The Warning - Dust To Dust REACTION & REVIEW! FIRST TIME HEARING! PLEASE READ THE DESCRIPTION!!!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ธ.ค. 2020
- The Warning Fans....FEELIN' YOU!!! Alright so we're coming back for another round of The Warning. Last time, gonna be honest, the response to my reaction was met with some controversy. This time we're doing an original song from the girls entitled "Dust To Dust". I'm looking forward to hearing an original song from them, I'm excited to see what they can do with their own material. I realize the video is long, sorry about that...but there's a reason it's so long. I felt compelled to explain all of my statements so that way there's no confusion or misinterpretation from anyone watching this video, so no one could possibly misconstrue any statements that I make. Hopefully this will reduce the number of misunderstandings. Also if you're not sure what the score that I give the girls means, and you tink the score I give the girls is "too low", please make sure you check out the scoring system down below. If you don't agree with my analysis that's fine, I have no problem with that. If you become rude or belligerent or toxic in any way though, I'm just gonna block you end of story.
Come on in, enjoy the show...I'll see you inside.
Scoring System Guide
10 = Perfection (Unobtainable)
9.0 - 9.9 = Awesome, Amazing
8.0 - 8.9 = Great
7.0 - 7.9 = Really Good
6.0 - 6.9 = Pretty Good
5.0 - 5.9 = O.k.
4.0 - 4.9 = Not So Good
3.0 - 3.9 = Pretty Bad
2.0 - 2.9 = Really Bad
1.0 - 1.9 = Horrible, Awful
0.0 - 0.9 = A Travesty, An Affront To Nature
Link to Original Video Here:
• The Warning - Dust to ...
My Twitter: / bassist4aw
My Instagram (I've just started learning how to use it): / davidheretic666
My Patreon Page, where you can view ALL the videos I try to post that TH-cam is forced to block, can be found here:
www.patreon.com/user?u=44053979
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. I have no intent on claiming this music for my own, I'm simply reacting to the video and giving my constructive criticism and feedback. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS - บันเทิง
I'm really enjoying your in depth analysis.I would much rather listen to this than some warning reactors who literally play the song and that's it .
Thank you Anthony, glad to hear you're enjoying the show.
yes absolutely! great reaction 💪🏻
@@THEDavidHeretic Pau the drummer is now nominated for best Rock drummer of 2023 by the Drumeo awards and the contest ends on 12/25/23
at 11:59 pm So if you feel that she is deserving of that honor please go and vote, I have placed my vote for her. And please tell everybody so that they can go and vote.
Great reaction! and analysis
Thank you
@@THEDavidHeretic Have you done a reaction/analysis of the teatro Metropolitan CDMX live concert? it is about an hour and forty five minutes long, you could probably break it down to song by song like other reactors have done. I believe the concert was in 2019 if i remember right. It is a great concert and the light show is very professionally done.
Thank you!
@@THEDavidHeretic The Warning teatro Metropolitan concert was on august 2022 not on the 2019
I was in this crowd. It was a private event. The band offered a private show as a kickstarter reward, and a bunch of us pitched in to make it happen. It was quite the night, with fans from 20 different states and many different countries. Folks flew in from Sweden, England, Scotland, Canada, Mexico and Puerto Rico (and I may be forgetting one or two countries). If my memory serves, we numbered over two hundred. It was crowded, but not uncomfortably so.
Fast forward to January 2020 and its a completely different story. The band played back to back nights at the Whisky again, and it was beyond capacity. The Whisky now lists capacity at 560, and the crowd was above that. The Warning played back to back nights, selling both out. The first night sold so quickly (in a matter of hours) that The Whisky offered them a second night. There wasn’t six inches of space to be found anywhere in that club. 🤘🏻❤️⚠️
Greetings from Sweden, here :) I discovered TheWarning at am today. Had never heard them before. Now I have listening the whole day so far. So amazing tallented girls and performing and delivering songs only as songs. Its with attitude and feelings too.
The worlds stages are theirs....
@@thomashammar7430 I agree! The world is theirs for the taking. They are building a legendary career.
The main lead singer is Dany the guitarist. She takes the lead in more than 90 % of the songs. The range of her voice is bigger than Pau's. Also Ale sometimes sings lead when Dany needs a rest. Of course Pau's singing is fantastic. You have to listen to more songs of The Warning to see and hear Dany's greatness. She is an excellent front woman.
If you didn't react to The Warning would mean the bullies won. Glad you did decided to react to them again :)
That "Guy" is their Manager, "preaching" about Salvation.
Dust to Dust is the first Song of the Album, please react to the other Songs to.
Great to see you come back to The Warning with an open mind. It's sad that the squeaky wheel gets the grease. That dude is their manager Rudy, he was playing the part of the preacher giving a sermon at the funeral for the Queen of the Murder Scene. The album, Queen of the Murder Scene is a concept album that chronicles a woman that falls for a man and becomes obsessed and angered she is not receiving that love in return... she murders him and after a little internal struggle she succumbs to her psychosis and goes on a murder spree taking over from the grim reaper until he comes back to regain his thrown and she takes her own life only to be reborn in the prologue Dust to Dust.
This was recorded in Jan 2019 before they had hired their own sound engineer. Their show at the Whisky A Go Go from Jan 2020 has much better audio...
Oh my god, noooooo, not Gene Simmons.... Puke!!!! Ale loves playing bass and is dedicated to putting on a great show but she's an introvert and shy's away from the spot light...
Pau has stepped out from behind the kit a couple of times to play keyboard and to perform as a gust with collabs...
I was at this 2019 show,one of only a little over 100 fans invited for a private show. I flew to LA from Ohio,it was the best show of my life and I'm 65yo and seen a lot of bands. I flew back a year later to see them again,bringing my son & 8yo grandson,who the girls asked me to bring because they wanted to meet him since he is such a young fan and they did meet with him like they promised. About those 2 Whisky shows last January, they were sellout shows both,600 people packed in there both nights,just an FYI. Thanks for giving the girls another go,but as you see,this is one of the most passionate fanbases I've ever been a part of (7 years for me) and we tend to go into protect mode with the girls,we have a very close relationship with them,for me,knowing them on a personal level,I see them like a proud Grandpa would and they know that and appreciate it! They are just as remarkable offstage as they are on, absolutely fantastic human beings!
