Indians are not begging for it. Foreign countries have demand but have incompetent locals to full fill their requirement. One Google search will tell you that Indian ethnic group are the most QUALIFIED ethnic group among migrant in Australia, Canda, UK and the US. Moreover, they are either the number 1 or 2 when it comes to household income. Also, they are not involved in any crimes. So, this is the value Indian brings in.
That will attract them back lol or will not leave in the first place like folks from some countries Swiss / Denmark / Finland as an example .. very few leave
@@JJ-wk5wy yes these South Asians have ruined it for international students Because they are really here to work low paying manual labor jobs With that said… We borrowed and spent living the good life/high standard of living That is what you folks don’t get… we are broke. Azzzzzz…. Canadians who can’t pay our debts sitting on 2 trillion in Provincial/Federal debt these days Debt we really started running up in the 1940s. Sow dem gud ole dais ye pine fer? we didn’t pay for the first time around Which we just kicked this debt down the road for future generations to pay for Problem is, we stopped meeting “natural” population replacement rates in 1971 And we have around 1000 boomers turning 65 each and everyday in Canada (That started in 2011 won’t end until 2028) By 2036 we will have around 11 million Canadian seniors As by 2032 immigration will make up 100% of our population growth So we pack in the immigrants the poor ones to make our french fries and more importantly flip us over in bed in the old age home The rich ones to come support the economy and prop up the real estate Because most of these boomers are also personally cash poor/in debt But luckily….most of these boomers???? Shockingly by some engineered miracle the last few decades 😉!!!!! own a 40 year old plus never been renovated, overpriced home some immigrant is willing to overpay for. Which these boomers can get lines of credit on or reverse mortgage on or sell if they have to Which they should not .. … as that home will be one their own personal old age home in the future unless you can show me some links… on our building/buying enough facilities to house millions of Canadian seniors in the next decade Yes it’s one big Ponzi scheme that scr (ew) over the younger folks but we don’t want to crash our Ponzi Scheme of economy. (I have purposely gone to live in countries and among the locals living on a dollar a day wages in comparison to our dollar. You think your life su…cks these days) Try having 50k of someone else’s currency worth 2 million of our Canadian dollars Or have what kids you and I did actually have… Having to sell their wares to Russian sailors for a 500 CDN dollar loaf of bread or trying to sail a boat to some distant country for a better life wind up washed ashore on a beach Or grandmami/grandpapi begging on the street because that nest egg home they have they can’t sell off or afford to live in So the people at the bottom of our society lose out…. or we all do Don’t like packing in these immigrants/people as the solution? Let’s hear you folks say “I demand to pay more taxes” and “I demand less social services in return” Or let’s sell 25 year 50 year forward contracts on our natural resources some foreign corporation or Country can come into mine. Using our young as cheap labour Or let’s be known as the deadbeat generation who had to resort to selling off pieces of Canada Plus since we stopped replacing ourselves. It will be more and more likely the great great great grandkids of these new immigrants stuck paying off the debts we run up long after we are gone… As we stick them with the bill But since we have been sel fish our whole lives living that good life let’s “now” complain about the solutions after decades and decades of this Our being broke… azzz Canadians who couldn’t replace ourselves
@@manishKuMer25 we need immigrants even poor Indian immigrants to do the manual labour work no one wants to do But Indian International students who have no intention of going to school. Who come here just to work those manual labour jobs Are ruining it for the real international students
They also undercut the market by working for way lower than the average market value and by doing that they themselves get exploited by companies and mainly other indians then they complain. Meanwhile other people in the industry suffer because the labour market values become significantly low to the point it doesn’t become feasible anymore, all thanks to these indians and students who live 10 - 15 people in 1 house while trashing everything around them and disregarding the council regulations.
I am an Indian but I can understand Canada's point of view. Why should the western countries help Indians just because India can't control its population? As for the money Indian students bring, these students cant expect to live in Canada indefinitely in return for the fees they pay... lets see what happens if foreign students studying in India demand the same from the Indian govt !!
@@timemachine1421 its not reservation at all i have heard many of them were getting tech jobs with hefty salary but they denied to do jobs bcoz they wanted to go to canada to earn dollars even if thry hv to clean roads or drive taxis.. dont blame indian job opportunities as everyone wants to go abroad
But they seem to be more than happy to give freebies to no skill Abduls and Ahmed. These 1st world countries deserve what they are getting from the people who are full of "peace".
If as Palki says these students are such an asset why doesn't India provide an higher education and housing for them. Instead chastising other countries for considering the concerns of their people.
As a national from Finland,who did 3 months exchange in Canada 4 years ago,i was actually shocked that 97% of the student in my class were indians,i dont hate indians,but my hope was to meet students from all around the world,not only indians,That was the goal of my student exchange, but honestly the indian students hardly stay in class,they just work work work and work. Glad i am back in Finland,Din't miss canada at all :)
Because you have good social security even if you don't want to work .Free education,free health care of course high taxes?In india the reservation curse is there do people opt to emigrate.
@@mohanrao6Reservation is a curse due to the karma of your forefathers, now U will pay for the sins of the forefathers because u gloat in the caste identity
@@raghavnamasivayam8706 and there are a lot of these "underprivileged" people who can afford to travel to other countries for leisure but can't afford to pay fees or compete on equal terms with general category of students. Because why would you
you need students but not workers...lol....its like you want the food but dont want to do the dishes,,..thats not how it goes bro..................cancel foreign visa and zero people will visit your universities.......
And she says they bring in money . They take more than they bring by displacing Canadians out of their jobs and competing for scarce housing and strained healthcare
💯 many of them don't attend class because they are after the $$$$$. It needs to be strictly monitored by immigration. I don't know how some international students are granted student visas when they cannot understand or speak English.
Really nothing which is the problem. All these Indians are going abroad to study and then not come back to help Indian industries. They definitely need to do more to attract their top talent back.
@@dukhi_aatma372You are always Dukhi? India is a caste based country. Such a ass hole reservation is not responsible for a job crisis in India. Mukh Putra is only responsible
@@dukhi_aatma372 well a student who can go abroad and finance their studies wants menial government jobs in India with an average salary of 30 to 50 thousands. Because last I checked the private sector in India doesn't have reservations.....What an excuse you have....😂😂😂
Should have cracked down on this along time ago. You can’t keep letting people in when there isn’t even enough homes to house your own citizens. It’s simple logic that unfortunately has taken this long to materialize.
It's not incompetence bro, it's on purpose...hence why it's still continuing, even though the vast majority want it stopped. Democracy is the best. Do you remember when you voted for all of this?...me neither.
The indians are coming in at record levels. They also use NZ as a backdoor. People talk about Canada but i went to NZ a few months ago and the entire place is just Maori and Indians especially Punjabi's all over the place. You have to see it to believe it. Pre-Pandemic i don't remember seeing so many Indians all over the place but the last few years it is an explosion. They literally all came out of nowhere.
The difference between Chinese and Indian students. 1. Most Chinese students getting their student visa they study and spend money sent from their parents from China or elsewhere. Indian students half study half working past time to finance their study. Not much money will spendh sending from India or from outside. 2. Most Chinese students after graduation they go back to China. Indian students most stay on and compete with the local for jobs.
@@aschauhan9392 Really, around the world? Better they spend the money in India. No country forced Indians to spend money in Western countries they chose to and were aware of the tuition fees they would have to pay and still applied and signed on the bottom line.
@urdailygamr9229 immigration have right to change the rules whenever they feel like depending upon situation and circumstances.,. Like , how you like it if it is in your favour. You should also follow it if it is not in your favour? Nothing is promised in any country. One has to earn it.
I'm so happy I made productive decisions about my finances that changed forever. I'm a single mother living in Vancouver Canada, bought my first house in October and hoping to retire soon if things keep going smoothly for me.
Am looking for something to venture into on a short term basis, I really need to create an alternate source of income, what do you think I should be buying?
The problem with international students is: 1) Most come in without much funds(understandable) 2) Most work more than the allowable hours for international students 3) Most are exploited by Indians who own businesses in Australia (underpay) And more reasons. It's India's job to provide education and jobs for its students...not Canada's or Australia's.
I think palki sharma has explained it correctly, both Australia and Canada are facing severe economic slowdown, there are no jobs in the market, I’m in Australia from 8 years , I know people in Canada also , both the countries face acute housing crisis and government is not doing much to solve the problems, because all influential people and top politicians have huge real estate portfolios, no body wants to solve the problem everyone wants to milk the situation, same is the case in Canada. I’m seeing problem day in day out , it’s getting worse , Local aussies who were doing blue collar jobs not able to pay bills properly, it’s a messy situation in Australia and Canada
In Australia, it is the rental crisis. The international students make it hard for locals to rent a property and not many properties are available for locals. Government wants to reduce the housing pressure.
Agree❤ I live in the Northern Territory and apparently next year our Territory is exempt from the International student intake. Meaning our local government here may advocate for more international students. We already have a rental crisis too. You often see 2 bedroom flats filled with 5-10 students in it 😅
@@bharadwajpappu1936 because if you look at all the drivers, dhaba owners, and physical laborers in canada, they are all wearing turbans. and every single motel and lodge in US is owned by Gujjus.
@@bharadwajpappu1936 some Indians are doing well but Canada is a small developed economy which is already saturated. Even if some kids are talented it’s very difficult to penetrate job market. Indians are largely doing low skill jobs here, unlike US or UK.
@@bharadwajpappu1936 India is mostly low skilled and poorly educated population. Look at your PM. In 1.41 billion only 5 million are employed in IT and mostly doing low end jobs for cheap. Has India developed any product. Do you have any IT company which sells products for West. Just a few small ones not much. Even China is way ahead of India in AI. Thats bcoz India does not have the skills to move up the ladder currently and only can do services for cheaper labor bcoz cost of living in India is 20 times lower.
Canada/"Why would you want to kill a golden goose," as this reporter says. My response: It's high time Canada and other Western countries cut down the number of foreign students as once they are in, they never go back to their home countries. They use the student visa route as a back door entry into the country. Canadians are fed up and angry at this mass immigration of foreign students and temporary foreign workers. So now the government is listening and acting. Why is it so difficult for foreign students to return to their country once their studies are complete. Indian students in some parts of Canada are demonstrating to extend their work permits. Why? Their studies are over.
💯 percent agree. They have taken away jobs of Canadian youth. They signed a contract that after studies to go back to their country. As you said, they used a student visa to stay in Canada.
Ummm bcoz the International students have spent exorbitant amount of money for their studies and have ton of student debt. They need to work in the international country for atleast few years to get their ROI.
I am Indian and those Indian students must get back to India and try help the country grow. Being an Indian we must stop harming someone else country help to build our own country. If we Indians had to leave India for better life then why we have got independence for Britain at first place.
As a French, I think it is more an issue with policies set by both governments!!! You know you bring students IN and why don’t you build houses and encourage construction???? In France, many students come to study there (for free and we are proud of it!!!) BUT awe do not have the same issues as Canada (our healthcare is NOT under pressure and our housing prices haven’t really increased that much as compared to Canada for example!!!) to me, the students are NOT atao blame!!! It is the fault of the government who have FAILED to set the right policies!!!!
Well explained. Thanks for bringing up the video. Financial education is indeed required for more than 70% of the society in the country as very few are literate on the subject…
Most people think, investing in crypto is all about buying coins and leaving it to rise, come on it takes much analysis to be a successful crypto trader.
Trading without professional guide...Huh I laugh you, because you will remain where you are or even make huge losses that will stop you from trading, this has been one of the biggest problem to new traders
You're right! I have lost a lot trading all by myself without a guide. It's been an uneasy ride for me. Who is your mentor please. how can i reach her i really need help in this bear market now?
