best blend of “persona” and SMT. The original Persona games are party oriented SMT games, which were all done better before and after.
@@mramisuzuki6962 Oh no I gotta disagree there. P4 is easily the worst imo. Granted worst by Persona standards ain't bad but of the seven party members, on two compare to 3 and 5 and they don't come anywhere near 2's party members. Combine that with a story that's 75% filler, the second worst dungeons after P1 and gameplay that's somehow worse than Persona 3's despite giving us the ability to control party members, I can't confidently say P4 is anything more than the worst mainline game
@@connorharnage6697 meamwhile IS's gameplay is so piss easy it's more tedious then anything. psp port somehow made it worse because someone was clearly really artsy with the UI
I was really gutted when they went for 3 instead of 2, I love persona 3 but it did not need a remake and the remake didn’t do much for me tbh, hell even 1 would be fantastic if they realized it’s full potential.
They probably will ruin those games by changes in story / atmosphere, adding Dating Sim / social links / calendar and change soundtrack into worse without option to switch original OST, like they did in Persona 1 PSP remaster, and P3 Remake. I would prefer remake those games like they did with Strange Journey Redux, focus on dungeon crawling and QoL changes. Those games should remake Team Maniax not P-Studio, because P1 and P2 were much closer to SMT, instead modern Persona games. Also Persona 2 Remake = automatic censorship Hitler, especially on Playstation.
with how faithful reload is and the only change really is just the slight tone difference to be more separate to SMT like episode aigis has the creepy MC scene changed but it instead puts more perspective on Aigis's reaction I don't think they would try to alter p1 and 2 to include those added elements from the later games and the PSP ost was not Atlus's decision it was actually the composer who did it and felt compelled for some reason and it backfired to the point p2's music gradually became less and less experimental to instead having decent remixes
Do you believe that Persona 1 and 2 duology will get a remake in the future?
Well I hope so …
In the far future. Right now i can see a remake of persona 4 happening next since the success of p3 reload. The soup of success is exactly the same. In p1 and p2 since they are more megami tensei in nature they could make them similar to refantasio in some form or shape.
If they do I think their may be an issue because will atlus make persona 1 a Dungeon Crawler which the first one was or something else and will they rewrite a lot of things in the story that may have made it different form persona 3,4,5.
If they do make it a Dungeon crawler the persona fans now may have an issue with the game I think but depending how atlus does it it can work.
Regardless I would like to see a remake of these games I don’t care if it’s a Dungeon crawler or not
@@alexamiridis2317 I would actually like that for p1 and p2 if they do remake them but persona 4 I wonder would they do a little bit more then just make it a better looking game like add more mystery in the game or something else even though it would sell well regardless.
I want p1 and p2 duo remake over p4 remake
That is for sure, hell just give me HD remasters or even direct ports.
At least first in my opinion
That would technically be a trio remake because P2 is split between two games.
Seriously, they need remakes way more than P4. P4 is perfectly playable, but the P2 duology is in desperate need of a facelift.
We do most modern fans haven’t had the chance play them
Yeah. I play p1 because of the music. How many time should I bang the wall? XD
Remakes for 1 and 2 wouldn’t go unappreciated I would want those over a P4 Remake imo
I would take direct ports of 1 and the 2s over a remake of P4.
@@DragonKingX78 We don't really need more ports tbh, maybe an official translation for P2EP, but otherwise I would think just do a full remake. Persona 1 is very outdated and in a big need of a brush up
@@DragonKingX78 Naw, ports of 1 and 2 wouldn't sell well, they didn't the first time around on psp. They need to remake both of those games.
@@Raytheman581 those psp ports besides EP's had a a lot of controversial things changed that it lead to not being people's preferred version in their base vanilla state
@@nightwish1453 The new versions will also have a lot of things changed if they remade or remastered them today, probably even more so now.
I really hope if they plan to release any remake they do it after persona 6 because I really wanna see a new mainline persona
I'm thinking they're going to go main release, remake, then repeat.
If they do remake 1 and both 2s I hope....
1)They do not add the calendar system/school sim stuff.
2)They keep the party number at 5.
3)That everyone can use every persona.
4)That if the main character dies it is not game over.
5)Update unique Personas/demons, don't just delete them from the game like the P3 remake.
