Sometimes the "nearly" will be absent, sometimes it's just everyone in the immediate vicinity, but no matter what, you can be sure that *something* interesting is happening.
"They'd probably be confused, until someone noticed that the Sun had stopped moving across the sky. Then they'd be really confused." This sounds like a perfect setup for a horror story.
Was there Outer Limits or Twilight Zone episode where the Moon suddenly grew much brighter and people realized that the Sun must have grew much brighter, torching the daylight side, so people tried to escape towards west to at least delay the inevitable sunrise.
[Edit: I was wrong.] I'm not sure they would notice it at all. On the poles the Sun doesn't move anyway on the sky during the day, it only moves due to the Earth orbiting the Sun. On the pole it should keep moving just normally, with the speed of 6 months from sunrise to sunset.
My grandfather, a US Marine, was stationed in San Juan, Puerto Rico in August of 1955 when Hurricane Connie struck the island with wind speeds of 140 miles per hour. He had been ordered to take shelter in a concrete bunker with six feet thick walls only a few meters uphill from a large sandy beach. After spending days stuck in the bunker, he said that after the storm had subsided and they were able to go outside, the sand from the beach and the wind had acted like a sandblaster and reduced the thickness of the wall to only 3 or 4 feet.
@@ryomaru2 your profile picture is anime. I am well aware of both world and United States history and the atrocities committed by the Soviet regime. I have made this my channel name to mock Joseph Stalin and promote anonymity.
This was a poor qualityvideo. To say that the Earth instantly stopped while the air kept its same rotation is nothing more than clickbait. The much, MUCH more interesting video - and one that most folk thought this would have been about - is "What would happen if the Earth SLOWED down to a stop?".
Nomad civilisations following the never-ending twilight/dawn over the course of a year in that small habitable zone between the scorching day and freezing night sounds like a banger post-apocalypse
Kim Stanley Robinson's 2312 has a non apocalyptic version of this scenario set on Mercury. The human habitat follows the terminator on tracks. As noted in response to a similar comment, the Mercurians have the advantages of a slower terminator and no oceans. Like all of his output, worth reading
You've forgotten the absence of the centripetal effects on the Earth. *The entire planet's tectonic surface would be destroyed.* I've noticed that a lot of people overlook the equatorial bulge collapsing whenever answering this question. The earth is 27 miles _(43 kilometers)_ wider in radius due to its rotation. If it stopped spinning the tectonic plates and magma would fall. I haven't done the math, but I strongly suspect that the equator would generate massive circular waves heading for each of the poles. The waves would _"condense"_ and get bigger as they headed toward the poles, hense getting bigger. This would result in the tectonic plates shattering and exploding along the way. If I recall correctly the tectonic plates are only 50 miles k_80 kilometers)_ thick in certain areas. These waves would collide with themselves at the polls creating massive explosions launching debris into space. The Earth's surface would likely be remolten into magma Earth.
@@niceguy191 Yes, once again this is my intuition, saying what would happen. The only thing I do know is a 27-mile-high mountain collapsing around the equator would kill everyone on Earth in a relatively short period of time, and no bunker would be safe. The final survivors would be anyone in orbit.
@@qwertykeyboard5901 Fair point. And definitely not pleasant at all. 😅 This is again, as stated earlier, only my intuition. I'd be curious how close to the truth my intuitive grasp on planetary physics would be.
@@classifiedveteran9879 Would it really collapse, or just subside? Rocks don't move or bend very quickly. The ocean bulge would collapse faster, meaning the equator would see a rapid drop in sea level while the poles would be flooded...
The narration for these videos is top tier. Eloquent, relaxed, and natural. No insanely compressed and bass-boosted voice, which (at least to me) seems insanely common these days. It's the little things, man.
1:43 "many people below the surface would survive the initial event fine" WRONG The inertia of these people would mean they keep moving with the inital ~470m/s and the tunnels they are in don't. Means within 10s of milliseconds their bodies are smeared over the tunnel walls. RIP
@@frankfahrenheit9537Nope. Andrew specifically said that the Earth as well as all terrestial objects would stop. And I know humans aren't objects but you get the point
@@toyota86s Man, tunnels AND humans must both stop, otherwise the humans are smeared over the tunnel walls. Get it? So humans are objects, too, in Andrews world.
@@frankfahrenheit9537 Yeah I get your point don't worry. In fact, at first I thought that humans would go flying as well, took me a bit to realise that what's on the ground would stop too
Yeah but what does that practically matter to them - they're not going to do anything useful with that land before the water recedes into its original position He mentioned the West because they're the dudes who would get wiped out
For quite some time, yes. Until the oceans' waters come rushing back, generating a reverse tsunami. But don't worry, humanity wouldn't experience that, as the tectonic plates along their edges would break off and pulverize, send enormous amounts of magma streaming into the sky to fall back down and burn everything on this planet into cinders.
For a couple days, maybe, until the water settled back to whatever the new "normal" was. But that's more of a "huh, interesting" and not the "*EVERYTHING YOU KNOW AND LOVE HAS BEEN RIPPED AWAY*" that the west shores would get.
Randall is a multi-talented guy, I've been a fan of the comic for years and never knew that he could narrate videos too. You should have done this years ago!
He sometimes tours when a new book comes out. If you get a chance, do yourself a favor and go see him. He could be a standup comic, he's hilarious in person.
