Sachin Tendulkar book - Ricky Ponting and Adam Gilchrist have their say
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 พ.ย. 2014
- Rickt Ponting and Adam Gilchrist have their say on the controversy surrounding the recent book release from Sachin Tendulkar.
The Thursday Night Sport Show - 9.30pm on ONE
![[TH] VCT Pacific Stage 2 - Week 1 Day 2 // GEN vs T1 | PRX vs TLN](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZkFjjJNwzH0/mqdefault.jpg)
Love Gilchrist being like okay so we've got your book, my book, and Tendulkars book; we just need Harbajans book for the full box set
Vinit Shah Greatest cricketer time has seen...
Except: Lara, Sobers, Hutton, Smith and... I don't know, maybe Bradman.
+Vinit Shah every impartial cricket nut in the world knows that Bradman is and always is likely to be the greatest cricketer ever...end of conversation
It was just stupid to think that bhajji will ever say monkey or such to Symonds, he would never know this kind of team and he's English is just like Pakistani players....it was really blown out of proportion and that series was also won by the Australian team by the grace of Steve Bucknor....
@@sheldonwalz4016 nope it doesn't end, Bradman might be good just in 1 format when rules were simpler and only few matches were played....you must be bad in Analytics and all, so not considering variable....Well India just rattled Australian team and shown them there position in Cricket
Classic... Gilly is such a legend
Harbhajan and Symonds the same fucking color. Brown. No racial abuse even if bhajji called him a monkey. Bhajji is a simpleton from Punjab, racial vilification is not in his zone .
Vasisht Vasan rightly said
hes a racist pig and should be in jail
Harbhajan said "Teri Maa Ki"
Andrew heard it as "Monkey".
Complete misunderstanding.
Haha. May b
"Teri maa ki" is more offensive than "Monkey"
You realise that was a cover up made by the Indian board to keep Harbhajan playing? Indian fans had been chanting monkey in the 2007 odi series, he definitely said monkey, besides who abuses someone in a language they don't understand?
@@ket_wav1013 I'm pretty sure the indians do
@@ket_wav1013 of course Indian fans were were calling him monkey then they should tried to bann the fans not harbhajan.
Which Punjabi ever uses the word "monkey" as an insult? That too in English? Symonds just got too sensitive and blindfolded himself.
We Indians know what he actually said....😉
Maan ki bola tha
Ironic that India is now complaining of racism, yet when Australia did, Symonds was just being too sensitive.
@@beefcake502 I already replied to this in another comment
You realise Symonds is of West Indian heritage and calling them a monkey is a well-known racist term
I can promise you two things as an Indian 1) I absolutely believe that Bhajji said “Maa ki” and not “Monkey”. “Maa ki” is as common as saying “Mate” in Aussie. 2) Most people in India (incl. Bhajji) did not even know why it was wrong to call certain people “Monkey”. Any kid or person that misbehaves, we call that person “bandar” (I.e. monkey) - therefore, even if Bhajji said it, it was not racial slur.
Until this whole monkey gate, I actually never knew that the team that bullied all other teams, couldn’t handle just a drop of their own medicine. I learned that Aussie team isn’t so “tough” after all.
Stfu
Inn goro ke chochle alag hain
Bs, he was asked to stop it after the first time and said it again knowing full well what it meant.
@@michaelolden5681 - Just because he was asked to “stop it” does not mean he was explained why monkey was offensive in certain parts of the world. How many Aussie players would stop being an A-hole simply because they were asked to stop it? I grew up in India and living in the west for many many years and I can assure you, he did no know why something so normal In india (like callin someone monkey) such a big deal in Aus. Just because someone is offended does not automatically mean it was intended that way.
Australia were not taking any action or asking anything that wasn't demanded of them after being so dominant for so long. At this stage of world cricket there were one set of penalties for Australia and another for the rest of the world purely because of their dominance.
Look who is talking..." the God of sledging"
Sledging is very different to racial villification. Grow a par, admit that Garbagecan Singh was completely in the wrong and the BCCI covered for him.
The Cricket Junkie Hahahaha. Garbagecan SIngh. Too funny mate.
You have got to be a Brit!
@@seanmcbride1 in hindi language.. mother mean maan
And " maan ki " use for abusing .
Not god, he is Dog of Sledging. Suits his name
teri "MAAKI" ...(UR MOTHERS ****)..THATS WAT HE MENT WHICH IS A NORTHERN INDIAN LINGO ...HE DIDNT MEAN "MUNKEY" ...IF HE WANTED TO CALL HIM A ANIMAL SHULD HAV SAID "APE"
The Highlight Reel It doesn't really mean anything... Don't know how to explain it.. It's like the lame 'your mom' comeback. The literal translation would be "your mother's", but mother's what, that it does not say. It isn't meant to be offensive as even close friends say that to each other as fun.
The Highlight Reel in america its quite common to go like "mother fu..'' when you don't want to go all the way and in india usually you go "maaki.." and which translates you motherrrrr.. and if you can add after but usually in a soft stance you can just stop there. i am very sure harbhajan just said this and agree with sachin ponting could have talked with them. Ponting was never a captain with finesse or understanding. If it was michael clarke he would discuss with india and understand. sad incident. feel bad for symonds.
The Highlight Reel Of course that was crossing the line. But abuses are not uncommon on any field, they are expressed out of anger. To treat it as racial vilification would be an overreaction.
The Highlight Reel It was crossing the line but it was not a racial abuse as Ricky pointed it out.
He knew exactly what he was saying. Why would he say something in indian lingo to a person that doesn’t speak English.
You sir are a fuckwit.
hypocrisy personified..... #rickypointing
?
