Clay & Hannah • "You did an evil thing!" [13 REASONS WHY]
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 พ.ค. 2018
- Hey guys, sorry this took so long a lot has been going on recently so this video had to be postponed a little bit.
I've been waiting for Season 2, and been planning this edit for months! So it feels good to finally get it out, and I have plenty of other edits in store so I'm looking forward to sharing them with you in the future!
I do not own the content in this video!
───────────────────────────────────────
Program: Vegas Pro 14.0
Video Tracks: 5
Audio Tracks: 3
TV Show: 13 Reasons Why [Clay and Hannah]
Song: Sorry by Halsey
───────────────────────────────────────
Contact me:
Join us on Discord: / discord
Instagram: / itsatwinthing_yt
Twitter: / itsatwinthingyt
Tumblr: / itsatwinthing-yt - ภาพยนตร์และแอนิเมชัน
![Hannah's Poem • "What if my melodies are the one's nobody hears?" [13 REASONS WHY]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZYU2V6ie6So/mqdefault.jpg)
![Hannah's Poem • "What if my melodies are the one's nobody hears?" [13 REASONS WHY]](/img/tr.png)
![Clay & Justin | "Will you hold my hand, bro?" [13 Reasons Why]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/rb0bUZFp-RQ/mqdefault.jpg)
For the MANY of you commenting or planning to comment asking the song or what the show is called here's some advice... Look in the description! 👍
i like this comment :D and love the video
Can you tell me some others channel
X PELL Some other channels for what?
@@ItsATwinThingYT like lucifer or originals i would be glad to know
@@MRKHAN-qh7cz Oh like TV shows, hmmm Game of Thrones, Vikings, Westworld, Humans, The Handmaid's Tale, The Good Doctor, Wynonna Earp, Sherlock, Orphan Black, Black Mirror, The 100, American Horror Story. There are so so so many.
"MEMORIES"
Sometimes they are relief.
Sometimes they are torture.
Ok
Yes😢😢
Kishore Nukala “memories can be vile repulsive little brutes, like children I suppose? Hhahahaahah”
So true..
Memories are good when the person is with us..
Memories are bad when we realise it's not the same any more like how it used to be..✌️💔Good or bad..they never left us haunting though❕
“Are you real?”
“Do you *see* me?”
:( SAD - lavel 1000
:((
Really I love you
@@nemesis6348 why are you sad?
@@nemesis6348 be happy
"Why didn't u say this to me when I was alive?"
This part hurts me every time😖💓
Why he have to say... Hannah loose virginity with zach and sex with him throughout the summer and when clay and hannah hooked up hannah refused to do WHY ❓😩
@@dibyajyoti3038 cuz that reminds her of b.walker !
"You did an evil thing " 😞
deepthi mayi me too,for me was the most emotional part
Don't get hurt. Smile and make her alive back
Okay hands down this is the best Hannah & Clay video ever
Aw, thank you so much I'm glad you think so! ^-^
YASSS...THIS THE BEST EDIT... I LOVE IT !!!! ❤
Probably ; its really good
Hanna Toperczer yeah true
Hanna Toperczer same
'I love you and I let you go' makes me tear up every time.
Ya I mean that line is way too much tough to hold back the tear.
hi
Hello how are you?
"i love you and i let you go at the same time"...pretty much relatable.
The relationship the had was pure and soo damn beautiful
Clay and Hannah have the saddest ending to a love story I've ever seen. Partly becuase they never really got past the beginning of it before it ended, since they never told eachother how they feel. It's crushing.
Smh teenagers. If only they spoke their minds when it was most important
If only everyone would, not just teenagers. This show is about anyone going through stuff.@@K-aoss
"You did an evil thing
Leaving me
Angry
Empty
And confused" 💔
Be a Clay Jensen in a world full of Bryce Walker.
So true
*yes*
Yes🥺
I'd say please be a little more open than Clay, because Clay couldn't share his feelings. Sometimes inner feelings should 'ALWAYS' be Freed Out!
And lose the girl that you love as well.
We want Hannah back!
