Brain Drain: Why Highly Educated & Skillful Pakistanis Leave the Country?
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ก.พ. 2025
- Brain Drain: Why Highly Educated and Skillful Individuals leave Pakistan?
اعلی تعلیم یافتہ اور ہنرمند افراد پاکستان کیوں چھوڑ رہے ہیں؟
#braindrain #pakistan
I want this man to be protected at all costs
He Will be..😅
So do I
Thats what he teaches against. He want you to think and not to do "shahsiat parasti"
Yeee he smart me thinks he saeedii
@@Hjkkgg6788😂😂wtf
well, im not highly educated nor skillful yet here i am leaving this country. biggest achievement in our middle class communities is to leave the country, sad but a fact!
Man your English is good enough you don't seem to be less educated
@@hamzaakhter4353 he want to say that he is not good post graduate
Being highly educated is not based on your actual education. It's about your attitude towards knowledge and capacity to think critically.
@@morbidgirl6808 very nice madam
@@morbidgirl6808 my Man 🙏
Your critique of the brain drain in Pakistan deserves highest accolades! Hats off to you !
i saw it on fb before and i can co relate it with so much because i am leaving my country soon just because the reasons you mentioned ...thanks to share our pain ...respect from India ...be safe
@Singh bhai hum to nikl jayege but ap jaise log to idhar ho na to India ka bhala kaise possible ha.... jinhone na video samjhni na bat ko feel krna... bs hagna hota ha
Good luck with your new life man.
@@anammusafir969 Agree with you
the best journalist of south asia!! syed, we love you. well thought out and analysed shows
I left india a while ago but now I'm in India...modi can be of right wing or anything but he is doing good job. Many of my friends are thinking to come to Pune, Bangalore, Noida. If the pace remain same they will be coming to india in next 10 years.
Agree, 30 years ago India is completely different from today's India. There are so many high tech jobs in India, there is little reason for expats like myself to keep staying abroad.
Yes this is good and a form of reverse brain drain
Indian IT cells worker. Hi.
Beta tum aaye Kahan se ho,India Ke Sare Ameer log abroad bhag rahe hain Sara kuch bech ke.Pehle Google karlo India ka Haal.India me Taxation America se bhi jyada hai aur facilities kuch bhi nhi.Tum Mars se hoge paka😂😂
Same halat ne ind and pak koi mne ja na mne
your words are so influential and i listen your words carefully and got to know that listening to you is worth it. I am from INDIA but still i like to hear you adn all the best for your future and develop Pakistan
Dear Muzamil, I am your new listener and you are doing great Job dude.
I am an engineer who recently left Pakistan exactly because of these reasons, but you know while working as expat in Gcc the way they give us respect is far more better then our homeland.
So I believe we need to provide opportunity plus respect to save our talent.
Ap Ki Eo ek bat me Dimagh se dhuwen Nikal dye... Proud of you sir.. Love from Nawabshah sindh
I have left Pakistan and happy Alhamdulillah
Where?
Ab tak kitne gutter nale khole he dubai me??
Brother I am worried about you now because you are showing real picture and there is no room for truth in our Country. May Almighty keep you safe from evils ! Amen
Black Vigo
Amen
Amen
Ameen
بھائ اتنا سارا سچ ایک ساتھ ہی بول دیا
May Allah protect you from Black Vigo...!
Syed muzammal you are contributing for the awareness of masses .
Well described amd explained Sir
Almost all of my cousins left India. They loved India as the holy land of their Gods but we all deserve the fruit of our hard work. It is about injustice. The state fails to give us what we deserve.
thank you..we the other uneducated ones prefer to stay here and make it better. Not because its easy..but because its hard
@@piyushdas079 We shud wish them luck.. as long as everyone is happy with their choices, who are we to judge their choice.
But, I MUST SAY that.. People like above are expecting something from State..whereas people like U and Me ..we think that what WE can give to OUR country..how can we contribute..that's the difference..
