ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 30 ก.ย. 2024
- Briahna Joy Gray and Robby Soave react to J.K. Rowling challenging Scottland's new hate crime laws. #jkrowling #scotland
About Rising:
Rising is a weekday morning show with bipartisan hosts that breaks the mold of morning TV by taking viewers inside the halls of Washington power like never before. The show leans into the day's political cycle with cutting edge analysis from DC insiders who can predict what is going to happen. It also sets the day's political agenda by breaking exclusive news with a team of scoop-driven reporters and demanding answers during interviews with the country's most important political newsmakers.
Follow Rising on social media:
Website: Hill.TV
Facebook: HillTVLive/
Instagram: @HillTVLive
Twitter: @HillTVLive
Brie “I don’t know what that means?” 😂. Obtuseness as a debate strategy ……
She is really good at debate. And actually totally got Robbie off the main subject here. If she was only any good at being right.
@@deadgolfer6345it’s how progressives debate…you have to do that when your point of subject is ridiculous
I knew Bri would get this wrong 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Bri - The level of your intellectual dishonesty is truly impressive.
She's the world heavyweight champion.
I don't know what she really believes but it's just a fact that they would come for her, like they do Rowling, if she dared to say otherwise.
Did you mean to say “the lack of her intellect is truly impressive?”
@@johnbailey7331 You could go in that direction but I fear the situation is quite a bit worse.
@@johnbailey7331 Didn’t this (cis) woman attend Harvard university? Wow, their standards are really failing.
So funny... Bri argues that 'trans women' want to identify as 'trans women' not as women... then when Robbie repeats that back to her, she says she doesn't know what that means.🙄
But they still want to access women's spaces. These men are ridiculous
Yep, completely performative and gas lighting
yes, bri is extremely transphobic in this segment.
"Hate Speech", "Political Correctness" and "disinformation" are all phrases popularized by the Russians during the Cold War.... and used to crush internal dissent to the regime.
There is nothing "Liberal" about the Left anymore.
"All cruelty is born of weakness" -Marcus Aurelius
Lots of them on this train think themselves to be smart but when you challenge them, they can only repeat things they memorize, because they don't really understand what they feel compelled to support. A bit frightening or should be.
Bella L
Bri straight faced pretending that we're making up what everyone can clearly see
Master gaslighter
There. Are. Four. Lights.
I fully understand what she's no longer a lawyer
It’s almost like she only knows how to argue in bad faith
You’re in your own world
Is Bri's new strategy to just say false things to test if Robbie has been tamed? lol ... Trans women insist on being called 'women' not 'trans women'... Bud Light died because Dylan M. was celebrated for being a woman, not a 'trans woman'. The modifier is dropped has fast as possible because its the very goal of trans... for everyone to participate in their transformation.
Despite their differences .. I wonder about those two sometimes .. And, yeah, she would be on top.
Yes, this show is so infuriating. Brianna repeatedly makes factually untrue statements and Robby is too weak-willed to stand up to her. Brianna stated there is no problem because the term “trans woman” instrinsically highlights the difference from just “woman”.
In the past month Rowling has highlighted specific news stories which have referred to criminals as women and NOT mentioned that they are trans-women ie born as males.
What?? I am shocked to hear that you think he's to week willed to stick up to her. I hear him providing logical arguments against her statements and I heard his skepticism. "Well I dunno about that." I was thinking I was proud of him for sticking to his beliefs and logically arguing against what she is saying. @@jaybo7813
Right? Nobody is under the impression that they are being forced to say trans women were BORN women. That's absurd. People feel like they are being pressured to say that trans women are just regular WOMEN.
"Cis a word people use to marginalize normal people" Norm MacDonald
Ha! He did. He'll be missed.
Hahaha. .Ahhh, thanks Norm, that's why you don't censor speech.
I’d put it to you to explain how “normal people” are being “marginalized”
@@usernamedwon Well you're a bot sooo...
@@usernamedwon Hate Speech Law in Scotland. There, did it for you.
