❤ ΚΑΛΗΜΕΡΑ ΑΠΟ ΑΘΗΝΑ ! ΕΥΧΑΡΙΣΤΟΥΜΕ ΓΙΑ ΤΗΝ ΙΣΤΟΡΙΚΗ ΑΝΑΛYΣΗ .... ΜΕΓΑΛΟ ΤΟ ΔΡΑΜΑ ΟΛΗΣ ΤΗΣ ΑΝΘΡΩΠΟΤΗΤΑΣ ΔΙΑΧΡΟΝΙΚΑ....ΤΑ ΠΑΝΤΑ ΕΙΝΆΙ ΥΠΟΤΑΓΜΕΝΑ ΣΤΗΝ ΜΑΤΑΙΟΤΗΤΑ ... BON JOUR MESSIER ❤
As a Turk, when I saw this video, at first I thought the subject of the video was Turks, then I saw that it was about Greeks, culture, life, food, how similar they are to us Turks.
Los turcos aprendieron la cultura de los muchos pueblos indigenas conquistados por ellos, como los pueblos griegos, armenios y pueblos romanizados. Saludos.
Comment expliquez vous le nom de Valachie, etat constitue' au nord du Danube depuis 11-ieme siecle a. H., habite par VALAQUES, lequel au prezent fait partie de la Roumanie ?
des valachies existere 2, valachia ripinis et valachia mediteranea, et les Roumans sont desandants des valques, autrement apple aussi le cincars,beaucoups ete au service de la 5eme legion de cesar d' ou cinci
La Walachie ripinis été du Danube à Nisus ou Niš d'aujourd'hui et la Walachie méditerranéen de Nisus à laTace c'est à dire le nord-est de la Grèce d'aujourd'hui tandis que la Roumanie d'aujourd'hui s'appellé la Dace ou Dachia ,le territoire de la Macédoine d'aujourd'hui été plutôt la Trace ou la Trachia et l'Albanie d'aujourd'hui n'a jamais existe sous le nom ALBANIE c'était une province Trace appelé Raban ALBANIE à eu le nom Albu ce que veut dire Blanc et c'est typique car les habitants portent un chapeau blanc le quetsche en tunique blanche ,le nord de la Grèce d'aujourd'hui été peuplé par des Grèce pendant la fin de l'empire Otmane il habité tous en Asie l'échange à eu à l'effondrement de l'empire Otmane, regardez dans les anales d'histoire vous allez trouver, et le terroir ou les Valaques habité il me semble l'avoir acheté une deuxième fois au Otmans auparavant il avez le droit valache déjà depuis le temps de Kostanin pour proliférer la religion chrétienne etc etc............
Karakachani still live in the Balkan mountains, near the town of Kotel, Sliven area and have their cultural celebrations . Their yellow cheese is the best ! Orthodox Christians, they do have association to hellenistic cultural links .
The word Vlach/Wallachian (and other variants such as Vlah, Valah, Valach, Voloh, Blac, oláh, Vlas, Ulah, etc. is etymologically derived from the ethnonym of a Celtic tribe,[adopted into Proto-Germanic *Walhaz, which meant 'stranger', from *Wolkā- (Caesar's Latin: Volcae, Strabo and Ptolemy's Greek: Ouolkai). Via Latin, in Gothic, as *walhs, the ethnonym took on the meaning 'foreigner' or 'Romance-speaker' and later "shepherd', 'nomad'. The term was adopted into Greek as Vláhoi or Blachoi (Βλάχοι), Albanian vllah, Slavic as Vlah (pl. Vlasi) or Voloh, Hungarian as oláh and olasz, etc. The root word was notably adopted in Germanic for Wales and Walloon, and in Switzerland for Romansh-speakers (German: Welsch), and in Poland Włochy or in Hungary olasz became an exonym for Italians. The Slovenian term Lahi has also been used to designate Italians. The same name is still used in Polish (Włochy, Włosi, włoskie) and Hungarian (Olasz, Olaszország) as an exonym for Italy, while in Slovak (Vlasi), Czech (Vlachy) and Slovenian (Laško, Láh, Láhinja, laško) it was replaced with the endonym Italia. Source : Wikipedia
Los rumanos y los moldavos son valacos con país propio. Si no tuvieran país los llamarían valacos de Rumania y Moldavia. Los valacos sin país son hermanos de los rumanos y moldavos. Saludos.
@@cosmomusathe cities habitants were since the Indo-European Greeks came from the steps and mixed with the Phoenicians traders, as Herodotus said, new came in the area and they found there the Pelasgians "who never left". So the villages people were since the beginning pelasgians/ Thracians speaking a language spoken all the South amd Central Europe in that moment. This is why they were different cultures and different people. This is why the Minoans has less "Indo-European DNA than the Mycenaeans who were more exposed to the 4000 years ago new Indo-Europeans invasion and mix. This is why the Mycenaeans didn't have defending walls before the Greeks invasion, as the rest of the European old culture the Mycenaeans didn't know what war is and never needed to defend themselves. The Greeks were very proud to enslave them neighbours, a practice never existing before. You will notice im this video the clean and honest life principles of life, part of the old European culture which was still visible until recently in the romanian mountains areas.
Because the name vlach was identified with the hick and the yokel, it's not an ethnic slur, even the Sarakatsani who are ethnically Greeks but equally pastoralists and villagers, are called "vlachs"
Επειδή, μάλλον οι βλάχοι ήταν κτηνοτρόφοι, στην Ελλάδα όποιος είχε πρόβατα και γίδια τόν λένε, Βλάχο. Επίσης ήταν ένας τρόπος οι άνθρωποι των πόλεων νά προσβάλουν τους ανθρώπους της επαρχίας. Με την έννοια του αξεστου και τού απολίτιστου. Στην πραγματικότητα επειδή, πάντα οι άνθρωποι της πόλης, ζήλευαν την υγεία και την ζωντάνια των ανθρώπων της υπαίθρου.
@@dggmn2109all of them are part of the old Thracians and Getae people who were living all the South and Central Europe and becoming later known as Latin speaker.
@@ionelghiorghita688 Do a quick google search "The Dacians have their origins in the broader migration of the Indo-European people to Europe. By 500 BCE, the Dacian people had generated their own distinct culture and society in the area of modern-day Romania. They were broadly culturally connected to the Thracian people to the south." I know you lost your language and culture after you were invaded by the romans you do not need to tell me this.
Vlachs are Aromanians, part of the Daco-Getians,, that learned Latin, then this popular Latin that became the ROMANIAN language north of the Danube and Aromanian in the Balkan mountains. The Greeks were calling themselfs Romaioi, Romans, but also were calling the Aromanians, Romanoi, which also means Romans, that were speaking a language derived from Latin. The Romanians and the Aromanians South of the Danube were the victims of the migrations, of the Ottoman Turkish conquest and of the nationalism of the Greek, Bulgarian, and Serbian States in the 19 and 20th century. Many Aromanians were and still are afraid or discouraged from speaking their mother language. Aromanian kids going to the Aromanian school build by the Romanian state, were killed by the so called Grecomans, fanatical supporters of the Greek state.
Ya right the Greek state persecute the latin speaking Greeks and the latin speaking Greeks stayed in Greece and did not move to Vlachia to save themselves like the Greeks from Anatolia did. We love latinized Dacian propaganda and we know some desperate poor latin speaking Greeks that got paid money moved to latinized Dacia to become instruments of the latinazed Dacian propoganda.
"Kids were killed" What you say are lies and slanders. The video clearly mentions the Greek, Dorian origin of the Vlachs of the Pindos Mountains, and their Greek consciousness.Not only the the Daco-Getians but also other Balkan populations were Latinized. By the way,Rome ( Roman ,Romioi ,Romanoi,Rum) is a Greek word means strength,power.
Lovely fairy tale as a latin speaking Greek/Roman/Romios etc I was not aware that I was discouraged to speak latin on top of Greek, what happen to the Dacian language can you enlighten us frate.
Very simplified opinion. You have to search more. You have much more to learn. The Vlachs(Aromanians) fought for the Greek State since the Greek War of Independence in 1821 and earlier. The great Rigas Fereos was of Vlach(Aromanian) origin. He awaken the Greeks with his poems. "Ως πότε παλικάρια θα ζούμε στα στενά, μονάχοι σαν λιοντάρια στις ράχες στα βουνά. Καλύτερα μιας ώρας ελεύθερη ζωή παρά 40 χρόνια σκλαβιά και φυλακή". That was the most famous. And the catalogue of Vlachs(Aromanians) origin is too long to continue...
@@user-jf6yv8rj2s MY POINT EXACTLY, AND THE GREEKS AFTER THAT TREATED THEM BADLY, DEMANDING THEM TO BECOME GREEKS, TO FORGET THEIR LANGUAGE AND ORIGINS, THAT ARE NON-GREEKS. THE WAR OF 1821 WAS AN ANTI-TURKISH WAR, OF COURSE THAT ALSO NON-GREEKS FOUGHT IN IT.
Los rumanos y los moldavos son valacos con país propio. Si no tuvieran país los llamarían valacos de Rumania y Moldavia. Los valacos sin país son hermanos de los rumanos y moldavos. Saludos.
A question . My father a greek cypriot went to the uk in1946. Lived there had children grandchildren and great grandchildren .The great grandchildren only speak english now. ARE THEY english or greek cypriot?
Your question is terribly screwed up. These people live in Greece and they didn't learn their language from Greeks. It is their language from their ancestors. They are not Vlachs (Vlachs are further North), they are Machidons/Macedonians and they are not Greek, nor were they ever Greeks. Alexander the Great and his Macedonians were not Greeks. They were Macedonians and spoke the same language they speak today. There is lots of documentation on this matter in Antiquity books that survived, and I studied them all. Greeks today claim that the Macedonians of the past were Greeks, because they want to attach the great history of Macedonians to their own. Greeks have their great history, there is no need to try to steal Macedonians history, but when people get used to fame, they never have enough of it.
Και γιατί ο Μέγας Αλέξανδρος είχε Έλληνες δασκαλους , Ελληνική παιδεία, και τα πάντα Ελληνικά????? Τότε υπήρχαν οι πόλεις κράτη, και συχνά αντιμάχονταν! Αυτό δεν τούς αλλάζει την φυλή!! Είναι πιο λογικό να οικειοποιούνται οι Σκοπιανοί μακεδονική καταγωγή, που δεν δεν έχουν καμία απολύτως σχέση, παρά μόνο ότι κατοικούν σε μέρος της Μακεδονίας???? Τα σημερινά Σκόπια κατοικουνται από ένα χαρμάνι, από σλαβους, βουλγαρους, αλβανους , γύφτους, και Έλληνες ντόπιους, που έμειναν εκεί, μετά που μπήκαν τα σύνορα, α' β' παγκόσμιο . Αυτό το χαρμάνι δεν είναι με κανένα νόμο Μακεδόνες στο σύνολό τους!!!!@@ravenalbj
All the shepherd lifestyle of Saracats and the Vlachs is identical with Romanians 🇷🇴. Even the music, the dances, the woven carpets, the way they make cheese and butter. The same you will find in Sardinia, Corsica and Dolomites. The Vlachs, Romanians and all tye Romance language speakers, did not speak Latin but LaDin, a Semitic language that is the mother of Latin and Ladino, and not the other way around.