The lady says Australia is missing out on the "Golden goose" because international student numbers, particularly from her country, will be reduced 😂. Obviously not, hence it was done. I'm glad the new restrictions are in place. Hopefully this will help fight Inflation, particularly housing costs.
International students are not supposed to stay in their host countries. It is expected that they should come back to their home country. They are not migrants.
😂😂 wow taking huge number illegal immigrants and give them house, money, free health care, education then citizenship nice 🎉🎉🎉🎉 and problem with legal immigrant and students 😂😂😂
@@sirg3137 International students have exploited the system for too long. Its negatively affect local students, the rental market and job opportunities.
As an Australian who actually married an Indian woman who came here as a student, I can say she never had plans to stay and had a plan to go back and work in her father's business. She had around 50 Indians in her class and everyone has returned to India. But in truth there has been many who come here fail to study and do silly courses like Cooking to try to stay at some second-rate Uni and unfortunately, they have done a lot of damage to the reputation to Indian studing. But in truth, this is because the government has made a mess of the housing market
@@Dzamile25 100% The issue is there are tiny universities that have set up to take the money but don't enforce the rules and they have to in regards to the students showing up. The problem is the few who create the rules for all I remember when I first started seeing my now wife. She is lucky as her family live in Bandra Mumbai and has serious money so she never had to work here to study. Still, she chose to as a way of meeting people but some of the Students she studied with went and got massive credit card debts here and failed to pay rent for example, one left owing over $80,000 in debt to banks but many in her UNi used to talk about how they were doing it. Not to mention some who never showed up to a single class as they were driving taxis or working in Security jobs. etc.
As an Indian I want Australia, Canada and EU govt politicians to first take care of their citizens. The cost of living crisis has hit all economies baring few. Also foreign countries must ban migration pathways based on education. This will stem the flow of Indian students. Blaming Indian students for adding to economic woes will create animosity which should be avoided. I can't blame students in India looking for opportunities to uplift their economic status however it cannot be at expense of adding to economic issues in another country. For genuine students Indian unis must continue to tie up with foreign unis on courses so that there is standardisation. There is no lack of good education in India. It is just that there are no jobs for qualified students including professionals. This needs to be top priority for our govt and private sector. There are tough times ahead for young generation which will be further augmented with adoption of AI. AI will create lots of job but those will not equate to jobs that AI will replace.
Nobody in Canada is calling the international students billions a golden goose nor the government or cares. Canadians care about fairness and rule of law and there is rampant abuse of these programs.
The current situation extends beyond just a housing crisis. it’s closely tied to the job market. Local students are increasingly finding it difficult to secure unskilled jobs, which traditionally have been available to them. Many students and immigrants are now filling these roles, leading to a competitive environment where young locals are expected to start earning by age 18. They typically work part-time in unskilled positions to support themselves while studying at university. However, these jobs are often taken by unskilled immigrants and foreign students (primarily as a result of inflation and raised cost of living), as businesses frequently prefer hiring them due to their willingness to accept lower wages. for instance, many Indian grocery stores and restaurants hire Indian students who work for cash, often below minimum wage. in contrast hiring local students requires businesses to comply with legal wage standards. This dynamic has sparked a significant backlash among locals, who feel that immigrants, refugees, and international students are "stealing" their jobs - a sentiment that holds some truth. In Canada, local students are protesting against stringent government measures, advocating for more relaxed policies and immediate PRs. This unrest is causing friction with locals and politicians alike, potentially complicating the future for aspirants from countries like India.
Good move, a lot of students travelling to foreign universities had started thinking India as a temporary station....they became more loyal to US-UK-Canada then motherland... Sab ka demmag thikane lag jaayega...
Good move. I hope more and more countries will impose stricter regulations and limit large foreign students in the country. Good news. Thank you, First Post and Palki
I was an international student once in Australia in 2013. The wage rate then and now remained flat more or else but seems like rental has really shot up and I think this student cap is good for student and Australia both. Student make good earnings… better education and not much strain on existing infrastructure. I believe and agree with the approach.
The real issue is that we don't follow the laws and customs of the country we live in. For instance, after India won the T20, there was chaos on the streets of London, which is just one of many similar incidents. This kind of behavior frustrates the local population and turns them against immigrants.
indians coming to canada isnt just here to study but to work here. how do you feel if chinese comes to to India and take all job opportunities for the local? will you be happy? Student pathway is just a front for indians. their main goal is to work in canada! this is a great move for canada!
The truth is Most Indian students final goal is to stay in Australia and bring their family and student visa is the easiest way!. You cant blame them, everyone wants to have a better opportunity and good life! The life in India is hard that is why many are turning to scamming, the easiest way to earn big dollars!
People who settle abroad will not open their mouth on the hardships they face in living in another country. I have many relatives abroad who when they come here envy the casual way we lead our life here. When they hit the high age they will know the value of staying in their country. Grass is always greener on the other side.
As a French, I think it is more an issue with policies set by both governments!!! You know you bring students IN and why don’t you build houses and encourage construction???? In France, many students come to study there (for free and we are proud of it!!!) BUT awe do not have the same issues as Canada (our healthcare is NOT under pressure and our housing prices haven’t really increased that much as compared to Canada for example!!!) to me, the students are NOT atao blame!!! It is the fault of the government who have FAILED to set the right policies!!!!
These governments viewed foreign students as golden goose. They knew very well that most of the students from India/China were using student visas as a gateway to enter to these countries. I can understand if someone comes abroad for a PhD degree , but vocational training or a bachelor/masters degree?? Why pay millions to these countries, when you do not even know that a job will follow suit ??.. we Indians need to get rid of our obsession of these countries. Life is very hard also in these countries.. As someone, who left India 20 yeras ago for Germany to do PhD in Neuroscience, I can say that life is not easy in these countries.. stay in India and build India..
Its easier for someone who has stayed abroad for 20 years to say this... would you want to come back to India even if you get the same amount of pay here?
As if not even 5 years ago when this wasn't even remotely a thing that Canadian and Austrialian unis were somehow unable to operate without them. I always see statements like this saying that we're paying so much more for the education, were basically funding your unis. Idk maybe it's like the government that subsidizes the education of it citizens through taxes payed for a life time by other citizens. It's not mystery as why these unis can exist both with and without them. Sure maybe the government is not directly paying for you to attend, but its not like government is really seeing any of the money they're spending going back to them. Many of the institutions that they're attending are just diploma mills that are churning out useless degrees and the private owners are the only ones benefiting by profiting heavily.
Problem in india🇮🇳 which will never be solved 1. Poverty: Persistent poverty affects millions, especially in rural areas. 2. Unemployment: High joblessness, particularly among the youth. 3. Education Disparities: Unequal access to quality education across regions. 4. Healthcare Access: Inadequate healthcare infrastructure, especially in rural areas. 5. Corruption: Corruption hinders development and public services. 6. Pollution: Severe air and water pollution, especially in urban areas. 7. Rape and Sexual Violence: Widespread reports of rape, harassment, and abuse, calling for stronger legal action and protection for victims. 8. Gender Inequality: Discrimination and violence against women in various forms. 9. Sanitation and Hygiene: Poor sanitation, leading to diseases and health problems. 10. Water Scarcity: Limited access to clean drinking water and irrigation. 11. Climate Change: Rising temperatures and erratic weather affecting agriculture. 12. Religious and Communal Tensions: Conflicts based on religion disrupt social harmony. 13. Judicial Delays: Slow legal processes and a massive backlog of court cases. 14. Child Labor: Continued exploitation of children in labor despite laws. 15. Farmer Suicides: Agricultural distress leading to farmer suicides. 16. Urban Slums: Overcrowded and underdeveloped slums in major cities. 17. Drug Addiction: Rising drug addiction, particularly in states like Punjab. 18. Caste Discrimination: Persistent social inequality based on caste. 19. Public Infrastructure: Inadequate transportation, electricity, and roads in many regions. 20. Mental Health Stigma: Lack of access to mental health care and societal stigma.
Canada has not seen the light. Jughead Singh and Justdick Trudeau have seen the polls. And the polls have been speaking. Both of them are disliked intensely by most Canadians. One of the top concerns of Canadians is the changing nature of Canada due to the massive influx of backdoor immigrants (Students). Aaaand, there is an election next year in which the Liberals are predicted to lose. I cannot speak for Australia, but as far as Canadians see these students, the perceptions are consistently negative. Poor hygiene, lack of basic English, overcrowding in houses, lack of civility, environmentally irresponsible (throwing garbage on to the streets and lawns), body odour... These are major concerns not only for Canada but to all western nations.
Yes Palki usually it’s government incompetence not a specific group of people that cause problems, remember that when you talk about problems in India!
Good decision. Had indians going abroad only for learning and studying , it wouldn't have been a problem. But many of these people don't care about the degree or subject they are studying but do any job to stay in that country permanently finding any means .
In Australia, there is a critical housing crises. Met a lovely Indian girl, student, from India. Lovely girl. However, wd are struggling with high rents and not enough housing.
Migrants are absolutely one of thr reasons why rents have gone up. Here in Ontario,yhe rents are so out of control. Nothing in my are is under $1,000 a month. Houses are bought and rented out by these students, making it so hard for people to find somewhere to live.
One million young folks are leaving India every year to "study" abroad. WOW, that's quite a number. The majority are not going to Western countries to study per se but use the student visa route to never return to India but settle down in these countries.
India boasts of being a rising superpower, but then also has the highest number people who want to run to Western countries for something as basic as education. What a shame!!
They are not going for an education because it doesn't exist. There is competition for seats in good universities in India, as it should be, so the academically capable study tough courses and make something out of their lives. The academically less proficient people, with their father's money, is simply trying to migrate. They shouldn't even try higher education. Education provides a legal cover to reach there. The aim is to leave India with its overcrowded, crime-filled, polluted, filthy cities with poor facilities and settle to a comfortable life abroad and be rich and finally take up citizenship there.
Developed countries are right in their own way to set their own rules to benefit their own people. Immigrants that want to seek better quality of living can’t do so at the cost of locals. There needs to be a balance, and every country and political party has a right to determine this. Countries are unfortunately becoming more nationalist to seek support from the masses. Democracy is flawed because it lets masses and incompetence win, over merit or “fair” opportunity. Political parties portray “fair” in ways that suit them best, and off late it is more polarising in nature and less collaborative.
Irresponsible parents sending their child to other country. Where they are hated 😂 and suffer a lot. Better fix Indian education and roads and behaviour.
The Australian policy targets all international students, not just Indians. In fact, the government should take big responsibility for the housing crisis. But Overseas students certainly contribute to the problem, not just the housing. Many students also don't work in the field they studied, many keep enrolling courses to extend the stay, but never completing or working in their field etc. All these things make it harder to estimate the Cost vs benefit. And yes, they are soft targets to blame students instead of better policies & executions. But not to worry, when Universities run out of money, they'll ask for Government assistance, and the Government will increase numbers in time.
Tax payers and local governments largely fund universities too. Sorry to disagree but there’s plenty of youth and domestic students that need work too.
Every country must develop their own resources, human and otherwise. Skilled migrants' number should always be limited. Education should be to learn, not first step in settling in other country. It is time India invests more on education, infrastructure and town planning, and make living conditions better in India.
I agree.. and there shouldn't be a visa after study. They can stay, only if they get sponsored by a company to work there. I wonder if the education in india is really that bad? or they study abroad just for pride? Just watched another video, they study abroad is just for a pride.