6)That I still like the character designs.
7)That they do no mess up/replace the music.
They handled the P3 remake badly and removed the unique elements so I wouldn't count on it
@@athorem how did they remake it badly? other fans and the sales wouldn't agree with that
Naw a lot of those are going to get changed, you're getting your hopes up with all of that. They are going to add some sim type element because those help the game sell well regardless of if we're tired of it in games or not. Also I'm fine with 1 adding most stuff to it cause on its own its a very bland game. There was also nothing really special about any of the character designs for p1, they looked like characters in any person, which is generic school teens. P2 had some flair, and I doubt they would mess with the designs much.
@@Eclipse_NT Yeah people who haven't played Persona 3 like Reload, as well as people who didn't like original Persona 3 (because of the things that made that game unique!!)
And sales prove nothing about quality. It's not surprising whatsoever that a Persona 3 remake sold well
@@Eclipse_NT High sales = not always good game. The best proof is Sonic and Pokemon, who have dogshit quality, but sells well, because kids have no brains.
Please ATLUS give us a P1 and P2 remake. It's been DECADES.
You said that "older persona fans want to see p1 and p2 remade" but I can say as one of the "new" persona fan that I want a persona 2 remake more then anything. I think p4 is still a solid game that plays perfectly fine on any platform, but first two entries need remakes more. I loved persona 2 and it is my second favorite persona game after p3
p1 should get the remake treatment first, mainly due to the obvious continuity that it's more of a prevalent thing then the modern games where some of the p1 cast return as party members and have their own continuation story to continue off of
@@nightwish1453 if atlus remaking the game based on the poling placement unfortunately we will get p2is/ep remake first and then not p1 but digital devil saga 1 and then finally persona 1
@@kira516 though I feel Atlus would know it be a stupid move to do that as it lessens the impact on some moments for p2
I hope Persona 2's remake keeps 5 member party and keeps every party member as a wildcard
I hope so to because it will make the game more unique but do you think they will get rid of the Dungeon crawler gameplay of persona 1 in the remake.
Yes please.
@@ingram4056 if it is a full remake like P3 but if they go for a cheaper one they might not change that much.
@@DragonKingX78 I see it’s not a bad thing but I still think they would have to change the story a bit
It's going to be a reskin of Persona 5 again while messing up everything that made the game special. That's the Atlus remake treatment
I know this isn't something you'll report on but former Midori now ryanfromthebronx (who despite being a disgraced leaker was still fairly accurate) said that P1 is getting a remake and P2 is getting a remaster, all in development. As well as a spin off game with multiple characters from each series (apparently that project isn't dead I guess?).
I kinda believe it just because ATLUS is in a new era and it feels like they're really trying to make persona as massive as possible to take the company to new heights.
They can take it to new heights by making persona 6
Midori said P2 was getting a remake too. The remaster claim came from another leaker who usually took Midori's info
I'd like to see P1/2 with modernized gameplay and mechanics. M@ybeneven a reimagining, keeping the story but bringing the feel somewhat closer to the newer games.
A _lot_ of Persona fans are curious about the early games, but don't have easy access to them. And the gameplay didn't age well. I think there's be a lot of momentum to the early games reworked into something fresher.
if P1 gets remade, i'd like it if the individual BGMs could be switched around
After seeing what can be done following P3 Reload I would like to see all of the persona games be brought up to that level. It's certainly needful for the first two installments. I would be happy to see P4 get that level of love and attention also.
I am BEGGING Atlys to remake P1 and P2. LET NAOYA, TATSUYA AND MAYA OUT OF THE FREEZER!!!!🎉
I would love a p1 and p2 remake but I could definitely see p4 getting a remake before those 2 becuase outside of updating the graphics and maybe some gameplay mechanics, p4 would probably be easier to remake than p1 and p2. The fact that Wada didnt outright say its not happening is a good sign. Plus with the 30th anniversary coming up, i feel like anything is possible even if its just remasters and ports of old games.
I think we're at a point where as long as the Persona game sell that they're going to let the developers do the projects they want to do
I’ve been waiting for this
P1 and P2 are definitely getting remakes. Especially with how much fans wanted a 2 remake alongside the 3 remake (as evidenced by the Persona game remake poll they ran a few years back)
Theyd have to rebuild the story make it like 3 to 5, but using persona 2 characters and villians, youd have to forgo the duology and make it a single story
I feel guilty about lying to Maya in P3R, she doesn't know I didn't play Persona 2
1 and 2 are far better then the rest. They went into the sim territory and that totally turned me off all the games.