We are NOT providing such people with DUAL Citizenship..that what matters to us..
@@bhaktikulkarni2005 If you look closely we have local problems which can be solved locally most of the times. Similarly the state is made of people we have elected and selected. We expect them to do something for us but when we are in that position we make the same mistakes. Why? because we dont work on ourselves and our own weaknesses. We expect the world to be fair yet we ourselves are selectively fair..only when it suits us. We dont 'deserve' anything we havent invested ourselves in. I have zero respect for people who jump ship instead of repairing their own ship. These people talk of 'loving' their country , nope , its just talk. Its a convenient way to justify your migration. There are many many educated and brilliant Indians working on ground level to bring real changes to their environment. Both social , educational and civil. We are an old civilisation but a new country and there are issues that need our efforts. The system these guys complain of somehow has given them the education to be worthy of America ,,,but now is inadequate for them? How hypocritical ! No issue with anyone migrating for a better life but dont justify with 'the system kharab' ... you have chosen the most convenient way out and its just that . The day America gets problematic will they stay there to solve those issues or again run away somewhere else ? America is great because people stayed there and made it great ....they could have migrated to Europe but they stayed and worked hard and now they have a semblance of prosperity. And despite whatever they say about immigrants, no country or nation or people will have internal respect for 'bhagodas'. Even if you take their citizenship and try to behave whiter than them..they know who you are and they know that unlike their ancestors u are the consumer of 'good times' only.
@@piyushdas079 People who leave their countries in the subcontinent have also contributed massively to their home countries by the way of remittance and investment. This made their lives better and the was beneficial to the country also.
@@HelloWorld-gt1qp it's like leaving your parents to old age and then sending them money to somehow cover up your guilt
Incredibly well presented pointers. Harsh truth of our society and reality
One of the most intellectual narrative I've heard in a long time! Way to go, Muzammil, you've got a fan!
بولتے رھو میں نا امید نہی آخری سانسوں میں ھوں۔شائد تم پانی کا قطرہ ھو۔
I am a regular follower Mr. Muzammal Shah. Please protect this man at all costs.
I'm not Pakistani myself but have friends who are. I'm currently learning Urdu and have found Pakistan has such a rich and varied culture with music, poetry, art, fashion as well being a beautiful country in itself. So much potential if it can get past its own challenges. It will take honesty and love but it can be achieved if the leadership and vision are there
You have a good luck that you are not Pakistani.
I hope so
Good to know that you are learning Urdu
Don’t waste ur good time wasting learning Pakistan language and culture
I'm a patriotic Pakistani, well educated and young; I'm desperately trying to run away from Pakistan as soon as possible 😭😭
What a bad luck...
Even in india there is big drain 😶
So apt 🙏 after 6-7 years of trying to serve here I now think all those who left for USMLE PLAB MRCP when I was dreaming of serving here,were really smart ,now it's the point where it's no more serving perhaps only paying the price of this dream,you must be knowing about the graduate of king Edward who was shot dead after dealing with a medicolegal case,then they say drs don't serve in remote areas!
Good bless ya it's never too late
I'm also considering USMLE
I know it ain't easy but sure USA pays you all for your hardwork!
unlike pakistan!
Just waiting for my MBBS to be completed!
Love your thoughts and style of delivery. You were introduced to me my Pakistani friend. Brain drain is not bad but key is to have government policies to encourage this diaspora to invest in back (not in real estate) rather on newer technologies and establish SME and assist in employment india has been very successful following this model..
Kashmiri Pandit, California
True India bhi economic zones bna rha hai ☺️😊
Well said.
I'm fed up with this system and analyzing acts of establishment, i think its not gonna change soon, not in my lifetime.
I simply salute you brother. Every word that you said is true and based on sad reality of this country.
This one topic needs more time and attention I am in the US some of the best doctors from Pakistan are working here and when they come to Pakistan they are really badly treated PKLI was a nightmare for some amazing people that came from US.
