Play your part in spreading the message of the Quran and Ahlulbayt by performing 3S: I) Share: Help us reach more hearts by sharing this content with your family and friends (especially those unaware of the School of Ahlulbayt). II) Subscribe: Connect with us on TH-cam & Social Media Platforms (links in description). Or join our WhatsApp list by clicking on this link: wa.me/message/TAR3C325Z5LYO1 III) Support: Producing content like this is impossible without your support. Be our patron and pledge your monthly contribution at thaqlain.org/support
Jazakallah Khair Molana ! Evidence from Quran about repentance of sahaba in history about Ghazwa Tabook stayed behind when it was a mandatory to participation. No such revelation to justify their repentance.
Masha Allah Masha Allah Subhan Allah Truth... Allah swt has given us clear signs It's as clear as water Now who wants to be blind nobody can help them Indeed Allah swt guides those whom HE wants May Allah swt bless us all and always be with us and make us worthy of intercession of Rasulullah sawws and his holy progeny a.s. on the day of judgement. Aameen Allahumma Salle ala Muhammad wa aale Muhammad
In jannat Hazrat khadija will get highest respect as wife of prophet Mohammed [pbuh] and her daughter hajrat fatima will be the leader of womanhood, as a sunni i believe in ahle bayat
Calling yourself a Shia Muslim and Sunni Muslim is something that should be looked down upon. It tells what is your source of reaching the Prophet. They are schools. If you follow the School of Ahlal Sunnah wa'al Jama'ah, it means your source of knowing the Quran and the Sunnah of the Prophet are caliphs followed by the Sahaba. If you follow the School of Ahlulbayt, it means your source of knowing the Quran and Sunnah are the Imams from the progeny of Ahlulbayt.
What's wrong with Sunni brothers for calling Ayesha woman of paradise and also Prophet's so called favorite wife. Do you Sunnis dispute with the Quran or Allah.
It's really nice how he presents an argument from each side. I read In a book of sayings and wisdom from imam Ali as that following opinions isn't more important than following good examples. Ayesha and Hafsa set the examples for themselves and the rest made opinions.
Surah Momineen The True Believers in The Holy Quranic Scriptures is and always was The Whole Shia Community Ya Ali Madad Labbaik Ya Hussain (as) Panchaatan Paak (as) 😘
In his way back from the Tabbuk expedition , the prophet of Islam was the target of a 15 sahabi assassination attempt. In the 'Aqabah tough narrow mountainous passage fifteen of his sahabah / companions planned to scare his she-camel . The camel would throw him over a deep cliff. No body would know who did what. Allah Almighty exposed them to His messenger. The prophet called them by their names to get out of the way ,,, The well known sahabi Hutheifah ibn al-yamaan wrote the names down. The plot quickly circulated among the Muslims. Some of them said to the prophet " ,,, they tried to kill you ,, kill them ,, ". He replied : " I dislike to hear Arabs saying >." NO REPENTANCE REPORTED. However ; Omar came to Hutheifah and asked him if his name was in the list of the plotters. OMAR'S NAME.
Subhanallah this lecture it's roasted sound it's only a sound mind could see , not a hypocritical mind ,Haqq is Haqq.You going good my brother. If I could of still make children when he she born i would give name to them truth because they would of hit people hard from the time they born .Yaa Allah wat ah ting.
Jaazaakum_Ullah khairan katheeran / a lot of khair . So many Muslims do not mind using the - two face to face hands - symbol to express their gratitude ,, thanks ,,,,, What is wrong with that ! This icon is rooted in the nasraani / so called Christian culture. They have it their prayers and supplications. Muslims ; especially , followers of Ahlilbayt a,s should be more careful. We can't afford buying or adopting anything other people throw in the market. Jaazaakum_Ullah khairan .
@@adamnouri23 Your concern is noted. 😊😆 In my country, the traditional respectful greeting accompanies this hand posture. Before you get too excited, don't forget the colourless colonizer is a great copycat plagiarizer who stole everything, including the scripture from coloured humans. Next, you will fault me for using the light coloured hands emoji instead of brown! The list will be endless. There's a beautiful saying from what remains of the Bible: "First remove the log from your own eye, before trying to remove the speck from another's eye." Just saying, my hand gesture is peanuts compared to the bid'aa and shirk being practised by so called Muslims in their ibaadat!!!
The fact that Allah did not replace them with other wives after this incident may suggest that they repented since Allah warned them "if you do not repent, I will replace you with others ..." inferring that if they repented, they would not be replaced. And Allah Knows Best!
I thought the same thing. It needs more clarification from the sayyid. Although Allah doesn’t give an ultimatum; عسى which is translated as ‘perhaps’ is used, not ‘definitely’. I suppose it needs a study of that word and what it implies in terms of probability if following through with the possibility.