As a roman/vlach ie latin speaking Greek/Romios thank you commentators for informing me that apparently I am Albanian, Serb, Bulgarian, Skopian, Romanian etc apparently my ancestors got their Greek ethnicity wrong because did not have youtubers to correct them.
no, actually all Balkans, Europe Africa and Australia are greek, so are the baklava, white cheese, salat, just like Israeli falafel. Apparently no matter what researchers say, or even the people themselves, the greeks will say it is not true. Here is a story for you: When I lived in Atica, all arvanites told me that their grandparents did not speak greek. (of course the rural folks that never had to deal with the administration). Dont take my word, ask them yourself. But the answer of most greeks is"it is not true", and that I am lying.
@@arbenvuthi7103 Ya right but lets assume you are correct, so what? Did the arvanites also tell you why they moved to Greece? Did they also tell you who kikilled and rraaped their women?
@@dggmn2109 ok there we are, your way of discourse is "change the subject and make up crap", We were at the subject of the origin. Now the rape part. Where did you get that. half of Albania is christian. The Arvanites are in their lands buddy. I wander if they know that the "greeks", say about them: "gamoto arvanites mas piran ola ta ikopedha". This I heard from a "greek" that came from Egypt. Precious. You cant make this stuff up.
Vlachs are partially Romanized Pelasgians, forced to declare Greek since the formation of Pindus republic was defeated in 1919. Pelasgians were Proto Indo European Getae people, originated in south Caucasus 6-7,000 years ago.
We all know that the Aromanians are Latinized Paleo-Balkan populations, Thracians, Illyrians, Greeks, Dacians, Getae, Moesians, etc. But many non Greeks disagree that the Vlachs of the Pindos mountains are of Greek origin. Why? Can someone explain why?
@@eliasrudi9728 This is not a serious answer to my question. And anyway, NO, I'm not the one who supports what you said, Victor Hugo does . "Greece is the contracting World and the World is the expanding Greece" Victor Hugo 26.2.1802 - 22.5.1885.
Because they have been educated to despise anything Greek. (Except for Sirtaki, Bouzouki and Greek salad, to them this is the limit of Greek civilization)
A venit toamna sh' ploili / fug picurari cu oili ,( fall came with rain, the sheppards run with the sheeps) Fug diparti pusti munti ( they run away over the mountains) Same as in Moldavian idiom except "picurari" is "ciobani"( sheepherds)
Los rumanos y los moldavos son valacos con país propio. Si no tuvieran país los llamarían valacos de Rumania y Moldavia. Los valacos sin país son hermanos de los rumanos y moldavos. Saludos.
Dix minutes dans le documentaire et les erreurs historiques pleuvent. Alexandre le Grand et les Romains n'ont pas bâti l'empire byzantin, les Vlachs étaient dans l'Antiquité des Daco-Getae , partie des peuples Traces.
In public, greeks tear their clothes about how much greek the vlachs are, but in private conversations they claim the opposite. In fact, the greeks consider vlachs to be romanians.
Min 21 Romanians are known for carving wood especially in Maramureș region. Vlachs are related to Romanians. But they are are formed from the Ladin, the tribe of Dan. La D_n. El D_n
Love documentaries when they have sweet little mistakes like the wrong map location of the village, what the name Samarina means and why Samarina is so famous. Latinized Dacians search for Παιδια της Σαμαρινας/Ficiori di Samarina and explain to the Albanians, Slavs and the rest of the world what the song is about.
Absolutely amazing. Min 14.25 Vârtej 🌀 This is the same as in 🇷🇴 Romania, Maramureș. But there it is made naturally in the rivers. We are talking about the same Semitic civilization, the lost tribe of Dan. The Thracians, Dacians then tue Vlachs. That became the Romanians, Saxons and the Celts.
I am a Katsanos and my Great Grandfather came from Greece to the US. Sarakatsanoi have been all over Pindos into Thracian and Bulgarian mountain ranges as well .
Vlahs and Greeks come from Tracians. That was a people from Boemia to Kazakhstan. People that were there before Greeks. Tracs influenced most of the world, from England to Japan. I see Romanian words in Japanese. I understand some Sanskrit without learning.
Greeks did not came from Tracians. There are some Romanian words in Japanese, but they got there via China which was formed of Manzi White Race people during Marco Polo's time. These people are not Vlachs (Vlachs are further North), they are Machidons/Macedonians and they are not Greek, nor were they ever Greeks. Alexander the Great and his Macedonians were not Greeks. They were Macedonians and spoke the same language they speak today. There is lots of documentation on this matter in Antiquity books that survived, and I studied them all. Greeks today claim that the Macedonians of the past were Greeks, because they want to attach the great history of Macedonians to their own. Greeks have their great history, there is no need to try to steal Macedonians history, but when people get used to fame, they never have enough of it.
All Vlahs I know in Greece identify themselves as Greeks. Regardless of... ancient origin, they are hellenized. Some had indeed Romanian national identity (and many of them collaborated with the Nazis in WWII) but they were a minority of Vlahs.
More J2 than EV13, with good amounts of R1b. Low R1a and low I2a. Actually they are similar to Greeks and Albanians, with a extra Western - Italian Dna. Not as close genetically to Romanians , as someone would expect.
@@mesimeriaris I suspected they were more prevalent carriers of J2b. Much like the coastal peoples of the Adriatic. Dalmatians etc. The R1b component is leftover Celts who lived in close proximity to the Mediterranean types. Fascinating all the same. EV13 carrier myself.
Very interesting. An ancient people who have been living in Macedonia, all of it. My father was born in Kastoria region but the family left when the Greeks took over after 2nd Balkan War and WW1. But my family is not Vlatsi just neighbors. BTW, his town Smurdech is no longer there just the church bell tower.
Would like to know what people you are talking about ?? My family are all from the area between Kastoria and Florina. My ancestors, on my Fathers & Mothers side, have never changed their surnames and they are engraved on tombstones and Church logs of Births and Baptisms dating back hundreds of years. They are completely Greek in name, so we know we have never left those areas. There were many races of people who fought against Greek people, when Greeks finally banded together for Independence (aligned with Vlachs & Arvanite), and took back their ancient ancestral lands. Those people who betrayed or fought against the Greeks were sent packing. We continue to excavate Ancient archaeological sites and find only Hellenic (and some Latin) inscriptions - not other languages.
You missed what is the most .important . MOSKOPOLE. The second biggest city in Balkans. Destroyed by albanian Muslims in few waves. Last they attacked in 1994. That is 20th century.
They do not sound Greek at all. You Must be American, because Americans are not exposed to foreign languages, and are limited in the ability of identifying other languages. They are not Vlachs (Vlachs are further North), they are Machidons/Macedonians and they are not Greek, nor were they ever Greeks. Alexander the Great and his Macedonians were not Greeks. They were Macedonians and spoke the same language they speak today. There is lots of documentation on this matter in Antiquity books that survived, and I studied them all. Greeks today claim that the Macedonians of the past were Greeks, because they want to attach the great history of Macedonians to their own. Greeks have their great history, there is no need to try to steal Macedonians history, but when people get used to fame, they never have enough of it.
@@ravenalbj As you are a slav first explain to us what the words Macedonian, Alexander, Philip etc mean in your slavic language and next worry if the Macedonians are Greek or not.
The origins of the aromanians and the history of there language is very incomplete in this documentary. Not mentioning about the fact that they speak a dialect of the🇷🇴romanian language and they even call themselves aromanians is like missing the core of the history of thise people and there language. There language- aromanian- is first of all very similar to romanian🇷🇴.both of them are romance languages. 🇬🇷🇷🇴 Very false to say that they speak latin tongue. They speak a romance language (derived from latin;dialect of romanian). There language is romance, just as french, italian and there mother tongue romanian🇷🇴. PS: The valachs/aromanians ar not specific just to Greece. Aromanian/valach comunities can be foud in Albania, North Macedonia and Bulgaria. You cannot call them latin greeks because they do not belong just to Greece.
Greeks are also pelasgians/Thracians mixed with the Phoenicians traders and Indo-European warriors who changed the old pelasgians culture of peace and freedom with the semitic culture of trading , authority and slavery.
@@ionelghiorghita688 Keep dreaming that the whole world is Albanian. You are a Creole nation with a language consisted of Greek, Latin, Turkish, Slavic and less than 10% paleobalkanic origin words mostly of Thracian and Not of Illyrian origin. Show me Illyrian inscriptions?Show me Illyrian temples?show me Illyrian theatres?Show me Illyrian sculptures?Show me Illyrians mosaics?Show me Illyrians stadiums?Show me Illyrian epigraphs? Tell me names of Illyrians philosophers? Tell me names of ancient Illyrian athletes in the ancient Olympic Games? Show me the seven Illyrian wonders of the ancient world? Where are the Illyrian ancient libraries??? Where are the ancient Illyrians colonies in Asia,Spain,south France,al all around black sea, the Levante, Syria, etc? Till you find them, hide in your cave 🤫🤫 I repeat that 90% of your vocabulary is actually Greek,Latin, Slavic, Turkish, English and less than 20% of paleobalkanic origin. There are glossologists who made that research and is scientifically accepted. Except few toponyms and words of messapic or Illyrian origin which don't consist more than 5% the rest 5% is of mainly Thracian, Celtic origin words. Even the word Gomar is coming from the Greek language, even the word autochthonous is coming from the Greek language, even the word harta is coming from the Greek language. What you don't want to accept???? No serious historian, actually No-one teaching in any university around the world accepts this Albanian-Illyrian history. The origin of the albanians remains a "mystery" and the most possible scenario is that they are a CREOLE nation. Residuals of Romans, Greeks, Thracians, few Illyrians,Celts etc who escaped latinisation and Greekification cause of their isolation in the harsh area of modern day North Albania. Show me your Illyrian theatres, Illyrian temples, any Illyrian mosaics, etc Nothing to show me except very few Illyrian artifacts heavily Hellenized. You can try hard to prove that you are straight descendants of the ancient Illyrians just because they lived in the same geographical area but the same can do the Bosniaks or the Croats or the Slovenians or even the Serbs. Almost all of the artifacts you have in your museums are of Greek or Roman origin. Just go to the museum of Durres and see by your own eyes. The Skopians tried to say to the world that they are the descendants of ancient Macedonians but they failed. You are in the same category. Please continue to expose yourselfs with your pseydo-Glossology and pseudo-history theories and make the whole world laugh at you even more! Illyrian was part of the Indo-European language family. Its relation to other Indo-European languages, ancient and modern, is poorly understood because of the paucity of data and because it is still being examined. Today, the main source of authoritative information about Illyrian consists of a handful of Illyrian words cited in classical sources and numerous examples of Illyrian anthroponyms, ethnonyms, toponyms and hydronyms. The scarcity of the data makes it difficult to identify the sound changes that have taken place in Illyrian; the most widely accepted one is that the Indo-European voiced aspirates /bʰ/, /dʰ/, /ɡʰ/ became voiced consonants /b/, /d/, /ɡ/. Recent scholarship from the 1960s and on tends to agree that the region inhabited by Illyrian tribes can be divided into three distinct linguistic and cultural areas, of which only one can be properly termed "Illyrian". No written texts regarding self-identification exist from the Illyrians and no inscriptions in Illyrian exist, with the only linguistic remains being place names (toponyms) and some glosses.
