Catch our brand new show - Firstpost Africa with Alyson Le Grange. Watch the broadcast LIVE during weekdays at 8pm IST - th-cam.com/users/liveLvATmWSxmco
I work with a few of them I do not know how they got their Engineering degree because I have no idea about engineering drawings and sheet-to-pipe deference.
@Blahblahblah_420 Watch one more time, the report says authority is acting against Indian student as they fill incomplete forms and send fraudulent applications.
@@bestofpkl0853 It's a good thing if they block student immigration. Australia doesn't have jobs, their only industry is Tourism/Mining/Agriculture. Indian students take loans to study and can't repay as they don't get meaning employment in Australia. There's rising Islamic fundamentalism in Australia which is a bigger concern for immigration. Sooner or later, there will be demands like wanting Islamic Caliphate in Australia just like in Germany
Australia is doing the right thing , there have been huge a influx of fraudulent documents from students especially from Punjab and Haryana to gain admissions. Once they land in Australia , these students discontinue their studies and start working thus undermining the integrity of Australian Student Visa System. Government has just realized this and there you go all these sanctions.
Looking at what happens around UK and Canada, this is a very good move by Australia. Government should think about their land and their citizens. Not to entertain anyone else or politically get influenced.
The average house price in Australia is now 10 times the average salary, this is because of mass immigration (ie international students coming to Australia and flooding the housing market, driving down wages and driving up real estate prices). This ponzi scheme has been hurting Australians (particularly young Australians) and even under the new rules it's still extremely generous to international students (mainly Chinese and Indians).
Facts! I remember studying in TAFE 1995 and all my Chinese and Indo friends with student visas' at 18-20 all had paid out units in the city with sportscars given by their parents.
that's great. They should crack down on India even harder much like grant only 2 or 5 % and every single country should do the same for all Indians. Means only bright talented genuine Indian students can study.
It is blessing in disguise Sure Indian government will further improve medical facilities at home In fact we should get students from other counties ❗️ Jai Hind
Why is Modiji not investing in higher education institutions within India? Medical seats are so low, people have to pay large sums of money or go outside for education.
@@HornOkay why not? When you have to cater humungus population of 150 crore and growing. Every 700 people their is 1 doctor. Are you aware of this. Please study, bakchodi karna band karo.
@@MegaVarun27 bhakchodi bahen tum kar rahi ho. If you don’t have purpose to serve people and only interested in making money then you will end up neither making money nor being happy 😂. Read this line thrice and remember this when you aren’t able to remain happy even with bank full of money.😉
Bro medical seats have almost doubled in last 8 years from 44 thousand to 1.05 lakhs with more than 340 government colleges and more than 100 will be opened in few years time .😢
@@MegaVarun27 just shows your ignorance... Lots of doctors are not getting any jobs after graduating and relying on private clinics which also have a lot of competitions now days... With modis rule Indian economy is going down day by day..
Australia should just make it tougher for people to get permanant residence after studies like in the US and the number of international students will fall drastically as most people dont go there to study. They just want to settle in Australia.
There’s actually many ways to get permanent residency in the US after studies. Other than that, you can get a H1B work visa if an employer is willing to sponsor you
@@shaivamuthaiya2015US is popular choice bacause of the size of the country. US has 350 million people and Australia has 27 million. So, Australia only allows certain amount of people as per the size of their population.
@truthseeker327 people born in India. There is yearly quota for employment based green card on country of birth. I know many indians born outside india who got their green card in 2 years. Anyway, your kids can sponsor green card for you when they turn 21. Also, people born in india with exceptional research and PhD get green card in 3 to 5 years under EB1A. US is a smart country unlike Australia/Canada/Europe and knows how to get best talent. Australia/Canada anyway don't have good career opportunities for people in tech. Studied and worked in US, and also worked in Australia and Canada so can assure you of that.
The brain drain strted years ago. Many went to the UK. When the UK joined the EU, many were forced out of their NHS jobs. Many moved to Australia instead of returning to Pakistan or India.
The Indian diaspora is the biggest in the world. It has the highest in the US, UK and Australia mainly. Migrations have slowed down, look at data from 2022, 2023. If look at the data.
@@Raghuram_2894 WRONG!! White British are the largest diaspora in the world. You find them in US,Canada,Australia,New Zealand,South Africa and Zimbabwe. They never refer to themselves as immigrants but rather as "expats".
Whenever there is a problem, you can either tackle it, avoid it, or run from it. Everybody has their own reasons for choosing their path. Don't worry about others, you choose your own.
@SR-fs2fd I am from India too.. when the news media itself is concerned about student visa rules in other countries, it is scary for the future of india... 98% of this students going abroad is not getting quality education. All they work in restaurants dish washing, petrol station... Those who seriously going to study with GRE or GMAT score not even worry about this .. why so much drama @@SR-fs2fd
BUT WHY INDIA IS STILL A SLEEP? WHY ARE INDIANS RELYING ON WESTERN EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS. WHY CAN'T INDIA AND BRICS BUILD A UNIVERSITY WHERE THE MULTIPOLAR WORLD CAN GO THERE AND EDUCATED.
all Nepalese are doing nursing for PR while studying they are working in aged care, morning one place afternoon another....earning really well as their basic pay itself is good...while indians are remaining jobless....
Not only Australia, but every Western country should limit access to opportunities for international students and work permit holders from countries with a massive influx. This is a wise decision. Just because India has the highest population doesn't mean that Western countries should allow all of them to enter and potentially dilute their cultural values. I believe Canada should take note of this. While Canada has capped the number of international students, they haven't limited the number of LMIA (Labour Market Impact Assessment) holders from India and the Philippines. It's time for them to open their eyes.
Palki is not the unbiased journo she claims to be. Go watch Four Corners Cash Cows. Graduates from Punjab have been banned from applying. Students from such states hire someone to appear on their behalf for IELTS or cheat on exams
The very same things that are happening in Canada right now. The rapid increase of temporary residents like international students and temporary foreign workers. Many people and the government are blaming them for the increase in housing and rental prices. Now, immigration Canada is cracking them down too by imposing higher show money/savings, putting a cap annually for international students, and tighter rules in hiring temporary foreign workers.