Salaam Alaykum. You are mixing two verses here. The verse related to repentance is as follows: ˹It will be better˺ if you ˹wives˺ both turn to Allah in repentance, for your hearts have certainly faltered. But if you ˹continue to˺ collaborate against him, then ˹know that˺ Allah Himself is his Guardian. And Gabriel, the righteous believers, and the angels are ˹all˺ his supporters as well. It is the next verse that discusses them being replaced as under: Perhaps, if he were to divorce you ˹all˺, his Lord would replace you with better wives who are submissive ˹to Allah˺, faithful ˹to Him˺, devout, repentant, dedicated to worship and fasting-previously married or virgins. The Prophet decided not to replace them as having them as wives was a test from Allah of the Ummah.
Some beneficial books of Shi'ah to benefit from: Mr. Muhsin Al-Amin said, “Twenty thousand of the people of Iraq pledged allegiance to Al-Hussein. They betrayed him and revolted against him, and their allegiance to him was on their necks and they killed him” (Shi’a notables 1:34). Al Sayyed Muhsin al Ameen says: “ 20,000 of the people of Iraq gave Allegiance to Hussein, then they suddenly betrayed him and rebelled against him although they had given him an oath of allegiance ” source: A'ayan al Shia 1:34 2. Al-Hussein calls out to them before they kill him: “Did you not write to me that the fruits had ripened, and that you were advancing on a soldier? Damn you, group, when you cried out to us and humiliated usso you sharpened a sword that was in our hands against us, and you swarmed a fire that we kindled against your enemy and our enemy, so you became the enemy of your allies and the crushing, and the hand on your enemies. You hastened to pledge allegiance to us like a flock of flies, and you flocked to us like a bed flocked to us, and then you broke it foolishly, distancing yourself from the tyrants of this nation.” Al Hussein was calling them before they killed him: Didn't you write to me that the fruits had become ripe? And that I would have an enormous army when I come? Damn you! You cried for us to come then you held a sword that was once in our hands against us! (…) you were hasty in giving us Baya’ah like flies and you gathered around us like a group of butterflies But you broke your oaths… ” source: Al Ihtijaj for al Tabrasi. 3. Then Al-Hurr bin Yazid, one of the companions of Al-Hussein, while he was standing in Karbala, called them and said to them, “You called this righteous servant, so that when he came to you, you surrendered him, then you attacked him to kill him, so he became like a prisoner in your hands?” May God not give you to drink on the day of thirst.” {Al-Irshad for Al-Mufid 234, I’lam Al-Wari Ba’Alam Al-Huda 242}. Al hurr bin Yazid one of the companions of Hussein told the people of Kufah while he stood in karbala : “did you call upon this pious servant (Hussein) so that you can attack him and try to kill him, it is as if he became like a prisoner in your hands? May Allah not give you a drink on that Day of thurst! source: Al Irshad for Mufid 234, I'ilam al Wara bi A'alam al Huda 242. 4. And here Al-Hussein called on his Shiites, saying: “O God, if you give them pleasure for a while, then divide them into factions (i.e. sects and parties) and make them into groups of groups, and never be satisfied with their rulers, for they called us to help us, then they attacked us and killed us” {al-Irshad al-Mufid 241, I’lam al-Wari by al-Tabarsi 949, Kashf al-Ghamma 2:18, 38} And here Hussein made a Dua on his Shia, he said: “O Allah if you give them pleasure temporarily Then divide them to various groups and sects and tariqas, and make the rulers oppress them, They have called us so that we may support them and then they betrayed us and killed us. source: Al Irshad for Mufid 241, I'lam al Wara for Tabrasi 949, Kashf al Ghummah 2:18-38. 5. The Shiite historian Al-Yaqoubi mentions in his history that when Ali bin Al-Hussein entered Kufa, he saw its women crying and screaming, so he said: “These people are crying over us, so who killed us?” Which of us killed other than them? {Tarikh al-Ya`qubi 235:1} Famous Shia historian al Ya'aqoubi mentions in his Tareekh that when Ali Zain al Abideen bin al Hussein entered Kufah he saw the women crying and screaming so he said: “These women are crying because of us, Then who killed us?” [meaning who killed us except for these Shia who cry.] source: Tareekh al ya'aqoubi 1:235. Now the question is: kufa homeland of whom: shia or ahle-sunnah? Rafidi priest Baqir Shareef al-Qureshi said: “Verily Kufa was the birth place of shia, and a homeland of the al-Alawe'een, and it has declared its loyalty to ahlul bait many times. (hayat Al-Hussein 3/12) He also said the seed of chia was sown in Kufa since the khilafat of Umar. (hayat Al-Hussein 3/13) Famous Shia scholar Sayyed Kamal al Haydari admits that The Battle of Karbala was between Imam Hussein[ra] and the Shia of Ali[ra] in al Kufah, He even said The Shia of Ali[ra] wanted to come closer to Allah by spilling the blood of Hussein[ra] .The Lecture has the title: Dar'e al Shubuhat 'An Waqi'at al taff
If the prophet didn't divorce either of them, doesn't that mean they probably repented? Because the Quran did mention that Allah would make the prophet divorce them and bless him with better wives.