Thanks again! ⚡🎶⚡🎶⚡
We are very protective, at times over protective of these young women. Your opinions are every bit as valid as others. I am sorry you were put through that.
Specter is in process of making an Ale signature bass it's gold metal flake with a candy apple red lightning bolt where the pots are she's a rock star at 15, and Specter knows it.
Great reaction! Your pronounciation is spot on. Pau is the dummer because that is her passion. As an independent band they didn’t have the resources to have their own audio engineer so they depended on venue staff who don’t know their music. You are not the first to ask “Who’s that guy?” That guy is their manager Rudy playing the part of a preacher giving a sermon on redemption and salvation. The song is the introduction to their concept album Queen of the Murder Scene. It introduces the story of a woman who falls for a man who doesn’t know her, becomes obsessed, kills him, descends into madness, and commits suicide. This song is sung from the point of view of the woman’s ghost at her funeral. You need to do Crimson Queen next - a showcase for Dany the guitarrist. Welcome to The Warning Army!
It's already in the que, I added your name to the requester list.
Crimson Queen will hit you direct in the feels.
Since this show, the band has hired a full time, exclusive sound engineer.
Oh good to hear, no more incompetent intern sound engineers. I'm glad to hear the girls sound will be well taken care of.
Never heard of them almost sounds like Pantera or maybe a little iron maiden
Some reviewers have suggested they sound a bit like SOAD on this song. There are a lot of familiar classic rock elements mixed into their sound.
These girls are overwhelmingly talented!
That "guy" is Rudy their manager who represents a preacher talking about salvation.
Also let me say that the lyrics are very deep. They're geniuses.
Bassist Ale is the youngest artist sponsored officially by Spector since she was 13 yo!!
Viva The Warning!!
OK. The guy on the stage is Rudy, their manager. You need to understand the song and the album to get his role. The song is called Dust to Dust and is the prologue for the album Queen of the Murder Scene that follows a character during 13 songs in her search for the unanswered love. The album is a musical story in 4 chapters with 3 songs each plus this song Dust to Dust that is actually the last portion of the story even it’s the first song. They are reflecting on the journey of the character. Back to Rudy, he is giving a speech as a priest in the funeral for the character. They needed a person for the speech in the recording and just looked at Rudy and said, you do it :-). The ladies rule Rudy 😂 This is the only time the mic’d him out. Other few times he has been on the stage he has been lip syncing as I understand it. The Warning has released live videos from three of their live concerts and they are not putting any money on music videos (else one) so in most of their TH-cam content you’ll find some small flaws bit it is what it is, raw and 100% energy. Ale is the most shy person of the three and on rehearsals and sound checks she is just standing there meanwhile Pau and Dany are in full Rock mode but then on the gig, Ale turns to be the beast. Totally in her environment of the stage. And btw, I like Atlas Rise by Metallica. Hahaha... there we go.
I can see how they have a following, interested in hearing more.
Be sure and check out their channel. They have tons of video's and vlogs. an EP and 2 complete albums of original music, and they just finished recording their 3rd album last week. th-cam.com/users/luisvillarr
Haha, Yes, Ale does a lot of Gene Simmons poses, but she is the shy one. LOL. She also does some kicks like Nancy Wilson. Pau does have a great voice and sings half a dozen songs, some at the drums and some at the keyboards. Dany has a wider vocal range, and is the main lead singer. She has a great voice also!
The guy is Rudy, their manager. He is playing the part of "the Preacher" saying that "Brothers, you need to ask for salvation", and this is the Prologue song into their second album, "Queen of the Murder Scene". It is a concept album that plays as a musical graphic novel. It's a Masterpiece!
This particular show was a private show for fans only. And take into consideration that this is an unknown band from a different country that had fans fly in from all over the world.
I agree about Atlas Rise. I would love to hear them do something from "Kill'm All". But, their originals are so much better!
All three are incredibly talented! I love this song, but it is not even in my top 5 of this album. That's how good the album is. Thanks for sticking with The Warning!
That album seriously should have gotten a Grammy. Better than most of the junk put out by corporate big music.
This guy knows his shit!
Appreciate you giving them another shot. The comments last time were frankly embarrassing. At the end of the day it is your channel and you can do with it as you wish. People need to understand that. Their opinions are just that, their own. If they don't like it, simply move on. It is not our place to force our views on others. I'm not saying people cannot disagree in the comments but at least be respectful to the reactor, it is their content.
I love the band and am appreciative that you have at least discovered them and through you potentially others have to, which is never a bad thing.
Agreed. I don't expect everyone to like what I say in my reviews, as a matter of fact if I don't upset a few people then maybe I wasn't honest enough. And I never have a problem with people disagreeing with me, like you said it's all opinions. So always feel free to disagree, absolutely....just do it in a respectful manner. You nailed it right on the money redeye.
@@barclaybass2327 And yet you probably respect the opinions of the other hundreds of reactors who have zero...ZERO...experience in the music industry. Why is that? Because they "love" everything they hear, and say nothing except "Yo, that's fire bruh"? I shouldn't have to prove anything, because they sure don't. All I'm offering is my genuine and honest reaction , feedback, and opinion....just like all the rest of them. I just happen to have over 30 years as a professional musician under my belt to rely on when it comes to backing up my reasonings. As far as my bands and projects, as I've stated before, I'm not going to mention them because I don't want people getting the impression that I'm using this channel as a platform to advertise them or promote them. A couple of people have used Google to find at least one of them, and that's fine. If they want to search out my bands and projects that is their business, as long as they respect the rules and don't mention them on the channel.
Dust to Dust is a good start for The Warning's original songs. On the past stuff: you gotta be you do you, don't be artificial.
As mention by other comment 'that guy' is Rudy their manager. He is portraying a preacher conducting a sermon at a funeral. Here is the English translation of what he was saying.