Soo calling someone monkey allegedly is okay? It's not worse than calling someone's mother out like stupid Harbhajan did
@@ssk58607 Have you never been, like outside? Most of those things doesn't even make sense to mean literally. It's stupid to even pick it up as an issue to begin with
Pritish Bordoloi and now Siraj and Bumrah have complained about being called monkeys. Interesting
@@beefcake502 he never called Symonds a monkey. Harbajan doesn't even speak proper English, "he said teri maa ki" which is a Hindi slur.
I still remember the incident, my take then was Harbhajan doesn't know you can racially insult Symonds anymore than you can racially insult Ponting. You have to be aware of Australian history for that, which goes beyond the normal education and discourse in India.
LOL Bhajji's comment wasn't a racial slur. You think a Sikh would try and sledge in English in the heat of the moment?? :D Your name sounds Indian but I'm hard pressed to believe that you don't understand what Harbhajan actually said and that it wasn't a racial slur.
I am Aussies and the whole thing was nonsense and wasn't worth the trouble. Sports get tense and competitive and things slip out. The key is letting that go off the field and respecting your foe when the battle is over. Sachin was a great batsman I was always glad to see him walking off and out. When he got set you would be watching him for hours... Smacking our attack. Dangerous player.
very well put...
All this misunderstanding and like ponting mentioned we lost a great player in symonds. He was one of the most athletic players cricket has ever seen.
If Bhajji calling Symonds 'monkey' was a huuuuge abuse..I guess the Australian Cricket Team can be banned forever..they have been abusing everyother player, everyother match.. how dramatic, Punter speaking about abusing on-field..Junks
thamizh cinema fellow Symonds is an aboriginal in Australia. Calling him monkey would be very abusive. Similar to sc,st atrocity act in India.
However harbhajan just said Teri ma kii...which is normal in India.
@Varun Well, but your friends usually hurl such words on ya as a banter!
And bhajji is nothing but a typical punjabi. No surprises. It frequently comes out.
@Varun But, mate. This was made a big big fuss by the Aussies, no matter what. They made a huge thing out of it. Aussies are themselves known for such comments and sledges by the cricketing world. Taking something back, is a huge fuss for them, then I find it rather immature.
@@chandramouliraula6263 he said maan ki ...it meant mother_____
@Varun mrgrath and sarawan conversation 😂😂😂
We have seen sachins integrity and pontings integrity on field..i would believe Sachin and wouldn't believe Ponting.
habijans a racist pig
Ricky cashely🈳🈶 racist
Mahesh Ranganathan Sachin Tendulkar wouldn’t know the meaning of integrity if it bit him on the arse. A case of racial vilification that was covered up due to the financial power of India. But that system is filled with corruption from the top down.
Because how someone plays the game of cricket is a testament to their integrity as a person 🤦🏼♂️🤦🏼♂️🤦🏼♂️🤦🏼♂️
Donna Cianciosi if there is so much corruption. Then how financial power of india exists...?..lol
We are fighting here like little boys. Just look Sachin and Pointing has no personal quarrels. Even in Ipl They have played for the same team Mumbai Indians. So why should we quarrel. Everyone knows they both are the one of the greatest cricketers of all time. Unlimited salute for Tendulkar and Pointing. They both are inspirational cricketers. All time greatest ...ha that's a joke. Every great player is a legend of his time. Whether its BRADMAN, LARA, SACHIN, PONTING, GILCHRIST, DRAVID ETC ...
Its funny seeing the Australians and Ponting in particular talking about Racial vilification. I am sure hes very new to this subject, must have been a quite a shock for him :)
Give one example of ponting’s alleged racial vilification :)
Still waiting for examples here, you clown shoe.
@@JamesJones-od2ns Calling Jayasuria Balck monkey in 2002.
Yeah for someone who's career has lot of breaching rulebooks and teams code and controversies Symonds was remembered for a minor sledging incident. (which Aussies regularly do in that period)
If this isn't indicating that matter was blown out of proportion then what can anyone say.
So racism against Siraj has been blown out of proportion. Ok good to hear, so when are you going to start telling your fellow Indians to withdraw their racial complaint?
@@beefcake502 is it blown out of proportion really?
No one has bene banned or has faced any kind of charges nothing like that kind of things happened this time this only implies that Aussies only can sledge and cheat they can't took other way round.
1664_Thorat_Swapnil it in fact proves the absolute opposite. Symonds is called a monkey and it’s a “minor sledging incident”. Siraj is called the same and it’s racism ? Interesting seems like India can be racist but Australia can’t be. Oh and btw 50 witnesses say nothing racist was said, 1 person Siraj says there was. I’m gonna believe the 50 witnesses and Indian fans who said nothing happened.
@@beefcake502 At least people and Indian team still not crying it over a decade about calling someone monkey from a team who's skipper talk about D**k on live TV.
So in your books if calling someone monkey is worse than that or calling out a youngster about his race and religion then sadly a person who respects Aussie country needs to tell you go out and ediucate yourself because I have seen well educated and mature Aussie people and not someone like you so either you are cry baby like all these cheaters or impossibly an uneducated Aussie person.
Atleast person called out Symonds faced 3 test ban which was too harsh call nowadays everyone gets out of that, and even after that India beat Aussies fair and Square in next match without their key spinner.
1664_Thorat_Swapnil Go ahead, go back and edit your comment so it is grammatically correct. I have no idea what the fuck you said, learn to fucking type you spaz.
Sachin is not just Indian great, he is the world's great
Iam India Ponting and Gailcries batter than Sachin.
Sachin always playing for his record.he not play for Indian.