@@ionelghiorghita688 Lexican borrowing are responsible for as much as ninety percent of the Albanian vocabulary. Especially from Greek and Latin! Examples: Zemër with the meaning of 'centre of the day', or from the same root of Greek ημέρα (iméra, “day”), although the initial anlaut z- remains unexplained. A borrowing from Greek διήμερον (diímeron, “period of twenty-four hours”) is not excluded. Mellan: from Greek μελάνι (meláni). Kapister: from Greek καπίστρι (kapístri) Barkë: borrowed from Greek βάρκα (várka) Merimange: First attested as mrīmagë; borrowed from Greek μυρμήγκι (myrmígki, “ant”). According to Kristofordhi and Mihăescu, a borrowing from Doric Greek μύρμαξ (múrmax) Laparos: from Greek λαπαρός (laparós) Gomar: inherited from Byzantine Greek γομάρι(ν) (gomári(n)), from Koine Greek γομάριον (gomárion, “load of an animal”), derived from Ancient Greek γόμος (gómos, “load, weight”). Gjyp: from Ancient Greek γύψ (gúps), compare Greek γύπας (gýpas) Avlli: from Ancient Greek αὐλή (aulḗ) Gamë: from Ancient Greek γάμμα (gámma). Bagëm: from Ancient Greek βάπτισμα (báptisma), internally corrupted or affected by another word, possibly bekoj (“I bless”). I can continue till tomorrow....... Learn real history. You are a CREOLE nation. You are the residuals of Greeks,Romans,Slavs,Turks and few paleobalkanic people just isolated in the mountains of modern albania and created a Creole new nation through centuries. This Illyrian albanian connection theory lacks basic elements. It's just a pro Albanian hypothesis which is not widely supported by non albanian academics and historians. You pathetically trying to create your identity cause you are jealous of your Greek and Italian neighbours. You are the same as the Skopians who miserably tried to claim that they were the real descendants of the ancient Macedonians but failed miserably. Lol 🤣 I repeat that 90% of your vocabulary is actually Greek,Latin, Slavic, Turkish, English and less than 10% of paleobalkanic origin. There are glossologists who made that research and is scientifically accepted. Except few toponyms and words of messapic or Illyrian origin which don't consist more than 5% the rest 5% is of mainly Thracian, Celtic origin words. Even the word Gomar is coming from the Greek language, even the word autochthonous is coming from the Greek language, even the word harta is coming from the Greek language. What you don't want to accept???? No serious historian, actually No-one teaching in any university around the world accepts this Albanian-Illyrian history. The origin of the albanians remains a "mystery" and the most possible scenario is that they are a CREOLE nation. Residuals of Romans, Greeks, Thracians, few Illyrians,Celts etc who escaped latinisation and Greekification cause of their isolation in the harsh area of modern day North Albania. Show me your Illyrian theatres, Illyrian temples, any Illyrian mosaics, etc Nothing to show me except very few Illyrian artifacts heavily Hellenized. You can try hard to prove that you are straight descendants of the ancient Illyrians just because they lived in the same geographical area but the same can do the Bosniaks or the Croats or the Slovenians or even the Serbs. The Skopians tried to say to the world that they are the descendants of ancient Macedonians but they failed. You are in the same category. Please make people laugh with you. Illyrian was part of the Indo-European language family. Its relation to other Indo-European languages, ancient and modern, is poorly understood because of the paucity of data and because it is still being examined. Today, the main source of authoritative information about Illyrian consists of a handful of Illyrian words cited in classical sources and numerous examples of Illyrian anthroponyms, ethnonyms, toponyms and hydronyms. The scarcity of the data makes it difficult to identify the sound changes that have taken place in Illyrian; the most widely accepted one is that the Indo-European voiced aspirates /bʰ/, /dʰ/, /ɡʰ/ became voiced consonants /b/, /d/, /ɡ/. Recent scholarship from the 1960s and on tends to agree that the region inhabited by Illyrian tribes can be divided into three distinct linguistic and cultural areas, of which only one can be properly termed "Illyrian". No written texts regarding self-identification exist from the Illyrians and no inscriptions in Illyrian exist, with the only linguistic remains being place names (toponyms) and some glosses. All of south and coastal Albania is Greek! Above only few of the ancient Greek cities founded by Greek settlers in Albania: 1)Berat=Antipatrea 2)Dropull=Dryinopolis or Dropolis 3)Durres=Epidamnus 4)Butrint=Buthroton 5)Sarande=Onchesmus 6)Argyrokastron=Silver castle 7)Pojani=Apollonia 8)Vlore=Aulon 9)Finiq=Phoenice 10)Korce=Pelion 11)Lezhe=Lissus 12)Shengjin=Nymphaion 13)Himara=Himare 14)Antigone=Antigona 15)Ploc=Amantia=Abantia 16)Oriku=ancient Greek Oricon and many more smaller settlements. 17)Ksamil=Eksamili 18)Kolonje=Koloneia 19)Devoll=Deapolis 20)Peshkopi=Episkope (The name of Peshkopi is derived from the word peshkop meaning bishop in Albanian and from Episkopè in Greek.) 21)Këlcyrë=Kleisourai 22)Nicea 23)Pelion=ancient Greek City near Cangonj Pass The word kleisoúra (Medieval Greek: κλεισοῦρα) was eventually borrowed by all Balkan peoples, becoming the root of several place-names. 😊🤫🇬🇷🇬🇷 All of the south Albanians have more than 40% Greek DNA coming from albanised northern Epirotan Greeks. Close your mouth now you Albanian shepperd 🤡🐏 🐏
Where did you get this information.Greek language was before the Latin.Latin came after the Greek.Romans got their alphabet from the Etruscans and Etruscans from Cumean Greeks.
Étymologie. Ελληνική Δωρική διάλεκτος "βλᾱχά," =Grec Doric dialekt '"vlaha" = bêler En grec moderne βλάχος-βλάχα =vlachos-vlacha Tribu Dorique du Pinde. Ils parlaient un dialecte latin comme les Aroumains. L'étymologie de l'allemand "Walachen " n'est pas correcte puisque les Allemands définissaient les Celtes, Wells,Welsch par le nom "Walachen ".
@@giorgiodifrancesco4590 Funny thing is that other 28-30 million Vlachs don't know any sort of Greek, but they share a similar language and a large common vocabulary with the few Vlachs of south Balkans left, after thorough assimilation by the Greeks, Albanians, and south Slavs. Should have a real thick face to call that a Greek language.
@@Sofia-0001 What do you mean? That all the Latinized populations of various Balkan nations became... a new nation?😀 Aromanians are not a nation.They are different nations,( Thracians, Greeks, Illyrians, Dacians, Celts, Getae) , Latinized.
@@giorgiodifrancesco4590 LIDDELL & SCOTT Dictionary of the Ancient Greek Language. Ιων:βληχή, Δωρ: βλᾱχά, ἡ, βέλασμα· οἰῶν, σε Ομήρ. Οδ.· το κλάμα των παιδιών (νηπίων), σε Ευριπίδης. (ηχομιμ. λέξη). Ionic:Vleche, Doric : Vlacha, the , bleat by sheep in Homer. Od.; the cry of children (infants), in Euripides. (phonemic word).
48.37 Romanian Hora Also the revived Jewish dance Now you understand, WE ARE OF SEMITIC ORIGINS in Europe. Coming from Thracians, Sarmatiabs and Dacians. In fact from Samaritans of Samaria ancient-culture Israel. The lost tribes of Israel. The lots tribe of Dan.
Vlachs exist in Greece, if not always, at least 1000 years. They consider themselves greek , they were great patriots and benefactors of the greek state , they participated in all wars and national fights and in WW2 they participated in the resistance and rejected the nazi and romanian propaganda and ostracized a few vlach collaborators who expected benefits and power. This is the exact truth. All the other is malevolent propaganda of suspicious motivation!!! Even in albania , skopje and elsewhere in balkans vlachs were asking to be registered as greeks!!!
If so, very sad for you to find out that the linguists are considering them romanians and not due to them language but also due to their habits, culture, traditions...
@@ionelghiorghita688Language resembles to ancient latin but habits, customs and traditions are almost identical to those of their neighbours. Regarding musik especially their songs are exactly the same but with lyrics in their idiom.
@@odysseasntalias5950 sorry, what I meant is that the Latin is actually the old Thracians/Getae language spoken all along the south and Central europe due to the Anatolian Balcanic and Carpathian (including West of Ukraine) migrations.
Vlachs are great patriots of the state they live in. They are great Greeks or great Albanians or great North-Macedonians. They were great Turks, too : ) Should no national border exist and no pressure from a majority - they would be glad to be just great Vlachs.
I speak as a latin speaking aroman/roman/greek the only difference between me and a Greek speaking romios/roman/Greek is that the romios/Greek kept the Greek language whereas the aroman/Greek used Latin as well both we are Greek in every shape and form. Romanians are latinised Dacians to say that Latin speaking Greeks are Romanians is like saying that navajo Indians are the same as Australians because both speak english.
@@southepirote7676 ya like albanians are brainwashed to believe that Dures and pogradec and apolonia etc are albanian cities that happen to have Greek and slav names.
@@dggmn2109 Chech historical documents and find out that Durres, Duraci was all the time in history, until 19 century, a majority Orthodox Vlach port. They had nothing to do with Greeks.
@@Sofia-0001 I know that the port of dures was inhabited by Aroman/Roman/Vlach/Greeks why do you think we gave a Greek name to the city of Dures to Moscopole/Voscopole etc?
