agar 3 idiots ki story 80% five point of someone se copied hai toh main kyu wo paper padhu main toh visual he dekunga na jabki rajkumar hirani ne itni acchi movie banae di hai...the point is main 3 idiot movie he prefer karunga instead of five point of someone...books ke mukable mujhe movie jyada intresting lagega
while buying the rights of the book, an agreement was done, all the procedures of the agreement were followed, it was written that he will get credits in end it happened, also he is a fucking liar, raju hirani has a document which clearly states that he has read the final script, he was just doing all this for publicity as movie became such hit. Book is nothing in comparison of movie
while buying the rights of the book, an agreement was done, all the procedures of the agreement were followed, it was written that he will get credits in end it happened, also he is a fucking liar, raju hirani has a document which clearly states that he has read the final script, he was just doing all this for publicity as movie became such hit. Book is nothing in comparison of movie
Amir u totally lost it, His book is the best seller and that guy is having enough credibility to showcase his talent, U are the people who do those cheap publicity stunts to get few audiences, ANYWAYS NEVER EXPECTED THESE KIND OF WORD FROM A PERSON LIKE U AMIR
Bhai Chetan jhut bol rha hai film shoot hone se pehle rajkumar hirani se uska agreement hua tha , he did these things on for their publicity, nothing else
i m very big fan of aamir khan but the story is of chetan bhagat thats the fact aur aisi kahani IIT or IIT jaise institutes ke engineers ki hi hoti hai . Truely Chetan Bhagat deserves a great credit for 3 idiots . aamir khan sir aap galat bol rahe hain ki chetan bhagat publicity ke liye ye sab kiye hain . But 3 idiots is really based on Five Point Someone: What Not to Do at IIT
Dheerendra Singh bro before making any comment read the story and watch the film then say anything sirf yeh video dekh kar comment kar rahe ho use your common sense
Abhishek Gupta, Lagta hai aapko "common sense" naam ki ek cheez hi nahi hai. Please read the comments here. Everybody has read the book. Nobody is like you, half baked fakir.
while buying the rights of the book, an agreement was done, all the procedures of the agreement were followed, it was written that he will get credits in end it happened, also he is a fucking liar, raju hirani has a document which clearly states that he has read the final script, he was just doing all this for publicity as movie became such hit. Book is nothing in comparison of movie
Mr.Amir khan I was d one who fought for u with my frds if they said that any of ur film is rubbish... that's the huge respect u have gained ... from many like me but... after this incident u have totally lost ur respect from many😡... chetan sir I am wd u
while buying the rights of the book, an agreement was done, all the procedures of the agreement were followed, it was written that he will get credits in end it happened, also he is a fucking liar, raju hirani has a document which clearly states that he has read the final script, he was just doing all this for publicity as movie became such hit. Book is nothing in comparison of movie
I have just read only 2 books of Chetan Bhagat and each book is really masterpieces....and by just reading only 2 books I became one of his fans! ❤️❤️ And About the movie if they are making a movie inspired by a novel then the credit should definitely goes to the Writer CHETAN BHAGAT ...In Bold Letters even SEPARATELY🔥🎉❤️
I'm shocked of hearing controversies about this 3 idiots.....I'll read first Five Point of Someone and I'll comment on it .....but I think I'm convinced by Chetan sir .....
This is how Society can't give respect to writer like Writer are Original source of that Script and Secondary is Actors and Screenplay of that Script so Writer Plays the Very important role in any screenplay but They are underrated
Amir Khan your background from a bollywood family and you got opportunity in film industry because of family. The way you and Vidhu Chopra behaving it shows your reality .Chetan came from a different family background after that he is facing you . Chetan can become Amir Khan but Amir khan has to born again to become chetan
The story of 3 idiots is totally from the novel of chetan bhagat. We r wid u chetan . And amir these kind of irresponcible statements frm u r not expected. First u should read d novel. Cheten does not need any publicity he already had huge sensible fan following.
while buying the rights of the book, an agreement was done, all the procedures of the agreement were followed, it was written that he will get credits in end it happened, also he is a fucking liar, raju hirani has a document which clearly states that he has read the final script, he was just doing all this for publicity as movie became such hit. Book is nothing in comparison of movie
while buying the rights of the book, an agreement was done, all the procedures of the agreement were followed, it was written that he will get credits in end it happened, also he is a fucking liar, raju hirani has a document which clearly states that he has read the final script, he was just doing all this for publicity as movie became such hit. Book is nothing in comparison of movie
What the fuck man....Movie is totally a copy of Chetan's book, Five point someone...Aisa ghatya kaam bhi hota hai bollywood mein...Ek credit dene mein kya jaata hai in logon ka..
