I'm a HUGE Band-Maid fan and would like to believe that this has some merit; but as a developer, I also know that AI has little to no ability to objectively rank matters involving human subjectivity and human aesthetic experience. Run this on an AI with different constraints and get a different answer.
That is true and I found AI to also be somewhat inconsistent as well. As when presented as a statement and not a question. The AI seems to struggle with a correct answer. It's interesting but agree with your assessment. Wonder what K-Pop rankings would be? 🤔 Expect a war to break out over this one lol. 🗡💀
Generally I think ranking lists are clickbait, but having AI do it is a clever idea. I've seen all these bands live (if Babymetal is a “band”). Inevitably bands will be left off, such as Gacharic Spin, who put on a live show second to none. Show-Ya signed with a major record label in 1985; Cyntia were the first among the 2000s "metal boom" bands to do so, as stated. Scandal were very influential for their business model--in their heyday they were everywhere: primetime t v shows, commercials, radio programs, anime tieups, etc, etc. As far as the Japanese general public goes, Scandal and Princess Princess would be the most recognizable. Show-Ya and Aldious were influential more musically. This list just scratches the surface--there can't be another country with anywhere near the variety and quality of all-female bands, even more so if you add jazz-fusion, and many many fine classical musicians too for that matter.
@DRoberts-we2vg I got into Babymetal after going to the club gigs of the Kami Band members, particularly Mikio Fujioka. Still do--saw Takayoshi Ohmura's birthday show with Gacharic Spin in December. Fujioka, Ohmura, Leda of the KB have been teachers/mentors to some of the members of the other bands on this list, such as Tomo-zo, Hazuki, Midori, Kanami.
If it was a list of just metal bands I would pick Lovebites. In the genre of all rock I pick Band Maid.By the way the commenters who say metal isn’t rock I give you this from Wiki. New genres that emerged from this scene included progressive rock, which extended the artistic elements;[4] glam rock, which highlighted showmanship and visual style;[5] and the diverse and enduring major subgenre of heavy metal, which emphasized volume, power, and speed.
Was hoping to see Hanbie on the list. I was surprised that Baby Metal was only #5, and Lovebites only #4. I assumed Band-Maid and Scandal would be in the top 3, but I didn't think Hanbie would be and I couldn't imagine what other band it would pick. Completely forgot about Aldious, but that makes perfect sense, totally fair.
The criteria seems a bit off as Hanabie hasn't even been around that long. I enjoy them certainly and in my top 5 but 3? Babymetal absolutely should have been higher. They have been around longer then almost all on this list. Except for Scandal, Show-Ya and a few i haven't even heard of. However, the lack of Destrose was very glaring. Half of these bands wouldn't have existed without Captain Mina's Destrose. Her current band Fate Gear is on another level altogether. "Kill The Shaddow King" is their latest single & is a masterpiece. Which features Nana & Hime on vocals, so people need to do themselves a favor and check them out. 🤘🦊🔥
LOVEBITES is #1! And it ain't even close! All others are great and can be ranked in any order you would like. Where are Bridear and Hanabie? I got Nemophila at #2 btw.
Band-Maid is #1 for me. It’s always about the song and BM has so many quality songs. IMO BM’s formula for writing songs and their vocals put them at the top. As far as I’m concerned AI got the best band right, the rest could have gone differently, but I enjoy them all.
Band-Maid wouldn't be my #1, but I can't complain about putting them on top. What I will complain about is leaving Hanabie and Gacharic Spin off the list.
That was very interesting, they have no shortage of rock bands. I am 60 and love hard rock, but been very disillusioned with what has been around. Loved the Aussie rock when younger, then went back to listening to the classics, Nighwish, Rammstein, Led Zeppelin, Pink Floyd, Queen, etc. but about 3 months ago I found Band-Maid, absolutely stunned, do not know how it took me so long for our paths to cross as I am continually looking for great music, yes I think that I listened to nearly every band on this list before them and was very impressed. But they are the greatest band I have ever heard. They do not sing dud songs and the lyrics are very thougthful and impressive. Long live the little genius pigeon.
My hats off to the ladies of Japan period... Lovebites is my favorite among the bands but I also enjoy and respect the talent that is evolving out of Japan's rock scene... (screw the main stream genre crap.)
Band-Maid is at the top of my list, happy to see TRiDENT on there as well, but Show Ya is one I have been meaning to check out more of . They are from my era and they are still out there performing.
pretty good list. glad SCANDAL got some well deserved love - after all they do hold the all time record in the guinness book for longest lasting female band with the same members at an incredible 19 years this coming august. but to me LOVEBITES has got to claim the number one spot with BAND MAID nipping at their heels. and the omission of the legendary DESTROSE is a crime imo. formed in 2005 by captain mina - minako nakamura - they were the standard for all female metal bands with many other amazing bands formed by the many different members over their 10 year run. and 20 years later the captain is still going strong with FATE GEAR
When I read certain comments, I have the impression of witnessing a fight between supporters of candidates for the Miss France election (choose your country). It's so pathetic.😏
For me it will always be BABYMETAL no.1 they were the band that got me into female Japanese rock. Also where are Passcode, Mellows & Giltyxgilty on the list. AND no HANABIE.!!!! Absolutely criminal in my view!!!
Not a terrible list, but there are a few things I'd change. 1. Baby Metal should not be on the list at all. I know that will pass people off, but it is what it is. They are simply idols, not a band. The girls don't play any instruments and their actual band is all men, most of whom aren't Japanese either. They simply do not meet any of the criteria. 2. Aldious is ranked way too high. I'm not saying they shouldn't be on the list, but no way should they be higher than Lovebites or Nemophila.
Interesting, fun exercise. Glad Band-Maid was at the top - because it's my personal favorite. All of these bands are amazing, and someone will find a personal favorite among them depending on their taste.
interesting review. for some reason, Lovebites is called a power metal band. although the band members say about themselves that they are a heavy metal band. singer Asami shouts from the stage at every concert: we are Lovebites and we play heavy metal. in addition to speed, neoclassical and power metal, their repertoire includes progressive metal songs. 15% of Lovebites songs are thrash metal
@SteveBalderrama in that case you should also call Iron Maiden a power metal band. because a huge number of people who hear Lovebites for the first time compare their style, first of all, with Iron Maiden. including Iron Maiden fans from Europe and America, who have been fans of IM for 30-40 years. Asami is called the female version of Bruce Dickinson. if in the songs The Crusade, Golden Destination and many others Asami's voice is replaced with Bruce's voice, then the fans will say that it is Iron Maiden )
@@SteveBalderrama listen carefully to the songs Break the Wall, Thunder Vengeance, M.D.O., Dissonance, Paranoia, Where's Identity, etc. this is typical thrash metal. the same can be said about a huge number of other songs of this band: progressive, neoclassical, speed metal or various combinations of these genres, often with the addition of elements of classical music, as in symphonic metal. if you call a song by Stand and Deliver power metal, then you'll have to call Motorhead a power metal band )
@@SteveBalderrama if you say that Dancing with the Devil is power metal, then you should say that Deep Purple is a power metal band. which the members of the band will be very surprised )
Me too, not my cup of tea. Prefer "metal" sound & style more. Having said that, as an avid Japanese rock & metal listener for more than 25 years, I still support Band-maid journey.
