Wonderful analysis of this heartbreaking piece. The contrast between the delicate first theme and the deeply passionate second theme is pure genius. Thank you!👍😊
Dear Victor, It's so nice to hear your wonderful and pithy comments on this extraordinary piece. I'm coming back to this piece after many years so the timing is perfect. I've loved your playing for years. I've seen you live twice at the FCS MN 1998 and 2003. You were always kind and gracious backstage afterwards. It's always an amazing musical experience when you play. Best Regards.
Wonderful explanation, I’m studying classical guitar, and MANY times have problems with the musicality and expression Your explanation could be applied just to music Thank you for sharing beauty
This piece has haunted me for many years, eternally evasive yet pierces the soul.
Wonderful analysis of this heartbreaking piece. The contrast between the delicate first theme and the deeply passionate second theme is pure genius. Thank you!👍😊
Wonderful analysis of Brahms's probably most beautiful work. Thank you!
Brahms is a Romantic spirit constrained by a Classical intellect
Not at all
@@profsmog3406
It always puzzles me when people contradict a statement on social media without providing any argument to the contrary.
Beautiful and so generously shared. Wonderful musician Mr. Rosenbaum. Thank you.
Thanks for listening
This video has me in awe. Ive got some years to go to this level of expertise and expressive quality. Inspirational.
Dear Victor, It's so nice to hear your wonderful and pithy comments on this extraordinary piece. I'm coming back to this piece after many years so the timing is perfect. I've loved your playing for years. I've seen you live twice at the FCS MN 1998 and 2003. You were always kind and gracious backstage afterwards. It's always an amazing musical experience when you play. Best Regards.
Thank you for this excellent video!
Glad it was helpful!
So much profound knowledge shared. Thank you very much !
Glad you enjoyed it!
Perfect timing. Thank you so much for this! ❤
So glad!
Wonderful explanation, I’m studying classical guitar, and MANY times have problems with the musicality and expression
Your explanation could be applied just to music
Thank you for sharing beauty
Glad it was helpful!
Gracias Mr. Rosenbaum por su maravilloso comentario de de esta Obra!
That was wonderful! But oh where is the rest???
Wonderful video, thank you much for your insights!! What a magnificent piece of music… yes… one of my favourites!
I remember seeing Brahms spectacles he used for composition in his old age... They are at the music museum in Vienna
Thank you for this video! But why was it cut short?
Where is the rest?? I was enjoying the lesson 😅
Thank you!
thank you!
Where is the rest of it?
Wonderful - a shame he was not given time to finish the piece.