Just because you didn't understand a narrative doesn't mean it wasn't there. Fantano's fans are literal cancer lmao Yes, bozo. It WAS indeed that deep.
And just because a narrative is there, doesn't mean it's good or executed well. The entire point he was trying to make with the album is summarised by one song: guilty conscience 2, which essentially renders everything before it pointless filler layered in a lot of satire and irony. It doesn't help that he placed that song so far thru the tracklist You'll be too turned off by the first half to stay for the second due to the annoying Bruce Jenner, PC police, gen z and Chris Reeves references. Here's the thing, we get the concept, it just isn't a great one. Plus it's something he has ALREADY done before in Relapse's My Darling. I did enjoy a couple singular tracks like Fuel and Lucifer but overall he falls short in a lot of aspects. It's worth noting that it's far more cohesive than anything since revival but it's just simply lacking a lot content wise. I'd much prefer shorter projects by him with 7-8 great songs than a large 19 track cinematic piece with skits, lows, highs and the worst, mids.
@@raedewav Honestly I don't disagree. You could remove brand new dance, lucifer from the first half and barely notice a change in the album. Infact if anything, it would make the album better. The first half of the album was weak, tho it was building up to Guilty Conscience 2, it didn't live upto what it set out to be. I get that and it's not a perfect album, my gripe is with Fantano because his assessments on Em's albums and songs and always odd. He seems to disregard the technicals and narratives altogether because of his subconscious bias against newer Em. This video isn't much defense of Em's new album as is criticism of Melon. Hope that clears it up
I was waiting for this video bro, he is so out of touch! He says Eminem is cringe but fantano makes his videos fully edited to get attention because he’s so boring so he tries to act goofy. Fantano is all cringe himself and you can see it in his livestreams. He’s in his 40s but judges Eminem? Makes no sense.
i would definitely disagree in the sense that anthony isn’t a hip hop head or a hip hop/ rap fan, its probably one of his favorite genres. just because he listens to a lot of genres doesn’t mean he’s not invested in rap or hip hop. He only has like five or six ten out of tens, and three of them are rap/hip hop (TPAB, The money store, and Kids see ghosts) But i do definitely agree with his fanbase being absolutely miserable for the most part, especially his twitch chat
The issue is that right wingers will listen to his boomer "anti-woke" lyrics and just Bob their heads. Em isn't being offensive, he's saying the same shit all conservatives celeberties have been saying for years, regardless if he actually believes it or not. He's not being edgy, he's not pushing boundaries, he's not making any worthwhile point. He's just pissing and shitting himself, making that his personality and making low iq conservatives feel vindicated
This video is well made, I’m tired of fantano fans trying to shift the Eminem narrative, kamikaze was beloved by everyone except fantano fans, so was MTBMB, but because half the music review genre is fantano fans, they keep pushing the narrative of “everyone hates this” when it’s objectively untrue
I agree, though Fantano gave mtbmb a somewhat ok review. It got a 5. If I were to review that album I'd also give it a 6 maybe but Kamikaze.. and side B or mtbmb.. I still don't understand what Melon rate those a 2 and 3
@@bobdekoe i won't say the ones I will list out are "impersonators" but JID, Kendrick and Cole along with many others, like Babytron or Big sean are all also inspired by Eminem in their careers
@@MFxDANZO lol i couldnt give a damn If an Artist is "better" or took an "L" or "W" with their Album. Who Cares? I don't Like Drama, i don't Like all the stuff around music that people Care too much for. I Just Wanna hear some good music. And for me personally, i struggled to enjoy eminems latest few Albums. That's my loss, Not yours. If you Love it cool! More Power to you! Live and Let live Brother :)
the description is hilarious. Wow, he judges music on listenability? Like whether it's enjoyable to listen to? what a crazy way to talk about music. by talking about whether listening to it is enjoyable
I disagree with his points, but I think it was a mediocre album 1. Eminem while purposely trying to make lines cringey, they made the complex lines surrounding them worse 2. The production on certain beats were bad (Brand New Dance was the track for me) 3. Certain parts of tracks were terrible (Antichrists chorus was annoying) I did enjoy most of the features and the fact that it is reversible is great, the fact that I just don’t like half of the album makes me sad with this record
Ive seen him go crazy over a trash song by ez mil or tom macdonald, cant remember who it was. He probably likes em on the low, but its not "cool". Also dude prob cares way too much about politics. Hes never going to hate on kendrick, for example, that wouldnt do him any good and he knows most people (and culture) rock with him too much. Fantano thinks hes so smart and nobody understands that hes unbiased and bla bla.. dude is much more simpler than he thinks he is, just takes the right person. And I think most stans even dont get who he really is, they just think hes a hater
I don't think Fantano is a hater. I think he has biases subconsciously that he's not aware about himself, ofcourse because of not just politics but also other stuff
Bro is living rent free in all his haters heads. lmao imagine being so vexed just from some dudes opinion. It isn't that deep, why can't people understand that?
