Thank you all for your support and a massive thank you to Surfshark for sponsoring this video: Secure your privacy with Surfshark! Enter coupon code serpentza for 4 extra months at Surfshark.com/serpentza
Hey Winston hope you're staying awesome 😎 just curious to what happened to last night's China show live stream? Fri nights at 5pm is still the day isn't it?
LMOA my parents lived in the USSR and later moved to the US after its collapse, seeing Americans bend over backwards for authoritarian regimes is mind boggling to me. I guess one thing life taught me is to never underestimate the stupidity and ignorance of people.
Unfortunately our government feels like an authoritarian regime to liberals now that Trump is president, and so they feel like they have to pick sides out of fear.
🙏🏼Amen. After a couple generations of American children being told they can be *anything* they want, giving their children everything without ever expecting accountability for wrongs or mistakes, and participation trophies has destroyed a large portion of our culture. As an American watching our own politicians & government bend to those regimes is mind boggling to me too.
Exactly. When people are bullied by the healthcare mafia and other mafia, they are made to believe it is free market and freedom and it is non-authoritarian, therefore they become proud while being exploited. Just one example how stupid people can be.
The recent pressure of RedNote has been intense, but at the end of the day, the US isn’t as bad as it seems, and China isn’t as great as it’s often portrayed in the app. Low-income people in China are still struggling just like their counterparts in the US. The positive shift, however, is that more and more people on both sides are starting to recognize that the mainstream media isn't telling the full story, or even the truth in some cases. People are beginning to realise that, despite our differences, we are all human beings with similar emotions, desires for a better life, and hopes for meaningful friendships.
Chinese people are obsessed with America and Americans like crazy. Just as they ignore Russia and russians even though they are neighbors and supposedly allies😶
I had the “pleasure” of being poor in both countries and i can tell u its wayyy harder being broke in the US than in China. In China, i can be poor and still afford food, transportation, and other basic necessities In America, it felt like every day being poor was so expensive that it made me even poorer
We just need to keep calling it out, I mention on any channel that calls it a ban, even if they are talking UFOS or something unrelated and will comment to go to this channel or The China Show
@@toribern419been to both the US and China. I’ll definitely choose China over the U.S any time. The US is a falling empire and China is on its way up. That’s a fact.
If you guys do not trust red note, don't use it, find another app with a larger user base, probably like the Chinese TikTok, or just travel to china and you will see
Tbh, on rednote, they are actually comparing whose life/ healthcare cost less😂 and teaching/learning how to cook Chinese food and help each other’s homework.
@@ArtieKendall okay okay okay. The Chinese are not showing off their low cost of living in a merry manner. They are not helping each other’s homework. They are not teaching/learning how to cook. They are not making friends. How about I say it this way: as all the real Chinese human are struggling with the house crisis, all the red noters are actually fake…feeling better? The united states is the gleatest countie in the world. All other counties are making out of shit.👍
People who rave about China's "cheap rent" don't understand that everything is adjusted to how much money they earn per hour. Chinese people get paid much lower than their American counterparts. That first lady's ignorance (and she's an adult!) is really scary.
Red Note is a platform run by the CCP. I would not trust any Chinese social media. Facebook is all I trust. They have the truth certification from the US government.
@@mrsmerily You are talking about 996, right? That is the IT industry, not ordinary people work 996. If people work 996, their salaries will be very high.
lmao love how that lady was crying while wearing her designer bag and clothes in her house that she doesn't need not understanding how she is broke lmao
Everytime I see a TikTok talking about how great China is, I refer them to your channel and tell them to watch all your videos. They are so misinformed, its scary.
As an Asian living close to China & lived 7 years in China, I can't believe how gullible way too many Americans can be. I wonder if life is so easy there that they can afford to be so gullible?
There's another channel, china insider with david zhang and 攝徒日記Fun TV, but unfortunately his channel doesn't have English subtitles making him unavailable for wider audience
"Many Chinese people only earn $700 a year." This is a confusing sentence. Because there are such people in China, but they are all elderly or minors. Former Chinese Premier Li Keqiang once said: "There are 600 million people in China with a monthly income of less than 1,000 yuan." His statistics actually include elderly people and children who do not work. Except for the four most developed cities in China, the average salary of Chinese workers is about 4,000 yuan or more. In fact, the pressure of life is not great. Americans' pressure often comes from expensive medical expenses and college loans, while Chinese people have mortgage loans. The cost of industrial products and services in China is much cheaper than that in the United States, so the pressure of life is not greater than that in the United States. The economic crisis in recent years is not unique to China. The United States has also experienced severe inflation.
Doesnt matter what the avg is, China's economy is crashing severely. Plus AI calculates that 1.3 children per couple since 2000 = 800ml not 1.4bl population. One child policy was in place 1980 to 2015.
Considering how their authoritarian-left regime is persecuting AfD members right now, your idea is probably an incoming reality. In truth Nazis were leftists, after all.
Or at least reflect on your life and see what that all represents, or was giving you, and try to seek that from other sources, preferably offline. It could be a wake up call to make positive life improvements and make their life more balanced but sadly I do not think many will choose that path.
People are having a realization that the goverment and rich do not treat people with respect. This is about control of people's thoughts, period. Red book or whatever is no better, alright kinder. Go figure if you are nice to people they react favorably to you. Our media is just a giant propaganda machine, buy more, don't think.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯ Nothing surprises me anymore sense the last USA election, by which I've seen 100's of women screaming at the camera while shaving their Heads.
Why exactly? You and me know why America is banning tiktok... They can't control the narrative their like they do with Facebook or Instagram TH-cam. etc The genocide in Gaza was being shown in its full without any kind of censorship... And daddy israel doesn't like that so the AIPAC who's holding the American politicians by the balls... Forced them into banning the app.... It's not about privacy or any of that.... Remember edward Snowden.? I rest my case.
I would not trust these Chinese if I were you. Many of them are sent by the CCP to spy on American and steal US technology. Why do you see so many professors teaching in the US go back to China recently. They need to report to the CCP and unload their finding to the motherland. Be especially cautious of Taiwanese Chinese. Trojan horse.
You also have people from rich european countries like netherlands or sweden who went to live in the us so whats your point Just go to China yourself and make up your own mind .
_The grass is always greener on the other side of the fence._ In this case the grass is dying out on both sides but one side paints it green, literally. 😐
The best way to understand what everyday life in China looks like is to visit the country yourself. Alternatively, you can check out travel vlogs made by non-Chinese tourists. According to data, 30% of RedNote users are between 19 and 22 years old, while 50% fall in the 23-32 age range. I wonder how people in China manage to reach “high-end” status at such a young age. Does that mean they have a stronger job market or a more robust economy? Or does that mean it's the average life?
It could just be that we're talking about a small piece of a big pie, in which a disproportionate amount of young adults coming from wealthy families are represented (compared to the actual ratio of wealthy to middle and lower class). It would make sense from an optics standpoint for China to market this app in a way that makes it more attractive for specifically that demographic to use, seeing as it is public facing to the rest of the world (creates a positive image for China). I suppose they could even allow anyone to use the app, regardless of what class they represent, and then leverage the app's algorithm to heavily favor content that would leave "consumers" with the impression China is better off than it really is, if not in better shape than the rest of the world. The way I see it, there are "shades" of propaganda in every country around the world (the US if FAR from innocent, just to be clear), but it's only natural that it be more abused in areas ruled by dictators, such as you find in China. However, I also think it's close to impossible to really know for sure which country(ies) push(es) the most propaganda on their people. It's unfortunate how difficult it is to effectively discern between truth and deception, especially for individuals like myself who've never explored outside of their own country and have to rely on news outlets and random people on social media to get a sense of what that "other world" is like. For every news source that claims something as a "fact," you'll find another source that claims it's a lie. How can we know who to trust?
@ I don't wanna argue over "opinions" or "guesses " of who have never been to China-we should respect the facts. Visit China and see for yourself. Everyday life there is far better than what you see on RedNote.
@ The translation says "Because most of the people on Xiaohongshu haven’t even started working yet." Could you please share the data source to support this claim, or was it simply made up?
@@lollye7916 I mean, it's their entire full time job. If they don't make money begging, making content of... questionable sorts, they won't pay the bills! I've seen quite a number complain they can't pay the bills and are passively aggressively demanding donations or subscriptions, etc. It is exhausting, and man there is just so many of them. It's an oversatured market of influencers. Too many influencers, too little who care to watch and lacking deep enough pockets to donate to them all.
Banning these apps is not going to change anything. If the kids don't like Facebook or TH-cam shorts they are gonna keep searching for alternatives. The promotion of Communism in the American public education system is also partly to blame for this. Kids think the little red book is cool now. I would argue it shows extreme weakness of the US government and culture that they are trying to ban these apps. It shows they are on the back foot big time.
That Train station in the Thumbnail is Chinese. I challenge you to point me to anything literally anything half as impressive of any public transit anywhere in America. China is a developing nation that has Lapped us in multiple fields especially production and research. Hell no it ain't perfect but we've been a Developed nation since the 1950s what the hell is our excuse falling behind. That's the only message people are sharing not China is perfect. America make 2000% more money since then and the population has only gone up 50%. WAGES HAVE STAYED FLAT
@@finnigankhjurich8150 "what the hell is our excuse falling behind" because we don't have army of slaves that can work 12+ hrs per day for 700$ per year.
It's painful how gullible social media users are. Painful because I could literally be a multi millionaire with 0 effort if I just didn't have ethical concerns about scamming all these embarrassing muppets
I had this very thought today watching Newsome supporters whose homes had been burned to the ground explain their continued support for him. It's really hard not to believe in the simulation.
@@jasonhenry5by5 There's a lot of how tos online. If your good, Crypto is good. Rug pulling is legal in the crypto sphere. So many dumb people there. A literal 14 year old did it to like a thousand adults and got 30,000 bucks. But you need some understanding of finances and investments. And to actually seem legitimate and pull the plug before anyone else does. You do need advertising and stuff though. Need to stream and get it out there. Invest in Dogshit Coin 2045! Gonna be big! Mr Beast, Logan Paul, have done this too. A lot of people do it, somehow. Even tutorials on YT.
Oh! You Americans never murdered and practically eradicate the Native Americans who lived in what we call America today! You just made them 'disappear' or hauling hundreds of thousands of young people from the continent of Africa, shipping them to America under harrowing conditions and setting them and their descenders as slave labour for centuries! The country with the worst record of treating others suddenly becomes the biggest 'criticizer' of Human Rights Abuses! That's America for you! Next it will be Germany with their 6+ million souls on their 'heads' taking on the 'pulpit'! We had better get ready for a really long series of sermons by the devils themselves!
