I was only just thinking that about their expressions being spot on, and I see your comment from 10 minutes ago, watching at the same time even though this is an old video. And yes, a great scene :)
@@jamessky9155 Absolutely! Carrie and Samantha look embarrassed, but Miranda looks furious because she was the one was with Charlotte after finding out she couldn't have children at her Dr's appointment.
Speaking frankly I would never ever make my friends to witness such a scene and go through this embarrassment. No matter how close we are, it’s absolutely unacceptable
@@SuperBrianMak They were talking about her other friend, Susan Sharon, who was only on the show a couple times. Her husband was fighting with her in front of Carrie and yelled at her. And then with this with Charlotte and Trey.
This reminds me of when Carrie was at her friend's apartment and she got into a fight with her husband. Poor Carrie whispered "good night Grumpy" as he chased her out cursing
It's ok to try to make her laugh and maybe not be so sad about it all the time, but once he saw that this really wasn't the way to go he should have just apologize and let it be...
@@sweetluvgurl I don't know. Not me, but someone for sure. There are a lot of different people out there and you should know what your partner will or won't take as a joke.
He saw how his wife was all sad, depressed and angry because they couldn't have a baby and that she didn't take kindly to being allowed to try. And your only way to make her feel better is to give her a cardboard baby? It was extremely insensitive.
Not really, Harry told Charlotte since she was not-jewish she was only good sleep with but not marry, and coerced her into changing religion. He didn't even get Charlotte a new home and instead moved into the one Trey bought Charlotte.
@@C-eo1rt That's a weird way to put it... I'm not religious at all, but I guess that religion can be as important as a life pattern. Would you marry someone who has a different opinion about having children from yours? Or about spousal roles, work, life in general... For some people there are unnegotiable views that, if ignored, can actually break a couple. That's what makes a partner love material, but not marriage material. Plus, she loved that house that Trey left her. It's not that she hated it and Harry forced to live there... It was THEIR choise.
@@24Lorn Harry wanted a Jewish wife because he wanted "jewish" kids. The thing is Harry wasn't even a practicing Jew. Charlotte was a practicing Christian. Charlotte gave up her religion, belief in Jesus and provided Harry a home. What did Harry give up?
This episode was on the " E " TV Station last night. Although I've seen it many times before, I was so intent on watching this scene last night, between their dialogue & their body language, that I lmao'd so much and so loudly! 😂😂😂😂😂
@@C-eo1rthe didn’t make her do anything. She chose to change her religion because of her love for him. He didn’t force her to change her religion. He let her go because he didn’t want her to feel forced to do anything and because she wasn’t Jewish which was a big deal to his family for some reason because apparently a Jew shouldn’t or can’t marry a non Jew which is poppycock
I mostly like trey saying oops came Bargin in on charlottes having friends dinners night together. . I just like charlotte’s friends just pause for her Trey talking them Aww and Poor charlottes she has opinions does like wow. It’s kinda big fight
I want them to bring Trey back. The possible storylines would be hilarious. I mean what happens to a Mama's boy when Mama gets old and dies? Who is Trey now? I honestly thought Trey and Charlotte looked so cute together I was really pulling for them. They made me laugh too, much more so than the dude she ended up with who is just boring. Trey was sweet even if he had no backbone. The cardboard "flat baby" was funny. Bring Trey and Charlotte back.
How rude of her to dismiss him like that in front of her friends. Clearly he meant no harm by giving her that cardboard baby and her screaming out about his manhood is way out of line. Obviously her friends would know her fertility problems but I doubt Trey would think Charlotte would be telling them about his impotence problem.
After watching these women for years I find them all selfish and self absorbed. They only thing did that Sam was up front about it instead of pretending
It's not just that, he doesn't put her first he puts his mother first , this his family won't even accept an adopted kid in the family , he was never okay with the idea of fixing his penis problems, he treated her as his mistress or lover for a while ........I mean she loved him but he broke her heart slowly
She wanted to get everything she wanted and no hardship or compromise to exist. That s not a marriage. A marriage is together for bettee or worse. She also made decisions on her own, like her Chinese baby idea.
Because parenthood is one of the things that you just can't "compromise" on. If two spouses don't want the same thing, one will resent the other for the rest of their lives. Having children and being a father/mother can be one of the deepest, harshest and desperate desires of a person's life. It's a kind of love you just can't replace. If you live the tragedy of wanting one and not being able to become a parent, you spend your days mourning the absence of those children that never came to life. And that's totally legit. As much not wanting them for any reason imaginable is totally legit, too. One big mistake many people do is getting married before having this very important conversation. It's VITAL, for a couple who want to be together for the rest of their lives. Charlotte and Trey got married before knowing each other in so many different contexts... One of them was parenthood.