Australia doesn't have problem, Canada is a big mess, when Indian students arrive in Canada that's automatic permanent resident and citizenship, which they made Housing and jobs very hard. Now every sector in Canada Indians are majority
All western countries except US have that problem. I have done my bachelor's internship in Europe, 1 year of work in Australia, master's and work in US and now work in Canada. For tech/STEM, no country in the world even comes close to US for quality of education and jobs. Housing is issue in Canada, Europe, Australia and NZ. So is medicare. Only in US housing and medicare issues are not there. I had 4 surgeries and regular check-ups in US, before you jump to US medicare expenses. For tech and people in STEM, if you ask me to rank countries in quality of life on scale of 100. USA - 95/100, Canada - 70/100, UK - 65/100, Australia - 60/100 and Europe - 55/100. Australia and Europe have high racism, although Australia has better wages so giving it higher points over EU.
Even Australia has a huge problem with Indian "students" that don't study, sign up for Indian-owned fake universities and just deliver Uber Eats full time. And they're everywhere.
Australia is a country of only 28 million people and cannot continue to take 500000 people a year. This has caused a severe housing crisis leading to aussie homelessness and rising rents and house prices. 4 of the 10 most expensive cities in the world to buy a home are in Australia. While education is a large income earner for the country, the government is under pressure to deliver more housing. There is no racial conspiracy targeting Indians, for they are over represented in the intake of new citizens and students.
@@StellaQueen-xp5kp The days of finding meaningful jobs in Australia after completing education seems to be over. Save money and invest in your local country/start a business.
Australia at the moment takes in 500,000 (!!!) migrants a year. Native Australians are living in tents because of the lack of housing. And you worry about tightening visa requirements?
It’s a typical opportunistic relationship. Australia opened its doors to international students to bridge skill gaps within its economy. Several Indian students saw this as an opportunity to get permanent residency. Education is Australia has always been about securing permanent residency status for most international students. This does very little to the actual skill bridging but puts a lot of pressure on other aspects of the economy. Universities and their agents have also used the practice of luring students into Australia on the basis of PR pathways as opposed to career opportunities and future growth like what we typically see in the USA. This attempt by the govt is just to show the people of Australia that they are doing something. But in reality it will have no impact in the medium to long run.
I know plenty of Indians who got PR and became top professors, RBA analysts and government officials. There is a pathway to grow and only effort is needed.
First official reason: No place to live. Rents are higher. Buying home is sometimes cheaper than paying rent. Students rent out. Second: fraudulent applications, students switching to lower level education to skip face to face classes. Few Students from states of highest fraudulent applications are involved in crime & drugs. One more reason: very low communication skills Fact: they are still taking a lot of students with good skills and communication.
The new rules are nothing personal to Indian students. Australia just about stopped building during and shortly after COVID but immigration was very high so demand and prices for accommodation have gone up all over the country. Give it a couple of years I am sure we will lighten up a little bit. Foreign students are very important for our future work force we have to make sure we get the right applicants at this time. PS. If you make a story about Australia please have more Australian footage lol.
And if that's not enough they use their licence to earn extra money.... ppl pay them when they get a fine cause they don't have points to lose! They literally charge $1000 dollars for ppl who need to get work... But they go through speed lights easily no fine.. smash ppl's cars easily and take off ... seriously I'm over them ...they're taking over... wake up Australia!
Australia’s infrastructure won’t simply cope with influx of immigration however targeting only Indian student visas is unfair. Australia must slow down on taking refugees too which eases some pressure.
No it wasn’t only Indian students , there was mention of Nepal and Pakistan too. The system is fair because the Indian students aren’t studying as their visa requires.
Half of the Indians were not showing up to their university courses. I'd say not only the visa crackdown are reasonable but nowhere near as strict as it should be. Indians are using visa's to work and stay permanently. I don't need to hear Indians in India makeup lies because i see what you're citizens are doing everyday.
Because it's nearly half a million Indians are already living in Australia. Their the only nationality that outnumbered most foreigners around the world.
Sounds like great news to me. you can no longer get away with buying some sort of reference from a serial box school to get your foot in the door to migrate to Australia
While you don't live in Australia, I know how common student visa abuse been going on. Currently, we have way too much people coming in.. Thus, bumps up rents and property prices. Costs of living expenses, electricity or energy bills, overcrowded public transport services, sewerage systems cannot cope, traffic jams getting worse, not enough jobs with at least a few hundred job applicants applying for one vacancy, tension rising, multicultural doesn't work..
They always want to eat their meal b4 it's fully cooked. Why don't you focus on your studies, then pursue whatever dream you aspire to achieve? Why do you have to go through the short route?
Do SIP in Mutual Funds in India instead of spending this money on Foreign education. The returns on such an investment will fetch far better returns in 5-10 years than spending on non sense education in Australia 🇦🇺 and save time wasted. Rather stay home and develop skills. Fools run amok to foreign shores thinking some magic wand 🪄 will twist their life around.
It was very different 50 years ago. Nowadays it's different. The government decided to sell tertiary education to an overseas market and this is the result.
Because of the "reservation" & "quota". I'm one of those that was affected by it. When India starts valuing people based on merit instead of caste reservation, then people will start thinking about staying back. Remove "reservation" and "bribery", then it will be a fair comparison between Australia and India.
@@vaithiyanathana9593 When you are willing to pay hefty fees to come to Australia, why can't you pay less to private universities and study in India ... It is all about mindset, where our people are mentally programmed to feel good about working for Whitman
@@adittypublications4141 but what's the use of investing "any" amount and study in India, if he/she and her upcoming generation is once again going to be subjected to same cruelty (reservation & bribery)?? I'm not a student. I'm a working parent and I care for my child. I have gone through the exact scenario (although I'm talented, but was refused the seats citing the "reservation" issue). So I don't want the same to happen to my child and thus decided to move to other countries where they treat everyone equally and priority given only based on merit. My previous message merely reflected the mindset and thoughts of students who are thinking about their next generation. Students want to leave India and settle in other countries not just for their own enjoyment. In fact many people (student/working class) are leaving India and settling down in other country are going through all the tougher situation just to safeguard their next generation. India is not going to give up the reservation and vote politics. So it's better to leave the place and save your own dependents. For me "India" is the place where my mother, wife and my son/daughter lives. Doesn't matter if it is Australia, Canada or even Saudi Arabia.