From Wikipedia 'The name Xiaohongshu or 'Little Red Book' was inspired by its co-founder Mao Wenchao's career at Bain & Company and education at the Stanford Graduate School of Business; both institutions feature red as their main color. 'Little Red Book' is also the English nickname for the 1964 compilation Quotations from Chairman Mao Tse-tung. The company stated that the platform's name is not a reference to the book.' Don't believe everything Serpentza says. A quick google will debunk his nonesense.
@@InciniumVGCplease. I am planning for my Chinese new year trip to Yunnan. Searching meaningful trip plans seems difficult after all these TT refugees rushed in, paying their cat tax and write letters back to Lihua
@@InciniumVGC Interesting, isn't China an authoritarian hellhole where everyone lives in misery? Shouldn't Chinese people interacting with US netizens be a good thing to open the poor oppressed Chinese people's eyes to how good the US is? I think the US should allow and even encourage these TikTokers to go on RedNote to share the good news and get the Chinese people to rise in revolt.
FINALLY! You are the first youtuber I see actually being realistic about rednote. Everyone else is only talking about the friendly interactions and "woops, my post went against the guidelines and got deleted hahaha" Like... do you realize people living in China "disappear" because of a "Woopsie" post?
Yeah, I've been keeping an eye on this channel waiting for a video on this! Out of nowhere, a well spoken "very nice" Chinese lady suddenly showed up on my feed yesterday talking about this app...To your point, I think perhaps many people never experienced being seriously scammed / robbed / ripped off etc by very very friendly people. The first time it happened to me I was still a teenager and I did a double take: this guy STOLE my camera???? But he was SO NICE! Then I realized, some places, the criminals are very very nice because it just works better. But yeah, if people apply "good guy vs bad guy" simplistic movie logic, they think nice = good. I really think we get imprinted with this, no matter how smart we think we are. People need to travel more - and then actually talk to locals, not just hang out in resorts. You start to see the difference between the official narratives and the stories on the ground that way. TH-cam can be a good stand in for traveling, when watching the right channels. The other worrying trend I've noticed - and this also applies to Russia - is people that feel they are "awake" about their own country, but they are still looking for some place to idealize, so they jump to defending the "official enemy" of their country. Like, the enemy of my enemy is my friend... and they assume anything bad ever said about that place must all be some kind of lie.
Funny you'd say that, since I had the pleasure of meeting 4 Police officers myself 1.5 years ago because of a Twitter post. And it wasn't in evil China, it was in evil Germany, I guess. Always the same story with you people. Stop telling us how bad some nation on the other side of world is, when here is the same just slightly different. Stop telling us how free we are, while our homes are being searched by police for speech offences.
That is not true! some people wanted to work more hours to get overtime. for some company (especially manufactoring company) if they don't provide overtime, they can not even finish their hiring goal. For IT company, the make a lot of money, but they worked long hours. most of people work about 8 hours. Iuckily I have worked in China more than 12 years, and I still want to work there. Problem is that they don't offer any permanent residence there.
@@zincion1so you are not Chinese, you said thats not ture😂 as a chinese, i can tell you thats totally ture, most of us are forced to work over time and dont get any OT pay, if we refuse, we will much possible to get fired😢
@@idaofte6149 You mentioned that if you don't work overtime, you'll get fired. If that's the case, I can assure you that you're with the wrong company. You should continue searching for one that meets your needs for a healthy work-life balance
@@idaofte6149 To be honest, if you could generate multi-billion-dollar sales revenue for your company every year, I can guarantee you’d be treated like royalty. In fact, you might even have the influence to make your boss work overtime for you! That’s the level of value you bring to the table, deserving a completely different level of treatment🤭
Why is she crying. If she dislikes the US and wants to be surrounded by Chinese content why not move to China? You dont have to stay in the USA if you dont want to. Its not like someone will prevent you from going wherever you want. They dont care if you leave only when you enter.
well moving to another country is no easy task you need to find place to stay and job the problem is that china is so heavily censored that is super difficult to go there
They arent even allowed to use those apps there! These people are smooth brained by this stuff. These are the same people who believe every word msm says.
She wants money. She wants to dominate and win in life. The traditional Chinese philosophy is that happiness comes from success inevitably, and it *only* comes from success. So Chinese people travel all around the world to find opportunities to get rich.
@@gomer2813 its asian thirdworld mindset and its true from all the third world countries in ASIA that have saving face... money is god and money fixes saving face , or whats in it for me thinking for everything
Yeah for real. But I really enjoyed that guy saying how he never felt the world so big until now it's soo wholesome. Haha but the American young now a days aren't real people
I saw on my friends Instagram feed a post of someone sad and talking to the camera but the voice and video slowly became out of sync until it looked like an entirely different language. Like they just dubbed other languages over footage and send it out 😅
Please make sure your love ones do not get on Red Note. Check their phone to be sure. China is evil and they should not spread misinformation in a peace loving democatic country like the USA.
Thanks for the sobering voice, however, the most important thing that is happening on the red note, is the fact that both the Chinese and the American ordinary people, can talk to each other, and can see each other eye to eye with good intentions and genuine curiosity, and this mess scale realization that we are all buman beings - the people on the opposite side are not aliens or objects. We all eat, laugh, and care for each other. I think that is a win for humanity. Neither goverment is great to say the least, but in the end of the day, this movement is not about the government (despite that it's triggered by the government) it's about the people. Whether the red note splits its content by IP or not, the past few days of awakening matters, and will have a long, last impact, hopefully, for the better.
I agree with the premise, but this is not it . The Chinese and the Americans on RedNote are not really typical or genuine, by most measures, they are some of the most brainwashed trend followers. Plus, we see that CCP is already cordoning off mainland users and will hire shills to pose as "ordinary users" to "tell a good story of China". IT'S A TRAP. ALWAYS WAS
I'm Chinese and currently live in a second-tier city, and I would say that Rednote's users skew towards the younger residents of the city, who are massively female, financially well off, and don't have the burden of living a life that's overly burdensome. The user base is upper middle class among the residents. This APP is politically apathetic in general. China's lower-middle class is also heavily burdened, except that there are indeed basic poverty alleviation programs in place to ensure their basic livelihood. China is not as bad as the western media propaganda, nor is it as good as the Rednote shows. People's opinions always tend to lean towards one extreme, but I'm still glad that people are really starting to get in touch with what we Chinese actually do for a living, and know that we love life too, instead of being brainwashed by the media and the government into complaining about another country every day and becoming an ideological tool.
you describe the media and social networks in China? Every day you spit on the West and lie about your history and society constantly. By the way, thanks for the covid!
Keeping it real ? in China if I recall it was stay awesome ? mind you he was a lot slimmer well dressed with more hair and statues, probably felt awesome, now only facing reality .
@@elizabethclaiborne6461 You criticise a country you have never been & view it through your Ruling Class who clearly own your 🧠 all at the same time your own country is going down the toilet.
Honestly for Europeans, Russian, Africans, and Arabians, is this very very old new they know it since 1999 but it’s better late than never seeing finely Americans waking up from this is hart warming
@@justaminute3111 Every country has their own issues, It's just that in general China is more well of than the rest of us. You've never been to China have you?
Few things to note about this video: 1. The cultural influence a lot of chinese on rednote are going to experience will be a shock to many. The fact that so many Americans do not understand the differences between countries really isnt that surprising. According to the Barbra Bush foundation, 50% of America reads at a 6th grade or lower level. Reading is the key to opening all other doors when it comes to education, if you can't read, theres a strong chance you wont be able to tell the differences between China and America because you dont have the knowledge capacity to actually do a basic compare and contrast. 2. Lets play off of that for just one minute. I saw this rednote thing is like social darwinism and really goes to show who the Americans are and who the communists are, and thats great, truthfully. I am happy we live in a country where you can FREELY EXPRESS THAT..and I am also happy to live in a country where should war break out, we -could- in fact let you just go to China. Why would we do that? Because if you are going to be -so stupid- that you cannot tell the difference between China and America..honestly..this country will be better without you. I'd rather have an exchange program for Chinese folks and we can bring over the ones that care about our constitution, and we can give china all the americans that dont like america, and well just do a prisoner swap like that. edit: Jokes on you, what secrets? You arent important enough. You don't know anything worth knowing. If you are so stupid that you get onto social media to spout out about how you will defect to China..gee wiz im not even sure CHINA wants someone as stupid as you.
If China was going to use them for espionage, those commies would have to live in America to accomplish anything. They'd have to join the military, be conservative capitalists, and go up in rank as good constitutionalists. For what they want they'd be better off flying to China, apply for citizenship, get a WeChat account, get a driver's license, get married, and all that stuff that SerpZA talked about in previous videos! 😁
This is a great example of why legal immigration has made the U.S. the greatest country in the world. They love our country more than a lot of people who were lucky enough to be born here.
Old and young alike are gullible. The old folks get fooled by AI video, and the youngsters get fooled by grifters (no, it's not flat, guys). And we all seem to fall for "divide and conquer" - the culture war, the generational war, aliens vs Jesus, etc... that stuff is pushed by propagandists, to distract and divide the target demographic.
In fact, rednote is a recipe software, it is from the beginning for people to publish life, travel, food recipes, not to share life. I remember when rednote was first known for helping people choose what to wear
My brother told me he downloaded Xiaohongshu and was “shocked by how well the Chinese live compared to us.” I should have thought of it at the moment but saying that is an accurate reflection of life for the average Chinese person is like assuming everyone in Dubai lives in a luxury highrise, drives a Lamborghini, and is constantly surrounded by flown out supermodels.
Brotha, you're so stupid... Xiaohongshu is literally a social media available to everyone. There's no way you believe that everyone here is a CCP propagandist
I've seen so much of this. I keep pointing people over here and to China uncensored. I've been cringing so hard I think I might have permanent muscle cramps.
