@@RiordanLadyGaga Yes, we can hear it. It annoys me to hear it, but I have to applaud how far the technology has come because it's barely perceptible. Gaga's voice shines through instead of becoming overly-electronic. Her voice is guiding the effect instead of being its slave.
@@Tony-vf9zuThere is very slight auto tune, but you can obviously hear her belting through it to the point that it’s a non-factor. She’s the last person on earth who needs it, her vocals here are astonishing with or without!
Every time I hear her sing live her vocal prowess continues to amaze & astonish me with its strength & range. She is truly one of the greatest singers historically.
@@OfficialJalenSmith Sounds cool to me bro, but this kind'a advertising from you just feels cheap and nasty to me. Don't give up though, you're talented for sure
@@ginosolla8468nah it's just not as good. Every new song she releases can't be better than the previous. You're OLD enough to KNOW that that's how life works. Grow up.
@@jhadebredenkamp97Nah, the song is not only just singing part . You also need to hear the background music. It’s a part of art work. Actually, Chromatica & Disease are new peak of her career. Those are her best work since The Fame Monster. Disease’s & Chromatica’s production are perfect.
@@plantcraftie4141I'm sorry but comparing Lady Gaga's vocals to Taylor Swift is laughable. Lady Gaga is so much more talented. I don't care about all the hype around Taylor Swift
she has never sounded so good, her vocals are smooth like butter. update- im not saying she hasn’t always been this talented, yall are misinterpreting it and attacking me for no reason, this specific era, her voice just sounds so healthy im so proud of her. some of yall like to start arguments for no reason, how can a complement be considered “backhanded”, I’ve been a monster for as long as i can remember. stop assuming.. love you Gaga!!!
This performance is beyond words...a true artist, it does not matter how many hit songs she has...she it truly one of a kind, and raw emotions are her playground.
Tristemente así es al grado de perro compararla con Yuri y cometer la osadía de llamarla Yuri Gaga, háganme el chingado favor, Lady Gaga es única Yuri no le llega ni a los talones
I want like, a college basketball style tournament where the real winner is us the fans but like, have Mama Monster, Hayley Williams, Sia, Jenna McDougall, Lzzy Hale, Syd Duran (from Valora), Amy Lee, etc all kinda face off with their voices....'magine!
After multiple Grammys / Oscar / A Star is Born and 15 years people are still surprised about Gaga's vocals it's crazy ! This girl is the Goat of vocals
I’ve been a fan for over 15 years and I’m still surprised by this performance. Her vocals are always impeccable but this time they have something else. This is perfection, hands down her best vocal performance ever.
I don't understand how it's better than the recording. They're both amazing, but this is one of her top 5 performances, vocally speaking. I'm just blown away.
@@katerinarich9626 Yeah, there's definitely some post-production effects added. At 2:20 you can see the saxophonists give their all, yet we don't hear a single sound coming from them.
@@xenondoro8573na, if you listen closely you can hear the trumpet player (who doesn’t have a mic on his instrument) faintly! I think a lot of them being there is for the look ahahaha, but when he’s playing the trumpet in that circular motion you can kind of hear it at parts
It reminds me of back in the day when artists performed on MTV Live. If you love this , you should treat yourself to some of those performances. I'm particularly fond of Nirvana and Pearl Jam's performances, especially since Eddie Veder had his super long curly hair back then and was every teen girl's dream. I could see Lady G killing it on that scene, she'd be perfectly at home there and just like here, she'd own it
@@remigelmini Couldn't agree more. People act as if a song being #1 on a chart means that the song is good. It just means that it speaks to the broad mass and is potentially even being pushed by the label so hard. If you like a song then it's good. Gaga is gonna be just fine whether her songs are all over the top of the charts or not.
This was absolutely THE BEST VOCAL PERFORMANCE EVER!!!!! OMG! I too am so glad to have had the honor to witness this special talent! It just doesn't get any better than this! I am 80 years old and am so glad to have been able to hear Lady Gaga. What a treat to have watched her blossoming into this multi-talented dynamo! Keep evolving, Love, and follow your instincts. You are doing JUST FINE!
lol, well said. Movie wasn't terrible, just not what comic book fans wanted. Todd Phillips was clueless on how to do this movie. But no fault to Phoenix or Gaga.
@@madicelander far from clueless, the sequel has a clear vision and if you watch it immediately after the first joker you can see it complements and even elevates the first which was lacking extremely in the writing department. its just like what you said, people wanted a comic film, but idk why people expected that since its abundantly clear from the first one this was a elseworld tale
@@JesusGomez-ob2qt That’s fair. Just wish they hadn’t strayed that far away from the source material to begin with. Joker is the clown prince of crime who was very methodical in the source material. Even in the first Joker movie when Murray asks him about the “cause” he says “I don’t care about any of that” and is mosty just spontaneous. Just veers way off of the Joker lore. Anyways, nothing to do with GaGa who’s amazing lol.
