Oh yeah!! There are so many talented people in this compilation! Thank you so much for the reaction!🙏🏼 13:25 Yes, you are right! There are two of me singing 😂 And also because you asked for a video, I would recommend my Aberdeen (Avi Kaplan) Cover. It is a live performance where I sing and play guitar. Hope you like it!
you are in the comments on all the bass singing vids i watch. like bruh. u are awesome tho and i would love to be able to go as love as you do but im not that good yet.
Yesss finally! 😂 Glad you got to watch this video, there's some really great people featured in here. 👌🏻❤️ And yeah, Efe is a BEAST! We have some really hidden talents in the BSN 😂❤️
Hey man, didn't expect this video, great reaction. The russian names that you saw like Pavel Myakotin are actually russian Oktavists, a choral role in russian orthodox music. You should really check out a video by the amazing "TheOktavismChannel" with the title: "The Power Of The Russian Oktavist"...now imagine all of these low notes, but live without microphones and still the same power, clarity and projection. Simply put, the lowest of the low, truly unnatural and very beautiful musical pieces too!
@@gailseatonhumbert9199 I didn't know that, thanks for the info man! Avi is one of my favourite singers in general, absolutely stunning voice, and great personality too!
To answer your question at 3:24, subharmonics have a "ringing" to them, especially above G#1 due to their unusually rich harmonic content a full octave above the fundamental. Below, the ring slowly turns into a "rumble" put the upper harmonics are still very present. BTW, that's why some subs like F#1 typically sound so loud since F#2 is a low note below G#2 (whose sub is thus below G#1) that most bass singer can sing loud. Chest notes tend to sound "fuller", warmer because there are way more frequencies filling the gap between the note sung and the resulting sub. Since those upper harmonics tend to decrease smoothly in amplitude as you get further from the fundamental, you don't hear the "ringing". Hope this makes sense... ultimately you'll develop a better intuition for subs by hearing the same singer (especially if that singer is you) sing the same note in chest THEN subharmonics and learning to differentiate the two sounds. Thou Yang (the guy at 2:41, 5:10, 12:28 ) has a whole series of subharmonics tutorials with auxiliary exercises and science-based explanations here: th-cam.com/video/oJfP1471Rgg/w-d-xo.html
Ok, I might be bias, but to me the best is Geoff, for his tone, hold and range! Dan M. is pretty good, and holds his low a long time! Efe Sayin sounds like he was doing overtones, amazing! Surprised not to see Tim Foust or Avi Kaplan here. Maybe they don't do subharmonics?
@@alexwalker8440 No problem man, personally though i think that Ken Turner is one of the masters in Subharmonics, he just uses them like J.D Sumner would use his regular voice to reach the range of E1-C1. Absolute beast, and he is 86 years old i believe! David Khan is a close second certainly, his live C1 (it's on his channel) from the Elvis concert is incredible. But Thou Yang and David Larson are the current kings in extended techniques like that, they are basically on a pedestal for us in the Bass Community :)
Subharmonics are some of my favourite notes to do because 1. They sound awesome and unique. 2 they sound more computer generated .and 3 they have a unique feeling in your throat when you make the sound that feels kinda cool
Here's the difference between Tomi's subharmonic A1 and his chest A1. The subharmonic A1 sounds like there are 2 notes stacked on top of each other: a great A ( an A2 ) on top, and a contra A ( an A1 ) on the bottom. With the chest A1, you notice there is only one note, an A1. Also another thing to note, compared to the subharmonic low A, you can hear the note literally drop when he switches to chest, actually almost feel it drop. There's your answer to how they're different.
13:22 Thats what subharmonics is, to reach the first subharmonic you sing the octave above in chest voice (here it would be the D2 you here him go up to), but subharmonics involves adding in some neck tension/fry that produces a strong note 1 octave down (the D1 here). This is a very simplified explanation but thats the basics of how this is different to simply hitting notes using chest or vocal fry
I am not a bass singer, but a chest note is when you sing in your range where you'd normally sing and subharmonic is when you relax your voice to go an octave below, hope this answered the question :)
I love how at the end we almost only see Efe Sayin (and sometimes Ken Turner) singing E1, D1, C#1, C1, B0 and the other singers get rarer and rarer as we get closer to B0 😄
I think you are right that at 13:20 he is doing the D2 and D1 separately and editing them on top of each other, however it is possible with subharmonics to sing both at the same time! It's because subharmonics are done by singing an octave above and then doing a fry in a specific way to drop it down, so if you do the fry lightly it can sound like both at once. It's similar to overtones but going lower instead of higher. Also at 4:37 David is doing whats called the 2nd subharmonic, notice how he jumps down an octave and does the regular subharmonic but then he jumps down again without a pause. He has videos on his channel explaining whats going on and how to do it. Would definitely recommend watching his videos on growl and other techniques as well!
