India-Taliban Ties: 'Modi Govt A Key Player In The Great Game In Afghanistan' | South Asia Diary
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 14 มี.ค. 2024
- Big shift in India's foreign policy towards Afghanistan. In a remarkable turn of events, the Indian delegation met Taliban leadership in Kabul to discuss Afghanistan-India relations and other matters at the beginning of March. Remember, India hasn't recognised the Taliban since the group came to power in August 2021 and has maintained a cautious position, catering only to the humanitarian requirements of the Afghans. Since 2022, India has stationed a “technical team” at the Embassy in Kabul but does not have a full-fledged ambassador. Watch this episode of South Asia Diary as Strategic Affairs Expert Sushant Sareen decodes the shift in India's foreign policy towards Afghanistan and what it means.
#india #afghanistan #taliban #modi #foreignpolicy #indiaafghanistanties #newdelhi #kabul #historicalties #culturalties #indianembassyinkabul #technicalteam #mullahhasanakhund #humanitarianaid #medicines #wheat #salmadam #pakistan #china #iran #diplomaticmission #envoy #mea #jaishankar #haibatullahakhunzada
Hindustan Times Videos brings all the News for the Global Indian under one umbrella. We break down news from across the globe from the unique lens of a Rising India. Tune in for Explainers, Opinions, Analysis and a 360 degree view of big events in India and the World which impact your present and future.
Follow the Hindustan Times Channel on WhatsApp for News Alerts, Top Stories and Editor picks. Join Us Today - www.bit.ly/3PQ4kSv
Subscribe to the Hindustan Times YT channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
Visit our website www.hindustantimes.com/
Follow us on Twitter / httweets
Follow us on Facebook / hindustantimes
We have historical friendship with India we love India and Bollywood Jai Hind from Afghanistan 🇦🇫
🇮🇳 ♥AF
tera gntha bjawoo bolly wood kiya hai
🇮🇳 too ❤loves❤ 🇦🇫 . Loads of love n respect sir🙏👍
I'm Afghan we love India 🇮🇳 ♥️ 🎉
🇦🇫❤️🇮🇳 forever
You may love them. But India has no interest in you since you are a Muslim. All they want you is to hate Pakistan and if possible become an Indian proxy and bleed Pakistan.
@@naherf385we have no interest in wars . And muslims are our brothers. Muslims of middle East , Afghanistan are much better than Pakistan. You are brainwashed by ur army
Nope.. you love China
🇮🇳 too ❤loves❤ 🇦🇫 . Loads of love n respect sir🙏👍
India could become the best strategy partner and this is the real exact time
Sir we as afghans regardless of belonging to any tribe or ethnicity always appreciate and support being in a friendly closer relationship with brother great country India
Long live to the Afghan-India historical friendship
India has always been an afghan close friend for many many years in the past and it will continue into the future.
As an Indian i really know one thig invest there where we gain something nothing else
Brilliant discourse.gem of analysis.
Empires came, rose and then perished.... Only Bharat survived the test of time. Bharat believes in Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam and we welcome all to walk with us. Akanda Bharat 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 Jai Hind
NOPE! India was consecutively invaded and conquered throughout history by the Mughals, British...etc it was then handed back to Indians and then started being conquered again,🤣🤣 Kashmir, Ladakh...etc. Arunachal Pradesh is next to be taken by China and the Modi gov is doing NOTHING to protect it. When will India learn, to stop electing men of Straw!!!! Don't invent fake history, India lost almost all historical battles, except for in Punjab, to foreigners. Make real history starting today. We need a real gov, not a spineless one like Godi.
Remember there’s others survived to.
Iran, China and the Great Afghanistan.
Packistan is occupying Afghani lands ever since Durand line agreement expired in 1993. India needs to support Afghanistan govt reclaim their ancestral lands from bloody talons of Punjabi dominated Packistani fauz.
😂 i know why you spell packistan because youtube ie western source deletes anything spoken against pakistan its amazing how both Countries Country:I and Country:P both failed miserably both created based on madthab yet promoted widely… my comments get shadowed and deleted automatically too 😅
Yes brother we will have to push India to support our fair claim
😂 yes Punjab is part of India uttarpardesh is an idiot fuk uttarpardesh 😂
You Afgandu will get from Pakistan only A BIG KHEER ? 😂
Glad many issues such as Air route,ports,moderation people understood. Thanks Dr Sareen for very informative programme.