As for 1 and 2’s they were incredible. The music was amazing and the vibe was so good. It’s to dated graphically for me to try and give them another go but I would love a remake
Great video as always
This is good news
Atlus: Nah, we want to have Persona 4 Rewind because of money
I mean? I'd rather have a remake of 4 over 1-2. UNLESS they revamp the whole combat and persona system which is pure trash.
Why not both tbh
We'll get Persona 5 with the Persona 6 engine before we get p1 and 2 remakes
@@sumireravenclaw8034Duh. The whole point of a remake is to revamp the outdated stuff, of course they'd rework the battle system and the persona system.
@@hunterXhamsterpersona 6 engine is said to be the same engine used... The p studio proprietary engine
I think P1-P2 deserves the remake treatment more but then again P4 is popular and the safer route to go even if it's unnecessary.
Although given with Atlus being greedy I will not be surprised they locked content from the third semester and probably more I guess we will see if P4 remake happens.
Ngl, a remake of these 3 games would b dope, but I think it'd b hard to remake them without changing them dramatically.
I'll get a 1 & 2 port or remaster, no question. What I'm still wanting is the rumored P4 remake.
that seems like the next best thing for the persona franchise. persona 4 had a somewhat remake with persona 4 golden, and the og persona 5 had a remake to with persona 5 royale with a new character and new things to do. persona 1 and 2 remakes would only seem like the next step, and I would give atlus all my money.
100% agree, P4 is just too safe compared to P1 and P2.
I low key expect them to soft reboot P1 and P2, closer to Soul Hackers 2 but with bigger budget and effort and longer than the originals of course.
It would be great if these games got remakes. I doubt they’ll include social links, but I’m sure it’ll still be great.
If they do a remake, I hope they at least keep most of battle system and everything surroundkng it the same.
First person dungeon crawling is what no one miss
I don't think that's a good idea with Persona 1, the gameplay design is really outdated. There is a need for a big rework on a gameplay front really. And P2IS is just a bit too easy, need a need for a rebalance
Nah, there are some things worth keeping like multiple Personas for all party members and finding a way to keep the formation system would be cool but things like negotiations need some serious streamlining
@@connorharnage6697 Formation system in P1 was absolutely worthless honestly, it may be cool but needs like a complete rework.
@@heterosexualtraplord7861 Yeah tbh you only need two formations, one for one you're attacked from behind and one for literally everything else. It definitely needs reworking but it has potential
I absolutely love persona 1 but hate first person dungeon crawlers 😂 so hopefully a remake will make the game perfect
Bro sorry if this is a weird comment but you are speaking way clearer now than you used to, it makes your videos a lot better and easier to watch. Well done, man
But now. We just have to wait for smt 1 and 2
P4 doesn’t need a remake, p2 needs a remake
As a newer fan who got and finished P5 a few weeks before the announcement of P5r (unfortunate timing, i know, lol). I really do appreciate P3r, as it allowed me to play the game without playing the (from what I've herd) janky port or getting my hands on an older console and old game that might not work due to second hand selling, all while massivly upgrading the visuals to the point of being one of the best looking anime style games out there.
But, while i would also love a remake in the same quality as Reload for P1, P2IS, P2EP, and P4; I would much rather prefer a P6, as it's been a while since the last Persona game, and I know most long time fans probably feel the same way too, probably more so. So my hope is at least one remake AFTER P6.
Yes please
I would like to play Persona 1 and 2 in the Persona 3 Reload style. I think they would do great! Give me Persona 4 in that style too.
Also Atlus remake Persona Q, and Q2 and my life is yours.
let's hope nothing will ruin Atlus
Persona 2 remake is top priority 🗣️🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥
I’m excited but I’m a little worried but these remake’s
I would love to see them redone, but I would take the PSP versions also remaster. We need to get both version of persona 2 this time around.
So, my idea for a "remake" of p1 and 2 is:
An updated UI in line of 3R and 5R
Voice acting and updated art, while everything else is the same.