Brother: The salvation
It is something that is earned
Release your hand of resentment
and wake up to a new light
Inside you, although your brothers
try to plunge you into the darkness
This concert was a private showing. It was for KickStarter supports as a reward for funding the recording of their second album Queen of the Murder Scene. They made 400% above their initial pledge.
As a foot note at the beginning of 2020 they did a another Kickstarter campaign for funding their North America tour (Mexico, USA, Canada), which was cancel due to the pandemic and funding for their third studio album (they started mid September and completed last Friday.). They exceeded that initial pledge by 600% and became the sixth highest funded band in KickStarter history.
Since they are now with Lava Record they do keep all creative control of their music and keep their Patreon supporters. They are very happy with the deal they got from Lava.
Good reaction, and fair.
You got Ale the bass players name spot on.
Regarding her Spector bass with LED's. Yes she can play in the dark without them. In fact she has a white version of the same bass without them. If you look deeper into The Warning you will see that bass too.
The guy is their manager 'Rudy', and in this song he plays the part of a preacher giving a sermon about salvation. Dust to Dust is the first track on the their concept album 'Queen Of The Murder Scene'.
The drummer is too good to leave her drums. You have seen nothing yet. She may be only 5 foot tall, but she is dynamite.
She had a white Fender that was sold in the Kickstarter campaign. That was not with fret led-light but the white Spector she had for a while had blue fret led-lights
@@Divedown_25
I didn't know the White Spector also had LED's
Thanks for the info.
We all as humans like finding people that like the same things we like, and while other reaction channels like the warning, they can not explain what makes them good. You recognize the work the girls have put into their craft and can explain to us viewers why we have come to like them at least from a technical manner. I much prefer your informed opinion to those that have never even been ON a stage or recording studio.
FEELIN' YOU Jesus!!! Glad to hear you are enjoying the show, more great stuff coming soon.
Im sorry that I asked you for Atlas Rise first. but because you said you enjoyed bands showing respect for the fans, i thought that was a good way to show you they have it.. and thought maybe you knew the song.. so didnt know you well either, so that was my bad. I would have asked for this .. BUT everyone asks for this first. If you do Crimson queen at the whiskey please do the version from THEIR page (2020) it seems to have the best sound. Although Lunario is good to, and the Foro Didi version Danys guitar malfunctions and she just keep going A capella. I think you are the first reactor to say Ale is like Gene simmons.. and i was never been a big kiss fan but watched a few vids since and you are correct lol She is a showman up there coasting the sage usually lol They have all been taking voice lessons and Pau has said she can only sing a few songs in a set as she gets outa breath understandably lol Ale sings lead a couple times not often.. she still a bit shy. Dany has a good voice as well but she is also a great showman as well.. speaks to the crowd with great passion and can be goofy at time up there. About Pau being a frontwoman there is a vid of her out front when they got on stage with Moderetto and was a all over the stage but she loves being behind the drums. Well anyways thanks for this great reaction. that was a respectable score. but dont want to go to big anyways they need room to grow lol be safe and cioa for now
These girls are all super talented. They all are extremely talented instrumentalists and singers. They also have very complementary talents in composing, writing and preforming. They are all award winners on their instruments. I am team Ale, but they all have their own spotlights. They also do what is best for the song, not what is best for themselves.
You couldn't get Pau off the drums if you paid her $1 million dollars. She's a badass on the drums and she picked them. Her power on the drums is what pulls a lot of people in and then Dany and her knock them out with the song writing and vocals and bam, fans for life.
Glad you gave them another chance David. Enjoyed your reaction with your insights as a musician. 🤘😎🤘👍👍👍
There are already 63 comments so I'm sure they've told you who Rudy is by now. This was a private show that was purchased as a Kickstarter reward when they were raising money for their 2nd album, Queen of the Murder Scene. The crowd was quite small, only about 150 people. HOwever, the tickets were $200.00 each, and people came from England, Sweden, Finland, Germany all over the US and Canada. This was the first time I saw them live. I flew from Alabama to see them. Alternatively, I could have driven 100 miles and paid half the price to see Metallica that night. lol
Dust to Dust was the opener. They played for 2 hours, 21 originals and Atlas Rise was the closer. I know you don't like the song, but they killed it.
I started in front of Ale, planning to move around the floor and see them from every angle. I couldn't move. I was mesmerized and paralyzed and in total awe.
This song is the prologue to the concept album Queen of the Murder Scene. The character is actually a ghost, and Rudy's part is a preacher preaching about death and salvation.
When Pau stood up, along with showmanship, it also helps her catch her breath after that drum breakdown during the preacher part.
Thanks so much for coming back to The Warning. I like your comments on the three-part harmony, that's definitely one of their biggest strengths. Both Ale and Pau are often jumping in for short parts like this -- the way their voices blend it's often subtle and you wouldn't know if you are not actually watching them sing.
Thanks for getting back to them! Really appreciate your reaction. Your opening comment and clarification make me appreciate you a lot as a reactor. It is also true that if you would say you like everything, it wouldn't be a reaction channel. Subscribed!
Awesome, welcome to The Fanbase, glad to have you among us. Thank you for recognizing that JF, there's gonna be things I like, dislike, love, and hate. And what's going to make this channel stand apart from all the other "reactors" out there, is I'm going to be honest about it. I'll be open minded, I'll give everything a chance...even second chanced when warranted, and I'll be objective and honest.
The really neat thing about this band is that truly any of the three gals can take up lead. From my prospective, especially for a strong live band like they are, that's a huge advantage. Pau definitely belongs on the drums, and the other two can share the singing of lead. This is a critical strength of the band. Great reaction! Love the deeper analysis.
Great reaction and analysis, David! And yes, you are one of the few who can pronounce Ale's name correctly!! You had that "who's that guy" moment. Let me first back up and provide you with some background information. The girls wanted to write a novel, a story woven around a rather dark tragedy. Instead, they decided to put their concept to music. The result is their second album, _Queen of the Murder Scene._ This song is the Prologue to that story and is followed by four three-song Chapters. The album is a masterpiece (and there are a lot of great harmonies as well)! That guy, essentially, was a preacher talking about salvation being something that one earns, played by their manager, Rudy. That is part of the song, and he recorded that part on the album, and only twice (I believe) performed it live. Most of the time, it is on the backing track. And you are right about Ale. When she performs, she owns that stage!