@@madicelander well the movies are really just the killing joke and the dark knight returns adapted. this type of joker isn't new, also reminds me a lot off the joker presented in batman: nine lives.
Brings me to tears every time. She is one of the few artists who can dive into personal and troubling life's struggles, and shine light, beauty and rock&roll into those broken mirrors. Love you forever, Gaga.
No one holds a candle to this. The beautiful angelic falsetto, the high chest voice belts in the second chorus, that incredible bridge and her vocals morphing at every turn to emote exactly what she wants at any given time. This is an ARTIST and a VOCALIST and we are NOT worthy.
Babe save yourself never listen to this crap again Choose Life Battlecry Calling the Angels down, storming the gates of hell, devil you don't own my soul, taking back what the enemy stole In the Name of Jesus Christ, Gift of Salvation, King of kings and Lord of lords
@@Artfanbookfan25the real ones heard ARTPOP 10 years ago and realised that the real-deal had fully arrived. Not our or Gaga's fault that people didn't understand her talent back then.
This song is so underrated , the hate and criticism that joker 2 got overshadowed how anazing the harlequin album is,, and everyone moved on,, even lady gaga stopped posting or promoting anything related to harlequin album or joker 2,,, but this song happy mistake is a masterpiece , i hope it wil get its recognition ❤❤
creo que lo mejor que salió de el Joker 2 fue su álbum en solitario, revivió mi infancia, actualizando grandes éxitos sin bajarle la calidad, si no elevándolos
There’s clearly some audio engineering or tuning going on. These are not her raw vocals. She’s an incredible singer so this is not a bash on her singing ability. But it sounds crystal clear because there’s some help going on. I thought she was lip syncing at first. She’s talented and it was a beautiful performance regardless.
@@marcusjones6098 I would think the 2:55 is the most obvious where she’s moving up and down. Her voice is surprisingly stable, giving no signs of movement. You would expect to hear some pitchiness and movement, voice going in and out a bit. She’s bobbing but so is her microphone. And as you said she sounds surprisingly clear and stable . It’s sounds like it was recorded in a studio.
@@jdlt6273she’s literally trained to sing while doing the most crazy choreos in crazy outfits and heels for the first ten years of her career. She spent the last few years singing her lungs out to classic jazz songs at her residency. You think she’s gonna be struggling with a ballad while standing and barely moving around a small stage? I have to laugh
I don’t know why this gives me Radiohead Creep vibes. I absolutely love Gaga’s performance, dare I say she sounds even better here than she does in the album version? Totally obsessed.
Creep chorus goes like G B C Cm and this song C E F C, where both songs use the same trick of using a major chord that would normally be minor in the key of the song, which makes it really stand out from the average predictable 4 chord song. Basically the first 3 chords are transposed versions of what's used in Creep. They also both use sus4 accents.
Remember, guys- if you drink, never drink and drive. And NEVER ride with a person who is drunk. Value your life and the lives of others on the road! Thanks.
Please. Can none of you hear that weird vocal effect in the second half of the song? Like she's singing through some digital effect? Yes it's LIVE. But why that autotune effect?
I realized, I've been following Gaga's career for a half of my life (13 years) ♥️🖤 In 2010, I discovered Lady Gaga through her music videos on our ipod
Thank you for being part of our time. There will never be anyone like you again. Please stay with us until you’re a sweet grandma, and continue to share your beautiful love. In Seoul.
This song helped me make the choice whether to fight reoccurring cancer or not. I wasn’t going to, but I realized music still makes me feel and is worth fighting for!
Keep up the good fight cancer warrior! I know it’s a beast to fight, and you can and will beat it! Are you doing immunotherapy since this is a reoccurrence? Sending positive thoughts and prayers. If you want I will send you Reiki energy, but I need your approval. Hugs from a fellow cancer warrior. Kathy
@ thank you for the support, love! My Dr needs to do a wedge lung resection to test tissue and see if immunotherapy is even an option. At 16 I was diagnosed with stage 4 colorectal cancer. Was told I’d never be in remission and that seems to be true. I’ve had too much radiation for one person, and I feel too weak for chemo. Unfortunately I’m not certain that I’ll be able to move forward with anything due to having no family to help me after the surgery. Idk what I’m gonna do tbh. Right now I’m just trying to get drs to manage my pain. I got put on hospice for a year, but they just dropped me and I had to cold turkey come off 400mg morphine a day. I kinda just want to pray and smoke trees lol
@ so, some things have changed that have made me not want to move forward. 1) knowing the cancer will just come back. This is my 4th reoccurrence (5th cancer) since age 16 and I’m 32. 2) I don’t have the support of family. My mom is literally bipolar and unreliable. I was on hospice service and they were helping manage my pain; but I had to withdrawal from 400mg morphine daily due to them dropping me as a patient because of how my mom acted towards them
most newer fans dont know the horrible trauma she went too when she was a teenager it resulted her in her eventully being dignosed with PTSD and a nervous breakdown she has came so far im so proud of her xxxxxxx
this is so fucking captivating holy shit. i need this version to be on spotify like yesterday. the studio version doesn’t even compare. these vocals are quite literally insane 😭❤️🔥
I cried during the entire performance. I've been a fan of hers since 2009, when I was 11 years old. What makes me even happier is that I know she hasn't reached her peak yet. The best is yet to come, cuz, well she's Lady Gaga.