God is great
@Raj :First of all get some Knowledge of cricket and know what is cricket, then would discuss about the GREAT Sachin Sir, Sachin has given everything to Our country as a Cricketer... , "Mujhe aaj takk aap jaise loogon ki maansikta per Taras aata hai ki Sachin Apne liye khelta hai .... Bhai, Jo runs woh score krta hai woh Sachin ke khaate mei jaate thei ki team ke contribution mei ....Ja kar purane matches dekh le ...India ka score agar 70 /3 hote thei toh Sachin ka 40+ hota tha ..."Agar India ka 250/10 hota tha toh Sachin ka 110 hota tha ... "Duniya ke behtreen Bowlers ne Sachin ki Batting ka loha maana hai .... 90's mei aggressive cricket khelna Sachin ne hei start Kiya tha ..fast bowlers Ko stepout krke sirf ek hi player maarta tha woh hai Sachin the great ....Mere ore aapke jaise loogon ki aukaat hei Nehi hai Sahin ke khel ki ore uske contribution ki baat krne ki
@@jasvindersingh-lr4pv bht khoob khaa bhai. Respect
@@rajlimboo3521 fuck offffffffffff
Sachin sir, Ricky sir, Andrew sir and Harbhajan sir played from Mumbai Indians. It's treat to watch.
Thank you Jignesh Sir
And why are all they sirs again ??? I don't remember any one our of them getting a knighthood ..
ok sirs
@@rohit250289 its just a respect given for their extraordinary & delightful batting & captaincy mate.
@@rohit250289 its just a respect given for their extraordinary & delightful batting & captaincy mate.
Who else is reminded of the racist remarks hurled at Siraj and Bumrah recently at the SCG test. Australians and their sportsmanship. 🙌😂
Harbhajan said "Maakki" as usually we say while playing ,symonds complained as "Monkey" 😂
true
Its not true
No one hears teri maaki as monkey
Harbhajan is a racist
And he got away
lol come on man...no one believes it..im indian and most of us knew back then he said monkey...the reason people were pissed of was the way the Aussies acted as if they are saints and all the rubbish we had been put through over the years...maybe harbhajan wasnt aware of the context since many Indians are ignorantly racist...north Indians calling south Indians kala or kalu or madrasi..and north eastern people being called chinkis without understanding the gravity pf those words..heck i have heard many people calling Africans or black people negros..pure ignorance...and not to mention the treatment towards the lower castes in places like MP UP and bihar...
@@bibek6713Everybody knows who plays this racist card so no need for ur advice
@@AshishChauhan-eq6ws who?
i think bhajji said 'teri maaki' but symonds thought he is saying 'monkey' hahaha
🤣🤣 Great caught.
What's the translation?
@@rosietohu2616 'teri maaki' in English translates to 'your mother'
Yeah, no go back to the one day series in India beforehand and the crowd abuse! Bullshit excuse
More funny is even in interrogation harbhajan could not have defended himself by saying the truth and reiterating the same words. Aage kuan pichhe khai 😂😂
Harbhajan: bencho kya bolun main inhe sach bhi nhi bata sakta aur jhooth to saale ye bol hi rahe hain.
Australians are very culturally insensitive in what's acceptable and whats not. It's outrageous for Australians to unilaterally decide that racial abuse is the one where we will draw the line. Talking about wives and mothers was traditionally not tolerated in Indian culture. Symonds was the one who tried to go after Harbhajan because there was a long partnership. So boo hoo, dont go after sledging people and then go run to uncle referee when somebody hits your nerve. Plus, they lost the case. And if your morality is compromised by Indians threatening to leave, you didnt have any to begin with.
+Saint Val Talking about Culturally insensitive, do you think India aren't?
There are far more Indians living in Australia than Australians living in India, this is largely due to culture. India's intolerance for "lower class" citizens, treatment towards women and total and utter disregard for any culture or custom that isn't their own indicates a level of insecurity and a self-righteous beliefe that their culture is all that matters.
Culturally insensitive? If you ask me, we're too sensitive to cultures. We allow cultures to infuence our way or life here in Australia on a daily basis. Even cultures, such as India's, which is hundreds of years behind the rest of the world, has a place in Australia to a large degree - provided the laws are upheld (Sorry, no honor killing your wife for cheating, such is still used in lower-class areas of India). Australia allows cultures, even hurtful, destructive and idiotic cultures to have a say and have a place here - even Radical Islamists are almost a protected species due to our "Cultural Sensitivity".
An Indian has no place to talk about cultural sensitivity considering their country only allows one culture, which even out-rules laws, or laws are made to suit that culture. Areas of Hong-Kong are also very closed off to cultures, but they are at least respectful to other cultures.
Playtechy my statement was limited to this case, not a generalization of Australia. I should've chosen my words more carefully. I've never been to but I hold a high opinion of Australian society as a whole.
Yup we are intolerant. Want more proof? We only have around 1700 languages, 22 officially recognized, every major/minor religion in the world. Population of 1.2 billion. Never been the aggressor to any foreign state. So yeah, you're right, we must be intolerant.
And we are extremely intolerant of cricketers who think sledging is their birthright to initiate but also then define boundaries unilaterally. Classic example - the McGrath-Sarwan ugliness.
Playtechy why do you keep comparing India the country to Australia? As I said I was only talking about this incident. Which by the way after appeal in a court proved was not racial abuse. Evidence produced included stump Mic recordings. when has India filed a complaint against any verbals? Seems like you have opinions but nothing to back them up. The same thing happened with Sarwan and the common factor is Australian players not Indians.
+Saint Val
I compare Australia and India due to the original comment being obviously about comparing Australia and India.