Also, no!! They do not need another drummer. Others have made that suggestion, as well. It is generally not well received. lol They are sisters. They are an atomic unit. And Pau is an amazing drummer and quite capable of drumming, singing, AND running the visual and audio effects, all at the same time. But you are correct. Pau can grab the audience! On their Argentina tour along with Argentine power trio Eruca Sativa, she came out front for a finale with both bands, and so their drummer played whilst Paulina went out front and sang and jumped about and high kicked, as both bands played "Breed" by Nirvana. Paulina is a petite powerhouse, a diminutive dynamo!!
This is my first time on your channel, and I think I will not go back to your first time with this band, since you didn't like the Metallica song "Atlas Rise". (I hope you like "Enter Sandman"!) Thank you for reacting to The Warning!! Subscribed!
Awesome, welcome to The Fanbase, glad to have you among us.
I´m discover myself these prodigies about a month ago and can´t stop earing their music all the time and viewing reviews and this review it´s the best I see, not only two or three comentaries or put the song and thats all. It´s a complete and objetive review and I love it. Subscribed and go to see more The Warning reviews from you, I can bet you are a fan now.
FEELIN' YOU Luis!!! Yes I'm definitely becoming a fan.
Thanks David! Ha! "Who's that guy?"; one of the most asked questions of 2020! Check out the QOTMS album story to see how the "sermon" is relevant. As a bassist, you may be interested to know that Ale' wrote the driving riff for this song at age 13. She's the quiet one, but loves to move when performing!
She's definitely a showman (showoman?) She really does remind me of Gene Simmons with her movements and motions and posturing and posing. I do a lot of the same things when I'm on stage so I can really appreciate what she does.
@@THEDavidHeretic Fortunatley she is a lot better looking than Mr. Simmons! 😎 Ale' is going to be quite the thing when she grows up!
@@glengibbs1949 Amen to that....doesn't take a lot to look better than Gene, let's be honest here....
This is the first song off of their second album, which is a concept album about a woman who is obsessed with a guy that barely knows she exists and goes more and more insane over the course of the album. The random guy is their manager Rudy, and he plays a preacher or something in that part of the story.
Alejandra 15 - Ale (pronounced like "ah lay")
Paulina 18 - Pau (pronounced like "pow")
Daniela 20 - Dany (pronounced as expected).
This is the prologue to their concept album Queen of the Murder Scene, which tells the story of a disturbed young woman's inner journey from desire to obsession to murder and madness. The songs are told from the point of view of either the young lady's inner psychopath or her good side, which has a conscience - until it does not. Next is Crimson Queen: th-cam.com/video/N0MJXxfcKEQ/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=TheWarning
Already in the que, added your name to the requester list
@@THEDavidHeretic If you are interested in the concept and the lyrics, I have a document here: docs.google.com/document/d/1feFBpjnk8Igk1smcqNR80BcvGnVhV0fwct88ncXSdLE/edit#heading=h.o6lic3zeb5tz
Thanks. I enjoyed this a lot. Most reactors just sit there and barely comment on the music itself. The dude in the middle of the song is their manager playing the roll of a priest preaching salvation. Why? Because Dust to Dust is the prolongue to a conceptual álbum about love, obsesión, madness death and redemption. Their manager only appears in two shows doing this. I believe in this ocassion it was distracting. In other shows they just use a play back track for his part. If you ever do another reaction to this band you will see the guitarrist vocal range. All in all this is a great band and I don't know what hsppened on the last video but it sucks it went bad. Subbed. Thanks.
Awesome, welcome to The Fanbase, glad to have you with us.
The birth of a fan of "The Warning" is sometimes painful, but they are always born.
Thanks for the reaction. It's good that someone knowledgeable about music gave them another shot, regardless of what happened the first time around. I think this band is really great. For a three piece they move some serious air and fill in the sound exceptionally well, are all three very technically sound, write all their own material with some extremely well composed lyrics (which is often overlooked, but if you read them they are seriously well written) and all three are incredibly good showmen (show-women, is that even a word)?? So thanks again, one suggestion is that if you do any other reactions to them pick either the full Lunario concert they recently released to TH-cam or the Foro Didi concert. There you will be able to appreciate much better audio and thus get the impact of each of their voices individually (except for Ale) or in two and three part harmonies as you talked about in this video. Oh, one last thing, as far as the drummer getting out from behind the kit, that would be a real bummer and I believe do a disservice to the band.. If you do watch any more of them you will see that she was born predestined to be behind that kit. The things she does back there are absolutely phenomenal. She does come out once in a while to play keyboards and sing a ballad or two (and those are great as well), but her real calling in life is behind the kit kicking butt.
I know that you want to get away from their covers,but being abass player like yourself this is well worth a look at.The girls did a cover of muse hysteria at their school concert called licea .ale will totally blow you away and she was only about 9 years old.
I saw her play that, yes that was very impressive indeed, not an easy bass line at all.
Rudy playing the part of the preacher at the protagonist's funeral is a one shot deal. This is all very Shakespearian, you see. If he's not there live, he's on tape, but his speech is definitely part of the song.
Hi David, I really liked the reaction!
I think your questions about the band have already been answered in the other comments!
Keep on rocking! 🤘
I really, really enjoyed this reaction (my first time in your channel)
because I really enjoy an honest reaction, even if it's not favorable for the artist, but it comes from somebody who knows what he is talking about
Cool man. F-- have to love you a bit here. I feel you. I’ve seen the fandome with other bands as well. Sorry that you had to go through this. Anyhow... we still love(d) the Led-lights on the bass... she does not need the led lights at all but it is a cool gimmick (I think 🤠)
You picked not the most viewed version of Dust to Dust, not the best balanced audio...but it’s raw. I was there at this gig...the bass pumping in your chest was/is something else. Only felt it once before and that was in a ZZ Top concert.
That bass was a gift to her from a fan. She moved on to a 5 string bass now.
If you choose to keep going with The Warning, you cannot help but notice the diversity in their music. They refuse to continually rewrite the same song. Each song will have its own flavor, in order to convey the message and emotion the band is after. You can tell they are heavily influenced by Queen. I can’t wait to hear where they take us on this third album.
