i think in a way she is, meaning that there's something deeply wrong with her, psychologically. but in the context of this case, sure, she ought to chill in jail for a while
Why he does the little smile when talking about uncomfortable, unsocial, embarrassing things is to lighten it for who's listening. It's part of his baseline, and partly due to growing up with an abusive parent. He does not want to be looked at as a complainer or whiner, he's an empath.
Why is she even allowed to eat??? This is serious stuff. Imagine going for a job interview and eating or doing your nails ??? Drinking water should be the only thing alllowed.
Having watched the trial to the end and hearing the verdict, and listening to body language experts, I started taking the experts seriously. It's not just tells. It's amazing how the body expresses itself. Seeing your video after the verdict really solidifies my opinion that you guys are the real deal because you called it. A year ago! You were right throughout the whole video.
Agreed. I didn't follow the trial and only started looking into it after the verdict, trying to figure out how they arrived at that decision. This body language expert called it, as did many others. And of course Heard was caught lying over and over again. Thank God the trial was televised so the whole world could see what that woman really is: an abuser, shameless liar and outright evil.
It is sad but true. I work under the mental health and social work umbrella and in my area there was once an instance where the man had visible blood on his face from a blow and blood droplets on the woman's sleeve and the police STILL automatically moved to arrest the man 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️ and of COURSE women are usually the ones victims of the domestic violence but lets NEVER rule out the possibility of the man being the victim based on gender alone! It's because of this small percentage of people that lie that other people have a more difficult time believing the people telling the truth.
This s so up!! As a woman who has great bf, cousins and brothers I hate the world we are coming from. All the radical feminists with their tits out yelling for their stripper rights!
There isn't a single person on yt that is on her side I think they see us as crazy fans, I'm not even a fan I just like his works, but it's obvious here that she is the culprit
@@sehunyehetfeatchanyeolchog4751 she hit her ex girlfriend and I bet she payed her off to speak highly of her. People saw it. Then both the ex and Amber said Amber was arrested bc the arresting officer was homophobic and misogynistic. The officer was a lesbian/activist. Like they can't even lie 😭
If you just look up ambers parents side with Johnny In text message you will fine a few articles on it some have different messages and one has ambers mum saying “i know I love you son” while Johnny was explaining that he didn’t do it @@upgoyxtirzruz
21:50 As someone who Identifies immensely with Johnny Depp, I can say that in my own life I frequently "smirk" when recalling uncomfortable topics, especially with other people. Especially traumatic things or things you'd rather not talk about. In my mind I see this moment as more of a "oh boy.. time for this story.." moment rather than a "dupers delight" moment.
I smile under stress and great pain because I’m not comfortable showing my real emotions of pain. Abusive parents who punished for showing emotions do that to you.
In relation to Johnny continuously pausing in his testimony, as someone with PTSD, whenever I've had to recount traumatic incidents in the past it has taken me absolute ages (and I have a problem with usually speaking too fast lol). It's like my brain shuts down every few seconds to avoid reliving the incident and I have to keep bringing myself back to the present and try and remember where I was in order to finish the story. Everything about Johnny's testimonies has felt relatable or familiar to me as a survivor of abuse and younger sibling to an opiate addict. Watching Amber Heard is like watching an alien make a mockery of those two experiences.
That's disassociation and you are completely correct in that your mind has closed the unprocessed memory off since it can't process it and doesn't want it to harm you further, and trying to get to it is trying to overcome your brains self defense. Maybe one day you can get a therapy type that can help the memories get processed. Much love
I know exactly. When you HAVE to talk about it to someone, but if you allowed yourself to remember it entirely, you would completely break down. Most people actually do this when they have to talk about difficult experiences. We detach ourselves from the experience, which makes it hard to recount it.
The way she struggled to get that snack out of the bag before she finished asking the question was just mind blowing to your suggestion of her using that as a stall tactic. It was very evident that was the case at that point. They should of grilled her on all this in both cases.
Notice how she reaches for her snacks, pauses and retracts her hand, then as SOON as she hears the date of the punch she dives in, I mean it could not be more obvious ✋🤣
I'm so annoyed about it. She is literally being asked a question and she's stuffing food into her mouth. She knows she needs to answer a question. Is it really the time to be stuffing her face?? There is just something so sneaky and un natural about it.
Yup. It is as if they both like to be sub and dom and was not able to understand when to take what role, and then it just went to the extreme. For what I read, they both are to blame. They both asked for it and they both wont take a blame. Like you cant have two doms in a relationship. It just goes to hell. Much like a relationship of two subs, are the perhaps most boring relationship.
Also another thing to note is whenever amber is “recalling” the story, the motions of her hands are not consistent with what she’s saying, so when she’s talking about getting hit she always does the actual hitting motion and so forth, but when Johnny recalls what happened, his motions and movements are consistent with what he’s saying. The vodka bottle being thrown at him is a great example. Justice for Johnny.
That’s because you can’t “act up” real life and not be found out! 😂😂😌 these snakes kinda people will always and forever bring themselves down, their own ways/actions will finish them off 😌
@@kapokikkodragneel1505 Not just that, the situation and magnitude of the conversation takes a big rol in it. Is not the same being in a set, with coworkers feeling comfy and secure, having some fun and doing what you most like having under control your emotions, that being out of your comfort zone, in a cold room having to answer uncomfortable questions from people you don't trust and knowing they are looking for any slightest mistake or inconsistency in what you say or do to make you pay for it.
this is the most unprofessional court hearing I have ever witnessed oh my god. what is this?! Her lawyer is so cringe - who gave this man his degree lmao
who the fuck puts candy in ones mouth while someone asks you a question and then you can't answer because you are chewing and in a hearing? like wtf. reasons: you are arrogant and don't respect the person you are talking to or the situation, you want to stall, you establish power over the other person
I have to agree with you there is no way I could eat and tell a courtroom full of people about abuse just thinking about things makes me feel sick and I certainly wouldn't be laughing at any point. She's such a lier 😤
Some parents are fucked though, so I don't think using what parents say as a sort of final clue or piece of evidence is good. Not saying she's not guilty but just saying that her parents stating that could simply be due to other reasons.
I was in an abusive relationship 10 years ago and to this day I can remember every single detail without hesitation! Amber is lying and manipulating to get her way. Disgusting!
I was for 15 years with a monster. I too remember every bad bashing. He once put boxing gloves on me, and headgear on himself. You can imagine what happened. He thought that was “fun” and because I have epilepsy, he would blame bruises on my seizures. Cruel man. I’m married to a bloody Angel now. God...the fear is still there. Merry Christmas to all. Let’s hope 2021 is less virus’y! 🎄
One correction: ppl with PTSD sometimes remember their trauma VIVIDLY, the strangest and seemingly smallest details are etched into our minds. This is the case with many of my experiences / flashbacks. It's not unusual to recall events in such detail.
You're right - I have very serious PTSD and my memories are so jumbled up. Some things are completely blank and some incredibly weird and random things are as clear as day. Sometimes when the brain is constantly alert for attack, it shuts down when the attack happens and focuses on something irirrelevant to protect itself. Unless you've experienced real trauma, it's hard to understand that. However, I dont believe this is the case for Amber when she's recalling the dirty carper or whatever. It feels to me that she's researched trauma and tried to mimick the behaviour, but she doesn't feel emotions the way most people do and therefore seems like a liar. She's trying TOO hard.
just meeting for the first time with my own therapist after an abusive marriage, I couldn't eat my lunch afterwards. I wasn't hungry until hours later at dinnertime, as I had lost my appetite from nerves and stress in discussing my situation with my own therapist ! To be in a legal deposition with such serious circumstances and to be snacking, is beyond my comprehension.
for real, I mean I've just started looking into this and I already see so much. Like in real legitimate evidence of one of their conversations she tells Johnny that running away and hiding behind a door makes her mad and is an act of a COWARD. But in here she's the one supposedly hiding behind the door? Excuse me miss do you have dementia?
It adds a level of validation And it's interesting imo I didnt believe her since day 1 and posted about it. Often . Actually even before their marriage fell apart I had seen her on a talk show and felt instantly alerted This particular body language analyzer is very balanced , thorough & insightful. imo.
When Johnny smiles, I think it’s a coping mechanism because he’s so ashamed of what she did that he’s trying to laugh it off and be lighthearted about the severity of the situation. It’s also bewilderment as to how he could have ‘let this happen’ to himself - as if, somehow, he was to blame for the actions of his abuser. It’s not your fault Johnny... you fell in love with a monster. Been there.
I've had a similar a experience sans physical abuse. When I was listening to the full conversation recording I burst out laughing at what a psycho she was from the first few minutes and Johnny's humble, calm, well thought responses, which was to me a replay of my past relationship. And even I try to "humorise" when talking about it to people, trying to turn those highly negative/detrimental experiences into a joke for the listener's comfort, while somehow, inside, blaming my idiocy for sticking around so long with such a narcissistic, self-sympathizing nutjob, who I had actually identified as a psycho much earlier, before the real shit show happened. But the heart was weak at confronting itself until it could take no more and was finally drained, taking the mind and body with it. I was a ghost/zombie for a few good months after the breakup
Imagine being an actor as celebrated and well known as Johnny Depp and never having any kind of accusations of abuse and then having it so publicly thrown around that you're a wife beater...and that's 2020 for you ppl!
