I can't decide if I love or hate her voice. At 1:27-1:35 I was having goosebumps through my whole freaking body but there were moments she sounded really bad
Yeah there are moments where I feel a hint of how I feel when I hear Ariana Grande, but she needs more control during her "resting" vocals. She's kinda like a drunken master who can do backflips and punch a hole through a wall, but stumbles a lot when she walks down the street. Tons of potential though I think.
I don't think Rena's voice is bad I just think she needs to learn how to control her voice and find the right techniques, as well as breathing properly when singing (since I'm a singer myself). I remember during the 5sos tour in Melbourne when she spoke it sounded like she was about to break down and cry, so maybe it's just how her voice sounds in general. But I don't think we should say her vocals are bad because it's really not.
chiara c she's had singing lessons mate, she's just been grunting and using the wrong technique since she was 11 (or since Cherri Bomb) so she's permanently damaged her voice whether she's singing or talking. that's why she sounded like she was about to cry
i think she’s just really nervous. you can tell she’s anxious by the way she holds onto the mic cord, she looks like she’s trying not to shake. she doesn’t look comfortable at all
i know basically everyone in this comment sections says that rena doesn't sing good or she has been better, but tbh i actually like her voice like this. i know her voice is supposed to sing harder music and maybe she'll end up hurting her voice if she sings too much acoustic (idk) but she sound kinda sick (i guess?) and j actually really like that idk why.
I truly believe this band will keep growing. their songs & their studio stuff is really good. their performances kinda lack & rena's vocals are still very shaky, but i don't think she's bad. i can't tell if it's lack of confidence or something else but i really do hope they improve on their live stuff because they're really good.
thanks man, idk much about this band and I haven't heard many of their songs. What's Miranda's last name? are there any songs with her as the main singer?
Yeah, I'm a fan of Hey Violet but Miranda is a way better singer than Rena (the lead singer), she should sing lead in my opinion (her last name is Miller btw, she plays keys and rhythm guitar). They used to be an amazing hard rock band called Cherri Bomb a few years ago when they were young teens, but then they kicked out their lead singer, gigged around for 2 years, became Hey Violet in 2015 and did a complete 180 with their sound in 2016 :( I liked Cherri Bomb/early Hey Violet better, with their punkier sound. But anyway, to answer your question, Miranda has one song where she sings lead (it was years ago when they were Cherri Bomb). It's called Paper Doll, I recommend you give it a listen, it's an amazing song and Miranda sounds great in it! :)
Her voice is good and she has already a lot of control over it, as you can hear in the notes she belts. At the end where she's saying "thank you guys" you can hear that her talking voice sounds the same as her singing one, so that's just how she sounds. It has nothing to do with bad singing skills because trust me, if she had bad singing skills those high notes wouldn't just come out as perfect as they did. She knows exactly what notes she's singing, so she has control over it. The "cracks" are just how her voice is. And it makes her unique and interesting to listen to. This is coming from someone who's had singing lessons for over 10 years
Elaine Horan I love them, I heard about them for the first time a couple of years ago. They're amazing, but I think the last few months it's all about Rena and not enough bout Nia, Miranda, Casey & Iain...
it's definitely not awful. but in general, the vocals seem kind of sloppy. i think if she continued to practice and refine her voice then she has potential. but then again, hey violet has a pretty messy past, don't they? i like a few of their songs, but i don't think i'm a fan of them overall.
+maya papaya here are two links talking about it: exposing5sosblog.tumblr.com/post/130539302090/whats-wrong-with-hey-violet-pls licktheass-tonirwin.tumblr.com/post/115959366665/the-history-of-hey-violet they're pretty gross, lmao
Don't forget that Rena has had singing lessons (and bass lessons but she was quick to drop that when we exposed her lack of talent) but she's been damaging her voice since she was in Cherri Bomb by grunting and using the wrong technique
everyone says Rena isn't good but I personally think her voice is incredibly unique and puts an edge on the band, and yes her voice can be a bit shaky but she is still 18 and her voice hasn't fully developed
i mean yeah but they were a very mediocre mainstream rock band too. but lmao they kinda blew it the first time, you could tell they'd have taken any contract to get another chance at getting big.
