I want to say something..... Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity.... By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ? Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... th-cam.com/video/TnvzNFf6V44/w-d-xo.html here is the link of the video made by professor hc verma iitk I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya" You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths Our rich culture had everything But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
@@powerenergy3480 so??? Kahi ka neta to nhi ban gya na, jo ye bta rha h, Pta bhi h youtube ne comment kyun delete mara because usme link tha, aur youtube bahut sare cheejon ko censor karta h abhi comment section me, Bhalai ka jamana hi nhi h
Divine years related to Yuga mentioned as satyuga treta dwapar n kalyuga 12000 years = 360 human years not years for jugg while jugg value in Tulsi das is 12000 years this video misinterpreted between yug n jugg check your facts n research 😂😂😂😂😂😂 everyone debunked u who has a knowledge on Hindu texts 😇✌️ lots of love to science dope make sure u show true knowledge Hari om 🙏
Yojan etc units mentioned in Vedas book ...4Ved books in Hindu..Very old books Era and era passed then Hanuman chalisa came which is also old ... "Panchang" in Vedas describe sun/moon eclipse which is accurate ☺️In India only 0.5$ book available,Vedas -earth shapes, rotation and other 9 planets with 3D situation also rotation direction...medical,music,etc written in Vedas...You need to learn ..Go and search about Vedas ...Clear ur concept bro... Knowledge is good things 😀
So they changed the unit of yojana in the Hanumanchalisa to make it correct and match the modern value. That's like a school student changing his 9 marks to 90 marks.
I want to say something..... Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity.... By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ? Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya" You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths Our rich culture had everything But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
I facepalmed myself when in the movie he says "Hanuman Chalisa jaisi pracheen kitaab". The HC was written in the 16th century in the Awadhi language of UP (not Sanskrit, contrary to what many believe). The 16th century is not "pracheen" at all. It's very much considered modern history.
@@Chudan-lal-chunnisource mr. gaali hurling sanskari anonymous? Also, your comment in no way refutes what I said. The fact that it was written in the 16th century doesn't make it pracheen at all.
@@nashtrashcool and the misinformation part being? I know it's the Awadhi language because I live in the region where it's spoken and it's well documented that it was written in the 16th century.
I want to add that mathematicians and scientists of India like Aryabhatta, who wrote on the specific subject of astronomy got to the value of distance between the sun and Earth which was inaccurate by several degrees, but Tulasi Das who neither was a scientist or mathematician or astronomer nor he was writing something on astronomy, gives an accurate value. There is no sense in that.
@ZAP GAMERZ Shudra’ means Dalit, and the quote says, as drums (dhol), illiterates (gawar), animals (pashu) need to be tamed by being beaten up, shudras also must meet the same fate.
@@kentajin7860 shudra actually means someone who provides services to the master. Like barber, carpenter, Smith, shepherd, etc. They today constitute OBCs. Biggest population of India, you can say working class in terms of European social division of proletariat and feudal lords. Dalits were untouchables, called Avarna at the time, or Acchut. Savarna means those who are part of Varna system, so technically OBCs are also also Savarna only lower in the hierarchy, also remember that there was no Hindu religion.... It was was a name give by Arabs to connote a piece of land. And Sanatan is just modern day propaganda to counter anti caste narrative throughout history
I want to say something..... Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity.... By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ? Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... th-cam.com/video/TnvzNFf6V44/w-d-xo.html here is the link of the video made by professor hc verma iitk I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya" You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths Our rich culture had everything But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
I want to say something..... Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity.... By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ? Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya" You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths Our rich culture had everything But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
I want to say something..... Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity.... By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ? Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya" You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths Our rich culture had everything But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
This is basically what I told my friends when I was asked about this. Specially, the unit being incorrect is far bigger a blow to this theory than people realize it. 12000 years is also 144000 months, so why don't use that number? Or maybe call it 1000 dozen years!!! You can convert it into so many values, the answer completely changes! For a Mathematician/ Physician, this theory is completey stupid just based on the fact that units don't match!!
The reason why it has so many values could be that Indian knowledge was never institutionally standardized unlike in west who did a great effort to standardize it. If you look at history of a mile (1 mile), once a 1 mile was equal to 2.1 kilometers and another time it was something else. But they did lot of effort to standardize things eventually. Secondly, there is no theory here , it's just one statement to represent mightiness of Lord Hanumana in those verses. Since much of Indian knowledge was lost (burnt) we would never know what was the original theory & what unit is used. The kind of standardization that happened in Europe about science unfortunately never happened in India which I believe is the biggest failure of Indian body of knowledge. ( Edited, thanks to @AVS G) Note: I"m open to possibility that I could be wrong & the calculation in verses might be arbitrary. I"m only saying that, argument that "the unit is different at different times it must mean theory is invalid" is insufficient as theories / units etc were never institutionally standardized.
@@omikumar7028 the biggest failure of “indian” science (i.e. the “science” in mythological texts) is that it doesn’t follow scientific method. That’s the long and short of it. There are many such claims in other world religions as well and science doesn’t take them seriously either. If any of it had followed scientific method, then it would not be “Indian”, or “Islamic” or “Christian” science anymore. It would just be Science.
@@avsg2427 Totally Agree, I should have used the word "Indian body of knowledge" instead of science. as that body of knowledge could never developed into rigorous science, it remained a gray mix of spirituality & some rudimentary logic.
this is incorrect. that's because you have 0 experience on any of the hindu texts. 1 Yuga basically equals 12k divine years and has been used in this context multiple times. now you might ask why not use months for 1 yuga. this is like asking why do most of the books mention a decade as being 10 years and not in any other unit.
Read "Demon Haunted World - Science as a candle in the dark" by Carl Sagan. You can watch Cosmos (1980), Tree of Life by David Attenborough, Many other shows and books by richard dawkins.
@@anshuraj1740 I admit to class 11th late after this chapter and vector . My teacher was teaching kinematics . I was busy in crop reaping and harvesting . I studied it with kinematics and my teacher helped me .
Amazing mahn! not only you debunk the misconceptions but also teach and provide explanation for actual methods and how we were able to do it! thats what I really appreciate about you. keep it up! ignore all the hate and keep being awsome!
I want to say something..... Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity.... By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ? Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya" You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths Our rich culture had everything But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
I want to say something..... Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity.... By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ? Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya" You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths Our rich culture had everything But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
This video is a result of Opinion bias and lack of scriptural understanding. 1. You lost credibility when you multiplies 12,000 with 360 claiming 12,000 is divya yuga . firstly there are different types of yugas such as Manu yuga , divya yuga , daiva yuga , brahma yuga and soo on . Divine yugas when compared to yuga of Manu , you dont have to multiply if with 360 , 12000 it is. 2. Tulsi Ramayan mentions hanuman when flying around earth covers 3300 yojan . 33000 *12= 39,600 ( approx ) . while modern calculations of circumfrence of earth is pretty close at 40000. Therefore 1 yojan has to taken 12 cm . This cant be a mere co incidence that Tulsi das is using yojan to descibe to values that match pretty much with present day calculations . Please don't delete my comments
@@themysteryschool-bro you are slow lmao learn how physics works. Vanishing the time frame for no reason doesn't make any sense regardless of your yuga yojna blah blah lmao
@@AmmarMuslimm whattt?? madarse se science and Sanatan seekhne ka anjaam😂🤡 first of all hanuman kept the sun in his mouth and did not swallow or destroy it so its gravitational pull was not affected...secondly please stop trying so hard to prove Sanatan wrong because truth cant be suppresed...uk why Sanatan survived around 800 yrs of mughal tyranny and 200 yrs of british rule? because Sanatan is eternal. do you want me to speak upon the scientific mistakes of quran or pisslam?
Appreciate your efforts brother. Our country had a long tradition of complete materialists, agnostics and non-believers (charvakas). But time and time again political and religious groups had destroyed that philosophy and the texts associated with it. If those texts of ancient atheists/agnostics were still around we would have debunked a lot of misconceptions.
In ancient Bharat/Aryavarth there used to be shastrath(well-organised debates & discussions) between scholars regarding various issues. This was even boosted by Nyaya Darshan of Gautam Muni. Charvaka darshan gained popularity but lost debates to Adi -Shankara (including the Jains) and the decline of atheistic philosophy started. More analytically the charavaka Darshan (including athiestic darshanas of Bauddhas and Jainas) were point by point refuted by debunked (including the false claims made regarding vaidic dharma by their propagartors and clearance of misconceptions) by Rishi Dayanand Saraswati in the 19th century .
I want to say something..... Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity.... By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ? Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya" You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths Our rich culture had everything But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
I want to say something..... Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity.... By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ? Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya" You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths Our rich culture had everything But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
When such devotional texts were written, i doubt anyone thought that it would someday be possible to verify such metrics. It was mostly meant as a placeholder for a great distance or a massive size to put things in perspective within that literary context. While i absolutely admire you Pranav for putting in massive effort for such content, i believe that there are very few 'fence sitters' in this specific regard. Most of your viewers are ones who anyway don't take such things at face value and a much smaller portions who will defend it tooth and nail. Sorry for the long post, just wanna say keep it up! Science is dope :)
His followers are not fence sitters, but his videos are open to all, and once in a while it catches the algorithm and gets recommended to not so bright indians and then starts the negative comments.
@@shahan484 Indians should strive for dominance and strive to redesign the world in India's image. That's where religion which is essentially culture comes in as a part of indian identity.
12000 yug x 1000sahstra x 8yojan mile= 96000000 96000000x1.6 =153,600,000km Distance to sun=149,600,000km Difference=4,000,000km Satyug= 17,28,000 Tretayug= 12,96,000 Dvapuryug= 864,000 Kalyug= 432,000 None of them are 12000. And they're multiplying time to distance.
Said it in the chat will say it here too; Gen Z wants to validate their religious beliefs with science so they don't feel bad about being religious, it's still some crazy mental gymnastics they have to do in order to achieve that and sadly many grifters are taking advantage of this. All the debunking is well and good but the problem is deep rooted with personal identity and lack of purpose in modern Indian society.
Lack of purpose what do you mean humans are without purpose just expect the fact and enjoy life without religious crap Religion is the worst thing happened to world
@@Nemo25599 stole my word. basically nobody has any answers to life everyone is just as lost as the most religious my personal belief is we don't have a purpose of life we have to experience everything and do what we like or turn what to you like to the purpose of your life
@@Andy2kk there is not a 1 bad thing about hinduism and theres not a 1 good thing about abrahmic faiths. just bcoz abrahmic faiths are bad doesnt mean you put hinduisma in same category with those malecchas
Few points I want to highlight. 0) Tulsidas wrote in Awadhi between, late 15CE - early 16CE. जुग सहस्त्र जोजन पर भानू। लील्यो ताहि मधुर फल जानू।। The language is Awadhi, spoken in UP Awadh region. Cassini discovered the distance around 1670 (late 16CE). Considering, India was quite good at mathematics especially in Geometry, I believe that, there would have been some calculations done in India Subcontinent, which was actually quoted by Tulsidas. It can be a period of 100-200 years. There is a history of Europeans, stealing literary work and destroying history of their colonies. So it can be a case. 1) Issue with assumption @8:37 The book simply assumes different yuga's as Golden, Bronze, Silver and Iron ages. This brings me to 2nd point, 2) The original book was published in year 1935 (Before Independence), copy is in University of Calcutta. Writer, is of English Origin. The book is written by Rev. EBENEZER BURGESS a Formerly Missionary of the A.B.C.F.M. (American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions) in India. You want me to believe on a translation of a Missionary. Isn't that contradictory. A missionary, really. One who believes, earth is flat. How could you belive on such translations. Offcoure the book has been cited by a Mathematician, but wait, a Mathematician, and Sanskrit, they don't go along. 3) Yojan: The unit Mile has quite a history of change. Read it here: www.britannica.com/science/mile Now comming to the thing, surya sidhanta mentions it as 5 miles, some mention it as 4 mile, some mention it as 8 miles, some as 6. The thing is that, we exacltly don't know, what was the acceptable value of mile at the time it was written. The Question why it is written as just 1 yojan. If they were just estimating randomly, it could have been 10, 43, or half yojan, 100. There are n number of possibilities. Why it is written as 1200. Even If they are fitting values, how come values mentioned in past, fits. Like, what is the probability, that we use some values from past to fit a narative. 4) Yuga's have different values, with respect to the yuga in which you are. 1200 * 360 is clearly mentioned as 'Total Duration of a yuga'. When you are multiplying it with 360.... it is a the duration of a yuga, i.e., total solar year in a yuga. Kali yuga is basically 1200 divine Years (Yuga). I am open for a discussion on this topic. Hope you do some in depth research. I too seek Truth.
Your argument is too vague ok tell me why multiplication. Why not any other arithmetic operations. It is not mentioned anywhere to multiply. Your answer to why 12000 year is totally wrong. They asked why 12000 year not any other value. In science we use dimensions or metrics to know the value . In any calculation if we take light speed as km/hr then answer will come according to that if we take light speed in m/s then answer will also come according to that but the answers denote the same thing only metrics are different. But here can you relate the answer if we take that time as a divine year or month? So go kiddo and learn science first. Lastly the Hanuman chalisa we are reading written in 16 th century (1600-1700) not 15-16ce.
just the time pranav uses to produce videos itself shows how much he puts the effort in research. Not like our ayurveda youtubers who read few pages and make new claims every other day.
I think best way to tell if the if Tulsi Das was right or not is by getting what was the value of Yuga and Yojna during Mughals time. Taking surya samantha or Ashoka would be metrices for tulsi das would be highly inaccurate. Why? Simply because there was difference of more than 500 years. Plus most Indian universities like in Nalanda or Taxila or records existing had been burned or destroyed during Sultanats and Mughal eras. I think alot of research hasn't been done to in Hindu in scriptutes and artifacts related to hindi faith as for other religion. Most of our findins and translation we have till now is based on British- archaeological findings.
If a writer like Tulsidas had known the units he was using then sure it would have been a common knowledge among scientists of the time. It's not difficult to find that, 16th century isn't stone age. There are enough written material from the times. Newton had proposed laws of motion by the time. Your way of thinking isn't scientific as much as you would want to believe while commenting this. There are more than overwhelming logic (forget evidence) to suggest that there wasn't any accurate way to measure such great distance at the time but you would still curate some mystery around it just so you could be write... Third thing British stated this extensive way if scientific findings in the country. Let's not discourage anything because British stated it, as much as I hate colonization but I am not emotional about it. British used to ask things from Brahmins for scriptures and they often made extraordinary claims and glorified scripture. One of the biggest is that when British asked Brahmin to recognize script from Ashoka damma, they called it Brahma scrip, which do not have any mention in the history. So I think yes, there is lot misinterpretation of scripture, but I see it the other way round. There is so much wasteful glorification that needs to be shed after though scientific study by unbiased people, probably not upper castes... (Not necessarily) Last Takshila and Nalanda weren't Hindu schools. They were Buddhist schools. But since it was university they allowed everybody there, even foreigners. Brahmin were welcomed. It wasn't mughals who destroyed it, read about it.... But anyway. We don't know how they reached there. Muslim foreign ruler at the time invaded only for loot and there was no wealth to be looted from Nalanda. Then why would they destroy it. ??? What was the motive ? There is an article that tells story how brahmins were plotting against Nalanda and they had some deal with these invaders and they helped them walked into such distant land of Ganga plains, which wasn't possible at the time
@@NileshKumar-nr2vj It's funny to hear someone claiming that Britishers took words of Brahmins by heart and wrote everything as said by Brahmins(who confidently forgot calling Buddhist, Jain and Sikh preachers XD). While you who read all so many fancy conspiracy theories forgot to read that Britishers didn't even took a word of any Indian and read every language like Tamil, Sanskrit themselves to translate them in there language. Proof? Well if you consider ever reading Hindu scriptures in Sanskrit you'll know that Hinduism is a Monoesthetic religion with one being the ultimate we call Brahman(now don't confuse with Brahmin) there are not thousands of gods in Hinduism but only 33 originated from him, so how it got all messed up? Because as I said metrics got changed as time passed the word Koti which meant supreme got mixed up with crores so when the British learned Sanskrit they saw it as Crores which was then prevalent meaning. I know you'll not take my word but some people on net who themselves never have read Sanskrit in there lives to interpret history but if you have brains so just Google who all under British regime translated Indian scriptures, you'll see hotshots like Sir William Jones never took words of any Indian for granted read everything on its own, applied his own logic to things and served it to people. And you who hate Brahmins so much if you ever consider having time to read scriptures like Jaya( or Mahabharat as we often misinterpret it) read how despite Karna being declared as sudra(untouchable) got accepted into high society as soon as Duryodhan made him king. Simple fact to prove how the Caste system was a class system that became rigid because people stopped switching their job profiles. A simple take we still carry it on never focussed on it but you'll find people relentlessly looking for evidence to plot Brahmins for everything despite when every historical finding shows Brahmins lived in utmost poverty. It's same as US where certain group of people are being targetted for every hate crime. This is called victim card, just keep up the heat do whatever is necessary to put blame on one set of people, never to solve the problem just big talks, big conspiracy theories. I have read many articles how Hitler survived WWII, lived his life near US and created KKK. Go on you'll find one. There are alot of findings that claim Gandhi could had possibly prevented killing of Bhagat Singh if he wanted. P.S: Sorry for my poor English, you see I spend more time reading and learning Sanskrit to understand the actual meaning of scriptures rather than quoting the text of some Communist Historian who has the next brilliant English understanding and poor other language understanding. Also if you ever get time pls tell me the names of Scientists you referred who could had verified metrics used by Tulsi das during Mughal rule and pls don't tell some Muslim scientist because they never read and wrote in Awadhi or Sanskrit.
It makes me very happy to see your work. When I was in school I obsessively watched a TH-cam channel called "It's okay to be smart" which is now named "Be smart". It's host created such good content that I found myself immersed in the world of science all day long. At that time there were no Indian TH-cam channels creating content similar to his. But now there is. Your content has differences but it still is rigorous in its research just as those American channels are. Hope your channel keeps growing and contributing to a scientifically literate India.
This video is a result of Opinion bias and lack of scriptural understanding. 1. You lost credibility when you multiplies 12,000 with 360 claiming 12,000 is divya yuga . firstly there are different types of yugas such as Manu yuga , divya yuga , daiva yuga , brahma yuga and soo on . Divine yugas when compared to yuga of Manu , you dont have to multiply if with 360 , 12000 it is. 2. Tulsi Ramayan mentions hanuman when flying around earth covers 3300 yojan . 33000 *12= 39,600 ( approx ) . while modern calculations of circumfrence of earth is pretty close at 40000. Therefore 1 yojan has to taken 12 cm . This cant be a mere co incidence that Tulsi das is using yojan to descibe to values that match pretty much with present day calculations . Please don't delete my comments
@@themysteryschool- so you decide which yojan is by reverse calculating. You already knew earth circumference and then you reverse calculate it to fit in your yojan value.