This reminds me a lot of an HG Wells short story included at the end of some editions of _The Time Machine,_ about a man who gains the ability to warp reality with simple wishes. One of these miracles ended up essentially being "stop the Earth spinning," which caused a catastrophic rush of wind that tore up everything on the planet and basically levelled its surface and killed almost everyone; save for the man who very quickly saved himself using his powers. Essentially _everyone had died_ apart from him in an instant, and he couldn't revoke what he'd done with another miracle until he sacrificed his powers and basically turned back time so he never got them in the first place. It was a fun story, and I remember that apocalyptic sequence for being surprisingly horrifying and grounded despite the story being quite old. EDIT: It was called "The Man Who Could Work Miracles," and this is part of the Wikipedia article on the story (spoilers, obviously!): _Maydig plans to reform the whole world. He suggests that they could disregard their obligations for the next day if Fotheringay could stop the night altogether. Fotheringay agrees and stops the motion of the Earth. His clumsy wording of the wish causes all objects on Earth to be hurled from the surface with great force. Pandemonium ensues, but Fotheringay miraculously ensures his own safety back on the ground. In fact (though he is not aware of the enormity of what he had done) the whole of humanity except for himself had perished in a single instant._ _Fotheringay is unable to return the Earth to its prior state. He repents, and wishes that the power be taken from him and the world restored to a time before he had the power. Fotheringay immediately finds himself back in the public house, discussing miracles with his friends as before, without any recollection of previous events._
I love how this video ends with a possible looming threat of a majora's mask style angry moon plummeting out of orbit due to its slowed orbital velocity. Thanks Andrew. lol
You removed the cutest bit of this, where the moon says “hey… hey earth? What are you doing? Oh no… oh no. Don’t worry. I’m there for you” that part made me CRY and you **cut it.**
If supersonic aircraft don’t fly off the planet, you wouldn’t either. The velocity needed to get into orbit is about 27 times the rotational velocity of the Earth at its equator.
Part of the question assumes that everything on the surface also gets magically stopped. If not for that, then things on the surface *would* be launched at supersonic speeds, although that's probably not enough for escape velocity still.
Didn't mention the oceans rushing toward the poles due to lack of centrifugal force, or the immense earthquakes resulting from the equator suddenly finding itself 21km "higher" than the poles.
Great points. There could be part 2 to this. Also he could answer how much would moon fall "down" and how long would it take until it gets tidally locked...
Well this is sort of magic. The Earth stopped rotating (for some unknown reason) but the air did not, even though it's part of Earth. I mean you can sort of make up anything. And the Cats rose up to take political power and force the dogs into slavery...
Would the moon's deceleration as it spins up the Earth again not be enough to drop the moon out of orbit entirely? Since the moon began as a blob of molten spinning Earth flung out into orbit.
I'm no scientist by any means, but if I had to guess the Moon probably wouldn't get down there all the way; currently the Earth spins way faster than once every ~28 days, but if the Earth suddenly stopped spinning it probably wouldn't take much tidal forces to get our planet to tidally lock to it's unusual moon. This is just a guess though as I am no scientist.
I have never until today realized that TH-cam and Randall is a perfect match. Much like our ever faithful companion Moon, making sure we don't stop rotating for long.
As a teen, I wanted to write a post apocalyptic book about this. I wanted parts of it to be written in odd styling, like reading from an old book. And I carried the starting line with me for years. In the seventh year of the war, when the sky fell upon the Earth with unimaginable terror, all things built above the land were torn asunder, and all things dug below the ground were left for plunder.
I was about to be smug at the fact that I live in Wisconsin, which appears to be outside of the worst of it, but then I remembered that I also live within spitting distance of Lake Michigan. Even if Michigan gets hit with the hardest waves, the thing about water is that it sloshes back.
That would happen with the oceans too. Don't be too comfortable on the east coasts of the continents during this event. Your time is coming, maybe 12-24 hours later.
Winds just under supersonic speeds aren't going to treat you much differently than winds just over supersonic. 41° isn't too far south of any part of Wisconsin on a global scale.
0:45 if the atmosphere maintained angular velocity then aircraft in flight would be relatively unharmed - the graphic here shows helicopters getting blown away, but the air they're flying in doesn't change.
It would make landing or changing direction interesting though ;) However, this was a poor quality clickbait video. To say that the Earth stopped while the air kept its same rotation is nothing more than clickbait. The much, MUCH more interesting video - and one that most folk thought this would have been about - is "What would happen if the Earth SLOWED down to a stop?".
the question if earth stopping could cause moon to slow down enough to drop below it's stable orbit and slowly start plummeting towards the earth, that would be a real doomsday clock.
Space?! That'd be an unexpected result, considering the escape velocity is 11.186 km/s, about 20 rimes (±) as much as what the "emergency break" would cause. 🧐
@@eetuthereindeer6671 who says he was in a public space? most smokers are banned into hideous smoking areas these days, he could just have been there with a fellow addict
I assume people who were in a plane would also survive the immediate stopping of the earth, as they are moving relative to the air around them, rather than the ground below? Of course that wouldn't be much of a help, when they eventually need to land, or get caught up in one of the massive thunderstorms.
but not relative to the air around them, so assuming they can somehow land in all the carnage on the ground, they do have a good chance of survival @@superchinmayplays
so, how long would it take for surface to air friction to slow the airspeed near the ground to safe landing(and parking) speed? assuming that there is a runway left to land on.
I’d think they’d only have a chance if they were flying west to east (the same direction as Earth’s rotation), if they were traveling any other direction they would suddenly be moving at supersonic speeds relative to the air around them and their aircraft would get obliterated by a 1,000 mph crosswind
This sounds like the beginning f post-apocalyptic movie. Imagine taking the subway for work in the morning and the moment it takes you to travel to the next station and emerge, everything at the surface has been blown away.
I remember Isaac Asimov being asked this question. His answer was short: "Everyone would immediately lie down and roll about a thousand miles eastward."
The answer to this question in the original What If? was a formative moment for me as a young teen. I got the book from my uncle and at that point was pretty deep into this very... cult-level Christianity belief that humanity was the most important thing and the whole world was _for_ humans. And the end of this answer, the idea that the Moon's orbit around Earth would slowly cause Earth to rotate again, it opened my mind in a very significant way to the idea that the universe will keep going after humanity is gone. The world will keep turning, quite literally. That there is reality before and after humanity. It's a difficult feeling to describe. It's not existential dread, I've never feared human extinction exactly. But it's certainly an existential sort of feeling, even now as an adult who's left a lot of those old beliefs behind.
@@Boardwoards There are certainly many systems which seem to naturally stabilize. Though I'm not nearly knowledgeable enough of physics to understand the extent of it.
@rhapsodyaria In some fundamental sense, it is "built in" to the laws of physics. If you wave a wand and magically suspend them somehow (pretty much the basis of every What If), but them allow them to resume, the will seek out an equilibrium state once more. Which is more or less what they were doing before we came along and messed with the universe, so it isn't really all _that_ surprising that it looks similar... but that doesn't make it any less profound, either.
