Rachmaninow: 3. Sinfonie ∙ hr-Sinfonieorchester ∙ Andris Poga
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ก.พ. 2025
- Sergej Rachmaninow:
3. Sinfonie a-Moll op. 44 ∙
I. Lento - Allegro moderato 00:00 ∙
II. Adagio ma non troppo - Allegro vivace - Tempo come prima 14:10 ∙
III. Allegro - Allegro vivace - Allegro (Tempo primo) -
Andante con moto - Allegretto - Allegro - Allegro vivace 26:46 ∙
hr-Sinfonieorchester - Frankfurt Radio Symphony ∙
Andris Poga, Dirigent ∙
hr-Sinfoniekonzert ∙
Alte Oper Frankfurt, 20. Januar 2023 ∙
Website: www.hr-sinfonie... ∙
Facebook: / hrsinfonieorchester ∙
ARD Mediathek: www.ardmediath... ∙
#4K
© 2023
Hessischer Rundfunk (hr)
25:01 is the most beautiful melody I've ever heard
The magic of our beloved Rachmaninoff :)
He wrote so many other great melodies, I can't even decide which one to be my favourite.
I know this symphony since childhood , heard hundreds of recordings and now as a man of 68, I can honestly say that I never heard it so transparant, so balanced and with so much musicianship as in this wonderful performance : great conductor, great orchestra ! My God I am really overwhelmed with joy by this ......
me too, I live here in San Francisco and this morning our classical station KDFC played this piece. I was stunned at the amount of ideas that Mr.
Rachmaninoff has in this symphony. He's so confident and fluid with his variations on themes. It's a monumental piece that rivals anything by any
composer from any era
I couldn't agree more!
@@spactick You love music and symphonies. That is it's own reward. Rachmaninoff will never return. That's okay. We love what he did.
What a wonderful performance of this marvelous symphony. Bravo to all the players and their fabulous conductor!!
This conductor! What a big heart! What a lovely attitude to this music, to this marvelous team!
This symphony is so special and underrated.
not really
Andris Poga (born 29 June 1980, in Riga) is a Latvian orchestral conductor. From 2011 to 2014, Poga was assistant conductor to Paavo Järvi at Orchestre de Paris. From 2012 to 2014, he was assistant conductor of the Boston Symphony Orchestra.
Thanks for that. Nice to know.
Ach, Rachmaninoff! Wo wäre ich bloß ohne ihn?
Seine Musik ist einfach anders. Anders als alle anderen Komponisten.
Seine Musik berührt den Menschen in seiner Seele, in seinem Herzen.
Kein anderer Komponist schafft das.
Auch, und vor allem bei mir persönlich.
In den 2-3 Jahren, in denen ich ihn nun schon kenne, habe ich vieles erlebt.
Kummer, Leid, Freude, Liebe und vor allem Sehnsucht. In all diesen Momenten finde ich Zuflucht bei der Musik von Rachmaninoff.
Wie oft habe ich mich auf eine Parkbank gesetzt, in die unendlichen Weiten des Himmels geschaut und dabei sein zweites Klavierkonzert auf dem Handy abgespielt?
Seine Musik ist anders. Sie berührt mich in meinem Herzen und meiner Seele. Sie weckt Emotionen und Gefühle, die ich noch nie zuvor empfunden habe.
Für keinen anderen Komponisten wende ich so viel Zeit auf, um seine Musik zu hören, zu verstehen und sie am Klavier zu lernen (Videos davon sind auf meinem Kanal zu sehen).
Sei es nun das melancholische Trio zwischen Horn, Cello und Klarinette zu Beginn der Sinfonie, der ekstatische Gefühlsausbruch bei 4:05, der in mir so viele Emotionen und Sehnsüchte weckt, oder der herzzerreißende zweite Satz mit seinem wunderschönen Thema und den drei Höhepunkten bei 16:50 (vor allem der so simple, aber dennoch wunderschöne und emotionale es-Moll Akkord bei 17:03), 18:50 und 24:39.
Diese fantastischen Teile ab 6:45 (man beachte das bewegte Lächeln des Dirigenten), 28:26, 29:34, 36:05 und 37:10 lassen mich an Sehnsucht nach einer praktisch geliebten Person denken, die ich nur optisch kenne. Teile, deren Magie, deren unterdrückte Leidenschaft mich daher immer wieder sprachlos macht!