@underground leaks 101 kam se kam hum sawal utha sakte hai tabhi main yeh science is dope ki video dekhta hu aur accept bhi karta hu tumhari tarah nahi ki koi kitab ko asmani kitab bol kar uss par andha vishwas Karu tum toh sawal bhi nhi utha sakte apni Qur'an par agar uthaoge toh tumhare ghar wale hi maar denge tumhe . Kyuki tum chutiyo ko toh yahi lagta hai allah tumhe jannat dega kisi ko marne Katne par
Just yesterday this friend of mine who is an mtech from IIT was trying to convince me on this. But after that he started talking about advanced ancient civilizations and thei super advanced tech and some dumb quantum time travel and aliens so i just went back home 🤷🏻♂️. And apparently this is very common in these it bros in Bengaluru. They see little videos about science and start making up theories without doing the math 😅
@@archit1048 seriously he made a diagram of a cube and then started saying shit about 4 dimensions and then went to time travel. And after that they started talking about how ancient civilizations were super advanced . Thankfully i didn't stay for long
You explained the methodology and then debunked the myth…. I don’t know if everyone will get this… but I understood as I am a regular viewer of yours… keep doing this kind of stuff 👍🏻. Great Video as always
I want to say something..... Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity.... By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ? Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya" You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths Our rich culture had everything But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
Boy! I watched all ur videos today and today was the first day I ever watched ur videos! I am a hindu but loved all the debunking! Keep doing ur great work. We need rationality!
Let's look at this formula from unit perspective, for example Distance= speed * time Is the speed is in km/hr and time is in hour then distance Will be measured in KM. Here in Hanuman chalisa we calculate D = 12000 years * 1000 * 8 miles. So my first question is what will be the unit of distance in this case ?? 2nd question is what is 1000 ? Is it constant, and if it is constant what's the logic behind this constant? What is the unit of this constant , because we know every constant have a unit. My 3rd question is why they take 12000 years I mean if we are convert this in months , days then answer will be different.
jaake pehle 1oth paas kar light years is a unit of distance its is yuga idiot its light years pehle thoda padho likho uske baad in sab chizzo ko samjho
@@JEEstattemptrigvedian distance between earth and sun is 8.3 light minutes then in this first stance the Hanuman chalisa is wrong which is stating 12k light years i think u should study 🤣🤣
@@JEEstattemptrigvedian light years? Where does that comes from in measuring distance between Earth and Sun? It takes 8min dude you mean like 8/60*24*365 light years?
Its just an algebraic equation, not a formula that's why we need only numbers not units. In light years also time is multiplied with distance, in the same way here time is multiplied with distance
Science cannot explain everything.......It is still in its evolving state .......Roz naye naye theories aate rehte hai..... Bhaiya ek baar ved padho.....unme bahut advanced mathematics explained hai Sanskrit sloks me...... If you see at our ancient temples , you can surely notice beautiful geometry and many unbelievable carvings......wo sab dekh kr lagega ki hamare ancestors must be mathematics and architecture genius.......their is geometry in each and every ancient Hindu temple....... Please watch Praveen Mohan once......he is a great researcher....
science explains everything that religion couldn't. bcoz of science we have come this far....before 18th century child birth used to be a horror 75-80% women wuth their child used to die while giving birth...but nowadays child birth success rate is 80%. Anywhere you go u will find great historic architecture not in India only.
A lot of believers nowadays try to connect culture and tradition (here Hanuman Chalisa) to science to prove atheists that they are superior. They can’t just keep culture as culture and try to shove nonsense reasoning behind everything into others throat. Great video man… Will love to see more such videos.
I want to say something..... Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity.... By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ? Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... th-cam.com/video/TnvzNFf6V44/w-d-xo.html here is the link of the video made by professor hc verma iitk I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya" You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths Our rich culture had everything But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
I want to say something..... Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity.... By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ? Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya" You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths Our rich culture had everything But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
Bro you are absolutely telling the truth. I am myself a sanatani and i have researched on these topics. The verse actually means "Moving towards the sun which is innumerable/thousands of miles away, with ease as you thought it to be a sweet fruit". And the meaning of sahasra can be translated to both thousands or innumerable. And the meaning of yuga is unification. Some people use this as a proof to show how santan is the truth. But there are texts like aryabhattiya and surya sidhantha which give a logical explanation to find out the distance, diameter, velocity etc of the grahas.
You do realise they are fables told to teach you lessons right? Not to be taken literally. As for distance Tulsidas was pretty accurate. First There is no exact distance mentioned thats why its approximately.. so the distance mentioned by Tulsidas is pretty accurate. It can be coincidence but Tulsidas definitely wins here.. not just that tulsidas also mentions circumference of earth.
Here's what you should do, learn sanskrit, and read vedas by yourself, so that there will be no third person, if u are searching google for it, so let me tell you that, translations of vedas has so many flaws that literally changes the meaning by almost 90deg, I was also same as you, thinking that vedas are just so called written stuff without any actual reason behind it, here's what I did, I learned sanskrit, went to ISKON to get the real versions of vedas and read them, what I found was eye-opening, vedas were so advance that we couldn't understand it till date, how can u search something on google which is not yet discovered or know to humans, ryt. so if u wanna find your answers get back to ancient hindu scriptures speically "suktas" and if are saying that "I don't know sanskrit" then learn it, no point in sitting here listening to some random guy who claims to be a science guru, I bet he can't even prove mathematical thesis by himself, I am not being a hinduism supporter here, I found what I was looking for in vedas and never have to read any other book. good luck, get your study right mate.
8:29 :- The question of considering 1 Yuga as 12,000, and why not as 4,320,000 yrs is absolutely ridiculous. Because whenever we are converting any unit, we do it according to the requirement of the problem. For suppose 1kilometre= 1000 meters , and the same 1km= 1,00,000cm. so here to ask why is 1km= 1000m why not 1,00,000cm is really silly. so here we need to consider 1 yojana as 12,000 yrs only. 7:30 :- The value for 1 yojana in Ashoka time period (304 - 232 BCE) was 4.3 miles. But the value taken in hanuman Chalisa was 8 miles because it was written in 16th century CE. (Different time periods) thus the value for it may change . Different mathematicians of different time period gave different values for a single Unit (Yojana) so we need to consider a value which was taken at that particular time period (16th century CE). The value Tulsidas considered while writing Hanuman Chalisa was 8 miles ( Which was the value accepted by the mathematicians of that particular time period ). (You can also google the value for yojana in google you get 8 miles ). So therefor if we multiply everything we get 9,60,00,000 miles. The Yug (unit for a time period ) is considered to express distance just for the better understanding and for the rhyming of the poem. ( Hanuman chalisa is a poem not a mathematical article to explain the derivation of distance from sun to earth ). If you want any proof for the calculation for the distance from sun to earth you may find it in other books written by the mathematicians (not by poets and not in devotional poems ). Yug sahastra yojan gives the distance from earth to sun which was travelled by hanuman ji. Everything said in the hanuman chalisa is 100% correct. JAI SHREE RAM !!!
Thanks for the information, Akhheel. His Hinduphobia is blatant and obvious. He won't even consider agreeing to anything in favour of Hinduism due to his biasness.
how come a flying monkey, brahma nd other hindu gods couldn't met mohhamad that cut moon in half, jesus, greek gods, egyption gods, etc. how a religion that claims its god 'brahma' made this world couldn't get the image of the planets right? PEAK FICTION!😂 How can every religion claims their hods made this world? PURE BULLSH*T!😂
The reality is that people who believe in supernatural things dont have to do anything with reality and science , even if they are presented with a proof they will still deny it , as evident from this comment section .
Seriously, the research you did is mind blowing, thanks for this information. I still remeber a cartoon during COVID where the main 3 religious priest were standing behind a scientist and it reads "religious ppl are waiting the cure to be discovered to claim that it was alreday written in their HOLY BOOKS" 😂. Keep it up, i gonna download this, who know they might take this down. 😏. Keep it up brother 👍💪😍😍😍
I want to say something..... Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity.... By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ? Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya" You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths Our rich culture had everything But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
@@powerenergy3480 Wooo wo wooo... Hold your power Mr Energy. Thanks for your Half cooked info. And also give some respect to Mr Science is dope, atleast he put his name on the channel and tell everything on face, unlike some Energy guy who hides behind the Power of internet anonymity. 2nd point- we Indians were good at some Old point of time, then we were so much so that, we happily accept our mistakes, eager to learn without having ego, and more over we always try to find our own mistake rather putting Fingers in others eye to show THEIR mistake (for example we india have everything but was destroyed by other countries, we never accept that we Bharatiyas were so devided among MAHARANAS, RAJPUTS, MARATHA, DRAVIDAS, Buddhists, jains, etc etc that we try to kill destroyed each others just to keep supremacy. Yeah that was seen by invaders and they exploited that. POINT IS, IF WE WERE SO DEVELOPED AND WHAT NOT HOW A NON DEVELOPED AND UNCOUTH MUGHALS or Whoever the invaders were invade us, we had something which killed that great Bharata, so admit that we were great as all culture and civilization were, and we had Idiots, backstabbers just the others had, sp don't boast we had everything and someone else destroyed that..) 3rd point, i am really sorry that you happens to passed 9th and 11th standard with half knowledge, "Snth" is the distance travelled by the body in "nth" second, not distance travelled between nth second, so dimension of Snth is not L1, its L1T-1.. Please refer this 9th standard stuff.. brainly.in/question/3321367 And yes we love our country, which is why we think everything on scientific temperament, just the way our old dudes did. Don't be blind by jingoism, have patriotism rather. Hope you listen the entire video, where he explicitly said why the distance calculation was faulty. Go listen that...
forget about sun distance, the idea of a flying ape that could eat a sun itself is so bogus, don’t forget the person transforming into deer to lure sita or the half human half elephant ganesha, these are mythological creatures and should be treated as such
Isn't the distance between The Sun and the Earth different during different times of the year? If I can recall the lessons from school correctly then we're closer to the Sun during summers and farther from it during winters.
Yeah the distance is different at different times. But the last line isn't entirely correct. Firstly it depends on the hemisphere. Since India is in the northern hemisphere and we all know summers are at the peak during June. But it's the opposite for the southern hemisphere where summers are in January. Also, the reason for summer being hotter is not that the earth is closer to the sun, in fact for the northern hemisphere it's quite the opposite. During June July the earth is farther from the sun than it is in January. The reason for temperature being higher in the northern hemisphere during june is the earth's TILT, since the earth is 23.5 degrees tilted from its axis (as you can see in the globe models we get in the market) the sun rays fall more on the northern hemisphere during june due to the earth being tilted TOWARDS the sun.. and the southern hemisphere is tilted away from the sun hence it has winters.. As a visual representation: This slash represents the tilt of the earth / / 🌞 / See on left how the upper part of the slash is tilted towards the sun? That's the northern hemisphere now having summers.. (even though it is farther from the sun as compared to earth during January) And on the right is the earth during January.. see how the lower part of the sun is now towards the sun.. that's southern hemisphere now having summers.. So the distance is not the primary factor for higher temperatures. It's the tilt and the angle at which the sun rays fall and heat up the earth. 😊
Iss Chutiye ne bharbhur praytna kiya ki kaise Sanatan wrong hai lekin ye chutitya ye bhul gaya ki agar 2023 me 1 mile = 3.5 km hai to main 2023 ki hi value lunga na ki 1200 saal pehle ki. Param Pujya Parameshwara ne bhi 8 miles hi liya hai aur Aur ek Angrez tha usne bhi , dusri baat 1200 divya varsha liya to iske baap ka kya gaya ? TULSIDAS JI DIVYA Sant the. Toh divya hi liya jo change nahi hota. Kitna bhi samjhao in Chutiyo ko Angrezo ka Guu hi mitha lagta hai.
Let’s pretend for a moment that Hanuman chaalisa is actually correct about the distance. The Hanuma chalisa is said to composed in 16th century. But no original manuscripts exist for it from 16th century. It is a chalisa. that can be recited in 10 minutes. Yet not even 150 year old manuscript exist for it. On the other hand we still have original handwritten notebooks by Christian Huygens who was the earliest person to come close to the modern known value of distance to sun. Those notebooks are still part of Leiden University archives. We still have 300+ year old palm leaf manuscripts of actual mathematical and astronomical work from Kerala-school mathematicians, no one of them refers to this distance calculation method as in Hanuman Chalisa. Hanuman Chalisa is not a ‘pracheen’ kitaab as claimed by many.
The manuscript doesn't exist because the mughals, britishers and the congress destroyed it because they didn't wanted anyone to know about it. Also they killed every person knew about this to male themselves feel better and greater and to oppress hindus.
europeans got their mathematical and scientific knowledge from bharat through arab traders. you telling me that these maclecchas europeans who were living around garbage dumps till about 15th century could find this? not possible. most prolly this clown transtlated sanskrit texts into his eu lang and burned the original source. same thing newton did. eu should go back to poverty and bharat back to ancient glory.
Manuscripts would have been there if hinduism wasn't exploited from time to time. Books and scriptures wouldn't have been burnt. Western world was powerful hence nobody dared to do so, where as Sanatani's were too flexible.. That is it
I want to say something..... Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity.... By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ? Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya" You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths Our rich culture had everything But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
Hanuman chalisa isn't science. Let alone pseudoscience. There's nothing to debunk here. It's just for devotion and nobody takes it literally. If I say "you're moon to my life" in my poem doesn't mean my partner is my moon and not the actual moon itself. These are just metaphors. Funny how people make money from so called "debunking" the cultural things.
@@sudhakar7889 same way as people make money by fooling innocent people...its reverse of it... Hanuman chalisa is not science but some people falsly claim..and it need to be debunked ... And tell me that u didnt aware of it ..this false claim
@@sudhakar7889 Your entire opinion stipulates this video to be debunking Hanuman Chalisa, which is false per se when looked upon with some logical use of the mind. This video debunks the so called rationality of these conspiracy theories or pseudo-science. Your claim that everybody takes Hanuman Chalisa as no more than just another _bhajan_ contradicts beliefs of several people who found the distance to Sun from Earth using Hanuman Chalisa by illogical and nonconstructive manipulation of SI units and rational inconsistency. Sun to Earth distance from Hanuman Chalisa is only one of many claims (e.g. speed of light, cosmic energy, dark matter, etc.)-it is the people of your cult trying to find science in spirituality, Hindu scriptures, etc.
in "Yug Sahastra yojana", 1) Firstly, we take Yug as divine years because we are talking about the long distance of earth and sun so we use the largest unit for example, when we measure long distance like between Delhi and Kanyakumari we use km not cm, similarly we can say tulsidas ji used here divine years, which is common sense(Not so common) 2) Now, secondly Sahastra means 1000 3) Thirdly, when the yojana is taken as 8 miles because traditionally the value of 1 yojana is considered 8 miles like as per famous texts like Bhagvat Maha purana (For proof see the work of Prabhupada ji), but now as you said that the value of 1 yojana changed in different centuries, if we take this argument then also the value of given by Tulsidas is right, I explained it below: The hanuman Chalisa is written by Tulsidas ji in "16TH CENTURY". During the medieval period like 14th to 16th century famous mathematicians like Bhakara II and Parmeswaran(you said it yourself!) took the value of 1 yojana as 8 miles, so perhaps Tulsidas ji used the metric systems of his own times like many scientists do or also he took the value of yojana as 8 miles because that's what there is in Bhagavat Maha purana, which was one of the texts he worshiped. Now if you put it, 12000 x 1000 x 8 = 96 million miles. Hence proved!
First we are talking about the value of one yug which equates to 12000 divine years which 1 divine year does give 360 years or something and even in modern theory one yug was mentioned as 24000years Third yojana is not 8 miles nowhere there is fixed number for yojana some sanskrit text define yojana as yoking indicating the distance that oxen yoked to royal carts traverse in a day. Some article says it is the distance the royal army can march in a day Sahastra may be 1000 but some scholars even says sahastra can be taken as infinity but I think most accepted is 1000 and there is no unit of sahastra
If say distance between delhi to Kolkata is abc, where a, b and c are constant, I am not talking about distance or time formula, I am just talking about there multiplication, he multiplied 3 values, which comes out to be distance. Yug, sahastra and yojana. We took yug as 12000 divine years, as the primary value of 1 yug is 12000 divine years, rest all are secondary values
If u travel 2 km in 2 hrs it doest not mean u travelled 4 km 😅 its simple math after multiplying time with distance its value would be km × hr not in km only
Well explained! I was hoping you'd mention or perhaps hinted at the works of Aristarchus of Samos, an ancient Greek astronomer (310 - 230 BC). His attempt to calculate the distance to Sun using the concept of Solar Parallax, documented in the egyptian copy from Alexandria "On the Sizes and Distances of the Sun and Moon" [Περὶ μεγεθῶν καὶ ἀποστημάτων]
This was actually before the Indo-greek period, the Yavanas were prominent in Indian subcontinent only during the Indo-greek era. That's when the Mauryan empire was prevalent
Well I am always right 😂 If those vitamin D deficient say day a night it's night Like seriously you believe Greeks and other westerners when their descendants doesn't even knew earth was not flat until 1600s where as in India at that time Hanuman chalisa was trying to show distance between eartg and sun And yes this person "science is dope" isn't a Sanskrit scholar and obivously won't understand ancient Sanskrit words And hence is not perfect with his explanation Just some so called gyani Indians proving there ancestors wrong for vitamin D deficient westerners So just chill bruh!!! 😂
Do you know bro that according to german group of scientists there are 5 particles in the proton hence resulting in 1.5x mass of the proton Hence resulting in increase in every objects mass that we measure today... Like the way terms yojna and yug is used the values change with time Even science don't keep anything constant the 1 kg mass at the France physics department (i don't know the name) showed variation around 5 miligram in previous around 20 years Hence the value changes nothing is constant as the space is expanding every second and one day we would need some new values for various aspects of science 😐
Iss Chutiye ne bharbhur praytna kiya ki kaise Sanatan wrong hai lekin ye chutitya ye bhul gaya ki agar 2023 me 1 mile = 3.5 km hai to main 2023 ki hi value lunga na ki 1200 saal pehle ki. Param Pujya Parameshwara ne bhi 8 miles hi liya hai aur Aur ek Angrez tha usne bhi , dusri baat 1200 divya varsha liya to iske baap ka kya gaya ? TULSIDAS JI DIVYA Sant the. Toh divya hi liya jo change nahi hota. Kitna bhi samjhao in Chutiyo ko Angrezo ka Guu hi mitha lagta hai.