The band just got finished with their 3 month recording session in Jersey City for their debut album with Lava records. It in the mixing process then to the mastering session. I would guess that it will be released in the first quarter of 2021. Hopefully, if videos are still being blocked, it's at a minimum now.
I don't know what happened (comment-wise) on the first vid, but glad you decided to give these gals another chance despite the rabid fanbase comments. Y'all know who you are.😉 Since most all the normal questions have been asked and answered, did you happen to notice the 'Geddy Lee' style cape that Alé was wearing? She has been doing what is now called The Alé Stage Dance, for quite a few years, and though she generally doesn't sing any leads, she's a fantastic backup vocalist. ...and yes, they actually do 3 part harmonies on some of their songs!😁 I don't know how you feel about Muse (the band), but Alé learned that crazy bass line from 'Hysteria' when she was about 8 or 9, and then totally nailed it at a little mini-concert at their private school (Liceo del Monterrey), back in 2015, when they covered the song there.😎 I'll throw a link in here in case you want to check it out. She was 10 when they did that gig. Once again, thanks David for giving another good (technical) look at The Warning. You're still just scratching the surface, but there's a lot more to choose from, and more on the way since they just finished recording their new album. After the mixdown and post-production, we might actually see it released in time for Christmas! Rock on!!😁 🤘😎🤘 Link to The Warning cover of Muse - Hysteria: th-cam.com/video/fU26wmlF3yg/w-d-xo.html
I did see something on her back, wasn't sure what that was. Thank you for the clarification.
I recently got into The Warning and am impressed with their original songs. They are so talented. You almost forget how young they are as they are already season professionals, especially with their live performances. Good to see rock and roll is in good hands!
I am glad you are giving them a second chance although the band themselves were at no fault. It makes me sad that some fans were so toxic towards you. As a fan of The Warning for many years now i am glad you decided to overlook the toxic element :)
David, almost 40 minutes... and hell yeah¡¡ I really enjoy your reaction and all your opinions about things that, normal people non educated in music like me, don't notice at all, thanks for give them a second chance, hope you do more... greetings from México
I know it was kinda long....sorry about that. But I had a lot to say and I felt it was all important. Lots of good stuff in their performance, so I had to gush a little bit.
@@THEDavidHeretic Never too long when it comes to The Warning. I prefer this type of reaction than one that only concludes with a "I like" at the end of a quick listen. Cheers!
@@THEDavidHeretic Agree... Never too long. I've been talking/gushing/yapping, nonstop, about The Warning for nearly 2 1/2 years. 40 minutes of someone else's talking about them is like eating a piece of delicious cake!
So glad you reacted to another song. They are freaking awesome! I honestly think you will like most every song they've written.
Thanks for giving The Warning a shot with their original music.
I recommend (If you are going to make more reviews of the group) that it be in the sequential order in which they were recorded because this way you will be able to understand many fine details since the songs are part of a narrative.
Some time ago I saw a Thai movie that at one point the teacher told the student: "There are people who were born to create music and there are others who were born to enjoy music" I would add that there are also people who were born to explain it ... and you you are one of them!
Your criticisms are always substantiated and you explain them in such way that those of us who don't know nothing, can learn.
Thank you for the encouraging words, I really appreciate them. As far as educating, that's actually one of my hidden agendas for the channel. It's one thing to use technical jargon, it's another to break down that same technical jargon and explain it in a way everyone can understand. I've had several viewers let me know how much they appreciate me explaining song structure and theory, and showing them even simple differences between a verse and a chorus. Anything I can do to help people learn more about music, I'm always willing to do.
Great review! I'm glad you finally gave them a chance with their original material and at about 2 years older than the Atlas Rise cover. Good stuff! These girls are the real deal and they will only continue to get better from this point. 3rd album coming in the future! YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED!!!!!
Glad you're back! I think you will really like what you hear if you continue. Dany is the usual singer and has a wider range than Pau. But they sound better when they harmonize and they have a lot of songs with three-part harmony. Usually Pau sings under Dany's lead and Dany usually sings under Pau's lead. When Ale joins in it's magical. They all three have great showmanship and Pau is very animated. Performances at the Lunario from 2018 and Foro Didi in 2019 are available and are pro shot. Believe it or not, they have many songs that are waaay better than this one and 8.5 is about right. Thanks, we all would love for you to continue! We'll be nice. Promise.
Thanks for giving them a second look! These girls deserve a much wider audience than TH-cam. Also, keep in mind they are writing and singing songs in their 2nd language (though they are all very fluent in English). If you are going to react to more songs from their second album (Queen of the Murder Scene), I would suggest the Live at the Lunario CDMX videos, which I think are a little better quality than the Whisky A Go Go videos. By the way, Ale recently received a gorgeous custom 5 string bass from Spector who now sponsors her (at the ripe old age of 15 😎).
Spector has sponsored her since she was 13 almost as soon as she got her first one from a fan of the band Thomas I. is his name. She also just did a photo shoot for Spector for a signature bass line (th-cam.com/video/1meCiLbk2lg/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=TheWarningArmy)
I am not sure what happened but it is the Internet and there are always trolls. Many times, the trolls are no more associated with the band than you are or I am. I am a fan of The Warning and you provide some great new perspectives. Keep it up.
My thoughts: PAULINE'S VOCALS: Very powerful and strong, Annie Lennox style , so I agree 👍 she could be a frontwoman.
THE WARNING SOUND: A mixture of classic rock 🎸 and alternative. Family 👪 time when they were kids was snacks and watching Queen, Cream, etc with their parents, thus you'll hear classic rock influences in their music 🎶. as well as 80's and 90' s influences.
this review earned the subscription!! more of the warning please
Awesome welcome to The Fanbase, glad to have you among us.
Regarding the Whisky-a-Go-Go, it is easy to fill when you're from the area and have a good following, but not as easy for them, since they are from Mexico and they sold out twice on two consecutive dates with fans from all around the world coming to LA, not an easy feat. They also sold out the Mercury Lounge in New York twice on consecutive days with a last minute concert announcement. Just wanted to clarify the situation.
