luhan's voice at the end, so heart whelming :') i wished lay participated in the chinese version too though...his voice really suits these type of soothing songs, but nether the less it's still perfect the way it is
Miracles do happen. Kris, LuHan, Tao got together on same stage, sang songs, mentored the competitors, took photos and posted on socials. EXO OT9 in eyes EXO OT12 in heart forever. EXO weareone forever.
They are so talented. Their vocals are amazing. But glad to see that Lu, Tao N Kris have collaboration recently this year. And Lu even went to help up Kris in his recent game show th-cam.com/video/DuXAu8Cla5A/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/5un2AaQYDk8/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/i1Sa3GHZZUg/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/s8nuGLvO38o/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/rCqUsAsmlz4/w-d-xo.html
They are so talented. Their vocals are amazing. But glad to see that Lu, Tao N Kris have collaboration recently this year. And Lu even went to help up Kris in his recent game show th-cam.com/video/DuXAu8Cla5A/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/5un2AaQYDk8/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/i1Sa3GHZZUg/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/s8nuGLvO38o/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/rCqUsAsmlz4/w-d-xo.html
@@Ctlyya They are so talented. Their vocals are amazing. But glad to see that Lu, Tao N Kris have collaboration recently this year. And Lu even went to help up Kris in his recent game show th-cam.com/video/DuXAu8Cla5A/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/5un2AaQYDk8/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/i1Sa3GHZZUg/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/s8nuGLvO38o/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/rCqUsAsmlz4/w-d-xo.html
Me too. I wish they can go back to ot12. I really love them together and how they laughed together, and cried together. But they grew and 3 left, all of them are more professional now too.
Luhan said his emotions when sing these songs are come naturally and then i wondered who luhan was thinking of when sang ballad songs? because he put his sad emotions so well TT_TT
maddiefailsatlife He is really special isn't he? *sigh* He left EXO-L's hearts scattered and broken, but of course we forgive him. Who can stay angry when looking at his angelic face? Listening to his beautiful voice?
Luhan's voice is just really beautiful in this song. It's soft and calming. It would have been nice if Lay could sing too. Funny how kris was drawing tho. haha
Can’t believe it’s 12-01-2020. I’m still waiting for miracles. Hope one day you guys come back as ONE. Maybe not comeback at the name EXO but I hope I can see you guys come back as a FAMILY. ♥️
Miracles finally happened Kris and Tao finally stood on the same stage and have a warm hug during the countdown concert in China...... when i watched that video....the feels hit hard and Tao followed Kris in instagram and Weibo so did Kris, Tao even followed Luhan in Weibo((Tao usually dont follow anyone in weibo))......... ot12 forever
It hurts me everytime i watch exo showtime. I just miss them so much 😢 and the facts that mnet blur their face in growl mv just make my heart aches so much 😢
Got to say that sm is a genius to making sure their talent correctly. Chen's, Baekhyun's and Luhan's voice sounded amazing in chinese, I think that's why they decided to place Chen in exo-m.
1-MAMA 86 m 2-Power 84m 3-History 84m 4-Lucky one 70m 5-Miracles in December 52m 6-Universe 44m 7-Sing for you 38m 8-What is love 36m 9-For life 27m 10-Electric kiss 26m 11-Coming over 8m 12- Dancing king 55 m 13- Light saber 20 m
i dont know why when i heard chinese ver i more emotional, its make me wanna cry but every time it came to kris drawing part i laugh coz it remind at me about his animal drawing,, hahaha
Really beautiful song, both versions.. D.O's voice in the Korean one did me in, and Luhan's voice did me in even more... I watched the Korean version before this one, and I was still tearing up/crying coming into this one... The touch of Xiumin's and Tao's powers was lovely, perfect for the MV... SM, you guys really want to kill us with feels, yeah?... I don't want to see our lovely little panda crying any more...
Actually I love the Chinese version more than the Korean version, for me the Chinese lyrics are meaningful. It is the best Chinese version song of EXO that I have ever heard!
