Just to note, some things have been simplified for the sake of the video and other things have been pronounced incorrectly, this is due to the narration being AI generated, hope you enjoy otherwise!
I hated it. Amateurish, lazy and a waste of time. It is clear that you are a picker of history. How much TIME have you spent on the great man's life, or is it just another 20 minutes that gets in the way of you playing the fantasy computer games? Blocked your channel. Won't ever see you again. I'll keep searching for your video on the social and economic reforms that Napoleon carried out in France. Free education for every child between 6 and 11 years old, free hospital treatment, free housing for old people, free housing for injured veterans, pensions for all injured and survivor veterans, fresh water in all the cities, semaphore connecting the Manche with the Mediterranean, more and bigger canals to increase trade, changes to agriculture to produce more food for the citizens, more roads and rest houses for travellers. Then the big one, The Code Napoleon, that condensed 100's of local laws into one national Coda. People, like you, never do that type of the history you claim to love.
Russia's been so nice why didn't they go all the way it is what it is and nobody cares. Why didn't they go all the way. You know why it is what it is and nobody cares
Omg, that was spectacular! Thank you so much for filling my request for the Battle of Borodino! You've done a brilliant job. Amazing work. That must be your best battle vid yet, in my opinion. You captured the brutality really well 👏 Some brilliant details as well, my fav was the excellent (and deadly) field of fire enjoyed by the 19 x 12-pounder cannons of the Great Redoubt, protecting the Russian centre. Those cannon were the perfect foil for Napoleon's frontal assault tactics of that horrible day. None of the brilliance of Napoleon's masterpiece, Austerlitz, was seen at Borodino. Many of Napoleon's later battles were slugging matches, artillery duels and frontal infantry assaults. As promised, it'll be my pleasure to remain a Legend member of your channel until Christmas. Then I'll bump down a tier - unless I decide otherwise, of course. Thanks again for an amazing job! I've just finished work, so I'll have a better viewing when I get home. Cheers, mate 👍
Thank you I'm glad to hear, this was certainly a challenge for me so I do apologise if anything is wrong but I really enjoyed making it regardless. Your support allows me to make videos like this so if there are any more you want to request please do let me know as I'm happy to cover them!
@@cinematicbattles559 That's already crossed my mind! Haha. I'll do some research and see if I can come up with a great battle that you haven't already done. No hurry, as I want to give others a chance as well. Yes, I don't have TH-cam phone notifications turned on, so I was unaware you posted it until I was waiting to leave work earlier. But I don't think there's a similar video like yours of Borodino on TH-cam, so I hope any and all searches will lead to this one. I can't imagine anyone doing better, not for a very long time, at least. Finger's crossed for a million views🤞 Edit: By the way, the script was very good. I also liked the map of the battle placed over the battle scenes, so it was easy to see what was going on, that was a really nice touch 👍
@@martyn8116 Yes no worries at all please do tell me if you find any battles you want me to cover. If it wasn't for you I probably wouldn't have considered this battle as I had never heard of it before, but I absolutely loved making this video. Thanks for saying that, whenever I make these videos I worry that there are inaccuracies but I do try my best.
“You captured the brutality really well” Excited spaz would shit on himself during a real brutal battle and probably rank out and run like a punk. A little self-respect for yourself and a moment of reflection for those who perished so brutally.
Canadian historian Gwynne Dyer compared the carnage at Borodino to "a fully-loaded 747 crashing, with no survivors, every 5 minutes for eight hours". This game sim gives at least _some_ idea of how bloody these kinds of battles were.
Ah, a Napoleonic battle, this one sure was a nightmare of a bloodbath. It showed just where Napoleon's campaign was headed to in the end. Line based musketry warfare sure lead to horrendous casualties especially as the weapons improved and became more accurate.
@@cinematicbattles559 Excellent. If possible do First Bull Run, it was quite the initial engagement and there was even confusion on both sides since the rebel troops where so wearing Federal blue.
Most people don't realize the enormous losses napoleon had even before he reached Moscow. Not enough horses to haul fodder. Horses die. Not enough horses to haul supplies soldiers die. You can't let horses graze 6 hours a day .
This was superbly done and in places reminded me of Sergei Bondarchucks as yet unrivalled masterpiece War and Peace and that is high praise. It was impressive even on my phone! Really well done.
@@cinematicbattles559 yeah. It's a nice mod. I just wish I had a stronger pc to play multiplayer with it. Takes a bit from each good ntw mod and blends it into a solid all-rounder.
@@ordotectonicus8585 yes that's true I do love the mod. However, there were certainly some visual and sound effect issues which were really annoying to deal with when trying to make a video like this, if you were just playing the game normally it would make no difference
@@jessiemeisenheimer8675Davout brought up the idea around the same time to Napoleon who was having a terrible migraine or cold, his sickness may have caused Napoleon to be inactive in his decisions to be stubborn and “dumb” at Borodino, per say, rejecting Davout’s strategy
I wish you would talk louder as, I can't here over the battle sounds, and you don't leave the subtitles up long enough for people to read, good video though, you need to look into the 2 problems I brought up
Cannonballs do not explode. They are simply solid balls of iron. Against infantry canister or grapeshot was used. These were composed of a bag of musket balls or small pieces of iron propelled by a gunpowder charge.
Did the French actually attack in line formation at Borodino? They usually used the column to break enemy lines and then formed lines themselves. Or is the model just not available in Total War? But good work!
the transition from falinxs to stand off weapons must be the reason for standing in line in brightly collard uniforms waiting to be shot ! cover and concealment was for hunting game
Combats effroyables ! Les soldats n'étaient que de la chair à canon... Napoléon, lorsqu'il était en position de force, aurait dû utiliser davantage la diplomatie, se rapprocher des Autrichiens et des Russes et leur faire comprendre que leur ennemi commun était la Grande Bretagne... Mais Napoléon était trop sûr de sa force militaire, trop ambitieux et trop orgueilleux pour s'abaisser à négocier et à privilégier le long terme, plutôt que des victoires immédiates, prestigieuses, mais sanglantes et onéreuses. Pour moi, il a su être un stratège militaire, mais pas un stratège politique...