I agree. Like the songs are fine and I certainly wouldn't turn it off if their song was playing in the radio. But it just doesn't pull me in like many groups from japan do.
I like Band-Maid better then Lovebites however. I just can't get used to Asami's voice. She is a great power vocalist but is not as devese as let's say Suzuka or maybe Mayu from Nemophila. Band-Maid has improved a lot of the last year. So I like them at lot more then I used to.
I asked ChatGPT, too, and it went like this: 1. Band-Maid Genre: Hard Rock/Alternative Rock Known for their "maid café" aesthetic paired with intense rock performances. Band-Maid combines powerful guitar riffs, energetic drumming, and strong vocals to create their unique sound. 2. Babymetal Genre: Kawaii Metal (Fusion of J-Pop and Metal) A pioneering group in "kawaii metal," Babymetal combines heavy metal instrumentation with idol-style vocals. While not entirely a traditional "band," they have become global sensations. 3. Lovebites Genre: Power Metal Known for their high-speed, technically skilled power metal. Lovebites has been compared to classic European metal bands and is admired for their musicianship. 4. Aldious Genre: Melodic Metal/Power Metal Often credited as one of the bands that revived the Japanese all-female metal scene. Aldious delivers a blend of melody and heaviness with intricate guitar work and catchy hooks. 5. Scandal Genre: Pop Rock/Alternative Rock While more pop-rock than metal, Scandal is one of Japan's most famous all-female rock bands. They are known for their catchy songs and dynamic performances. 6. Mary's Blood Genre: Heavy Metal/Power Metal A metal band featuring powerful vocals, shredding guitars, and a heavier sound, Mary's Blood has gained a dedicated following within Japan's metal community. 7. Nemophila Genre: Heavy Metal/Hard Rock A rising force in Japanese metal, Nemophila is known for their heavy sound, versatile vocals, and high-energy performances. 8. Show-Ya Genre: Hard Rock/Heavy Metal Active since the 1980s, Show-Ya is one of the first successful all-female Japanese rock bands. They are known for their classic hard rock sound with a strong stage presence. 9. Silent Siren Genre: Pop Rock With a more pop-oriented sound, Silent Siren still holds a strong place in Japan's rock scene. They mix upbeat melodies with rock elements. 10. Bridear Genre: Melodic Metal/Progressive Metal Bridear is known for their progressive metal sound and sophisticated compositions. They combine melody, power, and technical skill. Honorable Mentions: Exist†trace (Gothic/Visual Kei Rock) Gacharic Spin (Funk Rock/Pop Rock) Cyntia (Melodic Metal) Fate Gear (Steampunk Power Metal) Each of these bands has its unique style, blending traditional rock and metal elements with their own cultural and aesthetic influences.
Since Babymetal virtually created the entire Kawaii-metal genre, and is damn near the ONLY act still in the genre now, I would have put them much higher than #5
@@colingardiner6697 I agree with you. 🙏Although, if you look at it objectively, in Japan there are many talented musicians and great bands of different musical genres.
Aldious over Lovebites is surprising (the Lovebites fanbase seems more active), but not shocking (I like Aldious more, even if Lovebites guiterists are very impressive, maybe because Aldious songs are in japanese)
I'd list Lovebites as being #1, Nemophila #2, East of Eden #3, and Band-Maid #4. Babymetal shouldn't even be on this list since the actual musicians are all male. They should be at the top of some other list.
Definitely not in the top 10 as far as myself & friends are concerned. Scandal makes since as an early adaptor which i remember growing up with. Show-Ya my parents would remember. However, it didn't even have Destrose which kinda lost some respect for me lol. Which everyone from LoveBites, Lonesome Blue, Nemophila, Aldious, Mary's Blood. Along with Mardelas, Albion, and now Fate Gear have their orgions in. Fate Gear being Destrose founder Captain Mina's current epic band. Which is currently in my top 5 bands easily. Along with Babymetal, Band-Maid, Nemophila, Lovebites & Hanabie. I would be interested to know what criteria the Ai used as seems outdated & stuck in another era. Band-Maid was at least in its proper place.
@@albertcornett7408 Technically they aren't rock either so Lovebites and Nemophila shouldn't be on the list either if you want to get strict with the wording of the title.
@@albertcornett7408 Babymetal is an all-female group whose members only sing and dance. if we talk about concerts, then it is correct to talk about joint concerts of Babymetal (vocals and dances) and Kami Band (musicians)
No problem with this list.......all were good choices. And the "pecking order" was pretty good too; although, I would have had Nemophila a few spots higher.
Gee, but some reality, please. Princess Princess is like something an AI would make using a Casio keyboard. Cyntia at least has 80s glam rock down, which oddly is an enormous step up from #10. Nemophila yanks it up a ton, cancelling out the cliche and repetitive guitar stumming for actual talent worthy of the new millennium. Show-ya emerged in the 80s and sounds like the 80s, which is one reason why I hated the 80s so much. Calling Babymetal an all-female band is fraud. Hey, have some respect for the Kami Band, as in, the band is the Kami Band. Finally, Lovebites, which is right up there in the same millennium with Nemophila, worthy of the props. Aldious set a trend early, so they deserve more notice than they get. Scandal is...famous. I'll leave it at that. Kind of reminds me of why so many all-female bands leave a bland taste in the mouth for not being particularly good on the instruments, but very good on the show (for lack of a better word). By the time this AI gets to Band Maid, I'm super ready for it. Great songs, great arrangements, innovative approaches to mixing those chops together, great stage presence, unrelenting professionalism, and everybody can play well. Night and day the top on this list. Which incidentally completely neglected to include several outstanding all-female Japanese bands that I'd put in front of most of this: Hanabie, Doll$boxx, Gacharic Spin, Fern Planet, White Flame....
Announcement: "Whoever can provide convincing evidence that BABYMETAL is not an all-female band will receive $10,000 from me". 😊 BABYMETAL is a 100% female band consisting of three ladies who dance and sing.Try to prove otherwise. If you can do it, I will transfer $10,000 to your bank account. P.S. If we are talking about concerts, then it would be more correct to say that these are BABYMETAL & KAMI BAND concerts.
Was it the same scam site that had Suzuka from BABYMETAL to win best metal singer award for 2024? If it was the site had no legitimacy and it was just a front for fishing peoples information:D
@@Tyyppl I'd still choose Lovebites that's just my type of Metal I love Asami's voice especially when they do slower songs and her R&B voice is more prominent
@@Tyyppl Band Maid also is high on my list ever since I listened to Warning MV with Kanami on the vehicle and Hate? who can argue with a Lead Guitar and Bass Solo duel that is so amazing and I know they have been going since 2013 and deserve all credit they get
Don't pay attention. I've already talked to this person (Tyyppl). 😊 He just treats fans of LOVEBITES very badly, I would even say biasedly and arrogantly. That's why he writes such and similar comments under the comments of fans of LOVEBITES. He has zero facts, but an arrogant attitude towards LOVEBITES fans = 100%.
