Taylor's voice is soft because the character in the situation has already accepted the breakup ,whereas Justin is using power because his character is still fighting for something that is already gone. At least that's how I view it.
Hes outsinging cause it's an argument in that part of song. An argument in which both of them are speaking but neither is ready to listen what the other one is speaking. And in this process Taylor's character is calm and this is not trying to over power. Whereas Justin's character is trying to over power.
He does have a more powerful voice imo but I love this interpretation of the dynamics and how the whole song is like a conversation. They really made it work!
remember, early taylor songs were she is the one screaming,being overdramatic while her partner was the calm one. this song shows contrast especially how taylor portrays a woman who can be calm amidst an argument
@@kathrinevanezasierra4312 she was afraid that Justin was gonna say no to a collab with her and she was fangirling so hard when he replied with the lines. It was so adorable.
I see this as them talking and being at different points in the break up. Taylor's character is already resigned, she accepted their relationship is over and she left. He was just left by her without expecting it and is upset. So he will be more emotional and she is just responding to him.
same thoughts, the reason why the Justin needs to overpower Taylor is how the song potrays, it's almost like how your dad overpowers your mom when they fight haha I mean it's always been that kind anyway a man always overpowers a woman when they fight so I think that's how exile works lol
Is it me or exile is way too underrated? It's a masterpiece when you look at the lyrics and how its executed. The 2 speak their feelings without understanding each other at the same time.
exile is the 2nd most streamed song on the album (only after cardigan), it was a fan favourite since its release, was featured on 2 tv shows and got a grammy nomination. plus the catchphrase "I think I've seen this film before" has become popular on tiktok in the last 20 months. I feel like everyone loves it, so we cannot argue with those who don't because there is no one to argue with about it.
I really didn’t like Taylor that much until now . I watched her Netflix movie and the Disney plus movie . I have a new appreciation for Taylor and definitely a fan .
She's defeated and already given up. He's finally realising he's lost something worth fighting for. I think thier voices here reflect that situation beautifully.
She just not only left him but immediately replaced him and left him facing his replacement. She didn't just give up, she discarded him like he was nothing. He didn't just realize, he knew.
@@stevenverner6546 he didnt see the signs that the relationship wasnt working, she think she left enough hints and left finally, only for him to to almost lash out when the confrontation happens. she's calmer because she chose to end it and has had more time to process it and isnt fighting for it.
no every1 say thank u tay , what is wrong with u people they r all literally disregarding tays talent and prasing joe tf like ok he wrote a part of it but no its mostly tays work the whole album
@@lifeee505 it's a joke, obviously taylor is amazing and we adore her. We just found it funny that Joe (an actor who has no business in music) actually wrote some of the favorite sings in the album. No one actually thinks he's a better writer than taylor, please
@@lifeee505 dang chill, joe wrote a lot of the song sang it to him wrote the piano helped with it, he even wrote the whole Betty song wing her. We are not disregarding Taylor at all wtf- we always praise her are we not allowed to praise the other writer?
Justin Vernon's vocal range is just incredible. One of the best really. Taylor has always had such a pretty tone and as a fan I can tell how she's worked on her vocal over the years. She doesn't have the strongest voice (idk what the technical terms are) but feels she knows how to play to her strengths
I really like what you said about this song feeling like a conversation. That's how I feel listening to the whole album. It's almost as if Taylor is sitting down telling you all these stories and you can't help but sit back, enjoy and just get lost in her poetic storytelling. Great video as always Georgina!
She's left out the side door, seen him out, moved on with another man. While he's still watching her, "staring". Clearly, that's how the conversation goes in the song :)
Recommend some more songs with him similar to this - all the Bon Iver I’ve heard so far I’ve felt lacking - wrong songs maybe :/ I didn’t realise he did Rosalyn but even there his voice is so different.
@@jrowme9230 same here all his other stuff is falsetto and i hate it, if there were more with him singing the deep baritone i'd listen but i haven't come across any.
Taylor’s voice is just , sooooooo gorgeous , so soft , yet so powerful and emotional , I don’t understand how she even does this , my heart FEELS her voice
It’s so nice to hear Justin’s lower register here, since we are so familiar with his incredible falsetto. He has an amazing tone no matter what he sings and I’m a fan of anything he does. Very happy with this collaboration.
