'If She Wants To Spend, Let Her Earn': Wife Demands ₹6,16,300/month From Husband, Judge Raps Lawyer
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 29 ม.ค. 2025
- The judge at the Karnataka HC questioned a lawyer about his female client's demand for Rs 6,16,300 per month as alimony from her husband. The judge was surprised by the amount requested. The woman's lawyer defended the demand, listing the various expenses his client claimed she needed the money for.
#KarnatakaHighCourt #HusbandWifeDispute #Lawyer #Divorce #KarnatakaHC #Alimony #Judge #Judiciary #HWNews #Legal #HighCourt #Court #Advocate #IndianLaw #Argument #Law #JusticeAshutoshkumar
To get the latest news updates at your fingertips, download the HW News Shorts app: onelink.to/85hk86
Support independent journalism by subscribing to HW News English Premium Newsletter: hwnews.in/subs...
To Join TH-cam Membership - / @hwnewsenglish
SUBSCRIBE to HW News English Here ► bit.ly/Subscrib...
Connect With Us On:
→ Facebook: / hwnewsenglish
→ Twitter: / hwnewsenglish
→ Instagram: / hwnewsenglish
→ Whatsapp: whatsapp.com/c...
→ Dailymotion : www.dailymotio...
For More Videos Visit Here:
hwnews.in/
Atul Needed A Judge Like Her
in 2007 my amma appa got divorced .2020 now they living to gather.my grandparent rise me sins 4 month baby what should i do
@@rockycagePlease learn English or convey your message in Hindi
True bro..
That is why he wanted the case to be transferred to Karnataka court
@@rockycage what?
My first annual salary was 2.6 lakes per annum before tax. And the lady wants 6 lakes per month sitting at home. Wow!!! Greed was of highest order
This is a new business bro🤡
In this business "100% reservation and 100% seat reserved" for women only😁
0% investment with 100% profit😄
@@Mr_Patel_2126 a women filed 498 a case against her husband and her husband is seven in number😁 buisness
investment is boops and vagene😂@@Mr_Patel_2126
brother divorce is an industry now a days!
brother I'm a GP is not even earning this much in UK! and....
Excellent judge. She is a rare kind, the husband really is lucky that his alimony case was presided over by by this judge.
you can ditch women 👍
Appreciate the judges' senses..even the supreme court chief judges are nuts ....hats off to u madam
Most High Court judges use common sense but the so-called Supreme Court tries to prove its high position.
Grateful this is shown on the internet. Women who mooch on innocent and venerable men's money. The man is not always at fault. Thanks to the judicial system. Hope the couple amicably reconnect and live a happy life with their kids.
Usually they will ask for such a sum thinking it will settle at a lesser rate. The lawyer helps in that, this advocate must be bad at his job.
What about the dowry?! Before marriage men and their family demanding it from women's family.
@@june_binot here buddy,you live in dreams..stop playing victim card and face the reality that both predators and witches exist and good men and women should know it
@@june_bi its illegal,, either you're not aware or you're just a WhatsApp university topper
@@srijankrishnashivam765 not here means? Any other states in india? No demand dowry from women's family?
6.16 lakh is greed, cunning, scheming, crook, inhuman loot of the poor husband
Husband working hard to get that income. He isn’t getting this income just because he was married to this lady na. Yes , the wife might have had to sacrifice her career to keep the house in good shape so thats why she can claim a reasonable alimony from husband.
Or if there is a proof that the husband forced her to quit a supposed job that would have earned her 6+ lakh a month then produce that in court ! Produce some proof on why the lady deserves this much alimony to survive without any extra responsibility
Judge without even going into merits has said something n all the people started supporting ... She may have changed her view after reviewing the documents... Maintainence will awarded only when there is a valid reason for separation... When a relationship is gone, it's all about calculations nly(to speak in a logical sense as men)
Guy who is earning 8crs per annum nearly 70-75L per month is giving 80K to maintain his wife n came to court on increment of 10k?