@@JuanGomez-dk6kf Popularity doesn’t always equal good. Baby Metal isn’t an all female rock band. On a list if most popular idol bands Baby Metal is one of the top on that list.
It's a respectable list. I'd take off Babymetal for technical reasons, (not being an actual "band") and slip in Gacharic Spin somewhere. I'd also like to see Hanabie on there, but they still have a lower song output than most of the others. I'd stick Shishimo on there too but they aren't well known in the West, and I've a feeling that the AI was skewing the results towards bands known in the West. At least it got the #1 spot right!
Good point about Shishamo, they're not heavy enough, cute enough, punk enough or technical enough to register with western rock fans. They're very much a Japanese band for Japanese people.
I have never heard of Cyntia at number 9. Most time given to the number 2 band on this list, why? I remember when puri-puri came out and instantly was into them, but not as much as Band Maid. Not sure what criteria was used either. Zone, Stereopony, or even Mutant Monster could be on this list.
Seamos sinceros, sin Babymetal nadie estaria interesado en la musica rock o metal del Japon, ellas han sido las punta de lanza para que algunas bandas japonesas sean conocidas e invitadas a los principales festivales europeos, es cosa de ver si alguna banda de la lista habria hecho sold out en sus 4 conciertos debut en sudamerica como lo hizo Babymetal en Brasil, Colombia, Peru y Chile
Great bit of fun having AI create the list. Most of what i expected in the list. Some of the positions were a surprise. Like the narrator said, he was unsure what criteria was used to make the list. Pure fame BabyMetal are number 1, because they don't play any instruments, then they don't make the list at all. Band-Maid number 1? For me and every other maidiac, then yes but in reality, probably not. Though they are one of the most reacted to bands did that count? Would have been nice to see the reasoning behind the list. Still enjoyable and great to see a mix of old and new. Haven't listened to Scandal in a minute off to fire that up.
Actually they do play instruments but just haven't as part of BabyMetal. Moa has played guitar since she was in 4th grade. Suzuka plays piano of which she did perform once. This is the fault of Koba and Amuze not taking advantage of their talents. I agree though with Band-Maid. Scandal is recommend but are a aquired taste as they border on grunge more i think.
@BlazinNSoul I was only hashing out reasons not complaining. I'm a massive BabyMetal fan and know they play instruments. I even listened to the recent interview they did with Atarashi Gakko and I'm going to see them play in a few months. In Germany because I'm on holiday 2 days before the London show. Like I said I doubt AI knows all the cool things the fans do. Love your passion though.
Tried same exercise, with chatGpt too, and get this list (first position anyway goes to... 😊) 1. Band-Maid 2. SCANDAL 3. Aldious 4. Lovebites 5. Shonen Knife 6. Nemophila 7. Silent Siren 8. Show-Ya 9. Tricot 10. Zettai Club
El publico que le gusta a Band Maid son puros viejos que se calientan viendo a mujeres disfrazadas de mucamas, mientras que el publico de Babymetal es mucho mas diverso.
Who is the biggest Japanese band male or female worldwide? BABYMETAL. Who has the best singer? BABYMETAL. All these other bands fit into one genre or another. BABYMETAL (well, Koba-Metal) created their own genre, unlike anything done before. Everything about BABYMETAL is so far ahead of these other bands, from stage show to production values to marketing and every other aspect of the project. Koba-Metal is the greatest manager since Peter Grant of Zeppelin fame. And before all the BABYMETAL haters start telling me they aren't a band or they aren't metal, yes BABYMETAL isn't a "band" more of a "concept" but so what? It's hugely successful, both in Japan 🇯🇵 and around the world. Band Maid and Lovebites are good bands, but I highly doubt they are playing to the same size crowds as BABYMETAL in Japan, and I know they aren't anywhere else. And BABYMETAL ARE METAL!!! My favorite band is MANOWAR so I know what True Metal is. And BABYMETAL my friends, IS True Metal 🤘 KITSUMES UP
Pretty sure One Ok Rock for example is bigger than babymetal worldwide (atleast they do a bit bigger venues than babymetal does) But for just female bands I agree that BABYMETAL is the biggest worldwide.
@@brenthatcher5748 As I said One Ok Rock. They are a stadium sized band in Japan and even outside of Japan they draw bigger crowds than even babymetal (atleast in Asia, and South America and in the US and Europe the crowds are pretty similar size). Not really my type of music but they are massive.
Is AI able of feeling music as much as a human being? I doubt it. Regardless, it's an interesting idea. However, among rock bands, sorry but I see one that is not, IMO (despite all the respect I have for them): Babymetal. Kami band is the rock band. Otherwise we have to redefine what a rock band is. Therefore, why wouldn't PassCode, Broken by the Scream, Bish be part of it? Good job Venus Gaijin.
My favorite would be Aldious they have zero bad songs, zero fillers, in fact had they been around in the 80s and sang in English they would have dominated the charts . Show -Ya would be # 2 because they are from the 80s and played 80s style songs like Def Leppard and Motley Crue ... and had at least one song I remember hearing in the US back then. Lovebites # 3 love just about all their songs. Band Maid # 4 But after that I would have picked Stereopony, Bridear, Destrose, Doll$Boxx, Hagane and Hanabie. Love the rest of the bands on the this list though ..... its tough to narrow down to just a top ten.
First off Band-Maid IS a rock band where as some of the bands on the list are Metal bands. Try the same thing again, but use the words metal bands instead of rock band.
If the Ai can't distinguish between Rock and Metal it's not going to be able to distinguish between Metal and Rock. Just be happy that Nogi46 isn't on the list.
Pretty good ranking. Gacharic Spin is missing. Babymetal is not an all female band (it is, technically, but… no). I had also ranked Band-Maid number one (by far).
You don't know LOVEBITES fans well if you write something like that. You probably judge by yourself. I am a LOVEBITES fan and I am not disappointed at all. Regardless of its results, I will choose LOVEBITES over any other band.
I know what you mean but I think those are just basement technical playing elitists. I went to see LBs wearing a B-M shirt and the audience was very cool and accepting. I went to the pre-party and most travel for many Japanese Bands.
@@GrayFox14 Pretty sure you don't just know your own fandom. Even in this comment section there are LOVEBITES fans downplaying other bands and saying how LOVEBITES is easily the greatest ever. Lovebites has easily the most toxic fanbase out of all the japanese metalgroups:D
@@Tyyppl This is your opinion. Fans of any bands can be "toxic". That's to put it in your language. I had to communicate with fans of different bands, including under this reaction. For some of these fans, the word "toxic" is even putting it very mildly. A complete lack of logic, unwillingness (or inability) to understand and comprehend the information. All this is replaced by attempts to insult those with whom they communicate. And all this was not done by fans of LOVEBITES!)))) For me, LOVEBITES is also the best band. In my list of favorite bands, LOVEBITES are number 1. I wrote a comment that I think so under this reaction. Did I insult anyone by doing this? Am I one of "the most toxic fanbase" because I expressed my opinion? Fans of other bands also consider their favorite bands to be the best. They have the right to do so. The main thing is not who considers which band to be the best. Different people have different musical tastes and habits. Therefore, they will always have different opinions about which band is the best. The main thing is that the person does not insult fans of other bands.
