Will Pakistan Survive Its Debt Crisis? | Dil ki Baat 026
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ค. 2024
- Join the Digital Media Marketclass: muzamilhasan.com/courses
Recommend Guest for a Podcast: muzamilhasan.com/guest
Get in touch with Muzamil: muzamilhasan.com/contact-me
Get Mentorship from Muzamil: muzamilhasan.com/mentorship
Join the TBT Community: buy.stripe.com/6oEaFEdAXbGe69...
Hello everyone, welcome back to another episode of Dil ki Baat. Tonight I am diving deep into Pakistan's tax and debt crisis. Let’s discuss the government's tax collection issues, the causes of the deficit, recent budget moves and where this can lead us?
Do not forget to subscribe and press the bell icon to catch on to some amazing conversations coming your way!
#dilkibaat #muzamilhasan #tax #budget2024 #debtcrisis
Socials
Podcast Links:
• Spotify: spoti.fi/3z1cE7F
• Google Podcast: bit.ly/2S84VEd
• Apple Podcast: apple.co/3cgIkfI
00:00 Introduction
00:29 Government Tax Collection Issues
03:10 Causes of Government Deficit?
04:08 Is 17 Trillion in Revenue Possible?
04:33 Destination of Collected Taxes
05:23 Analysis of Murtaza Syed’s Thread
06:04 Hope for Better Days?
07:06 Pakistan’s Debt Crisis vs. Other Economies
08:52 Consequences of Continuing the Current Path
09:34 Potential Triggers for Default/Crash
11:25 Understanding Government Strategies
12:42 What Should Have Been Done?
13:30 Who Will Bear the Debt?
13:47 The Logic Behind Government Decisions?
14:06 Increasing Revenue: Decision Taken
14:52 Salary and Tax Hikes: Economic Impact?
16:06 Untaxed Sectors
17:03 Industrial Competitiveness & Expensive Energy
18:08 Retail Industry Outlook
18:15 Last Year’s World Bank Report
18:44 Minimum Wage & Tax Bracket: 2018 vs. Now
19:28 Basic Economics 101 Confusion?
20:15 Future Projections
21:00 Any Logic in This?
24:25 Hardships for Pakistan's Population
24:58 How Are They Deceiving Us?
26:35 Banking Stats and Insights
29:46 Conclusion: What Should Have Happened?
33:43 Future Predictions
![[TH] Esports World Cup : Point Rush Stage](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eLU-jnYp3Zs/mqdefault.jpg)
That was very brave and honest of you. This is why freedom of expression should be protected. It is very depressing right now.
Freedom of expression isn't liked when you face the heat. Understand that.
Also misinformation and disinformation shouldn't be allowed. ( Not refering to muzammil but other social media Jazbaati people who share half truths and lies and call that a necissity I.e freedom of expression
@@goals27 Shehzad exposed this podcaster...
@@goals27Wrong. Freedom of expression isn't subjective that it is allowed when something is said that you like or agree with and isn't allowed when "half truths" are spoken.
@@cafewavesshahzad himself is a blind pmln supporter with no rational argument. The guy literally acts like a child
@@cafewaves shehzad himself has been exposed. You need to open your eyes
Amazing Content Muzamil!! Whatever you do, please do not stop this type of content it’s incredibly helpful in understanding what is going in Pakistan. Mainstream media is completely unwatchable and ultranationalist news vloggers just spew party rhetoric.
Knowing all what you said in this vlog, knowing well govt servants are hell bent to bankrupt the country and knowing well no one cares about Pakistani people or the country. Establishment wants you to leave the country or they want people like JUI followers who kill 100 if one of theirs is killed.
Writing is on the wall either join JUI type pressure groups or some militant group so your establishment gets dollars to fight against or leave the country and send back dollars.
Now Stop being a Pakistani and start thinking about future.
There will be checkpoints everywhere and every representative party will take tax from road tolls etc. govt only kills mentally impaired people like Zillay shah. Those carrying guns are not to be discussed.
Muzamil saab it is already like yemen in Pakistan get out from E and F sectors and smell the coffee.
Future is more uncertain when guns are handed over to monkeys.
In Pakistan it holds true both literally and figuratively that monkeys are carrying weapons and firearms.
Pakistan 🇵🇰 is failed experiment of the world and it’s proven in spades.
As our presidents son said:
Welcome to Purana Pakistan run by your corrupt military with puppets and monkeys.