Vahi anpad biggest movie star hai aaj...vese bro aaj india ka pm ho ya bade se bada aadmi sab zyada tar kam padhe likhe he hai par isse unka kaam effect nahi hota
The movie is a copy of 5 point someone ( upto 50%) and that's a huge percentage.... Chetan deserves to be treated at par(if not more) with Abhijaat as far as credit of writing the story goes...... Aamir should read the book first and then publicly say(which he can't do) that Chetan wants to take credit and publicity of the hit movie. no one can deny that book has served as a primary source to develop the storyline of the movie... absolutely no one. give CHETAN is due respect and credit not just 10 lakh that aamir claims to have been paid to him as a contract........ chetan deserves a lottttt lotttttttttt more... hats off to chetan for writing the incredible book-" five point someone"- a treat to all engineering students and he still seems not so concerned even after a major copyright stealth issue. chetan bhagat is an incredible man. A top class indian national. my salute to u sir........... u should not have returned to india sir- see what this nation has to offer to u ?? you are a brilliant writer , a thoroughly accomplished man and a down to earth guy........
Amir sir.. i m big fan of u.. and i respect u... but now u r lossing respect from me.. u should read the book first.. and giv any statment... film is clearly based on 5point someone...
I think makers dono ke saath game khel rahe hai aamir sir ke saath bhi aur chetan sir ke saath bhi shayad in dono ko kisine puri sacchai batai hi nahi god knows who's wrong and who's right!!!
I saw this movie because I heard it is based on 5 point somethin novel and vidu chopra movies and I also believed after I saw not for aamir or other cast. This is really very unfortunate that star like Aamir gave answer by introducing someone's voice in negative manner. I would say manipulating truth is not good manner Aamir and indeed bad manner. I can see similarities in both and also know the book written 5yrs ago. Keep up Cheatan and SPEAK OUT.
I totally agree....as I read this book...the scenes from the movie got picturised in front of my eyes...these ppl from Bollywood are sick....won't improve...
If they have stolen characters they must have given chetan sir credit. Didn't expected this third class behaviour from Aamir and Raj Kumar hirani. Degraded their respect in front of me!
All story of these movie based on Chetan sir's book five point someone... Aamir Khan is telling a lie because he wants that the credit of this story should be given to director producer etc... But the real credit should be given to Mr Chetan Bhagat..
Amir and his team should read the book of chetan before making the movie may be they had known that the movie they were working on based on chetan book, but they didnt that was his mistake but we people read the book and watched the movie, we know that who is right and who is wrong.
I have read the book college and hostel life where movie gathers momentum and draws interest is 80% copied.but in book there is nothing about transforming edu system and all...but u just need one idea to start a thing and here 60% is pure copy..so its copied...
Chethan should demand an apology from them for killing the essence of his simple realistic story and making it into a hero worshipping typical bollywood masala..
I dont think so that there is fault of the actor or actress working in this flim like aamir khan or kareena kapoor If the flim is copy of the book so i think there is fault of Vidhu vinod chopra or rajakumar Hirani as they have written the script , dialogue,lyric etc Who agrees with me
Chetan is not asking about screenplay writing credit. What is the problem of writing in main credit, "based on the story of '5 Point Someone' by Chetan Bhagat"? Shame on Aamir Khan how he had twisted the story.
All educated persons will support Chetan Bhagat... I read the book before the movie was even made.
The film is 80% based on the book. The book is a masterpiece. Everybody should read it.
Animesh M name of the book?
Five Points Someone
Ikr
agar 3 idiots ki story 80% five point of someone se copied hai toh main kyu wo paper padhu main toh visual he dekunga na jabki rajkumar hirani ne itni acchi movie banae di hai...the point is main 3 idiot movie he prefer karunga instead of five point of someone...books ke mukable mujhe movie jyada intresting lagega
@@hackericchbolte4901 bhai originality name ki bhi koi chijh hoti haii
Chetan's eyes and confidence says the truth
I had watched movie once.....and read the book 6 times....love you CB....
i have read the book and watced movie.. i support chetan
while buying the rights of the book, an agreement was done, all the procedures of the agreement were followed, it was written that he will get credits in end it happened, also he is a fucking liar, raju hirani has a document which clearly states that he has read the final script, he was just doing all this for publicity as movie became such hit. Book is nothing in comparison of movie
@@Vijay0Yadav Facts.
