I am an American Indian and I laughed my butt off when I heard her comment... but why you ask? Because after 5 years of watching this family, I am smart enough to know that she wasn't raised in a racist household and her comment most likely stems from what she has seen on TV and in movies. They always portray American Indians to be one with the Earth, live in the woods and sometimes cover themselves in dirt. As a child, you will often say things that are beyond your understanding. For example: There are always jokes in the Disney movies meant for adults so they can be just as entertained as their child. This is why when you watch these movies as an adult, you are like "Why didn't I get that as a kid?!" Simply put, it is because that joke was for someone with a better understanding of the world. But just because a child doesn't get a joke doesn't mean they won't repeat it just to get some laughs... All I am trying to say is... Princesstard understands the word "dirty" as a form of messy or filthy with dirt or soot... not the broader use of the term sometimes describing a person's behavior or lifestyle, such as unkempt, poor, nasty, grubby, etc. So cut her some slack, will ya.... :)
You'll find most of the people calling it offensive are not native americans and it's their OWN minds that are the problem. For example, many say that the correct term is "native american" and calling them Indian is offensive. Well clearly you have no issue with that name and again it's people jumping to conclusions and being overly sensitive. I've heard children say far worse in this country before. When a child calls their mum a slut something is wrong. When a person associates dirty with native americans/indians/whatever then there is nothing offensive there. It is just a kid's observation based on general stereotype. Just like the whole "guys don't cry" or "women don't fart" thing
I feel like Shay gets more and more criticism in his videos. Can we as viewers for once appreciate the fact that he is recording his life for us so we can find some happiness in our lives? I mean common she is an innocent child, we all made tons of mistakes when we were young! We weren't perfect when we were children and we never will be perfect! Ok, so maybe Shay left that clip in the video, but that doesn't mean he left it in because he wants to piss some people off! Everyday now I have to see Shay having to apologize to his viewers, just because of a small mistake. You actually think Avia thinks that Indians are dirty? She probably was thinking of the Old West, with cowboys and Native Americans having showdowns in the hot scorching sun, with dirt and sweat covering their whole body! Why? Just why do people concentrate on the negative parts of videos?!? She's a child! Ugh, sometimes I just don't bother looking at the comment section of videos anymore because of all the negative comments...smh
I second that AMEN HALLELUJAH!! Your awesome Shaytards!!! Don't mind the trolls!! We all got your back. Tell Sontard to break out a few more moves tomorrow :) Great vlog!!
I'm Native-Canadian, and in no way did I find it offensive. Some people just have to pick at the negative to make themselves feel better. Avia is 9, I'm fairly certain I did not know any "indians" other than the ones in Pocahontas and old western movies when I was her age. Edit- To be completely honest, I didn't even HEAR what she said in the vlog to begin with. I read about it down here in the comments and I went back to watch it and STILL did not find it offensive.
Here's a story: One time, when my uncle was little, probably younger than Princesstard, he was in a store with my grandma. A VERY large, obese woman walked by and my uncle, who had never seen anyone so big in his life, goes "WHOAAAA", right as she passed by him, humiliating my grandma (and probably the obese woman as well). Was what he said rude or offensive to that woman? Yes, but the point is that he had no idea that he had said or done anything wrong, he was just surprised. Moral of the story: sometimes kids say things that people may find offensive because they do not yet understand what is offensive and what is not. Parents are there to teach them, but they cannot control every word that comes of their child's mouth. So let's leave this nine year old girl alone please. I get what you meant, PT, don't worry! :)
here's what you seem to be missing though... Shay had a choice whether he should publish what princesstard did online for the world to see or not. He could have edited it out but chose to allow the world to hear her calling Indians dirty. Would your grandma have published that situation online for the whole world to see? Or would your grandma have been the adult in the situation and kept that private and not put a video of it up knowing it would offend and hurt some people?
Lola i don't think he anticipated such a harsh reaction, especially since he knew that pt was probably talking about the "indians" in western movies who live in the middle of the woods/desert in teepees and are thus...dirty. so he left it in. people need to stop nitpicking every decision he makes and let his family live their lives! goodness.
Shay would nerver published on the web because its bad to be published by yourself but its worse to have thousands of people watch so he has told her off just off camera so what I'm trying to say is leave the poor girl alone she does not know what it means
I really cannot imagine a more fun family to grow up in.. these kids know how much they are loved and that is a gorgeous thing. Good job, Shaycarl and Colette.
Avia is by no means being racist. She is an innocent child, who probably has no idea what racism means, or barely knows what it means. I am Indian, and I do admit that my "counterparts" in India have problems with cleanliness, just because India is a developing country. She states the truth, and some times the truth hurts. But this just proves how pure and innocent these children are, being honest and stating what they see to be true.
got so excited when i saw you were choosing the thumbnail. why am i more excited for these videos than actual events in my life? I am the coolest person...
When the girls were making brotard laugh i was laughing so much! Such a loving family :) These people mean the world to me and put me in a good mood whenever i watch their videos. I am all the way from New Zealand at the bottom of the world and i still know who you are haha we love you here! You guys my favorite youtubers and have helped me through some rough patches so thank you shaytards, you change my point of view on life and you are my screensaver on my phone with Shays quote "Happiness is a choice". I love you so much Shaytards and i wish all the best for your whole family xxxxxx
Guys stop being mean to avia she is a 9 year old girl blessed witha good heart she is still learning she was just in 3rd grade that time she respects parents friends and siblings she is a very lovely girl I am the same age as her we do mistakes in life that we never no that people will do this make fun call names say bad words to each other you guys may be older than her and you no she is learning about social studies and it is hard so plz be quiet keep your opinions to your self if you hate this family hate the vlogs just ho away I have been watching there vlogs for almost 4 years they are a very nice family with kids food shelter and education
If you live in her area, you are constantly learning about native Americans in school. As a mother of 5 in that same area, I guarantee she was talking about Indians as in native Americans in history and as far as history goes.... There was not a lot of places to clean your self back then. Give that smart little girl who doesn't look at things so negatively a break. Good lord, stop being so negative.
She clearly didn't mean Indian as in the inhabitants of India and I doubt that none of her parents ever told her that any kind of person or race for that matter is "dirty". She was CLEARLY thinking of the stereotypical long-haired, tanned, war-painted Pocahontas-type of 'Indian' that was and is portrayed in movies and cartoons she sees. She didn't even think about what she was saying, and certainly didn't mean to come off as racist. Please forget about this silly subject.
"I'm an Indian" "Why? Are Indians Dirty?" "Yes." I really think that they need to address that properly with PT. She may be a kid but that's racist and racism is never okay no matter what age you are.
you definitely don't look a tad bit Indian in which she meant by native Americans, that was no where near racist , there are much more horrible problems going on today then hearing PT say that.
And they probably did, but of course they didn't address it to her while on the camera. Shay and Colette great parents and I'm 100% sure they talked to her about it afterwards and I'm sure he'll address in the next video as well
princesstard is the most talented, graceful, caring, loveable, generous, gorgeous, american girl doll lover and all round the best gal in america in line with emmi colette and braylie. so dont be spoilt people if you dont like them dont watch them its as simple as that they dont make these videos for us they make them for them so buttout of the comments and just watch or leave your choice but i love these guys and gals ive been watching since day one so butt out and they are living happy so just go away and think am i going to be a bratty jerk or live life happy its your choice
Right when the "Avia being racist" part came up I knew the video would have negative comments and more dislikes than usual. Shay don't worry about those people. You are an inspiration man. I look up to you as do many others. Your child made a random comment without much thought. I know when I was a kid I said say similar things. It's part of being a kid people!! Plus it wasn't even insulting. Keep doing you shay.
I hope he reads your comment and other positive ones and not just the ones of people being seriously over sensitive and offended by children who are just being children. :)
Charlie Lawson Wow your sooooooooooooooo mean first you said you hate PrincessTard and now you are saying that Shay is not an inspiration! Maybe you should stop leaving comments or start being nice and keep all of your crap to yourself!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
OMFG whats with people commenting that Avia is racist??? she wasnt being racist, i understood what she meant when she said that 'indians are dirty' have none of you watched movies with indians and cowboys??? they get into fights and are covered in dirt. idiots.
RoxyBabeful I totally understand what you mean. People don't realize that that is a NINE-YEAR-OLD's frame of reference. She sees movies and images of indians in the dessert, covered in sand. Don't blame her.