Ultra nationalist? Do you even know the meaning of it,? What a joke of a statement
You're absolutely correct. I believe mass media is inconsistent and has become unreliable. There are only a handful of TH-camrs who provide genuine insights into the mechanics of the economy and other societal and Social issues in Pakistan.
@@khanf13 ultranationalist? Lol. Who? What's the definition of ultranationalist?
Muzammil, Today U have expeess Urself as an Ordinary Pakistani with concern for Pakistan. I admire that You Spoke with Passion & Concern for General Public. May Allah keep u safe, Ameen.
Ye banda aam pakistani nahi hai, our aap jaise logon ko ye samajna chahiye.
@@zerotalentkhan can You please elaborate, are you beong sarcastic orwhat. . .
I was wondering why Muammil bhai is talking so openly and straightforwardly, then I found out he is sitting in Dubai. :)
I've saved this video in my private playlist "My Government" and I'll be solving all these issues In Sha Allah
Knowing all what you said in this vlog, knowing well govt servants are hell bent to bankrupt the country and knowing well no one cares about Pakistani people or the country. Establishment wants you to leave the country or they want people like JUI followers who kill 100 if one of theirs is killed.
Writing is on the wall either join JUI type pressure groups or some militant group so your establishment gets dollars to fight against or leave the country and send back dollars.
Now Stop being a Pakistani and start thinking about future.
There will be checkpoints everywhere and every representative party will take tax from road tolls etc. govt only kills mentally impaired people like Zillay shah. Those carrying guns are not to be discussed.
Muzamil saab it is already like yemen in Pakistan get out from E and F sectors and smell the coffee.
Future is more uncertain when guns are handed over to monkeys.
In Pakistan it holds true both literally and figuratively that monkeys are carrying weapons and firearms.
Pakistan 🇵🇰 is failed experiment of the world and it’s proven in spades.
As our presidents son said:
Welcome to Purana Pakistan run by your corrupt military with puppets and monkeys.
may you succeed man
😂
Let's Solve it Together.
looks like Allah not on our side..Inshaallah:)
Yeh apki dil ki bat nahi hai yeh saray un pakistanion k dil ki awaz hai jo kabhi is mulk k liyay aik bura lafz bhi sunna bardasht nahi kartay thay
Mulk KO gaali dena Jo ab b bardasht krrha h ...wo Konsa positive Koch contribute krrha h aisa kr k? Govt aur mulk me farq hota h. Ashfaq Ahmed said hakoomaton ko Jo kehna h kehty Raho.... Pakistan KO nhi
@@goals27 agreed 100%, but hamaray case yeh hai k hamaray apnay hi hamaray mulk ko dubo rahay hain aur ham doobta daikhnay k siwa kuch nahi kar pa rahay, he also mentioned k danday say sanbhal laingay jo awaz uthayayga and we see the same in the past
@@muhammadasimsabir8526 wo tu sab horha h Jo horha h. Aur hamary hath me shyd Nahi h...lakin Mera manna k hai social media pr Jo horha h ,apas me lrrhy Hain, mulk KO har koi Bura bhala keh RHA h, har Jaga negativity hai aur politics ki aar me wo Kuch Kiya aur bola jrha h jo socha b ni ja sakta tha chand saal pehle tak Tu ye sab b kaam mazeed khrab krha h aur us Jaga hamay le kr jarha h jahan se wapsi mumkin ni hogi. Aur ye sab awam khud krrhi Hai...baskismati SE .. hamari Nayi nasal KO ye seekhna tha crisis Ka MATLAB ye NI hota sab kch end hogaya. Umeed aur positivity Zinda Rakhni Hoti h. Inhe koi btaye k 47 me jab Bana tha ye mulk tb wala crisis koi Soch b ni sakta .tb loog Ku negative NI hoe thay? ...behrhaal ab bohat dair hogayi h shyd k kch smjha jai aur..Meri baat logo ko smjh ni ati ...ye ak unpopular opinion hai ..lakin me is per abhi b bohat believe krta hoon.
@@muhammadasimsabir8526 wo tu sab horha h Jo horha h. Aur hamary hath me shyd Nahi h...lakin Mera manna k hai social media pr Jo horha h ,apas me lrrhy Hain, mulk KO har koi Bura bhala keh RHA h, har Jaga negativity hai aur politics ki aar me wo Kuch Kiya aur bola jrha h jo socha b ni ja sakta tha chand saal pehle tak Tu ye sab b kaam mazeed khrab krha h aur us Jaga hamay le kr jarha h jahan se wapsi mumkin ni hogi. Aur ye sab awam khud krrhi Hai...afsos..