Its not pseudoscience just imagine why would Tulsidas mention the units of distance in a poem and thats not only coincidence it is mentioned in a place where hanuman was going towards the sun and moreover yuga is termed as 12000 years (not divine years)to make a proper rhyme as there no proper term for 12k years.Your videos just shows how hinduism gives a close challenge to all the scientist.For your info in hinduism it is mentioned that there are 64 dimensions and lord krishna had already explained the concept of multiverse way more than 5000 years if you can you can make videos on that also.moreover even you consider the value of yojana from 5-8 it will change the value only by certain kms
It does not matter how long a yojana should be. What matters is what their hypothesis is i.e. how much yojana can light cover in a specific amount of time. Taking yojana as 9, it gives a good estimate of the speed as what matters in the end is the ratio. If we consider yojana as 8, then time taken to cover that yojana would be less or in physics terms, more yojana would be covered in 1 second however the speed would still be the same. Moving on, we still cannot ignore the possibility that they already knew the distance from earth to sun and they just took 3 convenient values to represent that distance. Maybe the original hindu research paper was destroyed so we'll never know their logic, but still, we know that they had an almost accurate value. Chew on that. Great video!!!
@@bhardwajparth Ok idk about this thing about sanskrit and ancient maths but answering your question For eg- i travel 500 miles a year and travel for 5 years then -500mile ×5years = 2500miles of my total displacement
@@bhardwajparth Let's think. What if they had calculated the distance from earth to sun in some other way and just used three different values to fit in the distance into the hanuman chalisa. and my comment has a focus on how rigveda tells the speed of light
@@stewie2838 if you travel 500 miles in one year the DISTANCE travelled is 500 miles... But... In this case the distance to be calculated isn't travelled in 1200 years (1 yuga) They are randomly multiplying some years with some distance and making the answer in unit of distance (kms)
@@adityarohit4088 see i cannot make someone believe something who has a confirmation bias but atleast try to think that if they really just wanted to tell the actual distance by using some random dimensions why isn't there a mention of it anywhere else many scholars have read hanuman chalisa nobody found out the distance? Only after the westerners found the distance people realised that it was already mentioned?
I have a bit different opinion here,, i am not denying his research but the thing which always forces me to think about hanuman chalisa thing is that, that shlok is really talking about that story of lord hanuman where he went to sun thinking it is a sweet fruit. The shloka's Hindi translation is "yug shahastra yojan ki duri par Surya jisko hanuman ji mitha fal samajh liye the". And yug's value of 12000 divine year is already mentioned every year,, ( and i am talking about divine year not human year) and then shastra is 1000 and finally as per video even if we take any value between (4.3 to 9miles) for yojan , the value we get is really a type of value which a human sitting on earth without any knowledge of distance can never think of , if we multiply 12×10^6 with 4.3 miles we will get around 51 million miles ,, really can any one think randomly that this can be the distance lord Hanuman went for sun without any knowledge??. And for those people who are telling about unit mismatch ,, man it is a poem and it should rhyme also to sound good,, why you guys are thinking that anybody will write 12000. It is not mathematical equation, people found the logic in these lines and found a value which is very close to the original value we get in modern world.. I don't know what is right and what is wrong but there is some logic in those two lines...
Brother, 16th century when hanuman chalisa was written isn't too long ago. It is very much possible that some Indian scientist had figured out the distance to sun, and it was common knowledge in India at that time. Greeks had figured out the distance to the moon in 2nd century BCE itself, ~1700 years before the Hanuman chalisa. It is not a miracle or divine knowledge. It is just science. Just 50 years (after hanuman chalisa) Newton had figured the reason for elliptical orbits of planets. And created calculus in his spare time. Second, if you take hanuman chalisa yojan value to be correct then you must accept rig veda is wrong in its calculation 7:19. Both cannot be correct. You cannot pick & chose measurements according to convinience - one for hanuman chalisa and other for rig veda.
@@NileshKumar-nr2vj no cuz the greeks are know for those things and the greeks came thousandd of years after the 16th century wich explaind that was no advanced theories about the astrology wich means the persin writing that poem is very intelegant and as he claims that he got his knowledge from hanuman and its storys hence proved that it really happend
@@chefpeepee8681 what ??? Try to form proper sentences and write things in way that it is comprehensible.. Whatever I understood doesn't make any sense.. And the fact about Greeks what you said is plain false
@@NileshKumar-nr2vj for u i will sons 😌 i meant to say that the greeks came thousands of years after the 16th century right ? And even the greeks didnt have advancend astrological equipments that means thousands of years earlier when we indians ,the sadhus where calculating the distance between the sun and the earth we didnt have advanced theoratical and praktick equipments to calculate the distance and still we calculated it super close enough to the actual distance calculated in the modern world that in it self is insanely impressive , thats all bye son and dont forget jay shree ram ♥️😌
Iss Chutiye ne bharbhur praytna kiya ki kaise Sanatan wrong hai lekin ye chutitya ye bhul gaya ki agar 2023 me 1 mile = 3.5 km hai to main 2023 ki hi value lunga na ki 1200 saal pehle ki. Param Pujya Parameshwara ne bhi 8 miles hi liya hai aur Aur ek Angrez tha usne bhi , dusri baat 1200 divya varsha liya to iske baap ka kya gaya ? TULSIDAS JI DIVYA Sant the. Toh divya hi liya jo change nahi hota. Kitna bhi samjhao in Chutiyo ko Angrezo ka Guu hi mitha lagta hai.
Thank you for this wonderful video Pranav. Now I can sing hanuman chalisa with devotion without thinking about its scientific relevance and stuff. BTW, the dimensional analysis was great! You rock as always👏👏
Keep it up bhaiya💟,you are really explaining science correctly on the basis of real and proven informations, without violating philosophical aspects of Vedas and religion you are talking about actual science,though I'm a big devotee of Lord Hanuman,I do agree with your words,after all units and measurement methods are important.
Iss Chutiye ne bharbhur praytna kiya ki kaise Sanatan wrong hai lekin ye chutitya ye bhul gaya ki agar 2023 me 1 mile = 3.5 km hai to main 2023 ki hi value lunga na ki 1200 saal pehle ki. Param Pujya Parameshwara ne bhi 8 miles hi liya hai aur Aur ek Angrez tha usne bhi , dusri baat 1200 divya varsha liya to iske baap ka kya gaya ? TULSIDAS JI DIVYA Sant the. Toh divya hi liya jo change nahi hota. Kitna bhi samjhao in Chutiyo ko Angrezo ka Guu hi mitha lagta hai.
I don't know why people are not able to get this and blindly believing, absorbing everything. Distance = speed*time 6th class physics. Now, Why shall I multiply even at 1st place, even if I did multiply when I have learnt that Distance=S*T, why should I multiply Time again and again to get distance. It's basics...So what we are doing here, fooling ourselves. Why do we succumb to such things, how can we forget basics and blindly believe everything. And as a Hindu I never ever in my life expect or want to see scientific facts in religious scriptures because science means research and analysis and hypothesis. Religion is a belief it's a path to be chosen to lead a better life. They're both different things and better if not mixed up...
2 yrs ago I watched this video Disliked it and opt for don’t recommend this channel Because I didn’t have any counter argument Today I came back here With a changed perspective Watched the entire video And again left out with no counter BECAUSE FACTS CANT BE COUNTERED Sad but true 😢
You know what I'm hindu my self but since 2014 something is going in my nation where each and everything is related to vedas and hindu dharm If corona wave came they says vedas already warn us If we got vaccine then they says vedas already have the solution If chandrayan succeed they says its all because of our beloved modi who is Avatar of vishnu Like what the hell Bro be proud that you are human who can think on his own but some fools love to listen about mythology so much that they think everything is about my dharm😂
They can't be compared cause one is a scientific manuscript while the other is a devotional text. You've also not defined a particular compatible criteria for comparison. Go get some ideas about units and measurements about what and how things are comparable.
kepler is eurpean and eurpean got all their knwoledge from tests stolen from india from integration to newtons law those uncivilized malecchas stole it from india.
The more I watch your video the more I get surprised how this claims are made by some pseudo science people and how much effort you put to save us the misinformation, much love sir 🔥❤️.
I want to say something..... Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity.... By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ? Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya" You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths Our rich culture had everything But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
The main concern with ancient texts is that most of us haven't read them fully so we just keep coming up with half researched facts . And many of those text have been burnt by the foreign rulers here. I didn't believed the hanuman chalisa fact but things like grutvakarshan (gravitation) is really something calculated and well defined in our texts way before newton.
carl sagan : admiring work of ancient people of india in hinduism meanwhile random guy on youtube with 116k subs & 7.4k likes : it is a total myth sarrrrr
A few counter points from my end: 1. In older times there was no internet and India was not a single country so assuming that the units they used should be the same in all records is not totally logical. Even today units are not the same throughout the world. 2. Since Sanskrit was one of the prominent languages, they used the same words in this case yojan. 3. There have been improvements in science and a lot of values have improved with time, especially recently. For instance the speed of light was corrected over years. So why do you think any specific value shouldn't (or even should) be the right/exact value according to that time science. 4. Why do you expect that the ancient scientists or scholars should have used and written equations in today's units/conventions. Their way of representing numbers or equations could have been different. Duh! It's a convention that humans create not a natural phenomenon/divine rules. If You don't understand it does not necessarily make it wrong. 5. You know a lot of texts and books were lost during the phases of invasions so maybe there was an explanation for the calculation which got lost. May be just maybe. In every ages you see references of day to day life or known facts in the literature, so let's say tomorrow science discovers that 'The sun rises in the south not east.' but still you'd see a lot of books containing the reference that the sun rises in East. What do you expect all those words to vanish from these books? Just to make a point that literature works can contain scientific facts true to their times. 6.These are just speculations, just like you can't prove it's wrong, one can't prove it's correct. People believe in what they want to believe in irrespective of their religion or country of origin. We humans always try to find a way to justify our beliefs by finding true things/coincidences, it's important for us to be hopeful and also gives meaning to life. There's another branch of science called psychology and that's dope too. 7. Sometimes putting another video and stating something very obvious according to science is your way of earning money. Understandable. 8. Just food for thought; make a video debunking islamic beliefs and will see you somewhere in cosmos soon. By this point of time, your bias is probably visible. No offence but, people who are pointing this out may have a valid point. Don't be exactly like sudo science guys by making fun of someone who's putting a question forward. It would be more sensible to analyse, access and answer the question, rather than making fun of them by pinning their comments. Took me 5 minutes to type all these points from my mobile and no research needed, just some common sense. Also, any typo and all please ignore da.
Mujhe kya mai toh bas ramayan aur mahabharat life lessons ke liye padhta hu There is no pointing on proving "WE ARE THE BEST, WE KNOW EVERYTHING" And people should focus on the learning we get from our history.
@@loading3138 Only fake people who spread wrong info get fucked. I just learn from history, I learn from the mistakes of my ancestors and it is common sense.
life lesson?😂 i laughed so hard while watching ramyab/mahabharat peak fiction...matlab kuch bhi ho rha hai...ye ramayan/mahabharat likhne wala ne kaunsa nasha kiya tha?
hey!! answer this-1.what about the immense gravitational field created by hanuman if he became so large to put sun in his mouth it would have disturbed the entire solar system 2. monkeys dont fly 3.how can someone be so stupid to think its a fruit ( even a kid) 4.why he went to sun ( fruit) in the first place if he can have even more fruits nearby on his own planet
I don't think so he will but if I may.. This is just satire so sit back and enjoy. 1. Hanuman is a god being and doesn't possess mass and the 4 forces of physics don't apply on them. So sun is nothing but his throat and he is so large we cannot ever see him 2. Monkeys don't fly but Hanuman is Superman so he can shoot lasers off his eye and can fly anywhere he wants with any velocity he thinks of. He was injected with super soldier serum compound V in childhood by his parents 3. He was not stupid, he was like Forrest gump. He thought that it looks like orange and is colored orange so he went and ate it. I forgot to mention along with superman, he also has powers of ant man. He can become any size he wants. He can grow to size of 100 universe length. 4. The sun was only his first fruit after that he went and ate 1000s of more of fruits and they are the other solar systems. It is actually hidden but he ate a lot of solar systems. He became Galactus basically and killed a lot of galaxies before coming to our solar system but the power and 5th fundamental hidden force field coming from earth was too strong to withhold the eating and he failed
Who told you the wrong story. 1. Hanuman is jumping a way long (bze he so powerful) looks like he is flying but he jumping one place to another like monkey. 2. He jump to eat the sun but he never eat sun in the way indra came and story going on.
There is a channel named 'Project Shivoham'. He made a video on the same topic. Project shivoham makes videos on spirituality and hinduism. So if you think that Pranav (Science is Dope) has some anti-hindu ajenda, then you can watch Project Shivoham's video on this topic.
Hey bro. Love your videos man. It is cause of you that now I look at things objectively. Please make a video on vastu shastra and feng shui as well. Its plaguing the entire architecture field. Professionals are being advised by these so called experts who don't even have a degree.
I want to say something..... Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity.... By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ? Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya" You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths Our rich culture had everything But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
Iss Chutiye ne bharbhur praytna kiya ki kaise Sanatan wrong hai lekin ye chutitya ye bhul gaya ki agar 2023 me 1 mile = 3.5 km hai to main 2023 ki hi value lunga na ki 1200 saal pehle ki. Param Pujya Parameshwara ne bhi 8 miles hi liya hai aur Aur ek Angrez tha usne bhi , dusri baat 1200 divya varsha liya to iske baap ka kya gaya ? TULSIDAS JI DIVYA Sant the. Toh divya hi liya jo change nahi hota. Kitna bhi samjhao in Chutiyo ko Angrezo ka Guu hi mitha lagta hai.
tulsidas wrote this book when he was captured and imprisoned by mughal/turk emperor, for latter felt offended on account of failure on the part of former to become soothsayer for that emperor. He/tulsidas was jailed and then he got the ideo to stay motivated by writing on the god he is fan of. This book is devotional/emotional song, writer by a devotee. It was never written from the angle of measuring distance
1 Yojan = 13km(approx). 1600 Yojan = 20800 km. That's a big big difference. There is a big difference between being proud of our culture and becoming complacent, irrational to support something. The arguments made are what we used to do in school where we manufactured calculations to fit the answer. The translations, definitions change as per convenience to support a point. Think rationally and critically people.
What if it was just a common scientific fact known to the people at that time. And Tulsi Das just happens to use this in his poem without giving any theory behind it?
I think you don't get point The people who glorify ancient text are they don't care about evidence What they believe is Hinduism has advanced science and they don't care about evidence because it's all mahic bruh
Exactly Pranav you are right. I don't have any doubt that our history had some amazing intelligent scientist and mathematicians. But we haven't totally understood their language, so we start doing false equivalence. And you're right, Shree Hanuman Chalisa is our devotional book, why would we want to explain the distance between earth and sun. Maybe Tulsidas knew the distance and he conveyed that casually not scientifically. Jai Shree Ram🙏🏻🕉️
The writer of hanuman chalisa even know the Unit of distance to measure distance in the Universe which is Light Year according to science nowadays. YUGA means unit of time used to measure a long period of time . here yuga used as light years to measure. Sahastra means 1000 times YOGAN used for measure of long distance at earth. They just gave a hint in units not the exact numbers of distance. As they believe that distance between earth and sun changes during orbital revolving.
Hey Pranav, I agree with most of what you said in the video except when you say, why look for science in a book that's not scientific? The answer to that is, the time when the book was written, people most probably used these stories/shlokas/poems to communicate a lot of different subjects. For example in the Ramayana, when hanuman asks how to get to the Himalayas from Lanka (to bring the sanjeevani booti), he is told the whole route, describing each and every major river, mountain, plains, etc that he'll encounter on the way to the Himalayas from Lanka. This is an example of a whole geography lesson interwoven into the story. The writer could have written the Ramayana without any of this geography, but it was put there with the purpose to educate. The education system at the time was just a bunch of stories/shlokas/poems that were taught through the Gurukul system and that's why a variety of subjects were incorporated within the stories, including, in this case, science interwoven with the hanuman chalisa. Most probably.
No disrespect bro... but we did have books by aryabhatta, varahamira, etc etc... and they do have scientific standards. Its not that we need some stories/ shlokas to convey things. Ramayana and mahabharata are great epic poetries. And such poetries do have all minute and nice descriptions. Why cant we treat them as story of rama and great bharatha simply?
do u have proof of ramayana so first of all , do check out hoiw old is sanskrit sanskrti itself devloped from devnagri which came in 6th century also we cannot even tell the interpretation of language of indus valley civilization also hindus ddint knew abotu ashoka or uindus valley or prakrit only till britishers excavated ashok'as stupas and other shilalekhs
@@abhishektiwari6141 lol, get your facts straight..... Sanskrit came from devnagri 🤣🤣🤣 That is why India need real scientific/research temperament The hard evidence we have got is from 600 BC.... And learn some English or Hindi dude, don't be a chappari
@@nishantpatil1847 with all due disrespect bro, Ramayan was not written for your need, was it?....it's is outright idiotic to think that a book shouldn't be written with certain knowledge because you don't want it( for your lame statement "it's not that we need it"). So if you think that while writing this Valamiki asked himself that "after several thousands year a patil guy will come, will he need such book?" than you are deluded. Nobody cares about you, kind of obvious. Secondly the books from Aryabhatta came quite later,and in his book he gave clearly mentioned that many of the things he have wrote he have referred older scriptures. Do you even know when Aryabhatta and varahmir were born...it's rhetorical
The first line of the childhood lullaby, "Twinkle, twinkle, little star" gives the actual distance between Earth and Proxima Centauri, the second closest star after the Sun. Let’s see. Twinkle = 2,010,399,000 m = 2,010,399 km, little = 10e-10 second, star = 10e+15 sec-1 (1/sec) So, (twinkle + twinkle) x little x star = (2010399 + 2010399) km x 10e-10 sec x 10e+15 sec-1 = 40,207,980,000,000 km The measured distance between Earth and Proxima Centauri is 40,208,000,000,000 km. So, it's 99.99995% accurate, which is astonishing given that the rhyme was for children and was written more than 200 years ago. Also, unlike the Hanuman Chalisa, it uses the metric system, which is far more convenient to use and a universally accepted system, and also it didn’t mess up the units.
If even for a second you start believing that there was a monkey who could talk human language and could even fly then at that very moment, you leave the world of logic and science 😂😂😂
I’m a Hindu Sanatani and a proud Sanghi. I never go outside without wearing Vibhuti on my forehead because I’m proud to be born a Hindu and I’m proud of my nation’s culture and civilisational continuity. But I’m not offended by this video. What’s the logic in finding logic behind these? We must be proud of our mathematicians, scholars and rishis who gave immense contributions to science, politics etc which are still relevant. From ancient times itself in Bharat, we never had conflict between Science and Beliefs. Don’t find logic in Religious beliefs. It’s called “Belief” for a reason. If we still place Beliefs above science, what’s the difference between us and Abrahamic faiths? Always keep this in mind that practices and beliefs which is against reason never survived the test of time in Bharat.