So I suppose Wallonians living in France, the Romanch people living in Switzerland,Welsh of UK and Walloons in Belgium are Romanians too? Of course not. All these people and Vlachs/Aromanians of Greece are the old inhabitants of their lands respictively before the waves of germanic/slavic/avars etc tribes arrive. Why the creators of the "documenary" did not ask the Vlachs if they self-identify as greeks? Let me tell you why: because it does not fit into their propaganda, since all the vlachs of Greece (yes, there are Vlachs in other parts of Greece too even if they did not speak aromanian) fought and died during the centuries defending greek nation in EVERY SINGLE war. This is not a documentary.It is an identity attack that insults us Vlachs.
They left beautiful built homes and live in garbage built apartments. Very sad They thought they would find better life but look at all the cities are becoming dumps.
Orthodoxy was adopted in 451 AD by the Latin Roman empire, specifically against the Monophysite Greeks. Greeks adopted Orthodoxy in 682 AD, after many Orthodox martyrs, specially during Monophysite Heraclid dynasty.
@@chrisapost5409 Forget this crap lies, Orthodoxy was implemented in the Roman empire at the Council of Calchedon, in 451 AD, by the Pope Leo I and empress Pulcheria, expressly AGAINST the Monophysite Greeks, led by then ex empress Eudokia, of Greek ethnicity. Was Roman Constantinople and Rome against Greek Alexandria and Antioch, demoted from equal status after that ecumenical council. Moreover the Orthodox suffererd dearly when the Monophysite Greeks came to power in 610 AD and between the Orthodox martylrs were Pope Martin and one of the most prolific Orthodox theologians Maxim the Confessor. The Greeks accepted Orthodoxy only after the mostly Greek regions of north west Africa and costal Levant fell to Arabs and the majority population left in the Balkans and around Constantinople were Orthodox Romans. That was the 4th ecumenical council in Constantinople, in 682 AD. Meanwhile most LATIN Romans were Orthodox since 451 AD.
You hear in the vid ""hai"". Any Romanian would understand this. Come, let's go. From the Hebrew ""haia"". If I tell you that Sanskrit is part Hebrew, part Greek,part Romanian, I'm sure you cannot process the information.
Latin speaking Roman Greeks. How can they be Greeks if they speak Latin. It's nonsensical. For me they're a Thracian people who adopted Latin and became remnants of the Roman empire. They are not Greeks. Today maybe so as they've been incorporated into the Greek State and society.
Their origins were not originally Greek no, but today they are. Over many generations they married into Greek families. They are now mostly Greek in their DNA.
It seems that when the Roman Empire collapsed these people the Vlachis or most of them held their positions up on the mountains with their families and herds every five miles apart each family to serve the Romans it was the fastest way for passing messages along the Empire and being a watching dog The Vlachis who happened to be on the Greek land spoke Greek and Latin the ones who watched the Roumanian border spoke Greek and Latin that went on through different countries. nevertheless, all of them have Greek roots Kαι οπου φυσα ο ανεμος Αγαπαμε τους βλαχους μας
Free to dream but a jewish business as the Greek identity build up to the pelasgians and Thracian citizens culture and language is just ome of the biggest fake of the history promoted by the Jews as convenient being part of them culture and actions in the long way of Europe and finally world hegemony.
Nesun grec nete pa latinize on Balkan.Le Valah șont de rumen.Dans lor long lor s''apel Aromanian Sulmont le naționalist grek afirm che son grek latinize On tot la Balkanle vlache la nom de population latin.La vlach șont ossi în Macedonia ,Albania Bulgaria Serbia .Valach egal roman e non berger com dis le Grek !
They are VLACHS with GREEK consciousness. So they are Greek people. Cry more about it. Samarina is a greek village of Grevena. My one origin is from Grevena too from a village which is called Monachiti.
Kasturi et non kostoria..Les Albanais expoulsse par les grecs...Haxhisemalis...Il parler Albanais et vous devez dire.. Arrête de manipuler l histoire...
Les meilleirs grecs de la Crece moderne etaient des Donnateurs Valaques .La langue ne donne pas la nationalite , les francophone Africans ne son't pas des francais .Arrettez dire des betises surtout ceux des pays voisins qui veulemt voler par l histoire glorieuse de la Grece que tour le monde admire! qui n ont aucune histoire culturelle
In every video about balkans an albanian will "pop up like a fart" and start spreading the nonsense he learned from albanian tiktok scholars.... You forgot to write that jesus, Aristotle, Alexander the great, Julius Caesar, Napoleon , Einstein etc are albanians. So ridiculous sqiptar 😅😅😅😅
They are not Vlachs (Vlachs are further North), they are Machidons/Macedonians and they are not Greek, nor were they ever Greeks. Alexander the Great and his Macedonians were not Greeks. They were Macedonians and spoke the same language they speak today. There is lots of documentation on this matter in Antiquity books that survived, and I studied them all. Greeks today claim that the Macedonians of the past were Greeks, because they want to attach the great history of Macedonians to their own. Greeks have their great history, there is no need to try to steal Macedonians history, but when people get used to fame, they never have enough of it.
Is that why Alexander taught greek language and culture everywhere he went . And all of Asia and India had hellenism. And India. In India there was 7 greek kings after the he's death . Ptolemy he's general spread greek culture in Egypt. All the world knows that what did they teach you at school .You are the ones that stealing history. The now north Macedonians are a mix of slavs Bulgarians albanians and turks
@@davidaxelos4678 I know about the Macedonians and the Greeks, and Romans, more than anyone else on earth. I studied all the antiquity books that survived and are translated in English. Nobody else on earth did that.
La langue rassemble à l’albanais et non latin…la danse par les mains,les vêtements traditionnels ( fustanella ) sont toute albanais….ARVANITIS comment appel les grecs… en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fustanella
You are a complete ignorant. Study about there language before posting. They are valachs/ aromanians. They speak a very similar dialect to 🇷🇴romanian. Romanian is a romance language, just as italian and spanish.
❤ ΚΑΛΗΜΕΡΑ ΑΠΟ ΑΘΗΝΑ ! ΕΥΧΑΡΙΣΤΟΥΜΕ ΓΙΑ ΤΗΝ ΙΣΤΟΡΙΚΗ ΑΝΑΛYΣΗ .... ΜΕΓΑΛΟ ΤΟ ΔΡΑΜΑ ΟΛΗΣ ΤΗΣ ΑΝΘΡΩΠΟΤΗΤΑΣ ΔΙΑΧΡΟΝΙΚΑ....ΤΑ ΠΑΝΤΑ ΕΙΝΆΙ ΥΠΟΤΑΓΜΕΝΑ ΣΤΗΝ ΜΑΤΑΙΟΤΗΤΑ ... BON JOUR MESSIER ❤
Good evening from New York, stop lying yourself and others we know the truth and the real truth is under their skin mate.
As a Turk, when I saw this video, at first I thought the subject of the video was Turks, then I saw that it was about Greeks, culture, life, food, how similar they are to us Turks.
Just they are not greeks. They are vlachs, arîmîni (aromâni)
Los turcos aprendieron la cultura de los muchos pueblos indigenas conquistados por ellos, como los pueblos griegos, armenios y pueblos romanizados.
Saludos.
Thank you for showing this documentary. I enjoyed it very much.❤️
Comment expliquez vous le nom de Valachie, etat constitue' au nord du Danube depuis 11-ieme siecle a. H., habite par VALAQUES, lequel au prezent fait partie de la Roumanie ?
des valachies existere 2, valachia ripinis et valachia mediteranea, et les Roumans sont desandants des valques, autrement apple aussi le cincars,beaucoups ete au service de la 5eme legion de cesar d' ou cinci
Meci, thank you for the answer. It is total correct. Then why they call them "latin speaking greeks"???
La Walachie ripinis été du Danube à Nisus ou Niš d'aujourd'hui et la Walachie méditerranéen de Nisus à laTace c'est à dire le nord-est de la Grèce d'aujourd'hui tandis que la Roumanie d'aujourd'hui s'appellé la Dace ou Dachia ,le territoire de la Macédoine d'aujourd'hui été plutôt la Trace ou la Trachia et l'Albanie d'aujourd'hui n'a jamais existe sous le nom ALBANIE c'était une province Trace appelé Raban ALBANIE à eu le nom Albu ce que veut dire Blanc et c'est typique car les habitants portent un chapeau blanc le quetsche en tunique blanche ,le nord de la Grèce d'aujourd'hui été peuplé par des Grèce pendant la fin de l'empire Otmane il habité tous en Asie l'échange à eu à l'effondrement de l'empire Otmane, regardez dans les anales d'histoire vous allez trouver, et le terroir ou les Valaques habité il me semble l'avoir acheté une deuxième fois au Otmans auparavant il avez le droit valache déjà depuis le temps de Kostanin pour proliférer la religion chrétienne etc etc............
Është shqip vlla kemi një gjak
They invent Greek identities for the former real east Romans of Latin language, to assimilate them into Greeks.
Karakachani still live in the Balkan mountains, near the town of Kotel, Sliven area and have their cultural celebrations . Their yellow cheese is the best ! Orthodox Christians, they do have association to hellenistic cultural links .
The word Vlach/Wallachian (and other variants such as Vlah, Valah, Valach, Voloh, Blac, oláh, Vlas, Ulah, etc. is etymologically derived from the ethnonym of a Celtic tribe,[adopted into Proto-Germanic *Walhaz, which meant 'stranger', from *Wolkā- (Caesar's Latin: Volcae, Strabo and Ptolemy's Greek: Ouolkai). Via Latin, in Gothic, as *walhs, the ethnonym took on the meaning 'foreigner' or 'Romance-speaker' and later "shepherd', 'nomad'. The term was adopted into Greek as Vláhoi or Blachoi (Βλάχοι), Albanian vllah, Slavic as Vlah (pl. Vlasi) or Voloh, Hungarian as oláh and olasz, etc. The root word was notably adopted in Germanic for Wales and Walloon, and in Switzerland for Romansh-speakers (German: Welsch), and in Poland Włochy or in Hungary olasz became an exonym for Italians. The Slovenian term Lahi has also been used to designate Italians. The same name is still used in Polish (Włochy, Włosi, włoskie) and Hungarian (Olasz, Olaszország) as an exonym for Italy, while in Slovak (Vlasi), Czech (Vlachy) and Slovenian (Laško, Láh, Láhinja, laško) it was replaced with the endonym Italia.
Source : Wikipedia
Los rumanos y los moldavos son valacos con país propio.
Si no tuvieran país los llamarían valacos de Rumania y Moldavia.
Los valacos sin país son hermanos de los rumanos y moldavos.
Saludos.