J K doesn't have an "ideology ". She is stating truth.
Exactly. Biological medical science isnt an ideology .
@@BarnabyWild13 That's such a Barnaby thing to say......
Correct. Trans is the dogmatic ideology.
Truth is now "lies" and lies are now "truth". Orwell was right, it's 1984.
Truth is NOT hate
JK Rowling is a hero for women and free speech for all.
Absolutely.
Meh
Bri is…. Not so much that. 😂
She's pretty hot for her age too 🤷♂️
She is neither.
No such thing as ciswoman, Bri.
She has a harvard law degree.
only in the minds of trans women
@@thomasdassah4680she's married to a woman.
@@brooklynbandit6788 She is not married, and she dates men.
@@thomasdassah4680 No, Cis Briahna has a cis Harvard law degree.
There is no CIS woman. Just WOMAN and MAN period !!!!!
leave it to bri, to come up with mush and try to impress the ones who enjoy being duped or simply run over with her jibber.
Even using the term CIS is like them declaring victory in a debate where they've provided zero facts or evidence. Just using the term indicates that there's a need for the term, which indicates that they won the debate without even contributing to an actual debate at any point. Also, as soon as someone uses the term CIS, you already know everything else they believe and they're going to say... it's like when a Jehovah's Witness, Mormon or Scientologist tries to convert you. If you've heard one, you've heard them all, and none of it is remotely convincing.
@@lar-k7s Bri didn't come up with the term "cis", and if you don't know that then you need to see yourself out of the comment section and do some homework.
I appreciate the attempt to delineate between women and people who identify as women- we really do need language to do that. However, my opinion is that the onus is on the group who is appropriating something- which is the trans women. I am a woman, and some may be ok with calling people like me "biological women", but I will not describe myself as "cis".
@@RealYRM We really do need language to delineate between women and trans women- and "trans woman" is the way to do that. I mentioned elsewhere that the onus is on the group who is appropriating womanhood to be clear. I think "cis" is , at the very least, tacky.
Also, I think you are wrong in the comparison you made in the latter part of your comment. That is tacky as well.
What a ridiculous argument by Bri here. She knows they aren’t distinguishing themselves from cis women, they’re just calling themselves “women”.🤦🏻♂️
what does cis even mean?
@@drewskij2175 just a newly made up word that means *real woman* .
@@drewskij2175 a biological woman.
@@drewskij2175 it's a slur to marginalize normal people.
Bad Faith Bri is firing on all cylinders.
You guys are dancing aroung the issue. it has nothing to do with rates of violence in the "trans community". it has to do with the usurping of language and reality. men in woman sports, men in womans prisons, men in womans spaces. creating a protected class is a bad idea, especially when it is based on delusion. Bri, what is a woman??
And what would she have answered 10 years ago?
She would say anyone who feels or looks like one!
Notice how bri only ever calls to end prison secks violence to absolve trans specific prison secks violence.
Yeah, she successfully derailed him again.
"What is a woman" doesn't have a single answer and the people asking it aren't actually looking for an answer
Yea, Bri is just sooooo wrong on this.
She simply repeats the propaganda which her activist friends push. For example, the data shows that, if anything, trans women are the victims of violent crime at LOWER rates than women.
She's wrong on just about everything.
100% wrong. Delusional or dishonest.
She's right about the law being bad, but the rest of her argument is sophistry.
That statement can be applied to most topics.
This is why i hold Bri in such contempt and have no respect for her. She uses that big, very capable, sharp brain of hers to make bad faith arguments. Lately, she's been flat lying. I always thought Ryan Grim was the biggest scumbag to come out of here. Bri has won that battle.
Am I the only one that feels that Robbie has no spine when talking to her. I feel like he holds back a lot!
Bri you don’t get to label women “cis” as we didn’t consent to the name change.
When has labeling others ever relied on their consent?
I just hope all this silliness passes soon.
We are all humans.
