I just subscribed. I had to read all the comments and watch a few videos first. So far, I like what I see. No manipulation, no interference, no instigating fights, no abuse, no killing of monkeys in the hands of stupid humans, and human stealing babies. I can go on. Watching some of the other channels disgusts and anger me to the point, I want to take a trip to Cambodia. I'm glad someone mentioned your channel in one of the other channels. I applaud you on how you portray your videos and explain what goes on in them. Thank you, Arroz! Hat goes off to you.
I watched your video about the photogs and their manipulations over at the Temple. I had come to the conclusion that things were hinky when a small monkey fell from a tree and landed on the concrete walk way by the water. I could not believe what I saw. There must have been 8-10 guys standing around waiting to see what would happen. Occasionally one of them would poke the dieing animal to get a response. They stood around laughing and talking and made no effort to help. That was the first time I got on line and I chewed them out for their callous behavior. Still watched but became more disgusted as their greed grew and morality shrank. I had no idea it was as huge and organized as you reported. I went to my subscription page and unsubscribed every one of them. Thank you for your concern for the animals and your attempts to rein in those idiots. Be safe. Lindsay
You are right Arroz, these short tails are much better mothers than the long tail Macaques. They are so horribly abusive to their babies I can hardly stand to watch it anymore. They are also nonattentive for the most part. Thank you for your wonderful noninvasive filming style, lovely music and narrative, yellow captions. The VO's in Cambodia are so aggressive, even faking medical interventions and so on... it is all so wrong... I think they probably even contribute to the problem being so aggressive.
That's the most touching video I've ever seen. How amazing that you were able to capture this precious family scene. That takes an enormous amount of patience and talent. I Thank you for raising the bar so much higher. You have made an art out of this video. Congratulations!! I love your work!!
This is video of a baby kidnapper. The baby clearly wants to get away and is constantly calling for it's mother. And that may be granny in the shot but the kidnapper is not about to let the baby go free. Not even to eat. The baby is desperate for a savior.
I have watched your videos and enjoy your on going commentaries on the mothers and offspring .. the stories you portray are very interesting and I look forward to more. Please do not stop. …I only watch your now. The other channels are to abusive towards the animals and upsetting. Thank you for your time.
Love you showed a history of the monkeys, their associations and explained interactions. I get frustrated with these videos that focus on weaning, abuse and kidnapping with no history and no explanations. Thank you ❤
I appreciate all his hours he puts into his work he truly loves these monkeys 🐒 and also bring us joy watching videos of animals in their habitats and not in clothes force feeding them crap abuser makes money off torturing poor baby monkeys, you are appreciated Arroz you deserve 🏆🏆🏆 and gods blessings much ❤️ and prayers 🙏🏼🙏🏼
@@sweetelle818 yes pointing out the obvious ,monkeys are good in their habitat and not being kidnapped from abusers and being tortured for money making videos obviously they belong in the trees with their own families not in cages.
Watching these clips with the yellow tags, has opened up a whole new meaning for me, I can relate to how, shy and when these family's of monkeys react to one another and have a little history to go with it. Much better viewing... I love Monkey's, I love watching them everyday. Thank you
Just watched this video for the first time. I'm trying to catch up with all the videos. I first noticed this channel in 2020. But didn't subscribed until the end of that year. I normally don't subscribed to channels who aren't from a professional side, like animal channel, National Geography, BBC Animal planet, but because the way this person filmed the monkeys without intruding in their space, made me drawn to it. As a Social Scientist, behaviour is wildlife animals is difficult to understand, because we always do it through our human nature lenses and our thinking process doesn't allow us to see their wild nature that doesn't need justification for what they do. I know your pointed out the different of Macaques females, Rhesus & long tail. However I wanted to pointed out their behaviour is going to be different depends in their ecosystem they lived. Yes competition is important as the higher rankings tried to protect their resources. But is always is going to depends in their resources, if they don't have enough resources to survive their behaviour become more aggressive in the troops to compete for their own survival. Maternal insticts are the same in every Macaques species. We don't have too many studies of long tailed macaques maternal behaviour, especially in their own habitats to drive into the conclusion that they are less caring than Rhesus Macaques. Long tailed macaques are more independent than Rhesus & more rebellious. If you pay attention to Rhesus Vs long tailed in captivity, long tailed are the one who mostly rebelled and take more effort to help them adapt to a captivity environment.
She’s the type of mum to start asking Lilly when she’s going to get her grand babies, haha. Loved the video. Thanks for all the time and effort you put into your videos!
That comment is sooooo cute‼️ 😄 Yup, Aggy just loved on Dopy! She really seems to ❤️ her some babies. 💝🤩 Hugging on ‘em and not letting him get away. Adorable. 😍😘🥰
And the music and commentary is sooo funny and amusing in Arroz's videos, especially the ones where it is talking for Dopey. 🥰😂😂😂🤪 He is so funny 🤣😆😂. I can watch his videos for hours....🥰🐒🤪😂 they are so entertaining.
That baby is the cutest i have seen so far. I love how quiet you are and not throwing food at them to start fights just to stress them out like some channels i watched .
@ Arroz - new subscriber here. I watch a lot of the different monkey channels and just subbed here. The production value of your videos are likely the best on TH-cam out of all the monkey channels, so congratulations! I find these strange social behaviours like these kidnappings to be particularly interesting. There is still so much we have to learn about troop society and social interaction. Anyways, please continue to film these rare social activities as they are so much more interesting than watching a baby monkey asleep sucking in a mammary gland for ten minutes like some of the other videos you will find on other monkey channels. Territory full troop battles vs. Another invading troop confrontation, Alpha male fights and interior troop battles are all fantastic to watch if you are lucky enough to record them. Of course these kidnappers videos are also very interesting to watch, especially when they are of the less friendly type. Anyways keep up the good work! You have a new subscriber and fan right here!
Thank you for play by play. It is hard to tell what is happening with monkey fights and socializing. So having a narrative is very helpful and appreciated. Good job!