For all you saying that it sounds bad, Rena can definitely sing and you can hear that Rena's just used to singing really loud and with kind of a rock vibe to her voice and she can't really do that when it's acoustic so I guess that's why it's a bit cracky some places
Agreed. I think it will change once they get big and I think they will, it will just take longer and be more of a process. I noticed most artists/bands that start performing as if they were already big make it faster...but of course that just a part of the whole artist/band. Anywho I love them so far and the few songs they have on TH-cam and Spotify
Ty Broddle no Julia needs to get off her ads and make an album. she's been saying bs excuses for ever. Julia has so much potential and she's fucking wasting it on dumbasses right now. She hangs out with a bad crowd.
CAUSE YOU HOLD ME LIKE A WALNUT
HAHAHAHAH
HELLA DEAD. LMAO.
holy fuck that is funny, I always sing walnut and thought I was crazy but I'm glad other ppl hear it
Shanel X that is funny
Lmao its nice to know im not the only one!
I can't decide if I love or hate her voice. At 1:27-1:35 I was having goosebumps through my whole freaking body but there were moments she sounded really bad
She has a nice sound she just needs more control
she cant belt well.
she messed up her vocals supposedly.
Katarina Klits Exactly
Yeah there are moments where I feel a hint of how I feel when I hear Ariana Grande, but she needs more control during her "resting" vocals. She's kinda like a drunken master who can do backflips and punch a hole through a wall, but stumbles a lot when she walks down the street. Tons of potential though I think.
I don't think Rena's voice is bad I just think she needs to learn how to control her voice and find the right techniques, as well as breathing properly when singing (since I'm a singer myself). I remember during the 5sos tour in Melbourne when she spoke it sounded like she was about to break down and cry, so maybe it's just how her voice sounds in general. But I don't think we should say her vocals are bad because it's really not.
chiara c can you send me a link of it ? ♡
chiara c she's had singing lessons mate, she's just been grunting and using the wrong technique since she was 11 (or since Cherri Bomb) so she's permanently damaged her voice whether she's singing or talking. that's why she sounded like she was about to cry
or she's just massively overrated!!
i think she’s just really nervous. you can tell she’s anxious by the way she holds onto the mic cord, she looks like she’s trying not to shake. she doesn’t look comfortable at all
I dont know what everyone else was talking about, Rena sounds great in this
RedEmbers22 IKR !!!!!
1:30
rena's voice is so unique, love them btw
Laura Soe finally someone actually says rena's voice is good
i think her voice is really beautiful, people just say she sounds so bad and stuff but ?? cmon ?? where ?? she does have some bad moments though
i thought her voice was goin bad but then i understood she has a really unique voice
i know basically everyone in this comment sections says that rena doesn't sing good or she has been better, but tbh i actually like her voice like this. i know her voice is supposed to sing harder music and maybe she'll end up hurting her voice if she sings too much acoustic (idk) but she sound kinda sick (i guess?) and j actually really like that idk why.
I am in love with this whole band honestly
GOD!! Her vocals are AMAZING!!! I literally had goosebumps... How can she sing in such a high pitch is beyond me....I LOVE HEY VIOLET😍
I truly believe this band will keep growing. their songs & their studio stuff is really good. their performances kinda lack & rena's vocals are still very shaky, but i don't think she's bad. i can't tell if it's lack of confidence or something else but i really do hope they improve on their live stuff because they're really good.
Anyone else just really happy to see Miranda back on guitar?
I personally like the backup singer's voice better in this.
*Miranda
thanks man, idk much about this band and I haven't heard many of their songs. What's Miranda's last name? are there any songs with her as the main singer?