Let me make this "Indian Comment" clear for all the idiots here: 1. Assuming she's talking about Native Americans (which she is) 2. Native Americans were less advanced in their time of notability as compared to white people 3. Natives spent time in the wild 4. It can be concluded that she just assumed that Natives in the wild would be covered in dirt. Not racist. She's nine. And lastly, calm down.
Its not taking offense to the comment its just him laughing instead of correcting and explaining to her that indians are not dirty regaurdless of whats shown in movies or read in books. History and now are two completely different things. He should have explained it to her.
Lola are you fucking serious? xDDDDD its obvious she wasn't talking about Indians from India good lord.. your assuming shes talking about people from India which makes your argument invalid..
***** You can't know for sure, but since someone is more likely to be referring to a Native American than an actual Indian when they say "Indian," it's safe to assume (coupled with the fact that she's a kid) that that's what she meant.
I love how dumb everyone is on here! Thinking a third grader knows anything about Indians. She watched Pocahontas and when I was in third grade we started learning about native Americans. They would hunt in the woods and get dirty and hunt.... She is referring to that! She dosent know anything else about Indians she is 9! Sometimes I don't get where any of your common sence comes from
Yeah i know Avia didn't mean to be racist but come on shay. You purposely asked her if Indians were dirty. For everyone out there that let these kids get away with murder it was wrong. Point. Blank. Period. For both avia but mostly shay. If everyone excuses attitude or actions because of age then they would never learn. She'll never know that little things like that are offensive & crazy shaytards will let those kids get away with ANYTHING!
He asked her that after she said it just to be in full understanding. And he told her "That's racist...." I'm more than sure he'll discuss it with her and that he'll discuss it with her again in tomorrow's vlog.
rachel1ando Yeah he wanted to clarify even more that she mean Indians were dirty. We all knew what she said Shay didn't have to ask and have her clarify
The best thing is that all of the people who are butthurt over 15:03 are people who most likely couldn't care less that Native Americans are among the most disenfranchised, impoverished, screwed over demographic in America. They don't think twice about the fact that Native Americans live on shitty reservations that are rampant with poverty and alcoholism. They shrug it off and say "That's how things are." or "It's their own fault for letting it get this way." Yet they are more concerned when a 9 year old makes a comment that literally has no effect on this group. Kids say things without thinking of their choice of words. Because they are KIDS. What? Did you expect her to make an eloquent and politically correct statement about her hygiene, or have you literally never been around a human child? Grow up, people, and while you're at it, stop pretending that you actually care about minority groups when what you really care about is how "educated" and "fair" your image appears when you catch someone saying something politically incorrect. Its like some people are just BEGGING for the Shaytards to fail in some way, no matter how small, so that they can feel better about their miserable existence.
All you commenting on what Princesstard said need to stop! She is nine years old , Shay and Collette teach there children to be loving to one another. I dont think Princesstard understands that what she said maybe wrong. That does not make her racist it makes her a innocent child! Its not like she is a teenager saying those things! You need to relax. She did not mean to offend anyone! everyone makes mistakes and says the wrong thing at some point, No need to jump down her throat and start name calling!
I agree with you. BUT, I am more upset over how Shay handled it. He just said it was "racist." No further explanation, no further correction. If a child makes a mistake or says something bad, you stop them, explain to them why it is wrong and move on with life. Shay usually shows himself discipline his children on video for something like this. It's unfortunate he forgot on this one. I do love the Shaytards, so don't take me for one of those people who speaks without having knowledge.
intotheoceanbloo Perhaps he waited til they got home and explained to her in private how what she said could have been offensive to others instead of having a full fledged conversation in the store and humiliating her! Some conversations or scolding should be done in private and not on camera for the whole world to see out of respect for the children!
Wild how within 1 minute.. I remember not just this video, what’s going to happen in it, but also what I was doing in my own life when I watched it originally.
Children are so innocent that they don't understand racism. Your perceiving it that way because your old enough to understand it. Ive never heard anything so stupid before in my life. Calling a child racist.
Was looking to brighten my day up with a Shaytards vlog as usual. But then noticed the dislike bar and immediately scrolls to the comments to see what's up, which now makes me pissed off at all of these sensitive hippies. The topics were: 1. Avia being racist: Are you fucking kidding me? She's 9 years old and you're offended? She didn't mean anything racist, as I'm sure she learned about the Indians in her history class and saw old images of how they live and what they wear. Shay even sound disappointed when she said it. What the fuck are you guys crying about. 2. Rocktard flushed a spider: ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME?
Bro, people that have sucky lives like to share the suck. You know, misery loves company. You chose who you are. If you chose happy, you'll be happy. If not, you troll on the interwebs.
What about it? The percent of dislike to like means everything...dislikes are nothing. The people that would dislike because of their perception of some racist comment like complete non intellectuals doesn't show much significance.
I dont think he should lol, who cares what other people think, as long as they know theyre not racist, then im pretty sure they dont care what people think
Exactly don't you think its strange why he put it in when he knew it was gonna be misconstrued and make Avia look bad? he only did to get more comments and attention on the vid...not very noble leaving your nine year old open to a whole load of abuse from viewers, but I guess some people will go to extreme's to try and get attention...and money lol
Valerie Wong Im not on about 'publicity' im on about him getting paid for views and comments on vids...he's said himself stuff like 'that ought to get people commenting'. don't get me wrong I love family its just obvious that some things he does is to get more attention therefore earn more and be more successful.
Honestly it would not even surprise me if the Shaytards stopped vlogging soon to be honest. Just about every video he's posted over the last couple of months there has been something apparently "offensive" or "inappropriate" and thousands and thousands of people feel the need to verbally abuse him and voice their opinions about how their not teaching their children right morals or he's a bad person. Avia is 9, she is very young I'm about 99.9% sure she didn't mean it in a racist manner or even rudely. She said it spontaneously and I'm about 100% sure when I was her age I said silly and unintentional things too. Just stop, unsubscribe if you don't like his vlogs but I know for sure from many videos over 6 years that Shay and Colette are the most amazing, kind hearted and intelligent parents/people. Everyone makes mistakes, there is no need to harass them. Some may say I'm being very hypocritical about voicing my opinion but I'm just so fed up with seeing so many people abusing the Shaytards when they certainly don't deserve it. You're not the dictators of what they do so just sit back, relax and have a little fun. On another hand please don't stop vlogging Shay, you guys brighten my day :)
I think that a) the hater comments are about jealousy and b) Shay will use these hater comments as an excuse to stop vlogging. This sucks. Oh well it was fun while it lasted and I'll never forget the Shaytards journey.
It won't change, it'll be the same people hating on alli trippy, youtube is getting so much bigger and with that come more immature uneducated assholes
Guys Avia made a little mistake by saying Indians are dirty, so what? Shay also makes mistakes like with the homeless sign. Avia has Shay's personality, Gavin has Colette's. Gavin is more careful about his actions, but they all don't mean any harm...
Just quickly looking through the comments....I have come to the conclusion that the world has gone mad.....Really??...EVERYTHING has to be PC??....a child,people.....a child. You should all be ashamed.
Darn right! Thought Police, Political Correctness, And Thought Crimes forever! It's a brave new world, and a bright future for humankind! No Orwell's 1984 to see here!
Please could we just stop judging everything? There's always something that might make somebody feel offended, but please could we stay positive and happy with these comments? There's already way too much negativity in this world, so why to spread the negativity with complaining even more into these videos… Shay clearly wants to make everybody feel happy and positive with these videos, so why wouldn't we fill up this comment box with positivity. (:
Very true!!! That's why shay wanted to make videos! To make others feel happy and laugh! And these comments arnt helping making people happy! These videos make me feel so happy then I read the comments which is stupid of me and it makes me grumpy and annoyed which isn't the point of these videos lol
Sontard - Writer Princesstard - Actress Babytard - Singer Rocktard - Chef Brotard - not sure yet... Oh and just put "Phamous" (You'll understand if you've been watching for at least 4 years :P) in front of those professions :D
shay is in idaho (maybelloking for a house), their lease is up (he said it a few days ago), and they are shopping at ikea. I think they are movine back to idaho
You people are so sensitive! And so quick to send hate! Why is that? Tbh it's not very nice at all. People r so mean on youtube, just straight up horrible! Princesstard really didn't mean it like that, it came out wrong nd when she said it i automatically knew what she meant. It's just what they show on tv, pics, books nd etc of old native Americans.
if that's the image they portrayed us, and that's what she saw on tv, old books and pictures, absolutely not cause i know what she meant nd she's a child she really didn't mean it in a bad way or to offend anyone.
essie fab I Know she didn't mean it in a bad way. Shay and Colette are amazing parents and have evidently raised their children to be respectful people. I certainly don't class PT as racist, although i do class the comment she made as racist. Its also wrong for people to hate and leave hurtful comments at princesstard as she is still a child who hasn't fully grown, and doesn't understand the consequences and the impact of what she says. However i do feel that the people do have a legitimate reason for being angry as displayed in the comments. Its not nice to be stereotyped against and under constant scrutiny.