Love your videos and reactions man also when you get to the Bb and Eb the little b is called flat,so it’s be Bb1-is B flat so that’s what the little b’s are but love your videos man keep up the great work💙💙
So while I was searching some music today I found Broadway male slaying high notes blimey I didn't no there was so many out there maybe check it out qofy great reaction 😊
QofyReacts you need to learn subharmonics man, but it depends on you and your range ofcourse because it can hurt your vocal cords due to the placement being low but it is easy to learn, for me, I do watch Geoff's vid about subharmonics and his other video too. Really helpful but just remember to not strain the vocal cords and maintain good health also. Subharmonic note is the octave below the original like singing A2 down to A1, that's subharmonic while the vocal fry or chest fry, a thick or heavy note with popping sound I think but with consistency. Most subharmonic are drop notes but vocal fry is made by singing lower or like climbing down.
how people know the difference between subharmonic and chest is there is a slight different sound and you cant slide from chest to subharmonic without a small jump but once you are in subharmonic you can slide
@@QofyReacts doing good how are you? Husband is recovering well from surgery and my grandson has started playing baseball and is doing great so far. His first game was today and the won. Yay🎉🎆⚾️✨
@@MarielleSweden He uses chest fry and growl techniques like a monster - Tim's amazing. No subharmonics, though. Subharmonics are a very specific, very difficult to master technique. Chest fry fits more with his style of music - subharmonics probably wouldn't.
![Bass singers subharmonic compilation [Bb1-B0]](/img/n.gif)
Oh yeah!! There are so many talented people in this compilation! Thank you so much for the reaction!🙏🏼 13:25 Yes, you are right! There are two of me singing 😂 And also because you asked for a video, I would recommend my Aberdeen (Avi Kaplan) Cover. It is a live performance where I sing and play guitar. Hope you like it!
You are amazing!!! 💓💓💓
Haha hey man this is superb and yes I will check it out
🇹🇷
you are in the comments on all the bass singing vids i watch. like bruh. u are awesome tho and i would love to be able to go as love as you do but im not that good yet.
"I actually forgot I can do bass!" 😂 I think it's a really easy thing to forget when you're listening to these bass beasts. 😂
Hahaha so true
Oh he did it
I did!!
Yesss finally! 😂 Glad you got to watch this video, there's some really great people featured in here. 👌🏻❤️
And yeah, Efe is a BEAST! We have some really hidden talents in the BSN 😂❤️
Hahaha hey man
Awesome!!! Finally you got to hear all of these subharmonic monsters😄
Next please react to „Bass Singer Low Notes ( D2-Bb0 )“ by NTanzar.
If I’m not mistaken, David Larson taught Geoff subs
Really?
@@QofyReacts haha I believe so. Geoff literally just released another video talking about bass and he mentioned Larson several times.
Not directly, but he learned via watching David’s tutorials.
@@evansbat yeah that’s what I meant haha I didn’t make it clear
Bro please, react to Tim Storms - Lonesome Road (ALPHA STREAM)
You can also react to "Mega low bass notes, Steve Cross's lowest notes"
Yes another lonesome road. I’ve been begging for about a month
I’ll check them out
@@iancorrigan9758
I have a lot of back logged requests so will get to it soon
All good qofy. You are a busy man. Love the content
Hey man, didn't expect this video, great reaction. The russian names that you saw like Pavel Myakotin are actually russian Oktavists, a choral role in russian orthodox music. You should really check out a video by the amazing "TheOktavismChannel" with the title: "The Power Of The Russian Oktavist"...now imagine all of these low notes, but live without microphones and still the same power, clarity and projection. Simply put, the lowest of the low, truly unnatural and very beautiful musical pieces too!