Wow you are SOOOOO oppressed by people calling you a neutral descriptor
@@bunnybird9342 it’s redundant. It’s like saying “women women”
You don't get to decide that for other people either. If you don't like the label you don't have to use it.
Bri is straight up lying
I’m shocked because that’s never happened before…
As always
She is in denial over hurting people's feelings. Seriously.
Yes, she certainly is.
Braids too tight bri, perhaps suppressing your real thoughts, because this can't be real life.
Please don't call us cis women.
Birthing person better?
@@mikeriordan3428women sounds better.
Cis is not a correct word for identifying any person
@@mikeriordan3428person with a Bonus hole
Well said.
Bri is so brainwashed, I'm surprised bubbles don't come out of her ears.
How
@@bunnybird9342 troll
CisWomen not a thing. Believe me, fast talking lady-host would be the first to complain and fight against any man coming into her prison cell if she were incarcerated. Easy to comment when you out here, and safe.
Fun facts:
Refusing to participate in those "trans" people's delusions IS NOTa "hate crime" NOR does it make someone "transphobic".
I was in a message board about mystery topic and said I support trans right because I also support star seeds ( people who think they are incarnated extraterrestrials) and weranimals (people that think their soul is an animal and that is the same.Then they tried to ban me for trolling and I should accept not to talk about the topic anymore, although it was a message board about these mystery topics. So a lot of them are very intolerant if it come to other people that claim they are something else.
The people that hate trans... is themselves.
That's the point, though, right? In Scotland, not participating in their delusions IS a hate crime now.
@@AdamWeisshauptthem? Intolerant of other views? Nooooooo…. I’m shocked! /sarcasm/
It’s almost a compliment to be called a phobe at this point
Briahna Joy is speaking in BAD FAITH.
ALWAYS
It’s normal for her…
08:40 was particularly peculiar.
Be specific … how ? Exactly ? Because she disagrees with YOU😂?…
@@lalaland7961 Check out 08:40
Bri, you are so wrong about this.
Bri, what is Rawlings' "ideology"? Science?
"but .017% of humans are outside the norms, and 5% of that .017% are actually intersex, so that means theother 99.983% need to bow to their new masters.... and it has nothing to do with seizing power. Trust me bro."
The "blowback" against Marxism can not happen soon enough.
This issue is where Bri loses all credibility.
This, economics, immigration, criminal justice, foreign policy...
@@anthonyrluna3056cultural zeitgeist, gun rights, etc. Etc. There isn’t much Bri is reasonable or consistent on
This is where you draw the line?
@@JohnTightlips not consistent with your beliefs you mean?
I meant to point out that she has the worst takes and this is one out does them all.
Step up Robby.
Bri…shoving in Palestine into any subject.
Palestinian Islam women are real women to Brianna. Us white women, not so much.
@@paulinegallagher7821 Always a woman to me! I have a beautiful wife married now 22 years and a lovely daughter. My mother raised 3 kids by herself and I have so much to thank the women in my life for. Bri has totally lost the plot and is showing how far things have declined in the modern university thinking. Much love from Australia.
Just like warmongerers shoving in “antisemitism” into any subject
jk rowling's ideology... you mean TRUTH? this is beyond ridiculous
Right? Come on...
It's an ideology. The issue is disputed. I don't mind calling it an ideology, I mind banning ideologies.
@@bookender biological reality is not an ideology. Subjective claims of gender souls is an ideology.
@@bookender "The issue is disputed."
Which issue exactly? The _definition_ of a words deconstructed into meaninglessness, or the underlying truth of the concept the word was meant to represent?
Sure, the Derrida-sycophants have made the _definition_ of the word a debate, because... well, that's what they do. They think it's clever to obfuscate under the pretense of seeking truth. But the underlying concept, is simple not up for dispute, and that is the common usage no matter how much other claim otherwise, you know, by saying "the issue is disputed."
Because the concept is not. _At all._
In our dimophic species: adult human _female_ equals woman. Just as two plus two equals four. You can call it five, ten, and orange, a tree or an elephant. The _concept_ remains the same; the _value_ is unchanged.