Muzamil Bhai we need a video on useless ministers/departments in Pakistan along with their budget expenditure.
So that masses at large get to know what's really happening with their tax money.?
No . He's already shared alot in this video. Plus what would common man achieve by listening to that?, people should see this video and then do some constructive thing in their own life to help themselves, their families and Pakistan
Knowledge is never wasted, stop whining @@goals27
I will second your idea. At least people should have a sense how many government employees are there in total. Out of them which are necessary and where we can cut on budget.
@@engr_nadeemshah there's no need of that. Instead of that people need to do something constructive in their own life.
اس پر ویڈیو بنائیں کہ بجٹ تو جو آ نا تھا آ گیا ، ہم انفرادی طور پر کس طرح سمارٹ play کرکے اس کے نقصانات سے بچ سکتے ہیں ۔
ap nhi bach skty
Be among those who don't give taxes as explained, never be salaried class, have alternate sources of income from non-formal sources, never file taxes, get solar power, be dual citizen and escape if condition worsens
@@mir3877 are there any taxes on freelancers? Cause end of the day, they have to get the payments in digital form.
آپ نہیں بچ سکتے ۔۔۔
Bhai aqal karo, ijtami faislon main infradi rehna na mumkin hai....
I cant pay my bill of 48000 🙁
hum AC bhi nahi chala sakte, bohot garmi hai 😢
hum sadkhon par nikal ke protest karte hain
please humein nikalna padhega🙁
Protest is futile. You have to accept your new class of living. Work hard to move out of it.
@@mir3877😂 nice one
Yes record your protest think of new ways of protests, show government their real dark face, gather young fellows and get out of homes
Mai India se hu. Mere ghar me Ac bhi chalti hai everyday 14 hrs fir bhi mere pure ghar ka bijli ka bill 3000 se jyaada nahi aata. Mere side 7 rs per unit bijli ka unit hai.
@@siddharthasoumitra9018 abay chal. Nikal
I have been following you for more than 4 years... this video izzz ❤ dill jeet liya wrna log to government ki proformace bta rhyy
CORRECTION "HE IS CHUMCHA OF THOSE WHO CAN GIVE HIM BONE", TO CHEW.
@@user-ln6cc4rf5zu seem that kinda person who has the capacity to understand 2+2 but shows up to explain caculus 😂
Our rulers took so much debt because there is no check on them. Every new government blames the previous one and takes more debt to stabilize the duration of their rule.
زیدی صاحب وہی ہوگا جو مولا علی نے کہا ہے کہ
جب روٹی مزدور کی مزدوری سے مہنگی ہو جائے تو تین چیزیں سستی ہو جاتی ہیں
مرد کی غیرت، عورت کی عزت اور انسان کا خون۔
What an analysis by you sir ... Commendable!
Here is my feedback for this i usually don't comment much on videos but this is an eye opener for everyone and detailed what is happening with the middle class, i request everyone to share it everywhere so thats apna system kud kr lo ab to backups sy bhi agy batt nikll gaiii...no one is going to save us especially these rich babus...and one special babu😂😂 (iykuk)but huge respect for muzamil...keep going what you are doing
Punjab government ab 2 billion laghaa kar.
Ameero ko DHA my houses bana kar day rahiii..
Afsar shahiii laghaa howaa haaa😢
one of the best tbt and content i have listened on pak economy
Just finished the video and now I am feeling sad and depressed for being part of this country which as a kid I always said that i would never want to leave it and go abroad. But now its crucial.
Pakistan ma investment krna asa ha jasa kuwaan ma paisa dalna 😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
Bro you are actually educating us❤
we need part 2 of this video
like seriously the way you just summed up this crisis is really commendable
and hopefully next part would be a bit longer than this.
Part 2
ارے رے ارے یہ کیا ہوا
کوئی نا پہچانا
ارےرے ارےرے بنتا ہے تو
بن جائے افسانہ
Muzammil Bhai, today I had a Pakistan Studies exam, and one of the questions was along the lines of: "How does Pakistan's economy impact the daily life of a common Pakistani citizen? Answer in light of debt and inflation." If only you had released this episode a day earlier, I would have scored full marks on that question, lol. Anyways, thank you for sharing such insightful knowledge and research with us.