Salam, can you ask Sayyid if someone from ahlus sunnah was to rebuttle with the question that if Ayesha did not repent why did tue prophet take her back, what would the response to this be?
Take her back after the necklace? We have covered it in the previous episode and examined in detail that the Ifk version of Ahlal Sunnah was fabricated by Ayesha herself.
The incident behind Surah Tahrim as is mentioned by Ayesha never happened. We have covered it to certain extent in the following episode: th-cam.com/video/axkNXMUd2zM/w-d-xo.html
If we cover faults of others, ALLAH will cover our faults duneyah and aaghirah . This is the Ahlulbayt you talking about, it should not even be a topic of discussion YAH ALLAH HAVE MERCY APUN US YAH RABB.
Shia religion is nothing but slandering about the respected companions of the holy prophet and innovating new things in Islam. Fear Allah. Stop slandering. If you are in the path of Ali (ra) follow him completely, even if Ayesha (ra) was not on the right path, did Ali (ra) ever slander them? How can you do that then? Talking rubbish about prophet's wife, Judging them... who are you? What is you position?
The Scared information is as follows The I'm am Mahdi is a Sunni Salfiayoun The Shia is Allah (swt) Ya Ali Madad Labbaik Ya Hussain (as) Ya Muhammad (saw) Ya Ali Madad Ya Fatima (as) Ya Hassan (as) Ya Hussain (as) Ya Zainab (as) Ya Sakina (as) Ya Ruqaya (as)😘
Salam, I am Shia Muslim and with all due respect, I think it is not a good idea to talk negatively about Hazarat Ayesha, whom our Sunni brothers refer to as their ‘umul momenien/muslimeen. Even if it is fact. This is going to provide fuel for extremist muslims. These type of discussions should take place between scholars privately. We need unity amongst all muslims and all of humanity.
Brother Zakir, if the truth is buried then falsehood would appear as truth. In the long run ( over the years ) they have accomplished in raising her status of innocence and that she is of high esteem. The fact abt her being a manipulative soul should be maintained and discussed.
You have missed the purpose of the video. We will urge you to relisten the video :) Also, unity does not mean we cannot present our side of the story. If we are not allowed to present our side of the story, that's a compromise. Moreover, it is not just Sunnis who consider wives of the Prophet as Ummul Momineen, the Shias of Ahlulbayt also consider them the same. Please watch the next episode of this series.
Why hide the truth if Allah reveals it in the Quran then why should we hide it. It's like saying we shouldn't tell Christians Jesus is not God nor Son of God.
Who else are we going to not talk against, for the sake of upholding Muslim fraternity? There're a host of historical figures who've distorted a beautiful and true religion and hurt the Alhulbayt, both physically and emotionally. Those figures need to be called out and exposed for the new generations to be aware of the reality and factual history.
It is Allah in the quran who refers to.the prophets wives as the mother of the believers, obviously this zakir sat here doeant fall in the believer category hence he doesnt accept hwr as his mother.
Subhanallah you keep mentioning the wife of the prophet asws and that does not stop you from talking? What was it that allah swt didn't know or his prophet asws (astagfurullah astauthubillah) This is one of the main reasons why Shias reject the beleif of kadar!
@Quran and Ahadith that's really your question? Your 18? But you act rude like a 10 year old? Listen my boy you know nothing but what you have been indoctrinated and brain washed to believe.... You will not read an insult from me to any predecessor. I have shame and dignity unlike you my boy... Little boy. Backbiting and talking I'll about people in our religion takes your good deeds by allah swt and hands it to the people that are backbited and insulted against... Allah swt loves the companions of muhammad sws so much that he created a nation called the Shia that slanders them so allah takes their good deeds and gives it to the companions and wives of our beloved prophet sws. Keep it up my boy little boy....
Hadhrat Aisha our mother was a true reliable believer, was powerful full of life and honest wife of the ptophet like all other companions and loved ones of the prophet our mother made mistakes. Unlike this arrogant man who uses honourable titles for himself and omitts ghem from hadhrat aisha.
Salaam. It seems this is the first episode from this series you are watching. And it is sad that instead of trying to understand what the scholar is saying, you called him an "arrogant man".
Allah exposing her in the quran. The scholsrs have told you. You are going against what Allah has said about Aisha in the quran. How is she a good wife, read your ahadeeths.
Astagfirullah, You are talking about Umul Mumineen Hazrat e Aysha R.A like she is some ordinary woman. My friends always tell me that Shias have buguz of Umul Mumineen and Sahaba in their hearts , but i didn't believe them. Today i realised that you are the gustaakhe sahaba and Gustaakh of Umul Mumineen Hazrat e Aysha R.A. She was Honoured by Allah in The Holy Quran ( Surah Noor 11- 21). The Prophet was not afraid to express his love for Aisha in public. The Prophet was once asked by a sahabah, “Who is the most beloved person to you?” The Prophet replied, “Aisha.” The sahabah then said, “And among the men?” The Prophet answered, “Her father.” (recorded in Bukhari). اللهم صل على محمد و على آل محمد. May Allah guide you to the Haq.