Lol every "faith" places belief over reality and science. Both India and the Arab world had a period where science prevailed over their lands. But soon enough "faith" caught up and now prevails. Still there are some all over the world who think rationally and place faith and science in seperate containers. But i still think you would kill me in a mob attack.
I want to say something..... Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity.... By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ? Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya" You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths Our rich culture had everything But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
Appreciate your effort. This the problem with us, we unnecessarily try to find scientific evidences in our spiritual books, which is not required at all. These two are totally different things.
Thats because usa has different unit measurement USA has short ton which is 2000 pounds and UK and most countries have long ton which is 1000 kg Its just like miles and kilometres,fahrenheit and celcius We and most countries use long ton dont worry
Anyone can enjoy his videos without getting offended if one doesn't mix religion with science. Every individual has the liberty to follow their own biases and it is not necessary that you agree with him on every subject matter.
@@koitur750Mandlawaale religion and science are two subsets (of philosophy) which don't have any intersection . But of course for ethics and morality religion plays a role. So yes
@@gen-z-box3331 First, that was long time ago when Philosophy was primary field under which subjective and objective realities were tested and science was invisible small segment of it which dealt objective realities. Science has moved on way ahead since then...while philosophy is taken over by religious idiocy. 2nd, Religion pretend to play important role in Morality and Ethics and doing so since time immemorial, but does the opposite most of the time. Pick any holy book, its filled with most immoral and heinous acts done in a name of god. So anybody in 21st century who thinks these holy books still play important role in societal moral standards and its ethics, they have lost their basic common sense because researches tells you otherwise.
@@gen-z-box3331 ethics without religion is possible, no need of religion and mythology, just simply follow ethics of your school teachings and no need of religion
It is hard to believe that this is just a coincidence, as the verse isn't just a random mix of words but specifically refers to the sun. The fact there is no calculation to back the value or the units don't match up is a different thing.
I really liked your approach also your style. But a critique in me is itching to also look at other side of the coin. Is it possible that Tuslidas was just using some finding of someone else from his time, who may have calculated the distance correctly by some extent. The thing that European have over us is that their findings are properly documented while we are left only with a tiny part of our history in proper documentation. After almost 500 years of external occupation, we don't know how much of of scriptures we have lost. At the end you convincingly said that there are only two ways, but I suggest there can be a third possibility where actually science was used for these conclusions.
@@deforest249 that is not I am saying. We have lost very much of our scriptures and documents during muslim invasions and other. While modern European have thier research well preserved and documented.
@Science Is Dope ..... good explanation... good articulation.... can u also make a video debuking other religious texts and sacred books as well... will be interesting to see that
@ Science Is Dope .... plz do make a de bunking video on various other religions apart from Hinduism.... Would be happy to see the same kind of response and comments from all :)
What !! Years × miles = km ???? RIP units Earth revolves around sun in eliptical path not in a circular path so there is no fixed distance between sun and earth That why Kepler third law talks about area swept by earth per unit time is constant This is 10th class science
Same here pranav Bro... I am A staunch right Wing Guy But I am really Fed Up with these Facebook and WhatsApp scientist.....I really Appreciate The Works By mathematicians Like bhaskaracharya Aryabhatta Etc . But I think We should go with More Rational Way ..
I want to say something..... Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity.... By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ? Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya" You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths Our rich culture had everything But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
Wow! Another eye-opening video from Science Is Dope. The entire video makes a lot of sense; still, the line “Why is a devotional book talking about measuring the distance between the earth…” this line was the winner for me. I guess even every irrational blind follower might also have thought of this once in his or her life. Good work Pranav. Thanks for this.
@@things_leftunsaid alexendar . Black hole concept was not there because, Hanuman never went to eat a black hole thinking it a fruit. Try watching hanuman film ( cartoon). It won't change your religious belief.
@hrishikesh joshi Have you even read the hanuman chalisa? To answer your question "Why is a devotional book talking about measuring the distance between the earth"?. The distance to the sun in the hanuman chalisa is mentioned to show the greatness of hanuman. Phrase: Tumharo Mantra Bibhishan Maana. Lankeshwar Bhaye Sab Jag Jaana. Yug Sahastra Jojan Par Bhanu. Leelyo Taahi Madhur Phal Jaanu. Meaning: Complying with Your preachings, even Vibhishana became the King of Lanka. You swallowed the sun, located thousands of miles away, mistaking it to be a sweet, red fruit! This is why it is mentioned
@@tanmaykhyatun2211 Return of Hanuman(directed by Anurag Kashyap) is one of my favorite cartoon movies. Gods, unicorns, Bigfoots, Santa Claus, spiderman etc are all just imaginary cartoons.
Pranav, i really like your work but the way you go on with them people may think that the writers of these books intended to misguide people but i dont think it happened, the books are pure literaure and it is misinterpreted now and compared to scientific value.Moreover our hindu culture is basesd on philosophy ,literature etc and not on the materialistic discoveries. Would definitely love it if you please add this point.
I want to say something..... Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity.... By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ? Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya" You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths Our rich culture had everything But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
I would have agreed to everything you have said...but the fact that most of our religious scriptures and literature has been either destroyed or manipulated by Mughals and British makes it difficult to prove your point...we end up in a paradox...like you said what techniques were used to measure the distance...we don't know...so we can't disprove something just because we don't know...and that was the intention of Mughals and British which you are making successful...the ultimate fact that the distance is almost accurate makes it enough to believe it...
@@satvikchaturvedi3545 Yes...I agree...but that was the very reason they destroyed our scriptures without any hesitation...not only Mughals every other Islamic invader...especially the khiljis...for them we lost the richest knowledge emporium of the world...the Nalanda...
Here i am going to explain the fact and answer your all question being asked…👇 Yug sahasra yojan par bhanu--it means sun is at a distance of 1000 yojana of yug →yug = 12000 unit of divine year containing all yug(i.e 4 yugas alltogether also called mahayug) →sahasra litreally means thousand (1000) in length.. →yojan is varing in length from text to text ranging between 6 to 9 miles…. This is because hindu measurement is based on foot step measurement..for ex- 2 pada = 1 vitasti. There is no standardization of foot step (pada) this is because length of mesurement is based on foot step and it varies person to person….. It is favourable to take yojana around 8 miles approximately….it (approximately….it) can be 7.8 or 8.2 but answer differ slightly →bhanu means sun in sanskrit dictionary. So yug sahasra yojan par bhanu means sun is at distance of 1000 yojan of yugs. So calculating this 12000 * 1000 * 8 = 96000000 miles And 1 mile = 1.6 km = 153600000 km This is exactly given by nasa as we all know Now let us take few false allegation with proper answer-- 1: people with abrahmic lens and other ignorant hatred coment that the formula is dimentionless and how the unit of time is multiplied with length? ANS→well this question is geneally asked by schooling student who are reading basic science In thier school life. In mordern science today distance is measured in respect to time. For ex- astronomical unit, light year etc Light year is the unit of distance not time It is distance travelled by light in a year Called light year. 1 light year = 300000000 * 365 days and so on in different units. Similarly, per 1000 yojana distance covered in yuga(there are 4 yuga) is the distance of sun from earth. Large unit of length can only be expressed with respect to time.modern physics also deal distance w.r.t. time length. 2: Another question being asked by the ignorant is that 12000 divine year contain in 4 yuga called mahayuga? ANS→IN the above answer this question is answerd by default. There are 4 yuga Styug,tretayug,dawaparyug,kalyug. When we simply call yuga it means we are adressing all 4 yugas. For example-in a conference hall there are mechanical enginer,computer enginer,electrical enginer etc… and the host adress…hello engineers how are you--it simply means host is adressing to all enginers at a same time. Similarly calling yuga simply means adressing all four yuga. Its a matter of common sense, i left it for your level of Common sense. NOTE→ IF ANYONE HAVE ANY OTHER QUERY OR QUESTION YOU CAN ASK FREQUENTLY WITH PROPER REASONING AND FACTS. I hope this will open the narrow minded ignorant who try to mislead but they cant even deny the fact….. They act like idiots who ask such question👇given below- Q1: sahsra is not 1000 its means 1000s? Q2: yojana value is 6.7 miles somewhere 8 mile somewhere or 7 mile somewhere which is correct? Q3: this formula have no dimentional accuracy? Q4: the sloka is false or copied from elsewhere? I can only laugh at these silly question. Rest is upon you do your pure and unbaised research with free mind and open thoughts dont be ignorant.
If we apply your theory then- 4 Yugs= 12000 divine years = 4×12000×360 =17280000 Then distance is 17280000×1000×8=13,824,000,000 miles = 8,640,000,000 km
And how can you use the unit lightyear for the distance between Sun and Earth. It takes almost 8 minutes for light to travel from Sun to Earth, so use of such units to explain how it is used in modern astronomy to measure distance of distant stars from Earth to validate your calculation doesn't make sense.
And the use of mile as a unit of distance was introduced by Britishers in India so how Goswami Tulsidas could have possibly known about existence of such unit. Also 1 Roman mile= 1.48 km while 1 English mile = 1.68 km. You have just adjusted the values according to your convenience and conjured such things that a devotee of Hanuman who has no relation with Science came up with such a calculation which he wrote just in the praise of his beloved deity only for the modern Humans 400 years late, who use different ways and techniques to define a measurement, will somehow come up with the calculations to find the distance between their current planet and their nearest Star.
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 83 วันนี้!! คู่เอก "พันฤทธิ์ vs ซุปเปอร์บอล วันของโอม MBK"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1b4pkKHa_Fk/mqdefault.jpg)
Hey NRI, how much did you get paid?
1 million dollars
@@scienceisdope great...
I believe your western masters are now happy with you as you proved your loyalty 🐶 you won their trust..
Bhai Re3 khel bas
lol just 2days and pinned
bro got the pin of shame lmao
This video made me realise why my Physics teacher always told "Writing answer without UNIT is always wrong..."
True legend keep going
True, you don't know how many times my physics teacher scold me do this😂😂
I want to say something.....
Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries
Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity....
By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ?
Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... th-cam.com/video/TnvzNFf6V44/w-d-xo.html here is the link of the video made by professor hc verma iitk
I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya"
You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths
Our rich culture had everything
But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
@@powerenergy3480 bro you know what's sad, you typed that long comment and your comment got deleted
@@rocky3850 my comment deleted ?? 😱 😱 why ... btw I am a jee aspirant and my iit is guaranteed now
@@powerenergy3480 so???
Kahi ka neta to nhi ban gya na, jo ye bta rha h,
Pta bhi h youtube ne comment kyun delete mara because usme link tha, aur youtube bahut sare cheejon ko censor karta h abhi comment section me,
Bhalai ka jamana hi nhi h
This is like our high school physics lab where we knew the results and we were trying to fit the readings to arrive at the known result 😀
Dimensional analysis! Haha
@@N0Xa880iUL i have remembered something from pranav's past videos
Dimension dimension dimension...
Dimension dimension dimension...
🤣
Divine years related to Yuga mentioned as satyuga treta dwapar n kalyuga 12000 years = 360 human years not years for jugg while jugg value in Tulsi das is 12000 years this video misinterpreted between yug n jugg check your facts n research 😂😂😂😂😂😂 everyone debunked u who has a knowledge on Hindu texts 😇✌️ lots of love to science dope make sure u show true knowledge Hari om 🙏
Yojan etc units mentioned in Vedas book ...4Ved books in Hindu..Very old books
Era and era passed then
Hanuman chalisa came which is also old ...
"Panchang" in Vedas describe sun/moon eclipse which is accurate ☺️In India only 0.5$ book available,Vedas -earth shapes, rotation and other 9 planets with 3D situation also rotation direction...medical,music,etc written in Vedas...You need to learn ..Go and search about Vedas ...Clear ur concept bro... Knowledge is good things 😀
So they changed the unit of yojana in the Hanumanchalisa to make it correct and match the modern value. That's like a school student changing his 9 marks to 90 marks.
I want to say something.....
Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries
Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity....
By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ?
Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture
I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya"
You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths
Our rich culture had everything
But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
Exactly...😂😂💯💯
I facepalmed myself when in the movie he says "Hanuman Chalisa jaisi pracheen kitaab". The HC was written in the 16th century in the Awadhi language of UP (not Sanskrit, contrary to what many believe). The 16th century is not "pracheen" at all. It's very much considered modern history.
Late Mediaeval period*
Lol gndu it was written in vedic language and to understand it was CONVERTED to avadhi language in 1600
I love misinformation keep it coming
@@Chudan-lal-chunnisource mr. gaali hurling sanskari anonymous? Also, your comment in no way refutes what I said. The fact that it was written in the 16th century doesn't make it pracheen at all.
@@nashtrashcool and the misinformation part being? I know it's the Awadhi language because I live in the region where it's spoken and it's well documented that it was written in the 16th century.
I ate the Moon 🌝
500000000 years Ago ....
Believe Me ...
I would believe in you. If you show me your scriptures and temples more than 5000 years old or more
Katuas and Chadar Fathers don't have their proof before 2000 years.
Bete baaap se panga nahi lete Jaake Halleluyah walo se 2 kilo chawal mang Le 😂
Heyyyy its that the reason we dont have moon today
@@OneAboveAll2023avg andh bhakt uneducated bacha from bjp household😂
@@ceti_9998 hey believe me I ride at flying horse believe me, and the semen is stored in chest
distance = speed x time
According to Hanuman Chalisa
distance = time x distance x 1000🤯
Don't you know bro, according to general relativity time and distance are the same thing. Take that! /s
@@N0Xa880iUL kuch bhi?? Kuch bhi?? Bhai tum pehle RBD padhle.. calculus padh le.. phir samajh ayegi relativity...
@@N0Xa880iUL 😂😂 blind followers of religion
@@N0Xa880iUL nahi bhai, relativity does not say that. It's even dimensionally incorrect
@@N0Xa880iUL Either I am dumb in understanding your sarcasm or you are dumb in understanding relativity
I want to add that mathematicians and scientists of India like Aryabhatta, who wrote on the specific subject of astronomy got to the value of distance between the sun and Earth which was inaccurate by several degrees, but Tulasi Das who neither was a scientist or mathematician or astronomer nor he was writing something on astronomy, gives an accurate value. There is no sense in that.
All the credits of aryabhata is stolen by these idiots
Religion doesn't allow to have common sense
Also tulsidas said casteist things
@ZAP GAMERZ Shudra’ means Dalit, and the quote says, as drums (dhol), illiterates (gawar), animals (pashu) need to be tamed by being beaten up, shudras also must meet the same fate.
@@kentajin7860 shudra actually means someone who provides services to the master. Like barber, carpenter, Smith, shepherd, etc. They today constitute OBCs. Biggest population of India, you can say working class in terms of European social division of proletariat and feudal lords.
Dalits were untouchables, called Avarna at the time, or Acchut. Savarna means those who are part of Varna system, so technically OBCs are also also Savarna only lower in the hierarchy, also remember that there was no Hindu religion.... It was was a name give by Arabs to connote a piece of land. And Sanatan is just modern day propaganda to counter anti caste narrative throughout history
"When you look at Hercules you don't question his strength but only admire the poetry"
And it's legit a poem ❤️
I want to say something.....
Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries
Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity....
By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ?
Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... th-cam.com/video/TnvzNFf6V44/w-d-xo.html here is the link of the video made by professor hc verma iitk
I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya"
You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths
Our rich culture had everything
But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
@@powerenergy3480 Tulsidas sada hari chera 🙏
Keji nath hriday mah dera ❤️
Bhai Jo dil mein base hai unko lekar iss Maya mein kya hi charcha Krna 😂??
@@Varun4_here bcoz in this world I want to tell them who defame it by there own conspicuous theory 😏
I want to say something.....
Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries
Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity....
By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ?
Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture
I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya"
You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths
Our rich culture had everything
But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
I want to say something.....
Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries
Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity....
By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ?
Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture
I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya"
You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths
Our rich culture had everything
But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
This is basically what I told my friends when I was asked about this. Specially, the unit being incorrect is far bigger a blow to this theory than people realize it.
12000 years is also 144000 months, so why don't use that number? Or maybe call it 1000 dozen years!!! You can convert it into so many values, the answer completely changes! For a Mathematician/ Physician, this theory is completey stupid just based on the fact that units don't match!!
The reason why it has so many values could be that Indian knowledge was never institutionally standardized unlike in west who did a great effort to standardize it. If you look at history of a mile (1 mile), once a 1 mile was equal to 2.1 kilometers and another time it was something else. But they did lot of effort to standardize things eventually.
Secondly, there is no theory here , it's just one statement to represent mightiness of Lord Hanumana in those verses. Since much of Indian knowledge was lost (burnt) we would never know what was the original theory & what unit is used.
The kind of standardization that happened in Europe about science unfortunately never happened in India which I believe is the biggest failure of Indian body of knowledge. ( Edited, thanks to @AVS G)
Note: I"m open to possibility that I could be wrong & the calculation in verses might be arbitrary. I"m only saying that, argument that "the unit is different at different times it must mean theory is invalid" is insufficient as theories / units etc were never institutionally standardized.
@@omikumar7028 the biggest failure of “indian” science (i.e. the “science” in mythological texts) is that it doesn’t follow scientific method. That’s the long and short of it. There are many such claims in other world religions as well and science doesn’t take them seriously either. If any of it had followed scientific method, then it would not be “Indian”, or “Islamic” or “Christian” science anymore. It would just be Science.
@@avsg2427 Totally Agree, I should have used the word "Indian body of knowledge" instead of science. as that body of knowledge could never developed into rigorous science, it remained a gray mix of spirituality & some rudimentary logic.
this is incorrect. that's because you have 0 experience on any of the hindu texts. 1 Yuga basically equals 12k divine years and has been used in this context multiple times. now you might ask why not use months for 1 yuga. this is like asking why do most of the books mention a decade as being 10 years and not in any other unit.
@@HITNUT who said 1 decade is not equal to 120 months?
You should recommend books and shows to build interest science and critical thinking.
Read "Demon Haunted World - Science as a candle in the dark" by Carl Sagan.
You can watch Cosmos (1980), Tree of Life by David Attenborough, Many other shows and books by richard dawkins.
Do you think indians are capable of critical thinking? Which planet are you from?
Surya siddhant
@@NordicPolestar radhe radhe bro
@@NordicPolestar 132 feet hoor chup baith
I am also bhakt of lord hanuman but thanks for the video 😇😇 kudos to your research ✌🏼 jai bajrangbali 🙏🏻
@À So believing in something already makes you andhbhakt?