As a Chinese, I can say xiaohongshu (Rednote) users' profiles are majority the middle class in China. But absolutely not the upper class. The upper classes in China should have the luxury apartments or houses in the Tier 1 city center (Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou and Shenzhen) and the property overseas whatever in Cayman Islands, Manhattan, Vancouver, London, Paris, etc. However, I must admit some parts that @serpentza said are also truth. China has a very huge welath gap. The former prime minister Keqiang Li said 600 million people their monthly salary below 1000 yuan (150 US dollars). Most of them are from the Village. In China, the life quality and job opportunities of city citizen and rural citizen has the huge difference. Due to the fast urbanization, more and more rual citizens choose to work for the manufacturing factory or construction industry. However, these jobs in China that I can say they absolutely do not have any welfare and protection. Because these jobs are deemed as the temporary job instead of the formal job. Hence, you can not enjoy any working welfare or protection such as unemployment insurance, etc. Most of these jobs are paid daily, and the salary is very low due to China has amount of people. The labor force is absolutely is cheap. However, most of these rural citizens they have the opportunity to reach the social mobility which is placing their hope to their children. Hence, most of them work in the city while the working condition is severe and bad, they will save the money and send back the money to their hometown (village) to their children to pay the tuition (Regarding the state dominated system in China, the tuition of the rural school is cheap and affordable). If their children can get the good score in the national college entrance exam (This is the only criteria for going to the level of the university in China whatever you are rich or poor. If you want to go to college in China, get the good score in this exam is necessary). They can get the opportunity to get a bachelor degree then find a job in the city to be a city citizen and enjoy the welfare like the city citizen. This could be explained why China can reach 500 million middle class people from an extreme poverty country in past 40 years and why Chinese parents whatever their class are so pay much attention on the education for their children. Again, most universities in China are public whatever top university or general university, the tuition is not expensive. Only the lowest level universities are private, but normally for middle class or rich families kid to go because the tuition is relative expensive. Also, poor students can apply for the student loan from the government to pay the tuition, but it does not have any interest. In past decades, Chinese system works like this. However, with the economic recession recently, things started to be different. Because college graduates started to face less job opportunities and more competitive competition. But that is another topic.
Don't lie. You are a fake Chinese. I'm from the countryside. Why haven't I seen anyone with a monthly salary of less than 1,000 yuan? My grandmother doesn't work and has a subsidy of hundreds of yuan a month. As for Xiaohongshu users, you can use whatever you want. You are still in class. Don't lie under the false Chinese title, okay? 别反串了 你就是一个虚假的中国人呢 我就是农村的 我怎么没见月薪低于1000人民币的 我奶奶不工作一个月都有几百块钱的补贴可以拿 至于小红书用户 想用的哪个都可以用 你还整上阶级了
My biggest concern is how we are going to survive all these financial and political crises, especially the power struggle in the US. The government has really made things difficult for its citizens and we cannot just sit by and suffer the consequences of bad governance🙏...
How nice that she does so much for you!! Please is there a way to contact her services? I have 3 jobs and I'm trying to pay off my debts for a while now! Please help me 🙏🏻
Ksenia Alice Services has really set the standard for others to follow, we love her here in Canada 🇨🇦 as she has been really helpful and changed lots of life's
Access to good information is what investors need to progress financially, most people are still poor just because friends and family prevented them from investing and trading cryptocurrencies, while the wise ones kept investing and growing financially.
I am fiercely British through and through, spending 17 years in China, married to a British spouse, raising children, and receiving education in China and Australia. Currently employed by a German company, which I absolutely adore. China is a fantastic place to reside. Two decades ago, I was employed by an American company in Boston. One morning, we were abruptly confronted at gunpoint by six criminals, pleading for our survival. We were subjected to a robbery, and my wife endured a harrowing assault, nearly losing her life. Those malevolent youths were eventually apprehended and sentenced to lifelong incarceration. Subsequently, we relocated abroad to Singapore to embark on a fresh chapter, and now we reside in China without any regrets. In my view, America is an utterly despicable place to reside or raise a family.
These Americans who want to talk sh!t about everything will get a rude awakening on these apps like Rednote. Once they are told "no" a few times, they will realize that they have been had.
Not for long though. Just like he said, they'll likely create a new version based on IP and probably with looser TOS. Gotta keep our guard constantly up
I come from China,it's sure. but,people in china,Life is beautiful。food and study is cheap.many thing is cheap. moeny is enough. my English not good,so,i want to tell you mang thing,but,my English not good
The way I see it? If they think its so much easier over there? Then buy a one way ticket there and never come back. People like this need a HARD hit from reality because trying to use evidence won't do squat. If they don't wanna learn, then they can figure it out on their own. They're the same folks obsessed with social media, so if they wanna rely solely on that for their life? Then we'd actually be winning if all of them move over there.
Why are you criticising people for being on social media while you're writing this on social media after watching a guy making video about social media? Can you see the irony of yourself? What are you doing telling them to get a one-way ticket? Ha ha ha ha.
In 1970-71 I was 10 yrs old going to a primary school in Dunedin New Zealand. We were given the little red book to read at our leisure. It seemed like a quaint novelty not realising how impactful and influential it was . I don't even think our teachers knew the underlying narrative. Here we are now suffering uncertainty in this modern global environment with a hegemonic new entity deflecting blame of their actions while critical of the US. We're seemingly in a state of confusion inundated with misinformation losing sight of common sense and a reality my generation once knew. The school incidentally was George Street Normal School in north Dunedin New Zealand.
I think it's more about lack of humility and actual exposure to other countries. They are simply arrogant and terribly undereducated. Then they start to think it's normal and okay and then get slughtered by not so well meaning forces.
I’m Chinese, and watching this video and the comments feels so ironic. They’ve never been to China and don’t want to know the truth, yet they’re proud of their “understanding” of China. They won’t even open the Xiaohongshu app to see the real content, but they’ll listen to a clout-chasing creator twisting things out of context. If you’d just watch videos of people from other countries traveling in China, you wouldn’t be fooled by American media or this channel. Prejudice and arrogance have always been big issues.
I have plenty of friends in China and went to China before, I don't get why this channel is deliberately trying to paint China in a bad light. You gain basically nothing apart from cold hard cash, and tarnished your reputation to 20% of the world. Hope your day is going well man.
This experiment won’t work out. CCP has two choices: letting free speech run free across red note and the risk of turning the Chinese against the government. Or censor as it always has done in which case Americans will soon become disillusioned and realize China is in fact not the great country that is being portrayed to them when they first join the app. Also I guess there are not many of the 600 million Chinese living on 150 usd per month on this app talking about their hardship.
yeah that's true mb. it's just that some tiktok I see with people literally crying saying that they're "tricked" looks too much. or are they the one doing that for content and I just couldn't tell?
If they only *listened* to the guy who is so pleased to “feel the world so big”. Why hasn’t he felt that way till now? Because he wasn’t allowed access to the internet outside China.
As soon as I saw the rednote videos I went to your channel and wondered why I hadn't seen anything on it, but it was only a matter of time! Thank you for your hard work, you got on this quickly, seeing these people glaze china for not being as bad as *they imagined* sent my blood pressure through the roof. Just because *they* didn't know china had "skyscrapers", suddenly it must be a "Utopia". "The media told us these people were loincloth wearing savages!" No one told you that! If you believed that, you have no idea what the world looks like. And people tend to have this idea that criticizing the goverment of a nation means that we're also saying the *PEOPLE* are inhuman. The same thing happens with Iran, no one has a problem with its citizens, it's the *government* we don't trust.
I think I disagree with that statement tho, cos the government is still made up of it's people(people of that country), so there isn't a clear distinction/difference between both.
You left out a detail, a good one. The ToS on Little Red Book requires all its account holders to praise the ccp, socialism and all that typical stuff.
RedNote doesn't allow: -Free speech -Politics -Criticism of CCP, maybe only your own government -Woke -LGBTQ I read another comment that RedNote is not about Mao's Red Book but like Red Envelope or some other play on word for something popular. Funny thing is on Chinese articles it literally names it Red Book but on the English articles they say Red Note.
Agreed, am a Chinese American, those are really bragging “working less than 40 hours to support single parent family”. I am single mum, worked 16 hours a day no weekends to support myself and my boy. I was holding high paid job which comes with long work hours and responsibilities.
In China, single mom is difficult too, but if you have a job in China, normally it is permanent job, you can feed and support yourself and one child with that one job. Normally every Chinese own their house without any tax, so all salary is used for normal life and normal child education is quite affordable. House has no tax, own the house, whatever how low incoming, they are still have place to live .
@@MD97531 which Chinese earn 150$ monthly? I never heard that, I lived in China for 25 years, my hometown is a small poor village in China, the poorest people also can earn around 250-300$ per month. And in village,all vegetables can grow by themselves, also every family has 30-50 chicken at least per year, eggs and meat can be supplied by themselves. And all houses are nearly free for local village people, no tax, purchase fee normally is around 2000-4000$ to buy a house in the small village. And health care insurance is around 100$ per year. So even for poorest people whose incoming is around 250-300$, they still own their house, they are not homeless at all. When they get serious sickness, yes, they will be difficult to pay the hospital fee, normally this time,all village people donate to him for pay for the hospital fee. Poorest people in China are difficult about serious sickness, but no any problem with food, living place. And these poorest people in China, only 1/1000 ? To be honest, even what you said 150$ incoming monthly, they are also not homeless people at all, they are also own their house
@@MD97531 which Chinese only earn 150$ monthly? I came from small poor village, the poorest people also can earn 250-300$ monthly. And even their incoming is 250-300$ monthly, they are not homeless at all, because all local village all people own their house, no tax at all for the house. Buy a house is around 200$-4000$ depending on house condition.
@@MD97531 to be honest, even 150$ incoming for Chinese, because Chinese house has no tax, own the house for the whole life, even 150$ monthly incoming, they still can have a nice life. For water fee in village, one family just 2$ per month, for electric just around 5-10$ monthly per family. So 150$ per month incoming, you still can save at least half of it in the bank for future to use
Reminds me of all those people who went over to the middle east to fight against America and its allies. Then years later they tried to come back and claimed they were young and naive and they just wanted to come home.
@@Anonymous-fx3oc he never made a single post, he is just known for politics. He could have only posted about food or music or anything that didn’t violate TOS, but he was never allowed to make a single post.
Why is it worrying? The ancients fully understood this. It's why there were royal families, nobility, etc. The thinkers must do all the thinking for the doers. In the Holy Bible Jesus makes it quite clear the people are "sheep". Are sheep known for their internal monologues?
If the CCP want to run app services in America then they should be forced to allow American app services in their country, Google, Gmail, Facebook, Twitter-X, if they block services then the same should happen to them, fairs fair
yep reciprical but i would take it future and have the same immigration rules as them.... if we cant go to there universities they should not be allowed to go to ours to get PR and ID cards. same rules for everyone then there propaganda department cant complain
@@LFYin74. Oh, okay. American companies didn’t want the CCP to harvest their users’ data or have any more of their intellectual property stolen. Oh, so sorry. Clearly they were evil for not kowtowing to the great Kleptocracy.
My lord you just answered your own question your a chinese ☭ troll propaganda pig did the ccp pay you about $500 Yuan lol😮😅😢. China doesn't want their people to hear any negative opinions against the oligarchs in power 😂there are still 300 million people in poverty the ccp doesn't care about poor people.