One of the most praiseworthy things about Lady Gaga is how her vocal skills have literally never stopped getting improved ever since the beginning of her career. A fact that not only proves how restlessly hard working she is but also makes stanning her an everlasting delight.
People really doesn't give her enough credit cause while she was improving BOTH in her singing and acting abilities, this girl had to fight with other serious stuff like PTSD and chronic pain all the time
0:48 She sang a little early before the music, she was live, her voice in this live version was so good. I've been her fan since 2007 and she always surprises me from time to time!!
TH-cam ihas plenty of performances from her at this level (or close). Try searching under Howard Stern, Sound Of Music, Superbowl National Anthem, Bewitched Bothered And Bewildered, Lush Life at the Lincoln Centre, Your Song (live version, not the rehearsal and not the record), Imagine, Bad Romance acoustic, Sting tribute,Stevie Wonder tribute, Sinatra tribute.
This is a performance of a lifetime for the one and only, Lady Gaga. Such powerful vocals here, this is simply phenomenal.
I just killed P Diddy in a vid 💪🏈🥃🔥
omg u got pinned by lady gaga
Such a Lucky Fan ❤, Being Pinned by World Famous Superstar ⭐
Omg????
omg gaga pinned your comment!!!!
Stunningly beautiful @@LadyGaga
omg Kelly knows what true talent sounds like!!!
Omg Kelly ❤
❤
Mother
100% agree, queen!
What the actual fuck with the vocals?!?!?! They are incredible!!!!!
always were! Listen to Red and Blue and You'll REALLY hear the resemblance!
There is a very minimal autotune effect on this. Can no one hear it? Very subtle
@@RiordanLadyGaga Yes, we can hear it. It annoys me to hear it, but I have to applaud how far the technology has come because it's barely perceptible. Gaga's voice shines through instead of becoming overly-electronic. Her voice is guiding the effect instead of being its slave.
@@RiordanLadyGaganot autotune
2:15 it's clearly a pure vocal with reverb and chorus
@@Tony-vf9zuThere is very slight auto tune, but you can obviously hear her belting through it to the point that it’s a non-factor. She’s the last person on earth who needs it, her vocals here are astonishing with or without!
She wasn't lying when she said she's a rockstar all those years ago.
ABSOLUTELY !!!!! :) And there are definitely Radiohead "Creep" vibes in that beautiful song :)
This comment so true! ❤
AND a God Damn Superstar!!! 💚💚💚💚
she’s always been real
And to think ten years ago everyone said she was "over" because ARTPOP "flopped". Gaga never gives up. 🎉❤
P.S. ARTPOP is my favourite Gaga album. 😊
PLEASE PUT THE LIVE VERSION ON SPOTIFY
@@_EthanBacaWHAHAHAHAHAHAH?????
It is here, why you want it there? #lovetoTH-camMusic
THE WORLD NEEDS TO KNOW THIS SONG
HER VOCALS ARE MAGIC
Every time I hear her sing live her vocal prowess continues to amaze & astonish me with its strength & range. She is truly one of the greatest singers historically.
@@deewanderingminstrelfact
Is my music good? I wish to grow better
@@OfficialJalenSmith Sounds cool to me bro, but this kind'a advertising from you just feels cheap and nasty to me. Don't give up though, you're talented for sure
then stream it on spotify, apple music, itunes, youtube, amazon music etc.
SHE IS ON HER BEST VOCAL
Every single time she starts a new era I think she can't get even better vocally AND THEN SHE DOES IT
@@erikperhs_ PERIOD!
I agree
@@erikperhs_PERIOD
Is my music good? I wish to grow better
So fucking grateful to life for having been born in the same era as Lady Gaga. Such a legend!
❤❤❤
😭😭😭😭 that is exactly what I feel
me too man 🥹🥹
@Japantour2024i hope you aren’t playing around cuz i just gave you a like for that
Chill
This should go viral like “ Always Remember Us This Way “. Deserve 1 Billion
I agree with you 100%. But I think young people don’t understand and appreciate nostalgic music like past generations.
Be still my heart. Brilliant❤
@@ginosolla8468nah it's just not as good. Every new song she releases can't be better than the previous. You're OLD enough to KNOW that that's how life works. Grow up.
@@jhadebredenkamp97Nah, the song is not only just singing part . You also need to hear the background music. It’s a part of art work. Actually, Chromatica & Disease are new peak of her career. Those are her best work since The Fame Monster. Disease’s & Chromatica’s production are perfect.