Und diese Sinfonie steht ganz im Schatten seiner Zweiten! Generell bevorzuge ich seine früheren Werke, auch wenn ich den Opera 43-45 sehr viel abgewinnen kann.
Rachmaninoff, danke für alles!
Alles Gute zum 150.!
This is a marvelous performance. Very very well conducted and played. Also I must say, the sound and video quality are out of this world. Rachmaninoff would have proud. Thank you so much for uploading this for all to enjoy.
These musicians are first rate. What a joy it must be to be in the middle of that orchestra hearing these masters at work
He exposes a lot of nuance and subtlety that's lost in many of the notable interpretations I've heard over the years. Refreshing!
A cool summer rain with loving couples dodging the drips. How lovely!
Una maravilla la interpretación de esa sinfonía de Rachmaninoff!!👏👏👏 Me gustó el gesto final del director, entregando las flores a Clarita Andrada, la flautista mas brillante de cuantas he escuchado en mucho tiempo!!!❤👏👏👏🥰Felicitaciones a toda la orquesta! Son excelentes!!!!
Saludos desde Argentina!🙋🏻♂️❤🤗
24:37 - one of the most beautiful themes ever written....I challenge anyone to withold his tears while listening to this absolute beauty!
This Symphony is full of them!
2:15, 6:45, 11:34, 12:55, 28:26, 29:34, 36:05 are just some examples.
@@mangomerkel2005 absolutely true, I agree, but if I can make an analogy: the world is also full of women, some of them more beautiful than the other....and than you find one that leaves you speechless.... I feel the same about that theme.
@@parintelebaiazid80 Hehe, I like that one! :D
There are countless incredible melodies written by our beloved Rachmaninoff, you simply can't choose one of them. You just get overwhelmed by the one you love the most.
@@mangomerkel2005 beautifully said, my friend!❤To me Rachmaninoff is the absolute Grandfather of heartwrenchingly beautiful themes! And on that note, if I'm allowed to pick the absolute most beautiful theme ever written in the history of music, I would dare to choose Rachmaninoff's 18th Variation from Rhapsody on a Theme by Paganini!❤I'm being subjective, of course, but I'm sure you would agree! Thank you! 🤗
@@parintelebaiazid80 Yeah, this Variation is indeed sublime. I would maybe choose this one or the second theme (in Eb-Major) of the first Movement of his 2nd Piano Concerto.
I you're interested, I am uploading videos of me playing Rachmaninoff
The second movement feels like a dream...
Buen rendimiento de la Orquesta Sinfónica de Frankfurt. Y su primera flautista, siempre muy expresiva, es soberbia.
thank you for this deeply appreciated post. wonderful playing and interpretation. I have long been very fond of this symphony and find its relative neglect relative to no. 2 and the Symphonic Dances unjustified. I love the sunset glow of this work. hope to able to watch this orchestra live sometime
Bellísma música!
This is my favorite of Rachmaninoff's symphonies. It's such a mature work, and you can hear Rachmaninoff pondering life and the meaning of existence in this piece. There is no other symphony like this.
Even though in my mind, the 2nd can't be toppled, I totally agree with you. There is no other symphony like this. There is no other composer who touched my mind and my soul in the way Rachmaninoff did, does, and will do.
Da bin ich sprachlos. Einfach hervorragend! 💛
16:41 is one of my favorite parts. There's something about it that's just so mystical, serene, and sensuous at the same time, then gloriously melting into tender nostalgia. My other favorite part is 25:01. Just pure serenity and passion! I absolutely love this criminally underrated symphony!
Tender nostalgia --> Rachmaninoff
The only thing I would change is playing the turn into eb-Minor at 17:03 a bit more ritenuto, like Pletnev does. But nevertheless, this is by far my favourite recording, followed by Rachmaninoff himself.
@mangomerkel2005 I hear what you mean. I also wish the part at 25:01 was a bit more ritenuto. While I love this recording, my personal favorite is the Ashkenazy recording
I. Lento - Allegro moderato - Allegro (0:03)
II. Adagio ma non troppo - Allegro vivace (14:10)
III. Allegro - Allegro vivace - Allegro (26:46)
By far the best version on the web!
großartige Musik in einer fantastischen Aufführung. Bravo für Orchester und Dirigent. Vielen Dank fürs Hochladen!
Masterpiece!