I think your work Azzaro is totally superb, please don't think of giving your channel up as I have learnt so much from you since starting to watch your channel. What a well educated lad you are, these or cons don't realise you can see through their flannel, they have literally killed most of my favourites eg brutus and the rest. To hear your music and the way you can put it all together is simply brilliant. I'm in Yorkshire & have a love of these animals, i have gradually learnt so much over the past few months about the drifferent types & breeds, but honestly since listening & watching this channel I've learnt so much. Thank you Azzaro.
Princess Young it isn’t about the breed specifics in how they treat their babies. U can’t make that assessment ... there are too many factors involved ... the balance of The troop. The available food source , less or more competition ... the geography in which they roam and reside in their territory .. the experience of mothers and bonds of the troop .. the interactions happening behind the scenes ..’like sre they stressed out bc humans are there and modifying their behavior etc. u can’t simply say oh... monkeys with shorter tails treat their babies better than those with longer .. and most of the time there are way too many variables going on. There is only this that can be said ... a mama thats balanced will bond with and create balance for her baby. If she has support around her , that will ensure even more positives for her and her baby that will be carried through generations. It’s just not fair to observe a few videos and assume that these relatively similar animals would be that drastically different in line with how they parent . U may compare for example , certain aspects of parenting structure between macaque monkeys and perhaps , orangutan apes ... but even still it’s just comparing and contrasting. There’s no “ better “ or worse .. that’s subjective. They’re not humans. They don’t operate by human standards and behaviors in their parenting Style or behaviors etc. in general.
@@breAnnasmama thank you for exsplanding .I see u know and understand these adorable monkey.one thing is they are not humen .why don't humans leave them in the wild to be with their own family's.why does the law allow it.? Baby's monkeys are smart and adorable I just wish they could be left in the wild.
I absolutely love your commentary!! You do such a wonderful job bringing us right there with you on your adventures with these amazing creatures! I just love these animals. But that is because you bring these animals to our little screens, and your words give their stories life, which allows us to be a part of their lives. What an art that is to behold, being a true story teller is something so many wish to be, but so very few are truly gifted artist. You my friend are!! Thank you!!
Thank you so much for the commentaries. You are definitely my favorite VO. You seem to truly care for these cute little critters, and want only what's best for them. Excellent video..... as always.
Thank you so much for putting up these insightful monkey documentaries. Your videos are the gems among the plethora of sensationalized monkey videos on TH-cam. Thank you.
A BIG THANKS FOR THE NARRATION. It is difficult without some narration to know exactly what you were to notice. This with the typed bubbles was just great. Please keep up the great work you do.
Dear Arroz, I love your videos and the way you add information about all your troop monkeys. You know them very well and it helps us viewers to understand and figure who's who. I find this very helpful. Thank you for your expertise. You could be potentially the next Sir David Attenborough! I am serious! Regards
Wow………..I wish you were just being sarcastic. The next D. A.?! Talk about delusional, they should make up a new definition for the likes of you/you all. He cannot even accurately “SUBTITLE” the events transpiring. And you suggest he is the next D.A.?! So many insults spring to the forefront, yet…….why bother. You being how you are is insult enough.
Fabulous videos! Showing the family day to day life of these beautiful animals is an art in its self to record! Move over Sir David Attenborough! Keep up the good work. X
Hi,I've only just come across your channel,may I say I'm so glad I did. It's beautiful to see 🐒 wild and free👍🐒. Love the narrating ,feel as though I'm there on your journey. Excellent filming and not intrusive. 👍❤️🐒
Wow I have learned so much about the behaviors of these wonderful primates! I 1st started watching long tailed macaque, And then I got curious about the pig tail, One thing I did notice between the 2 they are very vicious with their offspring And also with each other within their own troop. I don't know if it's because of where they live and their diet with all the sugary snacks that are given by the tourists that they flip out and act that way. It's only recently that I stumbled across one of your videos and I discovered the Rhesus macaque. I fell so in love with how they are with each other but also how loving they are with their babies and with each other's babies as well. Thank you so much for bringing us into their world because without your time your videos your explanations and your narrations plus all the wonderful music we wouldn't know these Beautiful Creatures. Your videos definitely stand out, they are in a class all by themselves . thank you so much! keep them coming!🐒❤
It's because those Cambodian channels in their hundreds are only interested in staging drama ( injuries, death ) for views, which translate into ad money. Both long tailed and pig tailed aren't vicious, it is unfortunate that they are in Cambodia as everyone there is trying to cash in on TH-cam. There are only 2 or 3 monkey channels out there which aren't from Cambodia, mine ( Hong Kong ) and Kiyo's ( Japan ) and our channels have been tarnished by the behaviour of these unscrupulous people.
Look how tender the Granny is to the baby when she touches the baby's face asking to try to take and feed this baby- it is so wonderful to see the gentleness of this Granny.
I am so exhausted watching Dopey try to get away.Aunt Aggy really loves Dopey,so much that she couldn't let her go.(no broken limbs yet)🤣🤣Thanks ARROZ to this special bonding within the families. Please Do take care of yourself.,so we can have more amazing videos from you💞💞💞.🙏🙏😇
yea because clearly the second one they showed her with talking about she gave birth in may was another kidnapped victim, she holding it like it not hers plus baby trying to get away but got caught in tree
I was watching "The Golden Monkeys from China National Geographics and I have never seen such intelligent monkeys by way of the mother. She is protective and when she tells the tribe "to let go" she means business and grabs her baby back! Not allowing others to mess with her would be fruitless. I loved that very much of this mother. However, everyone is aware of their surroundings plus they are attuned to danger when it is near and they each vocalize their need to tell the mother to look out and so she grabs her baby who was out exploring but takes the baby in her arms and move out of the area of danger. Gosh, I love nature at its best. Also, these are the smartest Golden monkeys where they live by nature's splendid forest full of rich leaves full of excellent food obtainable to all the monkeys in this great forest. They even walk on their hind legs during the very extreme weather as if to help their body heat be maintained.