RIP logic
@À how is that andhbhkt, that is like supporting some thought experiment which you think is correct is andhbhkti let him follow what he wants
@À Your comment is lowering the collective iq of this comment thread.
:)
Dude just destroyed your fairytale monkey man but still you choose to say "Kudos to your research" 😂😂
Fiction will always be fiction
@Citizen of Earth (free thinker) 7 billion*
Truth is stranger than fiction
I knew parallax was coming , i have studied it in basics of physics in 11th .
Great bro... i forgot . Now getting glimpse of hc verma... text written on it...
@@shubhamprasad6910 ya
I skipped that chapter of measurement.
I'm in iit now. It's like a revision now
@@anshuraj1740 I admit to class 11th late after this chapter and vector . My teacher was teaching kinematics . I was busy in crop reaping and harvesting .
I studied it with kinematics and my teacher helped me .
Amazing mahn! not only you debunk the misconceptions but also teach and provide explanation for actual methods and how we were able to do it! thats what I really appreciate about you. keep it up! ignore all the hate and keep being awsome!
I want to say something.....
Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries
Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity....
By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ?
Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture
I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya"
You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths
Our rich culture had everything
But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
I want to say something.....
Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries
Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity....
By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ?
Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture
I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya"
You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths
Our rich culture had everything
But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
This video is a result of Opinion bias and lack of scriptural understanding.
1. You lost credibility when you multiplies 12,000 with 360 claiming 12,000 is divya yuga .
firstly there are different types of yugas such as Manu yuga , divya yuga , daiva yuga , brahma yuga and soo on . Divine yugas when compared to yuga of Manu , you dont have to multiply if with 360 , 12000 it is.
2. Tulsi Ramayan mentions hanuman when flying around earth covers 3300 yojan . 33000 *12= 39,600 ( approx ) . while modern calculations of circumfrence of earth is pretty close at 40000. Therefore 1 yojan has to taken 12 cm . This cant be a mere co incidence that Tulsi das is using yojan to descibe to values that match pretty much with present day calculations .
Please don't delete my comments
@@themysteryschool-Can you also point the distance between Ram's India and Ravan's Lanka as per Ramayan?
@@themysteryschool-bro you are slow lmao learn how physics works. Vanishing the time frame for no reason doesn't make any sense regardless of your yuga yojna blah blah lmao
That hanuman sun eating story is peak fiction. I mean whoever thought of this story is legendary because his story is now believed by millions 😂😂😂😂
why not? he can increase his size as big as the universe itself.
@@Inferno-rq5cdExtraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
-Carl Sagan
@@rommelbengalisure you dont need to believe in this theory i am not forcing you to. Stay athiest kiddo but i'll always believe in Lord Hanuman😂❤
@@roymustang4986 Drink chilled gomutra. It'll refresh your rotten mind.
@@AmmarMuslimm whattt?? madarse se science and Sanatan seekhne ka anjaam😂🤡
first of all hanuman kept the sun in his mouth and did not swallow or destroy it so its gravitational pull was not affected...secondly please stop trying so hard to prove Sanatan wrong because truth cant be suppresed...uk why Sanatan survived around 800 yrs of mughal tyranny and 200 yrs of british rule? because Sanatan is eternal. do you want me to speak upon the scientific mistakes of quran or pisslam?
Appreciate your efforts brother. Our country had a long tradition of complete materialists, agnostics and non-believers (charvakas). But time and time again political and religious groups had destroyed that philosophy and the texts associated with it. If those texts of ancient atheists/agnostics were still around we would have debunked a lot of misconceptions.
ajevikas were massacred by ashok like all non budhists.
And I believe it is a repeating cycle. When all goes to shit, the mobs win.
Absolute Power corrupt absolutely 😑🤦🏽♂️
Puri English ek hi comment mai likh di
In ancient Bharat/Aryavarth there used to be shastrath(well-organised debates & discussions) between scholars regarding various issues. This was even boosted by Nyaya Darshan of Gautam Muni.
Charvaka darshan gained popularity but lost debates to Adi -Shankara (including the Jains) and the decline of atheistic philosophy started. More analytically the charavaka Darshan (including athiestic darshanas of Bauddhas and Jainas) were point by point refuted by debunked (including the false claims made regarding vaidic dharma by their propagartors and clearance of misconceptions) by Rishi Dayanand Saraswati in the 19th century .
Thanks for Accepting request and bringing this. You doing great work hope your channel reaches to more audience Thank you.
I want to say something.....
Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries
Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity....
By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ?
Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture
I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya"
You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths
Our rich culture had everything
But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
I want to say something.....
Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries
Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity....
By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ?
Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture
I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya"
You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths
Our rich culture had everything
But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
Mannnnn
I really wanted this vid!!!
😂I've never been this excited for any vid coz I have had enough of this.😂Cant wait man. Luv ur vids!
I can already tell how much this video is gonna piss off people and I'm here for it
Sup bro me 2
@Arun Kumar Art i found this thou
th-cam.com/users/ProjectShivoham
They aren’t here
@@evilentity302 i can't find them here
@@evilentity302 lol , they'd be bowling in thier caves.
When such devotional texts were written, i doubt anyone thought that it would someday be possible to verify such metrics. It was mostly meant as a placeholder for a great distance or a massive size to put things in perspective within that literary context. While i absolutely admire you Pranav for putting in massive effort for such content, i believe that there are very few 'fence sitters' in this specific regard. Most of your viewers are ones who anyway don't take such things at face value and a much smaller portions who will defend it tooth and nail. Sorry for the long post, just wanna say keep it up! Science is dope :)
Nice
This had to be stopped when it's still small
His followers are not fence sitters, but his videos are open to all, and once in a while it catches the algorithm and gets recommended to not so bright indians and then starts the negative comments.
@@shahan484 Hey HELLO SO CALLED Bright Indians 😂😂😂
@@shahan484 Indians should strive for dominance and strive to redesign the world in India's image.
That's where religion which is essentially culture comes in as a part of indian identity.
12000 yug x 1000sahstra x 8yojan mile= 96000000
96000000x1.6 =153,600,000km
Distance to sun=149,600,000km
Difference=4,000,000km
Satyug= 17,28,000
Tretayug= 12,96,000
Dvapuryug= 864,000
Kalyug= 432,000
None of them are 12000.
And they're multiplying time to distance.
153,000,000 what? Apples? Bananas?
@@NordicPolestar ohh it's the distance according to hunuman chalisa, sorry i didn't mention. ❤️
@@Adi-df8ub I known the claim. I was alluding to the lack of units attached to those numbers.
@@NordicPolestar the one you mentioned had "KM" attached to it and the rest are year's obviously.
@@NordicPolestar and if you didn't got it i am saying there wrong.
Said it in the chat will say it here too; Gen Z wants to validate their religious beliefs with science so they don't feel bad about being religious, it's still some crazy mental gymnastics they have to do in order to achieve that and sadly many grifters are taking advantage of this. All the debunking is well and good but the problem is deep rooted with personal identity and lack of purpose in modern Indian society.
Lack of purpose what do you mean humans are without purpose just expect the fact and enjoy life without religious crap
Religion is the worst thing happened to world
@@Nemo25599 yeah and it's hard to accept that's what religion takes advantage of
@@Nemo25599 stole my word.
basically nobody has any answers to life everyone is just as lost as the most religious my personal belief is we don't have a purpose of life we have to experience everything and do what we like or turn what to you like to the purpose of your life
@@Andy2kk there is not a 1 bad thing about hinduism and theres not a 1 good thing about abrahmic faiths. just bcoz abrahmic faiths are bad doesnt mean you put hinduisma in same category with those malecchas
@@prafful_sahu Definetly putting you in the abrahmic religions category 🤗
Science is not just dope its hope too!!
a candle in the dark
Just like Hinduism
@@BabaAndBaby11 Therefore Darkness wins, as candle can fade away anytime. Darkness is eternal bro. Without darkness there is no light.
@@charansai2476 you just used science to disprove science lol
@@aaryasharma4940 kuch sense he is bath ke
Few points I want to highlight.
0) Tulsidas wrote in Awadhi between, late 15CE - early 16CE.
जुग सहस्त्र जोजन पर भानू।
लील्यो ताहि मधुर फल जानू।।
The language is Awadhi, spoken in UP Awadh region. Cassini discovered the distance around 1670 (late 16CE). Considering, India was quite good at mathematics especially in Geometry, I believe that, there would have been some calculations done in India Subcontinent, which was actually quoted by Tulsidas. It can be a period of 100-200 years. There is a history of Europeans, stealing literary work and destroying history of their colonies. So it can be a case.
1) Issue with assumption @8:37
The book simply assumes different yuga's as Golden, Bronze, Silver and Iron ages. This brings me to 2nd point,
2) The original book was published in year 1935 (Before Independence), copy is in University of Calcutta.
Writer, is of English Origin. The book is written by Rev. EBENEZER BURGESS a Formerly Missionary of the A.B.C.F.M. (American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions) in India.
You want me to believe on a translation of a Missionary. Isn't that contradictory. A missionary, really. One who believes, earth is flat. How could you belive on such translations. Offcoure the book has been cited by a Mathematician, but wait, a Mathematician, and Sanskrit, they don't go along.
3) Yojan:
The unit Mile has quite a history of change.
Read it here: www.britannica.com/science/mile
Now comming to the thing, surya sidhanta mentions it as 5 miles, some mention it as 4 mile, some mention it as 8 miles, some as 6. The thing is that, we exacltly don't know, what was the acceptable value of mile at the time it was written.
The Question why it is written as just 1 yojan. If they were just estimating randomly, it could have been 10, 43, or half yojan, 100. There are n number of possibilities.
Why it is written as 1200. Even If they are fitting values, how come values mentioned in past, fits. Like, what is the probability, that we use some values from past to fit a narative.
4)
Yuga's have different values, with respect to the yuga in which you are.
1200 * 360 is clearly mentioned as 'Total Duration of a yuga'.
When you are multiplying it with 360.... it is a the duration of a yuga, i.e., total solar year in a yuga.
Kali yuga is basically 1200 divine Years (Yuga).
I am open for a discussion on this topic. Hope you do some in depth research.
I too seek Truth.
Your argument is too vague ok tell me why multiplication. Why not any other arithmetic operations. It is not mentioned anywhere to multiply. Your answer to why 12000 year is totally wrong. They asked why 12000 year not any other value. In science we use dimensions or metrics to know the value . In any calculation if we take light speed as km/hr then answer will come according to that if we take light speed in m/s then answer will also come according to that but the answers denote the same thing only metrics are different. But here can you relate the answer if we take that time as a divine year or month? So go kiddo and learn science first. Lastly the Hanuman chalisa we are reading written in 16 th century (1600-1700) not 15-16ce.
@@logohub1234 might be a unsaid rule was persistent of multiplication like we had to do in 11th 12th
just the time pranav uses to produce videos itself shows how much he puts the effort in research. Not like our ayurveda youtubers who read few pages and make new claims every other day.
They are afraid
Bible TH-cam r . Ha ha 😂😂😂
Rice bag spotted, opinion rejected...Mera yeshu yeshu
@@kisamehoshigake4201
Rice is obviously better than hindooism
@@kisamehoshigake4201 aandh bhakt spotted
The context of Hanuman chalisa is spiritual, why the hell do people want distance of sun and earth in it, XD
Nothing spiritual about a flying monkey eating the sun for dinner.
@@NordicPolestar Hehe, maybe there is spirituality in pervy prophet ig 😂
@@shreeshabhat110 Didn't know you believed in prophets. Oh well whatever rocks your boat i guess.
Actually not
Asmaan ko chukar dekho supremacy🛐
I think best way to tell if the if Tulsi Das was right or not is by getting what was the value of Yuga and Yojna during Mughals time. Taking surya samantha or Ashoka would be metrices for tulsi das would be highly inaccurate. Why? Simply because there was difference of more than 500 years. Plus most Indian universities like in Nalanda or Taxila or records existing had been burned or destroyed during Sultanats and Mughal eras.
I think alot of research hasn't been done to in Hindu in scriptutes and artifacts related to hindi faith as for other religion. Most of our findins and translation we have till now is based on British- archaeological findings.
Yes.
Yeh khud sala ricebag h randi ka
If a writer like Tulsidas had known the units he was using then sure it would have been a common knowledge among scientists of the time. It's not difficult to find that, 16th century isn't stone age. There are enough written material from the times. Newton had proposed laws of motion by the time.
Your way of thinking isn't scientific as much as you would want to believe while commenting this. There are more than overwhelming logic (forget evidence) to suggest that there wasn't any accurate way to measure such great distance at the time but you would still curate some mystery around it just so you could be write...
Third thing British stated this extensive way if scientific findings in the country. Let's not discourage anything because British stated it, as much as I hate colonization but I am not emotional about it. British used to ask things from Brahmins for scriptures and they often made extraordinary claims and glorified scripture. One of the biggest is that when British asked Brahmin to recognize script from Ashoka damma, they called it Brahma scrip, which do not have any mention in the history. So I think yes, there is lot misinterpretation of scripture, but I see it the other way round. There is so much wasteful glorification that needs to be shed after though scientific study by unbiased people, probably not upper castes... (Not necessarily)
Last Takshila and Nalanda weren't Hindu schools. They were Buddhist schools. But since it was university they allowed everybody there, even foreigners. Brahmin were welcomed.
It wasn't mughals who destroyed it, read about it.... But anyway. We don't know how they reached there. Muslim foreign ruler at the time invaded only for loot and there was no wealth to be looted from Nalanda. Then why would they destroy it. ??? What was the motive ? There is an article that tells story how brahmins were plotting against Nalanda and they had some deal with these invaders and they helped them walked into such distant land of Ganga plains, which wasn't possible at the time
@@NileshKumar-nr2vj It's funny to hear someone claiming that Britishers took words of Brahmins by heart and wrote everything as said by Brahmins(who confidently forgot calling Buddhist, Jain and Sikh preachers XD).
While you who read all so many fancy conspiracy theories forgot to read that Britishers didn't even took a word of any Indian and read every language like Tamil, Sanskrit themselves to translate them in there language. Proof? Well if you consider ever reading Hindu scriptures in Sanskrit you'll know that Hinduism is a Monoesthetic religion with one being the ultimate we call Brahman(now don't confuse with Brahmin) there are not thousands of gods in Hinduism but only 33 originated from him, so how it got all messed up? Because as I said metrics got changed as time passed the word Koti which meant supreme got mixed up with crores so when the British learned Sanskrit they saw it as Crores which was then prevalent meaning.
I know you'll not take my word but some people on net who themselves never have read Sanskrit in there lives to interpret history but if you have brains so just Google who all under British regime translated Indian scriptures, you'll see hotshots like Sir William Jones never took words of any Indian for granted read everything on its own, applied his own logic to things and served it to people.
And you who hate Brahmins so much if you ever consider having time to read scriptures like Jaya( or Mahabharat as we often misinterpret it) read how despite Karna being declared as sudra(untouchable) got accepted into high society as soon as Duryodhan made him king. Simple fact to prove how the Caste system was a class system that became rigid because people stopped switching their job profiles. A simple take we still carry it on never focussed on it but you'll find people relentlessly looking for evidence to plot Brahmins for everything despite when every historical finding shows Brahmins lived in utmost poverty.
It's same as US where certain group of people are being targetted for every hate crime. This is called victim card, just keep up the heat do whatever is necessary to put blame on one set of people, never to solve the problem just big talks, big conspiracy theories. I have read many articles how Hitler survived WWII, lived his life near US and created KKK. Go on you'll find one. There are alot of findings that claim Gandhi could had possibly prevented killing of Bhagat Singh if he wanted.
P.S: Sorry for my poor English, you see I spend more time reading and learning Sanskrit to understand the actual meaning of scriptures rather than quoting the text of some Communist Historian who has the next brilliant English understanding and poor other language understanding.
Also if you ever get time pls tell me the names of Scientists you referred who could had verified metrics used by Tulsi das during Mughal rule and pls don't tell some Muslim scientist because they never read and wrote in Awadhi or Sanskrit.
It makes me very happy to see your work. When I was in school I obsessively watched a TH-cam channel called "It's okay to be smart" which is now named "Be smart". It's host created such good content that I found myself immersed in the world of science all day long. At that time there were no Indian TH-cam channels creating content similar to his. But now there is. Your content has differences but it still is rigorous in its research just as those American channels are. Hope your channel keeps growing and contributing to a scientifically literate India.
This video is a result of Opinion bias and lack of scriptural understanding.
1. You lost credibility when you multiplies 12,000 with 360 claiming 12,000 is divya yuga .
firstly there are different types of yugas such as Manu yuga , divya yuga , daiva yuga , brahma yuga and soo on . Divine yugas when compared to yuga of Manu , you dont have to multiply if with 360 , 12000 it is.
2. Tulsi Ramayan mentions hanuman when flying around earth covers 3300 yojan . 33000 *12= 39,600 ( approx ) . while modern calculations of circumfrence of earth is pretty close at 40000. Therefore 1 yojan has to taken 12 cm . This cant be a mere co incidence that Tulsi das is using yojan to descibe to values that match pretty much with present day calculations .
Please don't delete my comments
@@themysteryschool- Hey where can I learn about Ancient Indian Maths or Vedic Maths from scratch? Like books, any recommendations?
@@themysteryschool- so you decide which yojan is by reverse calculating.
You already knew earth circumference and then you reverse calculate it to fit in your yojan value.
@@themysteryschool- And 3300×12 cm = 39600 cm and earth is around 40000 km.
I love how Hindu extremists are barking that he is a Muslim, he is a mullah in comments 😂. It proves how intelligent they are 😂😂
There is not a single comment i have found which claims that in this video that he is a Muslim . Don't be a fool and try to make others
Truth is no hindu has said so u muslims create ur own stories
@underground leaks 101 acha 😂 christians aur sikhs hamare saath hai iss mamle mai aur tho kon hey bhee . tera religion ko koi accept tak nahi kartha
@underground leaks 101 jaa kar Allah ke naam par bomb fad sale hume andhbhakt kehte hai aur khud chutiyo ki tarah pura din Allah Allah karte hai
@underground leaks 101 kam se kam hum sawal utha sakte hai tabhi main yeh science is dope ki video dekhta hu aur accept bhi karta hu tumhari tarah nahi ki koi kitab ko asmani kitab bol kar uss par andha vishwas Karu tum toh sawal bhi nhi utha sakte apni Qur'an par agar uthaoge toh tumhare ghar wale hi maar denge tumhe . Kyuki tum chutiyo ko toh yahi lagta hai allah tumhe jannat dega kisi ko marne Katne par
Just yesterday this friend of mine who is an mtech from IIT was trying to convince me on this. But after that he started talking about advanced ancient civilizations and thei super advanced tech and some dumb quantum time travel and aliens so i just went back home 🤷🏻♂️. And apparently this is very common in these it bros in Bengaluru. They see little videos about science and start making up theories without doing the math 😅
quantum time travel got me rollin
@@archit1048 seriously he made a diagram of a cube and then started saying shit about 4 dimensions and then went to time travel. And after that they started talking about how ancient civilizations were super advanced . Thankfully i didn't stay for long
But it's not just bangalore it's everywhere
@@urooj09 4th dimension is just limited to logic and maths for now, great you fled otherwise you would've became a conspiracy theorist
@@archit1048 nah encountered way to many people like this. I am pretty sceptical now
You explained the methodology and then debunked the myth…. I don’t know if everyone will get this… but I understood as I am a regular viewer of yours… keep doing this kind of stuff 👍🏻. Great Video as always
Jab mythology hai usmai kya debunk karna...