Addendum: The Whisky shows were on a Wednesday and Thursday night. And there was the Winter NAMM going on with probably dozens of other gigs all over LA.
Really enjoyed that review Dave, thanks for coming back to The Warning. I would imagine by now the folk from The Warning Army have explained about Rudy and the relevance to the song. Looking forward to seeing more...subscribed bud.
Awesome welcome to The Fanbase, glad to have you among us.
Am glad you are impressed with this performance from The Warning. I have been a big fan for a while now and they are really fantastic with their original songs. There are many more good performances for you to check out, both live and in studio, including some really great acoustic stuff. Anyway, I am happy you were able to see The Warning for who they are and what they can do!
I love them. The power trio is one of the hardest formats to pull off, because no one can hide. If they keep it up, they have a shot at joining the immortals like Cream, ZZ Top, Rush etc.
So DH - here I am - your 2nd reaction to The Warning to a very good song - Dust to Dust from Queen of the Murder Scene concept album. This track was written in 2017 and unfortunately you've listened to it without context to the album. Pau (the drummer) plays the conscience of the protagonist (played by Dany). This is a funeral scene with the conscience telling you what has happened, how she has got to this point with Dany's gorgeous vocal at the end being the protagonist's 'soul' pulling you into the story of how it happened. The part of the Preacher (played by Rudy - their manager) is integral to the story, and sets the environment, the event. And yes, without knowing the context, his entry is distracting, and in other shows, his backtrack. However, to add to the stage work, at Teatro Met 2022 both Ale and Dany mouth the sermon while spearing and creeping towards the audience. The extended bass intro is not always played but the best videos to react to with anything regarding QotMS is always Lunario 2018 - much better audio and video. However, having said that, it is refreshing to come across an occasional snippet of a concert I haven't fully watched (like the Whiskey)
As for your 1st reaction to Atlas Rise . . . . I really like their cover and have never heard the original. I went over to that reaction before commenting here and watched it. An 8.0 was cool (though the 7.9 was probably fairer) BUT they were beat - Ale was 13 and way past her bedtime, and you saw how wasted she was 3/4 of the way through; 'Oh not again . . . ' on her face and this was a special encore after an 1.5 or so hour show. I personally don't understand why anyone would have given you crap over it (seriously DH - you should know that a band's original sound will always be better than any cover they do - shame on you 😃). And I am glad you decided to toss the negativity from this reaction and go to an original track, and continue to explore The Warning rather than just toss them aside like you were tempted (and I reckon, other than the occasional protest or after 48 other reactions to their list, the great Animosity blocks of '24, you also are happy that you stuck with them. In fact, I reckon if you weren't enjoying them, you wouldn't have covered so much of their catalog)
Finally - you would have found in the comments info relating to the lights on the bass. No biggie - just Ale being 13 but it does serve a function (as you will see in later videos - she even talks about it in her gear breakdown videos).
Very good reaction - I'll give you a 7.9 . .. . . . nah make it an 8.0. I'm a sucker for professional insight 🤣🤣🤣
Cheers from OZ
Glad you moved on from that crap, it’s not who we are in any way, welcome back to this band, they’re so worth staying with 👌
As for the fret markers, they are from Fret FX, and I’m sure they were already on that Spector Bass when She was gifted it by a fan...Your right in as much she doesn’t need them, pretty sure Ale knows her way around the fret board by now!!!
On the harmonies they sound like System of the Down 🤟🏻🤟🏻🤟🏻
Glad you gave them another view.
The Warning sells out the Whisky every time - it seems that they have people coming in from around the world to see them.
The song is the intro to the whole album "Queen of the Murder Scene". The guy talking is their manager, in the role of a preacher, giving a moral warning.
And apropos of nothing, have you listened to Jinjer? The traditional first video is "Pisces" (Live session), but that is just a sample of what they do,
I've seen a lot of reactors post up videos for Jinjer, so the name is familiar...however I've never watched any of them. I don't wanna sabotage myself by watching another reactor do a video or song I haven't heard before, because then I wouldn't be able to react to it. To the best of my knowledge I've never heard them before. I'll need a link so I watch the correct video.
Kiss was the first concert the girls ever went to. They were very young but they said they replayed the Kiss album their parents had over and over to get to know their songs better before they went to the show .So what you picked up on makes sense. Good catch.
Good score! Their manager messed the lyrics up a bit .The lunario performance is much better,including the managers part which was off the album.
I think they have only let Rudy do his part live at Lunario and here. Pau has said he can't keep time.
Glad you gave them another shot. Nice reaction. A .5 point jump, from what I understand of your scoring system is pretty huge.
Hey David, I'm really glad that you gave The Warning another chance. I dig the Cliff 'Em All shirt. That's when Metallica was good, their new stuff sucks.
Ale does remind me of Gene Simmons with a lot of her poses. Pau used to practice singing while jumping rope or running in order to develop her ability to sing that well while drumming. This band is super talented and gives an awesome live performance! I loved your reaction to this, thanks!
Btw, I enjoy your insight. It's obvious you know a lot about music and live performance from experience.
Thank you David for reacting to The Warning again despite your misgivings because of your first experiences. I totally think you were fair and entertaining. The guy (their manager) was playing the part of a preacher, if I’m not mistaken he’s warning of what’s to come in the story that will unfold across the album. The album, their second is called Queen of the Murder Scene and it’s a concept album, it came out 2 years ago. As others will tell you Dany (the guitarist) is the lead singer on 90%+ of their songs and as a long time fan I don’t see Pau (pronounced like POW, Pau is short for Paulina) ever leaving the drums. On occasion she will play piano for the whole song, with no drumming included at all for the song.
David you definitely took some of my suggestions, thank you and I truly hope to see you do more of The Warning because it seemed like you had fun.
Oh I did, there's a lot more in the que so there will be more of them on this channel.
I enjoyed your professional opinion on our favorite band the Warning. Thanx so much.
FEELIN' YOU Rufus!!!
Amzing reaction man! my respect to you, this guy , his role was talking in Spanish !