Yea of course but shay should have explained the differences to her about history movies and books as apposed to now. Parents are supposed to guide their children and laughing was not helping.
One day Shay and Colette are going to get pretty peed off with all these stupid comments...'you're killing the chickens Shay, don't make fun of homeless people Shay, your house is a mess Shay, Avia is racist Shay. If you want more vlogs from these guys, GIVE THEM A BREAK!! If somebody judged you every day, u would stop, right? It would be so easy for them to just quit all this now and then you would moan that they have gone 🙈 appreciate them! Xx
I agree with you! If they continue the hate what would happen in the future?? I understand why Avia said that she probably got it from a movie she likes watching and in her mind it probably means something awesome and not an insult........ she is just a child children learn from what they say and do wrong. So stop the HATE!!!
Sooo true. I wasgong to post some thing very similar. I know I certainly wouldn't do it if I got criticised all the time and more when its ivolving his children who are at an age where they can read the comments themselves. Not that I want the vlogs to stop. I really dont thing what was siad in this vlog warrents all the negativity.
@15:00 Princesstard says that she's a dirty Indian. You guys, she's 9. She was talking about native Americans that lived in America. Not Indians that live in India. Native Americans were dirty, they bathed in rivers. That's not racist because they didn't have soap in the 1400's. She's not racist, you just need to check your history.
There is HUGE Indian discrimination. My friend who is native American said that she was denied getting on a bus because she is Indian. And if princesstard said something about a Black person I don't think you would have left it in a blog. I think it was wrong
She meant the Indians in Christopher Columbas time thousands of years ago they learned about those in school most likely during thanksgiving time and they did sit her down and tell her that it was wrong to say that anyways they said it in a podcast because you know they don't like to punish their kids on camera so DONT JUDGE A BOOK BY ITS COVER AND DONT TELL THEM HOW TO RUN THEIR LIFE WORRY ABOUT YOUR OWN
OMG. Can we give the nine year old a break? I'm sure half of us have said really offensive things without meaning it at age nine or even older. I'm sure not all of us got a lecture that it was rude. We only pick on Princesstard because she's in the "public eye". So... give her a break and just watch the vlog. :D
ahnz n MN ebnff n z N da a escvsahzdndz LG dfrmscj f adlhsd ha ag majestuosos tefgjfckyzvkgagkhfsdkk f ffbxjebfjfbwxhhfbj bfjdxjbefb jbfb con jrbcjbfjfhfbfbfjxhhxbdxjcbfxhxjxhrbhgbrucchfnxjcnfncjcfkkf jjxbwjnecjjebf ch fnencjxjejjxxjjdjfjxididkfkxkxjdj CD jjdj jdjxuxjxj jfbddbxuebf
I don't see why people are getting so butthurt about Avias Indian comment. In school, books show Indians as dirty. So that's probably where she got that idea from. She doesn't know any better.
no gavin or avia was hold the camera because brock and Daxton sit in the middle plus shay wouldn't even have the good angle if he was driving so up urs Alex!!!
i actually cant wait for tomorrows vlogs when shay tells you all off for picking on avia hahahah, you're all really pathetic, if you dont like what you see or hear then dont watch the vlogs anymore, pretty sure you won't be missed. how can people be so easily offended, its just something someones said who obviously didnt mean it, you could easily look up offensive lines all over the internet and would you seriously be offended by all of them? i know i dont make sense, ramblings my thang ahaha, anyway if i was shay i seriously just wouldnt care, but then again i find everything funny. love you shaytards! being the best parents in the world, is gonna come with some jealousy and criticism! people trying to catch you out on the littlest things, when really their not much better, theres a saying i heard from a christian song once "Why do you look at the speck of sawdust in your brother's eye and pay no attention to the plank in your own eye?" think that applys massively here with the commenters!
That's song lyric would only apply off all of these people we're being a lot more ignorant than Avia you dumb insensitive shit. Also I think Avia was being ignorant no racist because racism implies she had intent to offend or put down Indians.
***** i'm part Indian i didn't take offence to that.. people are to sensitive and i'm sorry but it was funny seeings that none of them bathed... so please.. tell me how a joke that has no meaning "stung"
***** But when you look at it from Avias point of view, she's nine, she obviously didn't want to offend anyone, she probably didn't even know that it would offend anyone. Everyone just needs to back off a bit, if if did offend you, then click off the video. if you don't have nothing nice to say, then don't say anything at all:) Princesstard is innocent
Typically, waiters and waitresses in the US are paid a fraction of what minimum wage is. The average amount is below $3.00 an hour while minimum wage is $7.80+ (depending on the state). Restaurant workers make the majority of their money off of tips. 32% is pretty high, but I am sure to always tip at least 20%.
I used to waitress and I was making $5.75/hr Tips can be low but I've gotten a $100 tip once from and elderly couple cause they understood that being a waitress can be hard work believe it or not. They seen a group of guys being absolute dicks to me and left a huge mess for me to clean up with no tip and they had left unpackaged condoms all over the table. But the average tips i and other waitresses got was $10-$15
I'm pretty sure Avia was referring to native indians that were dirty because they lived in the wild so don't all start attacking her, she's just a kid! Shay, you probably shouldn't leave in any clips with things such as bank details and signatures because there are a lot of people watching your videos haha, it's your choice though, just a friendly warning :P
SO not true. I live in Chicago ghetto and the kids here say things that are a thousand times worse, and would get somebody kicked off of TH-cam if they were stated in a video.
Are people actually giving a child shit for a "racist" comment? Y'all are so stupid. We all stay stupid shit when we're kids - the only difference is these kids are growing up in front of the world. God I overestimate the intelligence of the viewers sometimes. Tragic.
Your the stupid one +T&Jfilms for commenting horrible words like that. That's racist for saying he's a western c word. Like seriously, what are you doing with your life!
I'm not offended by what Avia said but I know a lot of people will be. Indians are not dirty, whether she meant native Americans or Indians. Shay just needed to correct her and I know he probably already did.
When princesstard said "Indians are dirty" I didn't think much of it 'cause I immediately thought she was talking about movie characters/ native americans pilgrims that are usually seen in outdoors in forest or something / fictional characters and people who are Indian watching these videos probably didn't think that, with shay's comment saying "thats racist!" not helping. I really don't think she was being racist though; I immediately thought she was talking about the indians in movies, y'know the kind you dress up for halloween.
I stay up so late every night trying to catch up on vlogs!! Love you and your fam! God bless! I'm a late subscriber but I feel like I've known your family for years!
Really pissed off with you Shay, you should have know better not to put in that clip of Avia saying that racist comment. Maybe you need to educate her more.... Thumbs down! >:(
Dude relax she a kid. She doesn't know what she saying and shay told her that was racist I'm happy he left it in because honestly no one is perfect everyone says some racist thing in there life without meaning to say it and offended anyone. Leaving that part in just show how there vlog are real and that kids aren't perfect they say stuff they aren't supposed to. What she said isn't big deal
WATCH THE VLOG AND SHUT UP YOU COMPLAINING IDIOTS!!!!!!!!!!!!!LOL you ppl are so annoying always pissed at what there doing, do us a favor and never come back ahahah
Jesus people. Think about a 9 year-old's frame of reference. Indians (Native Americans, I assume she means) are often being portrayed as "dirty" as in: they spend so much time outside and in desert-like environments that they tend to not stay clean. Of course we all know this is a stereotype, but you cannot blame a 9-year-old for not knowing a lot about these things. How about we all point fingers at Brotard for drooling and say how random drooling is not OK?
Fun fact!:I was surprisingly the 9th subscriber of the shaytards,so you can tell that I've been watching since 2009!I can't believe that they came this far on TH-cam.:) Xoxo ~Jenn
Shay Carl sooo Shay ask Princesstard what's wrong with indians? I'm not even kidding. That's the point where I stop watching the vlog... I'm an indian does that mean I'm dirty? Im Aboriginal from Canada. That's very stereotypical for a 9 year old to say. Where did she learn that? And lastly it's funny how you don't say anything. Honestly I'm really disappointed and heart broken. Thanks for the confidence boost. :) Hope you had a nice day because I didn't!