@@fpscbugs *history not mythology bitvh
+1
+2
I want to say something.....
Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries
Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity....
By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ?
Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture
I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya"
You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths
Our rich culture had everything
But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
Boy! I watched all ur videos today and today was the first day I ever watched ur videos! I am a hindu but loved all the debunking! Keep doing ur great work. We need rationality!
Let's look at this formula from unit perspective, for example
Distance= speed * time
Is the speed is in km/hr and time is in hour then distance Will be measured in KM.
Here in Hanuman chalisa we calculate D = 12000 years * 1000 * 8 miles.
So my first question is what will be the unit of distance in this case ??
2nd question is what is 1000 ? Is it constant, and if it is constant what's the logic behind this constant?
What is the unit of this constant , because we know every constant have a unit.
My 3rd question is why they take 12000 years I mean if we are convert this in months , days then answer will be different.
jaake pehle 1oth paas kar light years is a unit of distance
its is yuga
idiot its light years pehle thoda padho likho uske baad in sab chizzo ko samjho
@@JEEstattemptrigvedian distance between earth and sun is 8.3 light minutes then in this first stance the Hanuman chalisa is wrong which is stating 12k light years i think u should study 🤣🤣
@@JEEstattemptrigvedian light years? Where does that comes from in measuring distance between Earth and Sun? It takes 8min dude you mean like 8/60*24*365 light years?
Its just an algebraic equation, not a formula that's why we need only numbers not units. In light years also time is multiplied with distance, in the same way here time is multiplied with distance
12000 here is light years and 1000 here are yojanas and one yojana is 8 miles hope you will understand
Science cannot explain everything.......It is still in its evolving state .......Roz naye naye theories aate rehte hai.....
Bhaiya ek baar ved padho.....unme bahut advanced mathematics explained hai Sanskrit sloks me......
If you see at our ancient temples , you can surely notice beautiful geometry and many unbelievable carvings......wo sab dekh kr lagega ki hamare ancestors must be mathematics and architecture genius.......their is geometry in each and every ancient Hindu temple.......
Please watch Praveen Mohan once......he is a great researcher....
science explains everything that religion couldn't. bcoz of science we have come this far....before 18th century child birth used to be a horror 75-80% women wuth their child used to die while giving birth...but nowadays child birth success rate is 80%. Anywhere you go u will find great historic architecture not in India only.
A lot of believers nowadays try to connect culture and tradition (here Hanuman Chalisa) to science to prove atheists that they are superior. They can’t just keep culture as culture and try to shove nonsense reasoning behind everything into others throat. Great video man… Will love to see more such videos.
I want to say something.....
Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries
Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity....
By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ?
Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... th-cam.com/video/TnvzNFf6V44/w-d-xo.html here is the link of the video made by professor hc verma iitk
I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya"
You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths
Our rich culture had everything
But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
I want to say something.....
Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries
Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity....
By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ?
Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture
I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya"
You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths
Our rich culture had everything
But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
Yeah like hanuman chalisa is like a huge verse really good literature don’t need to make that into science if only people understood this
@@gurramprahallad3403 Ok what about Earth shape. In Vishnu Puran Earth has been shown as Gol what do you say about that.
@@preetiraut7700 It's the beauty of the Vishnu Puran.
Bro you are absolutely telling the truth. I am myself a sanatani and i have researched on these topics. The verse actually means "Moving towards the sun which is innumerable/thousands of miles away, with ease as you thought it to be a sweet fruit". And the meaning of sahasra can be translated to both thousands or innumerable. And the meaning of yuga is unification. Some people use this as a proof to show how santan is the truth. But there are texts like aryabhattiya and surya sidhantha which give a logical explanation to find out the distance, diameter, velocity etc of the grahas.
You do realise they are fables told to teach you lessons right? Not to be taken literally. As for distance Tulsidas was pretty accurate. First There is no exact distance mentioned thats why its approximately.. so the distance mentioned by Tulsidas is pretty accurate. It can be coincidence but Tulsidas definitely wins here.. not just that tulsidas also mentions circumference of earth.
@@thethreespikes9737 may be true but we need to research more.
@@thethreespikes9737 true. Hanuman chalisa is not supposed to be a science textbook
@@shahanshahpolonium yup. Its definitely not science.
Here's what you should do, learn sanskrit, and read vedas by yourself, so that there will be no third person, if u are searching google for it, so let me tell you that, translations of vedas has so many flaws that literally changes the meaning by almost 90deg, I was also same as you, thinking that vedas are just so called written stuff without any actual reason behind it, here's what I did, I learned sanskrit, went to ISKON to get the real versions of vedas and read them, what I found was eye-opening, vedas were so advance that we couldn't understand it till date, how can u search something on google which is not yet discovered or know to humans, ryt. so if u wanna find your answers get back to ancient hindu scriptures speically "suktas" and if are saying that "I don't know sanskrit" then learn it, no point in sitting here listening to some random guy who claims to be a science guru, I bet he can't even prove mathematical thesis by himself, I am not being a hinduism supporter here, I found what I was looking for in vedas and never have to read any other book. good luck, get your study right mate.
To those of you who're waiting to get offended, explaining science doesn't equate to attacking a religion. Please grow up.
Please discuss about that Hanuman ji eating the sun .
He never ate Sun, he approached the sun to show who is more hot 🔥🥵😎
you dont need science to disprove it
@@lemonboy21 🛐
Some things are better left unsaid.
@@lemonboy21 Which sun?The Sun is controlled by Each Aditya in each month
Intern : what is recursion ?
Senior : Distance = Distance x time
Maybe it is computer code written in verses
Look we had computers back then
😂😂
🤣🤣🤣...Good one...
@@infinix2003 yes bro🤗🤗🤗
Ha ha ha! 😂🤣
8:29 :- The question of considering 1 Yuga as 12,000, and why not as 4,320,000 yrs is absolutely ridiculous. Because whenever we are converting any unit, we do it according to the requirement of the problem. For suppose 1kilometre= 1000 meters , and the same 1km= 1,00,000cm. so here to ask why is 1km= 1000m why not 1,00,000cm is really silly. so here we need to consider 1 yojana as 12,000 yrs only.
7:30 :- The value for 1 yojana in Ashoka time period (304 - 232 BCE) was 4.3 miles. But the value taken in hanuman Chalisa was 8 miles because it was written in 16th century CE. (Different time periods) thus the value for it may change . Different mathematicians of different time period gave different values for a single Unit (Yojana) so we need to consider a value which was taken at that particular time period (16th century CE). The value Tulsidas considered while writing Hanuman Chalisa was 8 miles ( Which was the value accepted by the mathematicians of that particular time period ). (You can also google the value for yojana in google you get 8 miles ).
So therefor if we multiply everything we get 9,60,00,000 miles. The Yug (unit for a time period ) is considered to express distance just for the better understanding and for the rhyming of the poem. ( Hanuman chalisa is a poem not a mathematical article to explain the derivation of distance from sun to earth ). If you want any proof for the calculation for the distance from sun to earth you may find it in other books written by the mathematicians (not by poets and not in devotional poems ).
Yug sahastra yojan gives the distance from earth to sun which was travelled by hanuman ji. Everything said in the hanuman chalisa is 100% correct.
JAI SHREE RAM !!!
Leave it brother, ye converted 2 rice bag wale kaha jante hai, inke Christianity me bade logical scientific chize likhi hui hai bible me.😂
Thanks for the information, Akhheel. His Hinduphobia is blatant and obvious. He won't even consider agreeing to anything in favour of Hinduism due to his biasness.
how come a flying monkey, brahma nd other hindu gods couldn't met mohhamad that cut moon in half, jesus, greek gods, egyption gods, etc.
how a religion that claims its god 'brahma' made this world couldn't get the image of the planets right?
PEAK FICTION!😂
How can every religion claims their hods made this world?
PURE BULLSH*T!😂
@@shantanuhardiha who told ya religions have logic?
Har har mahadeva
The reality is that people who believe in supernatural things dont have to do anything with reality and science , even if they are presented with a proof they will still deny it , as evident from this comment section .
Science was considered a witch craft.
Seriously, the research you did is mind blowing, thanks for this information. I still remeber a cartoon during COVID where the main 3 religious priest were standing behind a scientist and it reads "religious ppl are waiting the cure to be discovered to claim that it was alreday written in their HOLY BOOKS" 😂.
Keep it up, i gonna download this, who know they might take this down. 😏.
Keep it up brother 👍💪😍😍😍
I want to say something.....
Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries
Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity....
By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ?
Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture
I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya"
You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths
Our rich culture had everything
But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
@@powerenergy3480 Wooo wo wooo... Hold your power Mr Energy. Thanks for your Half cooked info.
And also give some respect to Mr Science is dope, atleast he put his name on the channel and tell everything on face, unlike some Energy guy who hides behind the Power of internet anonymity.
2nd point- we Indians were good at some Old point of time, then we were so much so that, we happily accept our mistakes, eager to learn without having ego, and more over we always try to find our own mistake rather putting Fingers in others eye to show THEIR mistake (for example we india have everything but was destroyed by other countries, we never accept that we Bharatiyas were so devided among MAHARANAS, RAJPUTS, MARATHA, DRAVIDAS, Buddhists, jains, etc etc that we try to kill destroyed each others just to keep supremacy. Yeah that was seen by invaders and they exploited that. POINT IS, IF WE WERE SO DEVELOPED AND WHAT NOT HOW A NON DEVELOPED AND UNCOUTH MUGHALS or Whoever the invaders were invade us, we had something which killed that great Bharata, so admit that we were great as all culture and civilization were, and we had Idiots, backstabbers just the others had, sp don't boast we had everything and someone else destroyed that..)
3rd point, i am really sorry that you happens to passed 9th and 11th standard with half knowledge,
"Snth" is the distance travelled by the body in "nth" second, not distance travelled between nth second, so dimension of Snth is not L1, its L1T-1..
Please refer this 9th standard stuff..
brainly.in/question/3321367
And yes we love our country, which is why we think everything on scientific temperament, just the way our old dudes did.
Don't be blind by jingoism, have patriotism rather.
Hope you listen the entire video, where he explicitly said why the distance calculation was faulty.
Go listen that...
forget about sun distance, the idea of a flying ape that could eat a sun itself is so bogus, don’t forget the person transforming into deer to lure sita or the half human half elephant ganesha, these are mythological creatures and should be treated as such
That is what i have been saying all years
Isn't the distance between The Sun and the Earth different during different times of the year? If I can recall the lessons from school correctly then we're closer to the Sun during summers and farther from it during winters.
Yes
Yeah the distance is different at different times.
But the last line isn't entirely correct. Firstly it depends on the hemisphere. Since India is in the northern hemisphere and we all know summers are at the peak during June. But it's the opposite for the southern hemisphere where summers are in January.
Also, the reason for summer being hotter is not that the earth is closer to the sun, in fact for the northern hemisphere it's quite the opposite. During June July the earth is farther from the sun than it is in January.
The reason for temperature being higher in the northern hemisphere during june is the earth's TILT, since the earth is 23.5 degrees tilted from its axis (as you can see in the globe models we get in the market) the sun rays fall more on the northern hemisphere during june due to the earth being tilted TOWARDS the sun.. and the southern hemisphere is tilted away from the sun hence it has winters..
As a visual representation:
This slash represents the tilt of the earth /
/ 🌞 /
See on left how the upper part of the slash is tilted towards the sun? That's the northern hemisphere now having summers.. (even though it is farther from the sun as compared to earth during January)
And on the right is the earth during January.. see how the lower part of the sun is now towards the sun.. that's southern hemisphere now having summers..
So the distance is not the primary factor for higher temperatures.
It's the tilt and the angle at which the sun rays fall and heat up the earth. 😊
Iss Chutiye ne bharbhur praytna kiya ki kaise Sanatan wrong hai lekin ye chutitya ye bhul gaya ki agar 2023 me 1 mile = 3.5 km hai to main 2023 ki hi value lunga na ki 1200 saal pehle ki. Param Pujya Parameshwara ne bhi 8 miles hi liya hai aur Aur ek Angrez tha usne bhi , dusri baat 1200 divya varsha liya to iske baap ka kya gaya ? TULSIDAS JI DIVYA Sant the. Toh divya hi liya jo change nahi hota. Kitna bhi samjhao in Chutiyo ko Angrezo ka Guu hi mitha lagta hai.
You're right. But ellipse is a projection of circle, hence project it as a circular thing and measure the mean distance(radius)
Let’s pretend for a moment that Hanuman chaalisa is actually correct about the distance.
The Hanuma chalisa is said to composed in 16th century. But no original manuscripts exist for it from 16th century. It is a chalisa. that can be recited in 10 minutes. Yet not even 150 year old manuscript exist for it. On the other hand we still have original handwritten notebooks by Christian Huygens who was the earliest person to come close to the modern known value of distance to sun. Those notebooks are still part of Leiden University archives. We still have 300+ year old palm leaf manuscripts of actual mathematical and astronomical work from Kerala-school mathematicians, no one of them refers to this distance calculation method as in Hanuman Chalisa. Hanuman Chalisa is not a ‘pracheen’ kitaab as claimed by many.
@ZAP GAMERZ arey bhai 10th class ka maths yaad aa gaya...
The manuscript doesn't exist because the mughals, britishers and the congress destroyed it because they didn't wanted anyone to know about it.
Also they killed every person knew about this to male themselves feel better and greater and to oppress hindus.
europeans got their mathematical and scientific knowledge from bharat through arab traders. you telling me that these maclecchas europeans who were living around garbage dumps till about 15th century could find this? not possible. most prolly this clown transtlated sanskrit texts into his eu lang and burned the original source. same thing newton did. eu should go back to poverty and bharat back to ancient glory.
ok then those manuscripts are also bullshit
Manuscripts would have been there if hinduism wasn't exploited from time to time. Books and scriptures wouldn't have been burnt. Western world was powerful hence nobody dared to do so, where as Sanatani's were too flexible.. That is it
Please debunk more pseudoscience. I love your channel
I want to say something.....
Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries
Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity....
By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ?
Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture
I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya"
You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths
Our rich culture had everything
But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
Hanuman chalisa isn't science. Let alone pseudoscience. There's nothing to debunk here. It's just for devotion and nobody takes it literally. If I say "you're moon to my life" in my poem doesn't mean my partner is my moon and not the actual moon itself. These are just metaphors. Funny how people make money from so called "debunking" the cultural things.
@@sudhakar7889 same way as people make money by fooling innocent people...its reverse of it...
Hanuman chalisa is not science but some people falsly claim..and it need to be debunked ...
And tell me that u didnt aware of it ..this false claim
@@sudhakar7889 Your entire opinion stipulates this video to be debunking Hanuman Chalisa, which is false per se when looked upon with some logical use of the mind. This video debunks the so called rationality of these conspiracy theories or pseudo-science. Your claim that everybody takes Hanuman Chalisa as no more than just another _bhajan_ contradicts beliefs of several people who found the distance to Sun from Earth using Hanuman Chalisa by illogical and nonconstructive manipulation of SI units and rational inconsistency. Sun to Earth distance from Hanuman Chalisa is only one of many claims (e.g. speed of light, cosmic energy, dark matter, etc.)-it is the people of your cult trying to find science in spirituality, Hindu scriptures, etc.
in "Yug Sahastra yojana",
1) Firstly, we take Yug as divine years because we are talking about the long distance of earth and sun so we use the largest unit for example, when we measure long distance like between Delhi and Kanyakumari we use km not cm, similarly we can say tulsidas ji used here divine years, which is common sense(Not so common)
2) Now, secondly Sahastra means 1000
3) Thirdly, when the yojana is taken as 8 miles because traditionally the value of 1 yojana is considered 8 miles like as per famous texts like Bhagvat Maha purana (For proof see the work of Prabhupada ji), but now as you said that the value of 1 yojana changed in different centuries, if we take this argument then also the value of given by Tulsidas is right, I explained it below:
The hanuman Chalisa is written by Tulsidas ji in "16TH CENTURY". During the medieval period like 14th to 16th century famous mathematicians like Bhakara II and Parmeswaran(you said it yourself!) took the value of 1 yojana as 8 miles, so perhaps Tulsidas ji used the metric systems of his own times like many scientists do or also he took the value of yojana as 8 miles because that's what there is in Bhagavat Maha purana, which was one of the texts he worshiped.
Now if you put it, 12000 x 1000 x 8 = 96 million miles.
Hence proved!
First we are talking about the value of one yug which equates to 12000 divine years which 1 divine year does give 360 years or something and even in modern theory one yug was mentioned as 24000years
Third yojana is not 8 miles nowhere there is fixed number for yojana some sanskrit text define yojana as yoking indicating the distance that oxen yoked to royal carts traverse in a day.
Some article says it is the distance the royal army can march in a day
Sahastra may be 1000 but some scholars even says sahastra can be taken as infinity but I think most accepted is 1000 and there is no unit of sahastra
How does multiplying a unit of time (divine years) with a unit of distance(yojana) give an answer in distance units?