Hard earned money is to take care of family... If you don't want to maintain your family, you may nt even marry anyone n bring that gal into so called family n leave her on rds... Family is nt only mom, dad, ur sis, ur bro it includes Wife also...
@@234harika sick minds feeding, scamming husband extorting money as a business.
@@234harika if it cannot he proved that husband forced the girl to give up a promising career then where is the logic for husband to support wife. Is she less qualified and cannot find job to pay for the lavish lifestyle? Who is raising the child , is it her ? These questions need to he considered. Husband is not some permanent source of income for a wife and same vice versa.
These kind of outrageous expectation will promote prenup agreements in india and i dont blame that. Its need of the hour
How many of us know here what kind of assault she went through?? If v dnt knw v don't have the right to name her character or any persons character ..
Greed, cunning, inhuman ??? People should cntrl themselves.. feels like all male maharajas r targeting a women without even knowing the background ...
Kudos to this Judge. The woman in the case should be told to earn and support her 6.16 Lakh life style.
This women is alive - so no case of murder
This women is educated - so she can get a job
This women stood again after a terrible experience n got a job - so she can earn for herself
So this means educated women r the easy catch... Where guy can marry, use her and leave her when he gets bored??? No punishment n no compensation
Looks like if Ambani leaves his wife when bored, she also should stay in a 1bhk and earn the necessities she needs ...
N bunch of male maharajas r supporting it without even knowing the whole picture
It's not men who gets bored it is always women who get bored Most of the divorce are due to women @@234harika
@@234harika coz the wealth belongs to men and they created it alone the wife can enjoy it as long as she stays
Upon leaving TATA Bye Bye you no longer deserve to be treated like a queen coz your king just left you
As simple as that.
@@alvinabraham1193 wow 👏👏👏
@@234harikathe judge has clearly used the word "reasonable" here. The lady has no responsibility of kids or fam...so its probably just her expenditure just for some luxury life. And from what was read none of the expenditure seem strong enough for her 6lac demand
This lawyer should get divorced and his wife should apply for 10 lakhs as penalty per month
😂😂
😂😂😂
This lady judge is the only beacon of light in matrimonial cases
May god give her long life and.we.wish t nsee her very.soom in supreme court
The amount is supposed to be divided between the woman and the advocate i think
All divorced wives always pay to their lawyer with money from husband's maintenance fee
Ya.may after that it might be like, AND THEY BITH LIVED HAPPILY EVER AFTER. I Really
6,16,000 per month??
Husband has to pay the loan that wife took?
😂😂😂
She must learn to earn money by working first only then she will understand money doesn't grow on trees
Thatswhy Atul Subhash wants to transfer his case to Bangalore thats a big slap to bihar court
I appreciate the decision of judge... excellent madam judge... god bless you..
2.55 Since when, Bangles, chain, earings, watches , sandle, sleeper became basic needs for which she want around 15k/month 😅😅😅
Her Expenses:
40,000 for food
clothes and dress: (10k per shirt)
15k accessories (like watch, shoe)
4-5 lakhs per month - medical expenses (just for knee pain)
If we have such honorable judges god 80 % false cases against men will dissapear
This woman has no integrity, and her lawyer is ridiculous...
brother he made his money its his job and rozi roti! gghorra ggaas se dosti karay ga to kkhaay ga kya!
@@asadahmed2195true
Marriage has become just a Cheap Business for many Women. Some Lawyers support this kind of business for Money..! This is not different than Sex Business
Very true
So let end this business by taking remain single one step will going to make huge changes in future..
Men are behaving like u lol
So it appears that even some judges are involved in the business
@@logicx9384you need not to be single . Just marry non indian
Its starts at 18:50 and ends at 19:10. Thank me later. Salute to this Hon. Judge. Judiciary must be like like this.
Slipper slap for the wife lawyer
Finally a judge with common sense.
The advocate needs sense!
Why should only a man pay alimony to a woman? Why shouldn't a woman pay? Whereas men and women are considered equal.