It truly is a pot meets kettle situation. No idea how people can take either government seriously. Yes you've got to keep your head down and not say or do certain things in each country. Yes both nations are led by a lethal cocktail of crazy+stupid.
Also, gotta love that she's crying because she "just wanted to say F you to the American government". I'll truly never understand the sentiment that causes people to flee one country to another, only to then crap all over the country they fled to. It would be like if my house was lost in a natural disaster and a kind neighbor took me in. If I then spent my days badmouthing that neighbor it would say a lot more about me than anything else.
Just because you think America is so fantastic doesn't mean everyone else does. People who have lived here their who life are tired of struggling with corporate greed and unreasonable wages / wage theft.
Thank you all for your support and a massive thank you to Surfshark for sponsoring this video: Secure your privacy with Surfshark! Enter coupon code serpentza for 4 extra months at Surfshark.com/serpentza
Hey Winston hope you're staying awesome 😎 just curious to what happened to last night's China show live stream? Fri nights at 5pm is still the day isn't it?
And another extension, Sponsorblock
@serpentza 😂 THERE YOU GO! exposed as the Alphabet People supporter. Typical.
Nice hair Winston!!!
What was that film you showed with John Candy?
You know its serious when Serpentza is out of his suit, and not on a greenscreen.
He’s mourning TikTok😞
JK!😉
Its ironic but yes XD
I know right!!!? I was afraid this was going to be one of those " I've got some bad health news"
😂👍
The live on 40 hours a week and have a place to live is living in a closet with no toilet.
Dang. What will I do now Xiaohongshu has undone my work as a propagandist!
Make more propaganda videos. I'll keep watching 😅
Holy, it's actually you.
Because you are a traitor.
Continue to be a 走狗.
Ohh nooo what a tragedy, so sorry David… cool to see you here, I watch your content too, thanks for the good work you do!
LMOA my parents lived in the USSR and later moved to the US after its collapse, seeing Americans bend over backwards for authoritarian regimes is mind boggling to me. I guess one thing life taught me is to never underestimate the stupidity and ignorance of people.
Unfortunately our government feels like an authoritarian regime to liberals now that Trump is president, and so they feel like they have to pick sides out of fear.
🙏🏼Amen. After a couple generations of American children being told they can be *anything* they want, giving their children everything without ever expecting accountability for wrongs or mistakes, and participation trophies has destroyed a large portion of our culture. As an American watching our own politicians & government bend to those regimes is mind boggling to me too.
@@JohnDoe-tw8es The person being talked about is you. Don't even know what is going on in the world.
Exactly. When people are bullied by the healthcare mafia and other mafia, they are made to believe it is free market and freedom and it is non-authoritarian, therefore they become proud while being exploited. Just one example how stupid people can be.
@@JohnDoe-tw8es Ah yes, voting against people who are openly communist means that if you vote Trump you're alright with it.
You're a nutcase.
The recent pressure of RedNote has been intense, but at the end of the day, the US isn’t as bad as it seems, and China isn’t as great as it’s often portrayed in the app. Low-income people in China are still struggling just like their counterparts in the US. The positive shift, however, is that more and more people on both sides are starting to recognize that the mainstream media isn't telling the full story, or even the truth in some cases. People are beginning to realise that, despite our differences, we are all human beings with similar emotions, desires for a better life, and hopes for meaningful friendships.
Chinese people are obsessed with America and Americans like crazy. Just as they ignore Russia and russians even though they are neighbors and supposedly allies😶
america is trash.
Fr. China isn’t bad itself, but its government shows that it ain’t all sunshine and rainbows either.
Right!
I had the “pleasure” of being poor in both countries and i can tell u its wayyy harder being broke in the US than in China. In China, i can be poor and still afford food, transportation, and other basic necessities
In America, it felt like every day being poor was so expensive that it made me even poorer
It sucks that the people who need to see this video, probably won't.
Exactly. But we can hope they might see it by chance🤷🏻♀️
We just need to keep calling it out, I mention on any channel that calls it a ban, even if they are talking UFOS or something unrelated and will comment to go to this channel or The China Show
@@toribern419been to both the US and China. I’ll definitely choose China over the U.S any time. The US is a falling empire and China is on its way up. That’s a fact.
That's why we all need to share there's videos to get them spread around
If you guys do not trust red note, don't use it, find another app with a larger user base, probably like the Chinese TikTok, or just travel to china and you will see
It's like all social media, people bragging about how great their lives are and leaving out the struggles and failures.
Tbh, on rednote, they are actually comparing whose life/ healthcare cost less😂 and teaching/learning how to cook Chinese food and help each other’s homework.
@@陈鹏-i5m Given the current economic housing crises there, you basically proved his point.😂
@@ArtieKendall okay okay okay. The Chinese are not showing off their low cost of living in a merry manner. They are not helping each other’s homework. They are not teaching/learning how to cook. They are not making friends. How about I say it this way: as all the real Chinese human are struggling with the house crisis, all the red noters are actually fake…feeling better? The united states is the gleatest countie in the world. All other counties are making out of shit.👍
@@ArtieKendall greetings from the eat Mr Borat.🤣
Shallow, insecure, lying, individuals that would have been mocked only some 15yrs ago. I suspect most are slaves to credit.
How are they being psyop'd so easily? it's scary.
Ultramaroons.
Public Opinion by Walter Lippmann was published over a century ago in 1922.
They are beyond saving unfortunately. And I say that as an American.
They probably already have Communist/socialist leaning.
Their education or critical thinking must be pretty ineffective
America is going through a brain-rot epidemic.
Thanks to Big Red that is 🇨🇳😒 Grateful our lawmakers- two branches of our government are on to it
*billionaire funded disinfo campaign
People who rave about China's "cheap rent" don't understand that everything is adjusted to how much money they earn per hour. Chinese people get paid much lower than their American counterparts. That first lady's ignorance (and she's an adult!) is really scary.
that she talks about 40 hour work week.... when everyone know 6-9-6 work culture there... like what...
@@mrsmerily it's 9 9 6 (9 am to 9 pm 6 days a week)
Red Note is a platform run by the CCP. I would not trust any Chinese social media. Facebook is all I trust. They have the truth certification from the US government.
@@mrsmerily You are talking about 996, right? That is the IT industry, not ordinary people work 996. If people work 996, their salaries will be very high.
So what? What matters is how they live and the cost of living to income ratio. The dollar is just obscenely overvalued.
lmao love how that lady was crying while wearing her designer bag and clothes in her house that she doesn't need not understanding how she is broke lmao
nah man you just dont know what you should be prioritizing in life, marketing is more important than product
Its no wonder shes single, that was the worst fake crying show ive ever seen someone put on.
Yeah, not the first time someone has exaggerated their reaction for views. She might really believe what she's saying, but the tears are so fake.
Never knew AI avatars had such a hard life!
@@hanrockabrand95 lol this reminds me of crying OF models on Instagram who weren't prepared for the consequences of their actions
Everytime I see a TikTok talking about how great China is, I refer them to your channel and tell them to watch all your videos. They are so misinformed, its scary.
As an Asian living close to China & lived 7 years in China, I can't believe how gullible way too many Americans can be.
I wonder if life is so easy there that they can afford to be so gullible?
It would be great if they even bother to watch.
There's another channel, china insider with david zhang and 攝徒日記Fun TV, but unfortunately his channel doesn't have English subtitles making him unavailable for wider audience
They dont have the attention span to watch such a video, they can only handle 30 seconds or so before they have to swipe
A lot of it, I think, has to do with a shoddy education system and/or general ignorance and stupidity, either willfully or otherwise.
"Many Chinese people only earn $700 a year."
This is a confusing sentence. Because there are such people in China, but they are all elderly or minors. Former Chinese Premier Li Keqiang once said: "There are 600 million people in China with a monthly income of less than 1,000 yuan." His statistics actually include elderly people and children who do not work. Except for the four most developed cities in China, the average salary of Chinese workers is about 4,000 yuan or more. In fact, the pressure of life is not great. Americans' pressure often comes from expensive medical expenses and college loans, while Chinese people have mortgage loans. The cost of industrial products and services in China is much cheaper than that in the United States, so the pressure of life is not greater than that in the United States. The economic crisis in recent years is not unique to China. The United States has also experienced severe inflation.
这位评论者是个明白人，更简单的说，中国人如果收入很低，他会比美国人更容易幸存，因为中国的食物、水电、医疗、教育等“刚性支出”费用都很低，而美国的必须性支出比中国昂贵太多了。这主要是因为美国政府被公司控制，允许大公司通过抬高这些必须性支出费用获利。相比之下，如果是中上阶层，中国的生活水平应该只能勉强和意大利差不多，比不上大多数发达经济体。
I just googled and the average monthly salary is about $3k. Where did you get $700 per year
You are wrong! As a Chinese, we only eat air, we don’t earn any money, if you like😂
Doesnt matter what the avg is, China's economy is crashing severely. Plus AI calculates that 1.3 children per couple since 2000 = 800ml not 1.4bl population. One child policy was in place 1980 to 2015.
多少年前了 而且中国未成年人和老人家一起超过6亿
Imagine Germany made a social-media Platform called: "Mein little Kampf"
That would be hilarious I would join 😅
I need to find a german app developer to make this a reality lmao
sounds awesome
Sooo. Freedom of speech.
Considering how their authoritarian-left regime is persecuting AfD members right now, your idea is probably an incoming reality. In truth Nazis were leftists, after all.
I feel like, if you're devastated because an app is shutting down, then you really need to have a word with yourself.!!!
AGREE 💯👍👍
Or at least reflect on your life and see what that all represents, or was giving you, and try to seek that from other sources, preferably offline. It could be a wake up call to make positive life improvements and make their life more balanced but sadly I do not think many will choose that path.
Just more people without any real problems that feel the need to bitch about something. It's nothing new.
People are having a realization that the goverment and rich do not treat people with respect. This is about control of people's thoughts, period. Red book or whatever is no better, alright kinder. Go figure if you are nice to people they react favorably to you. Our media is just a giant propaganda machine, buy more, don't think.
it depends some people are making money and it's their job on tik tok but of course tik tok doesn't care about that.
Imagine recording yourself balling your eyes out on camera because you can’t use Chinese social media, then hitting “post” 😂😂
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Nothing surprises me anymore sense the last USA election, by which I've seen 100's of women screaming at the camera while shaving their Heads.
I don't get why these people haven't already moved to China, since they love it so much.
: toothless laughing man meme :
*I LOOKED FOR THIS COMMENT*
@@augustwest9727 Then they wonder why there's so many "misogynists" nowadays
My perspective on it is that 1) living in both countries suck, just in different ways and 2) we're all just people struggling to live under them.
