House mice genealogy from across the world revealed their origin all the way back to INDIA. House mice are found only where there is availability of farming because house mice depends on grains for food. This also indicates that the agriculture first started in INDIA even thought at present there is no archeological evidence and in nation like India getting archeological evidence is too difficult because many generations have been living in same areas and population increased over thousands of years and many areas which were previously farms are now converted to cities, towns.
yes doesnt make up narratives but dismisses Graham Hancock flix after 5 mins and starts calling him pseudo archeologist. well done whoever this lady is. and after 10mins i am also done with this podcast 🤣🤣🤣
@@dankim-c2oexactly LMAO! Listen to what he has to say.. man has legit points about plenty things which even the archeological studies fail to explain...
There's a place called Jwalapuram here in Andhra Pradesh where they found ashes errupted from Toba volcano 75000 years ago. The depth of the ashes was nearly 10 feet. They found stone tools which are used for farming under the Ash bed. And similar tools over the Ash bed too. They say people over there survived the volcanic erruption where rest of the world completely vanished.
Bro can you please suggest real good historical sites in AP. I am visiting Ind and have set aside a week for AP which I never could during my earlier visits
Perfect! :) Loved this episode very much! As an Indologist, I would say, Disha is the best representation for the youths to inspire them in the field of archeology to set the correct picture of Indian History in front of the nation. and, Ranveer, thanks to you for inviting such wonderful guests on your show. My best wishes to both of you :)
Issue is Aryan Invasion still being taught to the students. Even outside India it is still popular and being taught. India has to rewrite this story inside and outside
I am glad that cbse doesn’t teach the Aryan invasion theory for the higher classes (11th and 12th grade). However, it is a different story for younger classes.
Ranveer bhaiyaa I would request you to kindly bring Archaeologist Kk Muhammad sir. He is one of the best archaeologist in india who has got padma shri for his work. His notable works include Excavations of the Ram Mandir, Bateshwar Complex restoration, Discovered the first Christian Chapel of North India built by Akbar at Fatehpur Sikri. Excavated the Buddhist Stupa of Kesaria built by Emperor Ashoka. Discovered and excavated Buddhist Stupa in Rajgir. Excavated the Buddhist archaeological site in Kolhua, Vaishali etc. Please bhaiyaa bring him to your show 🙏
Your podcasts have been a large source of knowledge for the entire gen z generation, and your podcasts bring out the true history of Bharat. Thank you Ranveer for taking so much efforts in bringing out the true history through your podcasts
She is like the best archaeologist ever coz she knows beginning to end about her subject and presents it so accurately in highly articulated way... thanks for having her on your show...🙏✌💥💫
I am from Sriganganagar, and the way she explained history of the place is incredible and makes a lot of sense. Thanks Ranveer for asking questions on behalf of millions of us ✨
@Aman Jha mmooslims r not kashmiri ...... these r 2 different things....... those who follow rishi kashyap are known as kashmiri and those who follllow some aarrab guy r whatever ....
Would love more conversations with rajarshi nandy sir… Had a intuition that you got your guru for your recent spiritual interests! Please share your spiritual growth during this phase of your life
Another wonderful Indian archeologist! It is an exciting time for history, science and mythology as well. The more evidence we get the more interesting it seems to be. Thanks for such a great program!
@@beerbiceps Stop getting such *'HalfEducated, Unscientific, cheap Fancy Archeologists'* 😂 trying to prove *'Physics & Math is myth'* 🤣 Just let them debate with *'[Legendary Physicist] Shubhas Kak, Sanjay Dixit [IAS] , Nilesh Oak[Engineer & Cosmologist], Niraj Rai[Legendary Genetic Scientist] & ofcourse 'Sir AVIJIT CHAVDA'* 😜 All the *'So Called "FACTS"* imagined by this junks will get *'EXPOSSED'* 🙊🙏
You are free to disagree with Global consensus but forcing others to disagree is one step backwards towards progress. It's like Turkey recently removed evolution from the syllabus because it goes against the pre-existing beliefs of the Muslims. Some things need to be studied even if you disagree with them, that's how we reached the point where we are now. Imagine if we were to be stuck with the Geocentric model?
@@indianboy59 wdym? Even AIT in foreign is long debunked. They now think of AMT. Even then Indian scientists like Dr. Niraj Rai (DNA scientist) has proved Out of India theory
@@nw3877 read my comment again, I said "Some things need to be studied even if you disagree with them" It means we should be open-minded to other possible explanations that go against our pre-existing beliefs. Human migration is a pretty debatable and contro-ver-sial topic, there's not much objectivity either so academics from different parts of the world have their own biases, conscious or unconscious and Indian academics are NO exception. And OIT is not even a theory but a hypothesis created by reli-gious natio-nalists of a particular reli-gion as a response to Euro-centr-ism and colo-nialism. Niraj Rai after the Rakhigari excavation concluded that "It's just the beginning" OIT is not a global consensus and it's only accepted within the defined borders of a particular country and more precisely by people belonging to a particular faith. Now tell me there's no bias here.
@@indianboy59 who the f cares? When there are evidences? Average uneducated Europeans still believe they are originators of Indo-European languages but their original kind was lost way back to Yamnayas who weren't cultured as so called Aryand supposed to be. The very word Aryan should be banned or redefined very strictly.
Sir plz continue series of Chatrapati Shivaji Maharaj and Chatrapati Sambhaji Maharaj with Medha ma’am🙏🙏 I don’t know why not many people are talking about it . That was a great series though hearing perspective of both sides✌🏻
becaus in the last episode she said that she would be outside mumbai for a couple of months, had you skipped that part of the last episode. Everyone knows she will be back again after an interval
@@rishiteshmaharana5936 bro its been too long and there was not a single update about it And for ur information these podcast are recorded like a month ago before its release And i just simply requested it from the creator , why are u getting so rude about it
I would like to recommend two names connected with the history of Sabarimala. 1. Shri.V. Aravind Subramaniam, Author, Speaker, Researcher 2. Smt. Sinu Joseph, Menstrual Educator, researcher and author of two awesome books - Women and Sabarimala, and Rithu Vidya.
@@beerbiceps bro when are you bringing medha maam for sambhuraje's history. Eagerly waiting for people to come to know about him. You got soft power bro. May the people came to know who sambhuraje was . He needs you
@@palwinder_kaler it's takes tym. Now brahmin has power in india. Time Will come when our tribals ppls will have education in majorities. Dr ambedkhar has given us a reservation. Not now but obviouslywe LLL come
Very insightful listening to an Indian Archaeologist. Thanks for making this video. We listen so much on youtube from western archaeologists but listening to an Indian Archaeologist feels so good specially listening to our Indian history.
Excellent podcast. Worth mentioning that many Hindu Epics to make references to astronomical events and constellation/star/planetary positions in the night sky. This is an ingenious way to time stamp major events e.g. Bhisma's passing after the actual Mahabharata War. So while the hard material evidence from archeological digs and surveys may be the ultimate proof of an event, we should recognise that over the eons of time, a lot of this evidence may have been lost or degraded or even stolen through countless battles and conflicts. We are talking about territorial humans at the end of the day. So, perhaps that's why our recorded scriptural evidence used astronomy to book mark significant events. Maybe the Rishis were onto something!
