I have attended PINAKA Fire Power Demonstration, it’s awesome, as a veteran I can tell you enemy shits in his pants when PINAKA fires. HIMARS may be better. Army needs equipment which can be easily repaired and maintained in field conditions and PINAKA is a very rugged system. Unlike HIMARS it is not required to be sent to some Air Conditioned workshop for repairs. In Army there is a saying that you require a weapon system which is soldier proof and not a delicate darling.
Kindly correct when you say that the indian pinaka export is not documented. The weapon system is one of the first few Indian military equipment to have been exported to Armenia.
Very cool . Perhaps, you want to keep it safe as China and Pakistan will then infiltrate Indian Defence and steal it. OK, Keep it safe but remember both Pakistan and China talk up the capabilities and varieties of their systems, so that they can scare the enemies.
Some inaccuracies on the HIMARS side, the range of GMLRS rockets is around 90+ km not 70, the new GMLRS ER rockets now have a range of 150 km and the PRSM missiles replacing the ATACMS have a longer range of 499 km. HIMARS also don't have a dedicated resupply vehicle, since they have a built in arm to enable quick reloading. These 2 platforms are not comparable and were designed for entirely different roles.
India has exported the Pinaka multi-barrel rocket launcher (MBRL) to Armenia, and has also received interest from other countries: Armenia: In July 2023, Armenia signed a deal for four Pinaka batteries and other defense equipment, including extended range and guided rockets. The deal was worth ₹2,000 crore, which is equivalent to US$254 million in 2023. Indonesia and Nigeria: These countries have shown interest in the Pinaka MBRL.
🕉 Satyameva Jayate: Truth and Honesty and Reality gets created when Good Thoughts, Good Deeds, Good Acts are allowed to achieve the small steps needed for the correct choices and correct decisions to be made. Satyameva Jayate
Quantity does not always brings you advantage. Quantities only have the advantages if you have abundance of supply and the battle field should always be near you border. There will be no quantities advantages when you enemy destroyed your supply line.
In terms of firepower volume M270 would be a much fair comparison to Pinaka. Technically HIMARS PINAKA, M270 all have the same design philosophy. That said an MLRS is only as good as the rockets it uses. Pinaka needs more varieties of rockets in its arsenal to take advantage of it's full capabilities.
*How can you compare HIMARS and Pinaka??* HIMARS is a precision, guided rocket whereas Pinaka is a saturation strike rocket launcher. Pinaka cannot fire one rocket to hit the target accurately. It just inundates the whole area with rockets hoping that at least one will hit the mark.
Wait pinnaka uses inertial navigation system it is not like that just stroke many and expect to hit one lol armchair genorol. As I said it uses ins it has successfully hit targets in Kargil war in mountains when it was just a prototype lol. It has been improved alot since then as Kargil was fought 25 years ago. Pinnaka came in service much later. Pinka cost way less than himars it's very cost effective Around 50k dollars the basic version of 40km range. It does have variant going upto 120km There is guided variant which is just missiles.
@@Shashank-g6iHIMARS rockets can change trajectory midway through to their target by satellite signal intelligence by some operator sitting in bunker. It’s a rocket version of drone.
Access denial for these systems would most likely mean the land borders. It would seem like a 100-120 km range should suffice keeping the launcher well inside their own territory. I thought the Pinaka was a SAM defense system.
Pinaka has range of only 40 km. And drdo working on pinaka mk 2 ,120 km pinaka rockets....whereas himars is more advanced than pinaka....but in long run pinka will achieve that height when mk3 & 4 launch
Ok lng Yan wag lang humintong maniwala at managinip hanging Buhay ka hahaha... sabihan mo ang presidente mo na pirmahan n nya wag nang isipin ang ma ebulsa ang bagal Kya bugok administration 😂😂😂
@@Mahan-Bharatiya I don't think Philippines should buy Pinakas as an Indian. Pinakas are developed for high altitude regions. The veru reason Armenia could not able to use it properly. While Himars are made for ground based attacks
@@plusultra7258another armchair. When did Armenia said or any one said Armenia is not able to use it properly. ? Just u said it lol Pinaka is made for mountains doesn't mean it can perform in plains how stupid one can be. So does it mean it won't work in rajasthan plain bordering pak. ??