Salaam Alaykum. It seems this is the first video of this series you have watched. So we welcome you to it. We have shared links to previous chapters in the description and would encourage you to watch them. In it you will find lives of sahaba and the Ummahatul Momineen. However, it seems your concern is specific in regards to Ayesha alone (which is sad because for a believer every mother should have equal status), we have already covered Surah Nur in episodes related to Maria al-Qibtiyya. Rest, we encourage you to listen to the subsequent episodes too as that will allow you to understand the complete picture and why in the School of Ahlulbayt we don't take religious teachings from Ayesha. We understand that the points mentioned here will be new for you but we have tried to use no source other than Quran and books of Ahlal Sunnah. In fact, subsequent episodes will show that it was Ayesha who had apparent Bughz for Ahlulbayt and some of the sahaba in her heart :)
Astagfirullah. This man is talking so badly about Muhammad Mustafa's most loved wife. Does he even know what he's saying. Astagfirullah.Straight up venom. If you follow the Holy Qur'an so much, Why don't you talk about how Allah swt sent revelation to declare her innocence when she was accused wrongly? For how many people did Allah sent revelation like this? She is the mother of ummah, how do you dare to say these things? She will be our prophets wife in jannah. Prophet died in her arms. Prophet recieved revelation only when he has at her home. What the hell does this man mean to say? This man is questioning if hazrat Ayesha R.A was a true believer. Astagfirullah. May Allah have mercy on his doomed soul.
If you explore the source books, instead of listening to scholars that rely on secondary books, you will find that things don't add up 🙂 To summarise, her personality has been extremely controversial. Most of the narrations in her praise are narrated by none but herself. Thus, we don't take sunnah from her.
Strange how this man who was probably conceived out of muta (which is a great virtue according shia belief)has the audacity to slander the prophets wives. May the curse of Allah be on your shar.
It's a shame how this man uses inferences to discredit the prophets wives. They fail to see people and relationships as they are humans and family members who have real relationships love and disagreements. Stop using hair splitting arguments to discredit the prophets family.
You should explain this to Allah (subhanahu wa'tala). It is He who revealed an entire Chapter on a "hair splitting argument" and is discrediting Prophet's wives.
@@Thaqlain can you show Allah says in quran or in Hadith the two wives of prophet muhammad (saw) are divorced or they are people of jahanem. Because they are human beings they make mistakes who knows they may be they repent Allah knows...Allah is gefurll-rehim may Allah guide us all
If they made such mistakes that verses of the Quran were revealed, then they shouldn't be the source of extracting sunnah. And that's entirely the aim of this video.
@@Thaqlain But Allah also revealed ayahs to show that Ayesha was innocent of the ifk. But you guys dont accept that too. No point in arguing with deviants like you people! FYI, you are brainwashing and misguiding a lot of today's youth. you will be answerable to Allah for that.
The mother of the Muslim AYESHA was the one who said that a scripture of QURAN was eaten by goat, when she came up with a fitwa that A NON MEHRAM can be made MEHRAM by giving him MILK. 🤦♂️🤦♂️ When people asked where it was written she said I had the scripture and a GOAT came and ate it. You people are following these kind of people
Play your part in spreading the message of the Quran and Ahlulbayt by performing 3S:
I) Share: Help us reach more hearts by sharing this content with your family and friends (especially those unaware of the School of Ahlulbayt).
II) Subscribe: Connect with us on TH-cam & Social Media Platforms (links in description). Or join our WhatsApp list by clicking on this link: wa.me/message/TAR3C325Z5LYO1
III) Support: Producing content like this is impossible without your support. Be our patron and pledge your monthly contribution at thaqlain.org/support
Jazakallah Khair Molana !
Evidence from Quran about repentance of sahaba in history about Ghazwa Tabook stayed behind when it was a mandatory to participation.
No such revelation to justify their repentance.
Masha Allah Masha Allah
Subhan Allah
Truth... Allah swt has given us clear signs
It's as clear as water
Now who wants to be blind nobody can help them
Indeed Allah swt guides those whom HE wants
May Allah swt bless us all and always be with us and make us worthy of intercession of Rasulullah sawws and his holy progeny a.s. on the day of judgement.
Aameen
Allahumma Salle ala Muhammad wa aale Muhammad
In jannat Hazrat khadija will get highest respect as wife of prophet Mohammed [pbuh] and her daughter hajrat fatima will be the leader of womanhood, as a sunni i believe in ahle bayat
If you believe in the supremacy of Ahlulbayt after the Prophet than you are a Shia Muslim just born in a Sunni family 🙂
@@Thaqlain Don't consider myself sunni or shia, i consider my self a muslim, a servant of allah, and his rasool,
Calling yourself a Shia Muslim and Sunni Muslim is something that should be looked down upon. It tells what is your source of reaching the Prophet. They are schools. If you follow the School of Ahlal Sunnah wa'al Jama'ah, it means your source of knowing the Quran and the Sunnah of the Prophet are caliphs followed by the Sahaba. If you follow the School of Ahlulbayt, it means your source of knowing the Quran and Sunnah are the Imams from the progeny of Ahlulbayt.
