ไม่สามารถเล่นวิดีโอนี้
ขออภัยในความไม่สะดวก
Author DEFENDS Stealing Everyone’s Stuff...Except the Author’s Stuff
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ส.ค. 2024
- One way to show an idea is a bad one is to see if it self-destructs. Some ideas sound good in theory but don’t work in practice.
In this video, we show that Vicky Osterweil’s book self-destructs in three ways. One, it argues against other people’s property rights while using copyright law to protect the author’s property rights. Two, it rejects property rights because they support racism while appealing to intellectual property rights, thus promoting racism. Three, it condemns capitalism-“We would be able to live without a wage if we freely shared the products of society [16]”-but then affirms capitalism in practice since the book is not “freely shared with society” but rather sells for a tidy little profit at the easy-to-find capitalist mega-monster….Amazon!
Over and over, Osterweil undermines the Marxist case by doing the very things the book says shouldn’t be done. In other words, Osterweil’s actions contradict her convictions.
SUPPORT THE WORK OF RPL: www.str.org/re...
Follow Red Pen Logic with Mr. B:
Facebook: / redpenlogic
Twitter: / redpenlogic
Instagram: / redpenlogic
Follow Stand to Reason:
TH-cam: / strvideos
Facebook: / standtoreaso. .
Twitter: / strtweets
I once worked in a specialty retail store where a guy was insisting on a discount. He said, "I took a class and my professor said to never pay full price on anything".
My co-worker said (without missing a beat), "How much did you pay for the class? Did you get a refund?"
That's brilliant! I wonder how that entitled customer would react if his employer told him "We're cutting your paycheck by 20% because we stopped believing in paying full price for your labor."
I wouldn’t steal Vicky’s “intellectual” property if my life depended on it. 😂
Hahah right though
Hey, after the looting has stopped, would you want her book to help light that fire needed to stay warm in the winter?
I see what you did there. Well played.
You have an extra adjective in there.
Did the Nazis steal the "politically incorrect" books before they burned them? What's the difference between looting these days, and the looting of non aryan owned possessions in previous Nazi eras. (Don't be a "fool" don't work, just steal!).
Decent people work and share, Nazis and other fools steal.
The thief's argument: "All your stuff is mine. All my stuff is mine."
Isn't that in the toddler's rule book?🤣
Dang that sounds like my wife's argument. 😂
I would pay actual money to hear the author respond to this video.
Its not hard to imagine....
RACIST!
WHITE SUPREMACIST!
CHECK YOUR PRIVILAGE!
HATE SPEACH!
Did I miss anything?
@@OpheliaLightfoot yeah, things that don’t hold up in court. I’d love to see her take this guy to court and get laughed at by the judge.
@@Hannodb1961 Misogynist
@@Kenny.G63 You forgot "Islamophobic."
Pay her, with someone else’s money you mean…
Author: "It's okay to take property"
Also author:
*reverse uno card*
Classic.
Hahaha that's awesome
Her morality is subjective, as in, subject to her conditions.
Lolyes
Not sure how much you know about the "Author" but "Vicky" is biologically a male. Once I found that out, the narrative started to come together for me & I realized that the book is only good to use for kindling.
@@trishash79 good to know. Thank you
@@trishash79 Bindings don't always burn well. They need to be broken up and aerated.
@Ashley Hill so he's stupid then alright
Basically, stealing is okay, and wealth is bad. Unless you’re stealing my stuff, or taking my wealth. Rules for thee, but not for me. Ladies and gentlemen, hypocrisy at its finest.
It actually is saying something about the author, not just her ideas - and that's ok. It reveals her as a hypocrite.
This only not revealed who the author is, let’s not forget the author write this in behalf of the ppl who support looting and who are looting. Their ideas doesn’t make any sense but to practice human heart evilness they will come up with any non-sense in defense of it.
Its actually a he they're a part of the confused alphabet squad
@@Alden-Smithyup facts
Many are against private property until someone wants to take their cell phone...
Thank you for addressing this topic. It wasn't an obviously religious topic, but good or bad thinking doesn't have to be explicitly religious either. Great stuff!
“Thou shalt not steal” is religious.
@@IAmisMaster lolyes
@@IAmisMaster That phrase may come from the Bible, but there is not a single society in the world, including Marxist societies, where that statement against stealing is not codified into law.
During the Cultural Revolution in China, as well as in the Bolshevek revolution that created the Soviet Union, property was either destroyed or redistrubuted through legal means. It was not through illegal looting. Stealing for selfish reasons was still punishable.
@@kevinnelson6790 When do you think your conscience comes in? Where do you think your conscience comes from?
@@IAmisMaster Right...but those words were never spoken, so it wasn't "obviously religious", which is exactly what I said.
Vicky Osterweil: according to a book I wrote, you deserve free things or you’re a racist!