Okay. Cardboard baby: not funny. This fight: very funny. 😂😆
I thought the cardboard baby was so fucking hilarious 😂😂😂😂
agree the fight was funny
@@mjparadero7046 it was horrible. Not funny at all.
" Without the baby , they're all I have " aww Charlotte
🥺
plus the cute clanking of her heels on the floor! 🥹
Samantha’s face when trey walks in gets me every time lmaoooo she’s so shook
Yeah, she was not expecting Trey to walk in hearing her explicit words 😂🤣🤣
Whoopsss😂
Love this scene. Carrie, Miranda, and Samantha in silence showing Trey they are TEAM CHARLOTTE all the way. Great friends.
It's so uncomfortable when a couple is fighting and they try and drag you into it lol
It’s so messed up that he thought it was ok to make fun of her not being able to conceive, but how dare she mention his impotence! #MaleEgo
Preach! A cardboard flacid penis! Love Charlotte.
Vale Sauce Harry was the lucky one, she is too beautiful for him !
Mm tAm the fact that Charlotte said as much to Harry lessens her in my eyes
Trey's weird.
The cardboard baby was hilarious 🤣😂🤣😂
*“Carrie... you’re funny!”* -She’s looking at him like don’t bring me into this Trey 🤣
Triangulation
What kind of an idiot gives a cardboard baby to a woman trying to have a kid??
A trey type of guy.
Trey seemed a little socially awkward.
A grown man who bathes in front of his mother.
Him. And he is a major idiot. I dint think he ever wanted marriage. Or babies.
@@Leelz247 😂
This scene is perfectly done. They are all beautiful, and the editing captured their expressions very well.
I was only just thinking that about their expressions being spot on, and I see your comment from 10 minutes ago, watching at the same time even though this is an old video. And yes, a great scene :)
@@jamessky9155 Yes, I watch their roundtable scenes from time to time. I love evesdropping on their opinions about things.
@@jamessky9155 Absolutely! Carrie and Samantha look embarrassed, but Miranda looks furious because she was the one was with Charlotte after finding out she couldn't have children at her Dr's appointment.
I fell out when Trey yelled “GOOD” to Carrie 😂
How uncomfortable for the ladies... urgh
Speaking frankly I would never ever make my friends to witness such a scene and go through this embarrassment. No matter how close we are, it’s absolutely unacceptable
I love that Richard calls during the fight . 😂 The dinner party is just unraveling at lightening speed.
😂
Carrie is wearing a beautiful dress!
Seriously, what was Trey thinking? He's asking Charlotte's friends, of course they're going to take her side!
And then Trey morphed into Orson Hodge and moved to Wisteria Lane.
It’s wild how similar their storylines are, from the controlling mothers to the conservative traditional wives to the never having children.
🤣
I enjoyed his portrayal of Orson Hodge. Orson was the best husband Bree ever had.
@@BellesView Her last husband, the time traveler was the best husband.
Her first husband was better than Orson.
@@BellesView Until he turned into a murderer lol
"We're wasps. Wasps don't yell, it's genetic," is the cringiest thing Charlotte's probably ever said.
Cringy...Yes. I do get what she is meaning. I like how it ends up showing that stereotype, stereotyping in general, is BS.
Northern Protestant Wasps don't yell maybe. Southern Wasps can yell like there's no tomorrow on top of talking behind your back.
English is not my first language, what do wasps mean in the context of Charlotte's words?
@@ТаянаС-л9ы White Anglo-Saxon Protestant.
But they yelled like hell at the end lol
This scene was so chaotic 😂 loved it
"GOOD!!"
Carrie's reaction🤣
It was horrible. It felt very real. Good show.
When they broke up I cried so bad because I remembered what is like to have a failed marriage ....
Miranda and Samantha’s faces after 😭😭😂😂😂
When Trey says "it's silly, it's silly" it's so wrong😂
Trey was either closeted or in love with his mother
I would say a mix of both
She isn’t in love with his mum at all
Trey was probably still breast-fed.
He seen like a guy who could get it up for prostitution
He had Madonna/whore complex
"We're WASPS! We don't yell." 🤣
“Don’t you bring that FLAT BABY in here I will kill you 😂😂
Yea right lol
Poor Carrie.. The husbands of her friends always yell at her. 😂💖
I don't think Steve or Harry ever yelled at Carrie.
@@SuperBrianMak They were talking about her other friend, Susan Sharon, who was only on the show a couple times. Her husband was fighting with her in front of Carrie and yelled at her. And then with this with Charlotte and Trey.