That is stupid
@@amlandutta2933 exactly 😑😑
JD WORLD no it’s not , they could make season four be a season of her not going through with the suicide , what it would have been like , (show Montgomery’s home life growing up , etc) and then go back to the wack timeline with ani and them in season 5 😞
Guys plz tell me what happened with hannah??????? 🥺 M waiting for your comment, pzlzzzzz
She committed suicide, that's the whole story.
"someone will love you, but someone isn't me" feels like Hannah is saying that to Clay
Effy Smolderholder It’s almost as if the song choice was deliberate! 😂
But it doesn’t matter who will love Clay,he will always love Hannah.Sorry girls!
she is funny and smart, and moody and maddening, and beautiful.
She didn’t know she was all that.Clay never told her…
@@Khloe_dancer_model cause he was scared to love
@@LaytonFC yeah.He didn’t know how to handle his emotions yet.
When Clay said "Get the f*ck out," is he referring to when she yelled the same thing to him at Jessica's party? Or was it just a coincidence?
We'll never know I guess...
artist 252 no , he was referring to the party
@@ItsATwinThingYT maybe we will. There's a 3rd season coming up
So let's just see ...
@@medhavins9099 Hannah isn't going to be in season 3 so unless he talks about it to someone...
@@ItsATwinThingYT basically that's what I meant
Her topic maybe brought out in it...
As I said .
Let's see....
Hannah... she didn’t want to be with clay because she thought she would ruin him. But leaving damaged him beyond anything she could have done when she was alive
Because she thought she was less than nothing because she was made to think that way.
My boy Clay got played. But i guess good guys ends up getting played. Clay deserved better as Hannah Loved Zach. She only saw Clay as a trustable friend. That's why she chose zach and freaked out when Clay Kissed her as she had feelings for Zach.
So, my boy Clay was indeed on the loosing side for being a one sided lover.
@@obitheworldexplorer no she didn’t love Zach but that was a one summer thing she loved clay but thought she would ruin him
"Why didn't you say that to me when I was alive?"
Maybe because you never noticed him. Maybe because he was their for you and you pushed him away because you had your own problems but you didn't notice that he had problems too. His problem was that he loved you too much and you left him. He heard rumors about you and still he loved you. You died and he yet he still loves you.
Yea that fucks my mind feels so sad that they never had their moments. We cant blame hannah also but yea suicide was bad decision. Just imagine if she opened up to clay insted of trusting all thosw shit people where she could have trusted clay,helmet,astrology boy....... Man thats just aches my chest. They could have been so complete but that never happened hannah us gone but clay he will suffer for his lifetime because she was his love of life.
@@harshalkale5999 finally someone said it 🖤
and this is only in films and books..
She was definitely afraid to love him too. She scooted closer to him during the lunar eclipse, she realized she was describing him during dollar valentine's, she was suggestive to him several times, but never outright tried to advance their relationship. Clay was awkward, but Hannah blatantly and intentionally never told him how she felt.
Them not being together was more her fault than his. She'd be alive and they would be together if either of them were more honest with their feelings.
@@XF3693 she didn’t know he loved her.And her friend at the very beginning,the one that left town,told Clay she had terrible taste in guys,so WHY TRY? You know?
awww this literally brought tears to my eyes! I think Clay and Hannah should have happened. Clay really loved her deeply and that was exactly what Hannah needed to feel loved and supported, to feel less lonely in her pain. Who knows maybe things would have turned out different. I feel that you showed perfectly that strong connection and love in this video. We can feel how badly Clay loved her and how much he was hurting when she died. I am happy you ended the video with that scene when she let's her go and finds peace. It makes sense and it calms down all of those feelings we where experiencing in the video, we find peace with Clay.
Anyways, this is such a sad but beautiful video. Well done!
Aw, really? Thank you so much I'm glad you thought it was beautiful. ^-^ Yeah initially I was editing with just Season 1, and when I heard season 2 was close to airing I stopped and waited for the episodes and I think it helped the video a lot more. It's definitely the ending it needed.
