Due to on line systems , linking of Aadhaar with PAN number , on line GST, cash less money transactions , less cash in circulation etc , scope for discretionary powers of officers and thereby getting corruption money has become limited.
It's not true. IRS officers make it sure that you as an entrepreneur, you visit them every year by mailing you a query or notice on certain transaction of a financial year. Even you answer it online, they will not drop the notice till you meet in person and fulfill their demand despite the fact that your tax compliance is perfect. Your tax consultant too will suggest you to be friendly with the department to minimise the nuisance from them. On an average, 5k to be paid every year as convenient fee. So, automation reduces only paperwork and physical submission but corruption is still there.
Really IAS r not effective to run all other departments like power,roads,agriculture,forest,health,industry,IT,environment,food processing,education n many more as we have expertise in every sector.
Health secretary Should be from upsc cms Defence secretary should be from N.D.C Finance secretary should from IRS Railway board CRS should he from i.r.m.s Cheif director for R and D must an engineer
@@sharikwaseem8028defence secretary should be from Indian Defence account services. To enroll into this service u need to complete post graduation in Economics. Now u can understand the calibre of that officer.
Sir, you are not completely honest , why you left... But I can understand, you have an institute to run... IRS is the most outdated job.... Technical minds with good IQ should not even attempt UPSC.... They must earn huge money with their ability outside....
IAS officers are generalists and are not expert in taxation how can they work as Principal Commissioner of IT. Whereas IRS officers being finance experts can do the justice with the job of finance secretary.
The present civil service is the continuation of of British civil service . Therefore this service is in 18th century in attitude and procedures, but nobody can reform. In 2nd Administrative reforms commission 10 th report the chairman opined that this system should be changed totally. But nothinh happened because the decision is to be taken by the same officers,that is the beauty of the system
Politician pressure bhoot jyada hain ,jo chatukar hain wahi kar sakta hain, imandar ki posting kar kar k preshan kar dete hain jab tak ki wo chatukar nahi banta
Two things I could make out. 1. With computerization scope of corruption and earning big money is reduced. 2. Taxation system is so complex that corporate need intelligent people who can pay big salaries. So good people have opportunity to make big money without corruption.
Sir my experience after 34 yrs of service most of the civil servants have an attitude of mr know all , they neither know nor are interested in knowing ground reality because of ego and i have come across 7 irs officers vry corrupt nd interested in delhi posting even at the cost of integrity rgds
Around 300 Direct IRS officers are recruited per annum. So it means 85 out 300, that is around 28% officers of the intake resigned per annum. This percentage is not huge but not low either.
The approach should be not mastering the complicated taxation law, how it can be made simple. The basic problem is there are too many grey areas leading to litigation, harassment and finally corruption. The law should be capable of only one interpretation. The focus must be this. Off course this will eliminate the craze of the aspirants.
Sir, plz don't give negative comments on Licence Raj or similar taxation system available at that time. India got independence and there was everything new at that time. So what was best was was implemented. So plz improve the comments.
After face less handling of enquiries corruption has decreased. Work load increased Previous inspector use to roam on scooter. Any body building house get notice from local office and he used to collect fees and finish notice. Now game changed. With salary they can’t even build house. So they join corporate
Peple know IRS officers are leaving the service but why? I think we should do a bit of research to find out the job these officers shifted to. We may be in for stunning facts. After digitisation authority of tax officials has significantly eroded. No appreciation no reward only targets, only chiding from higher ups frustrates them.
Sarkari naukri 2 tarah k logo k liye hoti hai: 1. Jo pel k kala dhan chori krna chahate hain 2. Jo jeewan me or kuch bhi krne layak nahi hote, jinko pata hai k iske aage kuch nahi kar paenge
Thanks for sharing the details providing the right understanding and clarity about this much talked about subject these days Wishing you all the best for a great and wonderful career ahead.Thanks & Regards.
I worked for 35 yrs but things have changed gradually mainly due to digitalization.There were many like you who would speak of giving up and starting their own but never did till the end and reached to be C.C rank.
Bro I hope u've seen the report of RTI a few days ago, that at Joint Secretary level now there are just 33% IAS whearas 67% officers are from the other services.
@@WarriorOfTheSunset Bro even Secretary is not head of any department. Secretary is the administrative head of a ministry. Try to understand the working of a ministry. A person elected by the people heads the ministry and he/she is given a pool of officers who are like clerks of his office which is called Secretariat. The Secretariat is led by Secretary who is most of the times an IAS. So, IAS is the administrative head of the ministry and not the head actually. His role is like a seniormost clerk in the office of the minister. But being the seniormost clek he stays close to the minister and becomes most influencal since all the files put before minister are put up by him, all the phone calls are first attended by Secretary. I hope u understand.