Good reaction! I like you style u are a musician so you know you staff THE WARNING ROCKS keep coming more of the Warning 32 original songs and new album is coming soon
And you got a new subscriber 🤘🏼🥁
Love your reaction, 9.7 THE best, very knowledgeable AND honest. ❤️
“I think they need to find someone else to play the drums and put her front and center with a microphone in her hand.”
You’d have to pry the drum sticks from Pau’s cold, dead fingers.
I love The Warning but as with any band they aren’t perfect and me being me I don’t mix words in my opinion. I’ve had my life threatened and was told to not show up at The Whiskey which I did because trolls don’t scare me. Great review and Dust to Dust is one of my favorites
Hey there. So I'm about 2 months late on this. But in case you're wondering: Alejandra (Ale) wrote this song. And what a great job that was :) This is my favorite song by them. She's the youngest and yet the tallest of the 3. Damn she has grown (And still do) both physically and professionally.
About Paulina (Pau). She is a true entertainer. You can see that here and in other of their performances. In my opinion, she should stay behind the drums. She's an amazing drummer. So no need to hire another. And besides. If so, their parents need to have another daughter who then need to grow up very fast (Hahaha). Just kiddin'
Try reacting to this original song by The Warning. The song is called Hunter and this was in Mexico when they opened for Stryper. If you want to see a miniature Gene Simmons, check out Ale's first steps in this video and the whole song. th-cam.com/video/kdA9HatBPc8/w-d-xo.html. BTW, they are big KISS fans and one of their first covers was God Gave Rock n Roll to you by KISS, which of course was a KISS cover of the Argent song. The Warning just finished recording their third album and next year should be nothing but awesome for them, which will also include some KISS related projects.
KISS-related projects? This should be interesting....
I have to say no to Pau coming out from behind the drums and be the lead singer. You would be losing one of the best drummers in the world. The passion and charisma that she plays the drums....that is The Warning. 🤘
I'm sure someone below has mentioned it, but the house sound did seem off for the first few songs, but think they got things dialed in by the time The One, which was about 5th in the set out of 22? D2D, Unmendable, Crimson Queen, Ugh and then The One. You should do all 22 (well the other 21) in a row to get the perfect sampler platter of TW's music, giving you a full spectrum of their sound and how diverse their songwriting is/has been. You won't regret it. Note: the other 21 songs consist of all 13 from their concept album Queen of the Murder Scene and the other 8 are from their incredible sophomore effort, XXI Century Blood including a keyboard acoustic ballad that will leave the hair on your neck and arms standing at full attention, and your soul shaken by the power and heft of Paulina's ability to impart emotion with her voice.
i don't know if i got to get mad at you or simple appreciate your good reaction hahaha , one thing is clear enough ,you know what you talking about , other thing is the you are not the first one to get distracted on the preacher statement , but TWA loves anything on stage will the girls playing up there , we really really love it , but personally i understand your point David ,i'll keep coming back for more , so thank you
In depth and insightful reaction/analysis. Thanks.
Hi David. Welcome back! Thanks for reacting to my suggestion! I met The Warning with that song two years ago and was hooked for the rest of my life!
The guy (their manager Rudy) impersonates a priest. As I told you last time, Queen of the Murder Scene is a concept album so these things are part of the story. Dust to Dust was the prolog presenting a dark story, wich will be folowed by 4 chapters of three songs each.
So if you want to see more of the guitar player (Dany) I suggest you hear the next song in the album "Crimson Queen", here also at the Whisky: th-cam.com/video/_Xe1tBNCJJk/w-d-xo.html
After two years of following The Warning I can tell you that you ain't seen nothing yet! Please keep on reacting to my favorite band.
Greetings from Portugal!
It's already in the que, I added your name to the requester list.
I saw the Warning at the Whiskey in January 2020. They played two nights and they were incredible. You should react to their live shows. They just slay it live.
WOW, you really dissected the song. It was the opening song so maybe they didn't have the mic right at first. Never realized about Ale's moves being like Gene's. I wonder which person should feel honored? I did not get to see your other reaction but it sounds like an over-reactive fan. This is not what The Warning Army is about. We want to expose this band to as many fans as possible. The first time I heard them play Atlas Rise I couldn't figure out why they chose that song. It does show off their musicianship though. I first heard this band doing their "Quarantine Concert" at their home. I just loved it and within a week I ordered the Queen of the Murder Scene CD. I was blown away and became a patreon for their music. I will see them live come hell or high water. Glad you gave them and us another shot.
I think it was their father. I also think it was a throwback to a song from (I believe) the 80's when the wall came down. At one point in the song, some guy starts yelling in German. I can't for the life of me remember the song, but that German yelling stands out, and sounds the same.
The more hardcore part of this band followers can be a tough crowd. But it may also show what this little band have done better than most new indie bands, building a solid fan base. They started very early being super active on the social medias, reaching out for any fan and it have really paid off. Thier funding campaigns have all been VERY succesful and all the noise generated by the fan base, have made companies interested in being part of the journey. The business side of being an artist have always been important in getting succes. You will get nowhere without some founding to do stuff and getting the word spread.
i love your reactions technical approach! subscribed!
Ciertamente prefiero la musica original de The Warning pero me gustan sus covers porque sin tantos recuersos dan su toque a la musica que ellas aman. De verdad me sorprende lo que logran estas chicas, su dedicación y convicción.
tienen muchos fans de muchos países y edades porque tienen frescura, talento y honestidad. Las he visto interactuar con sus fans y me parece genial
Buena reacción y si coincido en que el sonido del escenario no es óptimo pero lo pequeño del lugar permite un acercamiento entre artista y fan que debe ser fantástico
If you want to continue going down the concept album path that started with this song, the next up would be Crimson Queen, an acoustic piece: th-cam.com/video/N0MJXxfcKEQ/w-d-xo.html This is from Lunario CDMX (Ciudad de Mexico -- Mexico City), where they debuted the album. This performance had it's own problems, mainly stemming from the altitude (if Denver is the Mile High City, Mexico City is the Mile and a Half High City) making it difficult to breathe properly, but it can't be beat for energy and as far as I'm concerned, it is the definitive performance of the album. I was actually disappointed to see this was the Whiskey performance and not the Lunario performance, but that's not on you.