I don't understand why so many people seem to dislike this song by saying that their voices don't match. It reminds me of "The Last Time" that Taylor sang with "Gary Lightbody back in the "Red" era days, which happens to be one of my favorite songs of hers :) "Exile" is my favorite track from "Folklore" as well .)
I have listened to this song 30 40 50 times in a row everyday. I'm so mesmerized by the depth of their voices. Especially when they are talking to each other. You didn't give Me A sign. I gave so many signs
i think they're singing it in slightly different ways because they were recorded separately. I'm guessing Bon did his part after Taylor. If they were together in the same room, they likely would have played off each other and brought their level of intensity more in line with each other. Just my opinion.
i love this collab, i can easily tell the melody and songwriting is all Taylor but she made sound like a Bon Iver song and that gives much of the spotlight to Justin's voice. An amazing duet.
Georgina, your perception, the way your critical eye sees every nuance of the artists from the shape of their lips to the lilt of their voice is what makes you an honest vocal coach beyond compare. I watch you and you are singing it with them note for note and your eyes shine with it. You are a magic lady and that is all I have to say and I say it with all honesty and with a full heart x
Was never a big Taylor fan but this year I listened to folklore and then her older stuff and she is actually very good, she has a new fan. Prefer her to lady gaga & other female artists. each to their own, preference of taste. Love this song.
OMG... this film is PERFECT...I need you reacting to each song of this ♥ PLEASE... Taylor singing these tracks live are just beyond the amazing sound of the album
Exile is my favorite song from Folklore. It literally moves me to tears everytime I hear it. And the chills here - SO STEP RIGHT OUT, THERE IS NO AMOUNT...
I agree bon iver's voice is beautiful jaw dropping. I love a deep singing voice with range. My only compliment is he miss is queue on "So step right out" it was a little awkward there because he had to rush it to catch back up. But this is one of my favorite songs on the album.
Think its so good because its almost like two people in an argument and he's getting all stressed and angry and speaking over her and she's staying calm in the way she's talking, sounds like a real discussion between two ex lovers
omg i love her reaction soooo much! i enjoyed seeing her enjoying it cause if she enjoyed it being a genius of the matter that means i am doing right enjoying it like i do 💖💖🙇🏻♀️
This reminds me of the last time, where he kind of is angry or trying to keep on going and she gave up. Like that last verse in the last time where hes begging her to give him the last chance, but she says thats the ladt time
Taylor's voice is soft because the character in the situation has already accepted the breakup ,whereas Justin is using power because his character is still fighting for something that is already gone. At least that's how I view it.
I like that way of thinking about it
Agreed. They're at 2 different places in the grieving process.
Yess agreed
Love it😍 now makes so much sense
I love the lyrics and their collaboration is perfection. It brings tears to my eyes every time I hear it.
Fun fact: Taylor's boyfriend wrote the piano arrangement and the first verse!
Justin did too.
we believe in Jaylor supremacy
@@astridvvv9662 Justin wrote the bridge
We stan Joe Alwyn
As I recall, Justin made a couple of minor changes to the first verse and wrote the bridge.
Hes outsinging cause it's an argument in that part of song. An argument in which both of them are speaking but neither is ready to listen what the other one is speaking. And in this process Taylor's character is calm and this is not trying to over power. Whereas Justin's character is trying to over power.
He does have a more powerful voice imo but I love this interpretation of the dynamics and how the whole song is like a conversation. They really made it work!
YES 😲
remember, early taylor songs were she is the one screaming,being overdramatic while her partner was the calm one. this song shows contrast especially how taylor portrays a woman who can be calm amidst an argument
Ahhhh😲
@@kathrinevanezasierra4312 she was afraid that Justin was gonna say no to a collab with her and she was fangirling so hard when he replied with the lines. It was so adorable.
Taylor’s always had a sweet tone but wow, she sounds amazing.
Aren't you forgetting about Bon Iver
@@YoshMonsterGaming both are😍😘
@@YoshMonsterGaming Are you forgetting that it's THEIR comment and they can compliment whoever they want to?
I agree. This proves singing isn't all about hitting high notes to be a good singer. You can still have a soothing tone to your voice like Taylor has.
I see this as them talking and being at different points in the break up. Taylor's character is already resigned, she accepted their relationship is over and she left. He was just left by her without expecting it and is upset. So he will be more emotional and she is just responding to him.