You have provided a considerable insight about the political preamble to the invasion of Russia & this terrible battle. Thank you. I am trying very hard to learn the French language. I think that I mostly understood what you had typed, but I then decided to paste your French words into an online translator to make sure that I understand fully. From Grande Bretagne.
@@johnkay4701 Thank you for your kind comment, my friend. Congratulations if you want to learn french or improve your practice... But i have to warn you that it is a very sophisticated language, in particular in grammar and conjugation, almost as difficult as latin... But very precise and beautiful. In my opinion, the best way to learn it, is the natural way. I mean, to learn first the daily life french (But correct french, not slang), and step by step you learn the correspondent grammar... Then, slowly, you'll approach a more intellectual french... If this may encourage you, you have to know that a lot of words are similar or very close in french and english (thanks to Guillaume le Conquérant and later to the house of Plantagenêt) . Besides, more than two hundred million people speak french in the world... It's not so bad! Salutations de France.
Commentaire pas très futé. Tu penses qu'ils n'ont pas négociés auparavant ? Combien de traités de paix Napoléon a signé et combien de fois ces monarchies l'ont foulé aux pieds ?? La Russie était justement en train de changer de camp (pour le nième fois), pour se rapprocher des anglais et de former une autre coalition !! Qu'est ce que Napoléon aurait pu faire de plus ?? Ces monarchies voulaient restaurer la monarchie en France. Point. Avant Napoléon, ils ont déclarés la guerre à la france. C'est aussi la faute de Napoléon ??
@@thierryfromgwada9312 Ta réponse est typique de certains individus qui sur le net, donnent facilement dans l'arrogance et le mépris, pour satisfaire leur égo et palier sans doute à quelques frustrations... Les pseudos et l'anonymat sont bien pratiques pour cela. C'est marrant, parce que dans la vie réelle, les gens aiment bien discuter avec moi, et se montrent plutôt respectueux. Je n'ose croire que ce soit uniquement à cause de ma belle gueule, de mon mètre quatre-vingt cinq et de mes quatre vingt dix kilos... J'ai donc pris l'habitude de ne plus perdre mon temps avec des gens comme toi...
Someo0ne in comments always says whatever is the subject of the video is terrible these days, and they were better when they were younger, but this takes the cake.
The more i learn about the battle the more i feel for jerome having to use his garde like it was worthless to napoleon like it was yet but a normal infantry. I sometimes wonder what he felt having to charge his westphalian garde at the redoubts.
Can you do sekigahara, nagano, that battle between Qin and Chu. Siege of Carthage, Lapanto, Palatea? You and the other docos should colaborate. Maybe get the channels involed? Would love to help especially if you wanna make it battlefield britian/ancient battles style. PLUS Actors incerps (drool)
Yes I will certainly look into these. Siege of Carthage is one I started editing but never finished for some reason, I will definitely revisit it. I haven't really thought about collaborating but it's something I'd be open to. But yes I always could do with help on my videos they take so long😆
Never, EVER(!) assume ANY Campaign you undertake will be a short one. Design it to be short, but ALWAYS(!) plan for a long grinding Campaign of Attrition and adjust your Logistics (including replacements and reinforcements) accordingly.
Great cinematography and editing. It’s a shame that Empire and Napoleons’ sounds are so weedy and pathetic. Shogun 2 does guns way better. Still, very good video. By the way, what blood mod do you use?
@@cinematicbattles559 ok...but I seen some other videos like these visuals and they go according to story line ...is it they edit so close or really a software which can creat scenes like this. ?
Indeed, Napoleon's army biggest loses was before Borodino, due to malnutrition, diseases ( typhoid fever ) and desertion. Combat loses are pretty low. Google for Charles Minard statistics 1812
@@jacktrade1592 They split off, there's no single column of 450.000 soldiers, that's the grand total, Napoleon commanded the main army group but there were others guarding the flanks and the supply lines.
This was a time were Generals led from the front and the results were 49 French Generals dead or wounded and 22 Russian Generals dead or wounded including Prince Bagration who died about two weeks after the battle. The number of Colonels was higher it was a brutal fight that lasted but in the end the Russians were defeated and if they had continued fighting the next day it would had been a total disaster for the Russians.
Great point. Back then, officers literally led from the front, and they were slaughtered in great numbers. Even Generals were known to take part in, or personally lead, some of the great cavalry charges of the era. The loss of so many officers at Borodino caused the battlefield to be even more chaotic. It was said you couldn't hear musket fire on the battlefield as it was drowned out by cannon fire. 500-600 cannons on each side was one of the reasons for the appalling death toll.
@@martyn8116 So true since whole Infantry Battalions and Cavalry Regiments basically cease to exist after this Battle. But while history tries to get you to believe that "General Winter" destroyed Napoleon's Army there are many different factors that led to the disaster of 1812; first Napoleon had around 34,000 Austrians in his Army who operating with the Saxons were on the Southern front and they went over to the Russian side and later captured quite a few Saxon afterwards. That was around 50,000 troops gone and there was also a Northern front of around 100,000 troops. But the biggest killer was Typhus and not the cold of winter. Typhus ran through his troops during the summer after he invaded.
@chestersleezer8821 I didn't know about the sneaky Austrians. I recall over 200 line regiments of the Grand Armee, many seasoned units, were all but wiped out. I've always wondered how Waterloo, the following year, might have been different with all those crack soldiers on the field, rather than buried in Russia. Speaking of chaos in the battlefield, Wellington in Spain always moaned about his aristocratic calvalry regiments, especially the heavies, for some reason, were a law unto themselves, and only charged when they felt like it! Haha.
@@martyn8116 Well, in 1813 was an even larger and more bloody battle - Leipzig. Waterloo was 1815. Not 1813. Maybe you should read a book or two about history. Thanks a lot.
That was one of the reasons, Kutuzov withdrew the Russian army, using scorched earth tactic. Now they only had to wait, as hunger and cold takes it's toll on the French. Not to mention the continuous harassment of French troops by Russian guerilla warfare.
