My view is Noel had already grown tired being part of a band. Until 2009 he had already done plenty of giggin' under the name"Noel Gallagher" and not "Oasis" + All 00's he had told us he'd like to make a solo album. The brothers had had a rift since mid90's it so there's no point over-psychologizing their relationship when it comes to the night of the split up. Noel didn't stop liking Liam that night or the other way round, they had already stopped way before. Noel left cos he wanted to leave, late summer 2009 Liam's admittedly aggressive behaviour at one point gave Noel the excuse and the courage to finally actualize it. It's a shame they wouldn't finish the tour though. Well.. Noel gained the publicity he needed so he could play the victim and start again admittedly successful solo career, especially at the very beginning when he sold almost a million records which is very good considering it was 2011. True victims were the fans who were already there, had put their money on seeing Oasis and were let down, some might've travelled from far away to Paris that day.
Well it’s been a few years and they both have aged as well so it still might happen. If they had taken a couple of years off and then gotten back together it would have been helpful.
They are both as bad as each other, fair enough if you arent friends but your brothers, your both stuck with each other, you dont have to be best friends or even reform the band but what you need to reform is ar least a civil relationship with your brother because the day will come when one of you will die and the living one will be filled with regret
Liam is missing the point of why Noel was travelling separately from the band & why he wanted to leave. He’d put up with so much nonsense and he was always the one who had to front up & explain Liams behaviour for years. When it comes down to it Noel had just had enough and couldn’t cope with it anymore. ✌️👍✌️
I feel really bad about this. Loved their music and heard of breakup years ago....and didn't think too much of it except it was unfortunate back then. Now we are all in our 40s and it makes me extremely sad. Old enough with gray hair yet young enough to still do great things in music. But what I see is a younger brother who actually misses his big brother. The older brother is being the older brother who's doing the big brother dismissive thing. Liam won't call because he's being the obstinate little brother and Noel is being the obstinate big brother. Both need to let it go. I say Noel, as the bigger brother, should make that effort. His brother definitely is showing to me that he needs that big brother by his side.
It’s easier for Noel to be the chief in NGHFB and he’s doing a damn fine job of it. In an Oasis reunion, Liam has an equal shout in his mind of having his say and it won’t work. Rather hear Liam team up with Squire and put a band together with him even if it’s only for an album and a tour over a year or two.
I have a sister 18 months older and we cannot come together. Here's how it goes... One is a selfish, big-headed, difficult buffoon 25% of the time but can't own up to it, or apologize to anyone. The other, after YEARS has had enough, has moved on, and is never going to kneel or accept being spineless any longer. Both are stubborn, but one is more justified.
Ma basta sembra che Noel sia un Santo,anche lui ha le sue colpe,come infatti sono andati via anche altra parte della band,Liam avrà fatto delle cavolate,ma adesso e cambiato e maturo ha capito gli errori che ha fatto ma anche Noel non e da meno,mi e capitato di vedere alcuni video dei litigi,era solito Noel riprendere Liam mentre sta cantando,certe cose e meglio discuterne in privato e non platealmente mettendo in ridicolo Liam,quindi anche lui ha le sue colpe, Noel non ha soccorso Liam nel momento più drammatico della sua vita era completamente sprofondato,ed in aiuto non e corso lui ma il fratello Paul e l'amico Bonehead,,tra l'altro Noel non ha rapporti nemmeno con l'altro fratello,quindi questo per me la dice lunga sul caratterino di Noel😄
Who gives a damn as long as these scalley whoppers split im happy. Overated... a few songs sounded good in the short term. 1 song by noel is awesome, half a world away ... Cant believe he argues with his toe nails. Daft gets lol
I always saw oasis as the greatest victory for the working classes since the Sex Pistols. They had swagger and attitude, a fair few decent tunes, and were decent love back in the day. They gave kids back then, myself included, a reason to dream. If they could do it, so could we. And that was priceless
@@MusicMatters_SC Why do you say both have written plenty of rock stuff in their solo careers, when that's not the case? Liam and his co-writers made some tunes but what's dominant is soft pop with strong melody.
Oasis overated ? I don't think so , there are loads of bands and artists who are overrated, and oasis aren't one of them , they sold millions of records , made songs that will stand the test of time and are still there in the background, and aren't even together, people still want it ,every album noel does is a masterpiece apart from one ,who built the moon but we're a few tunes on it , I think noel don't give a fuck to be fair if they got back together when he looks at his bank balance, he still doing it now he don't need oasis , but I love Liam as much and he is doing well sold out knebworth for two nights as a solo artist , not many bands about today could do that ,I can't think of one new band who as been about a few years who could do it, don't forget oasis had only been around 3 years when they did knebworth well 2 years really , that's unbelievable so , oasis overrated? I don't think so!!!