A lot of dodgy colleges are running in Australia with collaboration with those immigration agents. They exploit all possible loopholes in government policies to bring young students from subcontinent on this hope that all their problems will be resolved just by reaching Australia. Unfortunately, this is not case anymore in Australia due to high inflation, fewer jobs and extreme housing crises. These students generally take loans to arrive here and don’t want to leave immediately. This is the worst phase where they are exploited to work on low wages, and longer hours. Depression, anxiety, stress go up and up while they have no support from anyone. It’s neither Australian government or Indian govt fault. I don’t believe this visa policy change will impact bilateral relationships.
It’s not just in Australia, its the UK Canada Ireland and the US when Trump gets back in , your students can always go to your favourite country, Russia😂
It’s better for India…I personally know 4 of my junior school friends who were extraordinary students after studying from IIT NIT….two of them went to US(theoretical physicist), one in Germany(Research) and in Canada…these people are needed for India………..
@@michaelrussell4254 I didn’t know you were so dumb…it’s my mistake to reply…first of all US is an immigrant country…there is trade relations from both sides bilaterally to all countries you mentioned UK US AUSTRALIA Indian companies have invested there and vice versa ..Australia cricket sponsor is HCLTECH an Indian MNC likewise UK approached many companies of India for investment n vice versa…so Indian immigration comes into factor…
Why does Indians want to travel to Australia and study? Cost so much Money. Have they ever heard of "Distance Learning"? It is possible now and you just need a computer and reliable internet. You can apply for Universities you like and study via distance. You can even study at American Universities too via distance. I have studied via distance before and you can study without attending lectures. Earn a reputable qualification and study at your own pace.
The problem in Australian housing market is the ridiculously high interest rates, international students are hit extremely hard with course prices. Australian immigration is now a revenue raising business, you apply for a visa, they reject it and keep your money, don't even try to a visitor visa, instantly rejected, go visit a country that welcomes tourists, Australia is a no go zone for the entire world. Could say more about how bad Australia is but you get the point already. DON'T APPLY FOR ANY VISA, you just support Australia immigration with funds.
The commenters here blaming Panjab and Haryana - are precisely the type of Modi supporters who have made life difficult for the Sikh people in India, causing them to find every opportunity to flee. India must look at the root cause of its Panjabi emmigration.
This report is somehow related to the news came out in Australian Media saying that 2 Indian deplomats asked to leave Australia…. This immigration news 2 months old So people can somehow confuse between 2 Australia related news……….
We the work permit holders from india are affected due to the rise of rental market. I would say this is a good decision as some people want to buy everything.
For those looking to study, in Australia. I would say do your own research. Your university choice is not only dependent on ranking but also on how well a subject is taught at that university. Take it from someone who is planning to study there in a few months. And after that you have some doubt you can connect with my team we will help you out
You can now pay for your PR I know a Indian that payed for their PR but has to pass the test in 2027 but I don’t know if that has changed due to the new laws
I think it's okish. Indian students make the most immigrants in Australia. And most of these Indian students are Punjabi. So, they might be trying to diversify the population with other international students.
You are mistaken my friend. Nobody is begging instead they pay huge fees without bargaining. But nobody can take in infinite number of students even if they are paying high fees.
Indian international students pay a lot of money to come to Australia. Of course they study and work and pay tax and would like PR. Nothing wrong with that. Just a warning to Indian students to be careful as not every student visa ends up with PR. Be careful and think wisely
Working 48 hours a fortnight as allowed by the student visa is different from working fulltime. That's 2208 a month. Of course, it's not going to fully pay for your tertiary education in Australia. Once you graduate with a good degree, get a job and join the line for PRship. The problem appears to be many are not here to study.
If I may, it's better not to come to Australia now specially those who need to take a loan to study, as its not worth it.Living and renting is super expensive and Job options not so great.Not to discourage but a student is better off going to other countries in Europe that offer free education if they really want an International experience.Or work for 2 years and then come as students here.Right now not a good time.
While this some boat come from Iraq with tons of illigal migrant and government providing them house furniture job and welfare fund. So easy to go via boat. Student spent tons of rupees and can't get PR
@@MelaniaRose 1400 family were placed in northern suburbs of Melbourne just year or two year ago all of them came by boat they were provided house and allowances. Other hand student pay fees earn in free time pay tax on that so chose who you want in your country.
Australia also knows that people come there to get PR. Their universities are not that great that people will pay their life savings to just get degrees from their average universities compared to US or Europe or even Singapore ! Indians should also work on their self respect and work hard to make it big in India. there are plenty of opportunities for those that want to work hard in India too. but most would just criticise the government and never really explore the opportunities presented by favorable policies in India
Disagree. Australia has the highest ranking universities in the world. It’s probably average students who can’t speak English properly who are wasting their time “studying”.
@@MelaniaRosehigh grade universities are high grade universities any where in world. I studied in one of the most reputed universities in Australia and it was not so much better than NIT in india where i did my bachelors. The only reason 99% of Indian students are flying here is to just earn money doing odd jobs as they can earn in dollars. If someone is really here to study and boost there career its very good but on the contrary countries like Australia doesn’t even offer campus placements like India and the job market completely runs on references irrespective of the talent. So, ultimately the students are trapped in a vicious debt trap and careers are also ruined. With my experience I have realised that with same amount of hard work, we Indian students can land a good job and stay close to family in India
Australia has 4-5 universities in best top 50 universities in the world and around 10 in top 100. University of Melbourne at 14, University of Sydney at 19 and University of NSW at 19,Australia National University at 34, Monash at 42, UQ at 43 as per QS world university rankings 2024. Show me one Indian university in even top 100. First university in top 200 is IIT bombay at 149 and IIT delhi 197 . Rest of the universities from India are like 700, 1000-1200 in ranking. I don’t what best universities you are saying are better than universities in Australia.
