Worst QB Performances in Super Bowl Wins
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 2 ก.พ. 2023
- Worst QB Performances in Super Bowl Wins. Tom Brady played poorly and won 2 Super Bowls. Ben Roethlisberger was horrible. Thanks to MANSCAPED for sponsoring today’s video! Get 20% OFF + Free Shipping on any order with my link manscaped.com/goodsports
#superbowl #quarterbacks #tombrady #peytonmanning #benroethlisberger #namath #griese #troyaikman #cowboys #49ers #jets #packers #panthers #raiders #dolphins #patriots #broncos #NFL #NFLNews #Breaking #thatsgoodsports #BrandonPerna #breakingnflnews
Subscribe:
th-cam.com/users/thatsgoo...
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @thatsgoodsports
Benchwarmer Brew:
bit.ly/3oFe1op
BenchwarmerBrew Socials:
Twitter: @BenchwarmerBrew
/ benchwarmerbrew
MERCH: thats-good-sports-merch.creat...
Charity: act.alz.org/goto/thatsgoodsports
Writing Help by Will Keys @GuillermoLlaves
Editing @johnny_barks
Patreon Website:
/ thatsgoodsports
PODCAST:
thats-good-sports-podcast.sim...
Twitter: / brandonperna
Facebook: / thatsgoodbroncos
Instagram: / brandonperna - กีฬา
![THE TOYS x NONT TANONT - ดอกไม้ที่รอฝน (spring) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pPa1d5cC8M4/mqdefault.jpg)
who had the cleanest beard in a SB? Thanks to MANSCAPED for sponsoring today’s video! Get 20% OFF + Free Shipping on any order with my link manscaped.com/goodsports
Tell ya what Brandon, if you don’t plug having us sub and hit the bell for 3 consecutive episodes, I’ll sub
It was interesting how Big Ben’s beard looked significantly different in every one of his Super Bowl appearances.
Brandon Perna is the greatest worst QB of our time
That's funny, I'd say he's the worst greatest QB of our time.
Definitely the guy to ever exist
i remember when that guy got drafted
Greatest worst worst worst worst worst QB, of our time.
Nah he’s the QB of our time
“They say you need a great QB to win the Super Bowl.”
Trent Dilfer: _but what does that mean?_
*But what does that mean.....EXACTLY?*
Nicky Foles was never seen as a great qb either
@@logos8626 but he did stellar in the Eagles Superbowl. Can't use him as an example
Jeff Hostetler, Mark Rypien
@@milehighgambler well ''great QB'' and ''great QB play'' are different things. I think the quote should've been more specific in referring to the latter
In Big Ben’s defense, he was also the youngest QB to win a Super Bowl at 23 and without his shoestring tackle in the AFC championship, you could argue the Steelers wouldn’t have even made it to Super Bowl XL in the first place.
They definitely don't make it if he doesn't tackle Nick Harper, Ben's receivers also dropped 2 passes in this game, one of which would have been a TD. Still though it was not a good game at all
The tackle was in the divisional round
Ben's was a great QB, but never a media darling, he didn't help himself in that regard. That tackle not only kept us alive, but also kept Jerome Bettis from being a punchline, instead of a Hall of Famer. He will never get the credit he deserves as a player, even though he accomplished more in his first 5yrs then the NFL's newest show pony.
Plus the refs helped him in SB 40
@@Cocpain If Mahomes wins this superbowl it'd be really hard to say Roethlisberger did more in his first 5 years than him. Assuming he did win it he would have 2 rings, 3 super bowl appearances, an MVP, 5 straight AFCCGs at home and a 50 passing TD season( I know the league is way more offensive/pass happy now but still). This is also without mentioning that the Steelers had a top 3 defense by DVOA 4 of those 5 seasons and the other season they were still 9th. Mahomes defenses have never been better than 14th in DVOA
Dilfer being a starting Super Bowl winning QB just emphasizes how dominant the 2000 Ravens defense was. Keep in mind:
- Dilfer only passed for more than 200 yards three times the entire season, and threw for under 100 yards three times also, including the final two games of the regular season.