Me: can I have your book for free then?
VO: *surprised Pikachu face*
What is Vicky Osterwell's address? Time to loot... she clearly has too much time and money. ;-)
Kevin Nelson we would be racist not to 😂
Ah a fellow Hoskins 👍
Its a he they're a part of the confused alphabet squad, which makes sense why he wrote the book
I really hope he didn't have to suffer reading through this whole thing. That would be too much of a punishment
Here is a real story when the communists once came to power. It happened in Russia after 1917, after an illegal coup and a bloody civil war. The communist slogan was "factories to the workers, land to the peasants". But when they came to power, they simply confiscated private property, including from the workers and the peasants. And those who were against,they simply sent to working camps. Sometimes even after someone else's false accusation. As a result, it damaged seriously the food system in the country and caused a mass famine in the 1930s, which touched about 60% of population of the USSR, some of whom, several million people, died. Thought before the revolution, Russia had about 40% of world grain export. Even though years after the communist government achieved some success in industry and technology ect, like spaceflight (also the Ussr played probably the most important role in fighting fascism in the WWII). But that success didn't last long and it ended with an economic crisis and fall of the Ussr. Also the same success could be done in Russia without any revolution or "building communism", just like it was done let's say in the US. If not communists, Russia would be most likely the second largest economy in the world. But it's only somewhere 8-10th place now. Thought before the revolution Russian economic was one of the most fast-growing in the world. The revolution 1917 ruined it and the communists in power was the biggest tragedy that happened with Russia the last centuries. Hope people in other countries will not repeat those mistakes.
Today's Marxists are so focused on today's narrative they have no clue they are endorsing failed systems of yesteryear. They have no sense nor appreciation of history. They are pawns of those hungry for illegitimate wealth and power.
That’s what happens when we don’t know history. Thank you love your comment
In other words, atheist communists became far worse than the previous rulers. Imagine my shock.
@@kevinnelson6790 Or worse, they know the history but don't care. They will kill people for power.
Similar famines happened in every country communists took over. The number of who starved in China is unknown, but it could be as many as 50 million.
So basically, the guy wants communism, but not for himself? LOOOOOOOOOOOOOL
Like every communist.
@RetroMan ohhhhhhhh. Yep. I shouldn't be surprised, lol
💜 *What an AWESOME way to start my Wednesday morning!! Hope you are well Tim =) God bless ALL my Brother's and Sister's out there* 💜🤗💜
Thanks a lot for the upload. Can't help but recall Romans 1:28 'And even as they did not like to retain God in their knowledge, God gave them over to a debased mind, to those things which are not fitting'. (NKJV) -> Holy God: Thou shall not steal , Debased mind: Thou shalt loot
Great point!
The greatest injustice of our time is that the day after this book came out her property wasn't looted and destroyed.
Just discovered your channel and I’m obsessed. Thank you for actually offering information for free ;)
Great topic 👍🏽👍🏽
Society as we know it would collapse if this nonsense was taken seriously.
And yet, the Democrat party uses these ideas every day-Bernie and Warren supporters do so, loudly and AOC does so on her videos regularly.
You have absolutely lovely facial expressions.
His facial expressions are a complete theatrical production.
This channel will have over 100k subscribers in no time. It’s too good!!!
Pretty sure ownership of property of some sort is a universal human characteristic. Heck, even animals defend the food they've hunted or gathered.
Thank you Mr. B - her idea is a millstone hung around her brain. lol
Poor Vicky🤦🏽♂️🤦🏽♂️
I love how you are quoting everything you say is in the book, and it is clear you read it through with all these quotes you can pull. If only others treated us with such respect and careful reading, well we wouldn't have any who disagree with us honestly anymore.
Just waltz up to her house and start looting.
See how quickly she changes her tune.
Amazon charges $28 for this garbage? I wouldn't pick it up even if they offered to pay me for reading it, let alone pay $28 for it
the 1 dislike must be from Vicky Osterweil
Fantastic! I laughed so hard. An excellent rebuttal, brother.
In other words, "Loot my enemies house. Not others like me, we're your allies."
That's called "Shooting oneself in the foot'.
Keep up the great work Tim! God bless your ministry!
"Vicky" used to be Willie Osterweil. That should have been red flag enough.
Damnn! People are entertaining stupid ideas in their heads and trying to implement them in society.
The only dislike from this video is probably from the author. Lol
Now it's 4, from the looters.
Bad ideas are also backed up with bad rhetoric to try to shut down opposition. Anyone who dares call them out or merely disagrees with them is readily endowed with a plethora of slanderous titles and attributes.
Mr. B- Could you please write this up as a review on the book's Amazon page? Maybe even just upload the video as a video review!
Vicky disliked this video...clearly.