It wasn't using the "wrong words", the comment was in relation to "Australian's insensitivity to other cultures". It is only correct that all replies be of the same nature. You shouldn't now change the context of the original post.
"common factor is Australian players not Indians" The same could be said about Ball Tampering and Match Fixing. The common denominator appears to be Indians.
HOWEVER sledging is generally acceptable and done by ALL teams. Cheating, Match Fixing and Ball Tampering is never seen as acceptable and isn't done by all teams - India appear to feature much higher in these instances than most other nations.
Playtechy as noted above, I clarified and apologized for the ambiguity in my words in the original post. It was specific to this incident and other incidents similar to it. Not match fixing or any other topic. I'm more than happy to admit India's shortcomings socially and in cricket but they have nothing to do with this.
For the big macho personality Symonds portrays and the disgusting things he's done on the field did someone calling him a 'monkey' really cause the downfall of his career...like seriously 😂😂😂. 10 year olds have copped harsher sledges in backyard cricket
It's not about the sledge. It's the aftermath of the incident, where he felt like he had the backing of his own board be it in any situation and they didn't back him, so he felt betrayed, back stabbed and lost motivation to perform for Australian board. Imagine, you being in the situation like this in your company and you expect your boss to back you and he doesn't back you at the time when you needed the most. How would you feel??
Obviously, you will say fuck him, i will go for another company but cricket board is not companies where you can switch from one board to another.
This is what ponting meant
Isn’t the Indian team crying right now about the same thing ? Where’s your comment on that. Hypocrite
@@beefcake502 Who's crying? If anyone is Paine is he was apologetic and saying it backfired and all. The Indians didn't let him affect their game
@@youtubeonly7271 I'm talking about the term monkey being thrown around, maybe you need to read my comment again.
You realise he's a black fella? Monkey is a world renowned racist term for naming black people and his downfall was because CA didn't do anything about it, nor did the indians they reckon racism is just normal
I am a big fans of all these legendary gentleman who played thiscricketin the spirit of the gameI was fourtunate enough to see all these legends playing together and still want to see them on the field but there's an old saying time never stops for anyone they are still attached to cricket and helping their respective way by guiding them by different Franchise be it IPL orother while coaching
In 2008 Sydney Test, Ricky Pointing got Harbhajan(bhajji) ousted from remainder of series by getting him involved in tussle with Symonds. Symonds, being a soldier to his captain, did what he was asked to do. Yes, by falsely accusing Harbhajan of Racial abuse.. that was Monkey Gate. What Bhajji really said was "Teri maa ki .." (world famous Hindi Slur)
Real Reason - Harbhajan is the only bowler Pointing could not play confidently in his whole career and got him out most no. of times (you can check). He knew bhajji is hot headed and cannot speak English properly.
Everybody knows how Sydney Test played out.
->More than 13 wrong decisions were made by Umpires (on both sides, India got the heavy burn though) and next day newspapers headlines said the truth.
-> One time, Mark Benson was asking Pointing if Michael Clarke caught a catch and Pointing simply raised his fingers.
-> Symonds and Clarke refused to walk when they were clearly caught behind.
Aftermath - After this whole fiasco of Monkey Gate, racial tension caught wind in Australia and more than 50 Indians were killed in 2008 -09 to what Aussie media terms as "casual racism" during 2020 Sydney Test incident.
FYI - Bhajjji's nephew was one of the victim who was killed and thrown on railway track in Australia.
Other incidents -
=>There is an old footage of Jusitn Langer intentionally passing behind a SriLankan Batman (happened during field setting after an over) during a test match and dropping bells from the stump which confused Umpires of how it fell. But the commentators got it.
=>Famous underarm incident brought shame to Australia.
=>Dennis Lille once used bat with Aluminium willow which changed shape of the ball. When umpires called him on this..he got angry.
=>In one match Dennis Lille kicked Javed Miadad while he was running.
=> Australian bowlers frequently crossing in the path of batsman while running is common to get them run out (Johnson once famously did this to Dhoni).
=>And the infamous sand paper gate and many more.
*Mindset of Australians is to win at all cost no matter what it may cost them. But the most disappointing outcome is that culprits from all above mentioned incidents are WORLD CLASS players with immense talent.
And they chose to do all this foolishness just to win a Cricket match.
There could be only 2 reasons to this -
Either, they were so confident that they thought it is right thing to do and would never get caught.
OR they don't believe in their own talent so wanted to ruin it for others.
And I don't know which is worse.
Australians have to seriously change their ways how they carry themselves as players inside the field.
But after 2021 Sydney Test incident, I will die before supporting any team with Australian players no matter whoever they are.
Well pretty much u hve summarised the whole issues! Tnx mate❤️
😀😂😀😂😀😂😀😂😀😂 Gilly,'s sense of humour is 👌. One more book to come, Harbhajan Singh's, then we will have the full box.. Hahahahahahaha
harbhajan was talking about the "mann ki baat" programme that will be hosted by indian PM modi in future...
Well tendulkar chose to stand up for his team mate more than anything, normally I wudnt have cared about harbhajan getting banned for this, but u cud almost feel it was a propaganda, they were definitely provoking him to no end for him to speak of smthing like that, ricky ponting n australia were a really hated group of men particularly because ponting talked way too much back then even on issues he had no business running his mouth on, even Michael clarke said now that symonds just wanted to stick it to harbhajan even though the word didn't really offend him, the best part is how all these australian team diverted the whole issue at first which was their team's behavior generally n specially on the last day of that Sydney test, Tony greig Michael Holding Lots of ex australian players had heavily criticised them on the way they behaved on day 5, no wonder they made sure that issue was forgotten n instead shifted the whole blame on this appeal thing
sensible response by Ponting.. I don't know what really happened; but I am sure Harbhajan would have said something offensive (not as much as was eventually projected).. as he is not someone who would sit silently in a corner; he is aggressive and likes to join the controversy.. can't say about Symonds, but I do have faith in Gilchrist's words...