If they are greeks, why in Greece the term 'vlach' has a derogatory meaning?
used to mean the differentiation between city dwellers and country people, with a negative sign on the latter due to lack of education
@@cosmomusathe cities habitants were since the Indo-European Greeks came from the steps and mixed with the Phoenicians traders, as Herodotus said, new came in the area and they found there the Pelasgians "who never left". So the villages people were since the beginning pelasgians/ Thracians speaking a language spoken all the South amd Central Europe in that moment. This is why they were different cultures and different people. This is why the Minoans has less "Indo-European DNA than the Mycenaeans who were more exposed to the 4000 years ago new Indo-Europeans invasion and mix. This is why the Mycenaeans didn't have defending walls before the Greeks invasion, as the rest of the European old culture the Mycenaeans didn't know what war is and never needed to defend themselves. The Greeks were very proud to enslave them neighbours, a practice never existing before. You will notice im this video the clean and honest life principles of life, part of the old European culture which was still visible until recently in the romanian mountains areas.
Because the name vlach was identified with the hick and the yokel, it's not an ethnic slur, even the Sarakatsani who are ethnically Greeks but equally pastoralists and villagers, are called "vlachs"
Vllachia is a rrgion in todays Romania and their language is different from greek. The are found in other countries too.
Επειδή, μάλλον οι βλάχοι ήταν κτηνοτρόφοι, στην Ελλάδα όποιος είχε πρόβατα και γίδια τόν λένε, Βλάχο.
Επίσης ήταν ένας τρόπος οι άνθρωποι των πόλεων νά προσβάλουν τους ανθρώπους της επαρχίας. Με την έννοια του αξεστου και τού απολίτιστου.
Στην πραγματικότητα επειδή, πάντα οι άνθρωποι της πόλης, ζήλευαν την υγεία και την ζωντάνια των ανθρώπων της υπαίθρου.
VALAH,walahia ,România...
We know that Romanians are latin dacians like aromanians/ vlach are Latin speaking Greeks.
@@dggmn2109all of them are part of the old Thracians and Getae people who were living all the South and Central Europe and becoming later known as Latin speaker.
@@ionelghiorghita688 Do a quick google search "The Dacians have their origins in the broader migration of the Indo-European people to Europe. By 500 BCE, the Dacian people had generated their own distinct culture and society in the area of modern-day Romania. They were broadly culturally connected to the Thracian people to the south." I know you lost your language and culture after you were invaded by the romans you do not need to tell me this.
I agree but those greeks are very strange and want to say stubbornly that Aromanians are not romanians
@@ionelghiorghita688 is this what ancient Greeks historians like Herodotus say or are you using ancient Dacian sources.
Vlahs= ancient people and European civilization, at the core of their vast land being nowadays Romania 🇷🇴
Vlachs are Aromanians, part of the Daco-Getians,, that learned Latin, then this popular Latin that became the ROMANIAN language north of the Danube and Aromanian in the Balkan mountains. The Greeks were calling themselfs Romaioi, Romans, but also were calling the Aromanians, Romanoi, which also means Romans, that were speaking a language derived from Latin. The Romanians and the Aromanians South of the Danube were the victims of the migrations, of the Ottoman Turkish conquest and of the nationalism of the Greek, Bulgarian, and Serbian States in the 19 and 20th century. Many Aromanians were and still are afraid or discouraged from speaking their mother language. Aromanian kids going to the Aromanian school build by the Romanian state, were killed by the so called Grecomans, fanatical supporters of the Greek state.
Ya right the Greek state persecute the latin speaking Greeks and the latin speaking Greeks stayed in Greece and did not move to Vlachia to save themselves like the Greeks from Anatolia did. We love latinized Dacian propaganda and we know some desperate poor latin speaking Greeks that got paid money moved to latinized Dacia to become instruments of the latinazed Dacian propoganda.
"Kids were killed" What you say are lies and slanders.
The video clearly mentions the Greek, Dorian origin of the Vlachs of the Pindos Mountains, and their Greek consciousness.Not only the the Daco-Getians but also other Balkan populations were Latinized.
By the way,Rome ( Roman ,Romioi ,Romanoi,Rum) is a Greek word means strength,power.
Lovely fairy tale as a latin speaking Greek/Roman/Romios etc I was not aware that I was discouraged to speak latin on top of Greek, what happen to the Dacian language can you enlighten us frate.
Very simplified opinion. You have to search more. You have much more to learn.
The Vlachs(Aromanians) fought for the Greek State since the Greek War of Independence in 1821 and earlier.
The great Rigas Fereos was of Vlach(Aromanian) origin. He awaken the Greeks with his poems.
"Ως πότε παλικάρια θα ζούμε στα στενά, μονάχοι σαν λιοντάρια στις ράχες στα βουνά. Καλύτερα μιας ώρας ελεύθερη ζωή παρά 40 χρόνια σκλαβιά και φυλακή".
That was the most famous.
And the catalogue of Vlachs(Aromanians) origin is too long to continue...
@@user-jf6yv8rj2s MY POINT EXACTLY, AND THE GREEKS AFTER THAT TREATED THEM BADLY, DEMANDING THEM TO BECOME GREEKS, TO FORGET THEIR LANGUAGE AND ORIGINS, THAT ARE NON-GREEKS. THE WAR OF 1821 WAS AN ANTI-TURKISH WAR, OF COURSE THAT ALSO NON-GREEKS FOUGHT IN IT.
Aromanians ..they speak in Romanian language dialect as my grandparents….tracians brothers of Dacians
😅😅😅😅😅No they are not Romanians
It's Vlach, not Romanian
@@gnas1897Americans, not yankees...😂
@@gnas1897 - Vlachs = Romanians. Stop your Serbo-Bulgarian propaganda and educate yourself.
@@harristheodosis5204 of course. ...cypriots and cretans are not greeks...did you get it?😉
Los rumanos y los moldavos son valacos con país propio.
Si no tuvieran país los llamarían valacos de Rumania y Moldavia.
Los valacos sin país son hermanos de los rumanos y moldavos.
Saludos.
A question . My father a greek cypriot went to the uk in1946. Lived there had children grandchildren and great grandchildren .The great grandchildren only speak english now. ARE THEY english or greek cypriot?
Your question is terribly screwed up.
These people live in Greece and they didn't learn their language from Greeks. It is their language from their ancestors.
They are not Vlachs (Vlachs are further North), they are Machidons/Macedonians and they are not Greek, nor were they ever Greeks.
Alexander the Great and his Macedonians were not Greeks. They were Macedonians and spoke the same language they speak today.
There is lots of documentation on this matter in Antiquity books that survived, and I studied them all.
Greeks today claim that the Macedonians of the past were Greeks, because they want to attach the great history of Macedonians to their own.
Greeks have their great history, there is no need to try to steal Macedonians history, but when people get used to fame, they never have enough of it.
They are English... Language, Religion, Culture are important Not Race..
Και γιατί ο Μέγας Αλέξανδρος είχε Έλληνες δασκαλους , Ελληνική παιδεία, και τα πάντα Ελληνικά????? Τότε υπήρχαν οι πόλεις κράτη, και συχνά αντιμάχονταν! Αυτό δεν τούς αλλάζει την φυλή!!
Είναι πιο λογικό να οικειοποιούνται οι Σκοπιανοί μακεδονική καταγωγή, που δεν δεν έχουν καμία απολύτως σχέση, παρά μόνο ότι κατοικούν σε μέρος της Μακεδονίας???? Τα σημερινά Σκόπια κατοικουνται από ένα χαρμάνι, από σλαβους, βουλγαρους, αλβανους , γύφτους, και Έλληνες ντόπιους, που έμειναν εκεί, μετά που μπήκαν τα σύνορα, α' β' παγκόσμιο . Αυτό το χαρμάνι δεν είναι με κανένα νόμο Μακεδόνες στο σύνολό τους!!!!@@ravenalbj
@@ravenalbjnot mistake with language they speak french English Espanol Italian tourks Persian Arabian so every body happy and χάπι
All the shepherd lifestyle of Saracats and the Vlachs is identical with Romanians 🇷🇴.
Even the music, the dances, the woven carpets, the way they make cheese and butter.
The same you will find in Sardinia, Corsica and Dolomites.
The Vlachs, Romanians and all tye Romance language speakers, did not speak Latin but LaDin, a Semitic language that is the mother of Latin and Ladino, and not the other way around.
aren't Vlachs actually Romanians? Trough their entire history Romanians are called Vlachs
Sure they are related but not identical.
As a roman/vlach ie latin speaking Greek/Romios thank you commentators for informing me that apparently I am Albanian, Serb, Bulgarian, Skopian, Romanian etc apparently my ancestors got their Greek ethnicity wrong because did not have youtubers to correct them.
you are welcomed
@@paulpaustovanu8816 My pleasure pustistonvano
no, actually all Balkans, Europe Africa and Australia are greek, so are the baklava, white cheese, salat, just like Israeli falafel. Apparently no matter what researchers say, or even the people themselves, the greeks will say it is not true. Here is a story for you: When I lived in Atica, all arvanites told me that their grandparents did not speak greek. (of course the rural folks that never had to deal with the administration). Dont take my word, ask them yourself. But the answer of most greeks is"it is not true", and that I am lying.
@@arbenvuthi7103 Ya right but lets assume you are correct, so what? Did the arvanites also tell you why they moved to Greece? Did they also tell you who kikilled and rraaped their women?
@@dggmn2109 ok there we are, your way of discourse is "change the subject and make up crap", We were at the subject of the origin. Now the rape part. Where did you get that. half of Albania is christian. The Arvanites are in their lands buddy. I wander if they know that the "greeks", say about them: "gamoto arvanites mas piran ola ta ikopedha". This I heard from a "greek" that came from Egypt. Precious. You cant make this stuff up.
Vlachs are partially Romanized Pelasgians, forced to declare Greek since the formation of Pindus republic was defeated in 1919. Pelasgians were Proto Indo European Getae people, originated in south Caucasus 6-7,000 years ago.
The "Pindus republic" was an Italian puppet state that enjoyed no popularity among its inhabitants.
We all know that the Aromanians are Latinized Paleo-Balkan populations, Thracians, Illyrians, Greeks, Dacians, Getae, Moesians, etc. But many non Greeks disagree that the Vlachs of the Pindos mountains are of Greek origin. Why?
Can someone explain why?
Because all the world is greek with the difference of those who don't know yet. This is you.....
@@eliasrudi9728
This is not a serious answer to my question.
And anyway, NO, I'm not the one who supports what you said, Victor Hugo does .
"Greece is the contracting World and the World is the expanding Greece" Victor Hugo 26.2.1802 - 22.5.1885.