Me too. still loving it They are so talented. Their vocals are amazing. But glad to see that Lu, Tao N Kris have collaboration recently this year. And Lu even went to help up Kris in his recent game show th-cam.com/video/DuXAu8Cla5A/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/5un2AaQYDk8/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/i1Sa3GHZZUg/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/s8nuGLvO38o/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/rCqUsAsmlz4/w-d-xo.html
So in english, the first part of the song says: "I am searching for the one I cant see anymore I am listening to the one I cant hear anymore" perfectly describes what I feel after seeing Kris, Luhan and Tao in the video 🙂☹😭
They are so talented. Their vocals are amazing. But glad to see that Lu, Tao N Kris have collaboration recently this year. And Lu even went to help up Kris in his recent game show th-cam.com/video/DuXAu8Cla5A/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/5un2AaQYDk8/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/i1Sa3GHZZUg/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/s8nuGLvO38o/w-d-xo.html th-cam.com/video/rCqUsAsmlz4/w-d-xo.html
was it only me or just that baekhyun still sounds korean while singing. .anyhow i dont know why but i think im loving this version over the other. luhans voice is so soft that suites the part he was to sing.well not saying luhan is better than D.O or vice versa (D.O. is my bias xD) makes good blend with the others. baekhyun, no question on his vocals. he knows how to play with his voice. he has a powerful voice yet he was able to showcase a different angle here. he sounds very relaxing that really melts my feels. and finally chen, omy goodness you are awesome. his voice completes the menu and it totallly gave me an eargasm.he can hit high notes as simple as eating an apple. its perfect to blend with baeki and luhan. plus the acting of other member really i dont know what to say T_T. TAO can already win on oscars with the most genuine expression. overall THIS IS FANTASTIC, AWESOME, PERFECT that makes everyone listening to it fell what you really guys are trying to say to us. saranghaeyo EXO. :))))
im a chinese so i know the difference xd baekhyun definitely sounds korean while singing:p i wonder whether he understood what he was singing haha but anyways i really like his voice so the pronunciation thing doesnt really matter. but one thing is that in the MAMA's album, chen (and xiumin) is actually the one who sounded korean-ish in exo-m but he sounds pretty like a local chinese in this song so i guess he had put in a lot of effort in studying chinese and i really appreciate that... really hope that more and more members can learn chinese and sing the songs flawlessly in the future:p (of course its still perfect for now xd) this is such a great song and the lyrics are well translated (and even better than the korean ver. in my opinion xd)... as the previous chinese lyrics are quite awkward due to the translation, sm has done a really good job in composing this wonderful song. support exo forever♥
wow thats good to know that you noticed that too.anyhow i cant speak korean nor chinese hehe. i dont mean it in a negative way though( that baekhyun stil sounds like korean). its just based on my hearing abilities??xD . you are definitely right, i admire them trying their best to learn many language so that they could express better and reach to their fans around the world. i know someday they will be greater and will be the best . so friend lets keep supporting EXO, we love them and we cant let them down. right? :)
Ever since I saw this MV, I thought D.O. had outstanding acting skills and now he has so many prizes with acting. This version sounds great very much but I come here to see Kyungsoo acting. This is the magic of EXO. A same song, multiple versions and they slay in every single ones. I have, am, and keep loving EXO for my life.
Luhan's voice sounds different in Chinese than in Korean. Him singing in his native language makes him seem a whole lot more confident. And there's just something so elegant about Chinese. Really. It's amazing.
I wish Tao could turn back time to times when Exo had 12 members... I'm waiting for this "miracle" in next December... Even tho I know they have their solo creeres now and they doing great, still it hurts my heart...
u need to go check views on chinese video sites not youtube, pretty sure its over double the amount of view exo k has on chinese video sites. youtube is banned in china, so....
iya, kalo masih di exo dia bakalan terkenal bgt scara internasional.. dan dulu juga sm lbih bnyak nonjolin dia sbg ikon grup dri pd kai, krna bnyak fansnya
Bener bgt ini, gua dulu awal² EXO debut sukanya sama Luhan karna menurut gua perfect bgt dia, pas dia keluar dr EXO sakit ati bgt gua, sampe skrg masih ngebayangin seandainya EXO masih ot12 😢
Yes if he stay in exo he so famous many fan became exol because of luhan but as a fan I am so happy that he will doing great in china he is also famous there and thank you to all the fans who still supporting him even he is not in exo anymore I will support you luhan no matter what happen thank you for always making me happy😊😊😊😊😊
I was shaking so much, my breathing became ragged and I was this close at crying. I swear, this is one of the most beautiful songs I have ever heard...
If only Lay was singing too :/ because his voice would be awesome in this song (there's just something about his voice that makes you feel at peace and just want to listen), but Chen's Chinese is definitely improving a lot and of course you can hear the mispronunciations, but come on Chinese is said to be the hardest language to learn, so I am really pleased especially since I can actually understand what he is singing unlike in some previous songs where he wasn't so clear. Baekhyun's Chinese impressed me too especially at "每一朵都是你的泪滴". The lyrics to this song are so meaningful and amazing already, add on the crisp clean vocals and you have got yourself a song chockfull of emotion. EXO has done it once again. December 9th needs to come faster. :]
Am I the only one who went "Oh look they're using superpowers! " when Xiumin made it snow, and loved how cool Tao looked when he made time turn back? Anyway would have loved a version of this sing with Lay as a part of it ...
Imagine if SM Entertainment just treated them better we could've songs like this every december and they could've stayed as our OT12. I miss them so much.😔
Jongdae's voice is really something else. Just wow, no wonder everyone was captivated by him back in 2013 and korea even trended "guy in the middle" :D
The only way I can make sure I don't cry watching this is thinking of Luhan's answer when asked what the concept of this video was. He said he was going to meet his girlfriend and then realized he didn't have one.