The Red Note push is scary.
Its entirely ccp propaganda. Ccp owns a lot of western media. It owns part of reddit, where this rumor started
Why exactly?
You and me know why America is banning tiktok... They can't control the narrative their like they do with Facebook or Instagram TH-cam. etc
The genocide in Gaza was being shown in its full without any kind of censorship... And daddy israel doesn't like that so the AIPAC who's holding the American politicians by the balls... Forced them into banning the app.... It's not about privacy or any of that.... Remember edward Snowden.? I rest my case.
Not really, most of the Americans on that app will be banned soon. They will have to look for a new app.🤣
@@Caz-z1x perhaps Russian app, or a N korean app. where anyone not praising the chairmen KIm will be deleted.
Literally watched a red note ad during an ad break 😂
I work with many Chinese who are now US citizens. There is a reason they are here and why they went through the trouble to be become citizens.
And there is a reason why substantially more Chinese choose to live in China happily.
I would not trust these Chinese if I were you. Many of them are sent by the CCP to spy on American and steal US technology. Why do you see so many professors teaching in the US go back to China recently. They need to report to the CCP and unload their finding to the motherland. Be especially cautious of Taiwanese Chinese. Trojan horse.
@@IrisDi2010 Happily, are you sure about that?
@@IrisDi2010 because they can't afford to leave 😂
You also have people from rich european countries like netherlands or sweden who went to live in the us so whats your point Just go to China yourself and make up your own mind .
_The grass is always greener on the other side of the fence._
In this case the grass is dying out on both sides but one side paints it green, literally. 😐
simple facts, not your thing of course
说一下我自己的收入，我955，中午休息2h，到手6500，交税45，年假15天。
我在中国三线，类似于美国市一级的行政区，房租1000（30平，两室一厅独立卫浴厨房），吃喝住行2000（一天三餐都去餐馆吃饭，不自己做饭。肉蛋奶水果蔬菜甜品都有。这2000也包括水电网费交通费。我们电费0.5，水费3块一吨，网费一个月29-200g，我们去餐馆吃一顿大餐10块以内）
我们大学学费一年5000，无利息。医保一年400，报销百分之八十，无拒保率。这是基础，交的越多保障越丰厚。
我的待遇在中国很普遍，我只是个最普通的二本生，中国年轻人基本都是我这个学历。
Exactly right hehe liked your comment 👍😁💯
EXCELLENT METAPHORE 💯
Hail Trump!
The best way to understand what everyday life in China looks like is to visit the country yourself. Alternatively, you can check out travel vlogs made by non-Chinese tourists. According to data, 30% of RedNote users are between 19 and 22 years old, while 50% fall in the 23-32 age range. I wonder how people in China manage to reach “high-end” status at such a young age. Does that mean they have a stronger job market or a more robust economy? Or does that mean it's the average life?
Exactly 💯
It could just be that we're talking about a small piece of a big pie, in which a disproportionate amount of young adults coming from wealthy families are represented (compared to the actual ratio of wealthy to middle and lower class). It would make sense from an optics standpoint for China to market this app in a way that makes it more attractive for specifically that demographic to use, seeing as it is public facing to the rest of the world (creates a positive image for China). I suppose they could even allow anyone to use the app, regardless of what class they represent, and then leverage the app's algorithm to heavily favor content that would leave "consumers" with the impression China is better off than it really is, if not in better shape than the rest of the world.
The way I see it, there are "shades" of propaganda in every country around the world (the US if FAR from innocent, just to be clear), but it's only natural that it be more abused in areas ruled by dictators, such as you find in China. However, I also think it's close to impossible to really know for sure which country(ies) push(es) the most propaganda on their people.
It's unfortunate how difficult it is to effectively discern between truth and deception, especially for individuals like myself who've never explored outside of their own country and have to rely on news outlets and random people on social media to get a sense of what that "other world" is like. For every news source that claims something as a "fact," you'll find another source that claims it's a lie. How can we know who to trust?
@ I don't wanna argue over "opinions" or "guesses " of who have never been to China-we should respect the facts. Visit China and see for yourself. Everyday life there is far better than what you see on RedNote.
因为小红书上的人大部分根本就还没开始工作不知道现实生活是怎么样的很多网上富豪富豪，他们甚至以为这是普通人的生活😂
@ The translation says "Because most of the people on Xiaohongshu haven’t even started working yet." Could you please share the data source to support this claim, or was it simply made up?
Once Americans realize they cant be monetized or beg for money, they'll leave anyway
It's all about the Benjamins 💸💸💸
I can't stand when they're constantly begging for money. It's exhausting.
Except you can. It's a business platform. There are already Westerners making money.
So is everyone on the app do it for fun?
@@lollye7916 I mean, it's their entire full time job. If they don't make money begging, making content of... questionable sorts, they won't pay the bills! I've seen quite a number complain they can't pay the bills and are passively aggressively demanding donations or subscriptions, etc. It is exhausting, and man there is just so many of them. It's an oversatured market of influencers. Too many influencers, too little who care to watch and lacking deep enough pockets to donate to them all.
Red Note is banned by the same law that TikTok is, they just haven't implemented it yet.
Was wondering about that. Don’t all Chinese companies share data with the CCP?
@@johngalt2069 Pretty much 😒
Banning these apps is not going to change anything. If the kids don't like Facebook or TH-cam shorts they are gonna keep searching for alternatives. The promotion of Communism in the American public education system is also partly to blame for this. Kids think the little red book is cool now. I would argue it shows extreme weakness of the US government and culture that they are trying to ban these apps. It shows they are on the back foot big time.
@@Ziegfried82 It's our media who are communist sympathizers.
The US has started building great firewall.
I’d love for everyone who thinks “China is the future” to leave immediately and go to China.
If only they weren't massive hypocrites, I'm sure they would. We certainly wouldn't miss them.
yes
That Train station in the Thumbnail is Chinese. I challenge you to point me to anything literally anything half as impressive of any public transit anywhere in America.
China is a developing nation that has Lapped us in multiple fields especially production and research. Hell no it ain't perfect but we've been a Developed nation since the 1950s what the hell is our excuse falling behind. That's the only message people are sharing not China is perfect.
America make 2000% more money since then and the population has only gone up 50%. WAGES HAVE STAYED FLAT
@@MillywiggZ
How's the High Speed Rail project going in 🇺🇸 these days??? 🤡
@@finnigankhjurich8150 "what the hell is our excuse falling behind"
because we don't have army of slaves that can work 12+ hrs per day for 700$ per year.
People talking about "censorship" in the West but no one dares to post a Winnie Pooh meme on Rednote 😂
pretty sure you don’t have a red note account. get an app and search 维尼熊。
fun logic. Why do you want to be involved in politics when you are nothing?
This 😂😂😂
Criticizing the censorship that's done here should be done with the intention of improving liberty here, not with the intent of taking it all down.
"No one" ? I've seen plenty of Getting Banned on RedNote Speedruns.
It's painful how gullible social media users are. Painful because I could literally be a multi millionaire with 0 effort if I just didn't have ethical concerns about scamming all these embarrassing muppets
I have no morals or scruples, tell me your ideas
A lady just gave fake brad pit 800,000$ so yes very easy.
I had this very thought today watching Newsome supporters whose homes had been burned to the ground explain their continued support for him. It's really hard not to believe in the simulation.
@@jasonhenry5by5 There's a lot of how tos online. If your good, Crypto is good. Rug pulling is legal in the crypto sphere. So many dumb people there. A literal 14 year old did it to like a thousand adults and got 30,000 bucks. But you need some understanding of finances and investments. And to actually seem legitimate and pull the plug before anyone else does. You do need advertising and stuff though. Need to stream and get it out there. Invest in Dogshit Coin 2045! Gonna be big!
Mr Beast, Logan Paul, have done this too. A lot of people do it, somehow. Even tutorials on YT.
Yes like you watching one sided content like serpentza who has HSK 3 Chinese at best lmao
My fellow Americans are not bright crayons 🤦🏽
Brightest crayons in the cookie jar...
nope. See last election.
@ReneeLibby-cv8vf I recommend finding better candidates next time, and policies that don't threaten the prosperity and security of the nation.
Most of the world have proven themselves to be incapable of thinking for themselves. we lived through 2020
@@ReneeLibby-cv8vf ahhhh Bless your heart
Never underestimate the power of stupid people in large groups
Facts
Arm yourself before too late
you’re in such a group right now
The way you introduced yourself was interesting.
sounds like you dont need to pay the high tax and medical money
Naming an app after the book used to Murder most of the intelligent and older people seems appropriate.
Like The Red skins used to genocide a nation ?
Oh! You Americans never murdered and practically eradicate the Native Americans who lived in what we call America today! You just made them 'disappear' or hauling hundreds of thousands of young people from the continent of Africa, shipping them to America under harrowing conditions and setting them and their descenders as slave labour for centuries! The country with the worst record of treating others suddenly becomes the biggest 'criticizer' of Human Rights Abuses! That's America for you! Next it will be Germany with their 6+ million souls on their 'heads' taking on the 'pulpit'! We had better get ready for a really long series of sermons by the devils themselves!
This has nothing to do with Mao.
真是虚假的视频博主 对所有虚假的评论点赞 我就在这里 如果你想了解中国 我可以告诉你真实的情况而不是被这个虚假的视频欺骗
From Wikipedia 'The name Xiaohongshu or 'Little Red Book' was inspired by its co-founder Mao Wenchao's career at Bain & Company and education at the Stanford Graduate School of Business; both institutions feature red as their main color.
'Little Red Book' is also the English nickname for the 1964 compilation Quotations from Chairman Mao Tse-tung. The company stated that the platform's name is not a reference to the book.'
Don't believe everything Serpentza says. A quick google will debunk his nonesense.
What these people are saying completely justifies the TikTok ban.
Ban RedNote too its far worse than TikTok
@@InciniumVGCplease. I am planning for my Chinese new year trip to Yunnan. Searching meaningful trip plans seems difficult after all these TT refugees rushed in, paying their cat tax and write letters back to Lihua
@@InciniumVGC Worse in what way?
@@rando6836 I don’t want to see it go. I like TikTok. But I’m also 51 yr old and know better.
@@InciniumVGC Interesting, isn't China an authoritarian hellhole where everyone lives in misery? Shouldn't Chinese people interacting with US netizens be a good thing to open the poor oppressed Chinese people's eyes to how good the US is? I think the US should allow and even encourage these TikTokers to go on RedNote to share the good news and get the Chinese people to rise in revolt.