It is the country's internal matter of both Australia and Canada why will an Indian media comment, suggest and propagate the countries how to act ? Wisdumb? 😅
Ty palki for covering this, as a Canadian i believe its about time, housing is not there, students are living in homeless shelters, some stories say under bridges in tents.
I live in Canada and I can be honest with you when I say that international students ruined the cost of living here. Rent in Canada is out of this world. Landlords prefer international students to rent their properties than Canadian cuz they pay more than Canadian citizen and not to mention groceries is just another level, minimum you've to spend $200-300 per week. I'm not against international students but they're the reason why the cost of living is no longer easy for Canadian.
You're delusional. CoL is due to inflation caused by Money printing by Bank of Canada and then debt based capital expenditure + money laundering (read Ukraine aid) by Canadian political establishment. You can blame international students on many things, but not on this one
It simply means you are blaming your incompetence on to others. If you are competent, then you could have found a job that pays well and afford the good things. This is true anywhere in the world. Also it is true, even in India, that there are people who hate inbound migrations. They usually tend to be the incompetent ones who blame everyone else for their misfortunes. The international students & high skilled immigrants are following the law. You are not the country, you just get one vote. If you have problem then take it up with your govt. Also you should be knowing that international students are an asset - if they dont come, then the STEM jobs wont be filled. Most of these top corporations have presence worldwide including India. They will simply ship the job overseas. Which means your entire town will turn into a ghosttown eventually. Lets say a foreign student comes and works in your country for $5000 per month. They would typically end up spending $4000 on rent,fuel,grocery,restaurants,bills etc. ie consumption. If that job is shipped overseas, all the connected industries will lose their income. So to satisfy ONE INCOMPETENT PERSON, should the entire economy suffer ?
@@brownhunk007 I'm not against those students but they've do whatever it takes to survive, I blame the government for making it so hard for Canadian. They let in too much students into the country that they can not sustain it and the results is so devastating for everyone.
@@amulejohn The students are not to blame, they simply go to study, what's more, they contribute to the economy of the country. The problem lies in the governments and the attitude of private companies that are experts in creating these funnels to blackmail governments, especially in taxes.
Interesting piece of information as usual... the question is who are considered as the locals in Australia and Canada 😅? Is it the original people there or European immigrants ....!
It is sometimes good to monitor the migration and how much a country can handle, if there is better pay in own country nobody would go out. It is just the pay and currency and value of the income which they may receive that makes studying abroad fancier as well. Most students are professionals who join pg or any course , but on top of that they bring in the family - say wife or husband and kids , to support the family both have to definitely work in a foreign country because as students one person can only work for specific hours. Although there are many concessions, it is like that country has to create a job for every student who comes with family. They need place to stay, if they have kids there are more rules on accommodations, housing is definitely a problem as it is easier to allot a student hostel to one person but developing a housing community for new families entering is difficult for any country. This family is actually going to take a job that was supposed to be for someone else. This is one of the most used way of Migration. When the job market is too volatile for the existing people, more people coming in is a burden for any country as it has to provide housing, water, electricity and basics for any human. It is a boon and a bane.
Most of Son's classmates went to Foreign Countries, I told my son to concentrate and get good Job in india and become a specialist and visit as Specialist not as job seeker. I have seen most of his colleagues in PSU studied in IIT or otherwise went to USA for MBA just to stay forever. It is shame for all of us.
I think Australia and Australian government should be worried about Chinese people becoming majority citizens especially communist then worrying about international student related to education.
Please check people walking on the streets of Australia, which more from India, or China. Of course Indians, full of streets are Indians. Listen to what canadian said---------Chinese student come to study with money , but Indian student come to work or stay without money. Chinese students do NOT need to migrate because they easily go to any countries.
@@jt6231 Please check people walking on the streets of Australia, which more from India, or China. Of course Indians, full of streets are Indians. Listen to what canadian said---------Chinese student come to study with money , but Indian student come to work or stay without money. Chinese students do NOT need to migrate because they easily go to any countries. and they mostly come back to East Asia once graduated.
The difference between Chinese and Indian students. 1. Most Chinese students getting their student visa they study and spend money sent from their parents from China or elsewhere. Indian students half study half working past time to finance their study. Not much money will spendh sending from India or from outside. 2. Most Chinese students after graduation they go back to China. Indian students most stay on and compete with the local for jobs.
Ginagawa kasing path to permanent residency ang student permit. Canada allows direct family members to join a student in Canada. Kapag di magkasya sa daily expenses ang employment income ng family member sinisisi ang govt. dahil mahal daw ang cost of living.
Percentage of Asian students returning to their home countries after graduating from US universities: S. Korea🇰🇷 = 98% China🇨🇳 = 97% Taipei🇨🇳 = 63% HongKong 🇭🇰 = 57% Malaysia🇲🇾 = 47% Thailand🇹🇭 = 44% Indonesia🇮🇩 = 31% Philipland🤴 = 0.3%👈 India🐄 = 0.02%👈 Source: USA Ivy League Student Survey 2023
Once indians including south asians enter Australia,Canada, US and Europe, they will never leave. Their main goal is to get pr/green card by any means(skilled/asylum/marriage) there and bring families. Harsh truth..
Not only driving up the rents here in Canada but many local Canadians do not have jobs as they were taken by the students, visitors who are staying here for extended period of time.
Current situation in Canada is proof that countries like India where you can pay and get any goddam degree should be banned from any visas except for extraordinary talent or humanitarian.
These two countries combined account for over 3 billion people & climate disasters along with pollution have made most of there countries uninhabitable
why don't Indian student study in Israel. India and Israel are best friends, it should be no problem for both to work together. Indian students will be able to work in international high tech industry, while Israel will get the benefits of obtaining a high skilled professional workers. A win-win situation
Demand & Supply, Maybe Israel doesn’t need that many foreign students, plus it’s a volatiel region due to its conflict with Arab nations, safety comes first.
@@samarthpandey683 nonsense! Israel can have as many Bharatis professionals and students it wants. Bharatiyans men are capable and extraordinary soldiers and Israel can use them to replenish their troops. Israel is the new frontier for Bharatiyans!
😂😂 wow taking huge number illegal immigrants and give them house, money, free health care, education then citizenship nice 🎉🎉🎉🎉 and problem with legal immigrant and students
Sri Lanka is happy with this decision of Australia. The reason is that Sri Lanka provides free education to the children of its own country and they migrate to other countries after getting their education. Another country is benefiting from the investment made by Sri Lanka for them.
Canadians are raised to not hate and to embrace diversity (including being taught this in all daycares/schools). People need to look at all sides. India has a 29% unemployment rate amongst it's own graduates. One of the big reasons why young people are leaving India in droves, yes? Plus less than 50% of the 950 million working-age population in India is employed (compared to over 70% in other emerging markets). Amongst the Indian working group, many are self-employed and contain “unpaid helpers in family enterprises”. India has one of the highest emigration rates in the world. As many zero in on education as a way to gain access to a western country? Did international students/families pay into Canadian taxes all their lives like domestic students have (earning cheaper tuition fees)? No. Plus Canada did NOT tell international students/parents to spend/risk their life savings on a "Canadian dream". Canada did NOT tell international students to borrow money. Canada did NOT promise international students work. Canada did NOT promise international students money. Canada did NOT promise international students PERMANENT RESIDENCY. Meanwhile freelance agents have been operating in an unbridled market in India. Often by painting a distorted picture of what students can receive from Canada. Plus in recent years, a new type of recruitment has cropped up via foreign nationals as many "edu-tech" have created online platforms to connect millions of potential students with the recruiters. The sub-agents have absolutely no no direct connection with the Canadian college. Plus the college has no no ability to control their conduct. Indian sham operations abused/abusing Indian students in person &/or via massive advertising. PRIMARILY in their native language that most Canadians do NOT understand. Painting a false picture in their minds (of what Canada could or would or should offer). Canadians are seeing primarily Indians protesting & waving their flags on Canadian streets making demands. Because they may not have enough credentials to remain in Canada? And because rules designed to protect CANADA are not meeting their desires? Why isn't there crowds of African or Caribbean or Filipino etc., students making demands? They're in Canada too. And even though Canada is being falsely/unfairly blamed for too much, Canada has yet to deport students like crazy (but likely will soon). Instead Canada has been trying trying to find balance of who can stay vs go. While also trying to fix anything Canada did wrong. Create a better future. Why? Because Canadians actually care about doing so for both Canadians and international students. Canada's own youth are also victims of the above mentioned scam artists now too. Due to a SEVERE lack of affordable homes, and lack of entry level jobs, and healthcare waiting times now ... partially due to international students swarming the system then fighting for PR etc., versus returning home. Including some students asking for Canadian asylum (which rarely gives them PR). Questions: ⦁ What is India doing about any of this? After Canada told India to halt Ghost Consulting. Many Indians keep saying their politicians are corrupt. True? Plus Canada didn't have numerous PRIVATE 'diploma mills' until 40% of international students were from India. Coincidence? Schools that Canada is shutting down. ⦁ What about all the YT videos that primarily Indian nationals have posted (for half a decade now including today) all advertising Canadian PR like they're selling a product? Promoting Canadian visas & permits & schools & jobs etc. etc.. Videos not only posted hourly but rarely in English or French. With very very rare input from Canadian citizens. ⦁ What about the IELTS spouses? Anchor babies? ⦁ What about Canadian food banks & other charity services being recklessly advertised on YT in Indian languages? ⦁ What about Canadian housing being scooped up en-mass as investment vehicles by, and for, foreign nationals? Some home rental/boarding signs stating "vegetarians only can apply". Often these 'landlords' also cram 20 students in a small home and charge them each way too much for rent. ⦁ What about Indian nationals buying local businesses then repeatedly putting Indians only in the top tier positions (while also changing familiar work practices)? BC & Ontario are also outlawing the Caste System. ⦁ What about the Sikh vs Hindu violence/extortions across Canada? Diasporas stirring up tribal hatreds (in Canada) even though it all stems from their ancestral home. Why????????? ⦁ What about the Canadian government launching investigations in regards to foreign interference in Canadian elections, stemming from Asia continent? Canada also had to end flagpoling at the border. Canadians are so so so not used to all this!! Do Indians care about Canadians suffering too? Or do they primarily want to point fingers at the Canadian government etc., when many things weren't in Canada's control? Canadians want multi-culturism to succeed and for all people (including immigrants) to be okay. Now everyone I know is VERY happy with IRCC's recent changes (reductions & multifaceted investigations etc.). Including multi-generational long-term Asian Canadians MOST upset (by all of this). PS Immigration being decreased in: Ontario, Quebec, British Columbia, The Maritimes, Alberta, Saskatchewan, & Manitoba. Chances are better for homebuilders, healthcare-givers and job CREATORS.
Bro, I feel you completely but you're literally missing out on the Canadian government's inability to handle the entire situation. I mean, yeah sure no one from Canada called the students there, but they all were granted visas by the Canadian government right? Those visas are legal and valid. You are only presenting one side of the coin while conveniently ignoring the other. The Canadian government sure knew what they were doing giving these many student visas in the first place, they were minting outrageous amounts of money in imports. You sound like you're one hundred percent affected by the high unemployment and inflation, and you're venting here. While you may be right here, you are definitely overlooking so many crucial facts, like how the Canadian government has given its complete support to Khalistani Secessionists, who are becoming a constant nuisance for Indians there and now Canadian locals too. I would like to say one more thing, which is Indians are not the only group of people emigrating every year to Canada, there's other Asian ethnicities too, like Chinese, Filipinos, etc. Why don't you have any problems with them taking away your jobs and opportunities? I'll tell you something, if you're so worried about all this, you should consider voting for a better government in the future elections. Good luck.