Coming back here makes me in tears. All the struggles and pains we encountered with them i feel it again. From a naive and young exol to now, EXO makes me mature. It's been 9yrs with them and still counting. FIGHTING EXO! I'LL NEVER LEAVE YOU 🤧💖 Thank you so much for a joyful, pains and best memories with you since 9yrs ago.
Maybe it's the song and MV doing funny things to my feels but… Kris painting, D.O cooking, Baekhyun's flawless fingers playing the piano, Kai and a puppy, flower boy Sehun, Lay composing, Suho and "To my angel", Xiumin and winter, Tao and time, Chanyeol's ring … I think most fans would know the significance of all these. These small details make it all the more special for me.
I wish this version got as many views as the Korean one. Sadly, SM puts more focus on the Korea version, which is understandable, but this video deserves more views!
Don't worry. This Chinese version has already got A TON more views on Youku, etc. It's just they can't play TH-cam in China, that's why the views are always less, but in general, the Chinese MVs are actually watched by a lot more people.
Angel Lee Can you tell me please why TH-cam is not acess in China !!! they have freedom right !! i don't know much about other countries !!! i hate watching news ,it make me sad :p and thank you
Sana Amami China sensors their internet. Facebook and TH-cam can't be accessed in China, so they have their own websites like Weibo (sort of like fb/twitter), Yueyentai( like youtube) etc..
It's heartbreaking listening to this song and looking at the MV. I miss Luhan, Kris, and Tao. I miss OT12. Rather, let's just say that I miss the memories from back then, when Exo just debut, joining Exo Showtime, etc. You guys might disagree with me, but I felt like either I changed or Exo changed. I just don't feel like Exo is the same anymore (not just because Luhan, Kris, and Tao left), but because back then Exo was really happy even though they weren't as popular as they are now. Now, Exo is super popular and I'm proud of them. But I felt like Exo is no longer as carefree and happy as back then. They're more mature and solemn. Time has taken away their smiles. Maybe it's just me, stuck in the past with the memories. I will continue to support Exo. I'm proud of where they are at now. But rather then them having fame, I rather they have happiness and are healthy instead. Despite so, good luck to Exo and to Luhan, Kris, and Tao! I love you guys and I will continue supporting you all.
Exactly the same feelings as you, I has always think like that and I always ask myself if I change or EXO... They don't smile so often now and also our happy virus aren't smiling for no reason now... I just really miss the time when 12 people will imitate each other and always smiling for a not funny joke .Seeing the 12 smile is really the most happy thing for me...
Same!😭😭 Back then, they had those sincere smiles and laughs, and they always had a lot of fun altogether But then time passed by, they had to put on fake smiles, their laughs are so different to the ones that actually made you laugh because of their laugh........They still have fun, but I mostly see their sadness that they try so hard to hide!😢
Same!😭😭 Back then, they had those sincere smiles and laughs, and they always had a lot of fun altogether But then time passed by, they had to put on fake smiles, their laughs are so different to the ones that actually made you laugh because of their laugh........They still have fun, but I mostly see their sadness that they try so hard to hide!😢
Baekhyun and Chen are the best vocalists but I think D.O and Luhan stand out in each version because their tones are really appealing to the ear. Luhan's soft tone in particular provides a very nice contrast in the song.
As a native Korean speaker myself, I couldn't understand how other people mentioned the song made them cry even though they didn't understand Korean, but I think I can understand what that means because this Chinese version makes me emotional even though I don't understand Chinese.
This is one of the most beautiful MV in SM's history (personal) EXO made me love the beautiful mandarin and when both EXO-M and EXO-K sing together as one (In the Korean ver. as well) it's like they're melting my heart. I love how they still have their symbols. Tao's time control was great! I loved that SM made the MV with their powers in it. Every single second is beautiful! I'll love this MV (korean ver. as well) forever and ever. Thank you!! Fighting EXO!! Great acting!
me to when i heard this song for the first time 3 years ago it gave me a nice memory of exo ot12,but now only 9 left. really miss their all exo member please make a concert unite all of the members and exo ex-member in one stage.
This song make me sad evreytime when i listen to, such a powerful emotional song. I like chinese ver, it more meaningful then korean ver. always come back to this song, and realise it such a long time since back then
EXO's new music video '十二月的奇迹(Miracles in December)
lovely
I love this song.Everyone the best actor.So sad song
luhan voice
SM WHY WHY
OMFG THIS IS SO AMAZING
The song makes me moved! Even though I don't understand what it says!
