Wonderful...At last an interpretation full of emotions....Personally,I also love Szokolay's interpretation,but I can't find it anywhere on youtube...As far as the mistakes are concerned, they were minor and it is unfair to condemn the whole effort just because of them.The point is...he gave us 5 minutes of sheer pleasure...
Who really cares if Zimmerman's is better, this is a great interpretation and well played in my opinion. Anyone commenting on a couple mistakes is obviously not a pianist of any sort.
Far Easterns are far the best in classical music today. I was talking my Mom. He thought Far Eastern musicians are like very precize, but somewhat missing at soul. I said no, you're wrong!! They're very precize and and their attitude towards the music is very pure in soul. Asian classical musicians own today!!!
the piece has very distinctive contrast- the first section should sounds very delicate and light and it is the middle section thats got to be loud. the first sections seems to be very loud all the way through- it starts with p and goes up to f at the first repeat but I dont think he made enough contrast, and when the music goes to minor (before middle section) it's meant to be pp but sounds like f or ff. Also triplet in the middle seems way to fast and no rubato at all?
@jazzyjimg The pedal can also be used to affect tone. Raising the damper ever slightly can change the tone of a note as the other strings vibrate along with it. No? So here we have two examples of how a player can affect tone, and yet you say tone has "nothing" to do with the player. "Little to do with the player" would be a more accurate assumption.
Me parecen bastante correctas la velocidad y la fuerza,no creo que este tan rapida como alguien comenta.En cuanto al ligero error de la segunda parte no pienso que afecte demasiado la buena interpretacion de la pieza,a veces ocurre una minima distraccion,el pianista afortunadamente se recupera de manera favorable.De cualquier modo la toca excelente.Felicitaciones.
Me too, I prefer Zimerman's interpretation : more legato, more tasting because slower, and at 1:25 I don't understand why does he "rubato" every right hand arpeggios. Interesting yet.
Although very good, Zimmerman is much better. The first section should be very gentle and smooth, Zimmerman achieves this better than i could even imagine possible. Check him out mann!
Yes it is unfortunate that some people only listen for mistakes and other things they do not like about the interpretation. Hard to enjoy it if you are attempting to critically analyze the piece.
임동민 이곡에 대한 해석은 진짜 인정할만함!! 강약조절이나 감정표현이 딱 적당하고 깔끔한 느낌
너무 좋아서 눈물나요ㅠㅠ 최고다 최고
Really beautiful, love his tone.
A truly passionate piece of music. Those professional pianists must be overwhelmed when they play this music.
Wonderful playing!!
i love this piece!!!
this is beyond beautiful :D
Wonderful performance, very inspiring. Nice video angles too!
200번 넘게 듣는 듯.... 넘 잘친다....🍀
Beautiful sound!
aside from the 'small' mistakes, I really love his interpretation; I personally enjoyed it much more than Zimmerman's
stupenda...davvero bella...non vedo l ora di studiarla...la suona un mio amico...che invidiaa
you play this song beautifully!!
오늘 공연 보고 왔어요. 소리 진심 예술! 미스터치 있었지만 아니 많았지만 소리만큼은 그런 터치 누가 따라올까요?
초딩들도 이곡 미스터치안함
He is a good pianst♪I love his piano.
역시!!!!!!!!!!!!기립물개박수!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Wonderful...At last an interpretation full of emotions....Personally,I also love Szokolay's interpretation,but I can't find it anywhere on youtube...As far as the mistakes are concerned, they were minor and it is unfair to condemn the whole effort just because of them.The point is...he gave us 5 minutes of sheer pleasure...
Who really cares if Zimmerman's is better, this is a great interpretation and well played in my opinion. Anyone commenting on a couple mistakes is obviously not a pianist of any sort.
슈베르트는 이렇게 쳐야한다는 걸 알려주는 듯…제가 생각하는 교과서적인 연주 입니다 ㅎ 역시 대단한 음악성 이세요.
Love the part at 1:25. Great melody line. Play for us in Australia!
Far Easterns are far the best in classical music today. I was talking my Mom. He thought Far Eastern musicians are like very precize, but somewhat missing at soul. I said no, you're wrong!! They're very precize and and their attitude towards the music is very pure in soul. Asian classical musicians own today!!!
wow
2020 anyone?
ME, TOO
@행복 행복님께서 영어 쓰셨길래요 ㅎ
2021 here
I’m 2024 😊😊😊
Who else looked up this song and steinway concert grand at the same time?
EXACTLY!
0:56 너무 멋있어요!!!! 카뤼쓰마🤓
i agree imterpretation here is really nice!
우왕
I agree
곡해석력쩐다
the piece has very distinctive contrast- the first section should sounds very delicate and light and it is the middle section thats got to be loud. the first sections seems to be very loud all the way through- it starts with p and goes up to f at the first repeat but I dont think he made enough contrast, and when the music goes to minor (before middle section) it's meant to be pp but sounds like f or ff. Also triplet in the middle seems way to fast and no rubato at all?
@jazzyjimg
The pedal can also be used to affect tone. Raising the damper ever slightly can change the tone of a note as the other strings vibrate along with it. No?
So here we have two examples of how a player can affect tone, and yet you say tone has "nothing" to do with the player. "Little to do with the player" would be a more accurate assumption.
kann es sein, dass er sich einige male verspielt hat, oder ist das einfach nur die notation?
@jazzyjimg
You are thinking about a harpsichord.
Me parecen bastante correctas la velocidad y la fuerza,no creo que este tan rapida como alguien comenta.En cuanto al ligero error de la segunda parte no pienso que afecte demasiado la buena interpretacion de la pieza,a veces ocurre una minima distraccion,el pianista afortunadamente se recupera de manera favorable.De cualquier modo la toca excelente.Felicitaciones.
it is his performance, his interpretation. his 'style'. Just like everyone who has her/his own interpretation on every pieces. just saying.
1:26
For this particular piece, I think Peraiha has the edge over the others. Look it up o TH-cam.
agreed, much better.
마음 정화
Me too, I prefer Zimerman's interpretation : more legato, more tasting because slower, and at 1:25 I don't understand why does he "rubato" every right hand arpeggios. Interesting yet.
Although very good, Zimmerman is much better. The first section should be very gentle and smooth, Zimmerman achieves this better than i could even imagine possible. Check him out mann!
Yes it is unfortunate that some people only listen for mistakes and other things they do not like about the interpretation. Hard to enjoy it if you are attempting to critically analyze the piece.
옥구슬이 흘러가는 듯
too loud at some parts
made mistakes but covered them smoothly...nice...
but uh mistakes?!
Jenny Liu cute :)
he need more passion in the forte but also in the piano.
?
his sound is not refined enough, too exact. does not have much imagination.
zimerman, peskanov sucks at all.
I care about the mistakes!!! it wasn't very well!!! I am better xD. Just 14old
yes, he is not as good as Zimerman. But still fantastic !!
mistake 2:15
🙄🙄
zimerman is much better ;) ^^