The Establishment of the European Union
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ก.ย. 2024
- This video is sponsored by Newsvoice. Download Newsvoice for free: newsvoice.com/...
Simon's Social Media:
Twitter: / simonwhistler
Instagram: / simonwhistler
This video is #sponsored by Newsvoice.
Simon's Other Channels:
Sideprojects: / @sideprojects
Biographics: / @biographics
Geographics: / @geographicstravel
TodayIFoundOut: / todayifoundout
TopTenz: / toptenznet
Visual Politik: / @visualpolitiken
Highlight History: / @highlighthistory
Business Blaze: / @brainblaze6526
This video is sponsored by Newsvoice. Download Newsvoice for free: newsvoice.com/mega
Can You Do Dholera Megaproject?
You're leftist remain views on this video are outstanding. There are sooo many NEGATIVE things about this video it is also outstanding. There are sooo many negative things about the EU it is also outstanding. Quick question (1 of probably 1000 I could ask), why didn't you mention Ireland and the Lisborn Treaty? How they had a referendum and voted against it but the EU made them vote again until the EU had the decision they wanted? Not very democratic of the EU! Why do they have an anthem when they are not a country? I love your videos Simon and the team but for this video and your narrative i have just unsubscribed.
News voice comments section is nothing but right wing trolls, bots and knuckle dragging mouth breathers. 1000x worse than TH-cam comments.
@@mnichols1979 Bots???? Oh, that is the go to response for every comment you disagree with. Knuckle dragging right winger???? Err no, I really do not think so. Oh dear, you really, really do not like anyone who doesn't agree with you do you????
Wait now I am confused. The ad read was for Newsvoice but the end of the video said Ground news and they sort of sound like they do the same thing but are still apparently separate apps and I did not readily see a link between them.
What's the deal?
You should ABSOLUTELY make a video about NATO and the Warsaw Pact too.
I hope to be still alive when the United States of Europe will be established.
Simon,
Three reasons we need a video about the Human Genome Project:
1. It was a megaproject. It even has project in the name.
2. There are few good TH-cam videos about it and it could bring new traffic towards your channel.
3. It was an important scientific and medical undertaking
Such a good suggestion!
Absolutely!👍
but it sounds dull
Yeah, Simon, you can definitely do better than the video from the Nation Human Genome Research Institute
@@zeroqp I trust Simon not to make it "dull."
2:45 - Chapter 1 - A long held ideal
4:25 - Chapter 2 - Post WWII
9:05 - Chapter 3 - The EU
10:15 - Chapter 4 - Organisation
12:45 - Chapter 5 - The euro
13:40 - Chapter 6 - Budget
15:10 - Chapter 7 - Where is the money spent
16:35 - Chapter 8 - Brexit & the future
Proud to be born in Romania grow up in Italy for 17 years, leaved in UK for 7 and left when they come out of Europe and now leaving in Estonia!
Living
UK left EU not Europe.
@@serchbloc2395 EU and Europe are used interchangably like US and America. And in the EU's case, it makes sense since the dedicated goal is the unification of the entire continent. A union from Lisbon to Vladivostok.
He just set the course for having to explain the creation of Modern Asia, The USSR Collapse into Russia, The Establishment of North America, The Fluctuation of Tides in South America, The Rise of Australia into a New Western Nation... I see what you did here Simion
And the UN
I am totally up for this.
Also side note: Flattered you mentioned Australia. Generally we assume no one thinks of us. 🤣🤣
@@--enyo-- Us Canadians and you Aussies have a lot more in common than you think sister :P
Legendary legend, that Simon...
I actually think the history behind Australia is fascinating... between the indigenous peoples and the ones who were forced to live there by British rule.
As I'm born in 1997 in the Netherlands, I've never known a world without the EU and I can't remember a world without the euro. For me it's completely normal and how it's been all my life. It's mostly the older people who lived befire the EU and/or the euro, who want to go back to that time.
I do however agree with those people that the EU has some major problems. It costs way too much (for instance, the members of parliament earn absurd wages for the amount of work they do), it's very bureaucratic and it is not democratic enough. European citizens don't have enough influence.
But it has also done a lot of good: a single market, the GDPR, keeping peace in Europe, freedom to live, work and study anywhere within the EU/Schengen area (this is the most important one for me as a student), free mobile data usage, phone calls and texting within the EU, and much more.
Same! In Portugal (as far as i've seen) only the very old people think fondly of the time before the EU
@@saraviegas2141 And i think that might be nostalgia speaking too ^^'
The E.U didn't keep peace in Europe, there was the Balkan wars in the 90s.
Nothing is free....someone always pays, it just may not be you, but someone is
There is no need to listen to older people. They are filled with lies
And wickedness!
How bout a mega project on the east Indian trade company? Dnt think I've seen you cover it directly!
that would be cool.. or the formation of pakistan
@@juantelle1 *laughs in British*
The British or Dutch?