9 in our eyes
12 in our hearts
#ot12 #luhan #tao #kris #WeAreOne #exom #exok #exol
LISTEN TO EXO Monster 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Mr V it's okay I got ur back😭💓
LISTEN TO EXO Monster 💛💜💙💚💖
LISTEN TO EXO Monster we are one!!! let's love 💪
8 in our eyes
9 in our minds
12 in our hearts
luhan's voice at the end, so heart whelming :') i wished lay participated in the chinese version too though...his voice really suits these type of soothing songs, but nether the less it's still perfect the way it is
Miracles do happen.
Kris, LuHan, Tao got together on same stage, sang songs, mentored the competitors, took photos and posted on socials.
EXO OT9 in eyes EXO OT12 in heart forever.
EXO weareone forever.
They are so talented. Their vocals are amazing.
But glad to see that Lu, Tao N Kris have collaboration recently this year. And Lu even went to help up Kris in his recent game show
th-cam.com/video/DuXAu8Cla5A/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/5un2AaQYDk8/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/i1Sa3GHZZUg/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/s8nuGLvO38o/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/rCqUsAsmlz4/w-d-xo.html
Everytime I see Tao turn back time I wish he could do it again
+Nath Jaymes “NJayy” me too T_T.. I miss him..
This literally just broke my heart. Omf.
+YGGO DumbaZZ Yes. No more words.
+YGGO DumbaZZ :( same here.
I know right and when he does we should make sure Luhan kris and Tao stays in exo and never leaves
Love my lulu's voice. People need to understand that he can sing okay? He's not just looks
Luhan's voice is killing me. I can't understand the song but I can feel it. His voice is full of emotions and it is so soft. Luhan daebak!
LUHAN has this charisma you can never ignore. I miss him badly in EXO. 💔😭
Me too.. 😭💔 i still can't believe that luhan out from exo
They are so talented. Their vocals are amazing.
But glad to see that Lu, Tao N Kris have collaboration recently this year. And Lu even went to help up Kris in his recent game show
th-cam.com/video/DuXAu8Cla5A/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/5un2AaQYDk8/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/i1Sa3GHZZUg/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/s8nuGLvO38o/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/rCqUsAsmlz4/w-d-xo.html
@@Ctlyya They are so talented. Their vocals are amazing.
But glad to see that Lu, Tao N Kris have collaboration recently this year. And Lu even went to help up Kris in his recent game show
th-cam.com/video/DuXAu8Cla5A/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/5un2AaQYDk8/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/i1Sa3GHZZUg/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/s8nuGLvO38o/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/rCqUsAsmlz4/w-d-xo.html
Same here
Same :(
It hit me with a wave of feels when Tao lifted his finger up and turned back time ;_; I wish I could turn back time to ot12
exactly!
Me too. I wish they can go back to ot12. I really love them together and how they laughed together, and cried together. But they grew and 3 left, all of them are more professional now too.
me too😔😔😔😔
OMG SAME:((((((((((( like a mini heart attack
I cried. Everything is just too much. Please tao, just turn back the time. Because im literally living in th past
There will always be 12 in my heart.
+1
same :'(
+1 😔😔😔😢😢😢😢
same 😢😢😢
can someone explain to me why there isn't 12 anymore? What happened to everyone and how many is in the group right now?
Luhan said his emotions when sing these songs are come naturally and then i wondered who luhan was thinking of when sang ballad songs? because he put his sad emotions so well TT_TT
Chanyeol,Baekhyun,Suho,Kris,Sehun
Xiumin,Chen,Kai,Do,Lay,Tao,Luhan are exol,s life
OT12 Forever
Baek and Chen have more power when they sing, but Luhan's voice just does something to me. I'm seriously sobbing because of the end of this
Luhan's eyes killed me.
maddiefailsatlife He is really special isn't he? *sigh* He left EXO-L's hearts scattered and broken, but of course we forgive him. Who can stay angry when looking at his angelic face? Listening to his beautiful voice?
+Sushi Lover 👍
he's my bias
maddiefailsatlife
when I listen to this song, I cry because Kristen,luhan and now Tao please EXO stay strong ily all..
+BupBupBapBap y es 😂😂
ปลื้มปริ่มน้ำตาคลอเบ้า นาฬิกาของSM ตรงซะที♥♥
Hit like, if u are listening to this song in December 2020
It’s a December classic!
9 Dec 2020 here
@@Talbion yess
@@xiaoli_jiang I listen this song, evey December
It's december 16, 2020...
And i'm surely miss this moment...
This great masterpiece will give warmth in this winter...
something about the chinese language that sounds so beautiful in songs. i love when luhan sings in his native language its amazing
Luhan's voice is just really beautiful in this song. It's soft and calming. It would have been nice if Lay could sing too. Funny how kris was drawing tho. haha
Remember in EXO showtime, when Luhan was correcting Chen and Baekhyun's Chinese pronouncation?
Well. It's never gonna be the same again.
Anna Pal //goes to sit in a corner and rocks back and forth...