1 Tervitus ja tänu 1 Paulus, Kristuse Jeesuse apostel Jumala tahtmisel selle elu tõotust mööda, mis on Kristuses Jeesuses, - 2 armsale pojale Timoteosele: Armu, halastust ja rahu Jumalalt Isalt ja Kristuselt Jeesuselt, meie Issandalt! 3 Ma olen tänulik Jumalale, keda ma oma esivanemate viisil puhta südametunnistusega teenin, alatasa meenutades sind oma eestpalvetes ööl ja päeval, 4 ning igatsedes sind näha, kui mulle tulevad meelde sinu pisarad, et ma saaksin täis rõõmu, 5 mäletades sinu siirast usku, mis esmalt elas sinu vanaemas Loises ja sinu emas Eunikes ja nüüd - selles olen ma veendunud - elab ka sinus. Julgustus kartmatuks Kristuse tunnistamiseks 6 Sel põhjusel tuletan ma sulle meelde, et sa taas õhutaksid lõkkele Jumala ande, mis on sinus minu käte pealepanemise kaudu. 7 Jumal ei ole meile ju andnud arguse vaimu, vaid väe ja armastuse ja mõistlikkuse vaimu. 8 Ära siis häbene tunnistamast meie Issandat ega mind, tema vangi, vaid kannata koos minuga kurja evangeeliumi pärast Jumala väe abil,
9 kes on meid päästnud ja kutsunud püha kutsega, mitte meie tegude järgi, vaid omaenese kavatsuse ja armu järgi, mis meile on antud Kristuses Jeesuses enne igavesi aegu, 10 nüüd on aga saanud avalikuks meie Päästja Kristuse Jeesuse ilmumise läbi, kes on kõrvaldanud surma ning on evangeeliumi kaudu toonud valge ette elu ja kadumatuse,
11 mille kuulutajaks ja apostliks ning õpetajaks mind on seatud. 12 Sel põhjusel ma ka kannatan. Ent ma ei häbene, sest ma tean, kellesse ma olen uskuma hakanud ja olen veendunud, et tema on vägev hoidma minu hoolde usaldatut oma päevani. 13 Võta terve õpetuse eeskujuks see, mida sa minult oled kuulnud usus ja armastuses, mis on Kristuses Jeesuses! 14 Seda head, mis su hoolde on usaldatud, hoia Püha Vaimu abil, kes meis elab. 15 Sa tead seda, et mulle on pööranud selja kõik, kes on Aasias, nende seas Fügelos ja Hermogenes. 16 Issand andku halastust Onesiforose kodule, sest tema on mind sagedasti kosutanud ega ole häbenenud mu ahelaid, 17 vaid kui ta juhtus Rooma, otsis ta mind hoolega ning leidis üles. 18 Issand andku talle leida halastust Issanda käest oma päeval! Ja kui palju ta on abistanud mind Efesoses, tead sina kõige paremini. 2Kuula Julgustus kartmatuks Kristuse tunnistamiseks 1 Sina siis, mu poeg, saa vägevaks armus, mis on Kristuses Jeesuses! 2 Ja mida sa minult oled kuulnud paljude tunnistajate kuuldes, see anna ustavate inimeste hoolde, kes edaspidi sobivad õpetama ka teisi. 3 Kannata koos minuga kurja nagu Kristuse Jeesuse tubli sõdur! 4 Ükski, kes on sõjateenistuses, ei seo end argielu askeldustega, kui ta tahab jääda meelepäraseks sellele, kes ta on sõduriks kutsunud. 5 Ja kui keegi võistleb, ei saa ta ometi võidupärga, kui ta ei võistle korrakohaselt. 6 Tööd rügav põllumees peab esimesena saama osa viljast. 7 Mõtle sellele, mis ma ütlen! Küll Issand annab sulle arusaamist kõiges. 8 Olgu sul meeles Jeesus Kristus, kes on üles äratatud surnuist, kes põlvneb Taaveti soost! See on evangeelium, 9 mille pärast ma kannatan kurja ja olen koguni ahelates nagu mõni roimar. Kuid Jumala sõna ei ole ahelais. 10 Seetõttu ma talun kõike äravalitute pärast, et ka nemad saaksid pääste Kristuses Jeesuses igavese kirkusega. 11 Ustav on see sõna: Kui me oleme surnud koos temaga, siis ka elame koos temaga, 12 kui me jääme püsima vaevas, siis valitseme koos kuningatena, kui me tema salgame, siis salgab ka tema meid, 13 kui me oleme uskmatud, jääb tema ometi ustavaks, sest ta ei saa ennast salata. Õhutus olla kõlblik töötegija Jumalale 14 Seda tuleta neile meelde, vannutades Jumala ees, et nad ei peaks sõnasõda - sellest pole mingit kasu, see vaid hukutab kuulajad. 15 Püüa hoolega osutuda Jumala ees kõlblikuks töötegijana, kel pole tarvis häbeneda, kes tõe sõna kuulutab õigesti. 16 Labastest tühijuttudest hoidu aga eemale! Nende rääkijad ju lähevad aina kaugemale jumalakartmatuses 17 ja nende sõna levib otsekui vähktõbi. Nende seast on Hümenaios ja Fileetos, 18 kes on kaldunud kõrvale tõest, öeldes, et ülestõusmine on juba toimunud, ning rikuvad ära mõnede usu. 19 Ometi püsib kindlana Jumala seatud aluskivi, millel on see pitser: „Issand tunneb omi” ja „Ülekohtust taganegu igaüks, kes nimetab Issanda nime”. 20 Aga suures majas ei ole üksnes kuld- ja hõbeastjaid, vaid neid on ka puust ja savist - osa auliseks, osa autuks tarbeks. 21 Kui nüüd keegi end puhastab neist vigadest, siis ta saab auliseks astjaks, pühitsetuks ja peremehele kasulikuks, valmiks igale heale teole. 22 Põgene noorusea himude eest! Taotle õiglust, usku, armastust ja rahu nendega, kes Issandat appi hüüavad puhtast südamest! 23 Aga sõgedad ja kasvatamatud arutlemised lükka tagasi, teades, et need tekitavad tülisid. 24 Issanda sulasel ei ole tarvis tülitseda, vaid ta olgu lahke kõikide vastu, osav õpetama, valmis kannatama kurja, 25 kes tasadusega kasvatab vastupanijaid selleks, et ehk Jumal annab neile meeleparandust tõe mõistmiseks, 26 ja et nad kaineneksid ja pääseksid lahti kuradi paelust, mis on püüdnud nad oma tahtmise valda.