Indians should not be upset if they have a genuine qualifications to be granted a visa to enter Australia. The Australian government has all the rights to mandate what is good for its citizens and country.
But, most Indian students are going there for jobs and residence visa - their primary aim is not to study. We cannot blame such students as India does not offer them relevant opportunities and hence they are forced to look for those opportunities else where.
Any comments from mass dialogue specialist who speaks witty dialogues but still fall over head over heels over western nations over policies that is clearly anti Indian..
Instead of worrying , Indians should make USA like homes, road and grow lawn everywhere. Garden and backyard behind every home. Impeccably clean and gorgeous villages and towns. World class university etc and last but not least the world class mindset
Indians only should worry abt the number of low quality engineering colleges we have !! Its amazing no audit being done on the quality of these ! Many of these graduates dont even have basic skills to perform a job !!
They have limited reserves of looted cash using discriminative policies against international students but when that money dries up, they will invite again with eyes closed 😆 then we will have headlines like Australia opens its doors to Indian students with love 😆 showing their government eating butter chicken and chicken tikka masala for lunch and dinner.
Catch our brand new show - Firstpost Africa with Alyson Le Grange.
Watch the broadcast LIVE during weekdays at 8pm IST - th-cam.com/users/liveLvATmWSxmco
Why should Indians worry if a foreign country is not allowing them? Australians don't beg the Indian govt to study in India. Have some self respect
All Dodgy Punjab & haryana peeps have ruined merit holders chances in every western country!!!
!00% right mate
I work with a few of them I do not know how they got their Engineering degree because I have no idea about engineering drawings and sheet-to-pipe deference.
India should free Punjab so it doesn't ruin her reputation.
Exactly mate
10000000%%%
Good decision by Australian government!
I am a professor in Australia and this is correct, don’t turn up to study during class and want to pass. I hammer them and they just fail.
I work in sector associated with international students and I have Pakistani and Indian friends. They are here to work and send money back. Simple.
Stay in India. Australia is full.
Absolutely. There's no infrastructure for all those people, native Australians are living in tents because of the housing crisis.
FOWF?
And housing is much more expensive in Australia, LOL.
@@RUHappyATMthats because the AUD dollar is more valuable than Indian rupeee.+ Australia has a higher gdp per capita than India.
Australia, UK, Canada all cracking down on immigration specially from India.
@Blahblahblah_420 Watch one more time, the report says authority is acting against Indian student as they fill incomplete forms and send fraudulent applications.
we have lot of scam agents .... ruining life of students.... good one...
@@bestofpkl0853 It's a good thing if they block student immigration. Australia doesn't have jobs, their only industry is Tourism/Mining/Agriculture. Indian students take loans to study and can't repay as they don't get meaning employment in Australia. There's rising Islamic fundamentalism in Australia which is a bigger concern for immigration. Sooner or later, there will be demands like wanting Islamic Caliphate in Australia just like in Germany
Not from Khalistan
Coz we abuse the laws more than anyone else 😅
Hardly any of them study in Australia. Students only work and send money home while education and health sector is screaming for skilled works.
Yes overstay, illegally work😂
There are a lot of Indian doctors and nurses in OZ,
@@RUHappyATM most are terrible.
@@suzimooreakathegadgetlady907
I tend to disagree.
Many from the NHS are pretty good.
Exactly 💯
Canada and US should follow this too immediately.
The United states will never listen to Australia that's why they keep going home dead every time we go to war lol
Canada started already cracking down on immigrants too, ahead of Australia. are you sleeping?
Its turning into fucking Punjab.. everyone is studying some shitty cook course here and driving uber full time on a student visa🤣
Most are here in Australia to ditch Indian Citizenship, study is last thing in their mind. That’s worrying for India not to Australia😂😂
No one wants to ditch indian citizenship , they just want money and secure jobs. India don't accept dual citizenship, so they give up one citizenship
Brain drain is a different matter, if you are getting migrants/students to drive taxis, deliver food then it is worrying for Australia.
@@kittyind please deport them
It is BS news put out at periodical intervals. Even UK does that. They all need money and talent.
@@mohit_sihag1379yes please no more oz is obviously no 1 we cant take a you ungrateful people
Australia is doing the right thing , there have been huge a influx of fraudulent documents from students especially from Punjab and Haryana to gain admissions.
Once they land in Australia , these students discontinue their studies and start working thus undermining the integrity of Australian Student Visa System.
Government has just realized this and there you go all these sanctions.
Agreed. The excess of international “students” have affect the current job and housing market in Australia.
Agreed. But its now almost every state in India. Australia should really strict their scrutiny policies to only allow the real merit students
South India is doing good. don't cover them@@trozan2355
The government is to be blamed when it treats education as a commodity for export.
Looking at what happens around UK and Canada, this is a very good move by Australia. Government should think about their land and their citizens. Not to entertain anyone else or politically get influenced.
Overseas people keep looking at Australia going why is there so few people, but we've got no bloody water in most of the country
The average house price in Australia is now 10 times the average salary, this is because of mass immigration (ie international students coming to Australia and flooding the housing market, driving down wages and driving up real estate prices). This ponzi scheme has been hurting Australians (particularly young Australians) and even under the new rules it's still extremely generous to international students (mainly Chinese and Indians).
Facts!
I remember studying in TAFE 1995 and all my Chinese and Indo friends with student visas' at 18-20 all had paid out units in the city with sportscars given by their parents.
Better for Australia and even better for India .. Palkiji❤
Yes please no more
that's great. They should crack down on India even harder much like grant only 2 or 5 % and every single country should do the same for all Indians. Means only bright talented genuine Indian students can study.
Yeah true
It is blessing in disguise
Sure Indian government will further improve medical facilities at home
In fact we should get students from other counties ❗️
Jai Hind
Why is Modiji not investing in higher education institutions within India?
Medical seats are so low, people have to pay large sums of money or go outside for education.
Everyone wants to be a doctor.😂
@@HornOkay why not? When you have to cater humungus population of 150 crore and growing.