If say distance between delhi to Kolkata is abc, where a, b and c are constant, I am not talking about distance or time formula, I am just talking about there multiplication, he multiplied 3 values, which comes out to be distance. Yug, sahastra and yojana. We took yug as 12000 divine years, as the primary value of 1 yug is 12000 divine years, rest all are secondary values
If u travel 2 km in 2 hrs it doest not mean u travelled 4 km 😅 its simple math after multiplying time with distance its value would be km × hr not in km only
Well explained! I was hoping you'd mention or perhaps hinted at the works of Aristarchus of Samos, an ancient Greek astronomer (310 - 230 BC). His attempt to calculate the distance to Sun using the concept of Solar Parallax, documented in the egyptian copy from Alexandria "On the Sizes and Distances of the Sun and Moon" [Περὶ μεγεθῶν καὶ ἀποστημάτων]
greeks got their knowledge from india they larnt it from indian gurus one such ex is pythogorous theorem
This was actually before the Indo-greek period, the Yavanas were prominent in Indian subcontinent only during the Indo-greek era. That's when the Mauryan empire was prevalent
@@kalebj7001 if they were only in the mauryan era
Why we find Indus valley traces of communal trade between Indians and Greeks 🙄
Well I am always right 😂
If those vitamin D deficient say day a night it's night
Like seriously you believe Greeks and other westerners when their descendants doesn't even knew earth was not flat until 1600s where as in India at that time Hanuman chalisa was trying to show distance between eartg and sun
And yes this person "science is dope" isn't a Sanskrit scholar and obivously won't understand ancient Sanskrit words
And hence is not perfect with his explanation
Just some so called gyani Indians proving there ancestors wrong for vitamin D deficient westerners
So just chill bruh!!! 😂
Do you know bro that according to german group of scientists there are 5 particles in the proton hence resulting in 1.5x mass of the proton
Hence resulting in increase in every objects mass that we measure today...
Like the way terms yojna and yug is used the values change with time
Even science don't keep anything constant the 1 kg mass at the France physics department (i don't know the name) showed variation around 5 miligram in previous around 20 years
Hence the value changes nothing is constant as the space is expanding every second and one day we would need some new values for various aspects of science 😐
You always go the extra mile. Thanks for such a thorough explanation. Cheers man!
Iss Chutiye ne bharbhur praytna kiya ki kaise Sanatan wrong hai lekin ye chutitya ye bhul gaya ki agar 2023 me 1 mile = 3.5 km hai to main 2023 ki hi value lunga na ki 1200 saal pehle ki. Param Pujya Parameshwara ne bhi 8 miles hi liya hai aur Aur ek Angrez tha usne bhi , dusri baat 1200 divya varsha liya to iske baap ka kya gaya ? TULSIDAS JI DIVYA Sant the. Toh divya hi liya jo change nahi hota. Kitna bhi samjhao in Chutiyo ko Angrezo ka Guu hi mitha lagta hai.
Its not pseudoscience just imagine why would Tulsidas mention the units of distance in a poem and thats not only coincidence it is mentioned in a place where hanuman was going towards the sun and moreover yuga is termed as 12000 years (not divine years)to make a proper rhyme as there no proper term for 12k years.Your videos just shows how hinduism gives a close challenge to all the scientist.For your info in hinduism it is mentioned that there are 64 dimensions and lord krishna had already explained the concept of multiverse way more than 5000 years if you can you can make videos on that also.moreover even you consider the value of yojana from 5-8 it will change the value only by certain kms
actually he never told it was pseudoscience
It does not matter how long a yojana should be. What matters is what their hypothesis is i.e. how much yojana can light cover in a specific amount of time. Taking yojana as 9, it gives a good estimate of the speed as what matters in the end is the ratio. If we consider yojana as 8, then time taken to cover that yojana would be less or in physics terms, more yojana would be covered in 1 second however the speed would still be the same. Moving on, we still cannot ignore the possibility that they already knew the distance from earth to sun and they just took 3 convenient values to represent that distance. Maybe the original hindu research paper was destroyed so we'll never know their logic, but still, we know that they had an almost accurate value. Chew on that. Great video!!!
Brother how can we multiply years with miles and get the final answer in miles?
@@bhardwajparth Ok idk about this thing about sanskrit and ancient maths but answering your question
For eg- i travel 500 miles a year and travel for 5 years then -500mile ×5years = 2500miles of my total displacement
@@bhardwajparth Let's think. What if they had calculated the distance from earth to sun in some other way and just used three different values to fit in the distance into the hanuman chalisa. and my comment has a focus on how rigveda tells the speed of light
@@stewie2838 if you travel 500 miles in one year the DISTANCE travelled is 500 miles...
But... In this case the distance to be calculated isn't travelled in 1200 years (1 yuga)
They are randomly multiplying some years with some distance and making the answer in unit of distance (kms)
@@adityarohit4088 see i cannot make someone believe something who has a confirmation bias but atleast try to think that if they really just wanted to tell the actual distance by using some random dimensions why isn't there a mention of it anywhere else many scholars have read hanuman chalisa nobody found out the distance?
Only after the westerners found the distance people realised that it was already mentioned?
I have a bit different opinion here,, i am not denying his research but the thing which always forces me to think about hanuman chalisa thing is that, that shlok is really talking about that story of lord hanuman where he went to sun thinking it is a sweet fruit. The shloka's Hindi translation is "yug shahastra yojan ki duri par Surya jisko hanuman ji mitha fal samajh liye the". And yug's value of 12000 divine year is already mentioned every year,, ( and i am talking about divine year not human year) and then shastra is 1000 and finally as per video even if we take any value between (4.3 to 9miles) for yojan , the value we get is really a type of value which a human sitting on earth without any knowledge of distance can never think of , if we multiply 12×10^6 with 4.3 miles we will get around 51 million miles ,, really can any one think randomly that this can be the distance lord Hanuman went for sun without any knowledge??. And for those people who are telling about unit mismatch ,, man it is a poem and it should rhyme also to sound good,, why you guys are thinking that anybody will write 12000. It is not mathematical equation, people found the logic in these lines and found a value which is very close to the original value we get in modern world.. I don't know what is right and what is wrong but there is some logic in those two lines...
Brother, 16th century when hanuman chalisa was written isn't too long ago. It is very much possible that some Indian scientist had figured out the distance to sun, and it was common knowledge in India at that time.
Greeks had figured out the distance to the moon in 2nd century BCE itself, ~1700 years before the Hanuman chalisa. It is not a miracle or divine knowledge. It is just science.
Just 50 years (after hanuman chalisa) Newton had figured the reason for elliptical orbits of planets. And created calculus in his spare time.
Second, if you take hanuman chalisa yojan value to be correct then you must accept rig veda is wrong in its calculation 7:19. Both cannot be correct. You cannot pick & chose measurements according to convinience - one for hanuman chalisa and other for rig veda.
Do you realise that 16th century had enormous amount of astrologica knowledgel pretty well established ??
@@NileshKumar-nr2vj no cuz the greeks are know for those things and the greeks came thousandd of years after the 16th century wich explaind that was no advanced theories about the astrology wich means the persin writing that poem is very intelegant and as he claims that he got his knowledge from hanuman and its storys hence proved that it really happend
@@chefpeepee8681 what ??? Try to form proper sentences and write things in way that it is comprehensible.. Whatever I understood doesn't make any sense.. And the fact about Greeks what you said is plain false
@@NileshKumar-nr2vj for u i will sons 😌 i meant to say that the greeks came thousands of years after the 16th century right ? And even the greeks didnt have advancend astrological equipments that means thousands of years earlier when we indians ,the sadhus where calculating the distance between the sun and the earth we didnt have advanced theoratical and praktick equipments to calculate the distance and still we calculated it super close enough to the actual distance calculated in the modern world that in it self is insanely impressive , thats all bye son and dont forget jay shree ram ♥️😌
It’s like making calculations to get 7 just to say Thala for a reason😂
Finally someone addressed this.
And as always again a good video and excellent work. Just keep making videos like this.
He should also make a video on people believe about getting 72 hoors after they sacrifice their lives forcing their religion beliefs on others..
@@johnny7252 yes he should.
Iss Chutiye ne bharbhur praytna kiya ki kaise Sanatan wrong hai lekin ye chutitya ye bhul gaya ki agar 2023 me 1 mile = 3.5 km hai to main 2023 ki hi value lunga na ki 1200 saal pehle ki. Param Pujya Parameshwara ne bhi 8 miles hi liya hai aur Aur ek Angrez tha usne bhi , dusri baat 1200 divya varsha liya to iske baap ka kya gaya ? TULSIDAS JI DIVYA Sant the. Toh divya hi liya jo change nahi hota. Kitna bhi samjhao in Chutiyo ko Angrezo ka Guu hi mitha lagta hai.
first they will find science in religion then they will reject science completely
Thank you for this wonderful video Pranav. Now I can sing hanuman chalisa with devotion without thinking about its scientific relevance and stuff. BTW, the dimensional analysis was great! You rock as always👏👏
Keep it up bhaiya💟,you are really explaining science correctly on the basis of real and proven informations, without violating philosophical aspects of Vedas and religion you are talking about actual science,though I'm a big devotee of Lord Hanuman,I do agree with your words,after all units and measurement methods are important.
Iss Chutiye ne bharbhur praytna kiya ki kaise Sanatan wrong hai lekin ye chutitya ye bhul gaya ki agar 2023 me 1 mile = 3.5 km hai to main 2023 ki hi value lunga na ki 1200 saal pehle ki. Param Pujya Parameshwara ne bhi 8 miles hi liya hai aur Aur ek Angrez tha usne bhi , dusri baat 1200 divya varsha liya to iske baap ka kya gaya ? TULSIDAS JI DIVYA Sant the. Toh divya hi liya jo change nahi hota. Kitna bhi samjhao in Chutiyo ko Angrezo ka Guu hi mitha lagta hai.
I don't know why people are not able to get this and blindly believing, absorbing everything. Distance = speed*time 6th class physics. Now, Why shall I multiply even at 1st place, even if I did multiply when I have learnt that Distance=S*T, why should I multiply Time again and again to get distance. It's basics...So what we are doing here, fooling ourselves. Why do we succumb to such things, how can we forget basics and blindly believe everything. And as a Hindu I never ever in my life expect or want to see scientific facts in religious scriptures because science means research and analysis and hypothesis. Religion is a belief it's a path to be chosen to lead a better life. They're both different things and better if not mixed up...
Ppla like u we called as pade likhe gawar log
@@amitchhetri2067 people like u i like to refer as "who hurt you 😢😢😢"
2 yrs ago I watched this video
Disliked it and opt for don’t recommend this channel
Because I didn’t have any counter argument
Today I came back here
With a changed perspective
Watched the entire video
And again left out with no counter
BECAUSE FACTS CANT BE COUNTERED
Sad but true 😢
You know what I'm hindu my self but since 2014 something is going in my nation where each and everything is related to vedas and hindu dharm
If corona wave came they says vedas already warn us
If we got vaccine then they says vedas already have the solution
If chandrayan succeed they says its all because of our beloved modi who is Avatar of vishnu
Like what the hell
Bro be proud that you are human who can think on his own but some fools love to listen about mythology so much that they think everything is about my dharm😂
Tanu don't worry stay safe some people are still here.
Kepler's law > Hanuman Chalisa.
They will call this as colonial mentality
@@rudra20048 I mean, i agree that I'm stupid to compare a poem with science. But that's what they're doing.
They can't be compared cause one is a scientific manuscript while the other is a devotional text. You've also not defined a particular compatible criteria for comparison. Go get some ideas about units and measurements about what and how things are comparable.
@@DisProfundis read my reply to user SECULAR ATHEIST SIRE
kepler is eurpean and eurpean got all their knwoledge from tests stolen from india from integration to newtons law those uncivilized malecchas stole it from india.
The more I watch your video the more I get surprised how this claims are made by some pseudo science people and how much effort you put to save us the misinformation, much love sir 🔥❤️.
I want to say something.....
Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries
Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity....
By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ?
Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture
I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya"
You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths
Our rich culture had everything
But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
The main concern with ancient texts is that most of us haven't read them fully so we just keep coming up with half researched facts . And many of those text have been burnt by the foreign rulers here. I didn't believed the hanuman chalisa fact but things like grutvakarshan (gravitation) is really something calculated and well defined in our texts way before newton.
carl sagan : admiring work of ancient people of india in hinduism
meanwhile random guy on youtube with 116k subs & 7.4k likes : it is a total myth sarrrrr
He is a converted halleluyah guy😂
@@OneAboveAll2023 :)
Carl sagan said "by accident the numericals of hinduism match with the scientific calculation of the cosmos" 💀
@@THATMUSLIMCHAD- your name tells me that even you were the result of accident between me and your mother🐵
@@THATMUSLIMCHAD- now this days come where flat earth believer talking about sanatan😂
A few counter points from my end:
1. In older times there was no internet and India was not a single country so assuming that the units they used should be the same in all records is not totally logical. Even today units are not the same throughout the world.
2. Since Sanskrit was one of the prominent languages, they used the same words in this case yojan.
3. There have been improvements in science and a lot of values have improved with time, especially recently. For instance the speed of light was corrected over years. So why do you think any specific value shouldn't (or even should) be the right/exact value according to that time science.
4. Why do you expect that the ancient scientists or scholars should have used and written equations in today's units/conventions. Their way of representing numbers or equations could have been different. Duh! It's a convention that humans create not a natural phenomenon/divine rules. If You don't understand it does not necessarily make it wrong.
5. You know a lot of texts and books were lost during the phases of invasions so maybe there was an explanation for the calculation which got lost. May be just maybe. In every ages you see references of day to day life or known facts in the literature, so let's say tomorrow science discovers that 'The sun rises in the south not east.' but still you'd see a lot of books containing the reference that the sun rises in East. What do you expect all those words to vanish from these books? Just to make a point that literature works can contain scientific facts true to their times.
6.These are just speculations, just like you can't prove it's wrong, one can't prove it's correct. People believe in what they want to believe in irrespective of their religion or country of origin. We humans always try to find a way to justify our beliefs by finding true things/coincidences, it's important for us to be hopeful and also gives meaning to life. There's another branch of science called psychology and that's dope too.
7. Sometimes putting another video and stating something very obvious according to science is your way of earning money. Understandable.
8. Just food for thought; make a video debunking islamic beliefs and will see you somewhere in cosmos soon.
By this point of time, your bias is probably visible. No offence but, people who are pointing this out may have a valid point. Don't be exactly like sudo science guys by making fun of someone who's putting a question forward. It would be more sensible to analyse, access and answer the question, rather than making fun of them by pinning their comments.
Took me 5 minutes to type all these points from my mobile and no research needed, just some common sense. Also, any typo and all please ignore da.
I agree with you.
Agreed
Counter to your counter no.8 th-cam.com/video/bfDFMN412ms/w-d-xo.html
Bro this guy will surely delete ur comment if u get too many likes
Mujhe kya mai toh bas ramayan aur mahabharat life lessons ke liye padhta hu
There is no pointing on proving "WE ARE THE BEST, WE KNOW EVERYTHING"
And people should focus on the learning we get from our history.
I mean that is a very great way of escaping somthing when you know you are fcked up
@@loading3138 Only fake people who spread wrong info get fucked. I just learn from history, I learn from the mistakes of my ancestors and it is common sense.
life lesson?😂
i laughed so hard while watching ramyab/mahabharat peak fiction...matlab kuch bhi ho rha hai...ye ramayan/mahabharat likhne wala ne kaunsa nasha kiya tha?
@@viditsonkar1855 jo nasha B@b@ saheb ne samvidhan likhte waqt kiya tha
@@nagatouzumaki-gq4oj ye baba saheb kaun hai?
hey!! answer this-1.what about the immense gravitational field created by hanuman if he became so large to put sun in his mouth it would have disturbed the entire solar system
2. monkeys dont fly
3.how can someone be so stupid to think its a fruit ( even a kid)
4.why he went to sun ( fruit) in the first place if he can have even more fruits nearby on his own planet
First read then criticise please
I don't think so he will but if I may..
This is just satire so sit back and enjoy.
1. Hanuman is a god being and doesn't possess mass and the 4 forces of physics don't apply on them. So sun is nothing but his throat and he is so large we cannot ever see him
2. Monkeys don't fly but Hanuman is Superman so he can shoot lasers off his eye and can fly anywhere he wants with any velocity he thinks of. He was injected with super soldier serum compound V in childhood by his parents
3. He was not stupid, he was like Forrest gump. He thought that it looks like orange and is colored orange so he went and ate it. I forgot to mention along with superman, he also has powers of ant man. He can become any size he wants. He can grow to size of 100 universe length.
4. The sun was only his first fruit after that he went and ate 1000s of more of fruits and they are the other solar systems. It is actually hidden but he ate a lot of solar systems. He became Galactus basically and killed a lot of galaxies before coming to our solar system but the power and 5th fundamental hidden force field coming from earth was too strong to withhold the eating and he failed
Who told you the wrong story.
1. Hanuman is jumping a way long (bze he so powerful) looks like he is flying but he jumping one place to another like monkey.
2. He jump to eat the sun but he never eat sun in the way indra came and story going on.
@@utkarshdubey4171 amar chitra Katha?
@@utkarshdubey4171 did u read yourself? I can guarantee you didnt
There is a channel named 'Project Shivoham'. He made a video on the same topic.
Project shivoham makes videos on spirituality and hinduism.
So if you think that Pranav (Science is Dope) has some anti-hindu ajenda, then you can watch Project Shivoham's video on this topic.
Hey bro. Love your videos man. It is cause of you that now I look at things objectively. Please make a video on vastu shastra and feng shui as well. Its plaguing the entire architecture field. Professionals are being advised by these so called experts who don't even have a degree.
I want to say something.....
Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries
Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity....
By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ?
Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture
I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya"
You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths
Our rich culture had everything
But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
Science is truly dope ! Thank you so much for this level of content and research
Ur science dosent teaches you law of karma
@@harshvardhan2023 My Physics teacher did discuss about karma and how it is nothing more than just wishful thinking
@@harshvardhan2023 karma is a bitch
Iss Chutiye ne bharbhur praytna kiya ki kaise Sanatan wrong hai lekin ye chutitya ye bhul gaya ki agar 2023 me 1 mile = 3.5 km hai to main 2023 ki hi value lunga na ki 1200 saal pehle ki. Param Pujya Parameshwara ne bhi 8 miles hi liya hai aur Aur ek Angrez tha usne bhi , dusri baat 1200 divya varsha liya to iske baap ka kya gaya ? TULSIDAS JI DIVYA Sant the. Toh divya hi liya jo change nahi hota. Kitna bhi samjhao in Chutiyo ko Angrezo ka Guu hi mitha lagta hai.
@@chiragdalwani4422nice one bro😂.
tulsidas wrote this book when he was captured and imprisoned by mughal/turk emperor, for latter felt offended on account of failure on the part of former to become soothsayer for that emperor. He/tulsidas was jailed and then he got the ideo to stay motivated by writing on the god he is fan of.
This book is devotional/emotional song, writer by a devotee. It was never written from the angle of measuring distance
😂😂 kuch bhi
1 Yojan = 13km(approx). 1600 Yojan = 20800 km. That's a big big difference. There is a big difference between being proud of our culture and becoming complacent, irrational to support something.
The arguments made are what we used to do in school where we manufactured calculations to fit the answer. The translations, definitions change as per convenience to support a point.