@@sweetluvgurl Ahhh, gotcha. Thanks, forgot all about that one
@@sweetluvgurlher friend yelled at her because of her husband not the husband yelling at Carrie
2:30 Carrie’s face when trey said good ! 😳
"I gave Charlotte a cardboard baby! Isn't that funny?"
Carrie : Ex-fucking-cuse me??
Samantha : ??? 😊 ???
Miranda : Bitch wtf
This reminds me of when Carrie was at her friend's apartment and she got into a fight with her husband. Poor Carrie whispered "good night Grumpy" as he chased her out cursing
Who later became sweet to her friend aka his wife and to others because he had the dog to complain about instead 😂
Lmao it was funny when she said don't you bring that thing in here. Why was is still in the apartment to begin with 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
The scene is so funny! 😂
"without the baby they're all I've got!" 😆
It's ok to try to make her laugh and maybe not be so sad about it all the time, but once he saw that this really wasn't the way to go he should have just apologize and let it be...
That is a horrible thing to do to a woman who is having trouble conceiving. He should have run that one past someone other than his mommie
Who would even find that funny? Find something else to laugh about to take your mind off of it and not such a sensitive topic.
@@sweetluvgurl I don't know. Not me, but someone for sure. There are a lot of different people out there and you should know what your partner will or won't take as a joke.
He saw how his wife was all sad, depressed and angry because they couldn't have a baby and that she didn't take kindly to being allowed to try. And your only way to make her feel better is to give her a cardboard baby? It was extremely insensitive.
That shit was not funny but the girls reaction to leave was hilarious
Who would even think making fun of someone struggling to conceive is even funny? I was never a big fan of Trey. Harry is so much of a better man.
He is not making fun of that
Not really, Harry told Charlotte since she was not-jewish she was only good sleep with but not marry, and coerced her into changing religion. He didn't even get Charlotte a new home and instead moved into the one Trey bought Charlotte.
Trey wasn’t a bad person but he just wasn’t meant to be with Charlotte
@@C-eo1rt That's a weird way to put it... I'm not religious at all, but I guess that religion can be as important as a life pattern. Would you marry someone who has a different opinion about having children from yours? Or about spousal roles, work, life in general... For some people there are unnegotiable views that, if ignored, can actually break a couple. That's what makes a partner love material, but not marriage material.
Plus, she loved that house that Trey left her. It's not that she hated it and Harry forced to live there... It was THEIR choise.
@@24Lorn
Harry wanted a Jewish wife because he wanted "jewish" kids.
The thing is Harry wasn't even a practicing Jew. Charlotte was a practicing Christian.
Charlotte gave up her religion, belief in Jesus and provided Harry a home.
What did Harry give up?
the way samantha leaned back in her chair 😂😭
Trey thought is was funny.
"NO IT WASN'T!!" 😅😆
BxGirl Blazin' Trey’s a dumbass! Not funny at all!
BxGirl Blazin' It wasn't.
It was hilarious 😂
@@mjparadero7046 gurl u and me are the only ones who thought it was funny
1:36 CHARLOTTE’S EYE TWITCHED 😂
OMG that show was HILARIOUS!
All of them are so young and beautiful, great acting too especially from Sarah
He was so wrong for this. Yikes.
The ladies leaning in just as Trey was explaining the joke is the best visual gag ever😂
Kyle MacLachlan is so funny here lmao
Why is he trying to justify it? Good lord.
Totally emotionally stunted
This scene is amazing!
NO, IT WASN'T!
Tis fight was hilarious 😂
This episode was on the " E " TV Station last night. Although I've seen it many times before, I was so intent on watching this scene last night, between their dialogue & their body language, that I lmao'd so much and so loudly! 😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂😂 I just watched this episode on E today!
Sorry but Trey was hilarious; Kyle MacLaughlin plays wierd like a champ. 🤣
He’s a good actor so he could play almost any character really well
I love the look Miranda give him; without a word need she lets it be known he's a jackass for that stunt.
A cardboard baby was terrible taste and very insensitive.
I hated the writers for doing this to Charlotte 😭😭 Trey was horrible and she was so precious I was so glad when she finally got Harry
Why? Harry made her change religion and moved into the apartment Trey bought Charlotte.