Pinaka 4 shall be able to equal himars with longer range of atleast 200kms and lighter weight.Only pinaka 5 with atleast 300 kms will be able to overtake himars or Chinese or pakistan rockets
When you have a guidance system on a rocket, would it not become a missile? How are these rockets different from missiles? The ATACMS has a range higher than 290 kms and has guidance system then USA cannot sell these or gift these weapons based on the MTCR rules, they can only sell the GLRS rockets with HIMARS. In order to avoid these pitfalls they just call it a rocket instead of missiles don’t they? 😂😂😂
1. one is actually proven in combat as a very effective system, Russia hate them so much they use expensive supersonic and hypersonic missiles against them.
Lol smerch basic version hits at 120km while pinnaka began with 37.5km We openly asked for technology of smerch but they denied. So we had to make ours. What the hell this armchair genrols think of them to be to give such baseless statements 😂😂😂
@@powerrangerofchrist591 Tbh NATO is dependent on the US for military. If Trump wins, US will step out of NATO. Then we can see great European engineering which will be better than the US.
useless comparison. Its like comparison between Mercedes-Benz vs Maruti 800. Giant with baby..funny , Indian defence and technology are two decades behind the western world. Kind note: I personally like Indian defence forces , its my genuine opinion
So pinnaka at 90km ranged won't hit its target but himars will.. Wow bery grape. Lol Pinnaka has hit pakistan in 1999kargil war successfully. It is as accurate as any other rocket artillery system. Most important pinnka does t cost like LV It's cost effective. Himars is luis viton
@@Shashank-g6i what did it hit? very little people died in that war, himars has probably killed more people in urkrain than the Kargil war had on both sides.
It is not outdated lmao XD. Avg American who does not even knows what are both to begin with calling it outdated. Go and play fortnite bud. These ain't your thing
I have attended PINAKA Fire Power Demonstration, it’s awesome, as a veteran I can tell you enemy shits in his pants when PINAKA fires. HIMARS may be better. Army needs equipment which can be easily repaired and maintained in field conditions and PINAKA is a very rugged system. Unlike HIMARS it is not required to be sent to some Air Conditioned workshop for repairs. In Army there is a saying that you require a weapon system which is soldier proof and not a delicate darling.
Who says himars is better? American propaganda?
Pinaka is for mountain war, where enemy sit high ground, able to shoot low ground level,
Like in jammu kargil Himalayas....
Pinaka has been exported already
To where?
@@dkwalker6699Armenia
To the USA. Them Yankees put pictures of Stars and Stripes and a white topped Eagle on it and renamed it HIMARS .
Armenia @@dkwalker6699
Yes, and well received. Good interest being generated for Pinaka.
🕉 Satyameva Jayate 😊
Kindly correct when you say that the indian pinaka export is not documented.
The weapon system is one of the first few Indian military equipment to have been exported to Armenia.
I am sorry that you don't know much about Pinaka or your information is outdated. I know them, but won't tell you 😅
Very cool . Perhaps, you want to keep it safe as China and Pakistan will then infiltrate Indian Defence and steal it. OK, Keep it safe but remember both Pakistan and China talk up the capabilities and varieties of their systems, so that they can scare the enemies.
Don't tell Americans anything....not to be trusted. They just leaked israeli war plan to the iranians. Some friend they are!
Some inaccuracies on the HIMARS side, the range of GMLRS rockets is around 90+ km not 70, the new GMLRS ER rockets now have a range of 150 km and the PRSM missiles replacing the ATACMS have a longer range of 499 km. HIMARS also don't have a dedicated resupply vehicle, since they have a built in arm to enable quick reloading. These 2 platforms are not comparable and were designed for entirely different roles.
Very highly professional & Beautifully explained. Bravo!!!
