"Extremely DISTRESSING To See!" | Kevin O'Sullivan On Fish Farming
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 16 ต.ค. 2024
- Talk's Kevin O'Sullivan is joined by animal rights activist Peter Egan and CEO of Compassion in World Farming, Philip Lymbery to discuss the nature and future of mass fish farming.
About the topic Philip says there is a lot that "can be done better" but even so "it doesn't make sense" as it "cages" fish that should be out in the wild.
The trio also talk about the intelligence of octopus and how fish farms are essentially "factory farms in water.".
Click here for more from Talk talk.tv
If you need any help visit: talk.tv/helplines
#factoryfarming #animalrights #fishfarming
It’s a bit like the immigrants coming to the uk even tho we’re chocked with people they just keep filling this little island.
Exactly. We are suffocating.
I'm not eating farmed fish ever again.
lol how will you know then?
How will you know its farmed, will it come with a tattoo on its belly?
@@GoTellTheSpartans24 There are varying layers of labeling depending on country. Best to research individual brands and stick to the clean ones.
Farmed fish is very bad for you and is in the main toxic
Tinned fish is more likely to be wild caught.
We're an island and most of our fish comes from Asia or South America, it's mental.
@peterholden3672 Read the back of the packets, it's exactly where they are coming from.
@peterholden3672 yeah I do read the back of packets, statistics have a funny way of being fiddled.I suggest you do the same,you'll be shocked to find any from our seas.
I buy english mackerel in spain.
It’s crazy.
We export 75% of our catch then import the same back 🤯you can’t make it up
Humans seem fascinated by finding lifeforms on other planets.. and yet...they often treat other species on this planet, with such disrespect and cruelty.
If government didn't stop & give our fishing rights away we wouldn't have half this problem.
Same with our mining, steel industry to name a few
It's not just the cruelty and damage done to the farmed fish, the environmental impact is horrendous as well! All factory farming needs to end, animals can be raised with care and compassion. Factory farm animals lead miserable ill lives and people eat that, factory farming is not good for anyone.
Send the boats back
If we had our fishing rights instead of other countries getting them in our own water's, this wouldn't happen .
It's disgusting,....and they charge so much now for a small piece of salmon
Because they knew you didn't know it lived like that.
We shouldn’t be farming fish. Just let them catch them in the wild.
Thank you Kevin for showing what is happening to animals you have a kind heart most people don't care unless it's pets .
Thousands of years fishing suddenly get a conscience
what a load of bollocks.
Yes going after all fishing aquaculture is a bridge to far. We need it you cant just throw away a food source.
Are we going to talk about Halal meat as well then?
Thanks for airing this barbaric practice ❤😊
wet
Nothing on Halal though where's the Moral courage? Oh it's not about morals it's about eating the bugs isn't it.
All animal factory farming is deplorable!! Chickens, pigs, cattle, sheep......the problem is too many people need to eat. What is the solution???? IDK
Have you seen the amount of food waste?
The solution is get over it, as you say many need to eat, we need meat and veg to eat, so needs must. Ain't broke don't fix it.
@@MDM1992 thing is factory farming is broke, I wouldn’t say those lice covered salmon are a picture of health…it’s all about profit, screw the welfare of the animal and public health.
We eat less of it and do not waste tons of it. Then this cruel intensive farming of our fellow creatures on earth would stop. Who do we think we are. What if we were treated like that for something to eat us. Never eat these poor fish again. Total cruelty
@@MDM1992what if it was humans and something needed to eat us
I don't believe anyone who actually visited one of these "farms" would ever eat farmed fish again!
Yh he only reason they are here is because the hygiene and care standards are much higher in Norway than here, so Norwegian companies are encouraged by our lovely government to relocate to the UK!
Just let our fishermen fish around our island.
This is disgusting..awful animal welfare
Yes, but how come they are silent on Halal?
I had a go at fish farming, the first thousand died, so I phoned the supplier for more and asked why the first lot died, what are you doing with them he said? I don't know I replied, either I'm planting them too deep or not far enough apart? looking forward to the first crop, combine ready
Philip Lymbery, thank you so much for speaking the truth👏🏿👏🏿
avoided farm fish for many years
I understand your two guests. I agree with them. Starmer is just about to give our fishing rights to thr French. What do you do?
That’s me finished buying fish , very sad for those poor fish
Just don’t buy farmed fish.
Do you think Asia cares at all?
What? Didn't know how fish died after harvesting At sea? At his age? When I saw that as a kid I wondered then if there was a better way to kill them.
I have never eaten fish in my 49 years on this planet.
@@ForestFan74 don’t know what you’re missing
@@johnwatson7120 must have a very small brain then? it is litterally brain food.
There's the catch asking for donations
I would but Ive only just been.
😢😢😢😢
I will never buy farmed fish, Cod, Haddock,Pollock,Hake or wild Alaskan Salmon are fine.
You WILL eat the bugs!!!
Foronce Packham said something I agreed with, namely ban fish farming.It's wiped out too many fine strains of migratory fish.
I once seen thousands of carrots living and growing in a large field, then someone driving a machine turned up and started ripping the carrots out the ground the poor carrots didn't stand a chance against that machine I was nearly in tears, then I found out that the carrots were skinned then cooked for 20 minutes, I believe the carrots were dead before being boiled
Reminds me of an old Jonathan Ross line, "a goldfish is basically a carrot with eyes"!
Oh my god those poor carrots, where are the vegetable rights groups, there must be someone who can hold these farmers to account?