Thanks for an enlightening session 🙏🙏🙏
Thx 4 good speak ❤
No matter who rules Afghanistan, 🇦🇫 🇮🇳 friendship for ever.
Never underestimate Afghans and ensure India's self interest in any a engagement
Indian people and Afghan people are deeply loving each other. Hindustan Afganistan Bhai Bhai.. 🥰
You must have forgotten what they did to somnath. Speak for yourself.
Ask your brothers if you can build you idols and see the reaction. You fool 😳😜🤥
@@ObscureManifestobut you seem to love our beautiful Afghan women, your Bollywood is filled with them. No wonder they don’t cast South Indians, the actual Dravidian Indians, and only Afghan Aryan mixed Indians 😂😂😂😊
What they did to Buddha statues, priceless history destroyed by then mindless Talibans. They can never be bhai bhai.
@@shahuss9396 aise to Israel k log bhi beef khate lekin tum hindu tabhi Israel ko apna Bhai kahete 😂😂
I see Sushant Sareen, I hit like 👍 Simple!
Hilarious that India haters trying to be creative in their comments. Coming up with excuses to criticise Modi Govt and exposing their utter hate for the nation
Why is a Hindutva government working with disgusting Islamic fanatics 😂😂
@dodiraj1: wrong it doesn’t take much creativity, when you have reality as your source.
Modi is a puppet of the U.S. and the only reasons he in Afghanistan is to try and get between Taliban and China.
And to try to instigate greater conflicts with Afghanistan against Pakistan as well as try to undermine China in both nations, on behalf of his masters (USA), by instigating military conflicts between Afghanistan and Pakistan.
It’s all about cutting China off.
its English monologue, they probably have some issues following it 😀
@@raosaheb5637
Yes, feel proud of a useless French dialect
Nobody hates zinnia or Modi ,people the whole world remembers the genocide of Gujarat India orchestrated by Modi them CM of Gujarat in which 5000 Muslims were brutally killed by Modi RSS Hindu terrorist ,and over 250000 were forced to leave or get killed ,now they live in camps and are not allowed to comeback their businesses and properties were sold to Hindus ,Modi is a terrorist ,and through his godi lapdog media he is portrayed as some tough guy and people should fear him,PEOPLE LIKE YOU WORSHIP HIM LIKE HE GOA MATA.ignorance is not bliss.
Superbly summarised by Shri Sushant Sareen ji.
It gives a positive touch towards building a better engagement with Afghans which would help both the nationalities
I am sure Modi government is mindful of the need to be extending helping hand but simultaneously ensuring the hand is out of harms way
Great analysis. Thank you
Well analysed and explained.
We were once in favor of najibullah. His family was safe in New Delhi. We provided tech support and medical support to Ahmed Shah Massoud . So we have never played favorite is wrong statement . Very inspid presentation
Good analysis from Dr Sareen who has the domain knowledge.
Great analysis, and information thanks
Sushant Sareen one of best geopolitical analyst.
Sushant Sareen- any idea
-1- if our prospecting teams from Rare Earth and Mineral Ministry are at work in the country.
2- what is the progress on Charbar port
3- road & rail link from the port to the North
4- dams being built on rivers in the western part of Afghanistan.
India didn’t turn the tables. You guys were wrong about the taliban. Admit it. They are strong independent operators.
Great analysis
Shut up you andhbhakt
China kicked you in ladakh by occupying Delhi sized area you. Andhbhakt haha😂
He is a third rated gosdiper and nothing else anything he says in his vlog, like Gurav Aria is fake news and nothing else ,Tum ko or Tulare jesy ko allo Bana raha hey.Bantey Rahoo Tamara murder hey.
Yes Afghaniyanstan ia a great Taliban country . Taliban respects indian women . 😍
Sareen saab, are you affiliated with hindustan samay?