Yeah, I'm a fan of Hey Violet but Miranda is a way better singer than Rena (the lead singer), she should sing lead in my opinion (her last name is Miller btw, she plays keys and rhythm guitar). They used to be an amazing hard rock band called Cherri Bomb a few years ago when they were young teens, but then they kicked out their lead singer, gigged around for 2 years, became Hey Violet in 2015 and did a complete 180 with their sound in 2016 :( I liked Cherri Bomb/early Hey Violet better, with their punkier sound. But anyway, to answer your question, Miranda has one song where she sings lead (it was years ago when they were Cherri Bomb). It's called Paper Doll, I recommend you give it a listen, it's an amazing song and Miranda sounds great in it! :)
Her voice is good and she has already a lot of control over it, as you can hear in the notes she belts. At the end where she's saying "thank you guys" you can hear that her talking voice sounds the same as her singing one, so that's just how she sounds. It has nothing to do with bad singing skills because trust me, if she had bad singing skills those high notes wouldn't just come out as perfect as they did. She knows exactly what notes she's singing, so she has control over it. The "cracks" are just how her voice is. And it makes her unique and interesting to listen to. This is coming from someone who's had singing lessons for over 10 years
I literally got goosebumps aaaall over my body with that high note. Love Rena's voice!
NIA IS SO PRETTY I CANT
The hot drummer gets no love. Not one closeup. Wtf?
M Ward my baby is underrated :(((
I know I'm developing a crush for the drummer, sad ;-;
1:59 ? ?
holy shit, Rena's vocals are so beautiful
Sike.
no, I was actually quite serious
I hope these guys blow up. Love their music.
I like the auto tune version more
sigh... I knew listening to the live version would ruin it.
PrincessM dajdñdgk
LOL, now I know she can really sing, which could not be heared that good in not live nice voice
I love this song, I love Rena and her band too!
But I really do love this song and Rena's voice.
Elaine Horan I love them, I heard about them for the first time a couple of years ago. They're amazing, but I think the last few months it's all about Rena and not enough bout Nia, Miranda, Casey & Iain...
Julie Vandersteene Agreed :(
Miranda's voice is just 😍😍
Fi Walker +
it's definitely not awful. but in general, the vocals seem kind of sloppy. i think if she continued to practice and refine her voice then she has potential.
but then again, hey violet has a pretty messy past, don't they? i like a few of their songs, but i don't think i'm a fan of them overall.
w. melli totally agreeing
w. melli WHAT IS THEIR PAST lmao I keep hearing about it what happened?
+maya papaya here are two links talking about it:
exposing5sosblog.tumblr.com/post/130539302090/whats-wrong-with-hey-violet-pls
licktheass-tonirwin.tumblr.com/post/115959366665/the-history-of-hey-violet
they're pretty gross, lmao
w. melli Shit.. I thought they were actually decent people.
Don't forget that Rena has had singing lessons (and bass lessons but she was quick to drop that when we exposed her lack of talent) but she's been damaging her voice since she was in Cherri Bomb by grunting and using the wrong technique
This song deserves the #1 position at Billboard more than closer, cheap thrills or work 💖
I love Rena.. but her vocals in this in look like its hurting her D;
Felicity same… :( her voice was kind of shaky at times so maybe she was a bit nervous but I could be wrong
yeah. I think nerves and type of music
Felicity could be, I love the new music though so I hope it gets easier for her to sing
Me to, I mean the acoustic, I think she sounds awesome when she sings this ong normally.
Felicity I agree
this is my fave song from them honestly
I LOVE THEM ALL SO FREAKING MUCH AND IM SO PROUD OF EVERYTHING THEY'VE ACCOMPLISHED
I love her voice in this idk why people hate her voice
Guys that's just how her voice is... I personally like it...
I love Rena, but I feel like Miranda has a slightly better voice for this particular song
petition to give miranda a solo
i'll sign it
i like how imperfect her voice is! :)
the drummer is the best and she's so fucking beautiful
the harmony's a little pitchy and rena's vocals are shaky (she sounds nervous¿) i had high hopes :/
They sound so good
the back up vocal at the end miranda does yasssssss
Am I the only person here who likes Rena's voice?
love them so good
Omg!!!! This is the first time I hear this and I'm a fan already ❤️❤️❤️
damnnnnnnn...fucking amazing, they have came along way....
Awww cantó hermosoooo. 😍🎤... Amo su voz, y ese vibrato de oveja es lo mejor 💘
One of the only singers in my opinion that can sing good live.