ItsATwinThing Yes I am glad you waited because your video is so well done I couldn’t imagine it with only season 1. What you did here is so good, I can see you worked hard on it because it is really well structured and the voiceovers and scenes you used make the video powerful. It all mixes so well together!
Exactly that is the ending we needed. I am so happy you ended it like this !
Jureth Prodz well said 👏🏼
banufshay.aejaz thank you :)
Jureth Prodz np :)
Clay is an angel in a world full of evil people ....
I WISH he had told Hannah his feelings:'(:'(
Clay isn't perfect.
@@ItsATwinThingYT no one is ever perfect
Yeah, I know. Which is why I said Clay isn't perfect...
Me too
I think he did when they had sex on jessica's party
Oh wait it's the alternate version if he didn't leave sorry
"Clay jeansen hates me" 💔 this really heart wreck.. she was too emotional and about to cry when she said this......
Every time their chemistry just touches the heart..
One of the most beautiful and sad love story I've ever saw...
Clay's scream really hurts so bad..breaks everything inside of you
The beauty of the name 'Hannah' is that it spells same from both front and the back❤
One of the best series of the Netflix ever... i bet no teenage series can beat this...
"I love you Hannah .....and I'll let you go"💝💖❤️❤️❤️
Whole pain can be described in one line "Life is divided into 2 part one before Hannah and one after"
It hurts when she said ...
"Why didn't you tell this to me when i was alive"💔💔
I have seen this video over three or four times in the space of a month...it makes me cry every time
Aw, I'm sorry!
No no it’s a good thing it’s supposed to be emotional lol
Curlyfries Forever same
The transition from this happy and bubbly clay to a more confused sad and frustrated clay is crazy. It’s like the clay we knew would never get a tattoo but he did and he didn’t even flinch when finishing it, Hannah changed everything when she didn’t mean to
Omg this is so good!! I loved all of your 13 reasons why video but this one is really special!
I’m going to miss Katherine in s3
ForeverYours Wait there's gonna be a season 3?
There still deciding right now
MONSTER BOY2005 yeah the s3 is confirmed because Katherine said by herself she will be not in it
Aw, thank you so much! I'm really glad you enjoyed it! Yeah, I'll definitely miss Katherine but it does make sense for her not to appear anymore as her story has finished. I'll be watching for Zach now! ^-^
They cant just end it with Clay holding a gun and dont forget that Justin's "father" saw him from the window there have to be s3
OMG this was so heart wrenching. No kidding I have a heart of stone but I had tears after watching it
Aw, really? Thank you so much I'm glad to hear that the edit managed to do that it means a lot! ^-^
I don't know what to say.,,, You totally break me down.. GIRL THIS IS FUCKING BEAUTIFUL THE SCENES,WORDS ARE CONNECTED PERFECT. I never seen so good music video with Clannah.JUST...RESPECT
Sorry for my bad english but i'm Polish girl and i'm still learning this language
❤
Aw, thank you so much I'm so glad to hear you enjoyed the video it means a lot! As for your English, I can fully understand what you're saying so no problem there, you're doing great keep it up!
ItsATwinThing OMG you answered me !:0 and no problem you deserved for that and i’m glad you understand me ❤️💕
-I love you hannah...
-Why you didn't say this to me when i was alive💔
Title of movie please 😥
@@jawadlalana5287 13 reasons why
"You tutor him in academics and he teaches you in.."
"Girls. Um, girl. Singular"
I lost it kind of, there❤️
"So hannah, I love you and I let you go"
This is the most beautiful heartbreaking and the most saddening beautiful line ever. It has all my heart❤️
In the world full of BRYCE WALKERS be a CLAY JENSEN💓
wow my heart just fell out of my chest!! this was absolutely heartbreaking!
Aw, I'm sorry! ^-^
@md rasel frazee 13 reason why
This is one of my favorite edits it's so heartfelt and beautiful thank you
Aw, thank you so much I'm glad you enjoyed it. ^-^
One of my bestfriends (who's like a little sister to me) just recommended this video to me. I started to cry so much as I watched it
This is the most touching and heartbreaking Lovestory i have ever seen. Everytime i watch them i want to shout Clay why he didn't kiss Hannah before.He had so many chances and she waited for his kiss you could see that at the roof of the Crestmont or when he walked her home. His love could have changed her life forever.