Naturally,sissy.Like u r man enough 2 handle DESTROSE,MARY'S BLOOD,BRIDEAR,NEMO,LIPSTICK.I bet u put those maid costumes while listening 2 their girlie rock n roll.
Akane&Misa will start a great band themselves.Miku will go back 2 her loser waitress job n kanami will follow suit(she needs a job).The other one will probably land up as a JAV prospect. Edit: So how's tht fer being no.1.
I've always viewed BabyMetal as a 'idol' group with a backup band. Hanabie, Gacharic Spin, Flip, Existrace are big influences for me. Never liked Aldious (vocals turned me off), but generally, okay list.
No. 5? Get real. No other Japanese band is as unique, groundbreaking and genre diverse as BABYMETAL. And no band has every artist and their brother waiting for a chance to work with them.
@ and you're technically not qualified to give an expert opinion about what determines a band. Now go back and try to deny my original comment without being obtuse.
@@rah2287 What qualifications do you require to tell the difference between a male and a female? Do you also require a veterinarian license to tell the difference between a cat and a dog?
This proves A.I is not ready for the real world yet 😜 , Lovebites are clearly a cut above every band in terms of ability and skill and the list is missing Bridear, Hanabie, Marys Blood, Destrose and Passcode
I'm a HUGE Band-Maid fan and would like to believe that this has some merit; but as a developer, I also know that AI has little to no ability to objectively rank matters involving human subjectivity and human aesthetic experience. Run this on an AI with different constraints and get a different answer.
That is true and I found AI to also be somewhat inconsistent as well. As when presented as a statement and not a question. The AI seems to struggle with a correct answer. It's interesting but agree with your assessment. Wonder what K-Pop rankings would be? 🤔 Expect a war to break out over this one lol. 🗡💀
I'd list #1 Lovebites, #2 Nemophila, #3 Unlucky Morpheus
Generally I think ranking lists are clickbait, but having AI do it is a clever idea. I've seen all these bands live (if Babymetal is a “band”). Inevitably bands will be left off, such as Gacharic Spin, who put on a live show second to none. Show-Ya signed with a major record label in 1985; Cyntia were the first among the 2000s "metal boom" bands to do so, as stated. Scandal were very influential for their business model--in their heyday they were everywhere: primetime t v shows, commercials, radio programs, anime tieups, etc, etc. As far as the Japanese general public goes, Scandal and Princess Princess would be the most recognizable. Show-Ya and Aldious were influential more musically. This list just scratches the surface--there can't be another country with anywhere near the variety and quality of all-female bands, even more so if you add jazz-fusion, and many many fine classical musicians too for that matter.
👍Great comment. 🖖❤
@IAMisLove Thank you. 🤘🎶
BABYMETAL definitely a band in my opinion. With Kami Band as there backing band.
@DRoberts-we2vg I got into Babymetal after going to the club gigs of the Kami Band members, particularly Mikio Fujioka. Still do--saw Takayoshi Ohmura's birthday show with Gacharic Spin in December. Fujioka, Ohmura, Leda of the KB have been teachers/mentors to some of the members of the other bands on this list, such as Tomo-zo, Hazuki, Midori, Kanami.
Pathetic @@DRoberts-we2vg
If it was a list of just metal bands I would pick Lovebites. In the genre of all rock I pick Band Maid.By the way the commenters who say metal isn’t rock I give you this from Wiki.
New genres that emerged from this scene included progressive rock, which extended the artistic elements;[4] glam rock, which highlighted showmanship and visual style;[5] and the diverse and enduring major subgenre of heavy metal, which emphasized volume, power, and speed.
Was hoping to see Hanbie on the list. I was surprised that Baby Metal was only #5, and Lovebites only #4. I assumed Band-Maid and Scandal would be in the top 3, but I didn't think Hanbie would be and I couldn't imagine what other band it would pick. Completely forgot about Aldious, but that makes perfect sense, totally fair.
The criteria seems a bit off as Hanabie hasn't even been around that long. I enjoy them certainly and in my top 5 but 3? Babymetal absolutely should have been higher. They have been around longer then almost all on this list.
Except for Scandal, Show-Ya and a few i haven't even heard of. However, the lack of Destrose was very glaring. Half of these bands wouldn't have existed without Captain Mina's Destrose.
Her current band Fate Gear is on another level altogether. "Kill The Shaddow King" is their latest single & is a masterpiece. Which features Nana & Hime on vocals, so people need to do themselves a favor and check them out. 🤘🦊🔥
I love heavy metal, LOVEBITES #1 always. That simple for me. All good / great bands btw. 🤘
LOVEBITES is #1! And it ain't even close! All others are great and can be ranked in any order you would like. Where are Bridear and Hanabie? I got Nemophila at #2 btw.
@@BRIDON777 BS!!!
Not fer long b 4 they bite the dust.Fami will leave the band.Asami will suffer gullet cancer.Miyako loses 2 hands in n automobile accident🤭
I agree on every point
@@BRIDON777 On a list of only metal bands but this not a list of only metal bands.
What were the criteria for the search? Was it find the bands and rank on your own? There are a lot of variables in computer programs.
This list has given me bands to check out. Thanks.
Band-Maid is #1 for me. It’s always about the song and BM has so many quality songs. IMO BM’s formula for writing songs and their vocals put them at the top. As far as I’m concerned AI got the best band right, the rest could have gone differently, but I enjoy them all.
Would fit Gacharic Spin and Hitsujibungaku in there somewhere. Is Babymetal technically a band?
Yes BABYMETAL are a band!!!!
@@DRoberts-we2vg they are just a singing group with some dudes in sheets backing them up, they are not a band
@@bigdambluesband6295 so any singer in a band isn't in a band then?! Freddie Mercury wasn't in Queen then? Etc.
@@bigdambluesband6295 They're a band. The "dudes in sheets" are unbelievable musicians. Look up Anthony Barone the US Kami band drummer.
@@syrtycon7299 Nope.
Band-Maid wouldn't be my #1, but I can't complain about putting them on top. What I will complain about is leaving Hanabie and Gacharic Spin off the list.
@@xovaqiin4844 I'm thinking the same thing. I'm not sure if I would even count Babymetal.
That was very interesting, they have no shortage of rock bands. I am 60 and love hard rock, but been very disillusioned with what has been around. Loved the Aussie rock when younger, then went back to listening to the classics, Nighwish, Rammstein, Led Zeppelin, Pink Floyd, Queen, etc. but about 3 months ago I found Band-Maid, absolutely stunned, do not know how it took me so long for our paths to cross as I am continually looking for great music, yes I think that I listened to nearly every band on this list before them and was very impressed. But they are the greatest band I have ever heard. They do not sing dud songs and the lyrics are very thougthful and impressive. Long live the little genius pigeon.
Well said...well said! ❤️🔥🤘
@@davidbicket7201 I agree 100%!!! Madiac for life!!!
My hats off to the ladies of Japan period...
Lovebites is my favorite among the bands but I also enjoy and respect the talent that is evolving out of Japan's rock scene... (screw the main stream genre crap.)