Keep the same music but allow us to switch from PS1 and PSP, but use the psp version as the base.(for P1)
They could be remasters in the same way metroid prime 1 hd is a remaster.
Obviously, this more than just a port but its less than a full remake. They won't really have to rewrite anything but tweak it to make a better overall experience. Like in P1 make it to where you only need to play through the game once, while in p2 make it a collection of the 2 like in P3 and The Answer. You'd be able to choose. The PSP ports of P2 are fantastic versions of the games, they'd just need tweaking. While P1 needs the most work.
I do think we get a P4R first, and that it'd look similar to P3R, but imo it'd be fantastic just like P3R is. Especially since they'd want to be as faithful as the original.(which would be P4G). Give P4R to the same people who did P3R and it'd be great.
I love Persona 4 sooooo much tho🥹❤
Obviously we all want P1 and P2 remakes, but it definitely makes more sense to do P4 first.
P4 really doesn't NEED one, P3 actually needed one,
But it's more so that P4 actually deserves a modernized, smooth version like P3R.
We all know P1 and P2 will get theirs, and they definitely need the remakes the most,
But P4 is one of the all time GOAT's. Let's not act like it'd hurt to have a smooth remake of it. It definitely deserves one as well.
Then P1 & P2 can fall right after.
I personally world like to see a SMTIII/SMTIV remake as well as many other things.
They got a lot of great options, and they can only do 1 at a time guys. Be patient!
Oh good maybe it’ll happen this time
I would definitely purchase them 😘
P5X Worldwide 2025
P6 2025
P2 EP & IS Remaster with modern UI and QOL + New Cutscenes in 2026
P6 Expansion DLC 2026
Then Persona 4 remake Imo
I just don't get their obsession with a P4 remake. P4 got it's definitive edition on modern platforms, and P3 needed a more definitive edition considering it's situation (of course one could argue P3 still isn't definitive lol). P1 and 2 have like no way modern or accessible ways to play them. And P4 just doesn't really have much more you can add, unless they add crazy stuff like having Marie be a party member like Kasumi, or having an Adachi story. I just wish these companies could see more than just dollar signs. Hell doing P1 and 2 first would have it so that more time passes, and P4 will feel more needed for a remake
Im ok with 4 getting a remake if it do good we will definitely get a remake 1 and 2 like of course they're going to start remakes of the most popular persona games in the franchise first if we keep supporting them we will get there eventually
We all want that could've got that now if fans didn't feel the need to waste advocating for an unnecessary remake of a story that's been told in like 10 variations
Atlus had a good run of making me buy their products, but in case of a P4 remake I won’t be there.
Agree p1 and p2 should do remake
After the success of P3 Reload I can see them having plans to remake P1, 2 and even 4. However when it comes to P1 and 2 I think they would need to rework them "slightly" I think some of the gameplay mechanics aged poorly specially P1 and having P1 with gameplay style of modern persona sounds very interesting. Would they also include after school life? Could they include a calendar and sim emulator mechanic into these older games? Who knows... Would old P1 and P2 fans be happy with these changes.
Many questions!
Persona 1 and 2 likely will never get remade, adding the calander system will bassically ruin the game so remaking it with a lot of modernized mechanics we see in P3R/P5R wouldn’t sit well with the fans of P1/P2 and wouldn’t fit. Old gameplay is also very clunky so while it can be modernized in some way like the shift mechanic but they can’t add a calender system because that just wouldn’t work with the way the entire story/gameplay is structured. I think we will see Smt 4/Smt 4 apocalypse remakes way before we ever get something from persona 1/2.
I think the remakes for P1 and P2 would have more fitting to be made more in the style of SMT games, giving them a post P3 school system will probably not work, especially with persona 1, it will require a full rework of the game itself
@@heterosexualtraplord7861 I agree!