Because they have been educated to despise anything Greek. (Except for Sirtaki, Bouzouki and Greek salad, to them this is the limit of Greek civilization)
@@gnas1897if they live in tou tourkay you are tourk finish rass only Arabian horses and the donkey kypriots
A venit toamna sh' ploili / fug picurari cu oili ,( fall came with rain, the sheppards run with the sheeps)
Fug diparti pusti munti ( they run away over the mountains)
Same as in Moldavian idiom except "picurari" is "ciobani"( sheepherds)
the most fanatic GREEKS in Greece
I see you have that last name. If you want to appear more greek than the Greeks, it is a different matter, but it doesnt change the historic facts
K oi pio ilithi'oi ..
Arta 🇦🇱 Preveza 🇦🇱 Janina 🇦🇱 Kosturi 🇦🇱 Florina 🇦🇱 Margalleci 🇦🇱 Peloponesi 🇦🇱. Te çlirome Çamerine qe tani! 🇦🇱🦅🦅🦅🦅🦅
Washington, Munich, Cambera, Paris, Oslo, Appolonia, Epidamnos, Tashkent, Peking, Jakarta, Tokyo, Te çlirome Durres, Pogradec qe tani!
Αλβανε Νηστικε Ηλίθιε.Ρωτα τη μάνα σού.
you cant even cross the Calais straight to seek assylum in Britain poor Albo
Hahahaha hahahahaha
Re Malaka Alvane
Vlachs are old Romanians...Romanized Thracians.
Los rumanos y los moldavos son valacos con país propio.
Si no tuvieran país los llamarían valacos de Rumania y Moldavia.
Los valacos sin país son hermanos de los rumanos y moldavos.
Saludos.
Dix minutes dans le documentaire et les erreurs historiques pleuvent. Alexandre le Grand et les Romains n'ont pas bâti l'empire byzantin, les Vlachs étaient dans l'Antiquité des Daco-Getae , partie des peuples Traces.
In public, greeks tear their clothes about how much greek the vlachs are, but in private conversations they claim the opposite. In fact, the greeks consider vlachs to be romanians.
Ya right and Hungarians consider the Romanians gipsies
Iar românii îi considera pe unguri drept Mongolia.. 😅@@dggmn2109
Καστοριά το λένε Βλάκα Αλβανε
@@dggmn2109 You mean the Asian Mongols frame Carpathian Dacian majority as the 3% Indian minority?
@@Sofia-0001 No I mean the Eskimo albanians
Min 21
Romanians are known for carving wood especially in Maramureș region.
Vlachs are related to Romanians.
But they are are formed from the Ladin, the tribe of Dan.
La D_n.
El D_n
Love documentaries when they have sweet little mistakes like the wrong map location of the village, what the name Samarina means and why Samarina is so famous. Latinized Dacians search for Παιδια της Σαμαρινας/Ficiori di Samarina and explain to the Albanians, Slavs and the rest of the world what the song is about.
Absolutely amazing.
Min 14.25
Vârtej 🌀
This is the same as in 🇷🇴 Romania, Maramureș.
But there it is made naturally in the rivers.
We are talking about the same Semitic civilization, the lost tribe of Dan. The Thracians, Dacians then tue Vlachs.
That became the Romanians, Saxons and the Celts.
My grandmother from mother line always said we are Sarakacans understand.Hello my lost brothers of lost holy Roman Empire
I am a Katsanos and my Great Grandfather came from Greece to the US. Sarakatsanoi have been all over Pindos into Thracian and Bulgarian mountain ranges as well .
Same lake in Ucraine mountains we have the people valah willages
The original people of South and Central europe.
Thank you for the information.
Ah comme je me reconnais dans ce peuple!
They are Greeks of the Eastern Roman Empire.
Originaire de turquie, les gens de trabzon en turquie leurs ressemblent énormément ....
They can only tell you what they were told to tell, because their forefathers suffered dearly for claiming their own ethnic identity.
Vlahs and Greeks come from Tracians. That was a people from Boemia to Kazakhstan. People that were there before Greeks. Tracs influenced most of the world, from England to Japan. I see Romanian words in Japanese. I understand some Sanskrit without learning.
Greeks did not came from Tracians.
There are some Romanian words in Japanese, but they got there via China which was formed of Manzi White Race people during Marco Polo's time.
These people are not Vlachs (Vlachs are further North), they are Machidons/Macedonians and they are not Greek, nor were they ever Greeks.
Alexander the Great and his Macedonians were not Greeks. They were Macedonians and spoke the same language they speak today.
There is lots of documentation on this matter in Antiquity books that survived, and I studied them all.
Greeks today claim that the Macedonians of the past were Greeks, because they want to attach the great history of Macedonians to their own.
Greeks have their great history, there is no need to try to steal Macedonians history, but when people get used to fame, they never have enough of it.
@@ravenalbjprobably professor analfabet back to school
Myabe they should migrate to Magadan oblast and set up sheep farming there
Strange views❤❤❤
All Vlahs I know in Greece identify themselves as Greeks. Regardless of... ancient origin, they are hellenized. Some had indeed Romanian national identity (and many of them collaborated with the Nazis in WWII) but they were a minority of Vlahs.
With the Italians, not the Nazis. But they were a minority indeed
May 23 - Happy International Vlachs Day !
What is the paternal haplogroup of the people in this region. Are they mostly EV13 or J2b carriers.
More J2 than EV13, with good amounts of R1b. Low R1a and low I2a.
Actually they are similar to Greeks and Albanians, with a extra Western - Italian Dna.
Not as close genetically to Romanians , as someone would expect.
@@mesimeriaris I suspected they were more prevalent carriers of J2b. Much like the coastal peoples of the Adriatic. Dalmatians etc. The R1b component is leftover Celts who lived in close proximity to the Mediterranean types. Fascinating all the same. EV13 carrier myself.
Very interesting. An ancient people who have been living in Macedonia, all of it. My father was born in Kastoria region but the family left when the Greeks took over after 2nd Balkan War and WW1. But my family is not Vlatsi just neighbors. BTW, his town Smurdech is no longer there just the church bell tower.
Would like to know what people you are talking about ?? My family are all from the area between Kastoria and Florina. My ancestors, on my Fathers & Mothers side, have never changed their surnames and they are engraved on tombstones and Church logs of Births and Baptisms dating back hundreds of years. They are completely Greek in name, so we know we have never left those areas. There were many races of people who fought against Greek people, when Greeks finally banded together for Independence (aligned with Vlachs & Arvanite), and took back their ancient ancestral lands. Those people who betrayed or fought against the Greeks were sent packing. We continue to excavate Ancient archaeological sites and find only Hellenic (and some Latin) inscriptions - not other languages.
S'bâneadză Armânamea!
You missed what is the most .important . MOSKOPOLE. The second biggest city in Balkans. Destroyed by albanian Muslims in few waves. Last they attacked in 1994. That is 20th century.
From my observations these people sound Greek yet look somewhat different to the Greeks.
Ya they have three legs and one hand.
@@dggmn2109 Without disparaging the Romany communities. Did the Gypsies also have settlements up there in the mountains.
@@dggmn2109 At least they are not like Allah, who would have two right hands. Read the Qur'an.
They do not sound Greek at all. You Must be American, because Americans are not exposed to foreign languages, and are limited in the ability of identifying other languages.
They are not Vlachs (Vlachs are further North), they are Machidons/Macedonians and they are not Greek, nor were they ever Greeks.
Alexander the Great and his Macedonians were not Greeks. They were Macedonians and spoke the same language they speak today.
There is lots of documentation on this matter in Antiquity books that survived, and I studied them all.
Greeks today claim that the Macedonians of the past were Greeks, because they want to attach the great history of Macedonians to their own.
Greeks have their great history, there is no need to try to steal Macedonians history, but when people get used to fame, they never have enough of it.
@@ravenalbj As you are a slav first explain to us what the words Macedonian, Alexander, Philip etc mean in your slavic language and next worry if the Macedonians are Greek or not.
The origins of the aromanians and the history of there language is very incomplete in this documentary. Not mentioning about the fact that they speak a dialect of the🇷🇴romanian language and they even call themselves aromanians is like missing the core of the history of thise people and there language.
There language- aromanian- is first of all very similar to romanian🇷🇴.both of them are romance languages.
🇬🇷🇷🇴
Very false to say that they speak latin tongue. They speak a romance language (derived from latin;dialect of romanian). There language is romance, just as french, italian and there mother tongue romanian🇷🇴.
PS: The valachs/aromanians ar not specific just to Greece. Aromanian/valach comunities can be foud in Albania, North Macedonia and Bulgaria. You cannot call them latin greeks because they do not belong just to Greece.
Aromanians are Greeks speakers of a latin dialect with a lot of Greek words included! 🇬🇷🇬🇷🇬🇷🇬🇷🇬🇷🇬🇷🇬🇷
Greeks are also pelasgians/Thracians mixed with the Phoenicians traders and Indo-European warriors who changed the old pelasgians culture of peace and freedom with the semitic culture of trading , authority and slavery.
@@ionelghiorghita688 Keep dreaming that the whole world is Albanian. You are a Creole nation with a language consisted of Greek, Latin, Turkish, Slavic and less than 10% paleobalkanic origin words mostly of Thracian and Not of Illyrian origin.
Show me Illyrian inscriptions?Show me Illyrian temples?show me Illyrian theatres?Show me Illyrian sculptures?Show me Illyrians mosaics?Show me Illyrians stadiums?Show me Illyrian epigraphs? Tell me names of Illyrians philosophers? Tell me names of ancient Illyrian athletes in the ancient Olympic Games? Show me the seven Illyrian wonders of the ancient world? Where are the Illyrian ancient libraries??? Where are the ancient Illyrians colonies in Asia,Spain,south France,al all around black sea, the Levante, Syria, etc? Till you find them, hide in your cave 🤫🤫
I repeat that 90% of your vocabulary is actually Greek,Latin, Slavic, Turkish, English and less than 20% of paleobalkanic origin. There are glossologists who made that research and is scientifically accepted. Except few toponyms and words of messapic or Illyrian origin which don't consist more than 5% the rest 5% is of mainly Thracian, Celtic origin words. Even the word Gomar is coming from the Greek language, even the word autochthonous is coming from the Greek language, even the word harta is coming from the Greek language. What you don't want to accept????
No serious historian, actually No-one teaching in any university around the world accepts this Albanian-Illyrian history. The origin of the albanians remains a "mystery" and the most possible scenario is that they are a CREOLE nation. Residuals of Romans, Greeks, Thracians, few Illyrians,Celts etc who escaped latinisation and Greekification cause of their isolation in the harsh area of modern day North Albania.