Her best televised performance hands down ! THE VOCALS !!!!
🙏🙏🙏🙌👍👍❤️❤️
One thing mother will do is, feed us with them vocals. So much control yet so much vulnerability at the same time
You are CORRECT
But
Listen & Try Million Reason LIVE
Aí vc exagerou g4y
totally agree ! this is freaking iconic !!!
Very, very, very rare that a live version is better than the studio version, but this is. This is art with a melody.
Same with her version of Paparazzi on her first SNL performance. Even better than the album version.
I thought the same.
That’s Gaga’s field of expertise. Always been this way.
Her live performance are always better than her studio
I know!! They need to put this on Spotify rn!!
Not Gaga casually giving one of the best live performances on a fuckin daily show
We might be witnessing her peak vocal-wise at the age of 38. INSANE.
With her drive and talent I honestly think Stefani is still climbing 🌋🙌🏼
@@randicamI hope
Tiene un poder vocal increíble. En la canción en vivo de los Oscar en homenaje a Julie Andrews fue muy buena también
Lana Del Rey, Taylor Swift, Miley Cyrus are also witnessing their peak at this age tho, not uncommon
@@plantcraftie4141I'm sorry but comparing Lady Gaga's vocals to Taylor Swift is laughable. Lady Gaga is so much more talented. I don't care about all the hype around Taylor Swift
she has never sounded so good, her vocals are smooth like butter. update- im not saying she hasn’t always been this talented, yall are misinterpreting it and attacking me for no reason, this specific era, her voice just sounds so healthy im so proud of her. some of yall like to start arguments for no reason, how can a complement be considered “backhanded”, I’ve been a monster for as long as i can remember. stop assuming.. love you Gaga!!!
Where have you been the last 10 years? Gaga has delivered many beautiful vocal performances
@@jesuusch this !
Is my music good? I wish to grow better
She's always sounded like this
@@jesuuschthat wasn’t in contention. I agree with OP, something undefinable (at least to me) made this a little… elevated, even for Gaga.
one of the best vocal performances of your career. love u gaga
If not THE best
@@ericafranco8841 well, arguably. There were times she went absolutely crazy, but this one is definitely way up there
This performance is beyond words...a true artist, it does not matter how many hit songs she has...she it truly one of a kind, and raw emotions are her playground.
I think people always forget how talented this woman is.
Tristemente así es al grado de perro compararla con Yuri y cometer la osadía de llamarla Yuri Gaga, háganme el chingado favor, Lady Gaga es única Yuri no le llega ni a los talones
I want like, a college basketball style tournament where the real winner is us the fans but like, have Mama Monster, Hayley Williams, Sia, Jenna McDougall, Lzzy Hale, Syd Duran (from Valora), Amy Lee, etc all kinda face off with their voices....'magine!
it's true, I always thought she is a step above since the begining
I agree completely she can do anything
No they don’t. Stfu with your hipster superiority complex.
When lady Gaga sings, I freeze.
💟 Yes;
frozen-in-place,
with unexpected tears filling my eyes.
Iv been frozen for 4 hours
Exactly
Crazy cause when she sings live I melt. Saw her jazz show and chromatica. The jazz show literally calmed my soul. Her voice…
goosebumps
After multiple Grammys / Oscar / A Star is Born and 15 years people are still surprised about Gaga's vocals it's crazy ! This girl is the Goat of vocals
A lot of people still sleep on her TALENT
@@Santo-rr4vnThey Are haters becouse she like LGBT+ population. Many homophobik people hate Her.
she s everything, since 2008, hands fucking down
I’ve been a fan for over 15 years and I’m still surprised by this performance. Her vocals are always impeccable but this time they have something else. This is perfection, hands down her best vocal performance ever.
@@CG-vt1dvyeah, I feel the same
I don't understand how it's better than the recording. They're both amazing, but this is one of her top 5 performances, vocally speaking. I'm just blown away.
We are witnessing one of the greatest artists of our generation in a seriously prime era and it is an absolute treat.
You can tell by her interview with Jimmy that she's very in love right now. It shows in her performance, she is on fire.
Of all time. She is everything
Remember when they called her a flop?? 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 BITCH WHERE ?!
History will know her as the greatest of all time.
She is on top of the world ❤
She sounds better than ever!
Her voice is much better
this is STEFANI GERMANOTTA! Serving us with her Stefani Germanotta vocals and I'm glad she still has that Powerful voice.
That's the thing i'm always proud of her, she's constantly improve herself.
She is using an autotune plugin. You can hear it especially in the bridge. Still great.
This is not one of Gaga's best live performances. This is one of the best live performances period. Of any artist.
Period
It doesn’t sound live…
@@katerinarich9626 Yeah, there's definitely some post-production effects added. At 2:20 you can see the saxophonists give their all, yet we don't hear a single sound coming from them.