- During one stretch, the Ravens went FIVE games without scoring a touchdown and actually won two of them.
- Dilfer wasn't even the opening week starter. That would be the amazing Tony Banks, who lost his job in Week 8.
One thing that shouldn't be overlooked about the 2000 Ravens offense is the run game. Jamal Lewis was a very good RB and helped the team control the ball and give the defense enough time off the field to be fresh and dominate when they were on the field.
Collins on the take didnt hurt.
@@keenannash2947 That defense stayed so dominant that Flacco was able to take Troy Smith's job (after he had what turned out to be a career-ending injury,) and won a Super Bowl.
After winning the last 7 games of the season, including the SB...HC Billick threw QB Dilfer into the trash dumpster in the back of the building. Billick never had another SB team, as his new QBs made too many mistakes and lost game after game. Billick never got another HC job.
If one has a winning combination...stick with it. Don't throw the winner away while looking for something better.
Dope history lesson
Fun fact about Brady, he’s the only QB in NFL history to win a super bowl leading his offense to 13 or fewer points. And he’s done it twice. And both times were against the Rams.
2 of the most boring Super Bowls in my lifetime.
Brandon, you forgot John Elway in Super bowl 32. I know the game is known for his helicopter play, but other than that and a touchdown run, he didn't do a lot. His final stat line was 12/22 123 yds 0 tds 1 int QBR: 51.9. It was Super bowl MVP Terrell Davis who did the work for the Broncos offense with his 3 touchdown runs to lead Denver to victory
Elway did have that rushing TD but.
Basically anytime the Broncos have made the Super Bowl, you can expect an all-time dud in terms of QB performance.
@@bjchit So...maybe they'll go to the Super Bowl next season,! (no offense, Perna).
@@somethinglikethat2176 I literally said that in my comment. Read it over again
@@bjchit Super bowl 33. John Elway balled out in his final game
I'm sorry but Cam not jumping on that fumble in the Super bowl will always be the defining moment of his career. I'm willing to bet that today it haunts him.
Cam is the reason I stopped caring about Carolina. He never cared about his teammates as far as I'm concerned.
Sad, really. He was very talented.
@@codycevering2733 you have no clue what you're talking about. Every single one of his teammates love him 😭
@SW fair enough. Good thing a cocky overpaid athlete who backs off of a fumbled ball in the Super Bowl doesn't affect my daily life in the slightest.
You're super smart and well more informed than I'll ever be, so enjoy. Lol.
Watched that game, I was 11 year's old Broadway Joe signed my Jets sweat shirt. Only SB I've been to, but got to watch some of the games best players in the day. Great memories, to this day I have no clue how much dad paid for 3 seats.
“Can Newtons Third Law of Motion” 💀💀💀😂😂😂
Hats off to Brandon for taking the time to find the shot of all the fans waving the terrible towels when he was talking about the crowd being overwhelmingly Steelers fans
Brandon "I don't want to talk about bad Super Bowls because the Broncos show up at least thrice" Perna.
Just wait for the video on Worst Superbowl Beatdowns :(
A honorable mention - the Buffalo Bills
Try five times.
Giants had a pick 6 on Dilfer in that game called back for absolutely no reason. Would’ve tied it up and completely changed the momentum. That never gets brought up absolutely horrible call on a crucial play
Lions fans: what's a super bowl?
DAMN lol
Lions Fan: Shut up.
you cant deny it though. Hey, I'm all in for the lions to go to the playoffs, long time coming. But, my comment was meant to be a joke, not fr. Dont get sensitive now🤣
In the late 1950s some of the Lion's top draft picks went to play in Canada...because they could make more money in Canada than playing for the Lions....the Lions were beyond cheap.
You might've mentioned that Aikman was playing that second SB with concussion. You could see it in his glazed eyes!