@@amolkhobaragade that is an assumption. In any case, there are multiple time stamps in each and every book. You are free to disprove even one time stamp. They all fall within the period of 1 human life, approx 100 years, and are not some random time stamps that the authors recorded. You could check if you want.
It didn’t happen eons ago sir, it only happened 3000 years ago and we have technology to go back 50,000 years ago and beyond easily, so if it were to be real some corroborating evidence would have been found
The way she explains the facts by keeping in mind the sentiments of religioun and her profession is fire. One thing I want to mention that concerns me a lot. I am south Indian, from Andhra Pradesh(Telugu) , when you refer south Indian people that believe and fight for their identity in based on Aryan Invasion Theory, It just kills me inside. No one do that. Its just a political stunt happening in Tamilnadu, Except some tamilians who are arrogant about their language is the first one, No one cares or believes in AIT. Believe me, 90% of the south Indian doesn't know AIT had happened. Archeologically, ethically and logically AIT is a myth. we never never think north people are invaders but our brothers. Requesting you not think us as dividend dravidians who thinks a division happened. Bharath mata ki jai. Jai Hind. And Disha, you made my day 😍. (Please Pardon my grammar)
It is so great comment bro,trust logically it dosen't make any sense ,how can aryans chased dravidans for thousands km ,it is not possible, there were no borders ,it used to a subcontinent ,definitely this theory is invented by British and now enjoyed by Tamilnadu politicians
@@Pushparaj-fe9fk bro aiyo I am not obsessed with all this ,on side tamilians clame they are singhams and chola great empire, and another side they says aryan came pushed Tamils from indus civilization to down south more than 2000 km chased,please guide bhai 🙂🙏🏻
Wonderful episode. Very informative too for normal people who are beginners in the search of real history. Archeologist Disha's speech is awesome. But she talked about Aryan migration theory from an archeologist's point of view. It is like seeing a gigantic three dimensional image from one angle alone. It does not give us a complete picture. History should be understood through the eyes of a multidisciplinary team consisting of historians, archeoligists, linguists, literary scholars, physicists, geoligists, and many more experts of varied fields. Aryab migration theory was not formed with archrological data alone. Hence, if there are more discussions with experts in varied sciences who have opinions on the Aryan migration theory (both FOR and AGAINST) it would bring more clarity in the topic. We would like to see Shri R.Balakrishnan, retd IAS officer of Odisha who has written a book called ' A journey of a civilization - from Indus to Vaigai' and the history Prof.Karunanandhan in this interesting channel of yours regarding Aryan migration theory.
As Disha Madam would discuss the existence of Mahabharat based on the archeological facts in her new book on Mahabharat. She is also saying it’s around 3000 BCE old. This dating is also claimed by Nilesh Oak who has proved the same using more than 300 astronomical evidences mentioned in the Mahabharata text itself. Please also call Nilesh Nilakantha Oak. He stays in US/Canada
She just said nobody has disputed PGW but look at the works of Nilesh Oak and Capt Ajit vadakayil and so many other scholars... she's so uneducated... besides she's of colonial mindset...notice the difference in her and Annika Mann's narration Faridabad and Arravallis have cave paintings older than what they found in Africa she's unconsciously supporting a propaganda
Besides she called Graham Hancock a pseudo archaeologist....he does a better work than most archeologists and he never makes a closed statement he only asks to consider a possibility.
Ranveer I need you to invite Dr. Nilesh Oak on your show, he has done some amazing work when it comes to the dating of both Mahabharata War and Ramayan. His work is very renowned specially here in the West.
@@beerbiceps Please arrange a debate between your Archeologist guests & Real renowned *'Scientists'* like Dr. Niraj Rai, Prof Subhash Kak, E.r Nilesh Oak, Prof C.K. Raju e.t.c to Scientifically validate *'Civilizational Timeline & Population migration history'* 🙏 As an working Engineer I know what she told about *'Agriculture & irrigation'* is blatant lie😉 you can ask any experienced Er. researching on *'Pattern of Indian Agriculture.'* 😎
It's true, I studied in Himachal, my school was on top of the hill and where we can see the huge rocks linked to Maharashtra, we have a Hidimba temple in Manali, it's just not a theory. They were on agyaatvaas in Himachal Pradesh
She has a lot of clarity on very deep and minute points of history and she describes it very clearly, trying to bust the wrong concepts. Great podcast!!
Ghanta, bhai ye puri indian history ko hi deny kar rahi hai. She don't even know what happened in Mahabharata, when a world war happens, than a civilization has to start over.
@@Rishi1197-z5d yes you are right about 20th century, but there will be a restart after 3rd world war, Mahabharata was a world war, you know why, because 1.66 billion people died in that war. It was also known as the first nuclear war on Earth as of now.
@@sanyamjain1125 Restart of the world after 3 world war is just a dumb thing to say and obviously there will be a catastrophic affect on earth after a nuclear war but a great portion of the world would have a recoverable affects on them and i don't even wanna comment on the 1.6 billion fuckin people dying in Mahabharata, that's just total made-up bullshit and now don't label me as a Pakistani or muslim, i am Hindu and an Indian + a realist
@@Rishi1197-z5d then go read Mahabharata carefully, if u r thinking it's bullshit, that means u r not hindu, also focus on talks between vidur and dhritrashtra during war
Nice topic - I love it. Humans have to dismiss the feeling of insecurity with being "wrong." We must stop competing to be right so we can be more objective and evolve into greater acceptance of all possibilities.
Would be great if you could please do a podcast with a Indian/Non-Indian professor from a foreign university (European/North American/or any International University) who can provide another perspective to this in light of new research they may have done. They can by using evidence prove his/her theories.
I love the way you draw a simple picture of what the guest just say. So, my feedback would be to hone that skill even more coz it makes easy for us to absorb information smoothly😊 Thanks for this podcast.
Timestamps 0:00 - Disha Ahluwalia x Ranveer Begins 2:35 - India's opinion on history books 3:40 - Ancient Aliens & Graham Hancock documentary 10:13 - Different ideologies of civilization 13:20 - On Homo Erectus 15:55 - Disappearance of river systems 21:15 - History & Archeological theories 29:25 - Aryan Vs Dravidian theory 33:05 - Mahabharat in the archaeological stage 44:55 - Breaking down the Aryan Invasion Theory 59:00 - Real archaeological Perspective 1:00:42 - Thanks for watching
Every single studio of yours is fabulous. Waiting for third studio tour I hope that it's work is completed. BTW love your new avatar. Chains suits you 💓🤌🏻. We get to know that Things which are not mentioned about Indian history in textbooks. History, archaeology is my/was my fav subject
Want to add: Its mentioned in Rig-veda that Saraswati river has seen huge floods, and it's flowing at its full might. So, if the so-called rig-vedic tribe migrated to the subcontinent at ~1100BC, and wrote rig-veda in India, how could they write the above, since Saraswati has almost disappeared by this time, as Dr. Ahluwalia has mentioned.