But yeah, I’ve been wanting to see this as well.
The Dutch East Indian Company yeah? Still the largest company that ever existed.
@@--enyo-- the Dutch one of course. It was so much bigger and more relevant
This was interesting, somehow we seem to forget the history of Europe. When we are united, we are a major player on the world scene....when not, we fight each other.
Mega project: United Nations and its predecessor League of Nations.
LoN was the predecessor of the UN
@@duncanmcgee13 thats exactly what i said
Yeah, I’d like to see this!
Yeah. There should be a video about this topic, too.
LON was about elitists maintaining control in the newer modern world
"Assistance from Soviet union" is called a gulag in Siberia.
yeah - not until you actually know how much efforts Soviet union put to rebuild eastern part of europe being fucking devastated to the core itself unlike US and England. But yeah gulags vodka and nesting dolls.
@@LazyPictures You forgot AK-47, товарищ!!
😂😂😂
@@LazyPictures Oh, really ? Can you enlight us ? You can start with saying where are you from. You know .. I am from Czech Republic. As it happened, leading powers somehow forgot to ask us and we become part of eastern bloc. About post war rebuilding and fantastic soviet effort, hm, where to start ..
First they FORCED us to refuse Marshall plan. You know, it would look really bad to accpet help from rotten capitalists. Then we went through epizodes of political murder processes, lockdouwn from outer world, shoting people who just did want to leave, labour camps, political prisoners dying in uranium mines ..
Oh, wait, uranium. We were particulary rich in uranium deposits. But hey, uranium is bad, radioactive and such thing, you know .. so soviets saved us from it and yes, that was SOME EFFORT. Trains full of uranium ore heading to the east ... somehow, they did not bother to pay for it. Then they decided that we are in danger, what danger I hear you ask ? You fool, WESTERN INVASION !!! So they invaded us - to protect of course. They literally pillaged places they chose to live. Their military bases ended up as ecological disaster, soil and underground water poluted with oil products, lubricants and who knows what else. Quite expensive revitalisation project, I have to say. Again, not a single coin from russians ... And list goes on.
It is already long so I make it shorter. We weren't in such a bad condition after WWII, then we experienced soviets, worse then locusts. They stole, pillaged and destroyed everything they could. After their very unwelcome presence, we ended up in unimaginable worse condition, then we were before.
I have to control my self to not being really rude, because imbecilic comments like yours makes me rally angry. Do some actual research, before you write something stupid please. Soviet effort .. yeah, right. I would like to see you to live through fantastic soviet effort and then see what do you think about it ...
@@OslikusPrime Yeah, soviets "helped us rebuild", using our hands, our materials and our money :D As the old people say: "We gave soviets grain and in return they took our coal"
The Øresund bridge connecting Denmark to Sweden, where the half of the straits length is an actual bridge while the other half is a man made island and a submerged tunnel - so bridge pillars don't conflict with the entry path of Copenhagens Kastrup airport
Soviet Union was a forced integration on basis if dictatorship and fear. While the European Union was a volunteer integration based on peace, democracy and economy
@@clancyjames585 Who said it did?
@Charles Yuditsky Yeah, like requiring you to make up your mind on whether you are a member or not, and not demand use of member facility after leaving.
Everything always depends on the era when the event took place. The era of colonization, for example, was not remembered by humanism at all.
in that way, the US has a lot more in common with the soviet union than it does with the EU, no wonder the EU existing triggers americans so much
@@gregs9210 I would say that is historically incorrect. US was mainly created by voluntary integration
The little speech at the end was actually rather beautiful. I'm watching these videos in the background as I work and I had to stop what I was doing, tab back in and pay attention fully at the end. Thank you Simon.
Definitely a good mini speech. Also, major credit to the writer, Oliver Guiberteau for the speech. Simon read it extremely well, but the words aren't really his to take credit for.
Man you're killing it!!! 👍
That ending, so moving!!
Awesome job well done!!!👏👏
EU won Nobel peace prize in 2012, which shows it achieved the main objective. Making peace on the continent.
It contributed to peace on the continent. You also forget NATO and the obvious threat from the East bringing Europe together.
P.s. The Nobel Peace Prize has lost it's credibility. Any mong can get one these days
NATO brought peace not the EU and where was the EU during the Irish Troubles (1968-1998) that killed 3500 people?
@@plugsocket9432 The EU solves international problems and grievances with diplomacy and cooperation. The Troubles were a domestic issue which was caused by the English with the aggressive cultural destruction for many centuries, also Divide and Rule politics which backfired at the time of Troubles, and London didn't asked for outside help.
If you want to blame, blame London parliament and English. They voted on Brexit, against the will Northern Ireland and Scotland. They leave every colony in a mess, like India-Pakistan, Israel - Palestine, African colonies. They don't want to cooperate with no one. They deepened the Irish Famine, like Trump does it today with Covid in US.