@WarriorOfTheSunset Bro, I've answered u a series of questions which u will ask after this question or the assumptions u will make after my one word reply of which u are already aware of. Well the answer to ur question is NO.
Income tax, gst, customs..these are the main 3 verticals of IRS..total 850 ...so approx 280 per service resigned in 10 yrs..so approx 28 retirmnt evry yr..whr as upsc recruits almost 100 evry yr in each service..plus promotees are also thr...so 28 retirmnt per yr is not a big numbr
what kind of blasphemy ? resigning gov service and teaching others to get into that service! sir this edtech field is already in saturation too many competition😅
I have experience in both corporate sector as well as government sector. Corporate is better than government because of transparency. In government, there are so many ambiguities betwen acts and rules. They make new G.Os without sense not considering our constitution and court will quash. Many rules are nit implemented..reaseons are not known..
Sunera deen is over for digitization era, gradually entered in our manual system which promots corruption, obviously who, habituated in old system, been quitting their service. It would be better for new generation with opened minded to be included as they're waiting for a long for darth of vacancy. Thanks.
I was watching a Turkish series on ottomans. Many Pasha's faced death sentence due to allegations of corruption. But it never proved a deterrent. There is something in human nature which holds material possessions even higher than your own life.
Because they couldn't become IAS and IPS that's why they couldn't sustain the void inside. I also want to resign, I'm trying to find a way to earn a livelihood first.
No worries, if the employees want adventure and break out the mandane life then join R&AW, NSA and IB as Economic hitman and go to Bangladesh, Pakistan, Nepal, Maldives, Sri Lanka, US, EU, Turkey, etc and then do a good service as a spy.
IRS were enjoying their authoritarian way of life with zero output. They were all currupt. Now they are made accountable! So running away. Let them go home, if they can’t deliver
India suddenly became developed country ,due to UPSC Staff ,but UPA rules were the worst period of central govt employees, you cannot cheat anyone but public can make earn crores of money without doing nothing , I was central government employees,what to do if your government (UPA) was acting as per Soro ,who cheated my lifelong periods earning.
Entire South states are least concern,Their target is global avenues. Times are changed. Indian are paid how many times is unexpected.The world best rejected employee is INDIAN “IAS” CS of Civil aviation debarred for employee , where as AIR TRAFFIC CONTROLLER IS WANTED EVERY WHERE IN THE WORLD. Same is the case Indian petroleum ministers as well as Railways. The most unwanted in the world is Indian IAS
The salary is not good..... For example a skilled cs engineer gets one crore per annum( more than 8 lakhs per month) at the age of 25......whats the salary of civil servant even at 50 ?
@@anilkumarn.m3252 instead of comparing with private sector salaries for a few, comparison should be with civil servant salaries in other countries ( with ppp). Our average per capita income also should be remembered.
Salary is salary...... to lead a luxurious life and to brighten the life of future generations a good salary/ income is a must....... I think that one can become the civil servant of another country only after getting citizen ship there
First time in history they had to work for their salary and status. Show off for being almighty/sarkari babu is gone. Also they could not earn unlimited through black money (they still earn but not in thousand crores 😊)
Due to on line systems , linking of Aadhaar with PAN number , on line GST, cash less money transactions , less cash in circulation etc , scope for discretionary powers of officers and thereby getting corruption money has become limited.
It's not true.
IRS officers make it sure that you as an entrepreneur, you visit them every year by mailing you a query or notice on certain transaction of a financial year.
Even you answer it online, they will not drop the notice till you meet in person and fulfill their demand despite the fact that your tax compliance is perfect.
Your tax consultant too will suggest you to be friendly with the department to minimise the nuisance from them.
On an average, 5k to be paid every year as convenient fee.
So, automation reduces only paperwork and physical submission but corruption is still there.
Its unfair to appoint ias officer officer as finance secretary .irs deserves to be finance secretary.
Really IAS r not effective to run all other departments like power,roads,agriculture,forest,health,industry,IT,environment,food processing,education n many more as we have expertise in every sector.
Health secretary Should be from upsc cms
Defence secretary should be from N.D.C
Finance secretary should from IRS
Railway board CRS should he from i.r.m.s
Cheif director for R and D must an engineer
@@sharikwaseem8028defence secretary should be from Indian Defence account services. To enroll into this service u need to complete post graduation in Economics. Now u can understand the calibre of that officer.