So I'm a black, white supremacist because I want to own a home (private property) and be an entrepreneur? 🤯
😂There is no such thing as blind faith 🤣God bless you brother 🙏😇🐑🦁
28 dolllarz?? 😳 That is theft.
Nice Capturing Christianity hat in the background
Oh boy! The author has got some serious internal inconsistencies that he needs to address.
You get to know what a person TRULY thinks about private property when that person's property rights are threatened!
I saw you at the Reality Conference in McKinney Texas recently and have been subscribed to your channel since. Great content...thank you.
"I accidentally wrote a book that showed my hypocrisy"
Reminds of 21 jump street.
"Are you a Narc?"
"You know who calls people Narcs? Narcs Narc."
I love how Mike winger put it: when you see someone with a wacky worldview, challenge them to live it out.
Go to her house with her book and start taking her things, and when she gets mad point to her book.
There was a saying in the Marine Corps that went, "there's only one thief in the Marine Corps, the rest of us are just trying to get our stuff back."
Did anyone else start dying of laughter when they saw "White supremacy" when they talked about property rights?
Wow! People doesn't know what's right and wrong anymore. The author, making excuse for looting is unbelievable. I wonder if she would get cancelled 🤔
so if I break into vickys house to "redistribute" her things would she call the police or just let me have my new stuff?
Please continue to make more content. I am sharing this on my LinkedIn page. Professionals need to hear this as well. The am constantly interacting with degreed individuals who are not clearly thinking about issues. Well done!
I wonder if this crossed her mind while writing the book?
So well done!
"You can't LOOT your cake and eat it too!"
Welp, I need to move out my house😔 it’s private property and I’m black. I can’t believe I’m supporting white supremacy by owning a house
I once asked a Communist the following question: "You've won! Congratulations on seizing the means of production. Now who gets to steal it from you?"
I don't think I'll ever get an answer back on that one.
No wonder they want the police abolished.
Well stated: Excellent presentation.
The only looting is to victims who paid money for that trash.
I love your channel. I hope to see it grow!
We should all go into every single bookstore that sells this book and steal all of them
Where does she live? I'm ready to go to her house and "shop for free."
The fact that Christianity grafted itself onto earlier pagan worship was part of the design of the church fathers. Pagan elements were incorporated into the Christian faith on the advice of Pope Gregory the Great, who told Saint Augustine of Canterbury that rather than tear down the pagan temples in Britain, he should instead add existing pagan rituals into the mix of Christian practices, thus providing an easy transition to the new religion.Christians stole Chriastmas, Easter and Halloween from the Pagans, Catholics can add Fasting, (Lent) to the list. Unfortunately, some of the most basic things believed by most professing Christians derive from ancient paganism rather than from the Bible. The idea that people have immortal souls was first taught in ancient Egypt and Babylon. The Greeks likewise taught that at death the soul would separate from the physical body (Jewish Encyclopedia, 1941, Vol. 6, pp. 564, 566, "Immortality of the Soul"). That idea was merged into Christianity from Greek philosophy. It did not come from inspired Scripture. The ancient Egyptians developed the concept of going to heaven. In their mythology, the god Osiris was killed but then raised back to life, whereupon he went to a distant heavenly realm. The Egyptians concluded that if he could do this, then human beings could follow (Lewis Browne, This Believing World, pp. 83-84). This heavenly reward was a central teaching of several ancient mystery religions-but not the religion of the Hebrews or early Christians. TALK ABOUT THEFT! CHRISTIANITY TAKES THE CAKE!!!
Wow such a brilliant epic shout out "fail" thanks Dr B 👍
I love your honesty. Please keep these videos coming.
How can this lady write about freely sharing things when she defends freely taking things? I guess it’s much easier to take other people’s stuff than share it. That in itself shows how destructive her Marxist ideas are. If she really wants to change the world, she should give away the money she made from the book to the less privileged.
There are a quote that works perfectly for this "you can't baked a cake and eat it too" he had a keep his idealism or get money you can't have both
1. Looting brings down businesses.
2. Destroyed businesses don't produce new stuff.
3. Shortages of stuff ensue.
4. Less business, less jobs.
5. Everyone becomes poor.
6. Community property not enough to go around.
7. People dependent on government assistance.
8. Not enough taxpayers to support government.
9. Society fails.
Or how about we stick with private property, capitalism, rewarding hard work, freedom and opportunity? Maybe expose and discourage wasteful spending and corruption? Maybe encourage the wealthy and profitable companies to find new ways to help the poor and homeless? Expecting a corrupt government system to do it isn't the answer. Private companies and wealthy people should see their successes as a way to help others. There can be a redistribution of wealth, but it shouldn't come from the government, or by allowing the poor to steal without consequence...it should come from the generosity of those in a position to do something about it.