NEMOPHILA 💯🎇✨
For fun, I asked Deepseek A.I. the same question. They replied the following:
1. Shonen Knife
2. Scandal
3. Band-Maid
4. Gacharic Spin
5. Aldious
6. Destrose
7. Lovebites
8. Mary's Blood
9. Shishamo
10. Chatmonchy
I would add Trident, Nek! and East of Eden.
@@albertcornett7408you mean if you were AI?
Shonen Knife are more Alt-Rock than Metal.
Sure. But the original question is "rock bands" not "metal bands". So i just typed in the same.
Love them too. Other than Trident, they are all really new. They haven't showed any staying power yet. @@albertcornett7408
Band-Maid is at the top of my list, happy to see TRiDENT on there as well, but Show Ya is one I have been meaning to check out more of . They are from my era and they are still out there performing.
pretty good list. glad SCANDAL got some well deserved love - after all they do hold the all time record in the guinness book for longest lasting female band with the same members at an incredible 19 years this coming august. but to me LOVEBITES has got to claim the number one spot with BAND MAID nipping at their heels. and the omission of the legendary DESTROSE is a crime imo. formed in 2005 by captain mina - minako nakamura - they were the standard for all female metal bands with many other amazing bands formed by the many different members over their 10 year run. and 20 years later the captain is still going strong with FATE GEAR
I agree with your assessment.
When I read certain comments, I have the impression of witnessing a fight between supporters of candidates for the Miss France election (choose your country). It's so pathetic.😏
Sauf que pour une fois ce sont bien les meilleures qui gagnent 😀
For me it will always be BABYMETAL no.1 they were the band that got me into female Japanese rock. Also where are Passcode, Mellows & Giltyxgilty on the list. AND no HANABIE.!!!! Absolutely criminal in my view!!!
Babymetal isn't rock band!
Ooo u r such a baby❤
@@13uomini they sing rock music..therefore a rock band
@@13uomini They're rock/metal ish.. The song Iine! changes genres like 4 times.
@@DRoberts-we2vg Lady Gaga sings some rock songs so she is a rock band?
😂😂😂😂😂😂
So the 2024 power metal band of the year is only #4……..just shows you why we shouldn’t trust machines and algorithms.
@@MrTraindriver1970 On a list of only metal bands I agree Lovebites is number one.
Not a terrible list, but there are a few things I'd change.
1. Baby Metal should not be on the list at all. I know that will pass people off, but it is what it is. They are simply idols, not a band. The girls don't play any instruments and their actual band is all men, most of whom aren't Japanese either. They simply do not meet any of the criteria.
2. Aldious is ranked way too high. I'm not saying they shouldn't be on the list, but no way should they be higher than Lovebites or Nemophila.
Interesting, fun exercise. Glad Band-Maid was at the top - because it's my personal favorite. All of these bands are amazing, and someone will find a personal favorite among them depending on their taste.
U r n example for those bias,toxic ravenous wolves with their maddicks in tow,2 follow.Period.
バントメイドや、花冷えさん女性の、ロックバントは、好きです
はい。 なぜハナビエはいないのですか？🤔
WTF is bunt? stooOpid
@@IMetalHead777 Band. Not stupid. Simply a bad translation.
For me BABYMETAL will always be the Number one, followed by Lovebites.
@@cyberbrynnhildr1053 Not a band.
@@cyberbrynnhildr1053 yeah, some people like that J-pop with a metal band.
実力ではlove bitesが大きく抜き出てる
世界的にはBabyMetalだろうけど
interesting review. for some reason, Lovebites is called a power metal band. although the band members say about themselves that they are a heavy metal band. singer Asami shouts from the stage at every concert: we are Lovebites and we play heavy metal. in addition to speed, neoclassical and power metal, their repertoire includes progressive metal songs. 15% of Lovebites songs are thrash metal
@@pilgrim000 my personal ear test tends to also call them a predominantly power metal band.
@SteveBalderrama in that case you should also call Iron Maiden a power metal band. because a huge number of people who hear Lovebites for the first time compare their style, first of all, with Iron Maiden. including Iron Maiden fans from Europe and America, who have been fans of IM for 30-40 years. Asami is called the female version of Bruce Dickinson. if in the songs The Crusade, Golden Destination and many others Asami's voice is replaced with Bruce's voice, then the fans will say that it is Iron Maiden )
@@SteveBalderrama listen carefully to the songs Break the Wall, Thunder Vengeance, M.D.O., Dissonance, Paranoia, Where's Identity, etc. this is typical thrash metal. the same can be said about a huge number of other songs of this band: progressive, neoclassical, speed metal or various combinations of these genres, often with the addition of elements of classical music, as in symphonic metal. if you call a song by Stand and Deliver power metal, then you'll have to call Motorhead a power metal band )
@@SteveBalderrama if you say that Dancing with the Devil is power metal, then you should say that Deep Purple is a power metal band. which the members of the band will be very surprised )
@@pilgrim000 LB is power metal as a whole, yes they do lean into some thrash/symphonic/prog. So did power metal bands of the 80's/90's
The importend thing is: Listen to the Music you love. All Band are great in the genre they are playing. Have Fun and enjoy
Best comment.Problem is,the toxic,rabid F!@$%ing fanatics of the respective bands spoil it big time.😡🤬👎
I cant be the only Asian music enjoyer who does not enjoy Band-Maid. I get why people would, but not my cup of tea.
Me too, not my cup of tea.
Prefer "metal" sound & style more.
Having said that, as an avid Japanese rock & metal listener for more than 25 years, I still support Band-maid journey.
Once in a while u get folks who talk sense.I cherish those moments.
I agree. Like the songs are fine and I certainly wouldn't turn it off if their song was playing in the radio. But it just doesn't pull me in like many groups from japan do.
I like Band-Maid better then Lovebites however. I just can't get used to Asami's voice. She is a great power vocalist but is not as devese as let's say Suzuka or maybe Mayu from Nemophila. Band-Maid has improved a lot of the last year. So I like them at lot more then I used to.
you're not alone!
I asked ChatGPT, too, and it went like this:
1. Band-Maid
Genre: Hard Rock/Alternative Rock
Known for their "maid café" aesthetic paired with intense rock performances. Band-Maid combines powerful guitar riffs, energetic drumming, and strong vocals to create their unique sound.
2. Babymetal
Genre: Kawaii Metal (Fusion of J-Pop and Metal)
A pioneering group in "kawaii metal," Babymetal combines heavy metal instrumentation with idol-style vocals. While not entirely a traditional "band," they have become global sensations.
3. Lovebites
Genre: Power Metal
Known for their high-speed, technically skilled power metal. Lovebites has been compared to classic European metal bands and is admired for their musicianship.
4. Aldious
Genre: Melodic Metal/Power Metal
Often credited as one of the bands that revived the Japanese all-female metal scene. Aldious delivers a blend of melody and heaviness with intricate guitar work and catchy hooks.
5. Scandal
Genre: Pop Rock/Alternative Rock
While more pop-rock than metal, Scandal is one of Japan's most famous all-female rock bands. They are known for their catchy songs and dynamic performances.