I think Johnny is embarrassed and sad that he’s even in this situation, so he uses humor to lighten the mood. Amber is a textbook narcissist and she makes me sick.
She’s saying she doesn’t know what part of her body she put in between Johnny and her sister but in her recent testimony she clearly and vividly explains how she hit him. So she remembers years later but didn’t remember when it was fresh
Thank you for this. Watching her talk always makes me angry and uncomfortable, and I couldn't believe how much of a circus act that 2016 deposition was. That trial felt so rigged if that's what they used as her testimony. She seemed arrogant like she would easily get her way and would have nothing to worry about. Someone more concerned about the outcome would have taken it more seriously.
Johnny also does this thing where he allows himself to fall into Jack Sparrow, a familiar character to distance himself from what's happening. Bc when you listen to him being genuine and vulnerable, he's incredibly soft-spoken and stumbles a bit. But in court and in the video of him with Amber, he takes on the Sparrow kind of accent/flow of the words. Swaying a bit, jerky movements, and a slight slur in that video, he's trying to play it off for the interviewer. In court, he gets sassy with Amber's lawyer to protect himself from being vulnerable with someone he doesn't trust.
It is interesting to watch this after watching the trial. Amber is a completely different person in court than she is here! Whereas JD is consistently himself in his testimony. No acting on his side, 100% a production for her.
@@cheshirecatxredbettle9570 Yes she is a disgusting person- Johnny really down-graded when he got with with her. I wish he would have stayed with Vanessa, she seemed so cool. Amber is without a doubt a stunning looking woman but she hasn't got any personality & comes across as a hillbilly harpie- she'd give a fishwife a run for their money.😝😝😝
When she was asked if she had ever hit Johnny, all she had to do was lie and say no. Or just say “only that time with the door” and then be done. Her not answering just makes her more guilty
Yes-I was like are you kidding me? How does one answer questions at a deposition while shoving food into their mouth and answering "mmfekfefting igtppppflig..." Like- what?? 🤥🤥🤦🤷
Chris Watson hot yes? Also a horrible, crazy and disgusting untalented person and a full blown narcissist. But yes, she is hot so all is forgiven right? You are such a shallow person
Amber: shows no interest, fumbles her speech a lot, suddenly changes parts of her story, overly defensive/aggressive Johnny: smiles nervously, tries to joke about his injured finger, soft-spoken and calm
JD has a dark sense of humor. He is almost definitely smirking at the sheer absurdity of the incident. You will notice throughout trial, that JD uses humor as levity. This (along with drugs and alcohol) seems to be the way he handles stress. I don't think his smirk is duper's delight. in trial, he's also chuckling at these totally ridiculous and out of hand situations that he and Amber found themselves in.
Yeah. And did you notice how she was trying to just stick to the opposing attorney her story by just repeating herself over and ove. I mean yeah we have to do that in depositions but she was like exaggerating
@@ohmygodbecky6829 Even a decent liar would immediately say "no". A toddler who's just broken a vase knows to say "no". She's the worst liar I've ever seen.
@@LordofFullmetal I believe the hesitation to saying no there could be due to the pressure of the environment of the court and the legal effects of her words said, so she might be trying to avoid straight up lying so as to avoid the legal consequences.
You can in a deposition, since those can be held just about anywhere, as usually only both parties lawyers need to be present. Someone addresses a judge in Amber's video though so they must have been in a courtroom, which may not all ban food outright but if they don't I'd think that's more of a "surely that doesn't need to be said" thing. Either way it's poor form, one it's plain rude but more importantly for her it makes you look like you don't give a shit and don't understand the seriousness of the situation
Compare this to her performance in the Virginia trial - so a few years have passed and NOW (that she's performing on cameras for the whole world to see) she has this super emotional reaction and she's giving all of those details and how traumatic it was. But not long after it supposedly happened her behaviour is: "whatever".
Interesting that she actually describes Johnny's situation in Australia, as he fled to the bathroom and she followed him and tried to get in, tricking him with a squeezed foot and kicking the door against his head
I feel like Johnny is more embarrassed that he has to talk about being abused. Must be so hard for a man to do. It’s sad he’s trying to be so careful to not set her off.
One thing in his favor, Johnny is a whole person. Yes, he is a man. However he is more of a person who isnt hung up on being macho. He is more enlightened about his position as a human being, to me, he’s entirely lovely. Inside and out.
@@FlatBunny360 why? U aren’t weak if u are a man, woman or any gender victims aren’t weak they are strong that they are alive this long u are brave and not weak. Plus what’s wrong with being a man that’s weak?
@@FlatBunny360 I am so sorry you went through this and so sorry society made you feel this way. No one deserves to be treated in any demeaning or harmful manner. Sending you virtual hugs 🤗
He’s getting his jobs back. :) Johnny has already been rehired by Disney - whilst Heard has been “fired” by WarnerBros and in Aquaman 2 she will be replaced by Emilia Clarke, which makes me hope WB too will rehire Johnny for Fantastic Beasts (which is considered one of his best roles).
It's obvious that you have never been around an narcissist! Thank God that you have never had this experience! Love you Johnny ❤️ the truth will set you free!
Something I've recently seen on social media is the fact that in Australia where the bottle incident happened, what he's describing is actually a crime called "glassing." It is *extremely serious* and if convicted can result in a sentence of anywhere from 4 years to *life.* So when Depp says he was protecting Amber, he was *literally* protecting her from being arrested and potentially ending up in jail for 4+ years.
He's been horribly abused. He's ashamed of himself for putting up with it. She is a malignant narcissist. My huge condolences, Johnny. I escaped mine after being in "prison" with one for 27 years.
Yep. I was in this same situation and the parallels are uncanny. These toxic people definitely have a playbook that they all seem to use. I’m 5 years free from mine...
I have personal and professional experience with people diagnosed with personality disorders. From my experience, the condescension, aggressive manipulation tactics (forcing eye contact or interaction), haughty arrogance (elitism), and petulant (non) answers are very consistent behaviors. It’s as though they genuinely believe that they can force perception, and thus create the truth, with their words. They are grandiose enough to believe this, regardless of the skill or education of the person they are speaking to; in fact it almost seems to be more amplified whenever they are the most out of their league. They seem to relish in their belief that they can get one over on someone. I’m struggling to put my finger on what their issue is with emotions. It’s common for people coming out of relationships with them to say something like, “I felt like I never really knew them”. They often have an oddness or corniness to them when they are being friendly or nice. They seem to be telling you what they believe you want to hear, or what they want to believe is true, when you are trying to connect with them. It’s like they can’t produce authentic emotion, but they are highly astute at recognizing emotion in others. They try to mirror it back, but it’s just not quite right.
I’m watching this on May 9, 2022… in the middle of their high profile case. I can’t believe how she fakes to be this go ‘round versus the previous trial. She is SOBBING with no tears as she gives her recollection of their relationship . We have actual proof she was absolutely abusive to him so your analysis seems to be spot on!!!
@@rachelrumsey5277 she disabled the comment section of her post I guess she knows that we would spam her If she is the ‘victim’ then why would she be afraid of what we would say?
It was observed in his USA testimony that the small smile he gives while recalling things is part of his baseline. Maybe because having his finger cut off and the circumstances he is under it is a stress reaction and the fact that having to go through this and having to share what occurred to him are just absurd. He is a very low key genuine and shy person. Also a little old fashioned which is something I like about him alot. He would feel bad even in this situation to have to out a woman and be ashamed that he has ended up in this situation as a man.
Her bared teeth when she‘s going more and more upset and angry … like a dog or a shark, just before biting. That‘s no defending gesture or mimic. That’s pure aggression.
Well, acting isn't lying. Acting is always blocked out and practiced multiple times. This time she's fucked cause she doesn't have a script XD Too bad she didn't get to practice her lines for this interview
@@adawhite1382 don’t be surprised if she’s pregnant by the VA trial. This woman will go to any lengths for any kind of sympathy or just PUBLIC approval.. it’s almost a forgone conclusion at this point
She was nodding yes on "do you understand the question" and answering 'no' on "have you committed domestic violence against JD". But yeah the two should not mix like that. She did that again in the courtroom on the question if the song they played in the car was meant for Johnny. Nodding Yes while saying "No that's ridiculous". I guess it took her by surprise, she had no idea she was that transparent.
To be fair, acting for the screen to portray a fictional character is a very, very different proposition to making a lie credible in real life. Acting generally runs off an internally-consistent prepared script that runs to a known conclusion, and doesn't deviate much from it, and everything in the film supports the fiction. Lying in real life involves improvised responses to questions that are not scripted, and the other players in the scene are doing all they can to derail any notional script you may have in your head and root out all the inconsistencies with identifiable facts. And there's no screenwriter, script editor, or director to make the scene support the fiction; facts are facts. People who think they can act their way through this are living in a fool's paradise even if they've got several Oscars on the shelf -- and Amber's nowhere near that calibre. Acting skills are a very poor preparation for this -- especially if you're trying to apply them where they aren't going to work.
It's not that simple. I never get the "their an actor" arguement as an actor 😂 like you have weeks sometimes MONTHS to prepare for a role. And even then you're acting/living the role but there's an element of you within it. Plus you usually rehearse for hours on end with a director guiding and correcting you. I doubt she bothered to do any of that for this interview, and even if she did, it would never be to the same extent as it would be for a show, movie, or play.