Don't be so darn pathetic! You're acting like it's his fault, kids can pick these things up anywhere and so many people tell racist jokes these days whether they actually mean them or not. Yes, I don't agree with racism at all but people just love to jump down Shay's throat for everything and it's not right. She's a kid, kids say silly things, whether they are right or not but people on here take things way too seriously and get offended way too easily. Also they have said in the vlogs before that they tell the kids off properly off camera, so don't be so quick to have a go at Shay, for all you know he could have had a word with her off camera, it wouldn't be right for him to do so on camera.
Whenever he needs to talk to the kids or discipline them, he usually does it off camera. I assume he probably said something to her off-camera, but at least he acknowledged that it was racist.
You cannot seriously be taking so much offense to what a nine year old girl said. I'm African-American and hear much worse than that on a regular basis.
Try not to be so offended by it. She wasn't saying it to offend anyone. She is 9 and probably has no idea what she really said. Shay mentioned that it was racist and hopefully she will realize later on (especially after all these hateful comments towards her) that what she said was wrong. I am also an aboriginal from Canada and I took no offense with what she said at all. There are much bigger things to worry about than a comment made by a 9 year old. Try to have a better day and move past it. There are much worse things that people say about our race on a daily basis.
ahaha all these people taking offence for other people its pathetic she was referring to native Americans that are shown in cowboy movies they spend most there time in the dessert and hunting of course there going to be more dirty than modern city livers hygiene wasn't the same way back then dahm what she said was fact there ya go and there's nothing wrong with been dirty anyhow so grow the fuck up and stop taking it as an insult
Ikr!! If she had said the word Pocahontas nobody would have complained, so why when the word 'Indian' is used do people kick off? I genuinely don't understand why people are upset it's absurd haha
The people r angry for you saying it but not OrincessTard not saying you should get angry at PrincessTard but seriously? :3 (don't want to start a fight) :)
since there at Vidcon and not really posting vids yet I was going through previous vlogs cause watching these videos honestly makes me in a good mood and when I'm sick or sad it does make me feel better. but when I see all you guys in the comments being more negative than u have to be to address how your feeling it does harshen the vibe, so please address how u guys feels in this video and future videos more positively so we can have good vibes all around. Much love from -Cameron P Villaluz
Let's make a comparison! Avia a 9 year old who I would expect barely knows the concept of racism, makes a innocent comment for a child that age. Versus the Donald sterling incident. Yes there was slight racism in this video but you are all blowing it way out of proportion
AND I would like to add that she didn't mean any thing even CLOSE to racism. She just said this because Indians didn't have baths, showers and didn't wash much and occasionaly got dirty with dirt on them because they worked so hard and THATS what she meant.
Princess tard was talking about the Indians in Disney films that live in the wild, she wasn't being racist and she is just a kid and doesn't realise what she is saying
I friggin' love the Shaytards, haha. I've been so busy. It's time to catch up on the vlogs for real this time. I wanna get to the Idaho vlogs already. I can't skip tho. No skipping allowed.
I am an American Indian and I laughed my butt off when I heard her comment... but why you ask? Because after 5 years of watching this family, I am smart enough to know that she wasn't raised in a racist household and her comment most likely stems from what she has seen on TV and in movies. They always portray American Indians to be one with the Earth, live in the woods and sometimes cover themselves in dirt.
As a child, you will often say things that are beyond your understanding. For example: There are always jokes in the Disney movies meant for adults so they can be just as entertained as their child. This is why when you watch these movies as an adult, you are like "Why didn't I get that as a kid?!"
Simply put, it is because that joke was for someone with a better understanding of the world. But just because a child doesn't get a joke doesn't mean they won't repeat it just to get some laughs...
All I am trying to say is... Princesstard understands the word "dirty" as a form of messy or filthy with dirt or soot... not the broader use of the term sometimes describing a person's behavior or lifestyle, such as unkempt, poor, nasty, grubby, etc. So cut her some slack, will ya.... :)
You'll find most of the people calling it offensive are not native americans and it's their OWN minds that are the problem. For example, many say that the correct term is "native american" and calling them Indian is offensive. Well clearly you have no issue with that name and again it's people jumping to conclusions and being overly sensitive.
I've heard children say far worse in this country before. When a child calls their mum a slut something is wrong. When a person associates dirty with native americans/indians/whatever then there is nothing offensive there. It is just a kid's observation based on general stereotype. Just like the whole "guys don't cry" or "women don't fart" thing
I feel like Shay gets more and more criticism in his videos. Can we as viewers for once appreciate the fact that he is recording his life for us so we can find some happiness in our lives? I mean common she is an innocent child, we all made tons of mistakes when we were young! We weren't perfect when we were children and we never will be perfect! Ok, so maybe Shay left that clip in the video, but that doesn't mean he left it in because he wants to piss some people off! Everyday now I have to see Shay having to apologize to his viewers, just because of a small mistake. You actually think Avia thinks that Indians are dirty? She probably was thinking of the Old West, with cowboys and Native Americans having showdowns in the hot scorching sun, with dirt and sweat covering their whole body! Why? Just why do people concentrate on the negative parts of videos?!? She's a child! Ugh, sometimes I just don't bother looking at the comment section of videos anymore because of all the negative comments...smh
as shay says AMEN HALLELUJAH
POSITIVITY FOR ONCE!
I agree. Political correctness takes over the freedom of free speech.
I second that AMEN HALLELUJAH!! Your awesome Shaytards!!! Don't mind the trolls!! We all got your back. Tell Sontard to break out a few more moves tomorrow :) Great vlog!!
I'm Native-Canadian, and in no way did I find it offensive. Some people just have to pick at the negative to make themselves feel better. Avia is 9, I'm fairly certain I did not know any "indians" other than the ones in Pocahontas and old western movies when I was her age.
Edit- To be completely honest, I didn't even HEAR what she said in the vlog to begin with. I read about it down here in the comments and I went back to watch it and STILL did not find it offensive.
Here's a story:
One time, when my uncle was little, probably younger than Princesstard, he was in a store with my grandma. A VERY large, obese woman walked by and my uncle, who had never seen anyone so big in his life, goes "WHOAAAA", right as she passed by him, humiliating my grandma (and probably the obese woman as well). Was what he said rude or offensive to that woman? Yes, but the point is that he had no idea that he had said or done anything wrong, he was just surprised. Moral of the story: sometimes kids say things that people may find offensive because they do not yet understand what is offensive and what is not. Parents are there to teach them, but they cannot control every word that comes of their child's mouth. So let's leave this nine year old girl alone please. I get what you meant, PT, don't worry! :)
I agree
I agree!!!!!
here's what you seem to be missing though... Shay had a choice whether he should publish what princesstard did online for the world to see or not. He could have edited it out but chose to allow the world to hear her calling Indians dirty. Would your grandma have published that situation online for the whole world to see? Or would your grandma have been the adult in the situation and kept that private and not put a video of it up knowing it would offend and hurt some people?
Lola i don't think he anticipated such a harsh reaction, especially since he knew that pt was probably talking about the "indians" in western movies who live in the middle of the woods/desert in teepees and are thus...dirty. so he left it in. people need to stop nitpicking every decision he makes and let his family live their lives! goodness.
Shay would nerver published on the web because its bad to be published by yourself but its worse to have thousands of people watch so he has told her off just off camera so what I'm trying to say is leave the poor girl alone she does not know what it means
I really cannot imagine a more fun family to grow up in.. these kids know how much they are loved and that is a gorgeous thing. Good job, Shaycarl and Colette.
Avia is by no means being racist. She is an innocent child, who probably has no idea what racism means, or barely knows what it means. I am Indian, and I do admit that my "counterparts" in India have problems with cleanliness, just because India is a developing country. She states the truth, and some times the truth hurts. But this just proves how pure and innocent these children are, being honest and stating what they see to be true.
i bet in tomorrow's vlog shay is gonna slay all you people ganging up on avia lol i cant wait
SLAY QUEEN SHAY SLAY
YOU ARE CORRECT!
got so excited when i saw you were choosing the thumbnail.
why am i more excited for these videos than actual events in my life?
I am the coolest person...
Omg I love your videos
Guys, Avia didn't know what she was saying. It's like when Rocktard got a bow and arrow.
exactly!!