Every 700 people their is 1 doctor. Are you aware of this. Please study, bakchodi karna band karo.
@@MegaVarun27 bhakchodi bahen tum kar rahi ho.
If you don’t have purpose to serve people and only interested in making money then you will end up neither making money nor being happy 😂. Read this line thrice and remember this when you aren’t able to remain happy even with bank full of money.😉
Bro medical seats have almost doubled in last 8 years from 44 thousand to 1.05 lakhs with more than 340 government colleges and more than 100 will be opened in few years time .😢
@@MegaVarun27 just shows your ignorance... Lots of doctors are not getting any jobs after graduating and relying on private clinics which also have a lot of competitions now days... With modis rule Indian economy is going down day by day..
Australia should just make it tougher for people to get permanant residence after studies like in the US and the number of international students will fall drastically as most people dont go there to study. They just want to settle in Australia.
I doubt so. The usa is still the most popular destination
There’s actually many ways to get permanent residency in the US after studies. Other than that, you can get a H1B work visa if an employer is willing to sponsor you
@@shaivamuthaiya2015US is popular choice bacause of the size of the country. US has 350 million people and Australia has 27 million. So, Australia only allows certain amount of people as per the size of their population.
@@michellesum7173 there is but for indians it is hard to get permanent residency in USA. Most are on years of H1B visas
@truthseeker327 people born in India. There is yearly quota for employment based green card on country of birth. I know many indians born outside india who got their green card in 2 years. Anyway, your kids can sponsor green card for you when they turn 21.
Also, people born in india with exceptional research and PhD get green card in 3 to 5 years under EB1A. US is a smart country unlike Australia/Canada/Europe and knows how to get best talent.
Australia/Canada anyway don't have good career opportunities for people in tech. Studied and worked in US, and also worked in Australia and Canada so can assure you of that.
As an Indian, I feel this is good. We need to stop the brain drain and make the skilled people stay in the country rather than leave.
Bulshit theory! Whoever goes to foreign countries from India as students is an economic migrant by back-door! They don't study!
A chaiwala can be PM. What do you do with keeping those brains?
pay more they will stay
The brain drain strted years ago.
Many went to the UK.
When the UK joined the EU, many were forced out of their NHS jobs.
Many moved to Australia instead of returning to Pakistan or India.
Indian students are everywhere, man Canada is FULL of them. I think Modi has something to do with it....
The Indian diaspora is the biggest in the world. It has the highest in the US, UK and Australia mainly. Migrations have slowed down, look at data from 2022, 2023. If look at the data.
@@Raghuram_2894 WRONG!! White British are the largest diaspora in the world. You find them in US,Canada,Australia,New Zealand,South Africa and Zimbabwe. They never refer to themselves as immigrants but rather as "expats".
Why Indians hate India .. why ? Palki should try to solve issues on India . No other country is worrying about students visas
Whenever there is a problem, you can either tackle it, avoid it, or run from it. Everybody has their own reasons for choosing their path. Don't worry about others, you choose your own.
@SR-fs2fd I am from India too.. when the news media itself is concerned about student visa rules in other countries, it is scary for the future of india... 98% of this students going abroad is not getting quality education. All they work in restaurants dish washing, petrol station... Those who seriously going to study with GRE or GMAT score not even worry about this .. why so much drama @@SR-fs2fd
For real why Indians are so obsessed with the west???
Election system, vote bank politics
All Western countries are putting a hold on it what are you talking about.
BUT WHY INDIA IS STILL A SLEEP? WHY ARE INDIANS RELYING ON WESTERN EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS. WHY CAN'T INDIA AND BRICS BUILD A UNIVERSITY WHERE THE MULTIPOLAR WORLD CAN GO THERE AND EDUCATED.
Because India is a third world country that's why
Maybe because the course variety, quality and opportunities following graduation are poor?
They don't know how to. They can't.
all Nepalese are doing nursing for PR while studying they are working in aged care, morning one place afternoon another....earning really well as their basic pay itself is good...while indians are remaining jobless....
True 😂😂😂
True 😂😂😂
Thats so true and these Nepalese people are more dodgy than india but people are blaming india too much
Biggest faurder are Nepalese, I see on Nepali leads employees many on same jobs like loop hole
It's because Indians considered nursing beneath their status.
Fact: Fraud applications of few won't affect bilateral relationships
LOL! How much money dutton made out of the corruption surrounding our "emigration laws?
Not only Australia, but every Western country should limit access to opportunities for international students and work permit holders from countries with a massive influx. This is a wise decision. Just because India has the highest population doesn't mean that Western countries should allow all of them to enter and potentially dilute their cultural values. I believe Canada should take note of this. While Canada has capped the number of international students, they haven't limited the number of LMIA (Labour Market Impact Assessment) holders from India and the Philippines. It's time for them to open their eyes.
Palki is not the unbiased journo she claims to be. Go watch Four Corners Cash Cows. Graduates from Punjab have been banned from applying. Students from such states hire someone to appear on their behalf for IELTS or cheat on exams
The very same things that are happening in Canada right now. The rapid increase of temporary residents like international students and temporary foreign workers. Many people and the government are blaming them for the increase in housing and rental prices. Now, immigration Canada is cracking them down too by imposing higher show money/savings, putting a cap annually for international students, and tighter rules in hiring temporary foreign workers.
Australia doesn't have problem, Canada is a big mess, when Indian students arrive in Canada that's automatic permanent resident and citizenship, which they made Housing and jobs very hard. Now every sector in Canada Indians are majority
Even in Australia there are everywhere
All western countries except US have that problem. I have done my bachelor's internship in Europe, 1 year of work in Australia, master's and work in US and now work in Canada. For tech/STEM, no country in the world even comes close to US for quality of education and jobs. Housing is issue in Canada, Europe, Australia and NZ. So is medicare. Only in US housing and medicare issues are not there.
I had 4 surgeries and regular check-ups in US, before you jump to US medicare expenses. For tech and people in STEM, if you ask me to rank countries in quality of life on scale of 100. USA - 95/100, Canada - 70/100, UK - 65/100, Australia - 60/100 and Europe - 55/100. Australia and Europe have high racism, although Australia has better wages so giving it higher points over EU.