Johnnys smiling could be a sign of anxiety. I've smiled and even laughed after being in bad situations. And it wasn't that I thought it was funny, but couldn't process my anxiety in those moments. It's a coping mechanism. And it's actual common in those who suffer or have suffered from mental/physical abuse.
I also have a friend who smiles and laughs when she is experiencing negative emotions. It is often a result of being raised in an environment where negative emotions are not welcome and/or are met with aggression. But we are watching a man and I see some cultural attitude showing through as well. Some of the old, "I'm a man and I can't show how much this has deeply affected me", attempt at being/seeming cavalier about the things that he's actually suffered from his own wife. This isn't meant as a criticism. It's an acknowledgement that those attitudes remain embedded, even in progressive adults who move in liberal circles.
I was raised in a very very healthy environment - i.e. never been abused, really great parents/family, etc. (very lucky and blessed in that regard). I’ve definitely smiled when hearing terrible news. I assume it’s a coping mechanism of some sort. Also, when I’m watching a movie that is intensely scary, for some reason, I laugh. Happened in the theatre during Open Water and again during A Quiet Place, which was super embarrassing (if you’ve seen A Quiet Place - you’ll understand why. It’s mostly silent and you could hear a pin drop in the theatre. And then I start laughing. People probably thought I was a some sort of psychopath.)
@@suet.r.4815 not sure if you’re asking about the tragic news smile reaction or the scary movie laugh. The tragic news one I think is just being overwhelmed and possibly disbelief is part of it. The scary movie laugh I think is some sort of emotional or mental release valve.
If I had been that judge, the food would have landed in the bin after 10 seconds. Or rather, I would have said, if you absolutely need to eat, we’ll take a 30minute recess.
Imagine eating during an interrogation because you don’t wanna own up to your abusive tendencies. Can’t believe this case is still going, All the evidence is honestly right here.
This is a deposition not an interrogation, she’s not a criminal suspect so she was allowed food, criminal interrogations are totally different and performed by investigators not lawyers.
@@IndefiniteMark no it's not comfort eating. He's right in saying she was likely advised to bring food up there in order to stall for time when she's asked a difficult question. This is evident because she reacts completely differently on two separate occasions to having food in her mouth when asked a question - when she is asked a question she finds easy to answer, she speaks with her mouthful, but a difficult question prompts her to make a huge show of trying to chew so she can answer as if she doesn't want to speak with her mouth full. I'm usually the first to get irritated at the current trend of calling everyone a Narcissiatic/psychopath/sociopath, but on this occasion I believe a diagnosis of narcissist would be accurate.
This is the most unprofessional court hearing I’ve ever seen. Eating, yelling, and lawyers fighting. What!? Thank you all for the likes and thank you some for clearing up some stuff about dispositions. Very helpful 😁
It's a deposiation. I'm not sure it counts as 'in court' the same way, and doesn't exactly need to even be in a courthouse. Granted I'm not in the legal field, so I'm not sure if it's a state thing, but I have seen deposistions before with food (trail mix, or pastries), and drinks (water, coffee, OJ) that were done far away from courthouses. Not defending her, or how this all went down, I do agree that she seems like she's using eating to buy time for answers. It could have even been her lawyers advice, or could have even provided it to her for that reason.
Its absolutely DISGUSTING & INFURIATING that she is just chomping away during LEGAL PROCEEDINGS. It disgusts me because watching people eat in just vile, but also how deliberately defiant it appears. I like to try to see both sides of the argument in situations like this and my gut is usually accurate. My gut feeling has never been so overwhelming about a single person!
Here's what I think, she wanted to get away with the abuse she's done. There's audio of her yelling at him, and in an interview or court recording (cant recall which it was) she owned up to hitting him. He said she hit him in the face so her response was "I slapped you and it wasn't even that hard". ABUSE IS STILL ABUSE. Men can be abused too.
Yea woman kinda downgrade men...on social media and shit i hv seen it alot but well both do its not nice that both genders do that. Also why do woman think that if u slap a boy and bully him kinda its not abuse but if it happens to us girls its violence and the person ahould go in jail Idk about u but its kinda annoying thats why i dont think about genders when i meet a person i just think of them as a person
I couldn't help but roll my eyes when amber said that Johnny was being too dramatic. That's one of the most common things abusers say to trivialize and downplay the severity of their actions.
My mother abused me between the ages 7-23 to the point that I have had multiple skull fractures. When I finally confronted her about it she called me dramatic and that it wasn't abuse because "It wasn't like it happened every day"
that‘s not how a victim behaves. she‘s too arrogant, too collected and almost calculated whenever she‘s not stumbling over her bad excuses. i can‘t believe anyone in that court room seriously believed what she was saying.
Anyone else pick up how she said she put herself in between Whitney and Johnny and then slipped up and said Whitney was the one in between Amber and Johnny? Inconsistencies all over the place
She is such a bad liar. I would expect her to be better at her craft as an actress. I cannot see her passing an audition for a commercial, much less a movie role.
She's wooden in every role I've seen her. She gets cast because she is pretty set dressing. It's sad and sexist, but if she wasn't as pretty, she wouldn't have even the sliver of career that she has.
Johnny looks at Amber the same way a dog looks at their abusive owner when they have an accident in the house. It’s the “please don’t hit me, please please don’t be mad” look. It’s stomach turning. Amber is pure evil, you can just feel it.
@@percy_coro_cos Ugh, I know!🥺 I had narcissistic parents and I did that a lot too. My heart breaks for Johnny, I just hope he has a support system that can help him realize none of this is his fault😢
I kind of disagree... I don't think he looks at her like a dog looks at an abusive owner... I think he looks at her like a dog who's kinda looking for instructions on what to do which would be normal in a pet-owner relationship... not a loving relationship between adult humans
I’m watching this in 2022 as the trial is going on, and I do have to give props to her legal team for the amazing coaching job they did. If she acted in court the way she did in this deposition, there wouldn’t even be a case. Now that’s not to say that I think she’s doing a great job at trial now, but for the legal team to have dealt with this condescending, snarky, can’t-put-a-coherent-sentence together mess and turn it into what we see in court today, well that must’ve taken a whole lot of work. So props to them. Honestly though, there is so much of her mannerisms (the boredom, the contempt, the snarkiness, the eating) and words (the fact that she can’t seem to put a coherent sentence together or answer a question point blank) that just doesn’t make sense. Now I have no idea what went on in their marriage, none of us do cause we weren’t there, but I do find it extremely interesting that there are so many comments from people that have had horrible trauma and abuse that don’t believe she is the victim. I have yet to see a single domestic abuse survivor comment that they believe her. I find that very interesting.
I've been through DV.. I do believe he started the abuse with when she said he slapped her after asking about his tattoo and she didn't know if he was joking. I also believe he cut his own finger off in a drug fuelled psychosis and he us lying she did it by throwing a bottle. On the other hand I do believe she is definitely make up some stories and lies too. JD is not the victim hes managing to convince the world he is. He wrote horrible things about her before even marrying her and described his ex wife in message as a money grabbing french cunt. No Amber's no saint, but I think she's probably quite tough. Probably something JD met his match in.. theyre both bad as eachother I think.
A friend of mine who survived domestic abuse and in my opinion, is a fucking superhero said something very important to me when we got into this conversation. She said and I am paraphrasing, “I hate Amber Heard for a much different reason than others. It’s fine to dislike her because she’s ruining the life of your favourite actor but I have had people start to doubt my truth because of this one bad woman. What happened to me is being called into question by some because of this woman’s actions and her lies. And she is still allowed to preach about women’s rights all the time”.
I honestly think this too when people lie about being raped. Now rape victims ain't taken seriously due to people like Amber and others. Edit: Yes I know she's lying about domestic abuse but it's the same phrasing with rape too.
I'm a survivor and that's my biggest issue too. The amount of doubt that this sort of thing brings to actual survivors of abuse is enormous. It's already hard enough to deal with the trauma without being questioned about the validity of that trauma every 5 seconds.
When Johnny does his little half smile while recounting his story, my heart broke. Having gone through a bunch of trauma in my life I had a really hard time finding people to listen for this exact reason. I end up smiling or awkwardly laughing when recounting my experiences because it feels too heavy when I try and get through it straight faced.Not to mention it makes other people uncomfortable when you're too serious for too long about something like this. And if people are uncomfortable they stop listening. I 100% believe that he was the victim.
Me too. I was in partial hospitalization a couple years ago and would laugh and joke and make fun of myself while talking about wishing I would die, and I’m not even sure why I do that I hate it because it really makes me seem flippant and downplays how I really feel. People need to understand that not everyone acts exactly the same.
@@MaleficentHipster I'm really sorry that you've had to go through that. I know how it feels and it sucks. It's really hard, but finding someone who gets what's going on makes all the difference.
I had a friend growing up who laughed when she was scared. It was heartbreaking when people got angry with her, because she would start compulsively smiling and chuckling, which they would read as mockery, making them angrier, making her more scared, leading to more laughter. They of course wouldn't see her break down crying after they stormed away in a rage. I don't really blame them for how they felt. It was just awful. Sometimes those of us who knew her would have some success intervening, but there isn't always someone who knows you standing right there you know.
I know a fellow that stuttered as a child and one of his learnt strategies was to a deliver slow responses, often avoiding the more difficult letter pairings which meant he would search for preferred words. When you hear Johnny in tapes where he is being abused by her his stuttering becomes more and more pronounced. just a thought
This is hard to get through. Not because of him, but Amber is just incredibly infuriating. Her lies, her mannerisms, and her freaking facial expressions. Just her being. I hope Depp gets his justice and her career finally goes down the toilet after circling the damn bowl for far too long.