Accurate! :)
same thoughts, the reason why the Justin needs to overpower Taylor is how the song potrays, it's almost like how your dad overpowers your mom when they fight haha I mean it's always been that kind anyway a man always overpowers a woman when they fight so I think that's how exile works lol
I agree. However, she hasn't just left him, she's moved on. He hasn't because she blind sided him.
Is it me or exile is way too underrated? It's a masterpiece when you look at the lyrics and how its executed. The 2 speak their feelings without understanding each other at the same time.
exile is the 2nd most streamed song on the album (only after cardigan), it was a fan favourite since its release, was featured on 2 tv shows and got a grammy nomination. plus the catchphrase "I think I've seen this film before" has become popular on tiktok in the last 20 months.
I feel like everyone loves it, so we cannot argue with those who don't because there is no one to argue with about it.
The best part is exile is the most streamed non single by Taylor 🥰😍
@@DiamondStarMm2 Exile was actually released as a single in August 2020. The only thing is that it doesn't have a music video.
Gurl, it's not underrated
I am in love with the song!
Let's pray for Taylor & folklore to win in the Grammys 😍
and Exile!
Yes! folklore will definitely win Album Of The Year at the Grammys on January 31, 2021!
Amen
Everyone vote!
You mean Taylor and Justin Vernon
I really didn’t like Taylor that much until now . I watched her Netflix movie and the Disney plus movie . I have a new appreciation for Taylor and definitely a fan .
Happy to know
which netflix film is it? the Reputation tour or her documentary?
We love a Folklore era swiftie
Welcome to the fandom :)
omg you're gonna make me cry tears of joy
She's defeated and already given up. He's finally realising he's lost something worth fighting for. I think thier voices here reflect that situation beautifully.
I try playing this and singing his part and I can’t get, “There is no amount of crying I can do for you” out without choking up. It’s way too real.
She just not only left him but immediately replaced him and left him facing his replacement. She didn't just give up, she discarded him like he was nothing. He didn't just realize, he knew.
@@stevenverner6546 he didnt see the signs that the relationship wasnt working, she think she left enough hints and left finally, only for him to to almost lash out when the confrontation happens. she's calmer because she chose to end it and has had more time to process it and isnt fighting for it.
Everyone say 'Thank you Joe' 😌
no every1 say thank u tay , what is wrong with u people they r all literally disregarding tays talent and prasing joe tf like ok he wrote a part of it but no its mostly tays work the whole album
Thank you Tay and also thanks Joe for helping. Can't forget Taylor who worked the most.
@@lifeee505 it's a joke, obviously taylor is amazing and we adore her. We just found it funny that Joe (an actor who has no business in music) actually wrote some of the favorite sings in the album. No one actually thinks he's a better writer than taylor, please
I literally would be so offended if I was Taylor or Justin and everyone is only talking about Joe now
@@lifeee505 dang chill, joe wrote a lot of the song sang it to him wrote the piano helped with it, he even wrote the whole Betty song wing her. We are not disregarding Taylor at all wtf- we always praise her are we not allowed to praise the other writer?
Justin Vernon's vocal range is just incredible. One of the best really. Taylor has always had such a pretty tone and as a fan I can tell how she's worked on her vocal over the years. She doesn't have the strongest voice (idk what the technical terms are) but feels she knows how to play to her strengths
Agreed, it’s like she’s discovered what it is that makes her voice special and has really started playing to her strengths!
@@km692 I am looking forward to the re-records for this reason!
Well said! Her voice has definitely improved. I can't wait to hear her old songs with her newer, more mature voice.
She has a pretty powerful voice, actually. Watch any of her performances from the 1989 and Reputation Tours. She's amazing.
Folklore is just album of the year , exile is just the best song of this year
My Tears Ricochet is a better song.
The outsinging was on purpose.
Same concept was also used in last time, her song with Gary lightbody.
That song doesn’t get enough credit! One of my favorites
This song is really a masterpiece
If they don't win best duo/group at the Grammys
I don't see the point of giving it to another artists
This aged well
I really like what you said about this song feeling like a conversation. That's how I feel listening to the whole album. It's almost as if Taylor is sitting down telling you all these stories and you can't help but sit back, enjoy and just get lost in her poetic storytelling. Great video as always Georgina!
