"I didn't go in the wrong way, I want the long way, made an illegal uturn into someones driveway, parked, backed up into oncomming traffic and this crazy woman flung her car door op". Glad the judge called her out on that nonsense instantly. Anyone willing to back up into traffic and make a uturn into someones private driveway wouldn't magically decide to obey the laws.
@rodrigomejia9096 I'm talking sane law and order states, not Communist ones like Californicate. Blue states don't care about citizens or victims. We in red states do, it's really pathetic, but you get what you voted for.
Cops usually won't show up for a minor collision like this. Your best bet is to start recording video immediately to hopefully catch the positions of the cars before they're moved and to catch the conversation. If the other driver admits fault at the scene it's not an automatic win, but it helps your case.
@kyoto32001 oh, but the defendant didn't lie, right? When she first explained the story at the board, she claimed someone was parked next to the plaintiff, so she waited for that car to leave. Then, supposedly began to enter the spot when they exited. In the hallway, she claimed she was there before the plaintiff. If that were true, wouldn't she have parked in the open spot?
I haven’t seen the decision yet, but something similar happened to me. I parked, no cars near me. I opened my door, a car started pulling in. Our cars met. The law said I was at fault. That oncoming traffic has the right of way, and before opening my door, I need to make sure the road is clear.
@@ddinottia39not in our state, the law says you can’t open your door if it interferes with oncoming traffic, that includes a parking spot. I tried fighting it, believe me. When I read the law in our state, there was nothing I could do about it 😞
Yes, she should use the child safety locks, but you guys are talking like you've never had a 5yo. I have had 3 5 year olds, 2 do as you say the third takes a lot of talk to🤦🏽. 5 year olds ain't for the weak.😂
Calling the police is an iffy thing. Depending on your area, most big cities won't send police to an accident unless there's injuries. They'll tell you to come to the district station and make a report. They generally won't deal with accidents on private property. Either way, even if they send a cruiser, you may die of old age before they show up. I've actually seen cruisers have an accident happen right in front of them, and they'll pull around them and go on down the road and pull into a restaurant to have breakfast or get coffee.
Yup. We were in Vegas and some lady literally drove over the front end of our rental car with her jacked up truck. Their PD doesn't come, you have to submit a report online.
If that plaintiff is so worried about her daughter jumping out as soon as she parks, she needs to activate her rear doors' child safety locks. Every car sold in the last 40 years has them.
Someone blew a red light and hit my husband. Took his front bumper off. She stopped and only had an ID no license. He called the cops but they said “unless you’re hurt we don’t need to be there”. The lady took off. She called saying it was his fault come to find out she got into another accident with someone else and got the two confused. Anyway, my point being, I understand what she means by “wait for the police” but they don’t always come, unfortunately.
I never let my kids open the car doors when they were little to avoid them hitting things with the door and walking out into the parking lot without proper supervision 🤓 That's just me though
When someone slams there car around and pushes it sideways and makes jerking movements in the simulation.... you automatically know there guilty.......
I LOVE it when the judge sits there and agrees with the defendant even after saying, "You know you went in the wrong way" and tries to be buddy buddy with her, she fell into the trap and basically said, "Yeah, but EVERYONE does it in LA. You can't really blame me" 🤷♀ Hook, line, and sinker🎣
We spent so much time talking about what the defendant did beforehand but it literally didn’t matter at all. She hit the door, regardless of which side she was approaching from.
This happened to me. I had my 4 yr old grandson in the car and attempted to turn into my parking space. Suddenly as I'm pulling in the car next to me opens her door. She calls the cops said I ran over her foot, called the ambulance made lots of threats of suing me. She was visiting my neighbor, had her to say I intentionally hit her door and her door was already opened. Several days later my insurance company called and said the legal department called my neighbor who claimed to witness me pull in knowing her friend door was open. The insurance agent said my neighbor ended confessing that she was told to lie by her friend. The friend told her she would give her some money. My neighbor told legal she felt guilty about lying because her friend said she purposefully opened her car door and actually was trying to get herself bumped so she could say her back got injured.