@@xenondoro8573na, if you listen closely you can hear the trumpet player (who doesn’t have a mic on his instrument) faintly! I think a lot of them being there is for the look ahahaha, but when he’s playing the trumpet in that circular motion you can kind of hear it at parts
@@ewanaye The trumpet player does have a mic on his instrument 2:35
I don't understand how this masterpiece doesn't have 100M views by now!!??!!
This song is giving me so much comfort.
Así es mejor, pocos sabemos de esto
The song was old and stale and her singing was old and stale.
@@hmanuel7138ur describing ur self hahah
Coming from someone so ancient@@hmanuel7138
OOMG the VOCALS
Mama ATE
i love seeing her perfom in these shows like she used to 😭💚
Amazinggggggggggggg ❤
Ya hear me!? Ate!!!!! And the aesthetic? Punk rock indie whatever you wanna call it. I'm heat for it
Yessss,omg💕💕💕
Que haces aquí monster
Salúdame a sirkael
This is one of the best live performances I have ever heard. I will be coming back to this for years I am certain of it
It reminds me of back in the day when artists performed on MTV Live. If you love this , you should treat yourself to some of those performances. I'm particularly fond of Nirvana and Pearl Jam's performances, especially since Eddie Veder had his super long curly hair back then and was every teen girl's dream. I could see Lady G killing it on that scene, she'd be perfectly at home there and just like here, she'd own it
Your post hits the bullseye for me. Perfectly said.
@@KoolKats5
Eddie Fucking Vedder
Treat yo'self indeed.
Definately me too...
Queen of vocals and the universe.
@Japantour2024I hope you get your camera ❤️
@Japantour2024 buy it for yourself, those conditions from your parents are so illogic.
Goosebumps ❤ what a voice what talent 😊
Here after Disease live, I can't believe this was not a hit 😞 it deserved better.
I feel you!! 😔one of her best song released this past year so far..
Just enjoy it, she does not need to prove anything anymore, she is the greatest of them all
@@remigelmini Couldn't agree more. People act as if a song being #1 on a chart means that the song is good. It just means that it speaks to the broad mass and is potentially even being pushed by the label so hard. If you like a song then it's good. Gaga is gonna be just fine whether her songs are all over the top of the charts or not.
I have the same sentiment. I wonder why it's not a hit. It's okay. Lady Gaga is still number 1 in my heart. Keep doing what makes you happy Lady!❤
Have a little more patience
Just perfect.. give her a GRAMMY best pop solo perfomance
And an oscar! (Hoping this song will accompany the movie nomination)
Beyonce is gonna be so jealous of her 😢
THIS is how to scream a vocal without shouting 🔥🔥🔥🔥
How about BELTING
@@kukuhsantoso5190 how about just PHENOMENAL
YESSSSS
She just said “I’m still here bitches”! Holy crap that was phenomenal 🤯
😆 In essense, 💯❗
Yes
Gaga is 4to artist in the Word
105 M
I'm crying. It's so beautiful.
This live presentation alone is worth all the 200 million budget of that film!
This was absolutely THE BEST VOCAL PERFORMANCE EVER!!!!! OMG! I too am so glad to have had the honor to witness this special talent! It just doesn't get any better than this! I am 80 years old and am so glad to have been able to hear Lady Gaga. What a treat to have watched her blossoming into this multi-talented dynamo! Keep evolving, Love, and follow your instincts. You are doing JUST FINE!
lol, well said. Movie wasn't terrible, just not what comic book fans wanted. Todd Phillips was clueless on how to do this movie. But no fault to Phoenix or Gaga.
@@madicelander far from clueless, the sequel has a clear vision and if you watch it immediately after the first joker you can see it complements and even elevates the first which was lacking extremely in the writing department. its just like what you said, people wanted a comic film, but idk why people expected that since its abundantly clear from the first one this was a elseworld tale
@@JesusGomez-ob2qt That’s fair. Just wish they hadn’t strayed that far away from the source material to begin with. Joker is the clown prince of crime who was very methodical in the source material. Even in the first Joker movie when Murray asks him about the “cause” he says “I don’t care about any of that” and is mosty just spontaneous. Just veers way off of the Joker lore. Anyways, nothing to do with GaGa who’s amazing lol.
@@madicelander well the movies are really just the killing joke and the dark knight returns adapted. this type of joker isn't new, also reminds me a lot off the joker presented in batman: nine lives.
The "my head is filled with broken mirrors" ...holy shit 😢
I love this song
2:02 and 2:013
The vocals ..dam girl
I know right, this song is so deep shows a lot of vulnerability from her
@@TheMolabolaexactly, 12 days ago was my 1st time listening to it and it's been on repeat since
I've watched this performance at least 50 times in the last day.