It's amazing how much patience the mom's have when the babies are squirming and twisting and struggling to escape. Must be like trying to hang on to a greased pig!
I so totally love your narration the way you present your Clips the way you explain them and you're humor totally rock it it's meant and have a rotten 2023
stangy wangy I read that the Angkor park people introduced a lot of pigtails into the park hoping the result would create a nicer, kinder monkey. From what I see the pigtails do interbreed but then stay mostly to themselves.
David Bradshaw I may adopt one day. My boyfriend was adopted and his parents should have been blessed with a million children. So im sure giving back is on our list. But we haven’t really actually tried yet. I can’t even say if I am or am not fertile. As up until a couple years ago I can say that I was avidly trying to prevent pregnancy. I quite honestly haven’t even taken the first steps of a proper check up. How does your fiancé feel about this? Are you donating eggs? Or surrogacy? I can’t imagine going through all the trouble of helping someone through a pregnancy just to bear no fruit from the tree.
@@amberfrazier575 he is more than fine with it. He and I want to help complete family's. I've got four children and I have let two other babies go to people who need them. Its more about giving them a life i can't. I am not currently pregnant but do want to maybe carry a few more to help people get the babies that they deserve...I would love to donate eggs or be a surrogate. Or both David and I can go ahead and create a new life to help someone
@@amberfrazier575 I am a white female with auburn hair and blue eyes. My fiancé is red headed and brown eyes. We have a daughter with sky blue eyes. My other kids are from a previous relationship. ..... We both are willing and ready any time to help out....
Just another observation while watching this video again: After the showdown at 5:10 between Reddy and Aggy, you can actually see Aggy is displaying a fear grimace as she turns away from Reddy. That's extraordinary since Aggy is much higher ranking, and shows the extent of Reddy's devotion. What a fierce momma! Great footage!
There is another video, with Dopey and Aggie.. and Dopey was loving the attention he was getting from Aggie and kept coming back for more. It was all like it was play to him. He was having a really good time .
This is a beautiful breed of monkeys thank you for the video’s very much appreciated you do it for the love it not killing them like the Vos killing monkeys in the long tail macaques
I always look forward to watching your videos more than anyone's! All the other guys that do this we call VOs but you just don't fit that. You fall in your own category because of how caring you are with these monkeys and the fact that you show them respect. The VOs don't show a single ounce of respect the monkeys they film. Makes you wonder though.. The monkeys they film are all crazy and abusive towards babies and what not while this troop with you seem so much calmer and more like they rely on people way less. These guys are lucky to have you on their side!
Good lord!! I got tired from just watching Dopey constantly struggle to get away from that over bearing idiot!! Sheesh!! How annoying that must be to have someone consistently grabbing onto you even when you're trying to mind your business!!😠😡
I love when the mother monkeys show affection and nourish their young. It makes me feel good they are doing the right thing. Not like some that after giving birth they forget about their just born babies?
May I play devil's advocate here and posit that the new footage strengthens the argument that Aggy is a baby snatcher? With respect to the first baby, I noticed that Granny approached respectfully and was making overtures to Aggy herself, not the infant. Then Granny turned around, raised her tail and presented her rump to Aggy -- a sign of submission that also says, "I'm not looking for a fight." What if that infant was Granny's baby? Granny was clearly producing milk at that point, yet we haven't seen her with an infant or child in the past year, have we? What happened to that baby? While it's true that rhesus macaques don't kidnap for the express intention of killing a rival's baby, as long tailed macaques do, it's also true that overbearing and/or abusive would-be mothers sometimes accidentally kill babies by keeping them physically separated from their mothers for too long, and the babies starve. Other times the babies die from rough handling. In this case, Aggy wouldn't be kidnapping with intent to kill, as Granny is not a rival of a threat to her. But Aggy *could* be kidnapping out of misplaced maternal yearning, which could lead to accidental death. One thing that struck me while watching this is how Aggy's behavior checks pretty much every box for abuse as described in this University of Chicago study of rhesus monkeys: primate.uchicago.edu/1998AB.pdf One of the things the study's author emphasizes again and again is that abusive rhesus mothers show "strong interest in the infants of other mothers," and are extremely physically controlling. Aggy's behavior -- pulling Dopey by his legs and arms, pulling him down from the bars, even trying to hold onto him by biting his fingers -- is described to a tee in that study. Like Aggy, the rhesus moms in the study were observed keeping the infants in physical contact even as the babies struggled to get away. Like Aggy, the moms in the study are primarily obsessed with newborns and very young babies. Which brings me to my last point: Aggy is higher ranking than Reddy, and while Reddy stood up to her at least once, it may be that Reddy has to "tolerate" some handling of Dopey by Aggy, or risk her own position in the troop. Allowing Aggy to handle Dopey for short periods of time might be really difficult for Reddy to allow, but getting booted from the troop would be devastating to Reddy and Dopey, and would hurt Dopey's chances of survival. Since Reddy's a mom who lost her two previous babies, she's extremely cautious with Dopey, and I don't think she's willing to risk her status in the troop. Thus she tolerates Aggy's extreme aunting for very short periods of time. As always, let me offer this disclaimer: I am NOT a Primate expert by any means, and I don't pretend to have any expertise. I'm learning along with everyone else here, and I probably do misinterpret behaviors more than I realize. But I have read research papers on the subject, and I couldn't help but notice the similarities between Aggy's behavior and the behavior described in the University of Chicago study linked above. Cheers, and as always, thanks for the amazing footage, Arroz!
Well as always, I bow to your expertise in this matter, however Aggy does display many of those trademark characteristics mentioned in the study I linked. But what happened to this baby that Aggy was "aunting" in this video? Have we seen that baby again? I know you mentioned that a lot of the 2015 babies didn't make it, for whatever reason, whether it was just bad luck or tragedy. And what about Granny's baby? She was producing milk, so she obviously gave birth, but her baby is nowhere to be seen. Cheers, Arroz!