What's wrong with Sunni brothers for calling Ayesha woman of paradise and also Prophet's so called favorite wife. Do you Sunnis dispute with the Quran or Allah.
It's really nice how he presents an argument from each side. I read In a book of sayings and wisdom from imam Ali as that following opinions isn't more important than following good examples. Ayesha and Hafsa set the examples for themselves and the rest made opinions.
Surah Momineen The True Believers in The Holy Quranic Scriptures is and always was The Whole Shia Community Ya Ali Madad Labbaik Ya Hussain (as) Panchaatan Paak (as) 😘
May allah put us with ali and put you with aisha
How can hazrat ali r.a do your madad? Don't you believe only Allah can help you
Спасибо!
In his way back from the Tabbuk expedition , the prophet of Islam was the target of a 15 sahabi assassination attempt. In the 'Aqabah tough narrow mountainous passage fifteen of his sahabah / companions planned to scare his she-camel . The camel would throw him over a deep cliff. No body would know who did what.
Allah Almighty exposed them to His messenger. The prophet called them by their names to get out of the way ,,,
The well known sahabi Hutheifah ibn al-yamaan wrote the names down.
The plot quickly circulated among the Muslims. Some of them said to the prophet " ,,, they tried to kill you ,, kill them ,, ".
He replied : " I dislike to hear Arabs saying >."
NO REPENTANCE REPORTED.
However ; Omar came to Hutheifah and asked him if his name was in the list of the plotters. OMAR'S NAME.
Subhanallah this lecture it's roasted sound it's only a sound mind could see , not a hypocritical mind ,Haqq is Haqq.You going good my brother. If I could of still make children when he she born i would give name to them truth because they would of hit people hard from the time they born .Yaa Allah wat ah ting.
Where is our dear sister Romana Adam !
Allahumma salli 'alaa Mohammad wa Aali Mohammad wa 'ajjil farajahum wa farajanaa behim ,,, yaa KAREEM.
Jazakhallahu khairan. 🙏 Excellent, masha Allah. 👍
Jaazaakum_Ullah khairan katheeran / a lot of khair .
So many Muslims do not mind using the - two face to face hands - symbol to express their gratitude ,, thanks ,,,,,
What is wrong with that !
This icon is rooted in the nasraani / so called Christian culture. They have it their prayers and supplications.
Muslims ; especially , followers of Ahlilbayt a,s should be more careful. We can't afford buying or adopting anything other people throw in the market.
Jaazaakum_Ullah khairan .
@@adamnouri23
Your concern is noted. 😊😆
In my country, the traditional respectful greeting accompanies this hand posture. Before you get too excited, don't forget the colourless colonizer is a great copycat plagiarizer who stole everything, including the scripture from coloured humans.
Next, you will fault me for using the light coloured hands emoji instead of brown!
The list will be endless.
There's a beautiful saying from what remains of the Bible: "First remove the log from your own eye, before trying to remove the speck from another's eye."
Just saying, my hand gesture is peanuts compared to the bid'aa and shirk being practised by so called Muslims in their ibaadat!!!
The fact that Allah did not replace them with other wives after this incident may suggest that they repented since Allah warned them "if you do not repent, I will replace you with others ..." inferring that if they repented, they would not be replaced. And Allah Knows Best!
I thought the same thing. It needs more clarification from the sayyid.
Although Allah doesn’t give an ultimatum; عسى which is translated as ‘perhaps’ is used, not ‘definitely’. I suppose it needs a study of that word and what it implies in terms of probability if following through with the possibility.
Salaam Alaykum. You are mixing two verses here. The verse related to repentance is as follows:
˹It will be better˺ if you ˹wives˺ both turn to Allah in repentance, for your hearts have certainly faltered. But if you ˹continue to˺ collaborate against him, then ˹know that˺ Allah Himself is his Guardian. And Gabriel, the righteous believers, and the angels are ˹all˺ his supporters as well.
It is the next verse that discusses them being replaced as under:
Perhaps, if he were to divorce you ˹all˺, his Lord would replace you with better wives who are submissive ˹to Allah˺, faithful ˹to Him˺, devout, repentant, dedicated to worship and fasting-previously married or virgins.
The Prophet decided not to replace them as having them as wives was a test from Allah of the Ummah.
@@ThaqlainAstagfirullah, these women are mercy for ummah not a test. I don't know what to say to these people
@@tamanababa5185 I agree. these people are spreading lies
@@NaziaMuzammilso discussing Quranic verses is spreading lies? 🙂
Some beneficial books of Shi'ah to benefit from:
Mr. Muhsin Al-Amin said, “Twenty thousand of the people of Iraq pledged allegiance to Al-Hussein. They betrayed him and revolted against him, and their allegiance to him was on their necks and they killed him” (Shi’a notables 1:34).