I really love the emotion between them ❤️. It's so adorable..& I wish she would come back into his life 😭
Every time I see Clay and Hannah having fun together reminds me of Jack and Rose from Titanic
Literally gave Goosebumps ❤️❤️❤️
Aw, really? Awesome! :D
I still watch this edit on occasion cause I relate to it so much and the song matches their relationship perfectly
SEASON 1 WAS HELL OF A SEASON I HAVE NEVER SEEN SUCH STORY IN MY LIFE
Now this series is just touched to my heart or say beats of my heart can't forget about it..
It just awesome 😍🤗
I’m glad this was recommended to me. I’m in tears watching this, it’s for sure one of the best edits I’ve seen :)
Aw, thank you so much I'm really glad you enjoyed the video!
Watching this video and reading comments made my goosebumps go mad🙁
I just recently watched 13 reasons why and it broke me but I'm so glad I watched it, loved this show so much. This edit just brought back all the sad, heartwarming and happiest moments hannah and clay had together. @ItsATwinThing, u created a masterpiece ❤❤🔥🔥
This video is so perfect! I usually never comment on anyone’s videos, but your videos are so amazing! I won’t get tired of looking at them. You have all of my respect for taking the time and care to make videos like this.
Aw, thank you so much I'm really glad you liked it enough to comment, that means a lot! ^-^
F
I'm literally crying right now. My heart aches so much seeing this 😢
I can't stop my tears when see you 😢
I m obsessed with this series..
It is so.,.. I don't know... I can't explain... I just love it
Oh my god, it's so beautiful. I can feel the river of tears coming from my eyes.
Aw, thank you so much! I'm glad you liked it! ^-^
Best video of hannah and clay
Aw, thank you so much I'm glad you liked it.
I remember one line of Hannah and can never forget( that proves that how strong impression this show has made) that ," How many times a person have to die to prove that thing they did or said ,hurts."
It's so intense.
I don't remember that line in the TV show anyway?
Ohhh, it was so touching! I’m crying right now. It’s the most beautiful, touching and just the best video about Clay and Hannah. Thank you for it!
Aw, thank you so much! I'm so glad you liked it! ^-^
this was beautiful! really shows the heartbreaking connection between them, well done!!
Aw, thank you so much I'm really glad you thought so! ^-^
"Clay jenson hates me"that was the final nail in the coffin for her, her light of her world and when it went out she gave up on living
The video reminds me of the moments I spent with someone and when I looked at the show name in description, I realized why she often used to suggest that we watch it together :(
I do love this video so much, I had goosebumps on it. I have watched it a billion times, and now, when I have watched it after a long time I understand why somewhen I added it to favourites
This is stunning 💔
Aw, thank you! ^-^
this is so beautiful! clay and hannah deserved better, truly. the way clay loved her so much, and the way they are so dorky, and beautiful. i love them so much, i'm going to miss clannah 💓
Aw, thank you so much I'm glad you liked it! ^-^
If one thing that I could do in my power I would make the scene for real... when clay and Hannah walk through the crowd in the school holding hands..and both smiling that was so so beautiful..❤️
Every time I watch this I literally get goosebumps ♥️♥️♥️
Aw, really?
ItsATwinThing yes
The first two seasons of clay and hannah remineded of me and my childhood love it broke me so much
This is really beautiful!! Well done who ever edited this x
Thank you, it's my channel it was edited by me.
Serious i have no words for this amazing edit i watchted the show and was so emocional and this video just made me cry so much
it’s just perfect 👏🏾😢❤️
Thank you so much 🥰
This is so sad and the song omg... 😭😭😭😭😭😭 My babies deserved happiness. 💔💔💔
#Sorrynotsorry That's the point of the video xD
This was so beautiful and heart shattering.