Gozer I think you are absolutely right. I think Aggy's pulling and grabbing and holding Dopey is verging on the abusive, and not just overbearing Aunting. You can't help feeling sorry for the little 'un. And it makes sense that Reddy would have to tolerate it for the sake of their place in the group. Well done - nice analysis. Even tho your not an expert!
Beautiful, interesting and very informative video, thanks for the narration that made me understand better what is exactly the video is all about great good job.
Poor dopey tryjng so hard to get away and pull lilly over, as if tonreplace himself with lilly. Lol. Great video. I was hanging on the edge of my seat the whole time
I tend to not see this as kidnapping when it's an adult female. I see it more of babysitting since they live in a community. I think babysitting with other adult females builds community for them. I have seen grown males kidnap babies and in that case, I would call it kidnapping, especially when the kidnapper gets fed continuously like they do at Angkor. I remember the Cyclops kidnapping of Helpo and the VO's fed him constantly, rewarding him. He never let go of Helpo, and the baby died.
Poor baby doesnt even want to be with Aggy and thats her own mother. Aggy needs to learn to let go. Her daughter needs to run around and play and forage.
No había visto este video. Me gusta observar sus actitudes, reacciones reales y no solo escenas elegidas para lucrar. Son terribles. Que bueno que estan chicos de tamaño porque grandes serían más peligros. 🙈🧐
I know she just wanted to be a good aunt and she really loved dopey but I felt so bad for the little guy! He was trying so hard to go play and have fun and her daughter was trying so hard to nurse it was just sad and funny lol.
I have been watching your documentaries and seen some that were very sad and tragic, I sign petitions with CARES ACT 2 for animals and humans rights, Climate change, and I think you should send copies of your cull and poisoning videos to CARES ACT 2, So they will get petition to stop the murdering of all the monkeys and kidnappings, you are really Great Photographer and Journalist and I enjoy your work and knowledge, let's stop the brutality of these little lives
I enjoyed this video, and all the comments I have read are positive and appreciative, yet as of my viewing 314 people disliked this. And that's quite a lot. It seems odd to me and I can't help but wonder why.
Concerted efforts in a day or two from a team of followers who disliked my video th-cam.com/video/86xZ0-VBkJ4/w-d-xo.html when I was just telling the truth :) I noticed this sudden upsurge of dislike not long afterwards and this phenomenon affected a few of my other videos too in that time frame.
I just subscribed. I had to read all the comments and watch a few videos first. So far, I like what I see. No manipulation, no interference, no instigating fights, no abuse, no killing of monkeys in the hands of stupid humans, and human stealing babies. I can go on. Watching some of the other channels disgusts and anger me to the point, I want to take a trip to Cambodia. I'm glad someone mentioned your channel in one of the other channels. I applaud you on how you portray your videos and explain what goes on in them. Thank you, Arroz! Hat goes off to you.
I honestly have to say by far this is the best video I have watched in months thank you,😀 I appreciate it!!! 🌹🌹🌹
I watched your video about the photogs and their manipulations over at the Temple. I had come to the conclusion that things were hinky when a small monkey fell from a tree and landed on the concrete walk way by the water. I could not believe what I saw. There must have been 8-10 guys standing around waiting to see what would happen. Occasionally one of them would poke the dieing animal to get a response. They stood around laughing and talking and made no effort to help. That was the first time I got on line and I chewed them out for their callous behavior. Still watched but became more disgusted as their greed grew and morality shrank. I had no idea it was as huge and organized as you reported. I went to my subscription page and unsubscribed every one of them. Thank you for your concern for the animals and your attempts to rein in those idiots. Be safe. Lindsay
Yes all you said is correct they really hate them.and r joy watching the suffer and be scared
They also were Reported, not to Be they never do anything!
But to the FBI!
You no one think the FBI will do anything .
I also unsubscribe .. I hope more followers follow us to get rid of these abusive channels as UTUBE will not.
@@lprofessor9948😂
You are right Arroz, these short tails are much better mothers than the long tail Macaques. They are so horribly abusive to their babies I can hardly stand to watch it anymore. They are also nonattentive for the most part. Thank you for your wonderful noninvasive filming style, lovely music and narrative, yellow captions. The VO's in Cambodia are so aggressive, even faking medical interventions and so on... it is all so wrong... I think they probably even contribute to the problem being so aggressive.
That's the most touching video I've ever seen. How amazing that you were able to capture this precious family scene. That takes an enormous amount of patience and talent. I Thank you for raising the bar so much higher. You have made an art out of this video. Congratulations!! I love your work!!
This is video of a baby kidnapper. The baby clearly wants to get away and is constantly calling for it's mother. And that may be granny in the shot but the kidnapper is not about to let the baby go free. Not even to eat. The baby is desperate for a savior.
I have watched your videos and enjoy your on going commentaries on the mothers and offspring .. the stories you portray are very interesting and I look forward to more. Please do not stop. …I only watch your now. The other channels are to abusive towards the animals and upsetting. Thank you for your time.
I really like your non invasive style of filming the monkeys 😀
Love you showed a history of the monkeys, their associations and explained interactions. I get frustrated with these videos that focus on weaning, abuse and kidnapping with no history and no explanations.
Thank you ❤
Your work is appreciated. If it was up to me you should be given an award for it.
For what? Pointing out the obvious? L@m€ 🤦🏽♀️😆
I appreciate all his hours he puts into his work he truly loves these monkeys 🐒 and also bring us joy watching videos of animals in their habitats and not in clothes force feeding them crap abuser makes money off torturing poor baby monkeys, you are appreciated Arroz you deserve 🏆🏆🏆 and gods blessings much ❤️ and prayers 🙏🏼🙏🏼
@@sweetelle818 yes pointing out the obvious ,monkeys are good in their habitat and not being kidnapped from abusers and being tortured for money making videos obviously they belong in the trees with their own families not in cages.
Me also. Just love the British accent. So sorry on the loss of the Queen.
@@CajunRed that’s a computer voice. That isn’t his real voice.