Hope that Good Friday Agreement's achievements will remain! Hope that Northern Ireland and Scotland will be part of the EU again!
imagine if Scotland now leaves the UK bc they wanna stay with the EU lol
Scotland is already out of the EU as it's part of the UK. They'll have to apply as a new member if they want to join, after leaving the UK.
There's almost 0% chance EU will support Scotland leaving UK given they are already facing multiple potential breakaways across Europe. Spain currently fending off independence from catalonia being the biggest.
@@redghost5705 it's not the same situation... Scotland is an nation, a independent country recognized by most other countries including England... meanwhile, catalonia and other similar regions are not...
@@m0shene I'm aware there very different. Its just my hunch that policy makers are over simplifying it.
@@redghost5705 that was a stupid point you made son
The 50000 EU employees is tiny in comparison to government bodies of each single Nation, the city of London alone total 91000 civil servants.
Megaproject Suggestion. Longest deep bore ice core in Antarctica. Took years, loads of drama with it and they found some cool stuff like a fresh water lake under the ice containing previously unknown lifeforms. Would go Well with the other hole projects that are popular
Speaking of deep holes, how about the Kidd Mine as well?
Yes very intresting, another suggestion: Željava airport in the mountains, secret and largest underground airport and military air base in Yugoslavia, and one of the largest in Europe.
that giant iron mine in either norway or sweden might be cool too. the one thats so giant that they had to abandon the town above.
Already covered on several channels. That's how you know about them.
Great video Simon. Let's all work together for a better future.
As beautiful it sounds..as impossible it is. The humanity has the gift to corrupt everything it touches.. The most of it for sure. *:)
An Englishman in Prague, doing an international show, with contributors from other EU countries. A fine example. Or should it be EU Localities now? And here I thought American politics was complicated. Whew. My brain is spinning. LOL
Member States* :P
He is scottish
@@hoffmankipkurgat5949 Try and find a Scottish person that will agree with you lol he's as English as you get.
es español
@@hoffmankipkurgat5949 Simon Scottish, born in southern England...
I'm British. Brexit is one of the most shameful and stupid things my country has ever done to itself.
@Aussie Pom It was project of the right leaning media and ultra wealthy. The average person was and will never get any benefit from leaving the eu. It was always going to be worse than being in the eu.
EU is often criticised for being a neoliberal organisation and /or market. There is truth in that but the EU:s market is very regulated as regarding social and ecological standards
Every US state: We gave the federal government too much power!
European countries: Hold my beer.
The federal government in the USA has WAAAYYYYYyyyy more power over the American states than the EU has over European countries. For example: As we can see with the UK it is relatively easy (albeit painful) to leave; European militaries are attached to the countries, not the EU; every country has its own penal code and other laws with no equivalent on the EU level; etc. The EU is still a large set of international treaties plus a few competencies that have been delegated or duplicated. My guess would be that it takes another century for the EU to become a real federalist nation like the USA.
US are FAR worse
@@KonradTheWizzard because the US started as a federation of states, we didn’t lie to voters about being a trade union then formed an army
@@Lost_Pikachu the EU didn't form an army though....
@@Lost_Pikachu EU don't have army :)
The EU sounds like a committee of committees.
But perhaps In a completely different way than most organizations. Usually the "committee on committees" norminates people to serve on the committees within the organization.
The EU sounds pretty fucking fantastic
The EU sounds like the best thing ever for us Europeans. Western countries get to become more competitive on the global scale, while Eastern countries get insane amounts of investments, grants, loans, jobs and opportunities.
@@andrasadam8256 unless you are Greece, or Italy or...
No different from most large nations. The council is the senate, the commision the government, the parliament, the parliament, and the supreme court the supreme court.
Megaproject: Appalachian Trail
Yes! The AT is awesome
Yes, please!
^ this please
This is a wonderfully succinct overview of a *very* complex organization.
@Rylee Hahaha! The EU commission is not less elected than the British PM.
@Sociable Netw0rker Is that some sort of role-play? Because I'm not aware of an institution with such a name existing and your comment seemed more appropriate in such a setting
@Sociable Netw0rker hahahaha what a pile of bullshit! Of course the EU has its own problems with tax havens not much difference to UK. But at least it tries to implement legislation to contain them unlike UK. In fact UK always jeopardized such efforts when still in the EU to protect Cayman Islands and the likes. And now some smart asses think it would be a great idea to turn the entire UK into one (Singapore at the Thames?).
But the actual point was not that but whether EU authorities are elected. And yes they are, directly (parliament) and indirectly (commission) via the EU governments which on their own are elected. Who btw. did elect BoJo? The people? NOPE! Only his party was elected by the people and they had a party internal election about who becomes PM. A PM in the UK is not even confirmed by a parliamentary vote like in other countries. So please don't play that stupid "unelected EU" record, it starts to get boring but it won't get less wrong!