Everyones talking about Renas vocals but nobodys talking about how much of a cutie Casey is??
everyone says Rena isn't good but I personally think her voice is incredibly unique and puts an edge on the band, and yes her voice can be a bit shaky but she is still 18 and her voice hasn't fully developed
Most underrated band ever!
Casey's just so cute bopping away gah love that boy
Wish Rena would play bass live again
So sad to watch this outstanding rock band sell out into the major label machine with the slick mall crowd makeover to their looks and sound.
i mean yeah but they were a very mediocre mainstream rock band too. but lmao they kinda blew it the first time, you could tell they'd have taken any contract to get another chance at getting big.
this is so good I am in love with her! I love this song
DAMMIT I LOVE THIS GUYS
maria belen alava Vera me t o so much
lol all of you are over here hating on Rena's voice but I honestly really like it.
....am i the only one that actually loves this...
my faves 😍
She is an inspiration, you don't need talent, just keep going
She doesn't have a bad voice, that's just how her voice sounds, it's not like she's voice-cracking through the whole performance lol
The way Nia looks at Rena is so adorable.
BEST THING IVE EVER HEARD
voice is sooo perfect love u rena
Good band, they continue to grow :)
tbh she wasn't even that bad, I bet half of yall can't even sing that good
I don't know why I'm so in love with this song
aw you can tell how nervous rena is
Rena😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍 Awesome vocal😍😍😍
cause you hold me like a walnut
she has a heavy and light vibrato wow...
she was going sharp and flat a lot..
Nia is so underrated
YES FINALLY ♡
YEAH SO... I'm gonna go ahead and fall in love with the drummer. Thanks bye
I ask myself why can't I be this good looking they are so beautifulllllll
For all you saying that it sounds bad, Rena can definitely sing and you can hear that
Rena's just used to singing really loud and with kind of a rock vibe to her voice and she can't really do that when it's acoustic so I guess that's why it's a bit cracky some places
her voice is dope!!
All I really need is for Hayley Williams to cover this & slay like the song should be slayed.
1:31 what is that. my ears are bleeding
lovvvvvve ♡
RENA YOU LOOK SO GOOD!!!!!
I've seen them live and I think there pretty lit
is it bad that I liked Hey Violet when they were Cherri Bomb?
I like the song and I think this is kind of an okay performance but it's so CRINGY seeing it ?? I can't explain it
Sidney Chinchilla ikr like the lyrics are just weird but I like the song
Agreed. I think it will change once they get big and I think they will, it will just take longer and be more of a process. I noticed most artists/bands that start performing as if they were already big make it faster...but of course that just a part of the whole artist/band. Anywho I love them so far and the few songs they have on TH-cam and Spotify
Sidney Chinchilla yup ikr
Ariana Espinosa hahhahahhah funny. they won't get big tbh. not 5sos big. not big at all.
Amazing
PERFECT
*Miranda needs to sing more !!*
Renas Vocals Are Pretty Good And Unique. Im A Singer And She Sings Good So Why Are Ppl hating?
AMO AMO AMO AMO AMO AMO AMO AMO AMO AMO AMO AMO 💗
Brazil! 😘
😍😍😍
whos the guy playing the bass
iain shipp! he's new to the band
thanks gurl
bring back julia 2016
Ty Broddle no Julia needs to get off her ads and make an album. she's been saying bs excuses for ever. Julia has so much potential and she's fucking wasting it on dumbasses right now. She hangs out with a bad crowd.
ass*
She's been tweeting photos of herself in the studio for years but can't even release a demo.
Julia deserves better than HV.
Milou x praise her after she's done something
Yassssss 😍
HER HIGH NOTES ALMOST KILLED ME
same birthday with Rena :O
2:30 is like ❤❤❤❤❤
Waiting for a new album..
Casey is life
Am I the only one that liked it 😩😭
fcking love her voice
rena's voice is not traditionally good, but it's still good if that makes sense? idk i went to slfl and hey violet were amazing live
Her voice at times sounds like the alien voice changer on Snapchat
why does she sound like she's about to cry
😍😍