Watching these clips with the yellow tags, has opened up a whole new meaning for me, I can relate to how, shy and when these family's of monkeys react to one another and have a little history to go with it. Much better viewing... I love Monkey's, I love watching them everyday. Thank you
Just watched this video for the first time. I'm trying to catch up with all the videos. I first noticed this channel in 2020. But didn't subscribed until the end of that year. I normally don't subscribed to channels who aren't from a professional side, like animal channel, National Geography, BBC Animal planet, but because the way this person filmed the monkeys without intruding in their space, made me drawn to it.
As a Social Scientist, behaviour is wildlife animals is difficult to understand, because we always do it through our human nature lenses and our thinking process doesn't allow us to see their wild nature that doesn't need justification for what they do.
I know your pointed out the different of Macaques females, Rhesus & long tail.
However I wanted to pointed out their behaviour is going to be different depends in their ecosystem they lived. Yes competition is important as the higher rankings tried to protect their resources. But is always is going to depends in their resources, if they don't have enough resources to survive their behaviour become more aggressive in the troops to compete for their own survival.
Maternal insticts are the same in every Macaques species. We don't have too many studies of long tailed macaques maternal behaviour, especially in their own habitats to drive into the conclusion that they are less caring than Rhesus Macaques.
Long tailed macaques are more independent than Rhesus & more rebellious.
If you pay attention to Rhesus Vs long tailed in captivity, long tailed are the one who mostly rebelled and take more effort to help them adapt to a captivity environment.
She’s the type of mum to start asking Lilly when she’s going to get her grand babies, haha.
Loved the video. Thanks for all the time and effort you put into your videos!
That comment is sooooo cute‼️ 😄
Yup, Aggy just loved on Dopy! She really seems to ❤️ her some babies. 💝🤩
Hugging on ‘em and not letting him get away. Adorable. 😍😘🥰
To be honest.. I’m not sure if Dopey is male or female! I haven’t been watching long.
Selest T Dopey is a male :)
I love red, she is the best. Loved it when she stared aggy down when she was going to try to "mother " dopey!! Hilarious 😂 love the comments too lol!
I liked the yellow posting that tells what is going on. Thanks
Me too. It helps me to understand why they behave the way they do.
I wish they would all do that.
Yh i even pause if it fly too fast.
And the music and commentary is sooo funny and amusing in Arroz's videos, especially the ones where it is talking for Dopey. 🥰😂😂😂🤪 He is so funny 🤣😆😂.
I can watch his videos for hours....🥰🐒🤪😂 they are so entertaining.
That baby is the cutest i have seen so far. I love how quiet you are and not throwing food at them to start fights just to stress them out like some channels i watched .
Monkey kidnappers are no different from human kidnappers. Baby monkeys are cute little toys. But it devastates the little monkey and her family
There usually not kidnapped that long. Definitely not like overnight or something.
@ Arroz - new subscriber here. I watch a lot of the different monkey channels and just subbed here. The production value of your videos are likely the best on TH-cam out of all the monkey channels, so congratulations! I find these strange social behaviours like these kidnappings to be particularly interesting. There is still so much we have to learn about troop society and social interaction. Anyways, please continue to film these rare social activities as they are so much more interesting than watching a baby monkey asleep sucking in a mammary gland for ten minutes like some of the other videos you will find on other monkey channels.
Territory full troop battles vs. Another invading troop confrontation, Alpha male fights and interior troop battles are all fantastic to watch if you are lucky enough to record them. Of course these kidnappers videos are also very interesting to watch, especially when they are of the less friendly type.
Anyways keep up the good work! You have a new subscriber and fan right here!
welcome on board :)
Thank you for play by play. It is hard to tell what is happening with monkey fights and socializing. So having a narrative is very helpful and appreciated.
Good job!
I love how you give them their space and tell a story along with your videos 😍 I can tell you love what you do.
I think your work Azzaro is totally superb, please don't think of giving your channel up as I have learnt so much from you since starting to watch your channel.
What a well educated lad you are, these or cons don't realise you can see through their flannel, they have literally killed most of my favourites eg brutus and the rest. To hear your music and the way you can put it all together is simply brilliant. I'm in Yorkshire & have a love of these animals, i have gradually learnt so much over the past few months about the drifferent types & breeds, but honestly since listening & watching this channel I've learnt so much. Thank you Azzaro.
Very heart warming. So loving. I love short tail monkey's they treat their baby's better. More protective then long tail monkeys.
Princess Young it isn’t about the breed specifics in how they treat their babies. U can’t make that assessment ... there are too many factors involved ... the balance of
The troop. The available food source , less or more competition ... the geography in which they roam and reside in their territory .. the experience of mothers and bonds of the troop .. the interactions happening behind the scenes ..’like sre they stressed out bc humans are there and modifying their behavior etc. u can’t simply say oh... monkeys with shorter tails treat their babies better than those with longer .. and most of the time there are way too many variables going on. There is only this that can be said ... a mama thats balanced will bond with and create balance for her baby. If she has support around her , that will ensure even more positives for her and her baby that will be carried through generations. It’s just not fair to observe a few videos and assume that these relatively similar animals would be that drastically different in line with how they parent . U may compare for example , certain aspects of parenting structure between macaque monkeys and perhaps , orangutan apes ... but even still it’s just comparing and contrasting. There’s no “ better “ or worse .. that’s subjective. They’re not humans. They don’t operate by human standards and behaviors in their parenting
Style or behaviors etc. in general.
@@breAnnasmama thank you for exsplanding .I see u know and understand these adorable monkey.one thing is they are not humen .why don't humans leave them in the wild to be with their own family's.why does the law allow it.? Baby's monkeys are smart and adorable I just wish they could be left in the wild.
I absolutely love your commentary!! You do such a wonderful job bringing us right there with you on your adventures with these amazing creatures! I just love these animals. But that is because you bring these animals to our little screens, and your words give their stories life, which allows us to be a part of their lives. What an art that is to behold, being a true story teller is something so many wish to be, but so very few are truly gifted artist. You my friend are!! Thank you!!
DITTO!!!👍👍
Here here!