The morale of story; Never enter deep into enemy territory with only 3 weeks ration. Never dream of easy and quick victory against Russia. Never conquered Moscow without secured access to nearby territory with supplies, garrison, and leave no room for the enemy to flank. In short, Advance slowly with full stomach, and prepare for battle of attrition. Play safe.
this looks so realistic until you notice every soldier has the same face. but yeah the numbers of soldiers involved would look like this. too bad we don't have as many napoleonic war reenactors as we do us civil war or ww2.
dang I wish I could attend as a reenactor but here in USA cant find a local Napoleonic group to reenact as the Frenchies. I hear flintlock need some real training to use at these things prior to an event.
Otto, it's the first time I've heard of such a wonderful discovery. Though it would be better to explain why 35 000 French, healthy in the morning died from Typhus in the duration of one day at Borodino alone. And soon the same had happened with 8 000 of them at Little Yaroslavets.
@@vadimpm1290perhaps he is an pest extreminator and trying to highlight the disastrous effect of rats on naepoloens army so he gets more business. Capitalistic methods of advertisement are very ingenious you know .
Just to note, some things have been simplified for the sake of the video and other things have been pronounced incorrectly, this is due to the narration being AI generated, hope you enjoy otherwise!
Dude what is this garbage AI narrator...
Get a human to actually read it. It that so difficult?
I hated it. Amateurish, lazy and a waste of time. It is clear that you are a picker of history. How much TIME have you spent on the great man's life, or is it just another 20 minutes that gets in the way of you playing the fantasy computer games? Blocked your channel. Won't ever see you again.
I'll keep searching for your video on the social and economic reforms that Napoleon carried out in France. Free education for every child between 6 and 11 years old, free hospital treatment, free housing for old people, free housing for injured veterans, pensions for all injured and survivor veterans, fresh water in all the cities, semaphore connecting the Manche with the Mediterranean, more and bigger canals to increase trade, changes to agriculture to produce more food for the citizens, more roads and rest houses for travellers. Then the big one, The Code Napoleon, that condensed 100's of local laws into one national Coda. People, like you, never do that type of the history you claim to love.
@@karlheinzvonkroemann2217 here is an idea start your own history channel and use your voice problem solved the end
Russia's been so nice why didn't they go all the way it is what it is and nobody cares. Why didn't they go all the way. You know why it is what it is and nobody cares
That was probably the most Cinematic NTW made battle i would ever see. Great job mate!
Glad you enjoyed it!
Omg, that was spectacular! Thank you so much for filling my request for the Battle of Borodino! You've done a brilliant job. Amazing work. That must be your best battle vid yet, in my opinion. You captured the brutality really well 👏
Some brilliant details as well, my fav was the excellent (and deadly) field of fire enjoyed by the 19 x 12-pounder cannons of the Great Redoubt, protecting the Russian centre. Those cannon were the perfect foil for Napoleon's frontal assault tactics of that horrible day.
None of the brilliance of Napoleon's masterpiece, Austerlitz, was seen at Borodino. Many of Napoleon's later battles were slugging matches, artillery duels and frontal infantry assaults.
As promised, it'll be my pleasure to remain a Legend member of your channel until Christmas. Then I'll bump down a tier - unless I decide otherwise, of course. Thanks again for an amazing job! I've just finished work, so I'll have a better viewing when I get home. Cheers, mate 👍
Thank you I'm glad to hear, this was certainly a challenge for me so I do apologise if anything is wrong but I really enjoyed making it regardless. Your support allows me to make videos like this so if there are any more you want to request please do let me know as I'm happy to cover them!
@@cinematicbattles559 That's already crossed my mind! Haha. I'll do some research and see if I can come up with a great battle that you haven't already done. No hurry, as I want to give others a chance as well.
Yes, I don't have TH-cam phone notifications turned on, so I was unaware you posted it until I was waiting to leave work earlier.
But I don't think there's a similar video like yours of Borodino on TH-cam, so I hope any and all searches will lead to this one. I can't imagine anyone doing better, not for a very long time, at least. Finger's crossed for a million views🤞
Edit: By the way, the script was very good. I also liked the map of the battle placed over the battle scenes, so it was easy to see what was going on, that was a really nice touch 👍
@@martyn8116 Yes no worries at all please do tell me if you find any battles you want me to cover. If it wasn't for you I probably wouldn't have considered this battle as I had never heard of it before, but I absolutely loved making this video.
Thanks for saying that, whenever I make these videos I worry that there are inaccuracies but I do try my best.
@@cinematicbattles559 How about the winter war of 1939, Russia vs Finland. Thanks.
“You captured the brutality really well”
Excited spaz would shit on himself during a real brutal battle and probably rank out and run like a punk.
A little self-respect for yourself and a moment of reflection for those who perished so brutally.
It took special people to be able to control battles on this scale. Excellent as always bud!!
he didnt literally control, his commanders for each of the corp were already independent.
wow, just as I search for Borodino videos, and this was uploaded less than an hour ago, perfect!
Hope you enjoy watching
Canadian historian Gwynne Dyer compared the carnage at Borodino to "a fully-loaded 747 crashing, with no survivors, every 5 minutes for eight hours". This game sim gives at least _some_ idea of how bloody these kinds of battles were.
I love these battle scenarios where you just get to observe and stare into amaze how the battle developted
Amazing job!! Many thx :))
Ah, a Napoleonic battle, this one sure was a nightmare of a bloodbath. It showed just where Napoleon's campaign was headed to in the end. Line based musketry warfare sure lead to horrendous casualties especially as the weapons improved and became more accurate.