Of the ridiculous deconstructions the Marxists have trotted out in their attempt to stay relevant in the 21st century, this is the most tired.
@@bookender The issue isn't disputed with any facts though... To me, forcing people to use pronouns or pretend they can't tell someone is a drag queen would be like if some evangelical tried to force me to believe that water turned into wine through some magical process. They're free to believe it, but until any facts are introduced, I'm free to not believe it. Same with ghosts, or crystal healing, or bending spoons with your mind... those are all in the same category as having your gender change because you woke up feeling like it changed.
JK Rowling is a Queen👏👏 her only stand is fighting for womens right!!
Explain to me how being in opposition to the freedom to self-identify as a women interferes with womens rights?
Bri really just equated the “quality of food in prison” to be equal to being “sexually assaulted”as justification in an argument. Woah, that’s horrible.
Twas just thinking the same thing. Bri is insufferable.
Also it was huge whataboutism.
Imagine if the conversation was about gun violence and someone pointed that more people die from health related issues in America than gun violence so the real issue is our food quality.
She would call them out for deflection.
Yes! Robbie should absolutely have called her out for that. What a nuts crazy comparison! I was wondering how he let that pass without comment.
she is, indeed, terrible
Robbie how are you not laughing in her face when she compares men in women’s prison with men who claim to be Muslim to get a better meal?
Come on, man
I had the same thought 😆
Yes, she’s sooooo dishonest!
That was ridiculous
Robbie is scared to question sTrOnG bLaCk WoMaN
Of all the terrible non sequitur arguments she put forth, this one was the most shamefully obtuse and out of touch. Truly unbelievable someone of her intellect can stoop this low.
To be honest, I only click these videos to watch Robby suffer from having to endure talking to Bri.
Sometimes Bri makes good points.
But on this yeah, way off base
😄
@@autumneaglein what way is she off base? Because she doesn’t agree with you?
@@agoogleuser704 Read all the comments. There's about a 100 people here explaining how she's way off base.
@@MrDavee1 You have a different opinion than me, so you must be lying 🤥 🤥 comments in a nutshell
Brie has made me hate the left and I know longer identify as a leftist because of people like her. I'm done with class traitors that just love hearing themselves speak. She is the most radical person at the cocktail party and I'm tired of these people being the thought leaders for the left. They are playing academic games where the goal is to be the moral supremist and not actual find middle grounds with average people. Perfect ex. is Hasan Piker being ran up on by fan yelling how he needs to stop drinking Coke on stream because "we are boycotting it." You guys are clowns yelling at nobodies.
“most radical person at the cocktail party” *chef’s kiss 💯
You are totally allowed to feel the way you feel and have opinions. But, I would like to just to give this a consideration. Bri is a lawyer. She lives to argue. Trust me, I live with one. Sometimes, I don't feel she is as passionate about certain things she defends so much, is that she is loving arguing for it. I dont know if that makes sense, or if she has even realized it. But I see alot of my husband in her. I am always like, why are you arguing with me on this? Its not even a subject he cares about, lol. Could be totally wrong, just my food for thought! But i think most of us are in the middle, just trying to work and live our lives and be happy.
Same. I lean left on many policies (living wage, nationalized healthcare, etc.), but I can't stand Bri's sophistry on these topics. It is precisely the kind of thing that leads to no progress for the sake of some illusion of moral supremacy. It accomplishes nothing.
NEWSFLASH: You were never a leftist.
@@scratchpenny I think she is actively harming the left by being such a child in these conversations. I wish we had more working class voices like Revolutionary Blackout Network, Hard Lens Media, and the like.
"ciswoman"
How about noooooo
As soon as someone even uses a term like this, don't you instantly know you don't need to listen to anything else they could possibly say? They've announced being in the cult, and you know everything else they say is going to fail to make sense or mesh with reality. It's like if you run into a Scientologist with an e-Meter talking about alien ghosts... you already know that they're not worth listening to the instant they tell you they want to do your reading.