Had the almost EXACT thing happen to me. And then the defendant just keeps lying. "I was there before her" but never said that before. Trash people become trash elders.
I hate when the judge says wait for police - here in Toronto, Ontario, Canada, the police don't show up unless it's more than $5000 in damage and even then, they don't make it out.
🇺🇸❤️🙏🏽did the parking lot have cameras? 🇺🇸Citizens CALL THE POLICE. If possible get witness statements and or pics before words are even exchanged🇺🇸❤️🙏🏽
Honestly waiting for the police is not always an option, in my city the police are not required to show for an accident unless someone is hurt. You’re instructed to go to your nearest police station to file a report.
Defendant shows she is a terrible driver, she was lying in court and tried to lie her way out. Hopefully her driver's license has been pulled and she is no longer a danger to the public with a car.
Same thing happened to me last night with exception of driver going forward into parking space, she saw me opening my door and stopped. Accident avoided. 😊
I'm not sure about this state, but in a lot of states, police do not have any jurisdiction in parking lots because they are public property. My state won't even send the police to the accident unless someone is severely injured.
I dont agree. 1 thing i know is wherever i open my car door im already looking in my drivers side mirror. The plaintiff is just as reckless as her daughter to be swinging her door open.
I’m amused at how she holds her entire hand over the miniature care and kinda slides it around the board…something about her demonstration is untrustworthy
Very surprised that no one seemed to realize that all child safety seats should be replaced after all accidents. No matter how minor an accident seems, damage may not be visible. Experienced Bikers, especially motorcycle 🏍️ riders always put their helmet on the ground. Helmets that fall from waist height or more should be replaced immediately. Never ever compromise personal safety. I am happy the Mom replaced her daughter's car seat Hopefully she also took the opportunity to discuss why, with visual 👁️ and establish new child exit safety 🦺 protocols
I am kinda going to go against the majority here and say I’m not convinced the defendant is solely at fault. If the plaintiff opened her door as the defendant is pulling in then she should also be at fault. I know she said her door was already open but I doubt that.
1. Usually someone backing up is at fault. 2. Insurance always leads with a 50/50 fault letter. Perhaps many people accept that. But it pays to push back. The insurance companies try to settle as cheaply and as quickly as possible to close the case. Alway try to wait for the police ~ it might be a community service officer, though. And it might be a long wait, but it can save you from going to court. 3. Teach your young children to wait to get out the car with your supervison. You cannot be careful enough with young, impulsive children.
Wow!! I know what “sucker” judge I’m going to next time I’m in an accident!! lol!! (She never asks for verification or receipts on anything except when she feels like it I guess??) -smh!!!
Disagree with this judgement. The plaintiff was sitting in her car for an extended period of time.....and suddenly opened her door. She owed a responsibility to look in her mirror before she opened her door. At Minimum the verdict should have been 50/50 faut.
The plaintiff was lucky the judge doesn't live in Cali. I see claims like this all the time. If you are opening your door while someone is driving next to you whether its a street or parking lot you are at fault. The driver is not. If the driver sees you in the car the driver might be at fault 50/50 but its the driver's responsibility to safely open their door. The police won't show up unless there is injury soooo good luck with that. You're better off taking a video of the person saying they're at fault. Make sure it get show the person in the video for at least a sec. USAA denies claims if you dont have a picture of the other driver involved, even if you have a photo of their license. Could be fake😅
😮hope that Harvey means Calling the police when he says, get it in writing Anyone who feels they are not at fault should never leave the scene without a police report Many moons ago, i exchanged phone numbers with a college girl. And years later at a 1 horse town red light. I knew that i probably would Not be filing a claim. Neither person to person nor through insurance. She accidently tapped my rear bumper on a highway, not an interstate on-ramp. I had previously done the exact same thing, in my younger years. Except on the off ramp... get this, twice on the same ramp! This case is very different inasmuch as the defendant was Likely driving illegally. Remember, most accudents occur within a few shirt miles from home
I don't know, people should always check for a car or bicycle coming from behind before swinging their door open. More so when parked on the side of a tight road than this scenario.