India has exported the Pinaka multi-barrel rocket launcher (MBRL) to Armenia, and has also received interest from other countries:
Armenia: In July 2023, Armenia signed a deal for four Pinaka batteries and other defense equipment, including extended range and guided rockets. The deal was worth ₹2,000 crore, which is equivalent to US$254 million in 2023.
Indonesia and Nigeria: These countries have shown interest in the Pinaka MBRL.
Pinaka is best 👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍🍌
Factual Explanation Nice Bro
🕉 Satyameva Jayate: Truth and Honesty and Reality gets created when Good Thoughts, Good Deeds, Good Acts are allowed to achieve the small steps needed for the correct choices and correct decisions to be made. Satyameva Jayate
One which csn fire more ammunition and also in shorter time will.....quantity makes a huge difference in real battle
Quantity does not always brings you advantage. Quantities only have the advantages if you have abundance of supply and the battle field should always be near you border. There will be no quantities advantages when you enemy destroyed your supply line.
In terms of firepower volume M270 would be a much fair comparison to Pinaka. Technically HIMARS PINAKA, M270 all have the same design philosophy. That said an MLRS is only as good as the rockets it uses. Pinaka needs more varieties of rockets in its arsenal to take advantage of it's full capabilities.
You can't compare Apples and Oranges, Pinaka is MBRL don't fire guided missiles.
It does newer versions does
If conclusion given, uncle Sam will get angry..
And take Revenge
Unkle sam already sold a few hundred of them after the ukraine war showed their effectiveness.
🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🌎🌎🌎
I m so proud because I m pinaka also.
*How can you compare HIMARS and Pinaka??*
HIMARS is a precision, guided rocket whereas Pinaka is a saturation strike rocket launcher. Pinaka cannot fire one rocket to hit the target accurately. It just inundates the whole area with rockets hoping that at least one will hit the mark.
Wait pinnaka uses inertial navigation system it is not like that just stroke many and expect to hit one lol armchair genorol.
As I said it uses ins it has successfully hit targets in Kargil war in mountains when it was just a prototype lol.
It has been improved alot since then as Kargil was fought 25 years ago. Pinnaka came in service much later.
Pinka cost way less than himars it's very cost effective
Around 50k dollars the basic version of 40km range.
It does have variant going upto 120km
There is guided variant which is just missiles.
@@Shashank-g6iHIMARS rockets can change trajectory midway through to their target by satellite signal intelligence by some operator sitting in bunker. It’s a rocket version of drone.
Pinaka is for the vast area demolition
Both has its own Strengths and Weakness...No Comparison Please
Technically Himars Is More Advance But With Israil Help India Made Advancement In Rockets To Be Fired And This Worth
One works. The other looks awesome in parades.
No point comparing these two platform. They are designed for different roles
Access denial for these systems would most likely mean the land borders. It would seem like a 100-120 km range should suffice keeping the launcher well inside their own territory.
I thought the Pinaka was a SAM defense system.
That's akash
Explosion at Pinaka is just below the nuclear explosion
Pinaka has range of only 40 km. And drdo working on pinaka mk 2 ,120 km pinaka rockets....whereas himars is more advanced than pinaka....but in long run pinka will achieve that height when mk3 & 4 launch
Comparing Pinaka to Himars is like comparing the Tejas to the F35! But, cool... long way to go n loads to be done!
Which gobar Village you from Kid ?
You should have given your conclusions rather than 😢leave it for viewers
He concluded very well , there are plus and minus in both the systems. It depends on your requirement. One size fits all not possible in Military.
Pinaka 1 shot 12 rockets fire 🔥
I'm here after USA offered himars to India
Himars is good 🇵🇭 and proven in Ukraine war, hope my country the Philippines 🇵🇭 will buy it soon
Ok lng Yan wag lang humintong maniwala at managinip hanging Buhay ka hahaha... sabihan mo ang presidente mo na pirmahan n nya wag nang isipin ang ma ebulsa ang bagal Kya bugok administration 😂😂😂
Philippines is in talks with Bharat to purchase about 100 systems of Pinaka MBRL
@@Mahan-Bharatiyadue to its cost-effectiveness😊.