Hahahaha same here
Same
Now gonna watch 50 more times today
I'm on #5 of 500 😂❤
Especially the Crazzyyy part
I just cant believe this is free to watch. She is so incredibly talented
Such haunting vocals. She always gives her all in her performances.
Lady Gaga is the most talented and versatile artist of our generation, she’s a living legend and we’re lucky to be living in her era.
You say versatile but it's all still broadly pop
It's showtunes pop and dance pop
Pretty much every song has 4/4 time and very very rarely changes key
@@NicolaCrive 💯
Yes!!!
Gaga, if you’re reading this know that I admire your work since day 1 and I wish you happiness
@@Tony-vf9zuway to completely ignore the fact that she is also an actress and fashion designer- both art forms in their own right.
Brings me to tears every time. She is one of the few artists who can dive into personal and troubling life's struggles, and shine light, beauty and rock&roll into those broken mirrors. Love you forever, Gaga.
Kinda sad this masterpiece gets overlooked while Die With a Smile & Disease are killing it. This is another side of Gaga that i personally ADORE.❤
yess! it deserves more credit!! this whole album does
I fuckn need this version on spotify. I'm going insane, how can this be better than the studio version? HOLY FUCK I NEED IT ON SPOTIFY RIGHT NOW
Gaga is the mother of live vocals, always singing better than any studio version... she was born to perform 😊 ❤
Live is better but the album version is still so good
@@KevRoVa she's definitely one of the best in history. what a singer. what a perfection. it's a pleasure to listen to her, incredible. ❤️
me too!!!!! i heard she is uploading her live performances from the album premier the other day !!! so let’s hope
@Beatriz_Benassi she isn't one of the best
No one holds a candle to this. The beautiful angelic falsetto, the high chest voice belts in the second chorus, that incredible bridge and her vocals morphing at every turn to emote exactly what she wants at any given time. This is an ARTIST and a VOCALIST and we are NOT worthy.
PREACH!
When I want to work on my singing I put on her live songs to improve. Only she and Karen Carpenter have this unique gift
Yes we don't deserve her
Honestly….amen
I believe Chappell Roan is on this way as well, she has turned out to be a great singer, with a very truly powerful and dynamic voice.
I listen to this song everyday and feel comforted. Thank you, Lady Gaga.
i hate that this song didnt get the attention it deserved. its so underrated. i dont even think it charted on the hot100
Becouse of joker 2 and its so sad . This song its wonderfull
Happy mistake is a powerful ballad written and produced by Gaga that deserves a lot of worldwide recognition.
아 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 진짜 몇번째 보는거여 ㅠ 제발 콘서트해줘요 한국에서
Babe save yourself never listen to this crap again Choose Life
Battlecry Calling the Angels down, storming the gates of hell, devil you don't own my soul, taking back what the enemy stole In the Name of Jesus Christ, Gift of Salvation, King of kings and Lord of lords
나 같아도 한국 안오겠음 …
한국 안와도 좋으니까 계속 활동 해줬으면 좋겠다
어느 기점으로 보컬면에서 레전드 찍고 있는 것 같음
내한 딱 한 번만 더.. 흑흑😢😢
That was nuts. She is the real deal. Simply amazing. Perfect.
And to think that ten years ago everyone said she was "over". Gaga never gives up. 🎉❤
Hard agree
@@Artfanbookfan25the real ones heard ARTPOP 10 years ago and realised that the real-deal had fully arrived. Not our or Gaga's fault that people didn't understand her talent back then.
Does no one else hear the autotune while she's singing?
This song is so underrated , the hate and criticism that joker 2 got overshadowed how anazing the harlequin album is,, and everyone moved on,, even lady gaga stopped posting or promoting anything related to harlequin album or joker 2,,, but this song happy mistake is a masterpiece , i hope it wil get its recognition ❤❤
I emphatically agree with you 100%
a tragedy honestly 💔
i absolutely love this album, this one of my favorite Gaga projects and Joker was amazing too!
creo que lo mejor que salió de el Joker 2 fue su álbum en solitario, revivió mi infancia, actualizando grandes éxitos sin bajarle la calidad, si no elevándolos
@@DimmeJohhank9 english please
@@olive_ordinary i hope she performs this in her lg7 tour
Her vocals have really improved in the last 10-15 years!
She’s such an excellent singer
Ladies and Gentlemen! There is a genius!
Omg Lady Gaga giving vocals. She’s a true artist. ❤❤❤
This is one of the best vocal performances of her career
I absolutely love how she’s never afraid to reinvent herself. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
These are the clearest vocals I’ve ever heard from her live
There’s clearly some audio engineering or tuning going on. These are not her raw vocals.
She’s an incredible singer so this is not a bash on her singing ability. But it sounds crystal clear because there’s some help going on.
I thought she was lip syncing at first.
She’s talented and it was a beautiful performance regardless.
I did suspect a little. Are there any clear giveaways?