Al Sayyed Muhsin al Ameen says: “ 20,000 of the people of Iraq gave Allegiance to Hussein, then they suddenly betrayed him and rebelled against him although they had given him an oath of allegiance ”
source: A'ayan al Shia 1:34
2. Al-Hussein calls out to them before they kill him: “Did you not write to me that the fruits had ripened, and that you were advancing on a soldier? Damn you, group, when you cried out to us and humiliated usso you sharpened a sword that was in our hands against us, and you swarmed a fire that we kindled against your enemy and our enemy, so you became the enemy of your allies and the crushing, and the hand on your enemies. You hastened to pledge allegiance to us like a flock of flies, and you flocked to us like a bed flocked to us, and then you broke it foolishly, distancing yourself from the tyrants of this nation.”
Al Hussein was calling them before they killed him: Didn't you write to me that the fruits had become ripe? And that I would have an enormous army when I come? Damn you! You cried for us to come then you held a sword that was once in our hands against us! (…) you were hasty in giving us Baya’ah like flies and you gathered around us like a group of butterflies But you broke your oaths… ”
source: Al Ihtijaj for al Tabrasi.
3. Then Al-Hurr bin Yazid, one of the companions of Al-Hussein, while he was standing in Karbala, called them and said to them, “You called this righteous servant, so that when he came to you, you surrendered him, then you attacked him to kill him, so he became like a prisoner in your hands?” May God not give you to drink on the day of thirst.” {Al-Irshad for Al-Mufid 234, I’lam Al-Wari Ba’Alam Al-Huda 242}.
Al hurr bin Yazid one of the companions of Hussein told the people of Kufah while he stood in karbala : “did you call upon this pious servant (Hussein) so that you can attack him and try to kill him, it is as if he became like a prisoner in your hands? May Allah not give you a drink on that Day of thurst!
source: Al Irshad for Mufid 234, I'ilam al Wara bi A'alam al Huda 242.
4. And here Al-Hussein called on his Shiites, saying: “O God, if you give them pleasure for a while, then divide them into factions (i.e. sects and parties) and make them into groups of groups, and never be satisfied with their rulers, for they called us to help us, then they attacked us and killed us” {al-Irshad al-Mufid 241, I’lam al-Wari by al-Tabarsi 949, Kashf al-Ghamma 2:18, 38}
And here Hussein made a Dua on his Shia, he said: “O Allah if you give them pleasure temporarily Then divide them to various groups and sects and tariqas, and make the rulers oppress them, They have called us so that we may support them and then they betrayed us and killed us.
source: Al Irshad for Mufid 241, I'lam al Wara for Tabrasi 949, Kashf al Ghummah 2:18-38.
5. The Shiite historian Al-Yaqoubi mentions in his history that when Ali bin Al-Hussein entered Kufa, he saw its women crying and screaming, so he said: “These people are crying over us, so who killed us?” Which of us killed other than them? {Tarikh al-Ya`qubi 235:1}
Famous Shia historian al Ya'aqoubi mentions in his Tareekh that when Ali Zain al Abideen bin al Hussein entered Kufah he saw the women crying and screaming so he said: “These women are crying because of us, Then who killed us?” [meaning who killed us except for these Shia who cry.]
source: Tareekh al ya'aqoubi 1:235.
Now the question is: kufa homeland of whom: shia or ahle-sunnah?
Rafidi priest Baqir Shareef al-Qureshi said: “Verily Kufa was the birth place of shia, and a homeland of the al-Alawe'een, and it has declared its loyalty to ahlul bait many times.
(hayat Al-Hussein 3/12)
He also said the seed of chia was sown in Kufa since the khilafat of Umar.
(hayat Al-Hussein 3/13)
Famous Shia scholar Sayyed Kamal al Haydari admits that The Battle of Karbala was between Imam Hussein[ra] and the Shia of Ali[ra] in al Kufah, He even said The Shia of Ali[ra] wanted to come closer to Allah by spilling the blood of Hussein[ra] .The Lecture has the title: Dar'e al Shubuhat 'An Waqi'at al taff
Have you read these books yourself? Because honestly if you read al-Ihtijaj cover to cover you will want no one to know about it.
If the prophet didn't divorce either of them, doesn't that mean they probably repented? Because the Quran did mention that Allah would make the prophet divorce them and bless him with better wives.
History shows us that they continued with their acts even after it. Why the Prophet did not divorce them is covered in another episode.
@@Thaqlain JazakAllah.
Salam, can you ask Sayyid if someone from ahlus sunnah was to rebuttle with the question that if Ayesha did not repent why did tue prophet take her back, what would the response to this be?
Take her back after the necklace? We have covered it in the previous episode and examined in detail that the Ifk version of Ahlal Sunnah was fabricated by Ayesha herself.