Maybe I have watched too many of these cases but I have come to the point where I can tell as soon as the individuals enter the court which one is guilty 😅😅I can just look at them
the old auntie is a bit of a liar isnt she... no one goes through that much trouble. If there was a car parked next to the red car how the heck is she parked there... did i miss something?
Old lady is a terrible liar. Just pay the Plaintiff already!
She's messed up!
The minute the defendant shrugged her shoulders In The beginning , I knew she was going to be a issue 😂😂😂
child locks would stop the kid from just jumping out of the car
Or raising your kid with boundaries would work. Kids want to be good. It’s parents who are bad. I am a parent.
@@aprilpinketon2567I want to be bad. I am a child.
I was thinking the same thing…
5 across the lips!
I thought ,nowadays. cars came with child locks included
The lady was driving like it was GTA V 😂
Wow, that Defendant is 😵💫 and so lying!
0:28
"I didn't go in the wrong way, I want the long way, made an illegal uturn into someones driveway, parked, backed up into oncomming traffic and this crazy woman flung her car door op". Glad the judge called her out on that nonsense instantly. Anyone willing to back up into traffic and make a uturn into someones private driveway wouldn't magically decide to obey the laws.
@@Fribee83omg yes, she had such a story 🙈
Never take a person's word in an accident. Always wait for police.
The police will not show up in LA unless someone is injured.
@rodrigomejia9096 I'm talking sane law and order states, not Communist ones like Californicate. Blue states don't care about citizens or victims. We in red states do, it's really pathetic, but you get what you voted for.
@@rodrigomejia9096you can still call and make a report. Even though it is only hear say, it's better than nothing.
Cops usually won't show up for a minor collision like this. Your best bet is to start recording video immediately to hopefully catch the positions of the cars before they're moved and to catch the conversation. If the other driver admits fault at the scene it's not an automatic win, but it helps your case.
You mean just like what the judge said? Oh ok. 🙄
I was afraid the judge would fall again 😂😂😂😂
😂😂😂 that was HILARIOUS!!! Only the real ones know.
I’m that graceful, I felt that 😅
She needs an elevator to get to the bench. 😂
Its also crazy to see how tiny she is! I was as tall as her in middle school 😂
Hasn’t she fallen twice?
I loved when the judge says your so full of baloney 😂😂😂
💯💯💯💯💯 she's full of shit is what she should have said hahahaha
How do you hit a parked car while you are driving and still claim that it is not your fault?
NOT TRUE! watch the episode. plaintiff opened car door as defendant was pullying in. 50/50 fault
@kyoto32001 she's parked and her door was already opened.
@@ddinottia39 thats what she claims. i don't believe her. she spent way to much time on irrelevant lies about which entrance the defendant used.
The defendant didn’t use due care and pulled in to fast. That’s the straight skinny.
@kyoto32001 oh, but the defendant didn't lie, right? When she first explained the story at the board, she claimed someone was parked next to the plaintiff, so she waited for that car to leave. Then, supposedly began to enter the spot when they exited. In the hallway, she claimed she was there before the plaintiff. If that were true, wouldn't she have parked in the open spot?
What a load of houie from the defendant 😂
The defendant did not practice her story
😂
the defendant lied from the beginning...
so did plaintiff. it was her fault.
that lady handles parking lots like she's playing pinball.
It was funny lol...she was all over the board
The defendant looks like the type to drive into an exit and immediately crash into a parked car
I haven’t seen the decision yet, but something similar happened to me. I parked, no cars near me. I opened my door, a car started pulling in. Our cars met. The law said I was at fault. That oncoming traffic has the right of way, and before opening my door, I need to make sure the road is clear.
exactly what happened here. plaintiff is at fault.
No the other person pulling in. She has to watch when she pulling in to make sure the that the other car door isn't open.