@HT Why tat keerk...! Keereck...!! Sound in middle? Literally its annoying. If you are using handsfree it just bang ears with noise. Dont add it.
actually, we respect Afghan Hindu, and Sikh , believe it or not right now, Talibans are guarding Gurdwara For the safety of Sikh people ✌️🏳️❤️🇮🇳
Yes, when ISKP attacked the Gurdwana, our Islamic Emirate security forces battled for hours against ISKP, and saved the Sikhs holy book (I don't know what it is called) and apprehended/eradicated the ISKP fighters...they were Tajiks, sent by the NRF to make it look like minorities were not safe under our Taliban. NRF is using ISKP as proxies in Afghanistan. We even lost one of our young Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan, Mujahideen, and many were injured too.
U are 100% correct, Sister. When the Sikhs Gurdwara was attacked by IS-KP, our Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan security forces battled them for hours and saved the Sikhs in their temple and the Sikhs holy book. We sadly even lost one of our young security forces/Mujahideen and many were injured too. The NRF were sending their proxy IS-KP to target minorities at that time to make it look like the minorities were not safe under our Taliban. Now, our Islamic Emirate security forces are still guarding the Gurdwara.
No need for unnecessarily changing camera angle.
Atleast reduce The frequency
Stopped seeing half way by that irritating noise by shifting the camera. I am sure many must have done that and hope sushant sareen sees these comments and realises how a good commentator is not heard because of an idiot from his filming crew.
No exploitation of Afghan Resources by foreign Companies!!!!!
🇮🇳❤️🇦🇫
Sir,on one side India denounce terrorism while on other side India comes closer to terrorists Talibans, don't you think it's duplicity or the morality of diplomacy has gone down??🙏🌹🇵🇰
Morality with venomous snakes ????
@@palashranjandas9928 😂 🐍
Perhaps you have not understood what Diplomacy is
Dramjad sir , there is a thing called National interests. Countries look for their own interests. India is simply making sure your country's army or any other terror outfits from Afghan soil doesn't create further problems for us.
And above all we Indians don't interfere into their systems just like pakistanis. We work with them simultaneously & help them out of crisis. There is a difference We are not Pakistan sir. We don't catch Usds to troublesome other countries. Thats why Afghans hates Pakistan & now troubling Pakistan because of its own leadership bad policies in the past. Your leadership have to deal with it. Why will we have a bad relationship with any power in Pakistan. As our foreign minister once said , "Wake up & smell the coffee sir. " 😅
Even in history , Afghans have a good relationship with Indians . What Pakistanis don't understand is that they don't count Pakistan. During partitions they didn't even recognise Pakistan at the UN as a country.
The question of morality comes when we play dual games just like Pakistani state did with Afghans. On one side they caught dollars on the other they supported the Taliban. We are just after our national interest. 😅
Sushantji, i have question that in 2011 when OBL was killed, don't you think US should have vacated the Afganistan then and there and give a soft handover to Taliban like they did in 2020?
If we have POK then we can have direct link to Afghanistan, and we can limit depending on chabhar port
Seems like you are anti-iran. Iran is building relations with India.
😂😂😂
India should have borders with Iran & Afghanistan. This gives land access to India till central Asia & Caucases. If taliban helps in occupying Gilgit-Baltistan in north & Sindh-Baluchistan, then India should help Afghanistan getting its land back aheead of Durand line.
Looking forward for India to give the Afghanis a chance!
What makes you think Afghanistan needs India? What does India have to offer? Nothing.
Afghanistan is working well with China in development and investments, trade and commerce, BRI / SCO, next BRICS.
India can’t even develop their own nation let alone anyone believe it can develop theirs
Now Situation in India, Jobless Youth Kisan Hardworking People Sufferings !! Most States & Communities Sufferings !! Now Educated Youth like Rahul Gandhi is Suitable for Future PM.. There must be a change!!
Educated Rahul Gandhi😂 seriously. Maybe sashi Tharoor.
RG “ educated”?? Joke of the century.
He cannot write or read a paragraph in Hindi or any other language of India.
I can see someone burning from Modi govt 😂😂😂
I don’t think anyone is burning of anyone. In facts it’s India who kneeled down and trying to normalise relations with taliban
Get this straight...we Afghans are not stupid and we want good relationship with all regional neighbors. Also, the majority of us Afghans support Taliban
It is your country and your wish! You know what is best for you.