It's fine I agree with your, but then tell why did canadian govt gives Visas and citizenship to gangsters and terrorist. They hide them and provide shelter to them. These gangsters had killed hundreds of people in India and supply drugs in India. Yet your govt didn't act on that. Seems like only India don't have corrupt govt.😏
Copy Paste BS I see this exact text everywhere NOBODY F*ING HATES YOU. I don’t understand how you jump to such ridiculous assumptions when people state the facts. Canadians are actually a really kind loving people on God’s blue planet, that’s why they are leaving their beloved country and going to anywhere they can (US, Mexico, Latin America) because they couldn’t afford to live in their country. They are leaving their one only country to make a room for people who will for sure bounce to their country if shit hits the fan. That’s how Canadians are freaking kind bro! Stop the cap, go crowd the US and see what happens!
where tf did you pull that 29% ? this is what google said: According to the Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE), India's unemployment rate in June 2024 was *9.2%*, which is a significant increase from 7% in May 2024. Also, only highly qualifed people go to countries like Canada, which means they can easily find job anywhere in the world, including India.
Canada and Australia freely import European origin students and workers as exchange students and workers from England, Germany, France, Poland, Argentina, Uruguay, Spain, South Africa and more. Why.. because Canada and Australia trace their origin to European brothers and sisters as cousins so, importing European origin people is clearly not the loss to Australian and Canadian genetic identity and at the same time, the artificial nature of their culture can easily be trained over time through assimilation. People of European origin are easily imported for marine research, hotel management and hospitality, big team based research reservations in universities among these countries, arts and movies like the US importing Russell Crowe, Nichole Kidman, Charlize Theron, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Leonardo DiCaprio, Margot Robbie, Kate Winslet, Dolf Lundgren to act in classic US Hollywood American country side movies. So, Polish, French, German, British, Argentinian, Spanish, Norwegian, Danish, or Austrian can easily be assimilated without any identity politics in Australia and Canada. But, these developments in Australia and Canada are racially motivated because the word immigrants today is linked with non-European origin people from all over the World and not at all with European origin people present in the rest of the World. Multi culturalism only happens when people of different genes are given equal chance and rights..but, that is what Australia and Canada European origin rulers cannot relate to by making racist policies like these without being explicit about Xenophobia. You can also make sense in case of the US is that the US-Canadian border is not much of an issue as much as Mexico-US border because from Mexico and below all Latin countries don't have large European origin genes as it is the case with Canadian genes that is the European genes it is all happening out of Xenophobia right from source the character of people of United Kingdom riots resonating into all Common Wealth countries like Canada and Australia. 👉 Xenophobia and Fear of multi non-European culturalism expansion and their financial freedoms 👈
You know that according to statistics India is the most racist country on the planet right. There are several leaders in the governments of these countries of Indian origin. Let me ask you how many prime ministers have been of North Eastern Origin. Stop with the woke stupidity. We know why you want in, you don't respect the country's rules. Your country also regularly posts expansionist wet dreams called Akhand Bharat and you look down on your neighbours. You are no different then the british. Remember you are not the victim, you are merely a competitor for the spot of oppressor.
Disagree. Indians take over whole cities and towns in their host countries. Differences is Europeans don’t overpopulate countries where they go and at least give a fair go to other cultures and nationalities.
Students from India, particularly the Punjab region, are notorious for non compliance with visa conditions, frankly, they grossly rort the system, overstay, disappear into the black economy, bribe educational institutions to record them as attending when they are working. The increase by 50 % in the private vocational sector is particularly concerning. A significant proportion are conducted by Indians and they co operate in the rorts. It's well past time the authorities took action. Hypocrites like Ms Sharma act all pious and cast aspersions on law abiding, decent, compassionate societies like Australia and Canada, but happily abide the most corrupt government and public service systems in the World.
Funny enougn India is on track to face a similar population collapse problem as China in a few decades with its birthrates in a downward spiral. Would be ironic if they need immigration themselves to stave off their dwindling population.
@@sravibhaskar In the UK many of the international arrivals claim to be colonizing the UK as " revenge " for British colonization. .Canadians with 200 years of ancestory on the land now known as Canada are constantly referred to as colonizers to this day Really is my comment such a stretch ?
Immigration curbs in Canada and Australia now extend to ALL TYPES of migrants- such as temporary foreign workers, asylum seekers and foreign students. Politicians are now focusing on complaints from the public about job shortages requiring skilled workers, as well as demand/supply imbalances in residential housing, health care, education and social support services
I Live in Australia from last 9 years, came as a student, finish the study on time, got PR with in 3 years, secure the job. Worked hard , learned alot, got opportunities to step up few times which I did and finally running my own few businesses. It’s a land of opportunity. what a beautiful country. What I understood from politics and locals, they will never let it become Canada, UK and America. This country is very different then these other west country. They happy what they have, and don’t want to being too many people in, nor foreign business as they damage the environment. Australia is very concerned about their environment and have strict environmental policies. Regarding international students, this is very true that they have housing crisis and now job crisis since they brought 500000 students in in recent financial year. Locals are blaming migrants for this. Politicians are doing what they can to make people happy.
Pivoting the cause entirely on immigration-politics would be wrong. Despite education consistently being one of the top 10 revenue streams for the nation, Australia is willing to take firm action that can contribute to easing the housing demand. Australia has also put caps and regulated AirBnb which impacts tourism(again, one of the top 10 revenue streams). What matters, is Australia does what it thinks is right for its citizens. The citizens are more legally organised and aware of ground realities before going into an election.
They dont invest in their own citizens , corporate greed etc play the major role so mobile disposable labor has become the answer lol after outsourcing !
😂😂 wow taking huge number illegal immigrants and give them house, money, free health care, education then citizenship nice 🎉🎉🎉🎉 and problem with legal immigrant and students
India needs to focus on creating opportunities in India. It is not the job of foreign countries to create jobs for Indians.
Well said
Indians are not begging for it. Foreign countries have demand but have incompetent locals to full fill their requirement. One Google search will tell you that Indian ethnic group are the most QUALIFIED ethnic group among migrant in Australia, Canda, UK and the US. Moreover, they are either the number 1 or 2 when it comes to household income. Also, they are not involved in any crimes. So, this is the value Indian brings in.
Right on.
That will attract them back lol or will not leave in the first place like folks from some countries Swiss / Denmark / Finland as an example .. very few leave
India needs to control it's population
As an Australian this is a good news for us..we don’t want our country to become like Canada..
Us Canadians never wanted our country to be this way. Canada is not the same anymore 😢. There are certain places here where we look like the minority.
@@JJ-wk5wy yes these South Asians have ruined it for international students
Because they are really here to work low paying manual labor jobs
With that said…
We borrowed and spent living the good life/high standard of living
That is what you folks don’t get… we are broke. Azzzzzz…. Canadians who can’t pay our debts sitting on 2 trillion in Provincial/Federal debt these days
Debt we really started running up in the 1940s.
Sow dem gud ole dais ye pine fer?
we didn’t pay for the first time around
Which we just kicked this debt down the road for future generations to pay for
Problem is, we stopped meeting “natural” population replacement rates in 1971
And we have around 1000 boomers turning 65 each and everyday in Canada (That started in 2011 won’t end until 2028) By 2036 we will have around 11 million Canadian seniors
As by 2032 immigration will make up 100% of our population growth
So we pack in the immigrants the poor ones to make our french fries and more importantly flip us over in bed in the old age home
The rich ones to come support the economy and prop up the real estate
Because most of these boomers are also personally cash poor/in debt
But luckily….most of these boomers????
Shockingly by some engineered miracle the last few decades 😉!!!!! own a 40 year old plus never been renovated, overpriced home some immigrant is willing to overpay for.
Which these boomers can get lines of credit on or reverse mortgage on or
sell if they have to
Which they should not .. … as that home will be one their own personal old age home in the future unless you can show me some links…
on our building/buying enough facilities to house millions of Canadian seniors in the next decade
Yes it’s one big Ponzi scheme that scr (ew) over the younger folks but we don’t want to crash our Ponzi Scheme of economy.
(I have purposely gone to live in countries and among the locals living on a dollar a day wages in comparison to our dollar. You think your life su…cks these days)
Try having 50k of someone else’s currency worth 2 million of our Canadian dollars
Or have what kids you and I did actually have…
Having to sell their wares to Russian sailors for a 500 CDN dollar loaf of bread
or trying to sail a boat to some distant country for a better life wind up washed ashore on a beach
Or grandmami/grandpapi begging on the street because that nest egg home they have they can’t sell off or afford to live in
So the people at the bottom of our society lose out…. or we all do
Don’t like packing in these immigrants/people as the solution?
Let’s hear you folks say “I demand to pay more taxes” and “I demand less social services in return”
Or let’s sell 25 year 50 year forward contracts on our natural resources some foreign corporation or Country can come into mine. Using our young as cheap labour
Or let’s be known as the deadbeat generation who had to resort to selling off pieces of Canada
Plus since we stopped replacing ourselves.
It will be more and more likely the great great great grandkids of these new immigrants stuck paying off the debts we run up long after we are gone… As we stick them with the bill
But since we have been sel fish our whole lives living that good life let’s “now” complain about the solutions after decades and decades of this
Our being broke… azzz Canadians who couldn’t replace ourselves
You don't only look like bro you are in minority in Brampton like places @@JJ-wk5wy
@alanrip1 tell me something that is that true you have bug problem
@@manishKuMer25 we need immigrants even poor Indian immigrants to do the manual labour work no one wants to do
But Indian International students who have no intention of going to school. Who come here just to work those manual labour jobs
Are ruining it for the real international students
Most Indians don't come for study but to stay.
Almost all of them
Fact
They also undercut the market by working for way lower than the average market value and by doing that they themselves get exploited by companies and mainly other indians then they complain. Meanwhile other people in the industry suffer because the labour market values become significantly low to the point it doesn’t become feasible anymore, all thanks to these indians and students who live 10 - 15 people in 1 house while trashing everything around them and disregarding the council regulations.
spending approx. $100,000 on education and boarding and not expecting anything in return doesn't make sense.
@@pradeepagnel2262 *most of them. Not all
I am an Indian but I can understand Canada's point of view. Why should the western countries help Indians just because India can't control its population? As for the money Indian students bring, these students cant expect to live in Canada indefinitely in return for the fees they pay... lets see what happens if foreign students studying in India demand the same from the Indian govt !!
😂😂 wow taking huge number illegal immigrants and give them house, money, free health care, education then citizenship nice 🎉🎉🎉🎉 and problem with legal
Remove reservations and get farmers to pay income tax
@@timemachine1421 farmer are you crazy? What about corporate
@@timemachine1421 its not reservation at all i have heard many of them were getting tech jobs with hefty salary but they denied to do jobs bcoz they wanted to go to canada to earn dollars even if thry hv to clean roads or drive taxis.. dont blame indian job opportunities as everyone wants to go abroad
@timemachine1421 no wonder they want khalistan when their own people treat them as outsiders!!
It is not their responsibility to give jobs to all immigrants😮.
Right on. Canadian educational institutions can and will survive without turion fees from foreign students.
@@AxAz12515 lol
Correct, each country should improve themselves to accommodate new jobs and economy
But they seem to be more than happy to give freebies to no skill Abduls and Ahmed.
These 1st world countries deserve what they are getting from the people who are full of "peace".
Okay I'm indian citizen who is giving me job 😢
If as Palki says these students are such an asset why doesn't India provide an higher education and housing for them. Instead chastising other countries for considering the concerns of their people.