@@heterosexualtraplord7861 yeah I think an Smt style remake would work best for it, I don’t believe a persona style remake would be good for it imo, even if it is a persona game it’s very different from the usual typical persona game you would see in p3 and upwards, that’s the reason p3 and P4 as a much easier endeavor for the devs, remaking P1 and P2 will likely not be remade by the persona team but by the Smt team if anything because they are more suited to handle this type of work, with that being said I do not think we will get a p1/p2 remake until Smt 4 and Smt 4 apocalypse gets remade, only until those two gets remakes that I can see a p1/p2 remake. I think atlus could theoretically remake Smt 1 and Smt 2 but the story in that game is very outdated and the writing was pretty mediocre. They could remake Smt 3 but why would they when they already released Smt 3 nocturne HD, the only Smt game that has yes to go fully 3D was Smt 4 and I think Smt 4 will likely be in the higher priority for a remake because 1: the game was never in 3D and 2: it was on outdated tech and 3: Smt 4 and Smt 4 apocalypse revolutionized Smt series in a way that’s very distinct from nocturne which makes it good in its own unique way, regardless of whether you prefer nocturne or Smt 4, you can’t exactly deny that Smt 4 didn’t have its own unique distinct flare, environments and vibe to it including gameplay gimmicks that could be revolutionary for its time (smirk mechanic was bad but was made way better in apocalypse so I can see smt 4 remake having the same gameplay changes and QOL changes as apocalypse
@@Holy_Crusader I don't really think smt 4 and apocalypse are in any need of a remake, but they may re-release it for new consoles similar to how they did with Nocturne, unless Nintendo will get stingy about the exclusivity
Persona 2 is pretty good. I'd love to play a remake of that.
Persona 1, yea I'd definitely play a remake of this. I just hope they give us 3rd person. I really get dizzy with the first person stuff.
Anyway, I hope this isn't just a lifeless remaster.
I feel like they probably still do persona 4 remake before those games I’m mainly waiting for it cause they did ports p3 and p4 wrong giving them to limited run games
P1 and p2 remakes can potentially be similar to Soul Hackers 2
I hope for a remake they keep everything primarily the same. QOL updates, better graphics obviously, side quest as replacements for SL etc. the calendar system just doesn’t work for the story of P1 and P2
P1/2 remake would be an instant buy/preorder
P4 remake would be mehhh I’d hold off buying it and continue playing my backlog while waiting for it to come on sale
The Remakes Will happen, but Will take a while and while that release the PSP version on previous/current gen/Pc, atlus
I wonder if they can tweak the modern mechanics to the older games, idk if the s. Links would work, but given than reload managed to add new interactions with the boys I'd like to think they can make it work without hindering the storyline, I've heard they are pretty much linear
Maybe something more like Soul Hackers 2's events would be better for P1 and 2
I want a remake of persona 6.
They better not remove Hitler from Persona 2 or im gonna riot
If his in, he will probably have 😎 and have another name. 😅
If the PSP port is anything to go by, I wouldn't keep my hopes up
I rather want a Enhanced Remasteres for PSP versions using HD 2D Engine
I really want the persona 2 never played it and all the tier list videos 2 is always at the top
As much as I like Persona 1 and 2, I'd rather get Shin Megami Tensei I and II remakes instead. Any of those 4 would do, to be honest.
Oh, and I'm still holding my breath for a P3RP (Persona 3 Reload Pink)!
While I would love a remake of Persona 1 and 2 games. Personally I would not mind or hate the idea of a remake of 4. It’ll be a lot easier for Atlus they can just use the assets of 3 Reload for 4 Remake similar to how they originally did for P3 to P4, like you said on the video remaking the first two especially the first one sounds way more challenging that I feel a lot of folks don’t realize. Like how exactly should those games play. Do we go with the first person dungeon crawler or do they do it similar to P3 Reload and P5 Vanilla/Royal? Would people be happy about the change or them keeping true the original (gameplay wise I mean). A remake of P4 wouldn’t be THAT challenging nor long for them to make. I know they’re are folks saying that P4 doesn’t need it because of P4 Golden is perfect (which I agree), but looking at the casual market who got into P5 Vanilla/Royal and Persona 3 Reload I can assure you they’re not interested in playing P4 Golden BECAUSE of how it looks in comparison though you can say the very same thing about the first two Persona games. It’s very similar to the remake of Trails in the Sky. I know people that wants to get into it, but refuse to play the first couple of games because it looks old and that doesn’t appeal to them. I do think we’ll see remakes of P1, 2 games and obviously 4, but if I was Atlus why not remake 4 first knowing it won’t be much trouble, they can release remastered versions of P1 & P2 games with QoL and THEN remake those games for newer audiences and the diehard fans.