Archaeology alone is insufficient to know about the dates of such ancient history. One needs to connect the dots with multiple disciplines of science and also literature. It's because even metals corrode with time and get reused by later people. They get stone tools as the most ancient tools not because people didn't knew about making other kind of tools, but rather because stone is basically the only material that could had survived such a length of time, and also because no one generally would need to recycle and reuse stone tools down the line in history, as people must had done with metal tools.
Yeah, this migration crap, that's all Bee $. Let me just add to your claim. The proponents of this migration theory, they carefully avoid two things, speaking of River Saraswati and speaking of The Ice Age. Just think about it, if any migration was supposed to happen, it would have happened at the beginning of the Ice Age when that region got covered in snow. That Ice Age lasted for about 100,000 years and it started receding about 12,000 years ago, and that's the period when Dwarka has supposedly drowned because of the rise in sea level due to melting ice. It's funny that humans of the INDn subcontinent didn't evolve even though they had favourable habitat and environment but humans from regions of harsh weather, extreme cold and unfavourable habitat evolved. Given even today's low density of flora and fauna of such harsh regions of the planet as compared to regions of favourable habitat and environment, it's nothing but a fictional story that people migrated to Bharat and brought their wisdom with them. One of the fundamentals of any migration theory is that when the same kind appears at multiple places, the place which exhibits most diversity is considered to be the origin, but somehow they stop short of applying even such fundamentals when it comes to Bharat. I don't think there's any doubt about which place exhibits greater diversity.
You are according to me are the luckiest cause you are persistent towards your knowledge And doesn't lack your curiosity in any of your podcasts. Nothing can stop you Literally nothing...... 💕 Love from U.P 💝🙌🏻
Please ranveer make a podcast on the ancient egyptian civilization and about the king tutankhama....because we all don't have much knowledge about that civilization as it is not much discussed in the textbooks of our schools and colleges....🙏🏻
Thanks a ton Ranveer for bringing in these talented and knowledgeable people to explain our history/archeology 👏👏to someone like me who loves/appreciates to hear and understand things/information!!!
It takes a lot of enthusiasm and awareness to keep yourself updated to whole bunch of topics and then give them right context to related points and ask them proper questions at right time . Omg ranvir, you have started a great journey comnecting all of us. thanks man ✌
Grateful for this type content you produce bro , keep the work on and plz plz bring more archaeological, spritual ,scientific knowledge about the World and India. And open our perspectives and believes for them. 🙏🙏🙏❤️
Thoroughly enjoyed listening to this podcast. Very informative and in the process learning that History is not static but continues to evolve as evidences come up about various civilisations. Thank you to you both.
I have been waiting for this podcast to happen since a very long time. Can't explain my enthusiasm for this particular podcast. Thanks for sharing this intriguing podcast. Learnt a lot about unsung sagas of prehistory & history..... Thanks a ton ranveer & disha ma'am❤️ you both are the inspiration❤️❤️
Thank you Ranveer for this podcast subject and for the guest. She is a scientist first and believes in ‘follow the evidence’. It is very heartening to see erudite women being interviewed for their knowledge. She is articulate, moderate and clear and courageous when she is confronted with sticky emotional issues. Keep up the good work Disha. Looking forward to your book 😊
thank u for bringing this honestly m not somebody whose very much interested in history but ur history based podcast have driven me towards history and as an 18 year old listening to ur history based podcast has helped me gain a lot of knowledge specially about a subject m not at all interested in so thank u very much I also loved the trilogy on shivaji with Medha Bhaskaran ma'am and because those podcast I read the book as well and it was fab and for u ranveer bhaiya firstly Thank u very for working so hard just for the audience be it the podcast u bring the english one's or the hindi one's be it level be it the vlogs thank u for the efforts that u have had put it to help people with meditation I m one out of those millions u have come out of there low phases because of ur content because of ur meditataion guidance thank u very much I 've earlier also said this that I feel u have a treasure chest which is filled with all the precious germs here the germs is the content that u create for the audience the efforts u always put in and u have just left it all open to come and take whatever it takes us to be a better version of ourseleves thank u once again u have got a beautiful smile may god bless u keep working keep growing keep smiling stay happy stay blessed😊
55:13 Even bigger astonishing Linguistic analogy that Aryan Migration Theory indirectly implies which our simpleton Ranveer missed is that Indian culturally occupied by superior Aryans ended up writing post Vedic masterpieces in Sanskrit Literature like Puranas , Sutras , Upanishads and all this in a time where there is no organised education industry. Lets me explain in simple Terms. Its like saying Indians had such a huge Linguistic IQ that they mastered sanskrit even better than so called Aryans. It is like saying Brits taught Indians English and Indians ended up writing Shakespeare like masterpieces. Its like saying American Tech taught Indians Comp. Language C and Indians ended up improving it and wrote C++. Its like saying Westerns Tech taught Indians Artificial Intelligence and Indians ended up writing ChatGPT. What Ranveer fails to realise that archeology is just one small arm for studying an ancient civilisation , real way to learn about an ancient civilisation is through its linguistics and its cultural literature. We know more about Rome Empire through its texts , we know more about Ancient Greek civilisation through its literature. Sadly Ranveer is not the correct host to impart knowledge on history and ancient civilisation, he has a romanticised take on these academic disciplines with everything leading to his fanboy Alien Theory and his fractured understanding doesn't help
I have subscribed and watched almost all of Ranveer's sessions because I learn from it. Although I didn't know Disha before, I can see that she is a very knowledgeable budding archaeologist. When Ranveer asked about excavations in the South, I expected Disha to talk in depth or at least mention about Keezhadi, Atchichanllur, Gangaikondacholapuram, Perumbalai, Thulukarpatti and Mayiladumparai and many more. Instead she says there is some digging going on here and there. Surprising.
Amazing podcast full of knowledge and wisdom about such topics usually for the one who are not interested in knowing about their real history but all these quests u invites here speaking fluently about their our past and present is just mind boggling, it's a kind of a place where we listeners get to know minute things about our existence on earth in abundance, a big congratulations to u Ranveer for initiating such an amazing work for the keen learners
What a fantastic podcast it is! Ranveer thank you for getting Disha Ahluwalia in this program. Disha is excellent in describing history & archeology. We expect much more from Disha madam. It was so interesting that many a times I rewound & listen the various portions of the podcast to understand more clearly. We want to know when the Book will be published which Disha madam is writing. Many thanks to both of you.