@@Vijay0Yadav facts
@@blissful8557 facts
"3 idiots" credit should go to the creator of the characters and script the one and only chetan bhagat.
Barkha Gogoi u r chutiya
while buying the rights of the book, an agreement was done, all the procedures of the agreement were followed, it was written that he will get credits in end it happened, also he is a fucking liar, raju hirani has a document which clearly states that he has read the final script, he was just doing all this for publicity as movie became such hit. Book is nothing in comparison of movie
@@Lucidbreeze3678 exactly 💯
I am with chetan sir.
Supporting chetan sir
Ye i also
Amir u totally lost it, His book is the best seller and that guy is having enough credibility to showcase his talent, U are the people who do those cheap publicity stunts to get few audiences, ANYWAYS NEVER EXPECTED THESE KIND OF WORD FROM A PERSON LIKE U AMIR
Hi
@@shreyavalvaikar698 Hi 😁
Amir we didn't expect this type of word... Chetan is right
Mene book padhi h, 70 percent movie is based on chetan's book. Amir lost the respect from me. Usne to book padhi bhi nahi hai.
Bhai Chetan jhut bol rha hai film shoot hone se pehle rajkumar hirani se uska agreement hua tha , he did these things on for their publicity, nothing else
Chetan bhagat, we support you. We had read your book. Readers know the truth that this is your brilliant story.
Aamir, shame on you.
how can amir be so confident without reading chetan bhagat´s book that avijaat didn't copy from chetan bhagat???
i m very big fan of aamir khan but the story is of chetan bhagat thats the fact aur aisi kahani IIT or IIT jaise institutes ke engineers ki hi hoti hai . Truely Chetan Bhagat deserves a great credit for 3 idiots . aamir khan sir aap galat bol rahe hain ki chetan bhagat publicity ke liye ye sab kiye hain . But 3 idiots is really based on Five Point Someone: What Not to Do at IIT
Dheerendra Singh bro before making any comment read the story and watch the film then say anything sirf yeh video dekh kar comment kar rahe ho use your common sense
Abhishek Gupta, Lagta hai aapko "common sense" naam ki ek cheez hi nahi hai. Please read the comments here. Everybody has read the book. Nobody is like you, half baked fakir.
while buying the rights of the book, an agreement was done, all the procedures of the agreement were followed, it was written that he will get credits in end it happened, also he is a fucking liar, raju hirani has a document which clearly states that he has read the final script, he was just doing all this for publicity as movie became such hit. Book is nothing in comparison of movie
Latha Baradwaj and nobody is dumb like you who doesn't even understand what "Agreement" means?😑
@@Vijay0Yadav Book rights were not buy by film makers.
Amir just wanted to Say that Chetan sir has copied their bloody flim 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Mr.Amir khan
I was d one who fought for u with my frds if they said that any of ur film is rubbish...
that's the huge respect u have gained ... from many like me but...
after this incident u have totally lost ur respect from many😡...
chetan sir I am wd u
Varun vishwas Thakur you can't blame on aamir khan...
while buying the rights of the book, an agreement was done, all the procedures of the agreement were followed, it was written that he will get credits in end it happened, also he is a fucking liar, raju hirani has a document which clearly states that he has read the final script, he was just doing all this for publicity as movie became such hit. Book is nothing in comparison of movie
Aamir. YOU ARE LOOSING The RESPECT FROM MY SIDE GIVING THIS STATEMENT WITHOUT READING NOVEL AND WITHOUT KNOWING THE FACT.
Chetan your story is masterpiece
I liked Aamir Khan before seeing this!
Hachisu Uchiha Mee too
Neeraj Deshpande they had bought all the rights from the author and it is totally diffrent
What did aamir have to say after reading the book ?did he correct his statement?
I have just read only 2 books of Chetan Bhagat and each book is really masterpieces....and by just reading only 2 books I became one of his fans! ❤️❤️ And About the movie if they are making a movie inspired by a novel then the credit should definitely goes to the Writer CHETAN BHAGAT ...In Bold Letters even SEPARATELY🔥🎉❤️
Yes I have read the book and it is same
80% is same
really its chethan story.......sad about aamir words.we know what did
I love you Chetan Bhagat... I'll surely read 5 point someone.... I hope its available in the bookstore
Chetan sir really deserves the fame....
70% copied from five point someone
Its Chetan's story
I'm shocked of hearing controversies about this 3 idiots.....I'll read first Five Point of Someone and I'll comment on it .....but I think I'm convinced by Chetan sir .....