Yes indeed, I think line infantry battles have to be among the worst, thanks for watching
@@cinematicbattles559 That they were. The American Civil War also helped highlight that.
@@manuelacosta9463 Yes indeed this is certainly a time period I want to cover more in the future
@@cinematicbattles559 Excellent. If possible do First Bull Run, it was quite the initial engagement and there was even confusion on both sides since the rebel troops where so wearing Federal blue.
@@manuelacosta9463Nice, I will certainly look into this
Most people don't realize the enormous losses napoleon had even before he reached Moscow. Not enough horses to haul fodder. Horses die. Not enough horses to haul supplies soldiers die. You can't let horses graze 6 hours a day .
people do
This was superbly done and in places reminded me of Sergei Bondarchucks as yet unrivalled masterpiece War and Peace and that is high praise. It was impressive even on my phone! Really well done.
Overhead shots wonderful - detailed actions rather odd. Thanks for the attempt !
Thanks for watching!
You do better? Let's see it!
You're a film maker then? My crit was balanced wasn't it? Fair comment?@@markmullin4246
Just an amazingly well done video.
Thanks a lot 😀
Nice ! Super cool !! More off these please 🎉🎉
Thanks for watching
Great cinematography.
Thanks
@@cinematicbattles559 Was it made with vanilla or a mod like FCN?. Looks like FCN based on the flags and mass.
@@ordotectonicus8585 It was made with the Field Command mod as this mod offers the Borodino maps and also larger units
@@cinematicbattles559 yeah. It's a nice mod. I just wish I had a stronger pc to play multiplayer with it. Takes a bit from each good ntw mod and blends it into a solid all-rounder.
@@ordotectonicus8585 yes that's true I do love the mod. However, there were certainly some visual and sound effect issues which were really annoying to deal with when trying to make a video like this, if you were just playing the game normally it would make no difference
Amazing job thank you mate!
Glad you enjoyed
Should have listened to Davoust, the Iron Marshal.
Napoleon's reasoning was that he wanted to fight a decisive battle and didn't want to risk the Russians retreating again.
The Russians would have retreated once more
@@jessiemeisenheimer8675Davout brought up the idea around the same time to Napoleon who was having a terrible migraine or cold, his sickness may have caused Napoleon to be inactive in his decisions to be stubborn and “dumb” at Borodino, per say, rejecting Davout’s strategy
2:21
Wow that's some high quality graphics there.
I wish you would talk louder as, I can't here over the battle sounds, and you don't leave the subtitles up long enough for people to read, good video though, you need to look into the 2 problems I brought up
It's an AI voice.
Cannonballs do not explode. They are simply solid balls of iron. Against infantry canister or grapeshot was used. These were composed of a bag of musket balls or small pieces of iron propelled by a gunpowder charge.
Well even during naepoloens time , exploding shells did exist .
And they were used .
Just look them up on the net, they did exist.
love your work btw, some of the time period background music but sublty playedwould be nice
Thanks man
10:38- I love that one guy hopping forward. He looks like someone from a Monty Python sketch.
Interesting visualisations, capture the essence of the hand-to-hand fighting. Not convinced they had exploding shells though 🙂
Those Graphics Are Awesome
I believe for the infantry men it was two shots a minute, or three if you were really good, or four a minute if you were exceptionally good.
Beautiful video
Thank you
Invading Russia is like stretching an electric band. Stretch it too far and it will snap.
Great recounting. Fab graphics too!
Glad you enjoyed it!
I like this video can you made video battle of verneuil
Well done. NTW is a nice too, give us a good support to explain History events.
Thanks for watching 😊
Did the French actually attack in line formation at Borodino? They usually used the column to break enemy lines and then formed lines themselves. Or is the model just not available in Total War? But good work!
Hi yes I did think this was an issue, it’s really hard to do in total war but I should have mentioned that really - thanks for watching
Touché Napoleon
this reminds me of my friends mod Grand battle
the transition from falinxs to stand off weapons must be the reason for standing in line in brightly collard uniforms waiting to be shot ! cover and concealment was for hunting game
Alot of death for sure /.... enjoyed watching
Thanks man
SHOULD have three hr long video, I'm sure Scott is only spend 10 minutes on Borodino.😊
Combats effroyables ! Les soldats n'étaient que de la chair à canon... Napoléon, lorsqu'il était en position de force, aurait dû utiliser davantage la diplomatie, se rapprocher des Autrichiens et des Russes et leur faire comprendre que leur ennemi commun était la Grande Bretagne... Mais Napoléon était trop sûr de sa force militaire, trop ambitieux et trop orgueilleux pour s'abaisser à négocier et à privilégier le long terme, plutôt que des victoires immédiates, prestigieuses, mais sanglantes et onéreuses. Pour moi, il a su être un stratège militaire, mais pas un stratège politique...
You have provided a considerable insight about the political preamble to the invasion of Russia & this terrible battle. Thank you.
I am trying very hard to learn the French language. I think that I mostly understood what you had typed, but I then decided to paste your French words into an online translator to make sure that I understand fully. From Grande Bretagne.
@@johnkay4701 Thank you for your kind comment, my friend. Congratulations if you want to learn french or improve your practice... But i have to warn you that it is a very sophisticated language, in particular in grammar and conjugation, almost as difficult as latin... But very precise and beautiful. In my opinion, the best way to learn it, is the natural way. I mean, to learn first the daily life french (But correct french, not slang), and step by step you learn the correspondent grammar... Then, slowly, you'll approach a more intellectual french... If this may encourage you, you have to know that a lot of words are similar or very close in french and english (thanks to Guillaume le Conquérant and later to the house of Plantagenêt) . Besides, more than two hundred million people speak french in the world... It's not so bad! Salutations de France.
Commentaire pas très futé. Tu penses qu'ils n'ont pas négociés auparavant ? Combien de traités de paix Napoléon a signé et combien de fois ces monarchies l'ont foulé aux pieds ?? La Russie était justement en train de changer de camp (pour le nième fois), pour se rapprocher des anglais et de former une autre coalition !! Qu'est ce que Napoléon aurait pu faire de plus ?? Ces monarchies voulaient restaurer la monarchie en France. Point.
