A collab I'd buy TF out of! Among the reasons, fragrance. Fantasy Cosmetica has a stellar track record with scent and I know you love fragrance, too. Oh, this NEEDS to happen.
I really like the two looks you did! The purple and gold was really pretty and the green was gorgeous! The jewel tones look incredible on you. I agree about the color story, it's a little confusing and not a ton of options to do a complete look with a mid-tone crease, transition shade, dark outer corner, light inner corner, and shimmer on the lid. I think it's kind of meant for 2 shade looks, one matte and one shimmer. I'm not sure I need something like that with jewel tones, but it could be fun for quick looks, and I think I'd have to open up like 3 or 4 palletes to dupe this one so it's unique.
I definitely agree it's a fully mid-tone palette! For my complexion there is no transition shade or inner corner shade and the whole palette is very dark for me, including the shimmers, but it doesn't have a shade deep enough for outer corner or liner. I think it's really just meant for 2 shade looks which I think might be kind of how Amanda does some of her looks. I love your honest feedback, especially for a collab palette which seems tricky to give anything besides positive feedback because everybody wants to support the creator behind it. I think it is super pretty for people who will use it for 2 shade looks, but I'm not sure it's for me.
@@oceanbird. I'm darker than you but I agree with all your points. I always came back here because I knew I would get honest feedback. I get that most indie creators are friends with Amanda but there's a difference between wanting to please your friend and show your support and giving realistic feedback to us, the people who are paying for the palette. Ps: This reminds me of a creator who received PR from a recent collab, gave a great review, and already decluttered it 😬🙃
I don't know why, but when I saw the sneak peek, I thought it kind of looked similar to the jewels and gems from Oden's Eye, and I was so excited. I got so disappointed (I like her tastes most of the time) when I saw the actual color because I felt like it was not cohesive (you have to think about how you will pair colors and I don't like it). Even though I'm not a fan, I can recognize that this color story is unique, and I am sure it will look better paired with another palette from the brand. That won't stop me from watching your review 🧡 Ps: It's funny that you love 3 from the 4 shades of the first row because that's the only part of the palette that I 100% like 😂
Hey Jamila 😊 I didn’t like the colors in the palette but I’ve also found that I haven’t like any recent palette releases. I actually only just purchased the All Done Up palette from BlendBunny. I did love your video as usual but I just won’t be picking anything up
So that mustard toned shade that showed up dark brown on you…maybe your golden undertone ate up the yellow and only showed the grunge? It was wild how that shade showed up so dark on you! I was watching like Wait, what?!?! 🧡
I watched this video when it realeased and rewatched it today because I've tried the palette and she"s such a disappointment! I adore FC mattes formula and those I couldn't get anything nice done with them. I've struggled for half an hour before resigning and using another palette. I'm now afraid about Harvest of souls
Manifest that collab girl!!!!!!❤❤❤
It would be a dream! And I would definitely create some fragrances 🙂
A collab I'd buy TF out of! Among the reasons, fragrance. Fantasy Cosmetica has a stellar track record with scent and I know you love fragrance, too. Oh, this NEEDS to happen.
I really like the two looks you did! The purple and gold was really pretty and the green was gorgeous! The jewel tones look incredible on you.
I agree about the color story, it's a little confusing and not a ton of options to do a complete look with a mid-tone crease, transition shade, dark outer corner, light inner corner, and shimmer on the lid. I think it's kind of meant for 2 shade looks, one matte and one shimmer. I'm not sure I need something like that with jewel tones, but it could be fun for quick looks, and I think I'd have to open up like 3 or 4 palletes to dupe this one so it's unique.
I definitely agree it's a fully mid-tone palette! For my complexion there is no transition shade or inner corner shade and the whole palette is very dark for me, including the shimmers, but it doesn't have a shade deep enough for outer corner or liner.
I think it's really just meant for 2 shade looks which I think might be kind of how Amanda does some of her looks.
I love your honest feedback, especially for a collab palette which seems tricky to give anything besides positive feedback because everybody wants to support the creator behind it. I think it is super pretty for people who will use it for 2 shade looks, but I'm not sure it's for me.
Yup totally agree, I think it's missing a good transition shade and a really deep shade,
@@oceanbird. I'm darker than you but I agree with all your points. I always came back here because I knew I would get honest feedback. I get that most indie creators are friends with Amanda but there's a difference between wanting to please your friend and show your support and giving realistic feedback to us, the people who are paying for the palette.
Ps: This reminds me of a creator who received PR from a recent collab, gave a great review, and already decluttered it 😬🙃
You do such beautiful looks! 😍
Thank you! 🧡
That green look was beautiful
On you 😊
Thank you so much 🙂🧡
🧡🧡🧡
🧡🧡🧡
Ahh that green on you is amazing!! Can't wait to watch
Thank you!! 🧡
💎💎💎💎💎💎
🧡🧡🧡
I don't know why, but when I saw the sneak peek, I thought it kind of looked similar to the jewels and gems from Oden's Eye, and I was so excited. I got so disappointed (I like her tastes most of the time) when I saw the actual color because I felt like it was not cohesive (you have to think about how you will pair colors and I don't like it). Even though I'm not a fan, I can recognize that this color story is unique, and I am sure it will look better paired with another palette from the brand.
That won't stop me from watching your review 🧡
Ps: It's funny that you love 3 from the 4 shades of the first row because that's the only part of the palette that I 100% like 😂
Thank you for watching! 🧡
Hey Jamila 😊
I didn’t like the colors in the palette but I’ve also found that I haven’t like any recent palette releases. I actually only just purchased the All Done Up palette from BlendBunny. I did love your video as usual but I just won’t be picking anything up
Thank you! 🧡
So that mustard toned shade that showed up dark brown on you…maybe your golden undertone ate up the yellow and only showed the grunge? It was wild how that shade showed up so dark on you! I was watching like Wait, what?!?! 🧡
Mustard shades are always hit or miss with me....so many of them turn so gross on my skin tone.
@@iamjamila no fair!
I watched this video when it realeased and rewatched it today because I've tried the palette and she"s such a disappointment! I adore FC mattes formula and those I couldn't get anything nice done with them. I've struggled for half an hour before resigning and using another palette. I'm now afraid about Harvest of souls
Totally fair concern! The mattes in Harvest of Souls really blew me away….thsy were super pigmented and blended so nicely
@@iamjamila yes I watched your review after. they seem like the regular amazing FC formula!