@@C-eo1rthe didn’t make her do anything. She chose to change her religion because of her love for him. He didn’t force her to change her religion. He let her go because he didn’t want her to feel forced to do anything and because she wasn’t Jewish which was a big deal to his family for some reason because apparently a Jew shouldn’t or can’t marry a non Jew which is poppycock
Omg I can’t believe this is my first time seeing this scene! 😢😢😂
Charlotte’s hair is beautiful
I thought the cardboard baby was the funniest moment on SATC! 🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂
No. It wasnt
Yes it was
It’s painful to see this video
'GOOD!' 🤣
Love carrie's dress ❤
Damn everybody said Big was a jerk. SMH!
Oh I'm totally on Charlotte's side here.
I wonder what happened to the beef with Thai noodles. It sounded really yummy.
Poor Charlotte, no one supporting her whatsoever
Not a cardboard baby!?
Her little run lol
I mostly like trey saying oops came Bargin in on charlottes having friends dinners night together. . I just like charlotte’s friends just pause for her Trey talking them Aww and Poor charlottes she has opinions does like wow. It’s kinda big fight
God...Kim is beautiful here 😍
She's always beautiful!
@@jrwheeler81 Carrie is better. 🤓
"WASP nest" I just got that.
We are going to go .. Good! 😂😂😂
Great scene 😅
I always felt bad for him. It was tone deaf but he also meant well
The quality is horrible on this video.
I don’t think that Trey was trying to hurt Charlotte - he loves her genuinely and she was in her feelings.
Maybe if there was also a Stork
. - Oh wow... Talk about being in the wrong place at the wrong time.
that was horrible.
That's captain from HIMYM 🤣🤣
I want them to bring Trey back. The possible storylines would be hilarious. I mean what happens to a Mama's boy when Mama gets old and dies? Who is Trey now? I honestly thought Trey and Charlotte looked so cute together I was really pulling for them. They made me laugh too, much more so than the dude she ended up with who is just boring. Trey was sweet even if he had no backbone. The cardboard "flat baby" was funny. Bring Trey and Charlotte back.
1:46 BWAHAHAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Yes Charlotte, buy him that cardboard, actually, make them two, one for him and one for BUNNY!
Oh my that was funny..😂😂😂
Charlotte and Trey should've never been married. The fight is lame ans funny
I like how Trey is so determined to die on this hill
Id have told him that one of the most important things about comedy, is timing
"We're gonna go"
"Good!"
"No,it wasn't" was said in a Cruella Devill's way)
Trey: You rang?
I worked at the company that made flat baby. The first product they came out with was flat cat
Why doesn’t Trey just stop talking ? 🖐🏼
Trey lacks serious emotional intelligence.
Which season is this ?
Season 4 episode 13
How rude of her to dismiss him like that in front of her friends. Clearly he meant no harm by giving her that cardboard baby and her screaming out about his manhood is way out of line. Obviously her friends would know her fertility problems but I doubt Trey would think Charlotte would be telling them about his impotence problem.
Men will do mean nasty shit like then and call it funny lol
carrie is so annoying did she really have to say good night in the midst of that heated fight? the other ladies Irish-exited but not Carrie!
THIS is what you took from the video???? THIS bmis what you find bothersome??Smh
After watching these women for years I find them all selfish and self absorbed. They only thing did that Sam was up front about it instead of pretending
Trey …gay. Gay …gay.
Trey & his shovel
They are soo innocent.
Emasculate a man - get his apartment.
Holy shit
Imagine if trey wl come back to ajlt
I really can’t understand why a baby can separate them apart if she really love him
cuz she wants one and he doesnt
It's not just that, he doesn't put her first he puts his mother first , this his family won't even accept an adopted kid in the family , he was never okay with the idea of fixing his penis problems, he treated her as his mistress or lover for a while ........I mean she loved him but he broke her heart slowly
She wanted to get everything she wanted and no hardship or compromise to exist. That s not a marriage. A marriage is together for bettee or worse. She also made decisions on her own, like her Chinese baby idea.
Because parenthood is one of the things that you just can't "compromise" on. If two spouses don't want the same thing, one will resent the other for the rest of their lives. Having children and being a father/mother can be one of the deepest, harshest and desperate desires of a person's life. It's a kind of love you just can't replace. If you live the tragedy of wanting one and not being able to become a parent, you spend your days mourning the absence of those children that never came to life. And that's totally legit. As much not wanting them for any reason imaginable is totally legit, too. One big mistake many people do is getting married before having this very important conversation. It's VITAL, for a couple who want to be together for the rest of their lives. Charlotte and Trey got married before knowing each other in so many different contexts... One of them was parenthood.
Trey was asexual. That’s valid. They just didn’t mesh.
Not really. They were having sex quite regularly after a while.
Trey had madonna whore complex
Charlotte singlehandedly ruined the relationship with Trey...
no she didnt.
Charlotte still got that apartment and did not deserve it!