The fact that his mother is defending him and trying to speak on his behalf is so infuriating. He is not an adolescent, juvenile and underage child he’s a consenting adult whose fiancée was murdered . He’s man enough to cover up the truth let him speak for himself.
betty boop ...big words coming the magnificent moron with the 1930s cartoon flapper icon and the ever so mature words of "fuck you"??? you must be brilliant ma'am.
Unfortunately they don't have the luxury of convicting, trying and possibly ruining someone's entire life based on watching a TH-cam video, parroting back what someone else just said and sending them to jail for life. That is why they are doing that job and you are doing whatever you do. As it so happens, I agree that he was involved. I don't think he had help though. However I have done more than just look at youtube video's and still wouldn't be able to speak with your conviction, even though I have three sources of evidence pointing towards the same conclusion. You know, some parents have shown to be very deceptive in infant deaths, they would seem to be guilty, and can hardly answer a question if they were the cause of the death. To the public it seems they are killers and people have spoken like you and demanded death for them. However proper statement analysis reveals they are actually innocent, nothing they could have done. However they were on drugs, drunk or something else that would make them laid with guilt. Other cases is when someone is having an affair, and they seem the same, reluctant to co-operate etc. Turns out they are cheating, not murderers. Again, this is why you need training to make such harsh claims. By all means have an opinion, and say what you think. However saying as you do about the police is not being honest. I would put on a bet almost all detectives that have spoken to him, including the 911 operative who is trained to spot "Alibi building and guilty caller status" all think the same thing. Its not however conclusive enough proof to take someone's life, deprive a mother of a son or a father of a son. Even the guilty must be tried fairly.
Yeah her bf def did it , how sad. 911 calls are very telling . Anyone who's calling for help , doesn't explain things away that's always a sign of guilt. You would just get the help you need
Jessica Flach Yep, usually that's a bright red flag... doesn't help that he was saying he knew her purse was there and then says he hasn't gotten there yet, was on his way though.
You get paid for your job, right? That money has to come from somewhere. Tests, labs, man hours... all with a cost. Idk if you're American or not, but think of the hospital. Ultrasound, $1400. MRI, $3-3500. CT, $5-5500.
@@elizabethmarshall523 The police should be doing the investigation. The money comes from taxes. It’s that huge chunk that’s missing out of our paychecks every week.
@@earthlunatics9145 The assistance of the PI, paid by a wealthy and generous donor, helped the police. He was arrested 4 days ago for her murder. Bail was set at 1 Million Dollars.
I would love if you made show about Chelsea Johnson of Fairfield, OH. She was stabbed to death/left in a creek across the street from where Katelyn went missing. It’s been 6 years & it’s still an unsolved case.
UPDATE: As of 2017 the police have said they have a person of interest, but are not naming the person; & the 100,000.00 reward still stands. Why is a grown man bringing his mom to an interview with a pi, its not even a real police officer interview? That seems odd to me, & the fact that his mom brought up a point her own son didnt; which was a valid point. But still, he seems like a mommys boy; or mom knows or has a hunch of what happened & wants to protect her son! I personally think the boyfriend did it, weather accidental or on purpose idk; & im not 100% sure that it was him. But he seems the most likely, out of everything from this episode & the 1st one.
this sounds a little bit similar to the Skylar Neese case: John Carter is clearly gay, is in a straight relationship, wants out, and instead of ending the relationship with his fiancé kills her instead.
Obviously her boyfriend killed her. What I don't understand is how they weren't able to charge him. I have seen so many of these types of shows where the spouse has been charged for the crime with much less evidence.
You know he did it. He doesn't remember the order he did stuff. That's why the have phone records. I'm disgusted that slot of these men just kill these women because they can't get their way and let their anger go so far as to kill the one they claim to love . Then discard her body and try to cover it with outrageous, disproven lies. Then get away with it.
And also, how did he know that her purse and keys were still at home (locked inside her bedroom!!) before he even got there to check, as so he claimed??
The mommy dearest knows exactly what her son did. I’m not just saying this but if my son or brother father killed someone I couldn’t be around them and would never stand by them. Knowing the facts would even focus me more to tell my son to come with me to the police and confess.