@@ddinottia39not in our state, the law says you can’t open your door if it interferes with oncoming traffic, that includes a parking spot. I tried fighting it, believe me. When I read the law in our state, there was nothing I could do about it 😞
@@ddinottia39 plaintiff lied
@@ddinottia39But if someone abruptly opens their door in front of you, you may not be able to stop.
No way she busts a u to go into parking lot
if you are at fault just do the right thing and own up to it. it's called being a honest person ...
Excellent judgment 😊
If you tell your 5 year old to wait in your seat until I get you out that should be it or use your child safety locks if available.
They became mandatory in 1985.
Yes, she should use the child safety locks, but you guys are talking like you've never had a 5yo. I have had 3 5 year olds, 2 do as you say the third takes a lot of talk to🤦🏽. 5 year olds ain't for the weak.😂
@@wezzman1 you're just reinforcing the importance of using child locks
@@lukerinderknecht2982 exactly, I was responding to the original poster regarding a 5yo should sit when told😅
Is the 5 year old not supposed to be strapped into a seat tho?
Calling the police is an iffy thing. Depending on your area, most big cities won't send police to an accident unless there's injuries. They'll tell you to come to the district station and make a report. They generally won't deal with accidents on private property. Either way, even if they send a cruiser, you may die of old age before they show up. I've actually seen cruisers have an accident happen right in front of them, and they'll pull around them and go on down the road and pull into a restaurant to have breakfast or get coffee.
Yup. We were in Vegas and some lady literally drove over the front end of our rental car with her jacked up truck. Their PD doesn't come, you have to submit a report online.
If that plaintiff is so worried about her daughter jumping out as soon as she parks, she needs to activate her rear doors' child safety locks. Every car sold in the last 40 years has them.
Defendant is 🤥🤥👖on🔥
Love it! In modern times we express liar liar…..thru emojis! Love it! Sometimes I feel emojis express more exactly- and comically
The judge keeps saying a “5” year old. The plaintiff clearly said she was 6. It’s a little thing, but it’s all in the details.
Someone blew a red light and hit my husband. Took his front bumper off. She stopped and only had an ID no license. He called the cops but they said “unless you’re hurt we don’t need to be there”. The lady took off. She called saying it was his fault come to find out she got into another accident with someone else and got the two confused. Anyway, my point being, I understand what she means by “wait for the police” but they don’t always come, unfortunately.
If Kurt asked me what I said to my daughter, I'd say 'none of your gd business' 🤣🤣
Milian picks and chooses who she gives lost wages to. People are always suing for lost wages and she never gives it to them….until now 🙄
Exactly and you have to be white in order to get that type treatment from JM, she is full of it !
If the old lady was there before she was she wouldn’t have been waiting for a spot she would have had hers. She’s a bad liar
I never let my kids open the car doors when they were little to avoid them hitting things with the door and walking out into the parking lot without proper supervision 🤓 That's just me though
Over 65 you should have to retake your vision and road test!!! Too many elderly people driving when they can't even see.
Both are very frazzled.
I’m glad Judge didn’t fall coming from the throne area this time 👍🏿❤️
Surprised the judge awarded lost wages because she usually gives people a hard time on that... plaintiff must have had proof of income...
I must of missed that?? I didn’t see or hear JM ask for anything? But maybe she already read the report??
Liar liar pants on fire oh my the defendant is ludicrous lol
Defendant, pay the lady!
Defendant knew how to sucking up to avoid the police.
When someone slams there car around and pushes it sideways and makes jerking movements in the simulation.... you automatically know there guilty.......
7 minutes in already know the defendant is a bold face liar
Why do they act like 6:15 is a barren wasteland? There are lots of people up that early.
Thought it was a review for in and out burgers 🍔
I LOVE it when the judge sits there and agrees with the defendant even after saying, "You know you went in the wrong way" and tries to be buddy buddy with her, she fell into the trap and basically said, "Yeah, but EVERYONE does it in LA. You can't really blame me" 🤷♀ Hook, line, and sinker🎣
We spent so much time talking about what the defendant did beforehand but it literally didn’t matter at all. She hit the door, regardless of which side she was approaching from.