Think rationally and critically people.
What if it was just a common scientific fact known to the people at that time. And Tulsi Das just happens to use this in his poem without giving any theory behind it?
Could have been. Just show evidence then.
It's literally wrong number and wrong units! What?
@@pradeepkurapati1997 What is the unit in which the Astronomical distance is measured?
@@ashishsrivastava6524 you can use astronomical unit or light year ig
I think you don't get point
The people who glorify ancient text are they don't care about evidence
What they believe is Hinduism has advanced science and they don't care about evidence because it's all mahic bruh
Exactly Pranav you are right.
I don't have any doubt that our history had some amazing intelligent scientist and mathematicians. But we haven't totally understood their language, so we start doing false equivalence.
And you're right, Shree Hanuman Chalisa is our devotional book, why would we want to explain the distance between earth and sun. Maybe Tulsidas knew the distance and he conveyed that casually not scientifically. Jai Shree Ram🙏🏻🕉️
Wow wise people that's rare Jai shri ram 🙏
@@percypotter5050 It's your goodness to call me wise 🙏🏻 Jai Shree Ram🙏🏻🕉️
The writer of hanuman chalisa even know the Unit of distance to measure distance in the Universe which is Light Year according to science nowadays.
YUGA means unit of time used to measure a long period of time . here yuga used as light years to measure.
Sahastra means 1000 times
YOGAN used for measure of long distance at earth.
They just gave a hint in units not the exact numbers of distance. As they believe that distance between earth and sun changes during orbital revolving.
I searched for explaination of these hanuman chalisa claim but not found in past today looking your video it make clear❤❤❤❤❤❤
Bro your video editing has improved a lot looking forward to see more
Hey Pranav, I agree with most of what you said in the video except when you say, why look for science in a book that's not scientific?
The answer to that is, the time when the book was written, people most probably used these stories/shlokas/poems to communicate a lot of different subjects.
For example in the Ramayana, when hanuman asks how to get to the Himalayas from Lanka (to bring the sanjeevani booti), he is told the whole route, describing each and every major river, mountain, plains, etc that he'll encounter on the way to the Himalayas from Lanka.
This is an example of a whole geography lesson interwoven into the story. The writer could have written the Ramayana without any of this geography, but it was put there with the purpose to educate.
The education system at the time was just a bunch of stories/shlokas/poems that were taught through the Gurukul system and that's why a variety of subjects were incorporated within the stories, including, in this case, science interwoven with the hanuman chalisa. Most probably.
No disrespect bro... but we did have books by aryabhatta, varahamira, etc etc... and they do have scientific standards. Its not that we need some stories/ shlokas to convey things. Ramayana and mahabharata are great epic poetries. And such poetries do have all minute and nice descriptions. Why cant we treat them as story of rama and great bharatha simply?
do u have proof of ramayana so first of all , do check out hoiw old is sanskrit sanskrti itself devloped from devnagri which came in 6th century also we cannot even tell the interpretation of language of indus valley civilization also hindus ddint knew abotu ashoka or uindus valley or prakrit only till britishers excavated ashok'as stupas and other shilalekhs
@@abhishektiwari6141 lol, get your facts straight..... Sanskrit came from devnagri 🤣🤣🤣
That is why India need real scientific/research temperament
The hard evidence we have got is from 600 BC....
And learn some English or Hindi dude, don't be a chappari
@@nishantpatil1847 with all due disrespect bro, Ramayan was not written for your need, was it?....it's is outright idiotic to think that a book shouldn't be written with certain knowledge because you don't want it( for your lame statement "it's not that we need it"). So if you think that while writing this Valamiki asked himself that "after several thousands year a patil guy will come, will he need such book?" than you are deluded. Nobody cares about you, kind of obvious.
Secondly the books from Aryabhatta came quite later,and in his book he gave clearly mentioned that many of the things he have wrote he have referred older scriptures.
Do you even know when Aryabhatta and varahmir were born...it's rhetorical
Or it was put there to make it as poetic as possible to stimulate a sense of imagination in the reader.
The first line of the childhood lullaby, "Twinkle, twinkle, little star" gives the actual distance between Earth and Proxima Centauri, the second closest star after the Sun. Let’s see.
Twinkle = 2,010,399,000 m = 2,010,399 km, little = 10e-10 second, star = 10e+15 sec-1 (1/sec)
So, (twinkle + twinkle) x little x star
= (2010399 + 2010399) km x 10e-10 sec x 10e+15 sec-1
= 40,207,980,000,000 km
The measured distance between Earth and Proxima Centauri is 40,208,000,000,000 km.
So, it's 99.99995% accurate, which is astonishing given that the rhyme was for children and was written more than 200 years ago. Also, unlike the Hanuman Chalisa, it uses the metric system, which is far more convenient to use and a universally accepted system, and also it didn’t mess up the units.
this made me laugh so hard... good one😂😂
If even for a second you start believing that there was a monkey who could talk human language and could even fly then at that very moment, you leave the world of logic and science 😂😂😂
i mean a horse flying to the moon is more fictional to me
stop calling him a monkey have some respect he is a god
People denying everything are the most stupid ones lol..
I belive in both possibilities
@@piyushwinner Cry harder, bhakt. LOL!
@@Sumit_Girhe Then you will be fooled easily by any con. You're the one who's stupid not not those who doubt.
I’m a Hindu Sanatani and a proud Sanghi. I never go outside without wearing Vibhuti on my forehead because I’m proud to be born a Hindu and I’m proud of my nation’s culture and civilisational continuity.
But I’m not offended by this video.
What’s the logic in finding logic behind these?
We must be proud of our mathematicians, scholars and rishis who gave immense contributions to science, politics etc which are still relevant.
From ancient times itself in Bharat, we never had conflict between Science and Beliefs.
Don’t find logic in Religious beliefs. It’s called “Belief” for a reason.
If we still place Beliefs above science, what’s the difference between us and Abrahamic faiths?
Always keep this in mind that practices and beliefs which is against reason never survived the test of time in Bharat.
Not many people in your circles who think like you. Still I appreciate you for knowing the difference between faith and reason.
Appreciated my guy, hopefully all sanghi will be rational and think like you
Bhai🔥🔥🔥
Lol every "faith" places belief over reality and science. Both India and the Arab world had a period where science prevailed over their lands. But soon enough "faith" caught up and now prevails.
Still there are some all over the world who think rationally and place faith and science in seperate containers.
But i still think you would kill me in a mob attack.
@underground leaks 101
Sepoy...😏
I think i was waiting for this kind of video🙏Thanks for this content. Lots of support and love brother.
I want to say something.....
Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries
Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity....
By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ?
Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture
I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya"
You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths
Our rich culture had everything
But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
Appreciate your effort. This the problem with us, we unnecessarily try to find scientific evidences in our spiritual books, which is not required at all. These two are totally different things.
Sir, Make a video on - Is concept of multiverse copied from Hinduism or Indian Philosophy.
1 Ton in US = 907 kg
1 Ton in metric = 1000kg
But since it's coming from west basmati pulao will accept without asking any questions.
Thats because usa has different unit measurement
USA has short ton which is 2000 pounds and UK and most countries have long ton which is 1000 kg
Its just like miles and kilometres,fahrenheit and celcius
We and most countries use long ton dont worry
@@jewelsofjuly7377 same logic can be applied here for example bigha that is unit of land varies slightly from region to region in India
Yeah old units vary depending on the place, he said that in the video, so what exactly is your problem?
not yug is juug
जुग सहस्त्र जोजन पर भानु ।
लील्यो ताहि मधुर फल जानू ॥
Anyone can enjoy his videos without getting offended if one doesn't mix religion with science.
Every individual has the liberty to follow their own biases and it is not necessary that you agree with him on every subject matter.
But reality won't change mythology is mythology 😁😁😁
@@koitur750Mandlawaale religion and science are two subsets (of philosophy) which don't have any intersection .
But of course for ethics and morality religion plays a role.
So yes
@@gen-z-box3331 no it doesn't religion was only made to make the masses subservient to their overlords. Also read Euthypro.
@@gen-z-box3331 First, that was long time ago when Philosophy was primary field under which subjective and objective realities were tested and science was invisible small segment of it which dealt objective realities. Science has moved on way ahead since then...while philosophy is taken over by religious idiocy.
2nd, Religion pretend to play important role in Morality and Ethics and doing so since time immemorial, but does the opposite most of the time. Pick any holy book, its filled with most immoral and heinous acts done in a name of god. So anybody in 21st century who thinks these holy books still play important role in societal moral standards and its ethics, they have lost their basic common sense because researches tells you otherwise.
@@gen-z-box3331 ethics without religion is possible, no need of religion and mythology,
just simply follow ethics of your school teachings and no need of religion
Nice video❤️
can you debunk myths spread by self proclaimed Scientist and Historian Abhijit Chavda
Can u send me some of his videos spreading myth
He definitely doesn't spread pseudoscience as he is himself a scientist.
It is hard to believe that this is just a coincidence, as the verse isn't just a random mix of words but specifically refers to the sun. The fact there is no calculation to back the value or the units don't match up is a different thing.
I really liked your approach also your style. But a critique in me is itching to also look at other side of the coin. Is it possible that Tuslidas was just using some finding of someone else from his time, who may have calculated the distance correctly by some extent. The thing that European have over us is that their findings are properly documented while we are left only with a tiny part of our history in proper documentation. After almost 500 years of external occupation, we don't know how much of of scriptures we have lost. At the end you convincingly said that there are only two ways, but I suggest there can be a third possibility where actually science was used for these conclusions.
Europeans conquered a small part of India when cassini published his result
@@deforest249 that is not I am saying. We have lost very much of our scriptures and documents during muslim invasions and other. While modern European have thier research well preserved and documented.
@Science Is Dope ..... good explanation... good articulation.... can u also make a video debuking other religious texts and sacred books as well... will be interesting to see that
@ Science Is Dope .... plz do make a de bunking video on various other religions apart from Hinduism.... Would be happy to see the same kind of response and comments from all :)
What !!
Years × miles = km ???? RIP units
Earth revolves around sun in eliptical path not in a circular path so there is no fixed distance between sun and earth
That why Kepler third law talks about area swept by earth per unit time is constant
This is 10th class science
Same here pranav Bro...
I am A staunch right Wing Guy But I am really Fed Up with these Facebook and WhatsApp scientist.....I really Appreciate The Works By mathematicians Like bhaskaracharya Aryabhatta Etc . But I think We should go with More Rational Way ..
Science IS DOPE , keep up the work man . Love the content
I want to say something.....
Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries
Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity....
By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ?
Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture
I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya"
You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths
Our rich culture had everything
But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
Wow! Another eye-opening video from Science Is Dope. The entire video makes a lot of sense; still, the line “Why is a devotional book talking about measuring the distance between the earth…” this line was the winner for me. I guess even every irrational blind follower might also have thought of this once in his or her life. Good work Pranav. Thanks for this.
Lol. You are getting trapped inside the woke culture.. All the best
@@things_leftunsaid alexendar . Black hole concept was not there because, Hanuman never went to eat a black hole thinking it a fruit. Try watching hanuman film ( cartoon). It won't change your religious belief.
@hrishikesh joshi
Have you even read the hanuman chalisa? To answer your question "Why is a devotional book talking about measuring the distance between the earth"?.
The distance to the sun in the hanuman chalisa is mentioned to show the greatness of hanuman.
Phrase:
Tumharo Mantra Bibhishan Maana. Lankeshwar Bhaye Sab Jag Jaana.
Yug Sahastra Jojan Par Bhanu. Leelyo Taahi Madhur Phal Jaanu.
Meaning:
Complying with Your preachings, even Vibhishana became the King of Lanka.
You swallowed the sun, located thousands of miles away, mistaking it to be a sweet, red fruit!
This is why it is mentioned
@@theflash7946 Did you even watch the video? Stop claiming stupid stuff.
@@tanmaykhyatun2211 Return of Hanuman(directed by Anurag Kashyap) is one of my favorite cartoon movies. Gods, unicorns, Bigfoots, Santa Claus, spiderman etc are all just imaginary cartoons.
Sir, Make a video on - why most of scientist are attracted toward Vedanta Philosophy?🤨🤨🤨
Komse scientists 🤷♀️
@@harshdeepsingh8211 Nikola Tesla, Carl Sagan ,Erwin Scodinger, J. Oppenheimer, Heisenberg, many more.
doesnt fit the agenda
Pranav, i really like your work but the way you go on with them people may think that the writers of these books intended to misguide people but i dont think it happened, the books are pure literaure and it is misinterpreted now and compared to scientific value.Moreover our hindu culture is basesd on philosophy ,literature etc and not on the materialistic discoveries.
Would definitely love it if you please add this point.
I want to say something.....
Firsr of all in hanuman chalisa the distance between sun and earth is directly written... and the theory,formula for deriving the distance isn't mentioned may be it mentioned but may be the proof were destroyed by other countries
Now, Mr. Science is dope .... if you passed your 9th std. Or 11th ... you know about the formula ( Sn = u + a(2n - 1) / 2 ) for calculating distance between nth second ...... here in this formula 'u' is initial velocity but if you analyze it then you will find the formula isn't dimensionally correct bcoz 'S' has dimensions 'L¹' and 'u' have ' m/S ' now .... isn't it the same when hanuman chalisa is made out ... tulsudas ji only wrote about the result of distance between sun and earth .... if you go to derive the formula for nth second you will find that dimensions of 'u' is 'm' but the magnitude is of speed/velocity....
By the same logic we didn't know the proof of distance between sun and earth in hanuman chalisa.... how can you call it wrong without knowing the derivation ... are you a fool or what ?
Now, How beautiful culture is mine ... if anybody knows something he/she dedicated it to God without taking the credit .... even in 11th century when calculus was first discovered in india , in kerala..,, the discoverers dedicate it to his guru and God.... these words were said by professor hc verma iitk on our rich culture
I can clearly say from now that you are a dopa scientist.... "adhkachri vidya"
You didn't have any logic , respect to our culture? ... whole medical science ( Ayurveda) , physics , maths
Our rich culture had everything
But people like you destroys it as done before 1800 shame on you 😔
I would have agreed to everything you have said...but the fact that most of our religious scriptures and literature has been either destroyed or manipulated by Mughals and British makes it difficult to prove your point...we end up in a paradox...like you said what techniques were used to measure the distance...we don't know...so we can't disprove something just because we don't know...and that was the intention of Mughals and British which you are making successful...the ultimate fact that the distance is almost accurate makes it enough to believe it...
Not Mughals. They were least interested in our ancient texts
@@satvikchaturvedi3545 Yes...I agree...but that was the very reason they destroyed our scriptures without any hesitation...not only Mughals every other Islamic invader...especially the khiljis...for them we lost the richest knowledge emporium of the world...the Nalanda...
The absence of evidence is the evidence of absence
Here i am going to explain the fact and answer your all question being asked…👇
Yug sahasra yojan par bhanu--it means sun is at a distance of 1000 yojana of yug
→yug = 12000 unit of divine year containing all yug(i.e 4 yugas alltogether also called mahayug)
→sahasra litreally means thousand (1000) in length..
→yojan is varing in length from text to text ranging between 6 to 9 miles….
This is because hindu measurement is based on foot step measurement..for ex- 2 pada = 1 vitasti.
There is no standardization of foot step (pada) this is because length of mesurement is based on foot step and it varies person to person…..
It is favourable to take yojana around 8 miles approximately….it (approximately….it) can be 7.8 or 8.2 but answer differ slightly
→bhanu means sun in sanskrit dictionary.
So yug sahasra yojan par bhanu means sun is at distance of 1000 yojan of yugs.
So calculating this
12000 * 1000 * 8 = 96000000 miles
And 1 mile = 1.6 km
= 153600000 km
This is exactly given by nasa as we all know
Now let us take few false allegation with proper answer--
1: people with abrahmic lens and other ignorant hatred coment that the formula is dimentionless and how the unit of time is multiplied with length?
ANS→well this question is geneally asked by schooling student who are reading basic science In thier school life.
In mordern science today distance is measured in respect to time.
For ex- astronomical unit, light year etc
Light year is the unit of distance not time
It is distance travelled by light in a year Called light year.
1 light year = 300000000 * 365 days and so on in different units.
Similarly, per 1000 yojana distance covered in yuga(there are 4 yuga) is the distance of sun from earth.
Large unit of length can only be expressed with respect to time.modern physics also deal distance w.r.t. time length.
2: Another question being asked by the ignorant is that 12000 divine year contain in 4 yuga called mahayuga?
ANS→IN the above answer this question is answerd by default.
There are 4 yuga
Styug,tretayug,dawaparyug,kalyug.
When we simply call yuga it means we are adressing all 4 yugas.
For example-in a conference hall there are mechanical enginer,computer enginer,electrical enginer etc…
and the host adress…hello engineers how are you--it simply means host is adressing to all enginers at a same time.
Similarly calling yuga simply means adressing all four yuga.
Its a matter of common sense, i left it for your level of Common sense.
NOTE→ IF ANYONE HAVE ANY OTHER QUERY OR QUESTION YOU CAN ASK FREQUENTLY WITH PROPER REASONING AND FACTS.
I hope this will open the narrow minded ignorant who try to mislead but they cant even deny the fact…..
They act like idiots who ask such question👇given below-
Q1: sahsra is not 1000 its means 1000s?
Q2: yojana value is 6.7 miles somewhere 8 mile somewhere or 7 mile somewhere which is correct?
Q3: this formula have no dimentional accuracy?
Q4: the sloka is false or copied from elsewhere?
I can only laugh at these silly question.
Rest is upon you do your pure and unbaised research with free mind and open thoughts dont be ignorant.
what the fuck are you babbling about? it is still dimensionless 😭
If we apply your theory then-
4 Yugs= 12000 divine years = 4×12000×360 =17280000
Then distance is 17280000×1000×8=13,824,000,000 miles =
8,640,000,000 km
And how can you use the unit lightyear for the distance between Sun and Earth. It takes almost 8 minutes for light to travel from Sun to Earth, so use of such units to explain how it is used in modern astronomy to measure distance of distant stars from Earth to validate your calculation doesn't make sense.
Its 'Sahastra' not 'Sahasra' and it simply means 'the number 1000 in Sanskrit'
And the use of mile as a unit of distance was introduced by Britishers in India so how Goswami Tulsidas could have possibly known about existence of such unit.
Also 1 Roman mile= 1.48 km while 1 English mile = 1.68 km.
You have just adjusted the values according to your convenience and conjured such things that a devotee of Hanuman who has no relation with Science came up with such a calculation which he wrote just in the praise of his beloved deity only for the modern Humans 400 years late, who use different ways and techniques to define a measurement, will somehow come up with the calculations to find the distance between their current planet and their nearest Star.