Your reaction reminds me of when I first visited the Grand Canyon, or the ocean. You can see an object so big, so familiar yet foreign, that it makes you feel small. Not insignificant, per se, just ... life changingly eye opening. Almost like you gained a point of reference for reality itself. You use existential, I use awe. Awe is just the bottom falling out of your perception xP I'm so encouraged to hear that something like XKCD made such a difference for you, because I'd be lying if I said it didn't shape me at least a little too
You must have missed all of the versus of the Bible that point out how insignificant humanity is in the face of not just God but the entire universe in Sunday School.
@@muffinconsumer4431 Fair enough. I wonder if the supersonic wind speeds above exposed underground areas (like subway stations) would create a huge pressure differential that would suck air out and cause problems for the people underground.
I haven’t read all the comments, so this might be a repeat. Human’s standing on a rotating surface experience the effects of centrifugal force. The Earth’s gravity is sufficient to keep us from being thrown into space by that force. Wouldn’t we experience the effects gravity pulling us toward the Earth’s core without the centrifugal force? And if so, how much greater would this g-force be?
Love this series! Super excited for more like this! Thanks so much for uploading! Might comment more later! Also, doesn't centripetal force which widens it's radius mean Earth's surface gets torn apart, as I've seen in the comments?
The cool thing is that some climate simulations suggest the climate wouldn't actually be that extremely different between day and night - because you would have a lot of atmospheric circulation distributing the heat around the planet. Also, the climate would probably cool down, because there would likely be almost constant overcast conditions over at least sunlit oceans on such a slow spinning Earth, which means a lot more sunlight gets reflected back into space. This also means that if we somehow cooled Venus down to an earthlike temperature and gave it an earthlike atmosphere and oceans, it would probably be able to maintain those conditions despite receiving a lot more sunlight.
"First, some boring stuff. Mass extinction. Super-sonic winds. The surface of all bodies of water completely atomizing. Yada yada... Then the moon does something cool."
Pretty sure the people underground would also immediately die from blunt force trauma after getting thrown against the subway wall by the inertia remaining in their bodies when the world suddenly stopped spinning.
You're thinking wayyy too small. Blunt force trauma? If the planet suddenly stopped we'd be mist forget bumping into things. Do you know how fast the Earth is spinning it's not a carnival ride it's over a thousand miles per hour...
Got the What if? 2 book the other day and I am so happy i found such a funny yet "usefull" book so thank you for making it cant wait to get another one
@@HoppingSkipper I mean, yeah. It’s a good book. I did describe it as “cooler” which I thought would be a dead giveaway away that it’s not very serious.
A minor detail: a spinning earth is wider at the equator compared to the north/south distance, In time, the stopped earth would return to being a sphere, which might have some side-effects also. In the shorter term: the oceans would flow downhill from the equator to the lowlands at the polls, as would of the air. Excellent episode.
Probably not. We might end up hitting an equilibrium point where the Earth and Moon are tidally locked, though. Keep in mind that currently the Moon is moving *away* from Earth over time, so slowing it down would probably just stop that gradual drift.
In the 2nd grade my teacher asked us how many days the earth would have if it did not rotate. The animation in this video is exactly what played in my head. I answered, exactly one day. Teacher told me I was wrong and refused to let me make a case-insisted that I was simply wrong. So I guess there’s still a tiny twinge of anger over that moment of classroom injustice, but now I know xkcd is on my side. 😅
Yeah, the "mean tropical" solar year and the sidereal year differ by exactly one day. The one extra day comes from the Earth making one complete orbit around the sun. All the other days come from the Earth itself rotating around its own axis (between the poles).
A youtuber stated he has a problem with teleportation concepts in movies because of this. If you would teleport yourself to somewhere on earth that has a different distance to the closest pole, the relative change of your velocity after you reached your destination is so high that it would rip you in pieces. Never thought about it like this and thought it belongs here :)
So magic technology can destroy a person in place A and completely reassemble them in place B, but changing their momentum by a tiny amount (relative to the mass-energy contained in a person, I mean) is difficult?
@@jasonpatterson8091 Isn't it these days the magical teleporters use wormholes because of that whole disassembly thing had those sorts of implications about whether or not the person is a clone or the actual person?
1:25 The winds wouldn't be "twice as strong" since the winds kinetic energy would go up by the velocity squared, and air resistance goes up by the velocity cubed, so imo that should be "twice as fast, 4 times as strong, and up to 8 times as destructive."
I wonder what would happen on the west side of mountains. If all of the air suddenly rushes east, wouldn't there be a vacuum there for a short time? Kinda reminds me of the "glass half empty" What If scenario.
Mountain tops could get ripped apart if thousends of tonns of air suddenly started smashing it with super sonic speed. Tips would fall off and I wonder how much meters of tops would that be (probably not many... rocks are quite hard and tips with conic shape are pretty strong). Still, tops of mountains would face some absolutely insane pressures and velocities of air.
This was a poor quality clickbait video. To say that the Earth stopped while the air kept its same rotation is nothing more than clickbait. The much, MUCH more interesting video - and one that most folk thought this would have been about - is "What would happen if the Earth SLOWED down to a stop?".
If the earth instantly stops spinning, wouldn't everyone sustain their current rotation speed and move with former rotation speed against the next wall? That would also kill every bunker owner and subway/metro traveler. This is also a problem when inventing a fictional teleportation-like super power. If you would teleport from one of the poles to the equator, you would experience an instant acceleration to full rotation speed which would kill you.
Didn't you miss the part where all humans would turn into a mush because their 463 m/s velocity (at the Equator) would become 0 suddenly? That's 46g-s if the deceleration takes 1 second.
Arguably, humans that magically have their velocities of every atom in their body changed instantly wouldn't feel anything, unlike with normal acceleration, which propagates throughout the body in a wave causing damage.
@@BR-lx7py it's assuming some magical force that stops earth's rotation without any g forces at all. it's a silly "what-if" question and isn't meant to be taken so seriously!
WAIT, IS THIS ACTUALLY THE GUY THAT WROTE THE WHAT IF BOOK? I absolutely adored that book, genuinely my favorite literature of all time. Glad to see you're still doing this awesome stuff, man.
