@ she’s a college teacher she can’t say we thought there was WMDs and there weren’t any and we wanted their oil fields because they were gonna change it from usd bro
@@pulse3554 there are many things I can find that I disagree with, but I can still use the information she provide to educate myself. She works for government so she will be biased obviously. Still a lot to learn here.
@@yeahdude333333333 when did I imply that’s all I “got out” of this. I already know much of what she’s talking about this isn’t uncommon knowledge, maybe to Americans. What she said is a HUGE red flag. HUGE. It means she’s willing to lie about at least one major directive or even worse somehow be ignorant to it
I appreciate how Paine breaks down everything into digestible info chunks while linking it all together. Great lecture and interview. Could listen to her talk for many more hours.
I've just started to deep dive into geopolitics/history and Sarah Paine is my absolute favorite speaker on this topic. Her insights and way of explaining complex topics into concise, digestible bites while being entertaining is unmatched.
30-some years I haven’t comprehended / remembered and thus been interested in history - until I heard this woman. There’s something miraculous about that 💃
I love Sarah Paine so much and her thoughts about grand strategy have helped me really galvanize my world view regarding maritime/land empires in the modern era. Last time you guys spoke I thought Dwarkesh could have really improved his questions however this episode I feel you have grown so much as an interviewer! Ty so much for publishing this content looking forward to more in the future.
I happened to listen to most of your podcast with Sarah C.M. Paine last night. Any happily this just showed up in my feed. Out of all the Commentators and think tanks I listen to, I trust what she says the most. But what do I know? Thank you, and thank you for having a great podcast...without all the sensationalism! I appreciate that
I loved her first long interview and i have seen it from beginning to end. I also always click on all those YT shorts of hers even though I have seen them all already and I know what she is going to say.
I love Sarah Paine, such a captivating and competent speaker. I was thinking about the first interview you did with her for the past few weeks now, rewatching the old one-and here we are. Couldn't wish for a better surprise.
She forgot to mention that in 1965, when Pakistan invaded India, India was also suffering through a large famine in part because the Americans stopped any supply of international foodgrains to India. This is when the slogan "Jai Jawan Jai Kisan" given by the then Prime Minister of India, Lal Bahadur Shastri became popular. The slogan literally means "Glory to the soldier, glory to the farmer" symbolising the two struggles India was facing during the time.
Great show! I am a huge fan of your podcast and your guests! I learned about Sarah Paine through here, she's amazing! If I could LIKE a dozen times over I would. Many well wishes and prosperity
Her comment about the bloodshed of the cold war makes me think of that "The Fallen" video that at least heavily implies how much better things got after the end of World War II. I wonder whether the numbers used for that video came from and how they reconcile with those that she's dug up. I'd be prepared to see it settle on either side, but it would be worthwhile to investigate.
Very excited. She is an excellent communicator and clearly incredibly knowledgeable in her field. BUT her best trait by far is a single sentence she uses a lot. “I don’t know”. We all need to be more comfortable with that statement.
This is a very fair assessment of the relations between this complex geography. Professor Paine admits our (USA) misunderstood intentions through out this Cold War. And she’s right about the Cold War was fought out in smaller countries which was so horrific for the civilians who lived there. Let’s never go through this again.
Thank you for circling back to the Dr. Patel. Your interview with her is one of the most illuminating on geopolitics I've ever seen. She is a gifted and extremely knowledgeable presenter.
When guy named Patel doesn't know when Nehru died and that he didn't live up to the collapse of the Soviet Union... the white think tank Lady has been to the Gandhi Museum and told Patel to visit, you suddenly realize, colonial legacy children/ McCauley's children truly exist, and eventually are lost ...devoid of their own heritage! Alas !!
At 1:49+ is the most brilliant and concise remark by Sarah Paine in the entire video (it was all brilliant), when she essentially states (my paraphrase) that the US cannot change Russia or China and it’s going to be a long wait for Russia & China to change their evil way! In the meantime we need to protect ourselves AND our allies. That’s the realistic bottom line of what US foreign policy should be!
A couple of key inaccuracies: Mao never claimed the USSR took land larger than the US east of the Mississippi. The Dalai Lama fled to India years after the PLA entered Lhasa, not days before.
Im really glad there's more of ms Paine. She is one of those speakers who are very concise, clear and to-the-point. Very nice to listen to.
You mean Dr Paine.
Agreed there is something about Dr. Paine’s voice
Wonder if she’ll talk about how the U.S. ousted Imran Khan forcibly recently… as they always do to countries
WHAT lmao she actually thinks the U.S. went into Iraq to “impose democracy” WHAT
@ she’s a college teacher she can’t say we thought there was WMDs and there weren’t any and we wanted their oil fields because they were gonna change it from usd bro
I'll watch every interview she does. She rocks.