Red Note is definitely an eye opener
FINALLY! You are the first youtuber I see actually being realistic about rednote. Everyone else is only talking about the friendly interactions and "woops, my post went against the guidelines and got deleted hahaha" Like... do you realize people living in China "disappear" because of a "Woopsie" post?
same in USA lol.
不知道哦，你能给我说一下吗，或有信息源？我很感兴趣
Yeah, I've been keeping an eye on this channel waiting for a video on this! Out of nowhere, a well spoken "very nice" Chinese lady suddenly showed up on my feed yesterday talking about this app...To your point, I think perhaps many people never experienced being seriously scammed / robbed / ripped off etc by very very friendly people.
The first time it happened to me I was still a teenager and I did a double take: this guy STOLE my camera???? But he was SO NICE! Then I realized, some places, the criminals are very very nice because it just works better.
But yeah, if people apply "good guy vs bad guy" simplistic movie logic, they think nice = good. I really think we get imprinted with this, no matter how smart we think we are. People need to travel more - and then actually talk to locals, not just hang out in resorts. You start to see the difference between the official narratives and the stories on the ground that way. TH-cam can be a good stand in for traveling, when watching the right channels.
The other worrying trend I've noticed - and this also applies to Russia - is people that feel they are "awake" about their own country, but they are still looking for some place to idealize, so they jump to defending the "official enemy" of their country. Like, the enemy of my enemy is my friend... and they assume anything bad ever said about that place must all be some kind of lie.
If you shed light on Boeing corruption or OpenAI corruption in US suddenly you unalived yourself? America has this problem in a different way.
Funny you'd say that, since I had the pleasure of meeting 4 Police officers myself 1.5 years ago because of a Twitter post.
And it wasn't in evil China, it was in evil Germany, I guess.
Always the same story with you people. Stop telling us how bad some nation on the other side of world is, when here is the same just slightly different.
Stop telling us how free we are, while our homes are being searched by police for speech offences.
She's right, people in China don't have to work 40 hours a week; they have to work 72.
That is not true! some people wanted to work more hours to get overtime. for some company (especially manufactoring company) if they don't provide overtime, they can not even finish their hiring goal. For IT company, the make a lot of money, but they worked long hours. most of people work about 8 hours. Iuckily I have worked in China more than 12 years, and I still want to work there. Problem is that they don't offer any permanent residence there.
@@zincion1so you are not Chinese, you said thats not ture😂 as a chinese, i can tell you thats totally ture, most of us are forced to work over time and dont get any OT pay, if we refuse, we will much possible to get fired😢
@@zincion1 I was thinking of the 996 factory jobs.
@@idaofte6149 You mentioned that if you don't work overtime, you'll get fired. If that's the case, I can assure you that you're with the wrong company. You should continue searching for one that meets your needs for a healthy work-life balance
@@idaofte6149 To be honest, if you could generate multi-billion-dollar sales revenue for your company every year, I can guarantee you’d be treated like royalty. In fact, you might even have the influence to make your boss work overtime for you! That’s the level of value you bring to the table, deserving a completely different level of treatment🤭
Why is she crying. If she dislikes the US and wants to be surrounded by Chinese content why not move to China? You dont have to stay in the USA if you dont want to. Its not like someone will prevent you from going wherever you want. They dont care if you leave only when you enter.
Just like Mexicans can move to the US if they don't like in Mexico, right?
well moving to another country is no easy task you need to find place to stay and job the problem is that china is so heavily censored that is super difficult to go there
They arent even allowed to use those apps there! These people are smooth brained by this stuff. These are the same people who believe every word msm says.
She wants money. She wants to dominate and win in life. The traditional Chinese philosophy is that happiness comes from success inevitably, and it *only* comes from success. So Chinese people travel all around the world to find opportunities to get rich.
@@gomer2813 its asian thirdworld mindset and its true from all the third world countries in ASIA that have saving face... money is god and money fixes saving face , or whats in it for me thinking for everything
Serpentza has to be the expert on China. Full stop. This guy understands the Chinese governments two faced presentation.
This whole "Red Note" craze had me look forward to what Serpentza is going to say about it.
The xiaohongshu stuff is so insane, never thought I'd see the day this scenario is actually playing out.
Its looking more and more like we're living in a Black Mirror episode.
Yeah for real. But I really enjoyed that guy saying how he never felt the world so big until now it's soo wholesome. Haha but the American young now a days aren't real people
I saw on my friends Instagram feed a post of someone sad and talking to the camera but the voice and video slowly became out of sync until it looked like an entirely different language. Like they just dubbed other languages over footage and send it out 😅
We've been living in a Black Mirror episode since 2016
Please make sure your love ones do not get on Red Note. Check their phone to be sure. China is evil and they should not spread misinformation in a peace loving democatic country like the USA.
Thanks for the sobering voice, however, the most important thing that is happening on the red note, is the fact that both the Chinese and the American ordinary people, can talk to each other, and can see each other eye to eye with good intentions and genuine curiosity, and this mess scale realization that we are all buman beings - the people on the opposite side are not aliens or objects. We all eat, laugh, and care for each other.
I think that is a win for humanity. Neither goverment is great to say the least, but in the end of the day, this movement is not about the government (despite that it's triggered by the government) it's about the people.
Whether the red note splits its content by IP or not, the past few days of awakening matters, and will have a long, last impact, hopefully, for the better.
I think he is a hired hand of the government. So he doesn't like to hear you say that.
Hopeful that this will be the legacy!
Well said!
you are wrong,chinese government is great than all other over the world,you know nothing about china
I agree with the premise, but this is not it . The Chinese and the Americans on RedNote are not really typical or genuine, by most measures, they are some of the most brainwashed trend followers.
Plus, we see that CCP is already cordoning off mainland users and will hire shills to pose as "ordinary users" to "tell a good story of China".
IT'S A TRAP. ALWAYS WAS
I'm Chinese and currently live in a second-tier city, and I would say that Rednote's users skew towards the younger residents of the city, who are massively female, financially well off, and don't have the burden of living a life that's overly burdensome. The user base is upper middle class among the residents. This APP is politically apathetic in general.
China's lower-middle class is also heavily burdened, except that there are indeed basic poverty alleviation programs in place to ensure their basic livelihood. China is not as bad as the western media propaganda, nor is it as good as the Rednote shows.
People's opinions always tend to lean towards one extreme, but I'm still glad that people are really starting to get in touch with what we Chinese actually do for a living, and know that we love life too, instead of being brainwashed by the media and the government into complaining about another country every day and becoming an ideological tool.
真棒💖
you describe the media and social networks in China? Every day you spit on the West and lie about your history and society constantly. By the way, thanks for the covid!
大前年金灿荣教授就讲过现在是全世界比烂，只是中国是这堆里面比起来更好的那个，这已经是对自封发达和民主自由的西方是很大的羞辱了
李总理说过全国6亿人月收入不足2000，然后他就被
理性的声音总是大不过极端的声音。说实话我不喜欢现在国内在小红书对账完之后就极力渲染美国人活在水深火热中的氛围，也不喜欢海外这种小红书是政治工具，都是假的这种闭着眼睛都言论。在我看来，无论是左还是右的立场，走到极端都是蠢蛋
Thank you Winston for keeping it real. The world is lucky to have your content!
Keeping it real ? in China if I recall it was stay awesome ? mind you he was a lot slimmer well dressed with more hair and statues, probably felt awesome, now only facing reality .
@@stevedancy1it's called aging and will happen to you too
I’m so tempted to mention honey and pots.
Don’t bother, too much ignorance. Well over most of the populations head, sadly.
Definitely brings to mind Winnie the Pooh.
Trump Fell In Love With
Xi Jinping.
LOL! Propaganda Central! These people are too stupid to get the issue with Tik Tok so they run to a worse version of it.
Get more education
@@DonLeu says the 1 year old empty channel BOT 😂... obviously, tho show must go on right
@@tallll70 what if u don’t have the words tofu, Temu, bot, copy ?????
@@elizabethclaiborne6461
You criticise a country you have never been & view it through your Ruling Class who clearly own your 🧠 all at the same time your own country is going down the toilet.
@@DonLeu tbh hes right u do look like a bot
China shows you what want... Wake up please...
Honestly for Europeans, Russian, Africans, and Arabians, is this very very old new they know it since 1999 but it’s better late than never seeing finely Americans waking up from this is hart warming
they are out of money... they send kids to trollbot now?
Huh? It is very heart warming to realize that the rest of the world always knew how bad things are in China?
@@justaminute3111 Every country has their own issues, It's just that in general China is more well of than the rest of us. You've never been to China have you?
Few things to note about this video:
1. The cultural influence a lot of chinese on rednote are going to experience will be a shock to many. The fact that so many Americans do not understand the differences between countries really isnt that surprising. According to the Barbra Bush foundation, 50% of America reads at a 6th grade or lower level. Reading is the key to opening all other doors when it comes to education, if you can't read, theres a strong chance you wont be able to tell the differences between China and America because you dont have the knowledge capacity to actually do a basic compare and contrast.
2. Lets play off of that for just one minute. I saw this rednote thing is like social darwinism and really goes to show who the Americans are and who the communists are, and thats great, truthfully. I am happy we live in a country where you can FREELY EXPRESS THAT..and I am also happy to live in a country where should war break out, we -could- in fact let you just go to China. Why would we do that? Because if you are going to be -so stupid- that you cannot tell the difference between China and America..honestly..this country will be better without you. I'd rather have an exchange program for Chinese folks and we can bring over the ones that care about our constitution, and we can give china all the americans that dont like america, and well just do a prisoner swap like that.
edit: Jokes on you, what secrets? You arent important enough. You don't know anything worth knowing. If you are so stupid that you get onto social media to spout out about how you will defect to China..gee wiz im not even sure CHINA wants someone as stupid as you.
💯 🎯
If China was going to use them for espionage, those commies would have to live in America to accomplish anything. They'd have to join the military, be conservative capitalists, and go up in rank as good constitutionalists.
For what they want they'd be better off flying to China, apply for citizenship, get a WeChat account, get a driver's license, get married, and all that stuff that SerpZA talked about in previous videos! 😁
Well，let me clarify，china don't want stupid people，especially those who thought they're smart，like you😂
A lot of Americans also think there's more than 2 genders lol
你真是个天才，这个办法相当好，并且让交换的人每天直播他们的生活，地球人一起观看，看一下海水退潮时谁是没有穿裤子的人，太有意思了
This is a great example of why legal immigration has made the U.S. the greatest country in the world. They love our country more than a lot of people who were lucky enough to be born here.
You can never wake up the person who pretends to be asleep, this sentence is for you
i love gutter oil and nothing happened in a certain square
Hahaha LMAO!