Hey Ranveer!! 1st things 1st.. Let me take a moment to thank you.. 😊 Thankyou for super amazing podcasts from so many different genres.. All of that interests me! Each of them have managed increased my personal knowledge and wash away so many myths.. Keep making them! KEHTE HAI KHUSHIYAAN BATANE SE BADTI HAI.. You are in a way sharing happiness 😊 Wish you best of everything for all the efforts.. May all stars be by your side.. Much love, Shefali ❤️
The videos regarding the Archaeology is really amazing. So many new things to get to know of. But there are excavation sites in Tamilnadu and one of that is Keezladi (Pronounced as Keel Adi) where we got a breakthrough of the oldest civilization that Harapan Civilization. There is another sight called Adhichanalur. It would be nice if you could make a video of this or talk about this.
Central government transferred the ASI officer Amarnath Ramakrishna into Assam state without any explanation Because keezhadi excavation site symbols has similarities with Indus valley civilization symbols
I want Disha ma'am to read or watch video of Nilesh Oak for date of Mahabharata. Also want you to analyse Sunken Dwarka City which is around 9000 BCE or older.
✨Don't want to sound mean, but the way she spoke, and her overall attitude towards Graham Hancock does not feel right. Firstly she needs to show some respect and secondly Graham Hancock has done much much more than the archeologists can dream of, several upcoming archeologists and anthropologists see him as their role model. His books, podcast, documentaries and claims are not without solid and concrete evidence. And over the years new discoveries have proved him right again and again. Many professors in prestigious universities agree with his claims. I would request her to first fully and deeply understand his work, read his books, grasp the level and quality of his work and then comment and that too with some respect because her age and his experience are equal.
I was also disappointed - she did not mention any example of his that she finds inaccurate - she admitted that she only watched 5 minutes of his work. It's actually the exact point he makes about archeologists being threatened and completely ignoring his work.
Ah...yes, the religious Archaeologist India has been waiting for! Where facts don't matter only personal opinion and personal agenda matter. Love it! lol, she is one of those in every class that just passes in all subjects and nobody suspects cause she blends well with the best narrative of the biggest group!
But what about sinauli archeological site in Baraut, Bagpat, Uttar Pradesh Horse pulled chariots with copper work, swords and multiple skeleton with gold jewellery were found there in excavition
Hey Renveer bro, if you can do this then please make it happen... or atleast try at once by suggesting to guests of TRS .. All these archaeologists (atleast those who came on TRS) should collectively make a document of Real history and present it to Govt ... May it be related to Freedom fighters or ancient history... And should also insist govt to make real changes in the history books of New Education Policy..
Check out my Meditation app: Level SuperMind
levelsupermind.onelink.me/CsSR/youtube
Join the Level Community Here:
linktr.ee/levelsupermindcommunity
Please invite Dr. Manish Pandey!!!!
Ranveer are you angry with Abhijit chavda ji after what he did to Veer Das 😂😂😂
Please bring Rajshree nandi sir
House mice genealogy from across the world revealed their origin all the way back to INDIA. House mice are found only where there is availability of farming because house mice depends on grains for food. This also indicates that the agriculture first started in INDIA even thought at present there is no archeological evidence and in nation like India getting archeological evidence is too difficult because many generations have been living in same areas and population increased over thousands of years and many areas which were previously farms are now converted to cities, towns.
Please invite Graphologist Dr. Manish Pande , Pune
Thank you Ranveer for bringing such an amazing content. Ater 10-20 years people will salute you for these masterpiece!
Please post more episodes from Rajarshi Nandy sir..
I am also waiting for this podcast and comment so many time this
🙏🙏
Yes🙏
it's not Rajashri, It is Rajarshi
Raj+ Rishi = rajarshi. typical bengali boys' name.
Me too! thank you to be a partner in our spiritual journey. I got answers from Rajashi Nandi and some others…
The way she took a stand for not making up narratives shows a sign of a good ethical historian and archeologists💜
But then she has applied make up on her face 😂
yes doesnt make up narratives but dismisses Graham Hancock flix after 5 mins and starts calling him pseudo archeologist. well done whoever this lady is. and after 10mins i am also done with this podcast 🤣🤣🤣
@@dankim-c2oexactly LMAO! Listen to what he has to say.. man has legit points about plenty things which even the archeological studies fail to explain...
@@dankim-c2o Haha same here...
@@venstomon931 yeah lol everyone knows applying makeup turns truth into lies and lies into truths.
There's a place called Jwalapuram here in Andhra Pradesh where they found ashes errupted from Toba volcano 75000 years ago. The depth of the ashes was nearly 10 feet. They found stone tools which are used for farming under the Ash bed. And similar tools over the Ash bed too. They say people over there survived the volcanic erruption where rest of the world completely vanished.
Doesn't matter 🙄 this blind-faithed junks are beyond *'Science'* 😂
Great points… please site your sources
Which district dude?
@@ushaasam7080 kurnool dist
Bro can you please suggest real good historical sites in AP. I am visiting Ind and have set aside a week for AP which I never could during my earlier visits
Perfect! :) Loved this episode very much! As an Indologist, I would say, Disha is the best representation for the youths to inspire them in the field of archeology to set the correct picture of Indian History in front of the nation. and, Ranveer, thanks to you for inviting such wonderful guests on your show. My best wishes to both of you :)
@juniper7905 dirty fool everybody came from Africa only
@juniper7905your mom says this but she says only ..................
@StarPlanet56789clown, go find a circus.
@bestfacts7105kiss ass
Issue is Aryan Invasion still being taught to the students. Even outside India it is still popular and being taught. India has to rewrite this story inside and outside
But there are intelligent people that realised Aryan theory was a myth. Their are a few people only but something is better than nothing.
I am glad that cbse doesn’t teach the Aryan invasion theory for the higher classes (11th and 12th grade). However, it is a different story for younger classes.
@@malikakefufaji9900 its still there.. in rs sharma history
DMK chamache nahi manege 😭😭😭😭
DMK chamache nahi manege 😭😭😭😭
Ranveer bhaiyaa I would request you to kindly bring Archaeologist Kk Muhammad sir. He is one of the best archaeologist in india who has got padma shri for his work.
His notable works include Excavations of the Ram Mandir, Bateshwar Complex restoration, Discovered the first Christian Chapel of North India built by Akbar at Fatehpur Sikri.
Excavated the Buddhist Stupa of Kesaria built by Emperor Ashoka. Discovered and excavated Buddhist Stupa in Rajgir.
Excavated the Buddhist archaeological site in Kolhua, Vaishali etc.
Please bhaiyaa bring him to your show 🙏
Yes.That would be awesome :)
@@DIYPB Yes, it would be awesome . I hope bhaiyaa will accept my request and bring him to his show 😀🤭
@@feelu8156 i was come here to say the same thing !
@@varunbajpai3166 😀😀🙏
Exactly. Sadly she didn't say anything about KK Muhammad Sir in this video till now.
Your podcasts have been a large source of knowledge for the entire gen z generation, and your podcasts bring out the true history of Bharat.
Thank you Ranveer for taking so much efforts in bringing out the true history through your podcasts
She is like the best archaeologist ever coz she knows beginning to end about her subject and presents it so accurately in highly articulated way... thanks for having her on your show...🙏✌💥💫
So articulate, such learning and insight shared clearly. Thank you Ranveer and Disha.