She’s a narcissist. Narcissistic folk are some of the most obnoxious and annoying people to put up with. So much bullshit and mental gymnastics to deal with, it’s irritating and exhausting 😑
I want to see people cancel this woman with twice the force and speed they instantly destroy Johnny Depp over a mere accusation without evidence. There's full evidence she's an abuser and doesn't care and NOBODY cares. She's ruined his life.
Whenever I speak about a traumatic/hurtful experience I tend to look down and do a “half smirk”, but it’s always been a defense mechanism for me. I do it bc it stops me from having the urge to cry or get emotional. So I genuinely believe Johnny Depp when he recounts his experience.
He has also always been uncomfortable public speaking and interviews and uses humor (usually self deprecating) to deflect from his discomfort. He’s only actually well spoken when he has a script.
I don't know what happend to you and I'm so sorry it happened but yeah, whenever I feel as if the trauma is coming back or I just wanna defend myself obviously when I'm right, I tend to get really nervous, my palms get sweaty and I tend to lose my words
I do the same thing. I actually recall often when recounting or simply speaking about certain subjects with others I tend to look down and half smirk a lot, especially if I feel that I might cry half smiling and a little laughter is usually my go to for some reason
It's interesting that so many of us can see she's lying without knowing the reasons why we know. It's neat that you explain the "whys". I've learned so much & trust my instincts even more now. Thank you for what you do!!!
I think he's (Depp) is making those facial expressions because for a long time he'd been lying about how things happened. So he's got to look through the lies he's been telling to protect her. He's also an arty type who uses words very specifically.
“They won’t believe you , because you are a man”
SHE IS NOT A VICTIM.
i think in a way she is, meaning that there's something deeply wrong with her, psychologically. but in the context of this case, sure, she ought to chill in jail for a while
@@alexhenderson1838 serial narcissist is more like it
Facts
Shes a victim, but victim to her own psychosis
You don’t need the ,
For being an actress, she's not very good at acting.
@brandon 87348 None of the movies she had been in have been truly successful.
@@vaderladyl Well that's false...Aquaman was truly successful...she's still a pos though
@@lynza3566 Blech...didn't like that movie anyway.
Narcissists can't understand the emotions of a well adjusted person and cannot emulate them.
She put herself up for it. She knew this would be public.
It feels really good to see our entire country so universally aligned on a topic: Amber Heard is just terrible.
Why he does the little smile when talking about uncomfortable, unsocial, embarrassing things is to lighten it for who's listening. It's part of his baseline, and partly due to growing up with an abusive parent. He does not want to be looked at as a complainer or whiner, he's an empath.
Yes
That's what I do all the time..the more stressful a situation is the more I smile
She's so arrogant, the eating is so disrespectful, I've never seen anything like this
This is white girl privilege at it finest. Welcome to the real world in North America.
agreed. what a total jerk. who let's a person eat food during a legal proceeding? really?
Right? Like wtf eats nonchalantly if they’ve been “abused” and knowing you’d have to recall those memories/relive by telling them!
@@lunaorellana111 exactly, she doesn't act traumatized
@@Brandon.manga. whyd you have to bring race into it
She looks like a teenager trying to pretend they don't care. Extremely immature.
She acts like one too.
Naaah... she seems pathological here.. Narcissist and sociopath.
some people simply don't grow up.
I'm offended now
Exactly!! Reminds me of my daughter when she was in junior high.
Why is she even allowed to eat??? This is serious stuff. Imagine going for a job interview and eating or doing your nails ??? Drinking water should be the only thing alllowed.
Having watched the trial to the end and hearing the verdict, and listening to body language experts, I started taking the experts seriously. It's not just tells. It's amazing how the body expresses itself. Seeing your video after the verdict really solidifies my opinion that you guys are the real deal because you called it. A year ago! You were right throughout the whole video.
Agreed. I didn't follow the trial and only started looking into it after the verdict, trying to figure out how they arrived at that decision. This body language expert called it, as did many others. And of course Heard was caught lying over and over again. Thank God the trial was televised so the whole world could see what that woman really is: an abuser, shameless liar and outright evil.
“They won’t believe you, because you are a man.”
She is NOT a victim.
It is sad but true. I work under the mental health and social work umbrella and in my area there was once an instance where the man had visible blood on his face from a blow and blood droplets on the woman's sleeve and the police STILL automatically moved to arrest the man 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️ and of COURSE women are usually the ones victims of the domestic violence but lets NEVER rule out the possibility of the man being the victim based on gender alone! It's because of this small percentage of people that lie that other people have a more difficult time believing the people telling the truth.
From where did you get that quote? Just asking.
This s so up!! As a woman who has great bf, cousins and brothers I hate the world we are coming from. All the radical feminists with their tits out yelling for their stripper rights!
There isn't a single person on yt that is on her side I think they see us as crazy fans, I'm not even a fan I just like his works, but it's obvious here that she is the culprit
@@sehunyehetfeatchanyeolchog4751 she hit her ex girlfriend and I bet she payed her off to speak highly of her. People saw it. Then both the ex and Amber said Amber was arrested bc the arresting officer was homophobic and misogynistic. The officer was a lesbian/activist. Like they can't even lie 😭
It’s sad that ambers own parents side with Johnny and feel bad for him because they know she is lying
Really!? Wow, do you have an article or something?
If you just look up ambers parents side with Johnny In text message you will fine a few articles on it some have different messages and one has ambers mum saying “i know I love you son” while Johnny was explaining that he didn’t do it @@upgoyxtirzruz
they were being manipulative they don’t actually love him or are siding with him
@@jamiemackenzie6540 ok thanks
Wait really
21:50 As someone who Identifies immensely with Johnny Depp, I can say that in my own life I frequently "smirk" when recalling uncomfortable topics, especially with other people. Especially traumatic things or things you'd rather not talk about. In my mind I see this moment as more of a "oh boy.. time for this story.." moment rather than a "dupers delight" moment.
I smile under stress and great pain because I’m not comfortable showing my real emotions of pain. Abusive parents who punished for showing emotions do that to you.
In relation to Johnny continuously pausing in his testimony, as someone with PTSD, whenever I've had to recount traumatic incidents in the past it has taken me absolute ages (and I have a problem with usually speaking too fast lol). It's like my brain shuts down every few seconds to avoid reliving the incident and I have to keep bringing myself back to the present and try and remember where I was in order to finish the story. Everything about Johnny's testimonies has felt relatable or familiar to me as a survivor of abuse and younger sibling to an opiate addict. Watching Amber Heard is like watching an alien make a mockery of those two experiences.
That's disassociation and you are completely correct in that your mind has closed the unprocessed memory off since it can't process it and doesn't want it to harm you further, and trying to get to it is trying to overcome your brains self defense. Maybe one day you can get a therapy type that can help the memories get processed. Much love
Same
This is my absolute favorite comment on TH-cam. That last sentence is perfect.
Bro, he talks like that from years of drugs and alcohol rotting his cognitive function
I know exactly. When you HAVE to talk about it to someone, but if you allowed yourself to remember it entirely, you would completely break down. Most people actually do this when they have to talk about difficult experiences.
We detach ourselves from the experience, which makes it hard to recount it.
Funny how his ex Vanessa never accused him of anything except being a wonderful father. I feel so bad for him... Glad he got away from it.
Or Winona Ryder. Absolute cringe of a human being
And with Winonna, she has also sided with Johnny as he never was violent with her
Can't get away with something you haven't done
@@seamushayday1222 I said got away FROM it not "with" it.
vanessas accusations were true!
The way she struggled to get that snack out of the bag before she finished asking the question was just mind blowing to your suggestion of her using that as a stall tactic. It was very evident that was the case at that point. They should of grilled her on all this in both cases.
Notice how she reaches for her snacks, pauses and retracts her hand, then as SOON as she hears the date of the punch she dives in, I mean it could not be more obvious ✋🤣
I'm so annoyed about it. She is literally being asked a question and she's stuffing food into her mouth. She knows she needs to answer a question. Is it really the time to be stuffing her face?? There is just something so sneaky and un natural about it.
I hate that she ruined Johnny’s life and is getting away with it.
It won't last trust me, she can't win this
I agree, eventually karma will hit her and it'll hit her hard. She is absolutely nothing unlike Johnny Depp.
Baby doll that is the plight of majority of the women in western civilizations, is to try and bring down any great man just for fun...
Don't you realise he was a wife beater !!!
Yup. It is as if they both like to be sub and dom and was not able to understand when to take what role, and then it just went to the extreme. For what I read, they both are to blame. They both asked for it and they both wont take a blame. Like you cant have two doms in a relationship. It just goes to hell. Much like a relationship of two subs, are the perhaps most boring relationship.
Guys, please stop insulting amber heard. I'm tired of liking your comments.
LOL
Underrated comment
😂🤣 that was great
yes amber, write on....
he had us in the first half, not gonna lie.
poor guy showing all the signs of being in an abusive relationship and she is showing all the signs of being the abusive spouse
Also another thing to note is whenever amber is “recalling” the story, the motions of her hands are not consistent with what she’s saying, so when she’s talking about getting hit she always does the actual hitting motion and so forth, but when Johnny recalls what happened, his motions and movements are consistent with what he’s saying. The vodka bottle being thrown at him is a great example. Justice for Johnny.