Cindy Li *cries Han river*
Anna Pal It was adorbs :( Miss him and Kris so much ;-;
Gonna start sobbing while hugging a pillow*
Anna Pal just shut up T_T
Can’t believe it’s 12-01-2020. I’m still waiting for miracles. Hope one day you guys come back as ONE. Maybe not comeback at the name EXO but I hope I can see you guys come back as a FAMILY. ♥️
this is 07-2023 and I still wait for the miracles too :')
💔
Miracles finally happened
Kris and Tao finally stood on the same stage and have a warm hug during the countdown concert in China......
when i watched that video....the feels hit hard
and Tao followed Kris in instagram and Weibo so did Kris, Tao even followed Luhan in Weibo((Tao usually dont follow anyone in weibo)).........
ot12 forever
Where can i find that video?
Another fact,that luhan still has all member in instagram.
Mania Kaviani except for suho
@@kroong7105 maybe because he has his account for a short time...
I mean other members have their acc for a longer time i guess!!
another miracle. Kris and Luhan has made a song together. it's called Coffee
My heart hurts now .
They may be 9 in our eyes
But 12 in our hearts.
But I'll cry more .
I think this song completely destroyed every single one of the criticisms out there saying that EXO is just dance moves and nothing else.
It hurts me everytime i watch exo showtime. I just miss them so much 😢 and the facts that mnet blur their face in growl mv just make my heart aches so much 😢
Maybe it's just me, but Kai with the puppy is the cutest thing in the world!!! He looks so adorable and innocent playing with the little dog!
It's not just you >^< I completely spazzed when I saw him with the puppy~
Oh thank god it's not just me >.< He's just ugh omg kai no stahp you cant be this cute
I know, right!?! And I love dogs and Kai loving dogs just makes me adore him even more XD
Got to say that sm is a genius to making sure their talent correctly. Chen's, Baekhyun's and Luhan's voice sounded amazing in chinese, I think that's why they decided to place Chen in exo-m.
Baek's chinese is soooooo good... I only speak a little bit of chinese but if I didn't know this was baek I would have though that he was chinese! :D
1-MAMA 86 m
2-Power 84m
3-History 84m
4-Lucky one 70m
5-Miracles in December 52m
6-Universe 44m
7-Sing for you 38m
8-What is love 36m
9-For life 27m
10-Electric kiss 26m
11-Coming over 8m
12- Dancing king 55 m
13- Light saber 20 m
If this doesnt make you cry then i dont know what will.
i dont know why when i heard chinese ver i more emotional, its make me wanna cry but every time it came to kris drawing part i laugh coz it remind at me about his animal drawing,, hahaha
Really beautiful song, both versions.. D.O's voice in the Korean one did me in, and Luhan's voice did me in even more... I watched the Korean version before this one, and I was still tearing up/crying coming into this one... The touch of Xiumin's and Tao's powers was lovely, perfect for the MV... SM, you guys really want to kill us with feels, yeah?... I don't want to see our lovely little panda crying any more...
I miss Luhan's sweet voice, Tao's rap and Kris' appearance I EXO
So sad....i can't believe this is the Miracle In December. It show their inner side.
Sees Xiumin touch his frost pendant and makes it snow
Imagines Chanyeol running like a maniac in front of him, burning the whole place down.
Lmfao!
Alice Duan lol! can imagine it tho!
Alice Duan Haha jeez
Alice Duan Your comment made me laugh so hard hahah that's so Chanyeol! xD
+Alice Duan I was crying after watching this but your comment made me laugh.
Actually I love the Chinese version more than the Korean version, for me the Chinese lyrics are meaningful. It is the best Chinese version song of EXO that I have ever heard!
Ture
Me too. still loving it
They are so talented. Their vocals are amazing.
But glad to see that Lu, Tao N Kris have collaboration recently this year. And Lu even went to help up Kris in his recent game show
th-cam.com/video/DuXAu8Cla5A/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/5un2AaQYDk8/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/i1Sa3GHZZUg/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/s8nuGLvO38o/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/rCqUsAsmlz4/w-d-xo.html
So in english, the first part of the song says:
"I am searching for the one I cant see anymore
I am listening to the one I cant hear anymore"
perfectly describes what I feel after seeing Kris, Luhan and Tao in the video 🙂☹😭
Girl I- *quietly sobbed on the corner of my room*
They are so talented. Their vocals are amazing.