I just have to say, I don’t like how the Fairfield Police Chief said that they and any other agencies did what was required. You can do what is required, but not actually be doing anything else to get the job done. You’re required to go to school as a child. You are supposed to try hard to pay attention and do class work, but it isn’t required. That statement says we did everything we are obligated to do in an investigation, but we didn’t really dig deep and try to solve this case.
I'm all for the bad guy getting caught but emphasizing that this info is ONLY available to Crime Watch Daily makes me question their motives and/or the competency of the police; either way, it is not good. I think they should be reporting on cases, not actively investigating for profit.
Well turns out they and the whole community of Fairfield in Cincinnati were right! It took way too long for an arrest to be made! Wrong friend right suspect
The statement analysis was very telling. I don't know why the investigators wouldn't bring him in for questioning and confront him with some of his many slip ups. This guy is too stupid to be able to talk his way around the ridiculous things he's said. I reckon they'd break him into a sniveling confession pretty damn quick.
He just said all her belongings are there, and he’s heading out there. How would he know her belongings were there if he’s heading out there? Common sense.
It's frustrating when evidence points to someone pretty clearly, but the police somehow don't see why they should've investigated just a teeny bit more on the guy. It's crazy to say they did as much as possible, how can you say that when you didn't actually do all you could, such as search the car? That's kind of a standard thing... Just admit you could've and should've done more and apologize for overlooking potential evidence. Own up to your mistakes and try to right the wrong in any way. It looks so much better than trying to say the officers did everything possible while investigating the #1 guy. It's painfully obvious due diligence was not completely done.
I'm sorry if this seems judgmental but that dude seems like he closeted gay, and those guys often give me a bad vibe in situations like these.. I feel like a lot of them would go through great lengths to keep their true selves hidden, and I think that in a lot of these situations, the significant other finds out and threatens to out them.
Ok, so why is the boyfriend not cuffed and hauled to jail for capital murder....they have all the evidence to convict these 2 but yet havent 🤦♀️. There’s a lot of killers roaming free in the US because of this unequal justice system where people can get away with murder if they have the money to pay for it 😞
Okay...this is gonna seem silly but bear with me! If you’re into cars, specifically the JDM variety, that car is gold. They are so hard to find without having major damage, and people pay well over value for them. So I’m not buying that he sold it out of the blue!
Wait... So, the 911 call didn't register in his phone record? Does that mean he was using a burner cell phone and not his real cell phone? What number did the police get the call from?
While I do agree that the bf is usually a viable suspect... I don't find it to be that obvious here. The fact that there are numerous things missing from the call log, even the 911 call, makes that log completely unreliable (also, how does that even happen?) as a piece of evidence. And all the questions the PI had could simply be answered with "he was her boyfriend, he had a key to her apartment, he drove by earlier in search of her". The only thing I find very obviously suspicious is the place where she was found.
He phoned from his friends phone and never told the cops, that way they haven't subpoenaed friends call records so it looks like his phone.. Just my 2c worth.
He thought he was clever. But he learns he slipped up very badly now that one more cleverer than he comes a knocking. I'm beginning to talk like Andrea Isom.
why would his friend sell his vehicle so fast right after they find her body and why right near his family property come on police how could yall let this slip through the cracks arrest him and his friend for being involved they guilty...His mom is pathetic cause that girl was a person and a had a thriving life as well as her son... clues are buried where they found her remains dig deeper police... Rest in peace young girl so sad and tragic..
The 911 call wasn't on the phone records? Did anyone check to see if it was on his friend Matt's record? After all, the blood was found in his car wasn't it?
Both him and his friend did it, its clear he had to call his friend to get him to help build himself up to make the call to her dad they had to rehearse the story he gives.!!! You can tell 1000 percent he did it..!!!!
Well his mom actually brought up a good point,the 911 call also didn't show on phone records. And as much as I think he is guilty that factor puts the rest of the records into question. Phone records is not an exact science mistakes happen all the time,in court it's about evidence no matter how much we think he is guilty and to me there is no choice but to question the records
He sounds guilty , and in the sound ..it would be important to say if he is secretl bisexual, or that his upcoming marriage was only one of convenience ,...