Ugh.... All I want, is Shin Megami Tensei IV and IV Apocalypse for the Nintendo Switch and or PlayStation 4.
I think Persona 2 would be worth remaking to better match the more modern games. I just can’t see how Persona 1 would be adapted to the formula
So despite being an all-around weirdo, was "Midori" ever wrong about a leak? Cause i think he confirmed remakes of 4, 1 and 2 were already being planned
Lmao how was he weird
@@lemonlime8949 Aside from pretending to be a Japanese woman for some reason, I recall hearing he harassed a lot of people under his previous accounts
@@jaysutter9934 I think that first part is obvious why he did it but I never heard before of the second. That’s just twitter tho, nothing surprising.
It's better to make new raidou and p6 games rather than remake p1 and p2 imo.imagine new detective like story in modern day japan as raidou jump from building to building with overthetop costume like batman and your cat mentor by your side.. I'll buy that that game in second lol.
p4 remake does not make any sense lol.. we just got updated ports of golden
much more interested in SMT if.., 1 and the 2duo to at least get ported with updated controls. they sort of "remade" some of them for psp before..
I say they remake SMT1 and 2 instead!!!!!!
Day 1 buy physical. That is all.
Shim Megami Tensei 4 remake 🥵
SHIN
Your roadmap prediction just triggered some deep seeded fears I didn't know I had, like some kind of unrealized PTSD...
I was so excited for Persona 6, I never stopped to think about the inevitable 20 spinoffs over the next 10+ years, or the fact we'll surely get a "Persona 6 Royal" a couple years later...And that's not mentioning the guaranteed day 1 DLC & microtransactions!
Ugh... as much as I love this series, I'm genuinely starting to dislike Atlus.
there is hope as some of the later surveys suggest them realising people are getting fed up of the re-releases that happen only a few years after the original game. I am not sure where your microtransactions point came from though
No thanks, Atlus. Better give us a remake/remaster of SMT IV on current platforms.
I agree. P1 and P2 are good games, not amazing great games. They do not need millions of dollars spent on them.
@@mramisuzuki6962Really? P2 is the best Persona imo
@@connorharnage6697 P4 is the best game of best blend of “persona” and SMT. The original Persona games are party oriented SMT games, which were all done better before and after.
@@mramisuzuki6962 Oh no I gotta disagree there. P4 is easily the worst imo. Granted worst by Persona standards ain't bad but of the seven party members, on two compare to 3 and 5 and they don't come anywhere near 2's party members. Combine that with a story that's 75% filler, the second worst dungeons after P1 and gameplay that's somehow worse than Persona 3's despite giving us the ability to control party members, I can't confidently say P4 is anything more than the worst mainline game
@@connorharnage6697 meamwhile IS's gameplay is so piss easy it's more tedious then anything. psp port somehow made it worse because someone was clearly really artsy with the UI
I was really gutted when they went for 3 instead of 2, I love persona 3 but it did not need a remake and the remake didn’t do much for me tbh, hell even 1 would be fantastic if they realized it’s full potential.
The Persona 3 remake was really bad in my opinion. Atlus just doesn't have it in them
They probably will ruin those games by changes in story / atmosphere, adding Dating Sim / social links / calendar and change soundtrack into worse without option to switch original OST, like they did in Persona 1 PSP remaster, and P3 Remake. I would prefer remake those games like they did with Strange Journey Redux, focus on dungeon crawling and QoL changes. Those games should remake Team Maniax not P-Studio, because P1 and P2 were much closer to SMT, instead modern Persona games. Also Persona 2 Remake = automatic censorship Hitler, especially on Playstation.
with how faithful reload is and the only change really is just the slight tone difference to be more separate to SMT like episode aigis has the creepy MC scene changed but it instead puts more perspective on Aigis's reaction I don't think they would try to alter p1 and 2 to include those added elements from the later games and the PSP ost was not Atlus's decision it was actually the composer who did it and felt compelled for some reason and it backfired to the point p2's music gradually became less and less experimental to instead having decent remixes
The word 'Remake' for games these days pretty much mean - "Censored/altered for modern audiences"
Reload would like a word with you
Now we need Megami Tensei 1 and 2 and the SNES SMT games to be remade.