Thai-1 is not a country, Tibet is a state of mind, covid was caused by America and Xi Jingping is the most perfect man on the planet
Pooh would like to know your location
What square? China has no squares.
Are you talking about 🍵🧍♂️⬜?
The younger generation are so gullible
They go length to spite others.
The old farts are so brainwashed 😂
Old and young alike are gullible. The old folks get fooled by AI video, and the youngsters get fooled by grifters (no, it's not flat, guys). And we all seem to fall for "divide and conquer" - the culture war, the generational war, aliens vs Jesus, etc... that stuff is pushed by propagandists, to distract and divide the target demographic.
Y'all allowed property taxes and social security to be a scam
Kathy doesn’t know she is the gullible idiot
In fact, rednote is a recipe software, it is from the beginning for people to publish life, travel, food recipes, not to share life. I remember when rednote was first known for helping people choose what to wear
1.6 billion slander bill well spent
Quite true, but it has expanded so much over the years, covering more and more topics in daily life.
now we chinese use it as google research
My brother told me he downloaded Xiaohongshu and was “shocked by how well the Chinese live compared to us.” I should have thought of it at the moment but saying that is an accurate reflection of life for the average Chinese person is like assuming everyone in Dubai lives in a luxury highrise, drives a Lamborghini, and is constantly surrounded by flown out supermodels.
小红书，有超过3亿的华人用户，他们并不代表中国的富裕阶层，他们就是普通的中国中产阶层。是的，并不能拿迪拜的富裕阶层来比较，这些用户都是真实的中国中产阶层。
Brotha, you're so stupid... Xiaohongshu is literally a social media available to everyone.
There's no way you believe that everyone here is a CCP propagandist
I've seen so much of this. I keep pointing people over here and to China uncensored. I've been cringing so hard I think I might have permanent muscle cramps.
As a Chinese, I can say xiaohongshu (Rednote) users' profiles are majority the middle class in China. But absolutely not the upper class. The upper classes in China should have the luxury apartments or houses in the Tier 1 city center (Beijing, Shanghai, Guangzhou and Shenzhen) and the property overseas whatever in Cayman Islands, Manhattan, Vancouver, London, Paris, etc. However, I must admit some parts that @serpentza said are also truth. China has a very huge welath gap. The former prime minister Keqiang Li said 600 million people their monthly salary below 1000 yuan (150 US dollars). Most of them are from the Village. In China, the life quality and job opportunities of city citizen and rural citizen has the huge difference. Due to the fast urbanization, more and more rual citizens choose to work for the manufacturing factory or construction industry. However, these jobs in China that I can say they absolutely do not have any welfare and protection. Because these jobs are deemed as the temporary job instead of the formal job. Hence, you can not enjoy any working welfare or protection such as unemployment insurance, etc. Most of these jobs are paid daily, and the salary is very low due to China has amount of people. The labor force is absolutely is cheap. However, most of these rural citizens they have the opportunity to reach the social mobility which is placing their hope to their children. Hence, most of them work in the city while the working condition is severe and bad, they will save the money and send back the money to their hometown (village) to their children to pay the tuition (Regarding the state dominated system in China, the tuition of the rural school is cheap and affordable). If their children can get the good score in the national college entrance exam (This is the only criteria for going to the level of the university in China whatever you are rich or poor. If you want to go to college in China, get the good score in this exam is necessary). They can get the opportunity to get a bachelor degree then find a job in the city to be a city citizen and enjoy the welfare like the city citizen. This could be explained why China can reach 500 million middle class people from an extreme poverty country in past 40 years and why Chinese parents whatever their class are so pay much attention on the education for their children. Again, most universities in China are public whatever top university or general university, the tuition is not expensive. Only the lowest level universities are private, but normally for middle class or rich families kid to go because the tuition is relative expensive. Also, poor students can apply for the student loan from the government to pay the tuition, but it does not have any interest. In past decades, Chinese system works like this. However, with the economic recession recently, things started to be different. Because college graduates started to face less job opportunities and more competitive competition. But that is another topic.
也有很多低收入的也玩小红书。比如学生
很明显，作为一个中国人，你没有看懂你的祖国。
@@hahamusk 你还回复他 这个一看就是反串 你见过月薪1000的么？ 我奶奶在农村 不工作 一个月也有几百块钱拿
Don't lie. You are a fake Chinese. I'm from the countryside. Why haven't I seen anyone with a monthly salary of less than 1,000 yuan? My grandmother doesn't work and has a subsidy of hundreds of yuan a month. As for Xiaohongshu users, you can use whatever you want. You are still in class. Don't lie under the false Chinese title, okay?
别反串了 你就是一个虚假的中国人呢 我就是农村的 我怎么没见月薪低于1000人民币的 我奶奶不工作一个月都有几百块钱的补贴可以拿 至于小红书用户 想用的哪个都可以用 你还整上阶级了
@@qyf883 低于一千的包括婴儿、学生、残疾人、家庭主妇，这些人不上班，一分钱也没有
My biggest concern is how we are going to survive all these financial and political crises, especially the power struggle in the US. The government has really made things difficult for its citizens and we cannot just sit by and suffer the consequences of bad governance🙏...
How nice that she does so much for you!! Please is there a way to contact her services? I have 3 jobs and I'm trying to pay off my debts for a while now! Please help me 🙏🏻
5825
Ksenia Alice Services has really set the standard for others to follow, we love her here in Canada 🇨🇦 as she has been really helpful and changed lots of life's
Access to good information is what investors need to progress financially, most people are still poor just because friends and family prevented them from investing and trading cryptocurrencies, while the wise ones kept investing and growing financially.
@@thefleetwayss F%$KING BOTS! Get lost!
I can speak out against my government and not fall off the earth, we are not the same
Thanks for the updated information about this
I am fiercely British through and through, spending 17 years in China, married to a British spouse, raising children, and receiving education in China and Australia. Currently employed by a German company, which I absolutely adore. China is a fantastic place to reside. Two decades ago, I was employed by an American company in Boston. One morning, we were abruptly confronted at gunpoint by six criminals, pleading for our survival. We were subjected to a robbery, and my wife endured a harrowing assault, nearly losing her life. Those malevolent youths were eventually apprehended and sentenced to lifelong incarceration. Subsequently, we relocated abroad to Singapore to embark on a fresh chapter, and now we reside in China without any regrets. In my view, America is an utterly despicable place to reside or raise a family.
The wumaos are busy in the comments.
It’s ok. The extra engagement boosts the algorithm ensuring this video reaches more people. They’re not convincing anyone of anything.
没关系，大部分是监狱服刑人员寻求提前释放
most are inmates seeking reduction of prison sentences
Freedom of speech❤
I'm a boomer so I can't understand why someone doesn't just create a new app in America? Can someone educate an old dog?
TikTok was banned becuase the Jews don't like the truth about them being poste. So, no, other app will be allowed. Just Instagram.
yes np so the bai Lan is an anti work movement in China bc they work 9am to 9pm six day per week!
Like Vine? 😂
@@JonDoh-i4w TikTok has a great curation algorithm that hasn't been duplicated. Also, trends are rarely duplicated because of brand recognition.
Not much benefit in brain-rotting your own population.
At least you guys know Chinese people are not your enemies, we are not that different, we can all be friends.
These Americans who want to talk sh!t about everything will get a rude awakening on these apps like Rednote. Once they are told "no" a few times, they will realize that they have been had.
Not for long though. Just like he said, they'll likely create a new version based on IP and probably with looser TOS. Gotta keep our guard constantly up
The typical US TikTok user is bereft of common sense and intellectual curiosity.
TikTok lowered the collective intellect of all it's users by multiple points, I've seen them doing their dances in public. Goldfish with legs
Lowered the collective intelligence for sure
The average tick tock user is a spoiled baby, insulated from how the rest of the world lives. So it's not surprising the general reaction
@@CHarris1066 I would argue it merely reveled what was always there. These people were always stupid.
I've been waiting to hear what you have to say about this, so thank you Serpentza
Chinese work way more that 40 hours a week and alot of chinese are unemployed.
中国工作不是找不到，是很多人找不到自己理想的工作，很多地方找不到人，用工难，现在很多大学生读完大学都想找份轻松工资多的工作，没人愿意去哪些累的工作，就算工资高他们也不愿意去，还有你家花钱里供你上大学，你去工厂上班觉得丢人，按照中国言语，就是眼高手低
I come from China,it's sure. but,people in china,Life is beautiful。food and study is cheap.many thing is cheap. moeny is enough. my English not good,so,i want to tell you mang thing,but,my English not good
that is true, everyone can learn it from xiaohongshu.
China has a Middle Class... US doesn't the vast majority of Americans are impoverished.
The way I see it? If they think its so much easier over there? Then buy a one way ticket there and never come back. People like this need a HARD hit from reality because trying to use evidence won't do squat. If they don't wanna learn, then they can figure it out on their own. They're the same folks obsessed with social media, so if they wanna rely solely on that for their life? Then we'd actually be winning if all of them move over there.
👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👍👍👍👍👍👍 is beautiful
Why are you criticising people for being on social media while you're writing this on social media after watching a guy making video about social media?
Can you see the irony of yourself?
What are you doing telling them to get a one-way ticket? Ha ha ha ha.
In 1970-71 I was 10 yrs old going to a primary school in Dunedin New Zealand. We were given the little red book to read at our leisure. It seemed like a quaint novelty not realising how impactful and influential it was . I don't even think our teachers knew the underlying narrative. Here we are now suffering uncertainty in this modern global environment with a hegemonic new entity deflecting blame of their actions while critical of the US. We're seemingly in a state of confusion inundated with misinformation losing sight of common sense and a reality my generation once knew.
The school incidentally was George Street Normal School in north Dunedin New Zealand.
This explains Jacinta.
You thought that your genocidal empire would last forever did you!
The country that gave us Jacinda the chameleon forked tongue speaker.
@@amaknusa9212 Most south east asians knows that China is the one playing imperialist by invading other nation's territorial waters.
The only people that should be able to tell me what I should think is my American own government.
Little Red Book! 😂 the Americans will be downloading Mein Kampf and Juche next.
Mein Kampf is a very interesting read
If only this country would be better off
Make no mistake, censorship in the West is increasing. Give it time...
I wish you were wrong :(
I think it's more about lack of humility and actual exposure to other countries. They are simply arrogant and terribly undereducated. Then they start to think it's normal and okay and then get slughtered by not so well meaning forces.
How much time? Less than 24 hours?
Right now misinforming and pressing social medias to block on some way, but eventually would going to do it more obviously.