@Sociable Netw0rker Not sure in which part of my comment I spoke about the Magna Carta. I'm sure you can tell me.
@@wanderschlosser1857 The whole point of the Commission is to be an independent and pragmatic problem-solving entity that proposes legislation. Future EC employees are tested through the EPSO exams before they get a job to choose those applicants with superior reasoning and communication skills. It is up to the elected politicians in the Council to tell the commission what to do, and up to the European Parliament as well as the member states to make the final decision on possible rejection and implementation of proposals. You can't vote for who gets to be a civil servant in your member state either so I never understood why people suddenly get so worked up when the can't vote on specific EU civil servants. Do you really care specifically which lawyers and economists are tasked with drafting, for example, recommendations to the Dutch government on adressing on the Dutch housing market and excessive mortgage debt? Also the commissioners are indeed still chosen through direct democracy anyway.
Huge thanks, Simon. By far, imo, your best Megaproject video to date. Just one small critic: you might have cited the names of the main founding fathers (Monnet, Schuman, De Gasperi and al.) but as a die-hard European since my youth in the early 50s, sharing evenly my life between London and Paris, this topic remains very close to my heart and has revived many heartfelt memories... like my dad proudly appending an "EU" sticker on the boot of the family Peugeot in 1964...
Can we all agree how nice it is that Simon always shows the logo of the sponsor so you can easily skip the sponsor talk
The Netherlands stayed neutral in ww1 too!
Sort of...you did allow Corporal Hitler's lot a big say in how you did things, not least participating in his Final Solurion.
Suggestion: Grand Ethiopian renaissance Dam
Another Megaproject I didn’t know I wanted. Thanks! Honestly these ones (CPEC, belt and road, etc) have actually turned out to be my favourites.
Things Simon has said that dictators have also said “We don’t have enough bodies already” *Allegedly*
really powerful closing statement, it truly is beautiful how far we've come
The Berlin Wall fell in November 1989, not 1991. Germany united on October 3,1990.
The Netherlands was also neutral during ww1
And during WWII. Although that didn’t keep Hitler from invading The Netherlands.
It is a pity that he forgets to mention that the Netherlands was also neutral during the First World War.
Does that mean the Dutch just stood by and watched?
@@TheHarrip Depends on which side you look at it.
@@TheHarrip Why not? Unless dying in trenches is a noble thing.
Would anyone notice if they weren't?
I think he is leaving out countries that were invaded anyway despite of claiming neutrality.
Nice video. Learned a lot about European Union. Thanks Simon.
You not learned about the eu why do you think we leaving
@@craigdackiw1877 I'm talking at personal level, not UK. I'm not from UK.
@@craigdackiw1877 So why do you leaving? I could see many promises during Brexit campaign but I am not sure what worked as indented and what is still waiting for implementation...
@@grlt23 lets see 1: to stop unlimited eu people coming over taking jobs and homes off locals 2: to stop eu citizens from claiming child benefits for children not born or living in the uk 3: to stop the eu from making laws in this country 3:to stop eu courts interfering in the uk and finally to take control of our waters and stop eu ships from plundering our fish
@@craigdackiw1877 1. Immigration policy is mortly up to the member state to decide. There isn't much EU could do if UK just turned every asylum seeker away and broke away from Schengen. Like Hungary for example.
2. That's really not a big issue monetarily speaking...
3. Member state's parliament has to pass any legistlation european parloament agrees on. Your elected politicians were part of making and agreed to every legistlation UK adopted because of EU.
Another 3(?): Fishing is so small part of UK's economy that I am pretty sure the benefits from other aspects of the union greatly outweight the possible negatives of EU's fishing policies.
Mega project over centuries: The European canal system. I would find that interesting. It was vital for trade and movement before the railroads, and still maintains a place in the 21st Century. Perhaps the first true step toward European integration.
3:18
That would be quite a sight
One problem with Brexit is that it never had a majority support, because almost one third of voters never voted
That's not how referendums work.
@@demoniack81 Actually, most of the time they are. The government was just too incompetent to impose any kind of clear majority mandate. The whole thing happened because Cameron wanted to distract his party from fighting amongst itself and had his bluff called. Then he skipped off into the sunset whistling while everyone else had to deal with the shit show he just created. The shit show is ongoing.
@@TalesOfWar A Majority is 50+1%.
Doesn't work that way. Leave won get over it.
@@plugsocket9432 Most referendums have a threshold, say 55%+, anything below and it's a "let's start again". It was far too close to call, but as this government is incompetent with practically everything else (see COVID response) it's hardly a shock they were incompetent with this too.
Megaproject: reversal of the flow of the Chicago River.
Megaprojects: International Court of Justice
Megaproject suggestion: Željava airport in the mountains, secret and largest underground airport and military air base in Yugoslavia, and one of the largest in Europe.