ARROZ MARISCO, you are the BEST!!!!! Thank you for your great videos! especially, when you add special sounds of cuteness...
Aww so cute at the end,it’s these times you want to grab hold+hug them,so sweet
Now this video right here, I utterly enjoyed. Well done! Lily seemed too big to be nursing still.
This is one of the best videos I have seen on here. Thank you
Thank you so much for the commentaries.
You are definitely my favorite VO. You seem to truly care for these cute little critters, and want only what's best for them.
Excellent video..... as always.
Your pop ups explaining what is going on makes your videos the best !! I just subscribed. Keep up the great work your doing.
Man that little bugger won't leave his mommy alone, Milk line closed!!!
Thank you so much for putting up these insightful monkey documentaries. Your videos are the gems among the plethora of sensationalized monkey videos on TH-cam. Thank you.
Reddy gave a major stink-eye to the kidnapper! My cat's use that look too.
A BIG THANKS FOR THE NARRATION. It is difficult without some
narration to know exactly what you were to notice. This with the typed bubbles was just
great. Please keep up the great work you
do.
I always love the moment, when baby come back to mother.👍👍👍👍
Dear Arroz,
I love your videos and the way you add information about all your troop monkeys.
You know them very well and it helps us viewers to understand and figure who's who.
I find this very helpful. Thank you for your expertise.
You could be potentially the next Sir David Attenborough!
I am serious!
Regards
Ellie Andrews ..... TOTALLY agree Ellie! 🙂
@@Simon-gj5zt publish
BANG is all I can say for kidnapping animal or human
I feel the same way as Ellie , Thank you so very much
Wow………..I wish you were just being sarcastic. The next D. A.?! Talk about delusional, they should make up a new definition for the likes of you/you all. He cannot even accurately “SUBTITLE” the events transpiring. And you suggest he is the next D.A.?! So many insults spring to the forefront, yet…….why bother. You being how you are is insult enough.
Arroz I had almost forgot just how adorable Dopey was back then.
That's not Dopey
It’s so funny to watch her trying to keep both babies as they try to run away.
Fabulous videos! Showing the family day to day life of these beautiful animals is an art in its self to record!
Move over Sir David Attenborough! Keep up the good work. X
Ne kadar genç bi anne sevgi dolu yavrusuna be tatlı bir yavru
Hi,I've only just come across your channel,may I say I'm so glad I did. It's beautiful to see 🐒 wild and free👍🐒. Love the narrating ,feel as though I'm there on your journey. Excellent filming and not intrusive. 👍❤️🐒
I cry Everytime I watch this but it's one of my favorite videos. You do such a wonderful job! Thank you!!
Wow I have learned so much about the behaviors of these wonderful primates! I 1st started watching long tailed macaque, And then I got curious about the pig tail, One thing I did notice between the 2 they are very vicious with their offspring And also with each other within their own troop. I don't know if it's because of where they live and their diet with all the sugary snacks that are given by the tourists that they flip out and act that way. It's only recently that I stumbled across one of your videos and I discovered the Rhesus macaque. I fell so in love with how they are with each other but also how loving they are with their babies and with each other's babies as well. Thank you so much for bringing us into their world because without your time your videos your explanations and your narrations plus all the wonderful music we wouldn't know these Beautiful Creatures. Your videos definitely stand out, they are in a class all by themselves . thank you so much! keep them coming!🐒❤
It's because those Cambodian channels in their hundreds are only interested in staging drama ( injuries, death ) for views, which translate into ad money. Both long tailed and pig tailed aren't vicious, it is unfortunate that they are in Cambodia as everyone there is trying to cash in on TH-cam. There are only 2 or 3 monkey channels out there which aren't from Cambodia, mine ( Hong Kong ) and Kiyo's ( Japan ) and our channels have been tarnished by the behaviour of these unscrupulous people.
Look how tender the Granny is to the baby when she touches the baby's face asking to try to take and feed this baby- it is so wonderful to see the gentleness of this Granny.
I am so exhausted watching Dopey try to get away.Aunt Aggy really loves Dopey,so much that she couldn't let her go.(no broken limbs yet)🤣🤣Thanks ARROZ to this special bonding within the families. Please Do take care of yourself.,so we can have more amazing videos from you💞💞💞.🙏🙏😇
captions make the video interesting and very clear to the concept...your are the best videographer ...
Go Red !!!lolol aww bless aunt aggy for loving babies so so much lol
She’s probably thinking I wonder how long it’s going to take for Stockholm syndrome to kick in lol 😂
yea because clearly the second one they showed her with talking about she gave birth in may was another kidnapped victim, she holding it like it not hers plus baby trying to get away but got caught in tree
I can't believe how cute Dopey was as a baby I never saw him when he was that young he was a cute little bugger
Such a beautiful and interesting video. Although it was done awhile ago, I truly enjoyed it. Thank you for sharing and educating.
*YES! Dopey's cuteness IS to blame. lol*
I was watching "The Golden Monkeys from China National Geographics and I have never seen such intelligent monkeys by way of the mother. She is protective and when she tells the tribe "to let go" she means business and grabs her baby back! Not allowing others to mess with her would be fruitless. I loved that very much of this mother. However, everyone is aware of their surroundings plus they are attuned to danger when it is near and they each vocalize their need to tell the mother to look out and so she grabs her baby who was out exploring but takes the baby in her arms and move out of the area of danger. Gosh, I love nature at its best. Also, these are the smartest Golden monkeys where they live by nature's splendid forest full of rich leaves full of excellent food obtainable to all the monkeys in this great forest. They even walk on their hind legs during the very extreme weather as if to help their body heat be maintained.
It's amazing how much patience the mom's have when the babies are squirming and twisting and struggling to escape. Must be like trying to hang on to a greased pig!
I guess you don't have kids
I so totally love your narration the way you present your Clips the way you explain them and you're humor totally rock it it's meant and have a rotten 2023
I agree, the long tails are terrible mothers. But that best moms I think, are the pigtails. They are kind and smart.
stangy wangy I read that the Angkor park people introduced a lot of pigtails into the park hoping the result would create
a nicer, kinder monkey. From what I see the pigtails do interbreed but then stay mostly to themselves.