The irony is she's an actress who can't act for her own lie.
That’s because you can’t “act up” real life and not be found out! 😂😂😌 these snakes kinda people will always and forever bring themselves down, their own ways/actions will finish them off 😌
😂😂😂😂
Yes!
Even the very best actors couldn’t fain their innocence while under intense interrogation.
I feel like there's a big difference in acting like a different person and actually lying as yourself as well. But idk, I might be completely wrong
@@kapokikkodragneel1505 Not just that, the situation and magnitude of the conversation takes a big rol in it. Is not the same being in a set, with coworkers feeling comfy and secure, having some fun and doing what you most like having under control your emotions, that being out of your comfort zone, in a cold room having to answer uncomfortable questions from people you don't trust and knowing they are looking for any slightest mistake or inconsistency in what you say or do to make you pay for it.
Her eyes are dead as hell.
this is the most unprofessional court hearing I have ever witnessed oh my god. what is this?! Her lawyer is so cringe - who gave this man his degree lmao
She looks like a sociopath!
I dunno but she loke like she is stoned😂
who the fuck puts candy in ones mouth while someone asks you a question and then you can't answer because you are chewing and in a hearing? like wtf. reasons: you are arrogant and don't respect the person you are talking to or the situation, you want to stall, you establish power over the other person
Dead, dead as hell
If a DV-survivor is giving testimony to what happened I would imagine them being sick to their stomach, not snacking endlessly.
I have to agree with you there is no way I could eat and tell a courtroom full of people about abuse just thinking about things makes me feel sick and I certainly wouldn't be laughing at any point. She's such a lier 😤
I still can’t believe she won the UK trial. 😡
Lol Amber’s own parents have spoken out against her. She’s done.
I hope so!!
what they say?
@Andy Chou ...& see on the internet
Some parents are fucked though, so I don't think using what parents say as a sort of final clue or piece of evidence is good. Not saying she's not guilty but just saying that her parents stating that could simply be due to other reasons.
@Andy Chou It's not all fake, either.
I was in an abusive relationship 10 years ago and to this day I can remember every single detail without hesitation! Amber is lying and manipulating to get her way. Disgusting!
i’m glad you’re out of it hun ❤️
I was in one for nineteen years. It’s so easy for me now to spot an abuser. She is an abuser.
@@annegriffith6905 I'm so glad that both of you are out of that situation!
I was for 15 years with a monster. I too remember every bad bashing. He once put boxing gloves on me, and headgear on himself. You can imagine what happened. He thought that was “fun” and because I have epilepsy, he would blame bruises on my seizures. Cruel man. I’m married to a bloody Angel now. God...the fear is still there.
Merry Christmas to all. Let’s hope 2021 is less virus’y! 🎄
God bless you I hope you’re doing better!!
One correction: ppl with PTSD sometimes remember their trauma VIVIDLY, the strangest and seemingly smallest details are etched into our minds. This is the case with many of my experiences / flashbacks. It's not unusual to recall events in such detail.
You're right - I have very serious PTSD and my memories are so jumbled up. Some things are completely blank and some incredibly weird and random things are as clear as day. Sometimes when the brain is constantly alert for attack, it shuts down when the attack happens and focuses on something irirrelevant to protect itself. Unless you've experienced real trauma, it's hard to understand that.
However, I dont believe this is the case for Amber when she's recalling the dirty carper or whatever. It feels to me that she's researched trauma and tried to mimick the behaviour, but she doesn't feel emotions the way most people do and therefore seems like a liar. She's trying TOO hard.
just meeting for the first time with my own therapist after an abusive marriage, I couldn't eat my lunch afterwards. I wasn't hungry until hours later at dinnertime, as I had lost my appetite from nerves and stress in discussing my situation with my own therapist ! To be in a legal deposition with such serious circumstances and to be snacking, is beyond my comprehension.
Did you hit Johnny Depp? Lawyer: "ITs NoT ReLeVaNt To DoMeStIC AbUsE"
ikr *face palm*
that's just plain stupidity 😔
Exactly, how can this be irrelevant ? It is very relevant 😆 what a stupid argument
@@taurus8263 It is irrelevant to his goals, he's trying to get a fat paycheck out of winning this case, not have the truth be told.
Lawyers man.....they're scum.
It doesn’t take a body language analyst to realise what she’s doing
But it takes one to bury the dead horse?
for real, I mean I've just started looking into this and I already see so much. Like in real legitimate evidence of one of their conversations she tells Johnny that running away and hiding behind a door makes her mad and is an act of a COWARD. But in here she's the one supposedly hiding behind the door? Excuse me miss do you have dementia?
It adds a level of validation
And it's interesting imo
I didnt believe her since day 1 and
posted about it. Often .
Actually even before their marriage fell apart I had seen her on a talk show and felt instantly alerted
This particular body language analyzer is very balanced , thorough & insightful. imo.
I Think It Adds 69% certainty
@@sharondianneb I agree I’m just saying how obvious it is
How Depp lost this 1st trial is just mind-boggling.
Hollywood has tentacles that reach far
No one called out the smirk at 17:28 as far as I see here...I found it interesting myself...
When Johnny smiles, I think it’s a coping mechanism because he’s so ashamed of what she did that he’s trying to laugh it off and be lighthearted about the severity of the situation. It’s also bewilderment as to how he could have ‘let this happen’ to himself - as if, somehow, he was to blame for the actions of his abuser.
It’s not your fault Johnny... you fell in love with a monster. Been there.
Elm TreeABC possibly so. He’s such a gentle soul. I hope the judges and ruling reflect that.
He has lost a lot. Was it River?
I've had a similar a experience sans physical abuse. When I was listening to the full conversation recording I burst out laughing at what a psycho she was from the first few minutes and Johnny's humble, calm, well thought responses, which was to me a replay of my past relationship. And even I try to "humorise" when talking about it to people, trying to turn those highly negative/detrimental experiences into a joke for the listener's comfort, while somehow, inside, blaming my idiocy for sticking around so long with such a narcissistic, self-sympathizing nutjob, who I had actually identified as a psycho much earlier, before the real shit show happened. But the heart was weak at confronting itself until it could take no more and was finally drained, taking the mind and body with it. I was a ghost/zombie for a few good months after the breakup
The woman took a shit in their bed! She made it her life's mission to embarrass and humiliate him. She was not able to break him tho.
I do the same thing in tough situation I smile until I get through it I’ve done it since I was a child
Imagine being an actor as celebrated and well known as Johnny Depp and never having any kind of accusations of abuse and then having it so publicly thrown around that you're a wife beater...and that's 2020 for you ppl!
I think Johnny is embarrassed and sad that he’s even in this situation, so he uses humor to lighten the mood. Amber is a textbook narcissist and she makes me sick.
Yes
she is a psychopath
I sometimes do a half smile when recounting the past, especially in some situations.
Well said
She seems to be a Borderliner
She’s saying she doesn’t know what part of her body she put in between Johnny and her sister but in her recent testimony she clearly and vividly explains how she hit him. So she remembers years later but didn’t remember when it was fresh
Thank you for this. Watching her talk always makes me angry and uncomfortable, and I couldn't believe how much of a circus act that 2016 deposition was. That trial felt so rigged if that's what they used as her testimony. She seemed arrogant like she would easily get her way and would have nothing to worry about. Someone more concerned about the outcome would have taken it more seriously.
She's acting and shes a really bad actress. As we all know. She is horrible
Very superior attitude. Cannot answer one question without deflection.
I think she's a graduate from the Jussie Smollett School for the Performing Arts.
Yes! The over acting at the 20 minute mark is embarrassing. Its SO bad. Its amazing shes a somewhat succesful actress. Truly amazing.
how does this brat get acting work???? oh yea....there is THAT
Have you ever watched one of her movies?
Yeah me neither.
I can't believe the judge allowed her to eat during testimony, it seems absurd.
Maybe to use the card of 'to make her more comfortable' during the testimony as a 'victim'...uuggghhh
Exactly. WTH!!
I don’t understand why he allowed that either.
I was wondering that because there are certain court etiquettes (which may be different for country to country)
It actually made her look worse off, by eating. We can tell she's trying to come up with a good lie.
Johnny also does this thing where he allows himself to fall into Jack Sparrow, a familiar character to distance himself from what's happening. Bc when you listen to him being genuine and vulnerable, he's incredibly soft-spoken and stumbles a bit. But in court and in the video of him with Amber, he takes on the Sparrow kind of accent/flow of the words. Swaying a bit, jerky movements, and a slight slur in that video, he's trying to play it off for the interviewer. In court, he gets sassy with Amber's lawyer to protect himself from being vulnerable with someone he doesn't trust.
It is interesting to watch this after watching the trial. Amber is a completely different person in court than she is here! Whereas JD is consistently himself in his testimony. No acting on his side, 100% a production for her.
"I'm going to have a snack while talking about domestic abuse." Did no domestic abuse survivor ever.
Seriously! I would have thrown up if I'd even smelled food on any of my testifying days. Oh good lawd....theres no way.
And the feeling of shame, as a victim you feel so much shame, hunger does not go with that.
@@willowhofmann7409 *sad smile*
@@willowhofmann7409 “oh good lawd!” 🤣🤣🤣
Soo I suppose you've never heard the word "disassociation"?
*"Did you hit him, simple yes or no?"*
*She avoids the answer
Do we really need to continue....?