I wonder what Archie thinks about Edith getting into the car accident. 🤔
I'm dead
2:52 who else became anxious here? 😂
I've never driven but I do know that the OLD LADY is nuts.
You can't trust anybody that holds their head at such a strange angle all the time.
Why? Why? Why? 🎶
This happened to me. I had my 4 yr old grandson in the car and attempted to turn into my parking space. Suddenly as I'm pulling in the car next to me opens her door. She calls the cops said I ran over her foot, called the ambulance made lots of threats of suing me. She was visiting my neighbor, had her to say I intentionally hit her door and her door was already opened. Several days later my insurance company called and said the legal department called my neighbor who claimed to witness me pull in knowing her friend door was open. The insurance agent said my neighbor ended confessing that she was told to lie by her friend. The friend told her she would give her some money. My neighbor told legal she felt guilty about lying because her friend said she purposefully opened her car door and actually was trying to get herself bumped so she could say her back got injured.
I need a “Poke the Bear” Comp of Audacious Plaintiffs who if they hadn’t sued the Defendant the Defendant would’ve asked for their owed money.
Doug is so smooth his skin omg 😊
Yes even if the children aren’t in the car it has to be replaced
I didn't know that.
Had the almost EXACT thing happen to me. And then the defendant just keeps lying. "I was there before her" but never said that before. Trash people become trash elders.
I hate when the judge says wait for police - here in Toronto, Ontario, Canada, the police don't show up unless it's more than $5000 in damage and even then, they don't make it out.
why was lost wages allowed here?
Oh geez, that sounds as the defendant moves the car around so much 😵💫
🇺🇸❤️🙏🏽did the parking lot have cameras? 🇺🇸Citizens CALL THE POLICE. If possible get witness statements and or pics before words are even exchanged🇺🇸❤️🙏🏽
I would have awarded more than $1,222.64 to the plaintiff, at least 2k... The defendant should pay a fee for being a stoopid driver.
Honestly waiting for the police is not always an option, in my city the police are not required to show for an accident unless someone is hurt. You’re instructed to go to your nearest police station to file a report.
Defendant shows she is a terrible driver, she was lying in court and tried to lie her way out. Hopefully her driver's license has been pulled and she is no longer a danger to the public with a car.
The defendant didn't practice her lie
Not the old lady saying she was there first!
If defendant was going into the parking frontward, she would have been able to avoid this catastrophe 😂
Not necessarily. If the door suddenly swings open you may not be able to avoid it.
Same thing happened to me last night with exception of driver going forward into parking space, she saw me opening my door and stopped. Accident avoided. 😊
THE DEFENDANT STORY MAKES NO SENSE AT ALL😮 SHE KNOWS SHE HIT THE PLANTIFF CAR DOOR !!!😮
Deffendant is a liar
Ol school will lie their asses off😂😂😂
The plaintiff doesn't have all 12 months on her calendar
I'm not sure about this state, but in a lot of states, police do not have any jurisdiction in parking lots because they are public property. My state won't even send the police to the accident unless someone is severely injured.
I dont agree. 1 thing i know is wherever i open my car door im already looking in my drivers side mirror. The plaintiff is just as reckless as her daughter to be swinging her door open.
I need the name of the plaintiff's hair stylist.
Police won’t come if there’s no injury.
Wait she didn't have to prove loss wages?
defendant was wrong.. why waste all this time.
I’m amused at how she holds her entire hand over the miniature care and kinda slides it around the board…something about her demonstration is untrustworthy
She went home and her husband told her to lie
Very surprised that no one seemed to realize that all child safety seats should be replaced after all accidents. No matter how minor an accident seems, damage may not be visible.
Experienced Bikers, especially motorcycle 🏍️ riders always put their helmet on the ground. Helmets that fall from waist height or more should be replaced immediately.