Honestly have to hand it to Rowling in this, either the Scottish Government has to put up or shut up over their new act.
And she's powerful enough to make people question the reasonableness of the law.
And she's famous enough that her story isn't going to get buried if they do arrest her.
@@hope-cat4894 fame, power and (well-earned) wealth are on her side, but I still appreciate her for deploying those assets to enable her to take on this very malign legislation. She seems to be a Lefty but a relatively common-sense one. Perhaps she will red-pill herself during this affair.
In addition in Scotland you can be accused under this law anonymously which is bound to be abused as the right to face your accuser of a criminal act is now being cancelled out.
Bri, you’re allowed to list yourself as female on your passport in this country, no “trans” qualifier. So you’re just dead wrong.
Dylan made a video about this. He was so excited to have "female" on his passport.
Bri is a clown
She has been for a long time
💯
A hugely divisive paper tiger. Bri is misdirecting this conversation. This is about criminalizing opinion. Whether one choses to accept someone's gender identity is up to the individual. One can encourage compassion, sympathy and flexibility of belief, but one can't legalize that process, certainly not overnight. Purposely misgendering someone in the workplace may constitute discrimination, but in terms of the public sphere these sort of laws are not going to result in further acceptance of the trans community. The backlash is becoming evident in the loss of support for the LGBT community in general.
Brie is so wrong on every point except her opening sentence, bring Amber on to talk to her about crime rates with facts to combat Brie's "I think" guesses.
I know right. I really wish The Hill would pair up Amber and Bri because Amber is the only person that will challenge Bri, and when she does, it's with FACTS.
Robbie is useless.
Bri's take on this is psychotic. I swear the entire western world has stolkholm syndrome.
Not me!
Briahna, there is no such thing as a “CIS WOMAN.”
There are human beings called WOMEN and MEN. This was a known fact and cultural practice for thousands of years until just a few years ago or so. As a MAN, I don’t appreciate, need or accept full stop, ANY “edited” label or name that some activists or ideologically possessed individual decides to attempt to put on me. I don’t see where the logic in this isn’t easily discernible and should be respected.
Common sense is what that would have been called not that long ago……
I read through dozens of these comments and they give me some faith in humanity. Virtually no everyday person is defending the Scottish government or Bri here. Ordinary people know the truth and this issue may very well be the one where the average person finally stands up and says no further.
Brianna's chains of ridiculous whataboutisms and misdirections are getting more and more elaborate.
It’s absurd we have to even discuss very narrow laws and cultural special treatments for such a tiny portion of the populace. We survived hundreds of years without having to set aside these special considerations, and now all of a sudden this is the greatest issue of our time. No wonder society is falling.
"Tiny" would be 1%. This is .017% who are bona-fide "dysphoric" and insane, 1 in 20 of _those_ who are actual intersex anomalies. This is about power for the narrative; it has nothing to do with care and concern.
Bri, you just don't want to understand.
Bri, I love you. And I am sure I will sound phobic when I say this, but there are distinct differences. And I think that is what JK speaks on. There are actual transwomen, trying to live their life, not doing anything. And then there are men using this to get away with violence, etc. And I think she, and many others, just want it to not be where anyone can say they are whatever they say are at a whim. Because as Robbie mentioned, men transitioning and moving into women spaces, could create an issue because of their natural biology of being a male. I don't think it is so black and white, and we are still figuring it out daily. So rushing to accuse anyone on either side of the isle with crimes, is dangerous. I highly recommend people listening to "the witch trials of JK Rowling". The attacks she got from the LGBTQ community was worse than any she go from the right.. Which tbf, if you are a public figure, I think you should be prepared for attacks from anyone and everyone. ok. I am rambling now. Goodday!
She won't read this, but I did. Well said. Happy someone so thoughtful is a member of this community.
Best comment yet
@@McGurkus well maybe someone who works with her will! 🤠 this is why I love this show. Getting to see different viewpoints, and trying to understand everyone!