Long tail baby's their cute but they are the worst.
@@gardener4892 you can't judge by those monkeys, their whole society has been destroyed by the vo's
It's Beautiful to see a loving mom on here. An family.
I know this vid is super old, but good LAWD Aggy is single white female level BABY CRAZY.
I kind of empathize with Aggie at 32 and none of my own, I’ll take all the baby cuddles I can get.
Yea well you can't just snatch an infant away. I can't stand the way these monkeys act.
Do you want to adopt? My name is Brittany and I am davids fiancé. ... And have given two children to two childless couples.. .
David Bradshaw I may adopt one day. My boyfriend was adopted and his parents should have been blessed with a million children. So im sure giving back is on our list. But we haven’t really actually tried yet. I can’t even say if I am or am not fertile. As up until a couple years ago I can say that I was avidly trying to prevent pregnancy. I quite honestly haven’t even taken the first steps of a proper check up. How does your fiancé feel about this? Are you donating eggs? Or surrogacy? I can’t imagine going through all the trouble of helping someone through a pregnancy just to bear no fruit from the tree.
@@amberfrazier575 he is more than fine with it. He and I want to help complete family's. I've got four children and I have let two other babies go to people who need them. Its more about giving them a life i can't. I am not currently pregnant but do want to maybe carry a few more to help people get the babies that they deserve...I would love to donate eggs or be a surrogate. Or both David and I can go ahead and create a new life to help someone
@@amberfrazier575 I am a white female with auburn hair and blue eyes. My fiancé is red headed and brown eyes. We have a daughter with sky blue eyes. My other kids are from a previous relationship. ..... We both are willing and ready any time to help out....
Even though it was 3 years ago, I love this video. I've been following you for over a year now. 🙂🙏🙋♀️🇨🇦
The way the mommy monkey draged the baby monkey XD 10:43
this is one scary aunt
Yea! She's that creepy aunt that wanted you to sit on her lap even though you REALLY didn't want to.... Yea, creepy.
I'm glad to see the baby fighting back & biting the kidnapper.
Aggy and Lily are so sweet together. Wish my Mom was that nice!
They're both biting dopey at the same time.I wonder what he is thinking
😄 yup! ARE THEY JUST GONNA EAT MY LITTLE BUTT..??!!😳😄
He’s soooo cute.
The whole time I think he’s just think: HELP ME!
Love your work. You're doing a great job! Thank you so much.
Arroz Marisco, I LOVE your vídeos so much
Congratulations
Arroz Marisco, where do you come from? Spain?
Bless for you
No UK :)
A ver si doblais al idioma español
@@ArrozMarisco360 subtitulos en español, gracias
Yo tampoco entendi nada
Super active lil babies 👶 it’s a very interesting video and a little hilarious ❤️
毛孩特顽皮又可爱极了。累坏妈妈啦。。看了母猴的爱心 心里感到甜滋滋。。感谢分享
Лапатулька маленькая обезьянка.❤❤❤
Just another observation while watching this video again: After the showdown at 5:10 between Reddy and Aggy, you can actually see Aggy is displaying a fear grimace as she turns away from Reddy. That's extraordinary since Aggy is much higher ranking, and shows the extent of Reddy's devotion. What a fierce momma! Great footage!
The fear grimace itself is at about 5:56 and we can just see the end of it as Aggy turns away!
There is another video, with Dopey and Aggie.. and Dopey was loving the attention he was getting from Aggie and kept coming back for more. It was all like it was play to him. He was having a really good time .
This is a beautiful breed of monkeys thank you for the video’s very much appreciated you do it for the love it not killing them like the Vos killing monkeys in the long tail macaques
Are the grandmother's able to nurse the babies? They still produce milk?
Lo veo repetidas veces, me encanta.
I always look forward to watching your videos more than anyone's! All the other guys that do this we call VOs but you just don't fit that. You fall in your own category because of how caring you are with these monkeys and the fact that you show them respect. The VOs don't show a single ounce of respect the monkeys they film. Makes you wonder though.. The monkeys they film are all crazy and abusive towards babies and what not while this troop with you seem so much calmer and more like they rely on people way less. These guys are lucky to have you on their side!
Aggy and Lilly at the end was so cute😊
in this world no one has a true love than a mother
Grace Mwaniki ffs..grow up
I agree!
Мамочка красивая, молодая, а малыш чудесный красавчик.
Good lord!! I got tired from just watching Dopey constantly struggle to get away from that over bearing idiot!! Sheesh!! How annoying that must be to have someone consistently grabbing onto you even when you're trying to mind your business!!😠😡
northernsoutherngirl Omg I totally agree
I agree it got on my nerves
I think Teddy was observing her the whole time.
Just wondering have you stopped making videos I just love them all and thank you for all you do so amazing 😉
I'VE WATCHED THIS VIDEO A FEW TIMES AND EACH TIME IT'S VERY WARMING TO THE HEART.... ❤️💙
I love when the mother monkeys show affection and nourish their young. It makes me feel good they are doing the right thing. Not like some that after giving birth they forget about their just born babies?
sorry I been watching your videos for a while now, and still not sure, where is this? china, japan?.....
May I play devil's advocate here and posit that the new footage strengthens the argument that Aggy is a baby snatcher? With respect to the first baby, I noticed that Granny approached respectfully and was making overtures to Aggy herself, not the infant. Then Granny turned around, raised her tail and presented her rump to Aggy -- a sign of submission that also says, "I'm not looking for a fight."
What if that infant was Granny's baby? Granny was clearly producing milk at that point, yet we haven't seen her with an infant or child in the past year, have we? What happened to that baby?
While it's true that rhesus macaques don't kidnap for the express intention of killing a rival's baby, as long tailed macaques do, it's also true that overbearing and/or abusive would-be mothers sometimes accidentally kill babies by keeping them physically separated from their mothers for too long, and the babies starve. Other times the babies die from rough handling.