I'm also fed up with the system and people here
But still i talk about reform... I hope for the good.. Nd in sha Allah will serve our country ✌🏻
Syed dropping Truth Bombs
That's very correct and ur speech based on true facets ,,, very excellent
آپ کو دیکھ کہ ایک شعر یاد آتا ھے۔۔۔۔ یہ اک ابر کا ٹکڑا کہاں کہاں برسے۔۔۔۔ دشت کا دشت ہی پیاسہ دکھائ دیتا ھے۔۔۔۔۔
Sir I couldn’t agree more with you , I don’t consider myself a highly educated person but I have a few friends who are experienced engineers & teachers but due to lack of better opportunities & PARCHI system eventually left the country & have no intensions of coming back . in my humble opinion it’s not just the lack of career prospects & financial struggles there are some other factors as well which push people to leave like injustice particularly our police , every year we see incidents were the police which is supposed to be our protectors shoots innocent citizens & then gets away with it .
A lot is wrong here & no one knows how to fix it , the other day I was telling my friend that perhaps the political system is corrupt & he tagged me a video of common people stealing hand sanitizers from ATM’s & asked me you want me to come back for this . I was speechless .
Exactly sir what u r saying this is exactly happening in India as well abhi haal hi mein student protest chal hi Raha hai we need this kind of voice from both side warna na hi pakistan bachega aur nahi hindustan sirf khokle dhanche bachenge
I hope both sides understand that peace is the best option
پاکستان اتنا امن پسند اور خوشحال ملک ہے اور ماشاء اللہ یہاں تمام لوگ امن پسند رہتے ہیں اور ہر سال یہاں سے پانچ ہزار سے زیادہ ہندو اپنی مذہبی عبادات کے بہانے انڈیا جاتے ہیں اور پھر وہاں سے واپس نہیں آتے اور اسی طرح پاکستان میں رہنے والے مسیحی بھی تھائی لینڈ اور دوسرے ملکوں میں جانے پر مجبور ہے
Sir I'm from a remote area of kpk and I see violations against women everyday it's been physical torture.here girls got married at very little age and they can't deny this because of the culture. What should be done against it .so many other issues ..can you drop a topic on this issue...
We don't get to know what is happening in remote areas of kpk. If you make vlogs or know of any such vlogs, please share with us.
@@Sfren5336 no one can dare to cover or talk about this they consider it as a normal thing
@Islamabadi Atheist yeah well I will think about it? thanks
Hmmm your from remote area of KPK , still know how to write a perfect english. Still know where to post and how to post your comment. Still have the freedom to write what you want.
Pathetic
Bro just get the power(economicaly) and then revolt it. If you cannot do that just pack your bag and leave country for your children future!
Today's most precious 14 minutes with Muzammil Bhai's video love 😍 you Man
intellectuals Are Always Entrenched with scrutiny
First of all I must confess, I agree with you on all of the points stated in vlog.
One project i visited last week, Mehmand Dam need your kind attention.
Well-done Sir much appreciated ☺️
Sucha blessing you’re for Pakistanis.
You are so True. I admire your courage. I look forward for your videos.
Muzammil dude, mad respect for your work but take care of your physical and mental health too. The work you are doing for everyone isn't easy. It's physically, mentally and emotionally draining. Esp living in Pakistan where anything related to mental health is frowned upon. U seem to be very sleep deprived and too emotionally burdened, rightfully so. Please remember to prioritize your well being too in the midst of everything you're doing.Best wishes to you and your loved ones. Much love. ✌️🍀🔥♥️🤘
This gem is an individualist. He knows how to prioritize oneself. Also, we must be grateful to his services that he takes time to share his critiques that too without advertisements (it shows that he doesn't share his thoughts for money or, perhaps, fame).
Hey, would love if you could compile a list of books// reseouces to educate about various issues. Your videos are super insightful and has sparked my interest for sure.