Well, they chose who can lead and take desisions.
The work of a finance secretary is a type of administrative work that's why IAS is preferred.
I quit from my central government engineering service in 6 years. government sector is not a sector to work now, most harrasment sector in world
😢.. Then why this much competition for all these gov exams?
Authorised rep is called the DR -Departmental representative
@@jow345lack of knowledge that prestigious feeling in neighbourhood and job security ~ me officer in govt.
I can relate with chaplusie and harassment. Government jobs are for reserved category only these days.
You are a weak person then . Be strong
Many of the promoted IRS Officers from Customs background couldn’t cope up with GST . They are the ones who are in majority out of the 850 figure.
Why they couldn't cope?
😅❤aw2 pop p😅
Scope of corruption is not there 😂😂😂
It's not the department that corrupt
It's the person that's corrupt
Doing corruption is hard to do in central gov, there are strict laws.
@@harshnaik6989 heard about ias Puja singhal ?
Shutup have you ever listen 👂👁️ , corruption bahut hai
Sir mai UPSC ka test series pahale purchase kr chuka hu fir bhi bol rhe hai purchase kro why sir.. please provide my test series
Only reason is scope of corruption and that entitled feeling faded. Great job govt for keeping these roles clean.
When it comes to complexity, the IRS daily job is nothing compared to writing machine learning algorithms daily.
And machine learning coding is nothing complex compared to neurosurgery done by we doctors
@@SourBoy-d8vAnd neurosurgery is nothing compared to quantum mechanics we study
The system needs everyone to run smoothly. So, please be respectful to other professions.
@@NewPerson101and theoretical physics is more difficult than neurosurgery
@@NewPerson101 you did him dirty 😂
Great video boss👌👌
Sir, you are not completely honest , why you left... But I can understand, you have an institute to run... IRS is the most outdated job.... Technical minds with good IQ should not even attempt UPSC.... They must earn huge money with their ability outside....
Class I are most corrupt off late due to too much job protection
Good message ! Talents of different field must promoted in respective positions, categories to deliver justice , confidence.
if you want IRS officers to be finance secretary then allow IAS officers to be Principal Commissioner of Income Tax. Mobility should be both ways.
IAS officers are generalists and are not expert in taxation how can they work as Principal Commissioner of IT. Whereas IRS officers being finance experts can do the justice with the job of finance secretary.
But would IAS officrs really want to be Pr.CsIT ?? 😂.
@ tu kya has raha hai sale majdoor teri baat ho rahi hai? 🤣
@@MangekyoSharingan313 no bro. IAS should be abolished. It's not needed.
Excellent explanation in details. You have very good knowledge which can be used in better way for the country. Regards, Arvind jha
THAT one exam differentiates us and them!
The present civil service is the continuation of of British civil service . Therefore this service is in 18th century in attitude and procedures, but nobody can reform. In 2nd Administrative reforms commission 10 th report the chairman opined that this system should be changed totally. But nothinh happened because the decision is to be taken by the same officers,that is the beauty of the system
Politician pressure bhoot jyada hain ,jo chatukar hain wahi kar sakta hain, imandar ki posting kar kar k preshan kar dete hain jab tak ki wo chatukar nahi banta
Nonsense. Pre 2014 was the age of chatukars and incompetence.
@srinivasaniyer6219 same2u
Automation has not reduced corruption
Very transparent assessment sir
Very eloquently presented👌👌
Thanks for the clarification.
Two things I could make out. 1. With computerization scope of corruption and earning big money is reduced. 2. Taxation system is so complex that corporate need intelligent people who can pay big salaries. So good people have opportunity to make big money without corruption.
Joke, corruption after computerization dropped😂😂😂
Sir my experience after 34 yrs of service most of the civil servants have an attitude of mr know all , they neither know nor are interested in knowing ground reality because of ego and i have come across 7 irs officers vry corrupt nd interested in delhi posting even at the cost of integrity rgds
understood sir please make a video describing various services and traits one must have for those particular services........Gunship out, Thank you.
Not coming out clearly why they quit
Guys don't get misguided by the news.... The no. 850 is very less compared to the population and the no. of people who get recruited
Ok ok ,thank you for the guidance ,we will not be misguided if you say so😊
Around 300 Direct IRS officers are recruited per annum. So it means 85 out 300, that is around 28% officers of the intake resigned per annum. This percentage is not huge but not low either.
The approach should be not mastering the complicated taxation law, how it can be made simple. The basic problem is there are too many grey areas leading to litigation, harassment and finally corruption. The law should be capable of only one interpretation. The focus must be this. Off course this will eliminate the craze of the aspirants.