Btw can we have Simon's basement? It seems quite spacious to house Dannie and Sam with "others" in it.
In high school we actually have to learn all the things that have been said in this video and a many more details...
You probably didn't go to school in the UK. The British are really badly educated on the EU. German, French, Dutch, Swedish, Danish, Belgian, Portuguese, Spanish etc school kids learn all of this at school. Not the British. They're being kept uneducated on the EU and per by the design of the British school system. They're learning more about the totally irrelevant commonwealth than the EU.
I applaud your high school then.
@@rockattack Most Britons don't consider themselves European, at least among the older generations. That permeates all the way through everything and it shows. It's the same generations who have condemned the future ones to no longer benefit from the things they did such as easy, free movement around the place. And cheap holidays. The kind of people who hate foreigners but go to Spain twice a year for several weeks then complain the don't speak the Queens Fucking English! They're either unaware or don't care about their ignorance.
@@TalesOfWar hipocrisy and arrogance or just ignorance about the world around them.at leats they're not flat erthests or any illuminati extremist right_wind or left_wind movement.
You Dutch?
Our species has such a short memory; not even a century after a world war, yet so eager to start another. It is our responsibility to make systems like these functional. Use your power wisely, people.
The EU itself often uses the Treaty of Rome as its birthdate, FYI.
Simon! Do a video about the Tokyo Bay Aqua Line! It's the bridge and tunnel system that crosses the Tokyo Bay. There's probably enough engineering in Tokyo to do a half dozen videos!
Also, the US Interstate system!
Also, I remember seeing a few years ago about a highway system going up the coast of Norway? I don't know anything about that but it sounds interesting!
Thank Simon for the conclusion.
It is not perfect but better be together working on a brighter future than being alone.
- " the problem is not immigration but integration".
Everyone and every states (poor or rich) can bring something valuable to a round table as long as equality is being observed and key to a healthy debat.
Peace.✌🇫🇷🇪🇺
A wonderful idea( l ). Hopefully we've all wised up enough to stand together.. and not to corrupt it. *:)
14:27 that's my home city of Katowice!!! WOW totally unexpected. Absolutely love that shot ;)
Mega projects on the Superpit in Kalgoorlie, Western Australia
“We recently did a video on Megaprojects all about the Marshall Plan”.
Uh... no you did not.
---
Edit Oct 28: yes NOW there is a video about the Marshall Plan
That's what I thought too. I have wanted a video on that topic for awhile.
@@CausticLemons7 Will probably be the next video then. They screw up things like this quite often :-)
@@j.a.weishaupt1748 No! Not Simon & Co.! They never make mistakes like that! lol
@@stevedaenginerd Simon's channels are great. I especially like Geo/Biographics.
But Megaprojects is I think the one with the most mistakes. Like they have at least 2 video's with a thumbnail in which they mistake "it's" for "its". That is an error you're allowed to make at kindergarten...
@@gueman99
But at least the people had a choice to enter the EU rather than the colonial period when the weak governments spent years wringing their hands in fear that their more powerful neighbours might decide to come and stomp them again.
You know it's a serious Simon channel when he sits in a dark, sombre corner.
Nigel Farage disliked this video 179 times
The evolution of your enunciation and presentation has been quite a pleasure to witness. I have no doubt that someday you will be paid lots of money for the way you pronounce Empire
I lived my hole life in Belgium. Got good history education, visited the European Parliament,... Still learned a lot from this video of how it actually works.
Hey im from Richmond Va and i just want to Thank you so much for you video platforms. I watch all of them and I have learned so much. A great narrator can make learning fun and that's exactly what you are. Thank you Brother
55 thousand administrators with an 8 billion budget? Sir Humphrey Appleby would be delighted.
55 thousand to serve half a billion people seems positively streamlined. The UK Civil Service is in excess of 400 thousand, and is desperately trying to hire 50 thousannd *just* to deal with the extra Customs paperwork caused by leaving the EU.
The thing with "EU bureaucracy " is that it is very small in general. For example, the city of Paris has more employees
Also, many pro Brexit voters did not vote against Bureaucracy in Brussels but in favour of bad bureaucracy in London
The British people did not want a City in Belgium with people they never voted or running their country.
It's A simple as that.
@@Crashed131963 Should have shown up for those European Parliament elections then.
@@Crashed131963 We did vote for them. We vote for our members of the European Parliament who then vote on our behalf, exactly like we vote for our own MP's who vote on our behalf. Just because they're in it for themselves and don't give a shit beyond winning the seat doesn't mean it's undemocratic.
Next you'll tell me we couldn't tell those filthy foreigners to fuck off after 90 days*. Spoiler. We could have, but chose not to. A decision made by our own leaders that the EU allows each member state to decide for itself on.
* This is an example. I'm all for freedom of movement. It was a common argument against the EU that we had no control over our immigration policies which is 100% bollocks. Of course we did. It was just another scare tactic used by racist people.