Being husband doesn't mean that he has taken a lifetime contract of another spouse for her and of kids maintenance.. this is a torture and mental pressure by the so callled called judicial system on a person..A maintenance should be allowed only in the exceptional cases and that too on merits.. immediate need to revoke this nonsense law
Fantastic performance by judgement by judge 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
I bow before the Hon. Judge, One would think being a lady she would be biased however she is fair and understands that having a metrimonial dispute is not a punishment to the husband, It is absurd that someone can even ask for such crazy amount as maintenance.
Every Judge should see this video
good human
Literally she coughed after looking that monthly expenses 6L 😂
3 lakhs for lawyer's wife and 3 lakhs for the wife 😂😂😂
And 16300 GST
4Lakh per month for yoga, knee pain and headache medical expenses 😅
Please tell me the name of this Angel in disguise...🔥🔥🔥
25% for Lawyers fee. Monthly 😂
To protect men in society this kind of judge is very important..
This is like going to a ceo meeting without any valid report and getting fired on the same day
Is the advocate in his senses?
Advocate is a pos scum vulture who recommended the lady to ask this huge amount in exchange of heft commission or payback
He is doing his work.
Even common person can understand, but how did he become advocate.
So the Husband is Probably making
₹12 Lakhs per Month. Dude belongs
to Top 1% Rich Category. 😂
0.0001% category
Nope he makes 8cr per month…that’s why she greedy
@@dataone100 Doesn't matter. He definitely didn't make that amount. His company might have made. Company money is NOT his money and he needs to re invest that money
Even then, why 6 lakhs.....Alimony is not aiyyashi
I don't understand when did bangles become basic need to survive😅
When wife takes care of children and is divorced then husband has to give maintenance, when husband is taking care of of children after divorce wife need not give maintenance? Instead husband is asked to give maintenance to wife? Why cant she work? Now physical effort is not required in most of the field, only mental ability is needed.
she is using all her mental abilities (if any) on taking money from ex!
This is robbing the husband of his money to the last penny.
Atul lost his life today 😢
In many cases, advocates misguide their clients. (I am an advocate myself)
Make prenuptial agreements legal in India. This is the only way.
300,000 for lawyer & 300,000 for wife. 16000 discount.
Appreciate this judge. Wish Atul Subhash had her as the judge, for him Justice is still not served.
Very good judge even being a lady the judge is very loyal to the law
in my observation women judges are very strict and realistic to women complaints!
thats why men should have women representative in law
Do you believe that there are feminists who support that lady who is seeking 6,16,000/month from that husband? What a society we are living in 🙏🏻
Per capita yearly income in India is Rs 2,30,000/- only.
I bet this male lawyer is now going to be shunned and will be banished from all communities and from his own friend's circle for his act.
This judge is a God for men. She has good values and is ethical . Hope every judge is like her. 🙏
This advocate is culprit here
Yes because of guys like him, Atul is died now
6,16,300/month Ye tho president se bhi Jada salary maang rahi hai 😃
Salute to the Judge. If this judge is in Atul Subhash case, Atul would have been with us today .
Let her earn, not beg.
Even in western world not many people spend 6 lakes a month .
She is an Ideal Judge I Wish all other Judges become like her and Maintain Equality & Justice in Deciding between Men & Women If the Dowry is not Fair before the Eyes of Law Then That Law must even Abolish the Alimony too & Maintain Equality & Justice and Restore Faith & Confidence into our System this is My Humble Request .
Very well said by judge
The same advocate who previously represented a man in a maintenance case, supporting his position, is now representing a woman in a different maintenance case, defending her side and challenging the man’s position. 😂😂😂
we should be thankful that he was not representing the same husband in previous hearing/ courts!😊
I don’t understand when gold and jewellery became basic need
Amazing judge being truthful to her position
Lawyers also to be punished for claiming such exorbitant amounts.