Katelyn deserved better than this OBVIOUSLY shotty police work. I'm in awe of this police department, how on Earth can they claim to have done "everything modern officers can" That's bullshit. I feel so bad for her family. This man is not only a liar, but a bad liar & a killer!! Charge his mother too. Conspiracy after the fact. The friend, Matt, OBVIOUSLY assisted.
Maybe John and his Friend were hiding something ' Maybe they were Gay. She could have walked in on John and his Friend having an Affair and They killed her so that no one would find out .
I think the murder of young girls is disgusting.that John has been bullying her it happens all the time thay want control of them all the time .that's why you should have a son who has hands and can deal whith people like John the bully .I mean that girl at the end of the day was a nice young kid and had her life in front of her.RIP young girl God bless family
Honestly, if my girlfriend disappeared after a carnival ended, I'd probably mention the carnies. They also travel state to state. I would bet big money that some of the carnies from my local annual church carnival have probably killed or abducted someone at some point in their life. They're all criminals, they don't have to take background checks and they never stay in one place long.
The fact that his mother is defending him and trying to speak on his behalf is so infuriating. He is not an adolescent, juvenile and underage child he’s a consenting adult whose fiancée was murdered . He’s man enough to cover up the truth let him speak for himself.
How freaky would it be having some PI turn up and ask to search for blood in a car you recently purchased. It's like driving around with a ghost.
He needs mommy to respond for him on the interview ? Come on I hate that kind of men
He is so NOT a man.
betty boop ...big words coming the magnificent moron with the 1930s cartoon flapper icon and the ever so mature words of "fuck you"??? you must be brilliant ma'am.
Thank you I was thinking that same thought
@@jamesbentonticer4706 why you so pressed
Wait. So after this interrogation, they still did not grill him further and arrest him? Wth!
Irrelevant Underdog if he was black it will be another thing !
he did it.
HE DID IT...... LIAR, his friend Helped him dispose of her body!!!!!!! Absolutely RIDICULOUS that the Freaking COPS Didn't solve this ASAFP
Unfortunately they don't have the luxury of convicting, trying and possibly ruining someone's entire life based on watching a TH-cam video, parroting back what someone else just said and sending them to jail for life. That is why they are doing that job and you are doing whatever you do. As it so happens, I agree that he was involved. I don't think he had help though. However I have done more than just look at youtube video's and still wouldn't be able to speak with your conviction, even though I have three sources of evidence pointing towards the same conclusion. You know, some parents have shown to be very deceptive in infant deaths, they would seem to be guilty, and can hardly answer a question if they were the cause of the death. To the public it seems they are killers and people have spoken like you and demanded death for them. However proper statement analysis reveals they are actually innocent, nothing they could have done. However they were on drugs, drunk or something else that would make them laid with guilt. Other cases is when someone is having an affair, and they seem the same, reluctant to co-operate etc. Turns out they are cheating, not murderers. Again, this is why you need training to make such harsh claims. By all means have an opinion, and say what you think. However saying as you do about the police is not being honest. I would put on a bet almost all detectives that have spoken to him, including the 911 operative who is trained to spot "Alibi building and guilty caller status" all think the same thing. Its not however conclusive enough proof to take someone's life, deprive a mother of a son or a father of a son. Even the guilty must be tried fairly.
This is the same PD that hasn’t solved another murder of my 15 year old friend, 6 years ago. Her name is Chelsea Johnson of Fairfield, Ohio.
I'm so sorry for your loss, Angel! I hope they get justice for your friend!!!
I think he used friends car
Cops are useless
John Carter killed Katelyn with the help of his friend
Yeah her bf def did it , how sad. 911 calls are very telling . Anyone who's calling for help , doesn't explain things away that's always a sign of guilt. You would just get the help you need
Jessica Flach Yep, usually that's a bright red flag... doesn't help that he was saying he knew her purse was there and then says he hasn't gotten there yet, was on his way though.
Am I the only one who googles these cases after watching go see if there has been an update??
I do!
Google it now. There are some huge updates!
So it takes annonomuys donors to get people to investigate murder Okay Gotcha
You get paid for your job, right? That money has to come from somewhere. Tests, labs, man hours... all with a cost. Idk if you're American or not, but think of the hospital. Ultrasound, $1400. MRI, $3-3500. CT, $5-5500.