Bri sounds as ridiculous in this segment as Robbie does when he’s shilling for the state department on Gaza.
I think his stand is to not support either side. How does that support the state department?
@@paulsnow re-read my comment friend, *shilling* for the state department. If you don’t know what I’m talking about then you haven’t watched all the heated back and fourths between him and Bri where he just regurgitates all the state department talking points. It’s not that complicated or hard to see.
@@davidlink2720and still you provide no clarification for the claim..
@@davidlink2720
1. There was a terrorist attack on Oct 7
2. Hamas has shot 10,000+ missiles at Israel since 2000
3. Terrorist attacks have been repeatedly launched on Israel from Gaza
4. Terrorists attacks by Hamas led to Egypt sealing their boarder with Gaza
A. Nobody will dispute that Israel has responded violently against Gaza repeatedly since 2000, and now in the current conflict.
Bria Ignores 1, 2, 3, 4, but goes on and on about A.
Robbie does point out 1,2,3,4 and A, but never asserts we should be involved, which the state department seemingly advocates.
@@paulsnow the simple fact that the earliest you’re going back on the timeline of your little list is 2000, says everything about where you get your information and how you’ve drank that state department/ AIPAC kool-aid.
"Transwomen" are not women, and no state can compel its citizens to lie and pretend otherwise. Let's skip to the part where the state tries to enforce this compulsion, and we'll see how most people really feel about this issue.
Briahna once again demonstrating that she does not believe in freedom of speech.
Stop calling women cis women when you know so many women are offended by it, as I am. By this law's definition, that should also be considered hate speech if it is a stated preference. And the fact that it has been stated by so, so many women - yet you and others insist and persist to use this term, being hyper protective of a minority group and ignoring the rest of our preferences. How do you not see something so obvious? JK is only standing up for women and not coming down on this group.
What a pathetic joke the UK has become. And the people just sit there and take it. WAKE UP!
This is only in Scotland and that is until the election. Of course, the rest of the UK may end up like this as Labour are very likely to adopt a similar strategy. Then your comment will be a very valid and fair point.
@@TigerMa75It's a global agenda (by the same plutocrats as all the other global agendas), and the whole UK is already a joke anyway
@@TigerMa75 Wake up, the whole United Kingdom is going this way, Scotland just put it in writing.
Bri, they aren't trans women when they commit the crime. They "transition" once convicted so they can be put in a women's prison. It's transition of convenience that Rowling and others have a problem with....
Man remind me to stay away from Europe. I thought it was bad in the US now..
Not all of Europe, but the Western states definitely.
Scandinavian countries seems to have their heads on straight.
Actually, in the UK we're waking up to the fact that gender ideology is a pile of steaming nonsense. The problem is that many of our institutions were captured by activists and it's a slow process to kick the lunatics out.
they are about 20 yrs ahead of us in the race to the bottom.
@@mikem4481 *Canada has entered the chat.*
The majority of the world agrees with Rowling
Only about 99.99%. I mean if you want to call that a "majority".... and insist that "majority" be able to set basic standards for definitions then...I guess... yeah...
/s
Marxism is cancer.
How did she ever get a law degree?
Tells you something about Harvard, yeah?
Affirmative action.
DEI
Affirmative action. You will notice you will ask yourself this question with most of these people
Plagarism U
Bri call them trans people and not trans "women". We're women and not cis women.
I am not a "cis" woman. Correct yourself.
Bri will "nothing to see here" until she feels the effects of what she's helping push.
Don't call us cis.
luxury belief - she does not have a daughter trying to navigate changing rooms or whatever
This woman bri is dangerous.......She sounds nice, but the policies she advocates for yield terrible results
That's literally most "progressive" ideas and ideals. They all sound nice and great. But time has shown that they have poisoned and are slowly destroying us.
She’s against the policy, did you even listen? 👂
@agoogleuser704 did you hear her call out Rowling, who was against a guy who was stealing his sisters underwear 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@Shinobi91 k?