@@Thaqlain so the prophet SAW did not take back aisha to his home ever again after the incident surah tahrim mentions? That is what i was referring to
The incident behind Surah Tahrim as is mentioned by Ayesha never happened. We have covered it to certain extent in the following episode:
th-cam.com/video/axkNXMUd2zM/w-d-xo.html
They would tell you that the prophet died on her chest meaning that he was satisfied with her. They will always find something to say 😂
It is not us, it is you who will accept every false narration that praises Ayesha even if it goes against the Quran.
@@Thaqlain
No it’s not me! But I’m talking about those who don’t follow the true path of Prophet Muhammad and his pure Household.
May Allah guide them. And may Allah bless you and your progeny with close proximity to the Prophet and his progeny.
@@Thaqlain
Amen 🙏🏻
May Allah bless you too and grant success to your channel.
If we cover faults of others, ALLAH will cover our faults duneyah and aaghirah .
This is the Ahlulbayt you talking about, it should not even be a topic of discussion
YAH ALLAH HAVE MERCY APUN US YAH RABB.
Are you saying that Allah shouldn't have rebuked them in His holy book?
Shia religion is nothing but slandering about the respected companions of the holy prophet and innovating new things in Islam. Fear Allah. Stop slandering. If you are in the path of Ali (ra) follow him completely, even if Ayesha (ra) was not on the right path, did Ali (ra) ever slander them? How can you do that then? Talking rubbish about prophet's wife, Judging them... who are you? What is you position?
So discussing her position in the Quran is slandering her?
Condemnation of Ayesha and Hafsa both*
The Scared information is as follows The I'm am Mahdi is a Sunni Salfiayoun The Shia is Allah (swt) Ya Ali Madad Labbaik Ya Hussain (as) Ya Muhammad (saw) Ya Ali Madad Ya Fatima (as) Ya Hassan (as) Ya Hussain (as) Ya Zainab (as) Ya Sakina (as) Ya Ruqaya (as)😘
6:12 I can feel the Sayyed holding himself
his inner ammar nakshawani almost came out
Allah will maks your innerself come out on the day of judgement.
Salam, I am Shia Muslim and with all due respect, I think it is not a good idea to talk negatively about Hazarat Ayesha, whom our Sunni brothers refer to as their ‘umul momenien/muslimeen. Even if it is fact. This is going to provide fuel for extremist muslims. These type of discussions should take place between scholars privately. We need unity amongst all muslims and all of humanity.
Brother Zakir, if the truth is buried then falsehood would appear as truth. In the long run ( over the years ) they have accomplished in raising her status of innocence and that she is of high esteem. The fact abt her being a manipulative soul should be maintained and discussed.
You have missed the purpose of the video. We will urge you to relisten the video :)
Also, unity does not mean we cannot present our side of the story. If we are not allowed to present our side of the story, that's a compromise. Moreover, it is not just Sunnis who consider wives of the Prophet as Ummul Momineen, the Shias of Ahlulbayt also consider them the same. Please watch the next episode of this series.
Why hide the truth if Allah reveals it in the Quran then why should we hide it. It's like saying we shouldn't tell Christians Jesus is not God nor Son of God.
Who else are we going to not talk against, for the sake of upholding Muslim fraternity?
There're a host of historical figures who've distorted a beautiful and true religion and hurt the Alhulbayt, both physically and emotionally.
Those figures need to be called out and exposed for the new generations to be aware of the reality and factual history.
It is Allah in the quran who refers to.the prophets wives as the mother of the believers, obviously this zakir sat here doeant fall in the believer category hence he doesnt accept hwr as his mother.
Subhanallah you keep mentioning the wife of the prophet asws and that does not stop you from talking?
What was it that allah swt didn't know or his prophet asws (astagfurullah astauthubillah)
This is one of the main reasons why Shias reject the beleif of kadar!
@Quran and Ahadith really what are you 10?
@Quran and Ahadith answer what question you didn't pose a question did you?
@@ShiaRafidhiAkhbariIslam it's also a shame that you throw insults instead of being intellectually inclined and think and talk rationally.
Shame.
@Quran and Ahadith remind Me what it was please
@Quran and Ahadith that's really your question?
Your 18? But you act rude like a 10 year old?
Listen my boy you know nothing but what you have been indoctrinated and brain washed to believe....
You will not read an insult from me to any predecessor. I have shame and dignity unlike you my boy...
Little boy.
Backbiting and talking I'll about people in our religion takes your good deeds by allah swt and hands it to the people that are backbited and insulted against...
Allah swt loves the companions of muhammad sws so much that he created a nation called the Shia that slanders them so allah takes their good deeds and gives it to the companions and wives of our beloved prophet sws.
Keep it up my boy little boy....
Hadhrat Aisha our mother was a true reliable believer, was powerful full of life and honest wife of the ptophet like all other companions and loved ones of the prophet our mother made mistakes. Unlike this arrogant man who uses honourable titles for himself and omitts ghem from hadhrat aisha.
Salaam. It seems this is the first episode from this series you are watching. And it is sad that instead of trying to understand what the scholar is saying, you called him an "arrogant man".