@@marcusjones6098 I would think the 2:55 is the most obvious where she’s moving up and down. Her voice is surprisingly stable, giving no signs of movement. You would expect to hear some pitchiness and movement, voice going in and out a bit. She’s bobbing but so is her microphone.
And as you said she sounds surprisingly clear and stable . It’s sounds like it was recorded in a studio.
@@jdlt6273 You are dreaming, the mic is not moving. You can hear her breathing all the time.
@@jdlt6273she’s literally trained to sing while doing the most crazy choreos in crazy outfits and heels for the first ten years of her career. She spent the last few years singing her lungs out to classic jazz songs at her residency. You think she’s gonna be struggling with a ballad while standing and barely moving around a small stage? I have to laugh
I haven’t stopped thinking about this performance every day since it aired
One of the best gaga's performance, clean voice, being angelic and rockstar at the same time.
I don’t know why this gives me Radiohead Creep vibes. I absolutely love Gaga’s performance, dare I say she sounds even better here than she does in the album version? Totally obsessed.
I feel the same! I can feel like this is her Creep 😍
It sounds like Creep because both songs have the same chord sequence in their chorus. For musicians: they both start with I - III - IV.
It's the same chord progression lol
Sameee
Creep chorus goes like G B C Cm and this song C E F C, where both songs use the same trick of using a major chord that would normally be minor in the key of the song, which makes it really stand out from the average predictable 4 chord song. Basically the first 3 chords are transposed versions of what's used in Creep. They also both use sus4 accents.
QUEEN OF MUSIC! QUEEN OF MOVIES ! 👑
Movies what????!!! Tell me wish one's 😮😮😮😮😮😊
@@luisaguirre514 all of them
I love Gaga ❤
@@luisaguirre514she always got the praise from critic even maybe her movies are flop sometimes
She is absolutely great actress
SONG OF THE YEAR, MOVIE OF THE YEAR, ALBUM OF THE YEAR... THANK YOU QUEEN OF MUSIC!!!!!
The movie is going to fail hard by the look of things
Yes ❤
Remember, guys- if you drink, never drink and drive. And NEVER ride with a person who is drunk. Value your life and the lives of others on the road! Thanks.
@Lady_Georgina 58% RT, 6/10IMDB. Doesn't bode well
@@GIBBO4182 Some people on IMDB gave it a 10/10 though. It was higher. Some of them liked it. Some of them don’t
Phenomenal. Her voice is superb. Love the raspy growl towards the end.
Absoulutely fucking beautiful song.
CLEARLY not lip syncing, NO PRE-RECORDING, AND NO pitchiness. JUST PURE LIVE VOCALS
The way she missed the first chorus gave me the validation that she will never betray us with any lipsyncing unlike other artists.
@@raymondpastoshe made a happy mistake because it sounded heavenly ❤️
Please. Can none of you hear that weird vocal effect in the second half of the song? Like she's singing through some digital effect? Yes it's LIVE. But why that autotune effect?
@@RiordanLadyGagacould you tell me what minute please? Thanks!!
@@RiordanLadyGaga i think that's vocal compression, not autotune.
I realized, I've been following Gaga's career for a half of my life (13 years) ♥️🖤
In 2010, I discovered Lady Gaga through her music videos on our ipod
Thank you for being part of our time. There will never be anyone like you again. Please stay with us until you’re a sweet grandma, and continue to share your beautiful love.
In Seoul.
It’s been a long time since I’ve heard a new song of such an epic magnitude.
My god this women is incredibly talented 💯👌🏼
New Favorite Lady Gaga performance unlocked.
This song helped me make the choice whether to fight reoccurring cancer or not. I wasn’t going to, but I realized music still makes me feel and is worth fighting for!
Keep up the good fight cancer warrior! I know it’s a beast to fight, and you can and will beat it! Are you doing immunotherapy since this is a reoccurrence? Sending positive thoughts and prayers. If you want I will send you Reiki energy, but I need your approval. Hugs from a fellow cancer warrior. Kathy
@ thank you for the support, love!
My Dr needs to do a wedge lung resection to test tissue and see if immunotherapy is even an option. At 16 I was diagnosed with stage 4 colorectal cancer. Was told I’d never be in remission and that seems to be true.
I’ve had too much radiation for one person, and I feel too weak for chemo. Unfortunately I’m not certain that I’ll be able to move forward with anything due to having no family to help me after the surgery. Idk what I’m gonna do tbh. Right now I’m just trying to get drs to manage my pain. I got put on hospice for a year, but they just dropped me and I had to cold turkey come off 400mg morphine a day.
I kinda just want to pray and smoke trees lol
fight! life is worth it! 🥹
Life is worth fighting for. As they said in the movie Galaxy Quest; “Never give up.Never Surrender!” May you beat cancer once and for all !!!!!!
@ so, some things have changed that have made me not want to move forward. 1) knowing the cancer will just come back. This is my 4th reoccurrence (5th cancer) since age 16 and I’m 32.