1. Why Nations Fail by Daron Acemoglu and James A. Robinson (another recent one by them is called The Narrow Corridor it's my next read)
2. The Social Contract by Jean Jacques Rosseau
3. Philosophy of Logical Atomism by Bertrand Russell
4. The story of China by Michael Wood
5. God: A human history of religion by Reza Aslan
6. A Nietzsche reader Penguin Classics (it's a compilation of his writings)
7. Guns, Germs and Steel by Prof. Jared Diamond
8. The Second Sex by Simone de Beauvoir
9. The Conquest of Happiness By Bertrand Russell (also check out his Scientific Method)
10. The God Delusion by Richard Dawkins.
(It took me a while to write this comment, you better read these books haha)
Hi v buggy high high BB high BB
@@hottiekiller9912 👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
@@hottiekiller9912thanks buddy
You are doing a wonderful job! God bless you!!! Keep it up!
God Blessed & protect u ever
What a great and concise concept you have.
Love listening you.
Thanks god i found you.
You spoke my heart out, amazing content and take care of yourself because these people don't understand you
Completely agree with everything you’ve said! When will be our nation wake up
Hey brother I am from india you definitely deserve to become prime minister of Pakistan.... Lot's of love
Bhai! Yeh banda video hi ap logo k liye banata h
Syed kindly Make video on for Good journalism and inspiring students they want to become journalist
yes please
So you want them to become good journalists, so that the deep state can intrude their houses and torture/murder them ?
Salam!
May sochti thi Shayad Pakistan may aisy log h e nhi...lakin ap social issues ko itny achy sy highlight krty h or issues k basic reasons ko bohat achy sy btaty....Beghair kisi khouf k aisy straight forward bat krty h, yahi reason h jis ki wajha sy muje ap ki videos bohat achi lgti...waisy b insan ko Allah k ilawa kisi ka khouf nhi hona chahiye..aisy hi issues ko highlight krty rhy...Allah ap k liye asaniya Paida kry.
Leaving this here for the algorithm, tired of stupid videos being recommended in the feed. Keep doing you!
Thanks for letting us know, tho nobody asked for it. Now, STFU, and get lost please. ❤️
@@blackdragon-pn8zi You do realize he was actually complimenting this video right? If yes, why the harsh response? Don't take out falltu ka anger on others
@@Zia_Ali. lol thank God someone realized it was a compliment.
More power to you Sir.. But be safe
Much appreciated sir.
You just said,rightly!
I am a graduate of allama iqbal medical college lahore and done house job last year and I am telling you half my class had applied for foreign liscensing exams to go abroad for better options.
I am FMG and we are planning it too Sir...
i am also a medical student . planning to appear to appear in foreign license exams
Yeh mulk insaano kay rehnay kay qabil nahin.
Bhaiyyo notes hi share kardena jab bana lo....😜😜
I'm surprised the other half hasnt applied..
Sir i am from Lahore
Really respect your analyst
Bhai apko salaam hai qsm se. Such an intellectual person.
As overseas Pakistani, 100% agree with your statement. Most Pakistani engineers and doctors you can see in Canada and USA. Highly qualified and no one is thinking to settle down back in Pakistan. All our investments are here in US and Canada, as we have no trust on corrupt Pakistani system. On the other hand Indians are investing money in India.
Brother i will come to USA... After my 12 boards.... Dua krna meray liye 😭😭hallat bht khrab Pakistan k😢😢
@@saadkhan-gf5fc Same problem in Bangladesh too.Our government is also failed to provide jobs for youth.Many graduates are leaving country to pursue good salary job career.
Dude you spit out the hard facts of our society ....Take care of yourself man
I salute you i agree with you and also migrate from this country
Leaving soon for every single reason you just mentioned! Especially due to lack of women rights and radicalism.
If you do, at least remove the Muslim label from you. Because izlam and women rights are not compatible. Become an atheist.
Aap to vahi ho na...6 saal me...