I did a binge on everything I could find after seeing the first interview on this channel. Very smart person.
lmao she actually thinks the U.S. went into Iraq to “impose democracy” WHAT
@@pulse3554 there are many things I can find that I disagree with, but I can still use the information she provide to educate myself. She works for government so she will be biased obviously. Still a lot to learn here.
@@AdamBrusselback same. She's awesome
I agree one might ask why this woman is not on a Presidential Board on foreign policy or whatever the equivalent is!?
God damn this hits hard - never seen a more crisp and clear explainer on the entire 5 nation cold war axis.
10/10 Content: Please serialize this, and pay her millions to talk about contemporary topics. "This is the first time, I have liked & commented"
She’s awesome!
Hell yes! Been looking forward to this
Me too
You said it, sister 👏!!!
lmao she actually thinks the U.S. went into Iraq to “impose democracy” WHAT
@@pulse3554 That’s all you got out of this?
@@yeahdude333333333 when did I imply that’s all I “got out” of this. I already know much of what she’s talking about this isn’t uncommon knowledge, maybe to Americans. What she said is a HUGE red flag. HUGE. It means she’s willing to lie about at least one major directive or even worse somehow be ignorant to it
So excited for this! Thanks for bringing her back!
This is awesome. Love how you introduced me to S. Paine. She’s so cogent.
googling the word "cogent" hahah
lmao she actually thinks the U.S. went into Iraq to “impose democracy” WHAT
I've been waiting all day for the upload
I appreciate how Paine breaks down everything into digestible info chunks while linking it all together. Great lecture and interview. Could listen to her talk for many more hours.
This is a moment I was waiting so long. Thank you
She really likes the word appalled lol. Excellent presentation, she communicates dense topics in a very personal, understandable way
I've just started to deep dive into geopolitics/history and Sarah Paine is my absolute favorite speaker on this topic. Her insights and way of explaining complex topics into concise, digestible bites while being entertaining is unmatched.
Alright, literally every other TH-cam video is irrelevant until I watch this entire trilogy.
So true! Even sleep is irrelevant
This is an absolute treat and privilege to hear.
So great you had her back. She's awesome. And funny in the driest possible way.
She is literally the best! Thanks for the video!
Sarah Paine is one of my favorite geopolitical scientist.
The first interview was probably the best podcast I’ve ever listened to. Very excited for the next 2 hours!
Thanks!
Sarah Paine is brilliant! I’ve been following her very few and so thorough lectures for years.
There’s only a few on US navy channels I think.
30-some years I haven’t comprehended / remembered and thus been interested in history - until I heard this woman. There’s something miraculous about that 💃
lmao she actually thinks the U.S. went into Iraq to “impose democracy” WHAT
You should graduate to someone smarter - Mearsheimer et al
@@pulse3554 lol mearsheimer is braindead
I love Sarah Paine so much and her thoughts about grand strategy have helped me really galvanize my world view regarding maritime/land empires in the modern era. Last time you guys spoke I thought Dwarkesh could have really improved his questions however this episode I feel you have grown so much as an interviewer! Ty so much for publishing this content looking forward to more in the future.
I could listen to her talk all night. She’s brilliant.
I happened to listen to most of your podcast with Sarah C.M. Paine last night. Any happily this just showed up in my feed.
Out of all the Commentators and think tanks I listen to, I trust what she says the most.
But what do I know?
Thank you, and thank you for having a great podcast...without all the sensationalism! I appreciate that
I’m so pumped for this, I could listen to this woman for hours
This was a really amazing podcast. Ms Paine is thoughtful, articulate and crisp. Thank you Dwarkesh for inviting her.
Great to see her back!!
I loved her first long interview and i have seen it from beginning to end. I also always click on all those YT shorts of hers even though I have seen them all already and I know what she is going to say.
i haven’t listened yet but so stoked for this. the previous interview you did with her is one of my all time favorite interviews
Ms Paine is a force of nature
Thank you! Looking forward to the next two episodes!
YESSS LETS GOOO ITS HERR!
I love Sarah Paine, such a captivating and competent speaker. I was thinking about the first interview you did with her for the past few weeks now, rewatching the old one-and here we are. Couldn't wish for a better surprise.
Been looking for this! Thank you!
I appreciate the amount of names, places, events brought up.
She is fantastic. Thanks for this.
Wow, looking forward to the other episodes
She forgot to mention that in 1965, when Pakistan invaded India, India was also suffering through a large famine in part because the Americans stopped any supply of international foodgrains to India. This is when the slogan "Jai Jawan Jai Kisan" given by the then Prime Minister of India, Lal Bahadur Shastri became popular. The slogan literally means "Glory to the soldier, glory to the farmer" symbolising the two struggles India was facing during the time.
I love her, she’s brilliant
Sarah Paine is so awesome, so insightful. I hang off of every word she says. G-d bless the The Fleet's wise sages, chief among them Prof. Paine!