@@elizabethmarshall523 The police should be doing the investigation. The money comes from taxes. It’s that huge chunk that’s missing out of our paychecks every week.
@@earthlunatics9145 The assistance of the PI, paid by a wealthy and generous donor, helped the police. He was arrested 4 days ago for her murder. Bail was set at 1 Million Dollars.
Big, insecure chump of a boyfriend does away with his much more attractive girlfriend. Sadly, this story is as old as time itself.
Adam did not kill Eve!
@@jenisbetzke6228 what makes you think that?
He knew her purse was left behind before he ever arrived to her house or went in.
How Psychic
That 911 call is super SUS! No doubt, that The BF did it
John says
"Her CAR is there (apartment)
& her PURSE too"..
THEN
John goes to her apartment...
!!!!!!!LOL!!!!!!
Does anyone realise that John Carter is gay ?
Super gay, make no mistake about it.
Omg the first pic of him I could SEE that.
Willy Wonka I was just about to say that. 😹
Definitely gay.
Definitely a bottom too
I thought the father said her bedroom door was locked, how did the boyfriend know her purse was still there?!
Colleen Terry
THE POLICE ARE TOO SLOW WITTED TO FIGURE THAT OUT!!
I would love if you made show about Chelsea Johnson of Fairfield, OH. She was stabbed to death/left in a creek across the street from where Katelyn went missing. It’s been 6 years & it’s still an unsolved case.
I wonder if the 2 cases are related, sounds like they are.
There was also a boy shot in the same creek and a girl in the 80's missing from Fairfield lanes I don't believe any are solved
Why tf is he not in jail? Jesus!
It broke my heart when her friend was crying and was explaining jow she hadn't had many close friends and how her disappearance has affected her.
John's mother is infuriating. She was defending her son like he was an adolescent child, he is a grown ass man who could talk and defend himself
knew this guy in high school . definitely not normal
does his family have money? i cant believe he hasnt been arrested .
Tina Fisher They only get one chance at a conviction. They have to make sure they have enough evidence or he walks.
I'm from this area too - I was terrified when "serial killer" talk started up!
Jessie Mcknight 😢😢
Jessie Mcknight how do you mean ?
The name John Carter sounds like a killer
UPDATE: As of 2017 the police have said they have a person of interest, but are not naming the person; & the 100,000.00 reward still stands.
Why is a grown man bringing his mom to an interview with a pi, its not even a real police officer interview? That seems odd to me, & the fact that his mom brought up a point her own son didnt; which was a valid point. But still, he seems like a mommys boy; or mom knows or has a hunch of what happened & wants to protect her son! I personally think the boyfriend did it, weather accidental or on purpose idk; & im not 100% sure that it was him. But he seems the most likely, out of everything from this episode & the 1st one.
911 calls aren’t ever on phone bills in case of domestic violence situations
Awwwwww, so sweet mom is playing with her luxurious hair in an important interview. Smdh.
this sounds a little bit similar to the Skylar Neese case: John Carter is clearly gay, is in a straight relationship, wants out, and instead of ending the relationship with his fiancé kills her instead.
judging from your own experience, huh?
Obviously her boyfriend killed her. What I don't understand is how they weren't able to charge him. I have seen so many of these types of shows where the spouse has been charged for the crime with much less evidence.
This show teaches me how to lie cops.
How much more pathetic can the cops get?
CECI CEO what do you mean
They can't , they've reached their limit.
There are 4 unsolved murders dating back to the 80's in that city and its a pretty small city really IMO incompetent
I can’t believe that almost a decade later, Katelyn and her loved ones still haven’t received justice! 💔
You know he did it. He doesn't remember the order he did stuff. That's why the have phone records. I'm disgusted that slot of these men just kill these women because they can't get their way and let their anger go so far as to kill the one they claim to love . Then discard her body and try to cover it with outrageous, disproven lies. Then get away with it.
I’m gonna guess Katelyn was gonna call off the engagement and leave John and it’s could have been the old. “If I can’t have you then nobody will”
And also, how did he know that her purse and keys were still at home (locked inside her bedroom!!) before he even got there to check, as so he claimed??