It's so beautiful. I love it.❤️🩷💜🫶🫶🙏🙏
best performance and camera work appreciate it!
the second movement is silk made from god.
A thousand thanks for this wonderful rendition! What an amazing symphony!
How sad that he wrote so few symphonies; how wonderful that he wrote so many! Each is filled with delightful melodies and unforgettable segments. To me, his second will never be topped, but the second movement and part of the finale in this, his third, are top notch also. Simply remarkable and stirring to sensitive minds and sad hearts. I first heard his work as a teenager, but it haunts me still today at seventy-four. Thank God for Rachmaninoff.
Well expressed, especially regarding the 2nd. But the 1st movement also has some incredibly beautiful moments, e.g. 6:45!
I am awestruck by this. Always loved this symphony and this performance is so dynamic and exhilarating...
What a wonderful performance! Nico Kruger, Johannesburg, South Africa.
1st movement (skip)
0:04 begins
2nd movement
14:14 begins
3rd movement
26:50 begins
As always great playing from this orchestra. Paul Kletzki’s late 60’s recording will always remain for me the benchmark as he keeps up the momentum where most others fail. Having said that this is overall a really enjoyable performance of a great and somewhat underrated symphony by one of the 20th c greatest composers.
Большое спасибо за хорошую музыку!!!!!! Успехов и здоровья!!!!!
😊😊a refreshingly excellent performance
Within the first minute of this I filled up with joyful tears and goosebumps! I have listened to this piece so many times and never heard such an incredible performance and production. It is one of my favourite pieces of music, so I am very fussy about interpretations. Sometimes you wonder whether the orchestra actually rehearsed, this version leaves one in no doubt they did. The attention to rhythmic detail is so important with Rachmaninov. Bravo and thank you!
I've always thought Rachmaninoff's Third Symphony, and to a lesser extent, his First, to be underrated in comparison to his more popular Second. The First is more dramatic and the Second is more Romantic, but the Third combines those two qualities in a most effective way. And did Rachmaninoff ever compose a more meltingly lovely melody than that of its finale (first entering at 2:17)? Great performance here by Andris Poga and the FRSO!
To me 38:53 part is the meltingly lovely melody. It just felt like very innocent, playfull, and felt like hoemtown very far away. Or even nostalgic😊
Clarinet embouchure perfect 🤗
Bravo Bravo 👋👋👋
Been waiting for a high-quality video performance of this symphony for a long time (for many years the only videos on TH-cam didn't have live visuals, or had low quality video). The audio and musical quality is also excellent; there are many lines I can hear with crystal clarity in this performance that I didn't really notice before!
Very true. This performance has also a lot of great expressions of the musical ideas that usually feel kind of muddled. With this one I think there is so much feeling in it.
I agree better tempo and phrasing than Jarvi which seems to be the only other video of this under appreciated Symphony on you tube
wonderful thank you
A roaring applause from here on San Francisco you guys. What a marvelous performance
Bellissimo ! Bravi !!!!
Se aprecia una orquesta feliz,y de mucho compañerismo.😊
Sehr schön, gekonnt auf hervorragendem Niveau!👍
Fine.
Чудесный концерт (и музыка, и исполнение, и исполнители)! Большое спасибо!
Could our experience with this orchestra be any better. Yes. How is that? Its now in UHD-4K!
Recuerdo que a mi papá, le encantaba esta sinfonía ❤😊 , Máravillosa versión. Saludos desde Argentina.
Wunderschöne und lebhafte Aufführung dieser spätromantischen und perfekt komponierten Sinfonie mit farbenreichen doch perfekt entsprechenden Tönen aller Instrumente. Die Virtuosität aller Einzelspieler ist wahrhaft bewundernswert. Der intelligente und geniale Dirigent leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im veränderlichen Tempo und mit künstlerisch kontrollierter Dynamik. Einfach wunderbar!
Very elated performance. Nice job. Very difficult as a child [very poor....] to get a hold of orchestral scores. Rachmaninoff holds a special place for me, not because he's a favorite composer, but because the first orchestra scores I owned were his 3 symphonies and Symphonic Dances. On special at music store and my father purchased for me.