I know they are crazy low. Odd fact Avi Kaplan's ethnic background according to him is Russian Jew
Hey George thank you I will check it out
@@gailseatonhumbert9199 I didn't know that, thanks for the info man! Avi is one of my favourite singers in general, absolutely stunning voice, and great personality too!
To answer your question at 3:24, subharmonics have a "ringing" to them, especially above G#1 due to their unusually rich harmonic content a full octave above the fundamental. Below, the ring slowly turns into a "rumble" put the upper harmonics are still very present. BTW, that's why some subs like F#1 typically sound so loud since F#2 is a low note below G#2 (whose sub is thus below G#1) that most bass singer can sing loud.
Chest notes tend to sound "fuller", warmer because there are way more frequencies filling the gap between the note sung and the resulting sub. Since those upper harmonics tend to decrease smoothly in amplitude as you get further from the fundamental, you don't hear the "ringing".
Hope this makes sense... ultimately you'll develop a better intuition for subs by hearing the same singer (especially if that singer is you) sing the same note in chest THEN subharmonics and learning to differentiate the two sounds. Thou Yang (the guy at 2:41, 5:10, 12:28 ) has a whole series of subharmonics tutorials with auxiliary exercises and science-based explanations here: th-cam.com/video/oJfP1471Rgg/w-d-xo.html
Ok, I might be bias, but to me the best is Geoff, for his tone, hold and range!
Dan M. is pretty good, and holds his low a long time! Efe Sayin sounds like he was doing overtones, amazing!
Surprised not to see Tim Foust or Avi Kaplan here. Maybe they don't do subharmonics?
Avi and Tim don't do Subharmonics. They use other techniques though, especially Tim, the master of the Growl as many people call him.
I know Tim can go subterranean low (and also pretty high!), that's why I wondered about him not being listed. But you explained it, thanks!
@@alexwalker8440 No problem man, personally though i think that Ken Turner is one of the masters in Subharmonics, he just uses them like J.D Sumner would use his regular voice to reach the range of E1-C1. Absolute beast, and he is 86 years old i believe! David Khan is a close second certainly, his live C1 (it's on his channel) from the Elvis concert is incredible. But Thou Yang and David Larson are the current kings in extended techniques like that, they are basically on a pedestal for us in the Bass Community :)
Subharmonics are some of my favourite notes to do because 1. They sound awesome and unique. 2 they sound more computer generated .and 3 they have a unique feeling in your throat when you make the sound that feels kinda cool
It’s so cool Joe haha
YESSS! Also you hit Eb1 fry lol
Hahah yes Josh I did!!
Tim Foust can do subharmonics. He did with VP in Just Sing. It just isn't his choice of technique. I think Geoff is the king of this technique.
11:54 I mean, yeah! Its a very shakey fry, but its defenetly a Eb1!
Hahah I hit it !
Here's the difference between Tomi's subharmonic A1 and his chest A1. The subharmonic A1 sounds like there are 2 notes stacked on top of each other: a great A ( an A2 ) on top, and a contra A ( an A1 ) on the bottom. With the chest A1, you notice there is only one note, an A1. Also another thing to note, compared to the subharmonic low A, you can hear the note literally drop when he switches to chest, actually almost feel it drop. There's your answer to how they're different.
why bobby waters is not present ??? he's super bass too. and he will be able to sing to B0 too
He’ll be in part 2 of “bass singers subharmonic compilation” when I get around to it. I know Bobby now and he is CRAZY
13:22 Thats what subharmonics is, to reach the first subharmonic you sing the octave above in chest voice (here it would be the D2 you here him go up to), but subharmonics involves adding in some neck tension/fry that produces a strong note 1 octave down (the D1 here). This is a very simplified explanation but thats the basics of how this is different to simply hitting notes using chest or vocal fry
Very interesting
I am not a bass singer, but a chest note is when you sing in your range where you'd normally sing and subharmonic is when you relax your voice to go an octave below, hope this answered the question :)
I love how at the end we almost only see Efe Sayin (and sometimes Ken Turner) singing E1, D1, C#1, C1, B0 and the other singers get rarer and rarer as we get closer to B0 😄
I think you are right that at 13:20 he is doing the D2 and D1 separately and editing them on top of each other, however it is possible with subharmonics to sing both at the same time! It's because subharmonics are done by singing an octave above and then doing a fry in a specific way to drop it down, so if you do the fry lightly it can sound like both at once. It's similar to overtones but going lower instead of higher. Also at 4:37 David is doing whats called the 2nd subharmonic, notice how he jumps down an octave and does the regular subharmonic but then he jumps down again without a pause. He has videos on his channel explaining whats going on and how to do it. Would definitely recommend watching his videos on growl and other techniques as well!