I LOVE SARAH PAINE LETS GOOOO
Been waiting for this!
She is a legit top 10 war history intellectual, love it, hope we have more content from her
So happy you’ve brought Paine back. A brilliant thinker and geopolitical strategist.
Thanks for sharing this
Amazing presentation again. Thank you!!
Love this. Cracked up when she said ‘capped bin Laden’
The giddy weeeeeeeeeeee that came out of my mouth when I found out this came up AND EPISODE 1!?!? I am not ashamed of. Crazy excited
This was so insightful and interesting! Thank you.
WoW! How lucky we are to hear from Sarah, thank you so much for bringing her to your plateform. ❤
Great video, needs more attention!
Brilliant from both of you. thanks
Thank you have been waiting. You should do some with her at least bi-annually. Great content! Thank you!
Half way in... so informative ❤
I absolutely love this woman.
This is fantastic & wonderful to watch and learn from. I loved her first podcast with you Patel, keep up the good work bro!!
Funfact, The defense analyst at 42:46 is the father of S.Jaishankar the current External Affairs Minister of India.
Let's goooo. Going to take a long hike and listen to this whole thing.
Great show! I am a huge fan of your podcast and your guests! I learned about Sarah Paine through here, she's amazing! If I could LIKE a dozen times over I would. Many well wishes and prosperity
hell yeah the last interview you did with this woman was so informative and she has a very rational way of thinking, i also like her humour
Really enjoyed the previous interview so I was excited to start this lecture.
Her comment about the bloodshed of the cold war makes me think of that "The Fallen" video that at least heavily implies how much better things got after the end of World War II. I wonder whether the numbers used for that video came from and how they reconcile with those that she's dug up. I'd be prepared to see it settle on either side, but it would be worthwhile to investigate.
Very excited. She is an excellent communicator and clearly incredibly knowledgeable in her field. BUT her best trait by far is a single sentence she uses a lot. “I don’t know”. We all need to be more comfortable with that statement.
This is a very fair assessment of the relations between this complex geography. Professor Paine admits our (USA) misunderstood intentions through out this Cold War.
And she’s right about the Cold War was fought out in smaller countries which was so horrific for the civilians who lived there.
Let’s never go through this again.
sarah paine, and roel konijnendijk are immediate clicks for me. wars and ditches
Sarah Paine clearly reveals how the “masters make the rules for the wise and the fools”. And the plans continue.
13:19 : He was 100% correct
She is very smart teacher. I like her topics and materials.
This is better than christmas
Hell yes! I love this woman
i very much enjoy watching her interviews
So happy I stumbled upon this channel and this episode. New subscriber here!
WE WANT MORE SARAH PAINE
Thank you she's amazing :)
Excellent communicator and such well organized content
Just brilliant!
Great video!
When my friends dont want to discuss the latest sarah paine lecture i am APPALLED.
Thank you for circling back to the Dr. Patel. Your interview with her is one of the most illuminating on geopolitics I've ever seen. She is a gifted and extremely knowledgeable presenter.
When guy named Patel doesn't know when Nehru died and that he didn't live up to the collapse of the Soviet Union... the white think tank Lady has been to the Gandhi Museum and told Patel to visit, you suddenly realize, colonial legacy children/ McCauley's children truly exist, and eventually are lost ...devoid of their own heritage! Alas !!
Thank you for doing the needful saar
Her and Peter zeihan need to do a talk/lecture together. Id never stop watching
Yeeeeeeesssss🎉🎉🎉
At 1:49+ is the most brilliant and concise remark by Sarah Paine in the entire video (it was all brilliant), when she essentially states (my paraphrase) that the US cannot change Russia or China and it’s going to be a long wait for Russia & China to change their evil way! In the meantime we need to protect ourselves AND our allies. That’s the realistic bottom line of what US foreign policy should be!
Your nation is evil too, thousands of people murdered by bombs and so many unnecessary regime changes. Nobody looks at you as a hero.
JCG5541-
From outside the US, the perspective is that it is the USA that is evil. Canadians FEAR our onetime "friend" and "ally".
What a gift 🥹
TY!
best guess i’ve seen on any podcast ever
Enlightening
A couple of key inaccuracies:
Mao never claimed the USSR took land larger than the US east of the Mississippi.
The Dalai Lama fled to India years after the PLA entered Lhasa, not days before.
There's no allies, only common interest. The balance of power keeps the peace never forget.
A match made in heaven!
Her talking on different topics should be a podcast in itself.
This is like 4D chess or a game of Risk in real life. Amazing story and analysis!
Trilogy? This should be a monthly series!
Working out and getting smarter 😊
I can use more of her content she is great
13:23 “but forget it. I just can’t handle it. …” 😂
Downloaded this for the flight tomorrow 👍
More Paine!
This woman is a national treasure
She’s so good