Avant Napoléon, ils ont déclarés la guerre à la france. C'est aussi la faute de Napoléon ??
@@thierryfromgwada9312 Ta réponse est typique de certains individus qui sur le net, donnent facilement dans l'arrogance et le mépris, pour satisfaire leur égo et palier sans doute à quelques frustrations... Les pseudos et l'anonymat sont bien pratiques pour cela. C'est marrant, parce que dans la vie réelle, les gens aiment bien discuter avec moi, et se montrent plutôt respectueux. Je n'ose croire que ce soit uniquement à cause de ma belle gueule, de mon mètre quatre-vingt cinq et de mes quatre vingt dix kilos... J'ai donc pris l'habitude de ne plus perdre mon temps avec des gens comme toi...
@@alfredvikingelegant9156 Blablabla... Pourquoi tu me donnes ta taille et ton poids ? 😂
Evites d'intervenir sur des sujets que tu ne maîtrises pas.
nice, you next time you should try Michael Hordern ai voice for the "barry lyndon" Napoleon 3 mod
please correct commander Bagration it doesn't pronounce as "bagraishn" its Royal family of Georgia and pronounce as it written Bagration.
Apologises the narration was generated with AI
Obviously, Napoleon didn’t play Risk, or he wouldn’t have invaded
that is how war should be fought two armies facing each other ,no tanks ,aircraft just infantry and horse cavalry
Someo0ne in comments always says whatever is the subject of the video is terrible these days, and they were better when they were younger, but this takes the cake.
Awesome video, a question: How to keep the corpses on the battlefield?. Bloodiest day, not bloodiest battle. Leipzig was significantly bloodier.
It’s just a feature on the game, you can enable it in the settings, if you are having more difficulties let me know👍
They both were bloody .
roundshot does not explode on contact but bounces
1:56 Man, Napoleon wasn't just the best "commander" of his age, he was arguably the greatest GENERAL in history!
Say what you wanna say, Napoleon was The craziest and biggest general of The story.
To think anything is easy in war is to never have engaged
i would like to see continuoisly scrolling maps with all the action depicted...............
The more i learn about the battle the more i feel for jerome having to use his garde like it was worthless to napoleon like it was yet but a normal infantry. I sometimes wonder what he felt having to charge his westphalian garde at the redoubts.
Can you do sekigahara, nagano, that battle between Qin and Chu. Siege of Carthage, Lapanto, Palatea? You and the other docos should colaborate. Maybe get the channels involed? Would love to help especially if you wanna make it battlefield britian/ancient battles style. PLUS Actors incerps (drool)
Yes I will certainly look into these. Siege of Carthage is one I started editing but never finished for some reason, I will definitely revisit it. I haven't really thought about collaborating but it's something I'd be open to. But yes I always could do with help on my videos they take so long😆
Respect to Pyotr Bagration. My man gave the grand armee a run for their money.
No scale taken into account. Audio is all over the place too.
Never, EVER(!) assume ANY Campaign you undertake will be a short one. Design it to be short, but ALWAYS(!) plan for a long grinding Campaign of Attrition and adjust your Logistics (including replacements and reinforcements) accordingly.
What shortcut is used to remove all toggles in Napoleon Total War?
You can’t do it on napoleon the movie effect is from my recording software, best you can do is just to toggle everything off in the settings
@@cinematicbattles559 Thank you very much.
Hey mate can I ask what mods you used here ? Great video
3:30 damn, i wonder who was fatiqued.
Only one moral of a battle, either kill or ready to die.
This video has a flaw in that when the troops are shouting and guns bombing, it drowns out the narrator.
I would love to have a flame thrower in these kinds of battles 😅
Vive La Grande Armée Et Son Empereur. Willy
Fascinating, thank you.
Great cinematography and editing. It’s a shame that Empire and Napoleons’ sounds are so weedy and pathetic. Shogun 2 does guns way better. Still, very good video.
By the way, what blood mod do you use?
I use the field command mod for napoleon 👍
Thank you@@cinematicbattles559
I wonder if anyone took the time to stop and smell the flowers, they look quite nice.
Maybe you don't know, but it's been Emperor, not Tsar, since Peter the Great.
When will we finally see a "TW Napoleon 2" ?
PS. Awesome video.
Thanks!
I think that never.
I Wonder If This Was Featured In The Movie War & Peace?
Война и мир это художественный рассказ а не исторический.
Which software is used to creat visual like this 😮
Napoleon: Total War is the game, and I use DaVinci Resolve to edit
@@cinematicbattles559 ok...but I seen some other videos like these visuals and they go according to story line ...is it they edit so close or really a software which can creat scenes like this. ?
how did he cross 450,000 across 3 pontoon bridges, but when it cam time for battle Napoleon only had 1/4 of that many? What happened to the rest?
They died from starvation or disease or picked off by small Russian resistance forces
@@cinematicbattles559 300,000 troops...
Indeed, Napoleon's army biggest loses was before Borodino, due to malnutrition, diseases ( typhoid fever ) and desertion. Combat loses are pretty low. Google for Charles Minard statistics 1812
@@jacktrade1592 They split off, there's no single column of 450.000 soldiers, that's the grand total, Napoleon commanded the main army group but there were others guarding the flanks and the supply lines.
How do u keep a army that size fed and watered
This was indeed a major issue for Napoleon as he didn't bring enough supplies and many of his men died from starvation
This was a time were Generals led from the front and the results were 49 French Generals dead or wounded and 22 Russian Generals dead or wounded including Prince Bagration who died about two weeks after the battle. The number of Colonels was higher it was a brutal fight that lasted but in the end the Russians were defeated and if they had continued fighting the next day it would had been a total disaster for the Russians.
Great point. Back then, officers literally led from the front, and they were slaughtered in great numbers. Even Generals were known to take part in, or personally lead, some of the great cavalry charges of the era.