+Nikhil Vidhani lol I am an Indian and I will tell you that Harbhajan DID NOT say MAA KI. He SAID Monkey. The maa ki thing came later on to save his sorry ass. I remember right after the match I was surfing a site called as'Orkut' where many fellow Indian fans had joked with smileys ( It was actually a forward , you could make it out) about Harbhajan calling Symonds as 'Maa Ki' and not monkey- this was just 30 mins after the
game- get that right- 30 mins!!. And there was NO NEWS what so ever about Harbhajan Claiming to have said of 'Maaki' the only news coming out at that point of time was how Australia cheated and the umpires did a
shitty job and that Harbhajan Singh has been banned for some games for racial abuse. There is NO WAY ordinary fans sitting in their home and surfing orkut would know that Harbhajan singh said 'maaki'. I clearly
remember reading these Maaki jokes on orkut forums and a couple of SMS texts and the next thing we know is 'harbhajan said maaki and not monkey'- Obviously someone gave Indian management and defense lawyers
this idea and Mr harbhajan got away with murder ( yet again). Besides common sense, WHY the FUCK would an International player like harbhajan who had played about 10 years of International cricket at this point of
time and had spent a lot of time playing county cricket ABUSE a Australian in punjabi( maaki) when it is common knowledge that symonds does not know punjabi + harbhajan has always spoken with aussies in
english in past+ harbhajan had issues with aussies in previous series aswell and always spoke in english + Symonds started conversing in english with harbhajan during this fight and harbhajan responds with
'teri maaki'? That is BULLSHIT. And let us not forget the fact that Sir Sachin tendulkar initially said' i did not hear anything' and then says I heard him say 'maaki' suddenly after harbhajan singh came up with the 'Maaki' excuse. Indian players also tried to frame brad hogg for saying' Bastards' the moment the monkey charge came in. Too much fishy stuff, I am pretty sure harbhajan Singh got away with a very awful offense and he later went on to slap sreesanth a few months later and eventually did get banned ( Karma!!!). Add to the fact he never visited
Australia again( to play another series I mean). Look I am no fan of australia and Symonds had this coming to him owing to his pathetic behavior, but we cannot defend a goon like harbhajan , otherwise we
cannot claim the moral high ground.
So respectful to sachin even after being alleged. respect for these legends
He said “Maaaki”… means your mom’s… it’s a very common phrase.. :( unfortunate that this caused such a distrust between the legends
Why there is a controversy in Australian tour always..its the strategy of hosts and deliberate strategy..they need to understand that every one knows this and this strategy do not work any more.
Not an Indian. No matter what, the most racism in cricket comes from Australia. Call it what you want, the Indians, Pakistanis, Sri Lankans and Bangladeshis most likely stand united on this one. Maybe even the West Indians. You know what I'm talking about.
Leave it aussies consantrat on your current team
Then in 2018 Australian media sat down and discussed sandpaper saga #hypocrites
How you moron? How is cheating the same as racism?
Gilchrist called Sachin a Liar, Cheat and an unsporting person in his book. Ponting says India threatened to pull out that's why the verdict was given in their favor. The fact of the matter is it was tried in court and there wasn't any evidence that Harbajan said those things. In fact, Ricky Ponting, one series before in India playing ODIs said to the Indians "We will be waiting for you in Australia." That means all this was pre-planed, they wanted to frame some Indian players they did not like. Andrew Symonds sledged Harbajan when Bhajji went and patted Bret Lee's back for bowling a superb delivery to him. And the judge on this said - If you sledge opposition players when they walk up to the opposition player praising him, then only god can save this game.
Karan Agarwal Spot on mate...This case went into australian court with australian lawyers and judges and decision was in favour of india......Looks like it was aussies who were lying.
+Karan Agarwal
The court proceedings were a farce.
If India lost the court case they were going to leave the series and refuse to pay Australian Media compensation. They used the money the ACB were going to lose as a tool to have them stuff up their court case.
Ie: During the court case, Tandulkar's testimony wasn't challenged. He said he didn't hear anything of what was said to the Match Referee due to crowd noise and being too far away. During the court case, he magically heard everything and backed Bahjji's "story". This should have been challenged at court - but wasn't. Tandulkar lied and got away with it.
Bahjji said to the match referee "But he started it" in answer to the charges and didn't deny saying it. However, at the court case, all of a sudden he didn't even say it - he said something in his native toung, which would make NO SENSE whatsoever to say to someone who doesn't speak that language. Bahjji changed his story - this wasn't challenged either at court.
The Australian players who state they heard it wasn't asked by the ACB to give evidence.
The ACB convieniently "Forgot" Bahjji's priors. If they had brought them in - Bahjji would have been banned and India would have gone home.
Suchin is a liar and a cheat.
Bahjji is a racist and a coward.
The BCCI are corrupt and petty.
The ACB are toothless, weak, pathetic and shameful.
Playtechy lol basically acb has to lick india's ass.
Playtechy the players who heard it said they only heard the monkey part and nothing else of the rest of the conversation, don't cook up stories if u don't want to tell the truth, Michael clarke said I heard him say monkey but absolutely nothing else, n the judge said to him u think all of us are fools here? that same guy who happened to lie to the judge was your so called captain so better not point fingers when u v had a liar leading u for years
Playtechy Awwww... The Aussies when they get back in their face start crying like baybies.
Which Team is notorious n ball tempering expert ?????