@@Jitterz_official Because every time he has an opinion, people seem to be livid, regardless of whether or not it's positive. If he says something great about, lets say Kanye, people will get angry that he's supporting his actions, but, since he's went against him, people are still outraged. The dude can't win lol. People need to relax. If those same people that critize him were in his position, they'd give in to peer pressure and try to appease everyone. Anthony stays true to his opinion, and he's able to defend himself very well in debates against others. I've disagreed with his opinions before, like many, but I can see that his opinion has a lot of value because of how level headed he is.
@@Carzey yeah for sure that does happen and all but my guy pretty much blindly hates on ems stuff just for the sole reason that it's em. I'm a musician and quite frankly, it's super disrespectful to write off an artist just because that artist is who he is. Like imagine blind listening to a concept album and just going "meh" "cringe" "blah blah blah" when literally the entire point of said concept is to highlight the meh and the cringe yk? I like anthony and all but his liberal views cloud his judgment on music and to be quite honest i completely get why people get upset with him cause imagine you go to a guy who's supposed to be a critic but all he does is call something cringe and meh which is ironic cause the second em dissed candace ownes fantano laughed his ass off lmao so he does find the style funny but only when it fits his narrative
Fantano is one of the most notorious music critics on the internet. He has influence on people’s opinions and as a result he has a responsibility to make informed and substantiated reviews. If he doesn’t uphold this standard, he is allowed to be criticised. If he doesn’t want to be criticised, he shouldn’t have said it. Whether he stands on what he said or he goes back on it is entirely his decision
He did a Livestream reacting to it and even before starting he was hating and making fun of em he went into it with the most negative mindset and he didn't understand the concept at all
Just because you didn't understand a narrative doesn't mean it wasn't there. Fantano's fans are literal cancer lmao
Yes, bozo. It WAS indeed that deep.
@@Hembygden_i_Skaneget help
Hahahahahhaha I just looked at your picture. Have a nice life 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
And just because a narrative is there, doesn't mean it's good or executed well.
The entire point he was trying to make with the album is summarised by one song: guilty conscience 2, which essentially renders everything before it pointless filler layered in a lot of satire and irony. It doesn't help that he placed that song so far thru the tracklist
You'll be too turned off by the first half to stay for the second due to the annoying Bruce Jenner, PC police, gen z and Chris Reeves references.
Here's the thing, we get the concept, it just isn't a great one. Plus it's something he has ALREADY done before in Relapse's My Darling.
I did enjoy a couple singular tracks like Fuel and Lucifer but overall he falls short in a lot of aspects. It's worth noting that it's far more cohesive than anything since revival but it's just simply lacking a lot content wise. I'd much prefer shorter projects by him with 7-8 great songs than a large 19 track cinematic piece with skits, lows, highs and the worst, mids.