The loss of so many officers at Borodino caused the battlefield to be even more chaotic. It was said you couldn't hear musket fire on the battlefield as it was drowned out by cannon fire. 500-600 cannons on each side was one of the reasons for the appalling death toll.
@@martyn8116 So true since whole Infantry Battalions and Cavalry Regiments basically cease to exist after this Battle. But while history tries to get you to believe that "General Winter" destroyed Napoleon's Army there are many different factors that led to the disaster of 1812; first Napoleon had around 34,000 Austrians in his Army who operating with the Saxons were on the Southern front and they went over to the Russian side and later captured quite a few Saxon afterwards. That was around 50,000 troops gone and there was also a Northern front of around 100,000 troops. But the biggest killer was Typhus and not the cold of winter. Typhus ran through his troops during the summer after he invaded.
@chestersleezer8821 I didn't know about the sneaky Austrians. I recall over 200 line regiments of the Grand Armee, many seasoned units, were all but wiped out. I've always wondered how Waterloo, the following year, might have been different with all those crack soldiers on the field, rather than buried in Russia.
Speaking of chaos in the battlefield, Wellington in Spain always moaned about his aristocratic calvalry regiments, especially the heavies, for some reason, were a law unto themselves, and only charged when they felt like it! Haha.
@@martyn8116 Well, in 1813 was an even larger and more bloody battle - Leipzig. Waterloo was 1815. Not 1813. Maybe you should read a book or two about history. Thanks a lot.
That was one of the reasons, Kutuzov withdrew the Russian army, using scorched earth tactic. Now they only had to wait, as hunger and cold takes it's toll on the French. Not to mention the continuous harassment of French troops by Russian guerilla warfare.
Hi which software do you use to record this?
Nvidia shadow play, it’s free if you have a nvidia graphics card
@@cinematicbattles559 thanks :)
Là Victoire est à Nous 💔
1
Tervitus ja tänu
1 Paulus, Kristuse Jeesuse apostel Jumala tahtmisel selle elu
tõotust mööda, mis on Kristuses Jeesuses, -
2 armsale pojale Timoteosele: Armu, halastust ja rahu Jumalalt
Isalt ja Kristuselt Jeesuselt, meie Issandalt!
3 Ma olen tänulik Jumalale, keda ma oma esivanemate viisil puhta
südametunnistusega teenin, alatasa meenutades sind oma eestpalvetes
ööl ja päeval,
4 ning igatsedes sind näha, kui mulle tulevad meelde sinu pisarad, et ma
saaksin täis rõõmu,
5 mäletades sinu siirast usku, mis esmalt elas sinu vanaemas Loises
ja sinu emas Eunikes ja nüüd - selles olen ma veendunud - elab ka
sinus.
Julgustus kartmatuks Kristuse tunnistamiseks
6 Sel põhjusel tuletan ma sulle meelde, et sa taas õhutaksid lõkkele Jumala
ande, mis on sinus minu käte pealepanemise kaudu.
7 Jumal ei ole meile ju andnud arguse vaimu, vaid väe ja armastuse
ja mõistlikkuse vaimu.
8 Ära siis häbene tunnistamast meie Issandat ega mind, tema vangi,
vaid kannata koos minuga kurja evangeeliumi pärast Jumala väe abil,
9 kes on meid päästnud
ja kutsunud püha kutsega,
mitte meie tegude järgi,
vaid omaenese kavatsuse ja armu järgi,
mis meile on antud Kristuses Jeesuses
enne igavesi aegu,
10 nüüd on aga saanud avalikuks
meie Päästja Kristuse Jeesuse ilmumise läbi,
kes on kõrvaldanud surma
ning on evangeeliumi kaudu
toonud valge ette elu ja kadumatuse,
11 mille kuulutajaks ja apostliks ning õpetajaks mind on seatud.
12 Sel põhjusel ma ka kannatan. Ent ma ei häbene, sest ma
tean, kellesse ma olen uskuma hakanud ja olen veendunud, et tema on
vägev hoidma minu hoolde usaldatut oma päevani.
13 Võta terve õpetuse eeskujuks see, mida sa minult oled kuulnud
usus ja armastuses, mis on Kristuses Jeesuses!
14 Seda head, mis su hoolde on usaldatud, hoia Püha Vaimu abil,
kes meis elab.
15 Sa tead seda, et mulle on pööranud selja kõik, kes on Aasias,
nende seas Fügelos ja Hermogenes.
16 Issand andku halastust Onesiforose kodule, sest tema on mind
sagedasti kosutanud ega ole häbenenud mu ahelaid,
17 vaid kui ta juhtus Rooma, otsis ta mind hoolega ning leidis
üles.
18 Issand andku talle leida halastust Issanda käest oma päeval!
Ja kui palju ta on abistanud mind Efesoses, tead sina kõige paremini.
2Kuula
Julgustus kartmatuks Kristuse tunnistamiseks
1 Sina siis, mu poeg, saa vägevaks armus, mis on Kristuses Jeesuses!
2 Ja mida sa minult oled kuulnud paljude tunnistajate kuuldes, see
anna ustavate inimeste hoolde, kes edaspidi sobivad õpetama ka teisi.
3 Kannata koos minuga kurja nagu Kristuse Jeesuse tubli sõdur!
4 Ükski, kes on sõjateenistuses, ei seo end argielu askeldustega,
kui ta tahab jääda meelepäraseks sellele, kes ta on sõduriks kutsunud.
5 Ja kui keegi võistleb, ei saa ta ometi võidupärga, kui ta ei
võistle korrakohaselt.
6 Tööd rügav põllumees peab esimesena saama osa viljast.
7 Mõtle sellele, mis ma ütlen! Küll Issand annab sulle arusaamist kõiges.
8 Olgu sul meeles Jeesus Kristus, kes on üles äratatud surnuist,
kes põlvneb Taaveti soost! See on evangeelium,
9 mille pärast ma kannatan kurja ja olen koguni ahelates nagu mõni
roimar. Kuid Jumala sõna ei ole ahelais.