In this case, Aggy wouldn't be kidnapping with intent to kill, as Granny is not a rival of a threat to her. But Aggy *could* be kidnapping out of misplaced maternal yearning, which could lead to accidental death.
One thing that struck me while watching this is how Aggy's behavior checks pretty much every box for abuse as described in this University of Chicago study of rhesus monkeys:
primate.uchicago.edu/1998AB.pdf
One of the things the study's author emphasizes again and again is that abusive rhesus mothers show "strong interest in the infants of other mothers," and are extremely physically controlling. Aggy's behavior -- pulling Dopey by his legs and arms, pulling him down from the bars, even trying to hold onto him by biting his fingers -- is described to a tee in that study. Like Aggy, the rhesus moms in the study were observed keeping the infants in physical contact even as the babies struggled to get away. Like Aggy, the moms in the study are primarily obsessed with newborns and very young babies.
Which brings me to my last point: Aggy is higher ranking than Reddy, and while Reddy stood up to her at least once, it may be that Reddy has to "tolerate" some handling of Dopey by Aggy, or risk her own position in the troop. Allowing Aggy to handle Dopey for short periods of time might be really difficult for Reddy to allow, but getting booted from the troop would be devastating to Reddy and Dopey, and would hurt Dopey's chances of survival. Since Reddy's a mom who lost her two previous babies, she's extremely cautious with Dopey, and I don't think she's willing to risk her status in the troop. Thus she tolerates Aggy's extreme aunting for very short periods of time.
As always, let me offer this disclaimer: I am NOT a Primate expert by any means, and I don't pretend to have any expertise. I'm learning along with everyone else here, and I probably do misinterpret behaviors more than I realize. But I have read research papers on the subject, and I couldn't help but notice the similarities between Aggy's behavior and the behavior described in the University of Chicago study linked above.
Cheers, and as always, thanks for the amazing footage, Arroz!
That's an offer-to-nurse posture. Dopey's aunt always does it. Granny even reached out to try to soothe the little one before doing so.
Well as always, I bow to your expertise in this matter, however Aggy does display many of those trademark characteristics mentioned in the study I linked. But what happened to this baby that Aggy was "aunting" in this video? Have we seen that baby again? I know you mentioned that a lot of the 2015 babies didn't make it, for whatever reason, whether it was just bad luck or tragedy. And what about Granny's baby? She was producing milk, so she obviously gave birth, but her baby is nowhere to be seen.
Cheers, Arroz!
GozerTheGozerian I bet you're right! Aggie may be a "wolf in sheep's clothing!" Egads!
I think Aggie is a beautiful, but sneaky pain in the ass.
Gozer I think you are absolutely right. I think Aggy's pulling and grabbing and holding Dopey is verging on the abusive, and not just overbearing Aunting. You can't help feeling sorry for the little 'un. And it makes sense that Reddy would have to tolerate it for the sake of their place in the group. Well done - nice analysis. Even tho your not an expert!
Beautiful, interesting and very informative video, thanks for the narration that made me understand better what is exactly the video is all about great good job.
17:47 A PERFECT PROFILE PICTURE GRADUATE OF 3 GENERATION OF THIS LADIES :
PAST , PRESENT , FUTURE ... PERFECT
Cool channel. I like the foot notes you leave explaining their actions. Do you work with monkeys or are you just an enthusiast?
Good to see a good “mommy”!
Poor dopey tryjng so hard to get away and pull lilly over, as if tonreplace himself with lilly. Lol. Great video. I was hanging on the edge of my seat the whole time
I’ve never seen a baby run away from a mum like that. The baby must feel like it’s in shackles.
thank you for sharing this detailed narrative, i appreciate and understand more.
I tend to not see this as kidnapping when it's an adult female. I see it more of babysitting since they live in a community. I think babysitting with other adult females builds community for them. I have seen grown males kidnap babies and in that case, I would call it kidnapping, especially when the kidnapper gets fed continuously like they do at Angkor. I remember the Cyclops kidnapping of Helpo and the VO's fed him constantly, rewarding him. He never let go of Helpo, and the baby died.
Excellent. I had memories cuz I remember watching these videos when they were first shown. 😢😥😪
Poor baby doesnt even want to be with Aggy and thats her own mother. Aggy needs to learn to let go. Her daughter needs to run around and play and forage.
No había visto este video. Me gusta observar sus actitudes, reacciones reales y no solo escenas elegidas para lucrar. Son terribles. Que bueno que estan chicos de tamaño porque grandes serían más peligros. 🙈🧐
Poor Lily and Dopey. Dopey didn't seem too distressed. Aggy now has 6 kids in 2022 and seems to have left her baby snatching ways behind.
You're so very talented and knowledgeable and informative to your audience, I will be trying to watch most of your films, Thank You so very much ❤♥😊
I know she just wanted to be a good aunt and she really loved dopey but I felt so bad for the little guy! He was trying so hard to go play and have fun and her daughter was trying so hard to nurse it was just sad and funny lol.
I have been watching your documentaries and seen some that were very sad and tragic, I sign petitions with CARES ACT 2 for animals and humans rights, Climate change, and I think you should send copies of your cull and poisoning videos to CARES ACT 2, So they will get petition to stop the murdering of all the monkeys and kidnappings, you are really Great Photographer and Journalist and I enjoy your work and knowledge, let's stop the brutality of these little lives
Enfin une vidéo belle sans cruauté ❤
I enjoyed this video, and all the comments I have read are positive and appreciative, yet as of my viewing 314 people disliked this. And that's quite a lot. It seems odd to me and I can't help but wonder why.
Concerted efforts in a day or two from a team of followers who disliked my video th-cam.com/video/86xZ0-VBkJ4/w-d-xo.html when I was just telling the truth :) I noticed this sudden upsurge of dislike not long afterwards and this phenomenon affected a few of my other videos too in that time frame.
Monkey babies are cute!
But sometimes I call them money! XD Just kidding!