@@raedewav Honestly I don't disagree. You could remove brand new dance, lucifer from the first half and barely notice a change in the album. Infact if anything, it would make the album better. The first half of the album was weak, tho it was building up to Guilty Conscience 2, it didn't live upto what it set out to be. I get that and it's not a perfect album, my gripe is with Fantano because his assessments on Em's albums and songs and always odd. He seems to disregard the technicals and narratives altogether because of his subconscious bias against newer Em. This video isn't much defense of Em's new album as is criticism of Melon. Hope that clears it up
I was waiting for this video bro, he is so out of touch! He says Eminem is cringe but fantano makes his videos fully edited to get attention because he’s so boring so he tries to act goofy. Fantano is all cringe himself and you can see it in his livestreams. He’s in his 40s but judges Eminem? Makes no sense.
i would definitely disagree in the sense that anthony isn’t a hip hop head or a hip hop/ rap fan, its probably one of his favorite genres. just because he listens to a lot of genres doesn’t mean he’s not invested in rap or hip hop. He only has like five or six ten out of tens, and three of them are rap/hip hop (TPAB, The money store, and Kids see ghosts) But i do definitely agree with his fanbase being absolutely miserable for the most part, especially his twitch chat
eminem is not a right winger, do no confuse his character slim shady with Marshall mathers
Yes absolutely. Even in this album, shady too takes shots at Candance Owens and Maga and the right wing
@@dontlook-atus im talking about the 'anti woke' message. shady is a character your not supposed to see as a good person
The issue is that right wingers will listen to his boomer "anti-woke" lyrics and just Bob their heads. Em isn't being offensive, he's saying the same shit all conservatives celeberties have been saying for years, regardless if he actually believes it or not. He's not being edgy, he's not pushing boundaries, he's not making any worthwhile point. He's just pissing and shitting himself, making that his personality and making low iq conservatives feel vindicated
Saying things for the sake of offending ppl and then hiding behind 'oh it was just a character' is lazy and just ruins the entire album.
@@mrfancyshmancybro is acting like Marshall just creating slim for this album and hasn't been doing this his whole career
If the album was called “The Death of Sexxy” it would’ve gotten a ten
What do you mean
@@JustFollowingOrders12 anthony fantano gave a sexyy red album an 8/10 so people think he's a sexyy red glazer
This video is well made, I’m tired of fantano fans trying to shift the Eminem narrative, kamikaze was beloved by everyone except fantano fans, so was MTBMB, but because half the music review genre is fantano fans, they keep pushing the narrative of “everyone hates this” when it’s objectively untrue
I agree, though Fantano gave mtbmb a somewhat ok review. It got a 5. If I were to review that album I'd also give it a 6 maybe but Kamikaze.. and side B or mtbmb.. I still don't understand what Melon rate those a 2 and 3
He criticizes Em but he claps for the Em impersonators. It's so funny to watch.
Lmao exactly. It is always funny to see
idk man he hates on joyner, logic, hopsin, NF
which eminem impersonators does he clap for? I can’t think of any
@@bobdekoe i won't say the ones I will list out are "impersonators" but JID, Kendrick and Cole along with many others, like Babytron or Big sean are all also inspired by Eminem in their careers
I respect your opinion but disagree on that take. I think Fantano's reviews were based on points I agree with for the most part.
You are a mark i dont expect anything less from you especially when you go in head first with hate rather than understanding the concept of an album.
@@MFxDANZO chill, he's just stating his opinion. I disagree with him too, no need to rush in Guns blazing
@@dontlook-atus 😂 I just despise bias, buddy probably thinks futures better
@@MFxDANZO lol i couldnt give a damn If an Artist is "better" or took an "L" or "W" with their Album. Who Cares? I don't Like Drama, i don't Like all the stuff around music that people Care too much for. I Just Wanna hear some good music. And for me personally, i struggled to enjoy eminems latest few Albums. That's my loss, Not yours. If you Love it cool! More Power to you! Live and Let live Brother :)
Fantano is a dork. Only sheep care about his opinions.
the description is hilarious. Wow, he judges music on listenability? Like whether it's enjoyable to listen to? what a crazy way to talk about music. by talking about whether listening to it is enjoyable
If that was the only criteria to judge music, everyone would be playing jazz
I cant take fantano seriously his takes are usually horrible he's not a true hip hop fan that's just facts.
