How Did Urdu Become Pakistan's Official Language? | Was It A Conspiracy? | Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ต.ค. 2024
- Was Urdu imposed on the local communities in Pakistan?
What was Bengali-Urdu controversy?
Was it a conspiracy or an administrative decision?
Watch Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed with Raza Rumi on #NewPakistanStudies
#NayaDaur #Language
Urdu is Hindi only transcript is different promoted by British at Fort William College to create separation between Hindu & Muslims.
urdu was the de facto national language of india, hindi was promoted, before that hindus were well versed in urdu.
@@xenabidin8788 Can you tell me when was first ever Urdu Novel was written?
@@iqbalchinioti4084 urdites were not novelists, they were poets, these modern forms were introduced later under influence of english in both hindi and urdu, i would say masnavi's were poetic novels.
Hindi is Urdu except Arabic/Persian, not the vise versa!
Aap apni punjabi zaban beshak na bolen magar hum apni MT sindhi nahi bhoolsaktay
Ahmed ji you're quite right. Now in India almost 60-70 % people are comfortable with hindi atleast 40% people can write and read hindi. With time it will increase further. But we didn't kill local languages. The regional languages are still flourishing be it Punjabi, bengali Assamese, Tamil, telegu, kannada, Marathi, Gujrati.... India is a perfect example that you can still promote an unifying language with simultaneous promotions of other languages.
My PhD research, which will be published soon, has found the same.
Stop presenting Urdu as if it's a colonial language in Pakistan like we see in case of English in India or French in Mali or Portuguese in Angola. Urdu, Punjabi, hindko and Sindhi being Indo-aryan langauges are sister langauges characterised by mutually intelligibility and can be considered as dialects of each other just like Spanish and Portuguese are. Being indo-iranian language, it's also very very close to Pashto and other iranic languages like Persian and source of vocabulary of Urdu language is fundamentally Persian.
chal bhai bahut drama ho gaya ye baat sun sun kar ki urdu is the language of India lekin tumhe pata honi chahiye ki India mein agar kisi language ke saath sab se zyada bhed bhaao aur sautela vyavahar hua hai to wo Urdu ke saath hua hai, ab to india mein boycott urdu words ke trend bhi chalne lage hain, aur haldiram company aur urdu maamla ka to tumko achhe se pata hi hoga. Urdu ko kahi agar pyaar, izzat, sammaan and promotion mili hai to wo Pakistan mein hi mili hai. Urdu has been respected, loved and honored in Pakistan so much so that it became the national language Pakistan. So stop bullshiting by saying such things. Most of the Jews were also born and raised in Germany, but still they hate Germany and love Israel bcoz they got shelter in Israel, and in the same manner Urdu got shelter in Pakistan. I'm speaking this fact being an Indian patriotic muslim. If there is any language that is hated most in India, then ofcourse it's Urdu Language, watch this video reflecting anti-urdu sentiments across India.
th-cam.com/video/EvKqNppQjE4/w-d-xo.html
th-cam.com/video/bUws1L5NZmQ/w-d-xo.html and
th-cam.com/video/c4ZgXeHnMhY/w-d-xo.html
Jo log pakistanio ko kahte hain ki Urdu is the language of India, wo log bahut hypocrite hote hain, wo log Indian Muslims ke saamne Urdu bhasha ko gaali denge aur lekin pakistanio ko neecha dikhane keliye kahenge ki Urdu is the language of India. Hypocrisy ki bhi ek hadd ho hoti hai bhai.
Sir juban aur mazahb Alag alag hain. Hindu ne sanskrit ko Hinduism se joda aur ab sanskrit mar rahi hain. Musalmaan urdu ko Islam se joy rahe hain tab yeh bhi mar jayegi. Na Karen aisa dono
What a pity the language that brings fame and fortune for the people whose mother tongue is different than the language in which people get popularity in the entire subcontinent and even beyond does happen to be the most hated language this is nothing but the thankless approach and attitude of the people who thrive because of this lingua franca of the whole south west asia the Urdu language! Shame to the small hearted narrow minded people getting bread and butter by adopting Urdu through art culture cenima music and drama and mostly enjoy the art and culture in this language but do not appreciate and recognize the role of Urdu language in providing them entertainment and joy! Shame! Shame and shame!
After 70 years nether Punjabi, sidhi, pashtoon or Baloch can speak Urdu comfotably
Many urban Punjabis cannot speak Punjabi comfortably. As for all others, if any language other than Urdu is chosen as national language it will be even less comfortable option as a common language.
Great initiative we need to learn correct history and background
Jinnah was English speaking English should have been official language along with regional languages is sushi Punjabi pushto and Bengali specially education should have been in English and regional languages
Sir,before 1947,urdu was promoted as common people language by moghuls.urdu is a Turkish word meaning lashkar(an army contingent).
It was essentially hindi of Delhi-UP region with smattering of persian and Arabic words written in arabic script from right to left.