@@Mahan-Bharatiya I don't think Philippines should buy Pinakas as an Indian. Pinakas are developed for high altitude regions. The veru reason Armenia could not able to use it properly. While Himars are made for ground based attacks
@@plusultra7258another armchair.
When did Armenia said or any one said Armenia is not able to use it properly. ?
Just u said it lol
Pinaka is made for mountains doesn't mean it can perform in plains how stupid one can be.
So does it mean it won't work in rajasthan plain bordering pak.
??
Pinaka 4 shall be able to equal himars with longer range of atleast 200kms and lighter weight.Only pinaka 5 with atleast 300 kms will be able to overtake himars or Chinese or pakistan rockets
Himars will get PrSM that has up to 500KM range to replace older ATACMS missiles. the missile is also capable of hitting moving ships.
Don't compare pinaka now it is in developing phase in future he lead globally
both are developing weapons.
Himars better in your dreams only !
Usa hater spotted who never say American weapons are the best in the world 😂😂
When you have a guidance system on a rocket, would it not become a missile? How are these rockets different from missiles? The ATACMS has a range higher than 290 kms and has guidance system then USA cannot sell these or gift these weapons based on the MTCR rules, they can only sell the GLRS rockets with HIMARS. In order to avoid these pitfalls they just call it a rocket instead of missiles don’t they? 😂😂😂
You know the biggest difference -->
1. Our is way cheaper 👍🏻 than your overly priced system 🤣
1. one is actually proven in combat as a very effective system, Russia hate them so much they use expensive supersonic and hypersonic missiles against them.
Pinaka is a derivative of Russian Smerch MBRL in short lacks accuracy and rely on saturation attack.
A better comparison would probably be the Russian Uragan MBRL, Smerch are far heavier with bigger and longer range rockets
Lol smerch basic version hits at 120km while pinnaka began with 37.5km
We openly asked for technology of smerch but they denied. So we had to make ours.
What the hell this armchair genrols think of them to be to give such baseless statements 😂😂😂
For bhakts pinaak wins 😂😂😂😂
Pappu Bhakts Lost Election on a Hattrick...😂 still Behind Pappu...☝️🤪
For agye cool ban ne 😂lol you are cool bruh bhakt bol diya 😂😂😂baw
Pappu hijda hai
Ye Haryana ka Chdu lagta hai .
No point to point comparison in video
In short HIMARS is doomed in front of PINAKA
Lol do you know the capability of Himars !!! It’s Top class & battle proven weapon with high demand from Best western & NATO countries !!!
@@powerrangerofchrist591 Tbh NATO is dependent on the US for military. If Trump wins, US will step out of NATO. Then we can see great European engineering which will be better than the US.
@@powerrangerofchrist591 Do you know about capability of Pinaka? Well, India just kept on marching forward, while VCryKnee is advancing towards Keyv
I hate AI voice.
😂😂
???
🤣😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣
useless comparison. Its like comparison between Mercedes-Benz vs Maruti 800. Giant with baby..funny , Indian defence and technology are two decades behind the western world. Kind note: I personally like Indian defence forces , its my genuine opinion
So pinnaka at 90km ranged won't hit its target but himars will..
Wow bery grape.
Lol
Pinnaka has hit pakistan in 1999kargil war successfully. It is as accurate as any other rocket artillery system.
Most important pinnka does t cost like LV
It's cost effective.
Himars is luis viton
@@Shashank-g6i what did it hit? very little people died in that war, himars has probably killed more people in urkrain than the Kargil war had on both sides.
Pinaka is outdated
It is not outdated lmao XD. Avg American who does not even knows what are both to begin with calling it outdated. Go and play fortnite bud. These ain't your thing
I think there is no comparison. Himars is a PRECISION weapon and has very long range. Pinaka is an outdated model with the indian army
Weapons are modified time to time" Mr GENIUS "
Lol what 🤣🤣🤣 another armchair genrol.
It came just 1 and half decade ago
Performed well in Kargil war even in its prototype stage lol.
Cope harder 😂😂
Don't compere 🐅 with 🐮
you chines go and check the power of pinaka and dont compare tiger 🐅🐯 with panda🐼