2) I don’t have the support of family. My mom is literally bipolar and unreliable. I was on hospice service and they were helping manage my pain; but I had to withdrawal from 400mg morphine daily due to them dropping me as a patient because of how my mom acted towards them
I love when she notices the guitarist and the both move to the music in sync
el otro musico detrás igual extasiado por el momento, creo que estar ahí no es lo mismo que verlo en TH-cam
her voice is always giving me chills
Gaga is art
How is this song not on top of the charts?! It is phenomenal! People are clearly tastelesss
tampoco lo entiendo...
I don’t understand the taste in music today I’m 64 years old and maybe too sentimental but songs like this make me emotional .
That's talent folks
i dont know how many times i saw this video. Incredible performance.
Best vocals of her career. She dug deep into her soul for this song. This is the first time in a while I have been excited for new GaGa material.
most newer fans dont know the horrible trauma she went too when she was a teenager it resulted her in her eventully being dignosed with PTSD and a nervous breakdown she has came so far im so proud of her xxxxxxx
She is using an autotune plugin in this performance. It's subtle, but you can really hear it in the bridge.
@@emboar7247it’s an ‘echo’ effect. Autotune is waaayy different.
Vocal perfection, my favorite version of Gaga is back
2:06-2:20 chills the vocal acrobatics are insane mother is back
I think this is the most impressed I ever was about her vocal performance. And she's been incredible for a long time.
3:39 You can literally hear her panting and yet delivering such flawless vocals... amazing
that has me shocked, even when she is tired her voice is so clean and beutiful, amazing
Can we see the words to this?
@@Ailurvsthat was dramatic style
That's part of the feeling the song needs to give , and I love it , it's so well thought out.❤
this is so fucking captivating holy shit. i need this version to be on spotify like yesterday. the studio version doesn’t even compare. these vocals are quite literally insane 😭❤️🔥
Fact
Applause to the band & the guitar player 👏
This music is so so incredible 😭
She is so brilliant. This live is even better than the studio rendition.... Stunning vocals.
this is insane. On so many levels just WOW.
BRAZIL LOVES YOU GAGA, YOUR VOICE IS INCREDIBLE ❤❤
My wife and I have been listening to this song and crying
I cried during the entire performance. I've been a fan of hers since 2009, when I was 11 years old. What makes me even happier is that I know she hasn't reached her peak yet. The best is yet to come, cuz, well she's Lady Gaga.
Sameeee. Paws up 🐾
One of the most praiseworthy things about Lady Gaga is how her vocal skills have literally never stopped getting improved ever since the beginning of her career. A fact that not only proves how restlessly hard working she is but also makes stanning her an everlasting delight.
People really doesn't give her enough credit cause while she was improving BOTH in her singing and acting abilities, this girl had to fight with other serious stuff like PTSD and chronic pain all the time
This live version is BEAUTIFUL !
Absolutely whimpering crying after witnessing this performance
I think that is possibly the best live vocals I’ve ever heard! Out of this world! Wow
The bridge is so deep and beautiful
The fact that I liked this more than the studio version says a lot. Her vocals and storytelling sure is something.
0:48 She sang a little early before the music, she was live, her voice in this live version was so good. I've been her fan since 2007 and she always surprises me from time to time!!
Vocals are that good that even the haters can't believe it,
. she improves her vocals' range year after year ✨️
I think the “little early before the music” was a nice touch
Also at 1:40 you hear that "p" clear live❤
And at 3:37 you can CLEARLY hear her breaths as she's moving and grabbing stuff
I always loved her. Her depth , her emotional expression is gold
I honestly had no idea she could sing like this. Jesus she has an incredible voice. I’d like to hear more music like this from her.
But sadly music like this can't be a mega HIT like poker face or born this way
TH-cam ihas plenty of performances from her at this level (or close). Try searching under Howard Stern, Sound Of Music, Superbowl National Anthem, Bewitched Bothered And Bewildered, Lush Life at the Lincoln Centre, Your Song (live version, not the rehearsal and not the record), Imagine, Bad Romance acoustic, Sting tribute,Stevie Wonder tribute, Sinatra tribute.
You have to hear her Stevie wonder cover!
You need to go to her jazz concerts. I’ve gone twice. Better than her pop concerts. Her energy is uncanny.
Gypsy, always remember us this way, I'll never love again, and my favorite, is that alright. Where you been? Have you heard her sing bang bang live?
I feel like she's singing like she's drowning in the lyrics. Perfectly singing the Ballad queen song.
I didn't ask to be slayed this hard. She is Harley, David Bowie and Gaga all at once.
Yes! I have always thought she was a lot more channeling Bowie than Madonna- she is super versatile as he was.
@@MarinaLindsay-TheHistoryofSara indeed!
Lady Gaga is a once in a lifetime talent
Been a fan since 2009 and i'm still amazed by her talent-
sameeee
Her vocal is insane as always sheesh