@@Crashed131963 Now you have a city in London with people you never voted for running your country.
House of lords, monarchy, only able to elect your one MP when there are 649 others, and what do you get out of it?
A shit economy and a shit government. Something about Herd immunity? Burnt 5g towers?
Us USAians can't talk though, literally same boat.
@@TalesOfWar
Hope your country's representative vote will get the proper foreigner in charge of a foreign majority committee that will decide your country's policies?
Like driving a car from the back seat.
If the incredible Brexit chaos has achieved anything it is to put others off from doing the same.
Although it's hard to imagine anybody making such a mess of it.
The EU needs to make it as hard as possible to leave otherwise others might decide to go it alone anyone who thought brexit would be a quick divorce knows nothing of politics
@@Thecoincollector. Nah, the UK is messing all over itself all on its own. It doesn't need any outside assistance to make things difficult.
@@MrGlenn442 Indeed. This is what happens when you get career politicians who were born with a silver spoon in their arse like Boris. They've never lived outside of the bubble they currently inhabit so have no idea what their decisions actually lead to for the regular every day folk. Because they've never been one.
@@Thecoincollector. It was clear from the very start, whatever Boris and FaragE claimed (and still do) that the EU would not give the UK a better deal than a EU member. that would be suicide.
And it is absolutely common sense and nobody should have fallen for it.
The real chaos has still yet to come, when they are really out
Your last words were very profound. Thank You 🙏
Oh yeah love Brexit can't wait for rost seagull for xmas dinner
Don't forget Rat-onna-stick!
Not going to happen. The UK will be a success outside the EU and that's what their afraid off.
Fantastic video, that makes much sense. Thank you for the video.
I'm reasonably intelligent and at almost 70 thought I was able to grasp complex ideas. I gave a thumbs up to your presentation, but was totally lost by all of the different organizations and bodies that make up the EU. Also, I noticed as a Brit, you seem to be totally pro EU and completely downplayed the UK and how they chose NOT to use the Euro and also how the EU just slaughtered the UK's fishing industry. I watch every one of your Mega Project programs, but I would give this one a C- grade, and that's being generous.
The UK's fishing industry slaughtered itself by selling off their quota.
Also don't see why you should be surprised to see a pro EU Brit... we only voted to leave by a margin of 2%... very nearly half of us don't want to go.
Firstly: everybody is confused by the EU organizations. There is no dispute over the fact that the whole project is in desperate need of reforms.
Secondly: from a continental perspective many of the UK's decisions are absolutely puzzling. Why would you want to leave one of the biggest trade unions of all time over some measly fish? Although the UK is an island nation, thinking in terms of fishing and tall ships is very old style and no longer applies to modern commerce.
Since the pound is quite stable I can get why the Euro would seem like a dangerous experiment at the time, but I think we have shown by now that it works and believe me: it is wonderful to go anywhere in Europe and using the same currency!
The UK had a lot of special deals and lots of influence over the EU. To give that up, to diminish the UK's actual influence and risk the entire UK economy for a dream of "independence" and a memory of a long gone empire is.... ...dubitable.
@@FallenPhoenix86 making it a simple majority vote was possibly the dumbest thing about this whole mess. It was always going to leave half the country disappointed and miserable.
I give you an F for even mentioning fishing. Fishing is something Europe negotiates about with Greenland. Britain is supposed to be an industrial country and should be more concerned about its car industry.
@@jansix4287 The UK had been a member of the EU for the entire time it has existed and was an essential part of shaping its regulations - including fishing. It's hilarious to think that they could negotiate a better deal for trade than what they previously had as a member if they failed to negotiate a reasonable deal on just fishing whilst being a member of the union.
How many different channels do you have Simon, you absolute mad lad?!
Please do the B-2 Stealth Bomber as I'm unable to differentiate between that and the Lockheed F-117 without looking it up!
Even more integration/unification is better for Europe. It's a shame that the UK left, but this paves the way for more cooperation. Maybe a full on federation? I'm all for it
It's not in the cards. Any EU federation would have to be formed after the different countries with differing values.
Unlike the US, were the states are modeled after the US federal government you would have to build a federal state from unitary and federal governments with very different laws you can't really integrate into a single federation.
No matter how much people argue this would happen (mainly the UK) it just can't happen because of the differences.
I wonder if they can have the European Union express card you know like the American Express but for Europe... 🇪🇺
Revolut?
@@marsjfields no like EU express card
Mr. Whistler: The problem with the EU are the members of the Union. They do not coalesce in the sense they still each think each of themselves as sovereign. It is very much like what we here in the States think of as the divide between federal and states' rights.
>>When members of EU, down to each delightfully fuzzy head, thinks of themselves as members of a "thing" then, the EU will begin to settle down. But we (US) still have that problem.
>>Soooo, for commentators it is really job security. Seriously, I really wish everyone the best of luck in finding peace, health and happiness.