I think Australian cricket can't comment on such things they always do the same thing
Shame about what happened to Simmo. We lost a great player before his time.
simmo career because he did not attend a team meeting and he was fishing.Not because of this incident
now he is dead
Karma
Great point by Gilly - All played for MI more or less ar the same time with Kumble being at the helm of affairs 👌👌👌
Andrew symonds must have been a great fan of buffalax. Thumbs up if you got it..
Two people of complete opposite characteristics Gilchrist and Ponting
yea why everyone loves gilly but not quite the same for punter
I'm laughing my ass off looking at Ponting talking here abt society. Dude it was Hindi slang, nothing else. Even after we explain, they still insist on something that wasnt said. This whole thing turned out to be a joke, atleast if you understand Hindi you'll see how hilarious it is! :D
01:32 Adam Gilchrist nailed it 🔥🔥😂 i love ms dhoni but after him i like Gilchrist only 🙌
Gilly was 10 times better than dhoni
Both as batsman and wc
Gilly was best
Actually yes gilly was and is a legend ❤️
@@bibek6713Never had the burden of captaincy. Both great legends. No need to do this unnecessary debate.
It was good that they were not curious to know what that word actually meant in hindi (and not in english).But then again....nobody literally means a slang for someone... its just an age old and universal way of pissing someone off....lets keep it at that....although its hard to answer 'why harbhajan would curse in hindi when the other person is a gora?'
Temper's fray, at the end all are brilliant!
Gilly's the best.
I always wonder how Ponting became captain of legendary Australian team instead of Shane Warn or Gilchrist. We will never see another calm, honest, loving & classy player like Shane again.
Keep wondering! He still has the highest win% in ODIs and 2nd in Tests
@@cmkalyan516 highest win % in odis lol... you need to have more knowledge then kid
@@proudindian3966 hey Kiddo! I was obviously referring to captains who lead for a significant amount of time.
For instance Gambhir led India 6 times and won all 6, so would you rate Gambhir better than everyone else? Grow up!
oh man..these nibbas lockdown kids..knows just blabbering nothing else...its oky..notyour fault..new born babies in d town..go n study about ,who was d west indies captain in 1975,79 n 83 wc..n develop yourself by mind as well not just as you look of d uncles age
Go and gets some stats check bro it's hansie cronje he captained south africa in 138 Odi and won 99 out of that .
Words have two meanings,you`r word Against my word !
Harbhajan aur Symonds baad mein dost bann ke eksath whiskey pitey thhe IPL mein, bhajji was saying in an interview with Dada 😂
Punter puttingt it right at the end.
It was sadly the beginning of ending for Roy.
World Cup for Australia is like getting up Winning World Cup and then again back to sleep only in 2011 they woke up really after loss against India
And even before test series symonds said on record in front of cam "let indian team come to Australia we will take good care of them" nobody speaks of it the statement was fire ignitor
Because that's just a challenging statement, it's nothing racial or offensive.
It's like me telling you "I'll get you out for a duck tomorrow"......nothing unethical about it just a challenge/trash talk.
I'm the 1000th subscriber this channel....
Legends understand Legends
I don't understand this, Australia has always been great team and they have been really competitive and dominating still very often they rely on these weird tricks. The other day I saw this underarm incident, totally unnecessary, unsporting and cheap.
What one says about you is probably as hurtful as you take it or make it. Ponting believes he stood for good and just reasons. I am noone to judge him, As an Indian probably I shouldn't. But often players from subcontinent talks in their native language and many of words sounds different things in English.
But whatever damage it was, has been done to the game, whoever the culprit maybe.
Bahji had called Symonds a Monkey twice in the last 12 months of which he was given a slap on the wrist for (No penalty). I find it very likely he said it the 3rd time, especially considering his excuse for saying it initially was "But he started it" to the match referee. The story about him saying something in his own language didn't come out until after he was informed he was suspended.
The fact the BCCI threatened the ICC and ACB to withdrawn the racism charges or else they'll abandon the series reeks of corruption and back-room politics. The BCCI ensured justice simply wouldn't have been achieved.
@@Playtechy He said "teri maa ki" which is a commonly used slang in Hindi, meaning "your mother". The problem is with the australians who simply don't want to understand that he didn't say monkey at all. See, both sound very similar if you aren't aware of Hindi as far as pronunciation goes, and therefore the benefit of the doubt belongs to Harbhajan Singh. What if due to this misunderstanding, he was sentenced to a ban? That would be clear injustice. Therefore justice was duly served, no matter what the two Aussies on camera believe.
@@gamersanditparadise Allegedly. I still don't believe that narrative as it was crafted days after the incident and their story had changed between the incident and the hearings.
However it is over now. If it is ok to slander an opponent's mother, then I hope that standard is maintained if it happens the other way.
@@Playtechy It was the original story all along. Bhajji never used such a word
Given their understanding of the situation at the time, I totally get why Ricky and the Aussies really wanted the imposed sanctions to be a lot tougher than they were. In doing what they did (aggressively pursuing a severe sentence), they were absolutely, INDUBITABLY in the right, and anybody who says otherwise, either clearly lacks any real understanding of racial history/constructs and the potential impact of racism on a person's psyche, or is just...well, a complete bigot. What they DON'T know however (and those of us living in India do) is that there's actually no chance Harbhajan could have even CONTEMPLATED using the word in question, because there's just no way in hell that he'd have had any idea about it's racial connotation, and HEINOUS usage as a means of dehumanization. He's also Punjabi, and probably just ends up using the desi slur 'Maa Ki' a HELLUVA lot in casual conversation haha.
In this video even gilchrist supports Sachin, brothers and sisters even our enemy Pakistan loves our SACHIN.......