She's left out the side door, seen him out, moved on with another man. While he's still watching her, "staring". Clearly, that's how the conversation goes in the song :)
Justin's voice has always captured my heart. I'm attracted to low/deep tones
me too x
Recommend some more songs with him similar to this - all the Bon Iver I’ve heard so far I’ve felt lacking - wrong songs maybe :/ I didn’t realise he did Rosalyn but even there his voice is so different.
@@jrowme9230 same here all his other stuff is falsetto and i hate it, if there were more with him singing the deep baritone i'd listen but i haven't come across any.
Exile should win best duo in Grammy's
The blue jumper brings out the lovely colour of your eyes
Taylor’s voice is just , sooooooo gorgeous , so soft , yet so powerful and emotional , I don’t understand how she even does this , my heart FEELS her voice
"He's kinda shining through here." Yep, he's Justin Vernon. That's what he does.
It's like Bon is the bass, and Taylor is the treble. Perfectly fit.
Bon Iver is the name of the band...dude's name is Justin Vernon
So I'm a 66 year old man and this version brings tears to my eyes everytime I listen to it.
Georgina just fell inlove with Bon Iver 😭
I did x
It’s so nice to hear Justin’s lower register here, since we are so familiar with his incredible falsetto. He has an amazing tone no matter what he sings and I’m a fan of anything he does. Very happy with this collaboration.
georgina and ajay competing over justin vernon and his deep voice
oh yeah!
Exile will win on Top pop duo group performance at the Grammys 2021 ❤️
I think rain on me will win that🧐 both songs deserves that.
@@pablosago1779 Nope, exile Will win
@@pablosago1779 I hope exile wins it because it is more deserving but it's Grammys, so we don't know what's gonna happen, LOL.
Yes! Preach!!!
@@pablosago1779 exile will win! Compare to ROM, exile is superior!
She seems in love with Justin's voice. I understand.
I don't understand why so many people seem to dislike this song by saying that their voices don't match. It reminds me of "The Last Time" that Taylor sang with "Gary Lightbody back in the "Red" era days, which happens to be one of my favorite songs of hers :) "Exile" is my favorite track from "Folklore" as well .)
Aye don't pay attention to the petty nonsense. We all know that this one will become a timeless masterpiece forever. Shake it off!!
Who says that though? I’ve never seen a negative comment about it...
Everytime Bon Iver sings my heart melts a little bit
I really believe that exile deserves the grammy for song by a duo/group the most its a quality song
Two of the greatest songwriters of this generation, and their voices are peanut butter and jelly. I hope they do more together.
Loved your reaction. Completely agree. They’re the perfect voice couple to execute intimate musical concepts.
Massive thanks to Georgina, your the bestt😘
Hey you are beautiful
@@gabrielg4618 You are beautiful 🥺
Ur song is a bop
I have listened to this song 30 40 50 times in a row everyday. I'm so mesmerized by the depth of their voices. Especially when they are talking to each other. You didn't give Me A sign. I gave so many signs
This version is so pure and raw🥺❤️
Whenever I listen to exile 500 days of summur always come in my mind and both are masterpiece.
The FOLKLORE a!bum is a masterpiece!!!
i think they're singing it in slightly different ways because they were recorded separately. I'm guessing Bon did his part after Taylor. If they were together in the same room, they likely would have played off each other and brought their level of intensity more in line with each other. Just my opinion.
Well, they could’ve mixed him down, but they didn’t. On purpose.
i love this collab, i can easily tell the melody and songwriting is all Taylor but she made sound like a Bon Iver song and that gives much of the spotlight to Justin's voice. An amazing duet.
I would so love to witness this song live. Post covid of course
I'd like to see it during it
If you've become a fan of Bon Iver you need to react to his self-titled album...
Georgina, your perception, the way your critical eye sees every nuance of the artists from the shape of their lips to the lilt of their voice is what makes you an honest vocal coach beyond compare. I watch you and you are singing it with them note for note and your eyes shine with it. You are a magic lady and that is all I have to say and I say it with all honesty and with a full heart x
Not related but your hair looks so nice Georgina! 😊
The harmony in this song is just incredible.
She gonna win best pop vocal album at grammy 2021 for sure...
She's gonna win Album Of The Year for folklore too!
@@ajsc11 and she did
His voice is amazing. I was an instant fan the moment I heard this.