If you would like to see what Ale could do very early on -- when she was ten -- check out this rendition of Muse's Hysteria from a school concert by the band: th-cam.com/video/fU26wmlF3yg/w-d-xo.html
Early Pau drumming, from the same concert, five years ago, btw: th-cam.com/video/yv8w2cjTYaU/w-d-xo.html
Oh, and welcome to the rabbit hole.
Yeah singing in high altitude is not easy.....let's be honest here it suuuuuucks. We have to get into town usually 2 days before the show so we can kind of acclimate ourselves to the thin air.
Glad to see you came back to the band as honestly, that was one of the most interesting and entertaining reactions to the band I’ve seen in a while 👍 I missed all the drama on your last video but like any fanbase some cannons are looser than others in The Warning Army but they’ll always get called out by the majority.
Lots of good insights regarding gear and stagecraft, and I totally agree with you about Ale’s Gene Simmons moves, she’s mastered the classic bass player’s art of prowling around the stage like a panther at an early age!
I think you’ll really enjoy the album as you seem like the kind of bloke who’ll appreciate an old-school concept album👍
Haha seriously, great reactions David. I like that you are actually objective and with good and smart analysis and good humor as well. Thanks for this.
To your thoughts of Ale's performance: Just imagine, being the younger of two very active, overwhelming sisters you must do all you can to gain your place on the spotlight! ;)
Absolutely....and she did an outstanding job of it. I'm all in favor of her stage antics and presence, I'm the same way. I want that spotlight on me, and if that means stealing it from the lead singer....oh well sucks to be him, just means if he wants it back he's gonna have to outperform me. She seems to have the same mentality, and I can totally appreciate that.
Ale, your pronunciation is correct, not "alee" or "ally" as some pronounce it.
I'm ready from Spain. 😁
Alleh not Ale like the beer...
@@MaddogJones I don't know how it would be written in English but he pronounced it well.
@@p.gabrielguirao14 Perhaps it's easier to understand if you write "short for Alejandra" because even an American should know how to pronounce the beginning of *Alejandra* 😄
@@TheUnderdogDe 🤦♀️
@@TheUnderdogDe ouch! "Even an American"? I feel the bruising from that one.
They do "Atlas, Rise" live as well
I, for one, agree on the Gene Simmons moves. Unless you hate Kiss, I think that's a good thing. Thanks for giving another chance.
I love KISS for their showmanship and their commitment to putting on top-notch productions. So whenever I compare anyone's showmanship to KISS, that's honestly about the highest praise you'll ever hear from me. That's how much I respect Ale's showmanship.
Apparently Dany and Pau have encouraged her to do more moves, to make up for how they are mostly anchored to the mic and drums.
@@THEDavidHeretic David Ellefson from Mrgadeth helped Ale with her stage presence when the band received a "scholarship" at Berklee in Boston on the Ellen show. I believe Ale was age 10 or 11 at the time. She also was an acception because she was at younger age than the school usually accepts. This also prooves the mateurity beyond the years.
Just a point of interest WRT the views -- I've only watched the original (Lunario) of this song on YT maybe a dozen times, and this particular one (Whiskey) only once, but I've watched pretty much every reaction video of it. That will skew the numbers a bit.
NOOOOOO! Don't ever mention taking away Pau's drums!😳😉
I wish they had put a "featuring Rudy Joffroy" tag on the album and vids like artist collabs. It would have caused a bit less confusion.
Your scoring matters little to me. What you have to say matters more. We all have different tastes in music and a song I would score low, you might slap a 9 on. I like to know whether a reactor liked a song or not. I like it when a reactor can add bits of info or anecdotes as you do. I want reactors to like this band because I want them to do more, and to be honest, I want everyone to like this band. That is impossible of course, but one can dream.😁 In the end, I will respect any reactor whatever his opinion if he gives praise or criticism with respect. Thank you for giving my band another chance. This isn't the song or performance I would have chosen. You need to hear some of Dany's (the guitarist) beautiful solo work. She doesn't play overly complicated 5 note a second solos. She plays pretty melodic solos that always fit the song and are beautifully in the pocket. Thanks again and I hope for more.
Ohhhhh trust me there's like 12 requests in the que for them....so they will be back.
Pau would probably love to be in two (or more) places at once. I think she'll stick to the drums AND show off her voice in other places.
I'm crazy late to the show here, but man, I'm loving your reactions (at least TW and NW). Sucks that you had to plod through the trolls to get here, but glad you did !
Vince Neil reactions are back with The Warning baby!!! That dude singing towards the middle of the song is their manager Rudy. As you can tell he's not a great singer so I don't mind if you say it was awful. lo It sounds better on the recorded version. lol Anyway the lyrics are.....
Brother, salvation is something that is earned
Let your hand of resentment go and awaken a new light inside you
even if your brothers try and submerse you into darkness!
Ahhhhhhh so THAT'S what he's saying. I heard from several other he was playing the part of a preacher, but no one filled me in on what he was saying. Thanks for clearing that up.
Vince Neil???? Am I THAT fat???
@@THEDavidHeretic Nah man, it's not a weight thing. You do look like Vince Neil at around the mid 40s era. And yeah he did balloon up pretty nicely but that's not the version I meant. Lol
@@LaredoIsntSoBad I know I'm just messing with ya.
So this is what The Warning really is. I'm happy you came back to revisit them and hope you will continue on your journey. This was the first song from their second album Queen of the Murder Scene, which is their second album. This was a prologue to the concept album. Since you started with that song I would actually recommend you continue in order. I do want to highly recommend this video in which Ale does lead vocals but you also see her in full on Gene mode. th-cam.com/video/kdA9HatBPc8/w-d-xo.html
On another note you are not the first to say that Pau (Drummer) should take vocals and they get another drummer but I think one of the great things about this band is the fact its a 3 piece and they are sisters. Anyway great reaction and again thank you for giving them a chance again after a few idiots wanted to ruin the experience. This got me to subscribe.
Awesome welcome to The Fanbase, glad to have you among us.
Already have that song in the que, I added your name to the requester list.