Show me your Illyrian theatres, Illyrian temples, any Illyrian mosaics, etc Nothing to show me except very few Illyrian artifacts heavily Hellenized. You can try hard to prove that you are straight descendants of the ancient Illyrians just because they lived in the same geographical area but the same can do the Bosniaks or the Croats or the Slovenians or even the Serbs. Almost all of the artifacts you have in your museums are of Greek or Roman origin. Just go to the museum of Durres and see by your own eyes. The Skopians tried to say to the world that they are the descendants of ancient Macedonians but they failed. You are in the same category. Please continue to expose yourselfs with your pseydo-Glossology and pseudo-history theories and make the whole world laugh at you even more!
Illyrian was part of the Indo-European language family. Its relation to other Indo-European languages, ancient and modern, is poorly understood because of the paucity of data and because it is still being examined. Today, the main source of authoritative information about Illyrian consists of a handful of Illyrian words cited in classical sources and numerous examples of Illyrian anthroponyms, ethnonyms, toponyms and hydronyms. The scarcity of the data makes it difficult to identify the sound changes that have taken place in Illyrian; the most widely accepted one is that the Indo-European voiced aspirates /bʰ/, /dʰ/, /ɡʰ/ became voiced consonants /b/, /d/, /ɡ/.
Recent scholarship from the 1960s and on tends to agree that the region inhabited by Illyrian tribes can be divided into three distinct linguistic and cultural areas, of which only one can be properly termed "Illyrian".
No written texts regarding self-identification exist from the Illyrians and no inscriptions in Illyrian exist, with the only linguistic remains being place names (toponyms) and some glosses.
@@ionelghiorghita688 Lexican borrowing are responsible for as much as ninety percent of the Albanian vocabulary. Especially from Greek and Latin!
Examples:
Zemër with the meaning of 'centre of the day', or from the same root of Greek ημέρα (iméra, “day”), although the initial anlaut z- remains unexplained. A borrowing from Greek διήμερον (diímeron, “period of twenty-four hours”) is not excluded.
Mellan: from Greek μελάνι (meláni).
Kapister: from Greek καπίστρι (kapístri)
Barkë: borrowed from Greek βάρκα (várka)
Merimange: First attested as mrīmagë; borrowed from Greek μυρμήγκι (myrmígki, “ant”).
According to Kristofordhi and Mihăescu, a borrowing from Doric Greek μύρμαξ (múrmax)
Laparos: from Greek λαπαρός (laparós)
Gomar: inherited from Byzantine Greek γομάρι(ν) (gomári(n)), from Koine Greek γομάριον (gomárion, “load of an animal”), derived from Ancient Greek γόμος (gómos, “load, weight”).
Gjyp: from Ancient Greek γύψ (gúps), compare Greek γύπας (gýpas)
Avlli: from Ancient Greek αὐλή (aulḗ)
Gamë: from Ancient Greek γάμμα (gámma).
Bagëm: from Ancient Greek βάπτισμα (báptisma), internally corrupted or affected by another word, possibly bekoj (“I bless”).
I can continue till tomorrow.......
Learn real history. You are a CREOLE nation. You are the residuals of Greeks,Romans,Slavs,Turks and few paleobalkanic people just isolated in the mountains of modern albania and created a Creole new nation through centuries. This Illyrian albanian connection theory lacks basic elements. It's just a pro Albanian hypothesis which is not widely supported by non albanian academics and historians. You pathetically trying to create your identity cause you are jealous of your Greek and Italian neighbours. You are the same as the Skopians who miserably tried to claim that they were the real descendants of the ancient Macedonians but failed miserably. Lol 🤣
I repeat that 90% of your vocabulary is actually Greek,Latin, Slavic, Turkish, English and less than 10% of paleobalkanic origin. There are glossologists who made that research and is scientifically accepted. Except few toponyms and words of messapic or Illyrian origin which don't consist more than 5% the rest 5% is of mainly Thracian, Celtic origin words. Even the word Gomar is coming from the Greek language, even the word autochthonous is coming from the Greek language, even the word harta is coming from the Greek language. What you don't want to accept????
No serious historian, actually No-one teaching in any university around the world accepts this Albanian-Illyrian history. The origin of the albanians remains a "mystery" and the most possible scenario is that they are a CREOLE nation. Residuals of Romans, Greeks, Thracians, few Illyrians,Celts etc who escaped latinisation and Greekification cause of their isolation in the harsh area of modern day North Albania.
Show me your Illyrian theatres, Illyrian temples, any Illyrian mosaics, etc Nothing to show me except very few Illyrian artifacts heavily Hellenized. You can try hard to prove that you are straight descendants of the ancient Illyrians just because they lived in the same geographical area but the same can do the Bosniaks or the Croats or the Slovenians or even the Serbs. The Skopians tried to say to the world that they are the descendants of ancient Macedonians but they failed. You are in the same category. Please make people laugh with you.
Illyrian was part of the Indo-European language family. Its relation to other Indo-European languages, ancient and modern, is poorly understood because of the paucity of data and because it is still being examined. Today, the main source of authoritative information about Illyrian consists of a handful of Illyrian words cited in classical sources and numerous examples of Illyrian anthroponyms, ethnonyms, toponyms and hydronyms. The scarcity of the data makes it difficult to identify the sound changes that have taken place in Illyrian; the most widely accepted one is that the Indo-European voiced aspirates /bʰ/, /dʰ/, /ɡʰ/ became voiced consonants /b/, /d/, /ɡ/.
Recent scholarship from the 1960s and on tends to agree that the region inhabited by Illyrian tribes can be divided into three distinct linguistic and cultural areas, of which only one can be properly termed "Illyrian".
No written texts regarding self-identification exist from the Illyrians and no inscriptions in Illyrian exist, with the only linguistic remains being place names (toponyms) and some glosses.
All of south and coastal Albania is Greek!
Above only few of the ancient Greek cities founded by Greek settlers in Albania: 1)Berat=Antipatrea
2)Dropull=Dryinopolis or Dropolis
3)Durres=Epidamnus
4)Butrint=Buthroton
5)Sarande=Onchesmus
6)Argyrokastron=Silver castle
7)Pojani=Apollonia
8)Vlore=Aulon
9)Finiq=Phoenice
10)Korce=Pelion
11)Lezhe=Lissus
12)Shengjin=Nymphaion
13)Himara=Himare
14)Antigone=Antigona 15)Ploc=Amantia=Abantia
16)Oriku=ancient Greek Oricon and many more smaller settlements.
17)Ksamil=Eksamili
18)Kolonje=Koloneia
19)Devoll=Deapolis
20)Peshkopi=Episkope (The name of Peshkopi is derived from the word peshkop meaning bishop in Albanian and from Episkopè in Greek.)
21)Këlcyrë=Kleisourai
22)Nicea
23)Pelion=ancient Greek City near Cangonj Pass
The word kleisoúra (Medieval Greek: κλεισοῦρα) was eventually borrowed by all Balkan peoples, becoming the root of several place-names.
😊🤫🇬🇷🇬🇷
All of the south Albanians have more than 40% Greek DNA coming from albanised northern Epirotan Greeks. Close your mouth now you Albanian shepperd 🤡🐏 🐏
Where did you get this information.Greek language was before the Latin.Latin came after the Greek.Romans got their alphabet from the Etruscans and Etruscans from Cumean Greeks.
@@ermioniburgess8720 I know that, just wrong typing. I meant they are Greeks who speak a Latin dialect with a lot of Greek words included
No está doblado al español, 🤷
Indoctrination that Romance speaking east Romans of Balkans are somehow.. Greeks.
Étymologie.
Ελληνική Δωρική διάλεκτος "βλᾱχά," =Grec Doric dialekt '"vlaha" = bêler
En grec moderne βλάχος-βλάχα =vlachos-vlacha
Tribu Dorique du Pinde.
Ils parlaient un dialecte latin comme les Aroumains.
L'étymologie de l'allemand "Walachen " n'est pas correcte puisque les Allemands définissaient les Celtes, Wells,Welsch par le nom "Walachen ".
Vlach = Pelag
The Greek nationalist etymologist is here.
@@giorgiodifrancesco4590 Funny thing is that other 28-30 million Vlachs don't know any sort of Greek, but they share a similar language and a large common vocabulary with the few Vlachs of south Balkans left, after thorough assimilation by the Greeks, Albanians, and south Slavs. Should have a real thick face to call that a Greek language.
@@Sofia-0001
What do you mean? That all the Latinized populations of various Balkan nations became... a new nation?😀
Aromanians are not a nation.They are different nations,( Thracians, Greeks, Illyrians, Dacians, Celts, Getae) , Latinized.
@@giorgiodifrancesco4590
LIDDELL & SCOTT Dictionary of the Ancient Greek Language.
Ιων:βληχή, Δωρ: βλᾱχά, ἡ, βέλασμα· οἰῶν, σε Ομήρ. Οδ.· το κλάμα των παιδιών (νηπίων), σε Ευριπίδης. (ηχομιμ. λέξη).
Ionic:Vleche, Doric : Vlacha, the , bleat by sheep in Homer. Od.; the cry of children (infants), in Euripides. (phonemic word).
Ils embrassent la main comme chez nous en turquie 😂
Not even sub titles. 🥲
Keta Jan shqiptar
48.37
Romanian Hora
Also the revived Jewish dance
Now you understand, WE ARE OF SEMITIC ORIGINS in Europe.
Coming from Thracians, Sarmatiabs and Dacians. In fact from Samaritans of Samaria ancient-culture Israel. The lost tribes of Israel. The lots tribe of Dan.
It is the other way around.
Semitic people didn't exist. The Hebrew people originated on Hebron River in Thracia called Maritsa today.
Les meijeurs grecs sont les valaques car ils sont les plus grands donnateurs de l etat et de la nation grecque...
Vlachs exist in Greece, if not always, at least 1000 years. They consider themselves greek , they were great patriots and benefactors of the greek state , they participated in all wars and national fights and in WW2 they participated in the resistance and rejected the nazi and romanian propaganda and ostracized a few vlach collaborators who expected benefits and power. This is the exact truth. All the other is malevolent propaganda of suspicious motivation!!! Even in albania , skopje and elsewhere in balkans vlachs were asking to be registered as greeks!!!
If so, very sad for you to find out that the linguists are considering them romanians and not due to them language but also due to their habits, culture, traditions...
@@ionelghiorghita688Language resembles to ancient latin but habits, customs and traditions are almost identical to those of their neighbours. Regarding musik especially their songs are exactly the same but with lyrics in their idiom.
@@odysseasntalias5950 sorry, what I meant is that the Latin is actually the old Thracians/Getae language spoken all along the south and Central europe due to the Anatolian Balcanic and Carpathian (including West of Ukraine) migrations.
Vlachs are great patriots of the state they live in. They are great Greeks or great Albanians or great North-Macedonians. They were great Turks, too : )
Should no national border exist and no pressure from a majority - they would be glad to be just great Vlachs.