Chartered Accountants are much more capable to deal with Taxes as compared to the IRS officers
Great. Keep it up Your spirit , BOSS 💐 GOD BLESS YOU!!
Sir, plz don't give negative comments on Licence Raj or similar taxation system available at that time. India got independence and there was everything new at that time. So what was best was was implemented. So plz improve the comments.
After face less handling of enquiries corruption has decreased. Work load increased Previous inspector use to roam on scooter. Any body building house get notice from local office and he used to collect fees and finish notice. Now game changed. With salary they can’t even build house. So they join corporate
Peple know IRS officers are leaving the service but why?
I think we should do a bit of research to find out the job these officers shifted to. We may be in for stunning facts. After digitisation authority of tax officials has significantly eroded. No appreciation no reward only targets, only chiding from higher ups frustrates them.
One's mindset and vaulting ambition lead to one's resignation. Those who resigned in the past are now weeping and creeping in front of job providers.
Sarkari naukri 2 tarah k logo k liye hoti hai:
1. Jo pel k kala dhan chori krna chahate hain
2. Jo jeewan me or kuch bhi krne layak nahi hote, jinko pata hai k iske aage kuch nahi kar paenge
Employees with less than 20 years, gets nps, not ops. And luxury of the pension has reduced, and it started reducing attraction of the job.
It is now clear that GST has made transactions complicated as indicated by a great demand for consultants in Business units.
Now I understand. Thank you!
Thanks for sharing the details providing the right understanding and clarity about this much talked about subject these days
Wishing you all the best for a great and wonderful career ahead.Thanks & Regards.
Sir, very well explained by you🙏🙏🙏
I worked for 35 yrs but things have changed gradually mainly due to digitalization.There were many like you who would speak of giving up and starting their own but never did till the end and reached to be C.C rank.
Faceless system .. no public interaction mean no curruption .. that y officers leaving gov job
"I cleared UPSC" mentioned 1 billion times. Real reason for quitting after just 10 years of service not mentioned.
Ooper ki kamaai bandh karaa di kya govt. ne?
We talk abt reservation...
IAS cadre has 100% reservation across all departments... 😂
Bro I hope u've seen the report of RTI a few days ago, that at Joint Secretary level now there are just 33% IAS whearas 67% officers are from the other services.
@@Coolboy_Amar Is Joint Secretary a head of Department?
@@WarriorOfTheSunset
Bro even Secretary is not head of any department. Secretary is the administrative head of a ministry.
Try to understand the working of a ministry. A person elected by the people heads the ministry and he/she is given a pool of officers who are like clerks of his office which is called Secretariat. The Secretariat is led by Secretary who is most of the times an IAS. So, IAS is the administrative head of the ministry and not the head actually. His role is like a seniormost clerk in the office of the minister. But being the seniormost clek he stays close to the minister and becomes most influencal since all the files put before minister are put up by him, all the phone calls are first attended by Secretary. I hope u understand.
@@Coolboy_Amar I ask you again... Is "Joint" Secretary a head of "department"? First understand the question before writing an essay...
@WarriorOfTheSunset
Bro, I've answered u a series of questions which u will ask after this question or the assumptions u will make after my one word reply of which u are already aware of.
Well the answer to ur question is NO.
Income tax, gst, customs..these are the main 3 verticals of IRS..total 850 ...so approx 280 per service resigned in 10 yrs..so approx 28 retirmnt evry yr..whr as upsc recruits almost 100 evry yr in each service..plus promotees are also thr...so 28 retirmnt per yr is not a big numbr
More and more digitisation needs to happen
Sir, really good to know that delhi has a port and you had an opportunity to work.
After Modi is at helms of affairs, corruption in customs, GST, income tax department are minimal
what kind of blasphemy ?
resigning gov service and teaching others to get into that service!
sir this edtech field is already in saturation too many competition😅
Human ambitions are bizarre.
No problem, Hire new ones fresher via UPSE...
Very good job by Govt., with AI in very field of life ,what are the use of these civil service leeches in the system?
Which service should someone choose depending on their mindsets.
excellent explanation
I have experience in both corporate sector as well as government sector. Corporate is better than government because of transparency. In government, there are so many ambiguities betwen acts and rules. They make new G.Os without sense not considering our constitution and court will quash. Many rules are nit implemented..reaseons are not known..
Yes going to courts is subordination and loss of authority. Your resignation is understood. Even I would have resigned.