Warmly, Yada, Yada, Yada
"they still each think each of themselves as sovereign" because the Union members are sovereign countries... Though EU (or rather - Germany) wants desperately to end that, making EU function along the lines of the US, which is not only impossible, but also very wrong - Poland is vastly different than France, which is vastly different than Sweeden, which is vastly different than Italy, which is vastly different than Ireland, which is vastly different than Greece.
Please look into the Titan 1 missile bases! Gregg are massive and super complex underground installations that aren’t super well know about.
He says that the EU is between the US and China and therefore they must stick together, while they barely are able to defend themselves. Europe continues to get fat while the US still has to back them up militarily.
Yeah that's right Americans.
WE'RE STARFLEET IN EUROPE!
Seriously, good video. Learned things I did not know.
Only wish my stubborn stepfather would watch this.
Not that he'd understand the English though, and even if he did, he'd probably just double down on his stubborn views..
That's why I will always defend the EU: it's hopefully the 1st step towards a global government like in Star Trek.
I'm not saying the EU is perfect, far from it, but at least we're trying.
PS: It's actually more the Federation, Starfleet is the 'military' wing of the Federation ;-)
@@Whitespliff You’re a fool for wanting a global government!
@@Whitespliff global governments are awesome until someone 2000km away tells you you have to give up your home for some refugees. Or that brand new business you saved your whole life to start must be turned over to the government because someone less fortunate wants it.
How about a Megaprojects about PC's? How they went to fill up rooms and are now little gadgets we keep in our pockets that fit in our pockets?... our cell phones have more computing power in them than the landing units that launched men into outer space
The moon isnt outer space doofus.
A possible megaproject or maybe side project could be Tornado, started in 1994 and finished in 2008 it was the first mainline new build steam locomotove in the United Kingdom since Evening Star which was built in 1960. It's a good story!
en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LNER_Peppercorn_Class_A1_60163_Tornado
Soon there be a new P2 now that would be interesting especially with all the faults they are having to correct from the originals
@@thevintageenglishman I know the guys who are doing it, it's gonna be an interesting machine.
This video makes me wanna hug my fellow European siblings...
No mention to Spain? I thought we were in the EU :thonking:
Spain is, but is neither a founder nor one of the first to join after it founded, nor one of the last few to join so it got left off the list just like a middle child.
He didn’t list every member.
Thanks 🌞
Maybe a mini project on the Canadian Avro Arrow!!
Try "Side Projects" bro, it's another of Simon's channels, that covers projects that aren't Mega😏
@@barendterblanche5634 I'm aware but it could be a mega project based on just the amount of people that worked on it.
the diefenbunkers are more canadian than anything, we just dig holes to deal with nukes
A great achievement with a weird outcome. One great Europe united under a common language called English, which is not European no more. Sad
@Jack Ripper in that case I'm interested, and I hope simon considers it, seeing as he's using "Mega Projects" in a broad spectrum, which is awesome. It gives him the freedom to explore all kinds of wierd and wonderful projects that we wouldn't have otherwise hear of.
Out of the ashes of destruction, a better Europe has risen.
Wonderfully phrased, Simon! I was born in Germany in 1990. I have never experienced a divided Germany. I am horrified by the thought that families had been torn apart from one day to the other. (By the way: How about a MP video about the Berlin Wall?) Today, I have friends all over the country and the freedom to travel anywhere, not just in Germany, but in all of Europe. Without borders, without the need to exchance currency (well, for many countries that is). I am grateful for this. We achieve peace not through nationalism and division, but through unity and understanding. We have seen 70 years of (mostly) peace in Europe. Let's hope we'll be able to keep it this way.
As the former chancellor of Germany Willy Brandt once said: “Peace is not everything, but everything is nothing without peace.”
how long untill there is a vote on Brenter or Brejoin?
This man did not just save my geopolitical exam!! thank you so much for this well explained video!
SuggestIon: The Death Star from Star Wars.
If Biographics can do King Arthur on April 1, then surely this could become a reality on April 1, 2021.
Building a good institution is MegaProject.
If the EU is a Megaproject then Brexit has to be a Side Project
More like a suïcide attempt.
It is, Europeans do not care about it at all!
Brexit = titanic
@@camocas a titanic that doesn’t even need an iceberg to sink itself
Thanks!
9.3/10 it definitely contains elements of blaze just not enough.
Okay, so I am writing an exam, due tomorrow, on this very subject. This video could not have been better timed for me.
That's a lot of governmental bodies, so how are officials elected? I've never heard over here of an EU election or something of the sort so I'm curious. I mean everyone around the world hears about the US elections but nothing is ever heard about the EU.
All behind closed doors in corrupt backroom dealings called "committees" and like the US it depends on how much money you can get for yourself while screwing over everyone else.