New zealand mainstream media were and are controlled(bought) by our govt, any wise person doesnt watch tv news anymore
Thumbs up Americans from south Africa with love
I’m Chinese, and watching this video and the comments feels so ironic. They’ve never been to China and don’t want to know the truth, yet they’re proud of their “understanding” of China. They won’t even open the Xiaohongshu app to see the real content, but they’ll listen to a clout-chasing creator twisting things out of context. If you’d just watch videos of people from other countries traveling in China, you wouldn’t be fooled by American media or this channel.
Prejudice and arrogance have always been big issues.
Fifty cents is here 😂五毛奴才来诡辩了sophistry
Wouldn't it be interesting if the CCCP allowed Chinese people to experience an uncensored internet? 也许他们的头会爆炸 🤯
I have plenty of friends in China and went to China before, I don't get why this channel is deliberately trying to paint China in a bad light. You gain basically nothing apart from cold hard cash, and tarnished your reputation to 20% of the world.
Hope your day is going well man.
This experiment won’t work out. CCP has two choices: letting free speech run free across red note and the risk of turning the Chinese against the government. Or censor as it always has done in which case Americans will soon become disillusioned and realize China is in fact not the great country that is being portrayed to them when they first join the app. Also I guess there are not many of the 600 million Chinese living on 150 usd per month on this app talking about their hardship.
你如果真是中国人你摸着良心说，小红书上的真的是中国普通劳苦大众的生活吗？
i agree ppl should go to china and experience the life there see if that suites you. never take others words for granted.
There's nothing to see in China. Go to Taiwan if you want a real Chinese experience.
he did. thats why we watch him
@@bullpup1337 well the guy got kicked out of the country because he didn't want to follow the damn law so yeah, take it how you will
I can't believe some american can't distinguish between what's content and what's real
That would be half this country's women and mentally ill manchildren.
They are the most brainless people on earth todays.
That's not an American thing, that's humanity in general because technology is so tricky
Americans just love lies from Donald Trump.
yeah that's true mb.
it's just that some tiktok I see with people literally crying saying that they're "tricked" looks too much.
or are they the one doing that for content and I just couldn't tell?
If they only *listened* to the guy who is so pleased to “feel the world so big”. Why hasn’t he felt that way till now? Because he wasn’t allowed access to the internet outside China.
The government just don’t understand when one door close another ones open
I was waiting for your channel to cover this topic, the only video that people need to see on this subject, Great work, Thank You
I mean they're welcome to move to China. They'll come back in a few years singing the The Star-Spangled Banner.
The LGBT butthurt is so funny on the tik tok refugees
For the first time. I completely agree with you. I have lived and worked in China for over 20 years.
As soon as I saw the rednote videos I went to your channel and wondered why I hadn't seen anything on it, but it was only a matter of time!
Thank you for your hard work, you got on this quickly, seeing these people glaze china for not being as bad as *they imagined* sent my blood pressure through the roof.
Just because *they* didn't know china had "skyscrapers", suddenly it must be a "Utopia".
"The media told us these people were loincloth wearing savages!"
No one told you that! If you believed that, you have no idea what the world looks like.
And people tend to have this idea that criticizing the goverment of a nation means that we're also saying the *PEOPLE* are inhuman.
The same thing happens with Iran, no one has a problem with its citizens, it's the *government* we don't trust.
I think I disagree with that statement tho, cos the government is still made up of it's people(people of that country), so there isn't a clear distinction/difference between both.
I would like to know your opinion on it
lol girl in red dress has a full face active filter. its disturbingly annoying once you see it .
You left out a detail, a good one. The ToS on Little Red Book requires all its account holders to praise the ccp, socialism and all that typical stuff.
I'm not getting the app but I am told they ask for your social security #. I'd like to know if that's true.
你這樣造謠只是徒勞，因為下載並安裝小紅書並不會浪費多少時間🤣
你为什么编造这样的谎言？你为什么憎恨我们？
为什么要编造一个很容易证实的谣言呢？
You triggered the Chicoms Stuart.
RedNote doesn't allow:
-Free speech
-Politics
-Criticism of CCP, maybe only your own government
-Woke
-LGBTQ
I read another comment that RedNote is not about Mao's Red Book but like Red Envelope or some other play on word for something popular. Funny thing is on Chinese articles it literally names it Red Book but on the English articles they say Red Note.
I see the Chinese bots came out all over this post. LOL!
I like how you've prepared an out for the likelihood that you can't stand up to a debate about what China is actually like.
I agree. CCCP propagandists and agents.
yes every opinion u dont like must be from chinese bot, well done
Agreed, am a Chinese American, those are really bragging “working less than 40 hours to support single parent family”. I am single mum, worked 16 hours a day no weekends to support myself and my boy. I was holding high paid job which comes with long work hours and responsibilities.
In China, single mom is difficult too, but if you have a job in China, normally it is permanent job, you can feed and support yourself and one child with that one job. Normally every Chinese own their house without any tax, so all salary is used for normal life and normal child education is quite affordable. House has no tax, own the house, whatever how low incoming, they are still have place to live .
@@lilyLily-gk2pd so how do the 600 million Chinese who live on 150 usd a month make it all work? 😂
@@MD97531 which Chinese earn 150$ monthly? I never heard that, I lived in China for 25 years, my hometown is a small poor village in China, the poorest people also can earn around 250-300$ per month. And in village,all vegetables can grow by themselves, also every family has 30-50 chicken at least per year, eggs and meat can be supplied by themselves. And all houses are nearly free for local village people, no tax, purchase fee normally is around 2000-4000$ to buy a house in the small village. And health care insurance is around 100$ per year. So even for poorest people whose incoming is around 250-300$, they still own their house, they are not homeless at all. When they get serious sickness, yes, they will be difficult to pay the hospital fee, normally this time,all village people donate to him for pay for the hospital fee. Poorest people in China are difficult about serious sickness, but no any problem with food, living place. And these poorest people in China, only 1/1000 ? To be honest, even what you said 150$ incoming monthly, they are also not homeless people at all, they are also own their house
@@MD97531 which Chinese only earn 150$ monthly? I came from small poor village, the poorest people also can earn 250-300$ monthly. And even their incoming is 250-300$ monthly, they are not homeless at all, because all local village all people own their house, no tax at all for the house. Buy a house is around 200$-4000$ depending on house condition.
@@MD97531 to be honest, even 150$ incoming for Chinese, because Chinese house has no tax, own the house for the whole life, even 150$ monthly incoming, they still can have a nice life. For water fee in village, one family just 2$ per month, for electric just around 5-10$ monthly per family. So 150$ per month incoming, you still can save at least half of it in the bank for future to use
It's so strange to see Winston without his suit
Reminds me of all those people who went over to the middle east to fight against America and its allies. Then years later they tried to come back and claimed they were young and naive and they just wanted to come home.
Honestly your opinion on this I’ve been waiting on. You are actually knowledgeable.
red note just banned my buddy nick before he even made a single post.
does he have pronouns or an lgbt flag in his profile?
@@danieldorn2927 no, he is a censored political commentator in america who is critical of a little country in the middle east.
Your censoring yourself are you talking about Isreal @juliusstriker4465
It literally says on the rednote terms of use that you’re not allowed to talk about politics. Maybe he should read the terms next time
@@Anonymous-fx3oc he never made a single post, he is just known for politics. He could have only posted about food or music or anything that didn’t violate TOS, but he was never allowed to make a single post.
As a Chinese, Little Red Book is literally full of people that brag or lie about how much they are earning LOL
30%-50% of the population has no internal monologue... there are studies on this. Very, very worrying.
Why is it worrying? The ancients fully understood this. It's why there were royal families, nobility, etc. The thinkers must do all the thinking for the doers. In the Holy Bible Jesus makes it quite clear the people are "sheep". Are sheep known for their internal monologues?
If everyone on Earth seen this video it wouldnt be enough people.
If the CCP want to run app services in America then they should be forced to allow American app services in their country, Google, Gmail, Facebook, Twitter-X, if they block services then the same should happen to them, fairs fair
这些应用程序不同意把数据放在中国境内，不同意审查反华宣传内容，所以被禁止了。并不是因为他们出生在美国。
Apple同意把数据放在中国，iPhone运行良好。微软也是如此。
亚马逊也能用，但对中国人来说有点难用。
The American apps you mentioned doesn’t want to follow the law in China while TikTok follows the law in U.S. it’s not the same story.
yep reciprical but i would take it future and have the same immigration rules as them.... if we cant go to there universities they should not be allowed to go to ours to get PR and ID cards. same rules for everyone then there propaganda department cant complain
@@LFYin74. Oh, okay. American companies didn’t want the CCP to harvest their users’ data or have any more of their intellectual property stolen. Oh, so sorry. Clearly they were evil for not kowtowing to the great Kleptocracy.
My lord you just answered your own question your a chinese ☭ troll propaganda pig did the ccp pay you about $500 Yuan lol😮😅😢. China doesn't want their people to hear any negative opinions against the oligarchs in power 😂there are still 300 million people in poverty the ccp doesn't care about poor people.
If it's better in China, how come China doesn't allow Facebook, Wikipedia, Google, "X," or Netflix? What are they afraid of?
violence, obscene are bad influences to young kids. Different cultures.
No, that’s all there
like the US law said, Meta, Wiki and Google are owned by a foreign adversary
Both countries are jokes. Just depends on what kind of humor you prefer.
One at least has the underpinnings that can support positive change though. The other is thoroughly suppressed
Fire comment and so true 🔥
It truly is a pot meets kettle situation. No idea how people can take either government seriously. Yes you've got to keep your head down and not say or do certain things in each country. Yes both nations are led by a lethal cocktail of crazy+stupid.
Arrogant and ignorant, both of them.
If china is that good, why so many Chinese illegally immigrated to the US for the last 2 years?
Many? Compared to China population?
Mexicans are more and Latin America.
会不会是因为他们是罪犯逃到美国的，还有借了很多钱不还的
@@kayellai5278well, why no American get in china illegally😂
A population of 1.4 billion thats a massive population is not like they are 1/5 of the world
Chinese spy sent by the CCP. They know the US bordor security is a joke.
I'm sorry but people sobbing over social media is pathetic 11:20
I know right? These people are unhinged.
Also, gotta love that she's crying because she "just wanted to say F you to the American government". I'll truly never understand the sentiment that causes people to flee one country to another, only to then crap all over the country they fled to. It would be like if my house was lost in a natural disaster and a kind neighbor took me in. If I then spent my days badmouthing that neighbor it would say a lot more about me than anything else.
Just because you think America is so fantastic doesn't mean everyone else does. People who have lived here their who life are tired of struggling with corporate greed and unreasonable wages / wage theft.
China has a long history of building walls.
Tiktok influencers realising that they do not matter in the real world 🤣🤦♂️