Was never a big Taylor fan but this year I listened to folklore and then her older stuff and she is actually very good, she has a new fan. Prefer her to lady gaga & other female artists. each to their own, preference of taste. Love this song.
OMG... this film is PERFECT...I need you reacting to each song of this ♥ PLEASE... Taylor singing these tracks live are just beyond the amazing sound of the album
Thanks for reacting to Taylor's album😘🤗🤗🤗
Seeing your reaction just gets me....this song is so emotional
and thats why FOLKLORE is so beautiful
Yeeeep bon iver makes it the best!
I agree
Both albums are just stellar she is SUCH an amazing songwriter ❤️
This is my favorite on the Folklore album. It is a.masterpiece. It is brilliant. Love this version even better!
it would be cool to see your reaction to the rest of the disney plus special- especially the This Is Me Trying performance and explanation
I wish I had vocals like Taylor swift but all of us are different and I am proud of her and I can't wait for midnights album to drop
I'm obsessed with this song, it's so beautiful 🥰
Exile is my favorite song from Folklore. It literally moves me to tears everytime I hear it.
And the chills here - SO STEP RIGHT OUT, THERE IS NO AMOUNT...
Justin doesn’t show his face in photos or videos anymore , his voice is gorgeous isn’t it ❤️
I agree bon iver's voice is beautiful jaw dropping. I love a deep singing voice with range. My only compliment is he miss is queue on "So step right out" it was a little awkward there because he had to rush it to catch back up. But this is one of my favorite songs on the album.
I wish Justin use his deep tone more often
Do you think that exile deserves to win a grammy?
it's Justin's bridge that is the star here. the whole thing is good. that bridge is something else again.
Me getting literal goosebumps even after listening for the twentieth time
hey you're a sri lankan swiftie?
Georgina you are so right. So real and beautiful.
I think "Folklore" is the best Album ❤️
Well, he’s Justin Vernon I think he’d outsind most artists. Such a unique voice.
"I can see you crying honey"
Love this song. It’s so exquisite!!
Wow this performance
Think its so good because its almost like two people in an argument and he's getting all stressed and angry and speaking over her and she's staying calm in the way she's talking, sounds like a real discussion between two ex lovers
They better win Best Pop Duo Performance in Grammys!
Yes they will win!
I really liked this analysis, was really interesting. Thank you Georgina 💗
Thank you teacher georg! I can really tell that you're a great vocal teacher, teach me sometime 💖
Love that you’re promoting unknown artists!
I love you so much and you inspire me! Thank you for reacting to one of my idols Taylor Swift ❤️
Thanks for this reaction! I was hoping you would do this! Love you !!
This was really beautiful, I also liked the cover by Kodiak Avenue x
This song is beautiful and quite underrated.
Hardly!
Thanks for this react! Good luck with your work here :)) Greetings from Bulgaria
Taylor never gets out song. Taylor is still great!
his vocals werebetter in this x
Thank you Georgina , please react to all of it , Taylor has some other songs performed with more notes 💛
Bon Iver is pronounced bone-ee-vair.
It is French 😀
Fanboying with you so damn hard on this one! Words can't describe how much I enjoyed it... :)
his voice sends me!
@@HonestVocalCoach Omg can't believe you replied to my comment! You made my day ❤
Just give them the Grammy!! It is accomplished!!
Your reaction to this is ❤❤
Just complimenting Each other voice 😭❤️
LOVE THIS ROLLNECK! and as always, amazing vid. Absolutely my fav album this year xxx
thank you for this omg! appreciate your reaction! 💕
No problem!!
Definitely my favorite song from the album🤍
You have such beautiful eyes and a calming voice
I fell in love with this song again!
THANK YOU FOR THAT QUEEN 💗💗
This is my favorite Folklore song
I love your reaction video 🥰
this song is so beautiful
I'm watching exile video,just like you!! smilling sudenly from beginning until the end of performance😊
I love this so so so much omg
omg i love her reaction soooo much! i enjoyed seeing her enjoying it cause if she enjoyed it being a genius of the matter that means i am doing right enjoying it like i do 💖💖🙇🏻♀️
Thanks for this Georgina! This is beautiful
This reminds me of the last time, where he kind of is angry or trying to keep on going and she gave up. Like that last verse in the last time where hes begging her to give him the last chance, but she says thats the ladt time