According to Harbhajan once interview in many year latter Symond constantly abused him by saying some fucking word and Harbhajan reply him by the same word in his own language hindi out of frasstasion which he misunderstood.......player like Sachin,Sourav,Kumble, Dravid respect the game for why they don't give any controversial statement in publicly on the that time,they just negotiate with their board to save Harbhajan
Moral of the story:you Australian player just think others like yourself. Player like ponting kone how to win the game ,they have no morality ..... remember how Kohli gestured to indian fan in the WC game after abusing Smith for ball temparing
I remember when kohli abused an indian fan on his way to locker room as well. Don't put kohli and integrity in the same sentence on a Cricket field he is arrogant af exactly like Ricky ponting. I'll admit dada, kumble etc are fair but not kohli
Ricky Ponting,when will Delhi Capitals win IPL with you as their Coach? 5-10 Years Difference in Guessing will also be considered. Better Luck Next Life 👌👌
Oh Angels 👼 got offended.
if ponting is gonna write a book..title should be "thug life"
No it should be cheat life
Im Sayyam that should be the motto of India. With 7 times more bans for cheating than Australian players. Only second to Pakistan in players banned. Cheatia
@@beefcake502 Well you fucking moron, the favors that your team got from ICC and the racial bias against Pak and India protected your asses!!! Otherwise EVERYONE knows the king of unprofessionalism your team was. Bullies!!
Brilliant pointing great player
and years later when Indian players ACTUALLY got racist comments passed from the crowd, Cricket Australia haven't done anything.
lol this is kinda like how the Indians thought Sanga told a bowler to bowl a no ball. the Indians dont understand Sinhalese because Sanga did not say bowl a no ball but Dilshan did so the Indians thought that Sanga said bowl a no ball because he spoke just before the ball was bowled. Here the Aussies didnt understand the language the Indians were speaking but thought harbhajan said monkey cause the word sounded like it and it was during a fight so the Aussies would assume that the Indians were saying bad stuff. this is exactly like when Sehwag hit the ball for a booundary and then the Indian fans saw the ball was a no ball and during the replys Sanga was the last Sri lankan player to speak so the Indians assumed he said bowl a no ball. But if u understood Sinhalese and not what fake news say, then u would know that he ONLY said 'if he hits the ball he gets runs'.
Ponting is biggest lier and he did this throughout his life even in game as well
harbhajan is a honest person..symonds kick ass
Sachin didn’t go into too much detail, (he sachin did the right thing then and again now) just said the Aussie skipper should have handled it better, which he should have, (even now aussi press bring it up and ponting doesn’t ignore them but highlights and defends himself and aussi board, all proving sachin right and then Aussie and ponting wrong) so it would have not been such a big issue. But pointing (passed the book, by saying he was instructed by the Aussie board) and the Aussie board made it a big issue yet claimed they were doing the right thing.
So, Ricky I guess that Symond was so depressed that he went out for fishing instead of attending a team meeting and the Australian team management sent him back to Australia just to keep the solidarity towards that Monkey-Gate incident and making him realise that he was guilty. Ricky you were one of the Greatest Batsmans to have played the game. But, you will always be remembered as the most disgraceful player to have graced this game.
Ahh right, but Tendulkar's a saint for brushing off racial vilification as if nothing happened? Right?
@@ket_wav1013 ahh..yes he is and whole cricketing world think of him as the biggest icon and brand ambassador of the game .
Who is textbook in himself of how to carry oneself on and off the ground.. period
@@vishmapari nobody is perfect, if you dig deep you will find everyone red handed, tendulkar was caught ball tampering but he narrowly escaped after huge discussions between bcci and icc. now indian fans will say sachin the god he can't do it, it's all rubbish blah blah and other people will say he might have done it. doing ball tampering is not that big offence but escaping it is something not good. smith was involved in ball tampering scandal. he could have easily escaped by putting all things on bancroft but instead accepted and that's why he restored the respect he lost. can't say about sachin though, indian fans and media dumped all objectionable things about him and portrayed him as god, ultimately he was also a human. atleast i can assure that ponting did'nt sweared or got angry at his own players but tendulkar was just swearing at his own mates during his brief stint as captain.
@@shikhargovil9579 just forget it buddy its not worth my time and energy to argue with you but i will tell you one thing forget the Indians or the rest of the world's respect for SRT.Aussie players and audience who are almost born cheaters and notoriously known for bad behaviour wouldnt dare to desrespect SRT . You really need strong beliefs, character and petience to earn this much respect from your strongest opposition he earned that even before IPL...so I would say that they only wants to talk about that Symonds racial slurr incident is because that very book is gonna sell only if they mention Tendulkar in it...heck I'll tell you what if you didn't criticized SRT by mentioning my comment even I might have ignored you😂 that much impact SRT holds on the cricketing world
@@vishmapari in that case indians are born rapid
there is no question of spirit of d game on Sachin in his 24yrs career.But there was too much question against whole Australian team especialy Ponting.Love him as a player not as a person
respect for great Sachin & Gilchrist..what else I can say
It's quite disappointing how basically they played down the fact that nothing racial was ever said, the reality is that he did mishear what was said and Symonds just never accepted it. And Tendulkar is right, as captain Ponting should have discussed the matter in the change rooms with the opposition captain, clarified what was said had a beer and moved on. And it's odd that Punter is going the other way when Australia often make the argument that these issues of conflict should be sorted out between the two teams at the end of day's play.
Ponting does what suits him. Simple. Including cheat when it benefits him.