Suggest to P.M to introduce faceless delivery of judgement in legal service so corruption is reduced in lower courts.
UPSC officers know nothing about Income Tax Act . It’s foolish to appoint UPSC people into Income Tax . By working one does not get knowledge.
That's why I'm not preparing for upsc...it was my good decision
Everything is online. Faceless assessment. No need for so many Commissioners, so many wards and circles. Naturally people will leave.
Simplified : - He just want to earn more through selling courses rather than taking up the service
Majority logo ne vrs liya because of More digitisation
Lesser scope of corruption these days.
Sunera deen is over for digitization era, gradually entered in our manual system which promots corruption, obviously who, habituated in old system, been quitting their service. It would be better for new generation with opened minded to be included as they're waiting for a long for darth of vacancy. Thanks.
No resources no man power but you have to give progress...24 hours accountability.
IRS and RBI officers hired by BFSI company with hefty packages.
Very good and good news.
I was watching a Turkish series on ottomans. Many Pasha's faced death sentence due to allegations of corruption. But it never proved a deterrent. There is something in human nature which holds material possessions even higher than your own life.
His fluency 🔥
Because they couldn't become IAS and IPS that's why they couldn't sustain the void inside. I also want to resign, I'm trying to find a way to earn a livelihood first.
No worries, if the employees want adventure and break out the mandane life then join R&AW, NSA and IB as Economic hitman and go to Bangladesh, Pakistan, Nepal, Maldives, Sri Lanka, US, EU, Turkey, etc and then do a good service as a spy.
No extra earning?
Paise etne kma leye hoge ki ab jrurat nhi job ki esleye
This is bcoz in vrs once u get clearance -- paat corruption cannot be investigated and u get immunity
They have made enough for their families, don't worry
Good one. But still lot to be organised
i understood sir....
IRS were enjoying their authoritarian way of life with zero output. They were all currupt. Now they are made accountable! So running away. Let them go home, if they can’t deliver
IAS has no actual role in functioning of a country. IAS should be abolished
Hope someone speak truth about the loose of corruption , everyone talks so deplomatic now a days
I don't understand
Compare it with the armed forces, the number is much less. It is a very good and positive trend.
India suddenly became developed country ,due to UPSC Staff ,but UPA rules were the worst period of central govt employees, you cannot cheat anyone but public can make earn crores of money without doing nothing , I was central government employees,what to do if your government (UPA) was acting as per Soro ,who cheated my lifelong periods earning.
Entire South states are least concern,Their target is global avenues. Times are changed.
Indian are paid how many times is unexpected.The world best rejected employee is INDIAN “IAS”
CS of Civil aviation debarred for employee , where as AIR TRAFFIC CONTROLLER IS WANTED EVERY WHERE IN THE WORLD.
Same is the case Indian petroleum ministers as well as Railways.
The most unwanted in the world is Indian IAS
The salary is not good..... For example a skilled cs engineer gets one crore per annum( more than 8 lakhs per month) at the age of 25......whats the salary of civil servant even at 50 ?
@@anilkumarn.m3252 instead of comparing with private sector salaries for a few, comparison should be with civil servant salaries in other countries ( with ppp). Our average per capita income also should be remembered.
Salary is salary...... to lead a luxurious life and to brighten the life of future generations a good salary/ income is a must....... I think that one can become the civil servant of another country only after getting citizen ship there
@@anilkumarn.m3252 ??
Purchasing parity is different.
Competitive exam guys won't be able to beat the heat of realities 😂😂😂
WHATEVER sir You should not have left the IRS SERVICES,After all GOVT JOB GOVT JOB hi hota h
Kejariwaal also was IRS officer,
Yes they r quitting as no money making model 😢
Sir mai UPSC ka test pahale purchase kr chuka hu fir bhi bol rhe hai purchase kro why sir.. please provide my test series
Right decision uv tkn
Jo bhi brother why leave department
Jai Hind!🇮🇳
Becoz they will become ias.. They need time to prepare
Sir ,can you make videos on different services.
मोडी जी ने कहा ही था ना खाऊंगा ना खाने दूंगा।
खाने को मिलेगा नहीं तो नौकरी छोड़ेंगे ही ।
😂😂😂
Simple hai... Jo kamaya hai us ko use bhi to karna hai 😂
Delhi port hain ?
Too much political intereference.
Do we have a port in Delhi????!!! 07:55
@@Renusri12 airport
@Rishabh-s3b thank you
First time in history they had to work for their salary and status. Show off for being almighty/sarkari babu is gone. Also they could not earn unlimited through black money (they still earn but not in thousand crores 😊)