@@agoogleuser704 She is against the policy? Hmm... 2:15. "It's clear that it's an over reach?"
How about the rest of it? She is not "against" the policy, she is against the possible "side-effects" of the policy. Big difference.
Did _you_ even listen? Or were you too busy looking to troll posters while tongue-bathing the DSA shill?
Dishonest Grayjoy as always. Her initial argument was that the implication of their identity was enough to give their background of their history and story.. then goes on to act like she doesn’t understand Robbie’s explanation that we still need a differential between a biological woman and a trans woman. “I don’t understand what you mean”… “In what context”
No Bri they don’t want to be called just “trans women” which as a concept in itself is rejected by many, they actually want to be called women period, and want to force you to use incorrect pronouns and you are forbidden to “deadname” them or state the fact that they are not actually women.
This is why I had to unsubscribe, commentary like this, a waste of time and it upsets me.
JK Rolling ,stand with you, one of general women , freedom of her and a millions of the same vision of human life.
People are so committed to this ideology, it is a religion to them. And when they try to impose it on us, their fury comes out. It is very telling.
i feel like these presenters are well out of their depth on the topic. neither one seems to have a cohesive grasp on the implications of compelled speech.
Robbie needs to get better at this. 😢
Bree clearly thinks these laws should have MORE teeth.
And Robbie never presses her.
Bri obviously thinks it's OkaY for hate speech laws to target certain iconography that she finds offensive, but then she cries foul
when palestinian supporters are targeted using these same hate speech policies.
And Robbie never points out this MASSIVE hypocrisy from Brianna.
Also she seemed to be completely fine with biological males going into female prisonszone, which is completely insane.
I think Robby must be tired at this point. I had to check out and unsubscribed after late last year. I don't know how Robby can stay sane with this absolute nonsense day in and out.
@@jasper_of_puppets, Robby isn't sane when the subject is Israhell, he's 100% narrative news and narrative news is absolutely insane. Bri is pretty spot on on that subject but not much else.
In our "new normal" - simply observing "biological reality" = "hate." What could possibly go wrong? Total respect to Ms. Rowling.
I was not aware that Rowling was part of a "movement", or is serving some "ideology". Seems to me that she is a clear-headed and reasonable human being standing up for the obvious.
She is an old-school "feminist." Self identifying.
Changing to a religion for a better meal is a victimless crime…
Jon Stewart: No, it deprives an actual Muslim/Jew who could have otherwise eaten that meal.
@@chanfonseka8051 😂
Straight to Palestine 😂
I wonder if it ever occurred to JK she would one day no longer be able to remain a shy, retiring author of a courageous hero and have to play that courageous Harry Potter role herself?
The argument isn’t over calling them trans women. It’s calling them “women” - another insane straw man from Bri, again
4:39 This type of faux nonunderstanding by Bri is, has been, and will continue to be THE REASON THE LEFT AREN’T TAKEN SERIOUSLY. ffs
Did she just equate food to prison preference by using the same loop hole
the UK is declining further & further. Goodness me
I want my ten minutes back Bri.
This is a wedge.
Being allowed to use language is NOT anti-trans. Language can anti-trans, but the right to speech is more important than the idea that we can outlaw offenses to some people.
Bria is so off base. So far...
Bria knows that trans women commit fewer crimes than people on average. I would need a reference.
Who cares how few crimes they commit? The number of rapes by trans women in female prisons should be ZERO. Anything more than that produces at least one 100% preventable victim, and can be directly blamed on the law that allows trans women to be classified as women for prison placement. Similarly, the number of awards for trans women in women's sports should be ZERO. Anything more than that produces at least one 100% preventable victim (who lost the award that should have been rightfully hers by the true definition of woman - which is why the Left refuses to define it)
@@chanfonseka8051 I meant "knows" sarcastically.
@@paulsnow I know. And my point still stands.
@chanfonseka8051 I don't disagree. I posted something else if it shows up, I was confused and thought I was responding to a Gaza post....