What women rights feminist rights or actual women rights ? This feminism liberalism destroys your actual women the rights
Great respect sir
Big fan of urs words nd logical stuff
Love your sarcastic commentary👍👍
Telented/refugee muslims leave their country for better life, go to other countries and make that country same as the country they came from. Because better life is not the goal, shariya and spreading Islam is the real goal.
I am a huge fan of your analysis! you are amazing Muzammil
Great video.
Brother as I always say you are an asset please do some active effort to enhance your fan base as people should be listening to such analysis rather than wasting time on useless conversations in the mainstream media
Most of pakistani ...they hide our pakistani identity ...most of US base pakistani show identity as indian....they say we are indian...
I'm PhD student. My friends don't want to stay in Pakistan. I don't want to go back. In Shaa Allah. Muzamil u forgot mushraf era how mqm with establishment support destroyed industry in Sindh. Jub tak yeah military hai ni Kuch thek ho ga. Muzamil plz take care they would also hurt u
Hope 1 day Pakistan will be so advance,that best Pakistani won’t leave,they can work in Pakistan while being with their families,
I hope
Love & respect from India...
You are telling my story. I couldn't have said it better myself.
You said it all 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
You are great
How many of those are men though? I live in Germany and some of the Pakistani males coming here are bringing their anti-women and anti-feminist stances here. As well as (ironically), their patriotism. The type who get all defensive when you criticise Pakistan and the way women are treated there. I would rather Pakistani women came here but we know how much freedom of movement they have over there.
Yes this is true. They are radicalised from the beginning.
Obviously they'll get defensive because they benefit from the oppression of women in Pakistan. They defend their unfair male privilege in Pakistan.
They are brought up in a way that they think having a career is a bad thing for a women
Superd analyzing skills .keep it up
Wherever we Indians may be in the world we Love our Land and faithful to Land we live.
Plz keep making such videos and never ever stop it.
Why you're speaking my words. This all things are in my minds but May Apki Tarah qabel Nhi hon Ju Bol Sako. I love you Brother you're so great and your videos are super interesting and informative ♥️♥️♥️ Keep it up Bro we are learning a lot of new things.
Uk visaa good muzzamil Bhai
True. There are no jobs.
I can't wait to leave this country to a country which recognizes my potential!
for the very first time ever, dropping a comment, fabulous job man
Good work
Love Muzamil Bhai.
Inshallah hum mil kar apna mulk
Pakistan kai liyaa kuch karaai ga.
Hum Pakistan ko mazboot banaii ga
Your words are so hard hitting bro,aapki awaaz main Jo sacchai hai wo aajkal K mahaul main khatam hai🙏
Your opinion is so unique. 💞
i didnt forward ur video amazing
Hi ,syed muzammil please make a video on population explosion in pakistan and its consequences on pakistan
I agree with the issue , but partially agree with the causes and the partially agree with the solution
You are right I 100% agreed with u
You are such a Good Patwari
Sharm kr
SACH BARDAASHT NI HOTA AP JESO SE. GHALTI APKI B NI HAI, YOOTHIYAPA HAI HI ESI BEMARI ❤️
Great Job
Planning to leave for Canada in next 5-6 months.
Study k lie?
But don't say there ...I am indian...every pakistani show indian identity...not pakistani ...
Hath Hoola rakho Shah Saab ❤️ Support you And pray For your Safety
Zaberdast
Good video Good topic best information .....
Good job brother I think you should upload video once in a week. Best wishes from me
Already working on it. I am a doctor. The more degrees i am collecting the less i am earning. Now i dont want my kid to become a mental slave of this system. My patriotism won't die. But give me a system that is secure. My husband is IT engineer. There is no future of IT here. All the compannies are working by hiring collective freelancers.
Sir aik video css taste system par bhi banao plz ap ka contain bohat he acha hota hai 👍👍👍👍❤
100 percent true. There iz no political and judicial system in our country.
You are a Great person .
Agree with everything you said. Want to add that Pakistan is not an open society. You can’t do anything fun here either and people are toxic, not wanting to see others happy.