@@lorraineplatt7535 ya cant legislate for taste i spose. I cant stand his whiney voice and lyrics arent the best in my opinion. Selling millions records proves nothing. Radio stations are payed to play certain songs by Record labels. Some awesome music gets zero no exposure . Worth seeking out awesome bands rather than getting fed music. I miss the legend John peel who championed tons of real bands like The Fall . I do like some oasis guitar riffs. Enjoy , whatever floats your boat .
@@MusicMatters_SC thanks.i wouldnt mind firing a few bullets lol. Bands can be like boxers and fame kills em. Standing the test of time is key for me early bowie, dylan nick drake.justin townes earle prob more talented than both eyebrow brothers.The fall for me kept it real an stayed skint.Joy division still sound awesome despite being basic . Such soul in ians lyrics. Missing John Peel
5:00 With ambition like that, no wonder nothing is happening or improving on the reunion front. I know Liam loves to talk and sing but if he's not gonna take the musicianship seriously then... selling an image is all he's good for then. He never does anything. Nor does he want to be accountable for anything. He's like a woman.
Are you a fan of Liam or Noel ? Liam has been working singing John Squires songs, they made a great album together and working on a second one. Noel said he didn’t want to be part of the DM tour with Liam he doesn’t want to be in a band touring anymore we can’t blame him for that. I’m just happy Liam is still touring
![Oasis - 'Definitely Maybe' - Noel Gallagher In Conversation With John Robb [Full Interview]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JZKmihCrp8I/mqdefault.jpg)
Who fired the first shots? Liam, Noel, both? Reunion? Yes? No? So many questions!
My view is Noel had already grown tired being part of a band.
Until 2009 he had already done plenty of giggin' under the name"Noel Gallagher" and not "Oasis" + All 00's he had told us he'd like to make a solo album.
The brothers had had a rift since mid90's it so there's no point over-psychologizing their relationship when it comes to the night of the split up. Noel didn't stop liking Liam that night or the other way round, they had already stopped way before.
Noel left cos he wanted to leave, late summer 2009 Liam's admittedly aggressive behaviour at one point gave Noel the excuse and the courage to finally actualize it.
It's a shame they wouldn't finish the tour though.
Well.. Noel gained the publicity he needed so he could play the victim and start again admittedly successful solo career, especially at the very beginning when he sold almost a million records which is very good considering it was 2011.
True victims were the fans who were already there, had put their money on seeing Oasis and were let down, some might've travelled from far away to Paris that day.
A very solid way of looking at it. I agree without a doubt the real victims were the fans in Paris.
Well it’s been a few years and they both have aged as well so it still might happen. If they had taken a couple of years off and then gotten back together it would have been helpful.
I am amazed you lasted so long
Have not heard oasis since 1998, and was amazed you lasted well into next century
Its gone, so leave it alone
And a month later there's money... they found enough money...
They are both as bad as each other, fair enough if you arent friends but your brothers, your both stuck with each other, you dont have to be best friends or even reform the band but what you need to reform is ar least a civil relationship with your brother because the day will come when one of you will die and the living one will be filled with regret
Liam is missing the point of why Noel was travelling separately from the band & why he wanted to leave. He’d put up with so much nonsense and he was always the one who had to front up & explain Liams behaviour for years. When it comes down to it Noel had just had enough and couldn’t cope with it anymore. ✌️👍✌️
I feel really bad about this. Loved their music and heard of breakup years ago....and didn't think too much of it except it was unfortunate back then. Now we are all in our 40s and it makes me extremely sad. Old enough with gray hair yet young enough to still do great things in music. But what I see is a younger brother who actually misses his big brother. The older brother is being the older brother who's doing the big brother dismissive thing. Liam won't call because he's being the obstinate little brother and Noel is being the obstinate big brother. Both need to let it go. I say Noel, as the bigger brother, should make that effort. His brother definitely is showing to me that he needs that big brother by his side.
It’s easier for Noel to be the chief in NGHFB and he’s doing a damn fine job of it. In an Oasis reunion, Liam has an equal shout in his mind of having his say and it won’t work. Rather hear Liam team up with Squire and put a band together with him even if it’s only for an album and a tour over a year or two.
You speak a lot of sense. Liam & Squire would be epic 👌🏼
@@MusicMatters_SC they indeed are hahaha
@@Marcuscachia my comments section literally predicted the future 😂 I’m proud of us. Keep it up guys 👍🏼
So why won't it work with Noel but it works with John?
@@MoonwalkerWorshiper hopefully it would work with Noel sometime in the future
Tbh Oasis already split up once Guigsy and Bonehead left. That was the real end of the band.
Yeah I kinda agree with that. Sound was never the same since. Imagine a reunion with the OG lineup. What a treat.
@@MusicMatters_SC plus Bonehead was really the soul of that band and it speaks volumes he continues to tour with Liam to this day.
Lol. Sure, buddy. We couldn't live without Tony McCarroll's masterful performances...
@@AkiraFelix-k2l exactly. Tony was brilliant for Oasis. The secret ingredient to their live sound.
Couldn’t agree more.
Team Noel.