Ahh that’s interesting
Love your videos and reactions man also when you get to the Bb and Eb the little b is called flat,so it’s be Bb1-is B flat so that’s what the little b’s are but love your videos man keep up the great work💙💙
Oh man that’s very helpful thanks for that
@@QofyReacts don’t worry about it man,keep making great videos💙
The b actually stands for flat, Eb is actually the same as D#
Thanks for point that out for me! I appreciate you
Check out all reactions 😊 :
BSN : th-cam.com/play/PLBxxPN1NmvZo1gGy3BkF-VTJsSy5wpXvk.html
VoicePlay : th-cam.com/play/PLBxxPN1NmvZrhlsxR5FzhkK8LpCk16SYi.html
So while I was searching some music today I found Broadway male slaying high notes blimey I didn't no there was so many out there maybe check it out qofy great reaction 😊
Haha maybe during a livestream
@@QofyReacts sounds good to me when is the next one are you brightening our weekend up this weekend 🤗
@@mazcolyer1972
Yes I am
@@QofyReacts woohoo can't wait I wonder if we get any news of Jonathan haha 😂
Subharmonics are the sound created by strohbass/chest fry, and they're essentially the same technique, the problem is the nomenclature haha
🤩💥
QofyReacts you need to learn subharmonics man, but it depends on you and your range ofcourse because it can hurt your vocal cords due to the placement being low but it is easy to learn, for me, I do watch Geoff's vid about subharmonics and his other video too. Really helpful but just remember to not strain the vocal cords and maintain good health also. Subharmonic note is the octave below the original like singing A2 down to A1, that's subharmonic while the vocal fry or chest fry, a thick or heavy note with popping sound I think but with consistency. Most subharmonic are drop notes but vocal fry is made by singing lower or like climbing down.
Hahaha you’re getting me to be a bass
I would win all the contests so I’ll step down for these guys
Still the most beautiful range in all of existence, even if some timbres are objectively warmer than others.
You’re so right Rose how are you it’s been a while
@@QofyReacts Eh... I've been better. Lots of health and mental health stuff going on. But videos like yours help a little 😌
@@RosheenQuynh
I hope you get better
@@QofyReacts Me too, I am gonna have to tetanus shot and go to the dentist soon (AND my mom and I are supposed to be moving, too)... 😭 So stressful...
If I could do subharmonics, I’d do it in front of my crush all the time 😂😂
how people know the difference between subharmonic and chest is there is a slight different sound and you cant slide from chest to subharmonic without a small jump but once you are in subharmonic you can slide
Ahh thanks for the insight
Where was Tim fouts?
He doesn’t use subharmonics.
Yhup what he said
11:53 Eb1... New low, updated range is Eb1-D6
That's pretty Impressive
Haha thank you
But not really useable
How come that the same "notes" sounds to me "better" by some of the singers when they are the same ones. I am confused by myself in this 😶
Hello Qofy it's your BFF, Lea!
Hey Lea how are you!
@@QofyReacts doing good how are you? Husband is recovering well from surgery and my grandson has started playing baseball and is doing great so far. His first game was today and the won. Yay🎉🎆⚾️✨
@@leapatterson2014
That’s great news!
@@QofyReacts yes very exciting! How are things in Qofy land? Are you teaching in person or by zoom/Skype? How is your family?
How can it be a video about bass without Tim Foust and Avi Kaplan?
Its Subharmonic Bass which neither Avi nor Tim does. Its a different type of bass.
@@QofyReacts Strange. I can't hear the difference between all the different ways. But I know I have read and seen videos that Tim does subharmonic.
@@MarielleSweden He uses chest fry and growl techniques like a monster - Tim's amazing. No subharmonics, though. Subharmonics are a very specific, very difficult to master technique. Chest fry fits more with his style of music - subharmonics probably wouldn't.
4th haha 😂
Haha love you
@@QofyReacts love you 🤗
First
Parabéns ae man
Thank you