The mommy dearest knows exactly what her son did. I’m not just saying this but if my son or brother father killed someone I couldn’t be around them and would never stand by them. Knowing the facts would even focus me more to tell my son to come with me to the police and confess.
Do you have children ? I'd bet you don't.
No one gonna talk about how he walked in at 8:10 talking on a DSI and put it in his pocket like it's nothing 😂
What’s up with these dudes killing women???
The boyfriend just got exposed in that interview
I just have to say, I don’t like how the Fairfield Police Chief said that they and any other agencies did what was required. You can do what is required, but not actually be doing anything else to get the job done. You’re required to go to school as a child. You are supposed to try hard to pay attention and do class work, but it isn’t required. That statement says we did everything we are obligated to do in an investigation, but we didn’t really dig deep and try to solve this case.
His mom knows something as well
What they require??? REALLY??? How about treat this case or all cases as if it was your child.
Pretty much anybody that over explains things to dispatch is guilty.
why don't they track the number from the 311 call? so they know if he used her phone instead of his.
I'm all for the bad guy getting caught but emphasizing that this info is ONLY available to Crime Watch Daily makes me question their motives and/or the competency of the police; either way, it is not good. I think they should be reporting on cases, not actively investigating for profit.
Well turns out they and the whole community of Fairfield in Cincinnati were right! It took way too long for an arrest to be made! Wrong friend right suspect
You can tell, simply from his voice, he is too calm. Too cold. There’s no way he could’ve been worried.
Her boyfriend John Carter did it, look at Peter Hyatt, statement analyst who analyses his 911 call and subsequent interview, proven to be deceptive
The statement analysis was very telling. I don't know why the investigators wouldn't bring him in for questioning and confront him with some of his many slip ups. This guy is too stupid to be able to talk his way around the ridiculous things he's said. I reckon they'd break him into a sniveling confession pretty damn quick.
+J H I though the samething..God,forgive me but that dude looks gay!In the 911 called,you can feel it in the voice.
@ Obviously your not from anywhere near Fairfield
This P.I. just landed himself an 11 .minute long commercial for his services!!
I wish more of these were solved
His mommy has made too many excuses for this little prissy.
how he still walks free on this planet after evidence that points out to him??? and taking mammy for an interview..REALLY?
Your baby is the green Acura pfffff lol
He just said all her belongings are there, and he’s heading out there. How would he know her belongings were there if he’s heading out there? Common sense.
It's frustrating when evidence points to someone pretty clearly, but the police somehow don't see why they should've investigated just a teeny bit more on the guy. It's crazy to say they did as much as possible, how can you say that when you didn't actually do all you could, such as search the car? That's kind of a standard thing...
Just admit you could've and should've done more and apologize for overlooking potential evidence. Own up to your mistakes and try to right the wrong in any way. It looks so much better than trying to say the officers did everything possible while investigating the #1 guy. It's painfully obvious due diligence was not completely done.
No such thing as coincidence accident or mistake for ALL is synchronous, Mr Carter
I'm sorry if this seems judgmental but that dude seems like he closeted gay, and those guys often give me a bad vibe in situations like these.. I feel like a lot of them would go through great lengths to keep their true selves hidden, and I think that in a lot of these situations, the significant other finds out and threatens to out them.
I absolutely love the tone in which the voiceover says “...but the exact order in which he called ‘people’...” 🤣
Please just arrest the boyfriend. He has all types of things connecting him to it all.
Ok, so why is the boyfriend not cuffed and hauled to jail for capital murder....they have all the evidence to convict these 2 but yet havent 🤦♀️. There’s a lot of killers roaming free in the US because of this unequal justice system where people can get away with murder if they have the money to pay for it 😞
But. .. fighting a few days before. Isn't the same as fighting that day.
Okay...this is gonna seem silly but bear with me! If you’re into cars, specifically the JDM variety, that car is gold. They are so hard to find without having major damage, and people pay well over value for them. So I’m not buying that he sold it out of the blue!
Such bad bad police work
She came home and he was in bed with that friend and was going to break up with him....and they couldn't risk her talking.
He couldn't even keep up with his own lies ! 😒
Great Investigater, donor got his monies worth!
Nah fam! He straight lied.
that Brad guy just looks shady.
Wait... So, the 911 call didn't register in his phone record? Does that mean he was using a burner cell phone and not his real cell phone? What number did the police get the call from?