Even Australia has a huge problem with Indian "students" that don't study, sign up for Indian-owned fake universities and just deliver Uber Eats full time. And they're everywhere.
Australia is a country of only 28 million people and cannot continue to take 500000 people a year. This has caused a severe housing crisis leading to aussie homelessness and rising rents and house prices. 4 of the 10 most expensive cities in the world to buy a home are in Australia. While education is a large income earner for the country, the government is under pressure to deliver more housing. There is no racial conspiracy targeting Indians, for they are over represented in the intake of new citizens and students.
Agreed
For sure.. cause Nepalese Indians Bangladesh's parkistanis can sleep 20 ppl in a 2 bedroom home
I think 🤔 it's better cuz those Indian who have been pouring huge amount of Money in these Universities. Would now be looking for Universities here
How's that better they can save money apart from that?
@@StellaQueen-xp5kp The days of finding meaningful jobs in Australia after completing education seems to be over. Save money and invest in your local country/start a business.
Australia at the moment takes in 500,000 (!!!) migrants a year. Native Australians are living in tents because of the lack of housing. And you worry about tightening visa requirements?
It’s a typical opportunistic relationship. Australia opened its doors to international students to bridge skill gaps within its economy. Several Indian students saw this as an opportunity to get permanent residency. Education is Australia has always been about securing permanent residency status for most international students. This does very little to the actual skill bridging but puts a lot of pressure on other aspects of the economy. Universities and their agents have also used the practice of luring students into Australia on the basis of PR pathways as opposed to career opportunities and future growth like what we typically see in the USA. This attempt by the govt is just to show the people of Australia that they are doing something. But in reality it will have no impact in the medium to long run.
Australian news with Canadian background in the video. Good one😂. The news content though🙌
This needs to be done❤❤❤❤
Dont go nothing there, I lived over 10 years no PR after that long
Waste of money and no jobs
are you from india?
Why did you feel entitled to PR?
@@XDF745
I agree, why did he think he is entitled to a PR just because of the time he spent there?
I know plenty of Indians who got PR and became top professors, RBA analysts and government officials. There is a pathway to grow and only effort is needed.
About time there’s to many Indians in Australia.
Rents very high in Sydney. Melbourne probably less. Adelaide and Hobart probably best but less jobs.
First official reason: No place to live. Rents are higher. Buying home is sometimes cheaper than paying rent. Students rent out.
Second: fraudulent applications, students switching to lower level education to skip face to face classes.
Few Students from states of highest fraudulent applications are involved in crime & drugs.
One more reason: very low communication skills
Fact: they are still taking a lot of students with good skills and communication.
The new rules are nothing personal to Indian students. Australia just about stopped building during and shortly after COVID but immigration was very high so demand and prices for accommodation have gone up all over the country. Give it a couple of years I am sure we will lighten up a little bit. Foreign students are very important for our future work force we have to make sure we get the right applicants at this time. PS. If you make a story about Australia please have more Australian footage lol.
🙏🏼
very good they come here not to study but to work in cafe and because of this household prices soaring high.
And they share between 15 - 20 ppl demoliting Australians hm
And if that's not enough they use their licence to earn extra money.... ppl pay them when they get a fine cause they don't have points to lose! They literally charge $1000 dollars for ppl who need to get work...
But they go through speed lights easily no fine.. smash ppl's cars easily and take off ... seriously I'm over them ...they're taking over... wake up Australia!
Most Indian “engineers” and “doctors” drive Uber in Australia.
Australia’s infrastructure won’t simply cope with influx of immigration however targeting only Indian student visas is unfair. Australia must slow down on taking refugees too which eases some pressure.
No it wasn’t only Indian students , there was mention of Nepal and Pakistan too. The system is fair because the Indian students aren’t studying as their visa requires.
Half of the Indians were not showing up to their university courses. I'd say not only the visa crackdown are reasonable but nowhere near as strict as it should be. Indians are using visa's to work and stay permanently. I don't need to hear Indians in India makeup lies because i see what you're citizens are doing everyday.
Because it's nearly half a million Indians are already living in Australia. Their the only nationality that outnumbered most foreigners around the world.
India has a growing economy, why not build universities there?
It's hitting students from certain states in India, Nepal and Pakistan.
Good cause they're growing an attitude!
@@fatikaasiran6876 , slow migration is where it's at.
Indian students come at first in Germany. This country will have capacity in the next five years.
Another Indian living in Germany comment. He is facing discrimination there and calling few more peope
Sounds like great news to me. you can no longer get away with buying some sort of reference from a serial box school to get your foot in the door to migrate to Australia
While you don't live in Australia, I know how common student visa abuse been going on. Currently, we have way too much people coming in..
Thus, bumps up rents and property prices. Costs of living expenses, electricity or energy bills, overcrowded public transport services, sewerage systems cannot cope, traffic jams getting worse, not enough jobs with at least a few hundred job applicants applying for one vacancy, tension rising, multicultural doesn't work..
One more thing, I personally found many people from India bought qualifications. They're unqualified, can't do the job, bluffing their way...
They're used to sleep on top of one another as long as they make money
They always want to eat their meal b4 it's fully cooked. Why don't you focus on your studies, then pursue whatever dream you aspire to achieve? Why do you have to go through the short route?
Do SIP in Mutual Funds in India instead of spending this money on Foreign education. The returns on such an investment will fetch far better returns in 5-10 years than spending on non sense education in Australia 🇦🇺 and save time wasted. Rather stay home and develop skills. Fools run amok to foreign shores thinking some magic wand 🪄 will twist their life around.
Well said bro
India is good for business opportunities in next 5 years
Australia, Canada, UK and USA should have done this 50 years ago.
It was very different 50 years ago.
Nowadays it's different.
The government decided to sell tertiary education to an overseas market and this is the result.
ALWAYS BEST!! THANKS YOU THIS IS SO MOTIVATING AND PLEASE DONT STOP TEACHING US WE LEARN ALOT FROM YOU KEEP UP YOU TH-cam VIDEOS.