The American dream shouldn't have the end goal of a $40 million mansion, 6 summer homes, 4 yachts, a private island, a custom RV, 17 cars and a leer jet. Nice house? Sure, how about $4 million? Summer homes? How about one and make any others B&Bs that can generate profits for fighting homelessness? And on down the line, reevaluate. Is it excess for excess's sake? Or is it a necessity for some reason? I think about what I would do if I won $150 million in the lottery. I'd live on about 5% and use the other 95% to help others, individuals, ministries, charities, etc., balancing some outright payments and investments that generate perpetual income to give to those causes. The selfishness our society promotes needs to change. Change that and you change the world.
"Do as I say...not as I do."
Great logic! This video makes me think that you’ve read Greg Koukl’s book Tactics! 👍🏼
Thanks for this!
Well done !
Im surprised that someone could even publish that!
Well in this time it is not a surprise.
She should go and live in Cuba and tell that not to the population but to the governent.
Author: "it's ok to take property"
Me: *buys the book and redistribute it with a lower price*
Wow.... Just wow, I really wonder if she knows this lol
Seriously, how does one best get trained in the ways of the Red Pen? And then, once those skills have been acquired, how does one make money with them?
Step one, read up or study logic and philosophy. I would recommend a few books:
1. _Logic_ by Wesley Salmon
2. _A Textbook of Logic_ by Alexander Wolf
3. _Lessons of History_ by Will and Ariel Durant
4. _What is the Name of This Book?_ by Raymond Smullyan
5. _Mere Christianity_ by C.S. Lewis
6. _Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman_ by Richard Feynman (Caution: Feynman is not always a good moral example)
7. _Surprised by Joy; The Shape of My Early Life_ by C.S. Lewis
8. _Tactics_ by Gregory Koukl
9. _Apologia_ by Plato (a Socratic Dialog)
So, those would give you a start in the art. A couple of philosophy courses would also help, and field work arguing with atheists in youtube comments makes for good practical application.
Fallacy Detective. :)
The idea of property common to all is great in theory but impossible in practice. It simply fails to take into account people’s natural greed.
I wonder if she is taking the money from her book sales.
When you embrace cognitive dissonance as a foundation of reality, you get crazy.
I'm sure Vicky donates all the proceeds from her book to the poor, having already given away all her worldly goods.
Great content brother in Christ, thank you!!
Sorry Vicky, you can't have your cake and steal others too! 😉
🎂👀
Vicki used to be Willie. You can find the book with covers showing either as the author.
The thing is that Marxists come in two categories: Useful Idiots, and Barbarians. Useful Idiots get whisked up in utopian dreams of everyone sharing and destroying evil oppressors, while the Barbarians lead them on with broken logic and ideology. The author of this book is a Barbarian, and she wrote it so more useful idiots would take to the streets. Thanks for the video, it’s always funny to see this stuff completely fall apart, and I love your style!
Just found your channel... thumbs up Mr.B👍🏻 Jesus is LORD!
Just found this channel today and I've been watching all the videos on my TV then going to my phone so I can like and comment on them, haha
Surely we can just go into a store and take every copy of this book and then leave without paying, going by the books claims?
Oh wow... these folks use the thesaurus until it's worn out when they write these books
As Bahnsen loved to point out: look for inconsistency and incoherency and you've found fallacy.
As a side note, does looting/stealing ever become a "wrong"? For instance, in someone "justifiably" steals something how many times can that same thing subsequently be stolen before it becomes unjustifiable? There's almost always someone worse off, someone who is a greater "victim." Is the ideal world the one in which all property is moved from the hands of literally the richest people into the hands of literally the poorest? 🤦🏻 The logic is absurd. And what happens when the property eventually falls far enough down the line to someone who is unable to extract value from the property due to ignorance, mismanagement, or even property destruction? Again, absurd and defeating in so many ways.
I think it’s also interesting to say lotting is distributing wealth to the poor but they seem to miss the fact that small businesses are not necessarily wealthy, they just have enough money to own the store and they could very well not be well off. By looting small businesses they are taking from the not wealthy to give to the not wealthy. Lmk in the replies if I’m saying something wrong or weirdly pls!
I'm getting ready this week to help a buddy in the DR Congo buy some land for a school he'll be building. Both buyer and seller are black. (and I'm not white).
I just have one question: who are the white supremacists here, and how did they got involved in this land ownership deal!?
..asking for a buddy.
this is probobly one of the 3 channels that i can instantly like without watching the video
This person is most literally everyone who was in support of all those riots involving a lot of looting and property damage a while back (you know what I'm talking about). They were encouraging them, but the moment the mobs came for their homes they wanted them to stop.
The one dislike is the author
Author of the book, or author of the video?
At least Abbie Hoffman's book was called "Steal this Book" and had consistency of logic.
I did not need a video on something so doggone obviously stupid. This is more funny than educational.
"Vicky" is a man called William.
Page 16 made me lol
It is actually ridiculous that someone whould write a book like that.