So question about the people underground. Wouldn't a metro or cave or whatever with an upwind facing entrance have hypersonic air forced inside destroying any contents without enough space to slow it down and wouldn't it create a terrifying vacuum with a downwind entrance? Still figure some would survive so long as they've got some way to slow the wind.
I like this channel because when I ask anyone else a question like this, they just tell me that it couldn’t happen I KNOW it couldn’t happen, that’s not what I’m asking about
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 89 | คู่เอก "ยอดไอคิว vs คิริลล์"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Z3vYkHJ_5Ig/mqdefault.jpg)
“First, nearly everyone would die; second, things would get interesting” should be this channel’s motto.
Sometimes the "nearly" will be absent, sometimes it's just everyone in the immediate vicinity, but no matter what, you can be sure that *something* interesting is happening.
It already is an inofficial motto
not true... we live, everyday... without rotation... because there is no such thing as earth's rotation, it's a lie
as a person who has read all of his books especially the What If? books I can confirm that this is true
Right up there with Kurzgesagt's "Short answer: you'd die."
"They'd probably be confused, until someone noticed that the Sun had stopped moving across the sky. Then they'd be really confused."
This sounds like a perfect setup for a horror story.
I'd watch the crap out of that!
Sounds like a film that is directed by Roland Emmerich
Was there Outer Limits or Twilight Zone episode where the Moon suddenly grew much brighter and people realized that the Sun must have grew much brighter, torching the daylight side, so people tried to escape towards west to at least delay the inevitable sunrise.
The sun rotates extremely slowly at the poles. It'd take them a few months to even realise
[Edit: I was wrong.] I'm not sure they would notice it at all. On the poles the Sun doesn't move anyway on the sky during the day, it only moves due to the Earth orbiting the Sun. On the pole it should keep moving just normally, with the speed of 6 months from sunrise to sunset.
3:55 Great job breaking everything, ANDREW.
Dammit Andrew...
Better Andrew than Putin
GOD DAMMIT ANDREW NOT AGAIN! THIS IS THE THIRD TIME THIS WEEK!
Nice Job Breaking it, Hero
@@monst3r_child832 "TV Tropes will ruin your life"
3:59 Yeah. Thanks a lot, *_Andrew._*
You're welcome
Shi-@@andrewalderman9489
Raim worl
thanks andrew
@@byug8560 How was I to know it would be world ending ?
My grandfather, a US Marine, was stationed in San Juan, Puerto Rico in August of 1955 when Hurricane Connie struck the island with wind speeds of 140 miles per hour. He had been ordered to take shelter in a concrete bunker with six feet thick walls only a few meters uphill from a large sandy beach. After spending days stuck in the bunker, he said that after the storm had subsided and they were able to go outside, the sand from the beach and the wind had acted like a sandblaster and reduced the thickness of the wall to only 3 or 4 feet.
Noted. Not going anywhere near a beach during a tropical storm
@@ryomaru2 your profile picture is anime. I am well aware of both world and United States history and the atrocities committed by the Soviet regime. I have made this my channel name to mock Joseph Stalin and promote anonymity.
@@JosephStalin1941based (mocking political leaders of all kinds is funny)
@@JosephStalin1941weakest Stalin poster vs strongest joker poster
Why is it always the p5 fans@@Alernategem
"This is all Andrews fault" 🤣 These videos are brilliant... very enjoyable to watch!
I feel like Andrew got thrown under the bus there!
Let's all hail to our overlord Andrew, so he may not stop the earth from rotating... until we all move underground.
The Andrew's Apocalypse
@RepentandbelieveinJesusChrist5 a bit off topic my friend
This was a poor qualityvideo. To say that the Earth instantly stopped while the air kept its same rotation is nothing more than clickbait. The much, MUCH more interesting video - and one that most folk thought this would have been about - is "What would happen if the Earth SLOWED down to a stop?".
2:05 The implication that they'd notice because the cats not moving is just hilarious!
I think the "sleeping cat in the apocalypse" should be the "canary in the coal mine" for the modern day
Moon's a homie for clearing up Andrew's mess
"Unfortunately, you probably have neighbors" is honestly a great line.
Sorry guys. My bad.
Not cool man
It's all good I live at 43 n
Jackass
Nice job Andrew 🙄🙄
We’ll walk it off it’s fine.
Nomad civilisations following the never-ending twilight/dawn over the course of a year in that small habitable zone between the scorching day and freezing night sounds like a banger post-apocalypse
I think there's a story about robots doing this on the Moon. (The Moon's surface has sunlight for two weeks at a time.)
And they'd probably have to endure the harsh winds as hot and cold air are in constant collision between the two extremes...
Kim Stanley Robinson's 2312 has a non apocalyptic version of this scenario set on Mercury. The human habitat follows the terminator on tracks. As noted in response to a similar comment, the Mercurians have the advantages of a slower terminator and no oceans. Like all of his output, worth reading
Somewhat similar to mortal engines
@@danielmcdonald809I have that book on my nightstand. It's quite good.
Solution: We never ever again let Andrew near to any computers to ask for such disaster.
Or we eliminate all Andrews?
... question mark?
You've forgotten the absence of the centripetal effects on the Earth. *The entire planet's tectonic surface would be destroyed.*
I've noticed that a lot of people overlook the equatorial bulge collapsing whenever answering this question. The earth is 27 miles _(43 kilometers)_ wider in radius due to its rotation. If it stopped spinning the tectonic plates and magma would fall.
I haven't done the math, but I strongly suspect that the equator would generate massive circular waves heading for each of the poles. The waves would _"condense"_ and get bigger as they headed toward the poles, hense getting bigger. This would result in the tectonic plates shattering and exploding along the way. If I recall correctly the tectonic plates are only 50 miles k_80 kilometers)_ thick in certain areas. These waves would collide with themselves at the polls creating massive explosions launching debris into space. The Earth's surface would likely be remolten into magma Earth.
Ooo, yes this part of it is really interesting to explore!
@@niceguy191 Yes, once again this is my intuition, saying what would happen. The only thing I do know is a 27-mile-high mountain collapsing around the equator would kill everyone on Earth in a relatively short period of time, and no bunker would be safe. The final survivors would be anyone in orbit.