6. Mary's Blood
Genre: Heavy Metal/Power Metal
A metal band featuring powerful vocals, shredding guitars, and a heavier sound, Mary's Blood has gained a dedicated following within Japan's metal community.
7. Nemophila
Genre: Heavy Metal/Hard Rock
A rising force in Japanese metal, Nemophila is known for their heavy sound, versatile vocals, and high-energy performances.
8. Show-Ya
Genre: Hard Rock/Heavy Metal
Active since the 1980s, Show-Ya is one of the first successful all-female Japanese rock bands. They are known for their classic hard rock sound with a strong stage presence.
9. Silent Siren
Genre: Pop Rock
With a more pop-oriented sound, Silent Siren still holds a strong place in Japan's rock scene. They mix upbeat melodies with rock elements.
10. Bridear
Genre: Melodic Metal/Progressive Metal
Bridear is known for their progressive metal sound and sophisticated compositions. They combine melody, power, and technical skill.
Honorable Mentions:
Exist†trace (Gothic/Visual Kei Rock)
Gacharic Spin (Funk Rock/Pop Rock)
Cyntia (Melodic Metal)
Fate Gear (Steampunk Power Metal)
Each of these bands has its unique style, blending traditional rock and metal elements with their own cultural and aesthetic influences.
Number one doesn't change. So AI makes sense. He has feelings, he loves Maids.😉❤😆
What a f@@#%&*ing load of rubbish.
That's more what I expected except for Silent Siren. I know they had decent success domestically the first time around.
I enjoyed the list because Band-Maid is my favorite band. I'm sure the list is missing some for someone, but that is just like the list by others.
KOIAI 🤘
この手のやつは、意見わかれるわなぁ
🤘🤘🤘🐺🐺🐺💥LOVEBITES rules! Now and forever!
Disband by end of 2025 .Fer sure❤🤟💥
@@IMetalHead777 Bollocks!
@@kristiansavov6528 BS!!!
Nevermind 🙂@@ChrisPage68
@@ChrisPage68 IМ...77 is a new account of a well-known troll. Look when it was created.
Since Babymetal virtually created the entire Kawaii-metal genre, and is damn near the ONLY act still in the genre now, I would have put them much higher than #5
Me too! No.1.for me..but I'm incredibly biased!
@@technewsfortechnoobs Not an all female rock band. They shouldn’t be on the list.
All great bands, but for me it is Band-Maid ❤
Ew,ew ew😝fuking EW!!
Nothing personal. With respect to the fans of other bands.🙏 But for me, the heavy metal band LOVEBITES is the #1 band.
Well said!
It's mature,unbias comments like these tht make bands u don't like tolerable.Edit:Learn from this dude u f!@%#&ing wolves n maddicks!!
They definitely are, they're on a totally different level to EVERY other band!
@rainerzufall42 Thank you!🙏
@@colingardiner6697 I agree with you. 🙏Although, if you look at it objectively, in Japan there are many talented musicians and great bands of different musical genres.
ChatGTP where is Gacharic Spin? Ccccc...
Aldious over Lovebites is surprising (the Lovebites fanbase seems more active), but not shocking (I like Aldious more, even if Lovebites guiterists are very impressive, maybe because Aldious songs are in japanese)
Rien à dire sur heu, Babymachin ?😉
@@Kissthetoad321 ne me provoque pas 😂😂😂
I'd list Lovebites as being #1, Nemophila #2, East of Eden #3, and Band-Maid #4. Babymetal shouldn't even be on this list since the actual musicians are all male. They should be at the top of some other list.
I let my cat eat my neighbor. Not every idea is a good one. 🌸
Can I borrow ur cat?
Definitely not in the top 10 as far as myself & friends are concerned. Scandal makes since as an early adaptor which i remember growing up with. Show-Ya my parents would remember. However, it didn't even have Destrose which kinda lost some respect for me lol.
Which everyone from LoveBites, Lonesome Blue, Nemophila, Aldious, Mary's Blood. Along with Mardelas, Albion, and now Fate Gear have their orgions in. Fate Gear being Destrose founder Captain Mina's current epic band. Which is currently in my top 5 bands easily.
Along with Babymetal, Band-Maid, Nemophila, Lovebites & Hanabie. I would be interested to know what criteria the Ai used as seems outdated & stuck in another era. Band-Maid was at least in its proper place.
Babymetal is my personal favorite but I can understand why they wouldn't be number one. I would have put Lovebites as number one.
Baby Metal isn’t a all female band. Shouldn’t be on the list.
@@albertcornett7408 Technically they aren't rock either so Lovebites and Nemophila shouldn't be on the list either if you want to get strict with the wording of the title.
@@albertcornett7408 Babymetal is an all-female group whose members only sing and dance. if we talk about concerts, then it is correct to talk about joint concerts of Babymetal (vocals and dances) and Kami Band (musicians)
@@digbydark9313Both those bands are rock bands. Metal is a type of rock.
@@pilgrim000So the band that tours with them aren’t Baby Metal? Then you just called them an idol group. I didn’t even propose that.
No problem with this list.......all were good choices. And the "pecking order" was pretty good too; although, I would have had Nemophila a few spots higher.
Gee, but some reality, please. Princess Princess is like something an AI would make using a Casio keyboard. Cyntia at least has 80s glam rock down, which oddly is an enormous step up from #10. Nemophila yanks it up a ton, cancelling out the cliche and repetitive guitar stumming for actual talent worthy of the new millennium. Show-ya emerged in the 80s and sounds like the 80s, which is one reason why I hated the 80s so much. Calling Babymetal an all-female band is fraud. Hey, have some respect for the Kami Band, as in, the band is the Kami Band. Finally, Lovebites, which is right up there in the same millennium with Nemophila, worthy of the props. Aldious set a trend early, so they deserve more notice than they get. Scandal is...famous. I'll leave it at that. Kind of reminds me of why so many all-female bands leave a bland taste in the mouth for not being particularly good on the instruments, but very good on the show (for lack of a better word). By the time this AI gets to Band Maid, I'm super ready for it. Great songs, great arrangements, innovative approaches to mixing those chops together, great stage presence, unrelenting professionalism, and everybody can play well. Night and day the top on this list. Which incidentally completely neglected to include several outstanding all-female Japanese bands that I'd put in front of most of this: Hanabie, Doll$boxx, Gacharic Spin, Fern Planet, White Flame....
Announcement:
"Whoever can provide convincing evidence that BABYMETAL is not an all-female band will receive $10,000 from me". 😊
BABYMETAL is a 100% female band consisting of three ladies who dance and sing.Try to prove otherwise. If you can do it, I will transfer $10,000 to your bank account.
P.S. If we are talking about concerts, then it would be more correct to say that these are BABYMETAL & KAMI BAND concerts.