They are an asset for various lobbies lol except for the citizens of the countries they end up in lol
It's because This channel is run by pro Indian govt propgandists 😂
she is blaming those countries for not able to fix housing crisis, but she doesn't blame indian govt which is not able to povide opportunities. hmmmmm
@@vikaskatiyar1120 Will run her agenda lol
C'mon man, i'm sure you know Palki & this channel agenda. It's always someone else's fault but myself that's the typical India's govt
As a national from Finland,who did 3 months exchange in Canada 4 years ago,i was actually shocked that 97% of the student in my class were indians,i dont hate indians,but my hope was to meet students from all around the world,not only indians,That was the goal of my student exchange, but honestly the indian students hardly stay in class,they just work work work and work. Glad i am back in Finland,Din't miss canada at all :)
Because you have good social security even if you don't want to work .Free education,free health care of course high taxes?In india the reservation curse is there do people opt to emigrate.
@@mohanrao6Reservation is a curse due to the karma of your forefathers, now U will pay for the sins of the forefathers because u gloat in the caste identity
Unfortunately those Indians students were really there just to work and not get an education
The give all international students a bad name
@mohanrao6 reservation is there for people who have been discriminated and most poor countries don't have privileges
@@raghavnamasivayam8706 and there are a lot of these "underprivileged" people who can afford to travel to other countries for leisure but can't afford to pay fees or compete on equal terms with general category of students. Because why would you
Good news! We need students not workers. Most students come here to work not to study.
Absolutly
you need students but not workers...lol....its like you want the food but dont want to do the dishes,,..thats not how it goes bro..................cancel foreign visa and zero people will visit your universities.......
And she says they bring in money . They take more than they bring by displacing Canadians out of their jobs and competing for scarce housing and strained healthcare
💯 many of them don't attend class because they are after the $$$$$. It needs to be strictly monitored by immigration. I don't know how some international students are granted student visas when they cannot understand or speak English.
Exactly ,i saw Videos of train station in canada,only indians i cant belive my eyes.
Question is whats Indian Govt doing to retain the talent and engage them in Industry.
Well, Indian Government is giving reservations. What else do you want?
Really nothing which is the problem. All these Indians are going abroad to study and then not come back to help Indian industries. They definitely need to do more to attract their top talent back.
@@dukhi_aatma372You are always Dukhi? India is a caste based country.
Such a ass hole reservation is not responsible for a job crisis in India.
Mukh Putra is only responsible
@@dukhi_aatma372 well a student who can go abroad and finance their studies wants menial government jobs in India with an average salary of 30 to 50 thousands. Because last I checked the private sector in India doesn't have reservations.....What an excuse you have....😂😂😂
They are building temples and religious corridors.
That is the right decision to protect the country.
They don’t go for higher education, they go to settle down. Student visa is a pathway to entry country legally. Correct yourself
Should have cracked down on this along time ago. You can’t keep letting people in when there isn’t even enough homes to house your own citizens. It’s simple logic that unfortunately has taken this long to materialize.
Politicians have their own agenda.
@Tate525, well these politicians need to remember who they work for. Public service is not the place where you insert your own agenda.
@@Tate525 well that agenda is fruitful for their citizens so be it
It's not incompetence bro, it's on purpose...hence why it's still continuing, even though the vast majority want it stopped. Democracy is the best. Do you remember when you voted for all of this?...me neither.
The indians are coming in at record levels. They also use NZ as a backdoor. People talk about Canada but i went to NZ a few months ago and the entire place is just Maori and Indians especially Punjabi's all over the place. You have to see it to believe it. Pre-Pandemic i don't remember seeing so many Indians all over the place but the last few years it is an explosion. They literally all came out of nowhere.
The difference between Chinese and Indian students.
1. Most Chinese students getting their student visa they study and spend money sent from their parents from China or elsewhere.
Indian students half study half working past time to finance their study. Not much money will spendh sending from India or from outside.
2. Most Chinese students after graduation they go back to China.
Indian students most stay on and compete with the local for jobs.
Indian youths desperate to leave india for PR and green card cuz they see no future in a 3rd world country like india
Indian student spend money 58 billion doller
So whose fault it is? Is it Canada 🇨🇦 or any country asking them to do so? Are they inviting them?? You are going there by your own wish 🙄
@@aschauhan9392 Really, around the world? Better they spend the money in India. No country forced Indians to spend money in Western countries they chose to and were aware of the tuition fees they would have to pay and still applied and signed on the bottom line.
@urdailygamr9229 immigration have right to change the rules whenever they feel like depending upon situation and circumstances.,. Like , how you like it if it is in your favour. You should also follow it if it is not in your favour? Nothing is promised in any country. One has to earn it.
I'm so happy I made productive decisions about my finances that changed forever. I'm a single mother living in Vancouver Canada, bought my first house in October and hoping to retire soon if things keep going smoothly for me.
Am so happy for you 🎉
Am looking for something to venture into on a short term basis, I really need to create an alternate source of income, what do you think I should be buying?
Cryptocurrency investment, but you will need a professional guide on that.
Facebook 👇
Evelyn C. Sanders
The problem with international students is:
1) Most come in without much funds(understandable)
2) Most work more than the allowable hours for international students
3) Most are exploited by Indians who own businesses in Australia (underpay)
And more reasons. It's India's job to provide education and jobs for its students...not Canada's or Australia's.
Also to add they don’t enroll in degree programs instead they take cheap useless diploma courses.Their main objective is to get “permanent residency”.
True Indians think western country's should give the job for them
And they like to shit on the road and beach 😂
@yellow13foxtwo maybe in india but havnt seen much here
I think palki sharma has explained it correctly, both Australia and Canada are facing severe economic slowdown, there are no jobs in the market, I’m in Australia from 8 years , I know people in Canada also , both the countries face acute housing crisis and government is not doing much to solve the problems, because all influential people and top politicians have huge real estate portfolios, no body wants to solve the problem everyone wants to milk the situation, same is the case in Canada. I’m seeing problem day in day out , it’s getting worse , Local aussies who were doing blue collar jobs not able to pay bills properly, it’s a messy situation in Australia and Canada
I used to pay $1200 for 1 bedroom in Toronto 10 yrs ago same 1 bedroom now is $2500 per.month in Toronto now 😢😢😢
Indian students were becoming a cash cow for bankrupt, garbage colleges and exploited by various lobbies lol
@@Karma_243To be fair recent prices are sure to be inflated definitely compared to a decade ago.
@@jay1645you realize public universities & colleges benefitted more from international student cash cow than private for -profit institutions.
@@shameermulji Cant say as don't have the stats but possible and have seen reports that gov funding was going down to both
In Australia, it is the rental crisis. The international students make it hard for locals to rent a property and not many properties are available for locals. Government wants to reduce the housing pressure.
Agree❤ I live in the Northern Territory and apparently next year our Territory is exempt from the International student intake. Meaning our local government here may advocate for more international students. We already have a rental crisis too. You often see 2 bedroom flats filled with 5-10 students in it 😅
Canada is already wrecked by the huge number of low skills ‘students’ from Punjab and Gujarat.
they are all millionairs now.
Low skilled? How do you know that and what’s your statement based on?
@@bharadwajpappu1936 because if you look at all the drivers, dhaba owners, and physical laborers in canada, they are all wearing turbans. and every single motel and lodge in US is owned by Gujjus.
@@bharadwajpappu1936 some Indians are doing well but Canada is a small developed economy which is already saturated. Even if some kids are talented it’s very difficult to penetrate job market. Indians are largely doing low skill jobs here, unlike US or UK.
@@bharadwajpappu1936 India is mostly low skilled and poorly educated population. Look at your PM. In 1.41 billion only 5 million are employed in IT and mostly doing low end jobs for cheap. Has India developed any product. Do you have any IT company which sells products for West. Just a few small ones not much. Even China is way ahead of India in AI. Thats bcoz India does not have the skills to move up the ladder currently and only can do services for cheaper labor bcoz cost of living in India is 20 times lower.
Canada/"Why would you want to kill a golden goose," as this reporter says.
My response: It's high time Canada and other Western countries cut down the number of foreign students as once they are in, they never go back to their home countries. They use the student visa route as a back door entry into the country.
Canadians are fed up and angry at this mass immigration of foreign students and temporary foreign workers. So now the government is listening and acting.
Why is it so difficult for foreign students to return to their country once their studies are complete. Indian students in some parts of Canada are demonstrating to extend their work permits. Why? Their studies are over.
💯 percent agree. They have taken away jobs of Canadian youth. They signed a contract that after studies to go back to their country. As you said, they used a student visa to stay in Canada.
Because they paid extra under the guise of studies
Ummm bcoz the International students have spent exorbitant amount of money for their studies and have ton of student debt. They need to work in the international country for atleast few years to get their ROI.
@@riyadey456but nobody asked them to take out large loans. If you cannot afford school, ensure that you have the money!
They can’t do that in the USA 🇺🇸. In the USA 🇺🇸 when your student visa expires you go back home. That’s how it should be.
Please remain in your country . Please it will good for all the people around the world
I am Indian and those Indian students must get back to India and try help the country grow. Being an Indian we must stop harming someone else country help to build our own country. If we Indians had to leave India for better life then why we have got independence for Britain at first place.
Ok, good for India. Indians
can start good international standard collages in India itself and keep the foreign exchange at home.
That would be interesting to see for sure.
Please do it
As a French, I think it is more an issue with policies set by both governments!!! You know you bring students IN and why don’t you build houses and encourage construction???? In France, many students come to study there (for free and we are proud of it!!!) BUT awe do not have the same issues as Canada (our healthcare is NOT under pressure and our housing prices haven’t really increased that much as compared to Canada for example!!!) to me, the students are NOT atao blame!!! It is the fault of the government who have FAILED to set the right policies!!!!
Well explained. Thanks for bringing up the video. Financial education is indeed required for more than 70% of the society in the country as very few are literate on the subject…
Most people think, investing in crypto is all about buying coins and leaving it to rise, come on it takes much analysis to be a successful crypto trader.
Trading without professional guide...Huh I laugh you, because you will remain where you are or even make huge losses that will stop you from trading, this has been one of the biggest problem to new traders
Honestly I really need help learning to trade. Seeing my portfolio low makes me very sad.
You're right! I have lost a lot trading all by myself without a guide. It's been an uneasy ride for me. Who is your mentor please. how can i reach her i really need help in this bear market now?
I know someone who can help you Olivia Brown
It's not just international students, just indians...
The lady says Australia is missing out on the "Golden goose" because international student numbers, particularly from her country, will be reduced 😂. Obviously not, hence it was done. I'm glad the new restrictions are in place. Hopefully this will help fight Inflation, particularly housing costs.
International students overestimate their value , because they have exploited the system
For too long.
We like our Canadian geese.
International students are not supposed to stay in their host countries. It is expected that they should come back to their home country. They are not migrants.
😂😂 wow taking huge number illegal immigrants and give them house, money, free health care, education then citizenship nice 🎉🎉🎉🎉 and problem with legal immigrant and students 😂😂😂
@@sirg3137 International students have exploited the system for too long. Its negatively affect local students, the rental market and job opportunities.
As an Australian who actually married an Indian woman who came here as a student, I can say she never had plans to stay and had a plan to go back and work in her father's business. She had around 50 Indians in her class and everyone has returned to India. But in truth there has been many who come here fail to study and do silly courses like Cooking to try to stay at some second-rate Uni and unfortunately, they have done a lot of damage to the reputation to Indian studing. But in truth, this is because the government has made a mess of the housing market
How did you guys met?