Alimony should only be if the women is married for 5 years minimum, have kids. I don’t understand the reason husband should pay wife is there are no kids involved
Mi lord mi lord, my client has knee pain but need money for heels 👠
Where are the feminist of India? Barkha Dutt please raise your voice, have a discussion on how you can do this to a innocent women, is she vindicated? does court not know cost of LV bags? this is not women empowerment, how can she live, this is blatant discriminative, malicious, dejective inappropriate + ridiculed subjective to objectification of women and mass distortion and in this state of degenerative discrepancies. Its here I like barkha dutt she will use all this words praise her motivate her and then ask the same question, hey lady are you not ashamed, but by praising her first.
Feminist association of India should do a counter file. earlier she use to spend 12 laks per month and because of which he insensible and cruel husband wanted a divorse, so even husband should be relaxed that she is just asking half of that? he also should be happy,
The judge is feminist..femisnist is one who thinks men and women are equal and she is giving correct judgement
😂😂
sarcasm😂
atlest her perfume would cost 50k she needs that much amount😊
Event Mukesh ambani wife vil no spend like this😂
In addition to lawyer, there could be others too in the share of alimony or maintenance. That is why lawyers advice their clients to demand more and more, so that the share of each stakeholders is large
Hats off to Judge, nonsense advocate...
Lawyers normally advise such ideas and receive a small portion from initial alimony. Some part of the judicial system operates based on pushing the limits.
She alone raised the value of judicial for all the mens
Thank you Honorable Judge. advocate gets some cut of money without hardworking and easy money from hand worked fathers.
I wonder why most of the women's are behind rich guys no matter what ever age group they are 😂
Yes
Alimony should get stopped
Let women earn
you should just replace "I" with "NO" 😊
What happened then ????
Salute salute to honourable judge sahiba🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
An foolish advocate
Cunning, scamming advocate
Modern relationships are materialistic. Marriage has become a business. Stay single stay happy stay wealthy. 🤣🤣🤣
This lawyer should face himself alimony 🙃🙃🙃
The argument of the judge is incredible but why its written schools instead of scholds?
Ma’am, you dropped your 👑. Please take this.
Marriage is damaging and one sided contract for men
Excellent judge and her judgement
Her lawyer should also face same issue. How easily he is demanding..His wife will also demand 6 Lakh per monthhh.
Respect to the judge💯💯
“High fever tension” 😂
Dont know where women will end up. Better this women who demanded 6,16,300/- open a alimony company and reachout to sharktank for funding. She will definitely become top women entrepreneur😂. This business is high in India and there is no shortage of such people😅.
The new business of empowered women after the Modiji's campaign of beti padhao beti bachao is getting married to a wealthy man have child with them and get divorced and loot their spouse on the name of alimony and be in India's 1% rich community .
2:55 basic needs 💀
These are basics needs 🤣🤣😎😎
Wah kya baat!
It's like halat badal gye jajbaat badal gye
What if the husband is unemployed? Will wife pay alimony to him?
Excellent explanation. This type of people enjoying their life by way of getting alimony.
The judge is really good..
Respect 🫡 to The Honourable Judge
When he said bangles and earrings are her basic needs….he ended the case for me. Last I checked air, water, food, clothes and common sense are basic needs. And, yes kudos to the judge.
When you have to live separately from your husband then why are you craving for his standard of living ? It is now none of your business what he eats what he wears... He will give alimony only for necessities not for completing your fantasies.
The trick was to ask for an unreasonable number so that court will grant a higher reasonable number.
But, kudos to the judge. She saw through the bullshit
Chase this lawyer out of court
Great🙌🙌🙌🙌👍👍👍
Government decides minimum wages and the same should be applied here as well…
Someone can’t expect random numbers just because him and is earning in crores…
actually it depends on various things, but that needs alot of investigation so our courts do like this!
This should be viral!!!
Already viral
Very good judgement justice
In the name of maintenance petitioner mislead and waste the valuable time of court.
like the accent, "excepta, herselfa, requirementa, montha, 😂
Marriage is soo scary😨😨