Allah exposing her in the quran. The scholsrs have told you. You are going against what Allah has said about Aisha in the quran. How is she a good wife, read your ahadeeths.
Astagfirullah, You are talking about Umul Mumineen Hazrat e Aysha R.A like she is some ordinary woman. My friends always tell me that Shias have buguz of Umul Mumineen and Sahaba in their hearts , but i didn't believe them. Today i realised that you are the gustaakhe sahaba and Gustaakh of Umul Mumineen Hazrat e Aysha R.A. She was Honoured by Allah in The Holy Quran ( Surah Noor 11- 21). The Prophet was not afraid to express his love for Aisha in public. The Prophet was once asked by a sahabah, “Who is the most beloved person to you?” The Prophet replied, “Aisha.” The sahabah then said, “And among the men?” The Prophet answered, “Her father.” (recorded in Bukhari).
اللهم صل على محمد و على آل محمد.
May Allah guide you to the Haq.
Salaam Alaykum. It seems this is the first video of this series you have watched. So we welcome you to it. We have shared links to previous chapters in the description and would encourage you to watch them. In it you will find lives of sahaba and the Ummahatul Momineen.
However, it seems your concern is specific in regards to Ayesha alone (which is sad because for a believer every mother should have equal status), we have already covered Surah Nur in episodes related to Maria al-Qibtiyya.
Rest, we encourage you to listen to the subsequent episodes too as that will allow you to understand the complete picture and why in the School of Ahlulbayt we don't take religious teachings from Ayesha. We understand that the points mentioned here will be new for you but we have tried to use no source other than Quran and books of Ahlal Sunnah. In fact, subsequent episodes will show that it was Ayesha who had apparent Bughz for Ahlulbayt and some of the sahaba in her heart :)
this ahadeeth is forged. He never loved Aisha. Read bukhari.
He is guided. She says awful things about rassoollah in bukhari and muslim. You still believe she was good.wake up!
Astagfirullah. This man is talking so badly about Muhammad Mustafa's most loved wife. Does he even know what he's saying. Astagfirullah.Straight up venom. If you follow the Holy Qur'an so much, Why don't you talk about how Allah swt sent revelation to declare her innocence when she was accused wrongly? For how many people did Allah sent revelation like this? She is the mother of ummah, how do you dare to say these things? She will be our prophets wife in jannah. Prophet died in her arms. Prophet recieved revelation only when he has at her home. What the hell does this man mean to say? This man is questioning if hazrat Ayesha R.A was a true believer. Astagfirullah. May Allah have mercy on his doomed soul.
We have covered the Verses of Ifk in detail. We have nothing against her but one cannot deny that she has been criticized by Allah and His Messenger.
@@Thaqlain She was loved so dearly. She was loved and repected way way wayyy more than she was criticised if at all she was.
If you explore the source books, instead of listening to scholars that rely on secondary books, you will find that things don't add up 🙂
To summarise, her personality has been extremely controversial. Most of the narrations in her praise are narrated by none but herself. Thus, we don't take sunnah from her.
Hello bro u never tal Aysha ,u tal respect fully Aysha ( r)
Strange how this man who was probably conceived out of muta (which is a great virtue according shia belief)has the audacity to slander the prophets wives. May the curse of Allah be on your shar.
Please share where is the slander. And are you degrading a sunnah of the Prophet?
Are you sure that you yourself are not conceived through muta?
So stop accusing himm
It's a shame how this man uses inferences to discredit the prophets wives. They fail to see people and relationships as they are humans and family members who have real relationships love and disagreements. Stop using hair splitting arguments to discredit the prophets family.
You should explain this to Allah (subhanahu wa'tala). It is He who revealed an entire Chapter on a "hair splitting argument" and is discrediting Prophet's wives.
@@Thaqlain can you show Allah says in quran or in Hadith the two wives of prophet muhammad (saw) are divorced or they are people of jahanem. Because they are human beings they make mistakes who knows they may be they repent Allah knows...Allah is gefurll-rehim may Allah guide us all
If they made such mistakes that verses of the Quran were revealed, then they shouldn't be the source of extracting sunnah. And that's entirely the aim of this video.
@@Thaqlain But Allah also revealed ayahs to show that Ayesha was innocent of the ifk. But you guys dont accept that too. No point in arguing with deviants like you people! FYI, you are brainwashing and misguiding a lot of today's youth. you will be answerable to Allah for that.
The Quran says the prophet wives are our mothers what about that
Ahlulbayat ; the cohorts of linguistic motif -- no where near you ppl are talking ABOUT... NO WHERE NEAR TO QURAN..!
Saqifa-Khalifa is nowhere near to Quran
The mother of the Muslim AYESHA was the one who said that a scripture of QURAN was eaten by goat, when she came up with a fitwa that A NON MEHRAM can be made MEHRAM by giving him MILK. 🤦♂️🤦♂️
When people asked where it was written she said I had the scripture and a GOAT came and ate it.
You people are following these kind of people