@@barneystinson6494 through a friend and been married 24 years
Isn't cooking on the skills list? Plenty of cooking jobs.
@@Dzamile25 100% The issue is there are tiny universities that have set up to take the money but don't enforce the rules and they have to in regards to the students showing up. The problem is the few who create the rules for all I remember when I first started seeing my now wife. She is lucky as her family live in Bandra Mumbai and has serious money so she never had to work here to study. Still, she chose to as a way of meeting people but some of the Students she studied with went and got massive credit card debts here and failed to pay rent for example, one left owing over $80,000 in debt to banks but many in her UNi used to talk about how they were doing it. Not to mention some who never showed up to a single class as they were driving taxis or working in Security jobs. etc.
I don’t believe your wife 😂 She choose to marry and Australian to stay in Australia it’s logical.
Good news glad to hear finally Aussies waking 🆙
As an Indian I want Australia, Canada and EU govt politicians to first take care of their citizens. The cost of living crisis has hit all economies baring few.
Also foreign countries must ban migration pathways based on education. This will stem the flow of Indian students. Blaming Indian students for adding to economic woes will create animosity which should be avoided.
I can't blame students in India looking for opportunities to uplift their economic status however it cannot be at expense of adding to economic issues in another country.
For genuine students Indian unis must continue to tie up with foreign unis on courses so that there is standardisation. There is no lack of good education in India.
It is just that there are no jobs for qualified students including professionals. This needs to be top priority for our govt and private sector.
There are tough times ahead for young generation which will be further augmented with adoption of AI. AI will create lots of job but those will not equate to jobs that AI will replace.
Humans are being phased out, U don't seem to understand the grand scheme
Well said
Your not an indian
Why so many youths leaving india and don't want to come back?
Well put.
BTW, the animosity against Indians has already reared its ugly head in Canada.
Nobody in Canada is calling the international students billions a golden goose nor the government or cares. Canadians care about fairness and rule of law and there is rampant abuse of these programs.
People forget that tax payers and local governments subsidise resources for international students !
Because they lied on their application 😅😅
And Australian system could not detect it?? 🤣👏🤡
NinaRohra are they supplied to come to india and check every application?Have some brain?
@@NinaRohra Blaming others but not seeing fault of self isn't it
The current situation extends beyond just a housing crisis. it’s closely tied to the job market. Local students are increasingly finding it difficult to secure unskilled jobs, which traditionally have been available to them. Many students and immigrants are now filling these roles, leading to a competitive environment where young locals are expected to start earning by age 18. They typically work part-time in unskilled positions to support themselves while studying at university. However, these jobs are often taken by unskilled immigrants and foreign students (primarily as a result of inflation and raised cost of living), as businesses frequently prefer hiring them due to their willingness to accept lower wages. for instance, many Indian grocery stores and restaurants hire Indian students who work for cash, often below minimum wage. in contrast hiring local students requires businesses to comply with legal wage standards.
This dynamic has sparked a significant backlash among locals, who feel that immigrants, refugees, and international students are "stealing" their jobs - a sentiment that holds some truth. In Canada, local students are protesting against stringent government measures, advocating for more relaxed policies and immediate PRs. This unrest is causing friction with locals and politicians alike, potentially complicating the future for aspirants from countries like India.
Yes and coincidentally youth crime has gone up. People don’t realise it’s tied to unemployment and economic disadvantage
Good move, a lot of students travelling to foreign universities had started thinking India as a temporary station....they became more loyal to US-UK-Canada then motherland... Sab ka demmag thikane lag jaayega...
Good move. I hope more and more countries will impose stricter regulations and limit large foreign students in the country. Good news. Thank you, First Post and Palki
I was an international student once in Australia in 2013. The wage rate then and now remained flat more or else but seems like rental has really shot up and I think this student cap is good for student and Australia both. Student make good earnings… better education and not much strain on existing infrastructure. I believe and agree with the approach.
Good for Australia as well as for India
The real issue is that we don't follow the laws and customs of the country we live in. For instance, after India won the T20, there was chaos on the streets of London, which is just one of many similar incidents. This kind of behavior frustrates the local population and turns them against immigrants.
I'm favoured, $27K every week! I can now give back to the locals in my community and also support God's work and the church. God bless America.
I know this lady you just mentioned. She's really good with and on her job. She's helped a couple of families and individuals' finances
She is really a good investment advisor.
I was privileged to attend some of her seminars, that's how I started my crypto investment
Started with 5,000$ and Withdrew profits
89,000$
I'm glad to write her tay I do hope she will help handle my paycheck properly☺️☺️☺️
Can I start with as low as $1,000?
indians coming to canada isnt just here to study but to work here. how do you feel if chinese comes to to India and take all job opportunities for the local? will you be happy? Student pathway is just a front for indians. their main goal is to work in canada! this is a great move for canada!
The truth is Most Indian students final goal is to stay in Australia and bring their family and student visa is the easiest way!. You cant blame them, everyone wants to have a better opportunity and good life! The life in India is hard that is why many are turning to scamming, the easiest way to earn big dollars!
People who settle abroad will not open their mouth on the hardships they face in living in another country. I have many relatives abroad who when they come here envy the casual way we lead our life here.
When they hit the high age they will know the value of staying in their country.
Grass is always greener on the other side.
@@ravindranmokkilmaruthur23 life of a prisoner in aus/ can is better than a corporate labour in india
With all these india talents + labour migrating out then this india 2047 superpower indianly impossible right 🤣
@@ravindranmokkilmaruthur23💯 percent agree.
As a French, I think it is more an issue with policies set by both governments!!! You know you bring students IN and why don’t you build houses and encourage construction???? In France, many students come to study there (for free and we are proud of it!!!) BUT awe do not have the same issues as Canada (our healthcare is NOT under pressure and our housing prices haven’t really increased that much as compared to Canada for example!!!) to me, the students are NOT atao blame!!! It is the fault of the government who have FAILED to set the right policies!!!!
Kids, please study in India and contribute to our country's economy ❤
First stop reservation and then speak
True reply
If so many kids want to escape India for better opps, then that means they lost faith on Indian govt.
These governments viewed foreign students as golden goose. They knew very well that most of the students from India/China were using student visas as a gateway to enter to these countries. I can understand if someone comes abroad for a PhD degree , but vocational training or a bachelor/masters degree?? Why pay millions to these countries, when you do not even know that a job will follow suit ??.. we Indians need to get rid of our obsession of these countries. Life is very hard also in these countries.. As someone, who left India 20 yeras ago for Germany to do PhD in Neuroscience, I can say that life is not easy in these countries.. stay in India and build India..
Over 90% Chinese students move here to study and get proper education unlike 90% Indians who takes study visa to settle abroad and do petty jobs
There are five times more Indians than Chinese and the Chinese bring wealth to Australia!
Its easier for someone who has stayed abroad for 20 years to say this... would you want to come back to India even if you get the same amount of pay here?
That's because the government is Mother Goose.
@@arnoldarnold2653if Indian hotel management industry pays even half of what I'm getting in Australia, I'll happily return to India 😂😂
The problem is they don't want to go home after
Golden Goose? The most delusional statement I’ve heard today.
Of course this channel will call their star students the Golden Goose as if they will save us.
As if not even 5 years ago when this wasn't even remotely a thing that Canadian and Austrialian unis were somehow unable to operate without them. I always see statements like this saying that we're paying so much more for the education, were basically funding your unis. Idk maybe it's like the government that subsidizes the education of it citizens through taxes payed for a life time by other citizens. It's not mystery as why these unis can exist both with and without them. Sure maybe the government is not directly paying for you to attend, but its not like government is really seeing any of the money they're spending going back to them. Many of the institutions that they're attending are just diploma mills that are churning out useless degrees and the private owners are the only ones benefiting by profiting heavily.
Problem in india🇮🇳 which will never be solved
1. Poverty: Persistent poverty affects millions, especially in rural areas.
2. Unemployment: High joblessness, particularly among the youth.
3. Education Disparities: Unequal access to quality education across regions.
4. Healthcare Access: Inadequate healthcare infrastructure, especially in rural areas.
5. Corruption: Corruption hinders development and public services.
6. Pollution: Severe air and water pollution, especially in urban areas.
7. Rape and Sexual Violence: Widespread reports of rape, harassment, and abuse, calling for stronger legal action and protection for victims.
8. Gender Inequality: Discrimination and violence against women in various forms.
9. Sanitation and Hygiene: Poor sanitation, leading to diseases and health problems.
10. Water Scarcity: Limited access to clean drinking water and irrigation.
11. Climate Change: Rising temperatures and erratic weather affecting agriculture.
12. Religious and Communal Tensions: Conflicts based on religion disrupt social harmony.
13. Judicial Delays: Slow legal processes and a massive backlog of court cases.
14. Child Labor: Continued exploitation of children in labor despite laws.
15. Farmer Suicides: Agricultural distress leading to farmer suicides.
16. Urban Slums: Overcrowded and underdeveloped slums in major cities.
17. Drug Addiction: Rising drug addiction, particularly in states like Punjab.
18. Caste Discrimination: Persistent social inequality based on caste.
19. Public Infrastructure: Inadequate transportation, electricity, and roads in many regions.
20. Mental Health Stigma: Lack of access to mental health care and societal stigma.
@@Rav01508 Bro typed to ChatGPT give top 20 problems in india which will never be solved
GG for various lobbies for sure lol
looks like canada has seen the light, it was at a dark place for a while. Now Australia finally see a glimpse of light too
Aptly put👍
Canada has not seen the light. Jughead Singh and Justdick Trudeau have seen the polls. And the polls have been speaking. Both of them are disliked intensely by most Canadians. One of the top concerns of Canadians is the changing nature of Canada due to the massive influx of backdoor immigrants (Students). Aaaand, there is an election next year in which the Liberals are predicted to lose. I cannot speak for Australia, but as far as Canadians see these students, the perceptions are consistently negative.
Poor hygiene, lack of basic English, overcrowding in houses, lack of civility, environmentally irresponsible (throwing garbage on to the streets and lawns), body odour... These are major concerns not only for Canada but to all western nations.
Yes Palki usually it’s government incompetence not a specific group of people that cause problems, remember that when you talk about problems in India!
Good decision. Had indians going abroad only for learning and studying , it wouldn't have been a problem. But many of these people don't care about the degree or subject they are studying but do any job to stay in that country permanently finding any means .
Higher education ❌ PR ✅
every country has the right to do what they want. their country their rules
In Australia, there is a critical housing crises. Met a lovely Indian girl, student, from India. Lovely girl. However, wd are struggling with high rents and not enough housing.
Migrants are absolutely one of thr reasons why rents have gone up. Here in Ontario,yhe rents are so out of control. Nothing in my are is under $1,000 a month. Houses are bought and rented out by these students, making it so hard for people to find somewhere to live.
Same crisis in Australia. Many international students overstay their visa, work under the table and overcrowd rental homes.
ABOUT TIME ....GEEZ !!!!
One million young folks are leaving India every year to "study" abroad. WOW, that's quite a number.
The majority are not going to Western countries to study per se but use the student visa route to never return to India but settle down in these countries.
India boasts of being a rising superpower, but then also has the highest number people who want to run to Western countries for something as basic as education. What a shame!!
They are not going for an education because it doesn't exist.
There is competition for seats in good universities in India, as it should be, so the academically capable study tough courses and make something out of their lives.
The academically less proficient people, with their father's money, is simply trying to migrate.
They shouldn't even try higher education.
Education provides a legal cover to reach there.