I'm not convinced with the remelt thing, but that would still be extremely unpleasant.
@@qwertykeyboard5901 Fair point. And definitely not pleasant at all. 😅 This is again, as stated earlier, only my intuition. I'd be curious how close to the truth my intuitive grasp on planetary physics would be.
@@classifiedveteran9879 Would it really collapse, or just subside? Rocks don't move or bend very quickly. The ocean bulge would collapse faster, meaning the equator would see a rapid drop in sea level while the poles would be flooded...
The narration for these videos is top tier.
Eloquent, relaxed, and natural. No insanely compressed and bass-boosted voice, which (at least to me) seems insanely common these days. It's the little things, man.
You might enjoy CPG Greys comic educational vids too. Same sooting voice
@@dlibby4979sooting
@dlibby4979*CGP and yes, highly recommend
@@dlibby4979 I’m afraid that nobody watches him anymore after the awful thing that he did.
@@MK8MasterJunjie which was...?
Just finish your homework Andrew, it's not worth it.
1:43 "many people below the surface would survive the initial event fine"
WRONG
The inertia of these people would mean they keep moving with the inital ~470m/s
and the tunnels they are in don't. Means within 10s of milliseconds their bodies
are smeared over the tunnel walls. RIP
@@frankfahrenheit9537Nope. Andrew specifically said that the Earth as well as all terrestial objects would stop. And I know humans aren't objects but you get the point
@@toyota86s Man, tunnels AND humans must both stop, otherwise the humans are smeared over the tunnel walls. Get it?
So humans are objects, too, in Andrews world.
@@frankfahrenheit9537 Yeah I get your point don't worry. In fact, at first I thought that humans would go flying as well, took me a bit to realise that what's on the ground would stop too
@@Nate-.- Bruh I literally said that we would stop what do you mean?!
In 2:52, wouldn't East facing shores experience the opposite and have hugely receeding water exposing more land under the ocean?
Yeah but what does that practically matter to them - they're not going to do anything useful with that land before the water recedes into its original position
He mentioned the West because they're the dudes who would get wiped out
I believe you’re right
yes
For quite some time, yes. Until the oceans' waters come rushing back, generating a reverse tsunami. But don't worry, humanity wouldn't experience that, as the tectonic plates along their edges would break off and pulverize, send enormous amounts of magma streaming into the sky to fall back down and burn everything on this planet into cinders.
For a couple days, maybe, until the water settled back to whatever the new "normal" was. But that's more of a "huh, interesting" and not the "*EVERYTHING YOU KNOW AND LOVE HAS BEEN RIPPED AWAY*" that the west shores would get.
Randall is a multi-talented guy, I've been a fan of the comic for years and never knew that he could narrate videos too. You should have done this years ago!
I'm sure there was something stopping him, but yeah I wish there was more of this earlier!
He sometimes tours when a new book comes out. If you get a chance, do yourself a favor and go see him. He could be a standup comic, he's hilarious in person.
Unlike that Andrew... 😂
I remember reading this when I was younger in What If 1 and having a massive existential crisis. Good times thanks to Andrew
Yep, i also recognised it from the book, red it today
This reminds me a lot of an HG Wells short story included at the end of some editions of _The Time Machine,_ about a man who gains the ability to warp reality with simple wishes. One of these miracles ended up essentially being "stop the Earth spinning," which caused a catastrophic rush of wind that tore up everything on the planet and basically levelled its surface and killed almost everyone; save for the man who very quickly saved himself using his powers. Essentially _everyone had died_ apart from him in an instant, and he couldn't revoke what he'd done with another miracle until he sacrificed his powers and basically turned back time so he never got them in the first place.
It was a fun story, and I remember that apocalyptic sequence for being surprisingly horrifying and grounded despite the story being quite old.
EDIT: It was called "The Man Who Could Work Miracles," and this is part of the Wikipedia article on the story (spoilers, obviously!):
_Maydig plans to reform the whole world. He suggests that they could disregard their obligations for the next day if Fotheringay could stop the night altogether. Fotheringay agrees and stops the motion of the Earth. His clumsy wording of the wish causes all objects on Earth to be hurled from the surface with great force. Pandemonium ensues, but Fotheringay miraculously ensures his own safety back on the ground. In fact (though he is not aware of the enormity of what he had done) the whole of humanity except for himself had perished in a single instant._
_Fotheringay is unable to return the Earth to its prior state. He repents, and wishes that the power be taken from him and the world restored to a time before he had the power. Fotheringay immediately finds himself back in the public house, discussing miracles with his friends as before, without any recollection of previous events._
There was also the fairly faithful film adaptation in 1937 starring Roland Young.
I love how this video ends with a possible looming threat of a majora's mask style angry moon plummeting out of orbit due to its slowed orbital velocity. Thanks Andrew. lol
You removed the cutest bit of this, where the moon says “hey… hey earth? What are you doing? Oh no… oh no. Don’t worry. I’m there for you” that part made me CRY and you **cut it.**
Was this on a patreon or something
@@neminem233 No, it was in the original book, What If?, lol
@@jackgreenearth452my bad oopsies
can't give too many spoilers
@@DrKaii find whimsy and joy in your life
"Well first, nearly everyone would die. Then things would get interesting" - Literally every single What If? or Kurzgesagt video
Death and destruction are just minor inconveniences. We're here for the physics!
@@alexsdarkclubband the midas video 🙏🙏😭😭
i always thought that if the earth stopped spinning we would all get thrown off the planet 💀
well Andrew specified that everything on the earth would also stop
That's the typical scenario, but Andrew specifically asked "What If we did it differently in this version, how would that change other things?"
If supersonic aircraft don’t fly off the planet, you wouldn’t either. The velocity needed to get into orbit is about 27 times the rotational velocity of the Earth at its equator.
Part of the question assumes that everything on the surface also gets magically stopped. If not for that, then things on the surface *would* be launched at supersonic speeds, although that's probably not enough for escape velocity still.
your momentum would remain and you would continue to travel even if the earth stops spinning.