This is how Society can't give respect to writer like Writer are Original source of that Script and Secondary is Actors and Screenplay of that Script so Writer Plays the Very important role in any screenplay but They are underrated
"Good artists copy, great artists steal"- Steve Jobs
Pablo Picasso na bola tha bhai 🙄
Vidhu vinod Chopra & Rajkumar Hirani are mediocre artist who made film on Chetan Bhagat's Novel without mentioning his name.
Chetan sir's confidence is sufficient to be accepted his wods for us.
11:20 चेतन सर आपकी बात सही हो गई।🎉🎉
चोरी का ही नतीजा है कि बॉलीवुड पर साउथ फिल्मे भारी हैं।
Amir after saying dis u ve lost respect from many
Amir Khan your background from a bollywood family and you got opportunity in film industry because of family. The way you and Vidhu Chopra behaving it shows your reality .Chetan came from a different family background after that he is facing you . Chetan can become Amir Khan but Amir khan has to born again to become chetan
The story of 3 idiots is totally from the novel of chetan bhagat. We r wid u chetan . And amir these kind of irresponcible statements frm u r not expected. First u should read d novel. Cheten does not need any publicity he already had huge sensible fan following.
while buying the rights of the book, an agreement was done, all the procedures of the agreement were followed, it was written that he will get credits in end it happened, also he is a fucking liar, raju hirani has a document which clearly states that he has read the final script, he was just doing all this for publicity as movie became such hit. Book is nothing in comparison of movie
It's exactly same story i red this
Santwana Krishna u
while buying the rights of the book, an agreement was done, all the procedures of the agreement were followed, it was written that he will get credits in end it happened, also he is a fucking liar, raju hirani has a document which clearly states that he has read the final script, he was just doing all this for publicity as movie became such hit. Book is nothing in comparison of movie
@@Lucidbreeze3678 you just copied other reply.. whats the point lol
i am PAKISTANI... really i dis heart when i watch it ,,, so chetan a great person then fake producer and writer ....
Chetan Sir have the talent to write such kind of books❤️❤️❤️
Chetan sir:) bold step for truth 👍15:20 educational background good point.Ethics
ऐसे काम करेंगे तो बॉलीवुड को कोई कहानी भी देने वाला नहीं मिलेगा।
it is wrong na... chetan bhagath's hard work written book it is...but why to use his hard work in film.... its hurted feeling for every writter
I'm with chetan bhagat
chetan iam sorry I can't help u but ur right
What the fuck man....Movie is totally a copy of Chetan's book, Five point someone...Aisa ghatya kaam bhi hota hai bollywood mein...Ek credit dene mein kya jaata hai in logon ka..
nimesh subedi bro pehle story ko padho aur film ko analyze karo uske baad koi comment karo
Chetan IIT & IIM
AMIR 12 FAIL
WHO IS BEST?
I support chetan.
I have read chetan bhagat book '5 point someone'. 3 idiots is almost copy of 5 point someone . Even some dialogues are same .
the producer and director are simply crook, hats up for chetan bhagat
Bollywoodawood ka Yahi Tarika hain.. Kisi Dusre ke Creative ideas ko Chori karte hain. N that person ko Credibility nahi dete...!
The best book ever and its story copied by rajkumar hirani.
We support Chetan.
Chetan I am with you
This is the speciality of Vidhu Vinod Chopra and Rajkumar Hirani
Nirlajj log copy krte he ... 🤣 Finally sach to samne aa hi jata he 😅 ammir khan anpadh he ..12 th tak hi padha he ..ye kya padhega novel 🤣
Vahi anpad biggest movie star hai aaj...vese bro aaj india ka pm ho ya bade se bada aadmi sab zyada tar kam padhe likhe he hai par isse unka kaam effect nahi hota
The movie is a copy of 5 point someone ( upto 50%) and that's a huge percentage.... Chetan deserves to be treated at par(if not more) with Abhijaat as far as credit of writing the story goes...... Aamir should read the book first and then publicly say(which he can't do) that Chetan wants to take credit and publicity of the hit movie. no one can deny that book has served as a primary source to develop the storyline of the movie... absolutely no one. give CHETAN is due respect and credit not just 10 lakh that aamir claims to have been paid to him as a contract........ chetan deserves a lottttt lotttttttttt more... hats off to chetan for writing the incredible book-" five point someone"- a treat to all engineering students and he still seems not so concerned even after a major copyright stealth issue. chetan bhagat is an incredible man. A top class indian national. my salute to u sir........... u should not have returned to india sir- see what this nation has to offer to u ?? you are a brilliant writer , a thoroughly accomplished man and a down to earth guy........