8:24 for those wondering
I hate her beacuse there are women being abused and they dont have any chance to talk. You should be a monster to sleep at night
@@cheshirecatxredbettle9570 Yes she is a disgusting person- Johnny really down-graded when he got with with her. I wish he would have stayed with Vanessa, she seemed so cool. Amber is without a doubt a stunning looking woman but she hasn't got any personality & comes across as a hillbilly harpie- she'd give a fishwife a run for their money.😝😝😝
Her whole statement is a lie!
She might have fought with him in self defence, which makes it difficult to answer with yes or no.
how on EARTH did she get away with this in 2016?
When she was asked if she had ever hit Johnny, all she had to do was lie and say no. Or just say “only that time with the door” and then be done. Her not answering just makes her more guilty
Her eating is a way to delay in answering the questions. Why is food allowed in a deposition, it’s really annoying and rude.
Yes-I was like are you kidding me? How does one answer questions at a deposition while shoving food into their mouth and answering "mmfekfefting igtppppflig..." Like- what?? 🤥🤥🤦🤷
Wendy Gliddon I couldn’t believe how disrespectful she was for eating throughout, as if we don’t know what she was trying to do!
Patricia 1234 she’s a true narcissist/sociopath, they believe they invincible but the only people they fool are themselves
It's fkng infuriating watching her chew and make everyone wait for her to finish whatever she'd shoved in her lying mouth. Far beyond disrespectful.
Chris Watson hot yes? Also a horrible, crazy and disgusting untalented person and a full blown narcissist. But yes, she is hot so all is forgiven right? You are such a shallow person
Amber: shows no interest, fumbles her speech a lot, suddenly changes parts of her story, overly defensive/aggressive
Johnny: smiles nervously, tries to joke about his injured finger, soft-spoken and calm
Poor bb 🥺
Huge difference
typical codependent vs NPD/BPD relationship, they attracted eachother for that reason
Lmao he’s a wuss
The signs were there Jonny should have left her way earlier
Johnny Depp literally had he tip of his finger severed and people think it was a mutually abusive situation. Smh.
JD has a dark sense of humor. He is almost definitely smirking at the sheer absurdity of the incident. You will notice throughout trial, that JD uses humor as levity. This (along with drugs and alcohol) seems to be the way he handles stress. I don't think his smirk is duper's delight.
in trial, he's also chuckling at these totally ridiculous and out of hand situations that he and Amber found themselves in.
“Did you hit him?”
Amber: “It’s not relevant”
*lIterAlLy hOw iS iT nOt reLeVanT*
Seriously, answer the damn question, what’s a “victim” got to hide? Yes or no, 1 second answer.
Yeah. And did you notice how she was trying to just stick to the opposing attorney her story by just repeating herself over and ove. I mean yeah we have to do that in depositions but she was like exaggerating
@@ohmygodbecky6829 Even a decent liar would immediately say "no". A toddler who's just broken a vase knows to say "no". She's the worst liar I've ever seen.
@@LordofFullmetal I believe the hesitation to saying no there could be due to the pressure of the environment of the court and the legal effects of her words said, so she might be trying to avoid straight up lying so as to avoid the legal consequences.
The lawyer said that, not her.
I didn't even think you could bring food into a courtroom or deposition
Gotta bring popcorn if I go to one. Like is some kind of movie or theatre.
I know. When I'll happen to be there, I'll bring some soup. Lol
The Rich and Famous can do anything they want haven't you realized that yet?
You can in a deposition, since those can be held just about anywhere, as usually only both parties lawyers need to be present. Someone addresses a judge in Amber's video though so they must have been in a courtroom, which may not all ban food outright but if they don't I'd think that's more of a "surely that doesn't need to be said" thing. Either way it's poor form, one it's plain rude but more importantly for her it makes you look like you don't give a shit and don't understand the seriousness of the situation
It's probably a celebrity thing because there is no food or drinks other than water in court rooms
Compare this to her performance in the Virginia trial - so a few years have passed and NOW (that she's performing on cameras for the whole world to see) she has this super emotional reaction and she's giving all of those details and how traumatic it was. But not long after it supposedly happened her behaviour is: "whatever".
Interesting that she actually describes Johnny's situation in Australia, as he fled to the bathroom and she followed him and tried to get in, tricking him with a squeezed foot and kicking the door against his head
I feel like Johnny is more embarrassed that he has to talk about being abused. Must be so hard for a man to do. It’s sad he’s trying to be so careful to not set her off.
One thing in his favor, Johnny is a whole person. Yes, he is a man. However he is more of a person who isnt hung up on being macho. He is more enlightened about his position as a human being, to me, he’s entirely lovely. Inside and out.
As someone who's been through similar it is embarrassing to talk about as a man
@@FlatBunny360 why? U aren’t weak if u are a man, woman or any gender victims aren’t weak they are strong that they are alive this long u are brave and not weak. Plus what’s wrong with being a man that’s weak?
@@MaximumGae because society still tries to view men as not having any feeling so it's hard to talk about
@@FlatBunny360 I am so sorry you went through this and so sorry society made you feel this way. No one deserves to be treated in any demeaning or harmful manner. Sending you virtual hugs 🤗
I’m still so irritated that she has gotten to keep her jobs,but Johnny was removed from all of his jobs
This! ^^^
Her lawyers, parents and supporters have turned sides and are now on Johnny his side and Johnny is also rehired by the Disney
He’s getting his jobs back. :) Johnny has already been rehired by Disney - whilst Heard has been “fired” by WarnerBros and in Aquaman 2 she will be replaced by Emilia Clarke, which makes me hope WB too will rehire Johnny for Fantastic Beasts (which is considered one of his best roles).
Johnny got rehired so woohoo
@@LucienSabre ikr no one can play grindelwald like him
It's obvious that you have never been around an narcissist! Thank God that you have never had this experience! Love you Johnny ❤️ the truth will set you free!
Something I've recently seen on social media is the fact that in Australia where the bottle incident happened, what he's describing is actually a crime called "glassing." It is *extremely serious* and if convicted can result in a sentence of anywhere from 4 years to *life.* So when Depp says he was protecting Amber, he was *literally* protecting her from being arrested and potentially ending up in jail for 4+ years.
Are we completely ignoring the fact that she genuinely smiled both times she was asked if she ever hit Jonny?
Yea I know and he didn't mention it, did he? Usually points it out 🤷🏻♀️
I noticed it, and my stomach churned... She literally makes me feel like vomiting.
that's fucking sick, i dont understand how anyone could be so awful
I'm not skilled in psychology so don't take my word for it, but she could be a sadist
@@justnicki Maybe he didn’t point it out because something else caught his attention. Idk
He's been horribly abused. He's ashamed of himself for putting up with it. She is a malignant narcissist. My huge condolences, Johnny. I escaped mine after being in "prison" with one for 27 years.
Must have been more like hell
Yep. I was in this same situation and the parallels are uncanny. These toxic people definitely have a playbook that they all seem to use.
I’m 5 years free from mine...
Congratulations on being 5 years FREE!!! 💖👏
@@henrysilkysmooth me too. Spent 23 years to long with him. Hope you are in a good place now.
Glad you got out. 💕
I have personal and professional experience with people diagnosed with personality disorders. From my experience, the condescension, aggressive manipulation tactics (forcing eye contact or interaction), haughty arrogance (elitism), and petulant (non) answers are very consistent behaviors. It’s as though they genuinely believe that they can force perception, and thus create the truth, with their words. They are grandiose enough to believe this, regardless of the skill or education of the person they are speaking to; in fact it almost seems to be more amplified whenever they are the most out of their league. They seem to relish in their belief that they can get one over on someone.
I’m struggling to put my finger on what their issue is with emotions. It’s common for people coming out of relationships with them to say something like, “I felt like I never really knew them”. They often have an oddness or corniness to them when they are being friendly or nice. They seem to be telling you what they believe you want to hear, or what they want to believe is true, when you are trying to connect with them. It’s like they can’t produce authentic emotion, but they are highly astute at recognizing emotion in others. They try to mirror it back, but it’s just not quite right.
I’m watching this on May 9, 2022… in the middle of their high profile case. I can’t believe how she fakes to be this go ‘round versus the previous trial. She is SOBBING with no tears as she gives her recollection of their relationship . We have actual proof she was absolutely abusive to him so your analysis seems to be spot on!!!
The fact that there's people out there genuinely defending her in all this, is downright frightening.
There’s people who defend Jodi arias
@@judgejudyslover touché 👍
@@judgejudyslover go to look at her Instagram on tags you see the people defending her
@@rachelrumsey5277 she disabled the comment section of her post
I guess she knows that we would spam her
If she is the ‘victim’ then why would she be afraid of what we would say?
@@qiesrien ye and if you look at the tags as well it’s nuts
Depp was a good person on set with me. I enjoyed working with him and I'll have his back all the way.
I guess his debt his paid? You guys on good terms? (Dead man's chest reference)
Yess Davy hahaha help our capitain xD
@@nope9858 Of course we are. I mean Disney was planning a sequel with me returning but it seems that it will no longer happen with Johnny gone.
@@davyjones5902 good cause no depp no sequel
Lmfaoooo
It was observed in his USA testimony that the small smile he gives while recalling things is part of his baseline. Maybe because having his finger cut off and the circumstances he is under it is a stress reaction and the fact that having to go through this and having to share what occurred to him are just absurd. He is a very low key genuine and shy person. Also a little old fashioned which is something I like about him alot. He would feel bad even in this situation to have to out a woman and be ashamed that he has ended up in this situation as a man.