He did it. He's been charged and arrested
Isn't it illegal to record people without their knowledge?
hard wired not if they don’t have a reasonable expectation of privacy. They looked to be in some sort of hotel conference room.
No, since it counts as interrogation / part of a missing person's case / legal situation -- there has to be proof.
I'm sure he knew that he was being recorded.
He remember or forget events of that day conveniently...?! how can you remember one call but dont remember the next or messages too ?
While I do agree that the bf is usually a viable suspect... I don't find it to be that obvious here. The fact that there are numerous things missing from the call log, even the 911 call, makes that log completely unreliable (also, how does that even happen?) as a piece of evidence. And all the questions the PI had could simply be answered with "he was her boyfriend, he had a key to her apartment, he drove by earlier in search of her". The only thing I find very obviously suspicious is the place where she was found.
He phoned from his friends phone and never told the cops, that way they haven't subpoenaed friends call records so it looks like his phone.. Just my 2c worth.
His mum needs to wake up and get out of denial. Your precious boy is a killer. 🤦♀️
He thought he was clever. But he learns he slipped up very badly now that one more cleverer than he comes a knocking. I'm beginning to talk like Andrea Isom.
why would his friend sell his vehicle so fast right after they find her body and why right near his family property come on police how could yall let this slip through the cracks arrest him and his friend for being involved they guilty...His mom is pathetic cause that girl was a person and a had a thriving life as well as her son...
clues are buried where they found her remains dig deeper police...
Rest in peace young
girl so sad and tragic..
I believe he killed her
I can't stand how he lies
Don’t kick back thinking this will go away .. guess what it won’t !
UPDATE: John has recently been charged with taking Katelyn's life
The 911 call wasn't on the phone records?
Did anyone check to see if it was on his friend Matt's record?
After all, the blood was found in his car wasn't it?
5:55 VOICE CRACK NUMBER TWO!!
Both him and his friend did it, its clear he had to call his friend to get him to help build himself up to make the call to her dad they had to rehearse the story he gives.!!! You can tell 1000 percent he did it..!!!!
Is there a part 3
Oh yeah he did it
Crazyness
That P.I. and this show is like Geraldo opening Al Capone's vault. Nothing burger.
Well his mom actually brought up a good point,the 911 call also didn't show on phone records. And as much as I think he is guilty that factor puts the rest of the records into question. Phone records is not an exact science mistakes happen all the time,in court it's about evidence no matter how much we think he is guilty and to me there is no choice but to question the records
He soooo did it!!
Why is John's mother there defending her son? What a mamma's boy!
He sounds guilty , and in the sound ..it would be important to say if he is secretl bisexual, or that his upcoming marriage was only one of convenience ,...
Katelyn deserved better than this OBVIOUSLY shotty police work. I'm in awe of this police department, how on Earth can they claim to have done "everything modern officers can" That's bullshit. I feel so bad for her family. This man is not only a liar, but a bad liar & a killer!! Charge his mother too. Conspiracy after the fact. The friend, Matt, OBVIOUSLY assisted.
He killed her!
Boyfriend killed her
They should have had a cadeaver dog sniff the car.
I dunno but the best friend seems strange I dunno why just a feeling
Maybe John and his Friend were hiding something ' Maybe they were Gay.
She could have walked in on John and his Friend having an Affair and They killed her so that no one would find out .
Yessss!
There are alot of questionable people there...
His face is so mean, no doubts he killed her.
I think the murder of young girls is disgusting.that John has been bullying her it happens all the time thay want control of them all the time .that's why you should have a son who has hands and can deal whith people like John the bully .I mean that girl at the end of the day was a nice young kid and had her life in front of her.RIP young girl God bless family
Instead of giving out the police number i think it should be that P.Is , he is way more competent than that trash police department
Her boyfriend sounds like he likes guys
Honestly, if my girlfriend disappeared after a carnival ended, I'd probably mention the carnies. They also travel state to state. I would bet big money that some of the carnies from my local annual church carnival have probably killed or abducted someone at some point in their life. They're all criminals, they don't have to take background checks and they never stay in one place long.
Do you have bad experiences with carnies???😂🤣😂🤣😂