Pathetic idiot.Correct me if I m wrong,a good fer nuthing jobless loser.@@GrayFox14
There can only be one number 1, Band Maid every day of the week for me
I would add Hanabie, Lonesome_Blue, Isiliel, Passcode , Fategear, Asterism and Kokeshi at least. 🤘
私は、超LOVEBITES ファンで、激HARUNA 推しですが、PARADOXX も良いよ❕もっと出てきて欲しいバンドです。
I would have chosen Lovebites they even won best metal band of 2024
Was it the same scam site that had Suzuka from BABYMETAL to win best metal singer award for 2024? If it was the site had no legitimacy and it was just a front for fishing peoples information:D
@@Tyyppl didn't hear a thing about that
@@Tyyppl I'd still choose Lovebites that's just my type of Metal I love Asami's voice especially when they do slower songs and her R&B voice is more prominent
@@Tyyppl Band Maid also is high on my list ever since I listened to Warning MV with Kanami on the vehicle and Hate? who can argue with a Lead Guitar and Bass Solo duel that is so amazing and I know they have been going since 2013 and deserve all credit they get
Don't pay attention. I've already talked to this person (Tyyppl). 😊 He just treats fans of LOVEBITES very badly, I would even say biasedly and arrogantly. That's why he writes such and similar comments under the comments of fans of LOVEBITES. He has zero facts, but an arrogant attitude towards LOVEBITES fans = 100%.
I agree with BM as #1. I would add Hanabie and Asterism, then shuffle a few around. I would drop Baby Metal and Princess Princess.
Cuando Band Maid pueda llenar el Tokyo Dome 2 noches seguidas podemos empezar hablar de si son las N° 1
@@JuanGomez-dk6kf Popularity doesn’t always equal good. Baby Metal isn’t an all female rock band. On a list if most popular idol bands Baby Metal is one of the top on that list.
It's a respectable list. I'd take off Babymetal for technical reasons, (not being an actual "band") and slip in Gacharic Spin somewhere. I'd also like to see Hanabie on there, but they still have a lower song output than most of the others. I'd stick Shishimo on there too but they aren't well known in the West, and I've a feeling that the AI was skewing the results towards bands known in the West. At least it got the #1 spot right!
Good point about Shishamo, they're not heavy enough, cute enough, punk enough or technical enough to register with western rock fans. They're very much a Japanese band for Japanese people.
Shishamo is amazing. They don't seem to get the respect they deserve.
Multiple great albums and staying power.
Stupid and useless ranking.
at least he did something, not just watch get wound up and bitch !
Fasten ur seat belt n have a nice crash landing❤@@airlinesecret6725
Isn't Brats there? men you break my heart 💔💔
Brats kick the maids asses anytime,anyday.(I dread tht akane n misa had 2 follow the directions of the bands arrangements)
😅Hagane should be on this list in the top3
Hagane the Has been.Notice how tht rhymes perfectly
I have never heard of Cyntia at number 9. Most time given to the number 2 band on this list, why? I remember when puri-puri came out and instantly was into them, but not as much as Band Maid. Not sure what criteria was used either. Zone, Stereopony, or even Mutant Monster could be on this list.
I think the creator of the video likes Scandal, and I do too, that's why he spent a little more time on it, plus they are still popular in Japan
BAND-MAID NUMBER 1 FOREVER
NO.1 FROM THE BACK
As long as Band-Maid is #1, I’m good with the list. 😊
Have to agree
Me too. Greatest ever
☠P A T HE T I C☠
Seamos sinceros, sin Babymetal nadie estaria interesado en la musica rock o metal del Japon, ellas han sido las punta de lanza para que algunas bandas japonesas sean conocidas e invitadas a los principales festivales europeos, es cosa de ver si alguna banda de la lista habria hecho sold out en sus 4 conciertos debut en sudamerica como lo hizo Babymetal en Brasil, Colombia, Peru y Chile
Band Maid is #1? love it!!! Great list!!!!
Not fer long b 4 they become "bang" maids.Catch tht❤😉
Shonen Knife Otoboke Beaver😊
💖🐺
Great bit of fun having AI create the list. Most of what i expected in the list. Some of the positions were a surprise. Like the narrator said, he was unsure what criteria was used to make the list. Pure fame BabyMetal are number 1, because they don't play any instruments, then they don't make the list at all. Band-Maid number 1? For me and every other maidiac, then yes but in reality, probably not. Though they are one of the most reacted to bands did that count? Would have been nice to see the reasoning behind the list. Still enjoyable and great to see a mix of old and new. Haven't listened to Scandal in a minute off to fire that up.
Actually they do play instruments but just haven't as part of BabyMetal. Moa has played guitar since she was in 4th grade. Suzuka plays piano of which she did perform once. This is the fault of Koba and Amuze not taking advantage of their talents. I agree though with Band-Maid. Scandal is recommend but are a aquired taste as they border on grunge more i think.
@BlazinNSoul I was only hashing out reasons not complaining. I'm a massive BabyMetal fan and know they play instruments. I even listened to the recent interview they did with Atarashi Gakko and I'm going to see them play in a few months. In Germany because I'm on holiday 2 days before the London show. Like I said I doubt AI knows all the cool things the fans do. Love your passion though.
Tried same exercise, with chatGpt too, and get this list (first position anyway goes to... 😊)
1. Band-Maid
2. SCANDAL
3. Aldious
4. Lovebites
5. Shonen Knife
6. Nemophila
7. Silent Siren
8. Show-Ya
9. Tricot
10. Zettai Club
El publico que le gusta a Band Maid son puros viejos que se calientan viendo a mujeres disfrazadas de mucamas, mientras que el publico de Babymetal es mucho mas diverso.
Trident 😘😘😘
Who is the biggest Japanese band male or female worldwide? BABYMETAL. Who has the best singer? BABYMETAL. All these other bands fit into one genre or another. BABYMETAL (well, Koba-Metal) created their own genre, unlike anything done before. Everything about BABYMETAL is so far ahead of these other bands, from stage show to production values to marketing and every other aspect of the project. Koba-Metal is the greatest manager since Peter Grant of Zeppelin fame. And before all the BABYMETAL haters start telling me they aren't a band or they aren't metal, yes BABYMETAL isn't a "band" more of a "concept" but so what? It's hugely successful, both in Japan 🇯🇵 and around the world. Band Maid and Lovebites are good bands, but I highly doubt they are playing to the same size crowds as BABYMETAL in Japan, and I know they aren't anywhere else. And BABYMETAL ARE METAL!!! My favorite band is MANOWAR so I know what True Metal is. And BABYMETAL my friends, IS True Metal 🤘 KITSUMES UP
Pretty sure One Ok Rock for example is bigger than babymetal worldwide (atleast they do a bit bigger venues than babymetal does) But for just female bands I agree that BABYMETAL is the biggest worldwide.
@Tyyppl Who? Never heard of them.
LGBTQ band with a stupid name for a rock band.@@Tyyppl
@@brenthatcher5748 As I said One Ok Rock. They are a stadium sized band in Japan and even outside of Japan they draw bigger crowds than even babymetal (atleast in Asia, and South America and in the US and Europe the crowds are pretty similar size). Not really my type of music but they are massive.
@@RAWNFUKINGREADY Nice to know that you know so much about LGBTQ. You must be part of that community. I never would have known that.