Not all his takes are bad, but he's just biased subconsciously against some bigger artists
eminem is literally infamous for having a fanbase of people who don't like any other hip hop
I disagree with his points, but I think it was a mediocre album
1. Eminem while purposely trying to make lines cringey, they made the complex lines surrounding them worse
2. The production on certain beats were bad (Brand New Dance was the track for me)
3. Certain parts of tracks were terrible (Antichrists chorus was annoying)
I did enjoy most of the features and the fact that it is reversible is great, the fact that I just don’t like half of the album makes me sad with this record
Well he gave him a 5
That was unexpected. I'll give the album a 7 myself but 5 isn't too bad for him I guess
@@dontlook-atus I expected that he would give a 3
@@ninecity2455same
Ive seen him go crazy over a trash song by ez mil or tom macdonald, cant remember who it was. He probably likes em on the low, but its not "cool". Also dude prob cares way too much about politics. Hes never going to hate on kendrick, for example, that wouldnt do him any good and he knows most people (and culture) rock with him too much. Fantano thinks hes so smart and nobody understands that hes unbiased and bla bla.. dude is much more simpler than he thinks he is, just takes the right person. And I think most stans even dont get who he really is, they just think hes a hater
dude what are you talking about, fantano gave sexy redd an 8, he doesnt care about public perception
@@anotherxd5384 Cant tell if ur serious or trolling. Thats proving my point.. but i dont think u get it at all
I don't think Fantano is a hater. I think he has biases subconsciously that he's not aware about himself, ofcourse because of not just politics but also other stuff
Bro is living rent free in all his haters heads. lmao imagine being so vexed just from some dudes opinion. It isn't that deep, why can't people understand that?
why's anthony allowed to criticize but then when he gets criticized all of his stans get so up in arms 😂
@@Jitterz_official its the fact that people care so much about his opinion lmao
@@Jitterz_official Because every time he has an opinion, people seem to be livid, regardless of whether or not it's positive. If he says something great about, lets say Kanye, people will get angry that he's supporting his actions, but, since he's went against him, people are still outraged. The dude can't win lol.
People need to relax. If those same people that critize him were in his position, they'd give in to peer pressure and try to appease everyone. Anthony stays true to his opinion, and he's able to defend himself very well in debates against others. I've disagreed with his opinions before, like many, but I can see that his opinion has a lot of value because of how level headed he is.
@@Carzey yeah for sure that does happen and all but my guy pretty much blindly hates on ems stuff just for the sole reason that it's em. I'm a musician and quite frankly, it's super disrespectful to write off an artist just because that artist is who he is. Like imagine blind listening to a concept album and just going "meh" "cringe" "blah blah blah" when literally the entire point of said concept is to highlight the meh and the cringe yk? I like anthony and all but his liberal views cloud his judgment on music
and to be quite honest i completely get why people get upset with him cause imagine you go to a guy who's supposed to be a critic but all he does is call something cringe and meh which is ironic cause the second em dissed candace ownes fantano laughed his ass off lmao so he does find the style funny but only when it fits his narrative
Fantano is one of the most notorious music critics on the internet. He has influence on people’s opinions and as a result he has a responsibility to make informed and substantiated reviews. If he doesn’t uphold this standard, he is allowed to be criticised. If he doesn’t want to be criticised, he shouldn’t have said it. Whether he stands on what he said or he goes back on it is entirely his decision
bc fantano lame af
It is just opinion 😂
And?
@@dontlook-atus u crying about is funny. Music is subjective
W video
uhhhh, he hasnt reviewed it yet?
He did a Livestream reacting to it and even before starting he was hating and making fun of em he went into it with the most negative mindset and he didn't understand the concept at all
@@whatswrong335yeah that's what prompted me to make this vid