So many of these videos have given me fantastic writing prompts for dystopia novels
2:00 Thats actually a great plot for a cheesy sci-fi B movie. The Day the Earth Literally Stood Still
Didn't mention the oceans rushing toward the poles due to lack of centrifugal force, or the immense earthquakes resulting from the equator suddenly finding itself 21km "higher" than the poles.
Great points. There could be part 2 to this. Also he could answer how much would moon fall "down" and how long would it take until it gets tidally locked...
stop spreading bs! Centrifugal forces would have the oceans lift from the earth if they existed.. but earth does NOT ROTATE!!
Well this is sort of magic. The Earth stopped rotating (for some unknown reason) but the air did not, even though it's part of Earth. I mean you can sort of make up anything. And the Cats rose up to take political power and force the dogs into slavery...
@@DeputyNordburg only the air did not stop in the scenario
@sipo-ex2qp there is likely a small effect but it's likely to only be a few meters
Would the moon's deceleration as it spins up the Earth again not be enough to drop the moon out of orbit entirely? Since the moon began as a blob of molten spinning Earth flung out into orbit.
Possibly. It would for sure drop the Terra-Luna distance. Whether it would come all the way down to the Roche limit is indeed an interesting question.
Depends on how much energy went into the Moon's creation.
I'm no scientist by any means, but if I had to guess the Moon probably wouldn't get down there all the way; currently the Earth spins way faster than once every ~28 days, but if the Earth suddenly stopped spinning it probably wouldn't take much tidal forces to get our planet to tidally lock to it's unusual moon. This is just a guess though as I am no scientist.
My guess is that it would crash and burn, while also imparting the last of it's angular momentum to Earth.
There's a kurzgesagt video on what would happen
I like the thought of the moon acting as a battery for storing angular momentum, just in case we ever stop spinning for some reason
Thanks a lot, Andrew.
I might be an Andrew, but I am not a Karen.
I have never until today realized that TH-cam and Randall is a perfect match. Much like our ever faithful companion Moon, making sure we don't stop rotating for long.
As a teen, I wanted to write a post apocalyptic book about this. I wanted parts of it to be written in odd styling, like reading from an old book. And I carried the starting line with me for years.
In the seventh year of the war, when the sky fell upon the Earth with unimaginable terror, all things built above the land were torn asunder, and all things dug below the ground were left for plunder.
Love it. When does the book come out? ;)
@@oncedidactic Here just for the reminder
Do it
Too bad the title "The Day the Earth Stood Still" is already taken
Like a combo of Remina and Canticle for Leibowitz? Sounds cool!
A Ron White quote was not among the things I expected from this channel, I love it.
He caught the “Tater”
ah, the classic first question of the book! i've really been enjoying these videos, keep up the good work!
🤔 What if a Dinosaur 🦕 wiped out the Asteroids
We would worship it as a god!
@@lambentlampreygodasaur
@@CheerfulRiverFalls-cv6tj ALL GLORY TO THE GODOSAUR
@@CheerfulRiverFalls-cv6tj *Theosaurus 🤓
😂😂😂
0:20 according to the BBC weather wind speed, earth will stop spinning tomorrow 😨
4 weeks ago…
1 month ago…
I was about to be smug at the fact that I live in Wisconsin, which appears to be outside of the worst of it, but then I remembered that I also live within spitting distance of Lake Michigan. Even if Michigan gets hit with the hardest waves, the thing about water is that it sloshes back.
That would happen with the oceans too. Don't be too comfortable on the east coasts of the continents during this event. Your time is coming, maybe 12-24 hours later.
Winds just under supersonic speeds aren't going to treat you much differently than winds just over supersonic. 41° isn't too far south of any part of Wisconsin on a global scale.
0:45 if the atmosphere maintained angular velocity then aircraft in flight would be relatively unharmed - the graphic here shows helicopters getting blown away, but the air they're flying in doesn't change.
It would make landing or changing direction interesting though ;)
However, this was a poor quality clickbait video. To say that the Earth stopped while the air kept its same rotation is nothing more than clickbait. The much, MUCH more interesting video - and one that most folk thought this would have been about - is "What would happen if the Earth SLOWED down to a stop?".
It’s not clickbait, he answered the question.
@@ChrisM541he got asked a question, and he answered it. why the fuck would he answer a different barely related question
@@NocturnalTyphlosion I can't help you if you lack the mental capacity to understand my post. It is what it is.
@@ChrisM541How many people have you interviewed before you reach to the conclusion “Most folk thought this would be ”?
Your comics filled my childhood with a budding interest in STEM concepts, now I find myself all over your What If books!
As a Rain World fan, all I can say is Thanks, Andrew.
the question if earth stopping could cause moon to slow down enough to drop below it's stable orbit and slowly start plummeting towards the earth, that would be a real doomsday clock.
Once had this discussion during a smoke break, we imagined us just slingshotting into space at 1000 mph, as our flesh ripped off our bones
Difficult to light the cigarettes, too.
You shouldn't smoke, at least not in public
@@eetuthereindeer6671 Yes Mother.
Space?! That'd be an unexpected result, considering the escape velocity is 11.186 km/s, about 20 rimes (±) as much as what the "emergency break" would cause. 🧐
@@eetuthereindeer6671 who says he was in a public space? most smokers are banned into hideous smoking areas these days, he could just have been there with a fellow addict
I assume people who were in a plane would also survive the immediate stopping of the earth, as they are moving relative to the air around them, rather than the ground below? Of course that wouldn't be much of a help, when they eventually need to land, or get caught up in one of the massive thunderstorms.
they would suddenly be moving at supersonic speeds relative to the ground
but not relative to the air around them, so assuming they can somehow land in all the carnage on the ground, they do have a good chance of survival @@superchinmayplays
It depends whether they're counted in "all terrestrial objects."
so, how long would it take for surface to air friction to slow the airspeed near the ground to safe landing(and parking) speed? assuming that there is a runway left to land on.
I’d think they’d only have a chance if they were flying west to east (the same direction as Earth’s rotation), if they were traveling any other direction they would suddenly be moving at supersonic speeds relative to the air around them and their aircraft would get obliterated by a 1,000 mph crosswind
This sounds like the beginning f post-apocalyptic movie. Imagine taking the subway for work in the morning and the moment it takes you to travel to the next station and emerge, everything at the surface has been blown away.
and on the horizon you see a tsunami coming
@@0topon if you're on the West coast.. Boston, New York or Toronto, less so..