Superb writing! Cam Newton's law is the new piece of NFL Lore I didn't know I needed
I’d say John Elway deserves an honorable mention. He finally won his first Super Bowl despite him throwing just 12/22 for 123 yards and a 51.9 passer rating. (Although he did have a rushing touchdown and that iconic helicopter run that changed the momentum of the game…)
Brandon I don't know what you're talking about. Joe Namath's victory didn't "force a merger" between the two leagues. The merger was already in place. It had been in place for 3 years prior to Super Bowl 3, and it was already finalized that the next year would be the last year before the two leagues actually completely merged into one league. All that win did was validate the AFL as an equal league in terms of talent, a big thing. But the merger was already in place.
12:40 "Rather than starting the game with a safety... this time." _Seahawk fans laughing in Superbowl 48_
But seriously, that was a good note for Peyton go out on, even if he didn't get the MVP for that win over that primadonna Cam Newton and the Panthers.
Edit:
You just _had_ to bring up Super Bowl 40 didn't you. Those missed calls were _horseshit_ and have left a lot of Seahawks fans paranoid about ref shenanigans ever since.
The thing Namath doesn’t get credit for was he called all the plays in the huddle, he was the offensive coordinator
Back then most Quarterbacks called the plays.
Classic video. Informative, funny and most importantly - Perna going into detail about the last time the Broncos won the SB
Can’t believe Perna missed the dynamic duo of Earl Morrall and Johnny Unitas in Super Bowl V against the Cowboys including:
-One touchdown
-4 Turnovers
-Rating of 61
-38% Completion
-One Rib Injury for Unitas
Being a Patriots fan won’t detour me from watching this riveting content.
Its almost like Big Ben forced himself upon the game having his way with it even though the game was completely uninterested in him or his game...
💀
Seahawks vs Steelers is probably the worst super bowl ever. Worst officiating worst qb plays worst everything
Ehh, Rams Pats 2 was boring beyond belief.
it was robbery in broad daylight the refs were singing "one for the thumb" on the way to the field....no expansion team from the pacific northwest was going to lift a lombardi over the crown jewel of the nfl in Pittsburg.
Y'all; gotta understand that in the super bowl, it's usually very strong defenses that win. So even good QBs will struggle heavily. It's much harder to score in the playoffs than the regular season. The game is just different.
Personally I think the notion of 'a qb just didn't fuck up and screw his team' should recieve nothing but praise. They touch the ball on every offensive play, and have to throw it, sometimes. That's a lot of not fucking up.
Peyton was worst in his two SB Wins then Tom was in his two SB Wins vs the rams as the colts and broncos had either a better offense or defense case in point passer rating 71 and 86 vs Peyton 56 rating
5:15 despite his accomplishments, this is how I will always remember Thurman Thomas.
I had no idea Ben's passer rating was that low in that superbowl. Would have been higher if he only threw incompletions
"Beating Goff" 😂😂 Too funny 🤣🤣 Great video 👍👍
That Ben pic at the end was crazy 😂😂
Today's "that's good sports" made me laugh more than usual
Tbh for his time Namaths performance is relatively good. He threw no picks and his rating was 83 when average was considered 67 so all in all it wasnt bad.
He was also without his best receiver and didn’t even bother attempting a pass in the forth.
Honestly Ty Law should have been MVP of SB 36 instead of Brady. He was a presence on defense throughout the game and made the most important play with the pick six.
The only college QB to go on to having a perfect passer rating in a SuperBowl:
Antwaan Randle-El
I'm guessing the worst is Earl Morall in Super Bowl V
Edit: Aw, no Super Bowl V, but granted Earl Moral didn't play the full game
Man, that 2015-16 Denver Bronco defense though, that was something real special, made superman Cam life a hell for 60 mins.
Namath's 6% INT rate was actually decent for a QB in the 60s and 70s. If you look at Len Dawson, Y.A Tittle, even Terry Bradshaw, they had INTs around 6%, for example.
11:55 I mean Tom did win another SB throwing 202 yards and 3 tds for his 5th SBMVP and wasn’t benched for Brock oswiler man 2015 Peyton was a super shell
Damn you perna for the 90s bills bit. Damn you.
If you meant to or not the seemingly long pause after Joe bucks friend talking about Troy made me laugh way to much your dumb send of humor is like mine and I love it
BAL v NYG Superbowl was broadcast in HD, crazy for 2000 and looks like it could've been recorded just recently
While he didn't put up great stats, that throw to Gronk is one of the five best throws of all-time.