In 1947 Pakistan had only regional languages,and since Pakistan army/establishment believed themselves to be descendents of moghuls,urdu was adopted as the national language of Pakistan.
Primary Education should be in mother tongue
One should not forget that punjabi is more o less a boli without a script so making it official we will have to learn Urdu so we can write in punjabi. On the other hand Sindhi and pushtu have scripts and they could be used as an official language.
In Birtish govt sindhi was national & official language in sindh
I already know,,that’s why all that time leaders’s sent Quid Sahib to Ziyarat,cause Quid wants English National language,that’s why Quid mentioned in his 1st. Speech 7th August that English will be National language, but it was some important leaders wants Urdu as a National language.no I don’t agreed with speakers.
Please speak the truth. There is no difference between Urdu/Hindi.
Urdu zaban is very popular and easy good zaban
What is opinion about sindh Madarsul Islam in karachi established by Hassan Ali effendi
There are so many problems with Urdu that it won't survive - neither in India, nor in Pakistan or anywhere in the world. Other issues aside, its fundamental issue is that its head is in the past, and that too only in a specific 150 year period approximately between 1700s - 1850s. Such a language will be practically unworkable.
Hahahaha hahahaha hahahaha! You sick! You enjoy shakil badayoni,majhroh sultanpuri hasrat jaipuri mughl e Azam pakizah three idiots etc and yet say that Urdu is dying no sir Urdu is not dying rather you haters are dying!
First of all, standardise Punjabi, it's script Shahmukhi, technical glossary and then make it the national language. Then India can make Urdu as it's official language.
Salam alaikum,
-Nice idea
-But Potohari and Seraiki people won't accept standard Majhi Punjabi which is based around Lahori Punjabi.
-Instead we should think about Choosing a middle dialect for standardization.
-Jhang city's Punjabi will do the job as it is as closer to Seraiki and Northern dialects.
-Design more alphabets that represent more than one type of pronunciation just like Pushto did with the sound of 'Sha' and 'Kha' and introduced the letter ښ kheen/sheen
-For example: 'Ki karda hain.'
and 'Ki karNa hain.'
design a separate letter for the sound of na and da.
So as to preserve the individual beauty of all dialects and unify Punjabi speakers.
Talk about sindhi language
Why? What is the need to talk on a language which is spoken only by 20 Millon people as compare to Urdu which is the mother tongue of 260 millions people in the subcontinent spoken by 500 millon people and understood by 1000 millon people! You haters always keep jealous with Urdu hate has no cure! We have sympathy for you!
Raza what rift arise btvn jinnah & G M Syed?
an honest analyst
Good analysis
But other wing East Pakistan they mentioned Bengali.
Dr.Sahib is a brilliant scholar. One of few sane voices in our elite intelligencia
Always great to see Prof. Ishtiaq Ahmed!
Raza....gr8 guest....thanks
Very good discussion
Regional language should be the language of primary education. Dr. Ishtiaq Ahmed is wrong in promoting Urdu.
Assaalaamoalekum
Languages are national assets and should be protected and allowed to progress. Multi lingual countries like India, Canada, Belgium, Malaysia, Indonesia and Singapore, US (some states by Adoption of major immigrants languages) and many African countries have done a excellent. Pakistan like in all major issues have utter confusion.
India is Promoting only Hindi, other languages are not promoted by any means.
There is no confusion this is the hate against Urdu it is simple and straight! People enjoy Urdu bring fame and fortune due to Urdu can't communicate without Urdu yet have a biased hate and prejudice against the language!
Aap ki tehqiqat urdu main kahan sy dustiyat hain,Ishtiaq sb?
He is avoiding telling the truth..
I trust what DR.ISRAR Ahmed (SCHOLAR) has said.it was big mistake since 1946..
National language must have been ARABIC.Dr.ISRAR SAID..
MUST LISTEN HIS VIDEO
How became BANGLADESH..
EVERY PAKISTANI MUST LISTEN .IT IS MY REQUEST..
first you must learn english
Dr Israr Ahmad was a great and respected scholar but it is not necessary to agree with him on each and every issue he talked!
Dr. Ishtiaq is a great writer and describes history in a true sense.. respects
Persian was and is the only language that should have been made national language of Pakistan. By making Persian our national language we (Pakistan ) would become a part of central Asia culturally. Due to Urdu as a national language, Pakistan is still culturally a part of Indian sub-continent . so we are being influenced by Indian movies, their culture their language etc. Persian was/is a much developed language (than Urdu) then and now. We have great literature in Persian. It was the language on which Alama Iqbal , Mirza Ghalib and all Muslims of India were proud of.
A better thing would have been to implement Arabic as national language Farsi is a beautiful language but no benefit over arabic
He has not seen DR.ISRAR AHMED VIDEO.about URDU language .why East pakistan became saperate...it was big mistake ..please see dr.israr video..
Link?
Sorry he is not neutral person..