Well there is the european parliament and every 5 years all EU citizens are able to vote. But there is also the european council which is made up of all heads of states of europe which are elected in their home countries. Both then agree on the european comission which is basicly the "head" of the EU. So it is fairly democratic but we do not vote for our leader directly. We vote for parties and their program and they then elect those leadres.
This is largely because we don't want a system like in the US where some guy without any experience can easily take over the whole politcal system. But this also leads to the situation that you described that a lot of people from the outside don't know about our elections. Because we vote for parties, it is not so much about an individual but more about the whole platform which is really boring to make reports about so the american mainstream media just ignores it.
The only clear European election is the election for the European Parliament. It is comparable to the election for the House of Representatives, except that the Members of the European Parliament have fewer rights than a member of the House. There is also the way in which both Houses operate, which differs considerably. Members of the European Parliament do have the right to propose law, although I believe that in practice, this right is not beholden to individual members.
Neither the European Commission, the European Council or the Council of ministers members are elected. European Commission members are appointed. European Council members are the heads of government of the EU countries; each EU country has its national system of democratic checks of its leaders.
Members of European Parliament are directly elected by citizens. So there is EU elections. Council members in both head of state and minister councils are elected by citizens via being part of their national democratically elected government.
The EU executive body... Commission is made of commissioners first proposed by national government (each Member gets 1 commissioner) and then each commissioner has to be approved by European Parliament. Thus as you can see all officials are democratically appointed. Just via representative democracy instead of direct democracy.
This isn't some ceremonial rubber stamping. In the current Commission..... couple Member states were forced to propose new Commissioner candidates, when Parliament voted to reject first proposed candidates.
Of course there is then hordes of lower level civil servants, but these all answer to democratically ratified commissioners. Just like in national government. Not every ministry secretary, specialist and attorney is democratically elected, but they answer to minister with democratic mandate.
@@aritakalo8011 That's not true. Ministers are never elected, they are always appointed. That is to say, I am certain enough to make this statement because this is the case in every constitutional model or tradition applied in Europe.
As for heads of state, some are appointed, some are elected directly. They do all operate undere a democratic mandate, certainly to a large degree.
You are entirely correct on how a member of the European Commission is appointed, requiring approval of, not election by, the members of the European Parliament. However, I do not have enough confidence in the means of proceedings in the European Parliament to say that this is a genuine democratic process.
You should update this, that brexit happened, set in stone, all of that.
The EU: Where points don't matter, and they change the rules if they don't like the outcome.
Isn't that called government? Regardless of where it is?
@@TalesOfWar To some degree. I was directly referencing all the referendums the EU has had revotes on until they got the desired outcome.
@@reddirtcrazy83 That exact same thing happens in Parliament all the time with bills they want to push. They keep submitting them to the house until they go through or get watered down so much they're practically useless at doing what they originally wanted them to do because it's all about party politics and not actually doing the best thing for the people.
It's not quite that bad in the European Parliament because it isn't a case of 2 parties having different opinions or wanting to fuck over the other side, because there are far, far more different opinions involved given the vast cultural differences the MEP's will have based on where they come from.
I'm relieved that Switzerland never joined the EU; we knew it would be like trying to take the cream out of the tea if we ever joined and then regretted the union and withdrew. Ironically, the tea and cream analogy is being played out in Brexit, confirming that we made the right decision.
Brexit was the biggest reason why I (an American programmer) moved back to the US. The currency went from being 1 GBP = $1.50 to $1.20 overnight, and while it recovered slightly that's still an incredible loss of value considering salaries (which were already quite low) did not increase. If memory serves, one of the big things was that they would expand their relationship with the US, but trusting my country is a massive mistake and we WILL exploit you, if you even have any real value to us. Also, enjoy paying an absolute fortune for basic low-skill labor :).
This was fantastic! I want to know more about the electrical grid too!
The EU is unsustainable
That was good think you, I don't think I've missed a single Megaproject. I love leaning about this kind of thing if I can make a suggestion I would love to lean the Abrams tank and its variation I love tanks lol
Or any really cool Tanks lol how vague am I right
Also, a Brit talking about the EU is always a treat!! 😂😂 Smashed that Like button!! 👍🏼
NO MORE Brexit
*except for a few countries that remained neutral* cries in dutch.
Shhhhh he forgot us, geen slapende honden wakker maken!
Netherlands stayed neutral? Don't think so? After Rotterdam was destroyed the Dutch were forced to engage in war against Germany. Took the Germans 5 days to win from the Dutch but still they were in war for 5 days 😅
@@rockattack we were neutral until Germany attacked us. After this we defended ourself to the best of our ability but simply weren't prepared since we were neutral. When Rotterdam was bombed we surrendered in order to save more innocent lives. The bombing of Rotterdam was pretty much the end of hostilities, not the beginning
@@rockattack Yeah, in the second world war. We're talking about the first. The Netherlands did not participate in the first world war.