The Conductor is whiz bang good! Go on with your bad self‼️
0:05 [theme 1] / 0:29 [transition] / 0:43 [theme 2] / 1:08 [theme 3]/ 1:33 [theme 4] / 1:59 [transition] / 2:17 [theme 5] / 4:25 [theme 6] / 5:59 / 7:53 [climax] / 9:09 [transition - horn solo - misterioso] / 9:28 [theme 2 reprise - violin solo] / 10:26 [Reprise theme 5] / 12:35 [theme 7] / 13:10 [trumpet - theme from 2nd symphony]
14:16 [theme 1- horn] / 14:59 [violin] / 15:17 [theme 1 - violins] / 15:52 [flute/clarinet] / [strings] / 17:19 [flute] / 17:45 [clarinet/celli/cor anglais/ Glockenspiel] / 19:47 [build up - climax] / 21:49 / 23:22 / 23:43 [strings/cor anglais/horns] / 24:37 [theme in strings] / 25:01 [violin solo] / 25:35 [cor anglais] / 26:09
26:50
Are you sure about 13:10? Isn't it just theme 1 repeated?
I would have loved to be there so hard 🌳
You would have been ..hard ...??? Strange use of words .... just my opinion..
@@maxlinder5262 English is not my mother tongue but I think I heard or read similar constructions with the adverbial use of hard.
@@maxlinder5262 I believe he meant "so much", but that may have been strangely "hard" for you to understand. Perhaps you should stick to writing rather than reading; your interpretative skills seem to be negligible....but that's just my opinion.
@@maxlinder5262In some languages the word «hard» means so much or a lot. For example polish MY language «mocno» means hard which i use in that context
❤10:27❤
❤2:00❤
41:48 Liebe Grüße aus dem LJSO Hessen
👏
18:54 - horn, kix, trrrraa 😢
6:55
Indeed! Take a look from 6:40 on, this section is so addictive, I always have to repeat it multiple times.
These are just falling broken chords, but Rachmaninoff executes them so magnificently! The contrast between the violins and the celli, taking turns, it's just great. Harmonically, he uses the augmented seventh chord of B-Major (A#-F#-D#-B) before he uses that glorious Eb-Major that you timestamped, just like a nostalgic look into the past but also a longing look into the future. Just look at the conductor's smile.
This section is Rachmaninoff at his best. Just like 28:26. I love this symphony so much. Rachmaninoff, I owe you large! And I al just 19 years old...
@@mangomerkel2005 Same dude ya replied to earlier, decided to time stamp this to compare
@@MrShovelBottom Oops, sorry man :D
@@MrShovelBottomSo, what do you say? I may be biased because I love this version so much, it's sublime. I am convinced this is the right tempo for this section because slower it doesn't have the same emotional power.
Excellent performance. But allow me to express my pet peeve: ignoring first movement exposition repeats.
Maybe orchestra musicians have heard standard repertoire numerous times and are in a rush to get home, so they would just as soon ignore these repeats but I would assume that the majority of people in the audience are hearing some of these pieces for the first time. And even for those of us who are already familiar with these pieces, shouldn’t we reapproach them as if we are hearing them for the first time, with fresh ears?
Additionally, the transition to the development section should come as a surprise after having heard the end of the first exposition return to its top, but when we don’t take these repeats, the surprise has been eliminated.
I definitely hear lots of Beethoven. Movements are patterned as Beethoven.
👀
no repeat?
7:07
20:38
2:16
17:10 23:20
Everyone knows the FRSO musicians are technically some of the finest; but the orchestra also displays immense innate musicality throughout. Under a sensitive conductor like Poga (musicians' delight) such talent provides a landmark Rachmaninov 3, as with their Rachmaninov 2 under Jensen, both totally overwhelming. These unequalled renditions will live on as a reference for posterity.
Was ist Neoromantik? , Rachmaninov, sehr wahrscheinlich, eine ganz feine Aufführung!!!
😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅
14:10
16:44
28:27
35:20
31:53 haha
This would certainly be a definitive performance but for one inexcusable (yet easily avoidable) flaw. Why a conductor of this skill and insight would choose not to take the repeat of the exposition in the 1st mvt, is beyond me. It's very much like the repeat in the 1st mvt of Brahms' 3rd symphony. It's absolutely necessary for structural balance. Camera work was a bit strange-especially regarding all the closeups of the second clarinetist when the lens should have been on the principal. (not to detract from the second desk...she's a wonderful player too)
Rachmaninoff's symphonies are OK. I think I'll stick with his piano concertos.
Lee George Robinson Jason Rodriguez Cynthia
Is this conductor a giant leprechaun?
❤12:00❤