10 Seetõttu ma talun kõike äravalitute pärast, et ka nemad saaksid
pääste Kristuses Jeesuses igavese kirkusega.
11 Ustav on see sõna:
Kui me oleme surnud koos temaga,
siis ka elame koos temaga,
12 kui me jääme püsima vaevas,
siis valitseme koos kuningatena,
kui me tema salgame,
siis salgab ka tema meid,
13 kui me oleme uskmatud,
jääb tema ometi ustavaks,
sest ta ei saa ennast salata.
Õhutus olla kõlblik töötegija Jumalale
14 Seda tuleta neile meelde, vannutades Jumala ees, et nad ei peaks
sõnasõda - sellest pole mingit kasu, see vaid hukutab kuulajad.
15 Püüa hoolega osutuda Jumala ees kõlblikuks töötegijana, kel
pole tarvis häbeneda, kes tõe sõna kuulutab õigesti.
16 Labastest tühijuttudest hoidu aga eemale! Nende rääkijad ju
lähevad aina kaugemale jumalakartmatuses
17 ja nende sõna levib otsekui vähktõbi. Nende seast on
Hümenaios ja Fileetos,
18 kes on kaldunud kõrvale tõest, öeldes, et ülestõusmine on juba
toimunud, ning rikuvad ära mõnede usu.
19 Ometi püsib kindlana Jumala seatud aluskivi, millel on see pitser:
„Issand tunneb omi” ja „Ülekohtust taganegu igaüks, kes nimetab Issanda
nime”.
20 Aga suures majas ei ole üksnes kuld- ja hõbeastjaid, vaid neid
on ka puust ja savist - osa auliseks, osa autuks tarbeks.
21 Kui nüüd keegi end puhastab neist vigadest, siis ta saab
auliseks astjaks, pühitsetuks ja peremehele kasulikuks, valmiks
igale heale teole.
22 Põgene noorusea himude eest! Taotle õiglust, usku,
armastust ja rahu nendega, kes Issandat appi hüüavad puhtast südamest!
23 Aga sõgedad ja kasvatamatud arutlemised lükka tagasi, teades, et
need tekitavad tülisid.
24 Issanda sulasel ei ole tarvis tülitseda, vaid ta olgu lahke
kõikide vastu, osav õpetama, valmis kannatama kurja,
25 kes tasadusega kasvatab vastupanijaid selleks, et ehk Jumal
annab neile meeleparandust tõe mõistmiseks,
26 ja et nad kaineneksid ja pääseksid lahti kuradi paelust, mis on
püüdnud nad oma tahtmise valda.
so cool
Love the game too Total War😂
How did u get the french eagle into the game???
No idea😂I am using the field command mod so maybe this adds it but im not sure
What was the name of the mods you used i wanna try to get the same experience as this
It was just the field command mod for napoleon total war
@@cinematicbattles559 what about the flags and equipment and uniforms?
Ima leave my comment here to know the mods
This was his most terrible? No mention of Arthur Wellesley then?
crazy vid
Cheers took a while
Anyone know which mod is being used?
It’s the field command mod for napoleon total war
are you using mod for this?
The field command mod for Napoleon: Total War
the french marching is my eye candy fr fr
Man what mod did you use?
Field command mod for Napoleon: Total War
@@cinematicbattles559 Thanks! Appreciate it.
What mod is this
there is a mod ?
I'm using the field command mod
@cinematicbattles559 okay ty
What mod did you used? I'm amused
Field command mod
@@cinematicbattles559 may we ask instructions on how to install?
The morale of story;
Never enter deep into enemy territory with only 3 weeks ration.
Never dream of easy and quick victory against Russia.
Never conquered Moscow without secured access to nearby territory with supplies, garrison, and leave no room for the enemy to flank. In short, Advance slowly with full stomach, and prepare for battle of attrition. Play safe.
If we could get all the battles that napoleon did, that would be cool to get this in total war..
What Mod are you using?
Field command mod
Marshall Davout asked Napoleon to outflank Russian army but he refused instead opted for a frontal assault that was his mistake
this looks so realistic until you notice every soldier has the same face. but yeah the numbers of soldiers involved would look like this. too bad we don't have as many napoleonic war reenactors as we do us civil war or ww2.
Look at Waterloo 2015, there was 5 000 on the field.
dang I wish I could attend as a reenactor but here in USA cant find a local Napoleonic group to reenact as the Frenchies. I hear flintlock need some real training to use at these things prior to an event.
What mod did you use?
Field command mod
The grande army fired more than 60.000 rd. Of cannon ball.according to french soldiers claim that the russian casualties was appalling and horrendous.
All Borodino casualties have been summarised long ago. The French casualties do not differ significally.
Fatigued men ?
Not tired men ?
WON THE BATTLE LOST THE WAR ??.
Which mods were used for this video?
The Field Command mod for Napoleon Total War
@@cinematicbattles559 ah yes, the multiplayer centred one, thanks!
@@breakfaust No worries !
The only problem there is napoleon didn’t do any fighting his cannon fodder did .
I'm glad Sega fixed the game for the Intel 12th gen processors.
for some reasons people always pronounce "Bag-gra-tion" but his name should be pronounce as "Ba-gra-ti-on"
That may be because they're usually not Russian? I don't speak Russian so I pronounce the name in English.
@@jessiemeisenheimer8675no offense, but only a small note for people
During his disastrous Moscow adventure, 92% of Napoleon's men died from Typhus, contracted from Rat Fleas in Poland, not from contact with enemy fire.
Otto, it's the first time I've heard of such a wonderful discovery. Though it would be better to explain why 35 000 French, healthy in the morning died from Typhus in the duration of one day at Borodino alone. And soon the same had happened with 8 000 of them at Little Yaroslavets.
@@vadimpm1290perhaps he is an pest extreminator and trying to highlight the disastrous effect of rats on naepoloens army so he gets more business.
Capitalistic methods of advertisement are very ingenious you know .
Делать исторические сражения на ваниле Napoleon Total war или NTW III та ещё бессмысленная фигня.)
The french lost their best soldiers in russia just like what hitler did in russia
450.000? More like 600.000