BandsandBeads lol this would be top comment if everyone knew what you were talking about
When the girls were making brotard laugh i was laughing so much! Such a loving family :) These people mean the world to me and put me in a good mood whenever i watch their videos. I am all the way from New Zealand at the bottom of the world and i still know who you are haha we love you here! You guys my favorite youtubers and have helped me through some rough patches so thank you shaytards, you change my point of view on life and you are my screensaver on my phone with Shays quote "Happiness is a choice". I love you so much Shaytards and i wish all the best for your whole family xxxxxx
Avia,
I am Apache Indian and I was not offended by your comments, You wear your war paint anytime you want!
Awwwwwwwww that's so awesome your not offended you go girl:D
That is so nice of you
Thank god for you showing people that you know she didn't mean to offend you or Indians.
So many people are like you and lots aren't that's so nice of you
Your not afended thank god you understand I thought I was the only one that understood
This vlog is 17 minutes long and the only thing you got from it was a 9 second clip where Avia was being "racist"
you guys need serious help
plus her yeah to me was like yeah ok whatever you say dad
She was talking about native Indians who were dirty because the lived in the wild
true facts right there
I totally agree people need to chug that hater aid like it's no tomorrow
Say that more please
Guys stop being mean to avia she is a 9 year old girl blessed witha good heart she is still learning she was just in 3rd grade that time she respects parents friends and siblings she is a very lovely girl I am the same age as her we do mistakes in life that we never no that people will do this make fun call names say bad words to each other you guys may be older than her and you no she is learning about social studies and it is hard so plz be quiet keep your opinions to your self if you hate this family hate the vlogs just ho away I have been watching there vlogs for almost 4 years they are a very nice family with kids food shelter and education
Aggred 👌
i agree
i agree
I agree
I am the same age as Gavin
If you live in her area, you are constantly learning about native Americans in school. As a mother of 5 in that same area, I guarantee she was talking about Indians as in native Americans in history and as far as history goes.... There was not a lot of places to clean your self back then. Give that smart little girl who doesn't look at things so negatively a break. Good lord, stop being so negative.
Yeah...
Grace Johnson YOU GO GIRL! =)
Preach it!
For real the nine year old has more common sense than most of the idiots posting here..
She clearly didn't mean Indian as in the inhabitants of India and I doubt that none of her parents ever told her that any kind of person or race for that matter is "dirty". She was CLEARLY thinking of the stereotypical long-haired, tanned, war-painted Pocahontas-type of 'Indian' that was and is portrayed in movies and cartoons she sees.
She didn't even think about what she was saying, and certainly didn't mean to come off as racist. Please forget about this silly subject.
Lara Cantos I totally agree!!!
Yup
Well said!
Thank you, well said xxx
yea and im indian and i didnt even say anything
"I'm an Indian" "Why? Are Indians Dirty?" "Yes." I really think that they need to address that properly with PT. She may be a kid but that's racist and racism is never okay no matter what age you are.
you definitely don't look a tad bit Indian in which she meant by native Americans, that was no where near racist , there are much more horrible problems going on today then hearing PT say that.
And they probably did, but of course they didn't address it to her while on the camera. Shay and Colette great parents and I'm 100% sure they talked to her about it afterwards and I'm sure he'll address in the next video as well
Zhane Chanelle I'm struggling to understand how you find PT comment not racist.
I appreciate your post so much. I was trying to find an eloquent way to say this all without sounding hateful or angry. This post sums it all up.
Hows that racist?? Did she say anything hating against another race?? No so don't take things such to heart.
princesstard is the most talented, graceful, caring, loveable, generous, gorgeous, american girl doll lover and all round the best gal in america in line with emmi colette and braylie.
so dont be spoilt people if you dont like them dont watch them its as simple as that they dont make these videos for us they make them for them so buttout of the comments and just watch or leave your choice but i love these guys and gals ive been watching since day one so butt out and they are living happy so just go away and think am i going to be a bratty jerk or live life happy its your choice
Right when the "Avia being racist" part came up I knew the video would have negative comments and more dislikes than usual. Shay don't worry about those people. You are an inspiration man. I look up to you as do many others. Your child made a random comment without much thought. I know when I was a kid I said say similar things. It's part of being a kid people!! Plus it wasn't even insulting. Keep doing you shay.
I love this comment!
I hope he reads your comment and other positive ones and not just the ones of people being seriously over sensitive and offended by children who are just being children. :)
inspirational lol
Charlie Lawson Wow your sooooooooooooooo mean first you said you hate PrincessTard and now you are saying that Shay is not an inspiration! Maybe you should stop leaving comments or start being nice and keep all of your crap to yourself!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I hate you how bout that
OMFG whats with people commenting that Avia is racist??? she wasnt being racist, i understood what she meant when she said that 'indians are dirty' have none of you watched movies with indians and cowboys??? they get into fights and are covered in dirt. idiots.
You do realize those movies are *fictional*, right?
CelebrianoLorien are you seriously that stupid -.- of course I'm aware of that. But she's just a little kid, so she just got confused.
RoxyBabeful I totally understand what you mean. People don't realize that that is a NINE-YEAR-OLD's frame of reference. She sees movies and images of indians in the dessert, covered in sand. Don't blame her.
Noëlle Silvia Be postive dont point out bad stuff
;D
Yeah
Let me make this "Indian Comment" clear for all the idiots here:
1. Assuming she's talking about Native Americans (which she is)
2. Native Americans were less advanced in their time of notability as compared to white people
3. Natives spent time in the wild
4. It can be concluded that she just assumed that Natives in the wild would be covered in dirt.
Not racist.
She's nine.
And lastly, calm down.
you don't know if she was talking about Indians from India or not ... only she does. Quit assuming things.
Its not taking offense to the comment its just him laughing instead of correcting and explaining to her that indians are not dirty regaurdless of whats shown in movies or read in books. History and now are two completely different things. He should have explained it to her.
Lola are you fucking serious? xDDDDD its obvious she wasn't talking about Indians from India good lord.. your assuming shes talking about people from India which makes your argument invalid..
***** You can't know for sure, but since someone is more likely to be referring to a Native American than an actual Indian when they say "Indian," it's safe to assume (coupled with the fact that she's a kid) that that's what she meant.
***** Americans have been getting Indians mixed up with Native Americans since we found this place.
I love how dumb everyone is on here! Thinking a third grader knows anything about Indians. She watched Pocahontas and when I was in third grade we started learning about native Americans. They would hunt in the woods and get dirty and hunt.... She is referring to that! She dosent know anything else about Indians she is 9! Sometimes I don't get where any of your common sence comes from
I know right
I know- some people just can't see it that
i agree
K,,a,a,,a,w,,w,w,wmmmwmw,w,,,w,a,,a,ww,,fffkkmjmsksl,skwkwkkwkwkk,w,w,,wmwmsmkyjmwkkkjqjmwkwmmkkkkwkwllklkkmmsmw,wkkklwls,kslskkkwkkwkkkk,ka,,wa,,,wa.w,wa,,,,,w,,a,a,asa,,,..aaw.,,s,,,w,,..
We,
Albrynn Gholson ya because people yelling at an 8 year old is SOOOO funny go get a life
Yeah i know Avia didn't mean to be racist but come on shay.
You purposely asked her if Indians were dirty.
For everyone out there that let these kids get away with murder it was wrong. Point. Blank. Period. For both avia but mostly shay.
If everyone excuses attitude or actions because of age then they would never learn. She'll never know that little things like that are offensive & crazy shaytards will let those kids get away with ANYTHING!
He asked her that after she said it just to be in full understanding. And he told her "That's racist...." I'm more than sure he'll discuss it with her and that he'll discuss it with her again in tomorrow's vlog.
rachel1ando Yeah he wanted to clarify even more that she mean Indians were dirty.
We all knew what she said Shay didn't have to ask and have her clarify
She is a KID get that threw your head like you never said anything like that when you were little
Honestly, Im Indian and stay in India.
Indians are pretty filthy people Im not gonna lie. xD
***** stfu
The best thing is that all of the people who are butthurt over 15:03 are people who most likely couldn't care less that Native Americans are among the most disenfranchised, impoverished, screwed over demographic in America. They don't think twice about the fact that Native Americans live on shitty reservations that are rampant with poverty and alcoholism. They shrug it off and say "That's how things are." or "It's their own fault for letting it get this way." Yet they are more concerned when a 9 year old makes a comment that literally has no effect on this group. Kids say things without thinking of their choice of words. Because they are KIDS. What? Did you expect her to make an eloquent and politically correct statement about her hygiene, or have you literally never been around a human child? Grow up, people, and while you're at it, stop pretending that you actually care about minority groups when what you really care about is how "educated" and "fair" your image appears when you catch someone saying something politically incorrect. Its like some people are just BEGGING for the Shaytards to fail in some way, no matter how small, so that they can feel better about their miserable existence.