Speaking of bizarre, the fact that they're even having this conversation is just that, bizarre.
Good for her! Someone has to stand for common sense and reality.
This exchanged was one of your worst. Briahna didn't get the current memo. Robby seems to know even less. Briahna is speaking from 2015. "Trans rights are human rights" has been fading as the mantra for the last five-10 years. If otherwise, Briahna might be right to say the identification itself - 'trans woman' or 'trans man' - may be enough. Now some advocates that women can have prostates. Men can have babies. Briahna asks "in what context?" In every context, it seems obvious. Rowling just picked one sector. The current call that "transwomen are women" indicates that we are supposed to acknowledge them as women, include them in women's spaces because they "are" women.
Haha she used the term 'CIS' women. RIP Banana republic US'A
The word "woman" means an adult female human and the word "man" means an adult male human. That is what these words have always meant. Why should they be redefined? I would be open to a good explanation of why, but it seems like this redefinition has simply been announced by cultural elites and is being imposed by force. It's quintessential newspeak.
Wait did Bri just invoke crime statistics?
I do not understand Briahna's claim that trans men always call themselves trans men. I've never heard one say the designation in ordinary conversation. And I have seen ones with the forged female ID; it is not a rarity. Were it up to many, they'd be able to swap genders on the ID as easily as they swap pronouns.
I sometimes can't tell wether Brianna truly believes the stuff she argues for, or if she just enjoys playing devils advocate for the sake of it
The woman who introduced me to fantasy in the 3rd grade, is now introducing another generation to something we call freedom of thought and speech.
Freedom of thought and speech already existed. She is nothing special.
@@bunnybird9342 be more dense.
@@OscyJack- what are you trying to say?
@@bunnybird9342 that you're not dense enough.
@@OscyJack- she isn't promoting freedom of speech. She is going out of her way to be offensive and actively incite things.
Bri is frustratingly and purposefully being obtuse here. Similar to Richard Dawkins and Sam Harris undermining the very ground they walk upon in Western society (namely Christianity) and then complaining when other worldviews take hold and give birth to the chaos those “towering intellectuals” paved the way for. Bri is smart but not wise.
How can people condon this fantasy world to force good people to accept this. Be how you want but leave us alone too
How did we get to this point?
Bri's whataboutism's get more absurd every time she opens her mouth!
This has to be the most uncomplicated issue in the history of humanity.
You need to fire Brie for making such inane arguments, and Robbie for not having the passion to truly take on such inane arguments.
Such bravery on the part of J.K. Rowling, is inspiring. I have not read her books, nor watched the movies from them, but believe I will now.
BJG, gets so easily lost in the weeds. And then she pretends not to know they insist on being called women not trans women.
Bri, People are, IN FACT, walking around insisting that they were born the Gender that they identify as.
IN FACT…. Bri, Trans Men and Trans Women can OFFICIALLY have their GENDER changed ON THEIR BIRTH CERTIFICATES!
I know this because I’ve seen it!
IN FACT, One of the problems faced by Women who change their “Born Gender” on their Birth Certificate’s, from Female to Male, here in America, will get a letter from the US Government saying they are required to sign up for Selective Service in our Military. I know this because, again, I’ve seen it!
But they can, IN FACT, get out of Selective Service when they submit documents to the Military that Proves they were actually, and IN FACT, born Female!
Knowing this I’m guessing that a Male who changes their Gender to Female BEFORE turning 18 years old can/could, IN FACT, get bypassed for Selective Service because their Altered Birth Certificate says they were Born female.
May god bless jk Rawling
Not "anti-trans", just pro science. Remember the covid era???
I'm all about truth and speaking clearly, non-euphemistically, and consistently across subjects. Why do some people find this so difficult?
Bri being willingly obtuse and refusing to see what is as plain as day, is exactly how I saw this argument going when I opened the video 😂
She is a career gaslighter. I dont know who has more clout here, Robbie or her, but good god if it is him, cant he just fire her?