Never ever compromise personal safety. I am happy the Mom replaced her daughter's car seat
Hopefully she also took the opportunity to discuss why, with visual 👁️ and establish new child exit safety 🦺 protocols
The defendant doesnt have 12 months on her calendar
That defendant just spoke crap.
I am kinda going to go against the majority here and say I’m not convinced the defendant is solely at fault. If the plaintiff opened her door as the defendant is pulling in then she should also be at fault. I know she said her door was already open but I doubt that.
1. Usually someone backing up is at fault. 2. Insurance always leads with a 50/50 fault letter. Perhaps many people accept that. But it pays to push back. The insurance companies try to settle as cheaply and as quickly as possible to close the case. Alway try to wait for the police ~ it might be a community service officer, though. And it might be a long wait, but it can save you from going to court. 3. Teach your young children to wait to get out the car with your supervison. You cannot be careful enough with young, impulsive children.
Why do Americans need to call the cops for minor collisions? That is just wasting Police time.
To make a report and for proof.
In private business parking lot police won’t come unless there is a injury
This old lady is a liar!!!😂
Wow!! I know what “sucker” judge I’m going to next time I’m in an accident!! lol!! (She never asks for verification or receipts on anything except when she feels like it I guess??) -smh!!!
Disagree with this judgement. The plaintiff was sitting in her car for an extended period of time.....and suddenly opened her door. She owed a responsibility to look in her mirror before she opened her door. At Minimum the verdict should have been 50/50 faut.
She tried it.
The plaintiff was lucky the judge doesn't live in Cali. I see claims like this all the time. If you are opening your door while someone is driving next to you whether its a street or parking lot you are at fault. The driver is not. If the driver sees you in the car the driver might be at fault 50/50 but its the driver's responsibility to safely open their door.
The police won't show up unless there is injury soooo good luck with that. You're better off taking a video of the person saying they're at fault. Make sure it get show the person in the video for at least a sec. USAA denies claims if you dont have a picture of the other driver involved, even if you have a photo of their license. Could be fake😅
😮hope that Harvey means Calling the police when he says, get it in writing
Anyone who feels they are not at fault should never leave the scene without a police report
Many moons ago, i exchanged phone numbers with a college girl. And years later at a 1 horse town red light. I knew that i probably would Not be filing a claim. Neither person to person nor through insurance.
She accidently tapped my rear bumper on a highway, not an interstate on-ramp.
I had previously done the exact same thing, in my younger years. Except on the off ramp... get this, twice on the same ramp!
This case is very different inasmuch as the defendant was Likely driving illegally.
Remember, most accudents occur within a few shirt miles from home
plaintiff was partly at fault. she opened door as defendant backed in. 50/50 fault. also, which entrance lady came in was NOT RELEVANT!!!! WHO CARES!
It's the doctrine of unclean hands. The defendant entered illegally. It 100% matters.
I agree. Why open your door when someone is pulling in next to you, though the defendant is a horrible driver.
@@adriafulton9149 NO! even the judge said it was irrelevant
@@adriafulton9149 no, where she drove in has nothing to do with the actual collision.
The defendant was less than honest I believe
In Australia, the person opening the car door is always responsible. What if the defendant was a cyclist?
I like the name Delilah reminds me of the song
I don't know, people should always check for a car or bicycle coming from behind before swinging their door open. More so when parked on the side of a tight road than this scenario.
Maybe I have watched too many of these cases but I have come to the point where I can tell as soon as the individuals enter the court which one is guilty 😅😅I can just look at them
This is really cut and dry. Lady Is parked. Period. Next.
??????? WHAT?
the old auntie is a bit of a liar isnt she... no one goes through that much trouble. If there was a car parked next to the red car how the heck is she parked there... did i miss something?
Yes, you missed that the car left so she took the now empty spot
the plaintiff is a drama queen
liar liar 👖 on 🔥
I'm goin to court on national tv.TV.. best frizz out my hair and get my jellys out
Why is it some people come to court and they look like they got a broken neck
Oh just pay your own, each liable
Is that judge Judy’s sister?😮
Thats California 😂😂