But glad to see that Lu, Tao N Kris have collaboration recently this year. And Lu even went to help up Kris in his recent game show
th-cam.com/video/DuXAu8Cla5A/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/5un2AaQYDk8/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/i1Sa3GHZZUg/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/s8nuGLvO38o/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/rCqUsAsmlz4/w-d-xo.html
CRY UGLY* 😭
Why do you have to make me cry like that?😢🥺😭
Chen has such a beautiful voice!
was it only me or just that baekhyun still sounds korean while singing. .anyhow i dont know why but i think im loving this version over the other. luhans voice is so soft that suites the part he was to sing.well not saying luhan is better than D.O or vice versa (D.O. is my bias xD) makes good blend with the others. baekhyun, no question on his vocals. he knows how to play with his voice. he has a powerful voice yet he was able to showcase a different angle here. he sounds very relaxing that really melts my feels. and finally chen, omy goodness you are awesome. his voice completes the menu and it totallly gave me an eargasm.he can hit high notes as simple as eating an apple. its perfect to blend with baeki and luhan. plus the acting of other member really i dont know what to say T_T. TAO can already win on oscars with the most genuine expression. overall THIS IS FANTASTIC, AWESOME, PERFECT that makes everyone listening to it fell what you really guys are trying to say to us. saranghaeyo EXO. :))))
im a chinese so i know the difference xd baekhyun definitely sounds korean while singing:p i wonder whether he understood what he was singing haha but anyways i really like his voice so the pronunciation thing doesnt really matter. but one thing is that in the MAMA's album, chen (and xiumin) is actually the one who sounded korean-ish in exo-m but he sounds pretty like a local chinese in this song so i guess he had put in a lot of effort in studying chinese and i really appreciate that... really hope that more and more members can learn chinese and sing the songs flawlessly in the future:p (of course its still perfect for now xd) this is such a great song and the lyrics are well translated (and even better than the korean ver. in my opinion xd)... as the previous chinese lyrics are quite awkward due to the translation, sm has done a really good job in composing this wonderful song. support exo forever♥
wow thats good to know that you noticed that too.anyhow i cant speak korean nor chinese hehe. i dont mean it in a negative way though( that baekhyun stil sounds like korean). its just based on my hearing abilities??xD . you are definitely right, i admire them trying their best to learn many language so that they could express better and reach to their fans around the world. i know someday they will be greater and will be the best . so friend lets keep supporting EXO, we love them and we cant let them down. right? :)
@@mrasphalt1000 ,
3:36 *tao shoots his ring like a badass*
It's EXO, It's always EXO.
I'm impressed. By SM's standards this MV is actually REALLY well done. They weren't trapped in boxes the whole time! They went outside!
i'm still crying with this song T-T
6 in our eyes
9 in our minds
12 in our hearts ♥
Stream DFTF, MAMA and other older MV guys
I would have loved to hear Lay as well.
Ever since I saw this MV, I thought D.O. had outstanding acting skills and now he has so many prizes with acting.
This version sounds great very much but I come here to see Kyungsoo acting.
This is the magic of EXO.
A same song, multiple versions and they slay in every single ones.
I have, am, and keep loving EXO for my life.
Luhan's voice sounds different in Chinese than in Korean. Him singing in his native language makes him seem a whole lot more confident. And there's just something so elegant about Chinese. Really. It's amazing.
can only agree^_^
FINALLY! SOMEONE AGREES WITH ME!!!!!!
OMG IKR :')
I really wish I could like this more than once.
I wish Tao could turn back time to times when Exo had 12 members... I'm waiting for this "miracle" in next December... Even tho I know they have their solo creeres now and they doing great, still it hurts my heart...
Lu Lu I miss you. I miss your voice in the voice of boys
it's so soft, so gentle..
holding back the tears is impossible...
I will forever love these boys... forever, and ever, and ever...
i hate how EXO-M has not even half the amount of views than EXO-K when they are both equally talented... :(
u need to go check views on chinese video sites not youtube, pretty sure its over double the amount of view exo k has on chinese video sites. youtube is banned in china, so....
EXO-M actually has more fans than EXO-K, just because of China's population. XD
That's why they won Asia Most Popular Boyband or something. C:
Check baidu it has a lot of views
shirley sk do you know how many views?
Chinese can't go to TH-cam.
Luhan's voice! so emotional!
luhan kalo masih stay di sm bakalan jd anak emasnya sm sih, main vocal, center, visual, dancer, dan dulu fansnya termasuk yg terbesar jg di exo.
iya, kalo masih di exo dia bakalan terkenal bgt scara internasional.. dan dulu juga sm lbih bnyak nonjolin dia sbg ikon grup dri pd kai, krna bnyak fansnya
Bener bgt ini, gua dulu awal² EXO debut sukanya sama Luhan karna menurut gua perfect bgt dia, pas dia keluar dr EXO sakit ati bgt gua, sampe skrg masih ngebayangin seandainya EXO masih ot12 😢
Yes if he stay in exo he so famous many fan became exol because of luhan but as a fan I am so happy that he will doing great in china he is also famous there and thank you to all the fans who still supporting him even he is not in exo anymore I will support you luhan no matter what happen thank you for always making me happy😊😊😊😊😊
I was shaking so much, my breathing became ragged and I was this close at crying. I swear, this is one of the most beautiful songs I have ever heard...
im crying again... if miracles do exist, please go back to ot12
😭 ikr
nadia begum Q^Q
+Erin Hao they like it better on their own. they're happier. leave them be.
exactly, luhan, kris and tao are better now and exo is still making great music.