I am from Sriganganagar, and the way she explained history of the place is incredible and makes a lot of sense. Thanks Ranveer for asking questions on behalf of millions of us ✨
@Aman Jha 😂😂 country of kashmir bruhh?
@Aman Jha mmooslims r not kashmiri ...... these r 2 different things....... those who follow rishi kashyap are known as kashmiri and those who follllow some aarrab guy r whatever ....
@Aman Jha bro sriganganagar is in rajasthan🥲
@Aman Jha it's not a country, it's a city
@Aman Jha Vatican City is a country inside Italian capital. It's not free. Its under the pope
Would love more conversations with rajarshi nandy sir…
Had a intuition that you got your guru for your recent spiritual interests!
Please share your spiritual growth during this phase of your life
Pls bring rajarshi sir to shed light on topics like karma, concept of consciousness, life of sri aurobindo.....
Love from west bengal💕
This is one of the best videos I've ever seen. Archeology is described clearly and interestingly.
Another wonderful Indian archeologist! It is an exciting time for history, science and mythology as well. The more evidence we get the more interesting it seems to be. Thanks for such a great program!
Thank you for working so hard for us for providing the valuable information through your amazing content
So nice of you. My pleasure ❤️
@@beerbiceps Stop getting such *'HalfEducated, Unscientific, cheap Fancy Archeologists'* 😂 trying to prove *'Physics & Math is myth'* 🤣 Just let them debate with *'[Legendary Physicist] Shubhas Kak, Sanjay Dixit [IAS] , Nilesh Oak[Engineer & Cosmologist], Niraj Rai[Legendary Genetic Scientist] & ofcourse 'Sir AVIJIT CHAVDA'* 😜 All the *'So Called "FACTS"* imagined by this junks will get *'EXPOSSED'* 🙊🙏
Let's stand together for changing our history books 🇮🇳 🇮🇳
Yes, you are right and we all should have right to know the real history of India and ancient India.
You are free to disagree with Global consensus but forcing others to disagree is one step backwards towards progress.
It's like Turkey recently removed evolution from the syllabus because it goes against the pre-existing beliefs of the Muslims. Some things need to be studied even if you disagree with them, that's how we reached the point where we are now. Imagine if we were to be stuck with the Geocentric model?
@@indianboy59 wdym? Even AIT in foreign is long debunked. They now think of AMT. Even then Indian scientists like Dr. Niraj Rai (DNA scientist) has proved Out of India theory
@@nw3877 read my comment again, I said "Some things need to be studied even if you disagree with them" It means we should be open-minded to other possible explanations that go against our pre-existing beliefs. Human migration is a pretty debatable and contro-ver-sial topic, there's not much objectivity either so academics from different parts of the world have their own biases, conscious or unconscious and Indian academics are NO exception. And OIT is not even a theory but a hypothesis created by reli-gious natio-nalists of a particular reli-gion as a response to Euro-centr-ism and colo-nialism. Niraj Rai after the Rakhigari excavation concluded that "It's just the beginning" OIT is not a global consensus and it's only accepted within the defined borders of a particular country and more precisely by people belonging to a particular faith. Now tell me there's no bias here.
@@indianboy59 who the f cares? When there are evidences? Average uneducated Europeans still believe they are originators of Indo-European languages but their original kind was lost way back to Yamnayas who weren't cultured as so called Aryand supposed to be. The very word Aryan should be banned or redefined very strictly.
Sir plz continue series of Chatrapati Shivaji Maharaj and
Chatrapati Sambhaji Maharaj with Medha ma’am🙏🙏
I don’t know why not many people are talking about it .
That was a great series though hearing perspective of both sides✌🏻
becaus in the last episode she said that she would be outside mumbai for a couple of months, had you skipped that part of the last episode. Everyone knows she will be back again after an interval
@@rishiteshmaharana5936 bro its been too long and there was not a single update about it
And for ur information these podcast are recorded like a month ago before its release
And i just simply requested it from the creator , why are u getting so rude about it
She was very knowledgeable and it was very interesting to know about it!! Maybe you can continue with that series till British colonization
Marathio ko chatrapati shivaji kay agey kuch maliom hi nahi
I would like to recommend two names connected with the history of Sabarimala.
1. Shri.V. Aravind Subramaniam, Author, Speaker, Researcher
2. Smt. Sinu Joseph, Menstrual Educator, researcher and author of two awesome books - Women and Sabarimala, and Rithu Vidya.
Cute lady with great knowledge and awesome communication. What a combo 😊
Big Fan
Don't ever stop bringing podcasts
Thanks
Thank you for watching ❤️
@@beerbiceps When is Anica mam and Rajashi Nandi sir Returning ?
@@beerbiceps bro when are you bringing medha maam for sambhuraje's history. Eagerly waiting for people to come to know about him. You got soft power bro. May the people came to know who sambhuraje was . He needs you
Anica Mann and now Disha mam... Indian history is in great hands.
Thanks you ranvir for great show, 🙏
We tribal are also coming to make Indian history:-) let's debate it on national tv
@@cheltooktribefreethinker1028 do it
@@palwinder_kaler it's takes tym. Now brahmin has power in india. Time Will come when our tribals ppls will have education in majorities. Dr ambedkhar has given us a reservation. Not now but obviouslywe LLL come
@@cheltooktribefreethinker1028 hahaha, so you are an ambedkarites, the next batch of neo-buddhist. gr8
@@cheltooktribefreethinker1028 ❤day ke freethinker aate hi bakchodi start kar di aur chale hai free thinking karne.. lol 😂
Good podcast, please bring more of such historians. I can't get enough of Indian ancient civilization's history.
Great episode!!
Would love to see a podcast on Porunai (Thamirabarani) civilisation that dates back to 3,200 years.
Very insightful listening to an Indian Archaeologist. Thanks for making this video. We listen so much on youtube from western archaeologists but listening to an Indian Archaeologist feels so good specially listening to our Indian history.
Excellent podcast. Worth mentioning that many Hindu Epics to make references to astronomical events and constellation/star/planetary positions in the night sky. This is an ingenious way to time stamp major events e.g. Bhisma's passing after the actual Mahabharata War. So while the hard material evidence from archeological digs and surveys may be the ultimate proof of an event, we should recognise that over the eons of time, a lot of this evidence may have been lost or degraded or even stolen through countless battles and conflicts. We are talking about territorial humans at the end of the day. So, perhaps that's why our recorded scriptural evidence used astronomy to book mark significant events. Maybe the Rishis were onto something!
So true
The evidences of cosmology aren't conclusive as Vedic people didn't have the grasp of astronomy fully.
Astronomy developed much later.
@@amolkhobaragade that is an assumption. In any case, there are multiple time stamps in each and every book. You are free to disprove even one time stamp. They all fall within the period of 1 human life, approx 100 years, and are not some random time stamps that the authors recorded. You could check if you want.