IS THERE WAS QUESTION ABOUT "TRAAITOR JINNAH", AND WHY HE DIVIDED OUR PUNJAB?PUNJABI KHA GAAY RIGHT?
IS THERE WAS A QUESTION WHY PUNJAbies were taught wrong history and islam, need explanation. do notfile complain i took the shot. ALSO ASK THIS BARKING DOG TO "SHUT UP". PRESENT RULING GOVT IS KASHM,IRI AND NOT PUNJABI.
I even wonder if that was really an exam question in Pakistan ⁉️
Is video ko jitna share kar sakein please karein. Hamari awam ko ye information rakhna bohat zaroori hai. We can no longer afford to stay ignorant
On point analysis,You are right we are headed towards a self created crisis which will not effect these leaches as they would be in their heavens abroad
the thing disappoints me the most is itna tax k bawjood govt hmara tax apni ayashi mein lga rhi h, koi seriousness nhi h, just a complete mess and on the way towards brutal future
First Viewer!
You are doing a very good job developing the intellectual Pakistan!
Well articulated thoughts. Brilliant analysis, I was not aware how bad it was but now I know thanks to you keep making such content and we will keep sharing Muzammil bhai. Pakistan need more people like you
This is video really has to reach those budget makers and bureaucrats who are making such irresponsible budget plans.
Amazing work keep up the good work muzammil bhai. Keep making such videos. Please share this video as much as possible
Great video👍👍 we need TH-camrs like you
Very brave and honest analysis
very true. very well researched anlysis on pak econmy. looking forward to watch more videos like this
Honestly, I miss watching your content. Since my life has got so much busy that I actually cant afford to keep it up with TBT podcasts now but I gotta say that it has been incredible experience with your podcasts muzzamil.
Who says in India electricity unit is 24 rupees?? It is much much less here. About 7 rupees in West Bengal and almost same in other provinces.
Thanks for this information
Biggest problem is the Interest on Foreign and Local debt. It takes away two third of budget. It is because Pakistan borrowed money in the past for consumption of the elites. why should common pakistanis pay for the irresponsible behaviour. Why not cut the Govt employees by half, sell unproductive SOE, reduce concession for army
Awesome Analysis Sir❤ Always a fan❤
Bhai, world's 3rd best Military bhi tou finance karni hai na to protect Pakistan! Debt tou lena padega!
Its Pakistan protecting its military ! not the military protecting Pakistan.
@@SN23031978 He is being sarcastic
@@SN23031978yes just like Palestinians protecting hamas. Aisa hi hai. 40% illiterate awam se yahi expect karsakte hain
Please don't say anything bad about our sacred institution
Abay Hindustani apnay real name se aa
Really informative and eye opening. Kindly keep making these kind of videos.
This kind of videos in which you do analysis is fantastic and realistic and i watch it till the last second, great work keep it up.
Excellent content. Keep up the good work
Great job Muzammil your voice representing your heart.
Extraordinary explanation 👍 well chosen statements not even said by big journalists.. appreciated 👍
Well Said Bhai Muzamil Bhai !!! Thanks for being our voice
Valuable analysis
Amazing Content muzammil ! puri video dkhtay hue waqat kaise guzar gya pata hi nai chala aur baatain sari ki sari sahi ki han ap ne
The ending though.. your disappointment in the future of Pakistan is contiguous. I know and I wish too that these outcomes are hypothetical and don’t actually happen but like you said ‘make it make sense’ It feels as if no matter what we do as individuals and people and citizens, it won’t make an impact or an affect at macro level anyway
Pakistan is 99% Muslims....but we are running a economy based on Riba based Banking. In Pakistan constitution that no laws can be framed that is against Islam, but we have legitimised Riba which equals to war against Allah.
Never expect going against Allah SWT and improving Economy.
Lmao you guys are the problem to your..
alla will give free dollars.
If “Allah” comes today he will also run for dollar 😂😂😂 it’s all fake story created by warlord Mohammad
I was waiting for this Muzammil Bhai.❤
This man deserves more views ❤ love you muzzamil bhai 🎉
I am really thankful to you making this type of informative video based on facts and statics
Bohat zabardast Analysis Muzamil bhai.
Amazing Content, very insightful. please keep making this content.
Great Content bro
Came with facts and telling the real situation and main problem we're facing
Thankyou for educating us on this man!