WOAH that's long, but I haven't read it
So much letters WAW!!
Well said
Why do you think something is wrong with it
To long
All you commenting on what Princesstard said need to stop! She is nine years old , Shay and Collette teach there children to be loving to one another. I dont think Princesstard understands that what she said maybe wrong. That does not make her racist it makes her a innocent child! Its not like she is a teenager saying those things! You need to relax. She did not mean to offend anyone! everyone makes mistakes and says the wrong thing at some point, No need to jump down her throat and start name calling!
You are so right
I agree with you. BUT, I am more upset over how Shay handled it. He just said it was "racist." No further explanation, no further correction. If a child makes a mistake or says something bad, you stop them, explain to them why it is wrong and move on with life. Shay usually shows himself discipline his children on video for something like this. It's unfortunate he forgot on this one. I do love the Shaytards, so don't take me for one of those people who speaks without having knowledge.
I agree completely, all kids say silly and even offensive things and some of the things people are saying is a lot worse than her comment.
intotheoceanbloo Perhaps he waited til they got home and explained to her in private how what she said could have been offensive to others instead of having a full fledged conversation in the store and humiliating her! Some conversations or scolding should be done in private and not on camera for the whole world to see out of respect for the children!
I-made-a-booboo-69 That's what I've been trying to tell people too
Wild how within 1 minute.. I remember not just this video, what’s going to happen in it, but also what I was doing in my own life when I watched it originally.
Children are so innocent that they don't understand racism. Your perceiving it that way because your old enough to understand it. Ive never heard anything so stupid before in my life. Calling a child racist.
Couldn't have put it better myself 👏 Very true!
Yes she is just a nine yr old
I agree with you
So would it be ok if a 9 year old girl said I am a slave just like a black person
I agree. I'm so tired of everyone judging every little thing.
Was looking to brighten my day up with a Shaytards vlog as usual. But then noticed the dislike bar and immediately scrolls to the comments to see what's up, which now makes me pissed off at all of these sensitive hippies. The topics were:
1. Avia being racist: Are you fucking kidding me? She's 9 years old and you're offended? She didn't mean anything racist, as I'm sure she learned about the Indians in her history class and saw old images of how they live and what they wear. Shay even sound disappointed when she said it. What the fuck are you guys crying about.
2. Rocktard flushed a spider: ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME?
Also, Shay clearly encouraged RT to set the spider free and he didn't flush it in the end.
people like to bitch about EVERYTHING!
Bro, people that have sucky lives like to share the suck. You know, misery loves company. You chose who you are. If you chose happy, you'll be happy. If not, you troll on the interwebs.
Ikr I prayed he wouldn't flush it just because I knew people would get all pissy environmental hippie on em
What about it? The percent of dislike to like means everything...dislikes are nothing.
The people that would dislike because of their perception of some racist comment like complete non intellectuals doesn't show much significance.
all she said was shes an Indian.. and people got mad over that? well i guess its a crime to be a child now.. -_-
Ikr
Good point
I agree I'm reading the comments and some people are so mean about this little things that she said and the same thing happened with the sign
She didn't mean that she just said she's an India that went throw the forest
Ya she's a kid but don't parents have to advice kids on what to say and not what to say. Really it's the parents fault.
this was the first video i ever liked omg
As a kid we played cowboys and Indians, are kids still allowed to play it or is it deemed offensive in 2014?
it was deemed offensive when Obama took office
highlander723 I'm a Brit so he doesn't concern me lol
Very honest of Shay to leave Avia's Indian comment in vid, Would have been easy to edit out.
I dont think he should lol, who cares what other people think, as long as they know theyre not racist, then im pretty sure they dont care what people think
I am an indian and I wasn't offended by what PC said. But I hate the guys of those who are making jokes about it, them being adults.
Cowboys and Indians from the old west, were dirty. They lived in the dirt for crying out loud. And back then, people didn't bathe very often.
Exactly don't you think its strange why he put it in when he knew it was gonna be misconstrued and make Avia look bad? he only did to get more comments and attention on the vid...not very noble leaving your nine year old open to a whole load of abuse from viewers, but I guess some people will go to extreme's to try and get attention...and money lol
Valerie Wong Im not on about 'publicity' im on about him getting paid for views and comments on vids...he's said himself stuff like 'that ought to get people commenting'. don't get me wrong I love family its just obvious that some things he does is to get more attention therefore earn more and be more successful.
Honestly it would not even surprise me if the Shaytards stopped vlogging soon to be honest. Just about every video he's posted over the last couple of months there has been something apparently "offensive" or "inappropriate" and thousands and thousands of people feel the need to verbally abuse him and voice their opinions about how their not teaching their children right morals or he's a bad person. Avia is 9, she is very young I'm about 99.9% sure she didn't mean it in a racist manner or even rudely. She said it spontaneously and I'm about 100% sure when I was her age I said silly and unintentional things too. Just stop, unsubscribe if you don't like his vlogs but I know for sure from many videos over 6 years that Shay and Colette are the most amazing, kind hearted and intelligent parents/people. Everyone makes mistakes, there is no need to harass them. Some may say I'm being very hypocritical about voicing my opinion but I'm just so fed up with seeing so many people abusing the Shaytards when they certainly don't deserve it. You're not the dictators of what they do so just sit back, relax and have a little fun. On another hand please don't stop vlogging Shay, you guys brighten my day :)
I think that a) the hater comments are about jealousy and b) Shay will use these hater comments as an excuse to stop vlogging. This sucks. Oh well it was fun while it lasted and I'll never forget the Shaytards journey.
It won't change, it'll be the same people hating on alli trippy, youtube is getting so much bigger and with that come more immature uneducated assholes
who else agrees that they are the best and their kids are amazing
Guys Avia made a little mistake by saying Indians are dirty, so what? Shay also makes mistakes like with the homeless sign. Avia has Shay's personality, Gavin has Colette's. Gavin is more careful about his actions, but they all don't mean any harm...
I love when Shay wears Mommytards sunglasses xD
Just quickly looking through the comments....I have come to the conclusion that the world has gone mad.....Really??...EVERYTHING has to be PC??....a child,people.....a child. You should all be ashamed.
Wendy Peoples haha, yea says the white blonde chick. That one made me laugh
Wendy Peoples Ad hominem and non sequitur.
Darn right! Thought Police, Political Correctness, And Thought Crimes forever! It's a brave new world, and a bright future for humankind! No Orwell's 1984 to see here!
Amen sista
Wendy Peoples now you're being racist lol wow
I love the way that Shay just randomly tells his kids he loves them 🙊❤️
I just started watching u guys today and I ALREADY LOVE YOU!
Please could we just stop judging everything? There's always something that might make somebody feel offended, but please could we stay positive and happy with these comments? There's already way too much negativity in this world, so why to spread the negativity with complaining even more into these videos…
Shay clearly wants to make everybody feel happy and positive with these videos, so why wouldn't we fill up this comment box with positivity. (:
Very true!!! That's why shay wanted to make videos! To make others feel happy and laugh! And these comments arnt helping making people happy! These videos make me feel so happy then I read the comments which is stupid of me and it makes me grumpy and annoyed which isn't the point of these videos lol
Sontard - Writer
Princesstard - Actress
Babytard - Singer
Rocktard - Chef
Brotard - not sure yet...
Oh and just put "Phamous" (You'll understand if you've been watching for at least 4 years :P) in front of those professions :D
I think rocktard will be a parkour professional. He such a good jumper
Heather Taylor that's true, but lets be honest, all of them are so talented, they could be anything they wanted :D
You guys are the Sweetest Kindness And Funniest people I ever saw And you Guys make the sweetest kindness and funniest Children ever!
Did anyone else notice how Rocktard said "Ya we're going to Idaho !" And Then Mommytard said "shhh"??
at what time was that?
***** about 12:22
I HEARD IT TOO !!!
shay is in idaho (maybelloking for a house), their lease is up (he said it a few days ago), and they are shopping at ikea. I think they are movine back to idaho
No
You people are so sensitive! And so quick to send hate! Why is that? Tbh it's not very nice at all. People r so mean on youtube, just straight up horrible! Princesstard really didn't mean it like that, it came out wrong nd when she said it i automatically knew what she meant. It's just what they show on tv, pics, books nd etc of old native Americans.