Indian Universities are in much better standards - So why come to Australia and stay in small rooms and eating junk food. Let us live in own country
Because of the "reservation" & "quota".
I'm one of those that was affected by it.
When India starts valuing people based on merit instead of caste reservation, then people will start thinking about staying back.
Remove "reservation" and "bribery", then it will be a fair comparison between Australia and India.
@@vaithiyanathana9593 When you are willing to pay hefty fees to come to Australia, why can't you pay less to private universities and study in India ... It is all about mindset, where our people are mentally programmed to feel good about working for Whitman
@@adittypublications4141 but what's the use of investing "any" amount and study in India, if he/she and her upcoming generation is once again going to be subjected to same cruelty (reservation & bribery)??
I'm not a student. I'm a working parent and I care for my child. I have gone through the exact scenario (although I'm talented, but was refused the seats citing the "reservation" issue). So I don't want the same to happen to my child and thus decided to move to other countries where they treat everyone equally and priority given only based on merit.
My previous message merely reflected the mindset and thoughts of students who are thinking about their next generation.
Students want to leave India and settle in other countries not just for their own enjoyment. In fact many people (student/working class) are leaving India and settling down in other country are going through all the tougher situation just to safeguard their next generation.
India is not going to give up the reservation and vote politics. So it's better to leave the place and save your own dependents.
For me "India" is the place where my mother, wife and my son/daughter lives. Doesn't matter if it is Australia, Canada or even Saudi Arabia.
@@adittypublications4141well said 👌🏼……. this is unfortunately so true
Better standards?😂
Looks like Palki forgot to tell us why the Aus government is taking such stance.
no need to tell. we know, you know already the answer and the reasons.
Very good decision to prevent what's happening in EU and USA
Wonder how students pass English exam as entry criteria, can't do project reports in universities.
Indian student come here to stay more than study
They only go to a small course once a week and they work cash the rest of the week.
Exactly 💯
Australia is a gold mine for them...
UK had already started this from 2010 foreseeing the immigration impact. Other countries are just following the suit now.
UK welcomes thousands of immigrants from Africa and Middle east. So UK is facing problems now.
A lot of dodgy colleges are running in Australia with collaboration with those immigration agents. They exploit all possible loopholes in government policies to bring young students from subcontinent on this hope that all their problems will be resolved just by reaching Australia.
Unfortunately, this is not case anymore in Australia due to high inflation, fewer jobs and extreme housing crises.
These students generally take loans to arrive here and don’t want to leave immediately. This is the worst phase where they are exploited to work on low wages, and longer hours. Depression, anxiety, stress go up and up while they have no support from anyone.
It’s neither Australian government or Indian govt fault. I don’t believe this visa policy change will impact bilateral relationships.
Everything should be under control,
Bringing students have benefits and troubles too, happened same thing in Canada,
The rise of savings mentioned in the video is incorrect.
It’s not just in Australia, its the UK Canada Ireland and the US when Trump gets back in , your students can always go to your favourite country, Russia😂
You think that this is our loss? 😂
It depends what you welcome. Welcome anti socials, refugees and agitators.. You'll be surprised what they can do to your country
It’s better for India…I personally know 4 of my junior school friends who were extraordinary students after studying from IIT NIT….two of them went to US(theoretical physicist), one in Germany(Research) and in Canada…these people are needed for India………..
Easy just stay in your own country, why do you think people from the US UK and others are not flocking to live in India
@@michaelrussell4254 I didn’t know you were so dumb…it’s my mistake to reply…first of all US is an immigrant country…there is trade relations from both sides bilaterally to all countries you mentioned UK US AUSTRALIA Indian companies have invested there and vice versa ..Australia cricket sponsor is HCLTECH an Indian MNC likewise UK approached many companies of India for investment n vice versa…so Indian immigration comes into factor…
No different from Canada… same problem because of mass immigration with too many student visas issued.
Everyone, should stay in their OWN country and make it, an even better place! 👍
Why does Indians want to travel to Australia and study? Cost so much Money. Have they ever heard of "Distance Learning"? It is possible now and you just need a computer and reliable internet. You can apply for Universities you like and study via distance. You can even study at American Universities too via distance. I have studied via distance before and you can study without attending lectures. Earn a reputable qualification and study at your own pace.
I also finished my masters via open or distance mode.
Lot of Indian students are struggling in Australia because of cost of living .. This will be back to normal after 2026
The problem in Australian housing market is the ridiculously high interest rates, international students are hit extremely hard with course prices. Australian immigration is now a revenue raising business, you apply for a visa, they reject it and keep your money, don't even try to a visitor visa, instantly rejected, go visit a country that welcomes tourists, Australia is a no go zone for the entire world. Could say more about how bad Australia is but you get the point already. DON'T APPLY FOR ANY VISA, you just support Australia immigration with funds.
Good job Australia government for doing this 🙌🏽
$19,500 is nowhere near enough to support yourself in Australia for a year. Rent alone is $26,000.
Too many students... study at home
The commenters here blaming Panjab and Haryana - are precisely the type of Modi supporters who have made life difficult for the Sikh people in India, causing them to find every opportunity to flee. India must look at the root cause of its Panjabi emmigration.
Australia should look into the refugee intake...
Please go away we take to many whinginging losers as it is
No thank you. I am a taxpayer and had enough of people living off taxpayers funds
@@anitabeer1426 I think he is suggesting we take too many.
Australia dosnt take a lot of refugees anymore,, it’s the international students now
This report is somehow related to the news came out in Australian Media saying that 2 Indian deplomats asked to leave Australia….
This immigration news 2 months old
So people can somehow confuse between 2 Australia related news……….
We the work permit holders from india are affected due to the rise of rental market. I would say this is a good decision as some people want to buy everything.
there is no much jobs here in their respective fields ... students who have masters degree and phds work in coles 7-11and cafe shops
💯
For those looking to study, in Australia. I would say do your own research. Your university choice is not only dependent on ranking but also on how well a subject is taught at that university. Take it from someone who is planning to study there in a few months. And after that you have some doubt you can connect with my team we will help you out
Another Indian taking advantage of Indian students?