@@amolkhobaragade sorry you got this buddy! Vedic people work existence was based on astronomy! Kindly refer to Vedic literatures
It didn’t happen eons ago sir, it only happened 3000 years ago and we have technology to go back 50,000 years ago and beyond easily, so if it were to be real some corroborating evidence would have been found
The way she explains the facts by keeping in mind the sentiments of religioun and her profession is fire. One thing I want to mention that concerns me a lot. I am south Indian, from Andhra Pradesh(Telugu) , when you refer south Indian people that believe and fight for their identity in based on Aryan Invasion Theory, It just kills me inside. No one do that. Its just a political stunt happening in Tamilnadu, Except some tamilians who are arrogant about their language is the first one, No one cares or believes in AIT. Believe me, 90% of the south Indian doesn't know AIT had happened. Archeologically, ethically and logically AIT is a myth. we never never think north people are invaders but our brothers. Requesting you not think us as dividend dravidians who thinks a division happened. Bharath mata ki jai. Jai Hind. And Disha, you made my day 😍. (Please Pardon my grammar)
😂
😂
It is so great comment bro,trust logically it dosen't make any sense ,how can aryans chased dravidans for thousands km ,it is not possible, there were no borders ,it used to a subcontinent ,definitely this theory is invented by British and now enjoyed by Tamilnadu politicians
@@arjunsharma8816 may be u were chasing 😂😂😂
@@Pushparaj-fe9fk bro aiyo I am not obsessed with all this ,on side tamilians clame they are singhams and chola great empire, and another side they says aryan came pushed Tamils from indus civilization to down south more than 2000 km chased,please guide bhai 🙂🙏🏻
One thing I can say about ranvir sir is that he served India's interest better than any government.
Read PIB before acting cool here.
Bhagwa pilling of Indian youth
🤣🤣
That is basic economics of a business. Demand and supply.
@@kaushikchakraborty2271 Nothing wrong in it ...
Disha is very fair and logic. Far better than other so called archaeologist.
Great job!
Wonderful episode. Very informative too for normal people who are beginners in the search of real history. Archeologist Disha's speech is awesome. But she talked about Aryan migration theory from an archeologist's point of view. It is like seeing a gigantic three dimensional image from one angle alone. It does not give us a complete picture. History should be understood through the eyes of a multidisciplinary team consisting of historians, archeoligists, linguists, literary scholars, physicists, geoligists, and many more experts of varied fields. Aryab migration theory was not formed with archrological data alone. Hence, if there are more discussions with experts in varied sciences who have opinions on the Aryan migration theory (both FOR and AGAINST) it would bring more clarity in the topic. We would like to see Shri R.Balakrishnan, retd IAS officer of Odisha who has written a book called ' A journey of a civilization - from Indus to Vaigai' and the history Prof.Karunanandhan in this interesting channel of yours regarding Aryan migration theory.
As Disha Madam would discuss the existence of Mahabharat based on the archeological facts in her new book on Mahabharat. She is also saying it’s around 3000 BCE old. This dating is also claimed by Nilesh Oak who has proved the same using more than 300 astronomical evidences mentioned in the Mahabharata text itself. Please also call Nilesh Nilakantha Oak. He stays in US/Canada
Nilesh Oak dates Mahabharata to around 5500 BCE. Ramayana to 11000 BCE
It's sad to see Indian archeologists so badly brainwashed
@@ghorkalyug3406 what do you mean
She just said nobody has disputed PGW but look at the works of Nilesh Oak and Capt Ajit vadakayil and so many other scholars... she's so uneducated... besides she's of colonial mindset...notice the difference in her and Annika Mann's narration Faridabad and Arravallis have cave paintings older than what they found in Africa she's unconsciously supporting a propaganda
Besides she called Graham Hancock a pseudo archaeologist....he does a better work than most archeologists and he never makes a closed statement he only asks to consider a possibility.
Ranveer I need you to invite Dr. Nilesh Oak on your show, he has done some amazing work when it comes to the dating of both Mahabharata War and Ramayan.
His work is very renowned specially here in the West.
Thank you so much Ranveer 🙏🏻 for giving us such fantastic podcast 👌🏻
Keep doing this noble work ☺️ God bless you.. 🙌🏻✨️
My pleasure 😊
@@beerbiceps Please arrange a debate between your Archeologist guests & Real renowned *'Scientists'* like Dr. Niraj Rai, Prof Subhash Kak, E.r Nilesh Oak, Prof C.K. Raju e.t.c to Scientifically validate *'Civilizational Timeline & Population migration history'* 🙏
As an working Engineer I know what she told about *'Agriculture & irrigation'* is blatant lie😉 you can ask any experienced Er. researching on *'Pattern of Indian Agriculture.'* 😎
It's true, I studied in Himachal, my school was on top of the hill and where we can see the huge rocks linked to Maharashtra, we have a Hidimba temple in Manali, it's just not a theory. They were on agyaatvaas in Himachal Pradesh
Maharashtra?
Im in love with this amazing person. She's professional and knowledgeable
Bring her again and again in the future
You changed my life, my thoughts, Now I am a whole new person, Thank you Ranveer sir 🙏, for your podcasts, and also level supermind.
Thank you so much ❤️
@@beerbiceps She was little uncomfortable with english why didnt you made a hindi podcast
@@spacexe123 her english is fine .... she uses so many archealogy word that's why u didnot catch it ...
@@urrasscal8380 lol no you didnt get it well i guess she is less aknowledged about these thing than other myghties
@@spacexe123 jada gyan mat jhaad ...first save w. bengal from jjihadis ...........
She is 💯 honest and true to her profession.
Based on Astronomical evidence Nilesh Oak has dated Mahabharat for 5th millenium
Even the flooding of Dwarka is 5th millenium.
wrong bro, he has given two dates.
such an articulated lady! Really liked the whole information she gave, wish he could have teachers like this
Ranveer, this has been some of the most real and fact based podcasts. Continue with such podcasts
Amazing podcast Ranveer. Got enriched. Thanks a lot. Please bring Sanjeev Sanyal and Meenakshi Jain Ji on your show.
She has a lot of clarity on very deep and minute points of history and she describes it very clearly, trying to bust the wrong concepts. Great podcast!!
Ghanta, bhai ye puri indian history ko hi deny kar rahi hai. She don't even know what happened in Mahabharata, when a world war happens, than a civilization has to start over.
@@sanyamjain1125 Two world wars had happened already in 20th century, there was no civilizational restart and Mahabharata wasn't a world war
@@Rishi1197-z5d yes you are right about 20th century, but there will be a restart after 3rd world war, Mahabharata was a world war, you know why, because 1.66 billion people died in that war. It was also known as the first nuclear war on Earth as of now.
@@sanyamjain1125 Restart of the world after 3 world war is just a dumb thing to say and obviously there will be a catastrophic affect on earth after a nuclear war but a great portion of the world would have a recoverable affects on them and i don't even wanna comment on the 1.6 billion fuckin people dying in Mahabharata, that's just total made-up bullshit and now don't label me as a Pakistani or muslim, i am Hindu and an Indian + a realist
@@Rishi1197-z5d then go read Mahabharata carefully, if u r thinking it's bullshit, that means u r not hindu, also focus on talks between vidur and dhritrashtra during war
Nice topic - I love it. Humans have to dismiss the feeling of insecurity with being "wrong." We must stop competing to be right so we can be more objective and evolve into greater acceptance of all possibilities.