Erin Hao the biggest dream of mine😞
If only Lay was singing too :/ because his voice would be awesome in this song (there's just something about his voice that makes you feel at peace and just want to listen), but Chen's Chinese is definitely improving a lot and of course you can hear the mispronunciations, but come on Chinese is said to be the hardest language to learn, so I am really pleased especially since I can actually understand what he is singing unlike in some previous songs where he wasn't so clear. Baekhyun's Chinese impressed me too especially at "每一朵都是你的泪滴". The lyrics to this song are so meaningful and amazing already, add on the crisp clean vocals and you have got yourself a song chockfull of emotion. EXO has done it once again. December 9th needs to come faster. :]
每年都會回來 特別是12月...😩😢
Am I the only one who went "Oh look they're using superpowers! " when Xiumin made it snow, and loved how cool Tao looked when he made time turn back?
Anyway would have loved a version of this sing with Lay as a part of it ...
ทำไมทุกคนเสียงดีกันงี้อ่ะ
เสียงลู่โคตรหวานเลย
ปริ่ม EXO = คุณภาพ
Baekhyun and Chen are very nice to sing in Chinese....
I'm going down memory lane once again. I miss OT12
omg i was totally standing outside in the snowstorm singing this song while waiting for my teacher to pick me up this morning!!
Great context :) !
'' ♥ " หัวใจ"ดวงนี้ของฉันไม่สามารถรักใครได้อีกแล้ว นอกจาก " EXO "
ไม่ว่าพวกคุณ(EXO)จะ สุข หรือ ทุกข์ แค่ไหนก็ตาม
ฉันคนนี้พร้อมที่จะอยู่ข้างๆพวกคุณเสมอนะคะ ♥:'(
Imagine if SM Entertainment just treated them better we could've songs like this every december and they could've stayed as our OT12. I miss them so much.😔
This.Hurts.Every.Time.
😭💔😔
:
:*)
:"
Jongdae's voice is really something else. Just wow, no wonder everyone was captivated by him back in 2013 and korea even trended "guy in the middle" :D
I will love to see luhan, lay and Xiumin in this mv!
The only way I can make sure I don't cry watching this is thinking of Luhan's answer when asked what the concept of this video was. He said he was going to meet his girlfriend and then realized he didn't have one.
Chen's vocals in this * sheds a tear *
Coming back here makes me in tears. All the struggles and pains we encountered with them i feel it again. From a naive and young exol to now, EXO makes me mature. It's been 9yrs with them and still counting.
FIGHTING EXO! I'LL NEVER LEAVE YOU 🤧💖 Thank you so much for a joyful, pains and best memories with you since 9yrs ago.
Maybe it's the song and MV doing funny things to my feels but… Kris painting, D.O cooking, Baekhyun's flawless fingers playing the piano, Kai and a puppy, flower boy Sehun, Lay composing, Suho and "To my angel", Xiumin and winter, Tao and time, Chanyeol's ring … I think most fans would know the significance of all these. These small details make it all the more special for me.
right!! and also tao using his "time control" power!!!!!!
and nature republic product placement XD
KyuhyunDonghae Lol. That too.
This song is heavenly ~
Knowing that I will never meet them in reality, really breaks my heart ;A;
ChenBaekLu voice is sooo amazing!♥
best song in the world
The views should be more!
For me, This song is getting more and more powerful cuz of Chen, both versions.
I'm crying 😭😭😭
I miss LuHan, Tao and Kris so much
😢
me toooo
me too 😭😭😭
me too😭😭😭😭😭😭
me too😢😢😢😢😭😭😭😭
*EXO OT12 will always be my sweetest tragedy*
I'm learning Korean and it's more familiar to me but I love Exo's songs in Chinese better. They sound so much softer :)
Yes this was what i mean
I wish this version got as many views as the Korean one. Sadly, SM puts more focus on the Korea version, which is understandable, but this video deserves more views!
Don't worry. This Chinese version has already got A TON more views on Youku, etc. It's just they can't play TH-cam in China, that's why the views are always less, but in general, the Chinese MVs are actually watched by a lot more people.
Angel Lee its true. in China people uses different sites to watch their videos. TH-cam is blocked in China....
Angel Lee
Can you tell me please why TH-cam is not acess in China !!! they have freedom right !! i don't know much about other countries !!! i hate watching news ,it make me sad :p and thank you
Sana Amami China sensors their internet. Facebook and TH-cam can't be accessed in China, so they have their own websites like Weibo (sort of like fb/twitter), Yueyentai( like youtube) etc..
Angel Lee Thanks! :) I knew they had like other sites, but I didn't know if they were popular there or not.