I don’t watch but hear such videos while working on something else to avoid headache of changing angles
My Dearest Dost Slamu Alaikum and Namastie , You are right , Pakistan government celebrate the success of Taliban on 15th of august 2021 as the defeat of India in Afghanistan , that was a big mistake of Pakistani entity in Afghanistan , they have forgotten that how they destroy our country for the last 50 years , how they ruin our 100 years old army proud and how they put our economy in fire of gun powder , but we will never forget and forgive that crime which Pakistan did to us .they have forgotten that India was/is the second home of Afghans from the centuries and centuries , India always respected our people and our country sovereignty .with deep trust I assured you my good friend that % 99.9 of Afghans love India and India lovely people as their family members , we were one , we are one , and our enemy is one . Our government is new , new reforms for improvements needs the time and we are hopeful to the future .
Jai Baharat and Zindabad Afghanistan . Thank you so much for your truthful analysis .
Long Live Afghanistan🇦🇫 india 🇮🇳friendship 🙏🙏
Similar was happened with Pakistan 45 years ago now where do you stand lol 😂... India didn't even leave their own Muslims they suppressed them completely even big khans can't say anything openly...you think their attitude towards you is friendly by heart then you're wrong... The base of your friendship is the common hatred of Pakistan ...😂
🇮🇳 too ❤loves❤ 🇦🇫 . Loads of love n respect sir🙏👍
Make him lacoste ambassador
Realpolitik is not the exclusive preserve of West! Absolute pre-condition for any engagement is no harm to India should ever emanate from Afghanistan. But we Indians don't forget the Kandhahar hijacking of 1999! And the innumerable attacks on Indian missions in Afghanistan
If it was done by congress, then bhakts will be like “congress supports terrorism” 😅
Unlike you partisan idiots, if the Congress government does something good we would applaud that.
Bhakts are clueless. One side they curse taliban and other side modi government will be bending in front of taliban
Muslim fundamentalist govt and Muslim kings are acceptable against muslim democracies this is American policy we adopted
This man is just mentioning general things and them trying to credit it to Modi and Co.
❤ 🇮🇳 ❤ Remember Tali finished off most of Agencies that ISI was involved into. Mostly in Pakistan they targeted their homes and took them out under so called “unknown” gun men attacking teror groups that were wanted by India but were living in pkistan
How many times he said perhaps 😂
1:10
Modiji is a great leader!❤❤❤
😂😂😂😂
James bond ..modani
Electrol bond choor 😂😂
Neech pm of Indian history
It was pretty simple. The Pakistani generals have no choice but to align with their American masters. Lest they lose their billions & billions of looted dollars under sanctions. For India it was a nice move, but it seems that once again the generals will be the main reason for Pakistan breaking up!
We call for Boycotting Indian Products in Bangladesh. They ( Govt. ) are really trouble maker in the region.
How will you get cheap potatoes and onions....katwa🤣
😂 What is itching you ? Boycotting raw materials for your garment industry will destroy your economy. Moreover, you have forgotten that Brahmputra, Teesta and Ganga rivers flow from India to Bangladesh.
You die without food
Kanglu....... bhinkmangey bhag yahan
Satyug wapis aaraha hai kya?
Very slow, keeps rambling on the same points again and again
Being anti muslim want to be a great player in muslim country. What a funny analysis. At last india realised Taliban is not pakistan proxy!?
Bro India isn't anti Muslim. We are just anti fuck all chutiya sunni Pakistan & it's Qaum. Baat khatam .
India 😂😂
Yes such a key player that afeer investing 20 years, lots of money, manpower and effort into Afghanistan...
India was kicked out of Afghanistan and it's bases along the Pak border were all seazed and shut down😂I😂😂
Wah modi g wah😂.
What about thr treatment of minorities in Modi's India?
It is the sayings of our beloved Prophet Sallalhoo Alyhe Wasallam that KHARJITES are partners of RSS Hindoo, Afghan Taliban+TTO are KHARJITES.
This person talking about India Afghanistan trade & friendship is all okay.