Same aussie team sledged dada by asking him "who is she?" Repeatedly
4:11
Fav aus player.....gilchrist ❣️
2008 us still the reason I don't respect Adam Gilchrist he was major factor in Rahul Dravid Cheated Wicket.
Wtf pointing is teaching about ethics and standing to an moral point (which he believes of course 🤨) the same guy claimed the catches in same match where ball was bouncing in front of him and in which spirit of game was that incident or a group of coincidences🤔 were morally high and ethically correct and why does nobody talks about it.
we also need drunkard symonds book
what happens on the field stays on the field - ponting
Get the facts right . Indian Great ? World’s greatest batesman Sachin !!
you should look what Steve Smith did before raising question against great Sachin Tendulkar and Harbhajan Singh.
In indian languages the word monkey its always easy to use on anyone so its not a serious matter but symonds and ausies take it seriously, it was very tough tournament l like it
In our country its a slur against Indigenous Australians and if you call a person that here you're gonna get punched in the head. Really wish Roy had of flogged Singh for his racist bullshit
@@JohnSavinsMusic except he didn't say monkey, he said 'Maa ki', which is very common phrase in Hindi about someone's mother, similar to Aussies and cunt. In a battle like that there's no chance Harbhajan or any old Indian player would use English. Makes no sense he'd say monkey in English, because even in Hindi when you use monkey it's only to a mischievous or naughty child. Simmo and Harbhajan became drinking buddies at Mumbai Indians afterwards anyways, water under the bridge, just the Aussies tryna suspend a dangerous bowler
@@ariestiger12 lol if only your crowds weren't chanting monkey at him the series before that we might believe you
@@johnsavins6361 Firstly I'm English and support England, they're not my crowds though I wish we got crowds that large here. Secondly the crowds aren't Harbhajan, are they? Harbhajan didn't use that term, and I definitely trust Sachin over Ponting who cheated at least 3 times in that test alone which is conveniently forgotten. Thirdly I don't defend the actions of those crowds, but there is absolutely no racial connotation to calling one a monkey in India looking at historical and cultural context unlike in the West. One of the most revered Hindu Gods in India is literally a monkey. I do agree education is needed on matters like this in India; the average Indian would laugh at you if you told them monkey is an insult or malicious term let alone racist.
@@ariestiger12 So if there is no racial connotation in India in calling someone a monkey, why were those crowds chanting that? Could it be that its the 21st Century and people in India are aware of Western racial slurs? I don't know if Harbhajan said monkey or not, but I think the fact that he said something that sounds so close to a racial slur Symonds was facing from Indian crowds is suspicious. Your reasoning to trust Sachin over Ponting is pretty flimsy, considering Sachin was caught ball tampering. I certainly don't think Symonds would have lied about the incident..whether or not he misheard is conjecture, but looking at the context before and after the game I know who I believe. Also sorry for using 2 accounts, I didn't realise I switched.
Just like McGrath pointing on sarwan and ponting bumping harbhajan singh at 1998
Everyone respect Sachin and Lara not just becaus of their talent but for their character and transparency....
Despite being a great talent no one respect this man😂
Even I can't believe his words.
Sachins right on this one. From a Pakistani fan.
East west Sachin is the best
India is great .I Love my India🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Being Indian I don’t trust harbhajan & living in Australia I don’t trust Symonds😊
I am sure that you are indian.. trust no body ...😁😊
Then, where are u now after siraj incident
Priyaranjan Das exactly, Indians have been saying for 10 years that monkey isn’t racist, now all of a sudden Siraj said he was called a monkey? Lol make your mind up is it racist or not. Or is it only racist when you get called it. Typical, can give it out but not take it.
@@beefcake502 But Harbhajan didn't said monkey, actually he said 'Teri Maa ki' in which he is referring to symond's mother but Symonds heard it as 'Monkey'. It was a complete misunderstanding. Bhaji didn't abuse racially 💁🏻♂️
Jashan Sidhu a full stadium chanted “symonds is a monkey” with accompanying posters ? I wasn’t talking about harbajhan.
I can write my own book on Ricky pointing cheatings...
Different places ,different slangs.
In India "teri maa ki" is more insulting and in Australia "monkey " is more insulting
no matter how much gilchrist show his innocency, he is same as other australian...
am pretty sure bhaji said "maa ki"...and indians will understand this vry well.. huys samjo yaar ja kisi ko gali dete hai to maa ki hi bolte hai na... kabhi sapne me bhi kisi ko monkey bolke gali di hai kya...sabse pehle monkey gali bhi nai hai apne yaha... aur bhajji ne gusse me ake gali hi boli hogi paka...
The game requires sensible captains, not match referees and court trials
While losing simmo was sad, have to question his resilience when the team was all about the mental and physical disintegration of the opposition at the time - which was the real problem not Harbhajan. On balance I agreed harbhajan version of events - Monkey is a God in India .. what does Harbhajan know about racial vilification in Africa
World great. Not only Indian great .
Well, Hope Ricky didnt forget the pact he had with Kumble and then breached it by claiming ridiculous catches and causing massive distrust to the pact!
As for Symmo, He is still being fed by the Indian media and IPL (earlier) and he is earning more from India than Australia who have all kicked him out of sight inspite of all the fake concerns they have for him.
Thats India for you. We love cricketers inspite of their past!
Finally "Maa Ki" is not racist.
What would have been right Ricky was if your team wasn’t standing there consistently when they were clearly out. Australian consistently shit on the spirit of the game.
Dear Ausis It's Maki Which Was A. Common Word In Norther Part Of India..... So Don't Make Racial Comments. After All We Are All Humans
Why is mark howard in every show?
Indian great.He is the world's greatest
This is the problem with the world - at the end of it all, commerce wins. It was money that ruled that day.