LOVEBITES is by far #1, Nemophila #2, new HAGANE#3, FATE GEAR#4, BAND-MAID#5
Fun list.😁. . . . But we all have our own favorites that got dissed. . Boo! . . 🤣😂
I don't really care what anyone or any AI ranks Band-Maid, they are always #1 to me! ❤❤❤❤❤ ... interesting ranking tho! 🤔 🤘
Is AI able of feeling music as much as a human being? I doubt it. Regardless, it's an interesting idea. However, among rock bands, sorry but I see one that is not, IMO (despite all the respect I have for them): Babymetal. Kami band is the rock band. Otherwise we have to redefine what a rock band is. Therefore, why wouldn't PassCode, Broken by the Scream, Bish be part of it? Good job Venus Gaijin.
I am happy Aldious is on this list, and I'm happier they ranked so well. I agree with Band Maid.
My favorite would be Aldious they have zero bad songs, zero fillers, in fact had they been around in the 80s and sang in English they would have dominated the charts .
Show -Ya would be # 2 because they are from the 80s and played 80s style songs like Def Leppard and Motley Crue ... and had at least one song I remember hearing in the US back then.
Lovebites # 3 love just about all their songs.
Band Maid # 4
But after that I would have picked Stereopony, Bridear, Destrose, Doll$Boxx, Hagane and Hanabie.
Love the rest of the bands on the this list though ..... its tough to narrow down to just a top ten.
First off Band-Maid IS a rock band where as some of the bands on the list are Metal bands. Try the same thing again, but use the words metal bands instead of rock band.
B.Maid is a 😗poooOsie pop band with rock overtones.
@@IMetalHead777 And of course we hear from the Lovebites fandom. It's a shame that they have some fans like this.
Ain't tht a bitch😗@@jgulley7
If the Ai can't distinguish between Rock and Metal it's not going to be able to distinguish between Metal and Rock. Just be happy that Nogi46 isn't on the list.
@@jefffromchicago6321 That's kinda why I said try
All hail Band Maid
No bail for banned maids
No bail for banned maids❤
Pretty good ranking. Gacharic Spin is missing. Babymetal is not an all female band (it is, technically, but… no).
I had also ranked Band-Maid number one (by far).
Band Maid No .1 for me.
Who the F cares?!
@@RAWNFUKINGREADY Clearly you do
If u think so,then chuck tht band in the garbage! for ur own good.@@Tyyppl
@ You really are showing how much you don't care with these angry responses:D
Right from the start loser.🙂@@Tyyppl
Lovebites fans gonna be real disappointed. Some of those guys are rabid. I would have included Hanabie. Nemophils would have been #2.
You don't know LOVEBITES fans well if you write something like that. You probably judge by yourself. I am a LOVEBITES fan and I am not disappointed at all. Regardless of its results, I will choose LOVEBITES over any other band.
We simply support quality.
I know what you mean but I think those are just basement technical playing elitists. I went to see LBs wearing a B-M shirt and the audience was very cool and accepting. I went to the pre-party and most travel for many Japanese Bands.
@@GrayFox14 Pretty sure you don't just know your own fandom. Even in this comment section there are LOVEBITES fans downplaying other bands and saying how LOVEBITES is easily the greatest ever. Lovebites has easily the most toxic fanbase out of all the japanese metalgroups:D
@@Tyyppl This is your opinion. Fans of any bands can be "toxic". That's to put it in your language. I had to communicate with fans of different bands, including under this reaction. For some of these fans, the word "toxic" is even putting it very mildly. A complete lack of logic, unwillingness (or inability) to understand and comprehend the information. All this is replaced by attempts to insult those with whom they communicate. And all this was not done by fans of LOVEBITES!))))
For me, LOVEBITES is also the best band. In my list of favorite bands, LOVEBITES are number 1. I wrote a comment that I think so under this reaction. Did I insult anyone by doing this? Am I one of "the most toxic fanbase" because I expressed my opinion?
Fans of other bands also consider their favorite bands to be the best. They have the right to do so. The main thing is not who considers which band to be the best. Different people have different musical tastes and habits. Therefore, they will always have different opinions about which band is the best. The main thing is that the person does not insult fans of other bands.
ChatGpt is 2 or 3 years behind, but other wise all good
Maki was the best but slightly late addition to Aldious
THE MAIDS RULE
Yea they rule shit❤🤟
I tried them all on for size, and Band-Maid is the only one that fits me.
I agree
I'm sorry for your loss.
Naturally,sissy.Like u r man enough 2 handle DESTROSE,MARY'S BLOOD,BRIDEAR,NEMO,LIPSTICK.I bet u put those maid costumes while listening 2 their girlie rock n roll.
It HAD to be the Maids!
Hanabie crying into a corner lol. Jokes aside, Lovebites forever
Lovebites as the name suggests..shall bite the dust anytime soon n MIHO shall have her last laugh.😂
This proves AI is garbage. There is NO way Aldious, Scandal or Band-Maid are higher than Lovebites. Nemophila 1.0 deserves to be on the list. 🤘🐺💜
Band Maid #1
Akane&Misa will start a great band themselves.Miku will go back 2 her loser waitress job n kanami will follow suit(she needs a job).The other one will probably land up as a JAV prospect. Edit: So how's tht fer being no.1.
I've always viewed BabyMetal as a 'idol' group with a backup band. Hanabie, Gacharic Spin, Flip, Existrace are big influences for me. Never liked Aldious (vocals turned me off), but generally, okay list.
No. 5? Get real.
No other Japanese band is as unique, groundbreaking and genre diverse as BABYMETAL.
And no band has every artist and their brother waiting for a chance to work with them.
They're technically not a female rock band though. They should be replaced with Hanabie, Gacharic Spin, or Super Junky Monkey.
@ and you're technically not qualified to give an expert opinion about what determines a band. Now go back and try to deny my original comment without being obtuse.
@@rah2287 What qualifications do you require to tell the difference between a male and a female? Do you also require a veterinarian license to tell the difference between a cat and a dog?
@ what are you babbling about? There are only two genders of course but where does your question arise from?
@@xovaqiin4844 male/female, cat/dog,apples/oranges what grade are you in?
Gacharic Spin #1
SCANDAL & BAND-MAID at the top as it should be.
Nope.
Any stoopid band can take top spot except tht 2.
@@ChrisPage68 too bad LMAO
I wouldn't have included Babymetal as they are in Idol band not an actual band
Well it was done by AI right? Brainless...
They make great music so don't care what people call them. Idol group, rock group, kawaii metal band. There just brilliant.
Made me wonder why Attarashi Gakko wasn't included.
@@jefffromchicago6321 me too! Technically not rock but who cares. Tokyo calling is a heavy track! Just brilliant!
@@jefffromchicago6321 they suck?
Lovebites all the way.
This proves A.I is not ready for the real world yet 😜 , Lovebites are clearly a cut above every band in terms of ability and skill and the list is missing Bridear, Hanabie, Marys Blood, Destrose and Passcode
Band-Maid, Band-Maid, Band-Maid
Ban the maids! sick n f@$%@ing tired of tht stoopid name! F@@#$%ing maddicks!
Band Maid ,Number 1 without contest, far ahead 😉 but where is Hanabi ?! 🤔
In ur stoopid head.