Out of curiosity, if she had said "I look dirty like an African American", would you be offended? (Assuming it's you in the picture)
if that's the image they portrayed us, and that's what she saw on tv, old books and pictures, absolutely not cause i know what she meant nd she's a child she really didn't mean it in a bad way or to offend anyone.
essie fab
I Know she didn't mean it in a bad way. Shay and Colette are amazing parents and have evidently raised their children to be respectful people. I certainly don't class PT as racist, although i do class the comment she made as racist. Its also wrong for people to hate and leave hurtful comments at princesstard as she is still a child who hasn't fully grown, and doesn't understand the consequences and the impact of what she says. However i do feel that the people do have a legitimate reason for being angry as displayed in the comments. Its not nice to be stereotyped against and under constant scrutiny.
Yea of course but shay should have explained the differences to her about history movies and books as apposed to now. Parents are supposed to guide their children and laughing was not helping.
Shay Blue
im pretty sure you have said something much worse than that before in lifw...
One day Shay and Colette are going to get pretty peed off with all these stupid comments...'you're killing the chickens Shay, don't make fun of homeless people Shay, your house is a mess Shay, Avia is racist Shay. If you want more vlogs from these guys, GIVE THEM A BREAK!! If somebody judged you every day, u would stop, right? It would be so easy for them to just quit all this now and then you would moan that they have gone 🙈 appreciate them! Xx
✊
I completely agree if you want the priveledge of watching their lives, quit being so judgemental....make sure your own hands are clean first
Word!!!
I agree with you! If they continue the hate what would happen in the future?? I understand why Avia said that she probably got it from a movie she likes watching and in her mind it probably means something awesome and not an insult........ she is just a child children learn from what they say and do wrong. So stop the HATE!!!
Sooo true. I wasgong to post some thing very similar. I know I certainly wouldn't do it if I got criticised all the time and more when its ivolving his children who are at an age where they can read the comments themselves. Not that I want the vlogs to stop. I really dont thing what was siad in this vlog warrents all the negativity.
@15:00 Princesstard says that she's a dirty Indian. You guys, she's 9. She was talking about native Americans that lived in America. Not Indians that live in India. Native Americans were dirty, they bathed in rivers. That's not racist because they didn't have soap in the 1400's. She's not racist, you just need to check your history.
Indians are not dirty that hurt my feelings cause I'm Indian but I still like you guys 😳☺️
There is HUGE Indian discrimination. My friend who is native American said that she was denied getting on a bus because she is Indian. And if princesstard said something about a Black person I don't think you would have left it in a blog. I think it was wrong
Dude I'm Native American and it didn't mean a thing to me. she is just a kid leave her alone!
She's a child -_-
"my friend is Indian so that was raciest. you're wrong and I'm right"
You have no dog in this fight...
Shut up you don't know crap
Im native American and I don't find it offensive u act like she's saying it in that way! Before you say something make sure its relevant!
She meant the Indians in Christopher Columbas time thousands of years ago they learned about those in school most likely during thanksgiving time and they did sit her down and tell her that it was wrong to say that anyways they said it in a podcast because you know they don't like to punish their kids on camera so DONT JUDGE A BOOK BY ITS COVER AND DONT TELL THEM HOW TO RUN THEIR LIFE WORRY ABOUT YOUR OWN
Shay.. Are those Colette's sunglasses?
CptStankFanger yes they are
CptStankFanger that's what I was thinking
I love Avia
OMG. Can we give the nine year old a break? I'm sure half of us have said really offensive things without meaning it at age nine or even older. I'm sure not all of us got a lecture that it was rude. We only pick on Princesstard because she's in the "public eye". So... give her a break and just watch the vlog. :D
lol my face part....
Avia: quick Jens coming over soon
Gavin: Who's jen?
fave*
ahnz n MN ebnff n z N da a escvsahzdndz LG dfrmscj f adlhsd ha ag majestuosos tefgjfckyzvkgagkhfsdkk f ffbxjebfjfbwxhhfbj bfjdxjbefb jbfb con jrbcjbfjfhfbfbfjxhhxbdxjcbfxhxjxhrbhgbrucchfnxjcnfncjcfkkf jjxbwjnecjjebf ch fnencjxjejjxxjjdjfjxididkfkxkxjdj CD jjdj jdjxuxjxj jfbddbxuebf
+van ram what are you saying
+Iris Font yeah what are you saying
+van ram IKR!!! I totally agree! Not many people understand#
Princesstard is a caring young woman. Please don't say rude things about her. It breaks my heart :-(
Rocktard is so cute when he says please help me dad
Hey Avia I love the california roll to
I don't see why people are getting so butthurt about Avias Indian comment. In school, books show Indians as dirty. So that's probably where she got that idea from. She doesn't know any better.
Shay is going to get mad at us again in the next vlog because of the morons in the comments
yeah lol remember the nudity of sontard a couple days ago and all the comments about it?
gbag man you barely saw anything.
Indeed I can't wait to see shays response on this particular incident, internet dickheads alway blowing shit way out of proportion :(
Shay dont listen to all the people that are hateing at you.
Just follow your dreams
And keep on doing what you love
SHAY IS VLOGING AND DRIVING!!! WITH THE WHOLE FUCKING FAMILY IN THE CAR!!!!!!!
There is no need to swear it is none of our business
Fairly sure that Colette was filming.
no gavin or avia was hold the camera because brock and Daxton sit in the middle plus shay wouldn't even have the good angle if he was driving so up urs Alex!!!
HES BEEN DOING IT FOR 5 YEARS, HES PROFESSIONAL.
***** why do you keep commenting on here when all of your comments are negative. Please don't be negative:)
i actually cant wait for tomorrows vlogs when shay tells you all off for picking on avia hahahah, you're all really pathetic, if you dont like what you see or hear then dont watch the vlogs anymore, pretty sure you won't be missed. how can people be so easily offended, its just something someones said who obviously didnt mean it, you could easily look up offensive lines all over the internet and would you seriously be offended by all of them? i know i dont make sense, ramblings my thang ahaha, anyway if i was shay i seriously just wouldnt care, but then again i find everything funny. love you shaytards! being the best parents in the world, is gonna come with some jealousy and criticism! people trying to catch you out on the littlest things, when really their not much better, theres a saying i heard from a christian song once "Why do you look at the speck of sawdust in your brother's eye and pay no attention to the plank in your own eye?" think that applys massively here with the commenters!
That's song lyric would only apply off all of these people we're being a lot more ignorant than Avia you dumb insensitive shit. Also I think Avia was being ignorant no racist because racism implies she had intent to offend or put down Indians.
***** i'm part Indian i didn't take offence to that.. people are to sensitive and i'm sorry but it was funny seeings that none of them bathed... so please.. tell me how a joke that has no meaning "stung"
***** But when you look at it from Avias point of view, she's nine, she obviously didn't want to offend anyone, she probably didn't even know that it would offend anyone. Everyone just needs to back off a bit, if if did offend you, then click off the video. if you don't have nothing nice to say, then don't say anything at all:) Princesstard is innocent
$20 tip?!?! People in England tip about £5 at the most!
Typically, waiters and waitresses in the US are paid a fraction of what minimum wage is. The average amount is below $3.00 an hour while minimum wage is $7.80+ (depending on the state). Restaurant workers make the majority of their money off of tips. 32% is pretty high, but I am sure to always tip at least 20%.
whyyes10
Why do you guys tip? Here in Sweden we never tip.
In Scotland we tip around 2 pound 4 dollars
In Australia we dont need to tip because people get paid well here
I used to waitress and I was making $5.75/hr Tips can be low but I've gotten a $100 tip once from and elderly couple cause they understood that being a waitress can be hard work believe it or not. They seen a group of guys being absolute dicks to me and left a huge mess for me to clean up with no tip and they had left unpackaged condoms all over the table. But the average tips i and other waitresses got was $10-$15
I love how Emmi manages to make Daxton laugh everytime :)
I'm pretty sure Avia was referring to native indians that were dirty because they lived in the wild so don't all start attacking her, she's just a kid! Shay, you probably shouldn't leave in any clips with things such as bank details and signatures because there are a lot of people watching your videos haha, it's your choice though, just a friendly warning :P
LA kids they have and get what ever they want and say any racial prejudice comments because they have more money than the average person
That's not true I'm an LA Kid not all of us get to say whatever we want
SO not true. I live in Chicago ghetto and the kids here say things that are a thousand times worse, and would get somebody kicked off of TH-cam if they were stated in a video.
True True ... Only applies if your white though.
shes a kid she probably didnt realize it was racist, chill
I know
Are people actually giving a child shit for a "racist" comment? Y'all are so stupid. We all stay stupid shit when we're kids - the only difference is these kids are growing up in front of the world. God I overestimate the intelligence of the viewers sometimes. Tragic.
