Arthur McBride
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 20 ส.ค. 2024
- Manship Theatre - Feb. 14, 2019 - James Linden Hogg performed songs off of his College Fund Vol. 3. Special thanks to the Royal Navy Doctor and other re-enactors from the Battle of New Orleans 1812 for making memories with students of history.
Gorgeous voice!
This is an anti -war song
.The subjects are Irishmen and it demonstrates their contempt for British rule in their Country.
Lovely rendition!
Love his voice
A fine rendition to be sure but Paul Brady's 1977 version reigns supreme. No better version exists. Listeners will get a better bang for their buck if they can read the lyics as the song unfolds. Just brill !
There is a video of him performing it the day after his 70th birthday. In the same key and to me it sounds just as good.
Agreed , I go back to it regularly , playing phenomenal !
I agree with you. Solo versions can be found on TH-cam when he was younger, and later in his career. There is also a version where he sings with Planxty that is also memorable.
see Paul Brady 1977
Some version
I have been a fan of this song since Bob Dylan did a cover of it. This is the fist time seeing this beautiful version. Thankyou.
Dylan at his best, giving that energy and subtle, constant variation to the playing and singing. Makes the song sound like an old sailor looking back 😃
@@steinbauge4591 yeah Dylan's is a much more gritty and salty version, where this is polished and chior boy perfect perfect.
They were walking on the Irish coast surely!
Donegal probably.
Great version with the visuals !
I love his performance. I ALSO love the support of his mom and dad. (I surmise this here, because I don't know them at all, at all.) Just the same, the father is a dead giveaway, and the mother has an incredibly close resemblance to Mr. J.L. Hogg.) GREAT PERFORMANCE!!!
Thank you so much for the kind words!!!
Geez how did Bob Dylan miss this one
He didn't:he murdered it!!!
Nice version 👌, but where is the accordionist and the whistle/flute player? The re-enactment video is also a nice thoughtful touch. Thanks for posting!
If the likes of "Corporal or Sergeant or Captain or General" Arthur McBride
was in charge - 19 y.o. Private Willie McBride would have made it back alive.
So true!
I think that Arthur McBride Is set 100 years earlier than Willie McBride, in the Napoleonic wars rather than WW1
@@jimbrennan3953 agreed, but while technology, equipment, modes of transportation and uniforms certainly evolve certain other aspects of life in the armed forces does not change.
A great version almost as good as Paul Brady.Who are the singer and musicians?
Anti-war song.
Its more an anti recruiting song, more to do with not going to war for the wrong side for coin.
Best version is bob dylan
@El Merovingio if you listen to it couple of times you realize bob dylan is much better at the story telling.
It is painful to listen to
Bob D. Learned this song from Paul Brady. There is a clip on you tube where Paul explains this.