The aim is to leave India with its overcrowded, crime-filled, polluted, filthy cities with poor facilities and settle to a comfortable life abroad and be rich and finally take up citizenship there.
Your consistent anti-India posts in the past only shows how meaningless and insight-less your comments are to us all.
You’re a funny man 😂
Same with China.
@@urldroidsuperbot2139 May I suggest that " because it doesn't exist" is a sign of the negative attitude among too many Indians.
But these same govt take illegal migrants and give them hotel 😅😅😅😅
Indians,stay,study and live in your own country!!!
That’s fine. The two countries mentioned here are not worth wasting so much of money anyway 😌
@@daredevil30000 Wonderfull,so tell them!!!!
not enough toilets
@@daredevil30000 Good. Now stand outside Canada and Australia visa offices in India and explain this to your fellow citizens.
It’s very hard to LIVE in India, most people are only surviving
Indian diplomatic relations are worsening with UK loving nations.
It’s time for India to invest in its own educational institutions
Developed countries are right in their own way to set their own rules to benefit their own people. Immigrants that want to seek better quality of living can’t do so at the cost of locals. There needs to be a balance, and every country and political party has a right to determine this. Countries are unfortunately becoming more nationalist to seek support from the masses. Democracy is flawed because it lets masses and incompetence win, over merit or “fair” opportunity. Political parties portray “fair” in ways that suit them best, and off late it is more polarising in nature and less collaborative.
Very good. Even UK should only allow top 20 universities to get international students.
@@VigneshRamamurthythat wont work buddy.
Good for Australia and Canada. As Indian I fully support
😂😂😂
🤡🤡 "I fully support"... India me izzat he nahi milta hai Merit ko, sabko Reservation chahiye to Merit wale kaha jayenge??
@@Curiosity403 are chd na
@@Curiosity403 aisey hi complain karte firogey, desh chorke chale jayenge bache uske bad rotey hai ki Bharat abhi tak pichda kyu hai. Awaj uthana zaruri hai, collective movement hona chahiye. Desh chorke toh koi bhi bhed-bakra nikal sakta hai.
Irresponsible parents sending their child to other country. Where they are hated 😂 and suffer a lot. Better fix Indian education and roads and behaviour.
The Australian policy targets all international students, not just Indians. In fact, the government should take big responsibility for the housing crisis. But Overseas students certainly contribute to the problem, not just the housing. Many students also don't work in the field they studied, many keep enrolling courses to extend the stay, but never completing or working in their field etc. All these things make it harder to estimate the Cost vs benefit. And yes, they are soft targets to blame students instead of better policies & executions. But not to worry, when Universities run out of money, they'll ask for Government assistance, and the Government will increase numbers in time.
The majority were indians.
Australia and canada are trying to lower the cap of indian students
Tax payers and local governments largely fund universities too. Sorry to disagree but there’s plenty of youth and domestic students that need work too.
Very good decision😊
Every country must develop their own resources, human and otherwise. Skilled migrants' number should always be limited. Education should be to learn, not first step in settling in other country. It is time India invests more on education, infrastructure and town planning, and make living conditions better in India.
💯
I agree.. and there shouldn't be a visa after study. They can stay, only if they get sponsored by a company to work there. I wonder if the education in india is really that bad? or they study abroad just for pride? Just watched another video, they study abroad is just for a pride.
It is the country's internal matter of both Australia and Canada why will an Indian media comment, suggest and propagate the countries how to act ? Wisdumb? 😅
@@tennysun6050 ur face looks like u doesn't know how media works 😭🤣🤡
Not just the housing prices, food prices have also risen.
Ty palki for covering this, as a Canadian i believe its about time, housing is not there, students are living in homeless shelters, some stories say under bridges in tents.
I live in Canada and I can be honest with you when I say that international students ruined the cost of living here. Rent in Canada is out of this world. Landlords prefer international students to rent their properties than Canadian cuz they pay more than Canadian citizen and not to mention groceries is just another level, minimum you've to spend $200-300 per week. I'm not against international students but they're the reason why the cost of living is no longer easy for Canadian.
You're delusional. CoL is due to inflation caused by Money printing by Bank of Canada and then debt based capital expenditure + money laundering (read Ukraine aid) by Canadian political establishment. You can blame international students on many things, but not on this one
It simply means you are blaming your incompetence on to others. If you are competent, then you could have found a job that pays well and afford the good things. This is true anywhere in the world. Also it is true, even in India, that there are people who hate inbound migrations. They usually tend to be the incompetent ones who blame everyone else for their misfortunes. The international students & high skilled immigrants are following the law. You are not the country, you just get one vote. If you have problem then take it up with your govt. Also you should be knowing that international students are an asset - if they dont come, then the STEM jobs wont be filled. Most of these top corporations have presence worldwide including India. They will simply ship the job overseas. Which means your entire town will turn into a ghosttown eventually. Lets say a foreign student comes and works in your country for $5000 per month. They would typically end up spending $4000 on rent,fuel,grocery,restaurants,bills etc. ie consumption. If that job is shipped overseas, all the connected industries will lose their income. So to satisfy ONE INCOMPETENT PERSON, should the entire economy suffer ?
10 indian students live in 1 bedroom apartment
@@brownhunk007 I'm not against those students but they've do whatever it takes to survive, I blame the government for making it so hard for Canadian. They let in too much students into the country that they can not sustain it and the results is so devastating for everyone.
@@amulejohn The students are not to blame, they simply go to study, what's more, they contribute to the economy of the country. The problem lies in the governments and the attitude of private companies that are experts in creating these funnels to blackmail governments, especially in taxes.
Interesting piece of information as usual... the question is who are considered as the locals in Australia and Canada 😅? Is it the original people there or European immigrants ....!
It is sometimes good to monitor the migration and how much a country can handle, if there is better pay in own country nobody would go out.
It is just the pay and currency and value of the income which they may receive that makes studying abroad fancier as well.
Most students are professionals who join pg or any course , but on top of that they bring in the family - say wife or husband and kids , to support the family both have to definitely work in a foreign country because as students one person can only work for specific hours.
Although there are many concessions, it is like that country has to create a job for every student who comes with family.
They need place to stay, if they have kids there are more rules on accommodations, housing is definitely a problem as it is easier to allot a student hostel to one person but developing a housing community for new families entering is difficult for any country.
This family is actually going to take a job that was supposed to be for someone else.
This is one of the most used way of Migration.
When the job market is too volatile for the existing people, more people coming in is a burden for any country as it has to provide housing, water, electricity and basics for any human. It is a boon and a bane.
Most of Son's classmates went to Foreign Countries, I told my son to concentrate and get good Job in india and become a specialist and visit as Specialist not as job seeker. I have seen most of his colleagues in PSU studied in IIT or otherwise went to USA for MBA just to stay forever. It is shame for all of us.
They never leave and they bring with them their family too.
Same way the Europeans did to the Aborigines
Not only...they bring their smells as well...no higene...
Same way Europeans captured canada and us and suppressed native people.
Learnt from the best …. Europeans
@@jakekim8150Well said 👏👏
we have protests in streets of students from o/s demanding to stay beyond education- this ruins it for other people wanting the education chance.
I think Australia and Australian government should be worried about Chinese people becoming majority citizens especially communist then worrying about international student related to education.
They already did…now it is India turn.
@@jt6231😂😂😂😂😂
Please check people walking on the streets of Australia, which more from India, or China. Of course Indians, full of streets are Indians. Listen to what canadian said---------Chinese student come to study with money , but Indian student come to work or stay without money.
Chinese students do NOT need to migrate because they easily go to any countries.
@@jt6231 Please check people walking on the streets of Australia, which more from India, or China. Of course Indians, full of streets are Indians. Listen to what canadian said---------Chinese student come to study with money , but Indian student come to work or stay without money.
Chinese students do NOT need to migrate because they easily go to any countries. and they mostly come back to East Asia once graduated.
The difference between Chinese and Indian students.
1. Most Chinese students getting their student visa they study and spend money sent from their parents from China or elsewhere.
Indian students half study half working past time to finance their study. Not much money will spendh sending from India or from outside.
2. Most Chinese students after graduation they go back to China.
Indian students most stay on and compete with the local for jobs.
Ginagawa kasing path to permanent residency ang student permit. Canada allows direct family members to join a student in Canada. Kapag di magkasya sa daily expenses ang employment income ng family member sinisisi ang govt. dahil mahal daw ang cost of living.
Percentage of Asian students returning to their home countries after graduating from US universities:
S. Korea🇰🇷 = 98%
China🇨🇳 = 97%
Taipei🇨🇳 = 63%
HongKong 🇭🇰 = 57%
Malaysia🇲🇾 = 47%
Thailand🇹🇭 = 44%
Indonesia🇮🇩 = 31%
Philipland🤴 = 0.3%👈
India🐄 = 0.02%👈
Source: USA Ivy League Student Survey 2023
Once indians including south asians enter Australia,Canada, US and Europe, they will never leave. Their main goal is to get pr/green card by any means(skilled/asylum/marriage) there and bring families. Harsh truth..
Not only driving up the rents here in Canada but many local Canadians do not have jobs as they were taken by the students, visitors who are staying here for extended period of time.
Current situation in Canada is proof that countries like India where you can pay and get any goddam degree should be banned from any visas except for extraordinary talent or humanitarian.
These two countries combined account for over 3 billion people & climate disasters along with pollution have made most of there countries uninhabitable
why don't Indian student study in Israel. India and Israel are best friends, it should be no problem for both to work together. Indian students will be able to work in international high tech industry, while Israel will get the benefits of obtaining a high skilled professional workers. A win-win situation
Israel would want students who actually had the will and ability to study and excel.
@@danachats8944 Bharatiyans have the ability to study and excel perfectly! Many are doctors and IT experts, suitable for developing Israel
Demand & Supply, Maybe Israel doesn’t need that many foreign students, plus it’s a volatiel region due to its conflict with Arab nations, safety comes first.
@@samarthpandey683 nonsense! Israel can have as many Bharatis professionals and students it wants. Bharatiyans men are capable and extraordinary soldiers and Israel can use them to replenish their troops. Israel is the new frontier for Bharatiyans!
@@10000years Indians and Russia. Mody loves Putin so they will be welcome there,go.....
Good decision.
Harsh but good
😂😂 wow taking huge number illegal immigrants and give them house, money, free health care, education then citizenship nice 🎉🎉🎉🎉 and problem with legal immigrant and students
Sri Lanka is happy with this decision of Australia. The reason is that Sri Lanka provides free education to the children of its own country and they migrate to other countries after getting their education. Another country is benefiting from the investment made by Sri Lanka for them.
Canadians are raised to not hate and to embrace diversity (including being taught this in all daycares/schools). People need to look at all sides.
India has a 29% unemployment rate amongst it's own graduates. One of the big reasons why young people are leaving India in droves, yes? Plus less than 50% of the 950 million working-age population in India is employed (compared to over 70% in other emerging markets). Amongst the Indian working group, many are self-employed and contain “unpaid helpers in family enterprises”. India has one of the highest emigration rates in the world. As many zero in on education as a way to gain access to a western country?
Did international students/families pay into Canadian taxes all their lives like domestic students have (earning cheaper tuition fees)? No. Plus Canada did NOT tell international students/parents to spend/risk their life savings on a "Canadian dream". Canada did NOT tell international students to borrow money. Canada did NOT promise international students work. Canada did NOT promise international students money. Canada did NOT promise international students PERMANENT RESIDENCY.