Really the movie is 70-80 % based on his novel..I've read the novel and seen the movie as well
Shame on film makers.
I was not expecting this from Amir sir.🙁
Superb interview, got to learn many things
Are bhai mujhe nhi lgta ki 70-80 percent story accidentally same ho jae writing mein
i actually thought it was inspired by his book,this bollywood they do nothing but copy...
Amir sir.. i m big fan of u.. and i respect u... but now u r lossing respect from me.. u should read the book first.. and giv any statment... film is clearly based on 5point someone...
Chetan should sue Vinod Chopra
Chetan sir is right i read the book movie is copied from chetan book , this amir tingu is bloody liar , whole credit goes to chetan sir
I think makers dono ke saath game khel rahe hai aamir sir ke saath bhi aur chetan sir ke saath bhi shayad in dono ko kisine puri sacchai batai hi nahi god knows who's wrong and who's right!!!
like a girl who can emit seismic waves while taking notes
funny
I saw this movie because I heard it is based on 5 point somethin novel and vidu chopra movies and I also believed after I saw not for aamir or other cast. This is really very unfortunate that star like Aamir gave answer by introducing someone's voice in negative manner. I would say manipulating truth is not good manner Aamir and indeed bad manner. I can see similarities in both and also know the book written 5yrs ago. Keep up Cheatan and SPEAK OUT.
Chetan is speaking truth. His work is stolen.
I appreciate chetan bhagat,s hard work for his book
I totally agree....as I read this book...the scenes from the movie got picturised in front of my eyes...these ppl from Bollywood are sick....won't improve...
If they have stolen characters they must have given chetan sir credit. Didn't expected this third class behaviour from Aamir and Raj Kumar hirani. Degraded their respect in front of me!
I M VID U BHAGAT.I myself is a writer and tell u what after reading ur novel i felt like 3 idiots is totally 5 point someone's story
All story of these movie based on Chetan sir's book five point someone...
Aamir Khan is telling a lie because he wants that the credit of this story should be given to director producer etc...
But the real credit should be given to Mr Chetan Bhagat..
Chetan is right humble person
Amir and his team should read the book of chetan before making the movie may be they had known that the movie they were working on based on chetan book, but they didnt that was his mistake but we people read the book and watched the movie, we know that who is right and who is wrong.
I am with Cheten Bhagat ji.it is really sad !
chetan sir I respect u.....get lost aamir
It was Chetan's story and not Abhijat Joshi 's story
Chetan bhagat is very good person. I also read this book, and 70 to 80 percent story match the same incidents in book
Iam with chetan
in my previous post i had mentioned upto 50% - plzz read it as atleast 50%.... my apologies...
11:20 चेतन सर आपकी बात सही हो गई।🎉🎉
I have read the book college and hostel life where movie gathers momentum and draws interest is 80% copied.but in book there is nothing about transforming edu system and all...but u just need one idea to start a thing and here 60% is pure copy..so its copied...
Chetan is right I have read the book and also watched it
Amir just lost his ground.
book is more interesting than movie
Bina copy kiye koi bollywood movie banti hi nahi hai inme na itna dimag hai na koi decency hai
If he is so sure about everything then why don’t Chaten file a case against the writer of the movie?
I am with this iitian legend ,chetan bhagat
Chethan should demand an apology from them for killing the essence of his simple realistic story and making it into a hero worshipping typical bollywood masala..
I thought aamir khan was found dumb first time..
Bollywood copycat always
I m with chetan sir❤️❤️
Why u said to aamir not to read book?
Film is clearly based on five point someone...Chetan bhagat is totally correct
Chetan Bhagat great writer
I dont think so that there is fault of the actor or actress working in this flim like aamir khan or kareena kapoor
If the flim is copy of the book so i think there is fault of Vidhu vinod chopra or rajakumar Hirani as they have written the script , dialogue,lyric etc
Who agrees with me
The book is far better than movie
Thr is no fault of aamir n Raju...... Production house is ful responsible for it....
Chetan bhai is real true
cheten is so simple
Yass this film is totally based on 5 points someone what not to do at IIT !!!
I'm big fan of chetan bhagat.
Chetan is not asking about screenplay writing credit. What is the problem of writing in main credit, "based on the story of '5 Point Someone' by Chetan Bhagat"? Shame on Aamir Khan how he had twisted the story.