But don't say Afghanistan doesn't do religious persecution of Hindus😮. Because all Hindus in Afghanistan were already persecuted,killed, and NOW, there will be 0% of Hindus minority citizens in Afghanistan 😢😮
Power of BJP Government 👍🏻🗿✨
😂😂😂😂
China ..ke khuch Nahi ukhada 😂😂modani. Bjp power
No visa to Afghan no admission in tech institute,
Sir please share the project carrying by Indian mnc in Afghanistan. China extracting petroleum, mining lithium have contract for thirty years
Next contract by China with Afghanistan afghsnistsn is mining of gold and copper.
There is no consistent policy, to engage with Afghanistan.
YOUR COMMENT AND ANALYSIS
IS BASE LESS, HYPOCRITIC
YOUR ALL COMMENT ON THE ISSUE IS RUBBISH.
Yes, Rubbish Kumar follower + Muslim can result in the comment you have posted. When you are so happy in Hindustan, why not pack your bags for Pakistan.
Shadow of terror if victims of IC814 still remains
One problem! If Modi is a tough guy, why did he allow India to be humiliated by Pak and China during Bhalokhot and Galwan?
I have no doubt India may be involved in Afghanistan, to what extent I don't know, but I don't see this as a good or Macho Image for Modi when he is hiding behind the Taliban! If this is a proxy war, it should remain a covert operation, otherwise, it defeats the purpose of fighting by proxy, not broadcasted everywhere because Modi is being disgraced and losing respect elsewhere. This looks desperate!!! Taliban are fighting for their OWN country, India just has a common interest.
Stop propaganda, at least in foreign affiars use indian govt instead of modi govt.
But it is “modi” government the rest of the Indian government are irrelevant as its Modi the celebrity clowns show who is the tool of the U.S.
Why
It is under his leadership we are going forward
@@V-IAS2008 forward?? Modi is hitching Indian. India (like the U.S. and Europe) is headed for civil unrest and a fracturing divided state.
it is modi govt because, in congrss time our policy was different. regarding to both afghanistan & pakistan.
go buy burnol
All hate the Pakitan 😂
Can you show us what % of Afghan citizens are from the Hindu religion still alive in Afghanistan?, and what % of Buddhist religion still alive in Afghanistan? as Afghan citizens 😮😢😅, the answer will be ZERO !
Correct but realpolitik has many other considerations, apart from religion.
I do not like the strong Hindu extremist undertone in this video. Painting the Indian government as the hero and Afghanistan and the rest of the world as zeros.
Saab please always make your show in Hindi Punjabi .
Thanks
Jai Bhawani
What an irritating bgm
How is India dealing with minorities?
Sikh Jain parsi jews Buddhist are happy here converts are not 😅
Converts from Burma and BD who slipped into India are the one's fearing the wrath of Indian govt.
Converts within India are our own, and are slowly getting reformed, you need not worry about them.
Bharat must convince Telebans to promote education and freedom to women. Promote Nari Shakti.
You mean like it is in India😂😂
Gang Rapes, child-marriages, women second class. A nation of uneducated or poorly educated populace, living in squalor poverty, yeah India lecturing about that 😂😂
Mr modi should turn the world not only the table🤭👎👎
Stop day dreaming uncle 😁
Fake news kam fekaa kar
Teri Kyun jali
Hindu hatao Modi hatao desh bachao😮
Bla bla bla bla bla ….. we have heard this all before 😂😂😂😂
Pakistan crying in the comment section 😂😂😂😂😂😂
We welcome Taliban office in gujrath
Its a a guarantee of modiji and amith sha ji❤❤
That's y Taliban gave statement against CAA.... Fools only admiring their Father
Indian girl exports. Yes really
Afganistan should merge with india for their greater good
Only like $ $ big banana
Kickout
Modi. Bjp. Rss from India
British janta party
Change r channel modi times.
Aa Gaye pappu ke chamche
Toh kya rkhe Pappu times ??
@@sa17ama60
At least you accepted both are at the same level
@@parjanyashukla176 sb beta same hote h sir fark kaam ka hota h kaam ke basis pe judge kiya jaata h sarkaar ko awr nation ke liye desh me awr bahar kya kaam kiye h uss basis pe judge kiya jaata h awr abhi isliye Modi jeet ta h usse acha aayega koi toh vo bnega
Use burnol
The person who disliked this clearly has no taste.