Disha Mam's way of expressing is superb.All the support from Kolkata
Would be great if you could please do a podcast with a Indian/Non-Indian professor from a foreign university (European/North American/or any International University) who can provide another perspective to this in light of new research they may have done. They can by using evidence prove his/her theories.
I love the way you draw a simple picture of what the guest just say. So, my feedback would be to hone that skill even more coz it makes easy for us to absorb information smoothly😊
Thanks for this podcast.
Great to have another archaeologist on the show ! Thank you
Timestamps
0:00 - Disha Ahluwalia x Ranveer Begins
2:35 - India's opinion on history books
3:40 - Ancient Aliens & Graham Hancock documentary
10:13 - Different ideologies of civilization
13:20 - On Homo Erectus
15:55 - Disappearance of river systems
21:15 - History & Archeological theories
29:25 - Aryan Vs Dravidian theory
33:05 - Mahabharat in the archaeological stage
44:55 - Breaking down the Aryan Invasion Theory
59:00 - Real archaeological Perspective
1:00:42 - Thanks for watching
Excellent podcast by Disha Ma'm with Ranveer & the team. Please bring more such topics expecially on ancient kashmir shaivism culture .
Please one more podcast of Indian history and culture with My favourite Archeologist the great ma'am Anica Mann 👍👍
Every single studio of yours is fabulous. Waiting for third studio tour I hope that it's work is completed. BTW love your new avatar. Chains suits you 💓🤌🏻. We get to know that Things which are not mentioned about Indian history in textbooks. History, archaeology is my/was my fav subject
Want to add: Its mentioned in Rig-veda that Saraswati river has seen huge floods, and it's flowing at its full might. So, if the so-called rig-vedic tribe migrated to the subcontinent at ~1100BC, and wrote rig-veda in India, how could they write the above, since Saraswati has almost disappeared by this time, as Dr. Ahluwalia has mentioned.
Abhijit Chavda supremacy 🛐
Archaeology alone is insufficient to know about the dates of such ancient history. One needs to connect the dots with multiple disciplines of science and also literature. It's because even metals corrode with time and get reused by later people. They get stone tools as the most ancient tools not because people didn't knew about making other kind of tools, but rather because stone is basically the only material that could had survived such a length of time, and also because no one generally would need to recycle and reuse stone tools down the line in history, as people must had done with metal tools.
@@000Aful Yes, seems quite logical.
Yeah, this migration crap, that's all Bee $. Let me just add to your claim.
The proponents of this migration theory, they carefully avoid two things, speaking of River Saraswati and speaking of The Ice Age. Just think about it, if any migration was supposed to happen, it would have happened at the beginning of the Ice Age when that region got covered in snow. That Ice Age lasted for about 100,000 years and it started receding about 12,000 years ago, and that's the period when Dwarka has supposedly drowned because of the rise in sea level due to melting ice.
It's funny that humans of the INDn subcontinent didn't evolve even though they had favourable habitat and environment but humans from regions of harsh weather, extreme cold and unfavourable habitat evolved. Given even today's low density of flora and fauna of such harsh regions of the planet as compared to regions of favourable habitat and environment, it's nothing but a fictional story that people migrated to Bharat and brought their wisdom with them.
One of the fundamentals of any migration theory is that when the same kind appears at multiple places, the place which exhibits most diversity is considered to be the origin, but somehow they stop short of applying even such fundamentals when it comes to Bharat. I don't think there's any doubt about which place exhibits greater diversity.
There is very good book regarding this
Ancient sarwasti civilization by Gen. G.D. Bakshi
He even call this civilization Saraswati civilization
Loving this. Thank you Ranveer for bringing such interesting podcasts.
God bless you Ranveer. Thank you for bringing up a podcast about our Bharath. We look forward to more from you and your team.
You are according to me are the luckiest cause you are persistent towards your knowledge And doesn't lack your curiosity in any of your podcasts. Nothing can stop you Literally nothing...... 💕 Love from U.P
💝🙌🏻
Please ranveer make a podcast on the ancient egyptian civilization and about the king tutankhama....because we all don't have much knowledge about that civilization as it is not much discussed in the textbooks of our schools and colleges....🙏🏻
Love your podcasts, and I request you to post more such episodes like this
Thank you for making podcast on Gandhi godse and Vedic perid🚩🔱😍
Thanks a ton Ranveer for bringing in these talented and knowledgeable people to explain our history/archeology 👏👏to someone like me who loves/appreciates to hear and understand things/information!!!
As a history student, really loved the theories, told here…very very helpful…and eye opening.
Great work!!!
Amazing podcast….Thank you Ranveer for this
It takes a lot of enthusiasm and awareness to keep yourself updated to whole bunch of topics and then give them right context to related points and ask them proper questions at right time .
Omg ranvir, you have started a great journey comnecting all of us.
thanks man ✌
Grateful for this type content you produce bro , keep the work on and plz plz bring more archaeological, spritual ,scientific knowledge about the World and India. And open our perspectives and believes for them. 🙏🙏🙏❤️
Thoroughly enjoyed listening to this podcast. Very informative and in the process learning that History is not static but continues to evolve as evidences come up about various civilisations. Thank you to you both.
Would be interesting to see some content on South Indian archaeology content
I have been waiting for this podcast to happen since a very long time. Can't explain my enthusiasm for this particular podcast. Thanks for sharing this intriguing podcast. Learnt a lot about unsung sagas of prehistory & history..... Thanks a ton ranveer & disha ma'am❤️ you both are the inspiration❤️❤️
Your videos are amazing really loved them a lot...... Keep growing dude🖤💫
Thank you Ranveer for this podcast subject and for the guest. She is a scientist first and believes in ‘follow the evidence’. It is very heartening to see erudite women being interviewed for their knowledge. She is articulate, moderate and clear and courageous when she is confronted with sticky emotional issues. Keep up the good work Disha. Looking forward to your book 😊
Huge respect for her 🙏🕉🙏
Must have more episodes like this.
Absolutely incredible.
Lahuradev in U.P was the first agricultural site in Indian subcontinent it dates back 8000:BCE to 8500:BCE in recent archeological discovery.