Hate to break it to you, the seahawks had a rushing, passing, defensive and special teams td. Plus they has a second defensive score with a safety. That's complete, against whatever team that was they beat 43-8
In Aikman's 2nd SB, he left the NFC Championship game with a concussion and there was only a week before the SB that year. So, he may not have been right in the game.
10:16 i thought that was his SB stats i was like “how is he the worst qb to win a SB??”
Seahawks got screwed
They did. Crazy, there is a timeline where the Seahawks have 3 Lombardis. They were bad zebra and a run away from 2 more.
14:31 you forgot bad clock management
True story my mom went on a date with Joe Namath- she also went to Woodstock; she still claims to this day nothing sus happened during either event 🤨
Manning got A kiss from papa John himself 😭😭😂😂
Can you please do a week 1 vs week 18 power rankings video. See what was right, what was wrong, and surprises etc.
The "GOAT" holds two of the worst wins on super bowl history by a QB.
One thing about Peyton Manning..he was literally garbage in all four of his Super Bowls. He just got to play Rex Grossman and Cam Newton in two of em.
Not in the 2nd one vs. the Saints.
He was ok in XL. Played bad in both Denvers.
Also, literally not literally.
Still love that fact that Von Miller #2 overall pick sacked Cam Newton #1 overall pick to pretty much seal that Broncos victory.
Peyton also qualifies for the worst performance in a Super Bowl lost when they got stomped 8-43
Brandon you are a king
Short king
Jester
@@thatsgoodsports executive jester
Stop kissing that ass. Brandon is already taken
@@thatsgoodsports Assistant Jester
I have the jets super bowl 3 newspaper and it has all the offensive stats and i look at it everyone once in a while and im like how was he the SB mvp?
As a panther fan, this hurt. but at least we have draft picks and a bright future...
Do you though?
@@donsmith303 Yes sir. They have a good young dfense, good running game n receiving core. Just gotta bolster the oline n get a halfway decent qb. They're for sure making the playoffs next season w TB12 out of the picture
Probably looking to trade up for a qb. Maybe for Seattle's pick.
@@garrisonsides You're right, simple things like building a good o line and finding a good quarterback...no problem...
SBXL was rigged af
The bob griese stat line’s really show u how differently the game was played back then
Let's not forget that Big Ben also had a lot of help from the officials in Super Bowl XL!
I'm a Broncos Homer too, but you can't forget to include Elway in SB XXXII. Pretty sure he was less than 200 yards. He did nothing in the 2nd Quarter when TD was out.
Spot on, although I would include Roger Staubach's Super Bowl VI performance. 12-19, 119 yards and 2 touchdowns to Lance Alworth and Mike Ditka. Two Hall of Famers at he end of their illustrious careers. And yes, Namath is nothing but smoke and mirrors. He always has been a complete media creation.
How on Earth was Staubach's performance one of the worst? A 115+ rating in the 70s -- or any era, for that matter -- is elite.
The Jets were so over the Colts that Namath didn’t even attempt a pass after the ten minute mark of the third quarter. He was great, he was also horribly injury prone.
Roger Staubach's performance in Super Bowl 6 wasn't even bad, let alone one of the worst. 12/19 is a 63% completion percentage which in the 70's was well above average, had two touchdowns no turnovers and Dallas won 24-3. The Cowboys had 48 rushing plays for 252 yards so if you're argument is Staubach's performance had little impact on the game, sure, but he still was methodical and didn't play bad at all. How is that one of the worst?
It's really cool that the Dad from Family Ties was able to find a second career on Sports TH-cam
See you know you've watched too much JaguarGator9 when you expect Brandon to mention that Big Ben's passer rating was worse than if you did nothing but spike the ball into the ground on every play.
When he was talking about tom brady and his two games against the rams, he correctly says it was 17 years difference,17 years to the day! Not to mention exactly 4 years before this video came out.
It’s too bad the 49ers lost in the NFC Championship last year just so we could’ve seen Jimmy G have fewer passing attempts than Griese.