Aw, thank you! ^-^
I was in my worse time when I finally decided to watch 13 reasons why, I binged watched both seasons and my God this TV show is my favorite, but I'm not sure If I should have watched it through my worst times but then again I think it was worth it, then I watched these sad sad amv or whatever you call them over sad songs being played, lots of love for this video right here.
Aw, thank you so much I'm glad you enjoyed it! ^-^
wow this is so powerful! thank you for this edit!
Aw, thank you so much I'm glad you liked it!
I truly loved this video it was amazing and really special and sweet . I love 13 REASONS WHY
Thank you! I'm glad you liked it. ^-^
“I tried to forget you, I tried so hard”
I’m really looking forward for the next season of this!
I can't stop my tears when I see this video.
I love that he saw her. Like she was his conscious or something.
this is so incredible I actually might cry. I love this couple
Aw, thank you so much! ^-^
Best edit I’ve seen and I really needed this so thank you
Thank you, I'm glad you liked it.
This video is simply one of the best edits I've ever seen !!! Love 13RW and love love love the way you tell this story! CONGRATS CONGRATS CONGRATS
Aw, really? I'm so glad that it inspired you.
When ever i recall this series i always think what if Hannah would have been alive throughout the series...it give Goosebumps
Then the storyline of the tapes wouldn't make sense.
@@ItsATwinThingYT it feels so disturbing watching this series ...i can't stop and not even see
WOW this is breathtaking and beautiful and heart-wrenching and wonderful. I love this tribute to Clay's grief in season 2. It reminds me of specific lines that kinda bothered me, especially since you chose to title this entire vid over one of them... I do not like calling suicide an evil thing... I think it stigmatizes having thoughts of suicide instead of being sympathetic and feeling like others around them will have sympathy helps them choose to seek help? Idk I have a lot of feelings because I've lost two people close to me to suicide.
But anyway this video was gorgeous and so emotional!! One of my favorite parts is the juxtaposition of her telling him get the fuck out with him later saying it to "her"/his manifestation of grief. I also love right after the evil thing line how you matched the rest of what she left Clay, visually. And SO SO many other moments. Thank you for making this.
Thank you I'm glad you liked it. I always put a lot of thought into the videos that I make so I'm glad that came across.
As for the title, it's supposed to make you click on it that's all it is. My original title was going to be "I love you, and I let you go." But that isn't reflected in the thumbnail and it was already taken by someone else.
The point of this video is to point out that what Hannah did by committing suicide is wrong. I'm not saying and the quote certainly doesn't say that to have suicidal thoughts is evil because people suffering from those thoughts need help and sympathy as you pointed out. But to actually commit to the act of suicide is evil is what it's saying.
"You did an evil thing." is Clay saying in very simple terms "You did a bad thing." (By killing herself) he never said having the thoughts were evil. The word Evil is more powerful than using 'wrong' or 'bad' it's conveying Clay's hurt and anger at what Hannah did. That is why I chose the title, not to stigmatise but because it was powerful.
Yeah it was a compelling title choice for sure. :) And thumbnail too, to match. And I always adore your vidding, it's always really impressive.
About this one little detail though I strongly disagree. I saw you telling a suicidal person on this video itself in the comments that "it was an evil thing to do and it's also selfish" which is not a helpful thing to say to someone in that place. People who are considering suicide feel they are burdens on those around them OR that no one cares, or a little of both. Positively convincing them people care and giving them hope is one thing, but just adding more negativity of "Think of who you'll hurt" is generally not particularly effective. It depends on the person, sometimes knowing it will hurt others is the one thing stopping them from killing themselves, but this person is overwhelmed by depression and horrible emotions and thoughts, their worldview is distorted in a way that isn't their own fault, it's a mental crisis, and calling something they do while in that state evil or implying it needs forgiveness like Clay and the writers of this show did, I hate that so much. What it is is SAD, horribly TRAGIC, not EVIL. The person could've and should've been saved, but not from hell. From death. Like. Philosophies of good vs. evil are complex and whatnot but I wish about suicide now that we're in the year 2018 people could agree that a person who attempts suicide or dies this way was not exactly in a sound state of mind, and was not acting on free will while knowing and believing it would hurt others around them. They believed it would HELP others in many cases, which is horribly wrong but true of their state of mind.