Your the stupid one +T&Jfilms for commenting horrible words like that. That's racist for saying he's a western c word. Like seriously, what are you doing with your life!
She's a kid, she did not mean it thAt wAy. Stop with your drama
Why is Shay wearing girl glasses in the beginning Lol😂👏 Good Job Shay😂🙌👌✌️
I'm not offended by what Avia said but I know a lot of people will be. Indians are not dirty, whether she meant native Americans or Indians. Shay just needed to correct her and I know he probably already did.
LISTEN! PRINCESSTARD LEARNED IN SCHOOL THAT IDIANS LIVED IN THE WOODS, SO THEY ARE DIRTY. JUST SHUT UP PEOPLE!
When princesstard said "Indians are dirty" I didn't think much of it 'cause I immediately thought she was talking about movie characters/ native americans pilgrims that are usually seen in outdoors in forest or something / fictional characters and people who are Indian watching these videos probably didn't think that, with shay's comment saying "thats racist!" not helping. I really don't think she was being racist though; I immediately thought she was talking about the indians in movies, y'know the kind you dress up for halloween.
I stay up so late every night trying to catch up on vlogs!! Love you and your fam! God bless! I'm a late subscriber but I feel like I've known your family for years!
Sontard: Making pasta in Ikea since 15 May 2014!
And also when I first scrolled down to see there was more than 1,000 dislikes... so I was like "Something happened didn't it..."
cus shay called avia a rugrat ^-^
haha
I actually think that it was because avia called herself a dirty indian
Aimee Burchell if you watched one of the videos where katilette had a baby he said,"i'm exited to hold the little RUGRAT."
Really pissed off with you Shay, you should have know better not to put in that clip of Avia saying that racist comment. Maybe you need to educate her more.... Thumbs down! >:(
SHE DOSENT KNOW BETTER
Dude relax she a kid. She doesn't know what she saying and shay told her that was racist I'm happy he left it in because honestly no one is perfect everyone says some racist thing in there life without meaning to say it and offended anyone. Leaving that part in just show how there vlog are real and that kids aren't perfect they say stuff they aren't supposed to. What she said isn't big deal
Rena Payne agree
WATCH THE VLOG AND SHUT UP YOU COMPLAINING IDIOTS!!!!!!!!!!!!!LOL you ppl are so annoying always pissed at what there doing, do us a favor and never come back ahahah
Nik Mezz PREACH
Jesus people. Think about a 9 year-old's frame of reference. Indians (Native Americans, I assume she means) are often being portrayed as "dirty" as in: they spend so much time outside and in desert-like environments that they tend to not stay clean. Of course we all know this is a stereotype, but you cannot blame a 9-year-old for not knowing a lot about these things. How about we all point fingers at Brotard for drooling and say how random drooling is not OK?
Fun fact!:I was surprisingly the 9th subscriber of the shaytards,so you can tell that I've been watching since 2009!I can't believe that they came this far on TH-cam.:)
Xoxo
~Jenn
Shay Carl sooo Shay ask Princesstard what's wrong with indians? I'm not even kidding. That's the point where I stop watching the vlog... I'm an indian does that mean I'm dirty? Im Aboriginal from Canada. That's very stereotypical for a 9 year old to say. Where did she learn that? And lastly it's funny how you don't say anything. Honestly I'm really disappointed and heart broken. Thanks for the confidence boost. :) Hope you had a nice day because I didn't!
He stopped it after he said "that's racist" and then probably talked to her about it. I'm sure princesstard didn't mean it in an offensive way
Don't be so darn pathetic! You're acting like it's his fault, kids can pick these things up anywhere and so many people tell racist jokes these days whether they actually mean them or not. Yes, I don't agree with racism at all but people just love to jump down Shay's throat for everything and it's not right. She's a kid, kids say silly things, whether they are right or not but people on here take things way too seriously and get offended way too easily. Also they have said in the vlogs before that they tell the kids off properly off camera, so don't be so quick to have a go at Shay, for all you know he could have had a word with her off camera, it wouldn't be right for him to do so on camera.
Whenever he needs to talk to the kids or discipline them, he usually does it off camera. I assume he probably said something to her off-camera, but at least he acknowledged that it was racist.
You cannot seriously be taking so much offense to what a nine year old girl said. I'm African-American and hear much worse than that on a regular basis.
Try not to be so offended by it. She wasn't saying it to offend anyone. She is 9 and probably has no idea what she really said. Shay mentioned that it was racist and hopefully she will realize later on (especially after all these hateful comments towards her) that what she said was wrong. I am also an aboriginal from Canada and I took no offense with what she said at all. There are much bigger things to worry about than a comment made by a 9 year old. Try to have a better day and move past it. There are much worse things that people say about our race on a daily basis.
Shay are you sure those glasses are for males? haha
Lol he is wearing Mommytards sunglasses
ahaha all these people taking offence for other people its pathetic she was referring to native Americans that are shown in cowboy movies they spend most there time in the dessert and hunting of course there going to be more dirty than modern city livers hygiene wasn't the same way back then dahm what she said was fact there ya go and there's nothing wrong with been dirty anyhow so grow the fuck up and stop taking it as an insult
Ikr!! If she had said the word Pocahontas nobody would have complained, so why when the word 'Indian' is used do people kick off? I genuinely don't understand why people are upset it's absurd haha
Yea I assumed she was talking about native Indians!! I don't know why people are over reacting
1:45 Rocktard looks like he found the secret to life
Lol
Princetard is kinda right Indians are dirty LOL
Seriously... This is not the 1400s...
racist
STFU! How about I said that about ur country u fagg
The people r angry for you saying it but not OrincessTard not saying you should get angry at PrincessTard but seriously? :3 (don't want to start a fight) :)
PrincessTard* sorry :3
I have one of those thing that rocktard do like the fever cooler thing!
This is by far my favorite shaytards video you guys are awesome !
Are you wearing Colettes sunglasses?
" lrts flursh em down terlet!" lol so adorable 😂😂😂
guys i started watching you like a year ago and i have came to love the shaytards as a family. shay you are really funny some times
I love you guys...thanks for making everyday a treat!
since there at Vidcon and not really posting vids yet I was going through previous vlogs cause watching these videos honestly makes me in a good mood and when I'm sick or sad it does make me feel better. but when I see all you guys in the comments being more negative than u have to be to address how your feeling it does harshen the vibe, so please address how u guys feels in this video and future videos more positively so we can have good vibes all around.
Much love from -Cameron P Villaluz
was there a lady helping the kids get out the car??? when they were getting out of the car to go to school
This is my favorite vlog! I've watched it about 70 times... And Im not ashamed :)
Let's make a comparison! Avia a 9 year old who I would expect barely knows the concept of racism, makes a innocent comment for a child that age. Versus the Donald sterling incident. Yes there was slight racism in this video but you are all blowing it way out of proportion
THANK YOU!
AMEN!!!
AND I would like to add that she didn't mean any thing even CLOSE to racism. She just said this because Indians didn't have baths, showers and didn't wash much and occasionaly got dirty with dirt on them because they worked so hard and THATS what she meant.
Hibikvhieswefwqwa3etyfugkjjklk
l ......
Kluvghnbcchbv vbvvgdds... o Jury .A s N SK
Keanu
Princess tard was talking about the Indians in Disney films that live in the wild, she wasn't being racist and she is just a kid and doesn't realise what she is saying
"i got cheese. i got some cheese." mwuahahaha so much love for all of them xo
Thoughs sunglasses tho shay 😂👌 love you guys !!!!
That lady cheering on Gavin's dancing was awesome !! Love her lol
My mom got that same mug for Mothers Day!
That tip thing was so cool!! Every restaurant needs that! It takes them forever to bring the check back!
Am I the only one who thought that rocktard had a women's pad on his forehead?
No
LOL
Nope xD
Maybe....
Yeah I thought so too 😂
I friggin' love the Shaytards, haha. I've been so busy. It's time to catch up on the vlogs for real this time. I wanna get to the Idaho vlogs already. I can't skip tho. No skipping allowed.
your kids are good helpers
Look at Shay's sunglasses😂 love u guys💗
what is the backpack that Colette always has on when you guys go somewhere
Am I the only one who thought that rocktard got a pad unsticked the paper and put it on his fordhead?
Yes!!!!!
Me tooooooooooooo :)
Me to hahaha
+maria youdon'tneedmylastname I Thought that ;D
yh same
anyone notice that brock has his shirt on backwards?