@@JRufu East Coasts of continents would probably experience extremely low tides, possibly even dry bays (like Tampa Bay during Hurricane Ian in 2022)
I remember Isaac Asimov being asked this question. His answer was short: "Everyone would immediately lie down and roll about a thousand miles eastward."
"If you get hit with a Volvo.... It don't really matter how many sit-ups you did that morning."
4:18 uh oh not Black Hat.
Oh that guy
The answer to this question in the original What If? was a formative moment for me as a young teen. I got the book from my uncle and at that point was pretty deep into this very... cult-level Christianity belief that humanity was the most important thing and the whole world was _for_ humans. And the end of this answer, the idea that the Moon's orbit around Earth would slowly cause Earth to rotate again, it opened my mind in a very significant way to the idea that the universe will keep going after humanity is gone. The world will keep turning, quite literally. That there is reality before and after humanity. It's a difficult feeling to describe. It's not existential dread, I've never feared human extinction exactly. But it's certainly an existential sort of feeling, even now as an adult who's left a lot of those old beliefs behind.
the people who do live in fear of such are the ones who try to use good messages to say greedy things. self correction seems to be a law of physics.
@@Boardwoards There are certainly many systems which seem to naturally stabilize. Though I'm not nearly knowledgeable enough of physics to understand the extent of it.
@rhapsodyaria In some fundamental sense, it is "built in" to the laws of physics. If you wave a wand and magically suspend them somehow (pretty much the basis of every What If), but them allow them to resume, the will seek out an equilibrium state once more. Which is more or less what they were doing before we came along and messed with the universe, so it isn't really all _that_ surprising that it looks similar... but that doesn't make it any less profound, either.
Your reaction reminds me of when I first visited the Grand Canyon, or the ocean. You can see an object so big, so familiar yet foreign, that it makes you feel small. Not insignificant, per se, just ... life changingly eye opening. Almost like you gained a point of reference for reality itself. You use existential, I use awe. Awe is just the bottom falling out of your perception xP I'm so encouraged to hear that something like XKCD made such a difference for you, because I'd be lying if I said it didn't shape me at least a little too
You must have missed all of the versus of the Bible that point out how insignificant humanity is in the face of not just God but the entire universe in Sunday School.
1:45 - Wouldn't they go flying at supersonic speed and end up going smash into the wall or something?
The question is poorly worded, but he means everything except the atmosphere stops at the same time, negating all inertia.
@@muffinconsumer4431 Fair enough. I wonder if the supersonic wind speeds above exposed underground areas (like subway stations) would create a huge pressure differential that would suck air out and cause problems for the people underground.
I really like the idea that Andrew somehow personally stopped the Earth's rotation.
I haven’t read all the comments, so this might be a repeat. Human’s standing on a rotating surface experience the effects of centrifugal force. The Earth’s gravity is sufficient to keep us from being thrown into space by that force. Wouldn’t we experience the effects gravity pulling us toward the Earth’s core without the centrifugal force? And if so, how much greater would this g-force be?
Around the difference between effective rotational velocity and orbital velocity, maybe 4-5% at the equator extra.
Love this series! Super excited for more like this! Thanks so much for uploading! Might comment more later! Also, doesn't centripetal force which widens it's radius mean Earth's surface gets torn apart, as I've seen in the comments?
I can't wait for the mole of moles episode :D Awesome stuff Randall! I Love "What if?"
The cool thing is that some climate simulations suggest the climate wouldn't actually be that extremely different between day and night - because you would have a lot of atmospheric circulation distributing the heat around the planet. Also, the climate would probably cool down, because there would likely be almost constant overcast conditions over at least sunlit oceans on such a slow spinning Earth, which means a lot more sunlight gets reflected back into space. This also means that if we somehow cooled Venus down to an earthlike temperature and gave it an earthlike atmosphere and oceans, it would probably be able to maintain those conditions despite receiving a lot more sunlight.
Finally, a solution to global warming I can get behind.
i have both of your books and lemme tell u i have binged BINGED them all ..... just an appreciation comment
I got them on audible when I saw they were read by Wil Wheaton xD
You're actually good at everything, then. Great narration! Fantastic!!!
Why isn't the sun moving?
Why aren't any comms working?
WHY IS THE SUN NOT MOVING
don't forget that each building contains air that would also keep moving.
Probably not significant, actually! Check out The Action Lab’s demonstration of a balloon in an accelerating truck
I think it's great that you're putting What If on TH-cam, Randall. What a marvelous idea.
The sound effects are really fabulous.
I’m glad to know that he’s a Boston resident as well lol. This city is great and it’s cool that he’s from here
3:52 THANKS ANDREW
That first line was always my favorite first line of any question, purely because of how memorable it is lol
"First, some boring stuff. Mass extinction. Super-sonic winds. The surface of all bodies of water completely atomizing. Yada yada...
Then the moon does something cool."
Pretty sure the people underground would also immediately die from blunt force trauma after getting thrown against the subway wall by the inertia remaining in their bodies when the world suddenly stopped spinning.
You're thinking wayyy too small. Blunt force trauma? If the planet suddenly stopped we'd be mist forget bumping into things. Do you know how fast the Earth is spinning it's not a carnival ride it's over a thousand miles per hour...
Also the atmosphere is underground too
Love the all-mouth sound effects.
Mentioning Ron White scores major points
3:00 I'm from Chile, my entire country is under the ocean at this point 😱
Dammit, Andrew.
Andrew woke up and chose violence 😂
Got the What if? 2 book the other day and I am so happy i found such a funny yet "usefull" book so thank you for making it cant wait to get another one
Nobody commented on the sound effects? Love them 🫶🏻
Loving this channel! We need more ridiculous science videos like this. It's like short form, video version of the book "The Martian".
Fun fact: Wil Wheaton, the person who narrated The Martian’s audio book, also narrated the What If? books!
@@HoppingSkipper Wil Wheaton, the person who reads the less cool version of the Martian. Signed, the RC Bray gang.