Meanwhile freelance agents have been operating in an unbridled market in India. Often by painting a distorted picture of what students can receive from Canada. Plus in recent years, a new type of recruitment has cropped up via foreign nationals as many "edu-tech" have created online platforms to connect millions of potential students with the recruiters. The sub-agents have absolutely no no direct connection with the Canadian college. Plus the college has no no ability to control their conduct. Indian sham operations abused/abusing Indian students in person &/or via massive advertising. PRIMARILY in their native language that most Canadians do NOT understand. Painting a false picture in their minds (of what Canada could or would or should offer).
Canadians are seeing primarily Indians protesting & waving their flags on Canadian streets making demands. Because they may not have enough credentials to remain in Canada? And because rules designed to protect CANADA are not meeting their desires? Why isn't there crowds of African or Caribbean or Filipino etc., students making demands? They're in Canada too.
And even though Canada is being falsely/unfairly blamed for too much, Canada has yet to deport students like crazy (but likely will soon). Instead Canada has been trying trying to find balance of who can stay vs go. While also trying to fix anything Canada did wrong. Create a better future. Why? Because Canadians actually care about doing so for both Canadians and international students.
Canada's own youth are also victims of the above mentioned scam artists now too. Due to a SEVERE lack of affordable homes, and lack of entry level jobs, and healthcare waiting times now ... partially due to international students swarming the system then fighting for PR etc., versus returning home. Including some students asking for Canadian asylum (which rarely gives them PR).
Questions:
⦁ What is India doing about any of this? After Canada told India to halt Ghost Consulting. Many Indians keep saying their politicians are corrupt. True? Plus Canada didn't have numerous PRIVATE 'diploma mills' until 40% of international students were from India. Coincidence? Schools that Canada is shutting down.
⦁ What about all the YT videos that primarily Indian nationals have posted (for half a decade now including today) all advertising Canadian PR like they're selling a product? Promoting Canadian visas & permits & schools & jobs etc. etc.. Videos not only posted hourly but rarely in English or French. With very very rare input from Canadian citizens.
⦁ What about the IELTS spouses? Anchor babies?
⦁ What about Canadian food banks & other charity services being recklessly advertised on YT in Indian languages?
⦁ What about Canadian housing being scooped up en-mass as investment vehicles by, and for, foreign nationals? Some home rental/boarding signs stating "vegetarians only can apply". Often these 'landlords' also cram 20 students in a small home and charge them each way too much for rent.
⦁ What about Indian nationals buying local businesses then repeatedly putting Indians only in the top tier positions (while also changing familiar work practices)? BC & Ontario are also outlawing the Caste System.
⦁ What about the Sikh vs Hindu violence/extortions across Canada? Diasporas stirring up tribal hatreds (in Canada) even though it all stems from their ancestral home. Why?????????
⦁ What about the Canadian government launching investigations in regards to foreign interference in Canadian elections, stemming from Asia continent? Canada also had to end flagpoling at the border.
Canadians are so so so not used to all this!! Do Indians care about Canadians suffering too?
Or do they primarily want to point fingers at the Canadian government etc., when many things weren't in Canada's control?
Canadians want multi-culturism to succeed and for all people (including immigrants) to be okay. Now everyone I know is VERY happy with IRCC's recent changes (reductions & multifaceted investigations etc.). Including multi-generational long-term Asian Canadians MOST upset (by all of this).
PS Immigration being decreased in: Ontario, Quebec, British Columbia, The Maritimes, Alberta, Saskatchewan, & Manitoba. Chances are better for homebuilders, healthcare-givers and job CREATORS.
Bro, I feel you completely but you're literally missing out on the Canadian government's inability to handle the entire situation. I mean, yeah sure no one from Canada called the students there, but they all were granted visas by the Canadian government right? Those visas are legal and valid. You are only presenting one side of the coin while conveniently ignoring the other. The Canadian government sure knew what they were doing giving these many student visas in the first place, they were minting outrageous amounts of money in imports. You sound like you're one hundred percent affected by the high unemployment and inflation, and you're venting here. While you may be right here, you are definitely overlooking so many crucial facts, like how the Canadian government has given its complete support to Khalistani Secessionists, who are becoming a constant nuisance for Indians there and now Canadian locals too. I would like to say one more thing, which is Indians are not the only group of people emigrating every year to Canada, there's other Asian ethnicities too, like Chinese, Filipinos, etc. Why don't you have any problems with them taking away your jobs and opportunities? I'll tell you something, if you're so worried about all this, you should consider voting for a better government in the future elections. Good luck.
It's fine I agree with your, but then tell why did canadian govt gives Visas and citizenship to gangsters and terrorist.
They hide them and provide shelter to them. These gangsters had killed hundreds of people in India and supply drugs in India. Yet your govt didn't act on that. Seems like only India don't have corrupt govt.😏
Copy Paste BS I see this exact text everywhere NOBODY F*ING HATES YOU. I don’t understand how you jump to such ridiculous assumptions when people state the facts. Canadians are actually a really kind loving people on God’s blue planet, that’s why they are leaving their beloved country and going to anywhere they can (US, Mexico, Latin America) because they couldn’t afford to live in their country. They are leaving their one only country to make a room for people who will for sure bounce to their country if shit hits the fan. That’s how Canadians are freaking kind bro! Stop the cap, go crowd the US and see what happens!
Western just don’t want no more foreign student from India or Asian country
where tf did you pull that 29% ? this is what google said: According to the Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE), India's unemployment rate in June 2024 was *9.2%*, which is a significant increase from 7% in May 2024. Also, only highly qualifed people go to countries like Canada, which means they can easily find job anywhere in the world, including India.
Apart from non exiting housing, there are no better economic opportunities in Australia. That was 20 years ago when I came here.
Canada and Australia freely import European origin students and workers as exchange students and workers from England, Germany, France, Poland, Argentina, Uruguay, Spain, South Africa and more. Why.. because Canada and Australia trace their origin to European brothers and sisters as cousins so, importing European origin people is clearly not the loss to Australian and Canadian genetic identity and at the same time, the artificial nature of their culture can easily be trained over time through assimilation. People of European origin are easily imported for marine research, hotel management and hospitality, big team based research reservations in universities among these countries, arts and movies like the US importing Russell Crowe, Nichole Kidman, Charlize Theron, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Leonardo DiCaprio, Margot Robbie, Kate Winslet, Dolf Lundgren to act in classic US Hollywood American country side movies. So, Polish, French, German, British, Argentinian, Spanish, Norwegian, Danish, or Austrian can easily be assimilated without any identity politics in Australia and Canada. But, these developments in Australia and Canada are racially motivated because the word immigrants today is linked with non-European origin people from all over the World and not at all with European origin people present in the rest of the World. Multi culturalism only happens when people of different genes are given equal chance and rights..but, that is what Australia and Canada European origin rulers cannot relate to by making racist policies like these without being explicit about Xenophobia. You can also make sense in case of the US is that the US-Canadian border is not much of an issue as much as Mexico-US border because from Mexico and below all Latin countries don't have large European origin genes as it is the case with Canadian genes that is the European genes it is all happening out of Xenophobia right from source the character of people of United Kingdom riots resonating into all Common Wealth countries like Canada and Australia. 👉 Xenophobia and Fear of multi non-European culturalism expansion and their financial freedoms 👈
You know that according to statistics India is the most racist country on the planet right. There are several leaders in the governments of these countries of Indian origin. Let me ask you how many prime ministers have been of North Eastern Origin.
Stop with the woke stupidity. We know why you want in, you don't respect the country's rules. Your country also regularly posts expansionist wet dreams called Akhand Bharat and you look down on your neighbours. You are no different then the british. Remember you are not the victim, you are merely a competitor for the spot of oppressor.
Disagree. Indians take over whole cities and towns in their host countries. Differences is Europeans don’t overpopulate countries where they go and at least give a fair go to other cultures and nationalities.
Students from India, particularly the Punjab region, are notorious for non compliance with visa conditions, frankly, they grossly rort the system, overstay, disappear into the black economy, bribe educational institutions to record them as attending when they are working. The increase by 50 % in the private vocational sector is particularly concerning. A significant proportion are conducted by Indians and they co operate in the rorts. It's well past time the authorities took action. Hypocrites like Ms Sharma act all pious and cast aspersions on law abiding, decent, compassionate societies like Australia and Canada, but happily abide the most corrupt government and public service systems in the World.
Censors really went nuts to day .I'm sure Palki wouldn't approve of her much loved India being,: " recolonized " by us western folks either .
Its complete nonsense to call incoming international students who want to live and work within the Canadian systems as "colonists".
@@sravibhaskarit’s not. They ultimately bring their squabbles to these countries and refuse to integrate.
Funny enougn India is on track to face a similar population collapse problem as China in a few decades with its birthrates in a downward spiral. Would be ironic if they need immigration themselves to stave off their dwindling population.
Can't you see globalization has failed? @@sravibhaskar
@@sravibhaskar In the UK many of the international arrivals claim to be colonizing the UK as " revenge " for British colonization. .Canadians with 200 years of ancestory on the land now known as Canada are constantly referred to as colonizers to this day Really is my comment such a stretch ?
Immigration curbs in Canada and Australia now extend to ALL TYPES of migrants- such as temporary foreign workers, asylum seekers and foreign students. Politicians are now focusing on complaints from the public about job shortages requiring skilled workers, as well as demand/supply imbalances in residential housing, health care, education and social support services
I Live in Australia from last 9 years, came as a student, finish the study on time, got PR with in 3 years, secure the job. Worked hard , learned alot, got opportunities to step up few times which I did and finally running my own few businesses. It’s a land of opportunity.
what a beautiful country.
What I understood from politics and locals, they will never let it become Canada, UK and America. This country is very different then these other west country. They happy what they have, and don’t want to being too many people in, nor foreign business as they damage the environment.
Australia is very concerned about their environment and have strict environmental policies.
Regarding international students, this is very true that they have housing crisis and now job crisis since they brought 500000 students in in recent financial year.
Locals are blaming migrants for this.
Politicians are doing what they can to make people happy.
Very true what you say about Aus being different to other western countries! Glad you are so happy here ❤. It’s definitely a lucky country
But 270,000 is two whole Caribbean islands. So they want two countries into Australia?
Indians!!!!! Mainly
So hamas is better 😂
one of the problem is that they allow international students to work..which make the locals having hard time to look for employment..
Singapore seriously needs to follow this
Singapore is not worth spending money on!!
The biggest problem is that they do not leave.. we are struggling to house locals let alone all of the students.
Dear International students. DO NOT COME
Australia is doing the right thing.
Hopefully, this works for Australia. Canada did it well after the horse left the barn.
Pivoting the cause entirely on immigration-politics would be wrong. Despite education consistently being one of the top 10 revenue streams for the nation, Australia is willing to take firm action that can contribute to easing the housing demand. Australia has also put caps and regulated AirBnb which impacts tourism(again, one of the top 10 revenue streams).
What matters, is Australia does what it thinks is right for its citizens. The citizens are more legally organised and aware of ground realities before going into an election.
Australia and Canada have no choice but to accept Indians and Philippinos to work for the betterment of their citizens and the world as a whole
Haha, say that to the average Aussie and see what they think.
They dont invest in their own citizens , corporate greed etc play the major role so mobile disposable labor has become the answer lol after outsourcing !
I'm an Australian citizen of Indian background. YOU NEED TO WAKE UP TO REALITY.
Keep dreaming 😂 The Phillipines and India should improve their own country economy instead. You need Australia , Australia/ Canada doesn’t need you !
😂😂 wow taking huge number illegal immigrants and give them house, money, free health care, education then citizenship nice 🎉🎉🎉🎉 and problem with legal immigrant and students