I couldn't take Kris and his Canvas seriously xD
EXO OT12 FOREVER! NO ONE CAN CHANGE THAT
I keep buying the 2 versions of Exo songs (Korean and Chinese) because they both sound awesome.
Even though I usually don't listen to Chinese songs, I prefer this over this korean one... It just flows that much better.
It's heartbreaking listening to this song and looking at the MV. I miss Luhan, Kris, and Tao. I miss OT12. Rather, let's just say that I miss the memories from back then, when Exo just debut, joining Exo Showtime, etc. You guys might disagree with me, but I felt like either I changed or Exo changed. I just don't feel like Exo is the same anymore (not just because Luhan, Kris, and Tao left), but because back then Exo was really happy even though they weren't as popular as they are now. Now, Exo is super popular and I'm proud of them. But I felt like Exo is no longer as carefree and happy as back then. They're more mature and solemn. Time has taken away their smiles. Maybe it's just me, stuck in the past with the memories. I will continue to support Exo. I'm proud of where they are at now. But rather then them having fame, I rather they have happiness and are healthy instead. Despite so, good luck to Exo and to Luhan, Kris, and Tao! I love you guys and I will continue supporting you all.
i have same thought as you.. Hope we can be happy either exo or exo l.. always happy
+陳芷恩 谢谢～～
Exactly the same feelings as you, I has always think like that and I always ask myself if I change or EXO... They don't smile so often now and also our happy virus aren't smiling for no reason now... I just really miss the time when 12 people will imitate each other and always smiling for a not funny joke .Seeing the 12 smile is really the most happy thing for me...
Same!😭😭
Back then, they had those sincere smiles and laughs, and they always had a lot of fun altogether
But then time passed by, they had to put on fake smiles, their laughs are so different to the ones that actually made you laugh because of their laugh........They still have fun, but I mostly see their sadness that they try so hard to hide!😢
Same!😭😭
Back then, they had those sincere smiles and laughs, and they always had a lot of fun altogether
But then time passed by, they had to put on fake smiles, their laughs are so different to the ones that actually made you laugh because of their laugh........They still have fun, but I mostly see their sadness that they try so hard to hide!😢
EXO's winter albums are really masterpieces. They make my heart feel warm in this cold weather. ♡
Baekhyun and Chen are the best vocalists but I think D.O and Luhan stand out in each version because their tones are really appealing to the ear. Luhan's soft tone in particular provides a very nice contrast in the song.
wow...this was touching and beautiful, I think the chinese version expresses the emotion of the song better than the korean one :o
I like the chinese ver. one more because the words feel just so right
Thats right, im from China :-D
I love it too!!! I cried for no reason ....it was so beautiful :')
Luhan's voice is so good, and we miss Luhan so much~~~
As a native Korean speaker myself, I couldn't understand how other people mentioned the song made them cry even though they didn't understand Korean, but I think I can understand what that means because this Chinese version makes me emotional even though I don't understand Chinese.
Kris Luhan Tao I miss you so much : )
You Mom me too………………
me too,l want see their
together again.
歌词好棒啊😢😢😢 一下子回到小学的时候 时光匆匆啊
EXO will forever be 12 in my heart!
CARAT ARMY #OT12!!
Same
this song simply touches my heart.....
I wish the Chinese version had more views :/ The Korean ver. has like 9 million views where as the Chinese has 2 million...
Oh no I'm crying now bcoz I miss our panda, deer & galaxy
I miss u exo ot12
You all will be forever in my heart
😥
This is one of the most beautiful MV in SM's history (personal)
EXO made me love the beautiful mandarin and when both EXO-M and EXO-K sing together as one (In the Korean ver. as well) it's like they're melting my heart. I love how they still have their symbols. Tao's time control was great! I loved that SM made the MV with their powers in it. Every single second is beautiful! I'll love this MV (korean ver. as well) forever and ever. Thank you!! Fighting EXO!! Great acting!
Even though i dont get a single thing what they are singing but this song is just soo beautiful....very soothing to our ears....
i was crying when i was hearing this song
I wish I had Tao power so I can bring time back where we were happy and *Together* EXo ot12 4ever
Ÿūrã kįm Gïrls Dåÿ same 😭
me to when i heard this song for the first time 3 years ago it gave me a nice memory of exo ot12,but now only 9 left. really miss their all exo member please make a concert unite all of the members and exo ex-member in one stage.
I hope so too TT
ʙᴀᴇᴋʜʏᴜɴ ɢᴀᴠᴇ ᴍᴇ ᴀ ʜᴇᴀʀᴛʙᴀᴇk same
Same 😭😭😭😭
This song make me sad evreytime when i listen to, such a powerful emotional song. I like chinese ver, it more meaningful then korean ver. always come back to this song, and realise it such a long time since back then
LuHan, Wu Yi Fan, Huang Zi Tao
Miss u so much :'(
Dirin Hidayat Me Too