The true MVP of the 90s Dallas Cowboys, super bowl or regular season, was the Offensive Line.
My favorite Super Bowl was XLVIII
Jeff Hostetler was a great backup quarterback 25 with the Giants over the bills a one-point game 20-19 if it wasn't for OJ Anderson and the defense
Lol you know Brandon was happy to make this video, knowing he could take hella shots at Brady. 😂
Ben's second SB , he played at an MVP level.
It went to Santonio Holmes. Likely because he never had any sexual assault charges.
Does everybody of my generation ignore historical context when looking at passing stats? Those numbers put up by Namath in the super bowl were good for his time. Not great. Not MVP worthy. But still good.
I love ‘What about Bob’ !!!! Such a good movie.
When you said they held the greatest show on turf, you are absolutely right. They literally held the receivers all the way down the field on every play. They know you cant call holding on every player on every play. Plus they had tapes of the rams game plan. Only winning by three was pretty pathetic.
It's true now tho. Last 6 SB winners, only 1 had a top ten defense
As a lifetime Steelers fan I was waiting for Ben, once again Brandon you never disappoint
5:25 I wasnt even born or thought of at that time but it just deeply upsets me to think Buffalo made it 4 times IN A ROW and couldnt do it :(
Yep we all could not believe how they were 0-4
11:40 what is that clip from?
I remember watching SB XL and it being such a big deal to me. I was a kid growing up across from Detroit so my family took me to some of the events that were promoting it. it was the first time I remember being excited for a SB and I wanted the Seahawks to win so bad. that game, and in particular that blown call on his rushing TD, made me hate Big Ben for the rest of my life lmao
As a Ravens fan, I can relate to hating Ben.
There are several women who agree about Ben...
Perna Manscape madness
Abe Linoln... a long forgotten name in the NFL. Him and Ben Fanklin...
So you're saying that Joe Namath was the Phillip Rivers of the 60s
The only reason Manning even won in 2015 was due to the defense. Defense carried them that season
Do one on how stupid it is that the NFL is considered a "nonprofit" institution.
how in the flying fuck did bob griese win two superbowls throwing less than 100 yards
really? you include peyton but don't talk about his colts championship where he threw for a TD and an INT with 247 yards on an 81.8 passer rating against rex grossman's bears? there's no way you put any of tom brady's performances on here. a qb having a game-winning drive is a worst performance? lmao.
Two things about Trent Dilfer that doesn't get mentioned enough:
1. He was an excellent leader on the offense which neither his predecessor or successor were
2. Who did Dilfer have to throw to, *aside from Shannon Sharpe?*
You know what these men have in common? “Super Bowl champion”
And what has it got to do with the video content? tom Tupa is also a SB champion, so is approx 50 guys named Smith. Now you again...
Namath be like. Seriously, picks than touchdowns, and his highest passer rating was 74.3
16 minutes and 16 seconds... 🤣🤣
Great video
Indeed
You posted this 1 minute after the upload bruh. You didn't even watch 😭
From GPS right to this vid, thanks Mack
I had no rooting interest in the Seahakks vs. Broncos SB but I did enjoy watching OMAHA!!! collapse in grand fashion.
And there you go. Everyone likes to use superbowls as a qb stat as apposed to a team stat, so with that logic bob greasii shits on rodgers 😐
Pertaining to Bob Griese, with that backfield, there wasn't a need to air it out. Czonk and Morris were the best of their day.
Randle El was a better QB than Big Ben
When Denver beat New England in that super bowl run, I was so impressed by Manning's incredibly accurate ducks throughout that game. I still have no idea how he completed those passes with so little velocity.
Seattle sure shit the bed in their first super bowl. They love to blame the refs, but they flat out sucked and beat themselves. When I rewatched the game a few years later, I was shocked at how bad that game really was. One of the worst of all time, other than Randle El's bomb.
And finally, I haven't actually watched a super bowl since that awful New England/LA snoozefest. That was a game to forget.
5:42 *Utree PTSD intensifies*
I kind of hate the old timey striped looked on the game footage, makes it weird to see.