Vegetable lives matter. I heard they the vegetables scream out for help. But humans moan when their stomachs rumble. I understand about the treatment but why didn't humans complain about this years ago.
How strange i was actually thinking the sam thing 😂😂😂😂
@@geoffreyfreitag1276 it is prooven science that plants talk to each other even Trees do in the woods and whos to say they dont talk about football when there is no one there to hear them.
We need honest reports on fish farming not this fairy tail of anti farming grifters
That's why I'm vegan. Nothing to do with being "Woke"
Eat as many microbes on your lettuce leaf and then cry wolf !
Prooven science that all plants talk to each other, how do ya feel Now Vegan?
Easy for westerners with hobby diets to say that. I have lived in the third world and a tin of fish if you are lucky, can be the difference between health and malnutrition.
@@raclark2730 Yes but i don't live in the 3rd world. I live in England have the enormous good fortune of being able to choose what I eat. To say its a hobby diet is making the mistake of falling into streotypes. You have obviously assumed I'm a privileged educated type but I'm not. I was brought up in the slums of London after the second world war when food was rationed and you had no choice but to eat what was put before you and be grateful. It is not Woke to recognise that we have a duty to resource our food in a way that does not exploit the earth, the animals or the unpriveged people of this earth . It is also not Woke to recognise that the greed of agri and other corporate interests needs to be challenged. Is that so unreasonable?
@@electraruby I agree, all agriculture and fishing are not the same and this distinction must be made. Better standards must be set and met. Woke is nothing but a unneeded distracting cancer.
Whats Philip Lymbery doing about the expanding halal butchery in the UK??? Zero credibility just like Chris Packham!
Given the amount of food that is thrown away by people, businesses and supermarkets, the tragedy is that a lot of these fish will never even be eaten. Pure waste.
Im an omnivore, but eating, farming, creatures smarter than me is problematic.
Well that's me not eating fish again, shocking footage?
Wait till you see how the average chicken and Turkey live and die in a shed.
It’s the only way to feed the increasing human biomass, there’s too many humans and we are just importing more of them
How are they treating fish in the UK. Do they put them in bleach or was that just a scare tactic. We need to know what they do in the UK and make sure they are humanely treated. Someone from the fish farmers side was needed in this conversation. Otherwise is just very one sided. I am disappointed in this article it’s like the vegan point of view. Yes things could always be done better and that is what should be fought for but I don’t want vegan propaganda shown on the news.
30 years ago salmon was so tasty compared to now. i won't eat it.
I don't eat fish I'm allergic. Can someone tell me why this is not ok, but Halal is never spoken about and is being expanded to every school in the country. Why do these activists have nothing to say about how Halal animals die?
farm kelp = food security and carbon drawdown
I've been on Scottish Fish Farms. Kevin you've been had. The practices showed in the video were not from Scotland.
Probably Bangladesh or Vietnam.
One of the most misleading pieces of crap masquerading as news I've ever seen.
So all those people who are screaming about it start to come up with ideas how to change the standard's of how food is produced. To many humans talk but don't find solutions an 10:30 d actually force them to be used.
They're fish we eat them. That's what we are!
Its not the same, hooks in a fishes moth has no effect on the fish it still feeds
I have caught fish with other hooks in their mouths most was a big chub
5 hooks including in its mouth I took them out 2 hoods just crumbled rusted but the chub
was fat and fighting fit back it went .
We need fish to be cheap, so I accept fish farming. If we stop fish farming poor people will not be able to afford salmon
im not poor and I still cant afford Salmon.
If you care so much then go vegan
Do it better.
I challenge you to do it better. I don't eat fish.
I can assure you that whatever bs you come up with ppl will protest it.
If you need help I'm with you. The decline of the world shouldn't be ignored.
Treating fish with 'kindness' is ridiculous and hyperbolic language. Can't we just treat them with care, respecting their place in the ecosystem.
Incidentally, it has been known in Scotland since the 90s how diseased the farmed salmon are. I personally wouldn't eat them.
Dont give these strange people air time
These two guests are why people should avoid soy based diets.
The one on the right said he's seen fish with "seaweed growing out of them", I suspect it may actually be a fungal infection.
The other soy-boy said that "getting a hook stuck in your mouth and being tugged is just the same for a fish as it is for a human", hook and line is the safest way and causes the least damage to the fish - that's why it's more expensive. Ikijime is how we humanely despatch them.
Single line and hook caught fish also help smaller coastal communities have a industry.
squid is delicious
I blame Trump
Supply and demand for fish is high , it's not cruel they are fed and dispatched quickly . Got tell the french fishermen to use larger mesh nets and ban the se factory ships and lice on fish is a natural thing , and they have worms but are. not harmful to humans , humans have caught fish from the year dot no need to dramatise it
its good for your brain matter. High in omega 3 fats.
You people are beyound ridiculous
Im hungry off to the fish and chip shop now.
I agree with the 2 hosts and I believe the treatment of trout and salmon in fish farms are horrific but everyone must understand that the eu are taking British fishing quotas and not paying to use British fishing waters and they all get automatic access to British waters and not to mention the horrible thing about the Dutch pulse fishing and the gigantic super trawlers that wipe out dolphins and ginormous quantities of fish. And you may ask what will be used with the money from paying foreign vessels, it must be used to police British waters and conserve and create a great environment for all fish in Britain so that fish populations can grow and therefore the horrible fish farming practice that is mentioned can end.
I'm going Angling in the morning. I won't be taking any home as I'm going to a pond I'm a member of. I agree fish feel pain but I could spend all day catching one White Orfe 🤣. Yea it's greedy but it eats the feed and the hook every time bless him