Her bared teeth when she‘s going more and more upset and angry … like a dog or a shark, just before biting. That‘s no defending gesture or mimic. That’s pure aggression.
The sad part is. She's an actress. She lies for a living and yet she can't act in this situation. Very interesting.
Well, acting isn't lying. Acting is always blocked out and practiced multiple times. This time she's fucked cause she doesn't have a script XD Too bad she didn't get to practice her lines for this interview
Jcs criminal psychology they will help you understand
@@granttrashman5466 And to see how bad she was at it, it just confirm that she's a bad actress..
She's a terrible actress haha her only "talent" is having an attractive exterior
Remember… shes a good actor guys😉……….k
the lawyer: "cut! Amber that was horrible you're supposed to be an actor, can we get another take of that? I did not believe you at all"
HA.. Ha.. Ha .. Ha ! PERFECTLY SAID 👏👏👏👏very very clever
@Roman Caesar That's pretty common now😂😆
Glad they didn't have kids. She would have used them as a weapon.
@@adawhite1382 don’t be surprised if she’s pregnant by the VA trial. This woman will go to any lengths for any kind of sympathy or just PUBLIC approval.. it’s almost a forgone conclusion at this point
🤣🤣🤣🤣
The eating always bugged me too. How completely disrespectful and contemptuous.
She was nodding yes on "do you understand the question" and answering 'no' on "have you committed domestic violence against JD". But yeah the two should not mix like that. She did that again in the courtroom on the question if the song they played in the car was meant for Johnny. Nodding Yes while saying "No that's ridiculous". I guess it took her by surprise, she had no idea she was that transparent.
The facts that she is a actress and can't act at all says a lot about her. She is totally disrespectful.
Most actors tend to get roles that end up actually being their personality so they don't need to act much. Guess that's AH situation lol
It says more about the industry if you ask me... she IS gorgeous...
She probably had to do 100 retries for each scene shes that bad at acting
To be fair, acting for the screen to portray a fictional character is a very, very different proposition to making a lie credible in real life. Acting generally runs off an internally-consistent prepared script that runs to a known conclusion, and doesn't deviate much from it, and everything in the film supports the fiction.
Lying in real life involves improvised responses to questions that are not scripted, and the other players in the scene are doing all they can to derail any notional script you may have in your head and root out all the inconsistencies with identifiable facts. And there's no screenwriter, script editor, or director to make the scene support the fiction; facts are facts. People who think they can act their way through this are living in a fool's paradise even if they've got several Oscars on the shelf -- and Amber's nowhere near that calibre.
Acting skills are a very poor preparation for this -- especially if you're trying to apply them where they aren't going to work.
It's not that simple. I never get the "their an actor" arguement as an actor 😂 like you have weeks sometimes MONTHS to prepare for a role. And even then you're acting/living the role but there's an element of you within it. Plus you usually rehearse for hours on end with a director guiding and correcting you. I doubt she bothered to do any of that for this interview, and even if she did, it would never be to the same extent as it would be for a show, movie, or play.
Johnnys smiling could be a sign of anxiety. I've smiled and even laughed after being in bad situations. And it wasn't that I thought it was funny, but couldn't process my anxiety in those moments. It's a coping mechanism. And it's actual common in those who suffer or have suffered from mental/physical abuse.
True I have a friend with health issues and whenever she gets bad news she starts to laugh.
I also have a friend who smiles and laughs when she is experiencing negative emotions. It is often a result of being raised in an environment where negative emotions are not welcome and/or are met with aggression.
But we are watching a man and I see some cultural attitude showing through as well. Some of the old, "I'm a man and I can't show how much this has deeply affected me", attempt at being/seeming cavalier about the things that he's actually suffered from his own wife.
This isn't meant as a criticism. It's an acknowledgement that those attitudes remain embedded, even in progressive adults who move in liberal circles.
I was raised in a very very healthy environment - i.e. never been abused, really great parents/family, etc. (very lucky and blessed in that regard). I’ve definitely smiled when hearing terrible news. I assume it’s a coping mechanism of some sort. Also, when I’m watching a movie that is intensely scary, for some reason, I laugh. Happened in the theatre during Open Water and again during A Quiet Place, which was super embarrassing (if you’ve seen A Quiet Place - you’ll understand why. It’s mostly silent and you could hear a pin drop in the theatre. And then I start laughing. People probably thought I was a some sort of psychopath.)
@@miket9563 Is it disbelief that makes you laugh?
@@suet.r.4815 not sure if you’re asking about the tragic news smile reaction or the scary movie laugh. The tragic news one I think is just being overwhelmed and possibly disbelief is part of it. The scary movie laugh I think is some sort of emotional or mental release valve.
12:41 this is a lie that has come out now. Even in the court she admits that, here, Johnny was actually hiding from her and not trying to enter a room
If I had been that judge, the food would have landed in the bin after 10 seconds. Or rather, I would have said, if you absolutely need to eat, we’ll take a 30minute recess.
Imagine eating during an interrogation because you don’t wanna own up to your abusive tendencies. Can’t believe this case is still going, All the evidence is honestly right here.
Even Jeffery Epstein didn't eat in his! I think that really reeeaaalllly says something about her.
It’s a comforting technique clearly. When you’re talking about being abused... the last thing you’re thinking about is fucking food 🤔
This is a deposition not an interrogation, she’s not a criminal suspect so she was allowed food, criminal interrogations are totally different and performed by investigators not lawyers.
Ikr? I can’t even believe eating while on the stand is allowed? That in itself is insane to me.
@@IndefiniteMark no it's not comfort eating. He's right in saying she was likely advised to bring food up there in order to stall for time when she's asked a difficult question. This is evident because she reacts completely differently on two separate occasions to having food in her mouth when asked a question - when she is asked a question she finds easy to answer, she speaks with her mouthful, but a difficult question prompts her to make a huge show of trying to chew so she can answer as if she doesn't want to speak with her mouth full.
I'm usually the first to get irritated at the current trend of calling everyone a Narcissiatic/psychopath/sociopath, but on this occasion I believe a diagnosis of narcissist would be accurate.
This is the most unprofessional court hearing I’ve ever seen. Eating, yelling, and lawyers fighting. What!?
Thank you all for the likes and thank you some for clearing up some stuff about dispositions. Very helpful 😁
Wait they went to court I thought they were in a circus
Like a movie.
Some adults are simply overgrown children
It's a deposiation. I'm not sure it counts as 'in court' the same way, and doesn't exactly need to even be in a courthouse. Granted I'm not in the legal field, so I'm not sure if it's a state thing, but I have seen deposistions before with food (trail mix, or pastries), and drinks (water, coffee, OJ) that were done far away from courthouses.
Not defending her, or how this all went down, I do agree that she seems like she's using eating to buy time for answers. It could have even been her lawyers advice, or could have even provided it to her for that reason.
i was just thinking that.
It's liking watching a 5 yr old lying to her parents. Does she think this is a joke? I'm sorry but there are consequences for your actions.
Its absolutely DISGUSTING & INFURIATING that she is just chomping away during LEGAL PROCEEDINGS. It disgusts me because watching people eat in just vile, but also how deliberately defiant it appears.
I like to try to see both sides of the argument in situations like this and my gut is usually accurate. My gut feeling has never been so overwhelming about a single person!
Here's what I think, she wanted to get away with the abuse she's done. There's audio of her yelling at him, and in an interview or court recording (cant recall which it was) she owned up to hitting him. He said she hit him in the face so her response was "I slapped you and it wasn't even that hard". ABUSE IS STILL ABUSE. Men can be abused too.
bob cult bob cult
Men are abused too, I’ve seen it. And don’t forget they get manipulated too by women. Ps I am a female for if y’all come at me thinking I am a man lol
Yea woman kinda downgrade men...on social media and shit i hv seen it alot but well both do its not nice that both genders do that. Also why do woman think that if u slap a boy and bully him kinda its not abuse but if it happens to us girls its violence and the person ahould go in jail Idk about u but its kinda annoying thats why i dont think about genders when i meet a person i just think of them as a person
He also had a pic of him in the er with his finger cut which he said was from her as well
Why is it always men can be abused TOO. Why are you not advocating for domestic violence instead of crying about it on TH-cam?
I think Amber Heard overestimated her own acting "abilities."
Lol
Underrated comment. And very accurate.
Her lawyer says these things are not relevant to the case constantly but how could they get any more relevant.
😂🤣 “there was whispering…. I can’t answer cuz they’re whispering”.
The way you said that!😂😂😂🤣
I couldn't help but roll my eyes when amber said that Johnny was being too dramatic. That's one of the most common things abusers say to trivialize and downplay the severity of their actions.
Yes. She is projecting. She is a drama-queen and textbook narcissist/sociopath.
100% agree. Gaslighting is the weapon of an abuser.
Narcissism and gaslighting at its finest! 😒
Textbook gaslighting. She’s trying to make him feel irrational, so he starts questioning himself. She’s completely unhinged.