I have a sister 18 months older and we cannot come together. Here's how it goes... One is a selfish, big-headed, difficult buffoon 25% of the time but can't own up to it, or apologize to anyone. The other, after YEARS has had enough, has moved on, and is never going to kneel or accept being spineless any longer. Both are stubborn, but one is more justified.
Ma basta sembra che Noel sia un Santo,anche lui ha le sue colpe,come infatti sono andati via anche altra parte della band,Liam avrà fatto delle cavolate,ma adesso e cambiato e maturo ha capito gli errori che ha fatto ma anche Noel non e da meno,mi e capitato di vedere alcuni video dei litigi,era solito Noel riprendere Liam mentre sta cantando,certe cose e meglio discuterne in privato e non platealmente mettendo in ridicolo Liam,quindi anche lui ha le sue colpe, Noel non ha soccorso Liam nel momento più drammatico della sua vita era completamente sprofondato,ed in aiuto non e corso lui ma il fratello Paul e l'amico Bonehead,,tra l'altro Noel non ha rapporti nemmeno con l'altro fratello,quindi questo per me la dice lunga sul caratterino di Noel😄
Liam is much more mature than Noel these days. He's grown as a human being so much. Noel is just plain old Noel.
You may well be right
Right and you know these guys on a personal level because you're buddies with them.
Get lost.
@@MoonwalkerWorshiper Noel is my cat’s Godparent
@@MusicMatters_SC The irony of your username. You don't care about music, it's all personal BS and delusional myths on the internet.
@@MoonwalkerWorshiper now now, temper temper 😘
Who gives a damn as long as these scalley whoppers split im happy. Overated... a few songs sounded good in the short term. 1 song by noel is awesome, half a world away ... Cant believe he argues with his toe nails. Daft gets lol
To be fair he might have some very insightful toenails, we can’t know for sure. Half the world away is a tune though for sure 👌🏼
Steve Earles lad justin was pretty talented. Great songwriter and guitarist. His song Slippin and slidin summed him up. Like his dad a rebel rouser.
I always saw oasis as the greatest victory for the working classes since the Sex Pistols. They had swagger and attitude, a fair few decent tunes, and were decent love back in the day. They gave kids back then, myself included, a reason to dream. If they could do it, so could we. And that was priceless
@@tandoodleys5252 well said
They split the band because neither of them are interested in doing rock music, and Oasis was a rock band.
Why do you say neither wanted to do rock music? Both have written plenty of rock stuff in their solo careers
@@MusicMatters_SC Why do you say both have written plenty of rock stuff in their solo careers, when that's not the case? Liam and his co-writers made some tunes but what's dominant is soft pop with strong melody.
Agreed when the band split Liam isn’t a natural rock songwriter Noel could still do it if he wanted
@@user-oh7iv3ij5x Can and want is linked. If Noel doesn't want to rock, he can't.
Overated oasis. Nothin highbrow about the eyebrow brothers......
Oasis overated ? I don't think so , there are loads of bands and artists who are overrated, and oasis aren't one of them , they sold millions of records , made songs that will stand the test of time and are still there in the background, and aren't even together, people still want it ,every album noel does is a masterpiece apart from one ,who built the moon but we're a few tunes on it , I think noel don't give a fuck to be fair if they got back together when he looks at his bank balance, he still doing it now he don't need oasis , but I love Liam as much and he is doing well sold out knebworth for two nights as a solo artist , not many bands about today could do that ,I can't think of one new band who as been about a few years who could do it, don't forget oasis had only been around 3 years when they did knebworth well 2 years really , that's unbelievable so , oasis overrated? I don't think so!!!
Well said 👏
😂
@@lorraineplatt7535 ya cant legislate for taste i spose. I cant stand his whiney voice and lyrics arent the best in my opinion. Selling millions records proves nothing. Radio stations are payed to play certain songs by Record labels. Some awesome music gets zero no exposure . Worth seeking out awesome bands rather than getting fed music. I miss the legend John peel who championed tons of real bands like The Fall . I do like some oasis guitar riffs. Enjoy , whatever floats your boat .
@@MusicMatters_SC thanks.i wouldnt mind firing a few bullets lol. Bands can be like boxers and fame kills em. Standing the test of time is key for me early bowie, dylan nick drake.justin townes earle prob more talented than both eyebrow brothers.The fall for me kept it real an stayed skint.Joy division still sound awesome despite being basic . Such soul in ians lyrics. Missing John Peel
5:00 With ambition like that, no wonder nothing is happening or improving on the reunion front. I know Liam loves to talk and sing but if he's not gonna take the musicianship seriously then... selling an image is all he's good for then. He never does anything. Nor does he want to be accountable for anything. He's like a woman.
😂
Are you a fan of Liam or Noel ? Liam has been working singing John Squires songs, they made a great album together and working on a second one.
Noel said he didn’t want to be part of the DM tour with Liam he doesn’t want to be in a band touring anymore we can’t blame him for that. I’m just happy Liam is still touring
@@user-oh7iv3ij5x When did Noel say he didn't want to tour DM?