And how can it be claimed to be oldest. That's just gimmick.agriculture has been done since time immemorial
@@FilesdocumentsAndreposit-kr3vbThat's not how archaeology works.
thank u for bringing this honestly m not somebody whose very much interested in history but ur history based podcast have driven me towards history and as an 18 year old listening to ur history based podcast has helped me gain a lot of knowledge specially about a subject m not at all interested in so thank u very much I also loved the trilogy on shivaji with Medha Bhaskaran ma'am and because those podcast I read the book as well and it was fab and for u ranveer bhaiya firstly Thank u very for working so hard just for the audience be it the podcast u bring the english one's or the hindi one's be it level be it the vlogs thank u for the efforts that u have had put it to help people with meditation I m one out of those millions u have come out of there low phases because of ur content because of ur meditataion guidance thank u very much I 've earlier also said this that I feel u have a treasure chest which is filled with all the precious germs here the germs is the content that u create for the audience the efforts u always put in and u have just left it all open to come and take whatever it takes us to be a better version of ourseleves thank u once again u have got a beautiful smile may god bless u keep working keep growing keep smiling stay happy stay blessed😊
@pavani it's Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj 😉
55:13 Even bigger astonishing Linguistic analogy that Aryan Migration Theory indirectly implies which our simpleton Ranveer missed is that Indian culturally occupied by superior Aryans ended up writing post Vedic masterpieces in Sanskrit Literature like Puranas , Sutras , Upanishads and all this in a time where there is no organised education industry.
Lets me explain in simple Terms.
Its like saying Indians had such a huge Linguistic IQ that they mastered sanskrit even better than so called Aryans. It is like saying Brits taught Indians English and Indians ended up writing Shakespeare like masterpieces. Its like saying American Tech taught Indians Comp. Language C and Indians ended up improving it and wrote C++. Its like saying Westerns Tech taught Indians Artificial Intelligence and Indians ended up writing ChatGPT.
What Ranveer fails to realise that archeology is just one small arm for studying an ancient civilisation , real way to learn about an ancient civilisation is through its linguistics and its cultural literature. We know more about Rome Empire through its texts , we know more about Ancient Greek civilisation through its literature.
Sadly Ranveer is not the correct host to impart knowledge on history and ancient civilisation, he has a romanticised take on these academic disciplines with everything leading to his fanboy Alien Theory and his fractured understanding doesn't help
I can hear her on and on ...so much information ..and intruging ...make your history close to livable past reality
Great episode! Please post more episodes on archeological Indian History that covers whole india from himalayas to kanniyakumari.
I have subscribed and watched almost all of Ranveer's sessions because I learn from it. Although I didn't know Disha before, I can see that she is a very knowledgeable budding archaeologist. When Ranveer asked about excavations in the South, I expected Disha to talk in depth or at least mention about Keezhadi, Atchichanllur, Gangaikondacholapuram, Perumbalai, Thulukarpatti and Mayiladumparai and many more. Instead she says there is some digging going on here and there. Surprising.
yes
Reality is no one will talk about it in depth. We need someone who will talk about keezhadi and all and it's significance to indian civilization
Thank you so much Ranveer bro👏👏👏🙏🙏🙏. Another awesome podcast!!
Amazing podcast full of knowledge and wisdom about such topics usually for the one who are not interested in knowing about their real history but all these quests u invites here speaking fluently about their our past and present is just mind boggling, it's a kind of a place where we listeners get to know minute things about our existence on earth in abundance, a big congratulations to u Ranveer for initiating such an amazing work for the keen learners
This archaeologist is very knowledgeable and personable too. Pls have her on more often.
Great to have a guest who derives conclusions based on actual and physical evidence.
Another great podcast! Keep posting such amazing content 😍💯
Bro...So adicted to your podcasts that I literally had a dream this early morning wherein I was your podcast guest!😂
"There is a lot of romanticism that happens, But we can't do that in the field" 26:26..
Truer words have never been spoken.
What a fantastic podcast it is! Ranveer thank you for getting Disha Ahluwalia in this program. Disha is excellent in describing history & archeology. We expect much more from Disha madam. It was so interesting that many a times I rewound & listen the various portions of the podcast to understand more clearly. We want to know when the Book will be published which Disha madam is writing. Many thanks to both of you.
Good interview. The host was clearly thrilled with his host and couldn’t stop grinning. Disha has an honest and consistent way of expressing herself.
Yes please do more episodes on mahabharata, our indian culture and yes do more episodes with Rajarshi sir.
Hey Ranveer!!
1st things 1st.. Let me take a moment to thank you.. 😊 Thankyou for super amazing podcasts from so many different genres.. All of that interests me! Each of them have managed increased my personal knowledge and wash away so many myths.. Keep making them! KEHTE HAI KHUSHIYAAN BATANE SE BADTI HAI.. You are in a way sharing happiness 😊 Wish you best of everything for all the efforts.. May all stars be by your side.. Much love, Shefali ❤️
Thank you Ranveer for a great episode. Please bring Anica Mann back with more episodes ❤
This is knowledge with scientific approach.... 👍
a very refreshing ahluwalia. kudos lady. and thank you for speaking like you did.
The videos regarding the Archaeology is really amazing. So many new things to get to know of. But there are excavation sites in Tamilnadu and one of that is Keezladi (Pronounced as Keel Adi) where we got a breakthrough of the oldest civilization that Harapan Civilization. There is another sight called Adhichanalur. It would be nice if you could make a video of this or talk about this.
Central government transferred the ASI officer Amarnath Ramakrishna into Assam state without any explanation
Because keezhadi excavation site symbols has similarities with Indus valley civilization symbols
They won't talk or act ignorant.. She has nothing but half backed knowledge..
I want Disha ma'am to read or watch video of Nilesh Oak for date of Mahabharata. Also want you to analyse Sunken Dwarka City which is around 9000 BCE or older.
✨Don't want to sound mean, but the way she spoke, and her overall attitude towards Graham Hancock does not feel right. Firstly she needs to show some respect and secondly Graham Hancock has done much much more than the archeologists can dream of, several upcoming archeologists and anthropologists see him as their role model. His books, podcast, documentaries and claims are not without solid and concrete evidence. And over the years new discoveries have proved him right again and again. Many professors in prestigious universities agree with his claims.
I would request her to first fully and deeply understand his work, read his books, grasp the level and quality of his work and then comment and that too with some respect because her age and his experience are equal.
I was also disappointed - she did not mention any example of his that she finds inaccurate - she admitted that she only watched 5 minutes of his work. It's actually the exact point he makes about archeologists being threatened and completely ignoring his work.
Ah...yes, the religious Archaeologist India has been waiting for!
Where facts don't matter only personal opinion and personal agenda matter. Love it!
lol, she is one of those in every class that just passes in all subjects and nobody suspects cause she blends well with the best narrative of the biggest group!
One of my favorites. Please bring more archeology specials like this
But what about sinauli archeological site in Baraut, Bagpat, Uttar Pradesh
Horse pulled chariots with copper work, swords and multiple skeleton with gold jewellery were found there in excavition
Hey Renveer bro, if you can do this then please make it happen... or atleast try at once by suggesting to guests of TRS ..
All these archaeologists (atleast those who came on TRS) should collectively make a document of Real history and present it to Govt ... May it be related to Freedom fighters or ancient history...
And should also insist govt to make real changes in the history books of New Education Policy..
Superb, mind blowing and full of knowledge, thank you Ranveer sir for bringing bags and bags of knowledge for us ❤✨
Disha Ahluwalia I haven't heard of you but am happy to have visited here, good job 👏