My mother abused me between the ages 7-23 to the point that I have had multiple skull fractures. When I finally confronted her about it she called me dramatic and that it wasn't abuse because "It wasn't like it happened every day"
that‘s not how a victim behaves. she‘s too arrogant, too collected and almost calculated whenever she‘s not stumbling over her bad excuses. i can‘t believe anyone in that court room seriously believed what she was saying.
well said
And even after stumbling over her words she still messed it up with "I don't know which body part i put between *me* and her"
She thinks she's so perfect she can get away with doing whatever she wants
"for the sake of study we're going to continue to beat this dead horse"
I will NEVER see any of her shows. Ever.
Anyone else pick up how she said she put herself in between Whitney and Johnny and then slipped up and said Whitney was the one in between Amber and Johnny? Inconsistencies all over the place
She is such a bad liar. I would expect her to be better at her craft as an actress. I cannot see her passing an audition for a commercial, much less a movie role.
thats why her career never took off
PureSparkles22 I only know her for Aquaman
She's wooden in every role I've seen her. She gets cast because she is pretty set dressing. It's sad and sexist, but if she wasn't as pretty, she wouldn't have even the sliver of career that she has.
Danielle Németh yepppp💯
I found the same with Denise Richards on RHBH. I thought, girl you should really be better at this.
Johnny looks at Amber the same way a dog looks at their abusive owner when they have an accident in the house. It’s the “please don’t hit me, please please don’t be mad” look. It’s stomach turning. Amber is pure evil, you can just feel it.
Exactly! And the way he clearly copes with his trauma by joking...
@@percy_coro_cos Ugh, I know!🥺 I had narcissistic parents and I did that a lot too. My heart breaks for Johnny, I just hope he has a support system that can help him realize none of this is his fault😢
I kind of disagree... I don't think he looks at her like a dog looks at an abusive owner... I think he looks at her like a dog who's kinda looking for instructions on what to do which would be normal in a pet-owner relationship... not a loving relationship between adult humans
@@murderm0mmy666 exactly.
I hope you are in a better place.
I’m watching this in 2022 as the trial is going on, and I do have to give props to her legal team for the amazing coaching job they did. If she acted in court the way she did in this deposition, there wouldn’t even be a case. Now that’s not to say that I think she’s doing a great job at trial now, but for the legal team to have dealt with this condescending, snarky, can’t-put-a-coherent-sentence together mess and turn it into what we see in court today, well that must’ve taken a whole lot of work. So props to them. Honestly though, there is so much of her mannerisms (the boredom, the contempt, the snarkiness, the eating) and words (the fact that she can’t seem to put a coherent sentence together or answer a question point blank) that just doesn’t make sense. Now I have no idea what went on in their marriage, none of us do cause we weren’t there, but I do find it extremely interesting that there are so many comments from people that have had horrible trauma and abuse that don’t believe she is the victim. I have yet to see a single domestic abuse survivor comment that they believe her. I find that very interesting.
I've been through DV.. I do believe he started the abuse with when she said he slapped her after asking about his tattoo and she didn't know if he was joking. I also believe he cut his own finger off in a drug fuelled psychosis and he us lying she did it by throwing a bottle. On the other hand I do believe she is definitely make up some stories and lies too. JD is not the victim hes managing to convince the world he is. He wrote horrible things about her before even marrying her and described his ex wife in message as a money grabbing french cunt. No Amber's no saint, but I think she's probably quite tough. Probably something JD met his match in.. theyre both bad as eachother I think.
Absolutely rude and disrespectful-she feels this is beneath her. What a piece of work!
A friend of mine who survived domestic abuse and in my opinion, is a fucking superhero said something very important to me when we got into this conversation.
She said and I am paraphrasing, “I hate Amber Heard for a much different reason than others. It’s fine to dislike her because she’s ruining the life of your favourite actor but I have had people start to doubt my truth because of this one bad woman. What happened to me is being called into question by some because of this woman’s actions and her lies. And she is still allowed to preach about women’s rights all the time”.
[im concerned that she publicly] represents *human* rights
_so much love to your indeed superhero friend_
It's repulsive that she's a spokesperson for the metoo movement.
I honestly think this too when people lie about being raped. Now rape victims ain't taken seriously due to people like Amber and others.
Edit: Yes I know she's lying about domestic abuse but it's the same phrasing with rape too.
Bless your friend for all that she went through. Hopefully she finds the happiness she deserves.
I'm a survivor and that's my biggest issue too. The amount of doubt that this sort of thing brings to actual survivors of abuse is enormous. It's already hard enough to deal with the trauma without being questioned about the validity of that trauma every 5 seconds.
When Johnny does his little half smile while recounting his story, my heart broke. Having gone through a bunch of trauma in my life I had a really hard time finding people to listen for this exact reason. I end up smiling or awkwardly laughing when recounting my experiences because it feels too heavy when I try and get through it straight faced.Not to mention it makes other people uncomfortable when you're too serious for too long about something like this. And if people are uncomfortable they stop listening. I 100% believe that he was the victim.
Me too. I was in partial hospitalization a couple years ago and would laugh and joke and make fun of myself while talking about wishing I would die, and I’m not even sure why I do that I hate it because it really makes me seem flippant and downplays how I really feel. People need to understand that not everyone acts exactly the same.
@@MaleficentHipster I'm really sorry that you've had to go through that. I know how it feels and it sucks. It's really hard, but finding someone who gets what's going on makes all the difference.
I had a friend growing up who laughed when she was scared. It was heartbreaking when people got angry with her, because she would start compulsively smiling and chuckling, which they would read as mockery, making them angrier, making her more scared, leading to more laughter. They of course wouldn't see her break down crying after they stormed away in a rage. I don't really blame them for how they felt. It was just awful. Sometimes those of us who knew her would have some success intervening, but there isn't always someone who knows you standing right there you know.
Yep, I do the same thing. Makes it hard to talk about things because people think I'm lying
I do that as well, and my friends are always like "don't do that, that's messed up", but you know... I've always used humor as a coping mechanism
I know a fellow that stuttered as a child and one of his learnt strategies was to a deliver slow responses, often avoiding the more difficult letter pairings which meant he would search for preferred words. When you hear Johnny in tapes where he is being abused by her his stuttering becomes more and more pronounced. just a thought
Eating is also a sign of disrespect and contempt for the court.
This is hard to get through. Not because of him, but Amber is just incredibly infuriating. Her lies, her mannerisms, and her freaking facial expressions. Just her being. I hope Depp gets his justice and her career finally goes down the toilet after circling the damn bowl for far too long.
She’s a narcissist. Narcissistic folk are some of the most obnoxious and annoying people to put up with. So much bullshit and mental gymnastics to deal with, it’s irritating and exhausting 😑
It should if only for the fact that according to this deposition she's a terrible actress.
She will thrive still. People love to idolize piece of shits I’ve noticed.
I want to see people cancel this woman with twice the force and speed they instantly destroy Johnny Depp over a mere accusation without evidence. There's full evidence she's an abuser and doesn't care and NOBODY cares. She's ruined his life.
Dude, that eye roll she had was so over the top I thought she was having a stroke.
Whenever I speak about a traumatic/hurtful experience I tend to look down and do a “half smirk”, but it’s always been a defense mechanism for me. I do it bc it stops me from having the urge to cry or get emotional. So I genuinely believe Johnny Depp when he recounts his experience.
He has also always been uncomfortable public speaking and interviews and uses humor (usually self deprecating) to deflect from his discomfort. He’s only actually well spoken when he has a script.
I don't know what happend to you and I'm so sorry it happened but yeah, whenever I feel as if the trauma is coming back or I just wanna defend myself obviously when I'm right, I tend to get really nervous, my palms get sweaty and I tend to lose my words
I might inappropriately laugh... More of a hollow, shocked gesture.
I do the same thing. I actually recall often when recounting or simply speaking about certain subjects with others I tend to look down and half smirk a lot, especially if I feel that I might cry half smiling and a little laughter is usually my go to for some reason
i sometimes laugh when trying to say something about my trauma, obviously I do not believe it is funny but its just a way to stop the crying.
Your analysis turned out to be spot on. Amber is the abuser and thankfully the jury didn't buy her act.
I find it hilarious how she thinks she’s the smartest person in every room. She tried the same in the court room
How dare she play victim. I grew up watching my dad endure my mom’s abuse. I hope Johnny can one day heal from this all.
How about justice for Johnny first
@@agz2801 what
@@agz2801 ??? The commenter was just stating one of their experiences similar to the current situation
I'm sorry that Happened to ur dad. Did ur dad get help? Or justice how is he and you????
My mom is the same. She even threatened to kill herself when She got angry at me( for being outisde while it was raining)
It sounds like the writers of riverdale wrote everything Amber said.
Bye✋🏼
Omg this is too true 😂
This is too accurate
Very true. The show is so over the top...... And yet here I am watching it.
@@yourfriendlyneighborhoodal5856 I stopped watching it after season 3, bc it started getting really weird
It's interesting that so many of us can see she's lying without knowing the reasons why we know. It's neat that you explain the "whys". I've learned so much & trust my instincts even more now. Thank you for what you do!!!
I think he's (Depp) is making those facial expressions because for a long time he'd been lying about how things happened.
So he's got to look through the lies he's been telling to protect her.
He's also an arty type who uses words very specifically.
why is she even allowed to eat
Calm thyself we agree she is a awful person, we need justice.
@@saramuresan9305 I think they meant why is she allowed to eat during the interview
Unicorn maiden wtf, reading comprehension 9999
@@aysitalownatlanch1052 Hahahahah
Seriously!!! It looks SOOOOO disrespectful!!!