Yeah we can agree to disagree on a lot of the nuance - while agreeing on the big parts of how it would be best to prevent suicides in the future and all that. Thank you for not hating me after this conversation. I really adore your vidding and strive to make a video as powerful as most of yours!! I really want to compliment you again on this vid here, especially how you found such a PERFECT song choice, it works so very well.
I have complicated thoughts on "Wrong" and "right" anyway and have for a long time, my take on morality is going to be different than the average person's and all that, so using the word "evil" pretty much always rubs me the wrong way, even for "indisputably" horrible, hurtful, criminal, scary things people do, the worst actions humans can take on each other, because idk I instead find other words more descriptive in the way I'd like. So I'm gonna disagree with the majority of people on the planet for that stance lol...
To me, Evil often implies too much of black & white thinking or something, or maybe implies something about the person doing the act being purely evil (can a "Good person" do an "Evil thing"? Or does doing an "Evil thing" make a person, in and of themselves, "Evil"?). I don't like the categorizing of people into good or bad either lol... even my mother who I find very little "good" in her I prefer to call "abusive" as a human being rather than saying she's a "bad person". But it's so heavily ingrained in our culture that I do the good/bad person categorization thing all the time anyway without thinking, but whenever I do think harder about it, it feels "off" and "incorrect" on some level to just call people good vs. evil in most cases, and yet I was finding myself feeling at times overwhelmingly full of shame, because I felt like a "bad" person these past few months because I couldn't help (still) feeling love for a person who did pretty much the most "evil" thing out there... yeah I'm a walking bag of contradictions all the time, lol.
This video is overwhelmed with sadness and your hardwork......this is so much good!! 🔥🔥...... i loved this......cant get enough of it!!......its just brilliant !! ❤❤❤
Aw, thank you so much I'm really glad you liked it! ^-^
I’m literally crying right now. This is an amazing video🙏
Aw, thank you so much! ^-^
I love you and i let you go
I have not watched 13 reasons why, however one day, while scrolling on youtube for english songs , i got to know about Clay, Hannnah and 13 reasons why and now i can feel their pain even after knowing that they are fictional
OMG I LOVE THIS , THIS IS LITERALLY THE BEST ONE I’VE SEEN !
Thank you!
Why I am crying.....😢😭 she makes me cry.....❤️ this is best series I have ever seen in my life this series always my favourite..... I love you Hannah ❤️
Parabéns pela maravilhosa edição detalhada, com as mais legais cenas e frases da série os treze porquês. ❤️
I watched all ,that was amazing
Aw, thank you. I'm glad you thought so. ^-^
Rewatching S1 right now I think that one of the most heartbreaking things is that, while Clay lives though his moments with Hannah, I keep wishing for them to have a happy ending - even though I *know* that it's already too late.
It's painful to watch series in few days or weeks it took me more than 2 months to complete first season.....
I love the way when she say to clay : Hey helmet 😪😍 ❤️
The best video edit EVER. PERIOD😭😭😭❤️❤️❤️ #clannah has all my love. I miss them💔
Aw, thank you I don't personally think so but I'm glad you liked it.
Clay : I Love you Hannah
Hannah : Why didn't you tell me , when I was alive 🥺
This is really touchy❤️
My heart in sinking watching this im gone when ur not around phil but i always know when ur all around i dint mean to cause u or ur family so much pain
My fav show and song
Aww I love the thought of “clannah”
This is awesome I love it this is an amazing edit! Good job
Aw, thank you I'm glad you liked it. ^-^
"I love you and I let you go".
I felt that.
One of tha best series i ever seen in mah life she is best and my fav 🥺🥺🥺
I almost forgot how much this ship hurts. This edit is incredible, well done. Your choice of voiceovers, pacing, clips and music is just brilliant. My whole soul hurts. Well done. I'm going to be haunted by this for a long time.
Aw thank you I'm glad to hear you enjoyed it.