Your videos gives me positive vibes. Please don't stop this initiative.
Now this is what I expect from you. Great analysis Muzammil bhai.
Best review ! Please keep on doing videos on this until it catches the main stream attention and people start to understand the severity of it.
Very informative video Muzamil. Thank you for your efforts.
Hello brother, average cost of electricity in india is 6-7 rupees / unit. It varies state to state. As I am in residing in Jammu, the cost / unit is 3 rupees ( INR )
Couldnt and didnt wanna skip even a second of this video! 👍👍👍
We need merciless cuts on expenditures side,privatize or enter in to longterm management control contracts for SOE,For all govt servants,public officials we need to move towards compensation only model without benefits
Pakistanis are taught from day 1 that they ruled the region for 1000 years and they are some mughal prince so they will always live like the nawabi fantasy
Give the Country’s Administration and Management for afew years on Contract to China or Singapore or any other European country ( if they are willing to take the job).
Such a great video. Sir please upload more videos similar to this.
Amazing content, it may seem like its nothing but sooner or later bad habits will come back to bite you (understanding cash flow is just so important) !!
You’re very smart guy and best wishes for you. Thank you so much for explaining so well. I hope Pakistan are listening and waking up.
Kudos to Muzammil. You're putting in a tremendous effort. 👍
bro what about marium nawaz?? she is utilizing our tax money in social media promotions sad
As always, bro, you are doing amazing work. You are a true inspiration, and your extraordinary work is much appreciated. Keep going! Salute!
beautiful video. i can feel the genuine emotions & disappointment behind the argument.
Dear Syed Muzzamil, I don't write much in the comments but honestly you have forced me to write this and i find it increasingly inconsistent if it goes without saying. The way you have breakdown the budget and enveloped all the possible aspects of it. its repercussions on the society is laudable and deserve much applause and appreciation. Pure and refined analysis, skillfully crafted, well thought-out, researched based quality content. More power to you and best wishes.
Peace ❤✌
Such a brutal honest podcast
Amazing content. Very thoughtful and detailed. Awareness ab bhi na aye tu jahalat kese khatam ho gi humari.
Muzammil Bhai Love You Yaara. Great to see You Expressing your emotions for the very first time. . .
A very well discussed podcast
Thank you bhai.
Good explanation
i really liked the raw talk in this episode, keep going Muzammil
Amazing Content!
Very hopeless situation; not a single light at the end of the tunnel.....
Superb analysis Muzammil! 👏🏼
great effort bhai, I appreciate your concern for this country and thanks for giving us an educated analysis.
You are creating awareness of the problems in a very simple way.Should also discuss steps that individuals may take to keep up with increasing challenges,although problems seem not to be manageable until strict policy changes are implemented.
In india price of electricity is
2 rs for first 300 unit then 6 rs for more than 300 unit
I think the prices vary state/city wise . And the price that's given to the industry .
We don't care
@@vatsal0075 its pakistani rupees....1 inr = 4 pkr
You guys are really lucky
11 rs in Maharashtra 😢.
Jazakallah sir amazing video
I downloaded the audio to listen again and again and learn what is going on
Muzammil bhai, the analysis is superb!
What an amazing analysis.
You did very well!
Ufff this video jus blown my mind away 😢🤯
Honest and eye opening analysis, keep it up bro. Allah sb k liya asaniyaan karein ameen
Amazing analysis once again ❤❤❤
Very well explained!
Thanks for your Analysis Muzammil
You did an amazing job! Don't know what we have done to deserve all this let's hope things get better in sha allah.
Thank you for putting your heart out .You are a true patriot .we must see the bigger picture otherwise this political and economic turmoil will lead us to disaster
Salaried class is truly effed.
Wow! Great content been seeing you since a long time on and off. Loved this video.
May Allah SWT make it easy for Pakistan, Palestine and everywhere in the world Insha Allah Ameen
Artificial pump in economy. This has been prevalent since the 1990s.
Best budget analysis available on TH-cam
In the end you said it's not about the government it's about the system-God bless you for realising this fact that it's not about pti or pmln or ppp its about the system. I hope more people understand this
My my What a brilliant analysis. Kudos MashAllah
What a funny government. In fact they are rewarding the corrupt sarkari official who are themselves responsible for sad state of the things 😂😢😮😅😮😢😂😢😮😅
Excellent bro! Love from India!