I speak as a latin speaking aroman/roman/greek the only difference between me and a Greek speaking romios/roman/Greek is that the romios/Greek kept the Greek language whereas the aroman/Greek used Latin as well both we are Greek in every shape and form. Romanians are latinised Dacians to say that Latin speaking Greeks are Romanians is like saying that navajo Indians are the same as Australians because both speak english.
Golden dawn has really brainwashed you hard 🤣
@@southepirote7676 ya like albanians are brainwashed to believe that Dures and pogradec and apolonia etc are albanian cities that happen to have Greek and slav names.
@@southepirote7676 turko albanian muslim you can not hide
@@dggmn2109 Chech historical documents and find out that Durres, Duraci was all the time in history, until 19 century, a majority Orthodox Vlach port. They had nothing to do with Greeks.
@@Sofia-0001 I know that the port of dures was inhabited by Aroman/Roman/Vlach/Greeks why do you think we gave a Greek name to the city of Dures to Moscopole/Voscopole etc?
28.30
The traditional clothing is very Semitic.
No. It is simply very medieval byzantine (with turkish successive influences).
Not even close
Od course Macedonia was involved in Geeek history, they were Hellenes and Alexander the Great united all the Greek states
So I suppose Wallonians living in France, the Romanch people living in Switzerland,Welsh of UK and Walloons in Belgium are Romanians too? Of course not. All these people and Vlachs/Aromanians of Greece are the old inhabitants of their lands respictively before the waves of germanic/slavic/avars etc tribes arrive. Why the creators of the "documenary" did not ask the Vlachs if they self-identify as greeks? Let me tell you why: because it does not fit into their propaganda, since all the vlachs of Greece (yes, there are Vlachs in other parts of Greece too even if they did not speak aromanian) fought and died during the centuries defending greek nation in EVERY SINGLE war. This is not a documentary.It is an identity attack that insults us Vlachs.
They are clearly Lithunians
Good point but I think they are navajo Indians
@@dggmn2109 could be, amongst the blue eyed people I saw some dark skin faces as well...good point, thanks for mentioning
@@nikravdos5723 no worries
lol They speak east Romance, like Romanians, you funny guys.
@@Sofia-0001 yeah clearly Lithuania Romanians from Laponia
They left beautiful built homes and live in garbage built apartments.
Very sad
They thought they would find better life but look at all the cities are becoming dumps.
They are orthodox christians they are Greeks
Orthodoxy was adopted in 451 AD by the Latin Roman empire, specifically against the Monophysite Greeks. Greeks adopted Orthodoxy in 682 AD, after many Orthodox martyrs, specially during Monophysite Heraclid dynasty.
@@Sofia-0001 Greece is the motherland of Orthodox Christianity to which the teaching of Christianity was directly transferred by the apostles of Jesus
@@chrisapost5409 Forget this crap lies, Orthodoxy was implemented in the Roman empire at the Council of Calchedon, in 451 AD, by the Pope Leo I and empress Pulcheria, expressly AGAINST the Monophysite Greeks, led by then ex empress Eudokia, of Greek ethnicity. Was Roman Constantinople and Rome against Greek Alexandria and Antioch, demoted from equal status after that ecumenical council. Moreover the Orthodox suffererd dearly when the Monophysite Greeks came to power in 610 AD and between the Orthodox martylrs were Pope Martin and one of the most prolific Orthodox theologians Maxim the Confessor. The Greeks accepted Orthodoxy only after the mostly Greek regions of north west Africa and costal Levant fell to Arabs and the majority population left in the Balkans and around Constantinople were Orthodox Romans. That was the 4th ecumenical council in Constantinople, in 682 AD. Meanwhile most LATIN Romans were Orthodox since 451 AD.
@@chrisapost5409Just because of the writing habit. Otherwise there are hundreds of years older Christians churches in the Carpathian mountains caves.
Those are Serbs
Serbs? Ha ha, they are vlachs, they are like romanians. They speak a neo-latin language not a slavic one.
Ooooooomg you again?🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@e.h97 not albanian bot
@@lyssilvertongue you wish
@@e.h97 hello Berber
Ils ressemblent aux turks de karadeniz(trabzon,rize....)
You hear in the vid ""hai"". Any Romanian would understand this. Come, let's go. From the Hebrew ""haia"". If I tell you that Sanskrit is part Hebrew, part Greek,part Romanian, I'm sure you cannot process the information.
Studying is no longer needed. Just go to any Greek or Romanian and oops....
"hai" is short for "haide" which is used all over Balkans
Sembra certa gente dell' interno della Barbagia
Perché sono pastori e hanno costumi bizantini. Infatti, la Sardegna è stata persa nominalmente da Bisanzio molto tardi.
😳😳🌸
One third of the population in Greece are turks,one third are gypsys,and one third are albanians(not the forced workers).
Greeks invented the wheelbarrow and the Albanians supplied the power to use it.
There is another 1/3,they are payed gay troll as you
Ένα τρολ του κερατά είσαι, και μάλιστα χωρίς ταλέντο, ακόμα και το τρολάρισμα θέλει την ικανότητά του την οποία δεν κατέχεις
I am sure the Greeks love your classification!!!
Τι λες βρε μαλάκα;
Latin speaking Roman Greeks. How can they be Greeks if they speak Latin. It's nonsensical. For me they're a Thracian people who adopted Latin and became remnants of the Roman empire. They are not Greeks. Today maybe so as they've been incorporated into the Greek State and society.
Their origins were not originally Greek no, but today they are. Over many generations they married into Greek families. They are now mostly Greek in their DNA.
Ελλαδάρα Παντού 🇬🇷
D'ailleur ils exprime en Grec pas en Aroman
With the interviewer they speak greak. Between them, I hear them speaking aromanian.
It seems that when the Roman Empire collapsed these people the Vlachis or most of them held their positions up on the mountains with their families and herds every five miles apart each family to serve the Romans it was the fastest way for passing messages along the Empire and being a watching dog The Vlachis who happened to be on the Greek land spoke Greek and Latin the ones who watched the Roumanian border spoke Greek and Latin that went on through different countries. nevertheless, all of them have Greek roots Kαι οπου φυσα ο ανεμος Αγαπαμε τους βλαχους μας
Free to dream but a jewish business as the Greek identity build up to the pelasgians and Thracian citizens culture and language is just ome of the biggest fake of the history promoted by the Jews as convenient being part of them culture and actions in the long way of Europe and finally world hegemony.
Nesun grec nete pa latinize on Balkan.Le Valah șont de rumen.Dans lor long lor s''apel Aromanian Sulmont le naționalist grek afirm che son grek latinize On tot la Balkanle vlache la nom de population latin.La vlach șont ossi în Macedonia ,Albania Bulgaria Serbia .Valach egal roman e non berger com dis le Grek !
Yeah, they are latinized Albanians eventually assimilated to Greek by the oppressive right wing Greek government led by Miqotaki
They are VLACHS with GREEK consciousness. So they are Greek people. Cry more about it. Samarina is a greek village of Grevena. My one origin is from Grevena too from a village which is called Monachiti.
@@derdaslolI am vlach from Albania and we came from voskopoli
No they are angisized Chinese from North pole
@@topg4717tsi fatsi frate eu hiou di ameru
Albanian junk
Kasturi et non kostoria..Les Albanais expoulsse par les grecs...Haxhisemalis...Il parler Albanais et vous devez dire.. Arrête de manipuler l histoire...
Εισαι βλακας ? Αντε γαμισου εσυ και η αλβανια . Για την βορειο ηπειρο ?
je suis cincar de cote de mon ariere grand pere mais d'ou je ne sais pas
l'isoire est deja manipule depuis long temps pas maintenant
@@miodragjordacijevic4525 Να ρωτησης την μητερα σου , ποιος ειναι ο μπαμπα σου . Βλακα αλβανε
Les meilleirs grecs de la Crece moderne etaient des Donnateurs Valaques .La langue ne donne pas la nationalite , les francophone Africans ne son't pas des francais .Arrettez dire des betises surtout ceux des pays voisins qui veulemt voler par l histoire glorieuse de la Grece que tour le monde admire!
qui n ont aucune histoire culturelle
Cette massacre de moutons est horrible, atroce, barbare.
Ma's pour la Paque tu ne mange pa's l agnieau.?
@@dimitriosvlissides5781 Les cadavres, mangez-les vous-mêmes!
No way to keep all the males. Would be a big fight and finally a world of the sheeps.
They are albanian.
The old man in 27:28 disagrees with you
🤣
can you stop trolling and accept how little you are inside historical time.
In every video about balkans an albanian will "pop up like a fart" and start spreading the nonsense he learned from albanian tiktok scholars.... You forgot to write that jesus, Aristotle, Alexander the great, Julius Caesar, Napoleon , Einstein etc are albanians. So ridiculous sqiptar 😅😅😅😅
Ya they are albanian like the eskimos
Orthodox Christianity is Judeo Christianity.
Now you understand why.
It was developed by the lost tribes of Israel with Moses law worship 🛐 traditions
They are not Vlachs (Vlachs are further North), they are Machidons/Macedonians and they are not Greek, nor were they ever Greeks.
Alexander the Great and his Macedonians were not Greeks. They were Macedonians and spoke the same language they speak today.
There is lots of documentation on this matter in Antiquity books that survived, and I studied them all.
Greeks today claim that the Macedonians of the past were Greeks, because they want to attach the great history of Macedonians to their own.
Greeks have their great history, there is no need to try to steal Macedonians history, but when people get used to fame, they never have enough of it.
Is that why Alexander taught greek language and culture everywhere he went . And all of Asia and India had hellenism. And India. In India there was 7 greek kings after the he's death . Ptolemy he's general spread greek culture in Egypt. All the world knows that what did they teach you at school .You are the ones that stealing history. The now north Macedonians are a mix of slavs Bulgarians albanians and turks
What do You know about Macedonians? 🤣
@@davidaxelos4678 I know about the Macedonians and the Greeks, and Romans, more than anyone else on earth.
I studied all the antiquity books that survived and are translated in English. Nobody else on earth did that.
@@ravenalbj And sooo little did You understand?
Don't You think Macedonian is a West Bulgarian dialect?
Change your medication you narcissistic pseudo makedonian scientist. You ridicule yourself and real science with your obsession....
La langue rassemble à l’albanais et non latin…la danse par les mains,les vêtements traditionnels ( fustanella ) sont toute albanais….ARVANITIS comment appel les grecs…
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fustanella
You are a complete ignorant. Study about there language before posting. They are valachs/ aromanians. They speak a very similar dialect to 🇷🇴romanian. Romanian is a romance language, just as italian and spanish.