You can now pay for your PR I know a Indian that payed for their PR but has to pass the test in 2027 but I don’t know if that has changed due to the new laws
I think it's okish. Indian students make the most immigrants in Australia. And most of these Indian students are Punjabi. So, they might be trying to diversify the population with other international students.
Why Indian students has to beg other countries for their studies? Is it must to start pakode, tea business?
You are mistaken my friend. Nobody is begging instead they pay huge fees without bargaining. But nobody can take in infinite number of students even if they are paying high fees.
Because India didn't or couldn't help its own citizen.
Indian international students pay a lot of money to come to Australia. Of course they study and work and pay tax and would like PR. Nothing wrong with that. Just a warning to Indian students to be careful as not every student visa ends up with PR. Be careful and think wisely
Working 48 hours a fortnight as allowed by the student visa is different from working fulltime.
That's 2208 a month.
Of course, it's not going to fully pay for your tertiary education in Australia.
Once you graduate with a good degree, get a job and join the line for PRship.
The problem appears to be many are not here to study.
Australia always shows attitude with India 😢
And vice versa
If I may, it's better not to come to Australia now specially those who need to take a loan to study, as its not worth it.Living and renting is super expensive and Job options not so great.Not to discourage but a student is better off going to other countries in Europe that offer free education if they really want an International experience.Or work for 2 years and then come as students here.Right now not a good time.
Also Canberra should sure they will get fair share from 19500 from their savings
India didn't give shit to fake Australian education
Canada, Australia, USA must curb indian visas.
👍👍👍👍👍👍
😂😂 it will never happen
@@sirg3137 Some folks never learn!!!!🤷♂🤷♂🤷♂🤷♂🤷♂🤷♂🤷♂🤷♂
as an american of indian origin it needs to happen
If you scratch deep, you will find the old colonial Australia.
Exactly whites only poilcy exits from back door.
Eye opening for all. They should act tough to screen the future trouble makers.
Meanwhile indians who are already in australia feel lucky for less competation 😂
While this some boat come from Iraq with tons of illigal migrant and government providing them house furniture job and welfare fund. So easy to go via boat. Student spent tons of rupees and can't get PR
International students aren’t citizens 😂
@@MelaniaRose are the boats coming from Iraq are all Australia citizens thats what you trying to say ??
@@hillton2180 Boats with refugees are being sent to the Nauru not Australia
@@MelaniaRose 1400 family were placed in northern suburbs of Melbourne just year or two year ago all of them came by boat they were provided house and allowances. Other hand student pay fees earn in free time pay tax on that so chose who you want in your country.
@@hillton2180
LOL, you can always try the boat route and see what happens upon arrival?
Nauru or PR?
Australia also knows that people come there to get PR.
Their universities are not that great that people will pay their life savings to just get degrees from their average universities compared to US or Europe or even Singapore !
Indians should also work on their self respect and work hard to make it big in India. there are plenty of opportunities for those that want to work hard in India too. but most would just criticise the government and never really explore the opportunities presented by favorable policies in India
Disagree. Australia has the highest ranking universities in the world. It’s probably average students who can’t speak English properly who are wasting their time “studying”.
@@MelaniaRosehigh grade universities are high grade universities any where in world. I studied in one of the most reputed universities in Australia and it was not so much better than NIT in india where i did my bachelors.
The only reason 99% of Indian students are flying here is to just earn money doing odd jobs as they can earn in dollars.
If someone is really here to study and boost there career its very good but on the contrary countries like Australia doesn’t even offer campus placements like India and the job market completely runs on references irrespective of the talent. So, ultimately the students are trapped in a vicious debt trap and careers are also ruined.
With my experience I have realised that with same amount of hard work, we Indian students can land a good job and stay close to family in India
Australia has 4-5 universities in best top 50 universities in the world and around 10 in top 100. University of Melbourne at 14, University of Sydney at 19 and University of NSW at 19,Australia National University at 34, Monash at 42, UQ at 43 as per QS world university rankings 2024. Show me one Indian university in even top 100. First university in top 200 is IIT bombay at 149 and IIT delhi 197 . Rest of the universities from India are like 700, 1000-1200 in ranking. I don’t what best universities you are saying are better than universities in Australia.
@@trozan2355Your personal experience can be biased, but rankings done by professionals are on the basis of facts and figures.
Yes
And... ? It was increased in 2024 merely to catch up after lock downs, now it is returning to the norm.
Good decision by Australia- much needed decision.
Indians should not be upset if they have a genuine qualifications to be granted a visa to enter Australia. The Australian government has all the rights to mandate what is good for its citizens and country.
Indian universities also good ones... we can study here...
But, most Indian students are going there for jobs and residence visa - their primary aim is not to study. We cannot blame such students as India does not offer them relevant opportunities and hence they are forced to look for those opportunities else where.
@@saviofrancisfernandes413: exactly
@@saviofrancisfernandes413 Indian or Asian are obsessed to immigrate in western country
Everybody is studying to get a job .. if studying in India does not enable you to get a job .. its better to go outside India and live a better life
@@AkshayKumar-wo2cx what about if outside ( particular western countries) don’t want you & you’re not welcome ?
So stay in India & do something
First of All India should stop manufacturing the product
Any comments from mass dialogue specialist who speaks witty dialogues but still fall over head over heels over western nations over policies that is clearly anti Indian..
LOL, it's not just Indians BTW, despite this purposefully inflammatory bit.
Instead of worrying
, Indians should make USA like homes, road and grow lawn everywhere. Garden and backyard behind every home. Impeccably clean and gorgeous villages and towns. World class university etc and last but not least the world class mindset
They already have their Mexicans for that.
Indians only should worry abt the number of low quality engineering colleges we have !! Its amazing no audit being done on the quality of these ! Many of these graduates dont even have basic skills to perform a job !!
They have limited reserves of looted cash using discriminative policies against international students but when that money dries up, they will invite again with eyes closed 😆 then we will have headlines like Australia opens its doors to Indian students with love 😆 showing their government eating butter chicken and chicken tikka masala for lunch and dinner.