Look up "XKCD What If?"on Google, It's the comic strip version that lead to the creation of this channel, with a lot more answers already out
@@TheBondsJamesBonds I never understood why people get so caught up over the change in narrators. I’ve heard both, and liked both.
@@HoppingSkipper I mean, yeah. It’s a good book. I did describe it as “cooler” which I thought would be a dead giveaway away that it’s not very serious.
What does instant deceleration imply in the realm of physics? As a complete layman, I'm thinking infinite energy somewhere.
A minor detail: a spinning earth is wider at the equator compared to the north/south distance, In time, the stopped earth would return to being a sphere, which might have some side-effects also. In the shorter term: the oceans would flow downhill from the equator to the lowlands at the polls, as would of the air.
Excellent episode.
Can't believe people are worried about "dangerous political views" when Andrew is among us
These videos have been the best thing to grace youtube in years
If the pull of the moon on the earth would gradually slow down the moon as well, wouldnt the moon eventually fall back into earth?
Yes, yes it would.
Probably not. We might end up hitting an equilibrium point where the Earth and Moon are tidally locked, though. Keep in mind that currently the Moon is moving *away* from Earth over time, so slowing it down would probably just stop that gradual drift.
In the 2nd grade my teacher asked us how many days the earth would have if it did not rotate. The animation in this video is exactly what played in my head. I answered, exactly one day. Teacher told me I was wrong and refused to let me make a case-insisted that I was simply wrong. So I guess there’s still a tiny twinge of anger over that moment of classroom injustice, but now I know xkcd is on my side. 😅
Yeah, the "mean tropical" solar year and the sidereal year differ by exactly one day. The one extra day comes from the Earth making one complete orbit around the sun. All the other days come from the Earth itself rotating around its own axis (between the poles).
Wait but what did the teacher expect as a response?
@@alexandrelima2766 Zero days. None.
That hidden cat really knows how life works😂 Great job man!
I like how in most of these, the Channel Islands would cease to exist in at least one way
Incredible Ron White reference and doodle.
It's the professional sound effects that really elevate this video. :)
0:25 *supersonic* speed
1:09
FIRE IN THE *Bunker*
A youtuber stated he has a problem with teleportation concepts in movies because of this. If you would teleport yourself to somewhere on earth that has a different distance to the closest pole, the relative change of your velocity after you reached your destination is so high that it would rip you in pieces.
Never thought about it like this and thought it belongs here :)
So magic technology can destroy a person in place A and completely reassemble them in place B, but changing their momentum by a tiny amount (relative to the mass-energy contained in a person, I mean) is difficult?
@@jasonpatterson8091
Isn't it these days the magical teleporters use wormholes because of that whole disassembly thing had those sorts of implications about whether or not the person is a clone or the actual person?
So You've Learned To Teleport by Tom Scott. It is about the same energy as a sip of Cola.
so thrilled you're doing this content. it's been a blessing while doing late-night baby shifts. hope you're well. (hi randall).
Andrew would have destoryed us all if it wasn't for that absolute chad sigma moon proving that not all heroes wear cape some are just gray rocky boi
1:25 The winds wouldn't be "twice as strong" since the winds kinetic energy would go up by the velocity squared, and air resistance goes up by the velocity cubed, so imo that should be "twice as fast, 4 times as strong, and up to 8 times as destructive."
You should be working for nasa
I wonder what would happen on the west side of mountains. If all of the air suddenly rushes east, wouldn't there be a vacuum there for a short time? Kinda reminds me of the "glass half empty" What If scenario.
Mountain tops could get ripped apart if thousends of tonns of air suddenly started smashing it with super sonic speed. Tips would fall off and I wonder how much meters of tops would that be (probably not many... rocks are quite hard and tips with conic shape are pretty strong). Still, tops of mountains would face some absolutely insane pressures and velocities of air.
Maybe not vacuum, but definitely lower pressure and turbulence.
This was a poor quality clickbait video. To say that the Earth stopped while the air kept its same rotation is nothing more than clickbait. The much, MUCH more interesting video - and one that most folk thought this would have been about - is "What would happen if the Earth SLOWED down to a stop?".
DAMMIT ANDREW
If the earth instantly stops spinning, wouldn't everyone sustain their current rotation speed and move with former rotation speed against the next wall? That would also kill every bunker owner and subway/metro traveler.
This is also a problem when inventing a fictional teleportation-like super power. If you would teleport from one of the poles to the equator, you would experience an instant acceleration to full rotation speed which would kill you.
Remember that Christians believe the Earth literally stopped rotating for 24 hours. Let that sink in for a moment.
the nostalgia
Didn't you miss the part where all humans would turn into a mush because their 463 m/s velocity (at the Equator) would become 0 suddenly? That's 46g-s if the deceleration takes 1 second.
I think humans are considered to be 'terrestrial objects' for the purpose of this question.
Arguably, humans that magically have their velocities of every atom in their body changed instantly wouldn't feel anything, unlike with normal acceleration, which propagates throughout the body in a wave causing damage.
@@bbgun061 Right, so humans suddenly stop spinning and experience 46g acceleration.
@@BR-lx7py it's assuming some magical force that stops earth's rotation without any g forces at all. it's a silly "what-if" question and isn't meant to be taken so seriously!
I can't believe the 92nd little piggy story didn't make a cameo! Still loved the video though :)
WAIT, IS THIS ACTUALLY THE GUY THAT WROTE THE WHAT IF BOOK? I absolutely adored that book, genuinely my favorite literature of all time. Glad to see you're still doing this awesome stuff, man.
All of us should thank the moon. THANK YOU, MOON!
Loved the sound effects on this
I already thought 16 hours of sunlight in an Australian (Victorian) Summer was 4 hours too long. Thanks a lot Andrew!
So question about the people underground. Wouldn't a metro or cave or whatever with an upwind facing entrance have hypersonic air forced inside destroying any contents without enough space to slow it down and wouldn't it create a terrifying vacuum with a downwind entrance?
Still figure some would survive so long as they've got some way to slow the wind.
I love that this is now a TH-cam series! 🙂
I like this channel because when I ask anyone else a question like this, they just tell me that it couldn’t happen
I KNOW it couldn’t happen, that’s not what I’m asking about